kepimpinan dalam islam minggu 1
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
1/36
Kepimpinan Dalam Islam
2012
Kuliah 1
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
2/36
Pengenalan Modul
Modul ini akan membincangkan:
i) Prinsip-prinsip kepimpinan Islam
ii) Bagaimana ia dapat digunapakai di dalam era
moden ini samada dalam keluarga atau organisasi.
iii) Peserta juga akan membuat perbandingan ringkas
mengenai teori-teori kepimpinan barat serta
tamadun-tamadun lain seperti, Cina, Jepun danIndia untuk melihatkan kelebihan prinsip
kepimpinan Islam.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
3/36
Hasil Pembelajaran
Di akhir modul pelajar dapat, inshaallah:
Mengenalpasti krisis kepimpinan dan jalan keluarkepada krisis tersebut berdasarkan teori
kepimpinan Islam Membezakan teori-teori kepimpinan selain Islam
dengan teori Islam serta membuat perbandingan.
Menghayati Islam serta dapat berfikir secararasional, kreatif, kritikal dan analatikalberpandukan Islam serta berpengaruh dalamkomunikasi.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
4/36
Cara Pembelajaran
Minggu Pertama
Pengenalan Konsep Kepimpanan Dalam Islam
serta Barat
Ciri Kepimpinan (Leadership)
Cara-cara memilih pemimpin
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
5/36
Cara Pembelajaran
Minggu Kedua
Ciri-ciri Pemimpin (Leader)
Rasulullah sebagai contoh
Pandangan Orientalist mengenai kepimpanan
Rasulullah saw
Konsep Khalifah dalam al-Quran
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
6/36
Cara Pembelajaran
Minggu Ketiga
Krisis kepimpinan
Modal pemerintahan Barat dan Dunia IslamSekarang
Sumber Perlembagaan
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
7/36
Cara Pembelajaran
Minggu Keempat
Perbincangan kertas kerja Kepimpinan dalamIslam (Sesi 1) - Krisis Kepimpinan
Rumusan
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
8/36
Cara Pembelajaran
Minggu Kelima
Perbincangan - Kepimpinan dalam Islam (Sesi2) Kegagalan Pemimpin: Apa jawapannya?
Rumusan
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
9/36
GENERAL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ISLAM AND THE WEST
Never the twain shall meet is an interestingphrase to use describing the ever conflictingrelationship between the West (reads secular)
and Islam.
Samuel P Huntingtons The clash of
Civilization?has opened the Pandora box andcritically examined this bitter sweetrelationship.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
10/36
GENERAL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ISLAM AND THE WEST
The West and Islam differ in practical every
aspect from its ideology, concept and
practices.
Religion to the West, plays second fiddle as
compared to sciences and this is not surprising
as the West had a bitter experience with it
(namely Christianity).
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
11/36
GENERAL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ISLAM AND THE WEST
When Constantine, the Roman Emperor, acceptedChristianity and made Christianity the State religion,which had all the necessary structures there were nosynthesis, no permeation of the state structure by
Christian values
In other words Christianity had no answer on how togovern a country. The two (the State and Christianity)
stood close but apart, no symbiotic relationship so saythe least. Thus they felt apart from each other.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
12/36
GENERAL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ISLAM AND THE WEST
In contrast to Islam which not only provide the structure,but also the blueprint on how to run the State - as religionis the basic guiding foundation of running it, of whichDivine laws is the only and ultimate law that is recognized,others must abide under its framework
In Islam religion is the Deen, a way of life and not as seenby the West as religion per se. This is the Deen wherethemessage is from Allah, whose sole purpose of creating Manis to worship Him and Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), the bestexample of Man is the messenger of this message.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
13/36
GENERAL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ISLAM AND THE WEST
With the Quran and the Prophets Hadith as theguiding principles, Islam has the answer to all mattersand Muslims are ordained to refer to these in the dailydealings of their lives, so much so if conflict arises
Islam and the West, each on its own promotes adifferent ethics, values and principles. Notwithstandingthis, the quest for power is both pursued by the West
and Islam relentlessly. Power is the name of the gameand a leader is the main character behind this powerplay
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
14/36
GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF LEADERSHIP
In politics, there are various factors that shaped thestyle of government. This holds true not only in seculargovernment states but also in Islamic governmentstates
However, the main driving force behind thesegovernments is the leadership. It will make or break agovernment just like driving a car which looks simple
but bringing the car to the intended direction requirescertain skills and concentration.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
15/36
DEFINITION OF KEYWORDS
The word leader carries the meaning as a person who rules orguides or inspires others.
In politics the leader is represented by the estate known as theExecutive.
According to Abdul Rashid Moten, In every political system thehighest executive power remains in the hands of a single individualor small elite and he further reiterated In its narrow sense theexecutive means only the heads of government, the chief executive
head of a state, members of the cabinet or council ofministers
Abdul Rashid Moten and Syed Serajul Islam, 2006, p. 163
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
16/36
LEADERSHIP BETWEEN THE WESTERN SECULAR STATE
AND AN ISLAMIC STATE
The differences and similarities of the concept and characteristics ofleadership in the Western Secular and Islamic States will bediscussed
Depending on the types of political system Presidential, Prime
Ministerial or Monarchy systems,
i) We will try to understand where power and authority resides,how the leaders are appointed the issue of legitimacy andmandate, and who make the laws.
ii) In the Islamic perspective, we will look at the concept of khalifahfil ardand the characteristics that come with it, like the roles of aleader, methods of selection, sovereignty, obedience to leadersand issue of gender.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
17/36
Concept and Characteristics of
Leadership in Western Secular State In the Western Secular State, there are a few models of
leadership depending on the types of political systemadopted by the State.
In a Democratic State, the Executives are in the centre ofthe power of the government with the President or PrimeMinister at the apex of the pyramid of the government.
Thus, power resides in the hands of a single person or a
group of elites. They are given the sovereign power andauthority by the constitution which allows them to makeor break laws they term fit directly or indirectly -according to the condition of the people and State.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
18/36
Concept and Characteristics of
Leadership in Western Secular State In the Western democracy like the US, where the President
is not under any control of the Legislators the Congress -the President can veto a bill passed by the Legislators.
It is also with this sovereign power and authority thatpowerful leaders of the world not only change theirdomestic laws, but also laws concerning internationalaffairs.
They used their influence to push for international lawsthat will suit and benefit their own national interest.
Here within, lies the opportunity for the abuse of power.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
19/36
Concept and Characteristics of
Leadership in Western Secular State
In a western functional democracy like the US,
having the Presidential system, the President is
elected by a direct popular election by the
people, but can only stay in office for a maximumperiod of eight years or two terms
Here, the people give mandate directly to thePresident. The President of the US is both the
Head of State as well as the Head of Government
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
20/36
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
21/36
Concept and Characteristics of
Leadership in Western Secular State For both types of system discussed above, legitimacy for the
leadership is obtained through the process of election.
In a country like Switzerland which adopts plural executive, theFederal Assembly selects a commission of seven persons to sit in
the Federal Council to act as the executive authority. Every memberof the commission has equal power.
Another atypical political system is the Monarchy, which is a one-person rule, appointment is normally through hereditary. In thepast, the Monarch held all the powers of the State as the ChiefExecutive, including legislation and judiciary.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
22/36
Concept and Characteristics of
Leadership in an Islamic State
Like the Western democracy, Islam sees theimportance of leadership and the need for a leader.
As commanded by the Prophet (pbuh) in a Hadith,when three people go on a journey, they must selectone of them as the leader.
In a Quranic verse, Allah commanded that the leadermust be obeyed, O you who believe! Obey Allah andobey the Messenger (Muhammad) and those of you(Muslims) who are in authorityQuran,4:59
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
23/36
Concept and Characteristics of
Leadership in an Islamic State
In Islam, a leader is known as khalifah fil ard
(Allahsvicegerent on earth). In this aspect, we
are able to look at several key characteristics
of Islamic leadership:
a) Leaders as Gods Trustees
b) Leaders have no sovereign powers and do
not make laws
c) Conditional Obedience to Leaders
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
24/36
Leaders as Gods Trustees
Leaders in Islam act as GodsTrustees. The role of a leader in Islamis one of an amanahnot a privilege that a person must fulfill.
The leader being the khalifah vicegerent must uphold Allahsdivine laws (Shariah) upon himself and upon his subjects and
citizens
It is thus a very heavy responsibility that one shall not demand orask for, nor it is a role that can be given to any individual.
It is a great trust to be undertaken not by any man but by Godabiding man
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
25/36
Leaders as Gods Trustees
Shahibuddin Lamin in his dissertation on the trust quoted theQuranic verse:
Lo!We offered the trust unto the heavens and the earth and themountains but they shrank from bearing it and were afraid of it.
Man alone undertook to bear it Al-Quran 33:72
And he further reiterated Trust, according to Ibn Abbas, impliesduties imposed upon man. The Giver of trust expects from thetrustee its proper use and not other wise. This implies that manshould discharge his duties in strict conformity with Divine Laws
Shahibuddin Laming,2002, p.189
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
26/36
Leaders as Gods Trustees
Thus the trust is taken not by any individualwithout prior evaluating his capabilities in Islamicperspective
And if he qualifies, a Muslim leader should bevery clear of his role and responsibility to thepeople he leads as well as his accountability toAllah.
In the Western democracy, the term amanah ortrust do exist but not to the same degree ofacceptance, measurement or extent as in Islam.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
27/36
Leaders have no sovereign powers
and do not make laws Sovereign powers solely belong to Allah and the leaders are but mere implementers of Allahs
shariahon the face of the earth.
Hence, upholding Allahsshariahis the prime responsibility of any Muslim leaders.
This differential in concept of leadership between Islam and the Western Secular State lies in theformer emphasis and indigenous attitude towards religion and the latter blatant indignant towards
the same.
In this aspect, we see the Western democracy different from Islam.
Unlike Islamic laws which are divine laws that believers cannot challenge and he must fully obeywith full obligation without fear and favour, and can only be changed and removed by Allah the AllMighty,
Where else Western laws are man-made which can be manipulated and broken when the leaderdeem fit to do so, even if it is with the intention to serve the interest of the political elites andruling party.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
28/36
Conditional Obedience to Leaders
Thus, in Islam there is check and balance between theleader and the citizens unlike the Western democracywhich do not allow such direct channel of communication,what more to reprimand or point out the wrong deed of aleader.
But this does not mean that the Western leader is abovethe law as any leader who breaks the law can beprosecuted by the Judiciary.
In this sense both Western and Islamic leaders are falliblejust like any human being and are not above the law.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
29/36
Conditional Obedience to Leaders
Citizens of an Islamic State can check on the leadersand correct them.
Hence, whether Muslims need to have an absoluteobedience to a leader is debatable as majority of
Muslim scholars deduced that obedience to a leadershall be conditional, subjected to the leader complyingwith Allahsdivine laws (shariah).
Muslims need not obey the leaders command if it isagainst the shariah.
In fact it is the duty of every Muslims to correct amungkarto the best of his ability, irrespective whetherthe mungkaris done by the leader or the commoner.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
30/36
Various methods of selection of
leaders The method of selecting leaders varies throughout the history of
the Islamic empire.
The Quran does not specifically mention how a leader shall beappointed.
As such even the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) did not appoint asuccessor prior to his death or leave any will.
Thus, when the shariahis silent on the appointment of the leader,
it was left to the Muslims to decide the most suitable candidate tobe the leader as the method of selection is immaterial compared tothe quality of the incumbent leader.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
31/36
All four khalifahwere appointed to the post in a different way. (See notes onselection of Caliphs)
The first Khalifah, Saidina Abu Bakar As Siddiq, was appointed after severalconsiderations by the Muslims.
The second Khalifah, Saidina Umar Al Khattab was directly nominated bySaidina Abu Bakar when he was about to die after a fortnight of high fever.
His nomination of Umar was agreed by all Muslims, who gave their baiahin Masjid Nabawi.
This direct nomination of a successor by the predecessor was the secondtype of election of a Khalifah.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
32/36
The third Khalifah, Saidina Uthman bin Affan
was appointed by a syura of six persons
appointed by Saidina Umar and among them
they would elect a successor.
This nomination was made after Saidina Umar
was struck by a poisonous dagger while he
was about to lead the Fajar prayer.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
33/36
The forth Khalifah, Saidina Ali was appointed after rebels martyred SaidinaUthman.
After Saidina Uthmansdeath, the rebels offered the Khilafah to severalprominent persons like Zubair, Saadand Ali but all rejected it.
Malik Ashtar the rebel, then forced Saidina Ali to accept the appointmentof Khalifahor be killed.
When Saidina Ali accepted, unlike the previous Khalifah, he did notreceive a full baiahfrom all Muslims.
Companions like Saad bin Abi Waqqas, Talhah, Aishah and Muawiyah,would not pledge the baiahunless Saidina Ali took revenge on the deathof Saidina Uthman.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
34/36
Issue of gender in Leadership
Last, on the issue of gender, there had never been a woman caliphor monarch in the history of the Islamic empire.
Of course we cannot deny historical fact that Saidatina Aisyah hadled an army in the Battle of Jamal, but never as a head of state.
Thus, the Western democracy is more acceptable to woman beingappointed as the head of state or government as can be seen inrecent times.
A point to note, the Quran does mention the only female leaderthat of Saba, however on further scrutiny the leadership of theQueen of Saba was invalidated and later came under the rule ofKing Solomon.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
35/36
Questions and Answer
Recap Recall..Revise.
-
8/11/2019 Kepimpinan Dalam Islam Minggu 1
36/36
InsyaallahNext Session
Ciri-ciri Pemimpin (Leader)
Rasulullah sebagai contoh
Pandangan Orientalist mengenai kepimpananRasulullah saw
Konsep Khalifah dalam al-Quran