list new2.asp
DESCRIPTION
COURT FILINGSTRANSCRIPT
-
PCNo:20/2011
MurtiDevi&Ors.Vs.State&Ors.
22.04.2015(11:55a.m.)
Present: Ld.Px.Counselforpetitioners.
Respondentno.1isState.
Ld.Px.Counselforrespondentno.2.
AnapplicationfiledtodayU/o22Rule3r/wSec151CPCand
furtherr/wSec5ofLimitationActonbehalfofapplicantsnamelyMr.Uday
Veer,Mr.TaraChand&Mr.JaiVeerSingh forbringingLRsofdeceased
petitionerno.1Smt.MurtiDevionrecord.Copyofthesamesuppliedtold.px.
Counselforrespondentno.2.
Nowtocomeupforreply&argumentsonthisapplication as
wellasforconsiderationofanotherpendingapplicationofMr.OmDuttU/o1
Rule10CPCandalsofurtherproceedingsasperlawon05.08.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
PCNo:36/2011
OmParkashVs.State&Ors.
22.04.2015(10:43a.m.)
Present: Noneforpetitionerbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Respondentno.1isState.
None for respondents 2 to 6 by this timedespite several calls
given.
Nowtocomeupforpersonalappearanceofpetitioner,forfiling
amended memoof parties, by petitioner side, in compliance to order dt.
12.11.2014, for withdrawal of this petition, if any, as well as for further
proceedingsasperlawon04.06.2015.Itislastopportunityforfilingamended
memoofpartiesbythepetitionerfornextdate.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
PCNo:29/2013
PremLataVs.State&Ors.
22.04.2015(10:59a.m.)
Present: Noneforpetitionerbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Respondentno.1isState.
Smt.RajniBala,Wifeofrespondentno.2.
Respondents3&4notyetservedasPFnotfiledfortheirservice.
Issue fresh notice of the petition to these respondents for
05.08.2015, on filingof PF/RCby the petitioner side within07days from
today.Tocomeupalsoforfurtherproceedingsasperlawonthenextdate.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
PCNo:41/2014
Dinesh&Ors.Vs.State&Anr.
22.04.2015(11:12p.m.)
Present: Petitionerno.1inpersonforallthepetitioners.
Respondentno.1isState.
Mr.Bijender,sonofrespondentno.2.
Thereispendingapplicationonbehalfofpetitionersfiledbefore
this court on04.04.2015U/o6rule17CPCr/worder1Rule10CPCfor
amendmentofmemoofpartiesandforseekingadditionofMr.PawanSolanki
asrespondentno.3inthispetition.Applicant/petitionerno.1Mr.Dineshalso
presentinpersontodayandheundertakestosupplycopyofthisapplicationto
respondentno.2/counselforrespondentno.2,within10daysfromtoday.Inthe
interestofjustice,alsoissue noticeofthisapplicationtoMr.PawanSolanki
fornextdateonfilingofPF/RCforthispurposebythepetitionerno.1within
07daysfromtoday.
Withthisorder,nowtocomeupforreply&argumentsonthis
applicationaswellasforfurtherproceedingsasperlawon12.08.2015andlet
suchreplybefiledbyrespondentno.2aswellasbyMr.PawanSolankionly
afterreceivingcopyofthisapplicationfromapplicant/petitionerno.1.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
M.No:92/2014
MakhanBaiVs.VishalMehrotra
22.04.2015(11:30a.m.)
Present: None for applicant, qua pending application of applicant dt.
17.10.2014, filed U/o 41 Rule 19 CPC r/w Sec 151 CPC, for setting
aside/recallingorderdt.17.09.2014videwhichMCAno.37/13,ofapplicant
was dismissed in default, by this time despite several calls given since
morning.
Nowtocomeupforpersonal appearanceofapplicantandfor
consideration of pending application of applicant as well as for further
proceedingsasperlawon03.06.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
CSNo:97/2014
ShashiVs.Chetna
22.04.2015(11:32a.m.)
Present: Plaintiffinperson.
Nonefordefendantbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Timesoughtbytheplaintiffforfilingreplication.
Now to come up for filing of the same as well as for
considerationofpendinginjunctionapplicationoftheplaintiffon20.05.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
CSNo:809/2013
SarojKumariJainVs.VineetJain&Anr.
22.04.2015(11:36a.m.)
Present: Plaintiffinperson.
Defendantno.1inperson.
Mr.SandeepJain,husbandofdefendantno.2,presentonbehalfof
defendantno.2.
Nowitnessreadytodaytobeexaminedonbehalfofplaintiffdue
tocompletelawyersstriketoday.
NowtocomeupforPEon18.08.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
CSNo:61/2012
KiranChadhaVs.PawanKumar.
22.04.2015(11:40a.m.)
Present: Plaintiffinperson.
Nonefordefendantbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Nowtocomeupforpersonalappearanceofdefendantaswellas
forDEon12.08.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
PCNo:32/2010
VinodSharmaVs.State&Ors.
22.04.2015(11:44a.m.)
Present: Noneforpetitionerbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Respondentno.1isState.
None for respondents 2 to 7 by this timedespite several calls
given.
Now to come up for personal appearance of parties and for
considerationofpendingapplicationon24.07.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
Arbtn.No:254/2011
NaveenMann&Anr.Vs.CiticorpFinaneIndiaMLTD.
22.04.2015(11:49a.m.)
Present: Petitionerno.1inpersonforboththepetitioners.
Noneforrespondentbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Asprayedfor,partargumentsheardonobjectionofobjectorfrom
petitionerno.1.
Now to come up for personal appearance of parties and for
further arguments on objections of the objector as well as for further
proceedingson05.08.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
PCNo:46/2012
AshokKumarvohraVs.RajKumarVohra&Ors.
22.04.2015(03:08p.m.)
Present: Noneforpetitionerbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgivensince
02:00p.m.today.
Respondentno.3Smt.Neelampresentinperson.
None present for remaining respondents by this time despite
severalcallsgiven.
Thereispendingapplicationofrespondentno.3filedearlierU/o
18Rule17CPC.
Asprayedfor,Iheardfreshargumentsinpartonthisapplication
fromrespondentno.3today.
Intheinterestofjustice,nowtocomeupforfurtherarguments
onthisapplicationfromthesideofcontestingpartieson05.06.2015.Itislast
opportunityforthispurpose.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
EX.No:06/2011
ICICIBankVs.NareshKumar
22.04.2015(12:04p.m.)
Present: Noneforpartiesbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Now to come up for personal appearance of parties, for
confirmationofsettlementofthismatterbetweentheparties,ifany,aswellas
forfurtherproceedingsasperlawon30.04.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
PCNo:18/11
KamlaDeviVs.State.
22.04.2015(02:25p.m.)
Present:
Theearlier petitioner Smt. KamlaDevihasreportedlyexpired.
ApplicantMs.MeenuGargispresentquaherpendingapplicationfiledon
02.08.2014u/o22Rule3CPCr/wSec151CPCforbringingLRsofdeceased
petitioneronrecord.TheLRsofdeceasedSmt.KamlaDevimentionedinpara
02ofthisapplicationhavealreadygiventheirstatementsbeforethiscourtto
theeffectthattheyhavenoobjectionifSmt.MeenuGargW/oLateSh.Om
ParkashissubstitutedasapetitionerinplaceofdeceasedSmt.KamlaDevi.
Fresh arguments heard today from Ms. Meenu on above
mentionedapplication.Fileyettobegonethroughminutelybeforedeciding
thisapplication.
Duetothisreason,nowtocomeupfororderonthisapplication
on16.05.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
GPNo:09/2015
ManojKumarVs.State&Ors.
22.04.2015(02:42p.m.)
Present: Petitionerinperson.
FreshpetitionU/s8(B)oftheGuardianship&WardsActfiledon
behalfofthepetitionerseekinghisappointmentasguardianofminorsMs.
Mansi &Master Dash, r/wSec29of this act and further r/wSec8(2) of
HinduMinority&GuardianshipActseekingpermissionforsale/transferof
abovementionedminors.Becheckedandregistered.
Issue notice of this petition to respondent no.1 i.e. State for
06.08.2015,throughCollector/concernedSDMonfilingofPF/RCforfiling
valuationreport, ofthepropertyinvolved.Citationtogeneralpublicbegot
published in the daily newspaper Veer Arjun on depositing publication
chargesasperrules.Copyofthecitationbealsodisplayedonthecourtnotice
boardasperrules.
Also issuenoticeof this petition torespondent no. 2 to7for
06.08.2015onfilingofPF/RCwithin07daysfromtodaybythepetitioner.
With this order, now to come up for personal appearance of
parties,forfilingvaluationreportofthepropertybyrespondentno.1andfor
furtherproceedingsasperlawon06.08.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII:N/W:ROHINI:DELHI
22.04.2015
-
GPNo.12/2012.
SudamaSinghVs.TheState&Anr.
22.04.2015.(12.20p.m.)
Present: Petitionerinperson.
Respondentno.1isthestate.
Respondentno.2Sh.KrishanKumarRaopresentinpersonand
asperhisownsubmission,hehascomeontemporarybailinacriminalcase,
allegedlypendingagainsthimforallegeddeathofhiswifebyhim.
Sh. SureshPal, fromschool concerned, bear the girl student
babyMahiRao,forwhompetitionfiledinthismatterforherguardianshipbyhis
maternalgrandfather(nana),presentonbehalfofPrincipaloftheschoolin
compliance to previous order. Hehas filed his authority letter (Ex.C1), to
appearonbehalfofPrincipal.Hisstatementrecordedtodayseparatelyonoath
in which he stated, on behalf of school concerned, that school has no
objection,ifgirlstudentbabyMahicontinuesherstudiesinthisschoolbutwith
aconditionthatheroutstandingduestotheextentofRs.2,77,074/,tilldatei.e
22.04.2015,beorderedtobepaidtotheschooltilltheendofApril2015byand
onbehalfofguardian(s)ofthisgirlstudent.Afterrecordinghisstatement,Sh.
SureshPalisherebydischargedinthismatter.
Atthisstage,itispointedoutbyrespondentno.2/fatherofgirl
studentbabyMahithathegotforwardedhisapplicationdt.27.03.2015tothis
courtthroughSuptt.ofjailconcernedseekingcustodyofherdaughterwithhim
and he further submitted that another application/petition also pending,
reportedly filedearlierbeforethiscourt on23.03.2015, filedbyhisyounger
brother Sh. Man Mohan (who is also present today), u/ss 7,9 & 25 of
-
Guardianship & Wards Act 1890 r/w section 13 of Hindu Minority and
GuardianshipAct1956andaccompaniedwith interimapplicationU/s12of
Guardianship&WardsAct,seekingcustodyofgirl studentbabyMahi.The
samehasbeenbroughttothenoticeofpetitionertodayandhehasstrongly
opposed the both i.e application of respondent no. 2 dt. 27.03.2015 and
applicationofpetitionerofapplicant/petitionerMr.ManMohan,asmentioned
above,withoutfilinganywrittenreplytothesame.
Now to come up for orders on both the above mentioned
applicationofrespondentno.2aswellasonpetition/applicationofMr.Man
Mohan,asmentionedabove,aswellasforpassingordersquacontinuationof
studiesofbabyMahiintheschoolconcerned,quapaymentofheroutstanding
schoolduesbyguardian(s)ofbabyMahi,aswellasforfurtherproceedingsas
perlawon02.05.2015at3.00p.m.Firstcallwouldbegivenat3.00p.m.on
nextdateforthispurpose.ThePrincipaloftheschoolisdirectednottotake
anycoerciveactionagainstbabyMahitillnextdatequanonpaymentofher
outstandingduesandMr.SureshPal,presentonbehalfofPrincipal,hasnoted
down this order for compliance. In the interest of justice, all the
contesting/interestedpartiesinthismatterareatlibertytofilewrittensynopsis
of arguments till 29.04.2015, qua above mentioned application/petition, by
suppliedadvancecopiesofthesametoeachother,andifsodesiredbysuch
party/parties,asthecasemaybe.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
GPNo.12/2012.
SudamaSinghVs.TheState&Anr.
22.04.2015.
StatementofSh.SureshPal,EstateManager,CSKMPublicSchool,Satbari,
Chattarpur,NewDelhi74.
OnS.A.
IamworkingasEstateManagerintheabovementionedSchool
since01.01.2005.Today,I haveappearedonbehalfofPrincipalofthesaid
school inthepresentmatterandIhavealsoplacedonrecordmyauthority
letterEx.C1.Asperinstructions,theaforesaidschoolhavenoobjection,ifgirl
student namely baby Mahi Rao continuous her studies with this school.
However,asperschoolrecord,ourtotaloutstandingduesagainsttuitionfees
quathegirlstudentnamelybabyMahiRaostandtotheextentofRs.2,77,074/
tilldatei.e22.04.2015,ofwhichdetailsgivenonaseparatepaperfiledtoday
on record (same marked as mark X1 today for future reference). Let
guardian(s)ofthisgirlstudentbedirectedtopaytheoutstandingduesofthe
-
school.
RO&AC. (Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
CSNo.50/2014.
DeepakNandaVs.M/sGopalPlastics&Anr.
22.04.2015.(11.40a.m.)
Present: Plaintiffinperson.
Defendantno.2inpersonforhimselfaswellasfor
defendantno.1.
Partiespresentorallysubmittedthattherearenodocumentson
recordfromanysideworthadmissionanddenialatthisstage.Hence,this
formalityisherebydispensedwithatthisstage.
Pleadingsofthepartiesarecompleted.
Fromthepleadingsoftheparties,followingissuesareframed:
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of Rs.9,00,000/ (Nine
LakhsOnly)withinterest,againstthedefendants?OPP.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree of permanent injunction
againstthedefendants,asprayedforintheplaint?OPP.
3. Whethertheplaintiffhasmadefalsesubmissioninhisplaintquathe
reliefclaimedintheplaint?OPD.
4. Whethertheplaintiffhasplayedfraudagainstthedefendantsquathe
presentmatter,asallegedinWS?OPD.
5. Whether the plaintiff not entitled to claim any relief against the
defendants?OPD.
6. Relief,ifany.
Inmyconsideredopinion,nootherissuearisesfordecidingthis
caseonmeritsnorpressedfromanyside. Nowtocomeupforevidenceof
plaintiff on 26.08.2015. Let copies of evidence affidavit(s) of witnesses of
-
plaintiffsidebesuppliedtoothersideatleast15daysbeforenextduedate.List
ofwitnessesfrombothsidesbefiledwithin15daysfromtoday.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
CSNo.901/2009.
DharampalVs.NafeSinghMaan&Ors.
22.04.2015.(11.45a.m.)
Present: Nonefortheplaintiffbythistimedespiteseveralcalls
given.
Defendantno.1inperson.
Noneforotherdefendantsbythistimedespiteseveral
callsgiven.
DW2Sh.PardeepMaannotpresenttodayforhis
deposition.
NowtocomeupfordepositionofDW2aswellasforremaining
DEon13.07.2015.Tocomeupalsoforfurtherproceedingsasperlawonnext
date.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
CSNo.711/2013.
RamPhalTomerVs.Sh.JagdishChander&Anr.
22.04.2015.(11.50a.m.)
Present: Nonefortheplaintiffbythistimedespiteseveralcalls
given.
Defendantno.1inperson.
Noneforthedefendantno.2bythistimedespiteseveral
callsgiven.
Lawyerstoldtobecompletestriketoday.
Now to come up for personal appearance of PW1, for his
deposition, as well as for reply & arguments on pending application on
23.07.2015. Tocomeupalsoforfurtherproceedingsasperlawonnextdate.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
CSNo.66/2014.
SavitaVs.Balwanti&Ors.
22.04.2015.(11.55a.m.)
Present: Sh.RanjitSingh,husbandofplaintiff.
Sh.ArunKumar,internonbehalfofalldefendants.
Replication filed today on behalf of plaintiff of which copy
supplied to other sides. As jointly prayed for part arguments on injunction
applicationofplaintiffheardtodayfrombothsides.
Asfurtherprayedfor,nowtocomeupforfurtherargumentson
pendinginjunctionapplicationofplaintiffaswellasforfurtherproceedingsas
perlawon03.06.2015.Intheinterestofjustice,interimorder,quamaintaining
statusquaofsuitproperty,tocontinuetillnextdate.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
RCANo.58/2013.
KrishanKumar&Anr.Vs.Yogita.
22.04.2015.(12.00noon)
Present: Noneforpartiesbythistimedespiteseveralcallsgiven.
Nowtocomeupforfreshargumentsonappealfrombothsides
aswellasforfurtherproceedingsasperlawon20.05.2015at12.00noon.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
MCANo.18/2013.
KamleshMalikvs.DelhiStateIndustrial&Infrastructure&Anr.
22.04.2015.(12.05p.m.)
Present: Ld.Px.CounselSh.ShivKumar,onbehalfofappellant.
Sh.ChattarSingh,UDCforrespondentno.1.
Noneforrespondentno.2bythistimedespiteseveral
callsgiven.
Lawyerstoldtobecompletestriketoday.Asjointlyprayedfor,
freshfinalargumentsinpart,onpendingappeal,heardfrompartiespresent.
Asfurtherprayedfor,nowtocomeupforfurtherargumentson
pendingappealaswellasforfurtherproceedingsasperlawon22.05.2015at
12.30p.m.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15
-
CSNo.52/2011.
TalewarSinghVs.NareshKumar&Ors.
22.04.2015.(3.10p.m.)
Present: Noneforcontestingparties,quathismatter,bythistime
despiteseveralcallsgivensince2.00p.m.today.
Bythisorder,Ihavetodecidependingapplicationoftheplaintiff
dt.25.02.2015filedu/o5rule20CPCforgettingadefendantservedthrough
substitutedserviceinthelocalnewspaper.
Heardandperusedthefileforthispurpose.
Asrevealedfromjudicialfile,thismatterwasrepeatedlyfixedfor
serviceofdefendantno.1onfilinghisfreshcorrectaddressaswellasprocess
feeforhisservicebytheplaintiff. However,plaintiffrepeatedlyfailedtotake
steps earlier for his service and even cost of Rs.1000/ imposed on two
occasionsi.eon07.09.2013&10.09.2014respectively,upontheplaintiff,qua
taking such steps, not deposited by the plaintiff. Nospecific nameof the
defendant(s) mentioned in this application, whose service has/have been
soughtbythisapplication.
Fortheabovementionedreasons,thisapplicationisfoundbeing
devoidofanymeritsandnotallowedasprayedfor.Noorderastocostsqua
this application. However, plaintiff asked not to move such applications
unnecessarilyinfutureasthesameresult indelaydisposalofthecaseon
merits.
Plaintiffisdirectedtodepositearliercostimposeduponhim,as
mentionedabove,beforenextduedateandtoshowreceiptofpaymentofthe
sametothiscourtonnextdate.
-
Onelastandfinalopportunity isgivento theplaintiff for filing
freshcorrectaddressofdefendantno.1within15daysfromtodayalongwith
PF&RCforthispurposesothatfreshsummonsbeissuedtodefendantno.1
fornextduedatei.efor24.08.2015.Ifsuchsteps,asmentionedabove,qua
depositofcostandquafreshserviceofdefendantno.1athisfreshcorrect
address,arenottakenbytheplaintiffwithin15daysfromtoday,adverseorder
asperlawmaybepassedagainsttheplaintifffornottakingsuchsteps,by
virtueofthisorder.
Withthisorder,nowtocomeupforfurtherproceedingsasper
lawon24.08.2015.
(Dr.Shahabuddin)ADJII(N/W):Rohini:Delhi:22.04.15