nicaragua vs. united states of america (1986)

Upload: ankush-vulcan-chattopadhyay

Post on 08-Jul-2018

236 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    1/21

    NCU LAW SCHOOL, COURT ROOM EXERCISE

    IN THE HON’BLE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE, THE

    HAGUE, NETHERLANDS

     

    IN THE MATTER OF

    Petitioner: Ni!r!"#!

    $%&De'en(!nt%: Unite( St!te% o' A)eri!

      WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER 

     

    MOST RESPECTFULL* SUBMITTED:

    An+#% C!tto-!(.!. /01LLB2003

    COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER 

    1

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    2/21

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    INDEX OF AUTHORITIES......................................................................................…3

    ABBREVIATIONS……................................................................................................4

    STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION…………………………………………………..5

    BACKGROUND OF THE CASE……………………………………………………..6

    SUMMARY OF THE FACTS………………………………………………………...9

    STATEMENT OF ISSUES..........................................................................................10

    SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS…………………………………………………….11

    ARGUEMENTS ADVANCED...................................................................................1

    !RAYER……………………………………………………………………………..1"

    JUDGEMENT OF THE COURT……………………………………………………19 IM!ORTANCE TO INTERNATIONA# #A$……………………………………..0

    BIB#IOGRA!HY........................................................................................................1

    INDEX OF AUTHORITIES

    STATUTES REFERRED

    0& T%& T'&()* +, F'-&/%-2 C+&'& (/ N(-()-+2 1956 7 !(& N8&' 92 13 : 1.

    4& !('('(% I ; A')-

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    3/21

    5& H(8& C+&)-+ VIII. =1" O)+&' 190@>.

    6& M+)&-/&+ C+&)-+ + R-%) (/ D8)-& +, S)()& =6 D&&&' 1933>.

    02& A')-

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    4/21

    STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION

    T%& +8&< ,+' )%& (&

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    5/21

    C+8')1 /8& )+ )%& T'&()* +, F'-&/%-2 C+&'& (/ N(-()-+ &)&'&/ -)+ (/ -&/ *

     +)% )%& &)-+&/ (')-& - )%& *&(' 1956.

    BAC7GROUND OF THE CASE

    T%& /-8)& &,+'& )%& C+8') &)&& N-('(8( (/ )%& U-)&/ S)()& +&' &&) -

     N-('(8( 8&8&) )+ )%& ,(

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    6/21

     N-('(8( -& )%() )-&. F+

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    7/21

    --

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    8/21

    ()- - '&

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    9/21

    T+ (- ('&/ ++-)-+ '+82 )%& F8&'?( D&+'()-( N-('(8&& =FDN> (/

    A

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    10/21

    SUMMAR* OF ARGUMENTS

    0& Weter te Intern!tion!8 Co#rt o' J#%tie !% te ;#ri%(ition to entert!in te -8e!

    !n( 8!i)% o' te Re-#

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    11/21

    4& Weter te Unite( St!te% o' A)eri! i% in(ee( "#i8t. o' !>in" o))itte( !n.

    ri)e% !"!in%t te Re-#

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    12/21

    O& 8% '+--+ - )%& '+--+ 8/&' A')-in" o))itte( !n.

    ri)e% !"!in%t te Re-#

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    13/21

    T%& USA &&' (& )+ )%& ICJ )+ +)&) )%&

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    14/21

    ( + '&(< &'-) - )%& (& +, R+N (/ )%() -) ( & /&)&'-&/ -

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    15/21

    I )%& &++- ,-&

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    16/21

    ; A')- T%() )%& U-)&/ S)()&2 - '&(% +, -) +

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    17/21

    ; &,,+') * /-'&) (/ -/-'&) &( )+ +&'& (/ -)--/()& )%& G+&'&) +, 

     N-('(8(.

    => T%() )%& U-)&/ S)()&2 - '&(% +, -) + T%() )%& U-)&/ S)()&2 - '&(% +, -) +

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    18/21

    PRA*ER 

    Wherefore in the light of issue raised, arguments advanced, reasons given and authorities

    cited the counsel for petitioner representing the Republic of Nicaragua, humbly request 

    the Hon'ble International Court of Justice to!

    0& T%& C+8') - '&8&)&/ )+ (/8/& (/ /&

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    19/21

    JUDGEMENT OF THE COURT

    C-)- 8&'+8 )'&()-& (/ +&)-+ +&'- -)&'()-+(<

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    20/21

  • 8/19/2019 Nicaragua vs. United States of America (1986)

    21/21

    BIBLIOGRAPH*

    Tre!tie% !n( Con>ention%

    0& T%& T'&()* +, F'-&/%-2 C+&'& (/ N(-()-+2 1956

    2. !('('(% I ; A')-