nps belene assesment wtd

8/6/2019 NPS Belene Assesment WTD

1/75

1

( , , )1

( )

28 2011

( 28 2011, , )

1 .

. , , , , , , , , . , .


2/75


3/75

3

............................................................................................ 54 ( )................................................................ 56

.............................................................................................................................. 58 .......................................................................................................................................60

1: 2020 . .........................................................................62

2: 2025 . .........................................................................62

3:

2010 - 2020 .........................................................................................63

4: :

2025 . ..............................................................65

2025 ........................................................................... 651. ......................................................... 65

1.1. ....................................................................................................................................... 651.2. ( 3 4)................................................................................................................ 66

2. ......................................................................... 662.1. .............................................................................................................................. 66

3. ....................................................................................... 673.1. - S............................................................................................................. 673.2. - ENEL........................................................................................................... 673.3. - 2.................................................................................................................... 683.4. -3................................................................................................................................ 684. ................................................................................ 685. , . GT.................................................... 686. ........................................................................................... 69

7. ................................................................................................................................... 697.1. ............................................................................................................................... 69

8. , .................................................... 699. .............................................................................................................................. 6910. ............................................................................................................................... 7011. ............................................................................................................................. 70

5: .. 1000 2008 71

6: ........................................................................72


4/75

4

, ,

, - , . . 45 .

2003 - 2005 . , , .- , , .

2001 2010 . 56 %, .

1: (2001-2010)

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

( ) 15,55 17,03 18,37 20,39 23, 25 26, 48 30,77 35, 43 34,93 36,03

(TWh) 36,83 36,37 37,07 35,72 36,59 37,94 38,6 39,54 37,37 36,53

:

, , , .

- . 2008 . ,

.


5/75

5

1:

2 , .

2: 2010 2015 2020 2025

, TWh 36,45 37,24 37,75 38,10

, TWh 35,50 37,00 39,30 42,15 , MAX, TWh 36,63 39,11 42,09

, MIN, TWh 36,25 37,60 36,62

- 2020 . 39,3 TWh/2020 . , 2025 . , 2020 2030 . , 42,15 TWh/2025 .

,

.

- - 42,09 TWh / 2020 2

,

. , ,.. 2011 2020 .

).

2 ,

2020 . 36,62 TWh/2020 ., .. 2010 .


6/75

6

, 15 . 20 .

, ,

,

, - , 2001-2010 .

5,49 TWh 900 MW 6000 h. . - , 2000 MW 15 TWh . ,

3

, ,

2020 .

2025 .

427 MW - 3 ENEL, 264 TWh - 2 , , 3 4 -3, 2020 . 2758 MW.

2020 . 2025 .4

, 5 6, , , -3, 3 4.

, , ,

.

, , - , , , - , .

2015 ., 2012 . 2015 . ( ). , 2015 .

3 - 2 - 3

ENEL , , 3 4

-3, 4.3 (MAX1) 2020 .4 15 % , -

, 2025 .


7/75

7

36% 2009 . 38,4% 2015 ., 40%.5 , ( 50% ) .6

1200 , 8,25 15- 12,35 . .

2010 ., .

, -6 700MW, 7

,

.

, , . (18% ), . - 2018-2019 .

. , .

1984.

1990 . ,

, .8

2004. 2005 . , ( . ) .

9

5 , 2015 . , 2004.

, . 31.6 , . 32. ,

, 2015 . .:Milovan Sudovic: Stanje i perspektive razvoja energetike u regionu Jugoistone Evrope, ELEKTROPRIVREDA,

GODINALXIII, BROJ4, 2010, str. 3763867.:www.EconomyNews.bg 29 2010 .

8 (). . ,

, 1990, . 302 ( . . ).
http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/


8/75

8

:

- ( 8- --), ;

- ( 1979 .) ;

- , 320 , , - ( , ) - .

2008 . RWEPower, , . 2009 .

, RWE Power . .

,

.

1984 . ;

.10

. .

20,97 % 1000 MW, 7,03 % 335 MW, 38,15 % 200 MW, 7,34 % 175 MW, 2,31 % 100 MW, - .

, 10 % . 3000 MW ( 2), .. - - 300 350 MW.

1000 MW ,

, .

1000 MW.

2:

2005-2010 . TWh; 4000 MW ("" + "")

9 , 2005 .

.10

, - : , . .


9/75

9

,

2005 - 2010 . , TWh. , , , . , . , .

.

1000MW , , , ,

- . , , , .

. , , , . ( , .)

, 1000 MW

, . , 2025 2030 . 1000 MW

.

, , .

, ,

. - , , , .


10/75

10

- .

, . , , (

) , 10-15 % .

. 2005 . , 6- 5,2 . 2010 . 1,050 . .. 2005 . 5,2 ( ) 10 - 11

. , , ,

.

. ,

.

. . 5 6 . 2006 . .

, . .12

(

)

.

, . 12 . 2011 . , . , .

. (- ) , .Westinghouse , .

11 ,

, . 12

Nucleonics Week, September 29, 2005, Nucleonics Week, April 13, 2006


11/75

11

2000 ., .

Eurostat . .

50% ( ), 70% (.. ).

,

, ,

Eurostat.

. , , :

- 80% ;

- 76,7% , ;

- 71,4% ( );

- , , ( 15 ) ;

- / 1000 ,

2 ;

- 1000 (- ).

:

13

50- , , .

13 .


12/75

12

3: /

6,3

( 7

)1,764

7% + 1%

0,50

0,70

0,75

(50% )

600

0,35. ,

,

(620 MW)

0,35 (

)

(500MW)

0,45

0,50

11,664 -

3 ( 10 ) 600 , . 9,264 .

KW,

( ),

, . , , , 40-50% . . .

4:

KW 1 2

14 14.6

(~) 27,3 28,5


13/75

13

1 KW ,

.

. , , , . ( .)

, , , ,, , , .., , ,

, , . , .. .14

14.5 TWh. , , , , . , . 28.6. . - 37.6 . - , .

, , .

6% ,

3

25 . : ,

,

, 1 015 (

) , ,

14

, ; , , ( ) .


14/75

14

, , -

.

2025 . .

KW, . ,

, .

,

. ,

.

-

80%. , , ,

,

.

,

, .

,

3 - 4 200 4 300 , .

5 000 , -

,

.

1. .2. ,

.

3. 2025 .4. 5 6 .5. .


15/75

15

2010 . 28 2011 .

. 23 .. , , .15

, 2002 ., 3- 4- (, , 2009 2010 .).

, . 2002 . , 29 2004 . - 2005 ., . .16

, - , 1989-1990 . .

17

15

- , , 2005 . , 29 2009 . . , , , ( , .), .

, - , , . - - ( ) .. , 2005 . - , - , , ,

, .

, .:http://www.parliament.bg/bg/parliamentarycommittees/members/224/documents .16

,

, .:http://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htm.17

1991 . , .
http://www.parliament.bg/bg/parliamentarycommittees/members/224/documentshttp://www.parliament.bg/bg/parliamentarycommittees/members/224/documentshttp://www.parliament.bg/bg/parliamentarycommittees/members/224/documentshttp://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htmhttp://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htmhttp://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htmhttp://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htmhttp://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htmhttp://www.aip-bg.org/documents/belene.htmhttp://www.parliament.bg/bg/parliamentarycommittees/members/224/documents


16/75

16

, - . , , HSBC. , 2004 ., , , , , - .

. 45, . 2 . , :

, ;

- ;

, , .

.

, 4 .

. , . , .

, .

, , .

, .


17/75

17

1: 18

. , .

Overnight cost e , , , . - ( ) KW. .. ,

. - , , , :

2003 2005 . $ 1 250 (892,9) kW $2 500 (1785,7)/kW19

2007 2008 . $2300( 1 642,9)/kW $6000 (4285,7/kW, - $1400 (1 000)/kW() $4500( 3 214,3)/kW()

;

20

2009 . - $4500( 3 214,3)//kW $10500 (7 500)/kW);

21

18

Mark Cooper, The economics of nuclear reactors: Renaissance or Relapse, June 2009.

.

19

NuclearTechnologyReview2009. 27 2011 .: $1,4 = 1.20

Nucleonicsweek, February22, 2007.21

TheGlobalNuclear Fuel Market Supply and Demand 2009, September 2009.


18/75

18

,

- , , , ;

, , 6-8 . , 2004 2007 .

69,2% , - 60,3%, - 19,6%, - 11,6%, - 25 35%22. . Olkiluoto 3 2003 . 3 2008 . 4,5 23, 2009 .

5,3 24

. . 4

, 10 % 5 , 1 .

;

Overnight cost .. All-in Cost, ( )

.. Direct cost ( Bus bar cost), , , 1 :

(, , , , - , ,, .);

. 1000 MW 150 200 , ;

( , ,, .), , , .;

.Bus bar cost $c/kWh Euroc/kWh.

Overnight cost, Overnight cost $1000 ( 714,3) Busbar cost 1,8 2,4 $/kWh ( 1,29 1,71), 2,4 $ ( 1,71)/kWh25 3,0 ( 2,14) $/kWh26

22

Nucleonics week January 24, 2008.

. 2003 2009 . Overnight cost $2000 (

23

Nucleonics week December 25, 2008.24Nucleonics week September 3, 2009.

25: MIT.

26 .


19/75


20/75

20

2: /

2004 . ( .. )

( 7 )

7% + 1%

,

()

(50% ); -

()

600

. , ,

()

(620MW )

( ); ,

(500MW )

(, )

, - / .

,

50-60 . , . . . .

, - (), - , . . .

:


21/75

21

- ;- ;- ;- ;- ;- .

, - . , , .


22/75

22

. , , .. . - . 2020 2025 .

( 1)28

50- . 29

.

2:

80- , 20. 100 , . , , . 1, ,

, .

2011 . 442 375 GW30

28 , , .

.

29IAEA, International Conference on Opportunities and Challenges for Water Cooled Reactors in the 21st

Century, 27-30 October 2009, Vienna, Austria


23/75

23

- - 361 (82 % ), 920 MW 332,2 GW. 47 (10,6 % ), 490 MW - 23 GW (6,6%). - 18 - 15. , .

: (104), (58), (54), (32), (21) (19). 2011 . 14400 -31

(2010) 74,1 %, (2010) 29,2%, (2009) 20,2 %, (2009) 17,8 %, - - 2 %.

.

125 1- . 10 , 17 .

: -27 177 1988 . 143 2011 . 1- ( 2011 .) 1- 2- .

10

,

430 440, 360 - 370 GW. - .

3: ,

. / . , MW

. / . , MW

2010 5 / 3722 1 / 130

2009 2 / 1068 3 / 2506

2008 1 / 412

2007 3 / 1857

2006 2 / 1490 8 / 22362005 4 / 3821 2 / 940

2004 5 / 3885 5 / 1385

2003 2 / 1625 6 / 988

18 / 13746 25 / 8467

1990 . 2004 . 1900 TWh 2600 TWh. 36 % 7 % -

30IAEA http://www.iaea.or.at/programmes/a2/

31WNA http://www.world-nuclear.org/


24/75


25/75

25

4:

, :

: - . ,

, , , / .

: . . ,

, . ,

. . , .

: 50 %, 50 . 150 -200 34

34

Nucleonics week, February 22, 2007

( ).


26/75

26

: . , .

: , .

- 15.

: , . , 10- .

: 1 100 1 700MW (), , 6 000 MW. ;

(): (/ ) . , . 4 - .

134 30 , 327 20 . , 2030 . .

2011 . 65 62,8 GW, (41) . 4 48 (27), (11), (5) (5). 4 2 .

2009 . .

5:


27/75

27

2009 . , 2030 . 509 GW.

2009 . 2030 ., 810 GW 510 GW.

2009 .35

, 2030 . 500 GW . , , 11 2011 . . , .

, 2030 . 580 600 GW. 812 818 GW, 240 .

7879 . . 67 . , 10-11 . .

2009 . 50 772 , 2010 . - 55 . 36

2009 . 76 % . .. , ( 13 % ), . ,

, . 2014 2016 .,

.

.

- (, , ) 60 % 5 (, , ) 30 %.

, .

35 The Global Nuclear Fuel Market Supply and Demand 2009, September 2009

36WNAhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.html
http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/uprod.html


28/75

28

2004 . (spotprice) $20/,

. 2007 . $300/ 2010 . $100/

37

1987 2006 Ux U3O8 Prices

. 2010 2011 $100/.

( ) 5,5. . 70 .

50 %, 50 . , 5 ..38

, , 1,5 .

.

15 % -.

1000 , 20 . 95 %, 4 % 1 %. , , .

, ( ). , 50 .

100 . . 11.03.2011 . . 1 , . No 4 , .

, .

37http://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspx

38OECD/NEA and IAEA, Uranium 2007: Resources, Production and Demand, Paris (2008).
http://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspxhttp://www.uxc.com/review/uxc_Prices.aspx


29/75

29

, 11 . .

6 . , - 4 . ., , , , , .

2009 . 324 . . 95 . , 16 . 213 . .

1 111 39 115 40

. 100 . . . 100 .

, . 1 350 , .

.

, - / () . . . . 10 . . - 200 ..

., 50 ., 15 . 18 . ( 1982) Yucca Mountain, 153 . . $41 $67 ( 143 . )41

. $10 2010 . .

39WNA,http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.html .

40TRENDS IN THE NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE:ECONOMIC, ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL ASPECTS, NEA 2001NEA 2001

41WNA, High cost for US radwaste alternatives.
http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.htmlhttp://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf04.html


30/75

30

, 110 . 40 . , , 10 - (MOX) . 2007 .

250 . $1,1 42

.

- , 2030 .

500 GW

.

,

, 11 2011 . . , .

.

,

.

.

. .

, 2025 .

2003 - 2005 . , , .- , , .

2001 2010 . 56 %, .

42WNA, UK government eyes MOX use.


31/75

31

4: (2001-2010)43

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

( ) 15,55 17,03 18,37 20,39 23, 25 26, 48 30,77 35, 43 34,93 36,03

(TWh) 36,83 36,37 37,07 35,72 36,59 37,94 38,6 39,54 37,37 36,53

:

, , , .

- . 2008 . ,

. ( 5.)

644

:

, 2009 . . . , , KW, - .

43 .

44 .


32/75

32

5: () , TWh ( )

/ TWh

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2011 2015 2020 2025

10,05 9,16 9,20 9,70 9,84 10,10 10,20 10,86 8,43 8,30 9,10 9,45 9,57 5,15 5,64 6,00 5,63 6,19 6,93 7,07 7,783 7,68 7,21 7,26 7,31 7,38 0,44 0,45 0,44 0,42 0,41 0,40 0,37 0,35 0,44 7,21 7,26 7,31 7,38

0,16 0,16 0,18 0,15 0,19 0,20 0,21 0,28 0,24 0,20 0,21 0,21 0,22

9,75 9,30 9,30 8,80 9,10 9,30 9,38 10,25 10,31 9,40 9,40 9,40 9,45

25,55 24,71 25,12 24,70 25,73 26,93 27,23 29,47 27,10 25,50 26,37 26,78 27,04

11,28 11,66 11,73 10,82 10,71 10,84 10,95 10,07 10,27 10,99 10,94 10,98 11,04

36,83 36,37 36,85 35,52 36,44 37,77 38,18 39,54 37,37 36,49 37,31 37,76 38,08

. .

6:

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

% 44,1 47,2 46,7 43,8 41,6 40,3 40,2 34,1 37,9

- . , - .

, 89 % - . , 2020 . . . . 2008 . 5,65 - 6,29 - .

, , :

; ,

;

, , -, ..


33/75

33

11 , .

745

: 2010 2015 2020 2025

, TWh 36,45 37,24 37,75 38,10

, TWh 35,50 37,00 39,30 42,15

, MAX, TWh 36,63 39,11 42,09

, MIN, TWh 36,25 37,60 36,62

- 2020 . 39,3 TWh/2020 . , 2025 . , 2020 2030 . , 42,15 TWh/2025 . ,

.

- - 42,09 TWh / 2020 . 46

,

. , ,.. 2011 2020 .

.

, 15 . 20 .

, ,

,

, - ,

2001-2010 .

5,49 TWh 900 MW 6000 h. . - , 2000 MW 15 TWh . ,

47

45

.

427 MW - 3 ENEL, 264 TWh - 2 , ,

46 2020 .

36,62 TWh/2020 ., .. 2010 . 47

. 1 2. - 2 - 3 ENEL , , 3 4 -3, 4.3 (MAX1) 2020 .


34/75


35/75

35

7:

2005-2010 . TWh; 4000 MW ("" + "")

, 2005 - 2010 . , TWh. , , , . , . , .

. 1000MW , , , , - . , , , .

. , , , . ( , .)

, 1000 MW , . , 2025 2030 . 1000 MW

.

, , .

2015 ., 2012 . 2015 . (


36/75

36

). , 2015 . 36% 2009 . 38,4% 2015 ., 40%.49 , ( 50% )

.

50

1200 , 8,25 15- 12,35 . .

2010 ., .

, -6 700MW, 51

2006 . (

3 4 ) 5000 GWh .

, , . (18% ), . - 2018-2019 .

52 2008

.

.53

, , , , , ,

, , . , . 30% . , , ,

54

,

.

49 , 2015 . , 2004.

, . 31.50

, . 32. , , 2015 . .:Milovan Sudovic: Stanje i perspektive razvoja energetike u regionu Jugoistone Evrope, ELEKTROPRIVREDA,GODINALXIII, BROJ4, 2010, str. 37638651

.:www.EconomyNews.bg 29 2010 .52

. (). . . , , 2009, . 71.53

.54

.
http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/http://www.economynews.bg/


37/75

37

1.

, 70- . , (150 ). .

, 4- 1977 . 1400 . . ( 10,5 ) , 120 , .

7,2 7,6 MSK-64. , . 500-/06.11.1984 .55

1990 .

. , , 400 300 , . , 1983 . .

56

1990 . , . 2006 . . , , -

50

(.. ) . , , . .

57

-

. .

58

55

SeismicrisksintheBeleneNuclearProject, P. Kovachev, J. Havercamp, 12.02.2008

: , . , . . , , . . ,

56

(). , , , 1990.57

:http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=74658

01.05.2009 . , http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861
http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861http://www.focus-news.net/?id=f11861http://www.nek.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=746


38/75

38

, , , .

- ( 475 , ), 59

.

, , , - . , (, .) - ( 100 . ), - .

0,24 g60

, -1200/MIR-1200 e - (0,25 g). - .

, 0,15 g ( 10000 ). ,

- .

59European Seismological Commission

http://wija.ija.csic.es/gt/earthquakes/imatges/ESC-SESAME_poster_A4_75q.jpg60

- , , 2004


39/75

39

, .

2007 . . - - - . ,

. . 2009 . - . .

11 2011 . 11 . -1 55 . , , . . , . , 1 - 4. , , 10% . . . , . - 1986 . 20 2011 . 5 7- INES,

6.

$100 , -1, , , , , .

, , .

2.

. .

, AES-92. -1000 -1200/MIR-1200, .

,

. - AES-91 Tianwan (), .


40/75

40

2 . - Kudankulam - .

AES-92 , .

61

AES-92 .

. .

AES-92 EUR (European Utility Requirements). , 16 , . , . , , , ..

. AES-92.

2009 ., . 2011 . 62

, , 2010 . " , , ", .

3.

.

, .

5 6 . .

1 2006 . 5- . , . , . .

Tianwan . 700 ,

61.: IAEA-TECDOC-1391 Status of advanced light water reactor designs 2004

6216.02.2011 .


41/75

41

.63

Bushehr . 2011 . ,

. ,

, .

64

, . . (Olkiluoto 3) , . . RWE Power .

.

, , , 65

.

66

5- , ..

, .

,

. . -.

90- . - , . .

2008 2009 . 2000 - , , .. , , , . . .. , . - .

63

Nucleonics Week, September 29, 2005, Nucleonics Week, April 13, 200664WNA, Nuclear power in Iran, updated 04.03.2011

6521.12.2009 . , -

6603.12.2008 . , 300 2009 .


42/75

42

- ( ) 67

, .

, . , . .

.

4.

, , . - , , , .

4.1.

6-7 . 1990 . , .

.

4.2.

, . . 2006 . , . . 22 , ... .

. 2008 ., . . ( ) .

4.3. ()

, . , , ( ) , 10-15 % . , , . - ,

6712.10.2009 . http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157306
http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157306http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157306http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157306http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157306


43/75

43

. .

.

, .... 68

1995 .

.

.69.

1999 . , 15% . 2005 . , 6- 5,2 70. , . . , 1- 78 71

2010 . 1,050 . 2005 . 5,2 ( ) 10 - .

.

72

5,2 6- - , ;

. :

;

.

, 2007 . . .

5.

. , :

, 1977 . . 1997 . ,

68 , 21.10.2005, 40- , 40-

69

70 , 2005 ., . 40

71

, 17.07.2009 ., http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15454472Comparison of Different Decommissioning Fund Methodologies for Nuclear Installations, Country Report

Bulgaria, 2007,http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_id=167&bid=43&searchart=projekt_uebersicht
http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?projekt_id=167&mzAdd=167&cType=3&pid=&searchart=projekt_uebersicht%29http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?projekt_id=167&mzAdd=167&cType=3&pid=&searchart=projekt_uebersicht%29http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?projekt_id=167&mzAdd=167&cType=3&pid=&searchart=projekt_uebersicht%29http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?&projekt_http://www.wupperinst.org/en/projects/proj/index.html?projekt_id=167&mzAdd=167&cType=3&pid=&searchart=projekt_uebersicht%29


44/75

44

360 . 2003 ., .

, 1963 . . . 570 73

1988 .

. 2004 .

1,5 , .

1997 . , 360 ( ).

:

: , 2,5 ;

: 5 160 1,2 74

: 2005 . 700 , .

.

: 600 , 2010 . ;

: 1957 . $10 ;: $350 .

96 ( 49 ). .

, , .

1.

. 15-20 , .75

73

WNA, Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage, November 2009http://www.world-nuclear.org74World Nuclear Association

75 Barry Buzan, Ole Wver, and Jaap de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Boulder

CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers 1998.)
http://www.world-nuclear.org/http://www.world-nuclear.org/http://www.world-nuclear.org/http://www.world-nuclear.org/http://www.world-nuclear.org/http://www.world-nuclear.org/


45/75

45

, , , . .

, . , .

76

. , , .

, .

- 2001 , .

. , , 2002, 2003, 2005,2006 ., 2009 .

2005 , . . - .

, . . . , , 1/3 . .

. , 5%

76Barton, Barry, et al.Energy security: managing risk in adynamic and regulatory environment. Oxford: Oxford

University Press, 2004.


46/75

46

, ( Centre for Strategicand International Studies 7%). , .

.

. . , . , , . . , .

, -

, .

, . , ( , ) .

, , . , .77

2.

, .

. , 2010 50% . -, 60-65%. , . .

77Operational Programmeof the Council for 2005 submitted by the Incoming Luxembourg and United Kingdom

Presidencies [online], Brussels, December 2004 [cit. 2007-04-29]. Accessible at WWW:http://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/UK-Lux%20prog.pdf.
http://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/UK-Lux%20prog.pdfhttp://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/UK-Lux%20prog.pdfhttp://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/UK-Lux%20prog.pdfhttp://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/UK-Lux%20prog.pdfhttp://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/UK-Lux%20prog.pdf


47/75

47

, ( ),

, .

, .

20-20-20, 2020 20% 20% .

, .

, Eurostat,

, , . , , , , , . , 90% ( ).

, OECD,

, . . .

, , . , .

, . . , - .

? , .

. (- ) , ( ) .


48/75

48

Westinghouse , . , .

3.

, . 50% (.. ) 70% (.. ). , 71% .78

,

, , Eurostat.

, - 80%.

, , . ? ( OECD) . ( ) . , , 51% . , . , , 4 6 .

, , 10-15% . "" , (.. ) (.. ).

, ,

, .

, . , .

, . ? , .

78. , . ., . 73.


49/75

49

, , . , ( ) , 1 . 620 . , .

, 20 (.. 2011 .), .

, . ? 20 , ? , - ?

. . , . ( , ) , . , , , , , - . .

, , , . , , , ( ) ( ).

.

, . , , .

( ) . , . .

( ) ,

( ) . .


50/75

50

, , , , , ,

, , .

, .

- 80% ;

- 76,7% , ;

- 71,4% ( );

- , , ( 15 ) ;

- / 1000 , 2 ;

- 1000 (- ).

KW

50- , , .

8: /

6,3

( 7 )

1,764 7% + 1%

0,50

0,70


51/75

51

0,75

(50% )

600

0,35. ,

,

(620 MW )

0,35 ( )

(500MW)

0,45

0,50

11,664 -

3 ( 10 ) 600 , . 9,264 .

, AE 2030 . 44,5 KWh, 1300 MW 1850 KWhe , , [ ;

4, 10 .79

KW

( ), , . , , , 40-50% .

. .

9:

KW 1 2

14 14.6

(~) 27,3 28,5

1 KW ,

.

79 . . . . 73.


52/75

52

()

.

,

, , . ( , - .)

, , , ,, , , .., , ,

, , . , .. .80

14.5 TWh. , , , , . , . 28,6 . - 37,6 - , .

, , .

, :

50 .80

, ; , , ( ) .


53/75

53

, .

KWh 2% . , ,

, 2% . 25 8%

8% . 6%

.

4% , 25 . , 50% ,

50% 25.

. .

( ), .

, , - , - - , .

, , .

14,5 KWh. 11,85

, , , , , , 2, , 620 MW (), 500 MW (), .

(, , , ) 2.86 .


54/75

54

. 4,2 .

KWh .

, , . .

=n

iiwr

1

*

:

- ,-

ir i,

-i

w i .

6%. 10%. 51%, 49%,

8% . 8%.

, 6%. 6% .

, , . 8%, 6%.

- 9,54 1 KWh .


55/75

55

8%.

8 6 1KWh. 1,2 9 1KWh.

9.54 1KWh . 8%, .

9,54 1 KWh . , 10 1 KWh 1 .

8:

8%

1 KWh

: .


56/75

56

( )

9:

6%

1 KWh

: .

- 8,46 1 KWh . 8%.

2,3 6 1KWH. 450 8 1KWh.

8.46 1KWh . 6%, .

8,46 1 KWh . , 9 1 KWh 540 .


57/75

57

10: ( ) 1KWh ,

.

: .

1 KWh .

8% 9,54 1 KWh.

4% 1 KWh 6,27 , 1 KWh .


58/75

58

11: ( ) 1KWh ,

: .

6% 8.46 1 KWh.

4% 1 KWh 6.32 , 1 KWh .

,

1 KWh 8%

6%

.

10:

KWh ( )

( )

\ 0,06 0,07 0,08 0,09 0,10 0,11 0,12

4% -1 189,2 3 314,9 7 819,1 12 323,2 16 827,3 21 331,5 25 835,6

5% -3 766,9 -68,0 3 630,8 7 329,7 11 028,6 14 727,4 18 426,3

6% -5 638,9 -2 543,6 551,8 3 647,1 6 742,4 9 837,7 12 933,0

7% -7 016,8 -4 381,8 -1 746,8 888,3 3 523,3 6 158,3 8 793,3

8% -8 044,6 -5 766,7 -3 488,7 -1 210,7 1 067,3 3 345,3 5 623,2


59/75

59

9% -8 821,3 -6 824,9 -4 828,5 -2 832,0 -835,6 1 160,9 3 157,3

10% -9 415,7 -7 644,8 -5 873,8 -4 102,9 -2 331,9 -561,0 1 210,0

: .

11: KWh ( )

( ) .

\ 0,06 0,07 0,08 0,09 0,10 0,11 0,12

4% -484,7 1 095,3 2 723,6 4 398,1 6 114,0 7 839,7 9 565,4

5% -1 555,8 -365,6 868,4 2 146,1 3 464,1 4 791,7 6 119,3

6% -2 303,9 -1 396,3 -448,9 539,7 1 567,6 2 605,1 3 642,5

7% -2 831,3 -2 131,2 -1 394,8 -619,5 194,1 1 017,1 1 840,1

8% -3 206,4 -2 660,5 -2 081,5 -1 465,7 -812,6 -150,1 512,3

9% -3 475,5 -3 045,5 -2 585,3 -2 090,3 -1 558,8 -1 018,2 -477,5

10% -3 670,2 -3 328,3 -2 958,8 -2 556,4 -2 118,4 -1 671,3 -1 224,2

: .


60/75

60

. 45, . 2 , .

- .

, . , .

KWh . , . , .

2020

. 2025 . 1 2 , , , , .

15 % - , 2025 .

, , - , , , - ,

.

:

- 5 6( 20),

- , , -3, 3 4.

, -.

, - .

:

, , , ?

(, -, 400 kV, ..),

280 ?

5,0 TWh/2020 ., ?


61/75

61

, ,

,

, ,

,

?


62/75


63/75

63

3:

2010 - 2020 .81

)

. (MAX) (MIN). - 2020 . 42,09 TWh, 36,6 TWh. 2025 . .

, , . 5,49 TWh 900 MW 6000 h. - -

. , 2000 MW 15 TWh

. . . . 3.1 , 10 15 , ( .......). , , , -3 .

2025 . ,

.

;

. , 2750 MW/2020 . 206 MW, 3875 MW/2025 . 291 MW. . 1800 MW /2020 . 600 MW /2020 .,

2,71 TWh/2020 .

350 MW -

7000 h .

. 10 6 . 4 , :

2 128 MW. , - 25 30 % , - . , - , ( ). ,

81) .


64/75

64

,

.

2 2000 MW.

. 4.2 (MAX1) , 427 MW - 3 ENEL , , 3 4 -3, 2020 . 2758 MW.

. 4.2 (MAX2) , - 2020 ., , -.

. 4.3 (MAX1) -

2020 .:

- 2, , 9,40 TWh/2020 . 6,76 TWh/2020 . (-2,64 TWh);

- 3 ENEL, , 5,98 TWh/2020 . 1,27 TWh/2020 . (-4,71 TWh);

, , 3 4 -3. - 2 - 3, 2,680 TWh/2020 .

4,74 TWh/2020 .

. 4.3 (MAX2) , 2020 . , 4,74 TWh/2020 .

, ,

2020 .

2, 2025 .


65/75

65

4: :

2025 .

,

,

, ,

, ,

, ,

, ..

, .

, - , ; , , -, ..

, , - , . 2025 .

1 2

2025 . : , 15 . ( ); - , .

2025 .

1.

1.1.

1260 MW. . - NOx. - . 60 kt.

15, ,

, , ( 50 100 % N n


66/75

66

), .

: , , ,

1 3, 4 6 , , , . 2500 - 6000 h 1000 - 1200 MW ; .

1.2. ( 3 4)

220 MW, - . NOx. . .

3 4 15 , , , , ( 50 100 % N n) , .

: -, , , , , , .

2500 - 6000 h 180 - 200 MW ; .

2.

2.1.

630 MW. , 570 MW. . -

. - 15 , ,


67/75

67

, , ( 50 100 % N n ), - , , ().

: -

, NOx, - , , , .

, 2500 6000 h 500/570 MW ; .

3.

3.1. -S

- S 670 MW. - . - . - S - , , .

6000 - 7000 h 670 MW ; .

3.2. -ENEL

- ENEL 908 MW. . -

- 400 kV .

- ENEL 2006 2009 . - 15 , ; .

: , , , , ; ( ).

6000 - 7000 h 900 MW


68/75

68

; .

3.3. - 2

- 2 1580 MW. . - .

- 2 2005 2011 . 15 , ; - .

, , , - ; 1 - 4 -- - , 6 8 . , - 1 4, 7 8, 5 6 .

6000 6500 h 1500MW ; .

3.4. -3

-3 120 MW. -

, , .

2005 . . - . , 10 .

- , .

4000 h

100 110 MW .

4.

, .

5. , . GT

4500 h 390 MW .


69/75


70/75


71/75

71

5: .. 1000

2008


72/75

72

6:

70-83

. 1979 25 , ,

, .

57 (). 7,5 , 100 , 4 10,5 . 2702 . . 150 8 . .

20 1981 . . 1981 1987 . 4 -1000/V-320. 1985.

, , , . 1987 . . 1989 . 1- 13,2 ., 40 %.

1990 . . 1991 . . .

1996 . . 1997 . . 1998 . , .

2002 .: 6 , 84. 1991 . 85

2003 .: - 5 . - Parsons Europe .

.

83

http://www.bnra.bg/bg/documents/conventions/reports/cns-reports8406.04.2002 . http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=1591885

http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15918http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15918http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15918http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15918http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15918http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=36752http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=36752http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=36752http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=15918


73/75

73

2004 .: - 86. - e . - ParsonsEurope -87

2005 . : - " "

" "

.

88

. - No260 2000 MW89. - ,

90

2006 .: - . - ,

.

91. AES-92 -1000/B466 2120 MW, "a . - , 92

2007 .: - 250 . - . BNPPariba, . 2008 . 600 . - .

( ). - 49 % , .

2008 .: - ASE 4 . - BNP Pariba . - . - 300 93

2009 .: - 400

600 2009 .;

" a . RWE Power

94. Electrabel RWE Power95. 3,9 . , .

2030%. - ""96. RWE Power 97

2010 .: ,

. - Pariba BNP ; , .

98

86

03.05.2004 .

. , ,

http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=10241687


- http://www.NEC.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=35489




- http://www.NEC.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.doc93

23.10.2008 . http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=145007 94

24.09.2009, - 95

19.02.2009 . http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=149225 96

23.10.2009 . http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157775 9728.10.2009 . http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157966 98

http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=102416http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=102416http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=102416http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=102416http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=102416http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=31695http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=31695http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=31695http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=145007http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=145007http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=145007http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=149225http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=149225http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=149225http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157775http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157775http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157775http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157966http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157966http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157966http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=161033http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=161033http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=161033http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=161033http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157966http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=157775http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=149225http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=145007http://www.nec.bg/tender/InfoRequest-ENG.dochttp://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1241http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1221http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=2&d=1219http://www.nec.bg/cgi-bin/index.cgi?l=1&d=354http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=31695http://www.mediapool.bg/show/?storyid=102416


74/75

74

800 . - , 1 99; , , , 100; "" "" "" 101;

, "" 102. - 103, 2011 . 104, - ""105; 6,3 . 106; "" "" 107; - " "", . .108; 8.5 9 ."109; HSBC ; : -51 %, 47 %,

"Altran" Fortum- 1 %110. ; 111

2011 .: -

.

112

5, "" , .

, . "", 18 .

.

" " . :

3 5 - , 12 - 52 - , .113

, 10 - ;

114

99

09.06.2010 . 100

11.06. 2010 . 10118.06.2010 .

10218.06.2010 . -

10331.07.2010 .

10413.10.2010 vsekiden.com

10502.11.2010 .

10613.11.2010 vsekiden. com

10709.11.2010 .

10824 2010 .

10926.11.2010 . vsekiden.com

11030.11.2010 .

111guardian.co.uk, Monday 20 December 2010http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-

documents/21540411216.02.2011 . 113

http://business.actualno.com/news_337970.html.
http://business.actualno.com/go.php?id=2073http://business.actualno.com/go.php?id=2073http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://business.actualno.com/news_337970.htmlhttp://business.actualno.com/news_337970.htmlhttp://business.actualno.com/news_337970.htmlhttp://business.actualno.com/news_337970.htmlhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/us-embassy-cables-documents/215404http://business.actualno.com/go.php?id=2073


75/75

22, , , 20 . , , , 20

, 40 , "".115

23: :

, , ..

E :

, , "" . "" - - .

"" 5 6 "", 5-6 . "" 1 3 ( 15.), - , .

"" - 51% , , , 4%. 10., 60. .

7 "" "". - 15.

"" -

. 116
http://business.actualno.com/news_336743.htmlhttp://business.actualno.com/news_336743.html

nps belene assesment wtd

Documents