open research: home...ehg c, 2xwr) `k * m_[x[zlk cfehrsi\vyx`zncfehg " qilkmi humc]kmr g ifg...

22

Upload: others

Post on 02-Mar-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� ��������� �

� � ���!��� ������

� ��� � s\bQ68/N* o0<cb8(+/2s

� " OiC]K� KMILKH_)CFEHGNX[PHILGJZ .�� CFKMX� ������HU�ZLGJUHO � C]K X�SR G CFEHXqUHI�UHGJI �JZLKMP~GJU K C]EHG �HZLG�.qKMX`OHI� E����QCFGJZ��9CFEHG ��� � O ��U�� C � IFG C-�!�`I R)�`UHG ZLG �`U " VYX[Z0C]EHG R)�`K� �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� �������"qILKMI %��EHX`C]X`RSG C]Z " KMI�X`V�O �HR X[ILCaK R)�~X[ZLC��� � G ��C]EQG^X`OQC��HOiC R OHILCaP~G^X V�IFO )� KMG� C$ O���� K C,"wCFXZFX[OiC]KQG ��"SUHG C]G � CNC]EHG IFR)�������yI � ��� GaCFZ���QIFK C�VYG � C]OQZFGJINK� �&��`ZF_`G0G HX`OH_[EmI��`R � �MG)X`V�I=C �`ZLIC]XSR ��� G C]EQG ZFG IFO �TC]I0I=C � CFKMI=C]K� �����" ZLX[PHOHI=C %0B I C]EQG UHG �iC]E X`V � � X`C-4`O �HK CFGJZaC]Z���HIFKTC)K IX� ��" G����~G � CFGJU CFX P~G#� 7 % 7 2 8 � 7 % 7#1 R)�`_�QK C]OQUHGJI��3�QZFG � KMILG ZLG � � C]K�.`G �HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6"�K�C]EHG IFG�JZLX �NUQGJU �HG �MUQI K I-HG � GJIFI��`Z "�% �, � ZFG � IFGJU �JZFX �NUHK�H_ � �NEHK� G&���� X �NKH_ � � � ZF_[G Z-qOQR P{G ZX`VrILC��`ZFI0CFXWP{G I��`R � �MG U �cILKMR O � C ��HGJX[OQI���"mE�� I)C]EHG O QVYX[ZLCFO �� CFG IFK UHG�� G��{G � C X`V �HZFX .qKMU3�KH_ �MG IFI^C]E���!I�� CFKMI=V ��� CFX[Z " �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZ "���O � GJILI � � ZFG KMI C ��� G K��K CFI �QZFXqUHO � CFKMX� % � CKMI:K R)�~X[ZLC��� C0C]XmUHK I��JOQIFI C]EHG�ZFG�� � CFK�.`G RSG ZFK CFI:X`VkCFEHG�UHK��{GJZLG C �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� R G CFEHXiUQI� .�� K� � P �MG C]XhZFG IFG �`Z�� EHG ZFI���K� X[ZFUHG Z0C]X � EHXqX[IFG CFEHG&�JX[ZLZFG�� C R G C]EQXiU CFXmP~GJI=C RSG G C:CFEHGC]EHG IFK I��`K RSI�% � G HG Z�������"�I��~G ���qK�H_ � C]EHG ZFG5�`ZFGaC]EHZLGJG)R G CFEHXqUHI�� .��`K��`P � G�� ���~GJZ=C]OHZLG5�HEHX �C]X[R G CFZ "�����X[K� C ���HZFG �`U)';O � CFKMX� � � ��' � �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ " � �qC]G C]ILX� 2 ) ��� � � ��HU �0K��{GJZLG � G�yR � _[KH_ � B � �`ZLU � �'O �iC]X� 2�) ) ���/!X ���HK ��� 1�7�7�7�� % � ��� E�RSG C]EHXqU E��`I�KTC]I�P~G QG��HCFI ��HUUHKMI��`U .��� C � _[GJI�����HU C]EHG IFG�� ZFGkUQGJI�� ZFK P{G U P{G VYX[ZFG2UHGJI �JZLKMPHK�H_ CFEHG���� C]O����qR G CFEHXqU � EHX[ILG ��HUhK CFI ��� � � K� � C]K X�wC]X�C]EQG^U � C �`ILG C %

� �JG�CFEHG�C]X`C����`CFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJIcU�� C � IFG C9K I X[PQC��`KQGJU:C]EHZLX[OH_[E:CFEHKMI �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]ZFK���R G C]EQXiU �C]EHGWILG �`Z � E VYX[Z � � ��QG C � Z "�CFZ���QIFK CFI&��HU0.��`ZFK�`P � GwILC��`ZFI&� ���P{G _[K %�B)I C]EQKMI U�� C��`IFG CK#.[X���.[G I�IFO � E)�-� �`ZL_[G! OHR P{G Z�X`V;C]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I ��� X[R �HOQC � C]KMX�����qRSG C]EHXqUHI�R OHI=C�P~G�OHIFG U %/�EHK� G K C K I-�{X[ILIFK P �MG CFX R)�� O�������"*�MXqX�� � C^G ��� E � KM_[E C�� OHZ .`G VYX[Z:C]Z���HIFKTC ��HU .��`ZFK�`P �MGILC��`ZkILKM_��� C]OHZLGJI � C]EQKMI �2X[O � USC����`G-��wO QVYG �`IFK P ��" � X�H_ C]KMR G ��HUwKTCkK I � K� G ��" CFE�� CkR ��#"� ��QUHKMU�� C]GJI �2X[O � U P{G�R KMILIFGJU UHOQG�C]XNE OHR ��:GJZFZLX[Z %�� ":OQIFKQ_��JX[R �HOQC�� C]K X����� RSG C]EHXqUHI �C]EHGwUHG CFG � CFKMX��G� �JK G ��"0��HU CFEHG ZLGJIFO � C]I C]EHG RSILG ��.`GJI � �� P~G ILC�� C]K ILC]K�� ������" �������"qILGJU��HU � X� ���MOHILKMX�HI2R � UHG �`I2C]X CFEHG0G��{G � C]K�.[G QGJIFI�X V'C]EHG0ILG �`Z � EhRSG C]EHXqU)�NKTC]EwCFEHG)C]EQGJIFK I�`KMR I�KSRSK�HU % � X �`OQC]X`R � CFG�C]EHGNC]Z���HIFKTCdIFG � Z�� E �HZLX�� GJIFI2KMI�C]EQGJZFG VYX[ZFG X�HGaX`V CFEHG R X[I=CKMR �{X`ZLC �� C^I=C]G �QI O HUHG ZLC����`G��UQOHZFK�H_ CFEHG �JX`OHZFILG X`V\CFEHKMI �kX[Z � � ��HU�CFEHG ��� _[X[ZLK C]EQRSI�HZFXqUHO � GJUhC]X�UHX�C]EHK I �`ZFG UHG I�� ZFKMP~GJUmKhUHG C �`K�� KhILOHPHIFG� OHG C � E ���QC]G ZFI�%

Page 2: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

� EHG C,�2XwR)�`K�*���M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG �������"qILKMI ��HUmC]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG INIFG � Z�� E I=C]G �QI �`ZLG^CFEHGIFG �`Z�� E�VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR � CFX��yEHK _[E �`R)� �MK CFOHUHG .��`ZFK�`P �MGmILC��`ZFI ��HU C]EHG ILG �`Z � EeVYX[Z �MX ��� C]X��RSG UHKMOQR �`R � �MKTC]OHUQG C]Z���HIFKTC:VYG � CFOHZFG I % � EHG ZFG KMI:G����~G � C]GJU!C]XhP{G � �MKTCFC��MG X .`GJZ����� P{G �C,�kG G C]EHG C,�2X % B)I:CFEHG C]Z���HIFKTC �`R � �MKTC]OHUHG KMI-� X[R)� �`Z��`P �MG CFXhCFEHG HX[K IFG � G�.[G���K CFEHGU�� C�� �kG I��~G �JK�����" VYX[Z V �`K� C I=C �`ZLI ��G��qCFG HILK�.[G � X� C]G ���`Z�� X!ILKMR O � � CFKMX�HI �kG ZFG O HUHGJZ �C ��� G CFX G HILOHZFG CFE�� C C]EHG � XiUQG �JX`O �MU UQG C]G�� C CFEHGSVYG � C]OHZLGJI ILEHX[O � U�C]EQG�" P~G �QZFGJILG CK CFEHG U�� C�� % � C VYX��� X �NI C]E � C ��HUQKH_ � CFZ���HILK C K C]EQG U�� C�� KMI � R O � E�G �`IFK GJZ C��`I��C]E��� �HZLX .iK�H_ C]EHG .qK �`PQK�MKTC,"�X V-� HX��� UHG CFG � C]KMX� % /�EQG CFEHGJILG C,�2X+�QZFX[_[Z��`R I E�� .[GP{G G IFO ���JG IFILVYO ���" ��� � � KMGJU C]X C]EQG U � C �`ILG C � � ������ � KMI=C0X`V .��`ZFK�`P �MG^ILC��`ZFI ��QU CFZ���QIFK C� ��QUHKMU�� C]GJIrK I �HZFXqUHO � GJU %�B " CFZ���QIFK C � ��HUHK U�� CFGJI � ���C]EQG wP~GNIFOHP �LG � CFGJUwCFX:VYX��� X �NO �X[PHILGJZ .�� CFKMX�QINCFX�UHG CFGJZFR KQG0C]EHG KMZ��MK��`G���" � C]OHZLG�%

� �`ZFK�`P � GWILC � ZFI)�`ZFG*�� K� C]ZFK�HIFK��WIFK UHG�� �HZFXqUHO � CwX`V ��#"�IFG � Z�� E VYX[Z&� X � �`R)� �MK CFOHUHGPHZFK _[E C�HG IFI .��`ZFK� C]K X�HI^K I=C]G ��� �`Z I "qILCFGJR I % /!GWE�� .[GhOHILGJU � V �`ILC VYX[OQZFKMG Z C]Z���HI=VYX[ZFRX`VrC]EHG C]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I CFXWKMUHG� CFK V "mX[P#.qKMX[OQI-�{G ZFKMXqUHK�� ��� CFC]G Z�HI�% B #" �~GJZFK XiUQK�JKTC,"hKMI0_`K�.[G�� ��� " �`I!� ILC]ZLX�H_ I��HK��`G)K�SCFEHG)X[OiC��HOQC!�{X �2GJZ2I��~G � CFZFOHR % � EHK I .`GJZ ")�JX`RSR X� RSG C]EHXqUX`V�.��`ZLK �`P �MG:ILC��`ZaUHG CFG � CFKMX�mKMINUHK I�� OHIFILGJU �`I �`ZLG X`CFEHGJZ �!� "qI X`V�K UHG C]KTV "qKH_ .��`ZFK�`PHK��MK C,"�%'8X[Z�C]EHG^R � KWC]Z���HIFKTCaIFG � Z�� E � �&.`GJZ "mI �{G��JK�� � R G C]EQXiU ��� I5�HZLXiUHO �JGJUmC]E�� C5� X[R)� �`ZFG IG ��� E�C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI �NK C]E � ILKM_�HK+��� �� C qOQR P{G Z X`V ��� �HZLX��HZLK � CFGwC]Z���HIFKTC R XiUHG��MI���OHIFK�H_�JZLX[IFI �,�JX`ZFZFG�� � CFKMX� C]G�� E HK� qOQGJI % B)_#�`K� � � UHG C]G � C]K X� KMI^_[K�.[G � ��� " �`I �mI��HK��`G K� CFEHGX[OQC��HOQC � C�C]EQG CFZFOHG �~GJZLKMXqU %� EHKMI � E����iC]GJZwUHKMI �JOHILIFGJI CFEHG I=C]G��HI HG��JGJILI��`Z6"�� ��HU O HUHG ZLC ���`G �aCFX�_[X VYZFX[R CFEHG

ZFG UHO �JG U KMR)�`_[G U�� C��`IFG C)CFX �SCFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJINU�� C �`P�� IFG�� ��HU CFEHG �������"qILKMIaO HUHG ZLC ���`G CFXUHG CFG � C .�� ZFK � P �MGdILC��`ZFI�% � EHG�ILG �`Z � E�VYX`Z�C]Z���HILK C]I�KMIAC]EHG\ILOHP �LG�� CrX`V~IFOQPHIFG� qOQG C � E����QCFGJZFI�%

�iG � C]K X� 1 �HZFG IFG CFI �WUHK I�� OHIFILKMX� X`VrC]EQG ZFG �� C]K�.[G R GJZLK CFI-��HU UHK I��`U .��� C��`_[GJI � IFIFX ��JK� C]G U �NK CFEwC]EHG C]EHZLGJG:R)�`K �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� RSG C]EHXqUHI�� .��`K�� �`P � G � ���~GJZLCFOHZFG5�HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6" ��HZFX'���MG �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ " �3��HUwUQK��{GJZFG� �JGaKMR)�`_[K�H_ ����HU�C]EHGaIFOHPQIFG� OHG� C�ZFG �`IFX�QIdVYX[Z � EHXqX[I �KH_ UHK��{GJZLG � G)K R �`_`KH_:C]X �HZFXqUHO � G)C]EQG C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJIdK C]EHG$��� � O �0U�� C �`ILG C % �qG � CFKMX� �UHGJI �JZLKMP~GJI�CFEHG!��� � �MK�� � CFKMX� X`VQC]EHK I�R G CFEHXiU^C]XaC]EHGdU�� C��`IFG C�K CFIFG�� V � �MKMI=C]K�H_�C]EHG2R �`K� ILC]G��HIO HUHG ZLC����`G�0��HU C]EQG � �����ZFG IFO �TC]K�H_WC]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I:U�� C��`P��`ILG�% �iG � C]K X� � UHG I�� ZFKMP~GJI:CFEHG��� CFO���� �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� �HZFG��JK IFKMX� KmC]EHG ������9C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJIaU�� C��`P��`ILG�� ��HU K CFI ILO �JK G ��"VYX[Z�C]EHG^UHG C]G � CFCFKMX� X`V �aX`C54`O �HK CFGJZ�C]Z���HILK CaIFK _����� I % �qG � CFKMX� 8 �HZFG IFG CFI-� UQGJI�� ZFK��QC]K X�X`VAC]EHG '8X[OHZLKMGJZ � Z���HILVYX`ZFR � �9X`R P�� �3� �`ZL_��MG��AGJZLKMXqUHX[_[Z��`R � �HZFX[_`Z��`R3C]E�� C��!�`IaOHIFG UmCFXUHG CFG � CkR GJUHK OHR � C]X �yEHK _[E �`R � � K C]OQUHG!.��`ZFK�`P � G\ILC��`ZFIdK C]EQGaU � C �`ILG C % �iG � C]K X� � �HZLGJIFG� C]IC]EHG � E����iC]GJZSIFOHR R)�`Z " ��HU � X� � � OHIFK X� � �NEHK� E �MG � UHI�K C]X C]EHG �HZLGJIFG� C � CFKMX� X`V)CFEHG��� CFO���� .��`ZLK �`P � G0ILC��`Z�� � C ��� X[_[OHG�%

Page 3: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��k� � �

� � � g�.0/�bH/21 7'bQ6;(+< � 7 b8.0/N*:4

� EHG0� EHX`K�JG�X`V�C]EHG � X[ZFZLG � C �HEHX`CFX[RSG C]ZLK� RSG C]EHXqUxC]X ��� � ��"pC]X C]EHG CFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJIU�� C��`IFG C KMI X V�C]EHGWO �QRSX[I=C KMR �~X[ZLC��� �JG K R)� �iKMR K � KH_WCFEHG OHR P~GJZ X`V �aX`C 4`O �HKTC]G ZC]Z���HIFKTC\UHG C]G�� C]K X�HI�� �`I!�2G ��� �`IkR ��� K�H_ CFEHG# O���� K C," X`V'C]EQG)C]K RSG �yIFG ZFK GJI �`I\EHK _[E �`I��~X[I �IFK P �MG�% B I ��� � O � K I �� G��qCFG HILK�.[G���" � ZFX �NUHGJU X[P �LG�� C � � ZFX �NUHK�H_hR OHILC0P{G C����`G�!K� CFX�JX�QIFKMUQGJZ�� C]KMX�*�NEHG� R ��� K�H_ CFEHG � EHX`K�JG�% � EQZFGJG �{X[ILIFK P �MG ��� �HZLX#��� EHG I-�`ZFG UHKMI �JOHILIFG U �K ���MOHUQKH_ CFEHGJK Z�ZFG�� � CFK�.[G:R GJZLK CFI ��HUmUHKMI��`U .��� C �`_`GJI %

��� ���*� � � � � ��� ����� ���#� ��� � � ���

� EHG ILKMR � �MG ILC ��� " CFX �~GJZLVYX`ZFR �HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6"mX� ILCFG ���`ZaKMR)�`_[GJIaKMIaC]X OQIFG ���~GJZ=C]OHZLG�HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6"��HK� �NEHK� E*� �JKMZ �JO ��`Z ���~GJZ=C]OHZLG^X V�UHG���HG U Z�� UHKMOHI�K I�� � ���JGJUmX .[G ZNCFEHG ILC��`Z� CFEHG-�{X`IFK CFKMX�WX V �NEHK�� E K I\VYX[O HUWVYZLX[R � �HZLG�.qKMX[OQI �HO�� �yR G �`ILOHZFK�H_&�HZFX[_`Z��`R � ��HUWCFEHGC]X`C����� OHR P~GJZ�X`V5�JX[O CFISK�HIFK UHG C]E � C ���~GJZLCFOHZFGmKMI � ���� O � � C]GJU % �!�MG � Z���"��dCFEHGhUHG�� HGJUZ��`UQKMOHIhX`V^C]EHG+���~GJZ=C]OHZLG!R OQILCmP{G X��QCFKMR KMILGJU � ��HU%E��`I ��pG��{G � C X��C]EHG ZFG IFO �TC]KQ_IFK _����� � C]X �,HX[K IFGNZ�� C]KMX %�B5hG ILC]K R � C]G)X VACFEHG0I � " �MG�.`G �{KMI���� IFX VYX`O HU �NK CFEwC]EHK I\R G C]EQXiU ���HU K I0IFOHPiC]Z���� C]G U VYZLX[R C]EHG CFX`C ��� �JX[O C � G�.`G � �cOHIFK�H_ � IFG��JX�HU+�� O � OHI �NK CFE � �`ZL_[GJZZ��`UQKMOHI\CFE���WC]EHG#�HZFILC % �kZFX �NUHKQ_SE�� I �� �`U .[G ZFILG G��cG�� C �NEHG OHIFK�H_ C]EHK I�RSG C]EHXqU � �`I�MK _[E C:VYZFX[R HG KM_[E P~X[OHZFK�H_mILC � ZFI � X[O � U!V ����� �NK C]EQK C]EHG)�HZFG UHG���QGJU �`ZLG �mVYX`Z I � "+�MG�.[G��GJI=C]KMR)� CFKMX� % � EHK ISR G CFEHXqU �HZLXiUQO �JG IwKQILC]ZLOHR G C ����R)�`_�QK C]OQUHGJI�_[K�.[G �P#" � �qCFG C]ILX�2�) ��� � �

� � � � ��� � � ����� � ��� 1! 8� �MX[_ � � � ��� �� ��� � �� �� ��� � � � % 2��

�NEHGJZLG � � � � ��� � � KMI CFEHGWKHI=C]ZLOHRSG� C ���2R �`_�HK CFOHUHGwX V�C]EHG �� ����"qIFG U�ILC � Z � � �� � � � � K IC]EHGmC]X`C����NIFOHR X`V0CFEHG � X[O C]I R G � IFOHZLGJU K�HIFK UHGmCFEHG �HZFILC ���{G ZLCFOHZFG�� ����� K I CFEHG I �#"�JX� CFZFKMPQOQC]K X� K �JX[O CFI � RSG �`IFOQZFGJU VYZLX[RDC]EHG�ILG �JX�HU � � � ZF_[G Z � ���{G ZLC]OQZFG�� � KMI�CFEHG\KMR)�`_[GG����~X[IFOHZLGwC]K RSG�� ��HU #�������� K I � �JX�HI=C �� C CFE�� C KMI C]EHG I�� RSG VYZFX[R�X�QGSK R �`_`G�CFX CFEHGHG��qC % � EHGJILG:KHI=C]ZFOQRSG� C����;R � _�HK CFOHUHG I � �� P~G C]Z���HI=VYX[ZFR GJUwCFX CFEHG)I=C ��HU �`ZFUWI6"iI=C]G RP#" �������"qIFKQ_ X`PHIFG Z .�� C]K X�HI�X`V�ILC��`ZFI��NKTC]E �3QX � R � _�HK CFOHUHG I\KWC]EQG �HG �MU %� G �`IFOHZLKH_ CFEHG:I��#" � G�.[G�� KMI!HX`C �`I�I=C]Z�� KM_[E C � VYX[Z �!�`ZLU �`I�K C!�kX[O �MU � C �HZFILCaILGJGJR % �,

C]EHGNILKMR � �MG ILC � �`IFG�� CFEHGNUHKMI=C]ZLKMPHOQCFKMX� X V{CFEHGNP���� � _[ZFX`O HU �JX[O CFI �NK���QP~G � � OHIFILK �� � UQOHGC]X Z���HUHX`R��8O � C]O � C]K X�HI0K� C]EHG I��#" � G�.[G�� % � .[G� V � K C � X� C �`R K��� CFI �NK��� �HZFXqUHO � G&�I�� G��pK�C]EHK I2UQKMILCFZFK PHOQC]K X� � R XiUQK V "qKH_0CFEHG � �`OQIFIFK���� UHGJZLK�.[G U ��� Z��`R G CFGJZFI�% ����#" �JX�3�C �`R K �� C]I �`ZLG � K� G ��"SC]X P{G �HZLGJIFG� C �~IFO � E � I QX���yZ���HUHX`R HX[K IFG �dP��`U �HK �QG��MI����JX[ILRSK��Z�� "qI � ��QU CFEHG �HZLGJIFG� �JG X`VdX`CFEHGJZ:O iVYX[ZFILGJG X[P �LG�� CFI^K� C]EQG P���� � _[ZFX`O HU % �, �JZFG �`IFK�H_C]EHG ���~GJZ=C]OHZLG X VcC]EQGaI �#" �� O �MOHI �HZLXiUQO �JG I��:C]Z�� UHG�� X ��% � CFEHG X�HGNE���HU � C]EQGaI=C � CFKMI �C]K��JI\X`V9CFEHG0P���� � _[ZLX[O HU �NK���{P~G � X[R G0P{G CFCFGJZ�O HUQGJZFI=C]XqXiU �NKTC]E � ��`ZF_[G Z����~GJZ=C]OHZLG��HPQOQC

Page 4: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

X�!CFEHG X`C]EHG Z �9C]EHG OHR P~GJZ^X`V�� X� C �`R K � C]K�H_hX[P �LG � C]I �{X`IFIFK P ��" � X� C �`K�HGJU �NK CFEHK K C�NK���cK �JZFG �`IFG�%� EHGJZLG K I HXSUHG�� HK CFK�.[G �!� "mC]X)�HZFXqUHO � G ������ � OHZ�� C]G R G � IFOHZLG X`V�C]EHG P���� � _[ZFX`O HU

I��#"�% � EHG P{G ILC0I � EHGJR G CFXwK �JX[Z �{X[Z�� C]G:CFEHGJILG C]Z��`UHG�� X �{I �2X[O � U P~G^CFX �HZLXiUHO �JG � IFG�����`Z�� C]G �{X��QO � � CFKMX�mX`V�I �#" � �MG�.[G ��GJILCFKMR)� C]G I �;P#"�� � ��� KH_�VYOHZLCFEHGJZ5���~GJZLCFOHZFG I0X`V�CFEHG I��`R GZ��`UQKMOHI �`I CFEHGwX[P �LG � C ���{G ZLCFOHZFG I ���JZLX[IFI C]EHGSKMR)�`_[G�% � EHGwRSG �� X`V\CFEHKMI UHKMI=C]ZLKMPHOQCFKMX��kX`O �MU�P~G �JX`RSGWC]EQG C]ZLOHG ��P ��� � _[ZFX[O HU I �#" �MG�.`G � % � V CFEHGhILC]OQUHKMG U I=C �`ZLI)� ZFGWPHZLKM_[E C ����~GJZLCFOHZFG �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ " � ����HZLXiUQO �JG ��� � OHZ�� C]G^ZFG �� C]K�.[G PHZLKM_[E C�QGJIFILGJI�% � X �2G�.[G Z �{P���� ���_[ZFX`O HU I��#" � X� C �`R K � C]K X� K I �0IFG ZFK X[OHI�UHK I��`U�.��� C��`_[G\X V8C]EHK I�RSG C]EHXqU �NEHG� � ZFX �NUHK�H_K � ZFG �`IFG I % � CNKMI�_[G�HGJZ������" OHIFG U X� ��"wVYX`Z\ZFX[OQ_[EhGJILCFKMR)� C]G I���HU �`I�ILO � EmKMI�HX C�C]EHG:X��3�C]K R OHR � EQX[K� G VYX`Z�OHIFG Kh_�� X[PHO ��`Z!���MOHI=C]G Z �HG �MUQI %

��� ��� � � � � ���#� ��� � � ���

B R X[ZLG �����JOHZ�� C]G ��� " X`V�UHG C]G ZFR KHK�H_SZLG �� C]K�.[G �HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6"mX� � IFKQ_��MG^KMR)�`_[G:K IC]X*�HZFXqUHO � G � � �`OQIFIFK�� RSXqUHG �rX`V2C]EHG ��X[K� C ���QZFG � U '8O � C]KMX� � � ��' � VYX`Z^CFEHGSI=C �`ZLIC]X P{G �� ����"qIFG U K�WC]EHG KMR)�`_[G�% �, X`ZFUHG ZNCFX�UHX CFEHKMI��HC]EHG K� CFG HILK C,"WR OHILCaP~G^R G � IFOHZLGJU�`I � VYO � CFKMX� X V C,�2X��yUQKMR G HILKMX�����kUHK ILC �� �JGWVYZFX`R C]EQG �JG CFZFGmX`V CFEHGhILCFG ���`Z K R � _[G�%� EHKMIkRSG C]EHXqU �2X[Z�� I�R O � EWR X[ZLG)IFO � �JG IFI=VYO ���"wVYX[Z �JZFX �NUHG U��HG �MUQIkC]E��� UHXqGJI����~GJZ=C]OHZLG�HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6"�% ���`Z��`RSG C]G ZFI�X V8C]EHG � ��' �yR XiUQG � VYO � C]KMX� �`ZLG .��`ZFK GJU CFX5�HZLXiUQO �JGkCFEHGkP~GJI=C�{X`IFIFK P �MGhZLG �HZLGJIFG� C � CFKMX� X V)C]EQG���� C]O���� � � ' �HZFX'���MG ISK�HEHGJZLG CSK�C]EHGmKMR)�`_[G�% � EHK IRSG C]EHXqU � �� P~G OHILGJUeG K C]EQGJZSCFX ��QU ��� � OHZ�� CFG I=C]G ��� �`Z �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ "��kX[ZSCFX�G�.���� O�� CFG�JX[ZLZFG�� C]K X�WC]G ZFR INVYX`Z ���{G ZLCFOHZFG �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ "�%

�iG�.`GJZ�����ILC��`ZFI&�`ZLG � EHX[ILG CFX OHIFGhK��CFEHG �HZLXiUHO � C]K X� X`VaC]EHG�� � 'uR XiUQG � % � EHG IFGILC��`ZFIdR OHI=C2P~GaO �JZLX �NUHGJU �iZFG�� � CFK�.[G���" PHZFK _[E C ��HUSVYZLX[R UHK+�cG ZFG� C �~X[IFKTC]K X�HI �NK CFEHK CFEHGKMR)�`_[G)VYZ��`R G�% � EHG^KMR)�`_[G0I � ��� G:R OHI=C QX`C � E���H_[G ��� ZFX[ILIaCFEHG KMR)�`_[G)VYX`Z\C]EHK I�RSG C]EHXqUC]X P~GWOHIFG U C]X P~GJI=C�G��{G � C % � EHG � ��'DR XqUHG �\_`G HG Z�������"!E��`I � � �GJZLIFK�WZ��`UHK���!�HZLX ��� G� �qCFG CFIFX� 2�) ��� � _[K�.`G mP " �

� ��� G���� � � � � � ��� ��� � � % 1 �

�NEHGJZLG KMIkCFEHG0C]ZLOHG:Z�� UHK ���{UHKMI=C �� �JG0VYZFX`R�C]EQG-�JG CFZFG X`VAC]EHG:I=C �`Z������� X �NKH_^VYX[Z�KMR)�`_[GG ���MK�iC]K� K C,"�� � KMINC]EHG � �`OQIFIFK����QZFX ��� G �NK UQC]E � ��HU��!K I CFEHG Z��`UHK ���9V ������ X � ��� Z��`R G CFGJZ %� EHGJILG5��� Z��`R G CFGJZFI �`ZLG UHG C]G ZFR KHG U �NKTC]EHK� CFEHG �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]ZFK�������� � �`_[GNVYZFX`R C]EHGaKMR)�`_[GX[Z\VYZFX`R�R ��qO �����"SUQG���HG U K R �`_`G��yUQG �~G HUHG� C � �`Z��`R G CFGJZLI %

ILKH_hC]EHK I � � '%RSXqUHG � � �HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6" KMI^X[PQC � KHG U!VYX[Z �����CFEHGwI=C �`ZLI K�!CFEHGSVYZ��`RSGP#" �QCFC]K�H_ C]EHGmRSXqUHG��\C]X!CFEHGmILC � ZFI&�NK C]E �MG �`ILC6�yI O�� ZFGJI R G C]EQXiU % � EHG � � '"KMI �8ZFI=CIFEHKTV C]G U ��HU I � ��� GJU CFXwC]EHG �{X[ILK CFKMX����HU PHZLKM_[E C�HGJILI0X`V�C]EQG ILC��`Z-�`I UHGJZLK�.[G U VYZFX[R�CFEHGGJI=C]KMR)� CFGJI�X`V����~GJZLCFOHZFG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZ "�% � EHG �QZFX ��� G:RSXqUHG�� KMI\CFEHG mIFOHPiC]Z���� C]G U VYZLX[R�CFEHG

Page 5: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��k� � �

KMR)�`_[G�� �MG � .qK�H_WP{G EHKQU CFEHG �HC � ZFG IFKMUQO����MI�% � EHG ZFG IFO �TC KMI0CFX �QZFXqUHO �JG�K�QVYX[ZFR)� CFKMX� X�C]EHG P���� � _[ZFX`O HU �MG�.`G � I-��HU I6"iI=C]G R � CFK� G ZFZFX`ZFI % � EHG IFG .����MOHG I-�`ZLG O��� C]K+�8GJU P#" CFEHGZFX[OiC]KQG�� ��HU CFEHG �NEHX�� G �HCFCFKH_��HZFX3�JG IFI�KMI ZLG �~G � CFGJU0�NK CFE � I�� KM_[E C���" UHK��{GJZLG C�� � 'RSXqUHG�� % � EHG �HZFX'���MG�KMI:ILOHPQCFZ���� C]GJU �`_#�`K� ��HU!CFEHG�ZFG IFKMUQO����MI R G �`ILOHZFG U % � EHKMI �NEHX�� G�HZFX3�JG IFI KMI^ZFG �~G � C]GJU O CFK��C]EQGwZFG IFK UHO���� I �`ZLG)QGJ_�� KM_[K P �MG�� �QZFXqUHO �JK�H_ � .[G Z " ��� � OHZ�� CFGRSG �`IFOQZFG X`VAC]EHG ILCFG ��� �`Z��QZFX ��� GJI\VYX[Z�CFE�� C ���`Z=C]K��JO ��`Z\KMR)�`_[G�%� EHG&�kX��MX[OHZ5���`_�HK CFOHUHG �0K �`_[Z��`R � ����� � �QZFGJILG C]G U K '�KM_ % 1 % 2 1 ���`I5�HZFXqUHO � GJU

OHIFK�H_)CFEHKMI � � ' �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]Z "^R G CFEHXiU �NK C]EQK �NB � � � � � % � EHG���� � �MK�� � CFKMX� �HZFXqUHO � GJU������ �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK��SO �JGJZ=C �`K� C]KMG I X V 7 % 7 2 1 R)�`_�QK C]OQUHGJI K � ��HU 7 % 7 2 �WR � _�HK CFOHUHG IK � � � VYX[Z I=C �`ZLI X`V � � 1�2 % 7 % � C �kX`O �MU CFEHGJZLG VYX[ZLGWIFGJG R}C]E � C�� � ' �HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6" � ���HZFXqUHO � G G � � G ���MG C)ZFGJILO � CFI)VYX[Z �JZLX �NUQGJU ILCFG ��� �`ZaKMR)�`_[G I %�� X �2G�.`GJZ � CFEHG �QZFX[P � GJR �NK CFEC]EHK I RSG C]EHXqU!K I:C]E�� C^KTC KMI HX`C^X��QCFKMR KMILGJU C]XmP{G �JX�HIFK ILC]G� C �NEHG� OHILGJU+�NKTC]E+�*��`ZF_[GU�� C��`P��`ILG:X`VAKMR)�`_[GJI�%�B�VYOHZ=C]EHG Z�RSG C]EHXqUWX`V �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ "SKMI�� .��`K��`P � G �NEHK�� E �HZFXqUHO � GJIR O � EmRSX`ZFG � X�HIFK ILC��� C �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]Z "SVYX[Z�� � � ZF_[G:U�� C �`ILG C % � EQKMINKMI�� OHZFZLG C���" C]EQG^R X[I=C��� � OHZ�� C]GWR G C]EQXiU � .��`K��`P �MG)��HU0�!�`I�OHIFG U�CFX �HZFXqUHO � GWC]EHG CFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJI U�� C � IFG C VYX`ZC]EHK I��kX`Z�� %

��� ��� � $ ��� � ������ � � � ! �+�*� �

�, X[ZLUHGJZNC]XSG��qC]Z���� C)C]EHG^R � �QK R OHR �~X[ILIFKMP �MG �`RSX`O C)X`V�KQVYX[ZLR � C]KMX� VYZFX[R�I=C]G ��� �`ZKMR)�`_[G I � C]EHG5�HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6"SR OHILCkP{G � �`ZLZFKMG U X[OQC��`I������JOHZ�� C]G���")�`I2KMI2VYG �`IFK P �MG�% �0K��{GJZLG ��C]K��� �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]Z " � K R �`_`G IFOQPQC]Z���� CFKMX� �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ " � KMI-�~GJZ=VYG � C���" IFOHKTC]G U CFX C]EHK I0C �`I � %� EHKMI�R G CFEHXqU � ��hP~G:OHIFG UmVYX[ZkIFG�.`GJZ����9UHK�.`GJZFILG PHZ��� � EHGJINX`V �`I=C]ZFX�HX[R "wK ���MOHUHK�H_ CFEHGUHG CFG � C]KMX�^X ViCFZ���HILKMG� CAG�.[G CFI�ILO � E �`I9ILO �{G Z�HX .��`G ��HU HG �`Z � �`ZLCFE �`I=C]G ZFKMXqUHI'X[Z � K0CFEHG� �`ILG X`V�CFEHKMI �kX[Z � � C]EHG ��� � � K� � C]KMX�hCFX �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ "mK � ZFX �NUHG U �HG �MUQI % � EHG RSG C]EHXqU��� CFO�������" �2X[Z�� I\P~G CLC]GJZ��`I2CFEHG �JZLX �NUHKH_ K � ZFG � IFGJI � O �wCFX � �MK RSKTC � �#�`I\K� UHG QIFGJZ �8G � UHI� � �`ZL_[GJZ� OHR P{G ZaX V �HK �QG��MI�� X� C �`K�mK�QVYX[ZLR � CFKMX� �`P~X[OQC ��#" � � ' UHK��{GJZLG � GJI�%� EHG �0K��{GJZFG� �JG��yR)�`_[G B5 ����"qIFK I � � �yB � R G CFEHXiU �!�`I X�HG X`ZFKM_`K�������"�UHG I�� ZFKMP~GJU P "

� X`R ��QG�" � �kZFX`CLC]I � 2�)�) ��� ��HU � � CFGJZ �`I ���X��QC]K R ��� � ��'xR � C�� EHKQ_ ��� _[X[ZFKTC]EHR P "B5��`ZFU � �9O �QC]X� � 2�)�) � � ����HU �!�`I2RSXqUHK��HGJUwP#" /�X �� HK��� � 1�7�7�7�� VYX[ZdVYOQZLC]EQGJZ���� � �MK�� � �C]K X�wC]X K UHG CFK V " RSK��JZLX��MG�HIFK�H_ G�.[G CFIaK� � � ZF_[GaC]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG IkU�� C �`ILG C]I�%rB)I ��WX .[G Z .qKMG�� �� �yB �JX�HIFK ILC]I X V CFEHG VYX����MX �NKH_ ILCFG �HI�� '�KMZLILC � ����� K R �`_`G VYZ��`RSG I �`ZLG C]Z���HILVYX[ZLRSG UX� C]X+� �JX[R RSX� � XiX`ZFUHK��� C]GWI6"qILC]G R*�kK�X[ZFUQGJZ C]X E�� .[G P{G CFCFGJZ&�{X`IFK CFKMX� ���kK�QVYX[ZFR)� �C]K X� C]EHZLX[OH_[EHX`OQC C]EHG�U�� C��`IFG C % � EHG �hCFGJR � � � CFG KMR)�`_[G K I-�HZFXqUHO � GJU!P " � X[R PHK�HKQ_C]EHG P{G ILC O���� K C,"�KMR)�`_[G I)�NK CFEeIFR)����NX �{IFG C]I � � EHX[IFG�%R)�� O�������" � K C]X0� .`GJZ6" EHK _[EIFK _����� � C]X �,HX[K IFG R �`I=C]G Z VYZ��`R G�% � EHG ��X[K� C ���QZFG � U '8O � C]KMX� � � � ' � X`V2CFEHG ILC � ZFI^X�G ��� E K R � _[GSK I CFEHG R XiUQG �MG U�OHILKH_ � �JX[R PQK�� CFKMX� X`V�C,�2X � � OHIFILK ��HI���X�HGSVYX[Z CFEHG�JX[ZLG ��HUWX�QG � V ��� C]X`Z\X`V 2 %(� � �NKMUHG Z\VYX[ZkCFEHG �NKH_`I % � EHG P~GJILC � � ' �yR)� C�� EHK�H_ �HZLX ��� G� � GJZ�QG � � KMINVYX[O QU*.qK � C]EHG^I�� RSG^RSG C]EHXqU*�`I UQGJI�� ZFK P{G U VYX[Z � � ' �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZ "�� �`RSG���"K CFGJZ�� C]KMX� ��HUmZFG IFKMUQO����'R KHK RSK I�� CFKMX� %�kG CFZ����\CFX CFEHKMI KMR)�`_[GwILOHPQCFZ���� C]KMX��R G CFEHXqU KMI C]EQG �`IFILOHR)�iC]KMX� C]E�� C CFEHGWKMR)�`_[G

Page 6: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

�HK��iG��MI:C]E�� C � X� C �`K� � � 'pKQVYX[ZLR � C]KMX� .�� Z " X� ��" I�� KM_[E C���" UQOHG CFX ILGJGJK�H_*.��`ZLK � CFKMX�QI %��� � ! ��� ! � HX � � GJUH_[GdX`ViC]EHG � � '*��HU^CFEHGdI��#"^P���� � _[ZFX`O HU K I HX`CAZFG� qOQKMZFG U % � ��� E KMR)�`_[GKMI'C]EQG ��� CFGJZFG U ILXaCFE�� C9C]EQG � � 'hKMI'CFEHGrI��`R G�C]EHZLX[OH_[EHX`OQC9C]EHGdU�� C��`IFG C���HU ILG� OHG� CFK ������"IFOHPiC]Z���� C]G UpVYZLX[R C]EHG CFGJR � � � CFG VYZ��`RSG�% '�K������"�C]EHG �HZLX ��� G � � � ' � �HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6" K IG��qC]Z���� CFGJUmVYZFX[R3C]EHX[ILG ILC � Z �~X[ILK C]K X�HI��QZFX .qKMUHG UmVYX[Z ���� K R �`_`GJI %� EHG � �yB RSG C]EHXqU �HZLXiUHO �JGJI:CFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJI C]E�� C � ZFG�K C]G Z�������" � X�HIFK ILCFG C �APHOQC HX C

X� ��I=C ��QU��`ZFUeR)�`_�QK C]OQUHG I6"qILC]G R*% � EHG C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI �`ZFG*�HZFXqUHO � GJUeK �MK�HG �`Z �8O��O HKTC]I �qVYZFX[R �NEHK�� E C]EHG �JX�QILC �� CNZLG VYG ZFG �JG �8O��wX`V'CFEHG)X[P �LG � C\X� C]EHGaC]G R)� �� C]G KMR)�`_[GE��`I P{G G IFOHPQCFZ���� C]G U % � EHG �JG ZFX�� �{X`K C�X`V)CFEHGmX[OQC��QOQC�C]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I KMI C]EQGJZFG VYX[ZFGWCFEHGPHZFK _[E C�HG IFIdX`V~C]EHGaILC��`Z�X��C]EHGNC]G R)� �� C]G2VYZ��`R G�% �kZFK _[E C�HG IFI .�� ZFK � C]KMX�HI � CFEHGNUHK��{GJZLG � G�8O�� � �`ZFG�R G �`ILOHZFG U � I^G K CFEHGJZ-�~X[IFKTC]K�.[G X[Z-HG _#� CFK�.[G �8O3� C]XmGJKTC]EHG Z:IFKMUQG X V2CFEHKMI � GJZFX ��{X`K C %� X)�JX�#.`GJZLC C]EHK I O HK C K C]X)�SI=C ��QU��`ZFU R � _�HK CFOHUHG I�� ���MG��~CFEHG �8O�� X`V�G ��� E ILC��`ZaX�

C]EHG)ZFG VYG ZFG� �JG:K R �`_`G R OQILC\P~G0UHG C]G ZFR KHG U %�B5WG ILCFKMR)� C]G X`V'C]EHG �8O�� � �� P~G0R)�`UHG P "ZFO HKH_ �aB � � � � � � �qCFG C]ILX� 2�) ��� � X� C]EHG ZLG VYG ZFG �JG C]G R)� �� C]G^KMR)�`_[G C]XwRSG �`IFOHZLGC]EHG �8O�� � K �JX[O CFI � VYX`ZaG ��� E I=C �`Z�% � EHG � X�#.[G ZFIFK X� P~G C,�2GJG� C]EHG X[OQC��QOQC5� KHG �`Z��8O��O HKTC]I ��HUhC]EQG^ZLGJILO � CFKH_�UHG�� C � R)�`_�HKTC]OHUQGJI�� ��mCFEHG mP~G � ���� O � � C]GJU .qK � �

� � � � 1! 8 � X[_�� � � � � � � %���2���� ��� � %"��2��� � � � % ���

�NEHGJZLG � %���2���� K IkC]EHG �HO��WX`VAI=C �`Z ! X� CFEHG0C]G R)� �� C]G)KMR)�`_[G�����HU � � � KMIkCFEHG:UHK��{GJZLG � G�8O�� X� �a_[K�.`G VYZ��`R G2K� C]EQG2C]K RSGrILGJZFK GJI�% �, CFEHKMI ��� "������� C]EQG2C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI9KMUQG C]K+�8GJU � I.��`ZFK�`P �MGNI=C �`ZLI���HUwX`C]EHG Z2X`P �LG � C]I\X`V K C]G ZFGJI=C!�2GJZLG �JX�#.`GJZLCFGJUWC]X ILC���HU��`ZLU R)�`_�HKTC]OHUHGO HKTC]I %

�rGJZ6" EHG � .3" P �MG�HUHKQ_ � �� � �`OHILG C]ZFX`OHP �MG��cEHX �2G�.`GJZ � �`I0CFEHG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZ " UHXqGJI HX CRSXqUHG��AILOHZFZLX[O HUQKH_SILC � ZFI % � E OHI)V �`K� C5��HU � X[ZaEHG � .qK���"hP � G HUHG U X[P �LG�� CFI � �� P{G �JX�3�C �`R K � C]G UWP " HGJK _[E P{X[OQZFI % �aX �2G�.`GJZ��;CFX�RSK�HKMR KMILGaCFEHG �HZFX[P �MGJR I�� � OHIFG U P#"WP � G HUQGJUILC��`ZFI���� �JZFX �NUHK�H_ � �`_ E��`I P{G G K� C]ZFXqUHO � GJU�K C]X CFEHG�� �yB %�B � �`_ X`V 2 KQUHK� � C]G IC]E�� C � �HK��iG��dPQZFKM_`E CFGJZ:C]E �� 7 % 2 8 UHKMI=C �� � GSK�+�QK��iG � I �HK �QG�� �8O�� �MK GJI-�NK CFEHK CFEHGKMR RSG UHK � C]G�VYX[OHZ��QK��iG � HGJK _[E P{X[OQZFEHXqXiUwX`V'C]EHG0C��`ZF_`G C\I=C �`Z�% '8X[Z2CFEHG-�HZFXqUHO � C]K X� X`V'CFEHG� � '!���0I=C �`Z�KMI�ZLG �LG�� C]G U�K V ��HX C]EHG Z �MX3� ���qR)� �iKMR OHR � C �MG �`ILC 1�� �`P~X .`GkC]EQG�P���� � _[ZFX`O HU�MG�.[G �'K I��HZFG IFG� C %� EHG � �yBpR G C]EQXiUSE��`I2CFEHG V ���JK� K C," CFX �`OiC]X[R)� C]K�� ������" UHG CFG � C�X[P �LG�� C]I2C]E�� C!�`ZLG5� ��`I6�

IFK+�8GJU �`I .�� ZFK � P �MG VYZLX[R}VYZ�� RSG CFX VYZ��`RSGhOHILKH_ C]EQGmVYX����MX �NKQ_ �JX�QUHK CFKMX�HI�� B\C � G �`I=CC]EHZLGJG �JX�HILG � OQC]K�.[G �~X[K CFIkR OHI=CkUQG ���`Z=C\P#")� C �MG � ILC ��� VYZLX[R C]EHG P��`IFG��MK�HGNKSCFEHG)I��`R GIFG�HIFG�� ��HU � C�� G �`I=C 2 7 �~X[K C]IkR OHILC\UHG ��� ZLCNP#" � � VYZLX[R�CFEHG0P�� IFG � KHG)KWGJKTC]EHG Z\IFG�HIFG�%B\CNC]EHK I�ILC � _[G�� � �iG U��~X[IFKTC]KMX�HI �`ZFG:OQIFGJU X�hC]EHG-�NEHX�� G:KMR)�`_[G-� ZFG ��IFG �`Z�� EQGJU VYX`Z�.�� ZFK���`P � GJI % � EHG R G CFEHXiU � �� C]EQG ��QZFXqUHO �JG �)� KM_[E C��JOHZ6.[G � CaC]EHG �HK��iG�� � XiX`ZFUHK��� C]G INX`V�CFEHGUHG CFG � C]GJU .��`Z "qKQ_ X`P �LG � C %

Page 7: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� �)� � � �: � �5� � � ��� � � ���k� �;� �1���1� � � �

B)I2C]EHG0R)�`K� �`K R3X V'C]EHG �QZFX��LG�� C��!�`I\C]X ��HU C]EQG �{G ZFK XiUHK��#� 2 � 1�� UHZFX��WK� PHZLKM_[E C �HGJILI!� �`OHIFG U P#" � � � ��HG C �`Z6" C]Z���HIFKTC ���NEHK�� E KMI �HZ���� CFK� �����" O QUHG CFG � C��`P � G)P#" C]EHK I �`OQC]X �R � C]K� .��`ZLK �`P �MG0UHG C]G�� C]K X���QZFX3�JGJILI)K� U�� C ��X`V�CFEHG O����MK C," KhC]EHK INCFEHGJILKMI��;CFEHG^RSG C]EHXqU��� I ���TC]GJZLGJU I��MK _[E C���"�% � EHG �HZFX`_[Z��`R �!�`I KHI=C]ZFO � C]G U C]X)�HZFXqUHO � G � �MKM_`E C��JOHZ6.[G VYX[ZaG�.#�GJZ6" .qKMIFK P �MG�I=C �`Z�X� CFEHGNP{G ILC � IFG GJKQ_ ��� � O �aKMR)�`_[G����NEHK� E&"qKMG � UHGJU CFEHG � �`ZL_[GJI=C qOQR P{G ZX`V2ILC � ZFI^X`V��� " X V2CFEHG�U�� C � IFG C KMR)�`_[G I % aIFKQ_*�NB � ' � "5� �NK CFEHK � � B '!� CFEHG&�HK��iG���MX3� � CFKMX�QIkX`V ����{ILC � ZFI�.qKMIFK P �MG)KWC]EHG K R �`_`GJI��2GJZFG UHG C]G ZFR KHG U %� EHG R)�`K��HEHX`CFX[RSG C]ZLK� �HK�~G � KHG �NK C]EQK � �yB ���`I0CFEHG K�HILCFZFO � C]GJU CFX �HZFXqUHO � G&�

�MK _[E C��JOQZ .[GhVYX[Z G ��� E X`V0C]EQGJIFG*�MX3� � CFKMX�QI % � CwKMI�EHGJZLG CFE�� CwCFG � GJI�� X��~G X �{IFG C]I P~G � X[R GKMR �{X`ZLC �� C � �`I ��#" ILC��`Z&� � X[IFG CFX CFEHGhGJUH_`G � �NK C]EQK 1�1 �HK �QG��MI��dCFEHGhR � �iK R OHR-IFEHKTV CX`VNC]EHGhK R �`_`GJI OHILGJU�C]X �HZLXiUHO �JGWC]EHG CFGJR � � � C]GwVYZ��`RSG � � �� HX`C E�� .[GWCFEHGhR � �iK R OHR�`R X[O CNX`V �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]Z " R �`UQG�� �`INIFX`RSG KMR)�`_[G I��kX`O �MUmP{G^IFO )� KMG� C���"hILEHK V CFGJUhC]X�V ����VYZFX[R�C]EHG GJUH_[G^X`V�CFEHG VYZ��`R G�% � C KMING ILC]K R � C]GJUmC]E�� C 2 8�� � 1�1 � 7�7�7�� X`V�CFEHG I=C �`ZLI)K�mCFEHG�8G � UWIFO �{GJZ2VYZFX[R C]EHK I\G��{G � C ��HUWEHG� �JG:E �`U HX �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ ")�HZFXqUHO � GJU % �0GJI �HK CFG)C]EQKMI �C]EHG:CFX`C ���cILC � Z�U�� C � P��`IFG I=C]K��� OHR P~GJZLGJU 2 7�) �(� � � I=C �`ZLI %B V CFGJZ�C]EQG^ILOHPQCFZ���� C]KMX�*�HZLX�� GJILI K I��JX[R � �MG C]G��QC]EHG UHG ZFK�.[GJU*�{X`IFK CFKMX�WX V�CFEHG I��`R � �MG U

ILC��`ZFI2KMI!QX`C��'�{G � C]G UWP " ��#"SIFOHZLZFX[O QUHKH_ O #.�� Z "qKH_ ILC � ZFI � ���� X �NK�H_ � .[G Z " ��� � OHZ�� CFGRSG �`IFOQZFG X V�C]EHG � E���H_`G K PHZFK _[E C�HG IFI X`V �SI=C �`Z X� �)���`ZLCFK� O � �`Z�K R � _[G�%�� "mZLO HK�H_C]EHGmR G C]EQXiU X� CFEHG �NEQX��MGmU�� C��`IFG C �\C]EQGmCFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJI&� KM_[E C�� OHZ .`GJI)� �� P{G*�HZFXqUHO � GJU�NEHK� E �`ZFGSX`VNIFK _�HK�� � �� C���" EHKM_`EHGJZ �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK�)��� � OHZ�����" C]E��� CFE�� C X[PQC��`KHG U �NK CFEGJKTC]EHG Z ���{G ZLCFOHZFG X[Z�� � ' �HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6"�%

� ��� n%j:j:@=(=<'$�bH(+/ks�bQ/3bH.07D#�$�bQ$�4Q7 b

� EHG � �yB �HK�~G � KHG ��� � �MK GJUWC]X�C]EHG ��� � O � U � C ��KMI�C]EQG^I��`R G � IaCFE�� C �HZFG IFG� CFGJU K�/�X �� HK��� � 1�7�7�7�� � ��HU G ��� E I=C]G � K I)ILOHRSR)�`ZLKMIFG U EHG ZFG�%-'�KMZLILCaC]EHG �JXqUHG �!�`I0R XiUQK��8G UC]X)��� � G �QC U�� C��)�HZLXiUQO �JG U*�NK CFE / '�� �~P#" �HZLX .qK UHKH_�K�QVYX[ZFR)� CFKMX� � P{X[OiC CFEHG �QE "qILK� ���IFK �JGJI X`V\CFEHGSK R � _[GJI K+�HK��iG��dO HK CFI % '8OHZLCFEHGJZLRSX[ZLG��9C]EHGSZFG UHO �JG U / ' �-' � � � KMR)�`_[GJI�kG ZFG*�JX�#.[G ZLCFGJU CFX!C]EQG ��� � � ' � ��VYX[ZLR � C .iK�+� IFO � � �MK GJU �HZFX`_[Z��`R}K�X[ZFUHG Z VYX`ZC]EHG R�C]X�P~G ZFG � U P#" CFEHG-/�X ���HK ��� � 1�7�7�7�� � XiUHG�%� X I �{G GJU�O � CFEHG)�QZFX3�JGJILI X VkUHG ZFK�.iK�H_ �HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6" C]E � C KMI IFOQK C � P �MG VYX[Z �������"qILKMI �

G ��� E�X`V\C]EQGSG KM_[E C / ' � �����0I �2GJZLG �JOiC K CFX O��`Z=C]G ZFI ��X[Z � ILG � C]KMX�HI��9VYX[Z^KHUHK�.qKMU��O���� �������"qIFK I � /�G ILC]Z�� � � % B % �+� �QZFK�.�� CFG)� X[R R O HK�� � CFKMX� � % �kG VYX[ZFGSZFO QKH_mC]EHG � �yB�HK�~G � KHGkX�SG ��� E X`VcCFEHGJILG ILG � CFKMX�QI � C]EHG�" �kG ZFGNVYOHZLCFEHGJZrILOHP{UQK�.qKMUHG USP#" CFEHG � XiUQGaK� C]X � ILOHPHILG � CFKMX�QI��8X`V 8�2 1 8�2 1 �QK��iG � I�IFK � G:G ��� E % � EQKMI�IFOQP{UHK�.qKMIFK X�WX`VAC]EHG �����0INK I\IFEHX � I�� EHG R � C]K� �����"mK '�K _ % � % 2 � �NEHG ZFG C]EHG �NEQX��MG / ' � �`ZLZ�� " K I0IFEQX � � �NKTC]E CFEHG �����0I�JOQCdK� CFX0C]EHG KMZ�ZLGJI��~G � C]K�.[GaIFG � C]K X�HI�� IFOHPHILG � C]KMX�HI � ��HU OHR P~GJZFG U � IdOQIFGJUSK CFEHG �JXqUHG � %� EHKMI ILCFG � �!�`IwUQX�HG��QOHZFG���" VYX[Z�C]K RSGhR)����`_[G RSG� CwZLG �`ILX�HI �\CFX �����MX ��VYX`ZSU�� C � CFXP{G � .��`K�� �`P �MG�VYX[Z �� ����"qIFK I �NEHK��MGwCFEHG HG �qC�IFG � C]K X� ��� I P{G KH_ �QZFXqUHO �JG U % B�I��`R � � GIFOHPQIFG � C]K X� K R � _[G-�`I�VYGJUmK CFX�CFEHG � �yB �JXqUHG KMI�ILEHX � K '�K _ % � % 1 %

Page 8: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

� ��� � ��� ������ ��� �.!iB ?3'3#i#*'34�hq2A7�#0���q[�'@` � �kb � � �v! ')4P#02F!0�,+/#0')284 !&[�'3'j`�984 %�!iX Q !i�1+-#*'3254 !&[�')')'@`�95!�X !0�,%M')4#*����Yb � B�')B�,?3')4��l984 % %(�,!*+/�*')Q�1%;')4 #0� ��#0�=<P#1aC��� �q!i�1+-#*'3254 !&9A4%6!0X�Q !0�,+/#0')284 !&� 9TG8��Q��=�=4{4>X�KlQ�,�0�1%95!�B�,�FX !0��'34 #*��� +/2(%(�5a;����'@!F!0B�?)'I#0#0')4�hS9A?)?32�DC�,% %�9A#*96#02{Q��LB��*2(%(X +=�,%�9A4 %�9TG�9A')?@9AQ�?)�\7�28�F9A49A?)J>!0'@!DE��')?)��#0���F+=2>%��vD�98!��*X�4�4 '34�hM254 #*����4��/<>#&B 98�i#E287�#*��� � � �qa

� C ��� I VYX[O HU�CFE�� C CFEHG U � C �`ILG C&�!�`I�IFX � �`ZL_[G C]E�� CSKTC �!�`I CFXiX � X[R)�QOQC � CFKMX� �����"G����~G HILK�.[G CFX�ZLO K ��IFK�H_�� GmPQOHZFI=C � G�.[G VYX`ZwX� ��" �!ILKH_�� G ILG � C]KMX� � ��QU IFX E �`UC]X P{G � X[R)� �MG CFGJU�K C,�2X�E�����.[G I � /!GJILCFZ�� � � % B % �+� �HZLK�.�� CFG � X[R R O HK�� � CFKMX� � % � EHK I��� IwUHOHGhC]X!RSG RSX`Z " ZLGJILCFZFK�� C]K X�HI�X`V C]EHG*� .�� K� � P �MGWR)��� EHK�HGJI�% � EHGmKMR)�`_[GWU�� C��`IFG C��� I �������"qIFGJU K�!C,�2X E�����.[GJI�� �NK CFE X�HG E ��� V�OQIFKQ_ XiUQU��, OHR P~GJZLGJU K R � _[GJI ��HU X�QG�NK CFE G�.`G �� OHR P~GJZFG U % � ��� EeILG � C]KMX� C]XqX�� CFEHZFG G U�� "qIwC]X+�HZFXqUHO � G CFEHG CFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJI�MK _[E C��JOQZ .[G IwVYX[ZSILC � ZFIWK C]EHG ��1 IFOHPQIFG � C]K X�HIWX`V^G ��� EeX`V C]EHG � �����0I % � G� �JG CFEHG�NEHX�� G$��� � O �)U�� C �`ILG CdC]XqX�� � 2 7�7 U � "qIdC]X^P{GNC]X`C������" �� ����"qIFG UwP#"�C]EHG � �yB �JXqUHG5��HU�HZFXqUHO � G:C]EHG ������ C]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I\U�� C��`P��`ILG�%

Page 9: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� �)� � � �: � �5� � � ��� � � ���k� �;� �1���1� � �

� ��� � ��� ��� �O� �.4S�/<�98K\B ?3��287�9L_�]1w � _(]1wqB�'3<(�=?d[�x�a~w�� �O284S9�!0')%��1`E!0X�Q !0�,+/#0')284 7��"9AKM�F98!�7��1%{')45#*2M#0����Yb � B�� 2A#025KM�/#0�*J B�')B�,?3')4��8a �&?)?:!$#"9A�"!&G>')!0')Q�?3�l284 #*��')!v')K�9Ah8�;[��/<�+=�=B(#Y#0��2P!i�lDE'I#*��'34 w8w�B 'I<(�=?@!&287�#0����1%(h8�T` DC�=�*��!098KMB�?3�1%L7�25��#0����#*'3KM�=ec!0�=�*'3�1!E%�9�#"9AQ 95!i�5a

��� ���*� � !#�*� � ��� ���*� � � � ��� �

� EHG5� �yB �HK��{G��MK�HG�Z��� �JX�HIFG��JOQCFK�.[G5�HZFX[_`Z��`R I�C]E�� C �HZLG ��� ZFGJUSC]EHGaKMR)�`_[G IrVYX`Z ��������"qIFKMI�� �HZLXiUQO �JG U C]EHG CFGJR � � � C]G VYZ��`R GJINVYX[Z)G ��� E IFOQPHIFG�� C]K X� � �~GJZ=VYX[ZFR GJU�� � � '*�HCLC]K�H_RSG C]EHXqU CFX IFG��MG�� C]G U�ILC � ZFI � ��QU IFOHPiC]Z���� C]G UeC]EHGmC]GJR � �� C]G KMR)�`_[GWVYZ��`R GJI VYZFX[R CFEHGU�� C��`IFG C�KMR)�`_[GSVYZ��`R GJI % �kX`CFE � � ' ��HU ���{G ZLCFOHZFG �HEHX C]X[R G CFZ " �kG ZFG �{G ZLVYX[ZLRSG U�X�C]EHGaIFOQPQC]Z���� CFGJUwK R � _[GJI ��HU�C]EQG K�QVYX[ZFR)� CFKMX� �NZLK CLC]G C]X �� B�� � � �����MG�VYX[Z � � C]GJZ ��������"qIFKMI�%� EHG P{G ILC�� 8 G����~X[IFOQZFGJI �2GJZFG OHILGJU�C]X �HZFXqUHO � G CFEHG C]G R)� � � CFG VYZ��`R GJI VYX[ZWG ��� E

IFOHPQIFG � C]K X� � � ���� O � � CFGJUmC]X E�� .`G&�wRSG �� ILGJGJK�H_WX`V 2 % 2�& & � ��QU X �{IFG CFI0P~G C,�2GJG VYZ�� RSG I�`IkILR ���� �`IdVYG �`ILKMP � G��qRSG �`IFOHZLGJU � C � % 1 & & % � EHGJILG#� 8 VYZ��`R GJI �kG ZFG5.qKMILO�������" K�HI��~G � C]GJU CFX� EHG � ��VYX[ZrI��QOHZFK X[OHI qO ���MKTC," .��`ZFK� C]K X�HI ���NEQK� E � X[O � UwP~G � �`OHIFG U P#"�I�� CFG ���MK CFG\C]Z��`K� I ��HUX`C]EQGJZ CFZ���QIFKMG� C �HEHG�HX[R G ���% '�KMZLILC ��C]EQGwVYZ��`R GJI �2GJZFG ����rIFEHKTV C]G U IFX CFE�� C C]EHG I=C �`ZLIR � C�� E �~X[IFKTC]K X� CFEHZFX`OH_[EHX[OiCkC]EQKMIkI��`R � �MG��3.qK � �JZFX`IFI6� �JX[ZLZFG�� � CFKMX� C]G � E HK OHG I � �NKTC]EwCFEHG�JX[ZLZFG�� C2IFEHKTV C]I �HZFXqUHO � KH_ � R)� �iKMR OHR K�C]EHGNVYO � C]KMX� % � EHG ZFGJILO � CFKH_^IFEQK V C]IdP~G C,�2GJG C]EHG KMR)�`_[GJIaE�� .[G&�� ��� � OHZ�����" X V �SVYZ���� C]K X� X`V � �QK��iG � % � EHG R G CFEHXiU VYX[Z5�HZLXiUQO �JK�H_C]EHGNC]G R)� � � CFGaVYZ��`RSG I2K I�C]EHG I��`R G5� I2C]E � C2VYX`Z �HZLXiUQO �JK�H_^CFEHG CFKMR G�� IFGJZLKMG I �3� V C]G Z �NEQK� EC]EHGaC]G R)� �� C]G KMR)�`_[G I!�`ZLG5� X�� �`UQUHGJU �iX� ��" �NKTC]EwCFEHG0ILOHPQC]Z���� CFKMX� �HZFX3�JG IFI\UHK IFZLGJ_#�`ZLUHGJU %� EHG �HZFX`_[Z��`R �kG� C X� C]X UHG C]G � C�C]EHGmILC��`ZFI .qKMILKMP � G K C]EQGJIFG HG�� ��"�IFEQK V C]G U ��HU

Page 10: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

R � C�� EHG U KMR)�`_[G I % � EHG � � '�KMI ��� �HZFX �iKMR)� C]G U�P#"+� � �`OHILIFK �� � ��QU!C]EQG �JX`ZFZFG�� � CFKMX��JXqG� �JK G C �NKTC]E CFEHKMI � � ' R XiUQG �NKMI�VYX[O HU � C G ��� E �HK �iG � �MX3� � CFKMX� % � P �LG � CFI �NK CFEI�� CFOHZ�� C]GJU X`Z)UHG �`U �HK��iG��MI � ZFG K _�HX[ZLGJU P#"mC]EHG ZLX[OQCFKHG�% �, �`UHUQK C]K X� � �JZLOHUHG ���~GJZ=C]OHZLG�HEHX`CFX[R G C]Z6" KMI �HZFXqUHO � GJU VYX[ZdC]EHG �MX3� � CFKMX�HI �NEHG ZFG)CFEHG�� � ' � RSXqUHG�� � X[ZFZLG �� C]K X�)� XiG ��JK G CaUHG CFGJZFR KQGJI � I=C �`ZNKMI �HZLGJILG C �~KmX[ZFUQGJZ�C]X � � ���JG:C]EHG^UHG C]G � C]G U IFX`OHZ�� GJI)K� X`ZFUHG ZX`V{PHZFK _[E C�HG IFI % � EQG � G C]Z������~X[IFKTC]KMX�HI�X`V~C]EHG�UHG C]G�� C]G UwI=C �`ZLI � ZFG�VYX[O HU .qK �:UHG C]G ZFR K�� �C]K X�hX`V�CFEHG PHZFK _[E C]G ILC �HK��iG�� X`V�� _[K�.[G�mI=C �`Z�% /�K C]EWCFEHKMI�R G CFEHXiU �QC]EHG �����JOHZ�����"hX V�CFEHGZFG IFO �TC]KQ_ � G C]ZLX[KMU �!�`I .`GJZ6" EQKM_[E %dB\CNC]EHK INILC � _[G�� �&�MK ILC��!�`I �QZFXqUHO �JG U X`V�C]EHG I=C]G ��� �`Z�{X`IFK CFKMX�QIkVYX[Z�G ��� E KMR)�`_[G�%� EHGWR)� C�� EHG U � KMI=C]I X`V � XiX[ZLUHK � C]G I VYX[Z C]EQGWILC � ZFI�K G ��� E K R � _[G)�2GJZLG�QCFC]G U .qK�

� VYO ��2IFG��JX�HU�X[ZLUHGJZ �~X���"�QX[RSK����C]Z���HILVYX`ZFR)� C]K X�!CFX ZFGJR X .[G �8G��MU UHK ILCFX[ZLCFKMX�HI�% � EHGC,"3�HK� ���{I � � CLC]G ZkK�C]EQG)R)� C�� EHG U ILC��`Z �{X[ILK CFKMX�HIrK I2R G �`ILOHZFG U �`I 7 % 7 � �HK �iG �MI�% � X �JZLG � CFGC]EHG^C]G R)� �� C]G��HC]EHG C]G R)� � � CFG^K R � _[GJI �`ZLG HX � � X#�`UHUHG U C]X`_[G CFEHGJZ�% � EHKMI �JX#� UHUHK CFKMX�hK I�:ZFG �� C]K�.[G���" ILKMR � �MG!�HZFX3�JG GJUHOHZLG����`I�K CrUQXiG I QX`CrZFG� qOQKMZFG � � ' R)� C�� EHK�H_ % � EHG UQK��{GJZFG� CP���� � _[ZLX[O HU���HUmI�� ���MG X`V�G ��� E K R � _[G0KMI �����JX[O CFGJUmVYX[ZNIFX�C]E�� CNCFEHG�"WE � .`G HG _��MK _[KMP �MGG��{G � C X�mCFEHG ZFGJILO � CFKH_ CFGJR � � � CFG�%� EHG �8ZFI=ChKMR)�`_[G K� C]EHG � KMILCwKMIWOHILGJU �`I � ZFG VYG ZFG� �JG VYX[Z P~X`C]E�I=C �`Z � XiX[ZLUHK � C]G I

��HUeP���� �q_`ZFX[O QU � I�� ���MG � X�HILKMUHG Z�� CFKMX�HI�%DB EHKMI=C]X[_`Z��`R KMI �HZFXqUHO � GJU�KHUQK� � C]KQ_ CFEHGUHKMI=C]ZLKMPHOQCFKMX� X`V �HK �iG � .����MOHG I ����HU K� � � OHUHGJI!� PHZLX#�`UwI �#" �~G ��� � C!�MX � .����MOQGJI �qVYX��� X �kG UP#" �hR O � E �kG ���`G Z �NKQ_ UHOQG CFX I=C �`ZLI %WB IFK R)� � G �HC^C]XhC]EHG I�� ���MG)��HU!P���� � _[ZFX`O HU_[G QGJZ������" �HZLXiUHO �JGJIrO QZFG � K �`P �MGkZLGJILO � CFI � ��HU�ILX �:UHG C]G ZFR K�� CFKMX� ��� IdR)�`UHGkX`V{CFEHG��8O���NK CFEHKwCFEHG ' / �5��X VACFEHG � X[O C]INEHK ILC]X`_[Z��`R VYX[Z2C]E�� C\KMR)�`_[G�% � EHG:Z�� CFKMX X VACFEHG �~G ���VYX[Z�����;KMR)�`_[G I �!�`I\CFEHG � X[R ���`ZFG UwC]X C]E�� CkK C]EHG �HZFILC � ��QU �`IFILOHR KH_ CFEHG � � '!UHXiG IHX`C&.��`Z " R O � E�P{G C,�kG G VYZ��`RSG I&����kKMR)�`_[GJI �`ZFGhZFG�HX[ZLR ��� KMILGJU �`_#� KHI=C C]E�� C�X V CFEHG�8ZFI=C KMR)�`_[G�% � EHG ZLGJIFO � C K I � .[GJZ6" EHK _[E�ILKM_� ����� C]X�� HX[KMILG .[G ZFIFK X� X`VNG ��� E IFOQPHIFG�� C]K X��NEHK� EwKMI � .�� K� � P �MG\VYX[Z �������"qIFK I %�B �JZLX[IFIkCFEHG �NEHX��MG$� / '�� �����0I �qC]EHG ZFG � ZFG 1�8 � IFO � EC]G R)� �� C]G:K R � _[GJI�� �#1 �~GJZ ����� %

" X � CFE�� C C]EHG CFGJR � � � CFG VYZ��`R GJI E�� .[G P~GJG +�HZFXqUHO � GJU �AC]EHG)� �yB �JXqUHG&� ��!_[XmX���HU �HZLXiUHO �JG C]EHG ��� C]O ���)C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]Z "�VYX[Z CFEHG ��� � O � KMR)�`_[G U � C �`ILG C %� EHG ILOHPQC]Z���� CFKMX���HZFX3�JG IFI0K I)X�HG X`V�CFEHG R X[ILC KMR �{X`ZLC �� C ��� ZLC]I)X`V�C]EQG �HK�~G � KHG�% � EHG_[X#����EHGJZLG�KMI)CFXmUQG C]G ZFR KHG CFEHG P~GJILC � � ' �yR)� C�� EHK�H_WIFX��MOQCFKMX� OQIFKQ_*������QK��iG � I0K CFEHGKMR)�`_[G ��QUwIFOQPQC]Z���� CdC]EHGNC]G R)� � � CFG\VYZ��`R G�VYZFX[R �����QC]EQG ZLGJR)�`KHK�H_:KMR)�`_[G I %�B%UHG C �`K��MG UUHGJI �JZLK�QCFKMX�hX`VAC]EHK INIFOHPQCFZ���� C]K X� �HZFX3�JG IFIaKMI�_[K�.[G mP#"WB5��`ZFU � �9O �QC]X� � 2 )�) � � %

�kG VYX`ZFG CFEHG ��� C]O�����ILOHPQC]Z���� CFKMX��� �� X3� � OHZ �cR � C�� EHKQ_wX`V�CFEHG � � ' �HZLX ��� GJI VYX`ZaCFEHGILC��`ZFIrX��C]EHG�CFGJR � � � CFG\KMR)�`_[G2C]X C]EHX[ILGNKMR)�`_[GJI�C]X �������"iILG�X����JOHZLI % � EHGaP~G CFCFGJZ O���� K C,"� � ' KMI�UHGJ_[Z��`UHG U C]X0R)���`G2K C�R � C�� E C]EQG!�kX`ZFIFG qO ���MKTC," �QZFX ��� GkX`V8CFEHGkC,�2X % � EHGkKMR)�`_[GJI�`ZFGaI�� ���MG U IFX C]E�� CdC]EQGJKMZdP���� � _[ZLX[O HU �MG�.`G � I2R)� C�� E ��HUSCFEHG SC]EHG IFOHPQCFZ���� C]K X�wX3� � OHZFI�%� EHG ZFG IFO �TCNX`V9C]EHG IFOQPQC]Z���� CFKMX�WK I ��UQK��{GJZFG� �JG:K R � _[G CFE�� CNKMI�UQX[RSK��� CFGJU P#" � X ��� �MG�.[G �IFEHX C HX[KMILG�� ��HU ��#" X[P �LG � C�CFE�� C�E �`I�.��`ZFK GJU K�WPHZFK _[E C�HG IFI\VYZFX`R3CFEHG0C]G R)� �� C]GaC]X CFEHG�������"qIFKMI KMR)�`_[G KMI _[K�.`G � ��� " �`I GJKTC]EHG Z � PHZLKM_[E C X[Z U�� Z�� I��~X`C&� C C]EHG UQG C]G ZFR KHG U

Page 11: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� �)� � � �: � �5� � � ��� � � ���k� �;� �1���1� � ���

� ��� � ��� ���@��� �&4��/<�9AKMB�?)�l#0�=KMB�?@9�#*�M7��*98KM�\B �02(%(X +=�,%�Q>JS!$#"98+ �>'34 h;u>_ 287 #*���MQ�1!$# �PX 98?3'3#$JS')KM98h8�1!#*2�B��*2(%(X +=� 9���')h8� !0')h84 98?Ie #028e 4�25')!0�SK�98!i#0�,�67��*98K\�5N&#*2�Q���X !i�1%p7�25�6')K�9Ah5� !0X�Q(#*�*95+-#0')284 9A4 %om X(<KM�,95!iX �0�,K\�,4P#vB�X �0B�25!0�,!,a\��� ')!�'@!�#0� �M!*9AKM��!0X�Q !0�,+-#*'3254 95!�!i��2�DE4 ')4 �k')h a�x�a~w69A4 % #0���M')4 +/�*�,95!i�\')4')K�9Ah8� �PX 98?3'3#$JL'@!E+/?)�,9A�*?)JLG>')!0'3Q ?3�5a

�JG� CFZFX[K U �{X[ILK CFKMX� � IFGJG '�K _ % � % � � %

� � ���� �6� �,���1� � � � � � � � � �� EHG ������cX[OQC��QOQCaX`V�CFEHG � �yB �HK��{G��MKQG0KMI � C]G �qC�� �MG0VYX[Z�G ��� E I��`R � �MG UmI=C �`Z��NEQK� E

�JX� C��`KHI KQVYX`ZFR)� C]K X� X� EHX � C]EHG �HO�� X V�C]E�� C ILC��`Z .��`ZLKMGJI �`I CFEHGwC]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI �HZFX �_[ZFG IFILGJI % � EQKMIrKMI�R G � IFOHZLGJU K&�-�MK�HG �`Z��8O�� O HK C ��QU K I �JX�#.`GJZLCFGJU C]X R � _�HK CFOHUHG\O HK CFI.qK �wG� qO � C]K X� � % � %��, �����9CFEHGJZLG �kG ZFG 2 1�1�7 K R �`_`GJI VYG U K C]XSC]EHG � XiUQG �NEHK� E ZLGJILO � CFGJUK 2 1�1�7 U�� C � �~X[K CFINVYX`Z�G ��� EhC]K RSG �yIFG ZFK GJI %

�,WC]X`C���� �qC]EHG#� ���� � � �,HK _[E CkCFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJIkU�� C � P��`IFG- OHR P{G ZFGJU 2 7 ) � � � � ILC��`ZFI ��� ZFX[ILIC]EHG �NEHX��MG X`V'C]EQG � ����� / ' � �`ZLZ�� "����JX .[G ZFKQ_&� IFOHPQILC �� CFK ���{I �!� C]EWX V9P{X`CFEwC]EQG �JX[ZLG��HU X[OQCFGJZ^ZFGJ_`KMX�HI X`V ��� � O � ����`G�% � EHG IFGwCFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJI0CFEHG !P{G�� �`R G�C]EHG IFOHP �LG � C X`VVYOHZLCFEHGJZ �������"iILKMIaC]X R G �`ILOHZFG C]EHG KMZ5�QEHX`C]X`RSG C]ZFK�� ��� �JOQZ�����" ��HU CFEHGJK Z)ZLG � � C]K�.`G �`PQK�MKTC,"C]XhUHK I�� �� " �WCFZ���QIFK C X V���� X`C 4`O �QK C]G Z � � ��QG C %�B !G �iCFG HILK�.`GwIFG �`Z�� E!X`VdC]EHG IFG�C]KMR G��IFG ZFKMG I �!�`I�� �`ZFZLKMGJUwX[OQCdC]X K UHG C]KTV " .��`ZFK�`P �MGNI=C �`ZLI\K C]EHG��8G � U ��HU �~X[ILIFKMP �MGNC]Z���HIFKTC]KQ_� � ��HG CFI � C]EHGaIFOQP �LG � C\X`V~C]EHG HG �iCdC,�2X � E����iC]GJZLI % � EHK I � E����QCFGJZdG HUHI �NK CFE)� UHK I��JOQIFIFK X�X`VdC]EHG&�HEHX C]X[R G CFZFK�, qO ���MKTC," X`V2C]EHG IFG�U�� C��*��QU �WUHG C �`K��MGJU UQGJI�� ZFK��QC]K X�!R)�`UHG X V2CFEHG���M_`X[ZFKTC]EHR UHG�.[G � X��~GJU CFX�IFG � Z�� E CFEHG U�� C�� VYX`Z�.�� ZFK � P �MG0I=C �`ZLI %

Page 12: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

��� � � ��� � � � �����

� ��� � ��� � � ��� �.4p�/<�9AKMB�?)�{!iX Q(#0�"98+/#0�,%�7��"9AKM�8N�9t%(' ��,�0�,4 +/�{')K�9Ah5�625Q(#*98'34 �,% Q>J�!0X�Q(#0�"98+/#0')4�h�#0� �#*�=KMB�?@9�#0�\')KM98h8�6[�!0�=�=4 '34 ��')h a�x a xP`�7��*28K #0���M%�9A#*98!0�/#v'3K�98h8� [�!i�,�=4 ')4 �k')h a�x�a~w8`/av�����\Q 95+ �Ph5�025X�4 %?)�=G5�=?>')!:B X��0�E!0��2A#:4�25')!0�8NA984 %l984>J�GT98�0'@9AQ ?3�C28Q(z$�1+-#:')!�!0�=�,4\95!:9.Q��*')h8�P#k25��%�9A� �F!iB�2A#1a�bg4l#0� ')!�%(' H�=�*�=4 +=�')K�9Ah8�Y9A�*�E#$Dd2 � � ��J>�"9A�&!i#*98�*!,NA#*2qQ��.B��*�,!0�=4P#0�1%M'34L#0���Y4��/<>#C+"�9AB(#*�=�Y[�DE'I#*��#0� �.�*�,!i# 2A7O#*���.G�9A�*'@9AQ�?)�!i#*98�*!"`-a �����6')45#*�=�*4 9A?�B�'3<(�=?��*�$z$�,+/#0')284 9A?)h828�*'3#0��K�!lh8')G8� 9SG8�,�0Jt!*9�#*')!i7�98+/#028�*J�K�98! �P')4�h�2A7YX 4PD�9A4P#*�,%98�0�198!C2A7�#0���F!0X�Q !0�,+/#0')284�N 95!E+=984;Q��F!i�,�=462846#0� ')!��=<(98KMB�?3�F!0X�Q(#*�*95+-#*�,% 7��*98K\�5a

��� ��� � ')����� � ��� � � ��� �#� ��� � � �� � �&� � � ��!#� �

� "WR G �`ILOHZFK�H_ C]EQG ZLXiX`C6�yR G ��3�yI O�� ZFG0UHG�.qK � CFKMX�HI�K�WC]EHG:C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI�����HUhP#" �JX�3�.[G ZLC]K�H_wCFEHG ZLGJIFO � C K C]XSR �`_�HK CFOHUHG O HKTC]I � I5�~GJZaG� O�� CFKMX� � % � � �SUQG C]G ZFR K�� C]KMX�*� ��P{GhR)�`UHGhX`VaC]EHG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK�� �HZFG��JKMILKMX��X`V C]EHG HG�� ��"#�yUQGJZFK�.[G U C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI U � C �`ILG C %� EHKMI KMI)�� KMR �{X[Z=C �� C�I=C]G � C]X RSG �`IFOHZLG*.qKMILKMP � G � X`C 4`O �HKTC]G Z CFZ���HILK C IFK _��� CFOHZFG IwK�ILC��`ZFIrX`V{IFO � KMG CdPHZLKM_[E C�QGJIFI�� � I �kG��� �`I ���K�HUHK� � C]K X� X`V~C]EQGaI � � CLC]G ZdK�HEHG ZFG CdK&�� "KMUHG� C]K��HGJU .��`ZFK�`P �MG)ILC � ZFI %� EHG �HEHX`CFX[RSG C]ZLK�WGJZLZFX[ZLI � ISUHG C]G ZFR KHG U ��� ZFX[ILISCFEHG �NEQX��MG / ' � � ZFZ�� " � ZFG �HZFG �

IFG� CFGJU K '�KM_[I�% � % 8 ��HU � % � � �NEQK� E IFEQX �NI:K� G ��� E X`V�C]EHG VYX[OHZ5� ��HG � I)C]EQG �� � ZFR I�HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK�aI�� � CFCFGJZ\K� X[OHZ �MKM_`E C��JOHZ6.[G I��`I�� VYO � CFKMX� X V �xR)�`_�HKTC]OHUHGaKwG ��� E �����X`VNC]EHGwU�� C � IFG C % � EHKMI K I UHX�QG .qK � R G �`ILOHZFK�H_ CFEHGWZFR I I � � CLC]GJZ K��C]EQG ��� CFO����2CFKMR G��IFG ZFKMG I VYX[Z ����rC]EHGwILC � ZFI K�!C]E � C ���`Z=C]K��JO ��`Z IFOHPHILG � C]KMX� � ��HU0�JZLX[IFI �yK UHG C]KTV "qKH_mC]EHX[ILGI��`R G ILC � ZFI^X�!CFEHG)� ���MK PHZ�� C]GJU ������U � C �`ILG C %WB5�G ILCFKMR)� C]G�X`V2C]EHG)�HEHX`CFX� HX`KMIFG�K I���MILX �QZFXqUHO �JG U �qP " � X�HIFK UHGJZLKH_ C]EQG C]X C ���� OHR P~GJZdX`V � X[O C]I2K P{X C]E�C]EHG ILC � Z ��HUSCFEHGI��#" .qK ��

Page 13: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� �)� � � �: � �5� � � ��� � � ���k� �;� �1���1� � ��

� � � � 1! 8 � X[_ � 2 ��� � � � � ������ � � � � %(� �

�NEHGJZLG � � � KMI CFEHG �HEHX`CFX�0HX[K IFGWK R)�`_�QK C]OQUHGwO QK C]I VYX`Z ILC��`Z �� ��� " � KMI C]EHG CFX`C ��� OHR P~GJZ�X`V � X[O C]IrR G �`ILOHZFG U�VYX`Z�ILC��`Z �� ����HU " ���� KMI�C]EHG� OHR P~GJZ�X V � X[O C]I�R G � IFOHZLGJUVYX[Z0C]EQG I �#" K �`IFILX�� K � CFKMX� �NKTC]E ILC��`Z �� ��% � EHKMI:VYX[ZLR X`VdC]EQG)�HEQX`C]X� HX`KMIFG�G� qO � C]K X��HZFX .qKMUQGJI��� GJI=C]KMR)� CFG K�wR)�`_�HKTC]OHUHGaO HKTC]I��3�NEHK�� EWE��`I!���MILX P~GJG � �MX`CLC]GJUSK '�KM_[I�% � % 8��HU � % � %

B)I�CFEHGJZLG^K I � IFKM_�HK���� �� C�� E���Q_[G K� �JZLX �NUQKH_�P~G C,�2GJG C]EHG:K� HGJZ\VYX`OHZ �����0I ��HUC]EHG X`OQC]G Z VYX`OHZ �����0I X`V / '��5��QU � E ��H_[G I K� �JZFX �NUHK�H_ �NK C]EQK � ������KTC]IFG�� V �cC,�2XO � GJZLC��`K C,")�JOHZ6.[G I �`ZFG �QZFGJILG C]G UWVYX[ZkG ��� E ����� �QX�QG VYX[Z!� �JZLX �NUQGJUhZFG _[KMX� ��HU X�HGVYX[Z �� O � ZFX �NUHGJU�ZLGJ_[K X� % '�KM_ % � % 8 IFEHX �NI CFEHG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK�� �HZLG �JK IFK X��X`V�CFEHGwVYX[OQZO � ZFX �NUHGJU X[OQCFGJZ �����0I % � EHG ����� qOQR P{G Z\C]X �NEHK�� E G ��� E*� ��HG �'ZLG VYG ZFI�KMI�R)�`Z �`GJU %� EHG^ZFGJUhC]ZLK ��Q_��MG I�IFEHX �xCFEHG �QEHX`C]X`RSG C]ZFK��0O � GJZ=C �`K� C," �NKTC]EHK� � I��`R)� �MGJUmIFOQPHIFG�� C]K X�ZFG _[KMX� X`V�� � ZFX �NUHGJU ���`ZLC X`V2C]E�� C I��~G � K���� ����� � �NEHGJZLG �`I^C]EHGSP �MOQG�CFZFK��H_�� GJI:IFEQX �C]EHG I��`RSG:UQG C]G ZFR K�� C]KMX� VYX[Z ��hO � ZFX �NUHGJU ZFGJ_`KMX�WX`V�C]E�� C ����� %� EHG)C,"3�HK�� ���~UHG��QC]E X V � � X C�4`O �QK C]G Z2CFZ���HILK C2KMI � 7 % 7 2 8 R)�`_�HKTC]OHUHG � �kE �`ZFP~X� HG �`O

G C ��� % 1�7�7�7�� ��HU E��`I0P~GJG� � �MX`CLC]G U �`I � UHX`CLC]GJU � KHG�%:B VYOHZLCFEHGJZ-� KHG � C 7 % 7#1�8 R)�`_��HK CFOHUHG � 1 % 8 � � E �`I ���MILX P~GJG�*� �MX`CLC]GJU �QC]X�R)�`Z�� C]EHG ��� �QZFX �iKMR)� C]G0O � �{G Z �MKMR K CdC]X CFEHGC]Z���HIFKTC�UHG �iC]E CFE�� C)� �aX`C 4`O �HKTC]GJZ&� ���HG C)� X[O � U � �`OHIFG�����HU�EHG� �JGmC]EHG IFG C,�2X � KHGUHG�� HG^CFEHG ZFG _[KMR G0K �NEHK�� E�� CFZ���HILK CNK I�G����{G�� CFGJU CFX � KMG�%� EHG2UHK��{GJZLG C�ILG HILK CFK�.qK CFKMGJI'X VQC]EQGdVYX[OQZ�X[OiC]GJZ �����0I � �� P{G � � G �`Z ��":ILGJG� K '�KM_ % � % 8 %

�, ��� ZLC]K��JO ��`Z �#����� 2 IFEQX �NI!� .`GJZ " ��`ZF_[G�UQK��{GJZFG� �JG � � 2 R)�`_�HKTC]OHUQG � K �HEHX C]X[R G CFZFK��HZFG��JK IFKMX� P{G C,�kG G �C]EHG � ZFX �NUHGJU ��HU�O �JZFX �NUHG U � �`ZLCFI X`VNC]E�� C&����� � EHK�� %+/�EQG ZFG UHO �JK�H_�C]EHG KMR)�`_[G I �)KTC ��� I�HX`CFK� GJU�C]E�� ChCFEHKMI*�����}E�� U%ILKM_�HK+��� �� C���" UHK��{GJZLG CIFG�HIFKTC]K�.qKTC," ��HU _[G HG Z���� �~X[ILC6�yZFG UHO � C]KMX� O���� K C," CFE���mC]EHG^X`C]EQGJZaIFG�.`G % '��� C �8G � UHKQ_��HU�U��`Z �#� IFOHPiC]Z���� C]K X��K ���`ZLCFK� O � �`Z � �`OHILGJU R X[ZLG C]ZFX`OHP �MGhEHG ZFGhC]E��� K��CFEHGhX`C]EHG Z�����0I � IFG G�'�K _ % 1 % ��� % � EHK I�E��`I�UHKMZLG � C���" � �`OQIFGJU C]EHGhUHK+�cG ZFG C �HZLG �JK IFK X�HI�IFG G K�'�KM_ % � % 8 % " G�.[G ZLC]EQG �MG IFI��2K�!C]EQKMI ����� �9C]EQG �HEHX C]X[R G CFZFK� �HZLG �JK IFK X� KMI^_[XqXiU!G HX`OH_[EC]X � � 2 � % 7 2 ) % 7 �iVYX[ZdC]EHG)C,�2X&�JZLX �NUQKH_ � G�.`G �MIkZFGJI �{G�� CFK�.[G���"��QC]X UHG C]G�� C � �aX`C 4`O �HKTC]G ZC]Z���HIFKTC %�����#�+���MILX IFEHX �NI)� UQK��{GJZFG� �JGmP~G C,�2GJG �C]EHGWC,�2X!ZLGJ_[K X�HI��!���TC]EHX`OH_[E X`V5� R O � E

�MX �2GJZ �`R � �MKTC]OHUHG CFE��� ����� 2 % B _#�`K �dCFEHKMI KMI�UHOHGhC]X C]EQG _[G�HGJZ���� O����MKTC," X`V C]EHK I����� P~GJK�H_SI �MK _[E C���" �MX �2GJZ�C]E��� C]EQG X`CFEHGJZLI % � EHKMI5����� �����MX �NI�C]Z���HIFKTC]I�C]X P~G^G �`IFK���"IFG G �X� ILC��`ZFI�CFX � � 2�) % 7 2�) % 8 VYX[Z�CFEHG\C,�2X � ZFX �NUHK�H_-�MG�.[G � I % � EHGNX`C]EHG Z�C,�2X �����0I � 8��HU�� � ILEHX � .`GJZ " �JX�HILKMI=C]G C �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZ ")�NK C]EWP~X`CFE � ZFX �NUHK�H_ �MG�.[G � I ����HU �`ZFG:_[XqXqUC]X � � 2 � % �)��QU � � 2�) % 7 �~ZFG I��~G � CFK�.`G ��"�% B �� � � X`C]I K*'�KM_[I�% � % 8 ��HU � % � ILEHX � �HEHX`CFX�HX[K IFG\R G �`ILOHZFG RSG� C]I �HZLXiUHO �JGJU&.qK � � % � % �0VYX[Z � X[R)� �`ZFK IFX� � I�C]EHG�ILR ����3�{X[K� C]I % � EHG

Page 14: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

� ��� � ����� � ���.f ��28#025K\�=#0�*')+�B �0�1+/'@!i')284 2A7:#*���F7�25X��&28X�#0�=�YX�4 +=�02�D&%(�1% � ��b � � �v!,NKM�,95!iX �0�1%695!E�*KM!%(�,G>')9A#0')284 !�7�25�&#$DC2L%('@!$#*'34 +/#Y�*�=h5'3254 !EDE'3#0��')4{�,95+"� � � � 7��"9AKM�8aE�����F�*�,%6#*�0'@9A4 h8?)�,!E')4 %('@+=9A#0��#*���F�*KM!')4t9{+/�*2�D&%(�,% !iX Q !i�1+-#*'3254�287d#*��� � � �qN�DE���=�*�,95!vQ�?3X ��#0�*')984�h8?)�,!v')4 %('@+=9A#0�M#0� �LKM�,98!0X��*�=KM�=4P#�7�28�F984X�4+/�*2�D&%(�,% �*�=h8')284 a;����� %�'H�=�*�=4 +=�L')4t�0K�!FB �0�1+/'@!i')284�'@!F+/?)�,98�,a �&4>J KM98h84�'3#0X%(� 9�#l28�F?)2�Dd�,��#0� 984#*���\w�a _�� ?)'34 �q'@!.287 !iX��L+='3�,45#YB���2A#*28KM�/#*�0'@+ �PX 98?3'3#$J;#02 %('@!0B�?)9TJ 9 �.2A#��8X�B 'I#*�=�&#*�*984 !0'I#1a.�����l%��=�*'3G5�,%B�� 2A#0254 4�28'@!i�v7�25�E#0���1!i�F!*9AKM��!i#*9A�"!�[�95!�B�,��� ��a x�a uP`d'@!&!i� 2�DE4695!&!iK�98?3?OB�28')4P#*!EQ��=?)2�Do#*���,!0��?)'34��1!=a��%('@!*+/X !*!i')28462A7k�,95+"�;')4 %(')G>')%(X9A? � � � '@!�K�98%(��')46#0����#*�/<>#,a

Page 15: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� �)� � � �: � �5� � � ��� � � ���k� �;� �1���1� � � �

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

15 16 17 18 19 20 210

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

2.5%

1.5%

� ��� � ����� �3� �.�����qB ��2A#*28KM�/#*�0'@+�B��*�,+=')!0'3254 2A7�#0� ��7�28X��v')4�4��=�v+/�*2�D&%(�,% � �kb � � �v!=a �.h598'34�N #0���l�0�1%984 %qQ ?3X���B�28')4P#*!:')4 %('@+=9�#*�C#0���EB��*�,+=')!0')284q287 #*���E+/�*2�D&%(�,%l9A4 %lX�4 +=�02�D&%(�1%F�*�=h5'3254 !k2A7 #*��25!0� � � �Y!,N5984 %#*���MB25'34P#*!Y#*� 9�#�?)'3�MQ��=?)2�D #0���MK�9A')4�+/X��*G8�1!v98�0�q#0���MB�� 2A#0254�4 28'@!i�\KM�,98!0X��*�=KM�=4P#"!=aq��� �\!*9AKM� �&28#�5X�B�'3#0�,�d#*�*984 !0'I#�%(�=B(#*� !E98!d')4 �k'3ha�x�a~_F� 9TG5�&Q��=�=46K�9A� �8�1%L98!C%(2A#0#0�1%L?)'34��1!=a ��� �v%(' H�=�*�=4P#�!0�=4!i'3#0')G>'I#$J?)�=G5�=?@!�2A7 #*���F%(' ��,�0�,4P# � ��b � � �v!E')!E+=?3�19A�1a

Page 16: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

�HEHX`CFX� HX[K IFG ���`I�UQG C]G ZFR KHG UwVYX[Z2G ��� EhILC��`Z!� �MX`CLC]GJUWX�wC]EHG IFG-� OHZ .`GJI � ��HUWEHG �JG �`ZLG�HZFG IFG� CFGJU�K C]EHG I��`R G �JX��MX[OHZ �`I CFEHGJK Z ZLGJI��~G � C]K�.[G �JZLX �NUHKH_ ZFGJ_`KMX� % �kX`C]E �HEHX`CFX�HX[K IFG � KHG I � ZFGSCFX`C �����" �JX�HILKMI=C]G C VYZFX[R�X�HG)�JZLX �NUQKH_ ZLGJ_[K X�!CFX C]EQG HG �iC VYX[Z G ��� E���`Z=C]K� O � � Z ����� �AK�HUHK�� � CFKH_WC]E � C P ��� � _[ZFX[O HU I��#" GJI=C]K R � CFGJI �`ZLG)� X�HIFK ILCFG C ��� ZFX[ILI���� �JZFX �NUHK�H_&�MG�.[G � I %'�KM_ % � % � IFEHX �NI C]EHG�I�� RSG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK�� �HZFG��JK IFKMX� R G � IFOHZLGJR G C]I:VYX[Z:G ��� E!X V2CFEHG

VYX[OHZdK QGJZ!� ZFX �NUHG U �����0I %�B)I!�^CFGJILCFKMR G CkCFX CFEHG �`PQK�MKTC," X`VcC]EHG5�0K��{GJZFG� �JG �yR � _[KH_�HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� R G CFEHXqU � C]EHG�_[G�HGJZ���� O���� K C," X V2CFEHG&�HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6" K CFEHGJILG G �qC]G QIFK�.`G ��"�JZLX �NUQGJUwZLGJ_[K X�HI�K I � X�HILKMILCFG C �NK CFE CFE�� C �HZLXiUHO �JGJUSK CFEHG O �JZLX �NUQGJU �����0I�%�B)_#� K �C]EHGkZFGJU �{X[K� C]I�K�HUHK�� � CFGdCFEHG!�HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK�� �HZLG � KMIFK X� VYX[Z9C]EQG��JZLX �NUQGJU�IFOHPQIFG � C]K X� X`VHCFEHG����� � ��QU C]EHG P � OHG �~X[K� CFI)VYX[ZaC]EHG O �JZLX �NUQGJU % ����� 1 IFEHX �NI .[G Z " �2G ����CFEHG G��{G � CX`V�G �iCFG HILK�.`G �JZFX �NUHK�H_ X��C]EHGSZFG IFO �TC �� C �HZFG��JKMILKMX� � �NK CFE!CFEHGwZLGJU �~X[K CFI G �QEQKMPHKTC]KQ_� ILKM_�HK+��� �� C���" ��`ZF_[G Z I��HZLG �`U � C ��#" ���`Z=C]K� O � � Z^R)�`_�QK C]OQUHG�% � EHG �JOHZ6.[GJI X V ����� 1R � C�� E .`GJZ6" �2G ��� C]EHX[ILG2X V ����� � ����HU E � .`G�� �HZFG��JKMILKMX�^X`V 7 % 7#1�8 R)�`_�C]X � � 2 � % 1 2�) % 7VYX[Z\C]EQG C,�2X �JZFX �NUHK�H_ �MG�.`G � I %� EHG&�JOHZ6.[G I X`V������ � ��HU �WILEHX � � GJIFI X`V �WI�� � CFCFGJZ P~G C,�2GJG C]EHG C,�2X*� ZFX �NUHK�H_

�MG�.[G � I % � EQKMIrKMIrUHOHGNC]X:CFEHGaCFG � GJI�� X��~GaX'�cILG C]I � � OHIFK�H_^CFEHG �JX[ZLG X V ��� � O �aCFX P{GNI�� KM_[E C���"IFEHKTV C]G U%K� CFX �����0I 1 ��HU � % � G ZFG C]EHG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK�� qO ���MKTC," KMIh_[XqXqUeG HX[OQ_[E�K�ILC��`ZFIaX`V�� � 2 � % 8 ��QU � � 2�) % 7 C]X G �`ILK��" �JX� C��`K*� CFZ���HILK C %2B _#�`K �HC]EHG �HEHX`CFX��QX[KMILGGJI=C]KMR)� CFGJI:VYX[Z:C]EHG IFGSILC � ZFI^E�� .[GwP~GJG� � � X`CFCFGJU+�`I IFR)���� �~X[K� CFI:VYX[Z �JX[R ���`ZLKMIFX� % '8X[ZC]EHZLGJGhX`VaC]EHG*�����0I��!�HEHX C]X� HX[K IFGWKMI � X �kG Z�CFE��� C]EQG*��� C]O �����MK _[E C��JOQZ .[GWI � � CLC]G Z)� CV �`K CaR)�`_�HKTC]OHUHG I % � EHK I)K I UHOQG C]X�C]EQG UHK+�cG ZFKQ_SILG HILK C]K�.qK C]K GJINX`V�CFEHG ����� UHG CFG � CFX[ZFI��C]EHG�" UHK I�� �� " UHK��{GJZLG CdIFK _����� � C]X �,HX[K IFGdVYX[Z � � �iGJU G����{X`IFOHZLGaCFKMR G�% �aX �kG�.[GJZ��iKTC � �� P~GIFG G CFE�� C�CFEHG �HEHX`CFX[RSG C]Z6"WKMI��HEQX`C]X�3�,�MK RSKTC]G USC]X � � 2 � 2 ��I �JZLX[IFINC]EHG-�NEHX��MG �`ZFZ�� "�%� EHGJILG#�8_[OHZLGJI�ILEHX �%CFE�� CkCFEHG �HEQX`C]X[R G CFZFK��5�HZLG �JK IFK X� KMI2_[XqXiU G�HX[OH_`E C]X �����MX � CFEHG

G����~GJZFK RSG� C^CFX �HZFX[P~G � C �MG �`ILC:CFEHG�PHZFK _[E C]G ILC 2 % 8 � 1 R)�`_�HKTC]OHUQGJI:X`VdC]EHG&���MOHI=C]GJZ R)�`KIFG� qOQG � G VYX[Z ��#"hX[ZFPQK C]K�H_ _[K�� C � � ��QG C]I�% � EQG ZFR I��HZLG �JK IFK X�*� OHZ .`GJI5���MILXSILEHX �xC]E�� CC]EHG UHG CFG � C]KMX� X`V .��`ZFK�`P � GaI=C �`ZLIkK I!�~GJZFR K CLC]G U CFX � � 1�2 % 7 �NKTC]E .��`ZLK �`PQK�MKTC," � R)� � K CFOHUHGJIX`V�� 7 % 1�7 R)�`_�QK C]OQUHGJIaVYX[Z CFEHG C,�kX � ZFX �NUHKQ_ �MG�.`G � I � �HZLGJILG C]K�H_ �� G����JG��� G C-� E��� �JGC]X UHG CFG � C��HZFG�.iK X[OHI ��" O � HX � .��`ZFK�`P � GJI % ';OQZLC]EQGJZdUHKMI �JOHILIFKMX� X`V'C]EQG ��� C]O���� �MK RSKTC]I�CFXC]EHG-.��`ZLK �`P � G0ILC��`Z �`R � �MKTC]OHUHG I!�NK���cP~G R �`UQG:K*�kE����QCFGJZ � %

Page 17: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � ��� �k����� � � � � �� � �1� � �6� �1� ��� � ��� � � � � � � �

2510 2511 2512 2513 2514 2515 2516 2517

-20

-10

0

10

20

2517 2518 2519 2520 2521 2522 2523 2524

-20

-10

0

10

20

2525 2526 2527 2528 2529 2530 2531 2532

-20

-10

0

10

20

2533 2534 2535 2536 2537 2538 2539

-20

-10

0

10

20

� ��� � ���l� � ��� �.4l�=<�9AKMB�?)� �"9TD�% 9�#*95!i�=#kG�98�0'@9AQ�?)� !i#*98��?)'3h5�P#*+/X �0G5�8N�98!kB��*2(%(X +/�1%�DE'3#0�F#*��� �.b ��KM�/#*��2(%%(�1!0+=�0')Q��,%\'34\#*���EB��*�=G>'325X !�!0�,+-#*'3254�a:����')! ')! 9A4\�,+/?)')B !i')4�h�Q�')4 98�0Jq!i#*98� '@%(�=4P#0'3� �1%lQ>Jq#0��� � 28KqQ � +,9A�*h8?)�f:�,�0')2(%(28h5�*98K ')4 #*����GT98�0'@9AQ ?3��!i�19A�"+"��a:����')!C'@!E9A4;�/<�9AKMB�?)�Y?)')h8�P#*+=X��0G5�.X !0�,% #02M!0��2�Dp#0� ��!0X�Q !0���PX��,4P#25X(#0B�X�#&2A7:#0��� � � f:N !0�=�,46')4 �k'3hadx�a ��N(')4 %('@+=9A#0')4�hM#0� �q9AQ�')?)'I#$J;2A7k#0����KM�/#*��2(%6#02L%(�=#0�1+-#.B��=�*'32(%('@+/'3#0')�,!')46#0����#*'3KM�/eg!0�=�*'3�1!C% 9�#*95!i�=#,a

� ��� , .07��!$�6;(+$ �:@+7 |�bQ$�6e#�7 bQ79<cb8(+/ks � 7 bH.0/N*

" X �DC]E � C)CFEHG C]X C ��� �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� C]K RSG �yIFG ZFK GJI)U � C �`P �`IFG E �`I)P~GJG� �QZFXqUHO �JG U � KTC)K IHX � CFKMR G\C]X^P{G _[K C]EQG5�� ����"qIFK I %�'�KMZLILC �JX`RSG IdCFEHGNIFG � Z�� EwVYX[Z�R GJUQKMOHR � CFX��yEHK _[E �`R � � K��C]OHUQG .��`ZFK�`P �MG ILC��`ZFI-��HU C]EHG� C]EHG R)�`K� IFG �`Z�� E VYX[Z � � ��QG C � Z "mC]Z���HIFKTC]I % � EQG C]Z���HIFKTCIFG �`Z�� E ��� _[X[ZLK C]EQR�KMI �HZLGJIFG� C]GJU K� C]EQG HG �iC � E����QCFGJZ %aB �'X[R P�� ��� �`ZF_��MG ��G ZFKMXqUHX[_`Z��`R� ���� � R G CFEHXiU �!�`I-� EHX`IFG C]XWILG �`Z � E VYX[Z �~GJZFK XiUQK� .�� ZFK � P �MG I)K CFEHG,�� ��� �MK _[E C�� OHZ .`GU�� C��`P��`ILG � �'X[R P 2�) � � ����� � ZF_�� G 2�) � 1 � �kZLG CFCFEHX[ZLILC 1�7�7 2�� % � EHKMI ���`I G �`ILK��" UHX�HGSP "OHIFK�H_ CFEHG����� VYO � CFKMX�)�NK C]EQK " OQRSG ZFK� ��� � G��JK�~GJI�� � �rZLGJILI�G C���� % 2�)�)#1�� �3�NEQK� E �!�`I�MK� �`G U C]X �-�HZFX`_[Z��`R �NZFKTCFCFG C]X ����� � G �QCrC]EQG\VYX[ZFR X`V;C]EHG�UHK+�cG ZFG� �JG�K R �`_`KH_ �HEHX`CFX[R&�G CFZ " � � %� �`E � �HZFK�.�� C]G �JX[R R O HK�� � CFKMX� � % '�KM_ % � % �SILEHX �NI-�� G � � R)� � G X`V �� G ���MK�QIFKQ_PHK �`Z "SILC��`Z��MK _[E C�� OHZ .`G-�`I\VYGJUWK� C]X C]EQG����� ZLX[OQC]K�HG�% � EQG-�{G ZFKMXqUHK��JK C,"�K I�� � G �`Z ��" IFG G P#"�G�"[G�� ��QUSC]EQG)ZFG IFO �TC]K�H_ �{X �2GJZkI �{G�� CFZFOHR �HZLX .qK UHGJI!� .`GJZ ")�����JOHZ�� C]G RSG �`IFOQZFGaX`VcCFEHG�MG�H_`C]EhX`VAC]EQKMI��~GJZFK XiUQK�JKTC,"wK�hO HK CFI�X`V�U�� "iI�%� EHK I �����RSG C]EHXqUeKMI � .��`ZFK� C]K X� X��C]EQG ' � ILC '8X[OHZLKMGJZ � Z���HILVYX[ZLR �~GJZLKMXqUHK� K C,"

IFG �`Z�� EhR G C]EQXiU � ��HU �!�`I�X[ZLKM_[K�������" �HZLXiUQO �JG UmI �{G��JK+��� ������"�C]X X .`GJZ�� X[R G)C]EHG-�QZFX[P � GJR

Page 18: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

X`V^O HG�.[G ��" I ����� GJUpU�� C ��% �,eX[OHZ � �`IFG�� C]EQGJIFG _����HI �`ZLG � � OHIFG U%P#" U � "3� KM_[E C ��HU� � X[OHU " HKM_[E CFI % B (HX[ZLR ��� � �{G ZFKMXqUHX[_`Z��`R UHXqGJI HX`C ��� �JX`O CmVYX`ZwC]EHG IFG _#���QI � ��HUC]EHG IFGS_[K�.`G I �HOHZLKMX[OHI O #�!�� C]G U ZFGJILO � CFI %&/�K CFE CFEHG ���� � �*'8X[OQZFKMG Z-�{X �2GJZ^I��~G � C]ZFOQRKMI �QZFXqUHO �JG U C]E�� C ��� � X[O C]I VYX[Z C]EHG IFGW_#���QI K CFEHGwC]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI�% � EHG��'X[R P�� ��� �`ZL_��MGRSG C]EHXqU�VYX[Z�O HG�.`G ��" I ����� GJU U�� C � KMI&� HX � C]X P{G*�+�~X �kG ZLVYO ���!� "�CFX ��QU � ��HUC]G ILC C]EQG IFK _�HK�� � �� � G X`V � �2G ���+�{G ZFKMXqUHK��SILKM_�����MI % � EQGWZFGJILO � CFKH_ I��~G � CFZFOHR}E��`I CFEHGI��`R G:ILC�� C]K ILCFK� ��� �HZLX��{G ZLCFKMGJI��`I � ILC ��HU��`ZLU �~X �kG ZNI��~G � CFZFOHR ��HUhK V � �{G ZFK XiUHK��JKTC," � � �KMI UHG C]G�� C]G U K��CFEHGhU�� C�� �!� I �HK� GmK I �HZFXqUHO � GJU K C]EQGmI �{G�� CFZFOHR � C � VYZFG� OHG ��"�X`V1 �.� � % � G� �JG P " �QE��`IFG � �NZ���� �HK�H_ CFEHG C]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I\C]X C]EQG EHK _[EHG ILC �{G ���WKWCFEHG �~X �kG ZI��~G � C]ZFOQR*�HCFEHG �� C]OQZFG X`VAC]EHG �~GJZFK XiUQK�JKTC," � ��mP{G IFG G � � G �`Z ��" K�WC]EHG �MK _[E C�� OHZ .`G�%� EHG)ZLGJILO � CkX`V9ZFO HKH_^C]EHG �MK _[E C��JOQZ .[G IFG G WK '�KM_ % � % � C]EQZFX[OH_`EwC]EHK I �~GJZLKMXqUHX[_[Z��`R

�HZFX`_[Z��`R K I2C]EQG �{X �2GJZ\I �{G�� CFZFOHR�IFGJG�WK '�KM_ % � % ��% � EHG �~G ��� UHG CFG � C]GJU �~GJZLKMXqUHK� K C," K I� � G �`Z ��"SIFGJG��� C ��hG��qC]ZLGJR G ��"wEHKM_`E �{X �2GJZ �JX[R ���`ZLGJUWC]X CFEHG:ZFG ILCaX`V9C]EHG UHK ILCFZFKMPQOQC]K X� %� EHKMI&�~G ��� �MKMG I � C 7 % 2 � � �`U � �NEHK� E�KMI G � ��� C���" E����TVNC]EHGWC]ZLOHG �{G ZFK XiU X`V � � 7 % � ��� � U %� EHKMIkKMIkUQOHG)C]X C]EHG0ILK OHILX[KMU���� �� C]OHZLG0X`V'C]EQKMIkG�� � K�HILKH_ I=C �`Z��iCFEHG �~GJZFK XiUQX[_[Z�� R �HK� � GJUO � X�HGwIFK OHILX[KMU ��� �~GJZLKMXqU ���NEHK�� E KMI E ��� V\CFEHGwCFZFOHG �~GJZLKMXqU0�`I X�HG X[ZLPHK C X`VNC]EHGwILC � ZG� O�� CFGJIdC]X:C,�kX IFK�qOQIFX[K U���� �~GJZLKMXqUHK� K C]K GJI�% � EHK IrKMI �� KMUHG ���HG � � R)� � GNX`VcEQX � C]EHK I �9X`R P��� � ZF_�� G���GJZLKMXqUHX[_[Z��`R R G CFEHXqU � �� P{G OHILGJU C]XhIFG �`Z�� E � ��`ZF_[G C]KMR G�� IFG ZFKMG I0U�� C��`P��`ILG��HU �HK� �wX[OQC�C]EQX[IFG:C]E � CaUHKMI � � � " ILO � E � ILKM_�HK+��� �� CNILKM_� ��� %B)I X[ZFK _[K������"wKMR � �MG RSG� C]GJU X� CFEHG CFKMR G��yILGJZLKMGJIaU�� C��`P��`ILG�� �� "mI �HK� G �`P~X .`G C,�NK� G

C]EHGaI�� � CFCFGJZrX`V{C]EHG �~X[K C]IrK��CFEHGNC]X`C������{X �2GJZdI��~G � C]ZFOQR ���`IdKMUQG C]K+�8GJU)�`I � � ��HUHK U�� CFG.��`ZFK�`P �MGdILC��`Z % ILKH_)CFEHKMI �JX�QUHK CFKMX� ����HU ZLO HK�H_ CFEHG��HZLX[_[Z��`RDX� C]EQG!�NEHX�� G 2 7�) � � � �

ILC��`ZFIrK CFEHG�C]K RSG �yIFG ZFK GJI�U�� C �`P�� IFG�� 1') � ��2 � �MKM_`E C��JOHZ6.[G I �kG ZFGNVYX[O HU C]X � X� C �`K� IFO � E ����� ��� ZFG C �~GJZFK XiUQK�JKTC,"�� G� O�� C]K�H_WC]X � 1 ��� X V2CFEHG C]X`C�����U�� C��`P��`ILG�% � EHG IFG UHG CFG � C]KMX�HI�kG ZFG\CFEHG �G�� �`R KQGJU K UHG C��`K� %�� C �!�`I HX C]K� GJU CFE�� C�CFEHG�.��`ILC�R)� �LX[ZLK C,"^X`V8CFEHKMI � KMI=C��!�`I�JX[R �~X[IFG U�X`V �JX[R R X� I "qILCFGJR)� C]K��SG��cG�� C]I KHEQGJZFG� C K� CFEHG U�� C ����UHOQG CFX I=C �`ZLI ���MX[ILGC]X I�� CFOHZ�� CFKMX� X[Z-.[G Z "+� � X[IFG�C]XhC]EHGSR � _�HK CFOHUHG � KMR K C]I)X`V\C]EQGSU�� C �`ILG C %WB � CFO���� � 1��.��`ZFK�`P �MG I �2GJZLG*���MIFX UQKMILCFZFK PHOQC]G U K CFEHKMI I��`R)� �MG�� ��HU0�kG ZFG �HO ���MGJU VYZLX[R�C]EHG � KMILC X`V1 ) � � 2 � � ��HUHKMU � C]G I .qK� .qKMILO�����G � � RSK��� C]K X� X`V2C]EHG&HX���,�HE �`IFG � �NZ���� �{G U � KM_[E C�� OHZ .`GJI�%B5���2C]EQX[IFG � ��HUHKMU � C]G I C]E�� C G��iEHKMPQK C]G U � � �MG �`Z �~GJZFK XiUQK�JKTC," P "�G�"`G �2GJZLG*� � C ���MX[_[OQGJU ��MG � .qK�H_ ��I��`R � �MG:X`V 2 7�7 VYX[Z\CFEHG ������ .�� ZFK � P �MG � KMI=C %

� �JG0CFEHG �MK _[E C�� OHZ .`GJI\C]E � C��2GJZFG ���MG � Z���" UHOQG0C]X .��`ZFK�`P � G I=C �`ZLI��kG ZFG:KMUQG C]K+�8GJU �QP "�HE��`ILG�� �NZ���� �QKH_ CFEHG � ��HUHKMU � C]G)�MKM_`E C��JOHZ6.[G I � C CFEHG UHG C]G�� C]G U �~GJZLKMXqU ��CFEHG �� C]OHZLG X`VC]EHG �{G ZFK XiUHK��JKTC," KMIrIFG G %rB G�� �`R � �MGaX`V � �JX[ZLZFG�� C���" �HE��`ILG�� �NZ���� �~GJU G�� � K�HILKH_^PHK �`Z "KMI\ILEHX � K� '�K _ % � % ) % � EHK I�KMIkCFEHG:I�� RSG0I=C �`Z��`I�IFG G hK '�K _[I % � % � ��HU � % ��iC]EHG � C]OHZLGX`VAC]EHG:UHG C]G�� C]G U��~GJZLKMXqUHK� K C," KMI\X`P .qK X[OHI % � � G �QE��`IFG � �NZ���� �~GJU �HCFEHG �{G ZFKMXqUWKQUHK� � C]G UP#" C]EHG ���� ��� I ���TC]G ZFGJU � � C^CFEHG C]EHK ZFU IFK _�HK�� � �� C �8_[OQZFG � O C]K�� �mR KQKMR OHR�K CFEHGI�� � CFCFGJZaX`V�CFEHG �{X[K� C]I��!�`I ILGJG���~CFEHKMI�.���� OHG-��� I ZLG �JX`ZFUHG U �`I�C]EQG C]ZLOHG � �~GJZLKMXqUmX V�CFEHG.��`ZFK�`P �MG�%�� " ZLO HK�H_WC]EHK I �~GJZLKMXqUHX[_[Z��`R ���M_[X`ZFK CFEHR�X� C]EHG �NEHX�� G�U�� C � P��`IFG�� .qK IFO����KHI �{G�� CFKMX� ��QU �HE��`ILG�� �NZ���� �HK�H_WC]X CFEHG�������yUHG C]GJZLRSK�HGJU �~GJZLKMXqU �cCFEHG ������ .�� ZFK � P �MGILC��`Z � � C ��� X[_[OHG ��� I X[PQC��`KHG U % � EQKMI � � C ��� X[_[OHG���� � OHISCFEHG �������"qIFK IwO HUQGJZLC����`G��X�

Page 19: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � �1� � ����� � � ��� �

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

0

50

100

150

200

250

� ��� � ��� ��� ��� �.4{�/<�9AKMB�?)��B2�DC�=�&!0B��,+-#*�0X K B��*2(%(X +=�,%6G>')9\#*��� ��25KqQ � +,9A�*h8?)��f:�,�0')2(%(28h5�*98K 2846#0���?)'3h5�P#*+/X �0G5�FB��*�,!0�=4P#0�1%{'34 ��')h a�x a~�(aY�����\B�19 �{%(�=#0�,+/#0�1%SB��=�*'32(%{'@!�+/?)�,9A�*?)J;G>'@!i')Q�?)�8NO9A4 %S')!v?)2>+,9�#*�,%S9A#9\B��=�*'32(%62A7:}�a)]T��x��8%ON>DE��'@+"� ')!��=<�98+-#*?3J;� 9A?37�287�#*����#0�*X���B��=�*'32(%Oa ��� ')!&!0��2�D&!C#*���F9AQ�')?)'I#$JL287�#*��� � � fKM�/#*��2(%;#02�!iX+=+/�1!0!*!i7�X�?3?)J %(�=#0�1+-#&G�9A�*')98Q�?)��!i#*98�*!,N>DE'I#*�S9A46�/<>#0�*�=KM�,?3J !i#0�*284 h\95!0!02(+/'@9�#0�1%;!0')h84 98?�a

C]EHG R�KMI\CFEHG IFOHP �LG � C X`VAC]EHG HG �qC5� E����QC]G Z %

� � � � .0$rj bQ796�| o:1�1 $�6Hl

� EHK I � E����QC]G Z5�HZLGJIFG� C]GJU � UHG C��`K� GJUmUHKMI �JOHILIFK X� X�mC]EHG^ZFG�� � CFK�.`G^R GJZLK CFI ��HU UHK I��`U3�.��� C �`_[G I �`IFILX�� K � CFGJU �NK CFE C]EHGNR)�`K RSG C]EHXqUHI � .��`K��`P �MGrC]X �HZLXiUQO �JG��HEQX`C]X[R G CFZ " VYZFX[R�`ILCFZFX�QX[RSK�� ���~KMR)�`_[G I % � VAC]EHG IFG�� �0K+�cG ZFG� �JG��yR)�`_[K�H_ B5 ����"qIFK I � � �yB � KMI\C]EQG:RSG C]EHXqUP{G ILC:ILOHK CFGJU CFX ��� � ��"hC]XwCFEHG ��`ZF_`G ��� � O � KMR)�`_[G U�� C��`IFG C � �`I K C �HZFX .qKMUQGJI-�).`GJZ6" ��� ��JOHZ�� C]G^R G �`ILOHZFG RSG� CaX`V�C]EHG^ZFG�� � CFK�.`G:UHK��{GJZLG � G K� PHZLKM_[E C�HGJILI X`V ��#" ���`Z=C]K� O � � Z\ILC��`ZVYZFX[R X�HG KMR)�`_[G C]XhC]EHG HG �iC % � EHKMI^RSG C]EHXqU KMI:C]EHGSRSX`ILC �JX�QIFKMI=C]G� C ��� " �JOQZFZFG� C���"� .�� K� � P �MG�C]X RSG �`IFOHZLG)PHZLKM_[E C�HGJILI�.�� ZFK � C]KMX�HI�VYZFX[R KMR)�`_[GNC]X KMR)�`_[G��3��QU C]EHK IkR OHI=C\P~GX��QCFKMR KMIFG U �`I �&�JZFO �JK ��� ILCFG � K� �HZFXqUHO � KH_�U�� C � IFOHKTC �`P �MG0VYX[Z\CFEHG:C]EHG IFKMI �`K RSI�%�0K��{GJZLG � G K R �`_`KH_ K#.`X���.`GJI R G �`ILOHZFK�H_!CFEHG PQZFKM_`E C�HGJILI UHK+�cG ZFG �JGJIwX`V:ILC��`ZFIwX�

KMR)�`_[G I�C]E�� C!�`ZLG ILOHPQC]Z���� CFGJUwVYZLX[R � R �`I=C]G ZdCFGJR � � � CFG�VYZ��`R G�% � EHG CFGJR � � � CFG �HZFX .qKMUHG I�8O���RSG �`IFOQZFGJR G CFI X`VNC]EHG I=C �`ZLI C]E�� C P~G �JX`RSGwCFEHG � GJZFX �,�~X[K C X VaCFEHG X[OiC��HOQC C]KMR G��IFG ZFKMG I % � EQGhCFKMR G�� IFGJZLKMG I �`ZFG � X�#.[G ZLC]G U C]X CFEHGhILC���HU��`ZLU � � � R � _�HK CFOHUHG O HK CFI .iK�

Page 20: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����

� ��� � ��� � � � �����L�*�,!0X�?3#q2A7EB��98!0�/ecDE�*98B�B�')4�h #0��� ?3')h8�P#*+=X��*G8�L!0�=�=4t')4 �k')h aSx�a � #02S#$DE')+=�L#0� �LB�19 �%(�=#0�1+-#0�1%6B�,�0')2(% 287 �k')h a�x�a � [j#02L!0�=�v#*���v#02A#"9A?�Q '34 98�0J�B��=�*')2>%`-a ������4 9A#0X��*��2A7�#0��'@!E�,+=?3')B !0'34 h\Q '34 98�0J!i#*98�C'@!�+/?)�,98�0?)J�!i�,�=4�N(DE'3#0�;#0����98K\B ?3'3#0X %��v287�#0� ��%��=G>')9A#0')284 !CKM�,95!iX �0�1%�'346K�9Ah54�'I#*X %(��X�4�'3#*!�DE'3#0�;#0� ���� � �?I#*�=�1a;����� � K�98h84�'3#0X %��L9A4 % �&ecb�+/25?325X���2A7C#0��'@!F!i#*98�F� 9TG8�MQ��=�,4 98%�%(�1%�7�28�F+/25KMB�?3�=#0�,4��,!*!=N984 % ')4 %('@+=9A#0��#*� 9�#E#*��')!.!$#"9A�E'@!E9A46�/<�9AKMB�?)��2A7:9 �C?)X�� � #*�*98h8h8?)�=�1N(9A4 %69\?3' �8�,?3J K\�,KqQ��=�&287�u(�q��X +8a

� HX � �MGJUQ_[GWX`V�C]E � C ILC��`Z�� I �8O���X� CFEHG C]G R)� �� C]G�% �,HKTC]K �����"��ACFEHG K R �`_`GwU�� C��`IFG C �!�`II�� � K C�K� CFX �#1 IFOQPHIFG�� C]K X�HI��2X`V 8�2 1 �HK �QG��MI�I O�� ZFG VYX`Z �HZFX3�JG IFIFK�H_ ������MX �NK�H_ U�� C�� CFXP{G � .��`K��`P � GwVYX[Z �������"qIFKMI �NEQK�MGWCFEHG HG��qC)���`ZLC X`V C]EHGmKMR)�`_[G)���`I&�2X[Z�� GJU X� % � "R ��qO �����" �HZLX .qK UHKH_hC]EQG � �yB �JXqUHG&�NK C]E+�JXqX[ZFUQK�� CFGJI X`V �����C]EQGSI=C �`ZLI X� C]EHGSP{G ILC6�IFG GJKQ_ � R G �`ILOHZFG U � C 2 % 2 & & � KMR)�`_[GhX`V0CFEHG U�� C��`IFG C � �!CFX`C ���aX V 2 7�) �(� � � ILC��`ZFI � �NK CFE2 � % 8 � � � 1�1 % 8�� �kG ZFGmI��`R � �MG U � ��HU � V C]G Z 2 7�7 U�� "qISX`V5�JX[R �HOQCFGJZ&�HZLX�� GJIFILKH_ �dCFEHGJK Z������ CFKMR G�� IFGJZLKMG I!�kG ZFG �HZFXqUHO � GJU %

� ��� EwC]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI �JX�HIFK ILC]I2X`V �^U�� C����{X`K CrVYX[Z2G ��� E K R �`_`GaOQIFGJUSC]X �QZFXqUHO �JG K C ����HUC]E OHI 2 1�1�7 KHUQG �~G HUHG� C �{X`K C]I�� �NKTC]E �� � .[G Z��`_[GdC]G R)�~X[Z���� ZFGJILX��MOiC]KMX� X`V � 2 7 RSK� OQC]G IX .[GJZdC]EHG �JX`OHZFILG)X`V � HK _[E C � �JX .[G ZFK�H_ CFEHG �NEHX��MGNX`V CFEHG ��7 %(� �,HK _[E CrX[PHIFG Z .qKQ_ �NKQUHX � %�kX�HILG� OHG C���" C]EHK I U�� C��`IFG CAKMI �~GJZLVYG�� C���"0ILOHK C��`P � G�VYX[ZcC]EQGdUQG C]G�� C��`PHK� K C," X`V � �aX`C 4`O �HKTC]G Z� � ��HG CNC]Z���HILK C � �`I �2G �� �`I �HZLX .iK UHKQ_SEHK _[EhC]GJR �~X[Z����'ZLGJILX��MOQCFKMX�WVYX[Z ����� �HE��`ILGJI X`V�CFEHGKMUHG� C]K��HGJU .�� ZFK � P �MG I=C �`ZLI % �qOHPHIFG� OHG C �������"qIFK I:X`VkCFEHKMI:C]K RSG �yILGJZFK GJI:U�� C �`P�� IFG IFEHX �NIC]E�� C C]EQG �HEHX`CFX[R G C]ZLK� �HZFG��JK IFKMX� KMI _[XiXqU�G�HX[OH_`E X .`GJZ CFEHG �NEHX��MG � ZFZ�� " C]X � � 2�) % 7C]XmUHG CFG � C � 7 % 7#1�8 R �`_�HK CFOHUHG � 1 % 8�� � C]G R)�~X[Z��`Z " UHZFX��!K PHZLKM_[E C�QGJIFI � � OHIFG U P#" ���`IFILX�� K � CFGJU��aX`C 4`O �HKTC]G Z!� ���HG C % � EHG ��� C]O���� �MX �2GJZ�� KMR K CrX`V'CFEHG-�HZFG��JK IFKMX� OHIFG UhKwCFEHGIFG �`Z�� E UHG �~G QUHI2X� C]EHG �`PHK��MKTC," X V~CFEHG\C]Z���HILK C � ��HUHK�H_-�JXqUHG\CFX:UHG CFG � CrCFZ���HILK CFI�K HX[K I "U�� C�� � ��HU ILE�����AP~G UHK I�� OHIFILGJU K��kE����QCFGJZ 8 % � EQKMI5�QEHX`C]X`RSG C]ZFK�� �HZFG��JKMILKMX������ X �NINVYX`Z

Page 21: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � �1� � ����� � � ��� �O�

� UHG C��`K� GJUhIFG �`Z�� EmC]X�X����JOHZ � X .`GJZLKH_)� C �MG �`ILCNCFEHG PHZFK _[E C]GJI=C 2 % 8 1 R)�`_�HKTC]OHUHG I�X`V����� O � ���MOHI=C]G ZaR)�`K�WIFG� OHG� �JG�%/�K CFE!CFEHKMI:C]X C ���rU�� C��`P��`ILG��AC]EHG IFG �`Z�� E VYX[Z R GJUHK OHR � C]X �yEHK _[E �`R � �MKTC]OHUHG .��`ZLK �`P �MGJI

ILC��`ZFI � ��!P{G _[K % � X R GJG C^C]EQGJIFGSG HUQI � � �'X[R P�� ��� �`ZL_��MG��AGJZLKMXqUHX[_[Z��`R �!�`I OHILGJU�CFXIFG �`Z�� E CFEHG0U�� C�� VYX[Z2IFKM_�HK���� �� C!�~GJZLKMXqUHK� K CFKMGJI�% � "wZLO HK�H_ � ' �`I=C�'8X[OHZLKMGJZ � Z���HI=VYX[ZFRX� CFEHG CFKMR G�� IFGJZLKMG I ����#" �~GJZFK XiUQK�JKTC," KQEHGJZLG C K IS_[K�.[G� � ��� " �`I � ILCFZFX�H_�I��HK��`G K�C]EHG X[OQC��QOQC-�~X �2GJZ:I �{G�� CFZFOHR %�� " K� �JX`Z��HZ�� C]K�H_ �wILKMR � �MG UHG CFG � C]KMX� �JZFKTC]G ZFK ��� ��QU P ".qKMIFO �����":G�� �`R KHK�H_NC]EHG�� KM_[E C��JOHZ6.[GJIAC]E�� C ���`ILIFG U C]EHK I��JZLK CFGJZFK� � 2 7�7 .��`ZLK �`P �MGrILC��`ZFI �kG ZFGKMUHG� C]K��HGJU K CFEHG ��� � O � �8G � U % � EHG��QZFGJILG C � C]KMX� ��QU)�������"qILKMI�X`V;CFEHGJILG .��`ZLK �`P �MGkI=C �`ZLIKMI\CFEHG IFOHP �LG�� C X`VAC]EHG HG �iC � E����iC]GJZ�%

Page 22: Open Research: Home...EHG C, 2XwR) `K * M_[X[ZLK CFEHRSI\VYX`ZNCFEHG " qILKMI HUmC]KMR G IFG ZFKMG INIFG Z E I=C]G QI `ZLG^CFEHG IFG `Z E VYX[ZwR GJUQKMOHR CFX yEHK _[E …

� � � � ��� � � � �����