8/13/2019 Ortega v. CA (G.R. No. 109248)

1/3

!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!># !$$# "0+.#**#?

!"#" %&" '()*+, -./0 12 '))3

4#56!7 8" 97

!"#$%&$''() +,-+.,/. 01 .,2-+34 2.536 .1 7-8 9362/88.4 :,14 #%;

L>$% M"#$%&$''(1 5$(# L>($F%>;

'LCJ &I> M#L&%>L(I$M C% &I> FLCE%; &I#& NM#L&%>L(I$M I#( H>#(>; &C O>

JE&E#""G (#&$('#H&CLGP4 #%; #( (EHI #(Q>; 'CL "$RE$;#&$C% C' I$( (I#L>(4

>(M>H$#""G $% HC%%>H&$C% K$&I &I> &KC '"CCL( C' &I> OE$";$%F1

2I> 6-9 I>#L$%F C''$H>L LE">; &I#& 3&&G1 5$(#S( L>($F%#&$C% ;$; %C&

;$((C"T> &I> M#L&%>L(I$M4 OE& &I$( K#( L>T>L(>; OG 6-9 >% O#%H C% &I>

FLCE%; &I#& &I> M#L&%>L(I$M K#( # M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$""1

2I> 6EML>J> 9CEL& LE">; &I#& &I> "#K '$LJ K#( # M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$""

O>H#E(> &I>L> K#( %C (M>H$'$H ;EL#&$C% 'CL $&1 2I#& $& K#( HC%(&$&E&>; 'CL

# MELMC(> ;C>( %C& HI#%F> $&( HI#L#H&>L O>H#E(> E%;>L &I> "#K14

NM#L&%>L(I$M( HC%(&$&E&>; 'CL # MELMC(>P #L> &IC(> 'CL # M#L&$HE"#L

MLCU>H&4 #%; &I>L>'CL> (&$"" 'CL # M>L$C;1 2I> "#K '$LJ4 O>$%F #

M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$"" H#% &I>L>'CL> O> ;$((C"T>; OG L>&$L>J>%& C' #%G C%>

C' &I> M#L&%>L(1 6EHI M#L&%>L $( %C& "$#O"> 'CL #%G&I$%F4 E%">(( I$(

L>&$L>J>%& K#( C' O#; '#$&I1 /% &I$( H#(>4 3&&G1 5$(# ;$; %C& I#T> O#;

'#$&I #%; $( &I>L>'CL> %C& "$#O"> 'CL ;#J#F>(1

7.92,/=-) 0CL #( "C%F #( &I> L>#(C% 'CL K$&I;L#K#" C' # M#L&%>L $( %C&

HC%&L#LG &C &I> ;$H&>( C' UE(&$H> #%; '#$L%>((4 %CL 'CL &I> MELMC(> C'

E%;E"G T$($&$%F I#LJ #%; ;#J#F> EMC% &I> M#L&%>L(I$M4 O#; '#$&I

H#%%C& O> (#$; &C HI#L#H&>L$V> &I> #H&1 ($F% &C ;C # KLC%F'E" #H& 'CL # ;$(IC%>(& MELMC(> CL JCL#"

CO"$RE$&G1

:79;!#4

! :#%E#LG X4 YZ[\ ! ,.664 83],-=9-4 6-8!A #%; 93,,369.6.K#( ;E"G L>F$(&>L>; $% &I> 5>LH#%&$"> ,>F$(&LG

! 3EFE(& X4 YZX^ ! &I> #OCT>_J>%&$C%>; "#K '$LJ K#(L>HC%(&$&E&>; K$&I &I> 6>HEL$&$>( #%; -WHI#%F> 9CJJ$(($C% C%

2I> 6-9 L>HCL;( (ICK &I#& &I>L> K>L> (>T>L#" (EO(>RE>%&

#J>%;J>%&( &C &I> #L&$H">( C' M#L&%>L(I$M1

! 7>H>JO>L Z4 YZ^`!:C#RE$% 81 5$(#4 :>(E( J(>"T>( &CF>&I>L4 #( (>%$CL M#L&%>L(

K$&I L>(MC%;>%&( +L>FCL$C 01 .L&>F#4 2CJ#( .1 ;>" 9#(&$""C4 :L14

#%; %U#J$% L(1

!0>OLE#LG Y\4 YZ^^

!5$(# KLC&> L>(MC%;>%&( # ">&&>L KI>L>OG

I> K$&I;L#K( 'LCJ &I> '$LJ C' L

">&&>L $% &I> (#J> ;#G (&>; &I#& I> KCE"; "$Q> &C J>>& K$&I

&I> M#L&%>L( HC%H>L%$%F &I> J>HI#%$H( C' "$RE$;#&$C% #%; I$(

$%&>L>(& $% &I> &KC '"CCL( C' &I> OE$";$%F &I>G K>L> CHHEMG$%F1

! 0>OLE#LG YZ4 YZ^^!5$(# KLC&> #%C&I>L ">&&>L (&$%F &I#& I$(L>($F%#&$C% $( O#(>; C% &I> '#H& &I#& &I> NM#L&%>L(I$M I#(

H>#(>; &C O> JE&E#""G (#&$('#H&CLGP

! :E%> [`4 YZ^^ ! 5$(# '$">; K$&I 6-9S( 9CJJ$(($C%a( 6>HEL$&$>(/%T>(&$F#&$C% #%; 9">#L$%F 7>M#L&J>%& b6/97c # M>&$&$C% 'CL

;$((C"E&$C% #%; "$RE$;#&$C% C' M#L&%>L(I$M1

! 5#LHI [Y4 YZ^Z ! &I> I>#L$%F C''$H>L I>"; &I#& 5$(#a(K$&I;L#K#" ;$; %C& ;$((C"T> &I> M#L&%>L(I$M1 2I> "$RE$;#&$C% K$""

O> FCT>L%>; OG &I>$L 3FL>>J>%&1

! 6-9 >% O#%H!L>T>L(>; &I> ;>H$($C% C' &I> A>#L$%F .''$H>L #%;I>"; &I#& &I> K$&I;L#K#" C' 3&&CL%>G :C#RE$% 81 5$(# I#;

;$((C"T>; &I> M#L&%>L(I$M C' d

9CJJ$(($C% LE">; &I#&4 O>$%F # M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$""4 &I> "#K '$LJ

HCE"; O> ;$((C"T>; OG #%G M#L&%>L #& #%G&$J>4 (EHI #( OG I$(

K$&I;L#K#" &I>L>'LCJ4 L>F#L;">(( C' FCC; '#$&I CL O#; '#$&I4

8/13/2019 Ortega v. CA (G.R. No. 109248)

2/3

!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!># !$$# "0+.#**#?

($%H> %C M#L&%>L H#% O> 'CLH>; &C HC%&$%E> $% &I> M#L&%>L(I$M

#F#$%(& I$( K$""1

! 9CEL& C' 3MM>#"(!#''$LJ>; $% &C&Co 3&&CL%>G :>(E( G 5#L$#%C 8CV#;# OC&I

;$>;4 L>(M>H&$T>"G4 6>M&>JO>L f4YZZY #%; 7>H>JO>L

gY4YZZY ;EL$%F &I> M>%;>%HG C' &I> H#(> K$&I 931

?@@

Y1 ]I>&I>L CL %C& &I> 9CEL& C' 3MM>#"( I#( >LL>; $% IC";$%F &I#&&I> M#L&%>L(I$M C' L(I$M #& K$""

g1 ]I>&I>L CL %C& &I> 9CEL& C' 3MM>#"( I#( >LL>; $% IC";$%F &I#&&I> K$&I;L#K#" C' ML$T#&> L>(MC%;>%& ;$((C"T>; &I> M#L&%>L(I$M

L>F#L;">(( C' I$( FCC; CL O#; '#$&I

[1 ]I>&I>L CL %C& &I> 9CEL& C' 3MM>#"( I#( >LL>; $% IC";$%F &I#&ML$T#&> L>(MC%;>%&a( ;>J#%; 'CL &I> ;$((C"E&$C% C' &I>M#L&%>L(I$M (C &I#& I> H#% F>& # MIG($H#" M#L&$&$C% C' M#L&%>L(I$M

K#( %C& J#;> $% O#; '#$&I

#6@4A#"( I#( >LL>; $% IC";$%F

&I#& &I> M#L&%>L(I$M C' L(I$M #& K$""!=.1 3 M#L&%>L(I$M &I#& ;C>( %C& '$W $&(

&>LJ $( # M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$""1 2I> "#K '$LJ d>; (EHI # M#L&%>L(I$M1

5#UCL !C$%& Y) 2I#& &I> M#L&%>L(I$M K#( # M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$"" $( MLCT>%

OG &I>$L M#L&%>L(I$M #FL>>J>%&1

3J>%;>; #L&$H">( C' YZ 3EFE(& YZX^ ;C>( %C& MLCT$;> 'CL #(M>H$'$>; M>L$C; CL E%;>LQ$%F1 2I> d7?,32/.=d H"#E(> ($JM"G

(&>()

df1 7?,32/.=1 2I> M#L&%>L(I$M (I#"" HC%&$%E> (C "C%F #(

JE&E#""G (#&$('#H&CLG #%; EMC% &I> ;>#&I CL ">F#" $%H#M#H$&G C'

C%> C' &I> M#L&%>L(4 (I#"" O> HC%&$%E>; OG &I> (ELT$T$%F

M#L&%>L(1d

5#UCL !C$%& g) 2I> "#K '$LJ $( %C& # NM#L&%>L(I$M K$&I # (M>H$'$H

E%;>LQ$%FP >T>% &ICEFI $& K#( HC%(&$&E&>; 'CL # M#L&$HE"#L MELMC(>1

3MM#L>%&"G KI#& &I> "#K HC%&>JM"#&>(4 $( # (M>H$'$H E%;>LQ$%FCL dMLCU>H&d KI$HI I#( # ;>'$%$&> CL ;>'$%#O"> M>L$C; C'

HCJM">&$C%1 2I$( $( %C& &I> H#(> I>L>1

?@@&I>L CL %C& &I> 9CEL& C' 3MM>#"( I#( >LL>; $% IC";$%F

&I#& &I> K$&I;L#K#" C' ML$T#&> L>(MC%;>%& ;$((C"T>; &I> M#L&%>L(I$M

L>F#L;">(( C' I$( FCC; CL O#; '#$&I !=.1

5#UCL !C$%& Y) 2I> O$L&I #%; "$'> C' # M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$"" $( ML>;$H#&>; C%

&I> JE&E#" ;>($L> #%; HC%(>%& C' &I> M#L&%>L(1 2I> L$FI& &C HICC(> K$&I

KICJ # M>L(C% K$(I>( &C #((CH$#&> I$J(>"' $( &I> T>LG 'CE%;#&$C% #%;

>((>%H> C' &I#& M#L&%>L(I$M1

3%G C%> C' &I> M#L&%>L( J#G4 #& I$( (C"> M">#(EL>4 ;$H&> #;$((C"E&$C% C' &I> M#L&%>L(I$M #& K$""1 A> JE(&4 ICK>T>L4 #H& $%FCC; '#$&I4 %C& &I#& &I> #&&>%;#%H> C' O#; '#$&I H#% ML>T>%& &I>

;$((C"E&$C% C' &I> M#L&%>L(I$M OE& &I#& $& H#% L>(E"& $% # "$#O$"$&G

'CL ;#J#F>(1

5#UCL !C$%& g) 2I> "$RE$;#&$C% C' &I> #((>&( C' &I> M#L&%>L(I$M 'C""CK$%F

$&( ;$((C"E&$C% $( FCT>L%>; OG T#L$CE( MLCT$($C%( C' &I> 9$T$" 9C;>1

ACK>T>L4 #% #FL>>J>%& C' &I> M#L&%>L(4 "$Q> #%G C&I>L HC%&L#H&4 $(

O$%;$%F #JC%F &I>J #%; %CLJ#""G Q>( ML>H>;>%H> &C &I> >W&>%&

#MM"$H#O"> CT>L &I> 9C;>a( F>%>L#" MLCT$($C%(1

/% &I$( H#(>4 &I> M#L&$>( I#; #% #FL>>J>%& HC%H>L%$%F"$RE$;#&$C% EMC% ;$((C"E&$C% C' &I> M#L&%>L(I$M !DEFEGFEDH ,2

7IJKLJL 7FMNO/JP &Q REFMKJFPHND"'

4 9 9 9 .@ ABC CDC@A EF ABC GCHAB EI ICAJICKC@A EF H@L MHIA@CI' BJN J@ACICNA J@

ABC MHIA@CINBJM NBHOO PC OJQRJGHACG H@G MHJG J@ HSSEIGH@SC TJAB ABC CUJNAJ@V

HVICCKC@AN H@G BJN MHIA@CINBJM MHIAJSJMHAJE@ NBHOO ICDCIA AE ABC ,C@JEI

)HIA@CIN FEI HOOESHAJE@ HN ABC ,C@JEI )HIA@CIN KHL GCACIKJ@CWW MIEDJGCG'

BETCDCI' ABHA TJAB ICNMCSA AE ABC ATE 128 FOEEIN EF EFFJSC SE@GEKJ@JRK

TBJSB ABC MHIA@CINBJM JN @ET HSQRJIJ@V' SE@NJNAJ@V EF ABC XAB H@G ABC YAB

8/13/2019 Ortega v. CA (G.R. No. 109248)

3/3

!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!># !$$# "0+.#**#?

2I> &>LJ dL>&$L>J>%&d JE(& I#T> O>>% E(>; $% &I> #L&$H">( C'M#L&%>L(I$M4 $( E(>; $% # F>%>L$H (>%(> &C J>#% &I> ;$((CH$#&$C%

OG # M#L&%>L4 $%H"E($T> C' L>($F%#&$C% CL K$&I;L#K#"4 'LCJ &I>

M#L&%>L(I$M &I#& &I>L>OG ;$((C"T>( $&1

?@@&I>L CL %C& &I> 9CEL& C' 3MM>#"( I#( >LL>; $% IC";$%F&I#& ML$T#&> L>(MC%;>%&a( ;>J#%; 'CL &I> ;$((C"E&$C% C' &I> M#L&%>L(I$M

(C &I#& I> H#% F>& # MIG($H#" M#L&$&$C% C' M#L&%>L(I$M K#( %C& J#;> $%

O#; '#$&I!=.1 3&&G1 5$(# ;$; %C& #H& $% O#; '#$&I1

5#UCL !C$%& Y)

!EO"$H L>(MC%;>%&( T$>K>; I$( K$&I;L#K#" &C I#T> O>>% (MELL>;OG d$%&>LM>L(C%#" HC%'"$H&d #JC%F &I> M#L&%>L(1 /& KCE"; %C& O>

L$FI&4 K> #FL>>4 &C ">& #%G C' &I> M#L&%>L( L>J#$% $% &I>

M#L&%>L(I$M E%;>L (EHI #% #&JC(MI>L> C' #%$JC($&G1

%4 @6R7#756 4R?%?4%@

7==?5?4%7A %456@>

"##$% &'()*( +,-- -.##./0

FOEEIN EF ABC !OMHM =RJOGJ@V' 473 !OFHIE ,AICCA' ,HOSCGE ZJOOHVC' [H\HAJ'

[CAIE [H@JOH' ABCJI AIRC DHORC HA ABC AJKC EF NRSB GCHAB EI ICAJICKC@A NBHOO

PC GCACIKJ@CG PL ATE 128 J@GCMC@GC@A HMMIHJNCIN' E@C AE PC HMMEJ@ACG 1PLABC MHIA@CINBJM H@G ABC EABCI PL ABC8 ICAJIJ@V MHIA@CI EI ABC BCJIN EF H

GCSCHNCG MHIA@CI' HN ABC SHNC KHL PC9 .@ ABC CDC@A EF H@L GJNHVICCKC@A

PCATCC@ ABC NHJG HMMIHJNCIN H ABJIG HMMIHJNCI TJOO PC HMMEJ@ACG PL ABCK

TBENC GCSJNJE@ NBHOO PC FJ@HO9 +BC NBHIC EF ABC ICAJIJ@V EI GCSCHNCG MHIA@CI

J@ ABC HFEICKC@AJE@CG ATE 128 FOEEI EFFJSC SE@GEKJ@JRK NBHOO PC

GCACIKJ@CG RME@ ABC PHNJN EF ABC DHORHAJE@ HPEDC KC@AJE@CG TBJSB NBHOO PC

MHJG KE@ABOL TJABJ@ ABC FJINA AC@ 1438 GHLN EF CDCIL KE@AB J@ J@NAHOOKC@AN

EF @EA OCNN ABH@ )23'333933 FEI ABC ,C@JEI )HIA@CIN' )43'333933 J@ ABC SHNC

EF ATE 128 CUJNAJ@V :R@JEI )HIA@CIN H@G )X'333933 J@ ABC SHNC EF ABC @CT

:R@JEI )HIA@CI9

$%&' ()*+,'*-&.( &)- /')-'0 +1 2' 34+4)556 -)+.-7)/+1*6 2'/)4-' 17 +&'

81*9.,: /1,0.+.1,- 17 14* '3(516''- .,/540.,: +&' )--.-+),+ )++1*,'6-"

;55 36 '771*+- +1 )3'5.1*)+' +&' 2'518 -42-.-+',/' 5' )*' 0*'--'0 018, (425./56 ., ) 5140 .,/540.,: +&' )--.-+),+ )++1*,'6-"$