osce magazine may 2004 (ru)

32
Cgtwbfkmysq htgjhnfé: Rfr d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt gjdsifñn cnfylfhns d jåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz – ≤htibntkmysq gjåjhybr ltkf JÅCT≥: bynthdmñ c gjckjv Hjccbb Rjcjdj: rhbnbxtcrbq cfvjfyfkbp. Ytlfdytt yfcbkbt – dspjd vtéleyfhjlyjve cjjåotcnde VFQ 2004 UJLF

Category:

Documents


36 download

DESCRIPTION

In this issue: How Bosnia and Herzegovina is raising its education standards; Russian Federation is "strong advocate" of OSCE cause: Interview with Russian Ambassador; Soul-searching on Kosovo: Recent violence poses challenge to international community

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Cgtwbfkmysq htgjhnfé: Rfr d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt gjdsifñncnfylfhns d jåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz

Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz – ≤htibntkmysq gjåjhybr ltkf JÅCT≥: bynthdmñ c gjckjv Hjccbb

Rjcjdj: rhbnbxtcrbq cfvjfyfkbp. Ytlfdytt yfcbkbt – dspjd vtéleyfhjlyjve cjjåotcnde

VFQ 2004 UJLF

Page 2: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

2 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

Jåhfotybt Ltqcndeñotujghtlctlfntkz r xbnfntkzvéehyfkf ≤JÅCT≥

Öjnz cathf jåhfpjdfybz rfrnfrjdfz lj cbö gjh yt gjkmpj-dfkfcm gthdjjxthtlysv dyb-vfybtv JÅCT, z cxtk ytjåöj-lbvsv drkñxbnm d xbckjjcyjdysö ghbjhbntnjd åjkufh-crjuj ghtlctlfntkmcndf pflfxeghbdktxtybz dybvfybz 55 yf-ibö ujcelfhcnd-exfcnybrjd ränjq dféytqitq ntvt. Jåhfpj-dfybt buhftn rkñxtdeñ hjkm deghjxtybb åtpjgfcyjcnb, jåtc-gtxtybb gjkbnbxtcrjq cnfåbkmyjcnb, cnbvekbhjdf-ybb ärjyjvbxtcrjuj hjcnf b cjrhfotybb ybotns.

Ghbtöfd d rjywt vfhnf d Cfhftdj, z c djcöbotybtvkbxyj yfåkñlfk htpekmnfns dgtxfnkzñotq hfåjns,rjnjhfz eét ghjltkfyf d änjq jåkfcnb VbccbtqJÅCT d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt. Dj dnjhjv yjvthtéehyfkf ≤JÅCT≥, rjnjhsq ctqxfc yföjlbncz gthtldfvb, jcjåsq hfpltk gjcdzoty njve, rfr gjcjk Hj-åthn Åbrhjan b tuj cjnhelybrb dvtcnt c yfwbjyfkm-ysvb b vtéleyfhjlysvb gfhnythfvb djgkjofñn débpym cnhfntubñ htajhvs jåhfpjdfybz d gjcnrjy-akbrnyjv, gjkbänybxtcrjv jåotcndt.

Z nfrét c hfljcnmñ jnvtnbk pyfxtybt, ghblfdft-vjt djghjcfv jåhfpjdfybz ghfdbntkmcndfvb buhfélfyfvb cnhfy Wtynhfkmyjq Fpbb, j xtv ujdj-hbkjcm 5 fghtkz yf rjyathtywbb JÅCT d cnjkbwtEpåtrbcnfyf Nfirtynt. Gjcdzotyyfz ntvt ≤Jåhf-pjdfybt – rfgbnfk, bydtcnbhjdfyysq d åeleott≥,jyf gjpdjkbkf cjukfcjdfnm wtksq hzl rjyrhtnysögjcktleñobö vth. Bö wtkm – gjvjxm jåhfpjdfybñd cnhfyfö htubjyf ghbjåhtcnb åjktt vtéleyfhjl-yeñ jhbtynfwbñ, ljcnbxm åjktt dscjrbö jåhfpjdf-ntkmysö cnfylfhnjd lkz dctö, erhtgbnm cbcntveghjatccbjyfkmyj-ntöybxtcrjuj jåextybz, gjlujnj-dbnm rdfkbabwbhjdfyyst rflhs d vbybcnthcndföjåhfpjdfybz b jåtcgtxbnm hfpdbnbt htubjyfkmysöbybwbfnbd.

D cdzpb c änbv pfckeébdftn jcjåjuj egjvbyfybzhjkm Frfltvbb JÅCT d Åbirtrt, ult z gjåsdfk döjlt gjtplrb d Rshuspcnfy d yfxfkt fghtkz.Dcnhtxf cj ckeifntkzvb änjuj yjdjuj extåyjuj pf-dtltybz ghjbpdtkf yf vtyz ytbpukflbvjt dgtxfn-ktybt; z eåtélty d ébpytyyjq ytjåöjlbvjcnb åj-ktt ljkujchjxyjq ghjuhfvvs, rjnjhfz jödfnsdfkfås dtcm änjn htubjy.

Tckb vs åeltv lfdfnm vjkjltéb cåfkfycbhjdfy-yst b ljcnjdthyst pyfybz jå bcnjhbb, hfcrhsdfnmtq ukfpf yf rekmnehyjt åjufncndj lheubö yfhjljd bdjjheéfnm tt evtybtv jåütrnbdyj fyfkbpbhjdfnmghjnbdjhtxbdst djghjcs, nj z yt cjvytdfñcm, xnjänj gjpdjkbn ljåbnmcz pyfxbntkmyjuj ghjuhtccf dhtitybb vyjubö yf gthdsq dpukzl nhelyjhfphtib-vsö ghjåktv, c rjnjhsvb ctqxfc cnfkrbdftncz ht-ubjy JÅCT.

Cjkjvjy GfccbDtyfVfq 2004 ujlf

Éehyfk ≤JÅCT≥ bplftncz yf fyukbqcrjv b heccrjv zpsrfö Jnltkjv ghtccs b jåotcndtyyjqbyajhvfwbb Jhufybpfwbb gj åtpjgfcyjcnb b cjnhelybxtcnde

d Tdhjgt. Dscrfpsdftvst d tuj cnfnmzö vytybzghbyflktéfn fdnjhfv b yt jåzpfntkmyj jnhféfñn jabwbfkmyeñ gjpbwbñ JÅCT b tt ujcelfhcnd-exfcnybrjd.

Htlfrnjh: Gfnhbwbz Y. CfnnthHtlfrnjhs-jåjphtdfntkb: Rbn Lébyrc, Fktrcfylh YbwitLbpfqyth: Yjyf Htqnth

Rjvvtynfhbb b fdnjhcrbt vfnthbfks ghjcmåf yfghfdkznm gjflhtce:[email protected]

Jnltk ghtccs b jåotcndtyyjq byajhvfwbbCtrhtnfhbfn JÅCTKärntner Ring 5–7A-1010 Vienna, AustriaNtk.: (+43-1) 514 36-180Afrc: (+43-1) 514 36-105

Jhufybpfwbz gj åtpjgfcyjcnb b cjnhelybxtcnde d Tdhjgt– jåottdhjgtqcrbq jhufy, pfybvfñobqcz jåtcgtxtybtvåtpjgfcyjcnb, exfcnybrfvb rjnjhjuj zdkzñncz 55 ujce-lfhcnd, hfcgjkjétyysö yf utjuhfabxtcrjv ghjcnhfycn-dt jn Dfyredthf lj Dkflbdjcnjrf.

Ghtlctlfntkmcndj JÅCT d 2004 ujle:Åjkufhbz

Cnhernehs b bycnbnens JÅCTGjcnjzyysq cjdtn, DtyfAjhev gj cjnhelybxtcnde d jåkfcnb åtpjgfcyjcnb, DtyfCtrhtnfhbfn, DtyfGhtlcnfdbntkm JÅCT gj djghjcfv cdjåjls CVB, DtyfÅñhj gj ltvjrhfnbxtcrbv bycnbnenfv b ghfdfv xtkjdtrf, DfhifdfDthöjdysq rjvbccfh gj ltkfv yfwbjyfkmysö vtymibycnd, UffufGfhkfvtyncrfz fccfvåktz JÅCT, Rjgtyufuty

Ltzntkmyjcnm yf vtcnföRfdrfpÅñhj JÅCT d ÅfreVbccbz JÅCT d UhepbbÅñhj JÅCT d ThtdfytKbxysq ghtlcnfdbntkm Ltqcndeñotuj ghtlctlfntkz gj rjyakbrne, zdkzñotvecz ghtlvtnjv hfccvjnhtybz yf Vbycrjq rjyathtywbb JÅCT

Wtynhfkmyfz FpbzWtynh JÅCT d Fkvf-FntWtynh JÅCT d FiöfåfltWtynh JÅCT d ÅbirtrtWtynh JÅCT d LeifyåtWtynh JÅCT d Nfirtynt

Djcnjxyfz TdhjgfJabc JÅCT d VbycrtVbccbz JÅCT d VjkljdtRjjhlbyfnjh ghjtrnjd JÅCT d Erhfbyt

Ñuj-Djcnjxyfz TdhjgfGhbcencndbt JÅCT d FkåfybbVbccbz JÅCT d Åjcybb b UthwtujdbytVbccbz JÅCT d ÖjhdfnbbVbccbz JÅCT d RjcjdjRjynhjkmyfz vbccbz JÅCT d Crjgmt gj ghtljndhfotybñ hfcghjcnhfytybzrjyakbrnfVbccbz JÅCT d Cthåbb b Xthyjujhbb

Page 3: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 3

D änjv dsgecrt:RFR D ÅJCYBB B UTHWTUJDBYT GJDSIFÑN CNFYLFHNS D JÅKFCNB JÅHFPJDFYBZ

– Bydtcnbwbb d åeleott:Åtpjgfcyjcnm b jåhfpjdfybt – ≤tcntcndtyysq nfyltv≥ 4– Dscjrbq ghtlcnfdbntkm kjhl ≤Gällb≥ Äilfey:Gjkbnbxtcrbt buhs c htajhvjq jåhfpjdfybz åmñn gj bynthtcfv rféljuj 6– Ytdjcgtnst uthjb:Åjhmåf c lbcrhbvbyfwbtq d irjkfö 8– Cldbyenm ltkj c vthndjq njxrb:≤Rkñx r ecgtöe – cjnhelybxtcndj b gfhnythcndj≥ 11– ≤Uhfvvfnbrf gbitn bcnjhbñ?≥ –Extåybrb b ébpym d ÅbU 13– Gjkbnbrt yt vtcnj d irjkt,cxbnftn åsdibq exbntkm b ltgenfn 15

GJCNJZYYSQ CJDTN

– Gjcjk F. Ñ. Fktrcttd:Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz – ≤htibntkmysq gjåjhybr≥ ltkf JÅCT 17

RJCJDJ: RHBNBXTCRBQ CFVJFYFKBP

Yfcbkbt – dspjd vtéleyfhjlyjve cjjåotcndeHtfrwbz JÅCT 21– Åtlf d Vbnhjdbwt:yfåkñlfz, rfr ubåytn d juyt ljcnbuyenjt 24– ≤Rjcjdj: öhegrbq vbh≥Hfccrfp jå JÅCT lkz phbntktq yf hjlbyt 26

ÅJKUFHCRJT GHTLCTLFNTKMCNDJ, 2004 UJL

– Yfvtxfz rehc åtcrjyakbrnyjuj hfpdbnbz Rfdrfpf 29

YFPYFXTYBZ

– Ghtlcnfdkztv Vbrkjif Öfhfinb,Ghtlcnfdbntkz gj djghjcfv cdjåjls CVB 31

Yf jåkjért: gthdjrkfcybrb chtlytq irjks bvtyb Åtöfelbyf Ctkmvfyjdbxf d Cfhftdj ltkfñn yf ehjrfö rjkkféb bp zxvtyysö pthty, cjtlbyzz ghbhjle b ndjhxtcndj.Ajnj: Vbccbz JÅCT d ÅbU/Ltléfy Dtrbx.Fdnjhs ajnjuhfabq, bcgjkmpjdfyysö d cgtwbfkmyjv htgjhnfét bp ÅbU: Ltléfy Dtrbx, Ythvby Gjlébx, Rtdby Cfkkbdäy b Älbå Zöbx.

www.osce.org

Vfq 2004 ujlf, Vol. No. 2

Cgtwbfkmysqhtgjhnfé

Page 4: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

4 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

ÅKÄH ÅKÄREÄKK

Rflhjdsq lbgkjvfn, bvtñobq pf gktxfvbjgsn ghtgjlfdfntkmcrjq hfåjns, gjcjk Hjåthn V. Åbrhjan c cfvjuj yfxfk jcjpyf-dfk äne ytgjchtlcndtyyeñ cdzpm. Djpukfdbd

d 2001 ujle Vbccbñ JÅCT d ÅbU, jy c jujhxtybtvb nhtdjujq eåtlbkcz, xnj cjcnjzybt jåhfpjdfntkm-yjq cbcntvs ghfrnbxtcrb yt ghtnthgtkj bpvtyt-ybq cj dhtvty tuj gthdjuj ghtåsdfybz d Cfhftdjd 1996–1997 ujlfö, rjulf jy chfpe gj jrjyxfybbdjqys åsk yfghfdkty cñlf gjdthtyysv d ltkfö b cgtwbfkmysv gjckfyybrjv CIF d åjcybqcrjqAtlthfwbb.

Gjkbnbpfwbz jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU yfytckf eothårfxtcnde b ehjdyñ jåextybz vjkjltéb. Cjlthéf-ybt extåybrjd b ghjuhfvv dfhmbhjdfkjcm jn ht-ubjyf r htubjye b pfdbctkj ukfdysv jåhfpjv jnänybxtcrjuj cjcnfdf yfctktybz. Extåyst vfnthbf-ks åskb dslthéfys d htprj yfwbjyfkbcnbxtcrjvleöt b ghjybryens jnrhsnjq dhféltåyjcnmñ rlheubv yfhjlfv.

Ghtgjlfdfntkmcrbq cjcnfd yt dkfltk cjdhtvty-ysv vtnjlfvb jåextybz. Dsgecrybrfv yt ödfnfkjpyfybq b yfdsrjd lkz htitybz pflfx, djpybrfd-ibö gthtl ybvb d htfkmyjq ébpyb. Dj vyjuböirjkfö jncencndjdfkb jnjgktybt b ghjcntqibtcfybnfhyst eljåcndf, yt ujdjhz eét j nfrbö dt-ofö, rfr rjvgmñnths.

D änjq cbnefwbb gjcjk Åbrhjan cnfk ltqcndj-dfnm åscnhj b htibntkmyj. ≤Eåtlbdibcm, rfr vfkjbpvtybkjcm pf ctvm ktn gjckt djqys, – ujdjhbnjy, – z crfpfk ctåt: c änbv yflj xnj-nj ltkfnm. Ghbänjv z dthbk, xnj e JÅCT ljcnfnjxyj ubårjcnb,djpvjéyjcntq b lfkmyjdblyjcnb lkz njuj, xnjåsdpznmcz pf äne pflfxe≥.

Vbccbz, c njxrb phtybz tt herjdjlbntkz, hfcgj-kfufkf eybrfkmysv gjntywbfkjv, gjpdjkzdibvhflbrfkmyj ecrjhbnm dshfåjnre ytjåöjlbvjq gj-kbnbrb d jåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz, jlyjdhtvtyyj rj-jhlbybhez jrfpfybt vtéleyfhjlyjq gjllthérb.Änj jåktuxfkjcm yfkbxbtv e ytt cjnhelybrjd, åf-pbheñoböcz d 26 geyrnfö gj dctq nthhbnjhbb ÅbUb cgjcjåysö gjpfåjnbnmcz j njv, xnjås cjjndtn-cndeñofz gjkbnbrf ghjdjlbkfcm d ébpym d rfé-ljq irjkt.

D bñkt 2002 ujlf Gjcnjzyysq cjdtn JÅCT lfkcdjt cjukfcbt, b yjdjt yfghfdktybt hfåjns åskjjabwbfkmyj drkñxtyj d vfylfn Vbccbb.GTHDST IFUB

Gthdsv ifujv Vbccbb åskf vjåbkbpfwbz ecb-kbq vtcnysö cgtwbfkbcnjd, dkfcntq ÅbU b vtéle-yfhjlysö gfhnythjd. Åskf hfphfåjnfyf cjdvtcn-yfz cnhfntubz, drkñxfñofz rhfnrjchjxyst bljkujchjxyst pflfxb b djpdjlzofz cbcntve jåhf-pjdfybz d hfyu jlyjuj bp ukfdysö ghbjhbntnjdghjuhfvvs htajhv d ÅbU. Cjnyb pfheåtéysö är-cgthnjd b ghtlfyysö cdjtve ltke uhfélfy cnhfysbyntycbdyj hfåjnfkb yfl cjcnfdktybtv cnhfntubbhtajhvs jåhfpjdfybz, rjnjheñ vbybcnhs jåhf-pjdfybz ÅbU pfntv kbxyj ghtlcnfdbkb yf hfccvjn-htybt Cjdtnf gj dsgjkytybñ vbhyjuj cjukfitybzd Åhñcctkt d yjzåht 2002 ujlf.

Jlyfrj dgthtlb åskj tot vyjuj ytkturjq hfåj-ns. Ghtélt dctuj lkz ghtjåhfpjdfybq yeéyf åskfghfdjdfz jcyjdf. Gjckt vyjujvtczxysö lbcreccbqb äythubxyjuj kjååbhjdfybz gfhkfvtyn ÅbU tlb-yjukfcyj ghbyzk d bñyt 2003 ujlf jåotujcelfhcn-dtyysq Hfvjxysq pfrjy j yfxfkmyjv b chtlytvjåhfpjdfybb.

Änjn pfrjyjlfntkmysq frn jnrhsdftn genm r ec-nfyjdktybñ tlbysö cnfylfhnjd rfxtcndf jåextybz

DCTJÅÜTVKÑOFZ ÅTPJGFCYJCNM

Bydtcnbwbb d åeleott ÅbUÅtpjgfcyjcnm b jåhfpjdfybt – ≤tcntcndtyysq nfyltv≥Gjxtve JÅCT pfybvftncz htajhvjq jåhfpj-dfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt? Rfpfkjcm ås, änj yt cfvjt gjlöjlzott ltkj lkz jhufybpfwbb, cgtwbfkbpbheñotqcz yf djghjcfö åtpjgfcyjcnb. Yj cnjbn ghbukz-ltnmcz, b gjybvftim, yfcrjkmrj ghzvj jlyj cdzpfyj c lheubv: bynthtcs äaatrnbdyjuj, ytlbcrhbvbyfwbjyyjuj jåhfpjdfybz b bynthtcs ljkujchjxyjuj vbhf, åtpjgfcyjcnb b cnfåbkmyjcnb jåhfpeñn tcntcndtyysq nfyltv.

≤C änbv yflj åskj xnj-nj ltkfnm≥, – ujdjhbn gjcjk

Hjåthn Åbrhjan j gkfxtdyjvcjcnjzybb, d rjnjhjv

jy pfcnfk cbcntve jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU.

CgtwbfkmysqhtgjhnféRfr d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt gjdsifñn cnfylfhns d jåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz

Page 5: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 5

yf dctq nthhbnjhbb ÅbU b jghtltkztn nhtåjdfybz,rfcfñobtcz tlbyjq åfpjdjq extåyjq ghjuhfvvs,jåzpfntkmyjuj ltdznbktnytuj jåhfpjdfybz, ajhvb-hjdfybz cjdtnjd hjlbntktq b exfoböcz b hfcib-htybz cfvjcnjzntkmyjcnb irjk.

Gjkyfz htfkbpfwbz tuj gjkjétybq åeltn jpyf-xfnm, yfghbvth, xnj öjhdfncrbt b åjcybqcrbtirjkmybrb bp yföjlzotujcz d Uthwtujdbyt Vjcnf-hf cvjuen gthtdjlbnmcz d irjks yf nthhbnjhbbHtcgeåkbrb Cthåcrjq (b yfjåjhjn), åelexb edtht-ys, xnj d kñåjv vtcnt yf nthhbnjhbb ÅbU jybcvjuen gjkexbnm rfxtcndtyyjt jåhfpjdfybt yfhfd-yt cj dctvb.

Gfhfkktkmyj hfåjnt yfl pfrjyjghjtrnjv cjcnfd-kzkfcm b tlbyfz åfpjdfz extåyfz ghjuhfvvf. Irj-ks yfxfkb gthtöjlbnm yf ytt eét c ctynzåhz 2003ujlf, åkfujlfhz xtve exfobtcz d hfpysö hfqjyföÅbU cnfkb gjkexfnm dj vyjujv eybabwbhjdfyyeñgjlujnjdre gj dctv ghtlvtnfv.

Jåobv åjktt xtv yf 80fi zdkztncz cjlthéfybtpfyznbq gj ghbhjljdtltybñ b vfntvfnbrt. Lfétgj nfr yfpsdftvsv ≤yfwbjyfkmysv≥lbcwbgkbyfv– bcnjhbb, zpsre b kbnthfneht – jrjkj 50fi bpe-xftvsö ntv tlbys lkz dctö irjk.

≤D ÅbU gjkbnbrb ythtlrj gjåeélfñn jåotcn-dtyyjcnm, b d njv xbckt exfoböcz, cjchtljnjxb-dfnmcz yf hfpkbxbzö, – jnvtxftn gjcjk Åbrhjan. –Tlbyfz ét åfpjdfz ghjuhfvvf jåzpsdftn ghtgj-lfdfntktq ghbdktrfnm dybvfybt r njve, xnj cåkb-éftn. Ntv cfvsv vs ljrfpsdftv, xnj ghb dctv edfétybb r rekmnehysv hfpkbxbzv ceotcndetn båjkmijt gjkt lkz cjukfcbz≥.

Gjrf cjnhelybrb ujkjdyjuj jnltktybz Vbccbb d Cfhftdj ljåbdfkbcm gthtcvjnhf gjkbnbrb d vfc-infåfö dctq Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbys, jrjkj 25 börjkktu yf vtcnfö htuekzhyj dcnhtxfkbcm c lbhtr-njhfvb irjk, hjlbntkzvb, exbntkzvb b ghtlcnf-dbntkzvb vtcnysö dkfcntq, jåceélfz djghjcsghjdtltybz htajhvs d rjyrhtnysö irjkfö.

Pf gthdst gjknjhf ujlf ecbkbq gj rjjhlbyfwbbhtajhvs Vbccbtq ljcnbuyens juhjvyst ecgtöb,jcjåtyyj d njv, xnj rfcftncz hfdyjuj ljcnegf rjåhfpjdfybñ b jnrfpf jn lbcrhbvbyfwbb.

Fgtkkbhez r gjkjétybzv Dhtvtyyjuj cjukfit-ybz j ltnzö djpdhfofñoböcz kbw, cjnhelybrb gj djghjcfv jåhfpjdfybz hfpüzcyzñn jåotcndty-yjcnb b vtcnysv dkfcnzv ghfdj ltntq gjctofnmirjks d ntö hfqjyfö, relf bö ctvmb dthyekbcm yf ghtéytt vtcnj ébntkmcndf. Cjukfitybt, ufhfy-nbhjdfditt nfrbv ltnzv ghfdj bpexfnm d irjkfö≤yfwbjyfkmyst≥ ghtlvtns gj ghjuhfvvt lkz cdjtq yfwbjyfkmyjcnb, gjpdjkbkj ceotcndtyyjedtkbxbnm xbckj åsdibö ñysö åtétywtd, gjcne-gfñobö yf extåe gj dctq cnhfyt.

Ghjwtyn ntö, rjuj ghböjlbncz rfélsq ltym dtpnb yf fdnjåect vbvj irjks, yföjlzotqcz d 100 vtnhfö jn ljvf, d lheueñ, rjnjhfz yfvyjujlfkmit, yj ult åjkmibycndj extybrjd ghbyflkt-ébn r njq ét änybxtcrjq uheggt, cjrhfnbkcz. Irjks d hfpysö hfqjyfö cnfkb yfybvfnm åjkmitexbntktq bp xbckf dthyediböcz åtétywtd.

Jhufybpetvst Vbccbtq ≤rheukst cnjks≥ b bylb-dblefkmyst dcnhtxb c herjdjlbntkzvb irjk cgj-

cjåcndeñn kexitve jcjpyfybñ gj-nhtåyjcntq ltntq wsufy b lheubö yf-wbjyfkmysö vtymibycnd, extybrjd,bvtñobö jcjåst gjnhtåyjcnb, f nfr-ét bysö vfhubyfkbpjdfyysö uhegg.Dj vyjubö irjkfö bltn frnbdysqgjbcr cjåcndtyysö htitybq. Eét cj-cnfdktys gkfys ltqcndbq, ghbpdfy-yst jåtcgtxbnm, xnjås ctujlyziybqgthtljdjq jgsn cnfk yjhvjq gjdcñle d ÅbU.DCTJÅOYJCNM B BYNTHFRNBDYJCNM

Ytkmpz jcnfdkznm pf crjårfvb b htajhve ds-cituj jåhfpjdfybz, zdkzñoeñcz jlyjq bp cfvsöfrnefkmysö pflfx. Rfr b d ckexft yfxfkmyjq bchtlytq irjks, Vbccbz ljåbdftncz d gthdeñ jxt-htlm ghbyznbz jåotujcelfhcndtyyjuj hfvjxyjujpfrjyf j dscitv jåhfpjdfybb, gjpdjkzñotuj ÅbUdsgjkybnm cdjb jåzpfntkmcndf gj Åjkjycrjq ltr-kfhfwbb b Kbccfåjycrjq rjydtywbb j ghbpyfybb,gjl rjnjhsvb jyf gjcnfdbkf cdjñ gjlgbcm d 2003ujle. Öjnz gjlujnjdrf pfrjyjghjtrnf pfdthityftot d ltrfåht ghjikjuj ujlf, gthcgtrnbds tujghbyznbz gfhkfvtynjv ÅbU jcnfñncz ytzcysvbbp-pf cjghjnbdktybz hzlf gjkbnbxtcrbö cbk.

D kñåjv ckexft åtpltqcndbt yt vjétn åsnm ds-öjljv bp gjkjétybz. Afrekmntns, döjlzobt d cj-cnfd itcnb bkb ctvb ltqcndeñobö d ÅbU eybdth-cbntnjd, ghfrnbxtcrb gjkyjcnmñ cfvjcnjzntkmysb abyfycbheñncz bp cjåcndtyysö bcnjxybrjd, xnjdtcmvf pfnhelyztn ddtltybt tdhjgtqcrbö cnfylfh-njd ghtgjlfdfybz, ärpfvtyfwbjyyjq ghjdthrb byfexyjq hfåjns. Cneltyns yt bvtñn ljcnfnjxyjujljcnegf r ghjatccjhcrj-ghtgjlfdfntkmcrjve cj-cnfde b kbitys ltvjrhfnbxtcrjuj ghtlcnfdbntkm-cndf. Gjckt gjkextybz lbgkjvjd bv åsdftn nhelyjyfqnb hfåjne, nfr rfr eybdthcbntns yt exbnsdfñnhtfkmyst gjnhtåyjcnb cnhfys d cgtwbfkbcnfö. Gthtåhfnmcz d lheujq hfqjy cnhfys bkb ghjcnjetöfnm pf heåté änbv kñlzv njét yt nfr kturj.

Vtéle jåhfpjdfybtv b ärjyjvbxtcrbv hfpdbnb-tv ceotcndetn dféytqifz dpfbvjcdzpm. Hfåjnf Vbc-cbb JÅCT ljgjkyztn cjåjq ghjuhfvve ≤Pfyznjcnm bcghfdtlkbdjcnm≥, jceotcndkztveñ gj kbybb ÅñhjDscjrjuj ghtlcnfdbntkz. Kjhl Äilfey eét yt hfplfdfk dscjreñ jwtyre ljcnbétybzv Vbccbb d änjqjåkfcnb, gjlxthrbdfz, xnj ghjåktvs jåhfpjdfybzyjczn cfvsq gthdjjxthtlyjq öfhfrnth b xnj bydtc-nbwbb d änjq catht vjéyj c gjkysv ghfdjv yfpdfnm rfgbnfkjv, dkjétyysv d åeleott cnhfys.

Ntcyj dpfbvjltqcndez c uhfélfyfvb Åjcybb bUthwtujdbys, gthtl rjnjhjq ctqxfc cnjzn nhelytq-ibt pflfxb, Vbccbz JÅCT pf gjcktlybt ldf ujlfcvjukf ljåbnmcz vyjujuj. Yj tq ghtlcnjbn tot yt-vfkj hfåjns. Cj cnjhjys jghtltktyysö rheujdghjljkéfñncz gjgsnrb gjkbnbpbhjdfnm cbcntvejåextybz, njhvjpzobt ghjdtltybt htajhv b ghb-yjczobt hfpjxfhjdfybt hjlbntkzv irjkmybrjd bcneltynjd, rjnjhst lfdyj élen htfkmysö ekexit-ybq d extåyjv ghjwtcct.

D änbö eckjdbzö frnbdyfz rjjhlbyfwbjyyfz hfåjnf Vbccbb b tt gjcnjzyyjt ghbcencndbt yfvtcnfö gj-ghtéytve cjöhfyzñn cdjt rkñxtdjtpyfxtybt.

Åkäh Åkäreäkk – cjnhel-ybr gj djghjcfv byajh-vfwbb d ltgfhnfvtynt jåhfpjdfybz Vbccbb dÅbU. Lj gthtöjlf d änevbccbñ d 2002 ujle jyfhfåjnfkf d vtéleyfhjl-ysö cnhernehfö d Rfpfö-cnfyt b d Åhñcctkt.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 6: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfhnf Ahbvty: Yt ctrhtn, xnj hfpdbnbt jåhfpjdf-ybz zdkztncz jlybv bp ukfdysö ghbjhbntnjd Åjkuf-hbb rfr Ghtlctlfntkz JÅCT. Rfrjd cjåcndtyysq drkfl JÅCT d ghjwtcc htajhvs jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt b rfr Jhufybpfwbz vjukf åsljåbnmcz ljkujdhtvtyysö htpekmnfnjd?Kjhl Äilfey: Drkfl JÅCT d änjn ghjwtcc juhjvty– åkfujlfhz rfr tt ntöybxtcrbv djpvjéyjcnzv,nfr b tt lbgkjvfnbxtcrjve dkbzybñ. D djghjcföjåhfpjdfybz tq elfkjcm vjåbkbpjdfnm nfrjq är-cgthnysq gjntywbfk, rjnjhsq gjpdjkztn Jhufyb-pfwbb gjlöjlbnm r änbv ckjéytqibv ghjåktvfv c vfrcbvfkmyjq rjvgtntynyjcnmñ b äaatrnbdyjc-nmñ yf dctö ehjdyzö. JÅCT nfrét jåkflftn cgj-cjåyjcnmñ cbcntvfnbpbhjdfnm b yfghfdkznm bybwbfnbds b htrjvtylfwbb vtéleyfhjlyjuj cjjåotcndf, jåtcgtxbdfz cnfåbkmyeñ b tlbyjlei-yeñ gjllthére htajhvs jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU vté-leyfhjlysvb gfhnythfvb cnhfys.

Xnj åjkmit dctuj åtcgjrjbn Dfc d cdzpb c htajhvbhjdfybtv cbcntvs jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU?

Vtyz nhtdjébn nj, xnj åkbpjherbt b crkjyystr pfrekbcysv vfybgekzwbzv ltzntkb ghjljkéfñnbuhfnm c jåhfpjdfybtv d gjkbnbxtcrbt buhs. Vté-le ntv htxm bltn j dtofö, jn rjnjhsö pfdbcbnébpym rféljuj uhfélfybyf ÅbU. Rfxtcndj jåext-ybz – jn yfxfkmyjq b chtlytq irjks lj eybdth-cbntnjd b ntöybrevjd, – rjnjhjt vjuen ctujlyzgjkexbnm kñlb d änjq cnhfyt, cfvsv ytgjchtlcn-dtyysv jåhfpjv jnhfpbncz yf tt åeleotv. Ytcvjn-hz yf änj, gthdjjxthtlyst ghjåktvs extåyjujghjwtccf jcnfñncz åtp dybvfybz, f d herjdjlcndtntv dhtvtytv ghjljkéfñncz ghthtrfntkmcndf gjybrfr yt cdzpfyysv c änbv djghjcfv. Ltnb ds-yeéltys exbnmcz d gthtgjkytyysö rkfccfö e gt-htuheétyysö hfåjnjq exbntktq gj ecnfhtdibvextåybrfv – yt gjnjve, xnj d cnhfyt yt ödfnftnhtcehcjd, f gjnjve, xnj jyb bcgjkmpeñncz ytäa-atrnbdyj.

D yfxfkt fghtkz JÅCT ghjdtkf rjyathtywbñ yf ntve jåhfpjdfybz d Wtynhfkmyjq Fpbb. Vjuen kb cnhfys änjuj htubjyf yfexbnmcz xtve-kbåj yfghbvtht ÅbU?

Ehjr ÅbU cjcnjbn, yf vjq dpukzl, d njv, xnj jåhfpjdfybt – änj ltkj, hfccxbnfyyjt yf jxtymlfkmyññ gthcgtrnbde; bydtcnbwbb d cathe jåhf-pjdfybz ghbytcen gkjls kbim cktleñotve gjrj-ktybñ, njulf rfr exfobvcz, exbntkzv b hjlbntkzveét ctqxfc ytjåöjlbvj gjcnjzyyj djpltqcndjdfnmyf cdjbö kblthjd, ljåbdfzcm, xnjås ghfdbntkmcndjyt erkjyzkjcm jn jndtncndtyyjcnb pf äne dféytq-

6 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

DSCJRBQ GHTLCNFDBNTKM KJHL ≤GÄLLB≥ ÄILFEY

Gjkbnbxtcrbt buhs c htajhvjqjåhfpjdfybz åmñn gj bynthtcfvrféljuj uhfélfybyf ÅbU

Dscnegfz gthtl xktyfvb Gjcnjzyyjuj cjdtnf JÅCT d Dtyt dcrjht gjckt cdjtuj yfpyfxtybz d vft 2002 ujlf yfgjcn Dscjrjuj ghtlcnfdbntkz b cgtwbfkmyjuj ghtlcnfdbntkz Tdhjgtqcrjuj cjñpf d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt, kjhlÄilfey gjlxthrbdfk, xnj cjcnjzybt jåhfpjdfntkmyjq cbcntvs cnhfys zdkztncz cthmtpysv ghtgzncndbtv yf genb r cnfåbkmyjcnb b åtpjgfcyjcnb, b ghbpsdfk JÅCT djpukfdbnm ecbkbz gj htajhvbhjdfybñ lfyyjq caths.Ctujlyz, ldf ujlf cgecnz, änjn åsdibq xkty åhbnfycrjuj gfhkfvtynf gj-ghtéytve ndthlj dthbn d cgjcjåyjcnmJhufybpfwbb jåtcgtxbdfnm gjcnhjtybt uhfélfycrjuj jåotcndf, jgbhfzcm yf cdjñ ≤kexieñ dj dctö jnyjitybzöctnm cjnhelybrjd yf vtcnfö≥. Htlfrnjh Tétujlyjuj ljrkflf JÅCT Vfhnf Ahbvty ytlfdyj gjkexbkf djpvjé-yjcnm pflfnm kjhle Äilfeye ytcrjkmrj djghjcjd.

ÅÑ

HJ

DS

CJ

RJ

UJ

GH

TL

CN

FD

BN

TK

Z

Ckjéyst ghjåktvs htajhvsjåhfpjdfybz b djjheétyysöcbk ÅbU åskb ukfdyjq ntvjqåtctl kjhlf Äilfeyf (ckt-df) c Ltqcndeñobv ghtlct-lfntktv JÅCT CjkjvjyjvGfccb (cghfdf) d Cfhftdj29 vfhnf. D öjlt dcnhtxb c ghtvmth-vbybcnhjv ÅbU Flyfyjv Nthébxtv C. Gfccbujdjhbk j ytjåöjlbvjcnbghbyznbz jåotujcelfhcndty-yjuj hfvjxyjuj pfrjyf j dscitv jåhfpjdfybb. Änjgjpdjkbkj ås cneltynfv bpÅbU cnfnm exfcnybrfvb tlbyj-uj tdhjgtqcrjuj ghjcnhfycn-df d jåkfcnb dscituj jåhf-pjdfybz, cjplfyyjuj d 1999ujle cjukfcyj Åjkjycrjqltrkfhfwbb j dpfbvyjv cjjn-dtncndbb cntgtytq åfrfkfd-hf, vfubcnhf b ljrnjhf dcnhfyfö Tdhjgs.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 7: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

ieñ hfåjne – rfr jyj gjcnegfkj d ÅbU vyjubt ujls, bp-pf xtujgjcnhflfkb ltcznrb nsczx ltntq.

Rfr ghfdbntkmcnde b tuj vtéleyfhjlysv gfhnythfv jåtcgtxbnmhtpekmnfnbdyjcnm cdjbö ecbkbq d jåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz?

Ljcnfnjxyj kbim gjckeifnm, xnj ujdjhzn extybrb, exbntkz bhjlbntkb, xnjås chfpe ghtlcnfdbnm ctåt xtnreñ rfhnbye njuj, yf-crjkmrj äaatrnbdyj bkb ytäaatrnbdyj bcgjkmpeñncz htcehcs.

Gj dctq Tdhjgt ctqxfc byntycbdyj jåceélftncz ntvf cdtncrjujjåhfpjdfybz lkz kñltq hfpkbxysö rjyatccbq. Xnj vjéyj bpdktxmbp änbö lbcreccbq gjktpyjuj lkz dshfåjnrb gjkbnbrb d jåkfcnbjåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU?

Änj ljkéys htifnm cfvb ébntkb ÅbU. Yfvb cjukfcjdfyf tlb-yfz åfpjdfz extåyfz ghjuhfvvf lkz dctö irjk, b z levfñ, xnjexfobtcz, exbntkz b hjlbntkb cvjuen ghbyznm tt pf jcyjde.

D bñyt 2003 ujlf Ds ghtleghtélfkb Gjcnjzyysq cjdtn JÅCT:≤Eqnb ctqxfc [c Åfkrfy] jpyfxfkj ås egecnbnm gjåtle≥. Bpvtyb-kjcm kb Dfit vytybt ujl cgecnz?

Fåcjkñnyj ytn. Ctqxfc d ÅbU joeofñncz gthdst htpekmnfnsfrnbdyjq hfåjns, rjnjheñ ghjdjlbn vtéleyfhjlyjt cjjåotcn-dj c 1996 ujlf. Jåotcndj ghböjlbn d ctåz; cnfyjdzncz dblysghbpyfrb djphjéltybz ärjyjvbrb. Ntvgs b vfcinfås djpdhf-otybz åtétywtd elbdkzñn ntö, rnj lj cfvjuj rjywf 1990-ö ujljd åsk crtgnbxtcrb yfcnhjty gj änjve gjdjle.

Vs cjplftv d cnhfyt bycnbnewbjyfkmyst vtöfybpvs lkz cnf-yjdktybz ghjwdtnfñotq gfhkfvtyncrjq ltvjrhfnbb, byntuhbhj-dfyyjq d tdhjfnkfynbxtcrbt cnhernehs d catht gjkbnbrb, ärj-yjvbrb b åtpjgfcyjcnb. Ctqxfc eé njxyj yt dhtvz åhjcfnmyfxfnjt ltkj. Vs ljkéys ghjljkéfnm tuj lj ntö gjh, gjrf jyjyt åeltn cltkfyj, b åjktt dctuj yfc ljkéyj jåjlhznm nj, xnjghtlghbyznst ecbkbz eét yfxbyfñn ghbyjcbnm gkjls.

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 7

Vfylfn Vbccbb JÅCT d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt (ÅbU) åskjghtltkty Jåobv hfvjxysv cjukfitybtv j vbht, gjkj-ébdibv rjytw 43-vt-czxyjve rjyakbrne.Gjckt tuj gjlgbcfybz dLtqnjyt d rjywt 1995ujlf ÅbU jrfpfkfcm gt-htl ckjéytqitq pflf-xtq: pfyjdj cnhjbnm ectåz gjkbänybxtcrjt,ltvjrhfnbxtcrjt jåot-cndj. Vbccbz JÅCT – jlyj bp ukfdysö exhté-ltybq, ghbpdfyysö gj-vjxm cnhfyt d jceotcn-dktybb änjuj gthtöjlf –ghbcnegbkf r hfåjnt dltrfåht 1995 ujlf.

Ghjuhfvvs Vbccbb yfwtktys yf ecrjhtyjthfpdbnbt gjkbnbxtcrböbycnbnenjd ltvjrhfnbbyf dctö ehjdyzö, jnvtcnyjuj lj jåotujce-lfhcndtyyjuj. Tt ltz-ntkmyjcnm jödfnsdftndjghjcs ltvjrhfnbpf-wbb, jåhfpjdfybz, ghfdxtkjdtrf, htajhvs uj-celfhcndtyyjuj fggfhf-nf b cjnhelybxtcndf djåkfcnb åtpjgfcyjcnb.

Jlyf bp cfvsö cbkmysö cnjhjy Vbccbb – jåibhyjt ghb-cencndbt yf vtcnfö, gjpdjkzñott tq cktlbnm pf öjljv cj-

åsnbq gj dctq cnhfyt bntcyj dpfbvjltqcndj-dfnm c vtcnysvb gjkbnb-rfvb, xbyjdybrfvb buhfélfyfvb. Htubjyfkm-yst wtynhs Vbccbb rjjhlbybheñn hfåjne yf ybpjdjv ehjdyt, cktlz pf ntv, xnjås ttgjkbnbrf b ghjuhfvvsghjdjlbkbcm d ébpymcjukfcjdfyyj b gjcktl-jdfntkmyj.

D cjcnfd Vbccbb JÅCTd ÅbU döjlzn ujkjdyjtjnltktybt d Cfhftdj,xtnsht htubjyfkmysöwtynhf d Cfhftdj, Nepkt,Vjcnfht b Åfyz-Kert b24 vtcnysö jnltktybz,hfpåhjcfyysö gj dctqnthhbnjhbb cnhfys. Bpghbvthyj 800 tt cj-nhelybrjd 600 zdkzñnczuhfélfyfvb Åjcybb bUthwtujdbys, f jcnfkm-yst – ghtlcnfdbntkzvbgjhzlrf 30 bp 55 ujce-lfhcnd – exfcnybrjdJÅCT.

Cghfdrf: Vbccbz JÅCT d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

OSCE Mission to BiH ● Fra Andjela Zvizdovica 1 ● 71000 Sarajevo ● Bosnia and HerzegovinaE-mail: [email protected] ● Phone: +387 33 752 100 ● Fax: + 387 33 442 479

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 8: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

RTDBY CFKKBDFY

Wdtneobt crkjys öjkvjd pfkbns cjkywtv.Ptktytñn yfåeöibvb gjxrfvb njgjkbystdtndb. Cdtébq rhfcysq rbhgbx cnhjz-oböcz plfybq rfr ås ljgjkyztn cdjbvdbljv rfhnbye ghjåeéltybz ghbhjls...

Jåott joeotybt yfxbyfñotqcz yjdjq ébpybnhelyj åskj yt ekjdbnm hfyytq dtcyjq änjuj ujlfd Rjpfhfwt, ytåjkmijv ujhjlrt yf gjkgenb vtélecnjkbwtq Htcgeåkbrb Cthåcrjq (HC) – jlyjuj bpjåhfpjdfybq d cjcnfdt Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbys(ÅbU) – b jrheujv Ghbtljh yf ctdtht cnhfys.

Dvtcnt c Dfkthbtq Nbcvjq, hfåjnfñotq pltcmhtubjyfkmysv rjjhlbyfnjhjv Vbccbb JÅCT gjdjghjcfv jåhfpjdfybz, vs tltv d tt vfibyt gjytåhjcrbv wtynhfkmysv ekbwfv Rjpfhfwf d uj-hjlcreñ chtlyññ irjke, nfrét gthtébdfñoeñ d änb lyb cdjtuj hjlf djphjéltybt. ≤Änj gthdsq

ujhjl, ult z jrfpfkfcm, rjulf yfxfkf hfåjnfnm dJÅCT≥, – dcgjvbyftn Dfkthbz, evtkj yfghfdkzzåtksq ckeétåysq ≤Gfléthj≥ d jåütpl uhzpysökeé b hsndby yf yfitv genb.

Nj åsk fduecn 2002 ujlf, rjulf Dfkthbz ghbikfyf hfåjne d njkmrj xnj cjplfyysq Vbccbtq ltgfh-nfvtyn jåhfpjdfybz. Tt yfghfdbkb d Rjpfhfw eht-uekbhjdfnm cgjh vtéle irjkmysv yfxfkmcndjv bhjlbntkzvb extybrjd, ytljdjkmysvb ntv, rfr exfnbö ltntq. D pyfr ghjntcnf hjlbntkb gthtrhskbldbétybt yf jlyjv bp cfvsö åjkmibö ujhjlcrbögthtrhtcnrjd. Lkz Dfkthbb änj cnfkj åjtdsv rht-otybtv b gthdsv ghbvthjv njuj, xtv tq ghtl-cnjzkj pfybvfnmcz d åkbéfqibt vtczws.

Pföjlz d nhtöänféyjt irjkmyjt plfybt, Dfkthbzb tt gjvjoybwf Yfnfif lfét ctujlyz, gjknjhf uj-lf cgecnz, ébdj dcgjvbyfñn njn gthdsq ghbtpl. Eirjks gj-ghtéytve ytjåébnjq dbl, rfr e pfåhj-ityyjuj ljvf, bp rjnjhjuj cütöfkb ébkmws; hfpdtxnj rjhbljhfv gjgsnfkbcm ghblfnm öjnm rfrjq-njeñn, pfvfpfd åtkeñ inerfnehre yf cntyfö cdtnkj-ptktyjq rhfcrjq.

Pf dscjrbvb jryfvb åtp pfyfdtcjr dbltyirjkmysq ldjh c nfxrfvb, ljdthöe gjkysvbcnheérb b otgjr. Änj åtpdjpvtplyfz gjvjom hfcgjkjétyysö gj cjctlcnde ktcjgbkmysö pfdj-ljd, åtp rjnjhjq irjke åskj ås ytxtv njgbnm.

≤Djjåot-nj vs yt vthpytv – ye nfr, ytvyjérj:gfkmws ckturf rjxtytñn≥, – ienbn lbhtrnjh irj-ks Veöblby Cfhbx yf djghjc Dfkthbb c Yfnfitq.Jyb cnfhst lhepmz, cdzpfyyst jåobvb djcgjvbyf-ybzvb j ltqcndbntkmyj nzétksö lkz irjks dht-vtyfö.

DJPDHFOTYBT

D öjlt djqys 1992–1995 ujljd irjkf d Rjpfhfwtåskf ghfrnbxtcrb hfpheityf. Änb vtcnf yföjlb-kbcm d ukeåbyt cthåcrjq nthhbnjhbb, b rjulf yfxf-kbcm åjb, gjxnb dct ghjébdfdibt pltcm 50 000åjcyzrjd åskb dsyeéltys cgfcfnmcz åtucndjv.Åhjityyst bvb ljvf chfdyzkb c ptvktq.

Ctqxfc, gj gjcktlybv lfyysv EDRÅ, d jrheuGhbtljh eét dthyekjcm åjktt 12 000 bp änbö kñ-ltq, vyjubt bp rjnjhsö dyjdm gjctkbkbcm d Rjpf-hfwt, jncnhjbd cdjb ljvf ghb abyfycjdjv cj-ltqcndbb vtéleyfhjlyjuj cjjåotcndf. Jlyfrjgjcskfnm cdjtq ltntq d irjks jyb gjyfxfke ythtifkbcm. Ghtgjlfdfybt dtkjcm gj cthåcrjq ghj-uhfvvt, irjkmyfz flvbybcnhfwbz b jcyjdyfz vfc-cf exfoböcz njét cjcnjzkb bp cthåjd.

Fyfkjubxyfz rfhnbyf, hfccrfpsdftn cjdtnybrVbccbb JÅCT gj djghjcfv ljcnegf b ytljgeot-ybz lbcrhbvbyfwbb Léj-Äyy Åbijg, yfåkñlfkjcmyf dctq nthhbnjhbb ÅbU. ≤Dthyedibtcz åtétywsjgfcfkbcm, xnj d irjkfö bö ltnb åelen gjldthufnm-cz gcböjkjubxtcrjq b abpbxtcrjq nhfdkt≥.

Dfkthbz öjhjij gjybvftn xedcndf djpdhfoty-wtd. Ehjétyrf ujhjlf Ryby, d 60 rbkjvtnhfö rctdthj-pfgfle jn öjhdfncrjuj Cgkbnf, jyf åskf dxbckt 180 000 cthåjd, dsyeéltyysö gjrbyenm hjl-yst vtcnf d htpekmnfnt ≤jgthfwbb ≤Injhv≥, rjnj-heñ öjhdfncrfz fhvbz ghjdtkf d fduecnt 1995 ujlf.

≤Tckb ås z dthyekfcm d Öjhdfnbñ, nj yt pyfñ,

8 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

HFDYSQ LJCNEG R JÅHFPJDFYBÑ

Ytdjcgtnst uthjb: åjhmåf clbcrhbvbyfwbtqd irjkföLtnb dthyediböcz åtétywtd öjnzn exbnmcz

Irjkmybr bp Rjpfhfwf gjrfpsdftn Dfkthbb Nbcvt,

rfr jy evttn xbnfnm.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 9: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

rfr vjz nhtöktnyzz ljxm Vbf xedcndjdfkf ås ctåzd nfvjiytq irjkt, – ujdjhbn jyf. – Yt levfñ, xnjnfv djjåot tcnm exbntkz-cthås. R cxfcnmñ, pltcm,d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt, Vbccbz JÅCT gjkexbkfgjkyjvjxbz rjjhlbybhjdfnm b ghjldbufnm htajh-ve jåhfpjdfybz≥.

PFCNFDBNM CTÅZ ECKSIFNM

Rjulf JÅCT dgthdst yfxfkf pfybvfnmcz djghjcf-vb jåhfpjdfybz, djpveotyyst hjlbntkb åjcybq-crbö irjkmybrjd d Rjpfhfwt njkmrj xnj gthtikbr jnrhsnjve ghjntcne. D nj dhtvz dct htitybz, jnjghtltktybz ghjuhfvvs pfyznbq lj yfqvf exbnt-ktq, ghbybvfkbcm lbhtrnjhjv-cthåjv b cjcnjzd-ibv bp cthåjd irjkmysv cjdtnjv d ujhjlt pf 30rbkjvtnhjd jncñlf. Hjlbntkb öjntkb, xnjås bövytybt exbnsdfkjcm ntvb, rnj exbn bö ltntq, flkz änjuj irjkt ytjåöjlbvj åskj ghblfnm cnfneccfvjcnjzntkmyjuj extåyjuj pfdtltybz, yt zdkzñ-otujcz abkbfkjv lheujq irjks.

≤Vs gjvjukb jhufybpjdfnm hzl dcnhtx c ghtl-cnfdbntkzvb dkfcntq Htcgeåkbrb Cthåcrjq lkzdszcytybz njuj, rfr vjéyj åskj ås ghbyznm djdybvfybt nhtåjdfybz hjlbntktq, – ujdjhbn Dfkt-hbz. – Xnjås bpvtybnm cnfnec irjks, nhtåjdfkjcmghtjljktnm vyjuj änfétq åñhjrhfnbb: pfhexbnmczcjukfcbtv vbybcnthcndf jåhfpjdfybz, f pfntvjljåhtybtv dctuj ghfdbntkmcndf HC, drkñxfz ght-vmth-vbybcnhf, tuj pfvtcnbntktq b ukfd 16 lheubövbybcnthcnd≥.

D rjywt rjywjd irjkf dct ét gjkexbkf cfvj-cnjzntkmyjcnm. Öjnz tt plfybt gj-ghtéytve yeé-lfkjcm d rfgbnfkmyjv htvjynt, ntgthm vjéyj ås-kj gj rhfqytq vtht yfpyfxbnm cjåcndtyyjujlbhtrnjhf b cajhvbhjdfnm cdjq irjkmysq cjdtn.

≤Åtp nfrbö kñltq, rfr Dfkthbz, z ås yt cghfdbk-cz c änjq cbnefwbtq, – ghbpyftncz V. Cfhbx. – Änjåsk pfvtxfntkmysq ghbvth cjnhelybxtcndf≥.

CJÅCNDTYYFZ JNDTNCNDTYYJCNM

Dct änj cnfkj djpvjéysv åkfujlfhz Dhtvtyyj-ve cjukfitybñ jå jåtcgtxtybb jcjåsö gjnhtå-yjcntq b ghfd ltntq djpdhfofñoböcz kbw, gjlgb-cfyyjve dctvb vbybcnhfvb jåhfpjdfybz ÅbU dvfhnt 2002 ujlf. Rfr b vyjubt jabwbfkmyst ljre-vtyns, jyj bvtkj ckjéyjt yfpdfybt, yj ghjcneñwtkm: cjplfnm ltnzv dthyediböcz åtétywtd rfrvjéyj åjktt åkfujghbznyst eckjdbz d irjkföhjlysö ujhjljd b ctk.

D Rjpfhfwt lkz änjuj ghbikjcm bpvtybnm jab-wbfkmysq cnfnec irjks. D lheubö ckexfzö htxmvjukf blnb j cjplfybb jåcnfyjdrb, gjpdjkzñotqltnzv xedcndjdfnm ctåz d åtpjgfcyjcnb, bkb j gj-dsitybb ljdthbz hjlbntktq r rfxtcnde jåextybz.

Ghfrnbxtcrfz htfkbpfwbz Dhtvtyyjuj cjukfit-ybz jrfpfkfcm ytkturbv ltkjv. ≤Dyfxfkt, – dcgjvb-yftn Léj-Äyy Åbijg, – rfynjys Atlthfwbb gjk-yjcnmñ åjqrjnbhjdfkb, yt ghbpyfdfkb tuj. Ntgthmét vbybcnhs jåhfpjdfybz cfvb ujdjhzn j ljcnb-étybzö yf gjldtljvcndtyysö bv nthhbnjhbzö≥.

Jnyjitybt vbybcnhjd rj Dhtvtyyjve cjukfit-ybñ bpvtybkjcm gjckt njuj, rfr Vbccbz JÅCT lj-åbkfcm gthtlfxb bv gjkyjvjxbq gj dshfåjnrt

gkfyf tuj jceotcndktybz. Änj åsk jlby bp ghbvt-hjd cgjcjåyjcnb JÅCT djgkjofnm yfgbcfyyjt yfåevfut d htfkmyeñ ébpym.

R extåt gj vtcne ébntkmcndf ctqxfc ghbcnegb-kb eét åjktt 33 000 irjkmybrjd b cneltynjd bpdthyediböcz ctvtq. D htpekmnfnt ghjltkfyyjq frnbdyjq hfåjns gj dctq cnhfyt yfyznj jrjkj1800 rdfkbabwbhjdfyysö exbntktq-djpdhfotywtd.Änj cthmtpyst wbahs, tckb extcnm, xnj djpdhf-ofñobtcz åtétyws b gthtvtotyyst kbwf ghb-yflktéfn d jcyjdyjv r änybxtcrbv vtymibycndfv.

Rfr c eljdktndjhtybtv jnvtxftn cjnhelybrVbccbb JÅCT gj djghjcfv jåhfpjdfybz Fphf Léeyepjdbx, vtcnyst dkfcnb b jåotcndtyyjcnmelfkjcm eåtlbnm d njv, xnj jyb ljkéys dpznm yfctåz dcñ gjkyjne jndtncndtyyjcnb pf htfkbpfwbñcjukfitybz. ≤JÅCT gjvjukf cldbyenm hfåjne c vtc-nf, yj dtcm ujl exhtéltybz ÅbU dtkb tt cfvjcnjz-ntkmyj. Jxtym vyjubt pflfxb tot yt htitys, yjehjdtym vtcnysö cgtwbfkbcnjd ntgthm gjdscbkcz,b vbybcnthcndf vjuen ghjljkéfnm änj ltkj cjåcn-dtyysvb cbkfvb≥.

AEYLFVTYNFKMYST DJGHJCS

Ljcnfnjxyj pfukzyenm d rjvgmñnthysq rkfccchtlytq irjks d Rjpfhfwt, xnjås gjyznm, rfrvyjuj pltcm bpvtybkjcm c ntö gjh, rfr irjkfdyjdm jnrhskf cdjb ldthb extybrfv. Cjchtljnj-xtyyst kbwf htåzn, ecthlyj yfébvfñobö yf rkf-dbib, gjlcdtxtys ptktyjdfnj-ujkeåsv cbzybtvvjybnjhjd.

Ghtgjlfdfntkm c ujhljcnmñ hfccrfpsdftn Dfkt-hbb, xnj gj jcyfotyyjcnb äktrnhjybrjq irjkfctqxfc – jlyf bp kexibö d jr-heut. Pltcm wtksö 16 rjvgmñnt-hjd, gj jlyjve yf 21 exfotuj-cz: änj ujhfplj åjkmit, xtv gjcnhfyt d wtkjv, ult jlby rjv-gmñnth ghböjlbncz d chtlytvyf 60 irjkmybrjd.

V. Cfhbx bcgsnsdftn pfrjy-yjt eljdktndjhtybt rfélsqhfp, rjulf irjkt elftncz ght-jljktnm rfreñ-kbåj bp vyjuj-xbcktyysö ghjåktv, jcjåtyyjnfreñ aeylfvtynfkmyeñ, rfrghjåktvf zpsrf.

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 9

D htrjycnhebhjdfyyjv plfybb irjks d ctdthyjv

jrheut Ghbtljh exfncz ltnbdthyediböcz cñlf ébntktq.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 10: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

10 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

C hfcgfljv Ñujckfdbb hfcgfkcz b tt ujcelfhcn-dtyysq zpsr, rjulf-nj bvtyjdfdibqcz cthåcrjöjh-dfncrbv. Ntgthm ébntkb ÅbU ujdjhzn yf nhtö tujdfhbfynfö, rjnjhsv ghbcdjtys yfpdfybz änybxtc-rbö uhegg, – åjcybqcrjv, öjhdfncrjv b cthåcrjv.Djpybrifz genfybwf ghbdtkf r ytcrjyxftvsv ltåfnfv j cjlthéfybb irjkmyjq ghjuhfvvs b jghbcencndbb d ytq gjntywbfkmyj jcrjhåbntkmysöyfwbjyfkbcnbxtcrbö vjnbdjd.

Jå änjv gjxnb cvtiyj dcgjvbyfnm, yj V. Cfhbxghbpyftn, xnj jy cfv jlyj dhtvz yt vju htibnm,rfrjve fkafdbne b rfrjq jhajuhfabb exbnm lt-ntq. Ytult åskj dpznm erfpfybz yfcxtn njuj, ghjbp-

dtltybz rfrbö fdnjhjd ≤ghbtvktvs≥ lkz drkñxt-ybz d ghjuhfvve. Irjkmyjt herjdjlcndj åtcgj-rjbkjcm lfét j njv, ≤ghfdbkmyst≥ kb gtcyb gjñnltnb yf ehjrfö vepsrb.

Pfntv, d fduecnt 2003 ujlf, vbybcnhs jåhfpjdf-ybz ÅbU cltkfkb dféysq ifu dgthtl. ≤Jyb ghbyz-kb åfpjdeñ extåyeñ ghjuhfvve lkz dctq cnhfys,b änj yfc cgfckj≥, – ujdjhbn Cfhbx, jpfhzzcmcxfcnkbdjq eksårjq. Irjks yfrjytw gjkexbkbljkujélfyyst bycnherwbb.

Rjpfhfw – jlby bp ghbvthjd, cdbltntkmcndeñ-obö, xnj djpdhfotybt åtétywtd htfkmyj jceotcn-dbvj. Tckb jyj cnfkj djpvjéysv lfét pltcm, d jlyjv bp hfqjyjd, ult d ujls djqys ndjhbkbcmöelibt pkjltzybz, nj b d lheubö vtcnfö c gjöjétqbcnjhbtq änf ghjåktvf vjétn åsnm htityf.

Dfkthbz yflttncz edbltnm änj cjåcndtyysvbukfpfvb. Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz rfcftncz b tt kbx-yj: ≤Z gjcnjzyyj levfñ j cdjtq ljxthb. Rjulf Vbfgjqltn d irjke – pltcm kb, bkb ljvf, d Öjhdfnbb,– z öjxe, xnjås tq nfv gjyhfdbkjcm. Z öjxe, xnjåse ytt åskb öjhjibt exbntkz b xnjås jyf gjkexb-kf öjhjitt jåhfpjdfybt≥.

Bp jryf hfpheityyjujljvf d lthtdyt Rfvbxfyb jnrhsdftnczdbl yf cdtétjnhtvjy-nbhjdfyyjt irjkmyjtplfybt.

♦ Ehjdtym uhfvjnyjcnb chtlb dphjckjujyfctktybz: 93 ghjwtynf (lfyyst ÑYBCTA).♦ Gj cdtltybzv, gjkextyysv Vbccbtq dÅbU jn lbhtrnjhjd irjk, d 2100 irjkföcnhfys exfncz jrjkj 560 000 xtkjdtr; yf rféljuj exbntkz ghböjlbncz d chtl-ytv 16,5 extybrjd.♦ Irjkmyjt jåextybt yfxbyftncz c itcnb bkb ctvb ktn.♦ Jödfn ltntq yfxfkmysv irjkmysv jåhfpjdfybtv – 86 ghjwtynjd (lfyystÑYBCTA).♦ D Htcgeåkbrt Cthåcrjq ceotcndetncbcntvf jåzpfntkmyjuj chtlytuj jåhfpj-dfybz d jåütvt ltdznb rkfccjd. Jcnfkm-yfz xfcnm cnhfys yföjlbncz d ghjwtcctgthtöjlf jn djcmvbktnytuj r ltdznbktn-ytve jåextybñ.♦ Pfyznbz ghjljkéfñncz jrjkj itcnbxfcjd d ltym, yj d ytrjnjhsö hfqjyföirjkfv, lkz njuj xnjås dvtcnbnm dctöyeélfñoböcz d jåextybb ltntq, ghböj-

lbncz hfåjnfnm d xtnsht cvtys, c djcm-vb enhf lj ctvb dtxthf.♦ Dsgecrybrb chtlytq irjks vjuen ghj-ljkébnm jåhfpjdfybt d xtnshtöktnytqjåotjåhfpjdfntkmyjq ubvyfpbb kbåjgjcnegbnm yf ldf, nhb bkb xtnsht ujlf dghjatccbjyfkmyj-ntöybxtcrjt exbkbotbkb ntöybrev.♦ D gjcktdjtyysq gthbjl åskb hfphf-åjnfys nhb ≤gfhfkktkmyst≥ irjkmystghjuhfvvs – åjcybqcrfz, öjhdfncrfz bcthåcrfz, – gj rjnjhsv ctqxfc dtltnczghtgjlfdfybt.♦ Hfphfåjnrjq extåysö ghjuhfvv pfyb-vfñncz bycnbnens jåhfpjdfybz gjl gjcnjzyysv rjynhjktv vbybcnthcnd jåhfpjdfybz.♦ Chtlyzz pfhgkfnf exbntktq ärdbdf-ktynyf 255 tdhj d vtczw.♦ D cnhfyt c jåotq xbcktyyjcnmñ yfct-ktybz jrjkj 4,1 vky. xtkjdtr ltqcndetnctvm eybdthcbntnjd, ult exfncz d jåotqckjéyjcnb ghbvthyj 100 000 cneltynjd.

Cbcntvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt: afrns b wbahs

Rtdby Cfkkbdfy, cnfhibq cjnhelybr Vbccbb JÅCT d ÅbU gj djghjcfv jåot-cndtyyjq byajhvfwbb, djpukfdkzk uhegge, gjlujnjdbdieñ änjn cgtwbfkmysq htgjhnfé j htajhvt cbcntvs jåhf-pjdfybz d ÅbU. Lj ghbtplfyf Åfkrfys d 2002 ujle jy hfåjnfk éehyfkbcnjv b pfybvfkcz cütvrjq ljrevtynfkmysö abkmvjdd CIF.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 11: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 11

HERJDJLZOFZ UHEGGF GJ RJVGKTRCE DJGHJCJD JÅHFPJDFYBZ

Hfpdbnbt jåhfpjdfybz dÅbU cldbyekjcm c vthndjq njxrbRkñx r ecgtöe – cjnhelybxtcndj b gfhnythcndj

ÄKMVBHF ÅFQHFCKB

Dbñkt 2002 ujlf Gjcnjzyysq cjdtn JÅCTgjhexbk Vbccbb d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbytrjjhlbybhjdfnm ecbkbz ltcznrjd vtcnysöb vtéleyfhjlysö gfhnythjd gj ghtjljkt-

ybñ gjkbnbxtcrjq bythwbb, gfhfkbpjdfditq hfp-dbnbt jåhfpjdfybz d cnhfyt.

Vbccbz jgthfnbdyj cajhvbhjdfkf ytåjkmieñuhegge ärcgthnjd, rjnjhst hfphfåjnfkb cnhjqyeñrjywtgwbñ dsdjlf jåhfpjdfntkmyjq cbcntvs bpnegbrf. Dpzd pf jcyjde htpekmnfns ltzntkmyjcnbghtéytq hfåjxtq uheggs gj djghjcfv jåhfpjdf-ybz, Vbccbz ghbpdfkf dct pfbynthtcjdfyyst cnj-hjys djqnb d cjcnfd nfr yfpsdftvjq Herjdjlzotquheggs gj rjvgktrce djghjcjd jåhfpjdfybz (HURDJ).

Rfélsq bp exfcnybrjd uheggs cjöhfyztn cfvj-cnjzntkmyjcnm b cjåcndtyyeñ cgtwbfkbpfwbñ; ghbänjv dct jyb jåütlbyzñn ecbkbz lkz ecrjhtybzghjwtccf htajhv. Ctujlyz d HURDJ åjktt cnf xkt-yjd, d njv xbckt Åñhj Dscjrjuj ghtlcnfdbntkz,ÑYBCTA, ÑYTCRJ, Cjdtn Tdhjgs, Tdhjgtqcrfzrjvbccbz b Dctvbhysq åfyr, f nfrét vyjujxbc-ktyyst ytghfdbntkmcndtyyst jhufybpfwbb, vbybc-nthcndf b gjcjkmcndf.

Exbnsdfz ibhjne b vfcinfåyjcnm ghjåktv djåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz, HURDJ hfcghtltkbkf rjy-rhtnyst yfghfdktybz hfåjns vtéle itcnmñ hfåj-xbvb uheggfvb, gjhexbd bv hfccvjnhtybt ckt-leñobö djghjcjd:♦ ljcneg r jåextybñ b ytljgeotybt lbcrhbvb-

yfwbb;♦ rfxtcndj yfxfkmyjuj b chtlytuj jåhfpjdfybz b

tuj vjlthybpfwbz;♦ ghjatccbjyfkmyj-ntöybxtcrjt jåextybt b tuj

vjlthybpfwbz;♦ rfxtcndj dscituj jåhfpjdfybz b tuj vjlthyb-

pfwbz;

♦ abyfycjdst b flvbybcnhfnbdyst fcgtrns jåhfpjdfybz;

♦ htajhvf pfrjyjlfntkmcndf jå jåhfpjdfybb.

Vtéle exfcnybrfvb HURDJ ecnfyjdbkbcm jnyj-itybz gfhnythcndf: änj njn ckexfq, rjulf rjytx-ysq htpekmnfn ltqcndbntkmyj åjkmit cevvs ckfuftvsö. Yfghbvth, nfrbt jhufybpfwbb, rfrÑYBCTA b ÑYTCRJ, c bö vyjujktnybv jgsnjvjöhfys dctjåotuj ghfdf ltntq yf jåhfpjdfybt,ghjrkflsdfñn genm r kexitve jåtcgtxtybñ hfd-yjuj lkz dctö ljcnegf d extåyst pfdtltybz b kbr-dblfwbb lbcrhbvbyfwbjyyjq ghfrnbrb. Ntv dht-vtytv Tdhjgtqcrfz rjvbccbz cjplftn aeylfvtyncbcntvs dscjrjrfxtcndtyyjuj yfxfkmyjuj b chtl-ytuj jåhfpjdfybz, jndtxfñotuj tdhjgtqcrbv yjh-vfv b ghbywbgfv.

Dvtcnt c Dscjrbv ghtlcnfdbntktv kjhljv Äi-lfeyjv gjcjk Tdhjgtqcrjq rjvbccbb d Åjcybb bUthwtujdbyt Vfqrk Öfvahbp frnbdyj dscnegftn pfecrjhtybt htajhvs. Ghb rféljv eljåyjv ckexftjy ghtleghtélftn j njv, xnj tckb änb djghjcs ytåelen ljkéysv jåhfpjv htitys, nj cbcntvf jåhf-pjdfybz vjétn ghtdhfnbnmcz d ≤bycnhevtyn hfplt-ktybz, f yt jåütlbytybz kñltq≥.

≤Bvtyyj tlbysq gjlöjl d hfvrfö HURDJ, åjktt,xtv xnj-kbåj lheujt, gjpdjkztn cltkfnm yfie pflf-xe htfkmyjq b gjvjuftn pfrhtgbnm yf lkbntkmyeñgthcgtrnbde htpekmnfns htajhv d jåkfcnb jåhfpj-dfybz, – gjlxthrbdftn gjcjk Öfvahbp.

C änbv cjdthityyj cjukfcys lheubt xktys HURDJ. Rfr jnvtxftn ukfdf ghtlcnfdbntkmcndf Dct-vbhyjuj åfyrf d ÅbU Lbhr Hfqythvfy, cjdvtcnystecbkbz gj kbybb änjq uheggs pyfxbntkmyj gjds-cbkb ifycs yf ecgtö d jåtcgtxtybb äaatrnbdyj-uj b nhfycgfhtynyjuj ujcelfhcndtyyjuj abyfycb-hjdfybz caths jåhfpjdfybz.

Ghtlcnfdbntkm åfpbheñotqcz d CIF ghjuhfvvsuhfélfycrjuj djcgbnfybz CBDBNFC Leukfc Äåythnfrét cxbnftn, xnj HURDJ csuhfkf gjktpyeñ hjkm,

Lhfufy Xjdbx, jlby bp nhtöxktyjd gjkbänybxtcrjuj

ghtpblbevf cnhfys, ghbdtn-cndetn cneltynjd yf ajhevtgj djghjcfv jåhfpjdfybz,

jhufybpjdfyyjv JÅCT d Cfhftdj d yjzåht

2003 ujlf. Dscnegfz gthtl 400 exfcnybrfvb änjq

dcnhtxb, jy pfzdbk, xnj ÅbUljkéyf vjlthybpbhjdfnm

cdjñ jåhfpjdfntkmyeñ cbcntve hflb åkfujgjkexbz b

åkfujcjcnjzybz uhfélfy.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 12: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

12 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

gjpdjkbd ≤pflfnm dthyjt yfghfdktybt d njv, xnj rfcftncz jcyjd-ysö yjhv≥. Pfckeue uheggs jy dblbn d njv, xnj jyf, jåkflfz≤tlbysv, fdnjhbntnysv ujkjcjv≥, gjvjukf pfjcnhbnm dybvfybtyf ghjåktvfö jåhfpjdfybz b yt gjpdjkbkf herjdjlcnde ÅbUjåjqnb djghjc j ghjdtltybb htajhv.

≤HURDJ dsldbyekf ntve jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU yf gthtlybq gkfyb jåtcgtxbdftn gjkbnbxtcreñ gjllthére, ytjåöjlbveñ lkzghbyznbz pfrjyjd jå jåhfpjdfybb, – ujdjhbn cgtwbfkmysqghtlcnfdbntkm Cjdtnf Tdhjgs d ÅbU Cjyz Vjpth-Cnfhhfö.

Zdkzzcm dtleobv exhtéltybtv gj hfphfåjnrt pfrjyjlfntkmcn-df jå jåhfpjdfybb d ÅbU, Cjdtn Tdhjgs yfåkñlfk pf ghjwtccjv,bnjujv rjnjhjuj d bñyt 2003 ujlf cnfkj tlbyjukfcyjt ghbyznbtgfhkfvtynjv jåotujcelfhcndtyyjuj Hfvjxyjuj pfrjyf j yfxfkm-yjv b chtlytv jåhfpjdfybb, cgjcjåcndeñotuj ghjldbétybñcnhfys gj genb cåkbétybz c Tdhjgjq. Ctqxfc yf gjdtcnrt lyzgfhkfvtynf ghjtrn jåotujcelfhcndtyyjuj hfvjxyjuj pfrjyf jdscitv jåhfpjdfybb, ghbyznbñ rjnjhjuj, gj hfcxtnfv CjdtnfTdhjgs, åeltn cgjcjåcndjdfnm gjkbnbxtcrbq dtc HURDJ.

Jlyfrj xktys HRUDJ tot yt crjhj cvjuen gjxbdfnm yf kfd-hfö. Lfkmytqifz ltgjkbnbpfwbz jåcnfyjdrb d catht jåhfpjdf-ybz, hfdyj rfr b jåtcgtxtybt dscjrjuj rfxtcndf ghtgjlfdfybz b äaatrnbdyjcnb extåyjuj ghjwtccf d irjkfö gj dctq cnhfyt,åelen b dghtlm nhtåjdfnm ytkturjq b egjhyjq hfåjns. Chtlbvyjétcndf ytjnkjéysö pflfx ÅbU – cjplfybt rjvbccbb gj gjlujnjdrt extåybrjd b ecnhfytybt cbnefwbb ≤ldt irjks gjljlyjq rhsitq≥, lj cbö gjh ceotcndeñotq d 52 extåysö pfdtlt-ybzö, ult extybrjd d cntyfö jlyjuj b njuj ét irjkmyjuj plfybzhfpltkzñn gj änybxtcrjve b htkbubjpyjve ghbpyfre.

Gjrf xktys HURDJ pfybvfñncz hfcxbcnrjq vyjétcndf ght-gzncndbq, ghtuhfélfñobö genm htajhvt jåhfpjdfybz, bö jå-obq rjjhlbyfnjh – Vbccbz JÅCT d ÅbU – ghjljkéftn cktlbnmpf ltzntkmyjcnmñ rféljq bp jhufybpfwbq b jrfpsdfnm bv ytjå-öjlbveñ gjvjom, c ntv xnjås gjcnfdktyyfz uheggjq wtkm gtht-cnhjqrb dctö pdtymtd jåhfpjdfntkmyjq cbcntvs cvjukf cnfnm htfkmyjcnmñ.

Vtlktyyj, yj dthyj gjkbnbxtcrbt ltzntkb enhfxbdfñn djp-vjéyjcnm bcgjkmpjdfnm cbcntve jåhfpjdfybz gj ghbywbge ≤hfp-ltkzq b dkfcndeq≥. Hjlbntkb, djcgbnfntkb b exbntkz åthen byb-wbfnbde d cdjb herb, ujnjdz ñysö uhfélfy cnhfys r njve, xnjåsibht jnrhsnm gthtl cjåjq ldthb d jrheéfñobq vbh.

Rhfnrbt cdtltybz j Åjcybb

Äkmvbhf Åfqhfckb – ghtcc-ctrhtnfhm Vbccbb JÅCT d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Gjckt hfcgflf Cjwbfkbcnbxtcrjq Atlthfnbdyjq Htcgeåkbrb Ñujckfdbb bghjdjpukfitybz ytpfdbcbvjcnb döjlbdibvb d tt cjcnfd htcgeåkbrfvb d Åjc-ybb b Uthwtujdbyt (ÅbU) yfxfkcz jétcnjxtyysq rjyakbrn, ghjljkéfdibqcz c 1992 gj 1995 ujl. Cjukfcyj jwtyrfv, djqyf eytckf ébpyb 250 000 xtkjdtr b pfcnfdbkf gjxnb gjkjdbye xtnshtövbkkbjyyjuj yfctktybz cnhfys gjrbyenmhjlyst vtcnf.

Djtyyst ltqcndbz ghtrhfnbkbcm d ltrfåht 1995 ujlf gjckt gjlgbcfybz Jåotuj hfvjxyjuj cjukfitybz j vbht (bpdtcnyjuj nfrét rfr Ltqnjycrbt/Gfhbécrbt vbhyst ljujdjhtyyjcnb).

Ctqxfc d cjcnfd Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbys döjlzn ldf ujcelfhcndtyysö jåhfpj-dfybz:

– Htcgeåkbrf Cthåcrfz (HC), cjcnjzofz bp 61 veybwbgfkmyjuj jrheuf;

– Atlthfwbz ÅbU, bvtñofz tot jlby ghjvtéenjxysq ehjdtym flvbybcnhf-nbdyj-nthhbnjhbfkmyjuj ltktybz b cjcnjzofz bp 10 rfynjyjd b 81 veybwb-gfkmyjuj jrheuf.

Jåhfpjdfy nfrét jnltkmysq jrheu Åhxrj, eghfdktybt rjnjhsv jceotcndkz-tncz gjl vtéleyfhjlysv rjynhjktv.

D cjcnfd jåotujcelfhcndtyyjuj ghfdbntkmcndf ÅbU döjlzn:

– gfhkfvtyncrfz fccfvåktz, cjcnjzofz bp Gfkfns ghtlcnfdbntktq b Gfkfnsyfhjljd;

– ltqcndeñobq yf jcyjdt hjnfwbb nhtöcnjhjyybq ghtpblbev, rfélsq xktyrjnjhjuj ghtlcnfdkztn jlby bp yfhjljd cnhfys – åjcyzrjd, öjhdfn b cthåjd;b

– Cjdtn vbybcnhjd, cjcnjzobq bp ghtlctlfntkz b ltdznb xktyjd.

Chfpe gjckt djqys gj dctq nthhbnjhbb ÅbU åskb hfpdthyens vbhjndjhxtcrbtcbks YFNJ xbcktyyjcnmñ 60 000 xtkjdtr. Gjcntgtyyj bö xbcktyyjcnm cjrhf-nbkfcm lj ghbvthyj 12 000, xnj cdbltntkmcndetn jå ekexitybb jåcnfyjdrb dcatht åtpjgfcyjcnb.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 13: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 13

AFKMR GBYUTKM

≤Gjybvftnt kb ds, rfrjt ghtcnegktybt

cjdthibkb? Dybp gj htrt Lhbyt gkskb

nhegs ytdbyysö éthnd≥.

Geufñobt ckjdf dhjlt änbö, ghbpdfyystpfcnfdbnm xbnfntkz dyjdm c uytdjv b uj-htxmñ dcgjvybnm j djqyt 1992–1995 uj-ljd d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt, ybrjuj yt

elbdbkb ås, åelm jyb jgeåkbrjdfys d jlyjq bpvyjétcndf rybu j pkjltzybzö ntö ktn.

Yj änf ghjdjrfwbjyyfz ahfpf – yt xnj byjt,rfr xfcnm uhfvvfnbxtcrjuj eghféytybz lkz yf-xfkmyjq irjks, gj rjnjhjve irjkmybrb d Cfhft-dj ljkéys åskb exbnmcz jghtltkznm hjlbntkm-ysq b dbybntkmysq gfltéb. D cnhfyt, ult gjjlybv b ntv ét extåybrfv xfcnj exfncz ltnbnhtö djtdfdibö vtéle cjåjq änybxtcrbö uhegg,nfrbt yfgjvbyfybz cgjcjåys gjctznm dtcmvf jcnheñ dhféle b d rkfccfö, b pf cntyfvb irjk.

Ghjwbnbhjdfyysq gfccfé, gjlhfpevtdfñobqjceéltybt jlybvb åjcybqwfvb lheubö, ckeébnghbvthjv njuj, rfr gjkbnbrf nhtö ukfdysö änyb-xtcrbö uhegg ghjgbnsdfkf cjåjq cbcntve jåhfpj-dfybz, pfnhelyzz cjdvtcnyjt jåextybt ltntq hfpysö yfwbjyfkmyjcntq. Cjlthéfybt irjkmysöextåybrjd cnfkj ntvjq lbcreccbb d jåotcndt,hfpdthyeditqcz d 1998 ujle gjckt njuj, rfr d cfhftdcrjq ufptnt ≤Jckjåjlétybt≥ gjzdbkfcm cnfnmz gjl pfujkjdrjv: ≤Uhfvvfnbrf gbitn bcnjhbñ?≥

C änjq ytkturjq cbnefwbtq vyt ghbikjcmcnjkryenmcz, rjulf d zydfht 2003 ujlf z cnfk lbhtrnjhjv ltgfhnfvtynf jåhfpjdfybz VbccbbJÅCT d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt. Jlyjq bp vjbö

gthdsö pflfx åskj exfcnbt d njkmrj xnj cjplfy-yjq rjvbccbb gj gthtcvjnhe irjkmysö extåyb-rjd b elfktybñ bp ybö dhtlysö b ytevtcnysövfnthbfkjd. Pflfxf åskf yt bp kturbö: ytkmpz åskj ghjgecnbnm ybxtuj, xnj gjntywbfkmyj vjukj jcrjhåbnm xedcndf kñåjq bp nhtö jcyjdysöänybxtcrbö uhegg cnhfys – åjcyzrjd-vecekmvfy,ghfdjckfdysö cthåjd b rfnjkbrjd-öjhdfn.

Cdjq abyfycjdsq drkfl d htfkbpfwbñ ghjtrnfdytckb Vbccbz JÅCT, Cjdtn Tdhjgs b vtcnystdkfcnb. D pfctlfybzö, yf rjnjhsö ghjdjlbkcz jåvty htpekmnfnfvb fyfkbpf b htifkjcm, rfrbtgfccféb ljkéys åsnm bpüzns, ghbybvfkb exfc-nbt 24 cgtwbfkbcnf gj irjkmysv extåysv gjcj-åbzv bp Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbys. Vbccbz b Cjdtnjrfpsdfkb bv gjllthére, ghbdktrfz fdnjhbntn-ysö rjkktu bp lheubö cnhfy lkz rjycekmnfwbq jnjv, rfr jcdtofnm cgjhyst ntvs d extåybrfö gjbcnjhbb b jåtcgtxbdfnm åjktt cåfkfycbhjdfyysqgjlöjl r hfpkbxysv änybxtcrbv uheggfv.

Rjvbccbz hfccvjnhtkf b ghjfyfkbpbhjdfkfextåybrb, gjlujnjdktyyst r 2003/2004 extåyjveujle. Nofntkmyjve bpextybñ gjldthukjcm rféljtbp åjktt xtv 250 eét bplfyysö bkb gjlujnjdkty-ysö r gtxfnb gjcjåbq gj zpsre b kbnthfneht, bcnjhbb b utjuhfabb, ghbhjljdtltybñ b jåotcn-djdtltybñ, f nfrét htkbubb. Gjlujnjdrf dct-jåütvkñobö ghtlkjétybq lkz vbybcnthcnd jåhfpjdfybz b cjjndtncndeñobö bplfntkmcnd jnyjcbntkmyj gthtcvjnhf extåybrjd – rjnjhstytjåöjlbvj åskj tot ecgtnm yfgtxfnfnm b hfc-ghjcnhfybnm r yfxfke extåyjuj ujlf – nhtåjdfkfjuhjvyjq hfåjns. Yj tlbyjleiyfz wtktecnhtv-ktyyjcnm xktyjd rjvbccbb ckeébkf jåyfltéb-dfñobv ljrfpfntkmcndjv njuj, xnj pf ltkj dpz-kbcm cthmtpyj.

Ghjwtcc åsk gjlxfc åjktpytyysv lkz åjcybq-wtd, rjnjhst ljkéys åskb jcjpyfnm, rfr bö vb-

YTQNHFKMYSQ GJCHTLYBR

≤Uhfvvfnbrf gbitn bcnjhbñ?≥Extåybrb b ébpym d ÅbU

Extåybr – yt ghjcnj cåjhybr afrnjd; jy jnhféftn yjhvs b wty-yjcnb, rjnjhst jåotcndj (bkb tuj ljvbybheñofz xfcnm) öjxtn gthtlfnm yjdjve gjrjktybñ. D gjcnrjyakbrnysö cbnefwbzö, gjljåysö njq, rjnjhfz ceotcndetn d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt, extå-ybrb njét vjuen ghjdjwbhjdfnm vtérekmnehyst cnjkryjdtybz b ghjnbdjhtxbz. Rfr gjlcnegbnmcz r cjplfybñ fnvjcaths ljdt-hbz vtéle kñlmvb, ghblthébdfñobvbcz hfpysö njxtr phtybz, b jåtcgtxbnm cdjåjlyeñ lbcreccbñ j cjlthéfybb extåybrjd? Jgbhfzcm yf gjvjom vtcnysö b vtéleyfhjlysö cgtwbfkbcnjd,JÅCT cnhtvbncz dscnegfnm d hjkb ytqnhfkmyjuj gjchtlybrf dirjkmyjq felbnjhbb.

Änf nhtnmtrehcybwf cfhftdcrjq ubvyfpbb exbncz

gj extåybrfv, rjnjhst ecbkbzvb cgtwbfkmyjq

rjvbccbb åskb jxbotys jnytevtcnysö gfccfétq.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 14: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

14 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

hjdjpphtybt vjétn ghtkjvkznmcz d cjpyfybb lheubö. Vs yt hfp ghbpsdfkb xktyjd rjvbccbbdjjåhfpbnm, xnj xedcndjdfkb ås bö cjåcndtyystltnb yf vtcnt ltntq lheubö änybxtcrbö uhegg. Rfrjdj bv åskj ås exbnmcz gj rybufv, cjlthéf-obv jcrjhåbntkmyst yfgflrb yf bö yfhjl? Yfyfibö ukfpfö e kñltq yfxbyfkj ghjzdkznmcz bcrhtyytt cnhtvktybt gjcnfdbnm bynthtcs dscj-rjrfxtcndtyyjuj jåextybz dsit gjkbnbxtcrböghbcnhfcnbq.

Jlby bp cfvsö nhelysö vjvtynjd åsk cdzpfy c extåybrjv, yf jåkjért rjnjhjuj åskf bpjåhf-étyf pyfvtybnfz åbndf yf Rjcjdjv gjkt – ägbpjlrjyakbrnf, eét 500 ktn zdkzñotujcz cbvdjkjvyfwbjyfkmyjq ujhljcnb cthåjd. D nj ét dhtvz eghtlcnfdbntktq lheubö änybxtcrbö uhegg åsditqÑujckfdbb bcgjkmpjdfybt änjq bkkñcnhfwbbvjukj dspdfnm ghjnbdjhtxbdst xedcndf.

D bnjut cthås, döjlbdibt d cjcnfd rjvbccbb,cjukfcbkbcm, xnj nfrjq rfhnbyt yt vtcnj d irjkmyjv extåybrt. Ghbxbys änjuj bv gjnjvghbikjcm jåüzcyznm cdjtve gjkbnbxtcrjve herjdjlcnde. Ujnjdyjcnm r rjvghjvbcce gj cnjkm ävjwbjyfkmyj yfcsotyyjve gjdjle åskf,ytcjvytyyj, veétcndtyysv ifujv c bö cnjhjys.

Yf bcöjlt ktnf gjljikf r rjywe b hfåjnf rj-vbccbb. Nj, xnj tq elfkjcm cltkfnm dctuj pf gfhevtczwtd, ghjbpdtkj yf vtyz ukeåjrjt dgtxfnktybt.Cdjt pfrkñxbntkmyjt pfctlfybt rjvbccbz ghjdtkfd uthwtujdbycrjv ujhjlt Vjcnfht yf ñuj-pfgfltÅbU. D njn gthbjl ujhjlcrfz nthhbnjhbz tot åskfhfpåbnf yf itcnm ctrnjhjd cjukfcyj ljujdjhty-yjcnb j hfpltkt dkfcnb – nfr, xnj åjkmibycndj d jlybö hfqjyfö ghbyflktéfkj åjcyzrfv, f d lheubö – öjhdfnfv. Ybult d cnhfyt änybxtcrfzhfpltktyyjcnm jåotcndf nfr yt åhjcfkfcm d ukfpf.

Dscnegfz yf gjcktlytv pfctlfybb rjvbccbb cjwtyrjq tt hfåjns, z dthyekcz r njve, c xtuj yf-xfkfcm dcz lbcreccbz, – r extåybrfv gj uhfvvfnb-rt. Vyt öjntkjcm yfltznmcz, xnj yfvb ljcnbuyenrjyctycec: ghbvths lkz uhfvvfnbxtcrbö eghfé-ytybq åjkmit ybrjulf yt åelen bvtnm ytevtcnyjqbltjkjubxtcrjq gjljgktrb. ≤Rfr ds cxbnftnt, –jåhfnbkcz z r ghbcencndeñobv, – ljkéyf kb yfif rjvbccbz b lfkmit rjynhjkbhjdfnm cjlth-éfybt gjcjåbq gj uhfvvfnbrt?≥ Jndtn åsk jlyj-pyfxysv: ≤R cjéfktybñ, lf≥.

Öjnz yf ghtlcnjzobq extåysq ujl ghjåktveelfkjcm htibnm, yfv jrfpfkjcm zdyj yt gj cbkfvufhfynbhjdfnm jåütrnbdyjcnm ghb cjcnfdktybb åeleobö uhfvvfnbxtcrbö gjcjåbq, yt ujdjhz eét jå extåybrfö bcnjhbb. Vjt eljdktndjhtybtljcnbuyensv jvhfxfkjcm vsckmñ j njv, rfr vyjuj tot jcnftncz ytcltkfyyjuj.

ERFPFYBZ LKZ FDNJHJD

Gthtcvjnh cjlthéfybz extåybrjd, åtpeckjdyj,ljrfpfk cgjcjåyjcnm uhfélfy ÅbU cjdvtcnyj ht-ifnm dtcmvf ghjnbdjhtxbdst djghjcs jåhfpjdf-ybz. Yj jy gjrfpfk b nj, xnj fyfkbp cjlthéfybzeét ujnjdsö extåybrjd b herjgbctq – yt cfvsqäaatrnbdysq gjlöjl r ltke. Vbccbz JÅCT jåhf-nbkfcm d jhufys jåhfpjdfybz c ghtlkjétybtv,xnjås d åeleotv rjvbccbz gj endthéltybñ extå-ysö gjcjåbq hfphfåjnfkf lkz fdnjhjd bycnher-wbb gj extne ghbywbgjd dctjåotuj ytlbcrhbvb-yfwbjyyjuj jåhfpjdfybz.

Extåybrb, jcyjdyjt dybvfybt d rjnjhsö cktle-tn eltkznm Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt, ljkéys cjlth-éfnm cåfkfycbhjdfyyeñ byajhvfwbñ jåj dctöuheggfö yfctktybz cnhfys b cjctlybö c ytq ujce-lfhcnd. Htrjvtylfwbb rjvbccbb ljkéys d jåzpf-ntkmyjv gjhzlrt exbnsdfnmcz ghb jabwbfkmyjvendthéltybb extåysö gjcjåbq, yj dcñ jndtncn-dtyyjcnm pf ghbujlyjcnm änbö gjcjåbq lkz irj-ks ljkéys ytcnb fdnjhs b jhufys jåhfpjdfybzÅbU. Ghb änjv rjvbccbb cktletn pfyznmcz d gth-deñ jxthtlm extåybrfvb gj bcnjhbb b utjuhf-abb, c ntv xnjås gjvjxm cltkfnm gjlöjl r ghtgj-lfdfybñ änbö ghtlvtnjd åjktt hfpyjcnjhjyybv b vyjujgkfyjdsv.

Öjnz ghjåktvf irjkmysö extåybrjd – kbimjlby bp vyjubö fcgtrnjd htajhvs jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU, dféyjcnm änjuj yfghfdktybz hfåjns djp-hfcnftn, tckb ghbyznm dj dybvfybt djpvjéyjcnmbcgjkmpjdfybz tt htpekmnfnjd d lheubö cnhfyföhtubjyf. Yfghbvth, Vbccbz JÅCT d Cthåbb bXthyjujhbb ctqxfc pfybvftncz fyfkbpjv b gtht-hfåjnrjq extåybrjd gj bcnjhbb lkz ghtlcnfdbnt-ktq fkåfycrjuj vtymibycndf. Vbccbz JJY gj ltkfv dhtvtyyjq flvbybcnhfwbb d Rjcjdj(VJJYR) yfghfdbkf yjdsq dfhbfyn extåybrf gj bcnjhbb lkz rjcjdcrbö irjk yf jnpsd d Uth-vfybñ, d Vtéleyfhjlysq yfexyj-bccktljdfntkmc-rbq bycnbnen extåysö gjcjåbq.

Levfñ, xnj yfit cjnhelybxtcndj c rjvbccbtqgj gjlujnjdrt extåybrjd zdkztncz ghbvthjv njuj,rfr JÅCT, ghtljcnfdkzz rjycekmnfwbb b gjvjomvtéleyfhjlysö ärcgthnjd, jrfpsdfz jhufybpfwb-jyyeñ b vfnthbfkmyeñ gjllthére, vjétn dyj-cbnm ceotcndtyysq drkfl d htajhve jåhfpjdfybz.

Åtpeckjdyj, jndtncndtyyjcnm pf ghbyznbt ytktu-rbö htitybq d rjytxyjv cxtnt ytcen vtcnystdkfcnb; jlyfrj d htubjyt, ult lfét ghbvths bc-gjkmpjdfybz dbybntkmyjuj gfltéf d jnkbxbt jnhjlbntkmyjuj gjhjq pfnhfubdfñn ukeåjrbt xedcn-df, exfcnbt ytqnhfkmyjq cnjhjys ltqcndbntkmyjvjétn gjvjxm kñlzv jndktxmcz jn gjkbnbrb b pfyznmcz gj-yfcnjzotve dféysv ltkjv: jåextyb-tv ltntq.

L-h Afkmr Gbyutkm djpukfdkzk ltgfhnfvtynjåhfpjdfybz Vbccbb JÅCT d ÅbU c zydfhz 2003gj zydfhm 2004 ujlf. Ctqxfc jy dyjdm pfyzkcdjq ghtéybq gjcn pfvtcnbntkz lbhtrnjhfVtéleyfhjlyjuj bccktlj-dfntkmcrjuj bycnbnenfextåysö gjcjåbq bvtybUtjhuf Ärthnf d Åhfey-idtqut (Uthvfybz), ulthfåjnftn eét 20 ktn, cgtwbfkbpbhezcm yf jcdt-otybb d extåybrfö ntvsöjkjrjcnf.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 15: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 15

ERHTGKTYBT LJDTHBZ

Gjkbnbrt yt vtcnj d irjkfö,cxbnftn åsdibqexbntkm b ltgenfn

RTDBY CFKKBDFY

Hexrb b ntnhflb eåhfys, hñrpfrb pfcntu-yens, jcnfkjcm hfcödfnfnm rehnrb – b yf djkñ. Dnjhjrkfccybrb irjks bvtyb Jc-vfyf Yfrfif (hfqjy Yjdb-Uhfl d cnjkbwt

Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbys Cfhftdj) c ytnthgtybtv ljéblfñncz pdjyrf, djpdtofñotuj jå jrjyxfybbpfyznbq.

Yj ghb dblt ytjéblfyyjq ujcnmb – htubjyfkm-yjuj rjjhlbyfnjhf Vbccbb JÅCT gj djghjcfv jåhfpjdfybz d Cfhftdj Qjheyy Öfutkth – d rkfc-ct åscnhj yfcnftn nbibyf.

≤D irjkfö åsdfnm jxtym dféyj: änj gjpdjkztngjyznm, xnj ltqcndbntkmyj ghjbcöjlbn yf pfyznb-zö≥, – ujdjhbn Qjheyy. Tq, dsyeéltyyjq ghjcb-ébdfnm ljkubt xfcs yf cjdtofybzö b vyjuj pfybvfnmcz flvbybcnhfnbdyjq hfåjnjq, dcnhtxbc htåznfvb yeéys b lkz njuj, xnjås gjlpfhz-lbnmcz cdtétq äythubtq.

Qjheyy pyftn, xnj ltnb d änjv rkfcct exfn fyukbqcrbq, b cfvf pflftn bv ghjcnjq djghjc:≤Xtuj dfv yt ödfnftn d irjkt?≥ D jndtn nzytnczktc her; vfktymrfz hecjdjkjcfz ltdjxrf edthtyyjjndtxftn: ≤Rjvgmñnthjd≥.

Ybxtuj elbdbntkmyjuj: gjxnb d gjkjdbyt bp2100 irjk cnhfys rjvgmñnthjd ytn djjåot, f bp ntö, xnj bvtñncz d lheubö irjkfö, gjkjdbyfyföjlbncz d ythfåjxtv cjcnjzybb.

Jlyfrj Qjheyy yt cjåbhftncz ljdjkmcndjdfnm-cz nfrbv ghjcnsv jndtnjv. Ghjhfåjnfd 25 ktnirjkmysv exbntktv e ctåz ljvf d Yjhdtubb, jyfghtrhfcyj pyftn, rfr dspdfnm htåzn yf hfpujdjh.Djghjcs cktleñn jlby pf lheubv: ≤F pfxtv dfvrjvgmñnths? Xnj ds åeltnt c ybvb ltkfnm? Rfrjyb gjvjuen dfv exbnmcz?≥ Nfrjq lbfkju nhtåetnjn extybrjd fyfkbnbxtcrjuj vsiktybz, f yt

ghjcnj vtöfybxtcrjuj pfgjvbyfybz, yf rjnjhjvjcyjdfyj jåextybt d åjkmibycndt irjk ÅbU.

≤Yeéyj evtnm bcgjkmpjdfnm ltncrjt kñåjgsn-cndj, – ujdjhbn Qjheyy. – Jyb ljkéys exbnmcz,cnfdz djghjcs b bof yf ybö jndtns. Exbntkm lj-kéty åsnm lkz ybö cjdtnxbrjv, gjvjufnm yfqnbjndtn cfvjcnjzntkmyj≥.

D Vbccbb JÅCT Qjheyy hfåjnftn c yjzåhz2000 ujlf, cyfxfkf d ljkéyjcnb cjnhelybrf gjltvjrhfnbpfwbb, f pfntv d ltgfhnfvtynt jåhfpj-dfybz. Lj ghbtplf d Cfhftdj jyf c 1993 gj 1997ujl åskf ltgenfnjv yjhdtécrjuj gfhkfvtynf. Nfrfz eybrfkmyfz rjvåbyfwbz jgsnf gjvjuftn tq, rfr ybrjve lheujve, dbltnm ghjåktvs htajh-vs jåhfpjdfybz d ÅbU jlyjdhtvtyyj c ytcrjkm-rbö cnjhjy.

Rfr exbntkm jyf ghtrhfcyj cjpyftn gkfxtdyjtcjcnjzybt åjkmibycndf irjk d Åjcybb b Uthwt-ujdbyt. Rkfccs gthtgjkytys; plfybz nhtåeñn htvjynf; exbntkz yt gjkexfñn pfhgkfns gj yt-crjkmrj vtczwtd gjlhzl; yt ödfnftn lfét cfvsöäktvtynfhysö irjkmysö ghbyflktéyjcntq; extåyfz ghjuhfvvf gthtuheétyf, f vtnjls ght-gjlfdfybz jncnfñn jn cjdhtvtyysö nhtåjdfybq.

Rfr åsdibq pfrjyjlfntkm jyf gjybvftn b nj,xnj gthdjghbxbyf vyjubö nhelyjcntq rhjtncz dgjkbnbrt.

CKJDF GHBDTNCNDBZ

D irjkfö ÅbU gjkbnbxtcrbq gjlntrcn vjétnghbcencndjdfnm gjdctvtcnyj, lfét d nfrbö ghj-cnsö dtofö, rfr gthdst ckjdf, c rjnjhsvb exb-ntkm jåhfoftncz r extybrfv d rkfcct. Ghbyznfzajhvf ghbdtncndbz – Djbfr dfn, xnj jpyfxftn≤Ljåhsq ltym≥. Yj d ytrjnjhsö irjkfö, ult yfgthtlybq gkfy dsldbufñncz gjkbnbrf b htkbubz,exbntkz gjhjq bcgjkmpeñn vecekmvfycrjt ghb-

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

≤Dcnhtxb c vjkjlsv gjrjktybtv pfhzéfñn yjdjq

äythubtq≥, – ujdjhbn Qjheyy Öfutkth.

Page 16: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

16 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

dtncndbt Salaamalaykum (gj-fhfåcrb– ≤Vbh dfv≥), cthå-crjt Gjvjé Åju (≤Lf

gjvjétn dfv Åju≥)bkb öjhdfncrjt Hvalj-en Isus (≤Öhfyb dfc

Bbcec≥).D htpekmnfnt ckjdf

ghbdtncndbz, wtkm rjnjhsö – cjplfnm e ltntq joeotybt,xnj d irjkt bv hfls,vjuen ghjbpdtcnbghjnbdjgjkjéyjtdgtxfnktybt yf ntö

bp ybö, rnj ghbyflktébn r lheubv rjyatccbzv. D irjkt bvtyb Jcvfyf Yfrfif, yfghbvth, exbncz750 xtkjdtr; åjkmibycndj bp ybö åjcyzrb, yjtcnm b öjhdfns, b cthås, b lfét wsufyt.

Exbnsdfz cnjkm hfpyjjåhfpysq cjcnfd exfobö-cz, lbhtrnjh irjks Chtxrj Étrbx cxtk dféysvghjdtcnb c exbntkzvb åtctle jå bcgjkmpjdfybbhtkbubjpyj ytqnhfkmysö ghbdtncndbq. Lfét änjn ghjcntqibq ifu åsk cdzpfy lkz ytuj c hbcrjv gjnthznm hfåjne, nfr rfr ghtåsdfybt yflbhtrnjhcrjv gjcne pfdbcbn jn htitybq, ghbyb-vftvsö ghtlcnfdbntkzvb vtcnysö gjkbnbxtcrböcbk.

≤Lbhtrnjh cxbnftn, xnj kñlb åjzncz jnrhsnjcgjhbnm c gjkbnbxtcrbvb kblthfvb, – ujdjhbnQjheyy. – Gjkbnbrb gsnfkbcm eåtlbnm tuj, xnj irjkf ljkéyf åsnm änybxtcrb jlyjhjlyjq,yj yflj jnlfnm tve ljkéyjt: gjrf jy ndthlj cjghjnbdkztncz änjve yfébve≥.

DYTIRJKMYFZ GHJUHFVVF

Ghbdtncndbz c htkbubjpysv jnntyrjv – kbimjlyf bp vyjubö ghjåktv, rjnjhst nhtåeñn htit-ybz tot b gjnjve, xnj jndktrfñn dybvfybt jnlheubö yfceoysö pflfx. D änbö eckjdbzö nhelyjåsdftn ljåbnmcz xtuj-nj cthmtpyjuj yf nfrböexfcnrfö hfåjns, rfr cjcnfdktybt extåysö ghj-uhfvv b vtnjlbrf ghtgjlfdfybz.

C. Étrbx, yfghbvth, eét gsnfkcz dytlhbnm åjktt ghjuhtccbdyst vtnjls, yfghfdbd cdjböexbntktq yf rehcs gj jcdjtybñ cjdhtvtyysö,bynthfrnbdysö ajhv jåextybz, cnbvekbheñoböfrnbdyjcnm extybrjd b gjjohzñobö rhbnbxtcrjtvsiktybt c bö cnjhjys. Jlyfrj, ceotcndeñofzcbcntvf ecnhjtyf nfr, xnj irjks yt vjuen ybxt-uj ghtlghbyznm gj cjåcndtyyjq bybwbfnbdt, åtp cjukfcbz gjkbnbxtcrjuj herjdjlcndf. Rfynj-yfkmyjt vbybcnthcndj jåhfpjdfybz htibkj gjrf juhfybxbnm ghbvtytybt yjdjq vtnjlbrbldevz yfxfkmysvb rkfccfvb.

≤Jyb yt öjnzn ddjlbnm d irjkfö ≤dytirjkmyeñghjuhfvve≥, – gjébvftn gktxfvb C. Étrbx. Änj

vjéyj åskj ås cxtcnm hfpevysv, yj, – jåüzcyz-tn jy, – htxm-nj bltn djjåot yt j cjlthéfybbextåyjq ghjuhfvvs, f kbim j åjktt cjdhtvtyysövtnjlfö jåextybz. Lkz gjkbnbrjd ét dct xfcnjcdjlbncz r ghjåktvt rjynhjkz.

≤Herjdjlbntktq cnhfys bynthtceñn d jcyjdyjvänybxtcrbt b rekmnehyst fcgtrns, – hfcceélftnQjheyy. – Vyjubt ghtgjlfdfntkb b lbhtrnjhfirjk öjntkb ås ghjdjlbnm htfkmyst htajhvs,yj bv vtiftn gjkbnbxtcrfz ghjwtlehf≥.

Änf ghjwtlehf ltqcndbntkmyj åsdftn dtcmvfckjéyjq. Nfr, gjckt ghbyznbz pfrjyf jå jåhfpj-dfybb cjjndtncndeñott vbybcnthcndj ljkéyjbplfnm yf tuj jcyjdt bycnherwbb lkz irjk. Änj jpyfxftn, xnj lfét tckb vjlthybpfwbz ght-lecvjnhtyf pfrjyjv, d irjkfö tt ghjdjlbnm ytkmpz lj ntö gjh, gjrf yf änj yt lfcn ljåhj ytgjchtlcndtyyjt yfxfkmcndj. Lf b cfvb vbybc-nhs yt dctulf gjlgbcsdfñn ytjåöjlbvst hfcgj-hzétybz, tckb jyb yt cjukfcjdfys c gfhnbqysvherjdjlcndjv.

Dljåfdjr rj dctve irjks cnhflfñn jn gjcnj-zyyjuj ltabwbnf htcehcjd. Gj lfyysv, gjkexty-ysv Vbccbtq JÅCT jn lbhtrnjhjd irjk, jrjkj400 irjkmysö plfybq kbitys yflktéfotujjnjgktybz, åjktt xtv d 750 jncencndeñn abprekm-nehyst pfks, ghbvthyj 500 yt bvtñn åbåkbjntr,f d 600 irjkfö ytn yb jlyjuj ntktajyf.

GHFRNBRF LTVJRHFNBB

Qjheyy eåtéltyf, xnj cfv gjlöjl r jåhfpjdf-ybñ d ÅbU ljkéty d rjhyt bpvtybnmcz. Öjnz yfpfyznbzö exfn ltvjrhfnbb, ltvjrhfnbxtcrbtghbywbgs yt yföjlzn cbcntvfnbxtcrjuj djgkj-otybz d ébpyb irjkmybrjd b cneltynjd. Dj vyjubö ckexfzö extybrb ghjcnj åjzncz exbntktq,f d rkfcct yt ghbyznj pflfdfnm djghjcs. Gjvjxmbpvtybnm änjn yfcnhjq vjuen cjdtns exfoböcz,cjplfdftvst ctqxfc gj dctq cnhfyt. Tckb e htåznåeltn cjåcndtyysq ujkjc, nj jyb, djpvjéyj, cnfyen frnbdytt b yf ehjrfö.

Htfkmyfz yfltélf yf gthtvtys cdzpfyf c nfrbvb kñlmvb, rfr lbhtrnjh C. Étrbx. D cdjtqirjkt jy hfåjnftn eét 32 ujlf b pfhtrjvtyljdfkctåz ndthlsv ghbdthétywtv cghfdtlkbdjuj, jn-rhsnjuj b cjdhtvtyyjuj gjlöjlf r jåextybñ. Gjcktljdfnm änjve ghbvthe jy ghbpsdftn b lbhtrnjhjd lheubö irjk, f d gjcktlytt dhtvz ythtlrj gjdnjhztn kñåbveñ ajhvekbhjdre ghtlcnfdbntktq vtéleyfhjlyjuj cjjåotcndf:≤Öjnbnt ds åsnm xfcnmñ Tdhjgs bkb ytn?≥.

Gj ckjdfv Qjheyy, gthtvty öjnzn dct, rnj pfbynthtcjdfy d ekexitybb ceotcndeñotq cbcntvs – extybrb, bö hjlbntkb b irjkmyfz flvbybcnhfwbz. ≤Jyb c ytnthgtybtv jéblfñnhtajhv. Bv öjxtncz, xnjås gjkjétybt bpvtyb-kjcm. B änj cfvfz åjkmifz vjhfkmyfz gjllthérfd kñåjq hfåjnt≥.

Htajhvf jåhfpjdfybz d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt

Page 17: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 17

Vböfbk Tdcnfamtd: C rfrbvb ghjåktvfvb Ds cnjkrye-kbcm, rjulf gjxnb nhb ujlf yfpfl ghbtöfkb d Dtye?Gjcjk Fktrcttd: Änj åskj ljdjkmyj nhelyjt dht-vz lkz JÅCT. Yf cjcnjzditqcz d Dtyt d ltrfåht2000 ujlf dcnhtxt Cjdtnf vbybcnhjd ghjzdbkczwtksq hzl rhbpbcysö ntyltywbq b gthtrjcjd dJhufybpfwbb. Gjnhtåjdfkjcm ghbkjébnm ytvfkjecbkbq, xnjås dsdtcnb JÅCT bp änjuj jgfcyjujnegbrf b dthyenm tt yf cnjkåjdjq ≤ötkmcbyrcrbq≥genm.

D cfvjv ltkt, vs ljkéys åsnm åkfujlfhys hevsycrjve Ghtlctlfntkmcnde 2001 ujlf pf nj,xnj jyj ghjzdbkj veétcndj b htibvjcnm, yfxfdghjwtcc ghtlvtnyjuj fyfkbpf ytljcnfnrjd Jhuf-ybpfwbb b hfphfåjnrb ghjuhfvvs ltqcndbq,drkñxfz ghjdtltybt htajhvs, ghbpdfyyjq jåtc-gtxbnm cjöhfytybt b dghtlm frnefkmyjcnb JÅCT d vtyzñotqcz gjkbnbxtcrjq jåcnfyjdrt.

Ytn ytjåöjlbvjcnb ujdjhbnm, xnj cjåsnbz 11 ctynzåhz 2001 ujlf cnfkb gjdjhjnysv vjvty-njv d hfpdbnbb JÅCT – nhtdjéysv cbuyfkjv, pfcnfdbdibv yfc jcjpyfnm, xnj d bynthtcfö äaatrnbdyjq åjhmås c yjdsvb euhjpfvb b jgfc-yjcnzvb, jcjåtyyj c nthhjhbpvjv, vs ljkéysjcnfdbnm yfib hfpyjukfcbz d cnjhjyt b pfyznmczhtfkmysv ltkjv.

Rfr Ds jwtybdftnt jnyjitybz vtéle JÅCT b Hjccbqcrjq Atlthfwbtq, jcjåtyyj d gthbjl gjcktCnfvåekmcrjuj cfvvbnf 1999 ujlf?

Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz dctulf åskf htibntkm-ysv gjåjhybrjv ltkf JÅCT. Hjccbz cxbnftn JÅCTjlyjq bp dféytqibö jgjh yjdjq jåottdhjgtq-crjq fhöbntrnehs åtpjgfcyjcnb, ghtlecvfnhbdfñ-otq tlbyst lkz dctö ujcelfhcnd wtyyjcnb b yjh-vs gjdtltybz.

Cnfvåekmcrfz dcnhtxf JÅCT yf dscitv ehjdytcsuhfkf dféyeñ hjkm d bcnjhbb Jhufybpfwbbåkfujlfhz ghbyznbñ yf ytq Öfhnbb tdhjgtqcrjqåtpjgfcyjcnb, d rjnjhjq pfabrcbhjdfy rjvgktrcghbywbgjd b jåzpfntkmcnd, rfcfñoböcz hfdyjg-hfdyjuj cjnhelybxtcndf vtéle ujcelfhcndfvb –exfcnybrfvb JÅCT. D Cnfvåekt vs dct ljujdjhb-kbcm hfccvfnhbdfnm änb ljåhjdjkmyst jåzpfntkm-cndf rfr cjcnfdkzñobt tlbysq ≤gfrtn≥, yt ltkzbö yf åjktt dféyst b vtytt dféyst.

R cjéfktybñ, chfpe gjckt Cnfvåekmcrjuj cfvvbnf e ytrjnjhsö cnjhjy yfcnegbkf zdyfz fvytpbz d jnyjitybb änjuj rkñxtdjuj ghbywbgf,b jyb cnfkb dsltkznm bp jåotuj hzlf jnltkmystjåzpfntkmcndf jnltkmysö cnhfy, cjdthityyj pfåsdfz ghb änjv j cjåcndtyysö jåzpfntkmcndfö.Änf ghfrnbrf ldjqysö cnfylfhnjd ytufnbdyj crf-pfkfcm yf fdnjhbntnt JÅCT b lj cbö gjh ghjljk-éftn gjlhsdfnm tt ltvjrhfnbxtcrbt jcyjds b åtcghbcnhfcnysq öfhfrnth.

Djgbñobv ghbvthjv änjuj zdkztncz gjkjétybtheccrjzpsxyjuj yfctktybz d Kfndbb b Äcnjybb.Crfée åtp jåbyzrjd: d wtynht Tdhjgs cjnyb ns-czx kñltq kbitys äktvtynfhysö xtkjdtxtcrböghfd – ghfdf yf uhfélfycndj, bpåbhfntkmysö

GJCNJZYYSQ CJDTN

HjccbqcrfzAtlthfwbz –≤htibntkmysqgjåjhybr≥ ltkfJÅCT

Gj ckjdfv Fktrcfylhf Ñhmtdbxf Fktrcttdf, ukfds ltktuf-

wbb Hjccbqcrjq Atlthfwbb d JÅCT c fduecnf 2001 gj yfxf-

kj 2004 ujlf, Jhufybpfwbz zdkztncz ≤jlyjq bp dféytqibö

jgjh yjdjq jåottdhjgtqcrjq fhöbntrnehs åtpjgfcyjcnb≥.

Jlyfrj d bynthdmñ, lfyyjv bv cjnhelybre JÅCT gj djghj-

cfv ghtccs Vböfbke Tdcnfamtde, 58-ktnybq lbgkjvfn ght-

leghtélftn jå jgfcyjcnb njuj, xnj ≤jxtdblyst cnhernehyst

bpüzys≥ vjuen gjljhdfnm fdnjhbntn JÅCT. Cnfvåekmcrbt

jåzpfntkmcndf Hjccbb, cbnefwbz d Xtxyt, ghbywbg rjycty-

cecf d JÅCT b hjkm vbccbq yf vtcnfö – djn kbim ytrjnjhst

bp ibhjrjuj rheuf djghjcjd, yf rjnjhsö jcnfyjdbkcz gj-

cjk, gjldjlz bnjub cdjtuj ghtåsdfybz d Dtyt.

CT

/KÑ

ÅJ

VB

H R

JN

TR

Page 18: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

18 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

ghfd, ghfdf lfnm cdjbv ltnzv jåhfpjdfybt yf hjl-yjv zpsrt b n.l. F JÅCT ghfrnbxtcrb buyjhbhetnäne fyjvfkmyeñ cbnefwbñ, euhjéfñoeñ åtpjgfc-yjcnb b cnfåbkmyjcnb d Tdhjgt.

Ctqxfc vyjuj ujdjhbncz j cnfvåekmcrbö jåzpf-ntkmcndfö Hjccbb. Rfrjd Dfi dpukzl yf änj?

Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz ljrfpfkf cthmtpyjcnmcdjtuj gjlöjlf r cjåkñltybñ cnfvåekmcrbö jåz-pfntkmcnd, pfrhtgktyysö rfr d Öfhnbb, nfr b dCnfvåekmcrjq ltrkfhfwbb. Hjccbz dsgjkybkf –yfvyjuj hfymit chjrf – dct cjjndtncndeñobtjåzpfntkmcndf, dpznst tñ yf ctåz d rjyntrcntflfgnbhjdfyyjuj Ljujdjhf jå jåsxysö djjhe-étyysö cbkfö d Tdhjgt (LJDCT). Ghjuhtcc, ljcnbuyensq d jceotcndktybb frnefkmysö cjukf-itybq b jåzpfntkmcnd, d njv xbckt rfcfñoböczUhepbb b Vjkljds, åsk gjlndthélty yf dcnhtxföCjdtnf vbybcnhjd d Åeöfhtcnt (2001 u.) b d Gjhne (2002 u.).

Ceotcndetn htfkmyfz djpvjéyjcnm njuj, xnj,ghb yfkbxbb gjkbnbxtcrjq djkb dctö pfbynthtcj-dfyysö cnjhjy, lfyysq djghjc åeltn hfphtity,tckb, rjytxyj, lkz änjuj åelen jåtcgtxtys dct ytjåöjlbvst eckjdbz. D nj ét dhtvz vs öjntkbås yfcnjzntkmyj ghbpdfnm b lheubt cnhfys JÅCTghjzdbnm cnjkm ét rjycnhernbdysq gjlöjl b dsgjkybnm – yf cghfdtlkbdjq b ytdsåjhjxyjqjcyjdt – cjåcndtyyst jåzpfntkmcndf, rjnjhst jyb ghbyzkb d Cnfvåekt.

Rfrjdj Dfit jnyjitybt r pfrhsnbñ vbccbq JÅCT d Äcnjybb b Kfndbb b r gjcktleñotq hfåjnt d änbö cnhfyfö Dthöjdyjuj rjvbccfhf JÅCT gj ltkfv yfwbjyfkmysö vtymibycnd?

Rjulf ltkj ikj r pfrhsnbñ änbö ldeö vbccbq, z yfcnjzntkmyj ghbpsdfk Jhufybpfwbñ yt cjdth-ifnm jibårb, rjnjhfz vjukf gjljhdfnm ljdthbt r JÅCT b gthcgtrnbds tt ltzntkmyjcnb yf vtcnfö.Ybrjbv jåhfpjv yt htityyjq jcnfdfkfcm ghjåkt-vf vfccjdjuj åtpuhfélfycndf b lbcrhbvbyfwbbheccrjzpsxyjuj yfctktybz Kfndbb b Äcnjybb.

Pf ldf ujlf, ghjitlibt gjckt pfrhsnbz vbccbq,gjkjétybt heccrjzpsxyjuj vtymibycndf yt ekex-ibkjcm, f crjhtt eöelibkjcm. Cnfkj jxtdblyj,xnj ecbkbq Dthöjdyjuj rjvbccfhf JÅCT gj ltkfvyfwbjyfkmysö vtymibycnd jrfpfkjcm ytljcnfnjx-yj, xnjås pfcnfdbnm dkfcnb änbö ldeö cnhfy bpvt-ybnm cdjñ lbcrhbvbyfwbjyyeñ gjkbnbre.

Tckb JÅCT yt ghblfcn änjve djghjce ghbjhb-ntnyjuj pyfxtybz b yt yfxytn ltqcndjdfnm cnjkmét htibntkmyj, rfr b lheubt vtéleyfhjlyst jhufybpfwbb, nj tt cgjcjåyjcnm hfåjnfnm d jåkfc-nb xtkjdtxtcrjuj bpvthtybz åtcghbcnhfcnyj b äaatrnbdyj åeltn gjcnfdktyf gjl cjvytybt.

Djpdhfofzcm r djghjce j ldjqysö cnfylfhnfö, yt vjukb ås Ds enjxybnm, d xtv, gj-dfitve, pfrkñ-xftncz ghjåktvf b xnj, yf Dfi dpukzl, cktljdfkj åscltkfnm byfxt?

Vs gjkfuftv, xnj d cdjtv ysytiytv dblt JÅCTyt jndtxftn ghjdjpukfityyjq tñ wtkb ckeébnm d rfxtcndt ltvjrhfnbxtcrjuj ajhevf lkz hfdyjg-

hfdyjuj lbfkjuf b cjnhelybxtcndf vtéle dctvb55 ujcelfhcndfvb-exfcnybrfvb. Jåüzcyñ gjxtve.

Dj-gthdsö, JÅCT enhfnbkf öfhfrnth jhufybpf-wbb, jcyjdfyyjq yf bylbdblefkmyjv xktycndt ujcelfhcnd. Dvtcnj njuj, xnjås ghtlcnfdkznm cj-åjq tlbyeñ ctvmñ, cjcnjzoeñ bp 55 hfdyjghfd-ysö ujcelfhcnd, jåütlbytyysö jåobvb wtkzvb bwtyyjcnzvb, jyf ctqxfc hfcrjkjnf yf hfpkbxyst≤ärcrkñpbdyst rkeås≥ cnhfy, ghtcktleñobö cjåcndtyyst gjkbnbxtcrbt wtkb b bynthtcs. Pfxfcneñ lbfkju gjlvtyztncz yfcnfdbntkmyj-vj-hfkbpfnjhcrbv gjlöjljv cj cnjhjys hzlf cnhfy,f hfdyjghfdyjt cjnhelybxtcndj ecnegftn vtcnjuheåjve gjkbnbxtcrjve yfébve.

Rfr bpdtcnyj, buhf åtp ghfdbk dsujlyf ntv, rnj cbkty, b ytdsujlyf ntv, rnj ckfå bkb yt eljc-njbkcz xtcnb ghbyflktéfnm r rfrbv-kbåj ärcrkñ-pbdysv uheggbhjdrfv. Tckb nfrjt gjkjétybt cjöhfybncz, änj vjétn ghbdtcnb r lfkmytqitvecybétybñ ljdthbz r JÅCT. Jncencndbt ecnfyjd-ktyysö ghfdbk b ghjwtleh – yfif nfr yfpsdft-vfz ≤ubårjcnm≥ – jnrhsdftn djpvjéyjcnb lkz ibhjrjuj bcgjkmpjdfybz ytrjnjhsvb uheggbhjd-rfvb bkb jnltkmysvb cnhfyfvb nfr yfpsdftvjuj≤flvbybcnhfnbdyjuj htcehcf≥, bkb ≤gjlrjdthyjqlbgkjvfnbb≥.

Cbnefwbz eceueåkztncz jncencndbtv ljkéyjqgjljnxtnyjcnb b nhfycgfhtynyjcnb d hfåjnt jcyjdysö bycnbnenjd b d jgthfwbzö yf vtcnfö.Cktlcndbtv änjuj zdkzñncz yfheitybz endth-éltyysö vfylfnjd b ythfwbjyfkmyjt bcgjkmpjdf-ybt abyfycjdsö b rflhjdsö htcehcjd. Jncencn-dbt ghfrnbrb xtcnysö rjycekmnfwbq rfr dyenhbJÅCT, nfr b vtéle JÅCT b ghbybvfñobvb ujce-lfhcndfvb ghbdtkj r eöelitybñ jnyjitybq vtéle ybvb, f d hzlt ckexftd b r dyenhtyytverhbpbce.

Änj kbim ytrjnjhst bp yfbåjktt jxtdblysöcnhernehysö bpüzyjd d JÅCT. Bö cgbcjr vjéyjghjljkéfnm åtcrjytxyj. Buyjhbhjdfybt änbö yt-ljcnfnrjd eét dspdfkj – b ghjljkéftn dspsdfnm– åjktt jgfcyst gjkbnbxtcrbt gjcktlcndbz, nf-rbt, rfr ntyltywbjpysq, gjkbnbpbhjdfyysq gjl-öjl, utjuhfabxtcrbt lbcåfkfycs b ltktybt cnhfyyf ≤hfdysö≥ b ≤åjktt hfdysö≥.

Cxbnftnt kb Ds, xnj JÅCT vjétn csuhfnm rjyc-nhernbdyeñ hjkm d ehtuekbhjdfybb rhbpbcf d Xtxyt,b tckb lf, nj rfrbv jåhfpjv?

Yf vjq dpukzl, nj, xnj ds yfpsdftnt ≤rhbpbcjv≥d Xtxyt, ltkj eét ghjikjt. Ctqxfc hjccbqcrbtatlthfkmyst dkfcnb b dkfcnb Xtxyb ghbkfufñn dhfvrfö ghjwtccf gjkbnbxtcrjuj ehtuekbhjdfybzdct cbks r njve, xnjås dthyenm ébpym d Xtxty-crjq Htcgeåkbrt d yjhvfkmyjt heckj dj dctö cathfö – gjkbnbxtcrjq, ärjyjvbxtcrjq b cjwb-fkmyjq.

Xnj ét rfcftncz njuj, vjétn kb JÅCT csuhfnmrjycnhernbdyeñ hjkm bkb jåtcgtxbnm rfreñ-kb-åj htfkmyeñ ≤ljåfdjxyeñ cnjbvjcnm≥ d gkfyt cjltqcndbz ntreotve ghjwtcce djccnfyjdktybz

Page 19: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 19

Xtxyb, nj e vtyz yf änjn cxtn tcnm cjvytybz. Gjcnfhfñcm jåüzcybnm.

Ghjwtcc gjkbnbxtcrjuj ehtuekbhjdfybz d Htc-geåkbrt yfghfdkty yf cjplfybt pfrjyyj bpåhfy-ysö jhufyjd dkfcnb. C änjq wtkmñ d 2003 ujle dXtxyt åskb ghjdtltys htathtylev gj rjycnbne-wbb b ghtpbltyncrbt dsåjhs. JÅCT åskf ghbukf-ityf yfåkñlfnm pf ghjdtltybtv änbö ldeö vthjg-hbznbq, gjcrjkmre vs cxbnfkb, xnj gjpbnbdyfzjwtyrf ghjwtccf ujkjcjdfybz cj cnjhjys JÅCTvjukf ås cnfnm rjycnhernbdysv drkfljv änjq Jhufybpfwbb d gjkbnbxtcrjt ehtuekbhjdfybt.

Jlyfrj Åñhj gj ltvjrhfnbxtcrbv bycnbnenfvb ghfdfv xtkjdtrf (ÅLBGX) ghtlgjxkj yt gjcs-kfnm cdjbö yfåkñlfntktq yf htathtylev, juhfyb-xbdibcm kbim yfghfdktybtv ytåjkmijq uheggsgj jwtyrt cbnefwbb, f yf ghtpbltyncrbt dsåjhsyt ghbckfkb b tt. Rjyrhtnysq ghtlkju, bcgjkmpj-dfdibqcz, xnjås yt gjcskfnm yfåkñlfntktq, ctqxfc eét yt cnjkm dféty, gjcrjkmre lheubt vtéleyfhjlyst jhufybpfwbb yfghfdbkb cdjböghtlcnfdbntktq d Htcgeåkbre b jwtybkb ghjitl-ibt d Xtxyt ghjwtccs djktbpüzdktybz yfhjlf rfr cdjåjlyst b ltvjrhfnbxtcrbt.

Dféyj nj, xnj pltcm yfkbwj zdyjt jncencndbt e JÅCT b ÅLBGX gjkbnbxtcrjq djkb buhfnm rjyc-nhernbdyeñ hjkm d Xtxyt. Wtkm, rjnjheñ ghtckt-ljdfkb Ghtlctlfntkmcndj JÅCT b ÅLBGX, pfyzdnfreñ gjpbwbñ, jxtdblyf: åhjcbnm ntym cjvytybzyf ktubnbvyjcnm bpåhfyyjuj ghtpbltynf Xtxty-crjq Htcgeåkbrb.

Xnj ét rfcftncz djghjcf j djpvjéyjcnb JÅCTcsuhfnm rfreñ-kbåj htfkmyeñ hjkm d cjwbfkmyj-ärjyjvbxtcrjv djccnfyjdktybb Xtxyb, nj e vtyzgjrf ytn jndtnf. D ntxtybt ljdjkmyj lkbntkmyjujdhtvtyb vs gsnfkbcm yfvtnbnm rfrbt-nj rjy-rhtnyst ghjtrns d änjq jåkfcnb. R cjéfktybñ,åjkmibycndj bp cltkfyysö yfv ghtlkjétybq yt bvtkb htfkmyjq ghfrnbxtcrjq wtyyjcnb b ytjndtxfkb gjnhtåyjcnzv Xtxyb.

Ctujlyz Hjccbz cjnhelybxftn cj vyjubvb vté-leyfhjlysvb jhufybpfwbzvb d Xtxyt, drkñxfz nt,rjnjhst döjlzn d cbcntve JJY, Vtéleyfhjlysqrjvbntn Rhfcyjuj Rhtcnf (VRRR) b Cjdtn Tdhjgs,b vs öjntkb ås bpåtéfnm leåkbhjdfybz d änjqhfåjnt.

Yf ljkñ vtéleyfhjlyjq gjvjob d wtkjv ghböjlbncz dctuj 5,7 ghjwtynf jn jåotuj rjkbxt-cndf chtlcnd, yfghfdkztvsö yf djccnfyjdktybt Xtxyb, f jcnfkmyst 94,3 ghjwtynf gjcnegfñn bphjccbqcrjuj atlthfkmyjuj åñlétnf. Änj cjnhel-ybxtcndj jceotcndkztncz d hfvrfö atlthfkmyjqghjuhfvvs cjwbfkmyj-ärjyjvbxtcrjuj djccnfyjd-ktybz Xtxtycrjq Htcgeåkbrb.

Ytgkjöbvb ghbvthfvb nfrjuj dpfbvjltqcndbzzdkzñncz jceotcndkztvst gj kbybb VRRR d 2004 ujle ghjtrns yf cevve d 21 vky. ljkk. CIFb ltzntkmyjcnm ÑYTCRJ d jåkfcnb jåhfpjdfybz c jåütvjv abyfycbhjdfybz d 2 vky. ljkkfhjd.

Z cjvytdfñcm, xnj JÅCT vjétn ghtlkjébnmxnj-kbåj cjgjcnfdbvjt c änbv d gkfyt abyfycb-hjdfybz b ärcgthnyjuj gjntywbfkf. Nj, d xtv ht-fkmyj ctqxfc yeélftncz Xtxyz, – änj gjvjom ddjphjéltybb cnhjbntkmyjq ghjvsiktyyjcnb, dcjplfybb hfåjxbö vtcn, ekexitybb plhfdjjöhfyt-ybz b jåhfpjdfybz b d cnhjbntkmcndt ébkmz lkzdjpdhfofñoböcz dyenhtyyt gthtvtotyysö kbw(DGK) b djjåot dctö, rnj gjnthzk cdjb ljvf.

Zdkztntcm kb Ds cnjhjyybrjv lfkmytqituj cvtotybz utjuhfabxtcrjuj frwtynf d ltzntkmyjcnb JÅCT d cnjhjye Rfdrfpf b Wtynhfkmyjq Fpbb? RfrjqDfv dblbncz hjkm Jhufybpfwbb d änbö htubjyfö?

D ghbywbgt, JÅCT ljkéyf eltkznm jlbyfrjdjtdybvfybt dctv cdjbv ujcelfhcndfv-exfcnybrfv bhtubjyfv. E dctö yfc jlbyfrjdst jåzpfntkmcndf, bybrnj yt kbity ytljcnfnrjd. Z ghjnbd bcreccn-dtyyjuj frwtynbhjdfybz dybvfybz yf rfrjv åsnj yb åskj rjyrhtnyjv htubjyt, gjcrjkmre änjvjukj ås ghbdtcnb r edtkbxtybñ utjuhfabxtcrj-uj lbcåfkfycf d JÅCT.

Yfif jhufybpfwbz ljkéyf pfybvfnmcz rjyrhtn-ysvb ghjåktvfvb d hfpysö cnhfyfö. Djpmvbnt, rghbvthe, yfheitybz d bpåbhfntkmyjv ghjwtcct,fynbctvbnbpv b lheubt ghjzdktybz ytnthgbvjcnbd Tdhjgt, rjhhegwbñ b ghjåktvs cdjåjls ghtccsgj jåt cnjhjys Fnkfynbrb, njhujdkñ kñlmvb djdctv htubjyt JÅCT, åelm nj d Hjccbb, Fdcnhbbbkb Idtwbb, ytehtuekbhjdfyyst rjyakbrns r pfgfle b r djcnjre jn Dtys, ghjåktvs yfwbj-yfkmysö vtymibycnd d Kfndbb b Äcnjybb, f nfr-ét ytljcnfnrb d hfåjnt gtybntywbfhyjq cbcntvsd wtkjv hzlt ujcelfhcnd-exfcnybrjd.

Hfpevttncz, rfrbt-nj ujcelfhcndf-exfcnybrb, d njv xbckt d Wtynhfkmyjq Fpbb b yf Rfdrfpt,dgjkyt vjuen jåhfnbnmcz r JÅCT pf cjltqcndbtv.Tckb yf nj bvtñncz chtlcndf b tckb nfrfz ghjcm-åf cjjndtncndetn vfylfne JÅCT, nj z yt dbée ybrfrbö ghjåktv c ntv, xnjås JÅCT yf ytt jn-rkbryekfcm. Dféyj, jlyfrj, xnjås jn dkfcntq ghb-ybvfñotq cnhfys gjcnegbkf xtnrj dshfétyyfzghjcmåf j gjvjob b xnjås nfrfz gjvjom jrfps-dfkfcm nhfycgfhtynysv jåhfpjv b, jgznm-nfrb,ghb eckjdbb yfkbxbz ljcnfnjxysö chtlcnd.

Dybvfntkmyj bpexbd JÅCT bpyenhb, yt öjntkb ås Ds gjhtrjvtyljdfnm rfrbt-kbåj bpvtytybz d tt cnherneht bkb vtnjlfö hfåjns, xnjås gjdscbnm tt äaatrnbdyjcnm? B rfrbv Dfv ghtlcnfdkztncz åeleott vbccbq JÅCT yf vtcnfö?

Xnjås yt jncnfnm jn hfpdbnbz cjåsnbq d cathtåtpjgfcyjcnb, JÅCT ljkéyf åsnm cgjcjåyf r ytghthsdyjve bpvtytybñ b hfpdbnbñ. Ghjwtccnhfycajhvfwbb b flfgnfwbb JÅCT ljkéty yj-cbnm gjcnjzyysq öfhfrnth. Änj gjlndthélftnczghfrnbrjq b lheubö vtéleyfhjlysö jhufybpf-wbq, drkñxfz JJY.

Vs cxbnftv, xnj ghjwtcc htajhvbhjdfybzJÅCT ljkéty bvtnm ldt jgjhs. Gthdfz bp ybö ljkéyf jcyjdsdfnmcz yf dshfåjnrt yjdjq gjkbnb-xtcrjq gjdtcnrb lyz JÅCT, jödfnsdfñotq dtcm

Page 20: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

20 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

htubjy JÅCT b tt djtyyj-gjkbnbxtcrjt, ärjyjvb-xtcrjt/ärjkjubxtcrjt b xtkjdtxtcrjt bpvthtybz.Htitybz, ghbyznst yf dcnhtxt Cjdtnf vbybcnhjdd Vffcnhbönt d ltrfåht 2003 ujlf, – dféysq ifud änjv yfghfdktybb.

Dnjhjq jgjhjq ljkéyf ckeébnm ghjuhfvvf dctjåütvkñotq dyenhtyytq htajhvs, jödfns-dfñotq hfpkbxyst fcgtrns cnhernehs JÅCT b ttltzntkmyjcnb. Jceotcndktybt htajhvs ljkéyjblnb herf jå here c dshfåjnrjq yjdjq gjdtcnrblyz, c ntv xnjås jåtcgtxbnm ytghthsdyjcnm dctujänjuj ghjwtccf b cjöhfybnm tuj yfwtktyyjcnm yfåeleott.

Cfvsq ytjnkjéysq öfhfrnth yjcbn djghjc jltzntkmyjcnb JÅCT yf vtcnfö. Vbccbb d bö ys-ytiytv dblt enhfnbkb cdjt gthdjyfxfkmyjt pyf-xtybt rfr vtöfybpv jrfpfybz gjvjob cnhfyfv gjbö ghjcmåt. Ythtlrj jåhfp bö ltqcndbq yt bvttnybxtuj jåotuj c bö vfylfnjv.

Dvtcnj jrfpfybz gjvjob vbccbb dvtibdfñnczdj dyenhtyybt ltkf b yt rjycekmnbheñncz rfr gj-kjétyj c dkfcnzvb ghbybvfñobö cnhfy. Jcyjd-yjq egjh d bö ltzntkmyjcnb cvtcnbkcz c ghtlj-cnfdktybz cjltqcndbz yf vjybnjhbyu b rhbnbre.Rhjvt njuj, gj-ghtéytve yfåkñlftncz zdyjt jn-cencndbt ljkéyjq nhfycgfhtynyjcnb b gjljnxtn-yjcnb d njv, xnj rfcftncz bö abyfycjd b rflhj-djq gjkbnbrb.

D hzlt ckexftd änj eét ghbdtkj r rjyakbrnfvvtéle vbccbzvb b dkfcnzvb ghbybvfñobö cnhfy.Z eåtélty d njv, xnj tckb ysytiyzz cbnefwbz yt bpvtybncz, nj lyb ≤gjktdjq≥ ltzntkmyjcnb cjxntys.

Öjntk ås crfpfnm ytcrjkmrj ckjd b gj djghjce,rjnjhsq jåceélfkcz d rekefhfö ytrjnjhsö bp gjcktlybö vthjghbznbq JÅCT, f bvtyyj j ghby-

wbgt rjyctycecf. Dscrfpsdfkjcm vytybt, xnj änjnghbywbg eét bpébk ctåz, cnfk ghtgzncndbtv d hf-åjnt JÅCT b ljkéty åsnm bpvtyty bkb jnvtyty.Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz cxbnftn gjljåyst dpukzlsdtcmvf jgfcysvb b euhjéfñobvb cfvjve ceotcn-djdfybñ JÅCT.

Ghfdbkj rjyctycecf – jlby bp jcyjdjgjkfufñ-obö ghbywbgjd Jhufybpfwbb, pfrhtgktyysq dhzlt htitybq JÅCT, drkñxfz Öfhnbñ tdhjgtq-crjq åtpjgfcyjcnb. Jy zdkztncz gjlkbyyj ltvjr-hfnbxtcrbv bycnhevtynjv d fhctyfkt JÅCT, jåtc-gtxbdfñobv hfdyjghfdbt dctö cnhfy – åjkmiböb vfksö – d ghbyznbb htitybq b dshfåjnrt gj-kbnbrb JÅCT.

Åtp ghfdbkf rjyctycecf JÅCT hbcretn ghtdhf-nbnmcz d ajhev, ult åjkmibycndj cnhfy åeltn yf-dzpsdfnm cdjñ djkñ vtymibycnde, pfcnfdkzz böghb änjv gkfnbnm pf ltzntkmyjcnm, c rjnjhjq ntyt cjukfcys. Ghb nfrjv hfpdbnbb cjåsnbq vyjubtcnhfys åjkmit yt gjétkfñn jcnfdfnmcz d Jhufyb-pfwbb yb lyz.

Lf, ltqcndbntkmyj, byjulf ghböjlbncz gjnhf-nbnm ytvfkj cbk b dhtvtyb, xnjås ljcnbxm rjy-ctycecf. D pyfxbntkmyjq vtht htpekmnfn ghb änjvpfdbcbn jn djkb b lbgkjvfnbxtcrjuj vfcnthcndfGhtlctlfntkmcndf. Yj tckb änjn ghjwtcc jhufyb-pjdfy ghfdbkmyj, nhfycgfhtynty b tckb ljkéysvjåhfpjv exbnsdfñncz bynthtcs dctö ujcelfhcnd,nj htibnm ghjåktve åsdftn ujhfplj ktuxt. B nju-lf d yfitv hfcgjhzétybb jrfpsdftncz vjoysqbycnhevtyn, gjhjq lfét pyfxbntkmyj åjktt vjo-ysq, xtv htitybz, bvtñobt jåzpfntkmyeñ ñhb-lbxtcreñ cbke.

30 ktn ceotcndjdfybz JÅCT ljrfpfkb äaatrnbd-yjcnm b frnefkmyjcnm rjyctycecf, b vs ljkéyscltkfnm dct, xnjås cjöhfybnm b eghjxbnm tuj.

GJCJK F. Ñ. FKTRCTTD lj cdjtuj yfpyfxtybz d Dtyepfybvfk d 1998–2001 uu. gjcn lbhtrnjhf nhtnmtuj ltgfhnf-vtynf Fpbb d hjccbqcrjv vbybcnthcndt byjcnhfyysö ltk.Tuj gjckeéyjq cgbcjr drkñxftn, d xfcnyjcnb, hfåjne d Gf-rbcnfyt, ult jy åsk gjckjv c 1993 gj 1998 ujl, b ldt rjvfy-lbhjdrb d Bylbñ: c 1969 gj 1974 b c 1980 gj 1985 ujl. GjcjkFktrcttd hjlbkcz d Vjcrdt d 1946 ujle, pfrjyxbk Vjcrjd-crbq ujcelfhcndtyysq bycnbnen vtéleyfhjlysö jnyjitybq bbvttn cntgtym rfylblfnf bcnjhbxtcrbö yfer.

C heccrjq dthcbtq éehyfkf ≤JÅCT≥ vjéyj jpyfrjvbnmcz yf cfqnt:

www. osce.org/publications/magazine

Page 21: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 21

ÅHFQFY ÖJGRBYCJY

16vfhnf cthås-rjcjdfhs, ghjébdfñobtd gjctkrt Wfukfdbwf, hfcgjkjétyyjvdåkbpb cnjkbws rhfz, Ghbinbys, åkj-rbhjdfkb fdnjvfubcnhfkm Ghbinbyf –

Crjgmt d pyfr ghjntcnf ghjnbd bywbltynf, d öjltrjnjhjuj dscnhtkjv bp ghjtpéfñotuj vbvj fdnj-vjåbkz åsk hfyty jlby bp vtcnysö ébntktq.

Ntv ét dtxthjv d hfcgjkjétyyjq yf ctdtht rhfzlthtdyt Wfåhf d htrt Båfh enjyekb nhb fkåfycrbövfkmxbrf. Gj ckjdfv dsébdituj xtndthnjuj, böghtcktljdfkb cthås c cjåfrjq.

Änb ldf yt cdzpfyyst lheu c lheujv bywbltynfcghjdjwbhjdfkb ghjljkéfdibtcz d ntxtybt nhtölytq vfccjdst åtcgjhzlrb rjcjdcrbö fkåfywtd.Djkyf yfcbkbz, yfghfdktyyjuj ukfdysv jåhfpjvghjnbd gjctktybq rjcjdcrbö cthåjd, f nfrét ghj-nbd lheubö änybxtcrbö uhegg b jåütrnjd VJJYR,pföktcnyekf b lheubt hfqjys.

Xbckj gjubåibö cjcnfdbkj 19 xtkjdtr. Åjktt900 gjkexbkb hfytybz, f 4000 jcnfkbcm åtp rhs-ib yfl ujkjdjq. Åskj eybxnjétyj bkb gjdhtélt-yj gjxnb 800 ljvjd b jrjkj 30 ghfdjckfdysö cdznsym.GJXTVE ÄNJ GHJBPJIKJ?

Rjcjdj ghjljkéftn cnfkrbdfnmcz c vyjétcndjvghjåktv, b e kñltq tcnm ytvfkj ghbxby lkz yt-ljdjkmcndf. Hfåjxbö vtcn yt ödfnftn, f ärjyjvbrfhfpdbdftncz ytljcnfnjxyj åscnhj, xnjås hfcneottyfctktybt vjukj cfvj ctåz ghjrjhvbnm. Åjktt nj-uj, d änjv ujle d htpekmnfnt ghjljkéfñotujcz cj-rhfotybz dfkñnysö gjcnegktybq b evtymitybzvtéleyfhjlyjuj ghbcencndbz vjétn lfét yfcne-gbnm ärjyjvbxtcrbq cgfl.

Cjöhfyzñobtcz hfpyjukfcbz vtéle VJJYR bajhvbhetvsvb gentv vtcnysö dsåjhjd dhtvty-ysvb jhufyfvb cfvjeghfdktybz (DJC) dczxtcrbhfpledfñncz chtlcndfvb vfccjdjq byajhvfwbb,xnj gjlhsdftn ljdthbt r jåtbv cnhernehfv. Gj-ljåyfz cbnefwbz cgjcjåcndetn cjplfybñ dgtxfnkt-ybz, åelnj Rjcjdj ybrelf yt ldbétncz b yt vjétnjåtcgtxbnm ljcnjqyjuj åeleotuj lkz cdjtq vjkj-ltéb. Rfr jnvtnbkb yfåkñlfntkb, åjkmibycndjexfcndjdfdibö d åtcgjhzlrfö cjcnfdkzkb ñyjiblj 20 ktn.

Ye b, rjytxyj, jcnftncz ythtityysv djghjc jå jrjyxfntkmyjv cnfnect Rjcjdj. Änf cjöhfyzñ-ofzcz ytjghtltktyyjcnm jnyñlm yt cgjcjåcndetncnfåbkbpfwbb jåcnfyjdrb.

Ntv yt vtytt, ytljdjkmcndj yfctktybz cfvj gjctåt yt vjukj åsnm ljcnfnjxyjq ghbxbyjq lkz nj-uj, xnjås yfcbkbt ghjljkéfkjcm d ntxtybt nhtölytq ghfrnbxtcrb dj dctö eujkrfö Rjcjdj. D cdtntgjrfpfybq cdbltntktq ghtlcnfdkztncz jxtdblysv,xnj rnj-nj yfghfdkzk ltqcndbz njkg b vfybgekb-hjdfk bvb. Rfélsq d Rjcjdj pyftn, xnj d jåotcn-dt tcnm äktvtyns, rjnjhst d kñåjq vjvtyn ujnjdsghbåtuyenm r yfcbkbñ hflb ljcnbétybz cjåcndty-ysö gjkbnbxtcrbö bkb ghtcnegysö wtktq. B dctét ybrnj yt jéblfk, xnj änb äktvtyns, lbhbébhezhfpüzhtyysvb njkgfvb, cvjuen yfltkfnm cnjkmrjåtl b dspdfnm nfrjt hfpjhtybt.GTHTCVFNHBDFZ HJKM JÅCT

Cnfkj zcyj, xnj vtéleyfhjlyjt cjjåotcndj ljkéyj jnytcnbcm r änbv ytjéblfyysv cjåsnbzvcj dctq cthmtpyjcnmñ. Xnj vjétn djcghtgzncndj-dfnm gjdnjhtybñ dcgsitr yfcbkbz dczrbq hfp,rjulf bvttn vtcnj ghjdjrfwbz? Jnxfcnb jndtn yfänjn djghjc pfrkñxftncz d dszdktybb b ghbdktxt-ybb r celtåyjq jndtncndtyyjcnb ukfdysö dbyjdyb-rjd. Yj cnjkm ét jxtdblyj b nj, xnj vs d JÅCTljkéys ljrjgfnmcz lj rjhtyysö ghbxby yfcbkbz.

C 1999 ujlf flvbybcnhfnbdyjt eghfdktybt Rj-cjdj jceotcndkztncz cgtwbfkmysv ghtlcnfdbntktvUtythfkmyjuj ctrhtnfhz JJY. Änj flvbybcnhfnbd-yjt eghfdktybt bvttn xtnsht aeylfvtynfkmysöcjcnfdkzñobö: gjkbwbz b ñcnbwbz (JJY), uhfé-lfycrfz flvbybcnhfwbz (JJY), bycnbnewbjyfkm-yjt cnhjbntkmcndj (JÅCT) b ärjyjvbxtcrjt hfpdbnbt (Tdhjgtqcrbq cjñp).

Åelexb jlyjq bp jcyjdysö cjcnfdkzñoböVJJYR, xnj d gjhzlrt htfubhjdfybz vjukf åsghtlghbyznm Vbccbz JÅCT d Rjcjdj?

DJCCNFYFDKBDFZ LJDTHBT

Rjcjdj: rhbnbxtcrbq cfvjfyfkbpVfhnjdcrfz dcgsirf yfcbkbz –dspjd vtéleyfhjlyjve cjjåotcnde

Rfr ét vjukj nfrjt ckexbnmcz yf gznjv ujle dtcjvjuj vté-leyfhjlyjuj ghbcencndbz? Dcgsirf yfcbkbz, bvtdifz vtcnjd Rjcjdj 17–19 vfhnf, cnfkf lkz Vbccbb JJY gj ltkfv dht-vtyyjq flvbybcnhfwbb d Rjcjdj (VJJYR) b tt gfhnythjdétcnjrbv yfgjvbyfybtv j njv, xnj bö ecbkbz gj gjcnhjtybñåjktt njkthfynyjuj b ltvjrhfnbxtcrjuj jåotcndf d rhfttot dtcmvf lfktrb jn pfdthitybz. Cnhtvzcm dsgjkybnmcdjñ xfcnm pflfxb, JÅCT ytpfvtlkbntkmyj jnhtfubhjdfkf yf ghjbpjitlitt b gthtcvjnhtkf cdjq gjlöjl.

≤D rfrjq-nj vtht yfyt-ctyysq eothå vjéyjbcghfdbnm, f d rfrjq-nj– ytn. Djccnfyjdbnm ljdthbt åeltn ytkturj,f tckb änb ecbkbz yt åelen dpfbvysvb, nj bdjjåot ytdjpvjéyj.Jlyféls vtéleyfhjl-yjt cjjåotcndj eqltn, b yfv ghbltncz exbnmczébnm dvtcnt≥.

Älbnf Åewfq, ghtcc-ctrhtnfhm JVBR,j vfhnjdcrbö cjåsnbzö.

Page 22: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

22 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

Dj dhtvz åtcgjhzlrjdyfitq gthdtqitq pfåj-njq åskf pfobnf yfiböcjnhelybrjd, jcjåtyyjcthåjd gj yfwbjyfkmyjc-nb. Ytrjnjhsv bp yböåskj ghtljcnfdktyj eåt-ébot d infå-rdfhnbhtJÅCT d Ghbinbyt. Dtcm-vf gtxfkmyj, yj ljvf yt-rjnjhsö cjnhelybrjd, dnjv xbckt b vtéleyfhjl-

ysö, åskb cjéétys. R cxfcnmñ, jlyfrj, ybrnj bpcjnhelybrjd JÅCT yt gjkexbk cthmtpysö hfytybq.GJBCR HTITYBQ

Jåtcgtxbd åtpjgfcyjcnm cjnhelybrjd, vs ghb-cnegbkb r gthtcvjnhe – d cdtnt ghjbpjitliböbywbltynjd – ghjdjlbditqcz Vbccbtq gjkbnbrb.Herjdjlbntkm Vbccbb gjcjk Gfcrfkm Amtib cj-plfk gznm wtktdsö uhegg lkz hfccvjnhtybz hfp-kbxysö gjkbnbxtcrbö fcgtrnjd, rjnjhst, rfrghtlcnfdkztncz, yfghzveñ cdzpfys c ukeåbyysvbghbxbyfvb bvtdituj vtcnj yfcbkbz. Hfåjnf wtkt-dsö uhegg rfcftncz cath rjvgtntywbb hfpkbxysöltgfhnfvtynjd Vbccbb:

Vjkjltém b jåhfpjdfybt. Gjxtve nfr vyjujvjkjlsö kñltq jrfpfkbcm ujnjds dsqnb yf ekbwsb fnfrjdfnm lheubö uhfélfy? Xnj tot vjétn clt-kfnm JÅCT, xnjås gjvjxm bv gjcnhjbnm cdtnkjtåeleott b gjjohbnm bö cnhtvktybt cnfnm gjktp-ysvb xktyfvb jåotcndf?

Vtéjåobyyst dpfbvjjnyjitybz. JÅCT btt vtcnyst b vtéleyfhjlyst gfhnyths ghbkjéb-kb ytvfkj cbk r cnbvekbhjdfybñ vtéänybxtcrjujlbfkjuf b jceotcndktybñ ghjuhfvv ghbvbhtybz.Gjxtve ét dct änb ecbkbz jrfpfkbcm ytljcnfnjx-ys, xnjås yt ljgecnbnm yjdjuj dcgktcrf ytyfdbc-nb? Vjétn åsnm, ghbxbyf gjghjcne pfrkñxftncz d njv, xnj yfc nfr b yt ecksifkb hflbrfkmyj yf-cnhjtyyst xktys jåotcndf – nt, rnj åjkmit lhe-ubö crkjyty r yfcbkbñ?

CVB. Vyjubt ébntkb ujdjhbkb, xnj bö yf ekbwedsdtk uytd, dspdfyysq, zrjås, ghbxfcnyjcnmñ cthåjd r ubåtkb ltntq d h. Båfh. Gj ckjdfv yfåkñ-lfntktq, änf htfrwbz åskf ytgjchtlcndtyyj cghj-djwbhjdfyf ävjwbjyfkmysvb b ghtldpznsvb hflbj- b ntkthtgjhnféfvb, dsitlibvb d äabhdtxthjv 16 vfhnf.

Rfr jnvtnbk Ghtlcnfdbntkm JÅCT gj djghjcfvcdjåjls chtlcnd vfccjdjq byajhvfwbb, tckb åsyt änb åtpjndtncndtyyst ctycfwbjyyst cjjåot-ybz, nj cjåsnbz, djpvjéyj, hfpdbdfkbcm ås byfxtb yt ghbjåhtkb ås cnjkm åehyjuj b étcnjrjuj öfhfrnthf. Lheubt nfrét ujdjhzn, xnj tckb åsCVB åskb åjktt clthéfyysvb d cdjbö htgjhnf-éfö b levfkb jå bö djpvjéysö gjcktlcndbzö, njåtcgjhzlrjd vjukj ås djjåot yt åsnm.

Gjxtve ét chtlcndf vfccjdjq byajhvfwbb jrf-pfkbcm r änjve ytcgjcjåys, ytcvjnhz yf jceotcn-dkzdibtcz d ntxtybt wtkjuj hzlf ktn JÅCT b lhe-ubvb jhufybpfwbzvb ghjuhfvvs hfpdbnbz CVB?

Cnhföb ghjikjuj. Gjxtve cthåcrfz jåobyf,rjnjhfz ddble tt cjrhfnbditqcz xbcktyyjcnb dhzlkb vjétn ghtlcnfdkznm cjåjq rfreñ-kbåj euhjpe,

dct tot jcnftncz ukfdyjq vbitymñ lkz yfgfljrfkåfycrbö ärcnhtvbcnjd? Vjéyj kb tot xnj-yb-åelm cltkfnm, xnjås jcdjåjlbnm yfhjl Rjcjdj jnuytneotuj yfcktlbz ghjikjuj?

Vjybnjhbyu b hfpdbnbt gjntywbfkf. Gjxt-ve dhtvtyyst jhufys cfvjeghfdktybz jrfpfkbcmyfcnjkmrj åtcgjvjoysvb b åtpdkfcnysvb, xnj ytcvjukb yb ghtljndhfnbnm, yb ghtctxm yfcbkbt? Xnjvjéyj cltkfnm, xnjås gjdscbnm bö lttcgjcjåyjcnm,jcjåtyyj exbnsdfz, xnj gj endthéltyyjve Gkfyejceotcndktybz rjcjdcrbö cnfylfhnjd jyb yfltkt-ys lfktrj bleobvb aeyrwbzvb b gjkyjvjxbzvb?

[J ghbyznbb Gkfyf jceotcndktybz rjcjdcrböcnfylfhnjd, cnfdituj htpekmnfnjv vyjujvtczxyjqhfåjns, åskj jåüzdktyj 31 vfhnf c.u. cgtwbfkmysvghtlcnfdbntktv Utythfkmyjuj ctrhtnfhz JJY Öfh-hb Öjkrthb b ghtvmth-vbybcnhjv DJC ÅfqhfvjvHtlétgb. D änjv gkfyt ghtlecvjnhty hzl vth, yt-jåöjlbvsö lkz gjcnhjtybz cjdhtvtyyjuj ltvjr-hfnbxtcrjuj, gkñhfkbcnbxtcrjuj b njkthfynyjujjåotcndf d Rjcjdj.]

Xktys dsityfpdfyysö wtktdsö uhegg tlbyj-leiys d njv, xnj JVBR ljkéyf b dghtlm d hfåjntc yfctktybtv b jåotcndtyysvb bycnbnenfvb Rj-cjdj ghjgfufylbhjdfnm vjltkm gfhnythcrbö jnyj-itybq. Ghb änjv jyb, jlyfrj, ghbpyfñn, xnj änfvjltkm dct tot ezpdbvf gthtl kbwjv cbk, ujnjdsöghbåtuyenm r yfcbkbñ hflb ljcnbétybz cdjbö gj-kbnbxtcrbö wtktq kñåjq wtyjq.

C ntv xnjås evtymibnm äne ezpdbvjcnm, wtktdstuheggs htrjvtyleñn cktleñott:♦ Pfltqcndjdfnm dct äktvtyns jåotcndf, drkñxfz

b ntö, rnj bpdtcnty cdjbv dhféltåysv jnyjit-ybtv r wtkzv vtéleyfhjlyjuj cjjåotcndf, bgjgsnfnmcz dszdbnm djpvjéyjcnb, tckb nfrjdstceotcndeñn, lkz ≤yfdtltybz vjcnjd≥; dj dczrjvckexft, ghjbpdtcnb nofntkmysq fyfkbp hfccnf-yjdrb cbk d jåotcndt.

♦ Hfphfåjnfnm ldetlbysq gjlöjl r hfpdbnbñ gj-ntywbfkf b vjybnjhbyue ltzntkmyjcnb flvbyb-cnhfnbdyj-eghfdktyxtcrbö cnherneh, CVB bbycnbnenjd uhfélfycrjuj jåotcndf. Lkz njujxnjås vjybnjhbyu ckeébk bynthtcfv åeleot-uj, cktletn bcgjkmpjdfnm tuj htpekmnfns d ecb-kbzö gj hfpdbnbñ gjntywbfkf, gjcrjkmre dghjnbdyjv ckexft jy ghtdhfoftncz d cfvjwtkm,yt dtleoeñ r htfkmyjve ghjuhtcce.

♦ Dtcnb hfåjne gj rekmnbdbhjdfybñ åjkmitujdpfbvjedfétybz yf dctö ehjdyzö jåotcndf,jcjåtyyj chtlb vjkjltéb.

Lfyyfz ghjuhfvvf yt hfccvfnhbdftncz rfr htwtgn vuyjdtyyjq nhfycajhvfwbb Rjcjdj. Ght-jåhfpjdfybt jåotcndf – pflfxf, lkz htfkbpfwbbrjnjhjq yb e JÅCT, yb e rfrjq-kbåj lheujq jhuf-ybpfwbb ytn ljcnfnjxysö htcehcjd, b, rhjvt njuj,rfr gjrfpsdftn jgsn, htpekmnfn nfrbö ecbkbq yb-rjulf yt åsdftn cnjkm bltfkty, rfr gkfybhjdfkjcm.

Ntv yt vtytt, JVBR vjétn b ljkéyf ghjljk-éfnm jrfpsdfnm dtcmvf wtyyeñ gjllthére njvegjlfdkzñotve åjkmibycnde yfctktybz Rjcjdj, rj-njhjt dct tot yflttncz yf cxfcnkbdjt åeleott byf nj, xnj elfcncz gjrjyxbnm c eyfcktljdfyysvbjn ghjikjuj ytelfxysvb b ltcnhernbdysvb cnt-htjnbgfvb.

Vbnhjdbwf, 18 vfhnf: pfnbimt gjckt åehb.

Htrf Båfh hfpltkztn ujhjlyf ldt änybxtcrbt xfcnb.

Åhfqfy Öjgrbycjy c yjzå-hz 2002 ujlf zdkztncz lbhtrnjhjv åñhj gj gjkbnbxtcrbv djghjcfvVbccbb JÅCT d Rjcjdj.Hfytt jy pfybvfk ljk-éyjcnb, d xfcnyjcnb, lbhtrnjhf åñhj vtéleyf-hjlysö rhbpbcysö uhegg d Åjcybb b Uthwtujdbyt,Rjcjdj (chfpe gjckt rjy-akbrnf 1999 ujlf) b Xth-yjujhbb. C 1980 gj 1986ujl yföjlbkcz yf lbgkj-vfnbxtcrjq ckeéåt Dtkb-rjåhbnfybb, cgtwbfkbpb-hezcm yf fahbrfycrböghjåktvfö b ltkfö Tdhj-gtqcrjuj cjjåotcndf, hfåjnfk d Kjyljyt, Eufylt b Gjhneufkbb. D1995–1996 uu., yf gjcktl-ytv änfgt åjcybqcrjqdjqys b d gthdst vtczwsLtqnjycrjuj vbhyjuj ghj-wtccf, åsk gjckjv cdjtqcnhfys d Cfhftdj.

ÄL

BN

F Å

EWF

Q/J

VB

R

Page 23: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 23

≤Ctujlyz – crjhåysq ltym lkz dctuj yfctktybz Rjcjdj. Yfcbkbt ghbdjlbn kbim r kñlcrbv cnhflfybzv b yfyjcbn eothå dpfbvjjnyjitybzv vtéle jåobyfvb. Bxnj åjktt dféyj, jyj tot åjkmit pfnhelyztn yföjéltybt ljkujchjxysö htitybqghjåktv Rjcjdj. D cdtnt änbö nhfubxtcrbö cjåsnbq yfhjl Rjcjdj b tuj gjkbnbxtc-rbt kblths jåzpfys djccnfyjdbnm cgjrjqcndbt b ghjljkébnm ldbétybt gj genbcnhjbntkmcndf ltvjrhfnbb b uhfélfycrjuj jåotcndf... Jlyf bp dféytqibö jåz-pfyyjcntq CVB – lfdfnm afrnbxtcreñ byajhvfwbñ j ghjbcöjlzobö cjåsnbzö, yt dspsdfz ghb änjv hjcnf yfghzétyyjcnb. Tckb endthéltybz, c rjnjhsvb dscne-gfñn CVB bkb rjnjhst jyb jåyfhjleñn, yt gjlndthélfñncz, nj jyb ljkéys ghbpyfnm cdjñ jndtncndtyyjcnm pf ltpbyajhvbhjdfybt jåotcndtyyjcnb≥.

Bp jåhfotybz herjdjlbntkz Vbccbb JÅCT d Rjcjdj gjckf Gfcrfkz Amtib r yfctktybñ b herjdjlbntkzv Rjcjdj, drkñxfz CVB. Ghbinbyf, 18 vfhnf.

≤Yfcbkbt, bvtditt vtcnj d Rjcjdj, ytghbtvktvj

d ltvjrhfnbxtcrjv jåotcndt b ytljgecnbvj yf genb

d Tdhjge. Dbyjdyst d frnfö yfcbkbz ljkéys ghtl-

cnfnm gthtl celjv. Vs jéblftv jn dhtvtyysö jhuf-

yjd cfvjeghfdktybz gkfyf ytjnkjéysö ltqcndbq b

öjntkb ås ecksifnm bö vytybt j njv, xtv vjukj ås

gjvjxm vtéleyfhjlyjt cjjåotcndj≥.

Pfzdktybt LG Cjkjvjyf Gfccb dj dhtvz tuj

cjdvtcnyjuj c utythfkmysv ctrhtnfhtv YFNJ

Zfgjv lt Öjjg Cötaathjv dbpbnf d Ghbinbye

22 vfhnf.

≤Cdbltntkmcndf njuj, xnj d bpdtcnyjq cntgtybdphsd yfcbkbz 17 vfhnfåsk jhufybpjdfy bcghjdjwbhjdfy, yt cyb-vfñn c éehyfkbcnjd jndtncndtyyjcnb pf lj-geotyyst bvb jibårb.Njxyjcnm d bpkjétybbafrnjd, njyfkmyjcnm brjyntrcn cjjåotybq, rf-cfñoböcz kñåsö fcgtr-njd änybxtcrbö djghj-cjd, jcjåtyyj dféys dgkfyt ytljgeotybz njuj,xnjås hflbj- b ntktgt-htlfxb cnfyjdbkbcm yt-gjchtlcndtyysv rfnfkb-

pfnjhjv yfcbkbz. D ghj-atccbjyfkmyjq éehyf-kbcnbrt, rjulf jyf bvttnltkj c endthéltybzvb,cgjcjåysvb dpjhdfnmcbnefwbñ, ytn vtcnf lkzckeöjd bkb ljvsckjd≥.

Bp fyfkbnbxtcrjuj ljrkflf dhtvtyyjuj rjvbccfhf gj djghjcfvCVB Hjåthnf Ébkktnfj hfåjnt nhtö jåotrj-cjdcrbö ntktcnfywbq.Ghbinbyf, 23 fghtkz.

Cv. ntrcn ljrkflf yfcfqnt: www.osce.org/kosovo

Crjhåysq ltym

≤Yf ytcrjkmrj rhbnbxtcrbdféysö lytq CVB Rjcjdjckjdyj gjpfbvcndjdfkb bpcdjtuj ytcdjåjlyjuj, ≤ljlt-vjrhfnbxtcrjuj≥ ghjikjujytrjnjhst bp xthn, rjnjhstkbxyj vyt jxtym öjhjij pyfrjvs, – jncencndbt ytnjkmrj jåütrnbdyjcnb, yj bgkñhfkbpvf. D Rjcjdj vs yfåkñlfkb yt njkmrj jlyjcnj-hjyyññ, åtpjndtncndtyyeñ b ytghjatccbjyfkmyeñ éeh-yfkbcnbre d ytcnfåbkmyjv gjcnrjyakbrnyjv jåotcndt,yj b nhfubxtcreñ ytödfnrefkmnthyfnbdysö, ehfdyjdtib-dfñobö ujkjcjd...≥.

≤...Jcjåtyyj äktrnhjyystCVB ghjltvjycnhbhjdfkb

ytljgecnbveñ cntgtym ävj-wbjyfkmyjcnb, ghtldpznjcnb,åtpjndtncndtyyjcnb b yt-evtcnyjuj ≤gfnhbjnbxtcrjuj≥gskf. Htgjhnféb, nhfyckbhj-dfdibtcz dtxthjv 16 vfhnfnhtvz jcyjdysvb rjcjdcrbvbntktrfyfkfvb, pfckeébdfñnghtltkmyj étcnrjq rhbnbrb. D jnkbxbt jn ybö dtleobt gtxfnyst CVB, pf ytrjnjhsvbljcnjqysvb cjéfktybz bc-rkñxtybzvb, ghjzdbkb ujhfp-lj åjktt rjycnhernbdysq gjlöjl≥.

≤...Zdyfz ntyltywbjpyjcnm gjlfxb chtlcndfvb vfccjdjqbyajhvfwbb cjjåotybq jåenjyedibö d htrt ltnzö..., rfrghtlcnfdkztncz, yt gjlrhtg-

kztncz rfrbvb ås nj yb åskjghbtvktvsvb c njxrb phtybzéehyfkbcnbrb ljrfpfntkmcndf-vb. Nfrét ytkmpz crfpfnm, xnjänb cjjåotybz åskb ghjlbr-njdfys cnhtvktybtv bpåtéfnmyfcbkbz...≥.

≤Ljgecrfz jibårb, chtlcndfvfccjdjq byajhvfwbb, hfpe-vttncz, yt bvtkb evsckfcghjdjwbhjdfnm yfcbkbt. Yj yf CVB ktébn jndtncndty-yjcnm pf yflktéfott b ghj-atccbjyfkmyjt jcdtotybtcjåsnbq d bynthtcfö yfctkt-ybz Rjcjdj≥.

≤Tckb ås yt gthtlfyyst16–17 vfhnf åtpjndtncndty-yst, gjhjéltyyst gjujytq

pf ctycfwbtq cjjåotybz, njcjåsnbz, djpvjéyj, hfpdbdf-kbcm ås byfxt. Dthjznyj, jybyt ljcnbukb ås njuj yfrfkf b njq cntgtyb étcnjrjcnb, rjnjhst vs yfåkñlfkb, f vj-étn åsnm b yt ghjbpjikb åsdjdct≥.

Bp cgtwbfkmyjuj ljrkflfGhtlcnfdbntkz JÅCT gj djghjcfv cdjåjls CVB Vbrkjif Öfhfinb Gjcnjzy-yjve cjdtne j hjkb vtcnysöCVB d vfhnjdcrbö cjåsnbzöd Rjcjdj. Dtyf, 22 fghtkz.

Cv. ntrcn ljrkflf yf cfqnt:www.osce.org/fom.

Nhfubxtcrfz ytödfnrf ehfdyjdtibdfñobö ujkjcjd

Page 24: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

24 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

HTGJHNFÉ C VTCNF CJÅSNBQ

Åtlf dVbnhjdbwtCkbirjv åkbprj,xnjås xedcndjdfnmctåz rjvajhnyj:yfåkñlfz, rfr ubåytn d juyt ljcnbuyenjt

ÅTHYFHL DHÅFY

Zgjxedcndjdfk ghbpyfrb yfldbufñotqcz åtls, rjulf hfyj enhjv d chtle, 17 vfhnf,djitk d plfybt vtcnyjuj jnltktybz JÅCT d Vbnhjdbwt.

Rfr hfccrfpfkb vyt jöhfyybrb, yfrfyeyt dtxt-hjv jåotcndtyyfz hflbj- b ntktrjvgfybz HNR cj-jåobkf j njv, xnj d veybwbgfkmyjv jrheut PeåbyGjnjr c ghtbveotcndtyyj cthåcrbv yfctktybtv dhtrt enjyekb nhjt fkåfycrbö vfkmxbrjd. Cjukfcyjcjjåotybñ, d htre bö pfuyfkb cthås, cgecnbdibtyf ybö cjåfre.

Öjnz änb cdtltybz yt åskb gjlndthéltys gjkb-wbtq, yfghzétyyjcnm yfhfcnfkf. Irjkmybrb cnhfycgfhfynfvb d herfö d cjghjdjéltybb cdjböexbntktq vtlktyyj ghjitcndjdfkb gj ujhjle dvjkxfkbdjv ghjntcnt ghjnbd njuj, xnj jyb cjxkbjxthtlysv ghtcnegktybtv yf änybxtcrjq gjxdt.

Dcrjht gjckt änjuj d n.y. ≤pjye ljdthbz≥ djikbcgtwgjlhfpltktybz vtéleyfhjlyjq gjkbwbb, gj-cnfdbdibt cdjb ÅNH dåkbpb vjcnf, dtleotuj yf ct-dth. Cjåhfkfcm uheggf fkåfycrbö veéxby, hfpvf-

öbdfdibö fkåfycrbvakfujv b uhjpzoböczgthtqnb xthtp vjcn.Gjckt njuj rfr bv elf-kjcm ghjhdfnmcz xthtpyföjlbdibqcz yf ñéyjqcnjhjyt vjcnf gjkbwtq-crbq rjhljy, yf ctdth-yjq cnjhjyt, ult d jéb-lfybb yföjlbkbcmytcrjkmrj cthåjd, ghj-bpjikf rjhjnrfz lhfrf.Njkge fkåfywtd yfxfkbntcybnm yfpfl, yf lhe-ueñ cnjhjye vjcnf.

Tckb ås dct pfrjyxbkjcm gjckt ytcrjkmrbö åhj-ityysö rfvytq b rekfxysö elfhjd, nj jå änjv by-wbltynt vfkj rnj epyfk ås pf ghtltkfvb Rjcjdj.Jlyfrj ekbxyfz gjnfcjdrf gththjckf d djjheéty-yjt cnjkryjdtybt c ghbvtytybtv gjkefdnjvfnb-xtcrjuj jheébz b åjtdsö uhfyfn, d htpekmnfnt xtujd änjv åsditv ifönthcrjv ujhjlrt, yföjlzotvczghbvthyj d 40 rbkjvtnhfö r ctdthe jn Ghbinbys,gjubåkb 7 xtkjdtr.

Vs, fkåfycrbt, cthåcrbt b vtéleyfhjlyst cj-nhelybrb JÅCT, vjukb kbim åtccbkmyj, yt dthzcdjbv ukfpfv, yfåkñlfnm pf yfhfcnfñobv yfcbkbtvbp jrjy itcnjuj, dthöytuj änféf jabcyjuj plfybzJÅCT, yföjlzotujcz dctuj d ytcrjkmrbö cjnyzövtnhjd jn vjcnf. Vs dbltkb, rfr vjkjlst fkåfywsyfgfkb yf gjkbwtqcrbö, gsnfdiböcz ghtuhflbnmbv genm xthtp gtitöjlyeñ njhujdeñ ekbwe.≤GKJÖFZ CKEÉÅF≥ CVB

Gjcrjkmre änj döjlbkj d vjb jåzpfyyjcnb, zcktlbk pf jcdtotybtv chtlcndfvb vfccjdjq by-ajhvfwbb ghjbcöjlzobö cjåsnbq. F jyj dspdfkjukeåjrjt hfpjxfhjdfybt. HNR yt njkmrj cjckeéb-kj ≤gkjöeñ ckeéåe≥ dctve yfctktybñ Rjcjdj yfrfyeyt dtxthjv, gjcnfhfdibcm ghblfnm dctqänjq bcnjhbb ctycfwbjyysq öfhfrnth b lfét yt gjgsnfdibcm dszcybnm afrns, yj b ≤gjlkbkjvfckf≥ d jujym gjksöfdibö cnhfcntq, gthtlfd yfcktleñobq ltym d ghzvjv äabht ≤htgjhnfé cvtcnf cjåsnbq≥ c jcjåsv egjhjv yf vfhit ghj-ntcnf irjkmybrjd r lthtdyt, ult gjubåkb nhjtvfkmxbrjd.

Z jéblfk, xnj HNR öjnz ås djpmvtn bynthdmñ erfrjuj-ybåelm rjcjdcrjuj xbyjdybrf fkåfycrjujghjbcöjéltybz, rjnjhsq dscnegbn d rjycnhernbd-yjv leöt b ghbpjdtn r cgjrjqcndbñ. R vjtve eéf-ce, jlyfrj, rjulf nfrjq xbyjdybr yfrjytw d äabhtgjzdbkcz, jy cnfk jåbkmyj gthtcsgfnm cdjñ htxmjcrjhåbntkmysvb ckjdfvb b dshfétybzvb.

≤17 vfhnf vyt ljdtkjcmåsnm d Vbnhjdbwt. Pderb cbhty yfgjkybkbvtyz xedcndjv gfybxtc-rjuj cnhföf. Eéfc ghj-bcöjlzotuj ghtdjcöj-lbk vjb öelibt yjxystrjivfhs. Tlbycndty-yjt, j xtv z levfk, änjj åtpjgfcyjcnb étys bcsyf. Jyb yföjlbkbcmljvf – nfr åkbprj b d njét dhtvz nfr lfktrj≥.

Bp pfgbcrb vkflitujcjnhelybrf gj zpsrj-dsv/flvbybcnhfnbdysvdjghjcfv JVBR Ckfdb-ib Vkfltyjdbxf lheue.

Page 25: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 25

Yt kexit dtkf ctåz b cthåcrfz ntktcnfywbz.Ghfdlf, gthtlfyyjt tñ d yjdjcnzö rhfnrjt cjjå-otybt jå bywbltynt yf vjcne jnhféfkj htfkmystafrns, f njn cthåcrbq ltgenfn gfhkfvtynf Rjcjdj,e rjnjhjuj åhfkb bynthdmñ, ltqcndbntkmyj gjcnf-hfkcz cyznm yfghzétyyjcnm, yj chfpe gjckt änjujåskf gjrfpfyf öeljétcndtyyfz rbyjktynf j gjkj-étybb cthåjd dj dhtvtyf Jnnjvfycrjq bvgthbb.

Z gjllthébdfk ntcysq rjynfrn c åñhj dhtvty-yjuj rjvbccfhf gj djghjcfv CVB – ytpfdbcbvsvjhufyjv, rehbheñobv chtlcndf vfccjdjq byajh-vfwbb d Rjcjdj ghb gjllthért JÅCT. Åskj zcyj,xnj rjulf ≤ekzétncz gskm≥, rjvbccfh – HjåthnÉbkktn bp Cjtlbytyysö Infnjd –ljkéty åeltnghtlghbyznm yflktéfobt ltqcndbz.

D njn dtxth JJY ädfrebhjdfkf cthåcrbö cjnhel-ybrjd jnltktybz JÅCT d Vbnhjdbwt bp yfitujplfybz yf ctdth, ult jyb ghjébdfkb. Z dvtcnt c ct-vmñ lheubvb vtéleyfhjlysvb cjnhelybrfvb åskgthtdtlty d plfybt ghtlcnfdbntkmcndf JJY, yföj-lzottcz ytgjchtlcndtyyj e vjcnf. Bvtyyj nfv vsb ghjdtkb yjxm, c nhtdjujq jéblfz dtcntq j njv,rfr hfpdjhfxbdfñncz cjåsnbz, pdjyz lhepmzv brjkktufv, hfpvsikzz yfl ntv, ult ghjbpjitk cåjq b xnj tot vjukj ckexbnmcz.

Lkz åjkmibycndf bp yfc änj åskf öelifz bpdctö ghjdtltyysö d Rjcjdj yjxtq. Yfc åhjcfkj d lhjém, yj yt jn öjkjlf b cshjcnb d åeyrtht, ult vs yföjlbkbcm, f jn hfpsuhfditqcz lytv nhfutlbb.18 VFHNF, XTNDTHU

Cktleñobq ltym åsk yfgjkyty yfghzétyysvjéblfybtv – yj xtuj bvtyyj, vs yt pyfkb. Åelenkb yjdst cnjkryjdtybz? Yjhvfkbpetncz kb cbnef-wbz? Cvjétv kb vs lfkmit ébnm b hfåjnfnm rfrhfymit? R cxfcnmñ, ltym änjn ghjitk åtp rfrbö-kbåj gjnhzctybq, gjcrjkmre CLR – yfnjdcrbt cnf-åbkbpfwbjyyst cbks lkz Rjcjdj – djccnfyjdbkbrjynhjkm yfl ujhjljv b ddtkb rjvtylfyncrbq xfc.

Ntv yt vtytt cjjåotybz j lheujv yfphtdfditvd njn dtxth cnjkryjdtybb dsyelbkb CLR gthtdtc-nb dctö vtéleyfhjlysö cjnhelybrjd, hfåjnfñobögj kbybb JÅCT, JJY, EDRÅ b lheubö jhufybpf-wbq, yf åfpe ahfywepcrjuj rjynbyutynf CLR yfñéyjq jrhfbyt Vbnhjdbws.

Jlyfrj, tldf ghbåsd d änjn kfuthm, vs gjlevf-kb, xnj kexit eé åskj jcnfnmcz d ujhjlt, gj-crjkmre chfpe jrfpfkbcm cdbltntkzvb juhjvyjujåeieñotuj gjéfhf, cjghjdjélfditujcz pderfvbdscnhtkjd. Gskfkf lthtdyz Cdbyzht, yföjlbdifz-cz dctuj d jlyjv rbkjvtnht jn vtcnf yfituj hfcgjkjétybz.

Åskj gjljéétyj jrjkj 112 ljvjd rjcjdcrböcthåjd. Rfr gjplytt yfv cjjåobkb ghtlcnfdbntkbCLR, yfctktybt änjq lthtdyb åskj d ärcnhtyyjvgjhzlrt ädfrebhjdfyj ytpfljkuj lj njuj, rfr nelfyf fdnjåecfö ghbåskb gjuhjvobrb.

Ébntkb lthtdyb – d jåotq ckjéyjcnb 119 ctvtq– åskb hfpvtotys d cnjkjdjq ahfywepcrjq åfpsCLR, ult jyb dct dvtcnt gbnfkbcm b cgfkb d dtcm-vf cntcytyysö eckjdbzö. Jyb rjhjnfkb dhtvz, rehz b jåvtybdfzcm vytybzvb j njv, xnj c ybvbåeltn lfkmit, dshféfz lheu lheue cjxedcndbt b

pdjyz hjlcndtyybrfv, yföjlzobvcz d lheubö vtc-nfö rjvgfrnyjuj ghjébdfybz cthåjd.

Vtlktyyj gjlyzkbcm jyb yf uhtåtym öjkvf, djpdsifñotujcz yfl bö lthtdytq, jnrelf bö dpjhejnrhskjcm nj, xtuj jyb åjzkbcm c 1999 ujlf: lthtd-yb Cdbyzht, gjkjdbye yfctktybz rjnjhjq cjcnfd-kzkb fkåfyws, f lheueñ gjkjdbye – cthås, åjkmityt ceotcndjdfkj.

Hfytt vyt eét ljdjlbkjcm pfybvfnmcz uevfyb-nfhyjq gjvjomñ, b z hfåjnfk chtlb ≤dyenhtyytgthtvtotyysö kbw≥, yj z ybrjulf yt pfåele ne ytbpåsdyeñ gtxfkm, jlbyjxtcndj b jnxfzybt, rj-njhst edbltk njq yjxmñd ukfpfö jlyjq cnfhjqétyobys, vjkxf yfåkñ-lfditq pf ntv, rfr eybx-njéfñncz tt yfltéls,vtxns b djcgjvbyfybz.

Jlby bp vjbö rjkktu,ntcyj hfåjnfñobq cjvyjubvb änybxtcrbvbjåobyfvb, åsk ukeåjrjgjnhzcty ghjbpjitl-ibv, rfr, dghjxtv, b dctvs. Dhzl kb vjéyj åskjyfqnb öjnm jlby cthåcrbq yfctktyysq geyrn, rj-njhjuj änb cjåsnbz yt rjcyekbcm. Chtlb eybxnj-étyysö bkb hfpuhfåktyysö plfybq åskb ghfdj-ckfdyst öhfvs, rjnjhst lj änjuj ghjcnjzkb dtrf.

D kfutht vs jcnfdfkbcm d ntxtybt itcnb lytq,yt jnhsdfzcm jn ghbtvybrf b dséblfz, gjrf cb-nefwbz ecgjrjbncz. Ybrnj yt htifkcz ghjbpytcnbänj dckeö, yj d ukeåbyt leib rfélsq bp yfc pyfk,xnj rjulf vs gjrbytv ghtltks yfituj yfltéyjujeåtébof, vs cnjkrytvcz c cjdthityyj bysv Rj-cjdj, ytétkb nj, r rjnjhjve ghbdsrkb.

D lthtdyt Cdbyzht åskj cjéétyj åjktt cnf ljvjd.

Ajnjuhfabb, cltkfyyst d Rjcjdj 17–18 vfhnf,

kñåtpyj ghtljcnfdktys Fahbvjv Öfqhekkföe

bp VJJYR.

≤Vtéleyfhjlyjt cjjåotcndj tlbyj d cdjtv

cnhtvktybb ghtljndhfnbnm gjdnjhtybt gjljåyjuj

yfcbkbz. Yfcbkbt b ytnthgbvjcnm yt cgjcjåcndeñn

ehtuekbhjdfybñ cbnefwbb d Rjcjdj. Yfjåjhjn, jyb

tuj pfnhelyzñn≥.

Pfzdktybt Ltqcndeñotuj ghtlctlfntkz

Cjkjvjyf Gfccb yf dcnhtxt cj cnfhibvb

ljkéyjcnysvb kbwfvb ghfdbntkmcndf Cthåbb

b Xthyjujhbb d Åtkuhflt 24 vfhnf.

Åthyfhl Dhåfy åsk cjnhelybrjv gj djghjcfv ltvjrhf-nbpfwbb CVB d vtcnyjv jnltktybb JVBR d Vbnhjdbwt,infn rjnjhjuj yfcxbnsdftn 60 cjnhelybrjd. Ytlfdyj jygjkexbk yjdjt yfpyfxtybt – yf ljkéyjcnm pfvtcnbntkzghtcc-ctrhtnfhz JVBR.

Page 26: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

26 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

RÄHJKBY VFRREK

≤Xtv ns htfkmyj pfybvfkfcm? Rfr dct änjåskj? Pfxtv ns nelf gjtöfkf?≥ – änbdjghjcs j vjtv ghtåsdfybb d Rjcjdjvyt pflfñn gjcnjzyyj.

Jndtxfz, z gsnfñcm jåüzcybnm: ≤Vs jnghfdkztv-cz d cfvst nhelyst vtcnf yf ptvkt d gjbcrfö yf-ituj jåotxtkjdtxtcrjuj yfxfkf, xnjås yfqnb nj,xnj jåütlbyztn yfc, ytcvjnhz yf hfpdthpibtczvtéle yfvb ghjgfcnb, b xnjås gjvjxm gjcnhjbnm– bkb djccnfyjdbnm – vjcns, rjnjhst erhtgzn yf-ib cdzpb lheu c lheujv≥.

Gjxtve-nj, jlyfrj, rfétncz, xnj kñåst jåüzcyt-ybz pdexfn yteåtlbntkmyj lkz dctö rhjvt ntö, rnjcfv gjåsdfk bkb dct tot yföjlbncz nfv b, cfvjtukfdyjt, rnj åeltn yföjlbnmcz nfv dctulf.

Yj dtlm ytkmpz ghjcnj jnltkfnmcz jnujdjhrjq,xnj änj yf cfvjv ltkt jxtym nhelyj jgbcfnm ckj-dfvb, yt nfr kb?

Djpvjéyj, bvtyyj gjänjve z b cjukfcbkfcm ghbyznm exfcnbt d jhufybpjdfyysö Yfwbjyfkmysvrbytvfnjuhfabxtcrbv cjdtnjv Rfyfls cütvrföabkmvf ≤Rjcjdj: öhegrbq vbh≥. Kñlb yf hjlbytyt njkmrj bvtñn ghfdj pyfnm, xtv vs pfybvftvczd JÅCT b gjxtve; lkz njuj xnjås yfif hfåjnfvjukf ghjljkéfnmcz b dghtlm, jyb nfrét ljkéysyfexbnmcz gjybvfnm tt, – f byjulf phbntkmyst jåhfps vjuen åsnm ujhfplj åjktt ljöjlxbdsvb,xtv kñåfz ktrwbz bkb ljrkfl.

Yfi abkmv gjcdzoty ghjdjlbdibvcz d 2001 uj-le gthdsv dsåjhfv d wtynhfkmyst jhufys dkfcnbRjcjdj. D nj dhtvz z åskf lbhtrnjhjv jnltkf lt-vjrhfnbpfwbb d Vbccbb JÅCT d Rjcjdj (JVBR), f vjz ljxm Rtqn Jléf ghbtöfkf nelf rj vyt yfitcnm vtczwtd.

D abkmvt nfrét hfccrfpsdftncz jåj vyt b Rtqn,öjnz htibnmcz yf änj yfv åskj ytkturj. VjqhtCbvgcjy, rbytvfnjuhfabcnrt bp Dfyredthf, b yf-ibv lhepmzv bp Yfwbjyfkmyjuj rbytvfnjuhfab-xtcrjuj cjdtnf ghbikjcm eåtélfnm yfc d njv, xnjabkmve yeéyj ghblfnm kbxyjcnysq hfrehc lkzkexituj tuj djcghbznbz ibhjrjq rfyflcrjq geå-

kbrjq, rjnjhfz yt nfr öjhjij pyfrjvf c åfkrfy-crbvb ghjåktvfvb, rfr tdhjgtqcrbt phbntkb.

Ghtvmthf änjuj jlyjxfcjdjuj abkmvf cjcnjz-kfcm d 2003 ujle jlyjdhtvtyyj d ytcrjkmrbö rf-yflcrbö ujhjlfö. Jhufybpfnjhjv tuj gjrfpf d Jnnfdt, yf rjnjhsq ghbikj ghbvthyj 450 xtkjdtr– åjkmit, xtv vjukj gjvtcnbnmcz d pfkt, cnfk vjqhfåjnjlfntkm – Dctvbhyfz eybdthcbntncrfz ckeé-åf Rfyfls (DECR). D lfkmytqitv DECR jhufybpj-dfkf ghjrfn änjuj abkmvf xthtp cdjñ ibhjreñctnm eybdthcbntnjd. Rhjvt njuj, ghjdjlbkbcm tujgjrfps d öjlt cgtwbfkmysö vthjghbznbq, nfrbö,rfr rbyjatcnbdfkm, ghjitlibq gjl äubljq ≤Vté-leyfhjlyjq fvybcnbb≥.≤CKBIRJV GJPBNBDYJ≥

Jnpsds d cdjtq gjlfdkzñotq vfcct åskb gjkj-ébntkmysvb, pf jlybv bynthtcysv bcrkñxtybtv:d hzlt ckexftd gjckt jåceéltybz abkmvf, ghjdj-lbditujcz dcktl pf ghjcvjnhjv, rj vyt gj jnltkm-yjcnb gjlöjlbkb rfyflws fkåfycrjuj b cthåcrjujghjbcöjéltybz b ujdjhbkb, xnj vs d cdjtv abkm-vt gjrfpfkb lheueñ jåobye d ≤ckbirjv gjpbnbd-yjv≥ cdtnt.

Rjytxyj ét, yföjéltybt ghfdbkmyjuj åfkfycfåskj jlyjq bp cfvsö åjkmibö nhelyjcntq, c rjnj-hsvb vs cnjkryekbcm, cybvfz änjn abkmv, b vsyt ghtntyljdfkb yb yf cjdthitycndj, yb lfét yfghjcneñ velhjcnm. Ghtélt dctuj vs levfkb jcktleñotv: pflfxf cjnhelybrf kñåjq vbccbb cj-cnjbn d njv, xnjås gjcnfhfnmcz gjyznm dct jåob-ys, jcjåtyyj nt, vtéle rjnjhsvb bvtk vtcnj dj-jheétyysq rjyakbrn, b ckeébnm bö bynthtcfv.

Vyjujt jcnfkjcm d abkmvt pf rflhjv. Nfr, d ytvyt yfitk jnhfétybz vjq jgsn hfåjns d rfxtcndtlbhtrnjhf jnltkf JÅCT gj Vbnhjdbwrjve hfqjyec fduecnf 1999 gj ltrfåhm 2000 ujlf – ghjåtk ju-hjvysq, exbnsdfz ne hjkm, rjnjheñ ujhjl b hfq-jy csuhfkb yf hfyytv änfgt gjcnrjakbrnyjuj gthbjlf.

Rhjvt njuj, ljkéyf xtcnyj ghbpyfnmcz, ytn d abkmvt b yfvtrf yf nj, xnj ghjbcöjlbkj ≤d re-kefhfö≥ Vbccbb JÅCT d Rjcjdj, åelm nj dj dyen-htyytv gkfyt bkb d jnyjitybb åjktt xfcnysö b rjyabltywbfkmysö fcgtrnjd yfitq hfåjns chfpkbxysvb uheggfvb yfctktybz Rjcjdj.

LTVJRHFNBPFWBZ

Dbpefkmystjåhfps RjcjdjLjdjlz njxre phtybz JÅCT ljphbntktq yf hjlbyt

Page 27: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 27

Yfrjytw, abkmv pfrfyxbdftncz jåüzdktybtv bnjujd dsåjhjd byt rfcftncz elbdbntkmyj bynthtcyjq, ckjéyjq b ävjwbjyfkmyjyfcsotyyjq caths ghfrnbxtcrjuj htitybz gjdctlytdysö fl-vbybcnhfnbdyj-eghfdktyxtcrbö djghjcjd. Åsdibt rjkktub, rj-njhst, rfr b z, öjhjij gjvyzn njn djkybntkmysq vjhjpysqltym d yjzåht 2001 ujlf, pyfñn, yfcrjkmrj ceotcndtyty änjnghjåtk, gjcrjkmre nj åsk ltym, rjulf gjåtlbdibt yf xtcnysödsåjhfö ghtlcnfdbntkb dctö jåoby Rjcjdj dgthdst cjåhfkbcmd Ghbinbyt dct dvtcnt gjl jlyjq rhsitq.

Yj rfr ås nj yb åskj, kñåjq abkmv ljkéty bvtnm yfxfkj brjytw, b ytbpåtéyj yfcnegftn vjvtyn, rjulf rbytvfnjuhfabcnsgj pfdthitybb cütvjr ljkéys jnghfdbnmcz ljvjq, xnjås yf-xfnm lkbntkmysq b nhelysq ndjhxtcrbq ghjwtcc vjynféf. E yfcyf änj eitk gjxnb wtksq ujl, b htpekmnfnjv cnfk abkmv ≤Rjcj-

dj: öhegrbq vbh≥.YFCKTLBT VBHJCNHJBNTKMCNDF

Rfyflws c jcjåsv edfétybtv jnyjczncz r vbhjcnhjbntkmcn-de. Yt vyjubv pf ghtltkfvb yfitq cnhfys bpdtcnty njn afrn,xnj rfyflcrbq lbgkjvfn b ujcelfhcndtyysq ltzntkm Ktcnth Å.Gbhcjy, d lfkmytqitv cnfdibq ghtvmth-vbybcnhjv, d 1957 ujleåsk yfuhfélty Yjåtktdcrjq ghtvbtq vbhf pf nj, xnj dscnegbkbybwbfnjhjv yfghfdktybz cbk JJY d pjye Ceäwrjuj rfyfkf,xnjås ≤gjneibnm≥ djjheétyysq rjyakbrn, dcgsöyedibq vté-le Tubgnjv b Bphfbktv. Nfrbv jåhfpjv åskj gjkjétyj yfxfkjcjdhtvtyyjq ghfrnbrt vbhjndjhxtcndf, f d gjcktleñotv b vb-hjcnhjbntkmcndf.

Yf vjq dpukzl, rfyflws, exfcndeñobt d ≤gjktdsö≥ jgthfwbzö,cnfhfñncz åsnm yf dscjnt änjuj bcnjhbxtcrjuj yfcktlbz. Kbxyj

lkz vtyz åskj åjkmijq xtcnmñ ltkfnm änj d hfvrfö JÅCT – ht-ubjyfkmyjq jhufybpfwbb, ghbpdfyyjq cgjcjåcndjdfnm endthélt-ybñ dscibö bltfkjd åtpjgfcyjcnb b cjnhelybxtcndf vtélecnhfyfvb b yfhjlfvb. Tckb e vtyz b tcnm rfrjt-nj gjétkfybt rrjkktufv gj JÅCT, åelm nj d yfwbjyfkmysö ltktufwbzö, Ctrht-nfhbfnt, bycnbnenfö bkb d vbccbzö yf vtcnfö, nj jyj pfrkñxf-tncz d cktleñotv: yfqlbnt, gjéfkeqcnf, cgjcjå jåüzcybnm cdj-bv cjjntxtcndtyybrfv, d xtv cjcnjbn cenm JÅCT. Gjcnfhfqntcmcltkfnm änj ébdj b ljöjlxbdj, xnjås jyb gjkexbkb htfkmyjtghtlcnfdktybt. Jcjåtyyj d yfib lyb, öfhfrnthbpeñobtcz cjv-ytybzvb b genfybwtq d njv, xnj rfcftncz öfhfrnthf ecbkbq gjbycnbnewbjyfkmyjve cnhjbntkmcnde b ltvjrhfnbpfwbb d cfvjvibhjrjv cvsckt änjuj ckjdf, dct vs ljkéys cxbnfnm ctåz kbx-yj jndtncndtyysvb pf jrfpfybt gjllthérb ntv, rnj ljrfpfkcdjñ cgjcjåyjcnm htifnm ghfrnbxtcrbt pflfxb d änjq jåkfcnb.JÅCT – jlyf bp jhufybpfwbq, rjnjhst htfkmyj dkbzñn yf gjkj-étybt dtotq. Ltkfqnt lkz ytt dct, xnj vjétnt, b ntv cfvsv dsåeltnt ltkfnm änj lkz ntö, rjve jyf ckeébn.Rähjkby Vfrrek, ñhbcn, cgtwbfkbpbheñofzcz yf djghjcfö gjvjob åtétywfv, ébkf b hfåjnfkf d Rjcjdj c fduecnf 1999 ujlfgj ctynzåhm 2002 ujlf. Jyf jlyf bp ghbvthyj 150 rfyflcrbö uhfélfycrbö ärcgthnjd, rjnjhst åskb yfghfdktys d Ñuj-Djcnjx-yeñ Tdhjge d hfvrfö ghjtrnf gj rjvfylbhjdfybñ yf Åfkrfysuhfélfycrbö cgtwbfkbcnjd, jceotcndkztvjuj gjl herjdjlcndjvDctvbhyjq eybdthcbntncrjq ckeéås Rfyfls b abyfycbhetvjuj Rfyflcrbv futyncndjv vtéleyfhjlyjuj hfpdbnbz. Ctqxfc jyf yf-öjlbncz d rjvfylbhjdrt d Faufybcnfyt c wtkmñ bpextybz djghj-cjd, rfcfñoböcz c dsåjhjd.

Rfr cjplfdfkcz abkmv ≤Rjcjdj: öhegrbq vbh≥VJQHF CBVGCJY

Dbñyt 2001 ujlf rj vyt jåhfnbkfcm éehyfkbcnrf,fdnjh hzlf ljrevtynfkmysö abkmvjd, c djghjcjvj njv, yt öjntkf ås kb z cyznm abkmv j tt gjlhe-

ut, Rähjkby Vfrrek, rjnjhfz åskf ≤lbhtrnjhjv gj dj-ghjcfv ltvjrhfnbpfwbb≥ d gjcnrjyakbrnyjv Rjcjdj. Z nen ét pfikf yf dtå-cfqn JÅCT b epyfkf, xnj Jhufyb-pfwbz gj åtpjgfcyjcnb b cjnhelybxtcnde d Tdhjgt –rhegytqifz htubjyfkmyfz jhufybpfwbz d vbht, pfyb-vfñofzcz djghjcfvb åtpjgfcyjcnb.

Nfr lkz vtyz yfxfkcz xhtpdsxfqyj bynthtcysq ujl.Vtyz edktrkf djpvjéyjcnm cnfnm jxtdblwtv cjåsnbq,ghjbcöjlzobö d gjcnrjyakbrnyjv jåotcndt. Lj änjuj z30 ktn cybvfkf ljrevtynfkmyst abkmvs yf cjwbfkmyj-gjkbnbxtcrbt ntvs, yj yb hfpe yt ltkfkf änjuj d cnhfyt,gjcnhflfditq jn djqys. Rfr b åjkmibycndj lheubö rf-yflwtd z ujhlbkfcm htgenfwbtq, rjnjheñ Rfyflf pfdjt-dfkf, jrfpsdfz gjvjom ≤ghjåktvysv≥ htubjyfv vbhf,yj z ybrjulf gj-yfcnjzotve yt gjybvfkf pyfxtybz nfrbönthvbyjd rfr ≤ltvjrhfnbpfwbz≥ b ≤ujcelfhcndtyyjtcnhjbntkmcndj≥.

D ghjwtcct bpextybz ntvs gthtl cütvrfvb abkmvf zepyfkf j ceotcndjdfybb ytljdjkmcndf d jnyjitybb byj-cnhfyysö vbccbq. D xfcnyjcnb, z ghjxbnfkf cnfnmñ jlyj-uj bp hfåjnybrjd, pfybvfñoböcz uevfybnfhyjq gjvjomñd Åtqhent, ult endthélfkjcm, xnj ≤jcdjåjlbntkb≥ ght-dhfnbkbcm d ≤jrregfynjd≥. Jlyf bp vjbö gjlheu, rjnjhjqjlyféls ljdtkjcm ébnm d gjcnrjyakbrnyjv jåotcndt, bc-

gsnsdftn crtgnbwbpv d jnyjitybb vjnbdjd, rjnjhsvb he-rjdjlcndeñncz ytrjnjhst bp vtéleyfhjlysö cjnhelyb-rjd, rjnjhsö jyf yfpsdftn ≤yjdst vbccbjyths≥.

Cnhtvzcm epyfnm cfvjq, xnj bp ctåz ghtlcnfdkztnvtéleyfhjlyfz vbccbz gj vbhjcnhjbntkmcnde, b bpexbnm

Page 28: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

28 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

ytrjnjhst bp cdzpfyysö c änbv ckjéytqibö ghjåktv, z xthtp ytcrjkmrj vtczwtd gjckt yfitq c Rähjkby gth-djq rhfnrjq dcnhtxb d Dfyredtht gjktntkf d Rjcjdj. D Ghbinbye z ghbåskf jlyf – bvtz ghb ctåt ctvm xtvj-lfyjd c rbyjjåjheljdfybtv – d rfxtcndt lbhtrnjhf,cwtyfhbcnf, rbyjjgthfnjhf b pderjhtébccthf d jlyjvkbwt.

20-ktnyzz ljxm Rähjkby, Rtqn, rjnjhfz njulf dhtvty-yj ujcnbkf d Rjcjdj e cdjtq vfvs, gjvjufkf vyt cjpderjpfgbcmñ. C gjvjomñ cjåcndtyysq rfvths jyf cyzkf dbltjéehyfk, ahfuvtyns rjnjhjuj åskb d öjltgjcktleñotuj vjynféf drkñxtys d abkmv. Hfåjnfz gf-hfkktkmyj c Rähjkby, yj yf ehjdyt hzljdsö uhfélfy,Rtqn exfcndjdfkf d jhufybpfwbb abyfycbhetvjuj JÅCTgthtldbéyjuj vepsrfkmyjuj ije, ghbpdfyyjuj cgjcjåcn-djdfnm vjåbkbpfwbb yfctktybz yf exfcnbt d ghtlcnjz-obö dsåjhfö. Åkfujlfhz änjve ghjtrne Rtqn åkbprj gjl-heébkfcm c lheubvb vjkjlsvb kñlmvb, rfr fkåfywfvb,nfr b cthåfvb.

D ntxtybt cdjtuj ldeövtczxyjuj ghtåsdfybz d Rjcjdjz bcgsnsdfkf dct nt ljcflyst åsnjdst yteljåcndf, crjnjhsvb cnfkrbdftncz kñåjq, rnj ébdtn d vtcnt, ult yt hfåjnftn byahfcnhernehf. Yj ukfdyst vjb pfåjnsåskb cdzpfys c abkmvjv. E vtyz ckjvfkfcm rfvthf, bgjcrjkmre nfv yt åskj yb htvjynysö fntkmt, yb ghjrfn-ysö geyrnjd, z åskf dsyeéltyf cybvfnm åjkmieñ xfcnmabkmvf ltitdjq pfgfcyjq rfvthjq.ÅJKTT IBHJRJT GJDTCNDJDFYBT

Vyt ghbikjcm ghfrnbxtcrb gjdcñle nfcrfnm cdjt nzétkjt jåjheljdfybt yf ctåt, nfr rfr z yt vjukf gj-pdjybnm b dspdfnm nfrcb, xnjås vtyz pfåhfkb, gjcrjkmregjckt rjyakbrnf ewtktkj jxtym vfkj nfåkbxtr c yjvt-hfvb ljvjd b yfpdfybzvb ekbw. Cnjbkj vyt ecnfyjdbnmjcdtnbntkmyjt jåjheljdfybt lkz cütvrb njuj bkb byjujcñétnf, rfr nen ét jåzpfntkmyj jnrkñxfkjcm äktrnhbxt-cndj; d htpekmnfnt rfhlbyfkmyj gjdscbkjcm vjt evtybtcybvfnm ghb cdtnt cdtxtq. Ytcrjkmrj hfp ghtlcnfdbntkbCLR rjyabcrjdfkb vjb gktyrb bp-pf njuj, xnj z cybvfkfd ≤pfghtnysö pjyfö≥, ghj rjnjhst z yt vjukf b gj-levfnm, xnj jyb cxbnfñncz jgfcysvb.

C cfvjuj yfxfkf z bcöjlbkf bp njuj, xnj chjr vjtujghtåsdfybz d Rjcjdj åeltn ckbirjv rjhjnrbv, xnjås z vjukf ljcnjdthyj hfccrfpfnm j gjkjétybb tuj yfct-ktybz, åelm nj c njxrb phtybz fkåfywtd bkb cthåjd. Gjänjve wtynhfkmyjq cñétnyjq kbybtq abkmvf ljkéyfåskf cnfnm bcnjhbz Rähjkby b Rtqn.

D nj ét dhtvz vyt öjntkjcm, xnjås abkmv åsk yfcs-oty rjkjhbnjv änjuj rhfz, yfctkzñobö tuj yfhjljd b rekmnehs gjcnrjyakbrnyjuj Rjcjdj. Vyt åskj dféyjxthtp hfccrfp j gthdsö d bcnjhbb Rjcjdj dsåjhfö dwtynhfkmyst jhufys dkfcnb gjrfpfnm öhegrjcnm ecnfyj-dbditujcz d Rjcjdj vbhf b ezpdbvjcnm pfhjélfñotqcznfv ltvjrhfnbb. Vjz wtkm pfrkñxfkfcm d njv, xnjåsdgktcnb ybnm hfccrfpf j vfnthb c ljxrjq d nrfym ujhfp-lj åjktt ibhjrjuj gjdtcndjdfybz.

Nhelytt dctuj åskj gjrfpfnm d abkmvt hfpkbxyst yfctkzñobt Rjcjdj änybxtcrbt uheggs nfrbv jåhfpjv,xnjås rfélfz bp ybö djcghbyzkf cdjt jnjåhfétybt dabkmvt rfr xtcnyjt b cghfdtlkbdjt, ytcvjnhz yf étcnj-rjcnb ytlfdytuj rjyakbrnf b tuj gjcktlcndbz. Pltcm ytvjukj åsnm eghjotyysö cwtyfhbtd c ltktybtv dctö yfgkjöbö b öjhjibö. Änj rfcfkjcm b vtéleyfhjlyjuj cjjå-

otcndf. Z öjntkf gjrfpfnm ktubnbvyjcnm vbhjcnhjbntkm-ysö ghjtrnjd, ghbpyfd d nj ét dhtvz jåjcyjdfyyjcnm dscrfpsdftvjq d bö flhtc rhbnbrb.

Rfélsq ltym cütvjr yfxbyfkcz jlbyfrjdj. Z ghböjlbkfcj cdjbv cyfhzétybtv d jnltktybt JÅCT, gjregfz gj ljhjut ujhzxbq zåkjxysq gbhjéjr. Ghb änjv z dczrbq hfpc ytbpvtyyjq jcnhjnjq bcgsnsdfkf ijr b åjkm ghb dblthfpåjvåktyysö b cujhtdibö ljnkf plfybq d hfqjyt, cnfd-itv dhtvtyysv vtcnjv vjtuj jåbnfybz.

Ghblz d JÅCT, z yfvtxfkf lkz ctåt gkfy ltqcndbq yfltym. Jy vju drkñxfnm, yfghbvth, gjctotybt c rtv-kbåjbp cjnhelybrjd JÅCT njuj bkb byjuj cthåcrjuj fyrkfdf,ghbcencndbt yf ghtldsåjhyjv cjåhfybb wsufycrjq jå-obys, exfcnbt d jhufybpjdfyyjq ahfywepcrbvb vbhjn-djhwfvb bp CLR gjtplrt gj vtcnfv, d rjnjhsö cütvrfhfphtiftncz njkmrj d cjghjdjéltybb djtyysö, bkb étytghbyeéltyyjt jåotybt c Rtqn b tt lhepmzvb, lfdfd-itt djpvjéyjcnm gjcvjnhtnm yf yfghzétyyeñ gjcnrjy-akbrnyeñ cbnefwbñ bö ukfpfvb.GHJRKFLSDFZ GENM

Rjulf yfv elfdfkjcm dsrhjbnm dhtvz, Åtrbv, kñåtp-ysq djlbntkm Rähjkby, djpbk vtyz gj ujhjlfv b ctkfvRjcjdj. Bp jryf fdnjvjåbkz z cybvfkf jåhfvkzdibt lj-hjue gfvznybrb djqys, dyjdm jncnhfbdftvst ljvf, cnfbåtpljvysö cjåfr, ltntq, bleobö d irjke, ghjyjczobtczvbvj rjydjb CLR, cnfhst b héfdst ctkmcrjöjpzqcndty-yst vfibys yf ljhjut, bp-pf rjnjhsö crjhjcnm ldbétybzcybéfkfcm lj xthtgfimtq, b dshbcjdsdfdibtcz yf ujhb-pjynt cbkeäns vtxtntq.

Rähjkby åskf lkz vtyz gjcnjzyysv bcnjxybrjv yjdjc-ntq. Åkfujlfhz tétlytdysv rjhjnrbv hfpujdjhfv c ytq zdctulf åskf d rehct cfvsö gjcktlybö cjåsnbq. Z bcgjkm-pjdfkf kñåeñ djpvjéyjcnm cyznm tt pf hfåjnjq. Cnht-vzcm gjvjxm d gjcnhjtybb gjkbänybxtcrjuj jåotcndf,Rähjkby cnfhfkfcm djdktxm d bpåbhfntkmysq ghjwtcc rfrfkåfywtd, nfr b cthåjd. Z vyjujt epyfkf j djpvjéyjcnzövbhjcnhjbntkmcndf, yfåkñlfz pf ntv, c rfrjq xenrjcnmñb cjgthtébdfybtv jyf gjvjuftn gjcnhflfditve jn djq-ys yfhjle ghjkjébnm genm d åeleott.

D öjlt hfåjns gjckt djpdhfotybz d Rfyfle yf gjkeyfitq vjynféyjq rjvyfns jcnfkbcm, rfr änj ghbyznj ujdjhbnm, rbkjvtnhs jncyznjq gktyrb, ärdbdfktynyjq 80 xfcfv ärhfyyjuj dhtvtyb. Jnjåhfyysq d rjytxyjvbnjut vfnthbfk ghtlcnfdkzk cjåjq rdbynäcctywbñ dctujjncyznjuj. Ghjwtcc dshtpfybz bp rfhnbys hfccrfpjd kñ-ltq, c rjnjhsvb vtyz cdtkf celmåf b rjnjhsö z gjkñåb-kf, åsk yfcnjkmrj vexbntkmysv, xnj kbim gj ghjitcndbbrfrjuj-nj dhtvtyb z yfxfkf jcjpyfdfnm, xtuj yfv elf-kjcm ljcnbxm änbv abkmvjv, dvtcnj njuj xnjås ujhtdfnmgj gjdjle njuj, xnj d ytuj yt gjgfkj.

Rähjkby, Rtqn b dct, c rtv vyt ljdtkjcm gjpyfrj-vbnmcz dj dhtvz änjq gjtplrb, jnrhjdtyyj ltkbkbcm cjvyjq cdjbvb jgsnjv, vsckzvb b kñåjdmñ r Rjcjdj. Yf-ltñcm, xnj jghfdlfkf bö ljdthbt. B cfvf z njét gjkñ-åbkf änjn rhfq.

Vjqhf Cbvgcjy, ytpfdbcbvsq rbyjhtébccth b jgthfnjh-gjcnfyjdobr, kfehtfn hfpkbxysö ghtvbq, gjcnjzyyj ghjébdftnd Dfyredtht. Ctqxfc jyf cybvftn ljrevtynfkmysq abkmv jåjhmåt vecekmvfycrbö étyoby Rfyfls pf cdjb ghfdf.

Vjqhf Cbvgcjy pf hfåjnjq d Rjcjdj.

Page 29: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 29

VBÖFBK TDCNFAMTD

14vfhnf, rjulf vs eét yföjlbkbcm d cj-abqcrjv fähjgjhne, cnfkj jxtdblyj,xnj cjåsnbz, j rjnjhsö cjjåofkjcm dcfvsö gjcktlybö dsgecrfö yjdjcntq,

nhtåeñn dytctybz rfhlbyfkmysö bpvtytybq d ghj-uhfvve gthdjuj änfgf yfitq gjtplrb yf Rfdrfp.Dscjrfz yfghzétyyjcnm, ceotcndjdfdifz lj änjujd jnyjitybzö vtéle yjdsv uhepbycrbv herjdjlcn-djv b ukfdjq Fléfhcrjq Fdnjyjvyjq HtcgeåkbrbFckfyjv Fåfiblpt, gththjckf d jnrhsnjt ghjnb-djcnjzybt, euhjéfditt cnfåbkmyjcnb cnhfys.

NÅBKBCB, UHEPBZ: 14–15 VFHNF

Dcrjht gjckt ghbptvktybz d Nåbkbcb vs epyf-kb j njv, xnj uhepbycrjt ghfdbntkmcndj d gjkyjvcjcnfdt dstöfkj d yföjlzobqcz yf pfgflt cnhfysgjhnjdsq ujhjl Gjnb, xnjås dvtcnt c ghtpblty-njv Vböfbkjv Cffrfidbkb ghbyznm exfcnbt därcnhtyysö gthtujdjhfö gj gjdjle djpybritujrhbpbcf. Chfpe ét jabwbfkmyfz ghjuhfvvf dbpbnfGhtlctlfntkmcndf JÅCT ≤gjktntkf d rjhpbye≥:Ltqcndeñobq ghtlctlfntkm (LG) htibk yfghf-dbnmcz d Gjnb yf dcnhtxe c ghtpbltynjv.

Herjdjlbntkm Vbccbb JÅCT d Uhepbb gjcjk HjqHbd lfk rjvfyle ärbgféfv dthnjktnjd Vbccbb yf-öjlbnmcz d gjcnjzyyjq ujnjdyjcnb. Jy nfrét hfc-gjhzlbkcz j njv, xnjås fdnjvjåbkb Vbccbb ds-töfkb yf hfccdtnt d Gjnb, c ntv xnjås ltktufwbzJÅCT vjukf bvb djcgjkmpjdfnmcz, tckb åeltn ghb-yznj htitybt djpdhfofnmcz yf fdnjnhfycgjhnt.

Jlyfrj ytktnyfz gjujlf yf hfccdtnt 15 vfhnf yt gjpdjkbkf djcgjkmpjdfnmcz dthnjktnfvb; d njétdhtvz djlbntkzv JÅCT åskj lfyj erfpfybt hfp-dthyenm cdjb vfibys, gjcrjkmre bp-pf uecnjuj ne-vfyf yf ghjöjlzotq xthtp pfcytétyysq ujhysqgthtdfk ljhjut crjhjcnm ldbétybz egfkf ghfrnb-xtcrb lj yekz. Ddble njuj, xnj d änbö gjujlysöeckjdbzö cfvjktn vbybcnhf – NE-154 – yt cvju åsghbptvkbnmcz d fähjgjhne Gjnb, åsk cgtwbfkmyjfhtyljdfy åjktt kturbq cfvjktn.

D Gjnb Ltqcndeñobq ghtlctlfntkm ghbpdfkghtpbltynf Cffrfidbkb djpjåyjdbnm lbfkju cfléfhcrbv herjdjlcndjv, xnjås gjgsnfnmcz cyznmyfghzétyyjcnm djrheu Fléfhbb. Uhepbycrbq herj-djlbntkm pfdthbk tuj, xnj cbkf ghbvtytyf yt åeltnb xnj jy ghtlkjébn u-ye Fåfiblpt dcnhtnbnmcz dnjn ét ltym lkz ghjdtltybz gthtujdjhjd.

Vbybcnh byjcnhfyysö ltk Gfccb chfpe ét gj-pdjybk u-ye Fåfiblpt b yfcnjzntkmyj ghbpdfk tujghbyznm änj ghtlkjétybt j dcnhtxt d bynthtcföehtuekbhjdfybz hfpyjukfcbq vbhysv gentv.

Geåkbxyj jåhfnbdibcm r jåtbv cnjhjyfv cghbpsdjv ghjzdkznm clthéfyyjcnm, LG lfk zcyjgjyznm, xnj JÅCT cltkftn dct djpvjéyjt, xnjåspfobnbnm nthhbnjhbfkmyeñ wtkjcnyjcnm cnhfys.≤Vs ghbdthétys ltke endthéltybz ltvjrhfnbb d Uhepbb b åeltv yfghzétyyj nhelbnmcz, xnjåsjåtcgtxbnm yfctktybñ änjuj htubjyf vbhyjt åeleott≥, – pfzdbk jy.

Nf ét vsckm åskf dscrfpfyf yf dcnhtxfö C. Gfccb c ghtvmth-vbybcnhjv Pehfåjv Édfybz,b.j. vbybcnhf byjcnhfyysö ltk Lfdbljv Fgnbcfehbb Rfnjkbrjcjv-Gfnhbfhöjv dctz Uhepbb Bkbtq ÈÈ.

Gjckt cdjtuj jnütplf bp Uhepbb LG gjllthéb-dfk rjynfrn c ghtpbltynjv Cffrfidbkb gj ntkt-ajye. D rjywt rjywjd, 19 vfhnf cjcnjzkfcm dcnht-xf uhepbycrjuj ghtpbltynf c kblthjv Fléfhbb, dhtpekmnfnt rjnjhjq cnjhjys ghbikb r cjukfcbñ.

≤Änj, ytcjvytyyj, vjétn hfccvfnhbdfnmcz rfrdtcmvf gjpbnbdyjt lkz dctuj htubjyf cjåsnbt, –pfzdbk gjplytt LG, ghbdtncndez äne dtcnm. – Gentvgthtujdjhjd elfkjcm hfphzlbnm yfghzétyyjcnm.Jckfåktybt yfghzétyyjcnb d Uhepbb åeltn cgj-cjåcndjdfnm ghjdtltybñ cdjåjlysö b xtcnysögfhkfvtyncrbö dsåjhjd≥.

ÅJKUFHCRJT GHTLCTLFNTKMCNDJ, 2004 UJL

Yfvtxfz rehcåtcrjyakbrnyjujhfpdbnbz RfdrfpfPfvtnrb j gjtplrt c Ltqcndeñobv ghtlctlfntktv

Ytjéblfyyjt jåjcnhtybt cbnefwbb d Uhepbb d vfhnt, rfrhfp d njn vjvtyn, rjulf Ltqcndeñobq ghtlctlfntkm JÅCT,vbybcnh byjcnhfyysö ltk Åjkufhbb Cjkjvjy Gfccb cjåb-hfkcz yfxfnm cdjñ lfdyj gkfybhjdfdieñcz gjtplre yf Ñéysq Rfdrfp, dytckj d gjcktlyññ vbyene rjhhtrnbds dtuj ghjuhfvve. Ybcrjkmrj änbv yt jåtcrehfétyyst, jy btuj rjvfylf ärcghjvnjv dscnegbkb d hjkb gjchtlybrjd,gjvjufz hfphzlbnm rhbpbcyeñ jåcnfyjdre.

Wthrjdm d Nåbkbcb, Uhepbz

CT

/VB

ÖF

BK

TD

CN

FA

MT

D

Page 30: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

30 Éehyfk JÅCT Vfq 2004 ujlf

ÅFRE, FPTHÅFQLÉFY:

15–16 VFHNF

Gjplyj dtxthjv vs dvtcnt c vbybcnhjv jnghfdbkbcm yf tuj cfvjktnt lfktt gj vfhihene.

Cktleñobq ltym, rjnjhsq LGghjdtk d Åfre, ghjöjlbk gj cnjkmét yfghzétyyjve uhfabre.

E C. Gfccb cjcnjzkfcm ghjljk-ébntkmyfz dcnhtxf c ghtpbltynjvFpthåfqléfyf Bkmöfvjv Fkbtdsv,f nfrét gthtujdjhs c ghtvmth-vb-ybcnhjv cnhfys Fhnehjv Hfcbpf-lt, cgbrthjv gfhkfvtynf Vehne-pjv Fktcrthjdsv b vbybcnhjv

byjcnhfyysö ltk Dbkfznjv Uekbtdsv.LG ghbpdfk r ghjljkétybñ lbfkjuf j gjkbnb-

xtcrjv ehtuekbhjdfybb yfujhyjrfhfåföcrjuj rjy-akbrnf åtp rfrbö-kbåj ghtldfhbntkmysö eckjdbq.

≤JÅCT dctulf ujnjdf dscnegbnm d hjkb cjltqcn-deñotq cnjhjys. Vs vjétv ghtlkjébnm vyjétcn-dj hfpkbxysö cwtyfhbtd ehtuekbhjdfybz rjyakbr-nf, yj dct änj åeltn kbim evjphbntkmyfz hfåjnf, lj ntö gjh gjrf Fpthåfqléfy b Fhvtybz yt ljcnbuyencjukfcbz pf cnjkjv gthtujdjhjd, – pfzdbk jy. –JÅCT yt vjétn cjndjhbnm xelf bkb yfdzpfnm rfrjt-kbåj ujnjdjt htitybt. Rfr gjrfpsdftn bcnjhbxtc-rbq jgsn, d njv, xnj rfcftncz rjyakbrnjd, dhtvzdctulf hfåjnftn ghjnbd yfc≥.

Vbybcnh nfrét lfk zcyj gjyznm, xnj Vbycrfzuheggf JÅCT, – cjghtlctlfntkzvb rjnjhjq zdkzñn-cz Ahfywbz, Hjccbqcrfz Atlthfwbz b CjtlbytyystInfns – f nfrét kbxysq ghtlcnfdbntkm Ltqcndeñ-otuj ghtlctlfntkz JÅCT gj rjyakbrne, zdkzñot-vecz ghtlvtnjv hfccvjnhtybz yf Vbycrjq rjyat-htywbb JÅCT, gjcjk Fylétq Rfcgibr, ltkfñn dct,xnjås gjvjxm ehtuekbhjdfnm rjyakbrn.

LG dshfpbk yfltéle yf nj, xnj jåhfpjdfybt, jl-yj bp ghbjhbntnysö yfghfdktybq hfåjns åjkufh-crjuj Ghtlctlfntkmcndf JÅCT, csuhftn cdjñ hjkm dhfphtitybb yfujhyjrfhfåföcrjuj rjyakbrnf. ≤Vsljkéys ≤bydtcnbhjdfnm≥ d jåhfpjdfybt cktleñot-uj gjrjktybz≥, – pfzdbk jy, gjlxthryed dféyjcnmghtljcnfdktybz vjkjltéb ljcnegf r afrnbxtcrbnjxysv b jåütrnbdysv rybufv gj bcnjhbb.

≤Tckb vs gjpdjkbkb ddtcnb yfibö ltntq d pf-åkeéltybt ghjgfufyljq, nj dhzl kb cktleñott

gjrjktybt cvjétn åsnm jåütrnbd-ysv b pfåsnm j cnfhsö hfyfö≥.

Ghjuhfvvf dbpbnf d Åfre nfrétdrkñxfkf ytjabwbfkmyst dcnhtxbc kblthfvb jggjpbwbb b ghtlcnf-dbntkzvb ytghfdbntkmcndtyysöjhufybpfwbq, dscrfpsdfdibvbjpfåjxtyyjcnm gj nfrbv djghjcfv,rfr ghfdf xtkjdtrf, dsåjhs b cdj-åjlf ghtccs.

THTDFY, FHVTYBZ: 16–17

VFHNF

Yfujhyjrfhfåföcrbq rjyakbrnåsk wtynhfkmyjq ntvjq jåceélt-ybz b yf cktleñobq ltym, rjulf

LG dcnhtxfkcz c ghtpbltynjv Fhvtybb HjåthnjvRjxfhzyjv, ghtvmth-vbybcnhjv Fylhfybrjv Vfh-ufhzyjv, vbybcnhjv byjcnhfyysö ltk DfhlfyjvJcrfyzyjv b Rfnjkbrjcjv dctö fhvzy Ufhtubyjv ÈÈ.

Gjdnjhbd cdjq ghbpsd r ghjljkétybñ lbfkjuf,C. Gfccb crfpfk, xnj cnjhjyfv yfujhyjrfhfåföcrj-uj rjyakbrnf cktletn gjcnfhfnmcz ghtjljktnmvyjujktnytt dpfbvyjt ytljdthbt. ≤Vs ljkéyscåhjcbnm änj bcnjhbxtcrjt åhtvz b ghbkjébnmdct cbks r njve, xnjås rfr vjéyj crjhtt pfktxbnmyfytctyyst d ghjikjv hfys. Yfv cktletn yfqnbyjdst genb lkz cktleñotuj gjrjktybz ébntktqFhvtybb b Fpthåfqléfyf≥, – jnvtnbk jy.

D rjywt cdjtq gjtplrb gj Ñéyjve Rfdrfpe LGJÅCT gjlxthryek, xnj ≤dhtvz yt zdkztncz cjñpyb-rjv≥ yb jlyjq bp cnjhjy b xnj ghbdktxtybt dyb-vfybz vtéleyfhjlyjuj cjjåotcndf vjukj ås gj-vjxm ehtuekbhjdfybñ rjyakbrnf.

Gthtl cfvsv djpdhfotybtv d Cjabñ LG epyfkj njv, xnj Fpthåfqléfy, ult jy gjlybvfk djghjcsj ltvjrhfnbpfwbb b edfétybb ghfd xtkjdtrf, fv-ybcnbhjdfk 130 pfrkñxtyysö, rjnjhsö hfpkbxystvtéleyfhjlyst b ytghfdbntkmcndtyyst jhufybpf-wbb cxbnfkb gjkbnbxtcrbvb epybrfvb.

Yf genb ljvjq vbybcnh ghjdtk rjycekmnfwbbcj cdjbv gthdsv pfvtcnbntktv Kñåjvbhjv Bdf-yjdsv b gjckjv Bdfyjv Yfqltyjdsv, d htpekmnfntrjnjhsö åskj ghbyznj htitybt jgeåkbrjdfnm en-hjv cktleñotuj lyz pfzdktybt lkz gtxfnb d cdzpbc egjvzyenjq fvybcnbtq. Vs åscnhj yfåhjcfkbghjtrn änjuj pfzdktybz, drkñxbd d ytuj ckjdf cf-vjuj vbybcnhf:

≤Yfltñcm, xnj änj cnfytn jxthtlysv ifujv yfgenb r ghbvbhtybñ b endthéltybñ ltvjrhfnb-xtcrbö wtyyjcntq d fpthåfqléfycrjv jåotcndt.Vs hfls njve, xnj Fpthåfqléfy ghbpyftn ytjåöj-lbvjcnm cktljdfnm ghbywbgfv JÅCT, rfcfñobvczjåtcgtxtybz ltvjrhfnbb b ghfd xtkjdtrf. Änjnifu lftn yjdeñ yfltéle yf gjpbnbdyjt hfpdbnbtcjåsnbq d cnhfyt≥.

CJABZ, ÅJKUFHBZ: 17–18 VFHNF

D nj dhtvz rfr bpvjéltyyst gjtplrjq xktysltktufwbb b éehyfkbcns vjukb yfltznmcz yf nj,xnj crjhj gjgflen ljvjq, vbybcnh byjcnhfyysöltk nfrjq hjcrjib ctåt gjpdjkbnm yt vju.

D öjlt jhufybpjdfyyjuj d gjcktlyññ vbyene dfähjgjhne cjdtofybz cj cdjbvb gjvjoybrfvb jyjpyfrjvbkcz c gjcktlybvb yjdjcnzvb, jåcelbkdjghjcs, cdzpfyyst c exfcnbtv d dféyjv enhty-ytv pfctlfybb gfhkfvtynf, yf rjnjhjv gkfybhjdf-kjcm hfnbabwbhjdfnm Ctdthjfnkfynbxtcrbq ljuj-djh, lfk erfpfybt chjxyj gjlujnjdbnm ntrcnpfzdktybz c jceéltybtv yfcbkbz d Rjcjdj b hfc-cvjnhtk djghjc j djpvjéyjq gjtplrt d änjn≤ghjåktvysq≥ rhfq.

Vböfbk Tdcnfamtd zdkztncz cjnhelybrjv gj djghjcfv gtxfnb Jnltkf ghtccs b jåotcndtyyjq byajhvfwbb Ctrhtnfhbfnf JÅCT.

Gjckt ghjljkébntkmysö gthtujdjhjd LG b vbybcnh

byjcnhfyysö ltk Fpthåfqléfyf Dbkfzn

Uekbtd jndtnbkb yf djghjcs éehyfkbcnjd.

Ajnjuhfabb: JÅCT/Vböfbk Tdcnfamtd

Vbybcnh C. Gfccb b fhvzycrbq vbybcnh

byjcnhfyysö ltk Dfhlfy Jcrfyzy cjikbcm d njv,

xnj rkñx r ehtuekbhjdfybñyfujhyjrfhfåföcrjuj

rjyakbrnf – d ghjljkétybblbfkjuf.

Page 31: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Vfq 2004 ujlf Éehyfk JÅCT 31

2 zydfhz 1945 u. – hjlbkcz d Bthecfkbvt dctvmt dtyuthcrbö åtétywtd

1948 u. – gthttpéftn c hjlbntkzvb d Åelf-gtin.

1960-t uu. – bpexftn abkjcjabñ b kbnthfnehed Åelfgtincrjv eybdthcbntnt; exfcndetn dldbétybb gjkbnbxtcrjuj ghjntcnf.

Yfxfkj 1970-ö uu. – hfåjnftn yf nhfrnjhyjvpfdjlt b gbitn jå änjv rybue ≤Lfhfååth≥(≤Gjinexyfz jgkfnf≥), rjnjheñ ytktufkm-yj dsdjpbn yf Pfgfl ytvtwrbq kbnthfnehysqltzntkm Ufyc Vfuyec Äywtycåthuth.

1975 u. – rybuf dsöjlbn yf ytvtwrjv zpsrt gjlyfpdfybtv „Stücklohn“ c ghtlbckjdbtv, yfgbcfyysv ytvtwrbv gbcfntktv UtyhböjvÅçkktv. D gjcktleñotv jyf gthtdjlbncz bgeåkbretncz d 15 lheubö cnhfyfö. Tt hec-crjt yfpdfybt – ≤Hfåjxbq d hfåjxtv ujce-lfhcndt≥.

1976 u. – cnfyjdbncz cjexhtlbntktv ≤Ldbét-ybz dtyuthcrjq ltvjrhfnbxtcrjq jggjpb-wbb≥.

1980 u. – gj djpdhfotybb yf hjlbye gjcktnhtöktnytuj ghtåsdfybz yf Pfgflt pfybvf-tn ljkéyjcnm htlfrnjhf ≤cfvbplfnjdcrjuj≥gthbjlbxtcrjuj bplfybz ≤Åtcwtkkj≥.

1988 u. – Ctdthj-pfgflysq eybdthcbntn (CIF)ghbcdfbdftn tve gjxtnyjt pdfybt ≤ljrnjhfuevfybnfhysö yfer≥.

1989 u. – exfcndetn d hfåjnt ≤rheukjuj cnjkf≥,ghbpdfyyjuj gjåelbnm gjkbnbxtcrbq bcntå-kbivtyn ufhfynbhjdfnm cdjåjle CVB.

1990–1994 uu. – xkty gfhkfvtynf, frnbdyj ds-cnegftn pf ghbyznbt yjdjuj pfrjyf j CVB,rjnjhsq, jlyfrj, yt yfåhfk ytjåöjlbvjujxbckf ujkjcjd.

Cthtlbyf 1990-ö uu. – eöjlbn bp gjkbnbrb, xb-nftn ktrwbb d eybdthcbntnfö CIF yf ntvsltvjrhfnbb b CVB.

2002 u. – xkty Cjdtnf eghfdkzñobö dtyuthcrj-uj jåotcndtyyjuj ntktdbltybz.

Äcct u-yf Öfhfinb geåkbrjdfkbcm d ufptnfö≤Ymñ-Qjhr nfqvc≥ b ≤Dfibyunjy gjcn≥, fnfrét d hzlt rhegysö tdhjgtqcrbö bplfybq.

YFPYFXTYBZ

Vbrkji Öfhfinb, yjdsq Ghtlcnfdbntkm gj djghjcfv cdjåjls CVBGFNHBR ÖFAYTH

10vfhnf änjn bpdtcnysq dtyuthcrbqgbcfntkm b åsdibq gjkbnbxtcrbq

lbccbltyn, ghjatccjh eybdthcbntnf bxkty gfhkfvtynf dcnegbk d ljkéyjcnmGhtlcnfdbntkz JÅCT gj djghjcfv cdj-åjls chtlcnd vfccjdjq byajhvfwbb.

≤Lkz vtyz änj dtcmvf djkybntkmysqvjvtyn, gjcrjkmre hfåjnf Ghtlcnfdbnt-kz JÅCT gj djghjcfv CVB dj vyjuböjnyjitybzö zdkztncz ghjljkétybtv lt-kf dctq vjtq ébpyb≥, – pfzdbk 59-ktnybqVbrkji Öfhfinb yf pfctlfybb Gjcnjzy-yjuj cjdtnf 11 vfhnf. Jy gjåkfujlfhbkujcelfhcndf-exfcnybrb pf ghtljcnfdkty-yeñ tve djpvjéyjcnm gjhfåjnfnm yfvtéleyfhjlyjq fhtyt dj bvz cdjåjlsghtccs.

≤Z nfrét jnlfñ ljkéyjt njq dslfñ-otqcz hjkb, rjnjheñ buhfk gthdsq xt-kjdtr yf änjv gjcne, jghtltkbdibq cfvetuj cenm, – cnhfcnyj ghtlfyysq cdjtveltke Ahfqven Ledt, d ntyb kbxyjcnb rj-njhjuj vyt ghtlcnjbn ytvfkj gjnhelbnm-cz, xnjås yfqnb cjåcndtyysq cnbkm herj-djlcndf yfitq hfåjnjq≥, – pfzdbk u-yÖfhfinb. (A. Ledt (Uthvfybz) åsk gth-dsv Ghtlcnfdbntktv gj djghjcfv CVBd gthbjl c zydfhz 1998 gj ltrfåhm 2003 ujlf).

Jy dsltkbk nhb ntvs, yf rjnjhsö cj-chtljnjxbn dybvfybt tuj åñhj b rjnjhstrfcfñncz ≤ltkbrfnyjq dpfbvjpfdbcb-vjcnb b ghjnbdjhtxbq vtéle cdjåjljq blheubvb gjnhtåyjcnzvb jåotcndf≥:♦ cdjåjlf dshfétybz vytybq d Bynth-

ytnt b ghjåktvf jykfqyjdjuj hfcghj-cnhfytybz ghjzdktybq ytyfdbcnb;

♦ cdjåjlf CVB b nhtåjdfybz yfwbj-yfkmyjq åtpjgfcyjcnb b åjhmås c nthhjhbpvjv; f nfrét

♦ gjkjétybz j rktdtnt b lbaafvfwbbghbvtybntkmyj r éehyfkbcnfv b CVBb ytjåöjlbvjcnm ≤ltrhbvbyfkbpfwbb≥änbö ltqcndbq bkb gj rhfqytq vtht jnrfpf jn yfrfpfybz pf ybö d ajhvtnñhtvyjuj pfrkñxtybz gj ghbujdjhecelf.≤D cdjtq hfåjnt z yt åele ltkfnm hfp-

kbxbq vtéle Pfgfljv b Djcnjrjv, vtéle≤yjdsvb≥ b ≤cnfhsvb≥ ltvjrhfnbzvb, –ujdjhbn u-y Öfhfinb. – Dct 55 ujce-

lfhcnd – exfcnybrjd JÅCT jåzpfkbcmghblthébdfnmcz yfibö jåobö ghbywbgjdltvjrhfnbxtcrjuj jåotcndf.... Eds, jlyfbp ghbceobö dctv yfv xthn pfrkñxftnczd njv, xnj yb jlyf cnhfyf yt cjdthity-yf≥.

Gj tuj ckjdfv, cfvfz nhelyfz lkz yt-uj pflfxf – yfqnb ghfdbkmyjt cjjnyjit-ybt ghb jceotcndktybb dsåjhf vtélehfpkbxysvb bvtñobvbcz d hfcgjhzét-ybb Ghtlcnfdbntkz gj djghjcfv CVBchtlcndfvb. ≤Ytjåöjlbvj ecnfyjdbnmghfdbkmysq åfkfyc vtéle yfåkñltybtv,cjnhelybxtcndjv, htrjvtylfwbzvb, fbyjulf b ghjntcnjv, c ntv xnjås ljåbnm-cz vfrcbvfkmyjuj äaatrnf, gjcnjzyyjgjvyz j njv, xnj yfif ghfrnbxtcrfzwtkm – gjvjufnm≥.

D cdjtv bynthdmñ fdcnhbqcrjq hflb-jcnfywbb JHA 29 vfhnf u-y Öfhfinb pfzdbk, xnj yt cnfytn juhfybxbdfnmcz bc-rkñxbntkmyj gjkbnbxtcrbvb ltvfhifvb:≤Z yt åelen ghjcnj kbim rjywtynhbhj-dfnm dybvfybt yf gjdtltybb ghfdb-ntkmcnd, gjcrjkmre vtynfkbntn ckbirjv vyjubö éehyfkbcnjd d ujls rjvveybcnb-xtcrjuj ghfdktybz åsk ≤cjwbfkbpbhj-dfy≥, b ntgthm d gkfyt bö ghjatccbj-yfkmyjq änbrb jyb jrfpfkbcm d cdjtujhjlf dfreevt≥.

Jy ujdjhbn, xnj åeltn ghbpsdfnm CVBeltkznm åjkmit dybvfybz rfxtcnde éehyfkbcnbrb b bpåfdkznmcz jn cnfhsöcnthtjnbgjd, c ntv xnjås dkfcnzv åskjytkturj ghjnbdjltqcndjdfnm bv.

D jgeåkbrjdfyyjq 19 vfhnf d fdcnhbq-crjq tétlytdyjq ufptnt ≤Infylfhn≥cgtwbfkmyjq cnfnmt ≤Gjhnhtn lyz≥ jnvtxfkjcm, xnj gjckt u-yf Ledt, kbxyjc-nb ghjnbdjhtxbdjq b étcnrjq, ≤dct jéb-lfkb, xnj 55 ujcelfhcnd – exfcnybrjdJÅCT ljujdjhzncz j åjktt ≤vzurjv≥ghttvybrt. Jlyfrj d htpekmnfnt nhel-ysö gthtujdjhjd jyb cjikbcm yf rfylb-lfnt, rjnjhsq cxbnftn ltkjv cdjtq ébp-yb pfobne cdjåjls chtlcnd vfccjdjqbyajhvfwbb≥.

Gfnhbr Öfayth, dsgecrybr afrekmntnf

éehyfkbcnbrb Vñyötycrjuj eybdthcbntnf,

ghjöjlbn cnfébhjdre d Jnltkt ghtccs b

Gjhnhtn Vbrkjif Öfhfinbkñåtpyj ghtljcnfdkty

Ähöfhljv Infrktv/≤Infylfhn≥.

Page 32: OSCE Magazine May 2004 (ru)

Jhufybpfwbz gj åtpjgfcyjcnb b cjnhelybxtcnde d Tdhjgt

www.osce.orgwww.osce.org/publications/magazine

e-mail: [email protected]