MH"HCTepCTBO 06pa30Ba"HSI H "ayKH POCCHUCKOU <l>e,lJ,epaUHH

<De,D,epaJIbHOe rocynapcrseaaoe 61O,D,:>KeTHOe 06pa30BaTeJIbHOe yspexneaae

BbI<::WerO npOepeCCHOHaJIbHOrO 06pa30BaHIDI

«rOCY,IJ,APCTBEHHhrM YHMBEPCMTET ynPABJIEHM.H»(rYY)

P~3aHcKHHnpOCneKT,99,~OcKBa,109542Tenerpon (495) 371-13-22, Ten .zdiaxc(495) 377-89-14,371-69-47,371-98-33

Http.//www.guu.ru, E-mail : inf@guu.ruOKITO 02066598, OrPH 1027739017976, I1HH 7721037218, KITIT 772101001

v-ir: O~ZO(jJ No 6'kI

HaNQ OT _

B ,LJ;HCCepTaQHOHHhIH COBeT

,lJ; 209.002.08 (lOpH,LJ;HQeCKHe HayKH)

"PH MrHMO MH,lJ; POCCHH

OT3bIBoqnUJ;:mUIbHOrO OIUIOHeHTa

aa .n;MCCepTaU:MlO Tparopseaa Tnxrypa IOpbeBWIa na reny:«TpaHCrpaHWIHbIe .n;MCTpM6blOTOpCKOe cornamenae M.n;OrOBOp TOprOBOrO

npencrasarenscrsa B pOCCMHCKOM M3apy6e:>KHOM npaae»,npeztcraanemryto na COMCKaHMe ~eHOH crenean xanmmara IOpM.n;WleCKMX

nayx rro crreU:MaJlbHOCTM 12.00.03 - rpaacnaacxoe rrpaso,npezmpaaanarenscxoe rrpaso, ceveiinoe rrpaso, Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;Hoe tIaCTHOe

rrpaBO

AKryaJlhHOCTh TeMhI HCCJle,LJ;OBaHHH. COBpeMeHHbIH aran pa3BMTM5I

MMpOBoro C006I.IJ;eCTBa xapaxrepasyercs rrpoueccasra rn06aJlM3aU:MM MMpOBOH

3KOHOMMKM M MHTerpaU:MM rocynapcrs B Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;Hoe rrpOCTpaHCTBO,

yCMneHMlO MX B3aMMHoro BnM5IHM5I M Me:>K.D;yHapo.n;Horo COrpy.n;HMtIeCTBa.

Cne.n;CTBMeM sroro .5IBn.5leTC.5I pa3BMTMe Me:>K.D;yHapo.n;HbIX noroaopnsrx CB.5I3eH

Me:>K.D;y KOHKpeTHbIMM ytIaCTHMKaMM Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;Horo KOMMepqeCKOrO 060pOTa,

rrpOMcxo.n;.5II.IJ;MMM M3 pa3nMtIHbIX rocyztapcrs. HeCMOTp.51 na TO, tITO OCHOBHbIM

KOMMeptIeCKMM .n;orOBopOM (MnM TpaHcrpaHMtIHbIM

KOMMeptIeCKMM .n;OrOBOpOM), 3aKnlOtIaeMbIM Me:>K.n;y YKa3aHHbIMM ytIaCTHMKaMM,

npononxcaer OCTaBaTbC.5I .n;OrOBOp Me:>K.n;yHapO.n;HOH xynna-rrponaaor TOBapOB, C

Ka:>K.n;bIM rO.n;OM pacrer KOnI1tIeCTBO M yBenMtIMBaeTC5I pasnoofipaaae

aaxmo-raexrsrx .n;OrOBOpOB. IIlMpOKOe pacnpocrpanenae B nocnezmae .n;eC.5ITI1neTI1.51

rronyaaror .n;OrOBOpbI, C rrOMOI.IJ;blO KOTOpbIX ytIaCTHMKM PbIHKOB CTpeM.5lTC.5I

1

«aasoeaars» HHOCTPaHHhle phIHKH, «npO.n;BHrIDI» CBOH TOBapDI, pa60ThI, ycnyrn C

nonouisto Pa3JIHqHDIX JIHD: na TeppHTOpIDIX 3apy6e:>KHhIX rocyztapcrn. B xanecrse

TaKHX JIHD: ssicrynaicr B TOM qHCJIe TOprOBDIe npe.n;CTaBHTeJIH H .n;HCTpH6hIOTOphI.

o BhICOKOM: npaKTHqeCKOM: BocTPe6oBaHHOCTH .n;OrOBOpOB C ysacraexr YKa3aHHhIX

JIHD: CBH.n;eTeJIhCTByeT CTaTHCTHqeCKIDI HHepOpMaD:ml EBpOCTaTa H Pa3JIHqHhIX

HHOCTPaHHhIX aHaJIHTHqeCKHX areHTCTB, YKa3hIBalOmHX na CymecTBeHHhIM: 061>eM

ysacraa TOprOBhIX npe.n;CTaBHTeJIeM: H .n;HCTPH6hIOTOpOB B TOprOBOM 060pOTe

3apy6e:>KHhIX rocyztapcrs, CKa3aHHOe 06yCJIOBJIHBaeT aKryaJIhHOCTh, HayqHYIO H

rrpaxraxecxyro 3HaqHMOCTh TeMDI, BhI6paHHOM: T.IO. Tparopsensra B uensx

npOBe.n;eHH5I HCCJIe.n;OBaHIDI.

I1cCJIe.n;yeMDIe .n;HCCepTaHTOM TpaHCrpaHHqHDIe .n;HCTPH6hIOTOpCKHe

.n;OrOBOphI H .n;OrOBOphI TOprOBOrO rrpe.n;CTaBHTeJIhCTBa He yHH<pHD:HpOBaHhI B

Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;HhIX COrJIarneHIDIX. Ilpanoaony peryJIHpOBaHHIO noroaopa

KOMMepqeCKOrO npe.n;CTaBHTeJIhCTBa nOCB5ImeHhI zme KOHBeHD:HH, B KOTOphIX P<I>

He y-racrnyer. O.n;HOM: H3 HHX 51BJI5IeTC5I )l{eHeBcKIDI KOHBeHD:H5I 0

npe.n;CTaBHTeJIhCTBe npa Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;HOM: xyrrne-nponaace TOBapOB 1983r.,

conepacamaa yHH<pHD:HpOBaHHhle MaTepHaJIhHO-npaBoBDIe HOpMhI, npH3BaHHIDI

.n;onOJIHHTh Beacxyto KOHBeHD:HIO OOR 0 noroaopax Me:>K.n;yHapO)];HOM: KynJIH­

nponaxca TOBapoB 1980r. H HMelOmIDI D:eJIhlO yperynaposaaae OTHOrneHHM:

npencraaarenscraa npa Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;HOM: xynne-rrponaace TOBapoB. OHa He

scrynana B CHJIY. ,lWyra51 Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;HIDI KOHBeHD:IDI - Taarcxaa KOHBeHD:H5I N!!

27 0 npase, npHMeHHMOM K areHTCKHM norosopaa, 1978r. nOCB5ImeHa

KOJIJIH3HOHHDIM sonpocav Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;HhIX areHTCKHX ztoroaopos, onaaxo xpyr

yqaCTBYlOmHX B HeM: rocynapcrs He3HaqHTeJIeH. TaKHM 06pa30M, yxasannsre

KOHBeHD:HH He peuraror np06JIeMDI Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;Ho-npaBOBOM: yHH<pHKaD:HH

zrorosopa Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;Horo roprosoro npe.n;CTaBHTeJIhCTBa, accnerryenoro B

.n;HccepTaD:HH T.IO. Tparopseaa.

I13BecTHO, qTO B crpanax EC npasosoe perynaposaaae roproaoro

rrpe.n;CTaBHTeJIhCTBa ocymeCTBJI5IeTC5I B COOTBeTCTBHH C .D:HpeKTHBOM: COBeTa E3C

«0 He3aBHCHMhIX ToprOBDIX arenrax» 1986r., HOpMDI KOTOpOM:

2

MMlmeMeHTMpOBaHbI B 3aKOHO,n:aTeJIbCTBO eBpOneMCKI1X rocynapcrs. O,n:HaKO

BHYTpeHHee 3aKOHO,n:aTeJIbCTBO M cy,n:e6HIDI npaxrmca eBpOneMCKMX CTpaH B

sonpocax MMnJIeMeHTal(MM M npMMeHeHIDI )J.MpeKTMBbI MMelOT pasnaxas. KpOMe

TOrO, eBpOneMCKOe peryJIMpOBaHMe YKa3aHHOrO ,n:OrOBOpa OTJIMqaeTC~ OT

pernaaenrauna CXmKMX C HMM ,n:OrOBOpHbIX KOHCTPyKl(MM, MMelOll(MX MeCTO B

aHrJIO-aMepMKaHCKOM npaae M npaae POCCMMCKOM <1>e,n:epal(MM. CJIe,n:OBaTeJIbHO,

pe3YJIbTaT npMMeHeHM~ HOpMaTMBHbIX npaBOBbIX aKTOB YKa3aHHbIX CTPaH BO

MHOrMX CJIyqa~X MO:>KeT pa3JIMqaTbC~. B :3TOM CB~3M aKTYaJIbHbIM BM,n:MTC~

nposenenae KOMnJIeKCHOrO MCCJIe,n:OBaHM~ npaaa Pa3JIMqHbIX rocynapcrs, He

o,n:MHaKOBO perynapyrourax zrorosopasre OTHOIIleHM~ no roproaony

npe,n:CTaBMTeJIbCTBy, xoropoe MO:>KeT 6bITb M36paHO ,n:JI~ peryJIMpOBaHM~ MX

CTopOHaMM JIM60 onpezteneao Cy,n:OM na OCHOBaHMM KOJIJIM3MOHHbIX HOpM, a TaK:>Ke

aHaJIM3a M CMCTeMaTM3al(MM cynefiaoii npaKTMKM no crropav, B03HMKalOll(MM M3

no,n:06HbIX ztoroaopos. He MeHee aKTYaJIbHbIM BM,n:MTC~ nposeneaae noztofiaoro

MCCJIe,n:OBaHM~M B OTHOIIleHMM TPaHcrpaHMqHOrO ,n:MCTPM6bIOTOpcKoro ztoronopa,

KOTOpbIM He TOJIbKO He MMeeT Me:>K,n:yHapo,n:HOM MaTepMaJIbHO-npaBOBOM

yHM<lmKal(MM, HO M, KaK npaBMJIO, He pernaaearapyerca BHYTPeHHMM npason

60JIbIIlMHCTBa rocyrtapcrn, no-pasaoay nOHMMaeTC~B npaxraxe M ,n:OKTPMHe.

Hayxaas M npaKTMqeCKIDI l(eHHOCTb rtposeneaaoro zmccepranaonaoro

MCCJIe,n:OBaHM~COCTOMT B TOM, qTO paaee nonofiasre MCCJIe,n:OBaHIDI B OTHOIIleHMM

TpaHcrpaHMqHbIX ,n:MCTpM6bIOTOpCKMX ,n:orOBopOB M ,n:orOBopOB ToprOBoro

npe,n:CTaBMTeJIbCTBa B cpaBHMTeJIbHO-npaBOBOM cpe3e npaBa POCCMMCKOM

<1>e,n:epal(MM M 3apy6e:>KHbIX rocyzrapcrs H~ npOBo,n:MJIMCb. Ocofias 3HaqMMOCTb

npoaeneaaoro KOMnJIeKCHOro MCCJIe,n:OBaHM~3aKJIlOqaeTC~ eute M B TOM, qTO OHO

OXBaTbIBaeT MHO:>KeCTBO rrpasonopanxoa, npaaaaneacanmx K Pa3JIMqHbIM

npaBOBbIM CMCTeMaM, M BKJIlOqaeT HOBeMIIIYIO npaaonpaaenarensayro npaKTMKY

uenoro pana 3apy6e:>KHbIX rocynapcrs, He MCCJIe,n:OBaHHYIO panee B

OTeqeCTBeHHoM. ,n:OKTPMHe.

HOBM3Ha pe3YJIbTaTOB nposeneauoro MCCJIe,n:OBaHIDI OTPa:>KeHa B HaM60JIee

3HaqMMbIX asraonax M nOJIO:>KeHM~X, CcPOpMyJIMpOBaHHbIX B HeM, xoropsre

3

OTJUPIaIOTC5I .n;OCTOBepHOCTbIO H OpHrHHaJIbHOCTbIO, rrOCKOJIbKY aBTOp OrrHpaJIC5I

aa paaee He HCCJIe.n;OBaHHbIe B OTe-qeCTBeHHOH .n;OKTpHHe HopMaTHBHbIe rrpasossre

aKTbI, npaaonpaaenarensnyro npaxrnxy H 3apy6e:>KHYIO .n;OKTpHHY.

,lJ,ocToBepHOCTb ztannoro HCCJIe.n;OBaHH5I 06yCJIOBJIeHa JIOrH-qHOCTbIO H

060CHOBaHHOCTbIO c.n;eJIaHHbIX B HeM BbIBO.n;OB H rrOJIO:>KeHHH, HCrrOJIb3yeMbIMM

ero aBTopOM MeTo.n;aMM Hay-qHoro rr03HaHM5I, CMCTeMaTM-qeCKMM rro.n;KperrJIeHMeM

ero paccyacztermri CCbIJIKaMM na rrpaBorrpHMeHMTeJIbHYIQ npaxraxy M .n;OKTpMHY.

B :n OH CB5I3M cnenyer 06paTMTb BHMMaHMe na TO, -qTO ztannoe

MCCJIe.n;OBaHMe OXBaTbIBaeT He TOJIbKO COBpeMeHHoe COCT05IHMe, HO H

acropasecxoe pa3BMTMe MHCTMTYTOB rropyxenaa M rrpe.n;CTaBMTeJIbCTBa,

OKa3aBlllMe BJIM5IHMe Ha pa3BMTHe MHCTMTyTOB ToprOBoro rrpe.n;CTaBMTeJIbCTBa M

.n;HCTpM6bIOI.I;HM. ABTOpOM HCCJIe.n;OBaHM5I 0603Ha-qeHbI Ba:>KHeHlllMe .n;JI5I

cpaBHMTeJIbHOrO npasoseneaaa acnexrsr, CB5I3aHHbIe onpeneneaaen uenoro psna

rrOH5ITMH. B -qaCTHOCTM, pacxpsrrsr Ba:>KHbIe acnexrsr rrOH5ITH5I «.n;06pOBOJIbHOe

rrpe.n;CTaBMTeJIbCTBO» (C. 33-36), rrpOaHaJIM3HpOBaHbI TepMMHbI «arenr» M

«arearaposaaae», rrpMcYIIJ;He aHrJIO-aMepMKaHcKoMy rrpasy M noxrpane (c. 36­

42), 06'b5ICHeHO conepxcaaae TepMMHa «on behalf of» (c. 39), paccaorpensr

.n;OKTpMHbI «pacxpsrroro» M «aepacxpsrroro» npaauanana B aHrJIMHCKOM rrpase M

npaauan «OTKpbITOCTM» B KOHTMHeHTaJIbHOM M pOCCMHCKOM npaae, ofiocnonano

MHeHMe 0 Heo6xo.n;MMOCTM pasrpaaaaenaa nocpenaaxecrsa M npencrasarenscraa

(c. 57). HeMaJIOBa:>KHOe snaneaae MMeIOT BbIBO.n;bI znrccepranra 0 roproaov

nocpenaaaecrse M npencraaarenscrae, cnenamrsre na OCHOBe aHaJIH3a THrrOBbIX

KOMMep-qecKMx KOHTpaKToB Meaotynapoztaoa ropronoii nanarsr M

Meaotyaapozmoro 'roproaoro I.I;eHTpa, 06JIa.n;aIOIIJ;MX crreI.I;McPMKoH M MMeIOIIJ;MX

onpeneneaasni rrpaKTM-qeCKMH aarepec .n;JI5I ysacrnaxos Me:>K.n;yHapo.n;Horo

KOMMep-qecKoro ofiopora (c. 62), a TaK:>Ke BblBO.n;bI, cnenannsre 0 KOHCTpyKI.I;HM

ztoroaopa KOMMep-qecKoro npencrasarenscraa, B COOTBeTCTBMM C pOCCMHCKMM

npaaov, M KOMMep-qecKMM arearapoaaaaev - B COOTBeTCTBMM C eBpOrreHCKMM

npaaov rrOCJIe MMrrJIeMeHTaI.I;MM ,lJ,MpeKTMBbI 1986r. (c. 82).

4

CYI.IJ;eCTBeHH)'IO 3HatIl1MOCTb ztna OTetIeCTBeHHOH rrpaBOBOH nayxn l1MeIOT

rrpOaHM11311pOBaHHbIe aBTOpOM l1CCne,n:OBaHl151 B 3HatIl1TenbHOM 06'beMe npasonsre

rr0311U;1111 l1HOCTpaHHbIX Cy,n:OB 11 3apy6e:>KHOH ,n:OKTpl1HbI rro sonpocy

KBMmpl1KaU;l1l1 rpaacrpaaa-nroro ,n:l1CTp116bIOTOpCKoro noroaopa, nposezreao

COOTHOWeHl1e YKa3aHHOrO zrorosopa C KOHu;eCC110HHbIMl1 cornauremonra (rrr. 2)

I1HTepecHbIM ,n:n51 nayxn 11 npaxraxa 51Bn5leTC5I nposeneaasni ,n:l1CCepTaHToM

aHM113 ,n:eHcTByIOI.IJ;erO acnancxoro 11 rropryranscxoro saxoaonarenscraa 0

,n:l1CTp116bIOTOpCKOM ztorosope, nccnenyerca rrOH5ITl1e OpraH113aU;110HHOrO

xapaxrepa nacrpatisroropcxoro norosopa (c. 148-150). B pafiore paccsrorpena

HOBeHWa51 cynefiaaa npaxraxa MHOrl1X rocyztapcrs B OTHOWeHl1l1 YKa3aHHOrO

zroroaopa, B TOM tIl1cne B OTHOWeHl1l1 sonpoca 0 BbIIInaTe KOMrreHCaU;l1l1

(indemnity) ,n:l1CTp116bIOTOPY. YtIl1TbIBa51 TpaHCrpaHl1tIHbIH xapaxrep

paCCMaTpl1BaeMbIX ,n:l1CCepTaHTOM norosopos, 3acnY:>Kl1BaIOT BHl1MaHl15I BbIBO,n:bI,

czterrannsre ,n:l1CCepTaHTOM B 3 rnase pafiorsr, rrOCB5II.IJ;eHHOH KOnJI113110HHbIM

sonpocaa, CB5I3aHHbIM C rrpl1MeHeHl1eM rrpaaa K paCCMaTpl1BaeMbIM ztorosopax.

,I:(ocTOl1HCTBaMl1 ,n:l1CCepTaU;110HHOrO l1CCne,n:OBaHl151 MO:>KHO CtIl1TaTb

KOMrrneKcHbIH nozrxon 11 51pKO BbIpa:>KeHHbIH cpaaaarensno-npaaonoa xapaxrep

pafiorsr, KOTOpbIH BbI,n:eAAeTC5I B Cl1CTeMHOM conocrasnemnr ero asropoxr HOpM

KOHTl1HeHTMbHoro, aarno-asrepaxaacxoro 11 apaficxoro npaaa,

Pesynsrarsr l1CCne,n:OBaHl151, BbIBO,n:bI 11 paccyxcneaaa nnocrpanasrx

CrreU;l1Ml1CTOB rro sarponyroit rrpofinexrarnxe, npencranneaasre B HaCT05.1I.IJ;eM

l1CCne,n:OBaHl1l1, BHe BC5IKOrO COMHeHl151 npencraanaror u;eHHOCTb ,n:AA aayxa 11

rrpaxrarca. HOBbIe aay-nrsre pesynsrarsr 11 3a,n:eHC!BOBaHHbIe ztna aroro aBTopOM

xrerozrsr 11 npaeusr CBl1,n:eTenbCTB)'IOT 0 BbICOKOM nl1tIHOM sxnazte C0l1CKaTen51 B

nayxy, Ilpoztenaaasra aBTopOM Tpy,n: BbI3bIBaeT ysaaceaae, 06'beM

rrpOaHM11311pOBaHHOH HOBeHweH 3apy6e:>KHOH nareparypsr 11 l1HOCTpaHHbIX

l1CTOtIHl1KOB 18-19 BeKOB rrp0113Bo,n:51T anexarnerrae rnofiansnoro nay-more rpyna,

bOnbWl1HCTBO BbIBO,n:OB, BblHOCl1MbIX ,n:l1CCepTaHToM na 3aI.IJ;l1TY, ofinanaror

Heo6xo,n:l1MOH HaytIHOH HOB113HOH.

5

BMeCTe C TeM, OTAeJlhHhIe nOJlO~eHUH AUCCepTanUOHHOrO

UCCJleAOBaHUH Hy~aIOTcH B AOnOJlHUTeJlhHOM nOHCHeHUU B npouecce UX

3aIQUThI, OHU HBJlHIOTCH AUCKyCCUOHHhIMU U He YMaJlHIOT BhICOKoro

3HaQeHUH npeACTaBJleHHOrO HayQHOrO TpYAa.

B "tJaCTHOCTM, XOTenOCh 6hI ycnsnnars MHeHMe asropa zracceprauaomroro

Mccne,[(OBaHM5I rro cne,[()'lOI.I..J;MM sonpocax:

1) 113 rrOnO:>KeHM5I na 3aI.I..J;MTy NQ 5 cnerryer, "tJTO ztoronop ToproBoro

npencraaarenscraa nonycrnvo OTHOCMTh K norosopaa 0 C6hITe rrp0,[(YK~MM. B

:nOM CB5I3M XOTenOCh 6hI ycnsnnars MHeHMe asropa Mccne,[(OBaHM5I OTHOCMTenhHO

KBanM<pMKa~MM TaKMX ztoroaopasrx OTHOIIIeHMM C yxacraea roprosoro

rrpencrasarens, npn KOTOphIX nocnennaa oCyI.I..J;eCTBn5IeT He C6hIT (nponascy), a

aaofiopor noxyrncy TOBapOB, nM60 npencrasnaer arrrepecsr ycnyroztarenea.

2) B rrOnO:>KeHMM NQ 8 OTMe"tJaeTC5I nepcnercrasrrocrs BKnIOYfeHM5I B rxPel> KonnM3MoHHOM HOPMhI ,[(n5I ztoroaopon 0 cfisrre npozryxrraa. ,[(MccepTaHTY

npennaraercs rr05ICHMTh, B03MO:>KHO na BKnlO"tJeHMe B rK P<I> KonnM3MoHHOM

HOpMhI, aaanoraanoii co,[(ep:>KaI.I..J;eHC5I B Pernavenre «PMM I», B orcyrcrsae era

cnenaansaoji MaTepManhHo-rrpaBoBoH pernaverrrarnra BO BHyTpeHHeM rrpase Pel>?

3) ABTOp rrMIIIeT: «MO:>KHO asrpasars naneacny na TO, "tJTO HOPMhI CT.

184 TK Pel> 0 KOMMep"tJecKoM npencraanrene B nepcnexrase rronyaar

«esponeacxoe coztepncanae», rrpa ycnoana yTo"tJHeHM5I saxoaonarenea paszrenoa 0

nopyseaaa M areHTMpoBaHMM, nocxonsxy ceiivac MMeeTC5I MHO:>KeCTBO

aeacenarensnsrx nepeceseaaa Me:>K,[(y HMMM» (C. 83). Xorenoci, 6hI ycnsnnars

KOHKpeTHhle npenrroacenaa rro C6nM:>KeHMlO poccaacxoro M esporreiicxoro

3aKOHo,[(aTenhCTBa, ofiocnonarr, MX Heo6xo,[(MMOCTh.

4) Ilo MHeHMlO zraccepraara, B03MO:>KHO nM OTrpaHM"tJeHMe

,[(MCTpM6hlOTopcKoro ,[(oroBopa Ha OCHOBe ero opraHM3a~MoHHoM <PYHK~MM OT

MHhIX ziorosopoa, npenycworpeaasrx B pOCCMMCKOM npase (aanpavep,

KOMMep"tJecKoM KOH~eCCMM, rrOCTaBKM, areHTMpOBaHM5I), 5IBn5IeTC5I nM 3Ta <PYHK~M5I

cYI.I..J;eCTBeHHoM ,[(n5I ztaaaoro ztorosopa?

6

5) Kaxosa n03MIJ,IDI caxroro asropa OTHOCMTenbHO 06}13aHHOCTM arerrra

nepeztars KnMeHTCK)'IO 6a3y no OKOHl:JaHMM ztorosopa npamnmany?

Yxasaansie sonpocsr M 3aMel:JaHIDI HOC}lT MCKnIOl:JMTenbHO ,n;MCKyCCMOHHbIH

xapaxrep, He YMall}lIOT BbICOKoro 3Hal:JeHM}I BbIBO,n;OB zmccepraara ,n;n}l HayKM

rpaacaancxoro rrpasa M He CHM)I(aIOT nOnO)l(MTenbHOH OIJ,eHKM pa60TbI B IJ,enOM.

Hay-mere nOnO)l(eHIDI, BbIBO,n;bI, M peKOMeH,n;aIJ,MM, crpopaynapoaaaasrc B

,n;MccepTaIJ,MM, 06na,n;aIOT BbICOKOH CTeneHbIO 060CHOBaHHOCTM M 0TPa)l(eHbI B

HaYl:JHbIX rry6nMKaIJ,M5IX asropa, B TOM l:JMCne B M3,n;aHM~, peKOMeH,n;OBaHHbIX

BAK npn MMHo6pHayKM POCCMM.

ITo csoesry cozrepacaamo ,n;MccepTaIJ,IDI COOTBeTcTByeT BbI6paHHOH rexre,

asroperpepar MMeeT nOrMl:JH)'IO nocnezrosarensrryro crpyxrypy M B normon xrepe

COOTBeTcTByeT OCHOBHbIM nonoaceaaxa nacceprauaa.

)J;MccepTaIJ,M}I aanroperpepar nonrorosneasr na BbICOKOM Hayl:JHOM yposne,

aBTOp noxasan yxremre CMCTeMHO cPopMynMpoBaTb CBOM paccyzcnemra, rroxasan

cefia KBallM<pMIJ,MpOBaHHbIM nccneztoaarenexr, cnoco6HbIM nsmsaran,

oparaaansnsie aziea M OTCTaMBaTb co6cTBeHHyIO HaYl:JH)'IO n03MIJ,MIO,

,n;eMOHCTPMpy}l BbICOKoe ananeaae IOpM,n;Ml:JeCKOH repwaaoxoraea.

ITpe,n;CTaBn}leTC}I, l:JTO nocrannemrsre aBTopOM IJ,enM M sanana accnenosaaaa

B nonnoii Mepe ,n;OCTMrHyTbI, pafiora T.IO. Fparopsesa BHOCMT cyIIJ,eCTBeHHbIH

srorazt B nccnenosamre TPaHcrpaHMl:JHbIX norosopos KOMMepl:JeCKOrO

npencrasarenscrsa M ,n;MCTPM6bIOTOpCKMX noroaopoa.

TaKMM 06pa30M, nacceprauaa Tparopsesa Tasrypa IOpbeBMl:Ja

«Tpancrpamrsasrc ,n;MCTPM6bIOTOpCKoe cornanrenne M noroaop .roproaoro

npeztcraaarenscrsa B pOCCMHCKOM M aapyfieacnoxi npaae» snnaercs 3aKOHl:JeHHbIM

HaYl:JHbIM rpynoa, BblIIonHeHHbIM B COOTBeTCTBMM C Tpe6oBaHIDIMM,

npe,n;'b}lBn}leMbIMM ITonO)l(eHMeM 0 npacyacneaaa Yl:JeHbIX creneaeii,

yraepacaemrsrsr ITocTaHoBneHMeM ITpaBMTenbCTBa POCCMHCKOH <l>e,n;epaIJ,MM OT 24

cearafipa 2013 rona NQ 824 (c nocne,n;)'IOIIJ,MMM M3MeHeHM}lMM), ee aarop

aacnyzcasaer npacyzcnenaa Yl:JeHOH CTeneHM KaH,n;M,n;aTa IOpM,n;Ml:JeCKMX aayx no

7

Crre~lHlJIhHOCTM 12.00.03 - Tpaactaacxoe rrpaso; rrpeJJ;rrpMHMMaTeJIhCKOe rrpaso;

ceveanoe npaso; Me:>KJJ;yHapoJJ;Hoe qaCTHOe rrpano.

KaHJJ;MJJ;aT IOpMJJ;MqeCKMX nayx

(cneuaansaocrs 12.00.03 - rpazcnancxoe rrpaso,

Ilonnacs ,n:.Il. CTpMryHOBOM 3aBep~IO: -, --'- '--.---~

I C ein e l a p ~l (\ 1 I

IY'wll or~ CO BC J9{YY I-----~~

8