periyar evr_தந்தை பெரியார்_critisism on hinduism_6

8/14/2019 Periyar EVR_ _Critisism on Hinduism_6

1/30

TV : pWW YRjL

BpV : TV

Y| : TV WP LZL

29, CRVX[ hz

YY SL, Y

N] 600 041

T B| : 2007 U

R RU : G.G. 60 .G.G

Aor G A[: 11 L

A[ : P 1/8

LVeL AyP YzYU: ArW FPL, |eL

AoNeL fVyz fWe, N]

fPehPjL: TV TzTL

TV TXV Af

Uy} 636 401

TV TzTL

YY TXV Af

LW LY 641 044

SLP : E. 10

pWW

YRjL

TV

Y|:

TV WP LZL29, CRVX[ hz

YY SL, YN] 600 041

[email protected]


2/30

3URjL TV [eL

1. peLX] WoN]

ThRY: URjL VW EPeLTyPY?

BL : URjL LP[ EPeLTyPY?

ThRY: AXAY URL[EPfVY

BL : H ATzo Nf\?ThRY : Nf\ L. URjL

GR] E|?BL : TX URjL E|ThRY : ERWQULo pX NBL : G|eLyPL C UR, R UR,

fY UR, LUVUR, qefVUR, Tp UR, N[WzW UR,RVYL CY TX EyL E|

ThRY : LPL GR] E|?BL : JW LPR E|ThRY : CY[ URjL VeLL

EPeLTyPY?

BL : UR YeLeLLR ThRY : URR HT| TV G]?BL : UR, LP[ AV, LPeh

R]eh NTR HT|eL[,BU O] T\, LP LQeh TW]L TVT|YRh.

ThRY : ATzV], JW LP UR YeLeh CR] URjL[ HT|

Y]?BL : C L peLX] WoN]VCef\. TX TVL[e L|TpV \h T Nf\.

C UR

ThRY: AR TLy|, C UR GT G]?BL : UR G\ YRUR G TVThRY: YR G\ G]?

BL : eh, Vr, NU, ARYQ G 4 YRjLE| AYR \R C UR GT.

ThRY : CYRjL VW HT|RTyPY?BL : YR LP[ HT|RTyPThRY : YR LP[ HT|RTyP G V

N]LBL : YR LP[ HT|RTyP G YR

Nf\

ThRY : CRh HRY NypV BRWU EP?BL : YReh, LP Yeheh BRWU,

NypV LyT G\ A TYU]LVUVh

ThRY : A TYUL CeLX. B] BRW ^CXU J\ JY SY G\ Ah\ULR?

BL : C peLX] WoN]VLR Cef\.

TVYL[e Ly| TeL Y|.

R UR

ThRY: N.R UR G\ G]?BL :R UR GT R Gf\YPV LLThRY: A VW HTyP?

BL : R, pRR Gf\Y LX HTyP.ThRY: ARh G] BRW?BL : R Gf\Y N]RLo NXT|

YehL RThRY: RR N] GTRh BRW G]?BL : R NjL NW TyPR Cef\.

A A C\V BU X U\URjL[ T LP, LP Yeh, TX

ARjL[ ST Y| G\ TR]RVY CX GTR| BXN]ehAeh TRU]R G|eL|U\YL[ R|Y TYU h\U,3 4


3/30

LP RP]V CX, BLV ARhBRW Rze LzeL YzV AYpVX.

ThRY: N WT SX U NUR] NLATzV] AURRT SUehe LYX

CX.

fY UR

ThRY: fRY UR GT G]?BL : fY UR GT fYW NX

TyP LLThRY: A G ?

BL : T ThRY: f GTY V?BL : f LP hUWThRY: ATzV V N]?BL : f N Cef\ThRY: JY R] C] G eL AYW

YehXU TU?BL : H TR?

ThRY: ATzV] CT JY Y EP S R LP G N] JeLW?

BL : C peLX] WoN]R TVYL[eLyL Y|.

LUV UR

ThRY: LUV UR G\ G]?BL : LU S GTYW NXTyP

LLL[ EPVThRY: ARh G] BRW?BL : hW G YefVThRY: A VW NXTyP?BL : LP[ ATTyP LU S AYL

X YVeLTyPThRY: ATz G V N]?BL : S AYL N]ThRY: ATz G V N]?

BL : hW YefVjL Cef\P Y TXNypVjLef\]

ThRY: Y TX NypVjL GT GY?BL : ARe LX S AYLP CR TX

TVYL Yeh Cef\.

ThRY: LP[ ATTyP R GTRh BRWG]?

BL : C peLX] WoN]?

T

ThRY: U\ URjL C T R]?BL : B, CTzTyP R

ThRY: ATzeL CY[ URjL[ JWLP EPef CT G SfW?

JeL UTyP WTyPU] LPYehL, LP[ ATTyPYL. LP AYRWjLGTYL, AYL[ YehL, NTRTyP URjLRYjL, TXR LP RU T\YL BfV GXW JW LP N]. AYW ATTyPL.AY pzR GT VVUhU?

AR] R, CYL, JY qReLWL[,AYL[, BW T UR NLehSU NV Y| G\ LYX LPYL[,(URL[) EPeLTyP G GQYzef\.ATzefXU JW LP C AYW CY[URjLeh URLRLeh BRW c G\, ATLP UUe hQ TeLTPXV? VW pXURLeh UU L|TRLLe LP[ yP[ehY TX LPL[o pzT TX YRjL[opzT NV?

BRX CU UR GT VTW; URLRLL, YR, WQ GTYL VTWo NWehLGT ThReLWLeh T| cV. C NUV RTL

CR CeLX.

S CY CcVjL JW LPVYL[fCYL GX N SWeh EU G\ Je5 6


4/30

LY. ARY C UR LP[ EPeLTyPGTR, YR LP Yeh GTR, f LPAYRW GTR, LUS LP[ ATTyPYGTR hW] U\ URR Je LY.B] AYL GX C J\ CXU YY

AWVjL[L pX WQ]YL[L pX JUReh U\ UR RYjLeh J URRXYehU\ URRXYLeh U\L CT]?

BL : C pWUU] WoN]VLR Cef\.TVYL[e LyL Y|

ThRY: NYLNU TVYL[e Ly| R

L[X. B] C S GR S GTzSPLY?

BL : CYL GX EU G\, AXEU AX G\, GTzV CeLy|. ARLL SLYXTP YP, EXf UR E[YW SXRG, SXRo NV Y| AY[R

ThRY : SX G V G GTRh A[ L

G]?BL : C L LPU] WoN]VL RCef\. B] TVYL SP LyzV NCT CYL[e L| R L[ YzVR.T : TVY V GTRh A[ L G]? JYY JYW TVY G\ U\Y AYWJeLYX. AYeh U\L AX Y\\oN]YW TVY Gf\ CRh J Tc h

Y|U?BL : C Lz]U] WoN]VLR Cef\.CRLX EPV NUR] R G]? NTT.

ThRY: G NUR] G]? SR UR YTT] Y, SL. rVUVReLW G\XTV Yjf]Y] yP]. G ToN V LyTL? BLW\ EUeh RU RVyPEPV E[ NR hzLzef\ LPEQY G L EUV] NRLR Y

N LYRLLY LyP. SX Y[VL TNXyP G] YVU TVYL[e Ly|oNf\ G NW AY G]eh WT BLL CTzTyPYL AU. L AU NRLLyP Az,ER,SL, WUQ Y, BVY

................ G\X Y zRYL T B|YL.BRX EU TeiP G]eh NRLR.

BL : G] NRL?

ThRY: BLW AXY GBL : S EU BL. ARY J LPCT G Sf\Y

B] CR] URjL[ URLRL[ ARRUR YRjL[ AYVX LP[ NXTyPYGTR, AYRe LRL WQjL BfVY EUGTYL[ T AYSeL LPY R.

ThRY: ATzV] LP JY E| GUy| if\ E LP SeLV V GR BL

XypV NY?J hyP URLR AX J hyP UR GTYL[ He L[RY STRY GX U\UReLWeh SL]SeLV\Y] BY.

BL : VW GTzV TLy| G]eL]? Geho N G TyPRo N y|o N Tf\.

ThRY: H Nf, EP R CU! EUeho NG TPRR R NU! G]eL] LYX? GTzCR BLL EU YL|RTLGTRR NXYR. Y\ CX. N TY. \h NeLX.

7 8


5/30

2. ATY Yehe L|yP!

R : Hz Nchyz AY NV Bor Rz, AYfyPG]z WLpV Tr\

UL : CX AU, S p]ehZRV CeLoNX [VzzRT UQ J |Lyz].

AR Y CR A|R B rei CzeL YR. SCzeLRP G N]. ATzV] G]Lyzef\V G LyP. S | CzTUBLy|U NyP. AR CR] S U]pXYopz CT Y LeL\z.

R : G]z N]?

UL : S G]U NXy|; BLy| G NRXoN

R : Az Az SNUT] P, eL]VLyzef\ N], TX TL, [efXTL, E]eh J E[ UR YW

UL : LoreLR AU, AT S BLy| G

NR AXY? AR Yop| Y LyP] S G] N\; AT S ATzo NXUCR yP CzopT]U

R : E RXX STe LyP S 2,3 Ych]V E]e LVQ TQ GEjLTfyP N]T NWR NyPU X NyPUG]U TWZoNyP hefP\Rz G N] ARWUQ; CT UeLop| [Vz]TRreieh Yehe L|yP NV, C] LtNS T] T\Veh Nefeh T hzef\TR

Yehe L|yP]\XYz NY. G YT GVWRz. AR reiW| Ltp]R T

UL : CXU, E]X S LtrY]U 2,3Ych ] LVQ BR iP AT S

Yeh RY\ UyP]U. Ceh R J Y NX.CT AY Y N] YR G]z NchyzGT]. AT CTzR] LyP.

R : AzoNP. N] YRVYUQjLyzVY, AY CU CjL YR E UWA|Y RU?

p]ehZRV CehT G]U N][.AY Y CT LeL\]. G]z AVV C?

UL : UW AeL YPU, reiW G UWeLorP\ G N CeL. VW NW^hyzL[. AL UW LRopzeL. AUG] LRop P\ N].

R : AVV Ly|ToNzLV. SU h|TRV, ^VV, TZefyPV, S LY TP\z E]X.

UL : AUU, YPU, ] S G]UNXy| reieh?

R : G]z NX\ S AT LZRV CeLoN

YzeLV N]. CT G]UP Y CR]RVULe LeL\ G ARyzo NXz.

UL : CT S LZRR]U

CT VWVY LyzP, Lyz] BTPV] C10 S T; S hZRV CehT LVQN LP. YP T C N]

T|Y]? ATz RU rei LyT. J RPYYeh RY] G]? CW| RPY Yeh RY]G]? A\ ] ] Yeh RY] R G]U?9 10


6/30

S rei fyP NyP. Lyz] AY]eLyzef\. CXyP LVUP Nef\.G]eh c] YP. rei L UTz SGTzU T.

R : EjLT YWy|Uz. S[e LX YWT\.CRX AYP N E] CR YWeh[LYGY RXXY Lyz RX P\.

UL : ATzV G]U NeL, S G]Ureieh YR L|yP.

R : E,E L|Tz B G[TV CR,

G Ny| ToN z yP.

CW 1 Ueh rei Ncehyz R KzyP].LX RLT] YR.

R : HToN Ly{[; Nchyz A|R reiPW KzyP

RLT] : AY]|R T] G E]eh GTzR.

R : S AY]| pop| TpefzR SLzoN. AY J p] LZRV UeLop| [V|T AY] Lyzef\YeheL|yP[. AeLL AY]e LyzeLU.ATz GP N\. YR. AT YR NWQ. TV| KzyP P.

RLT : NV RXR T; AY UX AYehBN Yy|. G]U N| KzyP; SXLV;CR SU AVefV XV AYeh RhR U[Y] .5000 YWRdQ LVQo NX .2000 BL7000 Teh GjL T\? VW ef\?

TLy| T! AY G.G.p. Tr TCeL; SX AN NV; WUQ]yPU NeLoNYX CeL. WUQ G.H.Tzef\ N, NV

G.G.p Tzef\ N; qefWX HR YXehY|Y, SU yP NV.

R : IVV ANy| WUQ! ATzR CRJ R SVeL CXV? NVTPY KP\?

RLT : G]U AY Leh zoNY]| TyP;SU ^X CXyPX Y VW| T]RG]? Reh NVeh G]z VN, UyPJR] E]eh G]eLz CR] BW.

R : rei AYX TQ zTyPXYYop|Y. C AY[ TeL zU?

RLT: Y] AYeh T ] Ty|Yz, V YPU\.

R : N N AYeh T] ST G] NY?

RLT : G]U NY. S NUoN A\ V{LeL\Y C ATz Rz GX.

SUeh G]z TV . 7000 oNUorz. rei AYTpTpX ST UefiP J EVL Y|. J NR TPR. VWY LyP G]N\jf\V. LjfWLW LyP C JUG NXz, ^zLW LyP rVUVRNyP G NXz. A\ V SUP YYTT.

R : N TLY] LX CTzV Ly| TL?

RLT: G]z Ly| Top? S[ Yceh T{,Nchyz RjLefWLUyPU [ TPT\,GjLV AY N[efVU CR N; T YXVT.

11 12


7/30


8/30


9/30

AoNL : S[eh YefZU AY Leh YY. Ajh Y AY[ BpYR Tf\UTpy|T. \h AY[ EU y|eh fWLTX RVYWoNf\ U\o NjL ^PUPVLo NAf\. A\ W Te LU; W

WUQ. EU EP AY TyP Ud GNW Nf\. ARo rXLR NVf\. E]eh C Rc Cef\ ARh J YW NTLYeh S [eh Y 2 S[eLY WUQ NYNR fWL Rc G NY. AYGP Y NY. ARh W N GN|f\. A\ EU NjL AY NjL ......

^pV : HjL AY RpV\, ULLyzeLVT[. CRLX HU |Y[?

AoNL : TjL TVU, Rp G]? ASL TVy| TLeh GX CU N AYLATzV SP fWLRcR eLf\L, WiyP z; S]o N] z. N fWLG N] AYL NUeL yP AYL

AYVYjL |. SUP TVY[ TVeLWG\ Gef\? sW G\ AN sWRjL.

^pV : N, SULW, T Yf\. S[eh R]

AoNL : B S[ehR. S[ehR. UWCRVX Y N PR.

^pV : CX. CX. RjLU[ RW U\RX]V U\ yP.

AoNL : N,N

SU SUa, SU SUa.

4. S CeL TVU?

RLT : P RjLY! G]P TzeLY UyPjf\V.E]eh TeiP NT[ GR], y| YVehNT[ GR]. C] RL, T, T GR]?UN 30,40 T E]eh JReh NX Bh. TzeLUCTzV \V, C G]P SV.

UL : G]T LQ zefy| TrjL. STzef\] CXV ARX EjLeh G]eh.Tr TTyP TUXY EjLeh.

RLT : APyP TVX TzeLyP GTzP TrTY?

UL : ARX EjLeh G]eh, EjLehTrR] Y?

RLT : AP! UTz ATzV TN\V. TzeLULR Uopy| \. Tr TQ T\VUGTzTY? NT rR TY.

UL : CXT; LopeLjL. A J WLpVCeh; S GTz Tr T T|Y.

RLT : GTzP?

UL : ATBB CRT. CR] RU CRNTT PX. CR Yjf LXV LXV,C|XV LyzefyP TzeLY YzVXT.R] TN| RU?

RLT : AP AP NRTVX! E]eh GR UPVP

CTzo Ne L|RY? AY] AzeLUP.......RX. C G]P AVV; S UR 30,40 E G[ehAf\. LehY [eh C|X Ly|\ SeLr

17 18


10/30

U JQeLyzefy|TzeL YzVX LRUef\VP, EjiP L[ CRe hyzorYjLX CTzR].

UL : BUT CRTNjLiP ATzR. AYRjLX Yjfe Lyzefy| Cef\; CY YXYjfe Lyzefy| Cef\; S AVX YjfeLyzefy| Cef\. TX GX JR. GXTr TQ T\ TjL[.

RLT : (AL LTP) AP UPTNjL[ EjLehGR yPTVP N]Y CTz.

UL : AT GjL[ Y] yzeLT. YVWyPRT. AYRT GjL[e iy| CWLpVUNe L| UP LT rTW LPX YjfeL|R. J S[eh GR] eh RjL[; LrehT\Y, Yeg, YzeLW JYR YjfeLyzefy| T\jL, SU YV TtNTLNNR]T CR Rop LPehe L| Cef\.UP LT rTW CR PXLeh ^ T G|e

L|ef\. AR CjL WT eh; yPjLT,LyPV Tr T T|Y.

RLT : HP NP[ TNjL[ CTz GR] S[SPehP

UL : CR CW| YNULR WU SPehjL.

RLT : GT zop Lyzefy| Cef\;

UL : T] YN zop Lyzefyzef\T.

RLT : ] HP T] Yc Tr TQUTyP

UL : AT S CWP TP SXe iP TzoN.

H TNLX G YVWe LyP. AY NTTNV STU TzoNVX. AR]X N rop

TyP. CUXVor AYWV S AT{

N] A WT WLpVULo N]WT. ARS NTTYV Sfy| N Tefy| TzeLUV Cef\]T G]eh RjLX NTT Yjfeh|efjL[.

RLT : Az NTX; RYzV UL], AY]P ARYV G Y TefP. S UN UN 30 EG[eh Af\. AR TXeh T\R YVTV ToNe Ly|efy| FyX NR efy|LR UopefyP \.

iTy\ EjLU[! Az Az LyPV EUYtNV. GY] NTTY. GjLV Cef\]. AY

tpTyP J RLyP C|X LyzefyP ToNXTN|U ARe LyzefyPjL TzeLe iPR. TzoN

AR NTTSeL E]eh TVU]? G] STU

TzoNV Lorefy| ToNX NT

Ty||U. AR]XR T] YN AR TT CYehrop TyPRU. Ae LNW CR YN LRUef\z TRV AR YV TVX G]TQeiPRz? TRVz CY]. CY] Tef\ SW

Tef hzopR CW| RW YRX TehU.SX L[eLyPVyPU Cfy| CTz TyP[V TeL\.

RV : LoreLjL! TVeh G] RjL; AR T[T] Ty| fPT AR YVS T]eh G] TV] Lop G]TQ\. S CY] TeL\eh jL J

TQU SUWU CY] TR EjLehRTjh|. YV N] YeLeL| Y |jL ARYVWe Ly|jL CTY AY] T C|iyWRXV SX pRyz Ey||\.

UL : AT, AT, YV NXjLT. YVW LeLjLT. YV CR JRefyPtNX YP. N]eL CR YN TT rop

T|Y G N]jL.

2019


11/30

RV RLT : G]eh R H AYATzoN] G, RtN S G] TYAYeh R. G] B] N. TX]t N;AR YV TVX HU AR ef\ ARGoNeLX Le LPeLW] JReLU PT\

X.

C AR TeiPeh TLR. yzXVTz. Y\YV Yore h|ef\ G NTy| L BeLQ G|fy| YVWRzefy| T\jL

SWUop C] S[ehY NoN NjLVo

Nf\.

h : C Y TVL VW hT]YX.

5. Ye fZU [ehYR SW !

SL VT: IV! RjL GP LX LrUX

Yjf YL[ A RjLeh RYV CXV GTRR yP AR Y JY Y|U NUV] LP Le Lzef\. AYeLYL| PX G Yef\. G]eh TQehL AYNWUTR RV N EP] R|jL

YL : NyzVW! AR SL RYX. YjfeL|

y|eh YT ] heL Tor. ATRYzVX G U yP. yz T|LT L BNTy| UX E[ LNGTRL. A 68 LrL, Gy| GeLLP G GjL h|Th BYYX.AR] AYL EP] gZ Ty| yPL. AR]A GjLeh YzVX.

SL VT : ATzV], RV N L||jL.Y JY LeLzef\.

YL : Ba, L| |Y ByNTQX LXUSW YjL L| |f\.

SL VT : AY C CWeh Feh Tf\YAR] RVN CTR L| |jL

YL : NyzVW RjL[] SLW CefL.Ye fZU. A [ehYR SW. CR NUV\R yz T SLV Y L|eLXU?A Xyr AXY?

SL VT : G] AV VTWLL T|LeheLyzy|e L| Yf\ G G|e L| YRSLVe LyP. Ye fZU [eh YR SWGfL[ C G] Jjh? FW SLeh S G]SWU] GT G]eh [jLXV.2221


12/30


13/30

G TR. Lr AT GyPR. EP]RXVo r GyP. EjLT TyzYyP. CT Y NyzV AYNWT|f\. VWY\ fWef Le Lzef\R. YefZU,[eh YR SW RXY TyzV \eLXU? V

N TT.

UL : IVV! CR] TV Aeh yPVef\.hy| SeL |jLXef\R, YVY,NVY WhBY,L BY? FW y|SLVYjfeL| Y Tyz Y yzeL|Yt, N TrY Yh JjL Cef\.TNU G|e L|Y L||, CXyP

TyzV EP |Y RU?

(ARh AT Y yP.)

AT : G]P TVX, TX AL WNjfVTyP! S ATR E] hz AWrTeLV TzeLYP. Ly| TY GN]] CXV? ATXY Tze Ly|e

hyzorYW TyPVXY? LU. LU. CRCZTL J [ F[ p[L[VX SLUef yP.

UL : Yh S\ef\ G NeL| EP]AU C| Nf CR NV |jfeL|T TyzV \ SLV G|eL| YL| NyzVW UehTz Ly|e LP,

c T^: WhLX AR NyzP SLYjfYRR NL] LV. C Y C]GY[Y L| Y. G] AzeL Y|...........XG JYeLY TpeLPL.

6. L WLpV

(CW| YL WUQ JYeLY TpeLf\L)

LQT NL : G] rYL[ NeV R]?

XyrUQ NL : HR RjL BqYRRNefVR.

LQT NL: hZRL GX dUR]?

XyrUQ NL : AYL pY TU ARWjLSRPV LPyNR dUULY Cef\L.

LQT NL: hZRL GX Tzef\R?

XyrUQ NL: Tzef\L. B] ARLLS TyP pWU Cef\R ANyN TLYehRR.

LQT NL: G] AY[ LP?

XyrUQ NL : ARV Lyf; J\YGPV hUWL WUQ G\ NX zV.

sW G R NX Y|. Tz cVJ NV] LYX G|e L[YX. GSWTR sW TVL[P N Lf\; pLWy|hzef\; S[X CTzV R; qUoNWV hzef\;zWU BPT |f\; AYL JY TyNehS TyPT| Y NX zV.

LQT NL: AR] cV, TVL TyNeh

RjL G] T|T|f\?

XyrUQ NL: ARV LyfL? TyN YyP G]eho NP SWX, J CWzh

2625


14/30

TLeiP SWX.

LQT NL: G] AY[ LP ?

XyrUQ NL : LPU? Nf\ LjL

RXY TyN LX Y yP TyNeLL[R Y TVLeho NYRh AX AXoNCY[ AY[ G NX zV. HR SPYY pyz RX]L WR]R] CTR]AYL RVeheLy|Ty|. TyNeL Gf\YLSU TRTR T ^P UPVL CW| JN |YL. A HRY LtN LP CehU], AoNreLWLeh ReL pTr z Ajh HRY

J CW| TyNeLfR TeLf\. A NVe fPeLyP, TyN B] \h TyN TTL[ Ueh T|f\L[ AYLPTLtpe iRz Ueh AL TPo Nf\. CTzVX LPTy| S[L[ .H TNefYR.

XyrUQ NL : CRX rXTUL zf\R?

LQT NL: IVV rXTU? A C]YyLeL|. GR] TV Uc pTr Yzef\.J NUV YNpX pTr: U\ NUVILy ^y^ pTr; U\ J NUV Gefz LpX pTr; U\ NUV AyYLy ^]W pTr; TXNUV G^Lc] zTyUz Ceh CTePRX]YL pTr. WpPp UyPy pTr iP

J RPY YjL SR.

LQT NL: CYL GX CRh NUTL[?

XyrUQ NL :CYL[X WUQL[ef\YLP R] S TY sWP AYVWY S iy|o N] JV S TLYUyP. pXNUV S yz BPV[ AY.

LQT NL : AYL T G] NYL?

XyrUQ NL: G] NY G\ LyfL? TVALL y| TLP T Af\. AY U]Wjf RjL ceho pTr Nf\. CTzR, CReLX ]Y G] NY? J RPY TjLLyL YzeLVeh; SU CWPY TV @pe

Gf\ TP G|eLP; @pe Gf\ YRAY Y ZV, GRXU GRRV. sW NYLN R]. WUQ Yeh GTzYeh. CTzeL TyN YyP. GPVRV TV RL iPYjLX. RLheL|R TQR pLWy| hzeL, P KyPehTL, NX T |f\. S G] Nf\? SUAV Y L T R. AY NNW WT

SXY. NL[, NL[ CTz TQXU?GjL G N EjLeh G] h\ GLyPL. EUVo N]. EP] J qy| GJYW RR.

AY YR CRo N]. EP] AY G]oNVW A Ueh R y|eh YWo N].ARTzV S AjL T]. K LfR GP

L| CR T Ge LP Te L|YL||Tzo N] . ATzV NR.ATz SU TV TyNeh T Y RTyN NV GRX G NyP. ]AY y|eh T AR. AYeh G]eh SPRNTcQVo Nf\ LjL.

AY : G]V TyN TT L|e iP EjL[

GR zVyP G] Nf\.?

S : GTzVY RjL R LT\ Y|.

AY : CTzV GY[ Teh S NY?

S : ATzV? C] Veho NfL.

AY : WUQ TVL GXeh R H\eh\VNL| Yf\.

2827


15/30


16/30

LQT NL : N EjL [L[X G]Nf\L?

XyrUQ NL: TVY BqYRR A Jh\X. BeL YX R Cef\L.

TVY Ny Nef CTePWef\. A|RYTr CTePWef\. \UY LjfWpTW dUU Cef\. SXUY YegXef\.

LQT NL : ATzV UTz EVLjLAYL GX GTz [jhf\L. AXU LjfWpTW dUU ef\ G NL[ A G]?

XyrUQ NL : LyTRh A L YzeLVLR Ceh, N Y[V. AP] N y|Y Nf\.

LQT NL : S T AP] Ny|Yf\. CR X[gLjL GX G]ehe LyLBNVef\.

XyrUQ NL: ATzV] C GY[YNjLef\; RW[Uo Nf\.

LQT NL : ERW L|eL Y|. XYoNR]. Ny|y| Yf\. TpeLzeLX. SULW T Yf\.

XyrUQ NL: N ATzV AYpV YjL

7. GXTL LXRYL[?

BLT : G] AV SLW! U RU NWU\ cVjL[T ByNTQL GTzRTL[e LP[ TNL[ \ yP. BRXAYL cV BL ^efWRV CeLY|U NT UW TV AVefVR] GTR G] AWV. A cV S EjLP

N Lf\.

SL : AU! ATz RjL NXeiP.URUNW U\ GR cVjL AVefVR]ULCR CR cV U RUNW NYRjL Je L[R Y|.

BL T: AR] AV jL iP ATzo

NfL? C R] EjL A CVeLVefVR? GX TLU TNL?

SL : B AU GXU RTNL CRLLjL Le LY TVX.

BL T: G] AV EXL E[ TLGXWU jL ToNL G ]efL?

SL : B.B. B. CR EXL E[ TLUWUX U EXL E[ TL[ iPRSL E[YL G NYX.

BL T : CTzo NY RUUhU?

SL : LP[ EPeLTyP YR NWU]

URUNW NY GTz TVh. ARUUh?NjL TT. Y|U] A NV S^T|R RVW Cef\.3231


17/30

BL T: G] ^? SNUT] ^? NLy|jL TT.

SL : SU TVYL LT TypeL ReLTyNL Yef\L, BRX AYL[ SrXT HUP zV.

BL T : G] TyN AV A?

SL : NXy|U LeL[e iP.

BL T : LTU]V; Uz L]R R]Y TV. RW[Uo NjL.

SL : RY RZ A LS RRYTV] T UZ! Gf\ TV U XYYRYeL LyzefL[?

BL T : B Lyzef\.

SL : LPV UjLVL UZ TV\ T

Gf\ YRYeL LyzefL[.

BL T : B Lyzef\.

SL : N ....... F UZ T YcUorhzeL R fPV. RV N J CW| EZ (2AjhX)UZ TVo NjL TT.

BL T: C SUXf\ LVU? RYhCPRXXY z? CR FeLWL G]AefWU T]L[! AR] CRTL UZCXU Ref\L.

SL : GR T GTz RR jLL[YL[R UZ TV\ T R] BLY|. AX CR F J L[ TQY

CR UZ T R] W Y|. GT TLN] UZ TYXV ATR TL[XL[YL AX; TNL G ^YL XV?

TUV Vp TjL CRVX SNXX. YRjL NWjL Nf\].BLV CU NWjL[T NRLTPL.A L YL N]YefV LPN] YR NRfV C URh BRWU]

UyNh NRLU]U] URUNW TVhU?AR]R] S iP LVQ N L[X.

BL T : GR]R?

SL : TL[e LVQ N LPcUL AYL TNR] NVU efWRVLeLT\ Y|U URUNW Cef\]

R.

BL T : ] G] NfL

SL : LP[ \XV TL[ TNL[\ yP V LT T zVU TyP. NWjL TR] Tz J Ny| UZehYX. L E[ T G RYRh UR VpV

V, SPeL zVR LVjL[o N LyP Y|ULRL GYef\L. UZ TV YT,YZRP GTY, sV] U\TYCeLPXV YLYTYU TL GXN T\zf\ BRX GY] LyzeL|LT\y|. LP NV WLW SUeh fPTfPeLy|, GTRLe L pY] G EyLLzef\], UW YRY R F\UyP],

Gf\ RV E|.

BL T: ATzV] jL NeLzR J h\X. CR U RU NWYR TVU CY\ EPefVRAX JeLPR B] LP[L SNU TLy|,CU CR BL SUeh YPY YP SUGL Sy|eh YP.

3433


18/30


19/30


20/30


21/30


22/30

RXY cV, hT NjLV CYVefVRV YVef. CR CWPY cVRYLeLX AWN]TY VefVR,T VefVRV YVef. CR CW|cVjL cL[ Je L[TPX

GTRVY Lyz \Y cVU c JeLP U JeLPL. EXL JeLP GTRe Lyz SXY cV. AYRWjLGTR VefVRV YVef.

tpV CWyNRL G, CWyNRL GBVL GTTyPYL[o Nf\L? NYef\L GTR J WP T L

Zeh BVL GTz Y LX Lf\LGTR YVef. CR TZU J EXLRHU\o NeL Y| AX C AYL TZeLYZeLUL CeL Y|. BLY Aeh CW|iPAYL NL EU CR A SPVcVjL R GT CR cV] YT|f\.

10. BpV UQeL NTcQL|Y L| ]T

CWUVQ Yh BpV : P BVNjLW!BVNjLW : AV YQeL.

CWUVQ Yh BpV : SU CWUVQ LVC L|Y L| ]T GTRh H\ NV]NTY J G|o N.

BV NjLW: AV, J SX TRU] NTY JG OTLh Yf\ Nf\.

CWUVQ Yh BpV : N TT

BV NjLW: CWUVQ LV Y RNWRCWU L|Y L| ]T GTRh NV]

G|e Ly| AV.

CWUVQ Yh BpV: G]P BVNjLW, rRyP[L Cef\. CWUVQ LR SVLL[fV RNWRNeLWYV CWUTLY] TV CTzoNf\?

BV NjLW: S NY RY\X AV. RjL

NYR LReh U\L, LRY\L Cef\.RXY RNWR NeWY AX. AY J p\WN],CWU, J TLY] AX LRTz AY eL gRWU]UR] BY. TT]L AYL[ LyP hQjL[U\ AYLeh CXR RUL[ Hf UeL[HUf\L.

CWUVQ Yh BpV : ATzV] L|Y L|

]T G\ TZUeh RNWR, WU GTzG|e Ly| BYL NTT.

4443


23/30

BV NjLW: reLULo Nf\. \h [eLLQX RNWR CWU TWR] Ytpe LyPGQP AVV CWU B Tzo sopNRL ARe LyP GQ sop [ RNWREW yP. CWU TPyzVyP, z

SyP CWYQ UeLeh yP.

CWUVQ Yh BpV : AP,AP, T, G]P CTzTrf\. E Sef SYWR?

BV NjLW: AV H LefL? RjL CWUVQYh BpV B\, RjL CWUVQ TzL[.

AVV S| Veho NR? GRh BLCWUeh TyP Ly|Y? GRh BL CWU AR HeLY? RNWR sRL YtNL GQP CWUehTyP LyP Vpef\. CWU LyP GQR|YtNL]L C S| TWReho NR G RRTyP Lyze L[o NUef\. CR TV] CWULy|eh WRTyP, RNWR E yP, L| N\CWU R U]V CWYQeh ] NTz

yP. CWYQ qReh [ L| hN, XYG C [L[ T\o NR.

CWU NR SyP CR CWYQ [LBPL. C AV AYL GR RY GfL?

BRX L|Y L| ]T GTRh YfCWUVQe LRTz RNWR CWUU NV]

TRU] G|eLy| BYL.

11. AVjL BpV RUQY EWVP

YQeL G N] LoNyPV

BpV RNWRWU AVjL : P RZWN!RZWN : AV, YQeL

B.R.W AVjL : G]P RL YQeL fQeL GBWopyP G] Lo NyP N yPV?

RZWN : ATz J CX AV SjL TUQYL S J iyP Ty| RZ Y[T GTzGTRT Tp]; A RZL i|U]YW RXV TpTZL Y| G UR; AR]XCU N GTRh TXL AV G SURGTRh TXL YQeL G NY GTRLz N LP. AY[RjL C

LoNyPX LRNyPjL RZ RTN Y| Gf\ JW NyP (LYX) RjL

B.R.W AVjL : ATzV] S Tr GXYReh RXV YRe L| z TNzU SU?

RZWN: H zVjL? RZeh RXV

TNzV G\ YyLUXY? RZeh RZ TpeL[ NL CX G\ A CWyz YyLjL[?

B.R.W AVjL : Ka, ATz] iReh C]Ro N?

RZWN: U

B.R.W AVjL : R]h?RZWN: X4645

j


24/30

B.R.W AVjL: LT GTRh?

RZWN : p]

B.R.W AVjL : CR YRL UeL CPTrYRh ApjLUL CeLR ?

RZWN: ApjL G] YR? CR NL YYWEXf p\R CXefVUfV h\ TX RPY TVT|RTyzef\. ATz CeL S NL[ SU CYeLe L| AV NL[ TVT|f\.ARY pX Yh] RjL Yh R TVW CYLeLe L| RjL[ U RjL Yheh C RYT SPTR CYh.

U RVR NLeh T] TLy| G y|PX; RR NLeh H Yo NL[o NXY|. ATzo NY RZ RZV C T|YT BLXV?

B.R.W AVjL : N.N TV RZUVL BfyP.

JW S CY[ U yPV?

RZWN: JW S J BfP XjL, [eLYR EP] YoN BfTh CRh GR]SBLY.

B.R.W AVjL : N,N CR R A G]eh JByNT] CX CRLL U\ UL Yc

YP GT R G BN?

RZWN: Ye iP GTR GjL GQ B]SUR GTRh YQeL G N]XV AR YG L] ARh SjL G] NV z?CT RjL[ S YQeL G N]P]VLoNyPV? G Ly| y{L[, CR RjL Nf\YW U\eLUy{L[, CT S Y TehR]

TL YzVY]L Cef\. CjfR G]RjLRXV|eL YyPU A |L.

B.R.W AVjL : G] RZWN. CTz ]ef\CRVX U\|, SXTV E G]eh LA RU?

RZWN: R AV, S CTR U\ |Y.

AV AYL R U\eLYUyPL. GTzV BLy|.RjL G] YQeL G\ LoNyP G]ef\T C S CRToiP AW ciP CeLUyP. Ai Nyz@Ly L|jL SY GjLY To N Tze Lf\.

B.R.W AVjL : N. C\eL Nyz@Ly YjfeL. CjfR U\ [L[ L| |Y.

E R CX. CT f[ CehYcTz E] CTz TrTz N yP. Tz WT LyzLW TV LyP NLYNRCTz Bf yP. CR GQR| C GjhT] ETz BLUyP.

RZWN: S ETz BLUyP G N]RhSV| YQeL AV. S ETz Bf G]

BLY|? ETz BLU T] Reh RZehEZeL Ye fPeh RjL N]R SYeLLeL| C GR Teh TY CX. YT] Lo NyP R Ty|e L| RYL, R YL GL JL G RP\Tf\. S.

4847


25/30

12. TY RY CWLpV

( TY T K AV BWop EWVPXe gZ Rf\.TUWL TXWY EU R Y R[TYV TzR iyPR iPe LP|f\L[! ARYyLeL|NYL GTYL iPe LP|f\L[. AC TV YyLeL| GXU CR TeLy|)

P : P, WU^ .......... GjLP Tf\ ?

WU^ : GjhX TX T G]eh CW|S LyL Tf\.

P: GRh ?

WU^ : 21 R TzL , 22B R NefZU23 R OefZU BL 3 S LX CX. CJ CW| S AR Jyz fPR Feh T

5 S NYLNU Cy| YWX G L CCW| S Lyf\.

P: G] TzL?

WU^ : TY TzL

P: TY G\ A J TzLV?

WU^ : B

P: ARLL GRh?

WU^ : TzL LP|YRh.

P: GTze LP|Y?

WU^ : ALX GQ R f VBP A TXLW Ny| TyPr r|Y.

P: h f V EP A TyPr r|YJ TzLV? CRLL Feh TL Y|U ARAN N, O YY TRU UL|CW|S RYV? CR]T SyL[e LX NTzLVL Cef\R. eh L LyT| CXV

Y W eh . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . S . . . . . . . . . . N ,O , YP 2 UR Y LX , YP15 S ^]Y , \h LcY , CYTG]]U CR 2 , 3 UR TX LTReh\eh SQVU , CTzV SyLTZf\]. SUeh zeh SWU J S[eh 5USWR Rf\. ATz R SyL CTze

LQehYZeh CXU SyL TZf\]. AV BypT rV Byp Y iPY CR RX? SyL[XCTz BfyP A\ TzR GTz Y?

WU^ : G]T, TY Yc J STzLVL Yf\. AiP E]eh TeLXV?UReh K YPU?

P : Yc J S[L JY S R Yf\.ARLL GX S |YR? Keh G] h\,N O TRR?

WU^ : N, O SUeh T. yzXh|TP LPP J K S YPU? NOL yz E[YLyh K H?

P : G] KY. G] LPyPU G]eh JVX CR TzLL TW YX SyLTZf\].

WU^ : G] Lo NyPeLW T Rf\.TzLL[ CTz Yef\V.

P: LoNyP CX. J CZ CX. G]

TzL C? SNU T] TzLL. CTz URUR Y EW Yjhf\]Y.

5049

e e


26/30

WU^ : ATzo NXR, TzLL GX URNTRU]YL, LP NTRU]YL, S URRoNRYL[L LP SeL EPVYL[L CRCR U TzLL[e h\i\e iP. URehUR LPR efVU JV CRe L Tz

GTRX URR NYW T LP[ NYW ATe NVR. BRX CTz GX TNR.

P: G]T oNz Ly|f\? TzL GRhG\ eh Gf\, GRh G\ Keh Gf\.N, O TRR G\ h|TR| KT\RGf\. Tze Ly||f\R G\ UReLLLPeLL TzL LP|YRLo Ne L|

CR RY G N] G]e Lo NyPeLWGf\. zYL TzTP UR LP R TARh BLR Tzef\ Gf\ C G] NUR]?U J UR \eh TR UR AY iPY\ef\. LP J UR \TRh CRAY iPY C AY NhYW AY] SPf\.CR CW| LyzV] NjLeh J UR TzeL YzVGRh? A LX TzeL YzV GRh

ATzV] LXX TzeLRYLeLX UR LPA Te CX G, YW GU Nf\?

WU^ : Lo NyPeLW R NRLXE]| Tp TVX.

P : Le L[R E TzLVAVY|UR LyP NjL GjLV T

yPR! TY G] TzL? GRLLe LP|Y?URR GTz Aef\? A LP Te GTzHT|f\? N TT.

WU^ : ATze L Nf\.

TY GT. EXLeh L| [eL J ArW.LP[ LXTyP S[ UeL LP|YRh. AR

LPPX. CT Y[V JRS[S rRW S[Le LPP XV? ATX

P: ATzV? AR ArWV? AY GTz EXheheL| NR ARe LX Ah| CeLR. CReLX Ah| YTY] C UeLNRVeh G]]Y L| Nf\YL[ T SJU TrYX. ATzeL AR ArW V?

AY]] L| NR.

WU^ : AR ArW TV SWLsW. AY \RY. AY RLT UL. AY RYLehRXe L| RYL TLehRXeL|R. AR] UL AY U]N AY]e L yPL. C GY RYLehRRW L|eLe iP GTR UeLeh

OTLT|YRLL AY NR S[e LP|YRRR? C R TYRY.

P : RR. B] AR [jfeL[Y|U G U] BNT|f\. ARY AYULeh eh GTz\eL z? V]U, L EY CRR ULeh P GTzLX NV zR? GTz LT Reh? ARh

GTz [ \eh? G]eh VXV?

WU^ : AP TVeLW], UL SWLYTe LX NY? ARh AYeh U]L CXV?BRX AY SWLe LXNVX. UL TEY G|R.

P: T,T CjL LtN [eL RY.

UL H T EY H G|R?

WU^ : AY N Nf\ L. CWVyNRG J CWyNR V TVLo ryz G|eL|LPeh T J LP

P: T, T, KPR, CjL G]eh J UVeL

WU^ : CX]T UVeL? SR RYLoNf\].

5251


27/30

AReh G|e L| Y R. TV ; P: CRTV ARh V CyPL R RRVL[?


28/30

AReh G|e L| Y R. TV ;trR?

P: VyP Le Lf\. AL WNjfGf\ N R. R V \h G] SPR?

WU^ : \L, V RP AR eh JNRc HTyP. J hc EP ARTV TR; AR T CR V TR.ARo NUV T UUR CW|TW LX VoN yP. A\ NX Y|U, LXRL \R[.

P: N CjL G NR NjL Lyf\; LoreLR

WU^ : N L.

P: YWL GT T A J LT NR]?

WU^ : N

P: L U EY NR]?

WU^ : N.

P : C CW| GTz LX? GTzeLReh?

WU^ : TV TV CR TefR]U] L

GT LP T GTz Y|U]NVXUXY?

P: G]T CWU^ TV TV GNVU TV L|ef\. C TV JNV.berY NVr NjL. CReLyP TefR]U]L Gf\. N. CR T TXe LyLX.A\ AR [ G] Bor?

WU^ : AR [R SWLrW

P: CRTV ARh V CyPL, R RRVL[?

WU^ : VW A]eLYzL CyPL? ARTG] WURU Lyf\. G]eh AYNW S TLY| G] |.

P: N TLX qefW z A\?

WU^ : AR SWLsW RYLeh RXeL|R. AY] UL L\.

P: APT. LPeh \RY] RYLehRXe L|R? ATzV\ RYL G]AY[ AVefVL[?

WU^ : CXT. CR SWLsW TXR Y[RYL fyP CY YXyz] AYL rU y||YL[?

P: ARh BL RLT ULeh NXU JWAzVLe L |YR?

WU^ : A AY CP AR LyL S V?

RYW]VLVY AYR UY] NRLX GSV] N Cef\. BRX S A H? C H?G L LyLXU?

P: N L\ ARh TYeh G] NTR.

WU^ : ARe LPP YzV AYpV H G\CU GY RYLeh RXe L|eLe iPGTRLL AR OTL YTRh AR]y|YRh S AzeLz LPP YzVGTR.

P: RYL Gjfef\L?

WU^ : Y] RYL Y] U EXLCef\L. RYL CR X Cef\L.5655

P: CR Ceh RYL V? WU^ AR T LYXTPR LjfW RT]


29/30

P: CR Ceh RYL V?

WU^ : AP yP A iPY RV? ARWUQL. WUQL G\X RYL R]?ALWVT

P : WUQL GTYL G] Yh?

WU^ : G] YhT SjL R.

P: jL G\ AVjL AVjL RN]?

WU^ : SjL UW AX AT SjL AV,

BoNV. N, NU, ypR RVYL.

P: ATzV TT]L VYU RYLGf\

WU^ : BU, BU, LXyPU BU.

P: N, RX TLy|, jL RYL G\

Ye LY. EjLeh RX L|eL ArW,WyNR JY CR EXL CXV? CjfTYL[TVT|R TY LPP Y|U?

WU^ : CjLV ArW, WyNR CX Gf\ CReLoNyPeLWL. r.UeL WP LZLRLGf\L[ AYL[X Y V? WUQL[ TT\UT|f\YL h\ iTYL; AYL[ TXY

YZ Y|UTYL YR NW WQ CLNjL[ThRY BWop NTYL RV CYL GXCWeLRTRL, CWeLU CXR AWeLL R, RRR,AYLeh TV EPYRLL RYLeh CPNR SNU T |Y G AYRhBLR TY LP|YRh. CR CWLpV. U\LR GTz CR G].

P : ATzV jL 100eh 3 T. jL AXRYL100eh 97T. CTz GR] S[eh WyP z.

WU^ : AR T LYXTPR, LjfW RT]Cef\. AR R\ TL J ThPQL[L AUL[L C WUQ RP\GL[ JeL TVT|YRh U TzR iyP.Tzy| EVLeh Le fPeh iyP. L

UP RU RT] Ceh iyP RLe LPeiyPNeiyP WeiyP TeiyP, EVTR YfehEVLR iyP, RpeiyP, pUe iyP, SPLZe iyP, LX YL AWpV ZeLWeiyP, RNTeRL VfL iyP CTzVL CPR AYL Tz NY WUQ AzUVGT T CehT 100eh 3, 100eh 97 G LQehyPR]U] LQeh Bh.

P: Ka, ATzV; N,N, TY GTR RYCWLpV RLP. S YQeL.

WU^ : SUR, ^ .

5857


30/30

6059

periyar evr_தந்தை பெரியார்_critisism on hinduism_6

Documents