sadruddin ali bhai rajani, a074 088 126 (bia jan. 12, 2011)

7/27/2019 Sadruddin Ali Bhai Rajani, A074 088 126 (BIA Jan. 12, 2011)

1/13

SUSAN FORTINO-BROWN, ESQURE

D Juic

Executive Oce Imaton Reew

Board ofImigration ppealsOce o he Clerk

507 ur Pik Su 000

Flb Chu Yr

W OICES OF SUSA FORINOBROW531 S. PLYMOUH COUR SUITE 03CCAGO I 60605

DSnCE Oice of Chief Cousel CH55 East Moroe Seet, Ste 700Chicago 60603

Name: A SADRDDN ALI BH A07488126

_ate o t ot /01

nclosed a copy of e Bod's dsion d orde in e above-eferncd case.

closre

Pane Mebes:Cole, acaA.Filu Sa g

Sce,

Donna CaChie Cek

Cite as: Sadruddin Ali Bhai Rajani, A074 088 126 (BIA Jan. 12, 2011)

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished


2/13

U eparent ofJusceExecutiv Oce r Imigaon Review

Decson of e Bod of ion Apl

Fal Vinia Fie: A074 088 16 - Ccago, Date:

SDRDD BH R a.ka. Raji Ali Bhai Sddin

REMOVAL PROEGS

APPEA

ON BAL OF EPODE: us FoinoBro, Esquire

ON BA OF

CHARE:

Paick M McKennaAssistt Chief Cose

Noce: ec 237a))B, &N Act [8 USC 1227(a((B] In e nted at in olaon o aw

APPICATON onnuce

'JAN 1 0

The resonen, a nave o Iia a cizen o Pisan, aeals e aion Judge'sNoember 19, 2009, ecision denyn s reues a continuce. e Deen o Hoeld

Sec HS) os the aeal e record wi be remed

We view e ndgs of fact, incuding e deteination of crediiliy, ade by theiation udge er a "clely eoneo. . 8 C .. 003 .1 (d)(3)() We reew loer ssue, inclug whether the pes ave et the relevt urden of poo d ssue ofdiscon, e a nv sndrd 8 C 1003(()ii); fHH & ZYZ N Dec 209, 11 (BA 00)

n appea, e espondent gues s otenal egiblity r adusent of coutedgood cae r a connce supo, he asse aplicaon r abor ceion wled on is eha d that s wfe aroed labor cerication d a ing Peon rAen Wore (o 140). e sondent er ses at, con to e Imition Judgessesnt tat e would b a ury wat r visa avaiait a visa would e availle oneye inaly, te ponent ue a cou condions Pit sod, at a mmjif dmiiiv lo n opoitin, DHS ges e mmgaon dg' diosould b smy e o e shou be sisse e ation Judgeproelyeed e espondents tenth moon o conne poceedings were te DHS opse he

1 e poden w preiousy conces on Apl 2003, e 15, 2004, Octo 7,004 May 6 005, Api 13, 2006 uy 18, 2007, November 1, 007 uy 7, 28, andua 6, 009



3/13

A074 88 16

moon e sondent fild to rove he w eble o adjus s stus, d mmnt vwnot immediely avaae o m

I deeing weer god ae exists r a connu, ation Juge sho t

deteie e responens pace in e employmetbed aent of

css d thencoside d bace te Hhmi fatos, i alcle, ad y ote relevt cosideoMaer o Rah &N D 17, 130 (BIA 009) (citingMatter f Hhi, 4 I&N Dec 785(BIA 9)) Te Hhmi facto iclde:

(1 te DHS resse to te motio; (2)weer e ueyng visa pon isprima aieapvale; (3) te sdent's suto eligibili adjent of ss; (4) wheher eeoents aplion r ajset mets a favoble exeise of discreo; d () eo r e connce d oer roce facto

d quo Hashmi, supra at 9). Te mmition Judge h obigaio to weigh al of egood-cause actos in e case be ing o te motion to one See Rajah, supra 37"Ievatiggod cause e ontuce remised o a ding labor ceication o -14, l tefactors levt to te aien's adjuset eigibili should b osidered iate eaplicabe, the miao Jdge should eicy aknowledge d cosider e odtsstus s a dfahee alie sectio 4(i) eligibili puoses); Hhmi supra 7993Wenadjsent of saus is ot iiately proximae upon e aproval of a visa tiion, i.e.,we duet elbl ded o wodde visa avlality te t o he adaoof a peo a continu may ot be aropate. See Rajah, supra at 136 (exlinig,inter aliaat a sodent wo primafacieprovale Fo -40 d adjet applicaon may otb ae to show goo cae a cotince beuse visa availi is too emote).

s cision te Immiio Judge emphsized te my oice-reuests peviously

ted (J at 4) e DS's ositio to te motion (J. at 7), d at te respodet otimmeiatey eligible immint visa "hs ori date [w] at t ye o(J at 6). e mmitio Jdge also seculated about e impact of the domesc ecnomy on e"cia viabiliy of te rsondet's emoyer .J at 67).

Wispt to the imot faos, the mmiaon Jdge not make scic igs offact to sppo ace Te rncipa adjet ce aes to b tat of te sondetsspouse e Immiation Judge di not me y ndigs of fact to he suses adjusenteligibili Moove, te Iiatio Judge's ndig he ondent's o v avilabilityw 4 ye o apes to ave e bed o e mmiatio Jdge's ogh compso of

2 A coule ofte facto i on by te mmiion Jdge w nodispositive. we td Hhmisura a 79, "he ne d le o o os no lone deeiveoeove, e sate of e domestic ecoomy is o aelevt onsido Bae we ewie aion Jdge t 4-ye w wod be oo moe sppo a ndgo good e,

wewould have d e decision, nosding te cosdetion of these nondisposive w s a deio upo y scie f-nding



4/13

A04 0 126

ied 2006 po dae w te Novembe200 Visa Bulle out eg te hsocpoessio of vsa be e esodet's pfeee tego.3

Be the Immito Judge did ot me suciet dgs to these fct, we notdeteie u n view whethe the sdet cred his be of shog good c cou Accodgly, we w emd hisc to e mmiao udge e fdg.4 Ma of S-H, 2 &N c 462, 465 (B 2002 (gve the Bods limitedfct-dig ctio t is "icigly impot the Iiato Judge to me cle dcompete dgs of fact at suppoed b he ecod d complice w coollig law

To the extet the spodet lo ses tat co codtios i Ps ettle hm to liefwe ote t he ot ded teto k lief e of l oldig ofemov o bees de e Coetio gst o. e esodet desied Ps e co mov pose o Je 15 20 t whch e he ough coel aso idictedtt he wou otb eekig syum.

e lowig ode il e ete:

OER e ecod mded to the mmato Cu fo e pocdigs istetwithe egoig opio d the e of ew decisio.

FORTIBO


5/13

_

NITED STAES DEPATENT OF USTEEXEUTIE OFFIE FO IMIGTION EVIEW

NTED STTES MMATION Tcago, llno

l No: 04 088 126 ob 19, 2009

n t Matt

SADDDIN AL BAI AAN IN EOAL POEEDINGS

Rpondnt

GE S 23{) ) {B) ) - and long anallowd

PLCTONS: oton to contnu puuant to 8 F cio100329 {2009)

ON BEALF OF SPONDENT

uan otno-Bown, Esq31 S Plym ouNo 103cago, L 6060

ON BEHALF OF S:

atc McKnna, EuDpatnt of oland

cuty Eat Moo

100cago, IL 60603

OL DSON OF TE IMMGTION UDET sponn an adut mal nat o nda, ut

zn Psa am U Sas on o aout

un 30 o 2000 a a to t t t, ad pon to

an n t ntd tat o a tpoa od no to cd

c 9 of 2000 Bcau t spon a naod wt

t as, l s as s

tu t onnt an ong tan alow, a any

s nsqly wn t Dpatnt mln Sy


6/13

go id e eode sil i e ied ae, e

isued im a oice o ea b eolly seg e docume

o im o Mc 1 of 003 Se Exibi 1e esode, oug cosel, coceded e, i ac,

ed o emi i e ied aes, ad, , i ife a

uig e labo ceificio Cosequel, e eode

did cocede emoabili s cged, geed o desigae Pakisa

e cou of emoa, bu ked is Judge fo addional

me o usue labo ceiicaio o o be abe o deive

someo fom e abo ceiicaio filed o bel of i

oue.

Begiig wi il 1 003 e esode fs peed

befoe i udge ad ased o addiiol ime o e

cousel is Judge, as is sul, i ey geeos i s

gaig of coices, ad ee e mae fo abou eig

mo, o ua o 004

O Jaua 15 004 e eode eued, d e

eed i Ms oio-Bo, akig fo u a lile moe

ime, udge, ad, of coue i udge ged im i e

eecie of disceo addiioa ime, b admosed e

ie o come bac ay ad all oms o elie o

Ocobe o 004

O Ocobe 7 o 004 e eode ad cousel eed

ad ifomed Judge ee as a lbo ceifico a

ad ee iled o s i e ocess of beig fled d asked

oembe 1 00


7/13

,

s Cout o som ddtonl tm s Judg gntd

t sondn's qust nd scduld t mtt o

y 6 o 2005

On My 26 200 t ts tund, nd sondd t

lbo ct nd t I140 w n pocss o bn

djudctd nd consunty qustd ust not y o so

ndstndng t sondn mnmy ws lw dng

nddul (ot tn mnng long tn llowd, nd ts

Cout gnd spondnts ust o ddtonl tm

scdulng t mtt to pl 13 o 2006

On l o 2006 cloudy nd nng dy t

sondnt tund On tt dt nomd t Cot tt

s w d bn t bncy o t lo ccton nd

tht sondn ws o l on o out l o 006 out

wk lt, w t sondns stong ssuncs ttytng would b n, nd would b bl to djust s

sus wtn only w mo mons sondnt gn skd

o som ddtonl tm.

Cout gnd sondnt no connunc gn

to Jnuy 8 o 200

On nuy 18 2007 t spondnt tund onc gn nd

nomd Cout t w gttng y clos udg w nd

som ddtonl m us lttl o nd sd to v th

cs scduld wc t ws to om 1 o 2007

On omb 2007 s Judg ws bgnng o gt

074 088 26 3 om 200


8/13

, .

sson tht th lbo ctcton ght no b s dy o

djustnt o sttus s s bn sntd but nonthlss,

g so ddtonl to July 17 2008.

On Juy 17 o 2008, ths Judg hd bn nod tht th

lbo ctcton hd bn od nd tht h sondnt

hd oty dt n 2004 nd th Cout dd g th

sondnt so ddtonl t o Jnuy 26, 2009, but s

ldy n th ocss o contltn ny nd l os o

l bcus th sondnts ocssng ws tkng

sgncnt nub o ys.

onthlss, ths Cout contnud th cs to

ob 19, 2009 t hch t th sondnt s th

counsl, nd ndcts tht thy h just lnd tht th I-0

hs bn od, nd h lbo ctcton hs bn od.

Ho, thy nod th Cout h onnt tht s tht

th sondnt hs oty dt o 2006 hch s

undsutd Ho th onnt o mont bsd

ttons, th ty o whch th sondnt hs ld, ou

ys o n oth ods, th onnt s cuntly gntng

loymnt bsd ss to thos ho h d n 2002

Bcus th sondnt ld n 006 h s ou ys wy

o bng n oton to sk o sdnc though djustnt

o sttus

OO U

h gultons do llo o contnuncs th s good

A 07 088 4 o 9 2009


9/13

I

cae e B F. ecto 1003.29 (2009). The oa haecet coee the e o cotace a hethe

thee s goo cae o atoa te coecto th

abo cetcatos a case ette Matte of Rajah I&N ec ( BI 0 I Raah the Boa eetacte t eco Hshmi 4 I&N ec. (BI 0 hchvove the a base va petto he Boa coce

that a e o actos sho be cosee eteg

hethe goo cae exsts clg ste a the ft acto

hethe the epaet o oea Sec s oppoe to a

oto to cote I the epatet o Hoea ect

ot the the Boa has cate ata that the vsa

petto a the cotace ho "geea be gate" the

appova o the a petto o ee h pa ace

egbe o ajtet o stat. Not that t ates bt thge beeve that that a ete eaoabe poto to

take Hoeve hat s to be oe the evet that the

ovee oppoe a cotato o the case o exape a

tato sch as the oe the tat case

he Boa goe oto etee a ho that ohe acto

ho be tae to accot hethe the eg va

petto s pa ace appoabe; th cae a be bt

t s o eas o

he Boa aso cosee hethe the espoet' statto

eigbt o ajtet o stat oe that ets a

07 0 5 Novee 00


10/13

r a of ausm. s case, ma, o a o

e ou elme e oa woul ae e Cour coir

i weer e eoe' applicaio fo jum mr a

faoa exrcie of icreio is o i ma. ere i

o criial acii a i Cour i awae of, i e ia

ca or a uabl caacsic.

ially, Boa a coiee wee ao for a

coiuace a oe lea poceura faco ma play or be

a aco i e ce I i cae, i i peculaie wer

reoe umae i ou ea wll b libl fo

ausme of au

Rja, upr, oe of criical faco, i eiw ofi ue, ee e epo i iiael eliible

for a iira ia bae o mlome ba isa eio

ia cas, i clar a rsoe i o

aiculal oublsoe o i u, dpie fac of

ii eo year o ae abor cer a e -0

auica i e c a i pioi ae i a lea fou

ea off. oe wo e wil o bcom lii o

ieia eceie a ia uil a lea four as from ow if

i coiue o oci w io aes as e

e, y-oay.

i e ueiy o e eooy oay wi may

buiee, bo lae a al be comomie i ir

biliy o ay bis i Cour i cocere a e

7 88 26 6 omber 9 09


11/13

reoet eloet bae va petto y ot be oe

trog c e ca g reecy or a ber of reao

clg cal vablty o t ge ca cote to

peclate a to reo y t oeat rk to ply

cote te cae or for ear oever gve te Goveret

objeco to atoal for year o cotace a gve te

certat of te vablt o te repoet tato te

copa c a pettoe or t ge beleve tat

er te act te tat cae goo cae oe ot ext to

arrt a cotto of roceeg for toal for

yer e te repoet a a cae cote ce 2003

oeqetl t ge ll e te repoet reqet or

atoal te

Repoet a offere voltar epartre or reao

o te repoet a ecle oeqetl teollog orer ll be etere

ORER

S HEREBY ORERE tat te reoet reqet for a

cotace ll be ee a tere o goo cae

S URHER OERE tat te repoet be reove

04 0 26 Noveber 9 2009


12/13

deported fom he Unid States to Pakian on e cage

cota n t Noc o Appea.

Da: Nve 9, 9

'

\._. CRLOS CEVASS. Iaton Jude

A 074 088 126 o 9, 9


13/13

\

CRFCAE P

I ereby certfy tat te attaced roceedng before

UG CRO CVA, n te matter of

DRUDDN AL BH RN!

07 088 2

Ccao, Illnos

s an accrate verbat ranscrt of e recordng as rovded by

te ecte Offce for gon evew an tat ts s te

orgnal transcrt ereof for te fle of e ecute Offce

for mgrato Reew

os o. s, ransrberree tate Repotng nc

Janary 20 2010(cometon ate)

B submssn of ts CRC A te Contractr certfestat a ony BC/4 for-cannel transcrber, or eqalent,andor CD as descrbed n ecton C Paragra C3 of tecontract, was sed to transcrbe te ecod of Proceedng sown nte aboe aragra

sadruddin ali bhai rajani, a074 088 126 (bia jan. 12, 2011)

Documents