S.D. unu 6ihu~du~~uuuim3~iu

t ~rnu ~fiGnm~ounianm~nu61~ ( t-test )

F nu 6 i~ f i~n i3~mRo~ 6 ~ ~ a d ( F-test )

* A A d LLWU 6~nstGuob"uhQiqwi~~nmnat~u o .05

s inmis ip I w v i i fnau~ iuvsaumur i~u I~~r~urw~~"~~ iu i iw2u 200 nu

An~iluiaua: 66.70 L W R M ~ ~ J SIU~U 94 nu R F I L ~ U ~ O U B : 31.30 r r a : ~ a o d ~ n 'baj

J:~{IU~U 6 RU ?RL~U?CIU~: 2.00

o i n n i n J 3 WU% ~ m a v ~ ~ ~ v ~ a v n i u ~ u ~ ~ 1 ~ d a t n a v a i 5 j w m i i a i a u 6 a

Q i u a u 122 n u G m ~ f l u i a ~ a t 40.70 SOJ~JUI ;a 3oUaim-ns/ ? ~ ? r n ~ f i o Q i u a u

105 RU a a ~ i l u i a ~ l a e 35.00 ~ a t d ~ a i ~ ~ l d ~ m l ia r14 ~ i u a u 2 RU A ~ l ~ i l u i a ~ l ~ t

0.60

o i n m i n J 4 w v i i d a r ~ n n u o ~ a n d ~ m o v ~ ~ v v ~ ~ v n i u ~ a u l ~ ~ o t ~ ~ o n ~ a

;a annatut k u a u 149 n u 3m~f lu iaua t 49.70 aasa;rui;a and^ 4 i u a u I I I

RW G a ~ f l u i a ~ ~ a t 37.00 k a ~ I k l ~ l ~ $ ~ ~ d l t ~ hKJI.4 2 n u A ~ l h ? a f l ~ t 0.70

o i u a u I n u

41uauu inn i i I Qiu

S.D. 1 F i ~ n e l o

0.69 1 u i n I 0.61

0.73 1 u i n I

u i n

w

n i ~ n ' a u i u ~ n n i K ~ n d ~ n < i r G u ~ ~ i b " ~ ~ a " ~ u 3.70 1 0.81 u i n

0.73 u i n

a inn inJ 6 wu i i n ~ i u ~ ~ w a l ~ u a ~ ; n F i i ~ ~ ~ n u n i w w ~ n ~ i u ~ i ~ Au nnunuisom~mmiu Imurnwnu ijn2iuW~wulsa$lus:Guuin ad~dol~ isminuu ' i l

w u i i h d i j n ~ i u ~ r w a l a 3 CuGuorn8a $9 2 nisni i2Cnnio;nninjoFii i i

6 $9 I nisud~niuqmwfioufa La: u'J 3 n is fuou 'u~~ iu~n

nisid 7 ri iraiu r i i h r n d ~ ~ ~ u u ~ i m ~ ~ ~ u ~~a:~t~unaiuwaaua~;n61da

Pin un iww Gnn~iuuiu niunaiufnaiu~Gilaluwlmfim6

6. a ~ u i u s i u a ~ i r t d u m u ~ d ~ n ~ ~ n n i a u ~ i 1 0 e i i ~ ~ m ~ ~ ~ V

r iauia:rasoimnadGa"~iu

7. ~l$fl&!dYS~ M ~ ~ ~ L I C ~ R ~ ~ X ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~ " I R M ' ~ D b d ~ ds:naunisGmFjulo

8. iinisbaualfi$nninmaad~usn (Test Drive)

0.91 1 u in

~ S.D.

1.01 ( u in

szGunaiu

w " ~ w Ell9

sa u 1 3.70 1 0.81 1 uin

n n n l n J 7 w u i ~ ~ ~ ~ u i ~ w e l s u o ~ ; n r i ~ d a C n u n ~ w w l i n ~ ~ u u ~ u n i u

n~~ufn~~u~uiIaIuwZmKru.ji w u i ~ I n U ~ I W T ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ J ~ J W O I O I U ~ : G U B J I ~ W a ~ s n r ~ s ~ u u ' a w u i ~ ~ d i i n 3 1 u i ~ w a l a 3 ii'uKuusn Wa Q 7 nlswlgnFiild.au

~ i ~ i i u ~ ~ ~ u s n d ~ n n i n u I a ~ ~ a ~ ~ : n a u n ~ ~ K m ~ u I $3 r n - - a ~ u n ~ u ~ s n a b u ~ u i %

qruauuEiua~ wlmJ-Ym6~46aei1~nsusl"au ~ d u ~ n i a ~ u u n ' n--nuas~ua~~n$ao~ n~sdsmui i l

I!IGU n u & nun- i sunaadku ~ I J 7 t 2 n1ss^rm1ui;o~nmuu3 t l P G u u

oa:qruds:luariuaawZmJ-YmA~a;n<1l6adi~.a"m1au ~~a:$'a 8 n n l ~ ~ u a l r i a n r i m m a a d

q u s n (Test Drive) 6 2 U ~ 2 l ~ L ~ ~ a 9 W ? ~ ~ n 1 ~ 8 1 ~ 2 U ~ 2 l B J ~ f ~ 2 n

S.D.

S.D.

ainmisi.1 8 w u i i n a i u ~ ~ w a ~ a u s ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ n u n i w w ~ n ~ i u " ~ i u G i u

nisu5nisGmmiup9~~nis~~Gi~l F m u n i ~ s a u ! ~ a i u i ~ ~ 0 l a l u s r 6 u d i u n a i ~ L L ~ L $ ~

f i a i s m i s i ~ l G o w u ~ i ~ n a i u i ~ w ~ l a 3 ZuGu~~sni% $9 $5 2 n i s a % u i ~ 1 d a ~ n i s ~ i

s n ~ G i i u u i n i s c i s ~ i n w i laa:nsaa~GnI*Ps mius:u:~~aidri inum $9 3 n iss%uiu e d aanisd1)um~unisGisn~Gi?uu5ni~ oarmsaat~nmiustuc ~ m c Q I nisa^auiu$Za

nis l%sn

~ i i ~ a u o

~ a u

3.02

3.36

0.97

0.87

d i u n a i ~

d i ~ n a ~ a

2. nh~ni7niu;nr i i r i?uAii i 6 1 ~ ~ ~ h ? u / i r t '

3. fuuu'uu.jula

4. ijynBnniwA d n w k u

5. Gau5u;nriil~ri[.a"~i~3u~~niw

l~n~aauwui 6. uawsmaiunsr4o3a?u uar

nsrGunx~~~lwnisn'ou5u;nrii $3 L L @ ; ~ R ~ LW u~~i I%i ;u

7. ~ u l a , lilalunaiuFiw~dwslo~

gnrii 8. GuilliionisGm^Rulauaagnrii 9. m n w 7 5 u ~ n n i ~ n n i e ~ r n ~ $ u

!aiyunsn ~ ? o ~ i i u ~ ; n 6 1 lo. ldmaT.;,naiunw$u~~etG~~u%9a

Y s z w i i ~ n i s ~ a ~ i u P. LQ

11. i r n i u ~ o k ~ ~ e r r l ~ u n w ~%yidI~<usnriiaeiiansusiau

12. ~~aw~oan3an31~6asn i sa r

~ ~ a t d a n s ~

3.89

3.85

3.75

3.68

3.65

3.72

3.54

3.61

3.74

0.70

0.70

0.77

0.71

0.76

0.76

0.85

0.74

0.74

u i n

u in

u i n

u i n u i n

u i n

u i n

u i n

u i n

3.69

3.70

3.60

3.47

3.55

3.47

3.48

3.53

3.60

0.79

0.80

0.88

0.83

0.78

0.84

0.77

0.79

0.79

u i n

u in

u i n diu

n a i ~ u in d l u n a i d

diu

naid

u i n

u i n

2.03*

1.56

1.45

2.26*

1.01

2.57*

0.59

1.15

1.47

0.04

0.12

0.15

0.03

0.312

0.01

0.55

0.25

0.14

3.69 0.79 u i n

3.61 0.79 u i n

3.71 0.76 u in

;:;; 1 ;:;; 1 u i n

all tl

- t-

value

2.21*

0.83

.96

1.47

1.62

2.25*

o i n a i n d 9 w u i i n a ~ u f l ~ w a ~ o u n ~ g n n i iapinnniwwGn.siuuiu u^srinlalurii

Wwylan $4 i~ r i iu ln lu t i i 4 i h n i u n a ~ u ~ i u i s n m i ~ n i m h u n i w m u ~ ~ n n i i ~ n i c ad i~ i i r iurh6l l~d3:~u 0.05 d ~ d a f i s i ~ n i ~ i l u n u ~ w u i i & ~ u a n i i ~ < u Wo uj 2

ni~nd ia~nn iugnr i7Kaui7 i i "RTNG~BI &%a 4 ni=6hpiinniwG dauriou u'n 7

n a i u ~ u l o l d 9 l ~ n 3 7 ~ 6 ~ L $ ~ ~ ~ 9 g n 6 7 $9 9 n ~ ~ ~ u m u i C u ~ n F i i ~ n n i n ~ m ~ : ~ d u l i i a ~ m s n l i 3 a ~ G u ~ p n k usrQ I 3 n i ~ ~ a i u u ~ d n m & i o u h ~ T u ~ i u u i u idu unnairjan lu3%ai h n n i u iuf ias 9a9 ~6auaul$~~r ign61 t i ? u ~ j d D u ~ ) 1 i ~ ~ n n d i ~ r h

Sig

niadsf~~mP%;iu s ~ u ~ f s

noatiounao&udi~ 7

2. a % u i u ~ ~ q o r ~ u u E i JalGY~fiuu

usr?rudduarlusJw'mniun'~a~wGaCrn4 dagn&bYadi~$a~ou

3. m u i s n a ~ i u ~ a ~ d u s l a ~ w 7 a -

s l " r n 4 d a ~ a n i i i u i d ~ ~ ~ ~

a d1~4 4. uo~nids:loaG~gnni~tlGY~"u

o i n e r ~ a s l " o r ~ d " ~ i u ~ ~ a u ~ ~ i i ~ i

~ ~ u r G i o d i ~ 0 k 1 0

5. i i n i r n u n u f i ~ s i ~ d ~ l 4 '

w"Psaa7uasaa~aai tJu s i n i

YIU L L ~ ~ L I J ~ ~ ~ a f ~ ~ n a a i i l a n

h a ~ f i u u ~ C i u u j u d a f ula'~awa u c l u

gnrii idalSiignniuuays

~ f i u u LC u u ' l u n i s ~ a ~ u l ~ d

6. ~ % ~ I U T I U ~ ~ L~U~"UOJ'~I~?I

qnniauloadidak~ilu riaud A'

O f l i l S 3 I ~ ~ ~ J ~ ~ Y l U

3.76

3.72

3.64

3.66

3.56

3.62

0.72

0.72

0.75

0.77

0.85

0.82

uin

in

uin

xrin

in

15lf1

3.79

3.72

3.70

3.64

3.59

3.65

0.60

0.68

0.77

0.88

0.80

0.81

uin

in

uin

u i n

U I ~

UlfI

-0.38

-0.04

-0.66

0.17

-0.24

-2.28

0.71

0.97

0.51

0.87

0.81

0.78

8. u'nia~wolfi;nfinn~oxh

sn (Test Drive) &?tln?iu

L6Ulil W%~U~IM?U~~?IU

oinnisia r o wvi i n2iurl~w o l o u a ~ g n r i i ~ i u ~ ~ ~ r ~ Q a diirin~numw

wrin~iuviu GGwlnluniAan$sn ~4mti iulnluGi 41% G i u n ? i u j n ~ i u ~ f i r

w anSm.n" lun~iwsau ua:siu$o!sj~~nndiarYu

&i lun is~~n is6rnm1a~w~~nis :? L W F ~ I F J . awe~w$s t : - -

~ I W % ~ I F J X S.D. +%&I .dl X S.D. sz6u

I I . !n--~sCmi;l~onais~~$~I< .i ~ n & n n u G a y e i -~-~msfb--~ il

n u b uazn7ssass6di~ 7 ; dlpb d l u

t -

value Sig

ainni3iJ 11 w u i ~ ~ ? 1 u ~ ~ ~ a ~ a ~ a ~ ; n 6 i % i u ~ ~ ~ z ~ ~ ~ d i i ~ a p i n u n i ~ ~ ~ n J i u

viu uiljnlnluhfiuculan $4iuri iulnluh 4iKn h u n i m i n i ~ 8 n n i u ~ i i J n i ~ ~ ~ r i i u

~ m i w s a u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i u ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ n n 6 i ~ n " u

:7'~~a78~178575np179n75a7~

7. a d o , ldlBlunaIui%rgiiu

yasgnni 8. CuiinnisKm3ul~uasqn61 9. a u n u i < u g n n i p n n i a ~ n ~ r

~ d u l iqmunsn ~ 7 a ~ B w

g nn i 10. Ybi~5isnaiunmKuw

2 G6ulus r~ i i sn1 '~~a"u1u P err

I I. i i n a i u ~ a l i n 6 ~ ~ a r d ~

niuiYtg-gdl<<u2n6i

aeiisnaudau I 2. ~~amsaanGsnaiuGasniaor

d a u ~ ~ i i a g n C l 6 a u m

9 ~ s I o La tdanss I 3. iinis~sisuu qdnsniwiau

h ~ ? u s i u ~ i ~ ~ 4 % L L ~ W 6'- 6- m~zan , '6us"113s, h i n i ,

u ~ u c m a r a r ~ d a u a u l <

~~rign61 3.66 0.81 uin 3.76 0.81 uin -1.04 0.30

14. ~ n i s a ^ r m i d ~ ~ a ~ a r ~ u a < u

'6dsIudu"u a s ~ ~ a ~ m ' b 6 a eiis

pnGas %mru riaudgnni o~bduniu 3.64 0.77 uin 3.67 0.85 a17n -0.29 0.77

3.50

3.60

3.55

3.41

3.49

3.65

0.74

0.71

0.70

0.79

0.77

0.79

nais u in

uin

d i u nais

d i u nnis

u in

3.68

3.64

3.70

3.59

3.69

3.74

0.75

0.78

0.82

0.84

0.74

0.73

u in nyn

u in

u in

u in

u in

-1.92

-0.50

-1.56

-1.80

-2.13*

-1.04

0.06

0.62

0.12

0.07

0.03

0.30

R~HR~IU~R~IUL~- I I~ IH uSan'm4

I. mui-ina%uitlii~qmAud

vo~w8mn"m.n" l$a t i i~

n3uniu ~ d u ln$o~tlu<

R ~ J L L ~ J " U B J & B J , mT

dxntk&aYu mu& mtl

s : ~ ~ s m a o d ~ u i i ~ 7

2. o % J I L I ~ J ~ N ~ ~ u u ? ~ $ ~ ~ ~ $

~ G o u a s r ~ m d ~ d t l a u '

" ~ a ~ w k n ' m G i a i n < i l $

etii~-i?m~ou

3. m u i ~ n a % ~ i t l ~ m ~ i u ~ a ~

w i i m n ' m G 6 ~ ~ i l e n i i d ~ ~ i ~

lC~"lilati1~1

4. ua~nid3:l~lau'i;n&1r

l$?uoinwEmn'mG6"uie,

w ?aul$ii UU:GI a d7 J

'3P3~lo

5. ~ n i m 7 ~ 3 ? u $ a ; s i ~ ~ i ~ l $

n " u ~ ~ t l ~ ~ i l F l l 3 E i l ~ ~ ~

3 7 R l " U l U LLRullJy LLAr unmmigan lmotfiau

~f i t lu~wdeju l i~r ruagnni

d a l ~ n n i i i + a r ? a ~ f i u u

~finu'iuni~6;im~ul-a 3.54 0.74 uin 3.56 0.88 uin -0.17 0.87

6. ai iui t l . r i t lsr~~tlm"~a~3ni

~ n 6 i a u ~ a d l J ~ m l o u Y r iau6or~osoimn~i~%a"~it l 3.59 0.76 uin 3.64 0.84 uin -0.56 0.58

- x

3.75

3.65

3.56

3.55

1sj~3u

S.D.

0.60

0.59

0.70

0.78

30 - x

3.78

3.76

3.73

3.69

t-

value

-0.27

-I .40

-1.80

-1.40

30 3

szKu

uin

uin

uin

uin

Sig

0.79

0.16

0.07

0.16

a#dd

S.D.

0.73

0.76

0.79

0.82

szGu

uin

u in

uin

uin

R " ~ M . A ~ I u ~ A ~ I u L ~ I ~ ~ ~ M . w3osn"mn"

7. wl~n8iilld%u ~ % $ ~ f % f

~ u 5 u i g n 8 ~ m l ~ ~ w ' o

d5=naun1sc@li?ula

8. ~ f l l ~ ~ H ~ Q ' I ~ ~ n ~ l W @ l ~ E l ~

<uTu (Test Drive 630

2. ~niso~bl~iuldaosnis~isn ~Gi?urisrns i i i~i i %w

L~n:mmQl%n# alUTrfJr

n31u~;ulilo w%u67u30

fl31JJH2@l311

3. o^rmiui~nisrlij~Ei'lunis

fi150L$l?¶JlI%ll% LLAf W-JQ

L ~ F ~ ~ I U ~ Z u=:

l d ~ f i ~ 30 2 - x

3.77

3.59

30 j1&1d t-

value

-0.81

S.D.

0.90

- x

3.87

0.69

Sig

0.42

~:Ku

ll~11-1

S.D.

0.93

uin

s:Ku

~ 1 ~ 1

3.72 0.73 uin -1.51 0.13

&l'Hnl-i~"sl-i~~~laJ~~~

~ I S ~ I H P ~ ~ U 4. B~anrns~~u:~i$umau~do

gnhdsz~uilqai ~ d u

GmiaaGausiu'bau, Ins

Yufim.aou r i a ahsnaiu

ulw~l%gnfi

5. Bniso%~i uu"umauni3l.a'

s i u ~ ~ ~ t k d ~ n n i n a s n n u

~"lj ~b:u:~a~\iIunia3UfI

ds:rYu 3:u:msaarQn nis

lvYu3niseindiuei79 61

6. n i s k a m a u i u ~ d a ~ ~ u ~ m V 8 - a W U

~n<iynn-r~n~uisuuinis

7. nis8mmiu~ilu~s:~nsi1lu

n-~iiou a~:LuauI$$nt?i

w~aul%Bi~~~uzdi~~~:

4auLa;o

8. dnis8mmiuagsnis

h m i i u ~daiunnu'ih~ai

vasan<iw5auI%h~~u:~i

L~@:.lia u 0

9. BnisAmmiupnni~ilu

szu: q aeilsH$lLHuo r4u

bws<~w" 'bdswdoGms

~$eru~,~uu ~ ~ u u ~ a u n i u

t -

value Sig I i

0 I

11. i n i s < m i ~ ~ a n a i s ~ ~ $ s l <

g n n i n n u l i a i a d i a a i s

fh.iiaulo ~ ~ a c n i s s m s s 6

61s 7~vesu7Gn

12. i n i s u a u u a s i 3 r ~ n m i u

~ a n i a ~ ? a a i s c 6 i s l u n

g nrii

I 3. i7nisu7ni-iGmmiu~%

n i s 4 i ~ i i u a e i i s a ~ i ~ a u a

sa ;M

o i n n i s i o 14 wuii naiuEiswa~sua~gnriiai~!ibiiu 30 3 ~ ~ a r ~ i i a i ~

30 $$dd 6ddu~numww~nsiuuiu ri513nlmlu6ifiaylan r$iiuiiulmlu& ii6m h ~ ~ ~ n i s u ~ n i s G m m i ~ ~ ~ ~ n i s ~ ~ ~ i u lun iwsau ~bazsi ~$a!~j~~mniisn"u

1 ~

I

I

3.25

3.07

3.02

3.32

0.88

0.81

0.89

d iu

na i s

d iu

naio

diu

n a i s

0.56 1 nald 'IM 1 3.39 1 0.68 n

3.23

2.92

3.03

-0.94

1.02

1.01

1.02

0.35

diu

na io

d iu

n a i ~

d iu

na io

0.10

1.33

-0.11

0.92

0.19

0.91

S.D. -

srGu x S.D. srGu

u i n 3.70 0.82 u i n

Yilr ~ d o u o u l ~ ~ ~ ~ r i g n n i 1 3.73 1 0.73 1 u i n 1 3.70 1 0.90 1 u i n 1

u i n 3.63 0.93 u i n

value

u i n i s t d a p n n i u i i ; ~ 3.56 0.76 1 u i n 1 3.77 1 0.89 u i n 1 -2.11' 0.04 I I

rinwuiuKugn61 1 3.55

I 6. n a i u w i o u l u n i s l g

~ p ~ . l LLMMG 1 3.52 0.73 1 u i n 3.72 1 0.76 ( u i n 1 -2.23' 0.03

oinmis i s 15 w u i i naiu~sw~Iouo~gnnid~nunsounsossn~iuau I KU

~m:$dmunsounso~snu inn i i I nir ii6oKnomwwrinsiuuio'u5Gw %mbonifiw+ban

64iw Giubmbu GI 4iKm G i u n a i u ~ i u i s n w i s n i s u i u l u n i w s a u !i~~mn6isn"pd

~ d ! , d a f i o i s m i m i u s i o ~ w u i i ~ ~ d ~ ~ m n i i ~ ~ u o ~ i i ~ i i r i u i i ~ i y d s : 6 u 0.05 A9

u'a 6 nisbbansnaion.r:~o~oa"u ua:ns:tiunr:basIunis6ou~u$nni g s ~ ~ d p n 6 1

0.78 u i n 3.59 0.90 u i n -0.40 0.69 ~ I

cliunaiu~naiulil9~'1~4'1l-alu

er3ciiln"m.n"

I . aiuirna^auiuRsqrn~uGi

vosw;afirn4 !6oeiis

nru$iau bdu rn+osuu6,

naiu L L T J Z I ~ ~ L ~ + D J , nir

3 ~ r : ~ ~ a L i ~ u raugs riu

a:Gua ood&uiio 7

2. sluieri;~?mauGGu'srn'a!6

~lPTeru rra:?rndr:luzrriuoa

w^aaniu4io2n<i!6oeiis

.a"arau

3. a i u i s n o ~ u i e r ~ ~ r ~ u " ~ o s

w'iafirn4dr~iionii i ~ ~ i s

!6l.~uoeiisGi

4. u u ~ ~ i d s c l e r a r i ~ ~ n 6 i x

I K u m n w ~ a 5 m 4 d ~ i er

wioulfi6iaru:Gi o eiis

o3sla

1 gI.4

S.D. ~ Z G U

I

0.63 uin

0.66 uin

0.72 uin

0.78 uin

t - Sig

value

o i n n i s i J 16 wuii n a i u i ~ w a I - a ~ a ~ ~ n ~ i 6 ~ ~ u ~ s a u n s a ~ n s a ~ s n ~ i u a u I

nic ~~arci~nunsaunzassnuinnii I i ~ u i i ~ a ~ n u m w w r i n ~ i u u i u u?~n~n~u;i

Wwqlan rj'4i~iiubnTu61 iliKn i i lunaiu~naiu~fiIaIuw~nfib~4 l w m w s a u l i

~ m n i i ~ K u o ~ i a i i i u i u a wuii G a 6 u n n i i a K u a r i i a i ~ u ~ i ~ ~ 6 s : ~ u

0.05 ;a $a 8 nisLilsud$n6innaaJ~usn (Test Drive) ~ - J ~ ? U ~ ~ I U L W U I O W%IU

W"Pdaa7f.J n a avl !,a a1 b4u

4 1 f l I " U l ~ bbfl8.Jbdz bba:

~~nnniEan bnu~ f iuu~ f luu

l ~ a n 6 i i G a u a ~ f i u u ~ f l u u

Iunis6'ni?ul-a

6. a % u i u s i u a ~ b ~ u n v a s s n 6

~n6 i i l sd -aad i~5 'n~au riau

i-a:b-as-ainnas$a"~iu

7. wiInnildau ~?ai?'a~Kils

j ~ s n 6 ~ n 6 i ~ d - a da ds:naunis6'nRuI-a

8. i i n i s ~ n u a I K ~ n 6 i n n m

?hsn(~est ~ r i v e ) & u n a i u

~Gu1-a w i o u i i u a u n a i x

a:nan

sau

3.59

3.62

3.86

3.83

3.71

0.81

0.80

0.87

1.01

0.57

uin

uin

uin

uin

u i n

3.53

3.62

3.78

3.56

3.67

0.87

0.85

0.99

0.99

0.66

a~in

uin

uin

uin

u i n

0.52

0.04

0.64

2.257

0.51

0.61

0.97

0.52

0.03

0.61

S.D. s:&u

u i n

u i n

u i n

u i n

u i n

u i n

1 u i n

value

t -

value

I

Sig I

0.49

I 0.90

I

I

0.06 I

0.21 I 0.20

0.31

o i nm is i J 17 wuil ~21u~~wo~auo~~n~i$~nernsaunso9sndiuau 1 6u a a : i i ~ n u n s o u n s o w i n n i , I Ri( ~G6~~nerniwwCnin~iuuieru7~~ l m l ~ G i f lwmlan fi~i~1iierlmT~61 di<m 6 iun1su5nis immiuw~~nisd i~ i i~ lmerniwsau

!a ioan i i~<u o i ~ d o f l o i s m i n o t wuii 5 a ~ u m n i i ~ < u a i i i ~ d C e r ~ i 6 ~ $s:&u

0.05 z n $8 3 nisa~ier~"sisIJ~u~~unis~isn~~iiuu5nis bba:msaoa~nmius:o-

LLat B 5 i j n ~ s o % u i o ~ u m a u n i ~ I . a " ~ i u ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ " i n a s n u riu ~:a:na i Iun is iu

d s r h s:er:msaorQn n is%Gu7n iso ind iu61~ 9

MSb

0.18

0.73

0.54

0.24

0.07.

MSb MSw F -value Sig

MSw

16. n~iuw~aulunis1$finisbda;n6iui6~

F -

value Sig

0.816

0.206

0.439

0.830

0.982

0.68 0.67 1.009 0.403

8. ~nis~nual<;nninnaa~~~sn (Test Drive) 1 1 1 i

oinnind 19 wui i n~iufi~walo2i3ua~~nnidd6a6nuniwwCn~iu"uiu~l3~~

TduniAwqTan ~~IMI~IUTRTU~I 4iKn niun~iu~n~iu~ui loluwGnfim4 4i~run

n iu ailwluniws3u!ri~~nniidn"u ~ ~ t i ~ a o i s m i ~ u s i u a wu i i ~nni i in3 iu

f i~wa~o~~nndi~n"uadi~!Cui i~i~ds:$u 0.05 lu.U*a 7 niswi;n6i!dau ~ 3 a b t Y ~

jusnfi;nni~ulo ~ i a d s m a u n ~ s ~ f i ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ : l ~ . U * ~ 8 ! n i s ~ s u a I ~ ~ n ~ i j l n n a a ~ ~ p l s n

(Test Drive) ~ 3 ~ n 3 i u ~ 6 u ~ ~ ~ i a u i i u a u n ~ i u ~ : n ~ n 83IAnh:u7 !liLlnniloni(

2s

a

E

as

&

&c

aP

cza

us -U

S C

-7

5 ;:

2 -E C

E

6 'F

u$ 2

9

C

-1s 5

as C

s

za 5

3

ra

c

as s

-7

s a

C +

-am

3s

a

3

T

az

~k

T

UP

7 ~

l ap

r

& -a

-6 C

uz

7

az

a a

-5 ?

-G = e

* c Y

E

-a$ Is"

s P

z

S

-5 E

'2 m

C

=C

L

za

P

@

"3

C

a: 3

ap

FG

?S

>

C

E E g

C

3a

E&

$

G= Q

T

C

P

a& 5

2s

a+

5

w

T

G

22

3

a$ w

Gl

I Q

br

nC

Ob

'o

b

hl

b

b

C? d

1=

wh

lm

C0

7

mh

lv

CO

0

0

L

'?

TF

(?

y

C?""

Ln "

7

:-

-h

l,

m

0

0

0

0

7

r

5 1 0

P. A d I

ainainJ 24 wuii n~iuG~wal~ua~gnniwuna$nuniwwrin~iuuiuu~Gw

bnilbu6iflwdan GSi~diubnilbuGi 6in"n 6iunaiuaiuisnwi~nisuiu Si~~unniu

ds~~nwsn~6iira1uniwsau1ai~~nndi~n"u ~~i~dafioismisiu$a wui i $9 4 n i s i

yninniwff dauriouuaowCn~iuuiu i~ar.3o 5 nis6~usiugnnilnul%$i~2uJ~niw

~ u n i s a u w u i r ~ n n i i ~ n " u a e i i ~ i ~ u ~ i ~ i ~ ~ s t ~ u 0.05 dau64u 7 I i ~~nn i ion i c

Sig

0.434

F-

value

0.837

A~wR?Iu~R~IuL~I '~o~ww~^(~~~"cM.~"

I. m u i m o ~ i u i i ~ ~ ~ ~ u d v o ~ ~ 8 m n " t x 6 ~ ~ 6 ~ ~ 1 ~ d d nsuhu ~ d u ~naosuu6, nnaiuussvos~nras,

t: n i d s r ~ k $ i ~ u nund nuaridunsod$udio 7

MSb

0.39

MSw

0.46

2. a % u i u i ; a ? n m u d u j ~ A G u u aammds:lumi

uaswlnfimm' 6agnniliYaiisi7niou

3. n u i s n a ~ u i u ~ n i r i u u a s w ~ n i ' m . J ; d i ~ ~ a n i i

$~,izio!&iluodisl

4. uas~idstlu~Gd!nGio:l6?uoinw8ni'mm'dviu

wio ulG61 iiut GI o i i so f s lo

5. dniss~us~uu'a;a$idsl~w"unfiun~oniaai idw

s i m v i u ~ i n u bdt-~~ i ~ a r i i A n n i ~ a n b n u i G u u i ~ u u

$ria$la"iauagn61 dalss"~n61f l~; a i G u u

i!uulunis$nEulo

6. 0 % u i u s i ~ ~ ~ b ~ u ~ v a s s n d g n ~ i a w ~ o a ~ i i ~ i 7 n ~ ~ ~ 8 a' 2 n o u ~ o t i o s a i n n a s ~ a v i u

7. wiinGi ld -m ~%tYuil'aj~1usnd!n~i~ulo ids dsrnauniri 'mEulo

8. flnir~nual~~n6innaas~urn (Test Drive)

63un3iu i6u lo w i a u i i u a u n a i u a t n a n

- MSw

F -

value Sig

MSb MSw value

5.601*

Sig

w dd I

a i n n i n J 28 w u i i n ~ i u f i ~ w ~ a u ~ ~ ~ n n i 9 ; ~ ~ m o < n u n i w w ~ n ~ i u u i u u ~ ~ ~

bmbu6 i f iwdan i4 i r r i iubmbu61 4iKm 6iunisu3nisGmmi81rr~~nis4irriiu Bibbun

m,juds:~nwsni$o niwsau!aj~~mndi~Ku ~ ~ 6 ~ d o f i a i s m ~ f l u s i u G o w u $ i Go 2

tio i n i s o ~ u i u d o ~ n i s ~ i s n ~ ~ i ~ u u ~ n i s + y i n w i u a t n n a t~nv~srnuscu:baai i

riirrum ~mn~i~Kuaeii~iiGui16~~s:~u 0.05 huu'aiu q k i ~ r n n d i ~ n i c

w '4'4 m i s i ~ 29 n i s ~ ~ T u u ~ ~ u u n ~ i u ~ ~ m n u i i ~ s i u ~ n ~ i u E i ~ w a 2 ~ u o ~ ~ n n i n u ~ o < n i n 1 n i w

wGnmuuiuu3Gn~mbu<ifiw~ban i 4 i r r h u I m I u 6 i B i K n 4 i r ~ u n m i u

ds:mnsni$a ~du3fiuiiniso%uiuda~nishsnilii?uu3nis O i p

? n w i ~ ~ a : ~ s a o ~ B n d T ~ i u s : u : ~ ~ a i ~ i i i r r u m

- LWQl"d70 ~ ~ L ~ u ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ 66.70

- o i q 30 ~14'uId ~ a ~ i l u i o ~ ~ a : 60.00

n n ~ u n m a o d g n ; ~ - ~rft -ahuh Ga~fIu?oua: 40.70

- annatut G m ~ f I u ~ o u a ~ 49.70

-4iuauan I <u 6a~3u<ouat 60.30

oinQ~a$i~siua?damuniw91o~;nsl'1 wuh ; n & h u l ~ n J ~ ~ u ~ w ~ m u i

o l q 30 CI~u~ddsrnnuoi$w~ftodau~a ot~~on$osnna:ut~~a:~nunaounao~an uu64iuau 1 Ku

I

a q n a ~ ~ ~ m ~ m s G w w n ~ a n ~ ~ G w w ~ ~ n a n ~ ~ ~ ~ n a ~ ~ ~ a d u ' w a c i o ~ ~ ~ u

P, 4

dana~wma;nriln.rdan m : r'.k indamnfpn$an @IHG~ i7~b1in~&-1 i 7 h

I .n-rsar%a3umru

1 .i nis~wuiCnwrniaviu%PSVW~nai~~iu '6muCnisnu~u~iflu~umnu<a~

i .I .i wCnaiuuiu%~d (daanm~naaiu~~a~oiqaiu~J~iiu 2 3 1 .A .i .A. ousunaiu~wlnn"~~.n"~~ernatuaunim L$U

-naiu~BBaGutdua<u ~MIY wlncmG nsruau

n iw iu nis7udstiYu L L R ~ U 7 t

i .i .I .2. ouauGnwsnimi~~'~naGu I$U

- rnsgiaauawGmn"m.n" aruusiuiia 7 nisafianaiu

iawnIaIG;nh ILR:: Qu 7

1 .i .2 wCnaiuviusr5un~ia ( a i q a i u 2-4 3 ) i .i .2.1 .~usu~nnQnni~~i~n61~a'~1a"a

i .i .2.2.ouauniarosai~nsoanisviu

i .A . ~ . ~ . ~ ~ W G ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ L L ~ I I A E L L ~ " ~ ~ M ~ I G ~ ~ ~ I i .i .3. w ~ n a i u v i u ~ i ~ I ~ ( JI;~IU 5 3:d.d )

1 .i .3.1 .nuaunisaiaLtwuniaviu

i .i .3.2. ousuniadar~CudarGn5niwnisviu

1 .A .3.3.nusu ?;nis?ninw;n61

1 .i .3.4 ou~unisdsrqnd PDCA <unis~iu

1.1.4. ~4mn is~ iu

1 .1.4.1. n u s u n i s ^ ? l n ~ l e ~ . i i n ~ l n ~ ~ u ~ l d l a 7

i .i .4.2. ousu1nnfinnisEPb~is~uviu%GCdsrEn5ni~

i .r .4.3. nusunisu5~1s~unuhwa"~l~~mnisiioai&

1.1.5. $nanu

i . i .5.1. s u s u ~ n r r m i ~ ~ i l w ~ n a n u

i .i .5.2. nusuna~uidu~u~iusnouC

2.2.3 nis~d~~uu~nnidjlu~"a~diiaiu~do1K~n6i~iinn~iu~uiul0

i i ~ i o ~ o 8 u n i ~ ~ ~ h w ~ n a i u ~ " a o u ~ ~ w q P:IJIIDGI$~ i j n $ a ~ a l d o ? u w s a n n i ~ ~ u 2 ~ n ~ l n i a d i a q ~ d u n i - m ~ u w s ~ u u u i l l ~ r i i u ~ R n i u n s u n i s ~ ~ d a a i u 8 u l j i u l ~ r i yay

3. n 1 3 i i a u u a ' o p

3.1 nis~Aui7o;a~nni ~ilunis~n?u~~a:s~u~auCo;a"~oa~n6il~7~io~ ~ ~ n o h n i u n i s Q R s n s s u d l J q huni. i~Auuby asioa~~unoonoeiia.a"n~ou ~ $ u n i s

uunniuafin ~ ~ u u oa:?IYnasn ~ d n h u d s n i s ~ f i s n s g u d i a q ~$!or:'lTinnu

i i ~ d a ! n i s ~ ~ ~ n s s u n ~ ~ o : ~ % ~ ~ n 6 i n ~ u ~ n u i a u a i u oa:n-xdruuiinu 0:~6;3uu t

Y ~ ~ ~ I ~ ? u M ? ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ M I ~ ~ ~ ~ & ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ l 0 ~ ~ f i l ~ ? ~ ~ ~ ~ n l ~ ~ l H ~ ~ ~ ~ d $ l " ~ l ~

I6fki4 d[uii?uaiudnu 3.2 nisuivnsi7oyapn6-1 ~ilunisQ8i~unisiiii0nssudia 7

3.2.1 ~ ? ~ I G ~ T M I ~ M " ~ ~ K I M ~ W ~ ~ ~ Y O J ~ ~ I W I ~ ~ I U ~ ~

3.2.2 Ki~un~~~uni~~~in~~a:a ianae~,~a%99'~~ui :~un"uaain

3.2.3 muisnd?unaYn$nianisanin~~ia"a4i~~uii~na~uo(~~non

n~'oan"unniunismrlu~aaiu"u q Id 3.2.4 ~ i ~ n : ~ u w ~ ~ n n u ~ o a ~ n 6 i ~ u a u i ~ n ~ d ~ ~ a : Ji~ad!d?~llunis

~n~~nssu~dd?u~~wun~siiaiunianisnai~~~a:Ji~dRi~unna ~ ~ a % u n i s ~ n i i s n s s u

n:adold

3.3 nis5~nai:gi7o;ain61

3.3.1 i7o;adiluds:ains ~ f l u ' ~ ~ ~ y a d ~ i u ? l j ~ a n " ~ l ~ o ~ f f q ? ? a ~ i i u ? ~ d A rj,uw~oa~nfirwon~m~:!Kwsiuii - gn6iusamftnlnsu o i f i ~ d u ~ w ~ l o i ~ nuI6

A - u si%w n i s l n u i nniuniwnum Siuaunulunsouni? d i u l u y n s ~ i n u i n u u n o

L~omil EqaiA yay 3.3.2 ~ * 0 ~ ~ d l ~ ~ f i ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ M " a ~ . u ' O ~ ~ d l ~ d ~ ( ~ l < ~ l f l ~ < E l ~ l L i ~ l ? n " ~

d A p f i r i ~ ~ u ~ ~ i o d o ; ~ ~ ~ ~ o a ; n n i ~w onqeI6n;nnuii 1a t ? n n i u o a m s ~ i I ~ u i i I K ~ m In 'nnu$ ignn ia i~u lun 'oa~ lnu nmln n in ln O q i i d s : ~ n ~ u a : o i n i ~ ~ ~ u u I ~ u ~ w s i : ~ n a ~ o d o a w s i u ~ d o n i s ~ n d o~orns$inasl.a"niwio:I3 ~ W U I T ~ ' L ~ J nifudaniu

p. PI A n a OQ ni.rinfiu?ns?n n i ~ d g u a n i t n i s n i ~uumru~iruuds:~wfi~~a:naiu16odia q

3.3.3 ~ o y a 6 i i u y ~ ~ n n i ~ ~ n : ^ a ~ n i ~ ~ i ~ f i u ~ ~ n ~ ~ u ~ o y a n i a i n ? n u i

d~its?rYu;ninniw ua:idnis~i~fiu~^3a~aa$uiInn~do~~iuRanaiu6oan1s~~3a~alo L~at&.rou q ~ ~ ~ i ~ ! ~ n ~ w a ~ o n ~ i u ~ n ~ ~ a ~ n i s G n E u l o ~ ~ a ~ n 6 i I T i JiilK~nf-ii