sisxlis samartlis procesi - supreme court of georgia · luri telefoni, sigareti, safule, wamlis...

1

s i s xl i ss i s xl i ss i s xl i ss i s xl i ss i s xl i s

s a m a rTli ss a m a rTli ss a m a rTli ss a m a rTli ss a m a rTli s

p ro c e s ip ro c e s ip ro c e s ip ro c e s ip ro c e s i

krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1

2

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebanisisxlis samarTlis saqmeebze2018, #4-6

Decisions of the Supreme Court of Georgiaon Criminal Cases(in Georgian)2018, #4-6

Entscheidungen des Obersten Gerichts von Georgienin Strafsachen(in der georgischen Sprache)2018, #4-6

Htitybz Dth[jdyjuj Celf Uhepbbgj eujkjdysv ltkfv

(yf uhepbycrjv zpsrt)2018= ̀ 4-6

gadawyvetilebebis SerCevasada damuSavebaze pasuxismgebeli rusudan WanturiZe

teqnikuri redaqtori marika maRalaSvili

redaqciis misamarTi: 0110, Tbilisi, Zmebi zubalaSvilebisq. #32, tel: 299 04 18; www.supremecourt.ge

Jurnali gamodis saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlosa dasaqarTvelos iusticiis umaRlesi sabWos saerTo sasamarTloebis

departamentis mxardaWeriT

3

sakasacio ganaCeni

gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da misnacvlad gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgena

ganaCenisaqarTvelos saxeliT

#507ap.-17 7 marti, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos sisxlissamarTlis saqmeTa palatam Semdegi SemadgenlobiT:

g. SavliaSvili (Tavmjdomare),n. gvenetaZe,p. silagaZe

ganixila msjavrdebul z. f-is interesebis damcvelis,advokat n. C-is sakasacio saCivari quTaisis saapelacio sa-samarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis21 ivnisis ganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. quTaisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 21 noem-

bris ganaCeniT z. f., ... _ ... cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis meore nawilis `a~ da mesamenawilis `g~ qvepunqtebiT da sasjelis saxed da zomad ga-nesazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 5 wliT.

saqarTvelos ssk-is 67-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Sesabami-sad, gauqmda z. f-is mimarT quTaisis saqalaqo sasamar-Tlos 2015 wlis 18 martis ganaCeniT daniSnuli pirobiTimsjavri _ 5 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.

saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanaxmad,bolo ganaCeniT daniSnul sasjels nawilobriv daemata wi-na ganaCeniT daniSnuli sasjelis mouxdeli nawili _ 1wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa da sabolood, ganaCenTa er-TobliobiT, z. f-s sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra6 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, romlis moxda aeTvala da-kavebis dRidan _ 2016 wlis 29 Tebervlidan.

2. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 21 ivnisis ganaCeniT quTaisissaqalaqo sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 21 noembris ganaCeni dar-

4

Ca ucvlelad.3. sasamarTlom daadgina, rom z. f-ma Caidina qurdoba,

ese igi sxvisi moZravi nivTis faruli daufleba marTlsa-winaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, ramac mniSvnelovaniziani gamoiwvia, Cadenili binaSi ukanono SeRweviT, racgamoixata SemdegSi:

2016 wlis 2 Tebervals, daaxloebiT 12.00 saaTidan 13.00saaTamde periodSi, z. f-ma ukanonod SeaRwia q. q-Si, ...-Simdebare #... poliklinikis SenobaSi mcxovreb n. S-as sac-xovrebel binaSi da marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebismizniT, farulad daeufla am ukanasknelis kuTvnil, 1800laramde Rirebulebis oqros samkaulebs, ris Sedegadacn. S-s miadga mniSvnelovani qonebrivi ziani.

4. kasatori _ msjavrdebul z. f-is interesebis damcve-li, advokati n. C. warmodgenili saCivriT iTxovs msjav-rdebul z. f-is mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadge-nas, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

msjavrdebul z. f-is mimarT gamotanili ganaCeni arisdausabuTebeli da ukanono; aRniSnuli saqme xelovnurad`Sekera~ gamomZiebelma, moxda mtkicebulebaTa falsifi-cireba, rac utyuarad dadasturda mowmeTa dakiTxvisas;sasamarTlom ganaCenSi ar Seafasa z. f-is gamamarTlebelifaqtebi da sruliad udanaSaulo adamians eqvsi wliTaRukveTa Tavisufleba.

samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam Seiswavla saqmis masalebi da mivi-

da daskvnamde, rom pirveli da saapelacio instanciis sa-samarTloebma saTanado samarTlebrivi Sefaseba ar mis-ces z. f-is braldebis sisxlis samarTlis saqmeSi arsebulmtkicebulebebs da maT mier gamotanili daskvna misi bra-leulobis Sesaxeb ar akmayofilebs sisxlis samarTlis sap-roceso kodeqsiT dadgenil gonivrul eWvs miRma stan-darts, ris gamoc sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildesda z. f. unda gamarTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `a~ da me-3 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtebiT war-dgenil braldebaSi, kerZod:

2. mowmis saxiT dakiTxul dazaralebul n. S-as Cvene-biT irkveva, rom is cxovrobs q. q-Si, ...-Si mdebare #... po-liklinikis SenobaSi, meoTxe sarTulze. braldebuli z.

5

f. mxolod erTxel hyavs nanaxi poliklinikis SenobaSi.SemTxvevis dRes, kerZod, 2016 wlis 2 Tebervals, daax-loebiT Tormet saaTs aklda wuTebi, ufrosi Svili romCaiyvana poliklinikis mesame sarTulze yuris eqimTan.eqims garkveuli xani elodeboda, magram vinaidan umcro-si Svili pirvelis oc wuTze skolidan unda gamoeyvana,masTan stumrad myof dedas sTxova eqimis kabinetSi Ca-suliyo da bavSvisTvis miexeda, radgan yuris gamorecxvisprocedura unda Catareboda. dedis CasvlisTanave wavi-da bavSvis skolidan gamosayvanad. maleve dedam daurekada uTxra, rom oTaxis kari Ria iyo. am dros masTan erTadimyofeboda mezobeli. eWvi gauCnda, bina gatexili ar yo-filiyo da mezobelze adre wavida saxlSi. meoTxe sarTul-ze liftiT avida, sadac dainaxa misTvis ucnobi piri, ro-melic wavida kibisken. mowmis ganmartebiT, meoTxe sar-Tulze arcerTi eqimis samuSao oTaxi ar aris, magram iyoSemTxvevebi, pacientebi SecdomiT zeviT adiodnen. uc-nobi piric aseTi pacienti egona. saxli areuli ar iyo, gar-derobis erT-erT ujraSi iyo tansacmeli Seweuli. asevenaxa komodis ujra, sadac hqonda organyofilebiani zar-daxSa, erT ganyofilebaSi naxa, rom beWdebi ido, xolo zar-daxSis meore ganyofilebidan, sadac erTad hqonda Sena-xuli sxvadasxva dasaxelebis oqros nivTebi, maT SorisZewkvi, kuloni, `brasleti~ da sxva, ise rom erTi xelismokidebiT ahyveboda yvelaferi, waRebuli iyo. mas gauk-virda, Tu ratom datoves beWdebi da aseve sayuris nawi-li, romelic qaRaldSi iyo Sexveuli da isic iqve iyo. aR-niSnulis Semdeg dedasTan erTad Cavida qvemoT da eZeb-dnen im pirs, vinc liftidan gamosvlis dros dainaxa, mag-ram ver naxa. am dros mas Sexvdnen poliklinikis direqto-ris moadgile da dacvis TanamSromeli, romlebsac uTxramomxdari faqtis Sesaxeb, ris gamoc dacvis TanamSromel-ma gamoiZaxa policiis TanamSromlebi, romlebic daaxlo-ebiT aT wuTSi mividnen. maTi mosvlis dros poliklinikisdireqtorma ganmarta, rom erTi piri iqceoda saeWvod, amo-iRes misi sabuTebi da aRmoCnda z. f., romelic mas nanaxihyavda SemTxvevis dRes. monawileobda SemTxvevis adgi-lis daTvalierebaSi policiis TanamSromlebTan erTad.imave oTaxSi, sadac idga komodi, taxtis qveS SeniSna siga-retis namwvi warweriT `sobranie~, rac amoiRes eqsperteb-

6

ma da daluqes polieTilenis parkSi. SemTxvevidan meoredRes aRmoaCina meore namwvi ukve derefanSi, rac Seatyo-bina gamomZiebels, Tumca reagireba ar mohyolia. polici-aSi dakiTxvis Semdeg saxlSi dabrunebulma aRmoaCina, romwaRebuli iyo safulec, romelSic hqonda sxvadasxva mow-moba. misi ganmartebiT, saxlidan waRebuli iyo daaxloe-biT 1800 laris Rirebulebis oqros nivTebi, maT Soris bav-Svis naTlobis jvrebi. dazaralebulis ganmartebiT, is po-liciaSi daibares amocnobaze, sadac mas aCvenes sami piri.maT Soris amoicno z. f., romelic im dRes naxa poliklini-kis SenobaSi. man aseve amoicno Tavisi oqros nivTi _ sayu-re. aRniSnuli sayure, rogorc mas uTxres, amoRebuli iyoz. f-is piradi Cxrekis Sedegad. dazaralebulma aseve aR-niSna, rom SemTxvevidan maleve oqros birJaze amoicno Ta-visi samkaulebi, ris Taobazec acnoba gamomZiebels, Tum-ca maTgan miiRo ganmarteba, rom Tu mis nivTebs raime gan-sakuTrebuli individualuri niSan-Tvisebebi ar hqonda,tyuilad nu Seqmnida problemebs. dazaralebulis ganmar-tebiT, marTalia, darwmunebuli iyo rom swored misi niv-Tebi iyo birJaze, gaCumda, vinaidan raime individualuriniSnebiT ar gamoirCeoda, Cveulebrivi nivTebi iyo.

3. mowmis saxiT dakiTxul d. n-is CvenebiT irkveva, romdazaralebuli n. S. misi Svilia. n. cxovrobs poliklinikisSenobaSi. meuRle gardacvlili hyavs, zrdis or Svils dadasaxmareblad xSirad dadis masTan. SemTxvevis dResacmasTan imyofeboda. n. S-as Svilebidan umcrosi Svili _ bi-Wi imyofeboda skolaSi, xolo ufross _ gogonas yuri stki-oda, ris gamoc n-m mesame sarTulze eqimTan Caiyvana. ram-denime xanSi mas daureka qaliSvilma da uTxra, rom rad-gan didxans daagviandeboda procudurebs, is CasuliyoeqimTan, xolo TviTon wavidoda skolaSi bavSvis gamosay-vanad. isic Cavida eqimTan, xolo saxlis kari daketa boq-lomiT. rodesac morCnen eqimTan procedurebs, SviliS-vilTan erTad avida saxlSi, bavSvi win gaiqca da naxa, romsaxlis kari Ria iyo, gamoiqca ukan da uTxra amis Sesaxeb.rodesac Tavadac Sevida binaSi da naxa, rom karze boqlo-mi aRar iyo, daureka Tavis Svils _ n. S-as da uTxra, sas-wrafod mosuliyo. rogorc Semdeg gaigo, misma Svilma damezobelma liftidan gamosvlis dros dainaxes ucxo pi-ri. saxlidan waRebuli iyo oqros nivTebi da safule. misi

7

ganmartebiT, qurdobis faqti moxda eqimTan Casvlisdros, daaxloebiT xuT-aT wuTSi, pirvelis naxevridanpirvel saaTamde periodSi.

4. mowmis saxiT dakiTxul m. x-as CvenebiT dadgenilia,rom is cxovrobs q. q-Si, ...-Si mdebare #... poliklinikismeeqvse sarTulze. SemTxvevis dRes is, daaxloebiT pir-velis xuT wuTze, wavida skolaSi bavSvis gamosayvanad,sadac aseve mivida n. S. umcrosi Svilis wasayvanad. daax-loebiT xuT wuTSi wamovidnen skolidan. gzaSi n. S-as dau-reka dedamisma, Tumca n-s misTvis ar uTqvams, ra moxda.dedamisTan saubris Semdeg uTxra, rom Cqara wasuliyvnenda daaxloebiT 12.25 saaTi iqneboda, liftiT avidnen me-oTxe sarTulze. rodesac liftis kari gaiRo, maT daina-xes ucnobi mamakaci, romelic meoTxe sarTulze gamodio-da n. S-s derefnidan da Cadioda kibeze, qveviT, rac maTgaukvirdaT. liftidan gavida n. S., xolo TviTon avida me-eqvse sarTulze da daaxloebiT aT wuTSi mas daureka n-mda uTxra, rom `yvelaferi daekarga~, ris gamoc is CavidamasTan meoTxe sarTulze. mowmis ganmartebiT, skolidanmaT saxlamde misvlas daaxloebiT 10 wuTi sWirdeba. qur-dobis faqti moxda n. S-as saxlidan wamosvlidan saxlSidabrunebamde, daaxloebiT 15-20 wuTis ganmavlobaSi. isSemdeg dakiTxes policiis TanamSromlebma, aseve amoic-no aRniSnuli piri, razedac gamomZiebelma Seadgina oqmi.

5. mowmeebis _ l. g-is, e. k-sa da p. n-is CvenebebiT dgin-deba, rom SemTxvevis dRes z. f. namdvilad imyofebodaq.q-Si, ...-Si mdebare #... poliklinikaSi, ojaxis eqim e. k-sTan registraciidan moxsnis mizniT, rac srulad Seesa-bameba braldebul f-is Cvenebas, romelmac miuTiTa, romSemTxvevis dRes namdvilad imyofeboda #... poliklini-kaSi, samedicino dazRvevis aRricxvidan moxsnis motiviT,sadac gamoarTves piradobis mowmoba da uTxres, rom pi-rad eqim e. k-sTan unda daewera gancxadeba. avida am uka-nasknelTan, romelmac uTxra, rom meoTxe sarTulze un-da asuliyo mTavari eqimis moadgilesTan, romelic mis gan-cxadebas daadebda rezolucias. aseve uTxra, rom Tu me-oTxe sarTulze ver naxavda, iqneboda pirvel sarTulze.braldebulis ganmartebiT, is aRar asula meoTxe sarTul-ze, radgan mTavari eqimis moadgilis saxeli da gvari verdaimaxsovra, Cavida pirvel sarTulze misaRebSi, sadac

8

miaswavles eqimis adgilsamyofeli, romelsac Caabara gan-cxadeba da gavida poliklinikidan.

6. mowmis saxiT dakiTxul m. d-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, igimuSaobs q-is saqalaqo sammarTvelos policiis _ ganyofi-lebis ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblad. 2016 wlis 2 Teber-vals moxda n. S-as sacxovrebeli binis qurdobis faqti daamasTan dakavSirebiT, 2016 wlis 4 Tebervals man miiRooperatiuli informacia imis Sesaxeb, rom am sacxovrebe-li binis qurdoba unda Caedina z. f-s, romelic gadaad-gildeboda q.q-Si, ...-Si mdebare sacxovrebel binasTan daTan unda hqonoda binidan dauflebuli nivTebi. amis Tao-baze jer sityvierad moaxsena xelmZRvanelobas da amas-Tanave, dawera pataki. aseve, mowmis ganmartebiT, 2016wlis 2 Tebervals is gasuli iyo SemTxvevis adgilze po-liciis TanamSromlebTan erTad, ra drosac daaTvalieraubani, gaesaubra dazaralebuls, gamokiTxa mezoblebi dapoliklinikaSi momuSave personali. SemTxvevis adgilimdebareobda q.q-Si, ...-Si arsebul #... poliklinikis meoT-xe sarTulze. mowmem ganmarta, rom sagamoZiebo moqmede-bebSi monawileoba ar miuRia, ubralod, SeaTvaliera, rarogor iyo. eqspertebi rodis mividnen da gadaiRes Tu arafotosuraTebi, ar axsovs.

7. q-is saqalaqo sammarTvelos policiis _ ganyofile-bis ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblebis _ b. j-as, m. g-is, i. m-sa da m. w-is Cvenebebis Tanaxmad, 2016 wlis 4 Tebervalsq.q-Si, ...-as quCaze, z. f-s Cautares piradi Cxreka. piradiCxrekisas misi Sarvlis marjvena, ukana jibidan amoiResoqros sayure ornamentebiT, razedac z. f-ma ganmarta, romaRniSnuli nivTi misi ar iyo. aseve z. f-sagan amoiRes mobi-luri telefoni, sigareti, safule, wamlis abebi da bankissabuTebi. amoRebuli nivTebi moaTavses paketebSi da ad-gilze daluqa gamomZiebelma, razedac moaweres xeli. ase-ve gamomZiebelma adgilze Seadgina piradi Cxrekis oqmi,razedac aseve moaweres xeli. Cxrekis Catarebisas f-s ra-ime winaaRmdegoba ar gauwevia, Tumca uari ganacxada oq-mis xelmoweraze. Cxrekis dasrulebis Semdeg is Casves av-tomanqanaSi, ra drosac iq mivida misi meuRlec, romel-mac maT sTxova, rom isic waeyvanaT avtomanqaniT ganyofi-lebaSi. z. f. iyo meore avtomanqanaSi, romliTac m. w-m, i. m-ma da gamomZiebelma gadaiyvanes policiis ganyofilebaSi,

9

policiis ganyofilebaSi miiyvanes misi meuRlec. z. f. sa-gamoZiebo moqmedebebis Catarebis Semdeg imave dRes ga-uSves ganyofilebidan. mowmeebis _ i. m-sa da m. w-is Cvene-bebiT dadgenilia, rom isini imave dRes, SuadRis saaTeb-Si, monawileobdnen z. f-is sacxovrebeli binis CxrekaSi,ra drosac e.w `servandidan~ amoiRes xelnakeTi gasaRebe-bi da raRac moxrili liTonis naWeri.

8. q-is saqalaqo sammarTvelos policiis _ ganyofile-bis deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZieblis _ m. w-is CvenebisTanaxmad, 2016 wlis 2 Tebervals imyofeboda samsaxurSi,ra drosac Sevida Setyobineba _ q.q-Si, ...-Si mdebare po-liklinikis SenobaSi arsebuli moqalaqe n. S-s binis gaqur-dvis faqtTan dakavSirebiT. aRniSnulze daiwyo gamoZie-ba saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxliT, ris Semdegac m. w. ope-ratiuli jgufis wevrebTan erTad gavida SemTxvevis ad-gilze. SemTxvevis adgili daaTvaliera m. w-ma da am saga-moZiebo moqmedebaSi mis garda monawileobdnen dazara-lebuli n. S., eqsperti da policiis me-... ganyofilebis ub-nis inspeqtor-gamomZiebeli m. d.. maT daaTvalieres, aR-weres da daasuraTes yvelaferi, maT Soris _ zardaxSacda masSi darCenili oqros nivTebi. eqspertma komodidanaiRo xelis kvalis nimuSebi, aseve uSualod saZinebelioTaxis iatakidan _ sigaretis namwvi, warweriT `sobranie~.man dakiTxa dazaralebuli da mowmeebi, aseve Caatara sxvasagamoZiebo moqmedebebi, ris Semdegac sasamarTlo gan-Cinebis safuZvelze advokatis TandaswrebiT daakava z.f.. mas dakavebis dros raime winaaRmdegoba ar gauwevia.gamomZieblis ganmartebiT, dazaralebulma n. S-am pirve-live dakiTxvis dros miuTiTa waRebuli oqros nivTebisCamonaTvali, maT Soris _ sayuris yunwic, rac Semdeg amo-iRes z. f-is piradi Cxrekis dros, Semdeg dakiTxvaSi da-zaralebulma miuTiTa aseve, rom safulec hqonda dakar-guli.

9. SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis 2016 wlis 2 Te-bervlis oqmiTa da fotocxriliT dgindeba, rom deteq-tivis TanaSemwe-gamomZiebelma m. w-ma SemTxvevis adgilidaaTvaliera 2016 wlis 2 Tebervals, 17:00 saaTidan 17:50saaTamde periodSi, q. q-Si, ...-Si ganTavsebul #... polik-linikis SenobaSi, n. S-as sacxovrebel binaSi, eqspert S. g-is, ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZiebel m. d-sa da n. S-as monawi-

10

leobiT, am ukanasknelis TanxmobiT. sacxovrebeli binismesakuTre n. S-am miuTiTa, rom komodis ujraSi Cadebulivardisferi zardaxSidan moparuli iyo misi kuTvnili oq-ros nivTebi, xolo ramdenime oqros nivTi zardaxSaSiadarCenili; miTiTebul zardaxSaSi moTavsebuli iyo mama-kacis erTi da qalis ori oqros beWedi, ori erTmaneTismsgavsi girCis formis sayure, aqedan erT sayures hqondayursakidis nawili ornamentebiT; n. S-am miuTiTa da ga-nacxada, rom moparuli iyo zemoaRniSnuli girCis formissayuris nawili _ ornamentiani yursakidi. imave oTaxSi,Sua adgilas, idga xis masalisagan damzadebuli taxti,romlis win, iatakis zedapirze, egdo sigaretis namwvi war-weriT `SOBRANIE~, romelic iqve amoiRo eqspertma. amo-Rebuli sigaretis namwvi SeifuTa polieTilenis parkSi 1paketad, warweriT ... . oqms xels aweren daTvalierebaSimonawile pirebi, maT Soris _ ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZie-beli m. d..

10. z. f-is piradi Cxrekis 2016 wlis 4 Tebervlis oqmisTanaxmad dgindeba, rom z. f-s q-is saqalaqo sammarTve-los policiis me-... ganyofilebis deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZiebelma m. w-ma, ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblebis _m. w-is, b. j-as, m. g-sa da i. m-is monawileobiT, q. q-Si, ...-SiganTavsebuli sacxovrebeli binis mimdebare teritoria-ze, avtomanqanis saval nawilze, 2016 wlis 4 Tebervals,12:50 saaTidan 13:20 saaTamde periodSi, Cautara piradiCxreka, ra drosac sxva nivTebTan erTad z. f-is Sarvlisukana, marjvena jibidan amoiRes oqrosferi qalis sayureornamentiT, romelic iqve SeifuTa da dailuqa. oqmi xel-mowerilia sagamoZiebo moqmedebaSi monawile pirebis mi-er, xolo z. f-ma oqmis xelmoweraze ganacxada uari im mi-zeziT, rom oqrosferi nivTi, romelic misi piradi Cxre-kis dros amoiRes, mas ar ekuTvnis.

11. sacxovrebeli binis Cxrekis 2016 wlis 4 Tebervlisoqmis Tanaxmad, deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZiebelma m. w-ma 2016 wlis 4 Tebervlis 16:20 saaTidan 17:15 saaTamde pe-riodSi Caatara q.q-Si, ...-Si mdebare z. f-is sacxovrebelibinis Cxreka, ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblebis _ m. w-is, i.m-is, aseve z. f-sa da m. m-is monawileobiT. sacxovrebelibinis Cxrekis dros sastumro oTaxSi, yavisferi karadismoTeTro feris saSaqreSi aRmoaCines ori Savi feris ga-

11

dakeTebuli gasaRebi warwerebiT `HONGXiN~ da `km,jh~ daor adgilas gaRunuli liTonis mogrZo sagani, romlebicamoiRes da daluqes. oqmi xelmowerilia monawile pire-bis, maT Soris _ z. f-is mier.

12. piris amocnobis 2016 wlis 5 Tebervlis oqmis mixed-viT, n. S-am misTvis wardgenili sami piridan amoicno z. f.,romelic misive ganmartebiT, man naxa 2016 wlis 2 Teber-vals q. q-Si, #-e sajaro skolidan dabrunebisas, ...-as qu-Caze arsebuli #... poliklinikis SenobaSi, me-4 sarTul-ze, liftidan gamosvlis dros da romelic misi sacxovre-beli binis mxares foiedan miemarTeboda Casasvleli ki-bisken.

13. piris amocnobis 2016 wlis 5 Tebervlis oqmis mixed-viT dadgenilia, rom m. x-am misTvis wardgenili sami piri-dan amoicno z. f., romelic, misive ganmartebiT, man daina-xa maSin, rodesac 2016 wlis 2 Tebervals skolidan mis me-zobel n. S-Tan erTad brundeboda sacxovrebel binaSi(mdebare #... poliklinikis SenobaSi), meoTxe sarTulzeda rodesac n. S. gadioda liftidan, is n. S-as sacxovrebe-li binis mxares arsebuli foiedan miemarTeboda Casasvle-li kibis mxares.

14. daTvalierebis 2016 wlis 5 Tebervlis oqmis Tanax-mad, 2016 wlis 5 Tebervals, 18:00 saaTidan 18:30 saaTamdeperiodSi, q-is saqalaqo sammarTvelos policiis me-... gan-yofilebis SenobaSi deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZiebel-ma m. w-ma n. S-as monawileobiT, amave sisxlis samarTlissaqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxul n. S-Tvis wardgenis miz-niT, gaxsna paketi, romelSic moTavsebuli iyo z. f-is pi-radi Cxrekisas amoRebuli oqrosferi sayure; sayurisdaTvalierebis Semdgom n. S-am ganacxada, rom warmodge-nili nivTi iyo swored is, romelic 2016 wlis 2 Tebervalsmoipares misi sacxovrebeli binidan; aseve ganacxada, romamoicno saerTo niSnebiT, ovaluri formis ornamentianinawiliT, dazianebuli rgolismagvari sakidiT; iqve miu-TiTa, rom warmodgenili nivTi iyo misi kuTvnili girCisformis erTi wyvili oqros sayuris, oridan erTi cali sa-yuris ornamentiani yursakidis nawili.

15. genetikuri eqspertizis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad, racaseve daadastures sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis saxiT da-kiTxvisas eqspertebma -S. k-em da e. s-em, paketSi, warwe-

12

riT: `...samzareulo oTaxSi iatakis zedapiridan amoRebu-li erTi cali sigaretis namwvi...~ moTavsebul sigaretisnamwvze arsebuli biomasalis genetikuri profili da z.f-is genetikuri profili identuria.

16. saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis dros sasamarTlo sxdo-maze daikiTxnen dacvis mxaris mowmeebi, kerZod:

16.1. i. k-ma (m-am) ganmarta, rom is braldebul z. f-s ic-nobs da masTan aqvs kargi urTierToba. 2016 wlis 4 Teber-vals SemTxveviT Seeswro f-is Cxrekis process, gaigonamisi yvirili, `araferi ar CaedoT misTvis~. mowmis ganmar-tebiT, mas surda misuliyo z. f-Tan da daxmareboda, mag-ram iq policiis bevri TanamSromeli iyo, Tavi Seikava dagaagrZela gza. rodesac aRniSnuli adgilidan wavida, mi-vida z. f-is sacxovrebel binasTan da iq myof mezobel bi-Webs uTxra z. f-is dakavebis Sesaxeb.

16.2. m. m-ma aCvena, rom cxovrobs braldebul z. f-TanerTad q. q-Si, ...-Si 2012 wlidan da masTan aqvs kargi urTi-erToba. 2016 wlis 2 Tebervals z. f. wavida me-... polikli-nikaSi registraciidan moxsnis mizniT. poliklinikidan isCveulebriv dabrunda saxlSi. 2016 wlis 4 Tebervals, ro-desac z. f. wasuli iyo `metadonis~ programaze, maTTandaaxloebiT oris naxevarze saxlSi mivida mezobeli mama-kaci, romelmac uTxra, rom z. f-ma mas sTxova misTvis eT-qva, rom is daakaves policiis TanamSromlebma da isic mi-suliyo iq. m. m. maSinve wavida. rodesac mivida afTiaqTan,sadac aseve aris avtofarexi, man naxa z. f. avtomanqanaSi.iqve myofma policiis TanamSromelma mas uxeSad mimarTada ar miuSva z. f-Tan, Tumca Semdeg, rodesac yvirili ate-xa, dauwyes damSvideba da miuSves masTan. man uTxra, romqurdobas abralebdnen, am dros z-s ekeTa xelborkilebi.man policiis TanamSromlebs mosTxova, rom gaeSvaT z. f.an isic waeyvanaT policiaSi, razedac mas ganumartes, romisini mas arafers ar abralebdnen, ubralod, mowmis saxiTdasakiTxad mihyavdaT da Tu surda, masac waiyvandnen. ro-desac mivida policiis ganyofilebaSi, z. f. ukve zemoThyavdaT ayvanili. ramdenime xnis Semdeg Camoiyvanes igida uTxres, rom maTi saxli unda gaeCxrikaT, razedac z-maTanxmoba ganacxada. aRniSnulis Semdeg policiis Tanam-Sromlebma gaCxrikes saxli da `servandidan~ amoiRes oricali gasaRebis msgavsi sagani, romelTac, m. m-is ganmarte-

13

biT, iyenebdnen dazianebuli karis gasaRebad mas Semdeg,rac 2012 wels igi daazianes policiis TanamSromlebma da`Caudes wamali~. Cxrekis Catarebis Semdeg maT moaweresxeli raRac dokumentze da Semdeg uTxres, rom unda wa-eyvanaT z. f. da aeRoT nerwyvis nimuSi da TiTis anabeWde-bi. man z-s uTxra, rom sigareti ar moewia, Tumca z-ma upa-suxa, rom ukve moawevines.

17. saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis dros braldebulma z. f-ma Tavi ar cno damnaSaved wardgenil braldebaSi da gan-marta Semdegi: igi imyofeba `metadonis~ programaze. Sem-Txvevis dResac, 2016 wlis 2 Tebervals, wavida Cveulebi-samebr metadonis programaze, q.q-Si, b-is quCaze. saxli-dan gavida TerTmetis naxevrisaTvis, daaxloebiT ormoc-daxuT wuTSi mivida n-s quCaze, #-... poliklinikaSi, same-dicino dazRvevis aRricxvidan moxsnis motiviT. gamoar-Tves piradobis mowmoba da uTxres, rom pirad eqim e. k-sTan unda daewera gancxadeba. avida am ukanasknelTan, ro-melmac uTxra, rom meoTxe sarTulze unda asuliyo mTa-vari eqimis moadgilesTan, romelic mis gancxadebas daa-debda rezolucias. aseve uTxra, rom Tu meoTxe sarTul-ze ver naxavda, igi iqneboda pirvel sarTulze. bralde-bulis ganmartebiT, is aRar asula meoTxe sarTulze, rad-gan mTavari eqimis moadgilis saxeli da gvari ver daimax-sovra, Cavida pirvel sarTulze misaRebSi, sadac miaswav-les eqimis adgilsamyofeli, romelsac Caabara gancxade-ba da gavida poliklinikidan.

2016 wlis 4 Tebervals `metadonis~ programidan brun-deboda da saxlisken mimavals gadaudga `golfis~ markisavtomaqana, saidanac gadmovidnen m. w. da i. m.. w-em mas daa-do xelborkili, xolo m-ma sabuTebi mosTxova. maleve mi-vidnen k-e, w-i da sxvebi, romlebmac mas ganucxades, romunda CaetarebinaT misi piradi Cxreka. aRniSnulze mas ua-ri ar uTqvams da TviTonve amoalaga Tavisi xeliT yvela-feri da gadasca, maT Soris amoiRo is nivTic, ris gamocgakvirvebuli darCa da ganacxada, rom es ar iyo misi sa-kuTreba. CamoarTves yvelaferi, maT Soris _ sigaretic.araferze ganucxadebia uari. Semdeg miiyvanes policiaSi,sadac uTxres, rom bina unda gaeCxrikaT, razedac asevedaTanxmda. binis Cxrekis Semdeg mas advokatis Tandaswre-biT auRes dnm-is nimuSi. misive ganmartebiT, martivi iyo

14

sigaretis Cadeba, radgan policiis TanamSromlebi sixa-ruliT aZlevdnen sigarets, rodesac sTxovda. Tavisi si-gareti ki CamorTmeuli hqonda da ar misces imitom, romdamTxveuliyo sigaret _ `sobranies~ namwvze, rac Cagde-buli hqondaT. Sarvlis jibe, saidanac man TviTon amoiRosayure, garRveuli iyo. amis Semdeg dakiTxes mowmis saxiTda gamouSves. aseve daibares meore dRes amocnobaze. araf-ris SiSi ar hqonda, radgan danaSuli ar Caudenia. amocno-bis damTavrebis Semdeg gauSves. 28 Tebervals advokat-Tan erTad mivida policiis ganyofilebaSi, sadac daaka-ves. braldebulis ganmartebiT, oqros sayure man piradad,Tavisi xeliT amoiRo, sxvas ar amouRia. misi varaudiT, sa-yure SesaZlebelia, Caedo romelime policiels.

18. saqarTvelos konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 nawi-lis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebodesmxolod utyuar mtkicebulebebs. yovelgvari eWvi, rome-lic ver dadasturdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, undagadawydes braldebulis sasargeblod. konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 punqtidan gamomdinare mtkicebulebiTistandarti valdebulebas akisrebs sasamarTlos, rom sa-Tanadod Seafasos mtkicebulebebi, samarTlianad gadaW-ras samxilebs Soris arsebuli winaaRmdegobebi da am pro-cesSi warmoSobili yovelgvari gonivruli eWvi gadawyvi-tos braldebulis udanaSaulobis, misi Tavisuflebis sa-sargeblod. ganaCeni unda emyarebodes saqmeSi arsebulmtkicebulebaTa Tavisufal Sefasebas, daskvnebs, romle-bic gamomdinareobs faqtobrivi garemoebebidan da mxa-reebis mier wardgenili mosazrebebidan. mtkiceba SeiZ-leba gamomdinareobdes sakmarisad naTeli da dasabuTe-buli daskvnebis an faqtis Taobaze gauqarwylebeli vara-udebis erTobliobidan.

19. braldebis mxaris mier warmodgenili da sasamarTlosxdomaze gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebis gaanalizebisa daurTierTSejerebis Sedegad sakasacio palata ver dar-wmunda z. f-is braleulobaSi, vinaidan isini winaaRmde-gobrivi da xSir SemTxvevaSi urTierTgamomricxavia, ker-Zod:

19.1. dazaralebulma n. S-am sasamarTlo sxdomaze gan-marta, rom SemTxvevis dRes z. f. naxa poliklinikis Seno-baSi. dacvis mxaris SekiTxvaze dazaralebulma daakonkre-

15

ta, rom im dRes z. f. naxa mxolod erTxel _ mesame sar-Tulze, eqim k-as kabinetTan. amdenad, sakasacio palatis-Tvis gaugebaria, Tu ras efuZneba gasaCivrebuli ganaCe-nis daskvna imis Sesaxeb, rom dazaralebulma meoTxe sar-Tulze nanax ucxo mamakacSi z. f. Seicno.

19.2. n. S-am kategoriulad uaryo aseve liftiT m. x-sTanerTad amosvlis faqti, kerZod, man ganmarta, rom dedissatelefono zaris Semdeg ganerviulda, bina gatexili aryofiliyo da amitom ufro swrafad wamovida, xolo mezo-beli CamorCa mas. dazralebulis aRniSnuli ganmarteba sa-eWvod xdis m. x-as Cvenebas imis Sesaxeb, rom igi liftiT n.S-Tan erTad avida da meoTxe sarTulze liftis karis gax-snisas man da S-m dainaxes ucxo mamakaci.

19.3. utyuarobis konstituciur-samarTlebriv stan-darts ver akmayofilebs aseve m. x-as monawileobiT Cata-rebuli amocnobis oqmi, vinaidan oqmis Tanaxmad, man f.amoicno Savi mokled SeWrili TmiT, momrgvalo formis pi-risaxiT, swori, mogrZo cxviriTa da muqi feris TvalebiT,xolo sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmem miuTiTa, rom bralde-buli kanis feriT amoicno, Tumca ver ganmarta, Tu rasgulisxmobda amaSi. mowmem aRniSna: ̀ xom ar mogatyuebT Sav-gvremani iyo, aseTi da iseTio~. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, romsagamoZiebo moqmedebisas mowmem detalurad aRwera bral-debulis pirovneba, xolo sasamarTloSi ganacxada, romar SeeZlo misi aRwera da mxolod kanis ferze miuTiTa,mticebuleba saeWvoa da ver iqneba gaziarebuli.

19.4. rac Seexeba SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebul siga-retis namwvsa da masze Catarebul genetikur eqsperti-zas, romlis Tanaxmadac, amoRebul namwvze gamovlinda z.f-is genetikuri profili, sakasacio palata yuradRebasmiapyrobs Semdeg garemoebaze:

SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmi, romelSic da-fiqsirebulia SemTxvevis adgilidan sigaretis namwvisamoRebisa da daluqvis faqti, amave oqmis Tanaxmad, Sed-genilia inspeqtor-gamomZiebel m. d-is monawileobiT da,Sesabamisad, oqmsa da luqebze misi xelmoweraa datanili.m. d-em sasamarTlo sxdomaze Cvenebis micemisas araer-Txel ganmarta, rom monawileoba ar miuRia arcerT saga-moZiebo moqmedebaSi, maT Soris _ SemTxvevis adgilis daT-valierebaSi. marTalia, sakasacio palata saeWvod ar miiC-

16

nevs Tavad genetikuri eqspertizis daskvnis siswores,magram saeWvod miaCnia nivTmtkicebis _ sigaretis namwvismopovebasa da SenaxvasTan dakavSirebuli garemoebebi,kerZod, gaugebaria, saidan aRmoCnda nivTmtkicebis Sena-fuTze im piris xelmowera, romelic kategoriulad uar-yofs mis mopovebasTan raime kavSirs. amdenad, vinaidanpalatisTvis saeWvoa mtkicebuleba, romlis safuZvelzecCatarda genetikuri eqspertiza, bunebrivia, Tavad das-kvnac uvargisia piris braleulobis samtkiceblad.

19.5. gamoZiebis obieqturad da keTilsindisierad Ca-tarebasTan dakavSirebiT, damatebiT eWvebs aCens asevedazaralebulis mier aRmoCenil sigaretis meore namwvsada oqros birJaze amocnobil nivTebTn dakavSirebuli in-formaciis samarTaldamcvelebis mxridan uyuradReboddatovebis faqti.

19.6. palata miuTiTebs aseve, rom mxareebs sadavod argauxdiaT is garemoeba, rom SemTxveva drois daaxloebiT5-10 wuTis SualedSi moxda. aseT viTarebaSi saeWvoa, z. f-s, romlisTvisac ucxo iyo n. S., moeZebna misi bina, moes-wro gaetexa boqlomi, moeZebna nivTebi da amasobaSi moe-wia erTi Reri sigaretic. aRsaniSnavia d. n-as ganmarteba,romelic SemTxvevidan umalve Sevida binaSi, rom sigare-tis suni saxlSi ar ugrZnia. saeWvoa aseve is garemoebac,rom f-ma gaxsna Sexveuli qaRaldi, sadac ori sayure damaTi yunwebi ido, masiuri sayureebi da erTi yunwi dato-va, xolo erTi yunwi wamoiRo da pirobiT msjavrdebuli,ori dRe jibiT daatarebda.

19.7. winaaRmdgobrivia aseve samarTaldamcvelebis Cve-nebebi sayuris yunwis amoRebis faqtTan dakavSirebiT,kerZod:

Tavad braldebulma f-ma ganmarta, rom sayuris yunwiTavisi xeliT amoiRo da Zalian gakvirvebuli darCa, Tusaidan moxvda is mis jibeSi. mowmeebis _ b. j-sa da m. g-isganmartebiT, maT ar axsovT, warmoadgina Tu ara nivTi Ta-vad f-ma. i. m-is ganmartebiT, gamomZiebelma misca f-s wi-nadadeba, nebayoflobiT warmoedgina nivTebi, rac hqon-da da manac amoalaga aRniSnuli nivTebi, rogorc axsovs,xolo m. w-is ganmartebiT, z. f-ma Tavad warmoadgina mxo-lod safule, sigareti, sanTebela, bankis sabuTebi dafurclebi, Semdeg gaCxrika m. w-em da Sarvlis ukana jibi-

17

dan amouRo sayure. garkveuli periodis gasvlis Semdegpolicielebs detalurad rom ar axsovdeT maT mier Cata-rebuli Cxrekis mimdinareoba, es bunebrivia, Tumca pala-tis mier zemoT miTiTebul winaaRmdegobriv garemoebaTafonze, aRniSnuli Seusabamobebi policielTa CvenebebsSoris kidev ufro aSkaras xdis braldebis mxaris mier war-modgenil mtkicebulebaTa utyuarobis problemas.

20. yovelive aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasaciopalatas miaCnia, rom z. f. cnobil unda iqnes udanaSau-lod da gamarTldes misTvis bralad Seracxul qmedebaSi.

sarezolucio nawili:sakasacio palatam ixelmZRvanela saqarTvelos sssk-

is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiTda

d a a d g i n a:

1. msjavrdebul z. f-is interesebis damcvelis, advo-kat n. C-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes.

2. msjavrdebuli z. f. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod dagamarTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis `a~ da me-3 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenil bral-debaSi.

3. z. f. dauyovnebliv gaTavisufldes sasamarTlo sxdo-mis darbazidan.

4. gamarTlebul z. f-s ganemartos, rom ufleba aqvs,saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 92-e muxliT dadgenili wesiT moiTxovos zianis anazRaure-ba.

5. quTaisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 18 martisganaCeniT dadgenili pirobiTi msjavri darCes ZalaSi.

6. z. f-s sasjelis vadaSi moxdilad CaeTvalos patim-robaSi yofnis dro 2016 wlis 29 Tebervlidan _ 2018 wlis7 martis CaTvliT.

7. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 21 ivnisis ganaCeni nivTmtkice-baTa nawilSi darCes ucvlelad.

8. ganaCeni sabolooa da ar saCivrdeba.

18






zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila msjavrdebul n. m-issakasacio saCivari Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 10 ivlisis ga-naCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. axalqalaqis raionuli sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 30 mar-

tis ganaCeniT n. m., ... - ... cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 360-e muxlis pirveli na-wiliT da ZiriTadi sasjelis saxiT ganesazRvra jarima _500 lari.

2. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 10 ivlisis ganaCeniT axal-qalaqis raionuli sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 30 martis gana-Ceni darCa ucvlelad.

3. sasamarTlom daadgina, rom n. m-em Caidina TviTnebo-ba, e.i. Tavisad dagulebuli uflebis dadgenili wesis sa-winaaRmdegod ganxorcieleba, ramac gamoiwvia mniSvnelo-vani ziani. mis mier Cadenili danaSaulebrivi qmedeba ga-moixata SemdegSi:

2016 wlis agvistoSi n. m-em TviTneburad, kanoniT dad-genili wesis sawinaaRmdegod, Tavisad dagulebuli uf-lebis safuZvelze gaTiba a. a-is kuTvnili ori heqtari sa-Tibi miwis nakveTi, mdebare n-is raionis sofel s-Si, moTi-buli Tiva ki Sin waiRo, riTac a. a-s miadga mniSvnelovaniziani.

4. kasatori _ msjavrdebuli n. m. warmodgenili saCiv-

19

riT iTxovs Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 10 ivlisis ganaCenisgauqmebasa da mis mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dad-genas, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

igi 2003 wlidan 2016 wlis seqtembramde sargeblobdan-is raionis sofel s-Si mdebare 2 heqtari sasoflo_same-urneo daniSnulebis miwis nakveTiT, romelic 2002 wlisSemodgomaze gadasca mas n-is raionis imdroindelma gam-gebelma r. a-ma da misma moadgilem r. n-em. igi aRniSnulmiwis nakveTs yovelwliurad amuSavebda, xolo bolo samiwlis ganmavlobaSi iyenebda saTibad. 2016 wlis agvisto-Sic Cveulebisamebr gaTiba miwis nakveTi, ris gamoc a. a-masaCivari Seitana policiaSi. apelantis ganmartebiT, mis-Tvis ar iyo cnobili miwis nakveTis a. a-ze gasxvisebis Se-saxeb. werili, romelic gamgzavnes, Sedgenili iyo somxurenaze da misi Sinaarsi ver gaigo, xolo roca misma SvilmauTxra l. a-is danabarebi, mas nakveTi ukve gaTibuli hqon-da.

samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamow-

ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rom sa-kasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes vinaidan warmod-genili mtkicebulebebiT ar dasturdeba n. m-is mier TviT-nebobis Cadenis faqti, kerZod:

2. pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi mxareebma saqmeSiarsebuli braldebis mtkicebulebebi sadavod ar gaxadesda saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis73-e muxlis `d~ qvepunqtis Sesabamisad, gamokvlevis ga-reSe iqna miRebuli Semdegi mtkicebulebebi:

3. dazaralebul a. a-is Cveneba, romlis Tanaxmad, 2003wlidan n-is raionis sofel s-Si ijariT, 10 wlis vadiT aRe-buli hqonda saTibi miwis nakveTebi sxvadasxva adgilas.2016 wlis ianvarSi Seisyida ijariT aRebuli 5,5 ha miwisnakveTi, romelic 2016 wlis 13 ianvars sajaro reestrSigaiforma sakuTrebis uflebiT, dazustebuli farTobi: 54900,00 m2, sakadastro kodi: ... . dazaralebulis ganmarte-biT, 2003 wlidan igi aRniSnuli 5,5 ha miwis naveTidan Ti-bavda mxolod 3,3 ha-s, xolo danarCen 2 ha-s Tibavda so-fel s-Si mcxovrebi n. m.. 2016 wlis ivlisSi, ricxvi zustad

20

ar axsovs, vidre soflis mosaxleoba daiwyebda saTibebisgaTibvas, daaxloebiT 15 dRiT adre, gancxadebiT mimarTan-is gamgeobis warmomadgenels g-is administraciul er-TeulSi l. a-s da sTxova, rom gaefrTxilebina s-s mosax-leoba, aRar gaeTibaT misi miwis nakveTi, vinaidan hqondaam miwis nakveTze sakuTrebis damadasturebeli dokumen-ti. 2016 wlis 6 agvistos dainaxa, rom v. e. da n. m. Tibavdnenmis nakveTs, ris gamoc mimarTa policias.

4. mowme l. a-is Cveneba, romliTac dasturdeba, rom igiaris n-is gamgeblis warmomadgeneli g-is administraciulerTeulSi. 2016 wlis ivlisis bolos an agvistos dasawyis-Si mas gancxadebiT mimarTa a. a-ma, romelic iTxovda, romgaefrTxilebina n. m., ar gaeTiba mis sakuTrebaSi arsebu-li miwis nakveTi, vinaidan gaformebamde miwis nakveTiT n.m. sargeblobda. gancxadebis Sesaxeb telefoniT acnobasofel s-is specialists _ a. n-es, romelsac auxsna gancxa-debis Sinaarsi da uTxra, gaefrTxilebina n. m. aRniSnul-Tan dakavSirebiT. gancxadeba ki a. n-saTvis gadasacemadgaatana n-is municipalitetis sakrebulos deputats _ j.b-s.

5. mowme a. n-is Cveneba, romlis Tanaxmadac, man l. a-ismiTiTebis Sesabamisad, gaafrTxila n. m-is Svili, a. m., rommamamiss aRar gaeTiba miwis nakveTi, radgan igi SeiZina a. a-ma. rodesac man a. m. gaafrTxila, Tibvis sezoni ar iyo daw-yebuli.

6. mowme j. b-is Cveneba, romliTac irkveva, rom aris n-is municipalitetis sakrebulos wevri. 2016 wlis ivlisisbolos, ricxvi ar axsovs, l. a-ma mas gaatana a. a-is gancxa-deba, rom n. m-es ar gaeTiba mis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli mi-wis nakveTi. gancxadeba imave dRes gadasca n. m-es. am drosjer Tibvis sezoni dawyebuli ar iyo. sezoni daaxloebiT15 dRis Semdeg daiwyo.

7. mowme a. m-is Cveneba, romlis Tanaxmadac, aris n. m-isSvili. 2003 wlidan misi ojaxi yovelwliurad Tibavda so-fel s-is teritoriaze mdebare 2 ha miwis nakveTs, rome-lic saxelmwifos ekuTvnoda. 2016 wlis agvistos dasaw-yisSi mas Sexvda sofel s-is rwmunebuli a. n. da uTxra, romaRniSnuli miwis nakveTi, romelsac isini yovelwliuradTibavdnen, iyida da Tavis saxelze daaregistrira a. a-mada miuTiTa, aRar gaeTibaT. mas amis Taobaze mamisaTvis

21

Tqma daaviwyda. aTi dRis Semdeg mamamisma, romelmac mi-wis nakveTis gasxvisebis Sesaxeb araferi icoda, aRniSnu-li 2 ha miwis nakveTi gaTiba.

8. saxelmwifo qonebis erovnuli saagentos -is momsa-xurebis centris specialistis, mowme m. b-is Cveneba, rom-liTac dasturdeba, rom a. a-s sakuTrebaSi gadaeca manam-de mis mier ijariT aRebuli, n-is raionis sofel s-Si mde-bare 54900.00 m2 sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis (saxna-vi) miwis nakveTi. rac Seexeba n. m-es, mis saxelze raime uf-lebiT gadacemuli miwis nakveTi saxelmwifo qonebis erov-nul saagentoSi ar fiqsirdeba.

9. amonaweri sajaro reestridan, romliTac dasturde-ba, rom n-is raionis sofel s-Si 54900. 000 kv. m sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis (saxnavi) miwis nakveTi (s/k ...) sa-kuTrebis uflebiT registrirebulia a. a-is saxelze.

10. 2016 wlis 12 seqtembris daTvalierebis oqmi, rom-lis Tanaxmadac, n. m-is mier gaTibuli miwis nakveTis ko-ordinatebi Seesabameba a. a-is saxelze sakuTrebis ufle-biT sajaro reestrSi registrirebuli miwis nakveTis sk -. koordinatebs.

11. sasamarTlo sxdomaze daikiTxnen dacvis mxarismowmeebi _ a. v. da a. v., kerZod:

11.1. a. v-em ganmarta, rom 1997 wlidan 2007 wlis bolom-de muSaobda n-is raionis gamgeblis moadgiled da iyo mi-wis ijariT gadacemis komisiis wevri. 2002 wels gamgeobaSigancxadeba Seitana n. m-em, romelic iTxovda miwis nakveTs.gamgeblis davalebiT, 2002 wlis noemberSi sofel s-Si, sa-dac iyo Tavisufali miwa, 2 ha auzoma da misca n. m-es 10wliT. 2003 wlidan n. m-em daiwyo aRniSnuli miwis nakveTisdamuSaveba da mohyavda kartofili. vadis amowurvis Sem-degac n. m. sargeblobda am miwis nakveTiT, Tumca raimedokumenti ar gaaCnda da masTan ijaris xelSekrulebacar gaformebula. radgan Camosaxlebuli iyo, ar uformeb-dnen, Tumca 2004 wlamde ijaris gadasaxadsac ixdida, me-re saerTod Sewyda ijaris gadaxdebi. n. m-em 2016 welsacisargebla am miwis nakveTiT, gaTiba da Tiva waiRo, radganicoda, rom miwis nakveTi misi iyo. n. m-m ar icoda, rom aR-niSnuli miwis nakveTi sakuTrebis uflebiT gaformebulihqonda a. a-s.

11.2. a. v-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2002 wels n-is gam-

22

geblis davalebiT n. m-es gamoeyo 2 ha miwis nakveTi, rom-liTac igi sargeblobda 13-14 wlis ganmavlobaSi. am miwisnakveTze n. m-es ijaris xelSekruleba oficialurad ga-formebuli ar hqonia. aRniSnuli miwis nakveTi 2016 wel-sac n. m-em gaTiba da Tiva waiRo. 2002 wels xuTma ojaxmaerTiani ijara gaaforma da fulic gadaaxdevines, magramsabuTi ar misces. garkveuli wlebi gadasaxadebsac ixdid-nen.

12. braldebulma n. m-em ganmarta, rom 2003 wels n-ismunicipalitetis gamgebelma r. a-ma da misma moadgilem r.n-em n-is raionis sofel s-is teritoriaze misces 2 ha nak-veTi kartofilis mosayvanad. mas Semdeg, 12 wlis ganmav-lobaSi, miwis nakveTze mohyavda kartofili, xolo bolosami wlis ganmavlobaSi miwis nakveTi aRar moxna da ro-gorc saTibi, ise sargeblobda. 2016 wlis 8 agvistos miwisnakveTi gaTiba. rodesac ukve gaTibva damTavrebuli hqon-da, masTan mivida Svili a. m. da uTxra, rom mas Sexvedriasofel s-is specialisti a. n. da uTqvams, rom saTibi SeuZe-nia a. a-s da mas aRar unda gaeTiba. danabarebis misTvis Tqmaki a. m-es daviwyebia. rac Seexeba a. a-is gancxadebas, rom-liTac mas afrTxilebda, rom nakveTi ar gaeTiba, radganiyo misi sakuTreba, Sedgenili iyo somxur enaze da vergaigo, ra ewera. amasTan, gancxadeba j. b-em gadasca nakve-Tis gaTibvis Semdeg. n. m-is ganmartebiT, miwis nakveTi roma. a-s hqonda gaformebuli, gaigo nakveTis gaTibvis Sem-deg, xolo gaTibuli balaxi, 210 tuki, saxlSi waiRo, raTaar gafuWebuliyo. miwis nakveTTan dakavSirebiT araer-Txel miumarTavs n-is gamgeobisaTvis da iTxovda, rom ga-eformebinaT ijaris xelSekruleba, Tumca ar daukmayo-files. aqamde miwis nakveTTan dakavSirebiT gaugebrobaar hqonia.

13. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom TviTnebobisas, pi-ri, romelic moqmedebs dadgenili wesis sawinaaRmdegod,axorcielebs Tavis namdvil an Tavisad dagulebul uf-lebas. Tavisad dagulebuli ufleba iseTi uflebaa, rocapiri SecdomiT fiqrobs, rom mas ufleba aqvs, isargeblosan ar isargeblos konkretuli uflebiT. Tu pirma icis, romufleba, romelsac is axorcielebs, mas ar ekuTvnis, TviT-nebobis Semadgenloba gamoiricxeba.

14. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, vinaidan mxareebi sadavod ar

23

xdian im faqtobriv garemoebas, rom n. m-em nakveTis ga-Tibvis momentisTvis ar icoda nakveTze a-is sakuTrebisuflebis daregistrirebis Sesaxeb, sakasacio palata da-dasturebulad miiCnevs, rom igi Tavisad dagulebuli uf-lebiT sargeblobda.

15. palata aseve aRniSnavs, rom TviTneboba ganzraxidanaSaulia, ra drosac piri acnobierebs, rom Tavis/Tavi-sad dagulebul uflebas kanoniT dadgenili wesis sawina-aRmdegod axorcielebs.

16. braldebis mxaris mosazrebiT, uflebis dadgeniliwesis sawinaaRmdegod ganxorcieleba gamoixata imaSi, romn. m-em Sesabamisi uflebamosilebis gareSe isargebla mi-wis nakveTiT, rasac palata ar iziarebs, vinaidan warmod-genili mtkicebulebebis gaanalizebis Sedegad dadastu-rebulad miaCnia, rom n-is raionis gamgeblis gadawyveti-lebiT sadavo miwis nakveTiT 2003 wlidan sargeblobda n.m.. marTalia, oficialurad aRniSnuli faqti ar daregis-trirebula (ar asaxula Sesabamisi monacemebi sajaro re-estris bazaSi), magram mowmeTa CvenebebiT dgindeba, romes faqtobrivi garemoeba ar iyo sadavo.

17. amdenad, safuZvels moklebulia braldebis mxarismosazreba, rom n. m. ar iyo uflebamosili, esargebla sada-vo miwis nakveTiT.

18. amasTan, mas Semdeg, rac sadavo miwis nakveTze da-registrirda a. a-is sakuTrebis ufleba, bunebrivia, n. m-es SeezRuda miwiT sargeblobis ufleba, Tumca im faqtob-rivi garemoebis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom man amis Sesaxeb Se-ityo qmedebis ganxorcielebis Semdeg, misi qmedeba verSefasdeba TviTnebobad, vinaidan misi ganzraxva qmedebisCadenis momentisTvis ar moicavda Tavisad dagulebuliuflebis dadgenili wesis sawinaaRmdegod ganxorciele-bas, ris gamoc n. m. unda gamarTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is360-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT wardgenil braldebaSi, qmede-bis subieqturi Semadgenlobis daudastureblobis moti-viT.


is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiTda

24

d a a d g i n a:

1. msjavrdebul n. m-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofil-des.

2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlissamarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 10 ivlisis gamamtyu-nebeli ganaCeni.

3. msjavrdebuli n. m. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da ga-marTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is 360-e muxlis 1-li nawiliTwardgenil braldebaSi.

4. gamarTlebul n. m-es ganemartos, rom ufleba aqvs,saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 92-e muxliT dadgenili wesiT moiTxovos zianis anazRaure-ba.




#549ap-17 22 marti, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi



ganixila Tbilisis didube-CuRureTis raionuli pro-kuraturis prokuror xaTuna kusraSvilis, msjavrdebula. m-sa da misi interesebis damcveli advokatebis _ z. n-isada z. d-as, msjavrdebul x. a-is interesebis damcvelis,advokat i. C-is, msjavrdebul b. c-s interesebis damcve-lis, advokat i. l-as, msjavrdebul m. s-s interesebis dam-cvelis, advokat a. s-isa da msjavrdebul n. a-is interese-bis damcvelis, advokat l. j-is sakasacio saCivrebi Tbi-lisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqme-

25

Ta palatis 2017 wlis 14 ivlisis ganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis

saqmeTa kolegiis 2015 wlis 29 dekembris ganaCeniT n. a., _,nasamarTlobis armqone; b. c., _ x. a., _ nasamarTlevi, _ cno-bil iqnen damnaSaveebad saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `b~, me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT imaSi,rom Caidines yaCaRoba, e.i. Tavdasxma sxvisi moZravi niv-Tis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, CadeniliZaladobis gamoyenebis muqariT, winaswari SeTanxmebiTjgufis mier, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT, didi odenobiT qo-nebis dauflebis mizniT; a. m., _ cnobil iqna damnaSavedsaqarTvelos ssk-is 25,179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, me-3nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT imaSi, rom Caidina yaCaRobisorganizeba, Cadenili Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqariT, wi-naswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier, binaSi ukanono SeRwe-viT, didi odenobiT qonebis dauflebis mizniT; m. s., _ na-samarTlobis armqone, _ cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTve-los ssk-is 25,179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, me-3 nawilis`b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT imaSi, rom Caidina Zaladobis gamoye-nebis muqariT, winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier, binaSiukanono SeRweviT, didi odenobiT qonebis dauflebis miz-niT yaCaRobaSi daxmareba.

2. amave ganaCeniT b. s., _ nasamarTlobis armqone, _ cno-bil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda saqarTvelos ssk-is25,179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qve-punqtebiT wardgenil braldebaSi; gamarTlebuli b. s. da-uyovnebliv gaTavisuflda sasamarTlo sxdomis darbazi-dan; masve ganemarta zianis anazRaurebis moTxovnis uf-leba.

3. ganaCeniT dadgenilad iqna miCneuli Semdegi faqtob-rivi garemoebebi:

a. m-saTvis cnobili iyo, rom a. s. da n. g. sacxovrebelbinaSi, mdebare T-Si, d., inaxavdnen didi odenobiT oqrosnivTebs da ganizraxa yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis organizeba. ammizniT a. m. daukavSirda naTesav m. s-s, romelic Tavis mxrivaseve daukavSirda nacnobebs _ b. c-sa da x. a-s, xolo x. a.daukavSirda biZaSvils _ n. a-s. danaSaulebriv jgufSi ase-ve iyvnen gamoZiebiT daudgeneli sxva pirebi. 2015 wlis 23

26

marts, Ramis saaTebSi, b. c., x. a., n. a. da gamoZiebiT daud-geneli piri n. a-is avtomobiliT, sax. #..., a. m-s organize-biTa da miTiTebiT mividnen T-Si, d-is korpusis mimdeba-re teritoriaze, ukanonod SeaRwies aRniSnul korpusSimdebare n. g-s kuTvnil sacxovrebel binaSi da Tavs daes-xnen mis ojaxs. Tavdasxmis dros saxlSi imyofebodnen n.g. da misi arasrulwlovani Svilebi _ n. da l. s-ebi, romel-Tac webovani lentiT Seukres xelebi. Tavdamsxmelebmacecxlsasroli iaraRis msgavsi sagnebisa da danebis de-monstrirebiT mosTxoves saxlSi arsebuli fulis, Zvir-faseulobisa da iaraRis gadacema, winaaRmdeg SemTxveva-Si daemuqrnen sicocxlis mospobiT. b. c., x. a. da n. a. gamo-ZiebiT daudgenel sxva pirTan erTad marTlsawinaaRmde-god daeuflnen n. g-s kuTvnil, 200000 aSS dolarad Rire-bul Zvirfas nivTebs, romlebic SemdgomSi erTmaneTSi ga-inawiles.

4. aRniSnuli qmedebisaTvis m. s-s miesaja 8 wliT, xoloa. m-s, b. c-s, n. a-sa da x. a-s _ 9-9 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkve-Ta; saqarTvelos ssk-is 67-e muxlis safuZvelze gauqmdazugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 22 ivlisis ga-naCeniT ssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis gamoyenebiT gansazRvru-li pirobiTi msjavri; ssk-is 59-e muxlis safuZvelze x. a-isaTvis Sefardebul 9 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTas dae-mata zugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 22 ivli-sis ganaCeniT gansazRvruli sasjelis mouxdeli nawili-dan _ 6 Tve da ganaCenTa erTobliobiT x. a-s saboloodmiesaja 9 wliTa da 6 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa. msjav-rdebulebs _ a. m-s, m. s-sa da b. c-s sasjelis vadis aTvladaewyoT 2015 wlis 31 martidan, n. a-sa da x. a-s _ imave wlis1 aprilidan.

5. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres Tbilisis di-dube-CuRureTis raionuli prokuraturis prokurorma g.osaZem, msjavrdebulma a. m-m da misma advokatebma _ z. n-em da z. d-am, msjavrdebul n. a-is advokatma l. j-em, msjav-rdebul m. s-s advokatebma _ a. s-ma da a. g-em, msjavrde-bulma x. a-m da misma advokatma i. C-em, msjavrdebulma b.c-ma da misma advokatma i. l-am.

6. prokurorma g. osaZem saapelacio saCivriT iTxovaTbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 29 dekembrisganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana da b. s-s damnaSaved cnoba sa-

27

qarTvelos ssk-is 25,179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ da me-3nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT, xolo danarCen nawilSi _ganaCenis ucvlelad datoveba.

7. msjavrdebulebma da maTma interesebis damcvelmaadvokatebma iTxoves gasaCivrebuli gamamtyunebeli ga-naCenis gauqmeba da msjavrdebulTa gamarTleba.

8. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 14 ivlisis ganaCeniT saa-pelacio saCivrebi ar dakmayofilda da gasaCivrebuli ga-naCeni darCa ucvlelad.

9. kasatori _ Tbilisis didube-CuRureTis raionuliprokuraturis prokurori xaTuna kusraSvili sakasaciosaCivriT iTxovs Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2017wlis 14 ivlisis ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setanasa da b. s-s dam-naSaved cnobas saqarTvelos ssk-is 25,179-e muxlis me-2nawilis `b~ da me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT im moti-viT, rom saqmeSi warmodgenili iyo sakmaris mtkicebule-baTa erToblioba, romliTac dadasturda b. s-s braleu-loba.

10. msjavrdebuli a. m. da misi interesebis damcveliadvokatebi _ z. n. da z. d. sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven ga-saCivrebuli ganaCenis gauqmebas da a. m-s gamarTlebas immotiviT, rom saqmeSi ar arsebobs misi braleulobis dama-dasturebeli arcerTi mtkicebuleba da gamamtyunebeliganaCeni eyrdnoba mxolod varaudebs.

11. advokati i. C. sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs gasaCivre-buli gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmebas da x. a-is mimarTgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgenas Semdegi motivebiT:SemTxvevis adgilze aRebuli anabeWdebi, sunis nimuSebida sxva kvlebi ar daemTxva x. a-is anabeWdebs, sunisa daboWkoebis nimuSebs; 2015 wlis 17 marts x. a. fizikurad vermividoda m. s-Tan T-Si mdebare binaSi, radgan am dRisTvismas aqvs alibi _ imyofeboda zugdidSi dakrZalvaze (ra-sac mowmeebi adastureben) da dafiqsirda probaciis biu-roSic; SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebuliminis qila Secvales aryis boTliT `xlebnaia~, saidanacaRebuli kvali daemTxva x. a-is genetikur masalas, Tanax-mad biologiuri eqspertizis daskvnisa.

12. advokati i. l. sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs gasaCivre-buli ganaCenis gauqmebas da b. c-s mimarT gamamarTlebeli

28

ganaCenis dadgenas, b. c-s reabilitaciasa da misTvis miye-nebuli zianis anazRaurebas, Semdeg motivebze dayrdno-biT: saeqsperto kvlevebis Sedegad b. c-s SemTxvevis ad-gilze yofna ver dadasturda; b. c-s binis Cxreka Catardasaproceso kanonis moTxovnaTa darRveviT gadaudebeliaucileblobiT informaciis miRebidan 16 saaTis gasvlisSemdeg; b. c-ma Cxrekis oqms xeli ar moawera; braldebiswardgenamde gamomZiebelma gaxsna da daaTvaliera niv-Tmtkicebebis paketi, Semdeg ki Caatara amocnoba; gamom-Ziebelma ganacxada, rom paketis gaxsnamde oqros nivTebivizualurad daaTvaliera gamWvirvale paketSi da msgavsinivTebi moitana oqros birJidan, konkretulad visgan _ar axsovs; es nivTebi amoicno dazaralebulma, kanonisdarRveviT Catarebuli moqmedebebiT amoRebul sagans kimtkicebulebis mniSvneloba ar gaaCnia; b. s-ebis CvenebebigamoZiebis sawyis etapze miRebulia Zaladobisa da muqa-ris Sedegad, xolo ganaCeni emyareba mxolod arafrismTqmel frazebs.

13. msjavrdebul m. s-s interesebis damcveli, advoka-ti a. s. sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs m. s-s mimarT gamamar-Tlebeli ganaCenis dadgenas Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo: Ta-vidan m. s-s brali waredgina danaSaulis Seutyobineblo-baSi da winaswari SecnobiT danaSaulebrivi gziT mopove-buli qonebis SeZenaSi an gasaRebaSi, e.i. realurad aranai-ri mtkicebuleba ar arsebobda; amis Semdeg, ise, rom dama-tebiT aranairi mtkicebuleba ar moupovebiaT, mas braliwauyenes yaCaRobaSi daxmarebisaTvis, Tumca a. m-s, b. c-sada a-ebis braldebis dadgenilebebSi miTiTebulia, rom m.s-ma uari ganacxada maTTvis daxmarebis gawevaze, rac sa-samarTlom ar gaiTvaliswina; satelefono zarebis inten-siuroba, roca saubris Sinaarsi ar aisaxeba, sasamarTlosmtkicebulebad ar unda mieCnia; saqmeSi ki ar moipovebaarcerTi pirdapiri mtkicebuleba, rom is Sehpirda daxma-rebas an vinmes daexmara yaCaRobis CadenaSi.

14. advokati l. j. sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs gasaCiv-rebuli ganaCenis gauqmebas da n. a-is gamarTlebas SemdegimotivebiT: n. a-is yofna n. g-s binaSi arafriT ar dastur-deba; minis boTli amoiRes ara dazaralebulis binidan,aramed _ sadarbazos Sesasvlelidan, rac upirobod ar niS-navs imas, rom n. a-m Caidina yaCaRoba; 2015 wlis 28 maisis

29

mdgomareobiT gamoZiebas ukve hqonda genetikuri eqsper-tizis daskvna; dazaralebuli Ziebis procesSi micemularcerT CvenebaSi ar uTiTebs sauTovebelze dadebul mi-nis boTlze da amas acxadebs mxolod sasamarTloSi Cve-nebis micemisas, es ki dazaralebulis Cvenebis sandooba-Si eWvs iwvevs da am informaciis gadamowmebis samarTleb-rivi da praqtikuli saSualebac aRar arsebobs; `112-is~saTvalTvalo kamerebze 2015 wlis 23 marts, gamTeniisas,n. a-is kuTvnili avtomanqanis dafiqsirebis faqti Tavis-Tavad ar niSnavs mis monawileobas yaCaRobaSi; ijda Tuara n. a. manqanaSi, iyvnen Tu ara masTan Tanamonawileebi _es ar dadgenila; igi ar amoucvniaT dazaralebulebs, Tum-ca mas aqvs vizualurad SesamCnevi ganmasxvavebeli niSani_ marcxena Tvali aqvs dazianebuli.

15. prokurori xaTuna kusraSvili SesageblebiT iTxovsmsjavrdebulebisa da maTi advokatebis sakasacio saCiv-rebis dauSveblad cnobas da ganaCenis ucvlelad dato-vebas a. m-s, b. c-s, n. a-is, x. a-isa da m. s-s damnaSaved cnobisnawilSi.

16. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze prokurorma g. osaZemmxari dauWira prokuror xaTuna kusraSvilis sakasaciosaCivars da iTxova Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 14 ivlisis ga-naCenSi cvlilebis Setana, kerZod _ b. s-s damnaSaved cno-ba saqarTvelos ssk-is 25,179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ dame-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT, xolo danarCen nawilSi_ ganaCenis ucvlelad datoveba.

17. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze dacvis mxaris warmo-madgenlebma mxari dauWires TavianT sakasacio saCivrebsda iTxoves gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgena, xolo b. s-s gamarTlebis nawilSi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos2017 wlis 14 ivlisis ganaCenis ucvlelad datoveba

samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam mxareTa monawileobiT ganixila sa-

kasacio saCivrebi, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civrebis safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rom Tbilisis didu-be-CuRureTis raionuli prokuraturis prokuror xaTu-na kusraSvilis sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofil-des, xolo dacvis mxaris sakasacio saCivrebi unda dakma-

30

yofildes da gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda Seicvalos, vi-naidan braldebis mxaris mier warmodgenili da sasamar-Tlo sxdomaze gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebi ar iZlevaimis safuZvels, rom sakasacio palatam gonivrul eWvs miR-ma dadgenilad miiCnios a. m-s, x. a-is, n. a-is, b. c-sa da m. s-smier yaCaRobis Cadenis faqti.

2. palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs im garemoebas, rom bral-debulebs brali TanamonawileobiTa da Tanaamsruleblo-biT Cadenil danaSaulSi edebaT da, Sesabamisad, mniSvne-lovania warmodgenil mtkicebulebaTa erToblivi anali-zi, Tumca aRniSnuli ar gamoricxavs sasamarTlos valde-bulebas, yoveli braldebulis mimarT gamamtyunebeli ga-naCeni gamoitanos konkretulad misi braleulobis dama-dasturebeli sakmarisi da utyuari mtkicebulebebis ar-sebobis SemTxvevaSi. mocemul saqmeSi ki gasaCivrebuli ga-naCeni efuZneba iseT mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobas, ro-melic zogadad miuTiTebs danaSaulebrivi qmedebis ar-sebobaze, Tumca utyuarad ar miuTiTebs konkretul pir-Ta braleulobaze.

3. sakasacio palata gasaCivrebul ganaCens Seafasebsswored im mimarTebiT, Tu ramdenadaa warmodgenili ut-yuar mtkicebulebaTa sakmarisi erToblioba TiToeulimsjavrdebulis mimarT gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis goniv-rul eWvs miRma standartiT gamosatanad.

4. a. m-s bralis dasadastureblad ganaCeni ZiriTadadefuZneba dazaralebul n. g-sa da misi Svilebis _ n. da l. s-ebis Cvenebebs, mowme i. m-is Cvenebasa da mobiluri opera-torebisgan gamoTxovil informacias, kerZod:

4.1. dazaralebul n. g-s CvenebiT, 2015 wlis 22-23 mar-tis Rames niRbiani SeiaraRebuli mamakacebi Sevidnen mas-Tan binaSi; isini dasavlur kiloze saubrobdnen, erT-er-Ti ki megrulad laparakobda; Tavdamsxmelebidan erTmamas mimarTa Semdegi sityvebiT _ `Senze amboben, vaJkacu-ri qaliao~, ase ki mxolod a. m. mimarTavda xolme, romelicmis meuRlesTan erTad saqmianobda ucxoeTSi da kargadicoda, rom n. g. agrovebda oqros; garda amisa, n. g-ma ga-nacxada, rom borotmoqmedebs aryis suni asdiodaT, xo-lo sauTovebelze SeniSna boTli, romelic misi ar iyo,Tumca SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis dros es boTlisaxlSi veRar ipoves.

31

4.2. mowmeebis _ n. da l. s-ebis CvenebebiT, 2015 wlis 23marts, 4-is wuTebze, maT ojaxSi Sevidnen niRbiani yaCa-Rebi da xel-fexi plastmasis salteebiT Seukres; maT ar-yis suni asdiodaT da kuTxur kiloze saubrobdnen; erT-erTma Tavdamsxmelma maT uTxra, rom iyo evropaSi maT ma-masTan erTad, masze Suri unda eZiaT da hyavda l. s-s asa-kisa da saxelis Svili. l. s-s ganmartebiT, swored im pirisxma miamsgavsa a. m-s xmas, romelmac Tqva, rom hyavda Svi-li, saxelad l., igi meuRlesTan erTad maT ojaxSi xSiradmodioda da Ramec rCeboda. mas hyavda misi asakis Svili _l..

4.3. sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli i. m-is CvenebiT, 2015 wlis martis bolos mas Sexvda a. m. dasTxova oqros gayidvaSi daxmareba, Tumca arc oqro uCve-nebia, arc mis warmomavlobasa da zust wonaze uTqvams ra-ime, mxolod is uTxra, rom oqro iyo Turquli.

4.4. Sps `...~ gadmogzavnili CD diskis daTvalierebis Se-degad miRebuli informaciis Tanaxmad, 2015 wlis 22 mar-tidan imave wlis 29 martis CaTvliT m. s-s, a. m-sa da b. c-shqondaT satelefono kavSirebi.

5. sakasacio palatis mosazrebiT, miTiTebuli mtkice-bulebebi ar akmayofilebs piris damnaSaved cnobisTvissaWiro mtkicebulebiT standarts Semdeg garemoebaTa ga-mo:

5.1. piris braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebidan irkveva,rom saxelmwifo braldeba a. m-s bralad sdebda yaCaRobisorganizebas ise, rom ar edaveboda n. g-s binaSi piradadSeRwevas. Sesabamisad, Tuki braldebis versiiT a. m. Sem-Txvevis adgilze ar imyofeboda, gaugebari xdeba bral-debis mxaris Zalisxmeva, mtkicebulebaTa moSveliebiT da-adasturos is faqti, rom a. m. imyofeboda SemTxvevis ad-gilze da monawileobda yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi. rasac izia-reben pirveli da saapelacio instanciis sasamarTloebimaSin, rodesac aRniSnuli msjelobis saWiroeba ar gamom-dinareobs piris braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebidan, rad-gan ar emsaxureba braldebis dadgenilebaSi aRwerili faq-tobrivi garemoebebis dadasturebis mizans.

5.2. garda amisa, sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 24-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Tanaxmad, or-ganizatoria is, vinc moawyo danaSaulis Cadena an xel-

32

mZRvanelobda mis ganxorcielebas. Sesabamisad, gaziare-bul romc iqnes sasamarTloTa pozicia a. m-s SemTxvevisadgilze yofnisa da yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi sxva pirebTanerTad monawileobis Sesaxeb, palatisTvis gaugebaria daarc gasaCivrebuli ganaCenidan ikveTeba, Tu ra formiTSeiZleba adasturebdes es faqti im garemoebas, rom m-mmoawyo danaSaulis Cadena an/da xelmZRvanelobda mis gan-xorcielebas.

5.3. gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni im nawilSic dausabuTebe-lia, imyofeboda Tu ara SemTxvevis adgilze a. m., vinaidanes garemoeba efuZneba mxolod n. g-s ganmartebas, rom fra-zas _ `Senze amboben, vaJkacuri qaliao~ _ ambobda xolme a.m. da aseve, l. s-s ganmartebas, rom Tavdamsxmelis xma mi-amsgavsa a. m-s xmas. palatis mosazrebiT, aRniSnuli war-moSobs mxolod varauds, rom SesaZloa, a. m. imyofebodaSemTxvevis adgilze, vinaidan arc mocemul frazaSia rai-me gansakuTrebuli niSani, rom mxolod a. m. SeiZleba iyosmisi avtori da arc mxolod xmis mimsgavsebaa sakmarisi sa-fuZveli piris zusti identificirebisTvis, xolo varau-di, bunebrivia, ver daedeba safuZvlad gamamtyunebel ga-naCens.

5.4. dausabuTebelia aseve saapelacio palatis mosaz-reba, rom m-s braleuloba dadasturebulia mobiluri ope-ratorebisgan amoRebuli informaciiT, vinaidan dadge-nilia, rom m. s. aris a. m-s meuRlis naTesavi, ris gamoc maTSoris ganxorcielebuli satelefono zarebi (maT Soris _yaCaRobis wina dRes) sruliad bunebrivia da ver iqnebaimis mamtkicebeli, rom naTesavebis saubari swored yaCa-Ruri Tavdasxmis organizebas exeboda. aRsaniSnavia isic,rom a. m-s satelefono kavSiri gamoZiebisTvis sainteresoperiodSi hqonda mxolod naTesav m. s-Tan da sxva bralde-bulebTan misi kontaqti saerTod ar fiqsirdeba.

5.5. a. m-s braleuloba ar dasturdeba aseve mowme i. m-isCvenebiT, rom 2015 wlis martis bolos mas Sexvda a. m. dasTxova oqros gayidvaSi daxmareba, vinaidan sasamarTlosxdomaze dakiTxuli mowme m. m-is CvenebiT 2015 wlis mar-tis bolos mas esaubra a. m., romelTanac aqvs megobruliurTierToba da sTxova finansuri daxmareba, raTa gamoe-tana lombardSi Cabarebuli Tavisi meuRlis oqros nivTe-bi da gaeyida. amdenad, eWvi imis Taobaze, rom i. m-s a. m.

33

sakuTari nivTebis gayidvaSi sTxovda daxmarebas, romlisgamotanasac apirebda lombardidan, ar aris gabaTilebu-li. metic, gaugebaria, ratom sTxovda a. m. m. m-s finansurdaxmarebas lombardidan oqros daxsnaSi, Tu mas hqondanayaCaRari nivTebi da, Sesabamisad, mis dauxmarebladacSeeZlo nivTebis lombardidan daxsna.

6. rac Seexeba n. da x. a-ebs, maTi braleulobis damadas-turebelad ganaCeni eyrdnoba biologiuri (genetikuri)eqspertizis 2015 wlis 21 aprilis #... daskvnas, romlisTanaxmad, SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebul, erTi minisboTlis pirsa da saxuravze, warweriT `xlebnaia~, aRmoC-nda biomasala Sereuli genetikuri profiliT, romlis Zi-riTadi wili identuria n. a-is, xolo meore wili _ x. a-isgenetikuri profilebisa da `112-dan~ amoRebul 2015 wlis23 martis videoCanawerebs, romelTa daTvalierebis Se-degad irkveva, rom T-Si, m-a da p-is quCebis gadakveTasada a. kilometrze (06:46 sT) gadaRebul CanawerebSi ar Cansmuqi feris avtomanqanis, romelsac adgas taqsis amosac-nobi niSani, saxelmwifo nomeri, xolo T-Si, a. kilomet-rze 06:48 sT-ze gadaRebul videoCanawerSi nomris amom-cnobs dafiqsirebuli aqvs muqi feris avtomanqana, sax. #....swored am saxelmwifo nomris mqone avtomanqana `opelveqtra B-s~ mflobelia n. a., rasac sakasacio palata verdaeTanxmeba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

6.1. minis boTli warweriT `xlebnaia~ amoiRes sadarba-zodan da ara _ dazaralebulis binidan, Sesabamisad, sxvamtkicebulebaTa ararsebobis pirobebSi, usafuZvloa upi-robod imis mtkiceba, rom aRniSnuliT dasturdeba n. a-isa da x. a-is yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi monawileoba.

6.2. garda amisa, sakasacio palata yuradRebis miRma verdatovebs Semdeg faqtobriv garemoebebs:

6.3. SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmSi miTiTe-bulia, rom amoRebuli minis qila dailuqa specpaketSinomriT _ ..., maSin, rodesac biologiuri (genetikuri) eq-spertizis #... daskvnis aRwerilobiT nawilSi miTiTebu-lia, rom 1 cali minis boTli, masze arsebuli warweriT`xlebnaia~, moTavsebuli iyo polieTilenis daluqul pa-ketSi StrixkodiT _ ... .

6.4. amdenad, SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmisTanaxmad, dailuqa minis qila StrixkodiT _ ..., xolo gene-

34

tikuri eqspertiza Catarda minis boTlze warweriT ̀ xleb-naia~, romelic moTavsebuli iyo polieTilenis daluqulpaketSi StrixkodiT _ ... . aRniSnuli Seusabamoba im fon-ze, rodesac dazaralebuls Ziebis procesSi micemul arcerT CvenebaSi ar miuTiTebia sauTovebelze dadebul mi-nis boTlze da amis Sesaxeb miuTiTa mxolod sasamarTlo-Si Cvenebis micemisas (mas Semdeg, rac cnobili gaxda gene-tikuri eqspertizis Sedegi), sakasacio palatis mosazre-biT, obieqtur damkvirvebelSi gaaCens safuZvlian eWvsnivTmtkicebis sandoobasTan dakavSirebiT, rac unda ga-dawydes braldebulebis sasargeblod.

6.5. dausabuTebelia msjeloba imis Sesaxeb, rom Sem-Txvevis dRes _ 2015 wlis 23 marts, gamTeniisas, n. a-is av-tomanqanis dafiqsireba T-Si gasasvlelTan raime formiTmiuTiTebs n. a-is yaCaRobaSi monawileobaze, miT ufro imisgaTvaliswinebiT, rom ar aris dadgenili, zis Tu ara av-tomanqanaSi Tavad n. a..

6.6. dausabuTebelia aseve msjeloba x. a-is braleulo-bis samtkicebelad SemTxvevis wina dRes m. s-Tan misi er-Ti satelefono zaris moSveliebis Sesaxeb, iseve, rogorcm. s-sa da b. c-s Soris ganxorcilebuli satelefono kavSi-ri SemTxvevamde ramdenime dRiT adre, romelic ar gamo-irCeva raime gansakuTrebuli intensivobiT, ver iqneba ya-CaRur TavdasxmaSi maTi monawileobis damadasturebeli.palata miuTiTebs, rom maTi kavSiri SesaZloa, gamxdari-yo maTi bralis gamamyarebeli mtkicebuleba sxva mtkice-bulebebTan erToblivad, calke ki ver gaxdeba maTi kon-kretul danaSaulebriv qmedebaSi monawileobis damadas-turebeli (ix.susg #393ap.-17).

7. gonivrul eWvs miRma standarts ver akmayofilebsaseve gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni m. s-sa da b. c-s msjavrde-bis nawilSic Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

7.1. m. s-Tan dakavSirebiT, sakasacio palata, pirvel yov-lisa, yuradRebas miaqcevs im garemobas, rom Tavidan m. s-s brali waredgina danaSaulis Seutyobineblobasa da wi-naswari SecnobiT danaSaulebrivi gziT mopovebuli qone-bis SeZenaSi an gasaRebaSi; amis Semdeg mas brali daumZim-da da waredgina braldeba yaCaRobaSi daxmarebisaTvis, ma-Sin, roca a. m-s, b. c-sa da a-ebis braldebis dadgenilebeb-Si miTiTebulia, rom m. s-ma uari ganacxada maTTvis daxma-

35

rebis gawevaze, anu wardgenili bralis Sinaarsive gamo-ricxavs mocemuli kvalifikaciiT (yaCaRobaSi daxmareba)qmedebis dakvalificirebisa da, Sesabamisad, misi msjav-rdebis SesaZleblobas.

7.2. garda amisa, gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT m. s-sa da b. c-s braleuloba efuZneba mxolod im faqtobriv garemoe-bas, rom maTgan amoiRes nivTebi, romlebic Semdeg daza-ralebulma amoicno, kerZod:

7.3. b. c-s administraciuli dakavebis #... oqmidan ir-kveva, rom misi piradi gasinjvisas marjvena xelidan amo-Rebul iqna mcire zomis, marTkuTxedis formis oqrosfe-ri detali, romelic SeifuTa da dailuqa. b. c-s binis Cxre-kis oqmidan irkveva, rom b. c-s binis Cxrekisas, sxva niv-TebTan erTad, amoiRes 7 TeTri feris plastmasis salte,oqrosferi brtyeli samajuri, aseve _ samajuris gadaW-rili naWeri da erTmaneTze gadabmuli perangis samagri _ori oqrosferi brtyeli nivTi.

7.4. m. s-s piradi Cxrekis dros, sxva nivTebTan erTad,amoiRes polieTilenis TeTri parki, romelSic moTavse-buli iyo oqrosferi nivTebi: oqrosferi, brtyeli naqso-vi yelsabami; brtyeli, oqrosferi yelsabami; brtyeli, oq-rosferi naqsovi samajuri; oqrosferi, mrgvali, dagre-xili samajuri zeda mxares yvavilis formis SesakraviT;oqrosferi, oTxkuTxedi broSi zeda mxares TvlebiT; 2cali oqrosferi naqsovi sayure; 2 oqrosferi, brtyelinaqsovi naWeri.

7.5. dazaralebulma n. g-ma amoicno b. c-s binis Cxreki-sas da m. s-s piradi Cxrekisas amoRebuli nivTebi.

7.6. palata aRniSnavs, rom garda zemoaRniSnulisa, ra-ime sxva _ pirdapiri da an/da arapirdapiri mtkicebuleba,romliTac dadasturdeboda maTi monawileoba jgufur ya-CaRobaSi, ar arsebobs (satelefono kavSirebis Sesaxeb pa-latam zemoT ukve imsjela). amasTan dakavSirebiT ki ar-sebobs saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos damkvidrebu-li praqtika, romlis Tanaxmadac, mxolod is faqti, rompirTan aRmoCnda dazaralebulis mflobelobidan misi ne-bis sawinaaRmdegod gatacebuli nivTi, ver ganixileba ut-yuar da sakmaris safuZvlad yaCaRobaSi am piris braleu-lad cnobisaTvis, Tuki aseTi faqti dadasturebuli araris kidev sxva iseTi mtkicebulebiT, romelic pirs uSu-

36

alod amxels danaSaulis CadenaSi (ix. susg #448ap-14,#51ap-17, #584ap-17).

7.7. warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi aseve ar iZleva imisutyuarad dadgenis SesaZleblobasac, rom b. c-ma da m. s-ma ukanonod (winaswari SecnobiT danaSaulebrivi gziT mo-povebuli qonebis SeZena) xom ar SeiZines dazaralebulismflobelobidan gasuli nivTebi, ris gamoc palata ver im-sjelebs im mimarTulebiT, xom ar Seicavs maTi qmedeba sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 186-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli dana-Saulis niSnebs.

8. rac Seexeba mowmeebs _ l. j-s, g. k-s, n. T-s, a. x-s, g. z-s, k. b-s, r. e-es, g. j-as, k. m-es, g. p-s, n. t-s, m. s-s, v. l-as, m.C-s, d. g-s, S. Z-es, g. u-as, v. v-es, g. s-es, t. k-asa da m. w-s, maTdaadastures operatiuli informaciis miRebisa da Cata-rebul saproceso moqmedebebSi monawileobis faqtebi, xo-lo eqspertebma _ i. m-am, e. s-em, m. f-ma, l. S-em, l. g-em da q.g-ma ki _ TavianTi daskvnebis siswore da raime informaciauSualod braldebulTa danaSaulebriv qmedebaSi monawi-leobis Sesaxeb, sasamarTlosTvis ar miuwvdiaT.

9. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasaciopalatas miaCnia, rom braldebis mxaris mier warmodgeni-li mtkicebulebiTi baza qmnis mxolod varauds a. m-s, b. c-s, x. a-is, n. a-isa da m. s-s mier yaCaRobis Cadenis Sesaxeb,ris gamoc ver gaxdeba maTi msjavrdebis safuZveli, vina-idan saqarTvelos konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 nawi-lis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebodesmxolod utyuar mtkicebulebebs. yovelgvari eWvi, rome-lic ver dadasturdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, undagadawydes braldebulis sasargeblod. ganaCeni unda em-yarebodes saqmeSi arsebul mtkicebulebaTa TavisufalSefasebas, daskvnebs, romlebic gamomdinareobs faqtob-rivi garemoebebidan da mxareebis mier wardgenili mosaz-rebebidan. mtkiceba SeiZleba gamomdinareobdes sakmari-sad naTeli da dasabuTebuli daskvnebis an faqtis Taoba-ze gauqarwylebeli varaudebis erTobliobidan (ECtHR, El-Masri v The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, 39630/09, §151,13.12.2012; ECtHR, Hassan v The UK, 29750/09, §48, 16.09.2014). sa-qarTvelos sssk-is me-13 muxlis me-2 nawilis, 259-e mux-lis me-3 nawilisa da 273-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Sesabami-sad, ganaCenSi Camoyalibebuli yvela daskvna dasabuTe-

37

buli unda iyos. gamamtyunebel ganaCenSi unda aRiniSnosutyuari da sakmarisi mtkicebulebebi, romlebsac emya-reba sasamarTlos daskvna. saqarTvelos sssk-is 82-e mux-lis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT pi-ris damnaSaved cnobisaTvis saWiroa gonivrul eWvs miRmaarsebul SeTanxmebul mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba.

10. rac Seexeba prokuror xaTuna kusraSvilis sakasa-cio saCivris moTxovnas b. s-s mimarT gamamtyunebeli ga-naCenis dadgenis Sesaxeb, palatas miaCnia, rom ganaCeni amnawilSi kanonieria da unda darCes ucvlelad, vinaidan b.s-s braleulobis damadastureblad braldebis mxare mi-uTiTebs mxolod misgan piradi Cxrekis Sedegad amoRe-bul nivTebze, risi arasakmarisobis Taobazec piris msjav-rdebisaTvis palatam zemoT ukve imsjela.

11. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom Tbilisis saapelacio sasamar-Tlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 14 iv-lisis gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni a. m-s, b. c-s, n. a-is, m. s-sada x. a-is mimarT unda gauqmdes mtkicebulebaTa arasakma-risobis motiviT, xolo b. s-s nawilSi unda darCes ucvle-lad.


is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT,me-3 nawiliT da

d a a d g i n a:

1. Tbilisis didube-CuRureTis raionuli prokuratu-ris prokuror xaTuna kusraSvilis sakasacio saCivari ardakmayofildes.

2. msjavrdebul a. m-sa da misi interesebis damcveliadvokatebis _ z. n-isa da z. d-as, msjavrdebul x. a-is in-teresebis damcvelis, advokat i. C-is, msjavrdebul b. c-sinteresebis damcvelis, advokat i. l-as, msjavrdebul m.s-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat a. s-isa da msjavrde-bul n. a-is interesebis damcvelis, advokat l. j-is saka-sacio saCivrebi dakmayofildes.

3. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-

38

Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 14 ivlisis ganaCenSi Sevi-des cvlileba:

4. a. m. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 25-179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis ̀ b~ da ̀ g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenil bral-debaSi;

5. n. a. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis ̀ b~ da ̀ g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenil bral-debaSi;

6. b. c. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis ̀ b~ da ̀ g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenil bral-debaSi;

7. m. s. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 25-179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis ̀ b~ da ̀ g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenil bral-debaSi;

8. x. a. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis ̀ b~ da ̀ g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenil bral-debaSi;

9. zugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 22 ivli-sis ganaCeniT x. a-isaTvis daniSnuli sasjeli _ 2 wliT Ta-visuflebis aRkveTa, rac CaeTvala pirobiT, 2 wlis gamo-sacdeli vadiT, 2015 wlis 1 aprilidan 2018 wlis 22 martisCaTvliT patimrobaSi yofnis gaTvaliswinebiT, CaeTvalosmoxdilad.

10. gamarTlebulebi _ a. m., n. a., b. c., m. s. da x. a. dauyov-nebliv gaTavisufldnen sasamarTlo sxdomis darbazidan.

11. a. m-s, n. a-s, b. c-s, m. s-sa da x. a-s ganemartoT, romufleba aqvT, saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saprocesokodeqsis 92-e muxliT dadgenili wesiT moiTxovon zianisanazRaureba.

12. ganaCeni b. s-s gamarTlebisa da nivTmtkicebebis na-wilSi darCes ucvlelad.


39



#11ap-18 27 ivnisi, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi


p. silagaZe (Tavmjdomare),n. gvenetaZe,g. SavliaSvili

ganixila msjavrdebul _ z. s-s interesebis damcvelis,advokat T. g-s sakasacio saCivari Tbilisis saapelacio sa-samarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis28 noembris ganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis Tanaxmad, z. s-s bra-

li daedo ZarcvaSi, e. i. sxvisi nivTis aSkara dauflebaSimarTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, ramac mniSvne-lovani ziani gamoiwvia, Cadenili sacavSi ukanono SeRwe-viT, rac gamoixata SemdegSi:

2013 wlis 17 dekembers, saRamos saaTebSi, T-Si, p-s #-Si mdebare Sps `b-s~ kuTvnil jixurSi, ukanonod SeaRwiaz. s-m, saidanac marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT,aSkarad daeufla _ 450 lars, ris Sedegadac dazarale-bul organizacias miadga mniSvnelovani materialuri zi-ani.

2. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiis 2017 wlis 21 aprilis ganaCeniT z. s, _dabadebuli 19.. wels, nasamarTlobis armqone, _ cnobiliqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-marTlis kodeqsis 178-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~ qve-punqtebiT wardgenil braldebaSi.

z. s-s mimarT Sefardebuli aRkveTis RonisZieba giraogauqmda. aseve gauqmda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlossisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa kolegiis 2014 wlis 1 ianvrisganCinebiT Sefardebuli aRkveTis RonisZieba _ giraos

40

4000 (oTxi aTasi) laris uzrunvelsayofad, Tbilisis sa-qalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa kolegi-is 2014 wlis 16 ianvris ganCinebiT, d. s-s ojaxis sakuTre-baSi arsebul, d-s raionis sofel a-Si, m. w-s teritoriazemdebare sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis miwis nakveT-ze _ s/k ... g. s-s ojaxis sakuTrebaSi arsebul, d-s raionissofel a-Si, satraqtoro brigadasTan mdebare sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis miwis nakveTze _ s/k ..., e. s-s oja-xis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli d.-s raionis sofel a.-Si, k.-sTanmdebare sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis miwis nakveT-ze _ s/k ... dadebuli yadaRa.

saqmeze mtkicebulebad cnobili:• SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis amsaxveli foto-

suraTebi diskis saxiT, romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlissaqmes, Sps `atlantikidan~ miRebuli videoCanaweri dis-kis saxiT, romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlis saqmes, dac-vis mxaris mier warmodgenili fotosuraTebi da diski,romlebic erTvis sisxlis samarTlis saqmes, Senaxuli un-da iqnes saqmis Senaxvis vadiT.

• sunis nimuSebi, romlebic inaxeba vake-saburTalosSs sammarTvelos me-5 ganyofilebaSi, saqmeze saboloo ga-dawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda ganadgurdes.

gamarTlebul z. s-s ganemarta saqarTvelos ssk-is 92-emuxliT gaTvaliswinebuli zianis anazRaurebis moTxov-nis ufleba.

3. aRniSnuli ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres Tbi-lisis vake-saburTalos raionuli prokuraturis proku-rorma levan kopalianma da z. s-s interesebis damcvelma,advokatma T g-m.

braldebis mxarem saCivriT iTxova gamamarTlebeli ga-naCenis gauqmeba da z. s-s damnaSaved cnoba wardgenilbraldebaSi.

dacvis mxarem saCivriT iTxova ganaCenSi cvlilebis Se-tana, kerZod: ganaCenidan gamarTlebulis udanaSaulobisgamomricxavi formulirebebis amoricxva.

4. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 28 noembris ganaCeniT Tbi-lisis vake-saburTalos raionuli prokuraturis proku-ror levan kopalianis saapelacio saCivari dakmayofil-da. z. s-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat T. g-s saapela-

41

cio saCivari ar dakmayofilda.gauqmda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-

Tlis saqmeTa kolegiis 2017 wlis 21 aprilis ganaCeni.z. s. cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-

marTlis kodeqsis 178-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~ qve-punqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis dasasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra 4 (oTxi) wliT Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa, romlis aTvla daewyo ganaCenis gamoc-xadebis momentidan _ 2017 wlis 28 noembridan.

msjavrdebul z. s-s sasjelis moxdis vadaSi CaeTvalapatimrobaSi yofnis dro _ 2013 wlis 31 dekembridan 2014wlis 17 ianvris CaTvliT.

ganaCeni danarCen nawilSi darCa ucvlelad.5. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-

Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 28 noembris ganaCeni saka-sacio wesiT gaasaCivra msjavrdebul z. s-s interesebisdamcvelma, advokatma T. g-m. kasatori saCivriT iTxovsgamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmebasa da mis nacvlad gama-marTlebeli ganaCenis gamotanas.


ma sakasacio saCivris motivebis safuZvlianoba da daas-kvna, rom msjavrdebul _ z. s-s interesebis damcvelis,advokat T. g-s sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes dagasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda gauqmdes Semdeg garemoeba-Ta gamo:

2. sakasacio palata, pirvel rigSi, aRniSnavs, rom izia-rebs rogorc pirveli, ise saapelacio instanciis sasamar-Tloebis Sefasebebs, rom saqmeze warmodgenil mtkicebu-lebaTa erTobliobiT gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiTdasturdeba, rom z. s-m Caidina Zarcva, ese igi sxvisi niv-Tis aSkara daufleba marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebismizniT, ramac mniSvnelovani ziani gamoiwvia, Cadenili sa-cavSi ukanono SeRweviT, kerZod:

dazaralebul n. b-s Tanmimdevruli da damajerebeliCvenebiTa da mis mier piris amocnobis oqmiT, ra drosacdazaralebulma, konkretuli individualuri niSnebis mi-TiTebiT, darwmunebiT miuTiTa z. s-ze, rogorc danaSau-lis Camden pirze. dazaralebulma pirveli instanciis sa-

42

samarTloSi saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvisas (piris amocnobisCatarebidan, arsebiTi ganxilvis sxdomaze dazaralebu-lis dakiTxvamde, gavida or welze meti) kidev erTxel da-bejiTebiT miuTiTa, rom swored z. s. iyo is piri, romel-mac p-s gamziris #...-Si mdebare jixuridan 2013 wlis 17dekembers gaitaca 450 lari; odorologiuri eqspertizisdaskvniT, romlis mixedviT, dadgenilia, rom SemTxvevisadgilidan amoRebuli 1 (erTi) sunis kvalis nimuSi iden-turia z. T-s Ze s-sagan aRebuli sunis kvalis nimuSisa.

3. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio pala-tis msjelobas, rom odorologiuri eqspertizis das-kvniT, utyuarad dasturdeba z.s-s jixurSi yofnis faq-ti. amasTanave, dazaralebulma n. b-m pirveli instanciissasamarTloSi Cvenebis micemis dros ganmarta, rom kli-ents raimes SesaZenad jixurSi Sesvla ar uwevda. niSan-doblivia is garemoebac, rom dacvis mxaris mowmeebisTqmiT, z. s-s Tavisi saxlidan _ mamidis saxlamde misas-vlelad ar uwevda p-s q. #-Tan gavla, rac adasturebs imgaremoebas, rom jixurSi z. s-s sunis kvali SemTxveviT veraRmoCndeboda da igi jixurSi aRmoCnda swored misi iqyofnis Sedegad.

4. sakasacio palata, aseve iziarebs saapelacio pala-tis Sefasebas, rom dacvis mxaris mowmeebis _ e. s-s, m. v-sada s. s-s Cvenebebi winaaRmdegobrivia da maTi mizania, romz. s-s Tavidan aaridon mosalodneli pasuxismgebloba,radgan isini arian misi naTesavebi, ris Sesaxebac detalu-rad msjelobs saapelacio palata, rasac sakasacio pala-tac eTanxmeba. aseve, marTebulia saapelacio instanciissasamarTlos msjeloba maRazia `m-dan~ mopovebuli vide-oCanawerebis gauziareblobis nawilSic.

5. amdenad, mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio palatas mi-aCnia, rom marTalia braldebis mxarem warmoadgina im ut-yuar mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba, romlebiTac dastur-deba, rom z. s-m Caidina saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis 178-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~ qvepunqtebiTgaTvaliswinebuli danaSauli, Tumca palatam unda imsje-los da gadawyvitos danaSaulis Cadenis momentSi z. s-sbralunarianobis sakiTxze.

6. aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT, sakasacio palatas dad-genilad miaCnia Semdegi faqtobrivi garemoebebi:

43

• z. s-m danaSauli Caidina 2013 wlis 17 dekembers.• dacvis mxarem 2014 wlis 14 Tebervals waradgina Sps

#- klinikuri saavadmyofos 2014 wlis 10 Tebervlis fsi-qiatriis departamentis samedicino dokumentacia _ for-ma IV-100/a-s, romlis Tanaxmad, z. s. fsiqiatriul stacio-narSi moTavsda _ 31.01.2014 wels, saidanac gaewera10.02.2014 wels. mas daesva diagnozi: sxva mwvave da garda-mavali fsiqozuri aSliloba F23.8. SezRuduli, pirovnebasub. normis farglebSi. Tanmxlebi daavadeba Jil-de la tu-retas sindromi F95.2 dauzustebeli anemia D64.9. formaIV-100/a-s Tan erTvoda z.s-s ojaxis wevrebis ganmarteba,rom winaaRmdegni iyvnen, mas Catareboda fsiqiatriulieqspertiza.

• mxareebma 2014 wlis 14 Tebervals, gamoZiebisaTvisgankuTvnili vadisa da saqmis sasamarTloSi warmarTvisbolo dRes, gacvales maT xelT arsebuli informacia, maTSoris _ fsiqiatriis departamentis samedicino dokumen-tacia _ forma IV-100/a. braldebulis sasamarTloSi pir-veli wardgenis sxdoma gaimarTa 2014 wlis 1 ianvars, xolowinasasamarTlo sxdoma dainiSna 2014 wlis 20 Tebervals.

• saqarTvelos sssk-is 180-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Ta-naxmad, `Tu arsebobs dasabuTebuli varaudi, rom bral-debuli danaSaulis Cadenisas Seuracxi iyo an misi Cade-nis Semdeg gaxda Seuracxi, da sajaro usafrTxoebis in-teresebi moiTxovs mis samedicino dawesebulebaSi izo-lirebas, gamoZiebis adgilis mixedviT sasamarTlos pro-kuroris an advokatis SuamdgomlobiT gamoaqvs piris sa-xelmwifo samedicino dawesebulebaSi moTavsebis Taoba-ze ganCineba. Suamdgomloba ganixileba zepiri mosmenis ga-reSe, 48 saaTis ganmavlobaSi, xolo miRebuli gadawyveti-leba ar saCivrdeba~. winasasamarTlo sxdomisa da saqmisarsebiTi ganxilvis etapebze, braldebis mxares hqonda in-formacia z. s-s SesaZlo SeuracxadobasTan dakavSirebiT,magram ar dainteresebula miTiTebuli sakiTxis garkve-viT.

7. saqarTvelos konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 nawi-lis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebodesmxolod utyuar mtkicebulebebs. yovelgvari eWvi, rome-lic ver dadasturdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, undagadawydes braldebulis sasargeblod. konstituciis me-

44

40 muxlis me-3 punqtidan gamomdinare, mtkicebulebiTistandarti valdebulebas akisrebs sasamarTlos, rom sa-Tanadod Seafasos mtkicebulebebi, samarTlianad gadaW-ras samxilebs Soris arsebuli winaaRmdegobebi da am pro-cesSi warmoSobili yovelgvari gonivruli eWvi gadawyvi-tos braldebulis udanaSaulobis, misi Tavisuflebis sa-sargeblod (ix. saqarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos2015 wlis 22 ianvris #1/1/548 gadawyvetileba saqmeze `sa-qarTvelos moqalaqe zurab miqaZe saqarTvelos parlamen-tis winaaRmdeg~). saqmis garemoebebis dasadgenad, sasamar-Tlo iTvaliswinebs ̀ gonivrul eWvs miRma~ standarts, romaseTi mtkicebuleba warmoiqmneba mxolod SeTanxmebuli,sakmarisad Zlieri, aSkara da damajerebel daskvnebiT angaubaTilebeli prezumfciiT (ix. adamianis uflebaTa ev-ropuli sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba saqmeze _ `feodo-rovi moldovis winaaRmdeg~ (Feodorov v. The Republic ofMoldova, N 42434/ 06, 29.01.2014).

8. sakasacio palata, Tavdapirvelad, aRniSnavs, romsrulad iziarebs saapelacio palatis motivacias im mimar-TebiT, rom saqmeze piris fsiqikuri Seracxadobis dasad-genad, aucilebelia Sesabamisi fsiqiatriuli eqspertizisdaskvnis arseboba, romliTac dadgindeba Seracxadoba/Se-uaracxadobis sakiTxi, Tumca sakasacio palata gansakuT-rebul yuradRebas amaxvilebs saqmis Semdeg faqtobrivgaremoebebze:

msjavrdebulma z. s-m danaSaulis Cadenidan _ 2013 wlis17 dekembridan, mokle droSi, kerZod, 2014 wlis 31 ian-vars mimarTa samedicino dawesebulebas, sadac gaiara Se-sabamisi fsiqiatriuli mkurnaloba, ra drosac mas daud-ginda diagnozi _ sxva mwvave da gardamavali fsiqozuriaSliloba F23.8. Jil-de la turetas sindromi F95.2.

dazaralebul n. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom, rode-sac man z. s-s hkiTxa Tu ra undoda, man upasuxa gaurkvev-lad, araadekvaturad, ris gamoc man ZaliT, mxriT gaagdois jixuridan da saswrafod Caketa kari urduliT.

dacvis mxarem ar ganaxorciela msjavrdebulis jero-vani dacva da ar miiRo zomebi z. s-s Seracxadobis dasad-genad. ufro metic, msjavrdebulis mSoblebma, saerToduari ganacxades fsiqiatriuli eqspertizis Catarebaze,xolo gamoZieba ar dainteresebula da ar miuRia raime zoma

45

z.s-s Seracxadobis dasadgenad.saqmis sakasacio sxdomaze ganxilvisas msajvrdebulis

qmedebebi iyo aSkarad araadekvaturi, ramac sakasacio pa-latas Seuqmna damatebiTi eWvi msjavrdebulis Seracxa-dobasTan dakavSirebiT.

9. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 34-e mux-lis 1-li nawilis Sesabamisad `am kodeqsiT gaTvaliswine-buli marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedeba ar Seeracxeba braladimas, visac am qmedebis Cadenis dros qronikuli fsiqiku-ri avadmyofobis, fsiqikis droebiTi aSlilobis, Wkuasus-tobis an sxva fsiqikuri daavadebis gamo ar SeeZlo gaec-nobierebina Tavisi qmedebis faqtobrivi xasiaTi an mar-TlwinaaRmdegoba anda exelmZRvanela misTvis~, xolo sis-xlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 105-e muxlis me-2 na-wilis `b~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, sisxlissamarTlebrividevna ar unda daiwyos, xolo dawyebuli devna unda Sew-ydes, Tu piri danaSaulis Cadenisas Seuracxi iyo, rac da-dasturebuli unda iyos sasamarTlo-fsiqiatriuli eq-spertizis daskvniT.

10. amdenad, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom danaSaulis Ca-denidan maleve, msjavrdebulma mimarTa samedicino da-wesebulebas, sadac mas Cautarda fsiqiatriuli mkurna-loba; dazaralebulis Cvenebis gaTvaliswinebiT, romel-mac ver gaigo ras iTxovda msjavrdebuli da araadekva-turi eCvena igi; araefeqturad ganxorcielebuli dacvis;sakasacio palatis sxdomaze msjavrdebulis aSkarad ara-adekvaturi qmedebebisa da yvela aRniSnuli garemoebe-bis erToblivad mxedvelobaSi miRebiT msjavrdebulisSeracxadobasTan dakavSirebiT, Cndeba realuri eWvi dabundovaneba, romlis gabaTilebisa da aRmofxvris SesaZ-lebloba sakasacio palatas sakasacio ganxilvis etapzekanonismierad ar gaaCnia, vinaidan ar aris uflebamosili,moipovos damatebiTi mtkicebulebebi da daadginos z. s-sSeracxadobis sakiTxi.

11. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom mocemul konkretulSemTxvevaSi, miTiTebuli saqmis faqtobrivi garemoebebi-dan gamomdinare, miuxedavad imisa, rom Catarebuli araris Sesabamisi fsiqiatriuli eqspertiza, eWvi, msjavrde-bul z. s-s SeracxadobasTan dakavSirebiT, unda gadawydesmis sasargeblod msjavrdebulis saukeTeso interesebi-

46

dan gamomdinare.12. yovelive aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasacio

palatas miaCnia, rom z. s. cnobil unda iqnes udanaSaulodda gamarTldes misTvis bralad Seracxul qmedebaSi.

sarezolucio nawili:sakasacio palatam ixelmZRvanela saqarTvelos sis-

xlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 307-e muxlis pirve-li nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT, me-3 nawiliT da

d a a d g i n a :

1. msjavrdebul _ z. s-s interesebis damcvelis, advo-kat T. g-s sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes.

2. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 28 noembris ganaCeni ga-uqmdes.

3. z. s. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 178-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~ qvepun-qtebiT wardgenil braldebaSi.

4. gamarTlebuli z. s. dauyovnebliv gaTavisufldes sa-samarTlo sxdomis darbazidan.

5. z. s-s mimarT Sefardebuli aRkveTis RonisZieba gi-rao gauqmdes. aseve, gauqmdes Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamar-Tlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa kolegiis 2014 wlis 1 ian-vris ganCinebiT Sefardebuli aRkveTis RonisZieba _ gi-raos 4000 (oTxi aTasi) laris uzrunvelsayofad, Tbili-sis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa ko-legiis 2014 wlis 16 ianvris ganCinebiT, d. s-s ojaxis sa-kuTrebaSi arsebul, d-s raionis sofel aSi, m. w-s terito-riaze mdebare sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis miwis nak-veTze _ s/k ... g. s-s ojaxis sakuTrebaSi arsebul, d-s raio-nis sofel a-Si, satraqtoro brigadasTan mdebare sasof-lo-sameurneo daniSnulebis miwis nakveTze _ s/k ..., e. s-sojaxis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli d-s raionis sofel a-Si, k-sTan mdebare sasoflo-sameurneo daniSnulebis miwis nak-veTze _ s/k ... dadebuli yadaRa.

6. saqmeze mtkicebulebad cnobili:• SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis amsaxveli foto-

suraTebi diskis saxiT, romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlis

47

saqmes, Sps `a-dan~ miRebuli videoCanaweri diskis saxiT,romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlis saqmes, dacvis mxarismier warmodgenili fotosuraTebi da diski, romlebic er-Tvis sisxlis samarTlis saqmes, Senaxuli unda iqnes saq-mis Senaxvis vadiT.

• sunis nimuSebi, romlebic inaxeba vake-saburTalosSs sammarTvelos me-5 ganyofilebaSi, saqmeze saboloo ga-dawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda ganadgurdes.

7. gamarTlebul z. s-s ganemartos saqarTvelos sssk-is92-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli zianis anazRaurebis moT-xovnis ufleba.


ganaCenis gauqmeba da sisxlis samarTlis saqmisSewyveta


#19ap-18 21 maisi, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi



zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila saqarTvelos mTavariprokuraturis prokuror leonti adeiSvilisa da msjav-rdebul m. n-is advokatebis _ g. s-sa da c. w-is sakasaciosaCivrebi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 7 noembris ganaCenze;

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 11ianvris

ganaCeniT m. n-i (monawileobis gareSe), _ dabadebuli .....s,nasamarTlobis armqone, _ cnobil iqna udanaSaulod dagamarTlda: saqarTvelos ssk-is 332-e muxlis pirveli na-wiliT, ssk-is 341-e muxliTa da ssk-is 182-e muxlis me-2

48

nawilis `b,~ `g,~ `d~ qvepunqtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswinebul braldebebSi(2000 wlis 5 maisis redaqcia); m. n-is mimarT aRkveTis Ro-nisZiebis saxiT Sefardebuli patimroba gauqmda; ar dak-mayofilda saqarTvelos finansTa saministros samoqala-qo sarCeli mopasuxe m. n-is mier 951 222.5 aSS dolaris ek-vivalentis Tanxis dakisrebisa da 43 980 laris saqarTve-los finansTa saministros sasargeblod anazRaurebis Ta-obaze;

2. sabraldebo daskvnis Tanaxmad, m. n-s bralad edebo-da: moxelis mier samsaxurebrivi uflebamosilebis boro-tad gamoyeneba sajaro samsaxuris moTxovnis sawinaaRmde-god, TavisTvis an sxvisTvis raime gamorCenis an upirate-sobis misaRebad, ramac iuridiuli piris uflebisa da sa-xelmwifos kanonieri interesis arsebiTi darRveva gamo-iwvia (saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 341-e mux-li; 2000 wlis 5 maisis redaqcia); samsaxurebrivi siyalbe,ese igi moxelis mier oficialuri dokumentis gayalbeba,Cadenili angarebiT (saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis ko-deqsis 332-e muxlis 1-li nawili; 2000 wlis 5 maisis redaq-cia) da samsaxurebrivi mdgomareobis gamoyenebiT, pirismarTlzomier gamgeblobaSi myofi, sxvisi moZravi nivTisaraerTgzis, didi odenobiT marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflan-gva, ramac mniSvnelovani ziani gamoiwvia (saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 182-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~`d~ qvepunqtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qve-punqti; 2000 wlis 5 maisis redaqcia), kerZod:

muSaobda sajaro samarTlis iuridiuli piris _ è-is~Tavmjdomared da warmoadgenda moxeles.

2000 wlis 19 ivliss `saxelmwifo qonebiT Seqmnili sa-warmoebis balansze ricxuli ZiriTadi saSualebebis ba-lansidan Camoweris Sesaxeb~ saxelmwifo qonebis marTvissaministros 1998 wlis 11 noembris #... brZanebiT Seqmni-li komisiis 2000 wlis 14 ivlisis sxdomis #... oqmis safuZ-velze, T-Si, sajaro samarTlis iuridiul pirs è-asa~ daf-Si registrirebul SezRuduli pasuxismgeblobis sazo-gadoeba à-s~ Soris 2000 wlis 19 ivliss daido garkveuliiuridiuli Sedegis warmomSobi samarTlebrivi mniSvnelo-bis damadasturebuli #... xelSekruleba. xelSekrulebasssip è-is~ saxeliT xeli moawera misma Tavmjdomarem m. n-

49

ma, xolo Sps à-is~ saxeliT sazogadoebis direqtorma m. m-am. xelSekrulebis Tanaxmad, Sps à.~ kisrulobda valde-bulebas, moexdina SemkveTis _ sajaro samarTlis iuridi-uli piris è-is~ obieqtis demontaJi, kerZod, Sps à-s~ m-is raionis sofel x-is teritoriaze ssip è-is~ filialis`x-is~ balansze ricxuli gamouyenebeli obieqtebis demon-taJi da Savi liTonis gabaritul jarTad miReba. amave xel-SekrulebiT, erTi tona produqciis fasi (demontaJi dajarTis Rirebuleba) ganisazRvra 5 aSS dolaris eqviva-lenti. m. n-ma gamoiyena Tavisi samsaxurebrivi mdgomare-oba borotad, sajaro interesebis sawinaaRmdegod, Tavis-Tvis da sxvisTvis upiratesobis da gamorCenis miRebis miz-niT da gaayalba aRniSnuli xelSekruleba, kerZod, TavisixelmoweriT daamowma iseTi xelSekruleba, romelSic Spsà-s~ warmoadgenda 2000 wlis 4 maiss gardacvlili direq-tori v. m-a. manve xsenebuli xelSekrulebis gaformebisasdaarRvia saqarTvelos sagadasaxado kodeqsis 27-e mux-lis (sabazro fasi) moTxovnebi da xelSekrulebaSi xelov-nurad Semcirebuli fasis miTiTebiT, sajaro samarTlisiuridiuli piris è-is~ interesebis sazianod, neba darToSps à-s~ simbolur fasad, 5 aSS dolaris eqvivalent la-rad mieRo Savi liTonis gabarituli jarTi. sul, 2000 wlis3 agvistodan _ 7 noembramde periodSi, Sps à-ma~ daWra dagaitana 988 tona Savi liTonis jarTi, ris sanacvlodac,Sps à-is~ mier ssip è-is~ sasargeblod anazRaurda mxo-lod 600 tonis Rirebuleba, sul 5910 laris odenobiT,maSin rodesac aRniSnul periodSi erTi tona Savi liTo-nis jarTis sabazro fasi Seadgenda 60 lars. m. n-ma TavisimizanmimarTuli marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebis Sedegad,Savi liTonis jarTis Rirebulebis xelovnurad Semcire-biT, ssip è-as~ miayena 33 580 laris zarali, ramac iuridi-uli pirisa da saxelmwifos kanonieri interesebis arsebi-Ti darRveva gamoiwvia.

1998 wlis 19 ianvars iaponiis s-sa (O…) da saqarTvelosmTavrobis saxeliT _ saqarTvelos finansTa saministrosSoris daido N… sakredito xelSekruleba saqarTvelosmTavrobisaTvis 5,332 miliardi i. ienis kreditis gacemisSesaxeb, romelic iTvaliswinebda saqarTvelos energo-sistemis reabilitaciis proeqtis dafinansebas.

1999 wlis 7 aprils kreditis mimRebs _ saqarTvelos

50

finansTa saministrosa da saxelmwifo kompania `s-as~ So-ris gaformda qvesasesxo xelSekruleba, romlis Sesaba-misad, kreditis mimRebma 1998 wlis 19 ianvris sakreditoxelSekrulebis pirveli cxrilis me-3 nawilis me-3 nawi-liT gansazRvrul `proeqtis aRmasrulebel saagentos~ _s/k `s-as~ gadaasesxa 4.397.000.000 i. ieni, romelic mas undagamoeyenebina mxolod proeqtis gansaxorcieleblad,kerZod, hidroeleqtrosadgurebis ̀ l-sa~ da ̀ x-ze~ aRdge-niTi samuSaoebis Catarebis mizniT. aRniSnuli xelSekru-lebiT è-as,~ rogorc proeqtebis aRmasrulebel saagen-tos, daevala sareabilitacio samuSaoebze zedamxedve-loba da samuSaoTa Sesrulebis mixedviT sakredito re-sursidan gamoyofili Tanxebis gankargva.

saqarTvelos qonebis marTvis saministros 1999 wlis18 noembris #... brZanebiT, imave wlis 6 oqtombers saqar-Tvelos respublikis kanonSi `mewarmeTa Sesaxeb~ cvlile-bebisa da damatebebis Sesabamisad, saxazino sawarmo sa-xelmwifo kompania `s-is~ bazaze dafuZnda saaqcio sazo-gadoeba è-a.~ vinaidan s/s è-a~ warmoadgenda s/k `s-is~ sa-marTalmemkvidres, masve daekisra saqarTvelos finansTasaministrosa da s/k ̀ s-as~ Soris 1998 wlis 7 aprils gafor-mebuli qvesasesxo xelSekrulebiT gansazRvruli ufle-bebis ganxorcieleba da valdebulebebis Sesruleba.

1999 wlis 22 dekembers saqarTvelos qonebis marTvissaministrosa da À...-s~ Soris gaformda menejmentis xel-Sekruleba, romlis Sesabamisad, am ukanasknels marTvisuflebiT gadaeca saqarTvelos energetikis aRdgenis pro-eqtis (…-P1) farglebSi aRsadgeni s/s è-is~ kuTvnili erT-erTi obieqti hidroeleqtrosadguri `x...~.

2000 wlis 18 Tebervals #... weriliT saqarTvelos fi-nansTa saministrom mimarTa `s-s~ (O…/J…), romliTac iT-xovda gamoyofili kreditis mxolod hidroeleqtrosad-gurebis `l-sa~ da `x-is~ reabilitaciisaTvis gamoyenebas,razec imave wlis 27 marts miiRo Tanxmoba.

2000 wlis 22 Tebervals s/s `g-sa~ da s/s è-as~ Soris ga-formda ̀ s-is~ (O…/J…) kreditis sabanko momsaxurebis xel-Sekruleba.

saqarTvelos prezidentis 2000 wlis 29 Tebervlis #...brZanebulebiT, s/s ̀ e-is~ bazaze Seiqmna sajaro samarTlisiuridiuli piri è-a~ da mis Tavmjdomared imave dRes sa-

51

qarTvelos prezidentis #... gankargulebiT dainiSna m. n-i. vinaidan ssip è-a~ warmoadgenda s/s è-is~ samarTalmem-kvidres, masve daekisra saqarTvelos finansTa saminis-trosa da s/k `s-as~ Soris 1998 wlis 7 aprils gaformebuliqvesasesxo xelSekrulebiT gansazRvruli uflebebis gan-xorcieleba da valdebulebebis Sesruleba.

2000 wlis 10 aprils ssip è-is~ Tavmjdomare m. n-ma #...weriliT mimarTa s/s `g-s~, romliTac iTxovda, 1999 wlis17 noembers konsorcium À.~-sTan gaformebuli sakon-traqto xelSekrulebis moTxovnaTa Sesabamisad, angariS-sworebis ganxorcielebis mizniT, akreditivis gaxsnasxelSekrulebis Tanxis _ 1999346639 iaponur ienad Sefa-sebul nawilze. am akreditivis gaxsna gaTvaliswinebuliiyo 1998 wlis 19 ianvars `s-sa~ (O…/J…) da saqarTvelosmTavrobas Soris gaformebuli sakredito xelSekrule-biT (...-P1), 1999 wlis 31 dekembers s/s `g-sa~ da `T-s~ Sorisgaformebuli xelSekrulebiTa da 1998 wlis ivlisis TviT-daTariRebuli `s-is~ (O…/J…) valdebulebis procedure-biT.

ssip è-is~ Tavmjdomaris Tanamdebobaze muSaobis pe-riodSi, m. n-ma ganizraxa mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSiarsebuli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaf-langva da nacvlad imisa, rom 1999 wlis 7 aprilis qvesa-sesxo xelSekrulebis 4.1.4 punqtis Tanaxmad, saqarTve-los finansTa saministros winaSe daeyenebina sakiTxi hid-roeleqtrosadgur `x-is~ dafinansebis nawilSi xelSekru-lebis SeCerebisa da masSi cvlilebebis Setanis Sesaxeb,vinaidan saqarTvelos energetikis aRdgenis proeqtis (...-P1) farglebSi aRsadgeni obieqti hidroeleqtrosadguri`x...~ ukve gadacemuli iyo marTvis uflebiT kerZo mesa-kuTreze _ À-ze~, am obieqtze Catarebuli sareabilita-cio samuSaoebisaTvis gaxarjuli `s-isagan~ (O…/J…) miRe-buli kreditis sabanko momsaxurebis Tanxebis anazRau-rebis mizniT s/s `g-dan~ araerTgzis gamoitana mokleva-diani sesxi (wliuri 36%) 1 056293,38 laris (savaluto kur-siT _ 538 897,70 aSS dolari) odenobiT, romelic Semdgom-Si gatarda (Camoiwera) xarjebSi da ssip è-as~ miadga didiodenobiT ziani, kerZod, 2000 wlis 10 aprils ssip è-is~Tavmjdomarem m. n-ma #... weriliT kvlav mimarTa s/s `g-s,~romliTac iTxovda, 3 Tvis vadiT 400 000 aSS dolaris ode-

52

nobis sesxis gamoyofas. am sesxis gamoyofis miznad igi mi-uTiTebda konsorciumebis À-sa~ da È-is~ sasargeblodgadaxdili akreditivebis momsaxurebis xarjebis anazRa-urebas.

2000 wlis 17 aprils kavSiris (asociacia) `s-s~ Tavdebo-biT, s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaformda sabanko kre-ditis xelSekruleba unaRdo angariSsworebiT 3 Tvis va-diT 400 000 aSS dolaris odenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb,romlis mizani iyo 2000 wlis 22 Tebervals s/s `g-sa~ dassip è-as~ Soris gaformebuli sabanko momsaxureobis ga-dasaxadis anazRaureba. sabanko kreditiT sargeblobisaT-vis msesxebeli ssip è-a~ valdebulebas iRebda: sabankokreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadaxdas, saprocentoganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis dafarvasTan erTadda sesxis dafarvas 2000 wlis 17 ivlisisaTvis, xolo ses-xis dadgenil vadaSi daufaraobis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis_ ssip è-is~ davalianebas daericxeboda wliuri 42%. amxelSekrulebis Sesabamisad, 2000 wlis 30 ivniss ssip è-as~ kreditis saxiT gamoeyo 383 897,70 aSS dolari anu 752477,88 lari, romelic imave dRes bankma mimarTa akredi-tivis momsaxurebisaTvis. 2000 wlis 22 dekembers s/s `g-sa~ da ssip ̀ e-as~ Soris gaformda 2000 wlis 17 aprilis xel-Sekrulebaze #... damateba, romlis Tanaxmad, 400000 aSSdolaris odenobis sabanko kreditis dafarvis vada gag-rZelda 2001 wlis 30 martamde.

s/s `g-Tan~ sabanko kreditis xelSekrulebis gaforme-bidan mxolod 7 dRis Semdeg, e. i 2000 wlis 24 aprils, ssipè-is~ Tavmjdomare m. n-ma #... weriliT mimarTa saqarTve-los finansTa saministros, romliTac iTxovda, 1999 wlis7 aprils gaformebuli qvesasesxo xelSekrulebis moTxov-naTa Sesabamisad, hidroeleqtrosadgurebis `l-sa~ da `x-is~ reabilitaciisaTvis xelmowerili kontraqtebis efeq-turobisa da angariSsworebis ganxorcielebis mizniT, s/s`g-dan~ moklevadiani sesxis aRebaze Tanxmobas.

2000 wlis 25 aprilis #... weriliT saqarTvelos finan-sTa saministrom neba darTo ssip è-as~ bankidan mokleva-diani sesxis aRebaze im pirobiT, rom ssip è-as~ sesxi undadaefara sakuTari SemosavlebiT.

amrigad, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgo-mareobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi ar-

53

sebuli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflan-gva, ssip è-is~ Tavmjdomare m. n-ma, miuxedavad imisa, romhidroeleqtrosadguri `x.~ ukve ar miekuTvneboda ssipè-as~ ar miiRo zomebi 1999 wlis 7 aprils gaformebuliqvesasesxo xelSekrulebis 4.1.4 punqtis moTxovnaTa Se-sabamisad, hidroeleqtrosadgur `x-is~ dafinansebis na-wilSi am xelSekrulebis moqmedebis SesaCereblad da mas-Si cvlilebebis Sesatanad. nacvlad amisa, 2000 wlis 17 ap-rils m. n-ma s/s `g-dan~ gamoitana moklevadiani sesxi 383897,7 aSS dolaris anu 752477,88 laris odenobiT, romli-Tac aanazRaura ̀ A.~-is marTvaSi arsebuli hidroeleqtro-sadguri `x-ze~ gaxarjuli kreditis sabanko momsaxure-bis Tanxa. SemdgomSi, hidroeleqtrosadgur `x-ze~ gaxar-juli kreditis sabanko momsaxurebis es Tanxa, kanonismoTxovnaTa darRveviT, gatarda (Camoiwera) xarjebSi, ri-Tac saxelmwifos miadga didi odenobiT _ 658 116 aSS do-laris (ZiriTadi Tanxa _ 375 188 aSS dolari da 2007 wlismdgomareobiT procentis Tanxa _ 282 928 aSS dolari) zia-ni.

m. n-i agrZelebda mizanmimarTul danaSaulebriv qme-debas mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arsebuli ssip è-is~kuTvnili qonebis gaflangvis ganzraxviT da 2000 wlis 17aprils kvlav kavSiris (asociacia) `s.~ TavdebobiT, s/s `g-Tan~ gaaforma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba unaRdo an-gariSsworebiT 3 Tvis vadiT 155 000 aSS dolaris odeno-bis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo konsorciumÀ-saTvis~ Casatarebeli sareabilitacio samuSaoebis Ri-rebulebis winaswari anazRaureba. sabanko kreditiT sar-geblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebulebas iReb-da: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadaxdas,saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis dafar-vasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2000 wlis 17 ivlisisaT-vis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi ardafarvis SemTxveva-Si msesxeblis _ ssip ̀ e-is~ davalianebas daericxeboda wli-uri 42%. am xelSekrulebis Sesabamisad, s/s `g-kma~ ssip è-as~ kreditis saxiT gamouyo 155 000 aSS dolari anu im pe-riodisaTvis arsebuli kursiT (1 aSS dolari _ 1,9601 la-ri) 303 815,5 lari, romelic imave dRes miemarTa daniSnu-lebisamebr. 2000 wlis 22 dekembers s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~Soris gaformda 2000 wlis 17 aprilis xelSekrulebaze #...

54

damateba, romlis Tanaxmad, 155000 aSS dolaris odenobissabanko kreditis dafarvis vada gagrZelda 2001 wlis 30martamde.

s/s `g-Tan~ sabanko kreditis xelSekrulebis gaforme-bidan mxolod 7 dRis Semdeg, e. i 2000 wlis 24 aprils ssipè-is~ Tavmjdomare m. n-ma #... weriliT mimarTa saqarTve-los finansTa saministros, romliTac iTxovda, 1999 wlis7 aprils gaformebuli qvesasesxo xelSekrulebis moTxov-naTa Sesabamisad hidroeleqtrosadgurebis `l-sa~ da `x-s~ reabilitaciisaTvis xelmowerili kontraqtebis efeq-turobisa da angariSsworebis ganxorcielebis mizniT, s/s`g-dan~ moklevadiani sesxis aRebaze Tanxmobas.

2000 wlis 25 aprilis #... weriliT saqarTvelos finan-sTa saministrom neba darTo ssip è-as~ bankidan mokleva-diani sesxis aRebaze im pirobiT, rom ssip è-as~ sesxi undadaefara sakuTari SemosavlebiT.

amrigad, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgo-mareobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi ar-sebuli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflan-gva, ssip è-is~ Tavmjdomare m. n-ma, miuxedavad imisa, romhidroeleqtrosadguri `x.~ ukve aRar miekuTvneboda ssipè-as,~ ar miiRo zomebi 1999 wlis 7 aprils qvesasesxo xel-Sekrulebis 4.1.4 punqtis moTxovnaTa Sesabamisad hidro-eleqtrosadgur `x-s~ dafinansebis nawilSi am xelSekru-lebis moqmedebis SesaCereblad da xelSekrulebaSi cvli-lebebis Sesatanad. nacvlad amisa, 2000 wlis 17 aprils m.n-ma s/s `g-dan~ gamoitana moklevadiani sesxi 303815,50 la-ris (savaluto kursiT _ 155 000 aSS dolari) odenobiT,romliTac winaswar aanazRaura À-is~ marTvaSi arsebulihidroeleqtrosadgur `x-ze~ Casatarebeli sareabilita-cio samuSaoebis Rirebuleba. SemdgomSi, hidroeleqtro-sadgur `x-ze~ gaxarjuli kreditis sabanko momsaxurebises Tanxa, kanonis moTxovnaTa darRveviT, gatarda (Camoi-wera) xarjebSi, riTac saxelmwifos miadga didi odeno-biT _ 255 238 aSS dolaris (ZiriTadi Tanxa _ 155 000 aSSdolari da 2007 wlis 1 Tebervlis mdgomareobiT procen-tis Tanxa _ 100 238 aSS dolari) ziani.

manve, 2000 wlis 10 ivliss s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Sorisgaaforma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 44 000 aSS do-laris odenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo

55

`s-Tvis~ (FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba. sabanko kre-ditiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2000 wlis 30seqtembrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufara-obis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis ssip è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa, rom aRniS-nuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procenti daefaraè-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadi Tanxa _ 44000 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganakve-Ti _ 7 951,00 aSS dolari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT,riTac saxelmwifos miayena didi odenobiT, sul _ 7 951,00aSS dolari.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2000 wlis 3 noembers s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaafor-ma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 43 007 aSS dolarisodenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo `s-Tvis~ (FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis. msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2000 wlis 3dekembrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufarao-bis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 43 007 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli saprocen-to ganakveTi _ 1686,00 aSS dolari dafara i-i _ kreditisTanxebiT, riTac saxelmwifos miayena 1686,00 aSS dolarisziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 10 ianvars s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaafor-ma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 43200 aSS dolaris ode-nobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo `s-Tvis~

56

(FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba sabanko kreditiT sar-geblobisaTvis. msesxebeli _ ssip ̀ e-a~ valdebulebas iReb-da: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadaxdas,saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis dafar-vasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 10 Tebervli-saTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufaraobis Sem-TxvevaSi msesxeblis ssip è-is~ davalianebas daericxebo-da wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi, m. n-ma nacvlad imisa, rom aR-niSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procenti daefa-ra è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadi Tanxa43200 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganak-veTi _ 2374,75 aSS dolari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT,riTac saxelmwifos miayena 2374,75 aSS dolaris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 14 maiss s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaaformasabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 43206,51 aSS dolarisodenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo `s-Tvis~ (FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis. msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 14ivnisisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufaraobisSemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas daeric-xeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa, romaRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procenti dae-fara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadi Tan-xa _ 43206,51 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli saprocentoganakveTi _ 2541,00 aSS dolari dafara i-i _ kreditis Tan-xebiT, riTac saxelmwifos miayena 2541,00 aSS dolaris zi-ani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 11 ivliss s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaaformasabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 81 377 laris odenobissesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo Sps à-saTvis~momsaxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba. sabanko kreditiT

57

sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebulebasiRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadax-das, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis da-farvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 10 agvis-tosaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufaraobis Sem-TxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-s~ davalianebas daericxe-boda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa, romaRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procenti dae-fara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadi Tan-xa _ 81377 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganakve-Ti _ 1686,00 lari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTacsaxelmwifos miayena 1686,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 11 ivliss s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaaformasabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 43007,76 aSS dolarisodenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo `s-Tvis~ (FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba. sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 11agvistosaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufarao-bis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 43007,76 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli sapro-cento ganakveTi _ 1928,00 aSS dolari dafara i-i kredi-tis TanxebiT, riTac saxelmwifos miayena 1928,00 aSS do-laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 28 agvistos s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaa-forma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 51343 laris ode-nobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo Sps à-saT-vis~ momsaxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba. sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebu-

58

lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 28seqtembrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufara-obis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-s~ davalianebas da-ericxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 51343 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganak-veTi _ 962,00 lari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTacsaxelmwifos miayena 962,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 29 agvistos s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaa-forma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 37900 laris ode-nobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo Sps à-saT-vis~ momsaxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba. sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 29setembrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufarao-bis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis ssip _ è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 37900 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganak-veTi _ 710,00 lari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTacsaxelmwifos miayena 710,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 8 oqtombers s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaa-forma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 39260 laris ode-nobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo Sps à-saT-vis~ momsaxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba. sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli ssip è-a~ valdebule-bas iRebda sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is ga-daxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis

59

dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 8 oq-tombrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufarao-bis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxis 39260 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganak-veTi _ 1123,00 lari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTacsaxelmwifos miayena 1123,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 8 oqtombers s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaa-forma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 43007,76 aSS do-laris odenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo`s-Tvis~ (FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba. sabanko kre-ditiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valde-bulebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 5noembrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufarao-bis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 43007,76 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli sapro-cento ganakveTi 2173,00 aSS dolari dafara i-i kreditisTanxebiT, riTac saxelmwifos miayena 2173,00 aSS dolarisziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 13 noembers s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaa-forma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 52061 laris ode-nobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo Sps à-saT-vis~ momsaxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba _ sabanko kre-ditiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2001 wlis 13

60

dekembrisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufarao-bis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis ssip _ è-is~ davalianebas dae-ricxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m.n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 52061 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganak-veTi _ 1232,00 lari dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTacsaxelmwifos miayena 1232,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2001 wlis 29 dekembers s/s `...-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaa-forma sabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 270562,00 larisodenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo ̀ ...-Tan~momsaxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba. sabanko kreditiTsargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebulebasiRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadax-das, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis da-farvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2002 wlis 29 ianvri-saTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufaraobis Sem-TxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas daericxe-boda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa, romaRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procenti dae-fara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadi Tan-xa _ 270562 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganakve-Ti _ 4537,00 laris dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTacsaxelmwifos miayena 4537,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2002 wlis 9 ianvars s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaaformasabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 8932 laris odenobis ses-xis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo Sps à-saTvis~ mom-saxureobis xarjebis anazRaureba. sabanko kreditiT sar-geblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebulebas iReb-da: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-is gadaxdas,saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi valis dafar-vasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2002 wlis 9 Tebervli-saTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufaraobis Sem-TxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas daericxe-

61

boda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m.n-ma, nacvlad imisa, rom aR-niSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procenti daefa-ra è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadi Tanxa _8932 lari da masze daricxuli saprocento ganakveTi _150,00 laris dafara i-i kreditis TanxebiT, riTac saxel-mwifos miayena 150,00 laris ziani.

manve, ganzraxuli hqonda ra samsaxurebrivi mdgoma-reobis gamoyenebiT mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arse-buli saxelmwifo qonebis marTlsawinaaRmdego gaflangva,2002 wlis 9 ianvars s/s `g-sa~ da ssip è-as~ Soris gaaformasabanko kreditis xelSekruleba 43007,76 aSS dolarisodenobis sesxis gacemis Sesaxeb, romlis mizani iyo `s-Tvis~ (FEPPIA) momsaxurebis anazRaureba. sabanko kredi-tiT sargeblobisaTvis msesxebeli _ ssip è-a~ valdebu-lebas iRebda: sabanko kreditis odenobis wliuri 36%-isgadaxdas, saprocento ganakveTis gadaxdas ZiriTadi va-lis dafarvasTan erTad da sesxis dafarvas 2002 wlis 9TebervlisaTvis, xolo sesxis dadgenil vadaSi daufara-obis SemTxvevaSi msesxeblis _ ssip è-is~ davalianebas da-ericxeboda wliuri 42%. SemdgomSi m. n-ma, nacvlad imisa,rom aRniSnuli krediti da sesxis sargeblobis procentidaefara è-is~ SemosavlebiT, miRebuli sesxis ZiriTadiTanxa _ 43007,76 aSS dolari da masze daricxuli sapro-cento ganakveTi _ 1584,00 aSS dolaris dafara i-i kredi-tis TanxebiT, riTac saxelmwifos miayena 1584,00 aSS do-laris ziani.

2000 wlis 28 ianvars è-asa~ da konsorcium E… Sorissakonsultacio momsaxurebaze gaformda G… kontraqti,romlis Tanaxmadac, konsorciums daevala `x-is~ da `l-s~hidroeleqtrosadgurebis reabilitaciis procesSi è-isaTvis~ sainJinro konsultaciis gaweva. kontraqti sxvavaldebulebebTan erTad, iTvaliswinebda proeqtis aR-masrulebeli rgolis (PIU) inJinrebis treningis xarjebs.kerZod, 2003 wlis 21 ivnisamde moqmedebis vadiT gafor-mebul kontraqtSi procesis aRmasrulebeli rgolis (PIU)6 inJinris treningis xarjebisaTvis gaTvaliswinebuli iyo36.000 aSS dolari.

sajaro samarTlis iuridiuli piris è-is~ Tavmjdoma-red muSaobis periodSi m. n-ma gamoiyena Tavisi samsaxu-rebrivi mdgomareoba da 2001 wlis seqtemberSi i-Si tre-

62

ningebze, nacvlad imisa, rom mievlinebina mxolod pro-eqtis aRmasrulebeli rgolis (PIU) inJinrebi, rogorc amasiTvaliswinebda E...-sTan dadebuli kontraqti, am kontraq-tis darRveviT, treningze misavlinebel pirTa siaSi Se-iyvana iseTi pirebi, romlebic saerTod ar iricxebodnenè-is~ saStato ganrigSi da samsaxurebrivad ar evalebo-daT treningze gamgzavreba. kerZod, i-Si gamgzavrebulpirTa siaSi moxvdnen m.n-is axlo naTesavebi: misi meuRlei. q., simamri a. q., TviTon m. n-i, misi moadgile g. C. da `s-os~(FEPPIA) generaluri direqtori m. n., m. n-ma isargebla imiT,rom Tavisi samsaxurebrivi mdgomareobiT SeeZlo, ganekar-ga mis marTlzomier gamgeblobaSi arsebuli saqarTvelosmTavrobisaTvis gamoyofili sakredito resursebi, im pi-rebs, romlebic ar iricxebodnen è-is~ saStato ganrigSi,sakredito resursis Tanxebidan usafuZvlod aunazRau-ra i-Si maTi yofnis xarjebi, sul _ 17 630,75 aSS dolari,riTac marTlsawinaaRmdegod gaflanga sxvisi, didi ode-nobiT moZravi nivTis, ramac saxelmwifosTvis mniSvnelo-vani ziani gamoiwvia.

amdenad, sabraldebo daskvnis mixedviT, ssip è-is~ Tav-mjdomaris Tanamdebobaze muSaobis periodSi m. n-is mi-zanmimarTuli marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebebis SedegadaraerTgzis gaiflanga didi odenobiT _ 951 222,5 aSS do-larisa da 43 980 laris saxelmwifo qoneba, ramac mniSvne-lovani ziani gamoiwvia.

3. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres saqarTvelosmTavari prokuraturis sagamoZiebo nawilis saprokuro-ro zedamxedvelobis sammarTvelos prokurorebma _ le-onti adeiSvilma da zaza suxiSvilma, romlebmac iTxovesgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da m. n-is wardgenilbraldebebSi damnaSaved cnoba; saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-marTlis kodeqsis 341-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli dana-Saulis CadenisaTvis 1 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis da-niSvna, àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis me-16 mux-lis Sesabamisad misi 1/4-iT Semcireba da 8 TviT Tavisuf-lebis aRkveTis daniSvna; saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis 332-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT gaTvaliswinebu-li danaSaulis CadenisaTvis 2 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkve-Tis daniSvna, àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis me-16 muxlis Sesabamisad, misi 1/4-iT Semcireba da 1 wliTa da

63

4 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis daniSvna; saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 182-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~da `d~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Cade-nisaTvis 4 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis daniSvna, `amnis-tiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis me-12 muxlis Sesabami-sad, misi ganaxevreba da 2 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTisdaniSvna; ssk-is 182-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiTgaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis 10 wliT Ta-visuflebis aRkveTis daniSvna, `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqar-Tvelos kanonis me-12 muxlis Sesabamisad, misi ganaxevre-ba da 5 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis daniSvna; saqarTve-los ssk-is 59-e muxlis Sesabamisad sabolood 5 wliT Ta-visuflebis aRkveTis daniSvna; agreTve saqarTvelos fi-nansTa saministros samoqalaqo sarCelis dakmayofilebada mopasuxe m. n-isaTvis 951 222.5 aSS dolaris ekvivlentilarisa da 43. 980 laris anazRaureba saqarTvelos fina-nasTa saministros sasargeblod.

4. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 7 noembris ganaCeniT pro-kurorebis _ leonti adeiSvilisa da zaza suxiSvilis saa-pelacio saCivris moTxovna dakmayofilda nawilobriv.Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saq-meTa kolegiis 2017 wlis 11 ianvris ganaCeni gauqmda:

m. n-i cnobil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda:saqarTvelos ssk-is 182-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~,

`d~ qvepunqtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qve-punqtiT wardgenil braldebaSi (2000 wlis 5 maisis redaq-cia);

m. n-is mimarT wardgenili braldeba, gaTvaliswinebu-li saqarTvelos ssk-is 332-e muxlis pirveli nawiliTa dassk-is 341-e muxliT, gadakvalificirda ssk-is 342-e mux-lis pirvel nawilze (2000 wlis 5 maisi redaqcia);

m. n-i cnobil iqna damnaSaved ssk-is 342-e muxlis pir-veli nawiliT da sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvrajarima _ 50 000 lari; ssk-is 28-e muxlis me-6 nawilis sa-fuZvelze, xandazmulobis vadis gasvlis gamo, m. n-i sas-jelis moxdisagan gaTavisuflda.

samoqalaqo sarCeli darCa ganuxilvelad.5. kasatori _ saqarTvelos mTavari prokuraturis sa-

gamoZiebo nawilis saprokuroro zedamxedvelobis sammar-

64

Tvelos prokurori leonti adeiSvili iTxovs Tbilisissaqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa kole-giis ganaCenSi (garda ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirveli nawili-sa) cvlilebis Setanas, kerZod: saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-marTlis kodeqsis 182-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b,~ `g~ da `d~qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaT-vis 4 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis daniSvnas, àmnistiisSesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis me-12 muxlis Sesabamisad,mis ganaxevrebasa da 2 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis da-niSvnas; ssk-is 182-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiTgaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis 10 wliT Ta-visuflebis aRkveTis daniSvnas, àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqar-Tvelos kanonis me-12 muxlis Sesabamisad, mis ganaxevre-basa da 5 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis daniSvnas; saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis Sesabamisad sabolood 5 wliTTavisuflebis aRkveTis daniSvnas; agreTve saqarTvelosfinansTa saministros samoqalaqo sarCelis dakmayofile-basa da mopasuxe m. n-isaTvis 951 222.5 aSS dolaris eqviva-lenti larisa da 43. 980 laris anazRaurebas saqarTvelosfinanasTa saministros sasargeblod.

6. prokuroris poziciiT, m.. n-i valdebuli iyo, fina-nasTa saministros winaSe `x-is~ dafinansebis nawilSi xel-Sekrulebis SeCerebis sakiTxi daesva. is, rom axali kerZosubieqtis Semosvlam namdvilad safrTxe Seuqmna proeq-tis ganxorcielebas, dadasturebulia Tavad m. n-is weri-lebiT. aRsaniSnavia, rom ssip è-as~ saqarTvelos finanas-Ta saministrosagan ar miuRia Tanxmoba imis Sesaxeb, romaxali kreditiT sargeblobis saprocento Tanxebi daefa-ra i-i kreditiT, rac mainc ganxorcielda TviTneburadda dairRva `sajaro samarTlis iuridiuli piris Sesaxeb~saqarTvelos kanonis me-12 muxlisa da 1999 wlis 7 apri-lis qvesasesxo xelSekrulebis moTxovnebi. m. n-is gan-zraxvasTan mimarTebiT sasamarTlos mtkicebulebebi un-da Seefasebina Sinagani rwmeniT.

7. i-Si gamarTul treningTan dakavSirebiT, kasatoriaRniSnavs, rom treningze mivlinebuli pirebi è-is~ saS-tato siaSi ar iricxebodnen. es pirebi iyvnen m. n-is axlonaTesavebi, magaliTad, meuRle da simamri. kontraqtiTki gaTvaliswinebuli iyo mxolod PIU-s inJinrebis trenin-gi. vizebis uzrunvelyofas, bunebrivia, rom i-is mxare mo-

65

agvarebda, magram finansebs qarTuli mxare anazRaureb-da. marTalia, finansTa saministro akontrolebda miznob-riobas, magram Zneli warmosadgeni iyo, mas Seemowmebinatreningze inJinrebis nacvlad meuRlisa da simamris way-vanis faqti. saqmeSi arsebuli sertifikatebi ar SeiZlebam. n-is udanaSaulobis damadasturebel mtkicebulebad Ca-iTvalos.

8. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebul m. n-is interesebis dam-cveli advokatebi _ g. s. da c. w-i iTxoven Tbilisis saape-lacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis2017 wlis 7 noembris ganaCenis Secvlas m. n-is sasargeb-lod, kerZod, saqarTvelos ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirvelinawiliT gaTvaliswinebul msjavrdebaSi mis gamarTlebas.

9. advokatebis miTiTebiT, saqarTvelos ssk-is 332-emuxlis pirveli nawili da 341-e muxli sasamarTlom gada-akvalificira, ris gamoc m. n-s, faqtobrivad, axali bral-deba warudgina. m. n-is qmedebebSi gulgrilobis niSnebisarseboba saqmis masalebiT dadasturebuli ar aris.

10. saCivris avtorebi aRniSnaven, rom sarealizaciojarTis Rirebuleba gansazRvra 2000 wlis 28 ivlisis ko-misiis sxdomam. #... xelSekruleba daido 2000 wlis 14 iv-lisis komisiis sxdomis #... oqmis safuZvelze; m. n-ma, ro-gorc e-is Tavmjdomarem, yvelaferi gaakeTa imisaTvis,rom sofel j-is gamgeblis mier wamoWrili problema kano-nis farglebSi mogvarebuliyo. sasamarTlo mowme l. c-asCvenebas argumentad iyenebs msjavrdebis dasabuTebis na-wilSi, xolo sxva nawilSi mis Cvenebas ar iziarebs. l. c-aganmartavs, rom m. n-ma ar icoda xelSekrulebis dadebisdros Sps `a-is~ direqtoris gardacvalebis faqti.

11. m. n-i valdebuli ar iyo, notariusis msgavsad, See-mowmebina xelSekrulebis meore mxaris warmomadgenlisqmedunarianoba. utyuarad arc is dadasturebula, romxelSekrulebas xeli uSualod m. n-Tan moewera. amasTan,mis qmedebas ar gamouwvevia ziani, piriqiT _ `x-is~ balan-sze arsebuli im obieqtebis demontaJi moxda, romlebicmudmivad iZarcveboda.


ma sakasacio saCivrebis motivebis safuZvlianoba da mivi-

66

da im daskvnamde, rom dacvis mxaris sakasacio saCivariunda dakmayofildes, xolo braldebis mxaris sakasaciosaCivari ar unda dakmayofildes.

2. sakasacio palata iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlosgadawyvetilebas m. n-is ssk-is 182-e muxlis me-2 nawilis`b~, `g~, `d~ qvepunqtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~qvepunqtiT wardgenil braldebebSi gamarTlebis Taoba-ze da eTanxmeba palatis daskvnas, rom am nawilSi bralde-bis mxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebiT (maT So-ris: mowmeebis _ g. W-is, v. T-as, T. m-is, d. m-as, l. j-isa da m.n-s CvenebebiT, 1999 wlis 7 aprilis qvesasesxo xelSekru-lebiT, ssip è-is~ debulebiT, ssip è-is~ Tavmjdomaris _m. n-is werilebiT, ss `g-Tan~ ssip è-is~ sabanko kreditisxelSekrulebebiT, konsultantTa samuSaoebis me-6 da me-9 ganaxlebebiT) ar dasturdeba m. n-is mier zemoaRniSnuldanaSaulTa Cadenis faqti.

3. Sesabamisad, saapelacio sasamarTlos detaluri daargumentirebuli msjeloba hidroeleqtrosadgur `x-is~dafinansebis nawilSi xelSekrulebis SeCerebis, g-danaRebuli sesxebis 1998 wlis 19 ianvris sakredito xelSek-rulebiT gamoyofili Tanxebidan dafarvisa da i-is tre-ningis epizodTan dakavSirebul sakiTxebze sakasacio pa-latis mier srulad iqna gaziarebuli.

4. rac Seexeba samsaxurebrivi siyalbis braldebis epi-zods, saapelacio sasamarTlom aRniSnuli qmedeba Seafa-sa, rogorc samsaxurebrivi gulgriloba da saqarTvelosssk-is 341-e muxliT wardgenili braldeba gadaakvalifi-cira ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirvel nawilze.

5. saapelacio palatis miTiTebiT, m. n-ma samsaxurebri-vi movaleoba arajerovnad Seasrula, vinaidan xelSekru-lebis xelmomweri meore mxare (Sps à-is~ direqtori) xel-Sekrulebis dadebis dros iyo gardacvlili, rac man arSeamowma. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba saapelacio sa-samarTlos aRniSnul samarTlebriv Sefasebas da miaCnia,rom ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT msjavrdebis epi-zodSi ganaCeni unda gauqmdes da saqme Sewydes, vinaidansasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvisas, braldebis mxarem verwarmoadgina utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebic daadas-turebda m. n-is mier samsaxurebrivi gulgrilobis Cade-nis faqts, kerZod:

67

6. mowme g. m-as ganmartebis Tanaxmad, Tavis Zmas m. er-qva, Tumca, pasportSi v. ewera. mowmem #... xelSekruleba-ze arsebuli xelmoweris misi Zmisadmi kuTvnileba uaryo,vinaidan igi iyo gansxvavebuli da ar Seesabameboda rea-lurs. amasTan, man ganmarta, rom, Zmis xelmowera araer-Txel aqvs nanaxi, magaliTad, rodesac m-Tan pensia mihqon-daT xolme.

7. gardacvalebis aqtis Canaweris Tanaxmad, v. a-is Ze m-as gardacvalebis TariRad miTiTebulia 2000 wlis 4 maisi.

8. mowme l. c-am, romelic muSaobda e-is iuridiuli sam-saxuris ufrosis Tanamdebobaze, sasamarTlo sxdomaze ga-nacxada, rom #... xelSekrulebis proeqti man m. n-is dava-lebiT moamzada. m. n-i xelSekrulebis gasaformeblad pi-radobis mowmobas ar iTxovda da imdroindeli xelSekru-lebis SablonebSi piradi nomeri arc iwereboda. mowmisCvenebiT, e-aSi im periodSi Sps à-is~ warmomadgenlebi da-diodnen, magram maT piradad ar icnobda.

9. 2000 wlis 19 ivliss gaaformebuli #... xelSekrule-bis Tanaxmad, ssip è-as~ Tavmjdomaris saxiT warmoadgensm. n-i (`SemkveTi~), xolo Sps à-s~ _ direqtori m. m-a (`Sem-srulebeli~); Sps à-ma~ ikisra valdebuleba, moexdina Sem-kveTis obieqtis demontaJi, Savi liTonis gabaritul jar-Tad (`produqcia~) miReba da masSi xelSekrulebiT gansaz-Rvruli Tanxis gadaxda.

10. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom 2000 wlis 19 ivli-sis #... xelSekrulebaSi saidentifikacio nomris grafa mi-TiTebuli ar aris, rac SesabamisobaSia mowme l. c-as Cve-nebasTn, romlis Tanaxmdac, imdroindeli xelSekrule-bis SablonebSi piradi nomeri ar iwereboda. sakasacio pa-lata yuradRebas miaqcevs l. c-as Cvenebis im nawilsac,sadac igi aRniSnavs, rom è-aSi~ im periodSi Sps à-is~ war-momadgenlebi dadiodnen. amdenad, m. n-isa da Sps ̀ a-is~ war-momadgenlebs Soris urTierToba ar iyo erTjeradi, racgamoricxavs xelSekrulebis meore mxaris pirovnebis re-alurobaSi undoblobis an daeWvebis safuZvels. miTume-tes, Sps à-is~ warmomadgenelma xelSekruleba daamowmaTavisi kompaniis beWdiTac, kerZod, #... xelSekrulebaSiaRniSnul beWedze ikiTxeba warwera _ Sps à.~ qarTuli dalaTinuri asoebiT. Sesabamisad, ar arsebobs garemoeba, risgamoc, m. n-s eWvi unda Seetana xelSekrulebis meore mxa-

68

ris pirovnebaSi da Seemowmebina xelSekrulebis gafor-mebis dros direqtoris gardacvalebis faqti.

11. qmedebis saqarTvelos ssk-is 342-e muxliT kvali-fikaciisaTvis samsaxurebrivi gulgriloba (gansxvavebiTssk-is 341-e muxlis Semadgenlobisgan), savaldebuloa iw-vevdes fizikuri an iuridiuli piris uflebis, sazogado-ebis an saxelmwifos kanonieri interesis arsebiT darRve-vas. braldebis am epizodSi saapelacio sasamarTlom ka-nonieri interesis arsebiT darRvevad miuTiTa: Sesabami-si pirebis mxridan `x-is~ balansze arsebuli obieqtebisdemontaJis, jarTis gatanis, xolo SemdgomSi _ `r-is~ fir-mis danadgaris aramiTiTebisamebr gamoyenebis faqtebze.

12. am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT, sakasacio palata izia-rebs dacvis mxaris versias, rom x-is teritoriaze ganTav-sebuli mowyobilobebis siZvelisa da saSiSi kriminogenu-ri viTarebis gamo, aucilebeli iyo maTi im teritoriidangatana, kerZod, `e-is~ direqtoris _ v. g-is mier `x-is di-reqciis~ direqtoris m. a-is (aslis saxiT walenjixis raio-nis j-is filialis policiis ufross) saxelze 2000 wlis 2ivniss Sedgenili weriliT dasturdeba gaxSirebuli qur-dobisa da saxelmwifo qonebis datacebis faqtebi. weri-liT v. g-e `x-is~ kuTvnili ZiriTadi saSualebebis, kerZod,amerikuli warmoebis betonCamwyobi meqanizmidan (`r-i~)darCenili mowyobilobis, meqanikuri saamqros teritori-idan gatanas iTxovs da amavdroulad, ixsnis pasuxismgeb-lobas misi SenaxvisaTvis. is, rom mSenebare x-is direqci-is balansze ricxuli mowyobiloba-danadgarebi, maTi moZ-velebisa da gaxSirebuli Zarcvis gamo, wlebis ganmavlo-baSi namdvilad saWiroebda adgilidan gatanas, dastur-deba sisxlis samarTlis saqmeSi warmodgenili sxva araer-Ti mtkicebulebiT, maT Soris: mowmeebis _ m. a-is (x-is di-reqciis direqtori) sasamarTlo sxdomaze sajarod wakiT-xuli da d. m-as sasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuli Cvenebebi-Ta da saqarTvelos saTbob-energetikis ministris _ d. m-as 2000 wlis 5 aprils gamocemuli #... brZanebiT.

13. Tu saapelacio palata am ori garemoebis miTiTebi-sas (Sesabamisi pirebis mxridan `x-is~ balansze arsebuliobieqtebis demontaJi da jarTis gatana), saxelmwifosaT-vis materialuri zianis miyenebas gulisxmobs, aq gasaTva-liwinebelia, rom sabraldebo daskvnis mixedviT m. n-ma

69

ssip è-as~ zarali (33 580 lari) miayena `Savi liTonis jar-Tis Rirebulebis xelovnuri SemcirebiT~ da ara iseTi xel-Sekrulebis damowmebiT, romelSic Sps à-s~ 2000 wlis 4maiss gardacvlili piri v. m-a warmoadgenda. amdenad, ze-moaRniSnuli masalebis analiziT ar dasturdeba _ `x-is~balansze arsebuli obieqtebis demontaJiTa da jarTis ga-taniT saxelmwifos kanonieri interesis darRvevis faq-ti.

14. rac Seexeba saapelacio sasamarTlos mier kanonie-ri interesis arsebiT darRvevad agreTve `r-is~ firmis da-nadgaris aramiTiTebisamebr gamoyenebulad miCnevis sa-kiTxs, am nawilSi sakasacio palata aseve eTanxmeba dacvismxaris pozicias da aRniSnavs, rom sabraldebo daskvna armoicavs mocemuli qmedebis samarTlebriv aRweras.

15. amdenad, saqmeSi arsebuli masalebiT ar dasturde-ba, rom m. n-is mier samsaxurebrivi movaleobis arajerov-nad Sesrulebam (misdami daudevari damokidebulebis ga-mo) fizikuri an iuridiuli piris uflebis, sazogadoebisan saxelmwifos kanonieri interesis arsebiTi darRvevagamoiwvia.

16. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom m. n-s bralad ag-reTve edeboda samsaxurebrivi uflebamosilebis boro-tad gamoyeneba. saapelacio sasamarTlom aRniSnuli bral-debisa (ssk-is 332-e muxlis pirveli nawili) da zemomiTi-Tebuli _ samsaxurebrivi siyalbis epizodi (ssk-is 341-emuxli) Seafasa erT qmedebad _ samsaxurebriv gulgrilo-bad. amdenad, wardgenili braldeba gaTvaliswinebuli ssk-is 332-e muxlis pirveli nawiliTa da ssk-is 341-e muxliTgadakvalificirda ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirvel nawilze.saapelacio sasamarTlos motivaciiT, kvalifikaciis Sec-vla ganapiroba im garemoebam, rom m. n-ma, Sps à-saTvis~ 5aSS dolaris ekvivalent larad Savi liTonis gabaritulijarTis miRebaze nebis darTviT, daarRvia saqarTvelossagadasaxado kodeqsis 27-e muxlis (sabazro fasi) moT-xovnebi, kerZod, mas ekisreboda valdebuleba, sabazrofasis dadgenis Semdeg ganesazRvra konkretuli fasi, racdadasturebuli iqneboda Sesabamisi dokumentiT. sakasa-cio palata ar eTanxmeba am motivacias Semdeg garemoeba-Ta gamo:

17. 2000 wlis 19 ivliss gaformebuli #... xelSekrule-

70

biT erTi tona produqciis fasad ganisazRvra 5 aSS dola-ris ekvivalenti lari. aRsaniSnavia, rom xelSekrulebisgaformebis safuZvels warmoadgenda 2000 wlis 14 ivliss`saxelmwifo qonebiT Seqmnili sawarmoebis balansze ric-xuli gamouyenebeli ZiriTadi saSualebebis balansidan Ca-moweris Sesaxeb~ saministros 11.11.1998 wlis #... brZane-biT Seqmnili komisiis #... sxdomis oqmi, romlis mixedvi-Tac, komisia iZulebuli iyo, ssip è-is~ `mSenebare x-is di-reqciis~ balansidan gamouyenebeli ZiriTadi saSualebe-bis Camowerasa da likvidacias dasTanxmeboda.

18. zugdidis regionuli savaWro-samrewvelo palatis2004 wlis 22 dekembris, eqspert d. b-as mier Sedgenili#... eqspertizis daskvnis Tanaxmad, 2000 wlis ivlis-ag-vistos mdgomareobiT, z-Si, ganxiluli xarisxis erTi to-na Savi liTonis jarTis Rirebuleba Seadgens 60 lars. xel-SekrulebiT miRebuli 5 aSS dolaris ekvivalentia 5 X 1.97= 9.85 lari. 1 tona Savi liTonis jarTis TviTRirebuleba(daba j-dan z-mde transportirebiT datvirTva _ Camot-virTvaze gaweuli xarjebisa da xelSekrulebiT gaTvalis-winebuli Tanxis gamoklebiT) Seadgens _ 36.84 lars. sul988 tona ganxiluli saxis Savi liTonis jarTis Rirebu-lebam Seadgina imave periodisaTvis _ 988 x 36.84 = 36 400lari; xolo fasTa sxvaoba realur Rirebulebasa da è-is~mier miRebul Tanxas Soris Seadgens: 36 400 _ 2816 = 33 580lars.

19. saqmis masalebis mixedviT, ar dasturdeba, rom m. n-ma fasis gansazRvris dros imoqmeda erTpirovnulad, ker-Zod: mowme l. c-am (e-is iuridiuli samsaxuris ufrosi) sa-samarTlo sxdomaze ganacxada, rom Sps à-Tan~ xelSekru-lebis dadebis sakiTxi qonebis marTvis saministrosTanSeTanxmebuli iyo da arsebobda qonebis marTvis saminis-trosa da saTbobenergetikis saministros erToblivi das-kvnac. m. n-i erTpirovnulad ar gadawyvetda jarTis ga-yidvisa da misi fasis dadgenis sakiTxs.

20. sakasacio sasamarTlos ar gaaCnia safuZveli, romssip è-is~ iuridiuli samsaxuris ufrosis _ l. c-as Cvene-bis nawili (rodesac igi erTobliv daskvnaze saubrobs)arasandod miiCnios mxolod imitom, rom es daskvna gamo-Ziebas ar moupovebia. l. c-am agreTve aRniSna, rom zoga-dad m. n-i erTpirovnulad gadawyvetilebebs ar iRebda.

71

21. m. n-is mier gadawyvetilebis araerTpirovnulad mi-Rebis faqts adasturebs #... xelSekrulebis gaformebi-dan ramdenime dReSi _ 2000 wlis 28 ivliss `x-is~ bazazericxuli obieqtebis Seswavlis mizniT, saTbob-energeti-kis ministris 2000 wlis 5 aprilis #... brZanebis safuZ-velze Seqmnili komisiis sxdomis oqmic. oqmis mixedviT,raionSi rTuli kriminogenuri viTareba iyo; obieqtebi ge-ografiulad Znelad misadgom adgilebSi iyo ganlagebu-li da maTi demontaJi ukavSirdeboda did sirTuleebsada xarjebs, risi saSualebac è-as~ ar hqonda; arsebobdaaRniSnuli obieqtebis srulad ganadgurebis safrTxec. am-denad, komisiam misaRebad miiCnia Sps à-is~ mier SemoTa-vazebuli winadadeba. Sps à.~ Tavisi teqnikiT, muSa perso-naliT moaxdenda CamoTvlili obieqtebis demontaJs, ga-dazidvas, sawyobebSi maT awonvasa da sxva xarjebTan da-kavSirebul yvela gadasaxadebs gadaixdida erTpirovnu-lad, ris Semdeg yoveli realizebuli tonis safasurad,aseve gadaixdida 5 aSS dolaris ekvivalent lars, imdro-isaTvis Sesabamisi kursiT. komisiam rekomendaciis saxiTrCeva misca ssip è-is~ xelmZRvanelobas, rom misaRebadmieCnia SemoTavazebuli winadadeba.

22. aRsaniSnavia, rom am sxdomas eswrebodnen: g. a. _ saT-bob-energetikis ministris moadgile (komisiis Tavjdo-mare); m. n-i _ ssip è-is~ Tavjdomare; g. b-i _ ssip è-is~seqtoris ufrosi; m. a-e _ ss `mSenebare x-is direqciis~direqtori; g. o. _ saTbob-energetikis saministros re-formebis departamentis ufrosi; v. j. ssip è-is~ hidro-teqnikuri ganyofilebis ufrosi; o. o. _ ssip è-is~ reabi-litaciisa da kap. mSeneblobis ganyofilebis ufrosi; n. e.institut `h-is~ mTavari inJineri.

23. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom xelSekrulebis ga-formebis Semdeg, ramdenime dReSi mocemuli sakiTxis (Spsà-is~ mier SemoTavazebuli fasis) komisiis sxdomis far-glebSi ganxilva da msjeloba (m. n-is monawileobiT) gamo-ricxavs saqarTvelos ssk-is 342-e muxliT (samsaxurebri-vi gulgriloba _ moxelis mier Tavisi samsaxurebrivi mo-valeobis arajerovnad Sesruleba, misdami daudevari da-mokidebulebis gamo) gaTvaliswinebuli marTlsawinaaR-mdego qmedebis Cadenis faqts. warmodgenili saqmis masa-lebiT ar aris dadasturebuli, rom romelime organos an

72

komisias Seusabamod mieCnia xelSekrulebiT dadgenilifasi, rasac SesaZloa, gamoewvia xelSekrulebis pirobe-bis cvlilebac, vinaidan #... xelSekruleba ar krZalavdaaRniSnuls (cvlilebis Setanas). sakasacio palatis moce-muli gadawyvetilebis 21-e da 22-e punqtebSi miTiTebulsxdomaze aRiniSna, rom cota xanSi SesaZlebeli iyo, esobieqtebi gaZarcvuliyo srulad, ris gamoc Sps à-is~ mi-er SeTavazebuli pirobebi, x-is teritoriaze mZime krimi-nogenuri viTarebis gamo, maT misaRebad miiCnies da komi-sias ar gamouTqvams SeniSvna fasTan dakavSirebiT.

24. amdenad, warmodgenili saqmis arcerTi masala ar mi-uTiTebs, rom m. n-ma fasis dadgenasTan dakaSirebiT dau-devari damokidebuleba gamoiCina.

25. sakasacio palata aseve ver daeTanxmeba saapelaciosasamarTlos miTiTebas, rom m. n-is mimarT saqarTvelosssk-is 332-e muxlis pirveli nawiliTa (samsaxurebrivi uf-lebamosilebis borotad gamoyeneba) da ssk-is 341-e mux-lebiT wardgenili braldeba (samsaxurebrivi siyalbe) un-da gadakvalificirdes ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirvel nawil-ze, (samsaxurebrivi gulgriloba) rogorc erTian qmede-baze, vinaidan, marTalia, m. n-ma gaaforma erTi _ #... xel-Sekruleba, magram sabraldebo daskvnis Tanaxmad, man xel-Sekrulebis gaformebis procesSi ori erTmaneTisagan da-moukidebeli qmedeba ganaxorciela: è-is~ interesebis sa-zianod, neba darTo Sps à-s~ simbolur fasad _ 5 aSS do-larad mieRo jarTi da meore _ Tavisi xelmoweriT daa-mowma iseTi xelSekruleba, romelSic Sps à-s~ warmoad-genda 2000 wlis 4 maiss gardacvlili direqtori. sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom mxolod erTi muxliT kvalifi-kacia im SemTxvevaSi iqneboda kanonieri, Tuki ori qmede-ba erToblivad Seqmnida danaSaulis Semadgenlobas (mag:Zaladoba ssk-is 126-e muxli da Zarcva ssk-is 178-e muxlispirveli nawili _ imis mixedviT, Tu romeli mxare asaCiv-rebs, SesaZloa dakvalificirdes erT qmedebad _ 178-emuxlis me-3 nawiliT _ Zarcva, Cadenili ZaladobiT, rome-lic saSiSi ar aris sicocxlis an janmrTelobisaTvis). m. n-is braldebis SemTxvevaSi ki xelSekrulebis damowmeba dafasis gansazRvra ori, gansxvavebuli Sinaarsis matarebe-li qmedebaa, romelic sabraldebo daskvniT erTmaneTis-gan damoukideblad, ori sxvadasxva muxliT Sefasda; Se-

73

sabamisad, maTi gaerTianeba da sxva (ssk-is 342-e) muxliTdakvalificireba aRar iZleva _ piris mimarT wardgenilyovel konkretul braldebaze sasamarTloTa mier saval-debulo saproceso _ samarTlebrivi daskvnis gakeTebisSesaZleblobas.

26. zemoaRniSnul garemoebaTa gaTvaliswinebiT, saka-sacio palatas miaCnia, rom saqarTvelos sssk-is 561-e mux-lis pirveli nawilis `g~ qvepunqtis Sesabamisad, m. n-is ssk-is 342-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT msjavrdebis nawilSi ga-naCeni unda gauqmdes da saqme Sewydes.


is 561-e muxlis pirveli nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT, 568-e mux-liT (1998 wlis 20 Tebervlis kanoni) da

d a a d g i n a:

1. saqarTvelos mTavari prokuraturis prokuror le-onti adeiSvilis sakasacio saCivari ar dakmayofildes;

2. msjavrdebul m. n-is advokatebis _ g. s-sa da c. w-issakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes;

3. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 7 noembris ganaCeni m. n-ismimarT saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 342-emuxlis pirveli nawiliT (2000 wlis 5 maisis redaqcia)msjavrdebis nawilSi gauqmdes da saqme Sewydes;

4. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 7 noembris ganaCeni da-narCen nawilSi darCes ucvlelad;

5. ganCineba sabolooa da ar saCivrdeba.

74

gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da misnacvlad gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis dadgena

(gansxvavebuli azri)





ganixila saqarTvelos mTavari prokuraturis proku-rorebis _ amiran guluaSvilisa da Tamar aRlemaSvilis sa-kasacio saCivari Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 4 oqtombrisganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis Tanaxmad, a. b-s, _

brali daedo ganzrax mkvlelobaSi, danaSauli, gaTvalis-winebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT, rac gamoixa-ta SemdegSi:

2004 wlis 27 oqtombers, daaxloebiT 19 saaTze, T-Si, p-is mimdebare teritoriaze, d. o-sa da a. b-s Soris mobilurtelefonTan dakavSirebiT warmoiSva konfliqti, ra dro-sac a. b-m daniT ramdenime Wriloba miayena d. o-s, maT So-ris erT-erTi _ Semavali gulmkerdis marcxena naxevarSi,marcxena filtvisa da marcxena winagulis gamWoli dazia-nebiT. danaSaulebrivi ganzraxvis sisruleSi moyvanis Sem-deg a. b. miimala SemTxvevis adgilidan, xolo d. o-i, miuxe-davad gaweuli samedicino daxmarebisa, saavadmyofoSigardaicvala.

2. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiis 2016 wlis 22 dekembris ganaCeniT a. b.cnobil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda saqarTvelosssk-is 108-e muxliT wardgenil braldebaSi.

gamarTlebul a. b-s ganemarta, rom saqarTvelos sssk-

75

is 92-e muxliT dadgenili wesiT ufleba aqvs, moiTxovoszianis anazRaureba.

3. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiis 2016 wlis 22 dekembris ganaCeni saape-lacio wesiT gaasaCivra saqarTvelos mTavari prokuratu-ris saprokuroro zedamxedvelobis sammarTvelos pro-kurorma naTia sonRulaSvilma. apelantma iTxova gamamar-Tlebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da a. b-is damnaSaved cnobasaqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT wardgenil braldebaSi.

4. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 4 oqtombris ganaCeniTTbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saq-meTa kolegiis 2016 wlis 22 dekembris ganaCeni darCa uc-vlelad.

5. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 4 oqtombris ganaCeni sa-kasacio wesiT gaasaCivres saqarTvelos mTavari prokura-turis prokurorebma _ amiran guluaSvilma da Tamar aR-lemaSvilma. kasatorebi saCivriT iTxoven a. b-is damnaSa-ved cnobas saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT wardgenilbraldebaSi, Semdeg garemoebebze miTiTebiT:

saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba ukanono dadausabuTebelia; sasamarTlos argumentacia ar efuZnebasaqmeze gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebis logikur Sefase-bas, gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebi ki damaxinjebulad daaraswori formiT aisaxa ganaCenSi; kasatorebis mosazre-biT, sxvagvar konteqstSia warmoCenili mowme l. b-is Cve-neba, rac Seexeba mowme m. l-es, igi sasamarTloSi ar da-kiTxula da arc misi dakiTxvis oqmi gamokvleula, Tumcamisi Cveneba asaxulia ganaCenSi. sasamarTloSi gamoikvli-es mxolod misi Cvenebis adgilze Semowmebisa da SemTxve-vis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmi, rac ar iZleva mowmis Cve-nebis gamokvleulad miCnevis SesaZleblobas; sasamar-Tlom arasworad Seafasa mowmeebis _ g. m-is, S. S-is, l. b-is,n. g-is, a. n-is, j. m-sa da z. m-is Cvenebebi, rom TiTqosda,maT Soris arsebobda faqtobrivi winaaRmdegobebi da Se-usabamobebi, magram realurad miTiTebul mowmeTa Cvene-bebs Soris araviTari Seusabamoba ar aris. bunebrivia, rommowmeebi erTnairi sizustiT ver aRiqvamen da TerTmetiwlis Semdeg ver gadmoscemdnen saqmis faqtobriv gare-

76

moebebs, Tumca miuxedavad amisa, maTi Cvenebebi erTma-neTTan srulad aris Tanxvdenili.

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio palatam Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma

sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da miiCnia, rom saCiva-ri unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

1. sakasacio palatis azriT, saapelacio sasamarTlom a.b-is mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgenisas ar da-icva saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kanon-mdeblobiT gaTvaliswinebuli is moTxovnebi, romlebicuzrunvelyofen yovel saqmeze obieqturi da samarTlia-ni ganaCenis dadgenas, imisda miuxedavad, es ganaCeni ga-mamtyunebelia Tu gamamarTlebeli.

2. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeq-sis 259-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, sasamarTlosganaCeni unda iyos kanonieri, dasabuTebuli da samarTli-ani. imave muxlis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, ganaCenSi Camoya-libebuli yvela daskvna da gadawyvetileba dasabuTebu-li unda iyos. am TvalsazrisiT ganaCeni dasabuTebulia,rodesac ganaCenSi warmodgenili daskvnebi, rogorc mtki-cebis calkeul saganTan mimarTebiT, aseve mTlianobaSipiris braleulobisa Tu udanaSaulobis Taobaze gamomdi-nareobs saqmis realuri faqtobrivi garemoebebidan da Se-esabameba am garemoebebTan dakavSirebiT saqmeSi arsebulsarwmuno mtkicebulebebs.

3. Tavis mxriv, calkeuli mtkicebulebis Sefasebisasunda vixelmZRvaneloT Semdegi kriteriumebiT: mtkice-bulebas mocemul saqmeSi aqvs Tu ara Sexeba mtkicebis sa-ganTan, masSi sworad aris Tu ara asaxuli saqmisaTvis ar-sebiTi mniSvnelobis mqone faqtobrivi garemoeba, sandoaTu ara is wyaro, saidanac miRebulia mtkicebuleba da, yo-velive aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, ramdenad relevan-turia mtkicebuleba misi utyuarobis TvalsazrisiT.

4. piris msjavrdebisas im principis dacva, rom gamam-tyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebodes utyuar mtkicebu-lebebs, garantirebulia saqarTvelos konstituciiT (me-40 muxlis me-3 nawili) da saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlissaproceso kodeqsiT (82-e muxlis pirveli nawili). Tavismxriv, mtkicebulebis utyuarobasTan dakavSirebiT saqar-

77

Tvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos mier ganmartebulia (ix. ga-dawyvetileba saqmeze #397ap-14) Semdegi: saqmisaTvismniSvnelobis mqone faqtebis dasadgenad aucilebelia Se-fasdes TiToeuli mtkicebulebis utyuaroba, damajereb-loba, rac saqarTvelos sssk-is 82-e muxlis pirveli nawi-lis Tanaxmad, yvela SemTxvevaSi savaldebuloa ganaCenisgamotanis dros. mtkicebulebaTa utyuaroba unda Sefas-des ramdenime kriteriumis mixedviT: 1. TiToeuli mtki-cebuleba, maT Soris mowmis Cveneba, Sinaarsobrivad xomar Seicavs urTierTsawinaaRmdego da urTierTgamomric-xav informacias; 2. TiToeuli mtkicebuleba amyarebs sxvamtkicebulebebs, Tu maT Soris aris sxvadasxva winaaRmde-goba, romelTa xarisxis Sefaseba yvela individualur Sem-TxvevaSi sasamarTlos kompetenciaa; 3. ramdenad gul-wrfeli da miukerZoebelia mowme, xom ar aqvs fizikurinakli, romelic negatiur gavlenas axdens movlenebisadekvatur aRqmaze; 4. rogor pirobebSi moxda mtkicebu-lebebis formireba, mag: garemo pirobebi _ cudi xilvado-ba (nisli), xalxmravali adgili, manZili mowmesa da Sem-Txvevis adgils Soris da sxva. mtkicebulebebis am krite-riumebiT Sefasebisa da maTze ganaCenSi saTanado msje-lobis gareSe mtkicebulebaTa utyuarobis siRrmiseuliSefaseba faqtobrivad SeuZlebelia. amasTan, TiToeulimtkicebuleba, aRniSnuli kriteriumebis Sesabamisad, un-da Semowmdes saqmeSi arsebul sxva pirdapir, aseve iribmtkicebulebebTan erTobliobaSi, maTi urTierTTavseba-dobis gansazRvris mizniT, rac aseve Zalze mniSvnelova-nia gonivrul eWvs miRma standartis dacviT gamamtyune-beli ganaCenis dadgenisa da, saerTod, nebismieri _ gamam-tyunebeli Tu gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dasabuTebulo-bisaTvis.

5. a. b-is saqmeze braldebis mxares pirdapiri mtkice-bulebebis saxiT warmodgenili aqvs braldebis mowmeebis_ S. S-is, g. m-is, l. b-isa da d. k-is Cvenebebi, romlebicgamokvleulia sasamarTloSi aRniSnuli saqmis ganxilvi-sas. garda am mtkicebulebebisa, saqmeSi arsebobs agreTvesxva mowmeTa arapirdapiri Cvenebebic, romlebic aseve ga-mokvleulia sasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvisas.

6. sakasacio palatis azriT, saqmeSi arsebuli mtkice-bulebebi, mowmeTa rogorc pirdapiri, aseve arapirdapi-

78

ri Cvenebebis saxiT, maTi Sinaarsidan gamomdinare, namdvi-lad exeba 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers T-Si, k. g. (yofili p.)gamzirisa da m-is quCis gadakveTaze momxdari SemTxvevisfaqtobriv garemoebebs, ra drosac ormxriv konfliqtSidaniT daWres d. o-i, ris Sedegadac is saavadmyofoSi gar-daicvala. aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi, romlebic erTma-neTs avseben, sruliad naTlad warmoaCenen xsenebul kon-fliqtSi monawile pirebis vinaobasa da am konfliqtis mim-dinareobas misi dasawyisidan dasasrulamde.

7. zemoT dasmul sakiTxs imis Taobaze, saqmeSi arsebu-li mowmeTa Cvenebebi sworad asaxaven Tu ara d. o-is gan-zrax mkvlelobasTan dakavSirebul mTavar faqtobriv ga-remoebebs, romelTac gadamwyveti mniSvneloba eniWebasaqmeze kanonieri sasamarTlo gadawyvetilebis misaRe-bad, mogvianebiT qvemoT SevexebiT. amjerad ki unda gan-vixiloT Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis mier a. b-is gamamarTlebel ganaCen-Si braldebis ZiriTad mowmeTa mimarT warmodgenili uar-yofiTi pozicia da daskvnebi, kerZod, saapelacio sasa-marTlo saeWvod da arasarwmunod miiCnevs mowmeebis: S. -is, g. m-is, l. b-isa da d. k-is pirdapir Cvenebebs. saapela-cio sasamarTlo Tavis pozicias amyarebs ramdenime argu-mentze, romelTa gamoc miiCnia, rom mocemul SemTxveva-Si ar arsebobda safuZveli d. o-is mkvlelobasTan dakav-SirebiT a. b-is msjavrdebisa da mis mimarT gonivrul eWvsmiRma standartis dacviT gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis da-sadgenad.

8. saapelacio sasamarTlos pirveli argumenti mdgoma-reobs SemdegSi: d. o-is mkvleloba Cadenilia 2004 wlisoqtomberSi, xolo aRniSnulma mowmeebma gamoZiebasTaniTanamSromles da am saqmeze pirveli Cvenebebi misces 11wlis Semdeg, 2015 wels. amasTan dakavSirebiT saapelaciosasamarTlo Tavis ganaCenSi svams Semdeg kiTxvebs: S. S-em,g. m-em, l. b-ma da d. k-em, rogorc danaSaulebrivi SemTxve-vis (mkvlelobis) TviTmxilvelma mowmeebma, ratom maSin-ve ar mimarTes sagamoZiebo organoebs da ar misces Cvene-bebi, an ratom ar ganucxades gardacvlilis ojaxis wev-rebs am mkvlelobis garemoebebisa da misi Camdenis Sesa-xeb; ratom gauCndaT maT aseTi survili mravali wlis Sem-deg da Tanac erTdroulad; mowmeebis _ S. S-isa da g. m-is

79

Cvenebebis Tanxvedraze xom ar iqonia gavlena im garemoe-bam, rom gamoZiebisaTvis informaciis miwodebisa da Cve-nebebis micemisas isini erTsa da imave dros ixdidnen sas-jels erT penitenciur dawesebulebaSi da Tanac erT sa-kanSi; aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, maTi Cvenebebi xom ariyo urTierTSoris winaswar SeTanxmebuli da, amdenad, im-saxurebs Tu ara es Cvenebebi ndobas obieqturi damkvir-veblis TvalTaxedviT.

9. saapelacio sasamarTlos mocemul poziciasTan da-kavSirebiT sakasacio palata aRniSnavs Semdegs: gaumar-Tlebelia, mowmis Cvenebis sandoobisa da relevanturo-bis Semowmebisas ganmsazRvreli mniSvneloba mivaniWoT imgaremoebas, Tu ramdeni welia gasuli momxdari danaSau-lis faqtidan Cvenebis micemamde. mTavaria, ramdenad sru-lad warmogvidgens mowme Tavis CvenebaSi faqtobriv ga-remoebebs, srulfasovnad gadmoscems Tu ara am garemoe-bebs Cvenebis micemisas, rogoria misi unari _ sworad aRiq-vas da daimaxsovros im SemTxvevis mTavari, saqmisaTvisarsebuli mniSvnelobis mqone garemoebebi, romlis Sem-swrec is gaxda da xom ar arsebobs raime safuZveli misamgvar unarSi gonivruli eWvis Sesatanad da a.S. SeuZle-belia da aragonivrulic, movTxovoT mowmes aramcTu 11wlis, aramed Tundac erTi wlis Semdeg mTeli sizustiTaRidginos da gadmosces im SemTxvevis yvela detali, rom-lis Semswre an uSualo monawilec is iyo. winaaRmdeg Sem-TxvevaSi azrs dakargavda gansakuTrebiT mZime danaSau-lebis xandazmulobisaTvis kanoniT dadgenili xangrZli-vi vada (25 weli), radgan aseT saqmeze mowmeTa Cvenebebisruliad miuRebeli iqneboda.

10. rac Seexeba saapelacio sasamarTlos miTiTebas imisTaobaze, Tu ratom maSinve ar mimarTes dasaxelebulmamowmeebma sagamoZiebo organoebs da ar ganacxades, vin iyomkvlelobis Camdeni da ratom ar misces Cvenebebi maSin-ve, an ratom ar ganucxades moklulis ojaxs mis Sesaxeb,unda aRiniSnos, rom SesaZlebelia, maTze mraval faqtorsmoexdina zegavlena, romelTa Soris dasaxelebulia xse-nebul mowmeTa SiSi maT mimarT mosalodneli SurisZiebi-sa. aq mniSvnelovania ara is garemoeba, Tu ramdenad rea-luri safuZveli gaaCnda maT SiSs, aramed maTi asaki _ maTiumetesoba momxdari SemTxvevisas daaxloebiT 14-15 wli-

80

sani iyvnen da Znelia, am asakSi adamians mosTxovo moqala-qeobrivi gabedulebisa da marTlSegnebis maRali done,gansakuTrebiT im rTul kriminogenur viTarebaSi, rome-lic maSin arsebobda T-Si da mTel saqarTveloSi. niSan-doblivia, rom maT gamoZiebas Cveneba misces ukve mowi-ful asakSi, rodesac maTTvis ukve moxsnili iyo Semakave-beli negatiuri faqtorebi. rogorc saqmis masalebidan ir-kveva, mokluli d. o-is ojaxis wevrebisaTvis imave dResgaxda cnobili savaraudo damnaSavis Sesaxeb sxvadasxvawyarodan, rac naTlad ikveTeba saqmis masalebidan, ami-tom saapelacio sasamarTlos eWvi imis Taobaze, rom ze-moaRniSnulma mowmeebma, Tuki isini mkvlelobis Semswre-ni iyvnen, ratom araferi ar ganucxades d. o-is axloblebs,safuZvels moklebulia.

11. ar arsebobs aseve safuZveli saapelacio sasamar-Tlos mier mowmeTa mimarT gamoTqmuli im eWvis gasazia-reblad romlis mixedviT, S. S-es, g. m-esa da l. b-s ratom-Rac mravali wlis Semdeg erTdroulad gauCndaT imissurvili, rom eTanamSromlaT gamoZiebasTan da miecaT a.b-is mamxilebeli Cvenebebi. saqme isaa, rom dasaxelebulimowmeebidan mxolod S. S-em mimarTa gamoZiebas d. o-ismkvlelobis saqmeze Cvenebis misacemad, xolo sxva mniS-vnelovan mowmeebs ar miumarTavT sagamoZiebo organoe-bisaTvis da arc gamouxatavT piradi survili da interesimaTTan TanamSromlobisaTvis. es mowmeebi TviTon am or-ganoebma daadgines S. S-is Cvenebis wyalobiT da sworedamis Semdeg misces maT Cvenebebi gamoZiebas. amasTan, ro-desac saapelacio sasamarTlo aRniSnuli mowmeebis Cve-nebebis arasandoobaze uTiTebs, aseve im motiviT, rom Se-saZloa, es Cvenebebi winaswar urTierTSeTanxmebuli iyo,gansakuTrebiT im garemoebis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom mow-meebi _ S. S-e da g. m-e erTad ixdidnen sasjels im period-Si, ewinaaRmdegeba Tavisive daskvnas, romlis mixedviT,am Cvenebebs Soris mniSvnelovani da arsebiTi winaaRmde-gobebi arsebobs, ris gamoc maTi gaziareba SeuZlebeli yo-fila. ismeba sruliad logikuri kiTxva: Tuki aRniSnulmowmeTa Cvenebebi urTierTSeTanxmebuli iyo, maSin ratomarsebobs winaaRmdegobebi am Cvenebebs Soris da ratom arizruna maTma SemTanxmebelma am winaaRmdegobaTa aRmo-safxvrelad? gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi ganviTarebul msje-

81

lobebSi am kiTxvaze raime damajerebeli pasuxi ar ikiT-xeba. ra Tqma unda, sxva sakiTxia, marTlac arsebobs Tuara mniSvnelovani da arsebiTi winaaRmdegobebi xsenebulmowmeTa Cvenebebs Soris, ris Taobazec qvemoT iqneba aR-niSnuli.

12. Semdegi ZiriTadi argumenti, romlis safuZvelzecsaapelacio sasamarTlom miuReblad da arasarwmunod mi-iCnia rogorc zemoT dasaxelebuli mowmeebis pirdapiriCvenebebi, aseve _ sxva mowmeTa iribi Cvenebebic, romle-bic faqtobrivad avseben pirdapir Cvenebebs da miuTiTe-ben maT realurobaze, mdgomareobs SemdegSi: sasamar-Tlos daskvniT am mtkicebulebebs Soris arsebobs mniS-vnelovani da arsebiTi winaaRmdegobebi, ris gamoc CndebasafuZvliani eWvi aramarto maTi sarwmunoobis mimarT, ara-med imis Taobazec ki, rom aRniSnuli mowmeebi saerTodmarTlac imyofebodnen Tu ara SemTxvevis adgilze 2004wlis 27 oqtombris saRamos, rodesac d. o-i daniT sasik-vdilod daWres.

13. imisaTvis, rom SevamowmoT, ramdenad safuZvlianiasaapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenSi mocemuli daskvnebimowmeTa Cvenebebs Soris mniSvnelovani winaaRmdegobebisarsebobis Taobaze, unda dazustdes da warmodgenil iq-nes _ ra garemoebebTan mimarTebiT arsebobs maT SorisTanxvedra, aseve, ra garemoebebTan dakavSirebiT iCensTavs garkveuli winaaRmdegobebi maT Soris da Seexeba Tuara es winaaRmdegobebi mtkicebis ZiriTad sagans. saami-sod aucilebelia gavecnoT Sesabamis amonaridebs mowme-ebis _ S. S-is, g. m-is, l. b-isa da d. k-is Cvenebebidan.

14. mowme S. S-em sasamarTloSi dakiTxvisas ganmarta: ic-nobda rogorc a. b-s, aseve d. o-s. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombersg. m-esTan erTad imyofeboda p. (imave k. g.) gamzirze, slot-klub `g-is~ mimdebare teritoriaze, im adgilis mopirda-pire mxares, sadac Semdeg incidenti moxda. iqneboda sa-Ramos saaTebi, rodesac 30-35 metrSi SeniSna d. o-i da a. b..iyo raRac CoCqoli, konkretulad miTiTebul slotklub-Tan. am dros man dainaxa da kargad axsovs, Tu rogor mouq-nia a. b-m sagniani xeli d. o-s da daartya wels zeviT, risgamoc d. o-i wabarbacda. Semdeg dainaxa, rom a. b-s imavexelSi eWira dana, romelic isev daartya d. o-s ukve dab-la, wels qveviT. rodesac a. b-m wabarbacebuli d. o-isken

82

gaiwia, kargad axsovs, rom mas xelSi ekava dana. am drosmaT Soris manZili iyo daaxloebiT 30_35 metri. bneloda,magram xilvadoba iyo sakmaod kargi, radgan gare ganaTebaiyo CarTuli. d. o-i cdilobda xelidan dasxltomas. aR-niSnulis danaxvaze man quCa gadakveTa sirbiliT, magramSemTxvevis adgilisken ar wasula da marjvniv wavida. ro-desac quCa gadakveTa, a. b. iq aRar daunaxavs, radgan mom-xdari SemTxvevis Semdeg is gaiqca, magram romeli mimar-TulebiT, ar axsovs.

15. mowme g. m-em sasamarTloSi Cvenebis micemisas gan-marta: icnobs rogorc a. b-s, aseve d. o-s. 2004 wlis 27 oq-tombers S. S-esTan erTad imyofeboda p. gamzirze, m-is qu-Cis kveTaze, sadarbazosTan, ra drosac slotklub `g-is~win dainaxes a. b. da d. o-i, romlebic maTgan daSorebuliiqnebodnen daaxloebiT 30-40 metriT. Tavidan isini saub-robdnen, rac Semdeg gadaizarda CxubSi. am dros a. b-m d.o-s tanis zeda nawilSi daartya dana, ris Semdegac d. o-iCaikeca da forTxviT wavida trotuarisken. a. b. kvlav mi-varda mas da meored daartya dana fexSi. am dros man da S.S-em gadakveTes gza, S-sTvis yuradReba aRar miuqceviada ar icis, Tu sad wavida. igi gaiqca `a-s~ (a. b.) dasaWerad,magram SeniSna, rom j. m-i garboda misi mimarTulebiT, ami-tom igi mivida d. o-Tan. SemTxvevis dRes `a-s~ ecva qurTu-ki da exura Savi `kepi~. a. b-m d. o-s pirvelad dana mouqniatanis zeda nawilSi, xolo meored _ fexSi, rac moxda wa-mebSi.

16. mowme l. b-ma sasamarTloSi dakiTxvisas ganmarta:icnobs rogorc a. b-s, aseve d. o-s. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers,saRamos gamovida saxlidan da unda Sexvedroda megobargogonas x-s quCaze. gamoiara i-s quCaze, sadac veravin na-xa, Semdeg ezoTi gadavida p. quCisken, radgan t-is mimar-TulebiT midioda da x-ze unda Sexvedroda megobar go-gonas. gadakveTa p. quCa da daaxloebiT 5 wuTis ganmavlo-baSi idga `j-is~ ofisis win da iyureboda slotklub `g-is~mxares. daaxloebiT 20_25 metrSi SeniSna d. o-i da a. b.,romlebic erTmaneTSi daZabulad saubrobdnen, Tumca sa-ubris Tema ar gaugonia. am dros maT garda man dainaxa ki-dev erTi ubneli biWi _ g-i. Semdeg a. b-m da d. o-ma erTma-neTSi daiwyes ZiZgilaoba. am dros d. o-i Caikeca. is Cake-cili iyo, ra drosac a. b-m mas dana daartya. a. b-s dana eWi-

83

ra marjvena xelSi. es yvelaferi misTvis moulodneli iyo,daibna, albaT, misi asakidan gamomdinare, da sastumro à-ken~ Setrialda, daaxloebiT 20 wamSi isev ukan moixeda dadainaxa o-i, romelic iyo Cakecili da gadadioda gzaze.uceb iq Zalian bevri xalxi Segrovda, gaveride iqaurobas,albaT, davibeni kidec. detalebi zustad ar maxsovs, rad-gan gasulia didi dro. iq imdeni xalxi iyo, rom SesaZlebe-lia Cemi nacnobebic yofiliyvnen. d. o.sa da a. b-s SorisZiZgilaoba, CxubSi ar gadazrdila. rodesac ZiZgilaob-dnen, a. b-s xelSi dana eWira, me davinaxe danis piri da er-Ti moqneva, meore dartyma ar daminaxavs.

17. sasamarTloSi gamokvleul iqna mowme d. k-is Cvene-ba, romelic man gamoZiebas misca 2015 wlis 18 marts. TavisCvenebaSi igi ganmartavs: icnobda d. o-s. momxdari SemTxve-vis dros is imyofeboda pokerklubis mimdebare terito-riaze. am dros pokerklubSi myof d. o-Tan mivida à.~, ma-Tive ubneli axalgazrda biWi. man d. o-i gamoiyvana gareTda mosTxova Tavanis Cabareba, razedac d. o-ma dro iTxo-va. isini marto saubrobdnen da idgnen pokerklubis win,trotuarze, Tavad ki idga maTgan daaxloebiT 15 metrismoSorebiT. uceb maT Soris daiZaba saubari, ra drosac à-m~ saxeSi daartya d. o-s da erTmaneTs dauwyes cema. CxubigagrZelda ramdenime wams, dasrulebis Semdeg ki im ad-gilze SeniSna sisxlis laqebi. d. o-i koWlobiT gaiqca gza-ze, g. quCis mopirdapire mxares. rodesac igi gadadioda,mas trotuaridan aginebda à.~. aseve d. o-ic aginebda mas.à.~ maleve gaiqca p. quCaze, man Tavze `kepi~ Camoifara dagarboda. (sakasacio palata am CvenebasTan dakavSirebiTaRniSnavs, rom rogorc saqmis masalebidan irkveva, à.~ a.b-is zedmeti saxelia).

18. rogorc vxedavT, miTiTebuli mowmeebis pirdapiriCvenebebidan amoRebuli amonaridebiT irkveva, rom: ammowmeebidan yvela maTgani icnobda konfliqtis monawi-le mxareebs _ d. o-sa da a. b-s, yovelma maTganma dainaxa is,rac maT Soris moxda, kerZod, a. b-is mier d. o-isaTvis da-nis dartymis faqti, agreTve is, rom am oris garda kon-fliqtis momentSi maT axlos sxva, mesame piri ar yofila,romelsac SeiZleba daeWra d. o-i. sakasacio palata yurad-Rebas miaqcevs im garemoebazec, rom aRniSnuli mowmeebisaq motanil pirdapir Cvenebebs Sorisac ki arsebobs mci-

84

reodeni gansxvavebani calkeul detalebSi, rac sruliadbunebrivia, radgan Tu davakvirdebiT, es mowmeebi mom-xdar SemTxvevas uyurebdnen sxvadasxva adgilidan, sxva-dasxva manZilidan da sxvadasxva rakursiT, rac adastu-rebs am Cvenebebis namdvilobasa da obieqturobas, amas-Tan, aSkarad da udavod gamoricxavs maT winaswar SeTan-xmebul xasiaTs. piriqiT, es Cvenebebi saeWvo SeiZleba swo-red im SemTxvevaSi gamxdariyo, Tuki isini identuri Sina-arsis mqoneni aRmoCndebodnen. garda amisa, sakasacio pa-latis azriT, aRniSnuli Cvenebebis obieqturobas arapir-dapir Semdegic adasturebs _ saqmis masalebidan ar ikve-Teba iseTi garemoeba, rac gvafiqrebinebda, rom mowmeebs,romlebmac es Cvenebebi misces jer gamoZiebas, Semdeg ki_ sasamarTlos, gaaCndaT raime seriozuli mizezi a. b-iswinaaRmdeg cru Cvenebis misacemad. saapelacio sasamar-Tlo Tavis ganaCenSi arapirdapir mianiSnebs da iziarebsdacvis mxaris mier gamoTqmul eWvebs ori mowmis _ S. S-isada g. m-is braldebis mxaresTan SesaZlo garigebaze _ maTiCvenebebis sanacvlod garkveuli SeRavaTebis miRebis miz-niT, magram arafriT ar dasturdeba maTTvis msgavsi SeRa-vaTebis gaweva. miTumetes, yovlad SeuZlebelia, eWvi ga-movTqvaT iseTi mowmis SesaZlo mikerZoebulobaze, ro-goricaa d. k-e, romelic d. o-sa da a. b-s mxolod Soridanicnobda, amasTan, man im droisaTvis maTi saxelebi da gva-rebic ki ar icoda da maT mxolod zedmeti saxelebiT ic-nobda, kerZod, a. b-s _ rogorc à-s~, xolo d. o-s _ rogorcù-s~. amitomac iyo, rom, rodesac momxdari SemTxvevisSemdeg, mas, rogorc TviTmxilvels, hkiTxes, ra moxdao,man upasuxa _ à-m~ daWra ù.~. momxdari SemTxvevis dros d.k-e iq aRmoCnda imis gamo, rom im ubanSi slotklub `g-is~mimdebare teritoriaze mowyalebis saTxovnelad dadio-da xolme.

19. amrigad, sakasacio palatis daskvniT, araviTari sa-fuZveli ar arsebobs saeWvod iqnes miCneuli braldebismxaris ZiriTadi mowmeebis _ S. S-is, g. m-is, l. b-isa da d. k-is pirdapiri Cvenebebis siswore da sarwmunooba, miuxe-davad imisa, rom saapelacio sasamarTlo am mimarTule-biT garkveul eWvebsa da varaudebs gamoTqvams. gasaCiv-rebul ganaCenSi yuradReba gamaxvilebulia zogierT Se-usabamobaze, rogorc ganxilul Cvenebebs Soris, agreTve

85

am Cvenebebsa da sxva mowmeebis mier sasamarTlosaTvis mi-cemul arapirdapir Cvenebebs Soris. magram saqme isaa, romes Seusabamobani ar exeba mtkicebis mTavar sagans, romel-Sic moiazreba: TviTon momxdari faqtis namdviloba, droda adgili, incidentSi monawile pirebi, maTi moqmedebanida damdgari Sedegi, incidentis monawileTa qmedebis obi-eqturi (mizezobrivi) da subieqturi (ganzraxva, motivi)kavSiri am SedegTan. imisaTvis, rom warmoCindes, marTlacarsebiTi da mniSvenlovania Tu ara aRniSnuli winaaRmde-gobebi da, aqedan gamomdinare, safuZvliania Tu ara saa-pelacio sasamarTlos mier gamoTqmuli eWvebi da varau-debi braldebis mowmeTa SesaZlo arasandoobis Taobaze,aqve movitanT sxva amonaridebsac, rogorc zemoT ukve mi-TiTebuli Cvenebebidan, ise _ sxva mowmeebis arapirdapi-ri Cvenebebidan, romlebiTac apelirebs a. b-is mimarT ga-mamarTlebeli ganaCenis damdgeni sasamarTlo. es amona-ridebi exeba momxdar SemTxvevamde cota xniT adre da amSemTxvevis Semdeg, ufro zustad ki jer kidev mis dasru-lebamde, saqmeze mowmed dakiTxul pirTa monawileobiTganviTarebul movlenebs.

20. amonaridi mowme S. S-is Cvenebidan: 2004 wlis 27 oq-tombers, saRamos, g. m-esTan erTad imyofeboda p. quCaze(amJamad k. g. gamziri), slotklub `g-is~ mimdebare teri-toriaze. sanam is cnobili incidenti moxdeboda, man Sei-xeda saxaWapureSi, sadac SeniSna j. m-i, a. a-i da g. b-i, SeiZ-leba sxvebic yofiliyvnen, magram ar axsovs. incidentisdros dainaxa, Tu rogor gadarboda quCaze j. m-i d. o-ismisaSveleblad. Tavad ki, marTalia, quCa gadakveTa, mag-ram SemTxvevis adgilisaken ar wasula, gezi aiRo marjvniv,maRazia `d-ken~, ratom moiqca ase, ver xsnis. Semdeg ki sax-lSi wavida. p. quCis gadakveTis Semdeg incidentis adgil-ze mas a. b. aRar daunaxavs, xolo d. o-is gardacvalebisTaobaze misTvis meore dRes gaxda cnobili.

21. amonaridi mowme g. m-is Cvenebidan: 2004 wlis 27 oq-tombers S. S-sTan erTad imyofeboda p. gamzirze, am quCi-sa da m-is quCis gadakveTaze, sadarbazosTan, ra drosacdainaxes slotklub `g-is~ win momxdari SemTxveva. im dros,rodesac a. b-m meored daartya fexSi dana d. o-s, man da S.S-em gadakveTes gza. S-sTvis yuradReba aRar miuqcevia daar icis, Tu sad wavida, Tavad ki daiwyo a. b-is Zebna, rome-

86

lic ver ipova da wavida saxlSi. mis mier aRwerili movle-nebisas saxaWapuresTan, birJaze, man SeamCnia nacnobebi _a. a-i, g. a., g. b-i da j. m-i. momxdari incidentis Semdeg is, S.S-e da j. m-i faqtobrivad erTdroulad kveTdnen gzas,maT Soris daSoreba iqneboda daaxloebiT aTi metri. j. m-i d. o-is dasaxmareblad midioda, Tumca maTi Sexvedra masaRar daunaxavs. rogorc axsovs, momxdari SemTxvevis ad-gilis mimdebare teritoriaze man naxa n. g-i, romelic masmouyva Cxubis detalebs, uTxra, rom rodesac afTiaqidangamovida, gaigona d. o-sa da a. b-s Soris kamaTis xma da Cxu-bis dros iqve iyo. Tumca damatebiT kiTxvaze pasuxis ga-cemisas mowme g. m-em ganmarta, rom man m. q-isgan gaigo, romn. g-ma dainaxa d. o-sa da a. b-s Soris Cxubis detalebi. imdRes mimdebare teritoriaze l. b-i ar SeuniSnavs.

22. amonaridi mowme l. b-is Cvenebidan: 2004 wlis 27 oq-tombers, saRamos, gamovida saxlidan da unda Sexvedro-da megobar gogonas x-is quCaze. gamoiara i-is quCaze, sa-dac veravin naxa. Semdeg ezoTi gadavida p. quCaze, gadak-veTa quCa da elodeboda samarSruto taqsis. igi daaxloe-biT 5 wuTis ganmavlobaSi idga `j-is~ ofisis win da iyure-boda slotklub `g-is~ mxares, sadac dainaxa is cnobiliSemTxveva, romelic aRwerili aqvs Tavis CvenebaSi. racmoxda, es yvelaferi misTvis moulodneli iyo, daibna dasastumro à-ken~ Setrialda. daaxloebiT 10-15 wamSi isevmoixeda da dainaxa d. o-i, romelic quCas kveTda. uceb bev-ri xalxi Segrovda da zustad yvelaferi aRar axsovs. da-inaxa is momenti, rogor svamdnen d. o-s avtomanqanaSi. a. b.iq aRar daunaxavs. n. g-i Tavidan SeniSna, Tumca SemTxve-vis dros iq aRar daunaxavs. man daaxloebiT naxevari wu-Tis ganmavlobaSi taqsiT datova is adgili. S. S-esa da g. m-es icnobs, magram im adgilze ar SeumCnevia.

23. amonaridi mowme d. k-is mier 2015 wlis 18 marts ga-moZiebisaTvis micemuli Cvenebidan: ganmartavs, rom mom-xdari SemTxvevis dros is imyofeboda pokerklub `g-is~mimdebare teritoriaze. momxdari SemTxvevis Semdeg, racman dainaxa iyo is, rom d. o-i koWlobiT gaiqca gzaze, k. g.quCis mopirdapire mxares. rodesac igi quCaze gadadio-da, mas aginebda à.~, aseve d. o-ic aginebda mas. à.~ malevegaiqca p. quCaze, man Tavze `kepi~ Camoifara da garboda. d.o-i orma biWma Casva avtomanqanaSi da waiyvanes. rodesac

87

TviTonac gadavida quCaze, `a.~ da d. o-i iqidan ukve wa-sulebi iyvnen. aRniSnul faqts Seeswrnen pokerklubisdacvis TanamSromlebi, aseve _ iqve arsebuli maRaziis Ta-namSromlebi.

24. Cvenebis adgilze Semowmebis da SemTxvevis adgilisdaTvalierebis oqmSi Setanili mowme m. l-is mier micemu-li ganmartebis mixedviT, 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers, daax-loebiT 19.00 saaTze, is imyofeboda maRazia `k-s~ sawyob-Si, ra drosac mas Semoesma Cxubis xma quCidan. gavida dadainaxa, rom saSualo simaRlis, misTvis ucnobi, daaxloe-biT 18 wlis axalgazrda biWi idga trotuarze, kidesTan,misken zurgiT, exura muqi feris `kepi~ da aginebda k. g.gamzirze gadamsvlel, misTvis ucnob sam axalgazrda biWs.gineba da muqara gagrZelda daaxloebiT 2_3 wuTs, ris Sem-degac `kepiani~ biWi mobrunda da gaiqca m-is quCis mimar-TulebiT, is sami biWi ki gadavida gamzirze, sadac gaaCe-res manqana da wavidnen v-as gamziris mimarTulebiT.

25. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamoqveynda mowme n. q-s Cve-nebebi, saidanac irkveva, rom 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers, da-axloebiT 19.00_19.30 saaTze, igi gamovida maRaziidan damiemarTeboda gastronomSi, romelic mdebareobda g. gam-zirze. maRaziidan gamosvlis dros karis win SeniSna axal-gazrda biWi, romelic laparakobda mobilur telefonze.rogorc Semdeg Seityo, es biWi iyo d. o-i. CvenebaSi mowmen. q-em ganacxada, rom d. o-s miuaxlovda misTvis ucnobi,daaxloebiT 20 wlamde asakis, susti aRnagobis axalgaz-rda biWi, romelsac ecva muqi feris qurTuki da Tavze exu-ra Savi feris qudi _ `kepi~. man d. o-s kategoriuli toniTmosTxova mobilur telefonze darekva, razedac o-ma ase-ve kategoriuli toniT miugo, rom ar daarekvinebda. axal-gazrda biWma d. o-s dauwyo lanZRva _ `ras qvia, ar dama-rekvineb, sadarbazoSi gagiyvano~ da daemuqra ginebiT, ra-sac d. o-ma upasuxa, `wamodi, gavideTo~. mowmis ganmarte-biT, amis Semdeg man Cauara mokamaTeebs da gadavida maRa-ziaSi, saidanac dabrunda daaxloebiT xuT wuTSi, ra dro-sac Seityo, rom d. o-i daWrili iyo mucelSi. mowmem aseveganmarta, rom `kepian~ axalgazrdas d. o-Tan laparakisasSeatyo, rom hqonda Cveulebrivi Tbilisuri aqcenti.

26. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli z. m-is CvenebiT dgindeba,rom a. b-s ar icnobs. 2004 wlis mdgomareobiT m-is quCisa

88

da p. quCis kuTxeSi mamamiss hqonda sasursaTo maRazia,romlis gverdiTac iyo slotklubi. 2004 wlis 27 oqtom-bers, saRamos, manqana gaaCera maRaziasTan, daaxloebiT10_15 metrSi. am dros Semoesma ginebis xma. gaixeda im mi-marTulebiT da dainaxa, rom erTi adamiani daiZra p. mi-marTulebiT, meore ki _ m-is mimarTulebiT. erTma CqarinabijiT gairbina. es adamianebi erTad myofi ar daunaxavs,arc saxeze daunaxavs isini. axsovs, rom m-is quCisken mima-vali piri aginebda p-ken gadamsvlels. mas xelSi telefo-nis ekrani unaTebda, romelic unda yofiliyo `samsungit100~ modelis. is piri, romelic gzas kveTda, ar axsovs,saiT wavida, yuradReba ar miuqcevia, arc is axsovs, koW-lobda Tu ara. is SeiZleba yofiliyo misi maRaziidan da-Sorebuli 40 metriT. meore pirma, romelic m-is quCiskenmidioda, misgan Caiara daaxloebiT 5-7 metrSi. maRaziaSimaleve Sevida da m-is quCisken mimavals rom vinme gamo-devnebodes, ar daunaxavs. SemdegSi, rodesac policia mo-vida, Seityo, rom mis maRaziasTan incidenti momxdara.

27. amonaridi mowme n. g-is Cvenebidan: im periodSi, ro-desac SemTxveva moxda, cxovrobda T-Si, g-is (yofili k-is) quCaze. d. o-s ar icnobda. icnobda a. b-s, romelic iyoZalian emociuri. misTvis cecxlsasroli iaraRi ar Seu-niSnavs, magram is xSirad unaxavs daniT. a. b-s zedmet saxe-lad à-s~ eZaxdnen. im saRamos dedam gagzavna afTiaqSi, radrosac mas Sexvda a. b. da isic Tan gahyva. mividnen im ad-gilze, sadac slotklubia. am dros a. b-m saubari daiwyoviRac misTvis ucnob pirTan, saubari iyo daZabuli. man da-tova isini da Sevida afTiaqSi. afTiaqi mdebareobda gzismeore mxares, daaxloebiT 30 metrSi. vinaidan afTiaqSirigi iyo, amitom iq dayovnda 10-15 wuTs. aRniSnuli mowmeaseve ganmartavs: amis Semdeg gamovedi afTiaqidan, gad-movdiodi gzaze da SevamCnie, rom slotklubTan xalxi iyoSekrebili. vin iyo, ar maxsovs, wavedi saxlisken. am droserTi biWi _ d. k-e, romelic mowyalebas iTxovs da ezoSicxovrobs, movida CemTan. eg iyo nacnobi, romelic aRvid-gine da miTxra, rom à-m~ daWra ù-o~, es ù.~ vin iyo, me arvicodi. Cveulebrivad wavedi saxlisken. sadarbazosTanSemxvda braldebulis da, man mkiTxa, sad imyofeboda b..me vuTxari, rom ar vicodi da wavedi saxlSi. misi da Seme-kiTxa aseve _ vin daWra à-mo~, me mivuge, rom ar vicodi,

89

radgan am pirs, saxelad `u-s~, ar vicnobdi. Semdeg a. b. arminaxavs da arc davinteresebulvar. mogvianebiT CemTviscnobili gaxda, rom gardacvlili iyo Cveni mezobeli, ub-neli, romelic ramdenime metris moSorebiT cxovrobda.gavige misi gvari da saxeli _ d. o-i. rodesac Semxvda a. b.,mas ecva muqi feris tansacmeli. me SemimCnevia, rom rode-sac CvenTan erTad idga, mas dana hqonda xolme xelSi. imdRes me mis xelSi dana ar SemimCnevia. rogorc maxsovs,rodesac midioda, mas xelSi ekava telefoni da saubrob-da, xolo Tavze efara `kepi~. vinme nacnobi, garda d. k-isa,axlo-maxlo aravin SeminiSnavs. slotklubTan myofTaganveravin amovicani.

28. amonaridi mowme a. n-is Cvenebidan: d. o-s axlos ic-nobda, rogorc bavSvobis megobars, xolo im pirs, visTa-nac mas konfliqti mouxda, saerTod ar icnobda. 2004 wlis27 oqtombers, saRamos, imyofeboda p. quCaze _ saxaWapu-resTan j. m-Tan erTad, isini saubrobdnen. am dros maTTanmivida d. o-i da sTxova maT mobilur telefonze darekva.vinaidan maT mobiluri telefonis angariSze Tanxa ar hqon-daT, d. o-i gadavida quCis meore mxareze, iq, sadac mdeba-reobs slotklubi `g-i~. garkveuli drois Semdeg dainaxa,rom d. o-i viRacas elaparakeboda. mas am garemoebisaTvisar miuqcevia gansakuTrebuli yuradReba da ganagrZobdaj. m_Tan saubars. erT-erTi gaxedvisas dainaxa, rom d. o-ida is meore piri, romelsac ar icnobda, TiTqos Widaob-dnen. magram mas ar CauTvlia, rom saqme seriozulad iyo,Tumca meore gaxedvisas dainaxa, rom d. o-i waiqca, mixvda,rom raRac moxda, ris gamoc is Seecada gzaze gadasvlas.rodesac miaRwia gzis Sua nawils, iq Semoxvda d. o-i, ro-melmac uTxra, rom iyo daWrili da Wrilobaze xeli hqon-da mifarebuli. man uTxra, rom misuliyo j. m-Tan, rome-lic mas daexmareboda, xolo TviTon moZebnida im pirs,vinc is daWra. gadavida gzis meore mxares slotklubTan,magram iq saeWvo veravin aRmoaCina, ris gamoc isev ukandabrunda, magram iq ukve j. m-i da d. o-i aRar iyvnen, mix-vda, rom es ukanaskneli waiyvanes v-as gamzirze mdebarer-r saavadmyofoSi, ris gamoc TviTonac iq wavida. rode-sac is d. o-isken gaemarTa, j. m-i sadRac mis ukan unda yo-filiyo. am dros SemTxvevis adgilze sxva vinme SeniSnaTu ara, ver ambobs, radgan Zalian didi droa gasuli. saer-

90

Tod ar axsovs, garSemo iyo Tu ara vinme, masTan da j. m-Tan erTad ki aravin yofila. S. S-es, g. m-es, n. g-sa da d. k-esar icnobs, isini vin arian, ar icis. l. -s icnobs da im Sem-Txvevis Semdegac Sexvedria mas.

29. amonaridi mowme j. m-s Cvenebidan: d. o-s kargad ic-nobda, is bavSvobis megobari iyo. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers,saRamos, imyofeboda p. gamzirze, m-is quCis SesaxvevTan,megobar a. n-Tan erTad. am dros maTTan mivida d. o-i, ro-melmac maT sTxova mobilur telefonze darekva, magramangariSze Tanxa ar hqondaT. d. o-ma uTxra, rom p. quCismeore mxareze gadavidoda, vinmes telefoniT darekavdada Semdeg isev maTTan gadmovidoda. amasTan, d. o-ma sTxo-va, rom sadRac apirebda wasvlas da isic wahyoloda. d. o-is wasvlis Semdeg man gaagrZela saubari a. n-Tan, romel-mac ramdenime wuTis Semdeg daiZaxa _ d. Cxubobso, gaixe-da p. quCis mopirdapire mxareze da SeamCnia, rom d. o-sesaWiroeboda daxmareba da misken gaiqca. a. n-i masze wingarboda, romelmac gzis Sua nawilze misul d. o-s uTxra _j-sTan midio da iqiT gaiqca, sadac d. o-s konfliqti mo-uxda. is mivida d. o-Tan, romelmac uTxra, rom iyo daWri-li. man d. o-i gzaze gadaiyvana, gaaCera avtomanqana da wa-vidnen r-r saavadmyofoSi. im momentSi, rodesac yoveli-ve es xdeboda, sxva pirebisTvis yuradReba ar miuqcevia.rodesac TviTon d. o-isken gaiqca dasaxmareblad, sxva pi-rebi ar daunaxavs. is d. o-is megobrebs _ S. S-esa da g. m-esicnobda, n. g-s ki ver ixsenebs, xolo d. k-e ar axsovs, vinaris. S. S-e, g. m-e da l. b-i iq mas ar daunaxavs. is gaiqca d. o-is dasaxmareblad, sxva pirebi ar daunaxavs. a. n-isa da misgarda sxva pirebma gadakveTes Tu ara quCa sirbiliT, aricis. mis ukan vin iyo, arc es icis. SeiZleba im dros quCazevinme gadarboda an gadmorboda kidec. is manqanebis na-kadSi cdilobda gzaze gadasvlas. a. n-i mis win garboda damas xedavda. sxvebze yuradReba ar gaumaxvilebia. gzis ga-dakveTis dros mis marcxniv an marjvniv vinme nacnobi da-inaxa Tu ara, ar axsovs, ar icis.

30. es sakmaod vrceli amonaridebi mowmeTa dasaxele-buli Cvenebebidan motanil iqna imisaTvis, rom ufro na-Teli gamxdariyo aRniSnul SemTxvevasTan dakavSirebu-li zogierTi sadavo momenti, romelTac eyrdnoba saape-lacio sasamarTlos mier a. b-is mimarT gamotanili gama-

91

marTlebeli ganaCeni. es sadavo momentebi obieqturad un-da gaanalizdes da Sefasdes, raTa gairkves, kanonieri dadasabuTebulia Tu ara xsenebuli ganaCeni.

31. saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqme-Ta palata gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi Tavisi poziciis dasa-buTebisas, ra drosac is ara marto ar iziarebs braldebismowmeTa pirdapir Cvenebebs, romlebic a. b-s mkvlelobaSiamxelen, aramed saerTod uaryofs maT SesaZlo yofnasacki SemTxvevis adgilze, Tavidanve aRniSnavs: `bunebrivia,palata iziarebs braldebis mxaris argumentacias im na-wilSi, rom yvela mowmis Cveneba absoluturad identuriver iqneba, miTumetes amdeni wlis Semdeg, Tumca mtkice-bulebebi, romelsac unda daeyrdnos ganaCeni, unda iyosurTierTSesabamisi, isini ZiriTad da arsebiT garemoebeb-Tan dakavSirebiT unda emTxveodnen erTmaneTs. winaaR-mdeg SemTxvevaSi, rodesac erTsa da imave garemoebas mow-meebi gansxvavebulad aRweren, gansxvavebulad warmoaCe-nen SemTxvevis Semdeg maT mier ganxorcielebul qmede-bebs, gansxvavebulad gadmoscemen informacias SemTxve-vis adgilze myof sxva pirTa vinaobebis Sesaxeb da sxva,maTi Cvenebebi imTaviTve sarwmuno da gasaziarebeli veriqneba~. aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT ismeba legitimuri kiT-xva: marTebulia Tu ara momxdari danaSaulis TviTmxil-veli mowmeebis Cvenebebis Sefaseba imis mixedviT, Tu ro-gor iqceodnen isini imis Semdeg, rac TavianTi TvaliT ixi-les, anda ras yvebian ara TviTon faqtis monawile pirTamoqmedebebis, aramed _ momxdari SemTxvevis dros iq myo-fi sxva pirebis vinaobis Sesaxeb.

32. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlosmosazrebas imis Taobaze, rom mtkicebulebebi, romleb-sac eyrdnoba ganaCeni, unda iyos urTierTSesabamisi, isi-ni ZiriTad da arsebiT garemoebebTan dakavSirebiT undaemTxveodes erTmaneTs. magram am udavo debulebis prob-lemuri mxare, misi swori gagebidan gamomdinare, mdgoma-reobs imaSi, Tu ras SeiZleba moiazrebdes ganaCenis dam-dgeni sasamarTlo mtkicebulebebis urTierTSesabamiso-baSi, agreTve, `ZiriTadi~ da `arsebiTi~ garemoebebis cne-baSi. amasTan dakavSirebiT sakasacio palata ganmartavs,rom SeuZlebelia, mtkicebulebebis urTierTSesabamiso-bis kategoriaSi aucileblad maTi absoluturi Tanxved-

92

ra da identuroba vigulisxmoT, radgan aseTi ram mxolodiSviaT SemTxvevebSi SeiZleba moxdes, rodesac saqmeSi ar-sebobs obieqturi mtkicebulebebi, magaliTad, nivTmtki-cebebis an fotodokumentebis saxiT. rac Seexeba mowmeTaCvenebebs, gansakuTrebiT ki pirdapir Cvenebebs, aseTimtkicebulebebis Sinaarsze gavlenas axdens subieqturida obieqturi xasiaTis mravali faqtori, romelTa gauT-valiswineblobam SesaZloa, mcdar daskvnebamde migviyva-nos, rogorc TviT am mtkicebulebebis relevanturobis,aseve _ saqmis faqtobriv garemoebaTa Taobaze. amitom ase-Ti mtkicebulebebis Sefasebisas mxedvelobaSi unda iq-nes miRebuli: uSualod ra faqtorebi axdendnen zegav-lenas mowmis mier momxdari SemTxvevisas im garemoebebisaRqmaze, romlebic mtkicebis mTavar sagans warmoadgenen,da rogoria sxvadasxva mowmis Cvenebebis Tanxvedra aR-niSnul garemoebebTan dakavSirebiT. amasTan, mowmeTa Cve-nebebs Soris urTierTSesabamisobis arsebobis dasadge-nad savsebiT sakmarisia maT Soris Sinaarsobrivi Tanxved-ra im zomiT, rom isini erTgvarovnad warmogvidgendnensaqmisaTvis gadamwyveti mniSvnelobis mqone erTsa da ima-ve garemoebebs. aq sakasacio palatas mxedvelobaSi aqvsswored isini, romlebsac saapelacio sasamarTlo Tavis ga-naCenSi `ZiriTad~, `arsebiT~ garemoebebad moixseniebs.

33. Tuki obieqturi da miukerZoebeli midgomiT vixel-mZRvanelebT, rTuli ar aris imis danaxva, rom mowmeebi,romlebic pirdapir Cvenebebs iZlevian mocemul saqmeze,sruliad SemTxveviT aRmoCndnen danaSaulis adgilze anam adgilis siaxloves. amasTan, TiToeuli maTgani gansxva-vebuli mizezis gamo aRmoCnda iq da, rac mTavaria, isinierTmaneTisgan gansxvavebul viTarebaSi imyofebodnenmomxdari SemTxvevis danaxvisa da incidentis monawile-Ta Secnobisas. amasTan, aRniSnul mowmeebs sxvadasxva ad-gilidan, sxvadasxva manZilidan da sxvadasxva TvalTaxed-vis kuTxiT uxdebodaT movlenis mTavari momentebisa daam movlenis monawileTa moqmedebebis aRqma. yovelive aR-niSnulze miuTiTebs xsenebul mowmeTa Cvenebebis Sina-arsi, romlebic zemoT ukve iyo motanili. ase rom, sruli-ad bunebrivad gamoiyureba calkeul detalebSi maT So-ris arsebuli gansxvavebebi miTiTebul pirobaTa gaTva-liswinebiT. magram mTavari isaa, rom miuxedavad amgvari

93

gansxvavebisa, mowmeTa pirdapiri Cvenebebi erToblioba-Si adastureben ZiriTad da yvelaze arsebiT faqtobrivgaremoebebs: 1. ganxiluli SemTxveva namdvilad moxda 2004wlis 27 oqtombers, saRamos, daaxloebiT 19.00 saaTze, T-Si, k. g. (yofili p.) gamzirisa da m-is quCis gadakveTasTan,slotklub `g-is~ mimdebare teritoriaze; 2. am SemTxve-vis monawileebi namdvilad iyvnen aw gardacvlili d. o-ida a. b., romelTa Soris mimdinareobda konfliqti; 3. romam konfliqts a. b-is mxridan namdvilad gaaCnda motivi-rebuli xasiaTi da am ukanasknelis qmedeba, rac man gana-xorciela d. o-is mimarT, ar iyo gaufrTxilebeli; 4. ase-ve, swored a. b-m daartya dana orjer d. o-s _ pirveladsicocxlisaTvis mniSvnelovan gulmkerdis marcxena na-wilSi, xolo meored _ fexSi; 5. am momentSi SemTxvevis ad-gilze maT garda sxva piri, romelsac SeeZlo, daeWra d. o-i, ar imyofeboda; 6. a. b. d. o-is mimarT danis gamoyenebisasar imyofeboda aucilebeli mogeriebis viTarebaSi. miTi-Tebul garemoebebTan mimarTebiT mowmeebis: d. k-is, S. S-is, g. m-isa da l. b-is Cvenebebi erTmaneTs ar ewinaaRmdege-ba da isini urTierTSesabamisia.

34. sakasacio palatis azriT, SesaZlebelia, pirdapirimtkicebuleba, maT Soris pirdapiri Cvenebac, asaxavdesmomxdar faqts, magram ara mTlianad, aramed mxolod miserT, Tumca mniSvnelovan monakveTs. amitom mocemul Sem-TxvevaSi zemoaRniSnuli Cvenebebis garda, pirdapiri mtki-cebulebebis ricxvs unda miekuTvnos aseve mowme n. q-sCveneba, romelic am CvenebaSi gadmoscems imas, rac uSua-lod TviTon naxa da moismina. mxedvelobaSia a. b-sa da d.o-s Soris konfliqtis dawyebisa da ganviTarebis pirvelistadia. aRniSnuli mowme miuTiTebs, rom d. o-Tan dapi-rispirebul axalgazrdas ecva muqi tansacmeli, xolo Tav-ze exura e.w. `kepis~ qudi. igi gadmoscems aseve maTi daZa-buli saubrisa da cxare sityvieri dapirispirebis Sina-arss. yovelive es mowmem aRiqva im momentSi, roca SemTxve-viT maT gverdiT Caiara. a. b-is aseT Cacmulobas adastu-rebs aseve mowme d. k-e, romelic yvelaze axlos imyofe-boda SemTxvevis adgilTan. aq yuradRebas iqcevs Semdegigaremoeba: momxdari SemTxvevis dros a. b-is erTsa da ima-ve Cacmulobaze miuTiTebs ori, erTmaneTisgan sruliaddamoukidebeli da erTmaneTisTvis sruliad ucnobi mow-

94

me. Tanac, orive iseTi mowmea, romlebsac veranairad verdaswameb imas, rom isini SesaZloa, dainteresebuli yofi-liyvnen a. b-is winaaRmdeg cru Cvenebebis micemiT, radgann. q. saerTod ar icnobda dapirispirebul mxareebs, xolod. k-e mxolod Soridan icnobda maT, rogorc im ubnismcxovreblebs, sadac is sistematurad Txoulobda mow-yalebas. marTalia, am ori mowmis Cvenebebs Soris arsebobsgarkveuli, sakasacio palatis azriT, araarsebiTi sxvao-ba d. o-sa da a. b-s Soris gamarTuli kamaTis Sinaarsis Tao-baze, magram orive CvenebiT dasturdeba is garemoeba, roma. b-is moqmedeba subieqturi mxriv motivirebuli iyo, racganzraxvis arsebobaze metyvelebs, amasve adasturebs d.o-is sxeulis dazianebis lokalizacia da am Tvalsazri-siT gadamwyveti mniSvneloba ver mieniWeba imas, Tu ra iyomxareTa kamaTis sagani _ mobiluri telefoni, razedac mi-uTiTebs mowme n. q., Tu e.w. `Tavani~, romelzec mowme d. k-e saubrobs Tavis CvenebaSi.

35. rac Seexeba mowme m. l-is Cvenebas, romlis legiti-muroba kasator prokurorebsa da mocemuli saqmis gan-mxilvel mosamarTleebs Soris davis sagnad aris gamxda-ri, sakasacio palatis azriT, mas ar gaaCnia raime ganmsaz-Rvreli mniSvneloba am saqmisaTvis, kerZod, masSi naxse-neb garemoebas _ piri, romelic aginebda da emuqrebodaukve daWril d. o-s 2-3 wuTis ganmavlobaSi, gaiqca m-is qu-Cisken. saapelacio sasamarTlo svams kiTxvas: Tuki is pi-ri, romelic daWril d. o-s aginebda da emuqreboda, a. b.iyo da igi, aRniSnuli mowmis CvenebiT, 2_3 wuTis ganmav-lobaSi imyofeboda SemTxvevis adgilze, maSin ratom vermiuswres mas sxva mowmeebma, romlebic TavianT Cvenebeb-Si miuTiTeben, rom ver ipoves is, vinc d. o-i daWra, radganmaTi misvlisas SemTxvevis adgilidan is ukve wasuli iyo.saqme isaa, rom aq gasaTvaliswinebelia Semdegi garemoeba:aRniSnuli mowmeebi Tavdapirvelad daWrili d. o-isken ga-eSurnen, romelic ukve quCaze gadadioda, raTa gaerkvi-aT, Tu ra moxda. saamisod ki maT sakmao dro dasWirdebo-daT, radgan, sanam isini d. o-mde miaRwevdnen, unda gaeR-wiaT quCaze moZravi avtomanqanebis did nakadSi (es iyointensiuri moZraobis dro, e.w. `pikis saaTi~), amasobaSi kia. b-s Tavisuflad SeeZlo SemTxvevis adgilidan gaqceva,Tundac daWrili d. o-is mimarT 2_3-wuTiani ginebisa da

95

muqaris ganxorcielebis SemTxvevaSic, Tuki CavTvliT,rom mowmes zustad axsovda, Tu ramden wuTs grZeldebo-da a. b-is gineba.

36. saapelacio sasamarTlo, undoblobas gamoxatavs raim mowmeebis mimarT, romlebsac saqmeze micemuli aqvTpirdapiri Cvenebebi, agreTve im mowmeTa mimarT, romel-Ta arapirdapiri Cvenebebi adastureben xsenebuli pirda-piri Cvenebebis realurobas, saeWvos xdis yvela am mowmisSemTxvevis adgilze yofnas, aRniSnul Cvenebebs Soris ar-sebul garkveul SeusabamobaTa gamo. sakasacio palata aruaryofs am Seusabamobis arsebobas, ris Sesaxeb zemoTacaRiniSna, magram sakiTxavia _ ramdenad mniSvnelovani daarsebiTia es ukanaskneli. magaliTad, saapelacio sasamar-Tlo ganaCenSi aRniSnavs: mowmeebis _ n. q-s, j. m-sa da a. n-is Cvenebebidan gamomdinare, d. o-sa da a. b-s Soris daviswarmoSobisa da konfliqtis mizezi mobiluri telefoniunda yofiliyo da braldebis mxarec am versias uWersmxars. magram, vinaidan gamoZiebas aRniSnuli telefonismesakuTre ar daudgenia, braldebis mxaris es versia arunda iqnes gaziarebuli, miTumetes, rom mowme d. k-is Cve-nebis mixedviT, xsenebul mxareTa Soris dapirispirebismizezi iyo e.w. `Tavanis~ sakiTxi. sakasacio palata ver da-eTanxmeba aseT msjelobas, radgan Seqmnili viTarebis ga-mo (daWrili d. o-i gardaicvala, xolo a. b. miimala) mobi-luri telefoni ver amoiRes, ris gareSec misi mesakuTrisdadgena SeuZlebeli iyo. mowme d. k-is CvenebasTan dakav-SirebiT ki gasaTvaliswinebelia Semdegi garemoeba: igimomxdar SemTxvevamdec ramdenime xniT adre Seeswro d.o-sa da a. b-s Soris kamaTs `TavanTan~ dakavSirebiT. mangamoZiebas Cveneba misca didi xnis _ 11 wlis Semdeg, risgamoc savsebiT SesaZlebelia, rom mas maxsovrobaSi darCadava `Tavanis~ da ara _ telefonis Taobaze. mowme n. q-em kigamoZiebas Cveneba misca momxdari SemTxvevis Semdeg. ami-tom mas kargad axsovda, rom davis sagani mobiluri tele-foni iyo. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom araviTari arse-biTi mniSvneloba ar aqvs imas, Tu ra iyo konfliqtis mize-zi _ mobiluri telefoni, `Tavani~ Tu kidev sxva ram. mTa-vari isaa, rac erTgvarovnad dgindeba mowmeebis rogorcpirdapiri, aseve arapirdapiri Cvenebebidan, rom namdvi-lad arsebobda konfliqtis realuri mizezi da, maSasada-

96

me, a. b-is mier d. o-is mimarT Cadenil qmedebas gaaCndaTavisi Sesabamisi subieqturi safuZveli _ saTanado mo-tivacia.

37. saapelacio sasamarTlo sarwmunod ar miiCnevs mow-me d. k-is yofnas SemTxvevis adgilze Semdegi motiviT: igiTavis CvenebaSi uTiTebs, rom urTierTdapirispirebamded. o-i slotklubSi iyo, saidanac is gamoiyvana a. b-m da mas`Tavanis~ dabruneba mosTxova, xolo d. o-i ki saamisod gar-kveul dros moiTxovda, ris safuZvelzec gaRvivda maTSoris konfliqti. sxva mowmeebi ki (j. m-i, a. n-i, n. g-i) Tavi-anT CvenebebSi miuTiTeben, rom d. o-i da a. b. erTmaneTsSemTxveviT Sexvdnen slotklubis gareT, mis mimdebareteritoriaze da ara _ slotklubSi. sakasacio palatis az-riT, aRniSnuli winaaRmdegoba ver gamoricxavs mowme d.k-is SemTxvevis adgilze yofnas, radgan SesaZlebelia Cve-nebis micemisas mowme d. k-es, zemoaRniSnuli mizezis ga-mo, d. o-isa da a. b-is slotklubSi Sexvedra axsovda, mag-ram iseve rogorc sxva TviTmxilveli mowmeebi, isic imazemiuTiTebs, rom maTi Sexvedris Semdeg mxareebs Soris kon-fliqti swored slotklubis gareT ganviTarda da dasrul-da a. b-is mier d. o-is daWriT. garda amisa, sakasacio pala-ta momxdari SemTxvevis dros mowme d. k-is iq yofnas da-dasturebulad miiCnevs Semdegi garemoebidan gamomdi-nare: mowme n. g-is Cvenebis mixedviT, mowme d. k-e momxda-ri SemTxvevisTanave xvdeba mas da eubneba d. o-is zedmetsaxels, romelic am ukanasknelma ar icoda, Tavis mxriv,d. k-emac ar icoda d. o-is namdvili saxeli da gvari. aRsa-niSnavia, rom imaves ambobs mowme n. q. Tavis CvenebaSi, romman SemTxvevis Semdeg swored d. k-isgan Seityo, rom `a-m~daWra d. o-i. aRniSnuli garemoeba amyarebs im versias, romdasaxelebuli samive mowme namdvilad imyofeboda Sem-Txvevis adgilze da maT gamoZiebaSi Cvenebis micemisas ve-ravin ukarnaxebda d. o-is zedmet saxels. am pirobebSi ga-ugebaria saapelacio sasamarTlos mosazreba imis Taoba-ze, rom mowmeebis _ n. q-sa da n. g-is Cvenebebi ar warmoad-gens mowme d. k-is SemTxvevis adgilze yofnis damadastu-rebel pirdapir mtkicebulebebs da es maSin, rodesac aR-niSnuli Cvenebebis mixedviT, mowmeebma _ n. g-ma da n. q-emswored iq naxes d. k-e da swored misgan Seityves momxda-ris Sesaxeb. garda amisa, d. k-e Tavis CvenebaSi imasac aR-

97

niSnavs, rom konfliqtis dasrulebis Semdeg `a.~ anu a. b.aginebda `u-s~ (d. o-s), Tavis mxriv, es ukanasknelic agi-nebda a. b-s. zemoT ukve iyo saubari imis Taobaze, rom mow-me m. l-ec uTiTebs Tavis CvenebaSi, Tu erTi axalgazrdarogor aginebda slotklubis mimdebare teritoriidansxva axalgazrdebs, romelTa vinaoba man ar icoda. gardaamisa, axalgazrdebs Soris momxdar ginebis faqts adas-turebs agreTve mowme z. m-e Tavis CvenebaSi. Tumca, misiCvenebis mixedviT, axalgazrda, romelic meores agineb-da, erT adgilze ar mdgara, rogorc amas aRniSnavs mowmem. l-e, aramed is garboda m-is quCisken da swored am drosaginebda p. quCisken mimaval meore axalgazrdas. erTmane-Tisgan sruliad damoukidebeli da erTmaneTisTvis uc-nobi sami mowmis mier TavianT CvenebaSi momxdar SemTxve-vasTan dakavSirebuli erTsa da imave garemoebis dadas-tureba, romelTagan erTi Cveneba pirdapiria, xolo oriki _ iribi, udavod adasturebs imas, rom samive mowme rea-lurad imyofeboda SemTxvevis adgilze. aRsaniSnavia, romsaapelacio sasamarTlo saeWvod ar miiCnevs mowme n. q-sCvenebas, ndobas ucxadebs aseve mowmeebis _ m. l-isa da z.m-is Cvenebebs. magram sasamarTlos mier ignorirebuliaam ori mowmisa da mowme d. k-is Cvenebebis, aseve am ukanas-knelis Cvenebis mowmeebis _ n. q-sa da n. g-is CvenebebTanTanxvdeniloba, radgan maTi korelacia safuZvels aclisvarauds imis Taobaze, rom mowme d. k-e ar imyofeboda Sem-Txvevis adgilze da is ar aris faqtis TviTmxilveli mow-me. zemoaRniSnuli garemoebebidan gamomdinare, sakasaciopalata aseT varauds ver gaiziarebs misi usafuZvlobisgamo. SeuZlebelia aqve ar aRiniSnos aSkara winaaRmdego-baze saapelacio sasamarTlos poziciaSi mowme d. k-esTanmimarTebiT. erTi mxriv, sasamarTlo dabejiTebiT askvnis,rom d. k-e SemTxvevis adgilze ar yofila, magram amavedros mowme m. l-is Cvenebis sisworis Sesamowmeblad dadasadastureblad sasamarTlo iSveliebs swored mowme d.k-is Cvenebas, kerZod, es mowmec imave garemoebas adastu-rebs, romelzec mowme m. l-e miuTiTebso (mxedvelobaSiaa. b-is mxriv daWrili d. o-is gineba). ismeba logikuri kiT-xva: Tuki d. k-e SemTxvevis adgilze saerTod ar yofilada araferi unaxavs, rogorRa adasturebs SemTxvevis ad-gilze myofi m. l-is mier aRweril garemoebas, an am Sem-

98

TxvevaSi sasamarTlo ratom ujerebs d. k-es, gaugebaria.sasamarTlo gverds ver uvlis im faqts, rom mowme n. q-ecuTiTebs Tavis CvenebaSi d. k-eze, rom am ukanasknelma uT-xra mas, rac moxda, Tanac uSualod momxdari SemTxvevisSemdeg. Tu sasamarTlo mowme n. q-sa da mis Cvenebas san-dod miiCnevs, maSin Cndeba kiTxva: ratom ar iziarebs amCvenebas im nawilSi, romelic mowme d. k-es exeba? arc amkiTxvaze Cans pasuxi gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi. aqve undaaRiniSnos Semdegi garemoebac _ miuxedavad imisa, rom er-Tsa da imave faqtTan mimarTebaSi mowmeebis _ m. l-isa daz. m-is Cvenebebi aSkarad gansxvavdeba erTmaneTisgan, amisgamo saapelacio sasamarTlos ratomRac es Cvenebebi sa-eWvod ar miuCnevia da am SemTxvevaSi arc is daskvna gamo-utania, rom aRniSnuli mowmeebi SemTxvevis adgilze aryofilan.

38. sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebs mowme l.b-is pirdapir Cvenebaze, romlis sarwmunoobas saapela-cio sasamarTlo aseve saeWvod miiCnevs, rac ganpirobebu-lia misi araadekvaturi SefasebiT. saapelacio sasamarTloaRniSnul Cvenebas srul undoblobas ucxadebs or Ziri-Tad argumentze dayrdnobiT. pirveli maTgani mdgomare-obs SemdegSi: Tuki l. b-i namdvilad imyofeboda SemTxve-vis adgilze da Seeswro momxdar faqts, maSin ratom verSeamCnia im momentSi aRniSnul teritoriaze myofi Tavisinacnobebi _ g. m-e, S. S-e, j. m-i da a. n-i, romlebic TavianTCvenebebSi miuTiTeben, rom momxdari SemTxvevis dros imadgilis mimdebare teritoriaze imyofebodnen. rogorcsasamarTlo aRniSnavs, l. b-i Tavis CvenebaSi am pirTaganarcerTi maTganis yofnas ar adasturebs SemTxvevis ad-gilze, saidanac gamoaqvs daskvna, rom mowme l. b-i aras-wor Cvenebas iZleva da is saerTod ar yofila SemTxvevisadgilze. meore argumenti, romliTac saapelacio sasamar-Tlo cdilobs, gaamagros mowme l. b-is SemTxvevis adgil-ze aryofnis versia, gamoixateba imaSi, rom is svams kiT-xvas: Tuki SemTxvevis adgilze imyofeboda l. b-i, ratomar gauCnda mas survili, misuliyo daWril megobarTan dadaxmareboda mas, amis nacvlad, man miatova SemTxvevis ad-gili da, rogorc TviTon aRniSnavs Tavis CvenebaSi, mego-bar gogonasTan Sesaxvedrad wavida.

39. ganvixiloT TiToeuli argumentis safuZvlianoba

99

cal_calke. pirvel rigSi, rac Seexeba saapelacio sasamar-Tlos mosazrebas mowme l. b-is mier momxdari SemTxvevisadgilze sxva, zemoT dasaxelebuli mowmeebis ardanaxvi-sa Tu verdanaxvis mizezs, unda aRiniSnos Semdegi: zemoTukve iyo motanili sakmaod vrceli amonaridebi mowme l.b-is Cvenebidan. erTi mniSvnelovani nawili am CvenebisaSinaarsobrivad exeba uSualod mis mier danaxul, d. o-sada a. b-s Soris mimdinare konfliqtis im momentebs, ro-melTa danaxvac man SeZlo da moaswro, vidre SemTxvevisadgilis mimdebare teritorias datovebda. Cvenebis am na-wilis mixedviT, man SeamCnia daZabuli urTierToba xsene-buli konfliqtis monawileebs Soris. man dainaxa aseve,Semdeg rogor gadaizarda es konfliqti fizikur dapiris-pirebaSi, ra drosac d. o-i Caikeca da aseT mdgomareobaSimyofs a. b-m dana daartya. dana mas marjvena xelSi eWira.aRniSnuli mowmis Cvenebis es nawili sayuradReboa immxriv, rom sxva mowmeebis (g. m-e, S. S-e) pirdapiri Cvenebis-gan gansxvavebiT, mas ar daunaxavs a. b-is mier d. o-isaTvisgulmkerdis areSi danis pirveli dartma. ufro metic, mow-me l. b-i imasac ki ver ambobs dazustebiT, a. b-m sxeulis ranawilSi daartya dana Zirs Cakecil d. o-s. Tuki gavizia-rebT saapelacio sasamarTlos versias l. b-is Cvenebisada sxva mowmeebis Cvenebebis (g. m-is, S. S-is) SesaZlo winas-war SeTanxmebaze, maSin erTob alogikurad gamoiyureba,rom am Cvenebebis SemTanxmeblebma ratomRac ar izrunesimaze, rom am Cvenebebs Soris Sinaarsobrivad meti Tan-xvedra yofiliyo, maTi damajereblobis xarisxisa da ro-gorc mtkicebulebis wonis asamaRleblad. ra uSlida xelsl. b-s Tavis CvenebaSi danis erTi dartymis magivrad ordartymaze mieTiTebina? arc araferi. maS ra aris am mniS-vnelovan momentTan dakavSirebiT misi Cvenebis sxva, `mas-Tan SeTanxmebuli~ mowmeebis Cvenebebisgan gansxvavebismizezi? aseTi mizezi ki swored is garemoebaa, romelicsaapelacio sasamarTlos ratomRac aradamajereblad mi-aCnia _ l. b-i, romelic momxdari SemTxvevis erT-erTiTviTmxilveli mowmea, gulwrfelad yveba mxolod imas,rac piradad dainaxa im adgilidan, sadac imyofeboda a. b-isa da d. o-is dapirispirebis momentSi. is ar cdilobs, ra-ime daamatos da xelovnurad Seavsos Tavisi monayoliimiT, rac mas ar SeumCnevia. yovelive es udavod miuTi-

100

Tebs am mowmis pirdapiri Cvenebis realur xasiaTze da aramis xelovnur warmoSobaze. davubrundeT im mniSvnelo-van kiTxvas, romelsac svams saapelacio sasamarTlo daromelic ukavSirdeba am Cvenebis sarwmunoobas. ratom verdainaxa mowme l. b-a Tavisi nacnobi sxva mowmeebi SemTxve-vis adgilze, Tuki igi marTlac iq imyofeboda? am kiTxva-ze pasuxis gasacemad isev unda mivmarToT l. b-is CvenebaszemoT moxmobili amonarididan. am Cvenebis mixedviT, l.b-i SemTxvevis adgilze ar yofila misuli Tavisi nacnobe-bidan Tu megobrebidan vinmes naxvis mizniT, is am adgili-dan apirebda megobar gogonasTan Sesaxvedrad wasvlas dasamarSruto mikroavtobuss elodeboda. amitom sruliadbunebrivia, rom d. o-sa da a. b-s Soris konfliqtis dawye-bamde, is ar dainteresebula, axlomaxlo teritoriaze maTgarda kidev vin moZraobda, an vin sad imyofeboda. sruli-ad bunebrivia isic, rom man movlenebis ganviTarebis jerkidev adreul etapze dainaxa a. b-sa da d. o-Tan axlos myo-fi n. g-i, romelic Semdeg, xsenebul pirTa Soris daZabu-lobis warmoSobisa da maT fizikur dapirispirebaSi gadaz-rdisas, ukve aRar daunaxavs da verc dainaxavda, radgan n.g-ma am momentamde karga xniT adre datova SemTxvevis ad-gili, quCa gadakveTa da afTiaqSi Sevida. am mimarTebiT l.b-isa da n. g-s Cvenebebi Tanxvdenilia, rac saapelacio sa-samarTlos mxedvelobidan gamorCa. n. g-i Tavis CvenebaSiaRniSnavs, rom arc konfliqtamde da arc konfliqtis Sem-deg SemTxvevis adgilze mowme d. k-is garda aravin una-xavs. esec sruliad bunebrivad gamoiyureba, Tuki mis na-ambobs cru Cvenebad ar miviCnevT, radgan n. g-s araviTarimotivi da mizezi ar SeiZleboda hqonoda cru Cvenebis mi-sacemad da am Cvenebis mowme l. b-Tan winaswar SesaTan-xmeblad. misi Cvenebis mixedviT ki, rogorc zemoT vnaxeT,is SemTxvevis adgilze a. b-sTan erTad mivida, sadac maTSexvdaT d. o-i, romelsac is ar icnobda. maTi SexvedrisSemdeg n. g-i ar dainteresebula d. o-isa da a. b-is saub-riT, maleve datova iqauroba da quCis meore mxareze mde-bare afTiaqSi gadavida. rodesac 10-15 wuTis Semdeg is ukanmobrunda SemTxvevis adgilze, iq ukve yvelaferi damTav-rebuli iyo da mas d. k-em uTxra, rac iq moxda mis misvlam-de. aseT viTarebaSi, is garemoeba, rom l. b-ma Tavidan da-inaxa n. g-i SemTxvevis adgilze, Semdeg ki is aRar dauna-

101

xavs, radgan man a. b-is mier d. o-isaTvis danis dartymisdanaxvisTanave datova SemTxvevis adgili, xolo n. g-s, Ta-vis mxriv, saerTod ar daunaxavs l. b-i, romelic zemoaR-niSnuli Sexvedris adgilidan 20_25 metris moSorebiT im-yofeboda, ver gaxdeba im daskvnis gamotanis safuZveli,rom mowmeebi _ l. b-i da n. g-i cru Cvenebebs iZlevian. sa-gulisxmoa, rom saapelacio sasamarTloc ver uTiTebs Ta-vis ganaCenSi raime iseT xelSesaxeb safuZvels, rac dama-jerebels gaxdida maT warmoCenas dainteresebul mowme-ebad. am ganmartebis Semdeg SeiZleba ganvixiloT is sakiT-xic, Tu ratom ver dainaxa l. b-ma SemTxvevis adgilze sxvamowmeebi _ S. S-e da g. m-e, aseve j. m-i da a. n-i. amasTan da-kavSirebiT unda gaviTvaliswinoT Semdegi garemoebebi:SemTxvevis adgili mdebareobs T-Si, k. g. (yofili p.) gamzi-risa da m-is quCis gadakveTasTan, slotklub `g-is~ mimde-bare teritoriaze, mis win. momxdar SemTxvevamde daax-loebiT 7_8 wuTiT adre, l. b-ma mopirdapire mxridan ga-dakveTa k. g. gamziri da gaCerda slotklub `g-isgan~ 20-30metris moSorebiT, sadac is elodeboda samarSruto mik-roavtobuss, raTa gamgzavrebuliyo x-is quCisken. xuTiwuTis Semdeg slotklub `g-Tan~ gamoCndnen a. b. da n. g_i,savaraudod _ m-is quCis mxridan, sadac isini Sexvdnen d.o-s, romelTanac a. b-m daiwyo saubari, xolo n. g-ma isinidatova da gadakveTa k. g. gamziri. es pirebi l. b-ma dainaxaimis gamo, rom maT mxares uwevda yureba, radgan sworedimave mxridan elodeboda samarSruto mikroavtobusismosvlas. dazustebiT rom iTqvas, miTiTebul dros isini,yvelani, imyofebian k. g. gamziris erTsa da imave mxareze,slotklub `g-Tan~ da mis Soriaxlos mdebare `j-is~ ofis-Tan. amitom aRmoCndnen isini l. b-is mxedvelobis areSi.am momentSi zemoxsenebuli pirebi _ g. m-e, S. S-e, a. n-i da j.m-i imyofebodnen k. g. gamziris meore, mopirdapire mxa-res, iq arsebul saxaWapuresTan. sruliad naTelia, rom l.b-i bevrad axlos unda yofiliyo SemTxvevis adgilTan,vidre gamziris mopirdapire mxareze myofi zemoxsenebu-li pirebi. maSasadame, SemTxvevis adgilze viTarebis da-Zabvamde da konfliqtis dawyebamde l. b-i gamziris meoremxareze myof pirebs ver dainaxavda, radgan am dros masyuradReba sul sxva mxares hqonda mipyrobili. Semdeg ki,rodesac dainaxa a. b-is mier d. o-is daWra, misi ganmarte-

102

biT, man maSinve datova SemTxvevis adgili da gaemarTa sas-tumro à.~ (amJamad sastumro `h-i~) mimarTulebiT, Tumcaimis danaxva ki moaswro, rogor daiwyo gamziris gadakve-Ta daWrilma d. o-ma. gamziris meore mxares, `saxaWapures-Tan~ myofma S. S-em, j. m-ma da sxvebma mxolod mas Semdegdaiwyes moZraoba daWrili d. o-isken, roca man mopirdapi-re mxridan daiwyo gamziris gadakveTa. am droisaTvis l.b-i ukve sakmao manZiliTaa daSorebuli SemTxvevis adgi-lidan da moZraobs gamziris mopirdapire mxareze sastum-ro à.~ mimarTulebiT. aseT pirobebSi gaugebaria, saape-lacio sasamarTlos saidan gamoaqvs kategoriuli daskvna,rom l. b-s aucileblad unda daenaxa zemoaRniSnuli pire-bi. man cota xnis Semdeg ukan moixeda SemTxvevis adgilis-ken, magram, misi ganmartebiT, iq ukve bevri xalxi iyo Sek-rebili. cxadia, rom maT Soris is nacnobebis moZiebasa dagamorCevas ar daiwyebda, miTumetes Tu gaviTvaliswinebT,rom l. b-i im momentSi araviTar survils ar iCens raimesaerTo iqonios momxdar faqtTan, miuxedavad dapirispi-erbul mxareebTan misi axlo nacnobobisa. is saerTod gae-rida SemTxvevis adgils da wavida megobar gogonasTan Se-saxvedrad. aqve unda aRiniSnos is garemoebac, rom saape-lacio sasamarTlo Tavis ganaCenSi zogjer mowmis Cvene-bis arazust interpretacias mimarTavs, razedac sworadamaxvilebs yuradRebas braldebis mxare Tavis sakasaciosaCivarSi. kerZod, saapelacio sasamarTlo mowme l. b-isCvenebis Taobaze aRniSnavs, rom is ar adasturebs arcer-Ti zemoT CamoTvlili piris (aq sasamarTlo gulisxmobssaqmeSi monawile ZiriTad mowmeebs, romelTa Cvenebebsaceyrdnoboda braldeba) SemTxvevis mimdebared yofnisa dadanaxvis faqts. mas arc S. S-e daunaxavs. magram saqme isaa,rom l.b-i Tavis CvenebaSi ar aRniSnavs _ ar vadasturebSemTxvevis adgilze an am adgilis mimdebare teritoria-ze aRniSnul pirTa yofnaso, aramed is ganmartavs: ìq im-deni xalxi iyo, rom SesaZlebelia Cemi nacnobebic yofi-liyvnen, iyvnen gamvlelebic. S. S-es vicnob, im dros sadiyo, ar vici. g. m-esac vicnob, im dros sad iyo, ar vici, me isar minaxavs. Semdeg mowme azustebs _ im momentSi ar mina-xavs, SesaZlebelia im dRes vnaxe kidec, magram im momen-tSi ar minaxavs. S. S-ezec imave pasuxs gagcemT~. sakasaciopalatis azriT, aRniSnuli mowmis Cvenebis realur Sina-

103

arssa da saapelacio sasamarTlos mier am Sinaarsis inter-pretacias Soris mniSvnelovani da arsebiTi gansxvavebaa,rac imaSi gamoixateba, rom rogorc vxedavT, mowme l. b-iTavis CvenebaSi ar gamoricxavs SemTxvevis adgilze an mismimdebare teritoriaze zemoxsenebul mowmeTa SesaZloyofnas. gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi ki mowmis Cvenebis es nawi-li sawinaaRmdego mniSvnelobiTaa warmoCenili. sakasaciopalatas ararelevanturad miaCnia saapelacio sasamar-Tlos meore argumentic, romelzec zemoT ukve aRiniSnada romlis safuZvelzec is cdilobs, saeWvod miiCniosmowme l. b-is Cvenebis siswore, imaze miTiTebiT, rom: a. b-is mier d. o-is daWris danaxvisTanave, ratom ar gaeSuramisken dasaxmareblad; amis nacvlad ratom miatova man Sem-Txvevis adgili da wavida megobar gogonasTan Sesaxved-rad; ratom ar gauCnda survili Tundac gardacvlili d.o-is ojaxis wevrebisTvis eamba imis Sesaxeb, rac SemTxve-vis adgilze dainaxa; ratom dumda didi xnis ganmavlobaSida 11 wlis Semdeg ratom gauCnda survili, gamoZiebisTvisCveneba mieca momxdari faqtis Taobaze da sxv. ise gamo-dis, rom Tuki piriqiT moxdeboda, kerZod, l. b-i maSinvegaiqceoda daWrili d. o-is misaSveleblad, amis Semdeg kidawvrilebiT mouyveboda gardacvlilis ojaxis wevrebsimis Sesaxeb, rac naxa, amasTan, sagamoZiebo organoebSicsaCqarod gamocxaddeboda da miscemda Cvenebas, maSin mi-si Cveneba sruliad uapelaciod SegveZlo migveRo rogorcudavo WeSmariteba da sarwmuno mtkicebuleba. rbiladrom iTqvas, mowmis Cvenebis sarwmunoobis amgvari krite-riumebiT Sefaseba erTob Seusabamoa saamisod mtkicebissamarTliT aRiarebul da Sesabamisi saproceso samar-Tlebrivi normebiT gansazRvrul institutebTan, miTuf-ro maSin, rodesac sakiTxi exeba ara ukve mowiful adami-ans, aramed _ 14-15 wlis mozards (daaxloebiT aseT asakSiiyo l. b-i, rodesac is momxdari SemTxvevis uneblie mowmegaxda). erTob ararealuria aseTi asakis mozards mosTxo-vo, rom Tavisi qcevebisas maRalzneobrivi, samarTlebri-vi movaleobisadmi maRali moqalaqeobrivi pasuxismgeblo-biTa da marTlSegnebiT ixelmZRvanelos, rac aramcTu mo-zardebis, aramed ukve mowifuli adamianebis SegnebaSicki Znelad yalibdeba da zogjer amis miRweva Zalze rTulamocanas warmoadgens. ukve mowiful asakSi myofi mowme

104

l. b-i Tavis imJamindel saqciels sruliad gulwrfeladda Seulamazeblad gadmoscems, aRniSnavs, rom im momen-tSi is daibna, radgan movlenebis iseT ganviTarebas, racrealurad moxda, ar moeloda amitom axlac ver xsnis, ra-tom moiqca maSin ise, rasac mas sasamarTlo sayvedurobsTavis ganaCenSi. rac Seexeba saapelacio sasamarTlos mi-er gamoTqmul eWvebs, Tu ra mizezis gamo gauCnda mowme l.b-s TerTmeti wlis Semdeg survili, rom mocemul saqmezeCveneba mieca gamoZiebisa da sasamarTlosaTvis, amasTandakavSirebiT sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom am saqmeSimonawile mowmeebidan Tavisi iniciativiT mxolod erTma_ S. S-em mimarTa Tavisi advokatis meSveobiT sagamoZieboorganoebs Cvenebis misacemad. yvela danarCeni mowmis ar-seboba ki sagamoZiebo organoebma daadgines da miakiTxeskidec TiToeul maTgans, ris gamoc isini, maT Soris l. b-ic, Tavs ver aaridebdnen Cvenebis micemas, radgan, wina-aRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, isini sakuTar Tavs sisxlissamar-Tlebrivi pasuxismgeblobis winaSe daayenebdnen. amrigad,zemoaRniSnuli garemoebebidan gamomdinare, ar moipove-ba raime iseTi realuri da dasabuTebuli safuZveli, rom-lis gamoc marTebuli iqneboda saeWvod migveCnia da argagveziarebina a. b-is mier d. o-is mkvlelobis saqmeze mow-me l. b-is mier sasamarTlosaTvis micemuli Cveneba.

40. calke unda aRiniSnos saapelacio sasamarTlosmsjelobebze saqmeSi arsebuli ori mowmis _ S. S-isa da g.m-is pirdapir CvenebebTan dakavSirebiT, romlebsac is ariziarebs, xolo am mowmeebs srul undoblobas ucxadebs,ZiriTadad, imave argumentebis moSveliebiT, romlebsacsasamarTlo eyrdnoba mowme l. b-is pirdapiri Cvenebis uki-duresad negatiuri Sefasebisas. rogorc zemoT ukve aRi-niSna, sasamarTlo am SemTxvevaSic aRniSnul mowmeTa Cve-nebebs saeWvod acxadebs im motiviT, rom momxdari Sem-Txvevidan 11 wlis Semdeg ratom gauCndaT maT survili,eTanamSromlaT gamoZiebasTan da miecaT Cvenebebi am saq-meze, Tuki manamde amdeni xnis ganmavlobaSi dumdnen. amas-Tan dakavSirebiT ukve iTqva, rom mowme g. m-e, iseve ro-gorc saqmeSi monawile sxva mowmeebi (garda S. S-isa), Tavi-si iniciativiT ar gamocxadebulan sagamoZiebo organoSida ar gamouTqvamT Cvenebis micemis survili. maTi arse-boba sagamoZiebo organom daadgina mowme S. S-is Cvenebis

105

meSveobiT, ris Semdegac gamoiZaxa isini Cvenebis misace-mad. rac Seexeba mowme S. S-is mier gamoCenil iniciativas,miemarTa da Cveneba mieca sagamoZiebo organosaTvis, TviTsaapelacio sasamarTloc ver uaryofs Tavis ganaCenSi sa-marTalSi micemuli piris aseT uflebas, Tundac bralde-bis mxarisgan garkveuli SeRavaTebis misaRebad masTan Ta-namSromlobis sanacvlod. ufro metic, sasamarTlo ima-sac aRniSnavs, rom mocemul SemTxvevaSi ar gaaCnia safuZ-veli aRniSnul garemoebasTan dakavSirebiT dacvis mxa-ris versiis dadasturebulad miCnevisaTvis, romlis mi-xedviT, aRniSnulma mowmeebma, romlebic Cvenebebis mi-cemisas sasjels erTad ixdidnen, SesaZloa, swored SeRa-vaTebis misaRebad misces cru Cvenebebi braldebul a. b-is winaaRmdeg da braldebis mxarem SesTavaza aseTi SeRa-vaTebi S. S-esa da g. m-es. miuxedavad amisa, sasamarTlo,xsenebuli garemoebis gamo, mainc saeWvod miiCnevs maTCvenebebs braldebis mxaris mier am eWvis gasaqarwyleb-lad mtkicebulebebis warmoudgenlobis gamo. sakasaciopalatis azriT, gaugebaria, saapelacio sasamarTlos ramtkicebulebebi aqvs mxedvelobaSi an saidan, ra wyaroe-bidan unda moepovebina braldebis mxares aseTi mtkice-bulebebi. aSkaraa, sasamarTlo arapirdapir mianiSnebs,rom mowmeebis _ S. S-isa da g. m-is mier gamoZiebisa da sasa-marTlosaTvis Cvenebebis micemis mizezi sanacvlo SeRa-vaTebis miRebis interesi iyo da sxva araferi, Tumca saq-meSi araviTari monacemi ar arsebobs amgvari versiis dasa-dastureblad da saamisod raime faqtobrivi safuZvlisarsebobaze ganaCenSi araferia aRniSnuli. amitom sakasa-cio palata ver miiCnevs safuZvlianad da dasabuTebuladsaapelacio sasamarTlos msgavs msjelobebs, maT Sorisimis Taobaze, rom mowmeebis _ S. S-isa da g. m-is CvenebebzeSesaZloa, gavlena moexdina erTsa da imave sakanSi erTsada imave dros maT mier sasjelis erTad moxdas da am gare-moebis gamoyenebiT aRniSnuli Cvenebebis Taobaze maT Se-saZlo urTierTSeTanxmebas. magram aseTi versiis safuZ-vlianoba baTildeba Semdegi garemoebiT: saapelacio sa-samarTlo ganaCenSi sakmaod vrcel analizs uTmobs im wi-naaRmdegobebis warmoCenas, rac, misi azriT, maT CvenebebsSoris arsebobs. sakasacio palata kidev erTxel aRniSnavs,rom sruliad logikuria kiTxva: Tuki xsenebul mowmeebs

106

Cvenebebi winaswar hqondaT urTierTSeTanxmebuli, maSinratomaa winaaRmdegobebi maT Soris, am mowmeebs xom sak-marisze meti droc da pirobebic hqondaT saimisod, romTviT umciresi detalebic ki SeeTanxmebinaT erTamaneTi-saTvis? am kiTxvaze gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis Sinaarsi veriZleva veranair pasuxs. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rommowmeebis _ S. S-sa da g. m-is CvenebebSi SeiZleba marTlacaRmovaCinoT garkveuli Seusabamobebi, magram ara iseTifataluri winaaRmdegobani, ris gamoc dasabuTebuli sa-fuZveli gveqneboda, gonivruli eWvi Segvetana maT sis-woreSi da saerTod, am mowmeebis SemTxvevis adgilze yof-naSi iq mimdinare movlenebis dros. aq aucileblad undaiTqvas im garemoebazec, romelTan dakavSirebiTac samar-Tlianad apelirebs braldebis mxare Tavis sakasacio sa-CivarSi. rodesac saapelacio sasamarTlo gasaCivrebul ga-naCenSi zemoxsenebul Seusabamobebs seriozul winaaR-mdegobebad miiCnevs, amis dasabuTebisas aRniSnuli mow-meebis Cvenebebidan aRebuli calkeuli monakveTis Sina-arsis arazust interpretacias axdens Cvenebis mTlianikonteqstidan mowyvetiT. magaliTad, ganaCenSi miTiTebu-lia: S. S-e acxadebs, rom mas quCa ar gadaukveTavs (igulis-xmeba a. b-is mier d. o-is daWris Semdeg mimdinare movlene-bi), magram sul sxva rames vigebT mowme S. S-is dakiTxvisoqmidan, kerZod, mowme ambobs: àm dros, marTalia, dabne-uli viyavi da, principSi, arc ki vicodi, ra unda gamekeTe-bina, magram erTaderTi, TavSi azrad rac momivida _ quCisgadakveTa iyo, sirbiliT gadavkveTe quCa~. axla isic vna-xoT, imave moments rogor ixsenebs mowme g. m-e (amonaridisasamarTloSi micemuli Cvenebidan): àm dros me da S-e ga-viqeciT iqiTken. à.~ gaiqca da CixSi Sevarda, me mas martoveZebdi. rom gamoviqeciT, mere S. S-isTvis aRar mimiqce-via yuradReba. me da S. S-e rom gaviqeciT, j-c garboda d.o-Tan~. analogiuri mdgomareobaa maSinac, rodesac saape-lacio sasamarTlo ganaCenSi msjelobs winaaRmdegobis ar-sebobaze, erTi mxriv, a. n-isa da j. m-s, xolo, meore mxriv,S. S-isa da g. m-is Cvenebebs Soris, am ukanasknelebis Sem-Txvevis adgilze yofna _ aryofnis sakiTxTan dakavSire-biT. sasamarTlos mier ganaCenSi isea warmoCenili, romTiTqos, S. S-e da g. m-e TavianT CvenebebSi gacxadebul ga-remoebas, rom momxdar SemTxvevamde k. g. gamziris mopir-

107

dapire mxares, saxaWapuresTan, maT dainaxes j. m-i da a. n-i sxva pirebTan erTad, es ukanasknelebi kategoriuladgamoricxaven da saerTod uaryofen zemoxsenebuli orimowmis aRniSnul adgilze yofnas. sinamdvileSi a. n-ma sa-samarTloSi dakiTxvisas ganacxada Semdegi: `ver getyviT,bodiSs vixdi, imdeni droa gasuli, saerTod ar maxsovs iqgarSemo iyo Tu ara vinme, CemTan da j-sTan erTad aravinar yofila, Cven marto viyaviT, magram garSemo vin iyo, ma-gaze verafers mogaxsenebT~. maSasadame, irkveva, rom sa-xaWapuris mimdebare teritoriaze, sxvadasxva adgilze im-yofebian _ S. S-e, g. m-esTan erTad, da j. m-i, a. n-Tan erTad,ra drosac S. da g. amCneven j-s, rogorc TavianT nacnobs,a. n-Tan erTad, romelsac isini ar icnoben. isic vnaxeT,rom a. n-i Tavis CvenebaSi sulac ar gamoricxavs maT gardaiq sxva pirebis yofnis SesaZleblobas, rac sruliad gasa-gebia. mowmeebs ufro kargad axsovT saqmisTvis mniSvne-lovani faqti, romelmac maSin yvelaze didi STabeWdile-ba moaxdina maTze da amitom mexsierebaSic ufro mkafiodSemorCaT TavianT nacnobebs Soris momxdari konfliqtida am konfliqtisas a. b-is mier d. o-is daniT daWra, vidresxva, meorexarisxovani garemoebebi, kerZod, im dros vinsad idga, vin saiT gaiqca da vin pirveli garboda daWrilid. o-isken da vin bolos, an im momentSi axlomaxlo, gver-diT kidev vin iyo. maTi Cvenebebis Sefasebisas gasaTva-liswinebelia isic, rom S. S-e da g. m-e a. n-s ar icnobdnen,xolo j. m-s mxolod saxeliT icnobdnen. aseT pirobebSiTviTmxilveli mowmeebisgan momxdar faqtTan dakavSire-buli yvela garemoebis, maT Soris SedarebiT naklebmniS-vnelovani momentebis srulad aRqma, Tanac maTi arasrul-wlovanebis asakSi da mravali wlis Semdeg ukanasknelwvrilmanebamde maTi zusti TanmimdevrobiT gadmocemismoTxovna, metismetad gadaWarbebulia. amitom, Tu mow-mis Cveneba aseT mkacr moTxovnas ver akmayofilebs, es arSeiZleba gaxdes misi Cvenebis saeWvod miCnevis safuZve-li maSin, rodesac igive Cveneba Tanmimdevrulia mtkice-bis saganSi moazrebul saqmis ZiriTad faqtobriv garemo-ebebTan mimarTebiT. swored amgvari midgomiT unda Sefas-des S. S-isa da g. m-is, rogorc faqtis TviTmxilveli mow-meebis, pirdapiri Cvenebebic, ris Sedegadac maT realo-basa da sarwmunoobaSi eWvis Setanis safuZveli gamoiric-

108

xeba. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenis safuZvlianadgacnobisas iseTi STabeWdileba iqmneba, rom a. b-is mimarTwardgenili braldeba mxolod am ori mowmis _ S. S-isa da g.m-is Cvenebebs emyareba da mocemuli saqmis Sedegic swo-red maT miRebasa Tu armiRebazea damokidebuli. sinamdvi-leSi ki ase sulac ar aris. rogorc zemoT warmodgenilianalizi cxadyofs, aRniSnuli ori Cveneba saerTodac romar iqnes miRebuli da gaziarebuli, saqmeSi mainc rCeba ki-dev eqvsi mowmis iseTi Cveneba, amaTgan sami _ pirdapiri(mowmeebis _ d. k-is, l. b-isa da n. q-s Cvenebebi) da sami _arapirdapiri (mowmeebis _ l. g-is, z. m-isa da m. l-is Cvene-bebi), romelTa momxdar faqtTan pirdapiri Sexeba, urTi-erTSesabamisoba da, rac mTavaria, maTi sandooba da ut-yuaroba, Zalian maRali xarisxiT, obieqturi, miukerZoe-beli damkvirveblisaTvis sruliad aSkara da udavoa go-nivrul eWvs miRma standartis doneze.

41. sakasacio palata d. o-is ganzrax mkvlelobis saqme-Si arsebuli mtkicebulebebis Sefasebisas iTvaliswinebsda savsebiT iziarebs am sakiTxisadmi adamianis uflebaTaevropuli sasamarTlos midgomasa da praqtikas. kerZod,evropuli sasamarTlo Tavis gadawyvetilebebSi yuradRe-bas amaxvilebs Semdegze: sasamarTlo msjelobs imaze, Turamdenad samarTliani iyo samarTalwarmoeba mTlianoba-Si da ramdenad iyo daculi dacvis uflebebi. kerZod, un-da Sefasdes: mieca Tu ara momCivans SesaZlebloba _ edavamtkicebulebebis avTenturobaze da SewinaaRmdegebodaam mtkicebulebebis gamoyenebas. garda amisa, gasaTvalis-winebelia mtkicebulebaTa xarisxi, is garemoebebi, rom-lebSic mtkicebulebebi iqna mopovebuli da ramdenad ba-debs eWvs es garemoebebi mtkicebulebebis namdvilobasada sarwmunoobasTan dakavSirebiT. miuxedavad imisa, romar aris savaldebulo, samarTlianobaSi eWvis Setanis sa-fuZveli warmoiqmnas, Tu mopovebuli mtkicebuleba araris gamyarebuli sxva masalebiT, xazgasasmelia _ im Sem-TxvevebSi, rodesac mtkicebuleba sakmaod woniania da ararsebobs imis riski, rom igi SeiZleba arasarwmunod iqnesmiCneuli, damatebiTi mtkicebulebebis wardgenis miT uf-ro naklebi aucilebloba arsebobs (ix., bikovi ruseTis wi-naaRmdeg, (Bykov v. Russia); didi palata; ganacxadi #4378/02; §90; ECHR; 10.03.2009; jalo germaniis winaaRmdeg, (Jalloh

109

v. Germany); ganacxadi #54810/00; §96; ECHR; didi palata;11.07.2006). sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom ganxilul saq-meSi arsebuli yvela mtkicebuleba mopovebulia da am saq-meze samarTalwarmoebis ganxorcielebisas Semowmebuliasaproceso kanonmdeblobis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT,mxareTa Tanasworobisa da SejibrebiTobis pirobebSi, radrosac rogorc braldebis, ise dacvis mxareebs sruli Se-saZlebloba hqondaT, warmoedginaT TavianTi mtkicebu-lebebi, monawileoba mieRoT mowinaaRmdege mxaris mtki-cebulebebis gamokvlevaSi da jerovnad daecvaT Tavian-Ti poziciebi. am mxriv, mocemuli saqmis warmoebisas yve-la sasamarTlo instanciaSi dacvis mxarisaTvis sruladiyo uzrunvelyofili adamianis uflebaTa evropuli kon-venciis me-6 muxliT garantirebuli _ saqmis samarTlianiganxilvis ufleba. mocemul SemTxvevaSi ar arsebobs ara-viTari safuZveli eWvisaTvis im mtkicebulebebis legi-timurobis TvalsazrisiT, romlebzec sakasacio palataafuZnebs Tavis gadawyvetilebas. rac Seexeba am mtkice-bulebaTa utyuarobasa da sakmarisobas gamamtyunebeliganaCenis dadgenisaTvis, zemoT warmodgenili da gaana-lizebuli garemoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT, am mxrivac veriqneba aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi saeWvod miCneuli, rad-gan aseTi eWvisaTvis ar moipoveba dasabuTebuli da rele-vanturi safuZveli.

42. amrigad, yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare,sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom Tbilisis saapelacio sasa-marTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatas ar gaaCndadasabuTebuli safuZveli saimisod, rom ar mieRo is kano-nieri mtkicebulebebi, romlebic saqmeSia da romelTa ana-lizi zemoT iyo warmodgenili, agreTve _ is faqtobrivigaremoebebi, romlebic dadgenilia mocemul saqmeze Ca-tarebuli sasamarTlo gamoZiebis Sedegad da pirdapir ga-momdinareobs aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebidan. rogorcmaTma obieqturma da urTierTSejerebulma analizma da-adastura, es mtkicebulebebi, romlebic a. b-s amxelen d.o-is ganzrax mkvlelobis CadenaSi, mTlianad akmayofile-ben maT mimarT wardgenil gonivrul eWvs miRma standar-tis moTxovnas da erTobliobaSi, isini savsebiT sakmarissafuZvels qmnian gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis dadgenisa daa. b-is damnaSaved cnobisaTvis. sakasacio palatas miaCnia,

110

rom mocemul SemTxvevaSi mtkicebulebebi, romlebicadastureben a. b-is braleulobas, savsebiT SeesabamebianSefasebis im kriteriumebs, romelTa Sesaxeb zemoT ukveiyo aRniSnuli da romlebic gamomdinareoben saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kanonmdeblobiT dad-genili moTxovnebidan, kerZod, saqarTvelos sssk-is 82-emuxlidan da, amis Sesabamisad, saqarTvelos uzenaesi sa-samarTlos mier damkvidrebuli praqtikidan (ix. gadawyve-tileba saqmeze _ #397ap-14).

43. sabolood sakasacio palata mivida im daskvnamde,rom a. b-is mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgenisassaapelacio sasamarTlom arsebiTad daarRvia saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis zemonaxse-nebi normebiT, kerZod, 259-e muxlis pirveli da me-3 nawi-lebiT gaTvaliswinebuli moTxovnebi imis Taobaze, romsasamarTlos ganaCeni unda iyos dasabuTebuli da is undagamomdinareobdes saqmeSi arsebuli utyuari mtkicebu-lebebis erTobliobidan, romlebic saqmis sasamarTloganxilvis dros iyo gamokvleuli. saapelacio sasamar-Tlom usafuZvlod uaryo aseTi mtkicebulebebiT dama-jereblad dadasturebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebi da sa-marTlebrivad arasworad Seafasa isini, ris gamoc sasamar-Tlos mier ganaCenSi ganviTarebuli msjeloba da aqedangamotanili daskvna a. b-is udanaSaulobis Taobaze sru-liad ar Seesabameba aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebisa da faq-tobrivi garemoebebis obieqtur analizsa da Sefasebas,ramac arsebiTi gavlena moaxdina saqmis Sedegze. am gare-moebaTa gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, romsaxelmwifo braldebis warmomadgeneli prokurorebis _Tamar aRlemaSvilisa da amiran guluaSvilis sakasacio sa-Civari unda dakmayofildes: Tbilisis saapelacio sasamar-Tlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 4 oq-tombris ganaCeni a. b-is gamarTlebisa da udanaSaulodcnobis Sesaxeb unda gauqmdes da is unda Seicvalos gamam-tyunebeli ganaCeniT. a. b. cnobil unda iqnes braleuladd. o-is ganzrax mkvlelobaSi, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebu-li saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 108-e mux-liT, risTvisac mas unda Seefardos Sesabamisi sasjeliTavisuflebis aRkveTis saxiT.

44. msjavrdebul a. b-is mimarT sasjelis zomis gansaz-

111

Rvrisas sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs Semdegs: masar gaaCnia pasuxismgeblobis damamZimebeli garemoebebi,amasTan, sakasacio palata iTvaliswinebs msjavrdebulispasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebel garemoebebs, kerZod,saqmeSi arsebuli masalebidan gamomdinare, gonebrivi gan-viTarebis TvalsazrisiT, misi janmrTelobis mdgomareo-ba aradamakmayofilebelia, Tumca, imave masalebis mixed-viT, es garemoeba ar gamoricxavs mis Seracxvaunariano-bas, igi pirveladaa samarTalSi, xolo danaSaulis Cadeni-dan mis msjavrdebamde gasulia sakmaod didi dro, rom-lis ganmavlobaSic mas ar Caudenia axali danaSauli an sxvamarTlsawinaaRmdego qmedeba. am garemoebaTa gaTvalis-winebiT, mas sasjelis zomad unda ganesazRvros Tavisuf-lebis aRkveTa 9 (cxra) wliT, rac `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ sa-qarTvelos 2012 wlis 28 dekembris kanonis me-16 muxlissafuZvelze unda Seumcirdes erTi meoTxediT da msjav-rdebul a. b-s sabolood mosaxdelad unda darCes Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa 6 (eqvsi) wlisa da 9 (cxra) Tvis vadiT.


is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiTda

d a a d g i n a:

1. saqarTvelos mTavari prokuraturis prokurorebis_ amiran guluaSvilisa da Tamar aRlemaSvilis sakasaciosaCivari dakmayofildes.

2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlissamarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 4 oqtombris gama-marTlebeli ganaCeni.

3. a. b. cnobil iqnes damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT wardgenil braldebaSi da miesajos 9 wliT Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa, rac `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos2012 wlis 28 dekembris kanonis me-16 muxlis safuZvelzeSeumcirdes erTi meoTxediT da sabolood mosaxdeladganesazRvros 6 wliTa da 9 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.

4. msjavrdebul a. b-s sasjelis moxda aeTvalos am gana-Cenis aRsrulebis mizniT misi dakavebis momentidan. mas-

112

ve sasjelis vadaSi moxdilad CaeTvalos patimrobaSi yof-nis dro _ 2016 wlis 25 martidan 2016 wlis 22 dekembrisCaTvliT.


mosamarTle g. SavliaSvilis gansxvavebuli azri

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos sisxlissamarTlis saqmeTa

palatis 2018 wlis 29 martis ganaCenze msjavrdebula. b-is mimarT

1. sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa sakasacio palatis Cemmakolega mosamarTleebma miiCnies, rom Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 4 oqtombris gamamarTlebeliganaCeni a. b-is mimarT iyo ukanono, vinaidan braldebismxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi mTlianad ak-mayofilebs gonivrul eWvs miRma standartis moTxovnasda erToblivad savsebiT sakmaris safuZvels qmnis gamam-tyunebeli ganaCenis dadgenisa da a. b-is damnaSaved cno-bisaTvis.

2. mimaCnia, rom Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 4 oqtombrisgamamarTlebeli ganaCeni a.b-is mimarT iyo kanonieri da ararsebobda misi gauqmebis safuZveli, vinaidan saqmeze war-modgenili mowmeebis mier sasamarTlo ganxilvisas mice-muli pirdapiri Cvenebebi ver akmayofilebs mtkicebisprocesisaTvis savaldebulo _ utyuarobis kriteriums.saqmeSi arsebuli sxva mtkicebulebebi ki ar aris sakmari-si gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT piris damnaSaved cno-bisaTvis.

3. mocemul sisxlis samarTlis saqmeSi piris braldebaefuZneba mxolod erTgvarovan mtkicebulebebs. eseniamowmeTa Cvenebebi, romelTagan pirdapiri mtkicebulebe-bi (romelsac daeyrdno gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni) gamoZi-ebam moipova SemTxvevidan 11 wlis Semdeg. Sesabamisad, ase-Ti mtkicebulebebis Sefasebisas sasamarTloebma unda ga-moiyenon mtkicebulebaTa utyuarobis Semowmebis gaci-

113

lebiT maRali standarti, vidre im saqmeebze msjelobi-sas, romelTac aseTi maxasiaTebeli ar gaaCniaT (igulis-xmeba sisxlis samarTlis saqmeebi, romlebzec, garda mow-meTa Cvenebebisa, arsebobs eqspertizis daskvnebi, audio-video Canawerebi, amocnobis dokumenturi mtkicebule-bebi da sxv.).

4. aqedan gamomdinare, CemTvis a. b-is braldebis sis-xlis samarTlis saqme, masTan dakavSirebuli am da sxva(romlebzec qvemoT gveqneba saubari) specifikuri sapro-ceso-samarTlebrivi garemoebebis gamo, iZens gacilebiTmet mniSvnelobas, vidre erTi konkretuli sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmea. mocemul saqmeze Cemi pozicia swored sap-roceso _ samarTlebrivi aspeqtebidan gamomdinareobs damiznad isaxavs imas, rom sakasacio palatam ar daadginosmtkicebulebaTa utyuarobis Sefasebis iseTi standarti,romelmac SesaZloa, samomavlod xeli Seuwyos udanaSau-lo pir(eb)is msjavrdebis riskebis gazrdas.

5. Tavad is faqti, rom saqmeze 2004 wels dawyebuli wi-naswari gamoZieba iyo arasakmarisi da zerele _ naTelia,vinaidan saqmeze, marTalia, daikiTxa rigi mowmeebisa, ase-ve Sesrulda ramdenime sagamoZiebo moqmedeba, magram arCatarebula iseTi savaldebulo da relevanturi sapro-ceso moqmedebebi, rogorebicaa: sacxovrebeli binis Cxre-ka, fotosuraTiT amocnoba (Tundac mowme n. q-sTan, imisdasadgenad kepiani biWi iyo Tu ara a.b.) da sxva. Semdegiwlebis ganmavlobaSic _ 2015 wlamde saqmes, obieqturiWeSmaritebis dasadgenad, arsebiTad araferi Sematebia.am droidan saqmeze axali mowmeebis gamoCeniT, marTalia,aqtiurad ganaxlda gamoZieba _ maT misces pirdapiri Cve-nebebi, magram a.b-is braldebis damadasturebeli sxva sa-xis mtkicebuleba (mag: dokumenturi, nivTieri _ sxvadas-xva saqmeze aseTi SeiZleba iyos: satelefono zarebis nus-xa, mowmis mier miTiTebuli konkretuli adgilidan mopo-vebuli nivTieri mtkicebuleba, an dnm-is eqsp. daskvna dasxv.) saqmeSi ar moipoveba. amitom sasamarTlos saboloodaskvnac mxolod mowmeTa Cvenebebis analizis Sedegadunda dadgindes.

6. aqedan gamomdinare, mowmeebis: S. S-is, g. m-sa da l. b-is Cvenebebis sandoobis Sesafaseblad sruliad legiti-muria kiTxvebi imis Sesaxeb, Tu ratom ar miawodes maT Ta-

114

vis droze gamoZiebas es informacia; ratom arc erT maT-gans ar gauCnda survili, misuliyo da daxmareba gaewia daW-rili megobrisaTvis; aseve, SemTxvevis adgilze myofmaverc erTma sxva mowmem ratom ver dainaxa zemoaRniSnulipirebi; gasaanalizebelia mowmeebTan dakavSirebuli ise-Ti obieqturi garemoebebic, romlebmac SesaZloa, maT da-interesebaSi dagvaeWvos _ mxedvelobaSi maqvs S. S-sa da g.m-is sasjelaRsrulebis dawesebulebaSi erT sakanSi jdo-mis faqti; agreTve Sesafasebelia, ramdenad arsebiTi xa-siaTisaa saqmeSi arsebul mtkicebulebebTan dakavSire-buli sxva winaaRmdegobebi.

7. metic, dacvis mxare gamoTqvams eWvs imis Sesaxeb, romS. da m. saerTod ar imyofebodnen SemTxvevis adgilze daisini SesaZloa, garkveuli SeRavaTis sanacvlod iZlevianbraldebis mxarisaTvis saWiro Cvenebebs. saapelacio pa-lata ki aRniSnavs, rom S. S-is, g. m-sa da l. b-is mier mice-mul CvenebebTan dakavSirebuli sakiTxebi, aseve maTi war-sulisa da sxva pirovnuli maxasiaTeblis gaTvaliswinebiT,dabali wonis matarebeli da damajereblobas moklebulimtkicebulebebia. isini ar aris urTierTTavsebadi sxvamtkicebulebebTan, ris gamoc ar unda iqnes gamoyenebu-li a. b-is mimarT gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotanis sa-fuZvlad.

8. Sesabamisad, sakasacio palatam saqmeSi arsebul mtki-cebulebaTa utyuarobis sakiTxis gadasawyvetad unda ga-aanalizos swored zemoT miTiTebuli sakiTxebi.

9. saamisod, mizanSewonilad mimaCnia, Tavdapirveladmoviyvano mtkicebulebaTa baza srulad, raTa qvemoT gan-viTarebul msjelobaSi Sesafasebeli epizodebi da deta-lebi metad TvalsaCino iyos:

9.1. dazaralebulis uflebamonacvle g. o-is CvenebisTanaxmad, 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers ufrosi Svilisgan _ k.o-sgan Seityo umcrosi vaJis _ d. o-is daWris Sesaxeb. miu-xedavad mcdelobisa, d. ver gadaarCines. im periodSi yve-lam icoda, rom mkvleli iyo q-li a. b.. manve ganmarta, romTviTmxilvelTan piradad ar usaubria, Tumca yvela am-bobda, rom a. b-m mokla misi Svili.

9.2. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamoqveynebuli mowme m. m-isCvenebiT irkveva, rom 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers rZlisaganSeityo, rom misi Svili _ d. o-i iyo daWrili da moTavsebu-

115

li iyo r-r saavadmyofoSi. igi maSinve wavida saavadmyo-foSi, sadac Seityo, rom d. operaciis dros gardaicvala.mogvianebiT Seityo, rom misi Svilis mkvleloba Caidina a-ma a. b-em, romelTanac d-s telefonis gamo mosvlia Sela-parakeba. danamdvilebiT ar axsovs, Tu vin uTxra aRniS-nulis Sesaxeb, Tumca mowmis ganmartebiT, maSin yvela amasambobda.

9.3. sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxvisas mowme k. o-ma ga-nacxada, rom 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers, saRamos saaTebSi,daukavSirdnen saavadmyofodan da uTxres, rom misi Zma _d. o-i iyo daWrili da r-r saavadmyofoSi imyofeboda. Sem-dgom xalxisgan Seityo damnaSavis _ a. b-is Sesaxeb, romel-sac mobiluri telefonis gamo mouxda Selaparakeba misZmasTan. misTvis misi Zmis arcerT megobars ar uTqvams,rom Seeswrnen mkvlelobis faqts.

9.4. sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxuli mowme j. m-is Cve-nebiT dgindeba, rom a. b-es ar icnobs. d. o-s icnobda damisi axlo megobari iyo. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers imyofebo-da p-is gamzirze arsebul `birJaze~, a. n-Tan erTad. bin-ddeboda, roca d. o-i mivida maTTan da sTxova telefon-ze darekva, magram telefoni ar hqondaT, Tu angariSze _Tanxa, ver ixsenebs, ris gamoc d. gadavida mopirdapiremxares, slotklub `g-ken~. is da n-i darCnen imave adgil-ze. ramdenime wuTis Semdeg a-ma daiZaxa, rom d. Cxubobso,man wamierad gaixeda im mxares da SeniSna, rom d-s daxma-reba sWirdeboda, Tan gaiqcnen im mimarTulebiT. a. n. cotawin garboda, TviTon cdilobda, rac SeiZleba swrafad ga-suliyo manqanebis nakadSi. Sua xazze rom dadga, gaigona a.n-is d-Tvis naTqvami _ j-sTan midi, me iqiT gaviqcevio.gverdze rom miixeda, dainaxa d. o-i, romelmac uTxra, daW-rili varo, man xeli mohkida da gadmoiyvana gzaze, gaaCeramanqana da waiyvana saavadmyofoSi. mividnen r-r saavad-myofoSi, saidanac gamobrunda ezoSi, raTa biWebi enaxa daojaxis wevrebisTvis gaegebinebina, Tumca, rogorc Seit-yo, ojaxis wevrebma ukve icodnen. SemdgomSi panaSvideb-ze iyo saubari, rom d. o-s mobiluri telefonis gamo mo-uxda SekamaTeba warmoSobiT a-l a. b-sTan. mowme j. m-ma aseveganmarta, rom icnobda d. o-is megobrebs _ S. S-sa da g. m-es.momxdari faqtis dros mas isini iq ar unaxavs. aseve ar da-unaxavs l. b-i. mTeli am drois ganmavlobaSi misTvis ara-

116

vis uTqvams, rom Seeswro momxdar faqts da TviTmxilve-li iyo.

9.5. sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma a.n-ma ganmarta, rom d. o-s icnobda skolidan da iyvnen ax-lo megobrebi. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers is da j. m-i idgnenp-is gamzirze, saxaWapuresTan. maTTan mivida d. o-i da te-lefonze darekva sTxova. man upasuxa, rom angariSze Tan-xa ar hqonda, ris Semdegac o-i gatrialda da gadavida gzismeore mxares `g-Tan~. radgan TviTonac undoda telefon-ze darekva, ifiqra, rom Tu o-i moZebnida telefonian ada-mians, Tavadac mividoda da sTxovda darekvas, amitom ak-virdeboda mas. dainaxa, rom o-i viRacas elaparakeboda,konkretulad yuradReba ar miuqcevia. erT-erTi gaxed-vis dros dainaxa, rom `WidaobdnensaviT~, Tumca ar CaTva-la, rom saqme seriozulad iyo. Semdegi gaxedvis dros kidainaxa, rom o-i waiqca. igi gaiqca dasaxmareblad. vinai-dan manqanebi moZraobdnen, gauWirda gadasvla, daaxloe-biT Sua gzaze Semoxvda d. o-i, romelsac xeli hqonda mi-debuli da Tqva _ daWrili varo. man d. o-s uTxra, rom mi-suliyo j. m-Tan, Tavad ki damWrels gamoedevneboda, ra-Ta gaego, vin iyo. gadavida meore mxares, Seixeda `p-ic~,Tumca saeWvo veravin dainaxa da dabrunda SemTxvevis ad-gilze. iq ukve aRaravin daxvda da wavida r-r saavadmyo-foSi. mowmis ganmartebiT, masTan da j. m-Tan erTad sxvaaravin yofila, arc garSemo SeuniSnavs vinme nacnobi. impirs, romelic d. o-s esaubreboda, ar icnobda da misi si-luetic ki ar daamaxsovrda. SemdgomSi gadmocemiT Seit-yo, rom es danaSauli viRac a-l biWs Caudenia. S. S-sa da g.m-es ar icnobs. aseve ar icnobs d. k-sa da n. g-s. g. b-sa da a.a-s icnobs, Tumca im momentSi masTan erTad ar yofilan.l. b-s SemdgomSi Sexvedria, Tumca am Temaze ar usaubri-aT.

9.6. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma n. g-ma sasamarTlo sxdo-maze ganmarta, rom a. b-s icnobs, vinaidan cxovrobdnenerT korpusSi, erT sadarbazoSi da iyvnen mezoblebi. ezo-Si xvdeboda xolme mas da TamaSobdnen fexburTs. igi ko-munikabelurobiT ar gamoirCeoda, iyo emociuri, zedmetsaxelad eZaxdnen `a-os~. d. o-s ar icnobda. 2007 wlis 27oqtombers, saRamos, daaxloebiT 19 saaTze, dedam gaag-zavna afTiaqSi, romelic mdebareobs m-is mopirdapire mxa-

117

res, g-as gamzirze. rodesac Camovida ezoSi, Sexvda a. b. dahkiTxa, Tu sad midioda, razedac upasuxa, rom midiodaafTiaqSi. a-ma uTxra, mec iqiT movdivaro da wavidnen. ro-gorc axsovs, kepi efara, dana mis xelSi ar SeumCnevia. gza-Si a-i telefonze saubrobda. rodesac mividnen slotklub`g-Tan~, sadac amJamad aris `... banki~, a-s Sexvda viRac piri,romelTanac daiwyo daZabuli saubari, Tavad ar SeCere-bula, gadakveTa quCa da Sevida afTiaqSi, sadac gaCerdadaaxloebiT 10-15 wuTs. roca afTiaqidan gamovida da qu-Caze gadmodioda, slotklubis win SeniSna xalxmravloba.TviTon wavida saxlisken. gzaSi Sexvda d. k., romelmac uT-xra, rom à-om~ daWra ù-sa~. a. b. iq aRar unaxavs. rodesacsaxlTan mivida, sadarbazosTan Sexvda a. b-is da, romel-mac hkiTxa, sad aris à-o~, razedac upasuxa, rom ar icoda.Semdeg hkiTxa _ vin daWra à-o~, razedac aseve uaryofiTipasuxi gasca. im dRis Semdeg a. b. aRar unaxavs. Semdeg dRe-ebSi misTvis cnobili gaxda, rom ù-sa~ yofila misive ub-neli d. o.. mowmem aseve ganmarta, rom saxaWapure iyo af-Tiaqis gverdiT, 2_3 metrSi. axlomaxlo vinme nacnobi, gar-da d. k-sa, ar SeumCnevia. im periodSi mamamisi iyo polici-is TanamSromeli, Tumca ojaxis wevrebisTvis araferi uT-qvams, radgan ar CaTvala saWirod. aRniSnulis Taobaze sa-erTod aravisTan ar usaubria, garda gamomZieblisa, ro-desac Cveneba misca 2016 wels.

9.7. sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxuli mowme S. S-is Cve-nebiT dgindeba, rom icnobda a. b-es, Tumca urTierTobaar hqonia. g. m-es icnobs bavSvobidan da masTan axlo me-gobruli urTierToba akavSirebs. bavSvobidan icnobda ase-ve d. o-s da megobrobda masTan. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers g.m-sTan erTad imyofeboda p-is quCaze, `g-is~ mimdebare te-ritoriaze, incidentis mopirdapire mxares. iqneboda sa-Ramos saaTebi, rodesac SeniSna d. o-i da a. b.. iyo raRacCoCqoli. dainaxa, Tu rogor mouqnia a. b-m sagniani xeli d.o-s da daartya gulmkerdis areSi, ris gamoc o-i wabarbac-da. Semdeg dainaxa, rom a-s xelSi eWira dana da isev daar-tya o-s wels qveviT. manamde iq a. b. ar SeuniSnavs, arc maTisaubris Tema gaugia. mowmem ganmarta, rom danis dartymismomentSi moSorebiT SeniSna n. g-i. mowmis ganmartebiT, ma-namde gaixeda saxaWapurisken, sadac SeniSna j. m., a. a-i dab-i, SeiZleba sxvebic yofiliyvnen, magram ar axsovs. dai-

118

naxa, Tu rogor gadarboda quCaze j. m-i, albaT, misaSve-leblad. TviTon daibna da ar icoda, ra eqna, gaucnobie-reblad moqmedebda, gadakveTa quCa da gezi aiRo SemTxve-vis adgilidan marjvniv, maRazia `d-ken~, Tu ratom, verxsnis. Semdeg ki saxlSi wavida. a. b. iq aRar daunaxavs. d. o-is gardacvalebis Taobaze misTvis cnobili gaxda mogvia-nebiT, rogorc axsovs, meore dRes. konfliqtis mizezadramdenime versia saxeldeboda. erTi versiiT _ mizezi iyotelefonze darekva, meore versiiT gaJRerda, rom b. gar-dacvlils sTxovda mogebul fuls. aRniSnulis Semdeg a.b. aRar unaxavs, rogorc ambobdnen, igi dedamisis gavle-niani megobrebis daxmarebiT gaapares saqarTvelodan daaarides pasuxismgeblobas. ojaxis wevrebisTvis momxda-ris Taobaze ar mouyolia. rogorc axsovs, aravisTvis uam-bia am mkvlelobis Sesaxeb. SesaZloa, gasvenebaSi isaubresbiWebma, zustad ar axsovs. TerTmeti welia, imyofeba sas-jelaRsrulebis dawesebulebaSi, saidanac 2015 wels mom-xdaris Taobaze Seatyobina prokuraturas da misca Cve-neba. kiTxvaze, Tu ratom gadawyvita amdeni wlis SemdegCvenebis micema, mowmem ganmarta: `erT-erT mkvlelobissaqmeze, romelzec vicodi, rac moxda, gardacvlilis de-dam momaZaxa, Sen xom ici, rac moxdao da Tqvio, aman moax-dina Cemze raRacnairad gavlena da gadavwyvite am saqme-zec meTqva simarTle~. sasjels ixdis adamianis sicocxlisxelyofisTvis, mosaxdeli darCa 14 weli.

9.8. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma g. m-em ganmarta Semdegi:icnobs a. b-es, romelTanac erTad bavSvobaSi TamaSobdafexburTs. d. o-ac icnobs, romelTanac Zmakacobda bavSvo-bidan. icnobs aseve S. S-es, romelic aris misi bavSvobismegobari. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers S. S-sTan erTad imyofe-boda p-is gamzirze, m-is quCis kveTaze, saxaWapuris mxa-res, sadarbazosTan, ra drosac slotklub `g-is~ win dai-naxes a. b. da d. o-i. isini maTgan daSorebuli iqnebodnendaaxloebiT 30-40 metriT. Tavidan isini saubrobdnen, racSemdeg gadaizarda CxubSi. am dros a. b-em d. o-rs sxeuliszemo nawilSi daartya dana, ris Semdegac d. o-i Caikeca daforTxviT wavida trotuarisken. a. b. kvlav mivarda mas dameored dana daartya fexSi. am dros man da S. S-em gadakve-Tes gza, S-sTvis yuradReba aRar miuqcevia da ar icis, sadwavida, TviTon ki daiwyo a. b-is Zebna, romelic ver ipova

119

da wavida saxlSi. mowme g. m-is ganmartebiT, saxaWapures-Tan, birJaze, man SeamCnia nacnobebi _ a. a-i, b-i da j. m-i. j.idga misgan daaxloebiT 10 metrSi. rogorc axsovs, mimde-bare teritoriaze naxa n. g-i, romelmac mouyva Cxubis de-talebi, uTxra, rom danis dartymis dros iqve iyo. dama-tebiT kiTxvaze mowmem ganmarta, rom man m. q-sagan gaigo,rom n. g-ma dainaxa o-sa da b-es Soris Cxubis detalebi. imdRes mimdebare teritoriaze l. b-i ar SeuniSnavs. mowmemaseve ganmarta, rom im dros, rodesac man da S. S-em gamom-Ziebels Cvenebebi misces, orive ixdida sasjels da is-xdnen erT sakanSi. manamde policiisaTvis momxdaris Tao-baze ar ucnobebia, vinaidan icoda, rom a. b-is dedas hyav-da xelisuflebaSi gavleniani pirebi da SeeSinda. nasamar-Tlevi aris oTxjer, bolo danaSaulze daaxloebiT erTiwlis win gauformda saproceso SeTanxmeba da gaTavisuf-lda. dacvis mxaris kiTxvaze mowmem ganmarta, rom igi sxvamkvlelobis saqmezec aris TviTmxilveli mowme. a. n-s aricnobda. j-sgan icis, rom n-i ar icnobda b-es, arc j. aricnobda, panaSvidebze sul iyo am Temis ganxilva. im mo-mentSi d. k. iq ar daunaxavs. mere uTxra d-ma, rom im drostrialebda teritoriaze da dainaxa, rogor daartya b-emdana o-s.

9.9. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma l. b-ma aCvena, rom a. b-esicnobda, Tumca axlo urTierToba ar hqonia. d. o-s icnob-da da hqonda axlo urTierToba, radgan erT skolaSi swav-lobdnen. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers, saRamos, gamovida sax-lidan da unda Sexvedroda megobar gogonas x-is quCaze.gamoiara i-is quCaze, sadac veravin naxa. Semdeg ezoTi ga-davida p-is quCaze, gadakveTa quCa da elodeboda samar-Sruto taqsis. mowmis ganmartebiT, igi daaxloebiT 5 wu-Tis ganmavlobaSi idga `j-is~ ofisis win da iyurebodaslotklub `g-is~ mxares, sadac, daaxloebiT 20_25 metrSiSeniSna d. o-i da a. b., romlebic erTmaneTs daZabuladesaubrebodnen, Tumca saubris Tema ar gaugonia. Semdegdaiwyes ZiZgilaoba, ra drosac a. b-em dana daartya d. o-s,romelic Caikeca. es yvelaferi misTvis moulodneli iyo,daibna da sastumro `a-ken~ Setrialda, daaxloebiT 10_15wamSi isev moixeda da dainaxa o-i, romelic quCas kveTda.uceb bevri xalxi Segrovda da zustad yvelaferi aRar ax-sovs. dainaxa mxolod is momenti, rodesac d. o-s manqanaSi

120

svamdnen, Tu vin svamda, ar axsovs. o-i rom Caikeca da bor-ZikiT daiwyo quCis gadakveTa, b. iq aRar daunaxavs. n. g-iTavidan SeniSna, Tumca ZiZgilaobis dros iq aRar Seum-Cnevia. daaxloebiT naxevari wuTis ganmavlobaSi taqsiTdatova is adgili. SemdegSi gavrcelda versia, rom d. o-sada à-s~ telefonis gamo mouvidaT kamaTi. mowmis ganmar-tebiT, mas survili ar gasCenia, misuliyo d. o-Tan, vinai-dan daibna da moerida im adgils. S. S-sa da g. m-es icnobs,magram adgilze ar SeumCnevia. d. k-es SeiZleba icnobs, mag-ram ver ixsenebs, viszea saubari. momxdaris Taobaze arcojaxSi da arc megobrebTan ar usaubria, sagamoZiebo or-ganodanac aravin dahkavSirebia. pirvelad gamoZiebas Cve-neba misca 2015 wels, roca gamomZiebelma daibara dakiT-xvaze. warsulSi ramdenjermea nasamarTlevi da iyo Zeb-nili.

9.10. saapelacio palatis sxdomaze gamoqveynebuli mow-me d. k-is mier 2015 wlis 18 marts micemuli CvenebiT dad-genilia, rom cxovrobs s-is quCa #...-Si mdebare kerZo sax-lis erT-erT oTaxSi. materialuri gaWirvebis gamo m-s qu-Caze Txoulobs mowyalebas. d. o-s daWramde ramdenimexniT adre idga pokerklubis SesasvlelTan. am dros klub-Si imyofeboda d. o. masTan erTad iyo misi megobari g-i,rogorc icis, es biWi iyo vakeli. am dros pokerklubSi Se-vida maT ubanSi mcxovrebi axalgazrda biWi, romelic iyoraionidan. igi mivida d. o-Tan, romelic TamaSobda poke-ris aparatebze da gamoiyvana quCaSi. TviTon maTgan daSo-rebuli iyo ramdenime nabijiT. am biWs, romelmac d. o-igamoiyvana gareT, eZaxdnen à-os~. mas esmoda à-sa~ da d. o-is saubari. à-om~ hkiTxa, Tu rodis apirebda misTvis e.w.`Tavanis~ Cabarebas, razec d. o-ma upasuxa, rom ramdenimeTveSi Caabarebda Tavans. maT ar daukonkretebiaT TavanissaxiT ra Tanxa hqonda misacemi d. o-s à-sTvis~. saubrisSemdeg d. o-i da à-o~ mSvidobianad daSordnen erTmaneTs.am saubridan ramdenime xnis Semdeg imyofeboda isev po-kerklubis mimdebare teritoriaze. klubSi Sesuli iyo d.o-i. dainaxa, rom klubSi Sevida da masTan mivida à-o~. mankvlav gamoiyvana d. o-i gareT da mosTxova Tavanis Cabare-ba, razec d. o-ma uTxra, rom ar hqonda fuli da ver Caaba-rebda Tavans. amisTvis unda mieca dro. isini saubrobdnenganmartoebiT, idgnen pokerklubis win, trotuarze. Tvi-

121

Ton am dros idga maTgan ramdenime metris moSorebiT. maTSoris daiZaba viTareba, isini saubrobdnen xmamaRla. amkamaTis dros à-om~ daartya saxeSi d. o-s, ris SemdegacmaT erTmaneTs dauwyes cema. maTi Cxubi gagrZelda ram-denime wams, ris Semdegac d. o-i koWlobiT gaiqca gzaze, g-as quCis mopirdapire mxares. quCaze gadasvlisas mas tro-tuaridan aginebda à-o~, aseve d. o-ic aginebda mas. à-o~maleve gaiqca p-is quCaze. mas ecva ruxi feris Sarvali,muqi feris naWris qurTuki da Tavze exura `kepka~. im ad-gilze, sadac d. o-i da à-o~ Cxubobdnen, sisxlis wveTebimogvianebiT mowminda pokerklubis TanamSromelma qal-ma, romlis saxeli da gvari ar axsovs. d. o-i gadarboda gza-ze, rodesac gaaCera muqi feris, rogorc axsovs, ̀ o-is~ mar-kis avtomanqana. d. o-i manqanaSi Casva, rogorc axsovs, or-ma biWma, romlebmac waiyvanes daWrili. es biWebi sxva drosar unaxavs. rodesac d. o-i da à-o~ Cxubobdnen, dainaxa,rom p-is quCis meore mxridan m-is mxares gadmoirbina n-am,à-os~ megobarma. rodesac is gadmovida quCaze, am drosà-o~ da d. o-i ukve gaiqcnen. am Cxubs aseve Seeswrnen p-klubis dacvis TanamSromlebi _ m. da f-i. mas Semdeg, racyvelaferi Cawynarda, f-s hkiTxa, Tu ra moxda, razec f-mauTxra, rom Selaparakeba mouxdaT erTmaneTSi, d. o-i daW-reso. am SemTxvevas aseve Seeswro pokerklubis gverdiTarsebuli maRaziis TanamSromeli qali n., aseve axsovs sa-sursaTo maRaziis mepatrone axalgazrda biWi z.. d. o-isdaWris Semdeg SemTxvevis adgilze daaxloebiT naxevarsaaTSi mivida policia. mogvianebiT ubanSi mcxovreble-bisgan gaigo, rom daWrili d. o-i saavadmyofoSi gardaic-vala.

9.11. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli z. m-is CvenebiT dgindeba,rom a. b-es ar icnobs. 2004 wels m-sa da p-s quCebis kuTxeSimamamiss hqonda sasursaTo maRazia, romlis gverdiTac iyoslotklubi. 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers, saRamos, manqana gaa-Cera maRaziasTan, daaxloebiT 10-15 metrSi. am dros Se-moesma ginebis xma. gaixeda da dainaxa, rom erTi adamianidaiZra p-is, meore ki _ m-is mimarTulebiT. erTma Cqari na-bijiT gairbina. isini erTad myofebi ar daunaxavs, arc sa-xeze daunaxavs. axsovs, rom m-is quCisken mimavali piriaginebda p-sken gadamsvlels. mas xelSi eWira telefoni,romlis ekrani anaTebda, es unda yofiliyo `...~ modelis

122

telefoni. is piri, romelic gzas kveTda, ar axsovs, saiTwavida, yuradReba ar miuqcevia. arc is axsovs, koWlobdaTu ara. m-is quCisken mimavals rom vinme gamosdevnebo-des, ar SeuniSnavs, ar yofila es movlena misi dakvirvebissagani.

9.12. sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowme b. j-em ganmarta, rom2004 wlis 27 oqtombers gadaadgildeboda p-is gamzirzeTavisi kuTvnili a/manqana `...~, sax. #... . iyo sacobi da nelamoZraobda, imyofeboda g-as gamzirze mdebare maRazia `r-sTan~, rodesac SeamCnia ori biWi da erTi gogo. maT SoriserT-erTi biWi daWrili iyo, romelic SuaSi idga biWsa dagogos Soris. man daWrili piri manqanaSi, ukana savarZel-ze moaTavsa, xolo misi Tanmxlebi piri wina savarZelzedajda, ris Semdegac wavidnen r-r saavadmyofoSi.

9.13. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamoikvlies mowme m. l-s Cve-nebis adgilze Semowmebisa da SemTxvevis adgilis daTva-lierebis oqmi, romlis Tanaxmad, 2004 wlis 27 oqtombers,daaxloebiT 19 saaTze, imyofeboda maRazia `k-s~ sawyob-Si, ra drosac Semoesma Cxubi quCidan. gavida da dadga kar-Tan. dainaxa, rom saSualo simaRlis, misTvis ucnobi, da-axloebiT 18 wlis biWi idga trotuarze kidesTan, miskenzurgiT, exura muqi feris `kepi~ da aginebda g-as gamzirzegadamsvlel, misTvis ucnob sam axalgazrda biWs. ginebada muqara gagrZelda daaxloebiT 2-3 wuTs, ris Semdegac`kepiani~ mibrunda da gaiqca m-is mimarTulebiT. is samibiWi ki gadavida gamzirze, sadac gaaCeres manqana da waiy-vanes v-as mimarTulebiT.

9.14. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamoqveynda mowme n. q-isCvenebebi, saidanac irkveva, rom igi gamovida maRaziidanda wavida gastronomSi. maRaziis karis win SeniSna axal-gazrda biWi, romelic saubrobda mobilurze. rogorc Sem-deg gaigo, es biWi d. o-i iyo. mas miuaxlovda 20 wlamdeasakis biWi, SavqurTukiani da Savkepiani, romelmac kate-goriulad mosTxova o-s damarekineo. o-ma aseve katego-riulad uTxra, arao. am biWma lanZRviT dauwyo laparaki _sadarbazoSi agiyvano. o-ma uTxra, wamo, gavideTo. am drosCauara da gadavida maRaziaSi. dabrunda daaxloebiT 5wuTSi da gaigo, rom o-i iyo daWrili mucelSi, Tumca iqvemyofma axalgazrda biWma, romelic maTxovrobs, uTxra,rom o-i mZimed ar unda yofiliyo daWrili, vinaidan Tavi-

123

si fexiT gadavida gzazeo. meore ki, romelic ekamaTebo-da o-s, gaqceula m-is siRrmisken. am biWs, romelic esaub-ra, Tu ar cdeba, hqvia d. k.. damWrelis aRwera ar SeuZlia.kamaTisas, rasac Seeswro, erTmaneTisTvis saxeliT ar mi-umarTavT. `kepians~ Cveulebrivi Tbilisuri aqcenti hqon-da.

9.15. m. k-is gamokiTxvis oqmiT dasturdeba, rom igi spe-cialobiT aris skolamdeli aRzrdis meTodikisa da peda-gogikis specialisti. is icnobda T. m-as, romelsac hyavdadaaxloebiT 17 wlis Svili, romelmac ar icoda wera-kiT-xva. mas T. m-am sTxova, rom moemzadebina misi Svili _ a. b.da eswavlebina misTvis wera-kiTxva. is a. b-s amecadinebda6 Tvis ganmavlobaSi, 2003 wlis bolodan 2004 wlis dasaw-yisamde. am periodSi a. b-es ver aswavla wera-kiTxva, igisaerTod ver imaxsovrebda, rasac uxsnida da elaparake-boda, ver imaxsovrebda davalebebs. a. b-em eqvsi Tvis man-Zilze Zlivs SeZlo Tavisi gvaris dawera. man ver aswavlaa. b-es elementaruli leqsic, romelsac Zalian iolad iT-viseben sabavSvo baRis aRsazrdelebi. a. b-em ver iswavlaaseve aTis farglebSi angariSi, ver werda Tanmimdevru-lad cifrebs. a. b-es Zalian moswonda da TamaSobda pata-ra, daaxloebiT 3-5 wlamde asakis bavSvebis saTamaSoebiT.mas ar SeeZlo damoukideblad cxovreba, ramdenadac aricoda elementaruli cxovrebiseuli moqceva. misive gan-martebiT, rodesac erT dRes a. b-is samecadinod mivida,igi saxlSi marto daxvda, ra drosac gazis suni igrZno.rodesac samzareuloSi Sevida, naxa, rom gazquris yvelaonkani Ria iyo, xolo a. b. Cabnelebul da fardaCamofare-bul oTaxSi marto ijda.

9.16. mowme n. k-is gamokiTxvis oqmis Tanaxmad, a. b. iyomisi sadamrigeblo klasis moswavle q-is _ sajaro skola-Si. a. b. bunebiT iyo Zalian kargi bavSvi, Tumca advilad`gamodioda wyobilebidan~. mas ufro ar SeeZlo swavla,vidre ar undoda. hqonda urTierTobis problema. a. b. misimoswavle iyo me-8 klasamde, Semdeg is gavida skolidan.Tavisi gonebrivi mdgomareobidan gamomdinare, mas undaeswavla inkluziuri swavlebis programiT.

9.17. stacionaruli sasamarTlo-fsiqiatriuli eqsper-tizis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad: `a. b-es aReniSneba msubuqigonebrivi CamorCeniloba (kodi _ ...). marTlsawinaaRmde-

124

go qmedebis Cadenis dros a. b-es aReniSneboda msubuqi go-nebrivi CamorCeniloba da mas SeeZlo, gaecnobierebina Ta-visi qmedebis faqtobrivi xasiaTi da marTlwinaaRmdego-ba da exelmZRvanela misTvis (Seracxadoba). a. b-is fsiqi-kur aSlilobas axasiaTebs qronikuli mimdinareoba. Tavi-si fsiqikuri mdgomareobiT a. b-es SeuZlia, angariSi gau-wios Tavs, uxelmZRvanelos mas, misces Cveneba da monawi-leoba miiRos sagamoZiebo da sasamarTlo moqmedebebSi. a.b-es aqvs gacnobierebuli gadawyvetilebis miRebis una-ri. a. b. imgvari fsiqikuri avadmyofobiT, romelic xelsuSlis sasjelis moxdas, daavadebuli ar aris. a. b-es aqvsfsiqikuri nakli, rac xels uSlis mis mier sakuTari dac-vis ganxorcielebas. a. b. Tavisi fsiqikuri mdgomareobiTiZulebiT mkurnalobas an aranebayoflobiT staciona-rul-fsiqiatriul daxmarebas ar saWiroebs~.

9.18. ambulatoriuli sasamarTlo fsiqiatriul-fsiqo-logiuri eqspertizis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad, amJamad S. S-s aReniSneba arafsiqozuli donis fsiqikuri aSliloba _organuli pirovnuli aSliloba (kodi _ ...). aRniSnul fsi-qikur aSlilobas axasiaTebs qronikuli mimdinareoba.2004_2005 wlebSi S. S-es raime fsiqikuri aSliloba, risgamoc ver gauwevda angariSs Tavis moqmedebas da ver ga-nagebda mas, ar aReniSneboda. 2004-2005 da 2014-2015 wleb-Si S. S-es ar hqonda da dReis mdgomareobiTac ar aqvs ise-Ti fsiqikuri nakli, ris gamoc ar SeeZlo da ar SeuZliasworad aRiqvas, daimaxsovros da aRidginos saqmisaTvismniSvnelobis mqone garemoebebi da miawodos informaciaan misces Cveneba, monawileoba miiRos sasamarTlo da sa-gamoZiebo moqmedebebSi. mexsierebis imgvari problemebi,ris gamoc SesaZloa, sworad ver daimaxsovros da gaixse-nos esa Tu is movlena, S. S-es ar aqvs.

9.19. eqspertma a. t-em sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxvi-sas daadastura mis mier gacemuli eqspertizis daskvne-bis siswore da ganmarta, rom a. b-es Tavdapirvelad Cau-tarda ambulatoriuli eqspertiza, ris Semdgomac saWi-ro gaxda stacionarulad dakvirveba. Semdeg Catarda sta-cionaruli eqspertiza; moxda dakvirveba; gamokvleul iq-na sisxlis samarTlis saqmis masalebi, warmodgenil iqnaalternatiuli eqspertizis daskvnac; sabolood dadgin-da, rom mas aReniSneba msubuqi gonebrivi CamorCeniloba,

125

kodi ... . marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebis Cadenis dros masaseve aReniSneboda es fsiqikuri paTologia, mas SeeZlo,gaecnobierebina Tavisi qmedebis faqtobrivi xasiaTi damarTlwinaaRmdegoba da exelmZRvanela misTvis. misi fsi-qikuri aSliloba atarebs qronikul xasiaTs. ar aris daa-vadebuli iseTi fsiqikuri daavadebiT, rac xels uSlissasjelis moxdas. rac Seexeba S. S-es, mowmis ganmartebiT,dasmuli iyo SekiTxvebi _ iyo Tu ara igi daavadebuli fsi-qikurad 2004-2005 wlebSi da 2014-2016 wlebSi da dReismdgomareobiT hqonda Tu ara fsiqikuri nakli, aseve max-sovrobis problemebi. S. S. ambulatoriulad gamoikvlies.daskvna iyo aseTi: S. S-es aqvs arafsiqozuri donis fsiqi-kuri aSliloba, kodi _ ... . mas miTiTebul wlebSi ar hqondaraime fsiqozuri daavadeba, rom ver gaewia angariSi Tavi-si moqmedebisTvis da aseTi arc dReis mdgomareobiT araqvs. rac Seexeba mis Seracxadobas, kvlevis sagani ar yo-fila, radgan mas brali ar hqonda wardgenili.advokatiskiTxvaze eqspertma ganmarta, rom kodi ... niSnavs msubuqgonebriv CamorCenilobas da a. b-sTan mimarTebiT Seesaba-meba 12-13 wlis asaks.

9.20. sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis 2004 wlis 27oqtombris #... daskvnis mixedviT (udavo mtkicebuleba),d. o-is sikvdilis uSualo mizezia naCxvlet-nakveTi Wri-loba gulmkerdis marcxena naxevarSi, Semavali gulmker-dis RruSi, marcxena filtvisa da gulis dazianebiT, ra-sac Sedegad mohyva masobrivi sisxldena da organizmismwvave sisxlnaklebobis ganviTareba.

10. rac Seexeba mtkicebulebaTa utyuarobis Sesafaseb-lad gasaanalizebel pirvel sakiTxs _ rom Cvenebebi, rom-lebsac daeyrdno gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni, micemulia Sem-Txvevidan 11 wlis Semdeg _ amasTan dakavSirebiT mindaaRvniSno: Cemi kolega mosamarTleebis mosazrebiT, gau-marTlebelia mtkicebulebaTa sandoobis Sefasebisas gan-msazRvreli mniSvneloba mivaniWoT momxdari faqtidanCvenebis micemamde gasul dros. me veTanxmebi Cemi kole-gebis aRniSnul zogadi xasiaTis ganmartebas, vinaidan, sa-kasacio palatas Cvenive SemadgenlobiT, araerT saqmezedaudgenia ganaCeni wlebis Semdeg micemuli Cvenebebis sa-fuZvelze. Tumca, mocemul saqmeSi pirdapiri Cvenebebisgaziarebis problema dakavSirebulia ara drois faqtor-

126

Tan, aramed _ mis SeuTavseblobasTan saqmis sxva garemoe-bebTan, kerZod:

11. mowmeebi: S. S., g. m. da l. b. TavianT CvenebebSi gamoZi-ebasTan droulad arTanamSromlobis mizezad asaxelebenyofil xelisuflebaSi a.b-is dedis gavleniani megobre-bis sakiTxs. ufro zustad, maTi mxridan SesaZlo SurisZi-ebis SiSis faqtors.

12. am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT, sakasacio palatis Cemikolega mosamarTleebis poziciaa, rom a) SiSis faqtorzemetad, aq mniSvnelovania maTi asaki, vinaidan aRniSnulimowmeebi im dros iyvnen 14-15 wlisani da am asakSi ar moeT-xovebodaT moqalaqeobrivi pasuxismgeblobisa da mar-TlSegnebis maRali done; amasTan, im dros qveyanaSi iyomZime kriminogenuli viTareba da gamoZiebas Cvenebebi mis-ces ukve zrdasrul asakSi; b) Tanac, d. o-is ojaxisaTvisisedac imave dRes gaxda cnobili savaraudo mkvlelis Se-saxeb.

13. aRsaniSnavia, rom mowmeebi TavianT CvenebebSi saer-Tod ar miuTiTeben asakobriv faqtorze (ramac, savarau-dod, ganapiroba maTi dumili), aramed isini erTmniSvne-lovnad asaxeleben a. b-is dedis megobrul kavSirs maSin-deli xelisuflebis gavlenian pirebTan da amasTan dakav-Sirebul SiSis faqtors. Sesabamisad, Cemi kolegebis Se-faseba met-naklebad gansxvavdeba mowmeTa ganmartebisa-gan.

14. amasTan, gaugebaria 2012 wels saqarTveloSi xeli-suflebis Secvlis Semdeg, ratom dumdnen isini kidev 3wlis ganmavlobaSi _ 2015 wlamde. am dros xom ukve mox-snili iyo rogorc asakobrivi, ise zemoT miTiTebuli ga-remoebebiT gamowveuli SiSis faqtorebi.

15. rac Seexeba Cemi kolegebis mxridan mowmeTa gauT-qmelobis motivad, damatebiT im faqtoris moSveliebas,rom ojaxma imave dRes isedac icoda savaraudo mkvlelisSesaxeb, vfiqrob, es ewinaaRmdegeba maTsave pozicias, vi-naidan, Tuki yvelam isedac icoda mkvlelis vinaobis Se-saxeb, maSin gaugebaria, ratom unda yofiliyo didi samo-qalaqo gabedulebis an gansakuTrebuli marTlSegnebis ga-movlenis magaliTi maTi mxridan gardacvlilis ojaxis-Tvis realuri informaciis miwodeba.

16. sxdomebze S. S-e mTeli dakiTxvis periodSi sasamar-

127

Tlos urTierTgamomricxav informaciebs awvdida. manganmarta, rom mowmis saxiT pirvelad ikiTxeboda. TumcaCvenebis bolos daaviwyda aRniSnuli da dacvis mxaris kiT-xvaze, Tu ram ganapiroba mis mier Cvenebis micema 11 wlisSemdeg, aRniSna, rom erT-erT mkvlelobis saqmeze, romel-zec icoda, rac moxda da ikiTxeboda, gardacvlilis de-dam sTxova eTqva simarTle, ramac masze gavlena moaxdinada gadawyvita am saqmezec eTqva simarTle.

17. amasTan dakavSirebiT, bunebrivia, Cndeba kiTxva: Tu-ki 11 wlis Semdeg ucxo qalis erTma sityvam (sxva sisxlissamarTlis saqmeze naTqvamma) gadaawyvetina a.b-is sisxlissamarTlis saqmeze TanamSromloba, imave dReebSi, panaS-videbze yofnisas, ratom ar uambo yvelaferi Tavisi uax-loesi megobris Wirisufal ojaxs, romelTac, ra Tqma un-da, garda mkvlelis vinaobisa, ainteresebdaT am saqmes-Tan dakavSirebuli yvela detali.

18. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, mimaCnia, rom mow-meebis: S. S-is, g. m-isa da l. b-is ganmartebebi gamoZiebas-Tan 11 wlis Semdeg TanamSromlobis sakiTxTan dakavSire-biT, aris aSkarad aralogikuri da aradamajerebebli, risgamoc ar veTanxmebi Cemi kolega mosamarTleebis pozici-as am ganmartebebis gaziarebis nawilSi.

19. rac Seexeba utyuarobis Sesafaseblad gasaanalize-bel Semdeg komponents _ mtkicebulebebTan (CvenebebTan)dakavSirebuli winaaRmdegobebis sakiTxs _ aq aRsaniSna-via, rom es winaaRmdegobebi gamokveTilia da samive instan-ciis sasamarTlo msjelobs praqtikulad erTsa da imavemocemulobis irgvliv. gansxvaveba mxolod Sefasebis na-wilSia. pirveli instanciisa da saapelacio sasamarTlo-ebma miiCnies, rom aRniSnuli winaaRmdegobebi arsebiTi xa-siaTisaa da amitom ar gaiziares es mtkicebulebebi, xoloCems kolega mosamarTleebs miaCniaT, rom Cvenebebs So-ris arsebiTi xasiaTis winaaRmdegobebi ar arsebobs da mow-meebis: S.S-is, g.m-is da l.b-is Cvenebebis utyuaroba aravi-Tar eWvs ar iwvevs. Cems kolegebs aRniSnul SefasebaSicver daveTanxmebi Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

20. rogorc S. S-e Tavis CvenebaSi aRniSnavs, igi g. m-es-Tan erTad imyofeboda slotklub `g-is~ mimdebared, mo-pirdapire mxares, ra drosac SeniSna raRac CoCqoli. dai-naxa, Tu rogor daartya daniani xeli a. b-em d. o-s orjer.

128

Semdeg naxa, Tu rogor gadarboda quCaze j. m-i, albaT,misaSveleblad. Tavad SemTxvevis adgilisken ar wasula,daibna da gezi aiRo xelmarjvniv, maRazia `d-sken~. Sem-deg ki saxlSi wavida. meore dRes gaigo d. o-is gardacva-lebis Sesaxeb. S. S-is ganmartebiT, manamde Seixeda saxaWa-pureSi, sadac SeniSna j. m-i, a. a-i da b-i. analogiuri Sina-arsis Cveneba misca sasamarTlos mowme g. m-mac, oRond imgansxvavebiT, rom daWris Semdeg man gadakveTa quCa da wa-vida a. b-is mosaZebnad, Tumca ver ipova da saxlSi wavida.d.o-is daWramde saxaWapuresTan, birJaze, SeniSna nacno-bebi _ j. m-i, a. a-i, a-e da b-i. daWris Semdeg quCas TiTqmiserTdroulad kveTdnen Tavad da j. m-i. mowme j. m-i ki,romelmac, rogorc saqmis masalebiTaa dadasturebuli,namdvilad gadakveTa quCa da mivida daWrilTan, katego-riulad uaryofs S. S-isa da g. m-is SemTxvevis adgilis mim-debared danaxvis faqts.

21. aRsaniSnavia aseve S. S-isa da g. m-is miTiTeba, romSemTxvevamde, saxaWapuresTan SeniSnes j. m-i, a. as-i, g. a-eda g. b-i, maSin, roca mowmeebma _ j. m-ma da a. n-ma erTmniS-vnelovnad ganmartes, rom am dros maTTan erTad sxva pi-rebi, maT Soris _ a-i da b-i, ar yofilan.

22. am garemoebas Cemi kolegebi saapelacio sasamarTlo-sagan gansxvavebul interpretacias aZleven da aRniSna-ven, rom a. n-ma ar gamoricxa S. S-isa da g. m-is maT siaxlo-ves yofnis faqti, maSin, rodesac rogorc j. m-i, ise a. n-iSinaarsobrivad namdvilad gamoricxaven zemoaRniSnulfaqts. isini ar adastureben obieqturad, mowmeTa mieraRweril garemoebebSi, maTi ganlagebis, maTi moqmedebe-bis gaTvaliswinebiT, sxva nacnobebis iq yofnas. mxolodbraldebis mxaris araerTjeradi SekiTxvis Semdeg aRniS-na a. n-ma, rom garSemo SeiZleba kidev vinme yofiliyo, racar axsovs. mimaCnia, rom a. n-is CvenebasTan dakavSirebuliCemi kolegebis interpretacia ar gamomdinareobs mowmisCvenebis suliskveTebidan da ar unda ganimartos im mniS-vnelobiT, rom TiTqos m-isa da n-is siaxloves imyofebod-nen S-e da m-e da n-ma, marTalia, ver dainaxa, magram dauSvamaTi iq yofnis SesaZlebloba.

23. am sakiTxTan mimarTebiT ar veTanxmebi Cemi kolege-bis kidev erT Sefasebas, rodesac aRniSnaven, rom j. m-isada a. n-is mier maT siaxloves nacnobebis verdanaxva sru-

129

liad bunebrivia, radgan gonebaSi maT ufro metad Semor-CaT TavianT megobarTan dakavSirebuli konfliqturi si-tuacia, vidre -sxva, meorexarisxovani garemoebebi (ro-goricaa nacnobebis danaxva). Tumca, aRsaniSnavia, rom amSefasebas isini akeTeben mxolod j. m-isa da a. n-is Sesaxebda ara aseve S. S-isa da g. m-is mimarTac, romlebic analogi-ur situaciaSi imyofebodnen (j. m-sa da a. n-is msgavsadxedavdnen konfliqtis faqts, d. o-i maTi megobaric iyoda mTeli koncentracia konfliqtisken unda hqonodaTaseve mimarTuli) magram, miuxedavd amisa, maT ratomRacmainc kargad dainaxes j. m-ica da a. n-ic.

24. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, mimaCnia, rom aR-weril epizodebSi arsebiTi xasiaTis winaaRmdegobebi aS-karaa.

25. Cemi kolegebis poziciis mixedviT _ mocemul saqme-Si pirdapir CvenebebTan dakavSirebuli Seusabamobebi veriqneba xelis SemSleli garemoeba maTi gaziarebis Tval-sazrisiT, vinaidan, miuxedavad amgvari Seusabamobebisa,mTavari isaa, rom mowmeTa pirdapiri Cvenebebi erTobli-vad adastureben ZiriTad da yvelaze arsebiT faqtobrivgaremoebebs. amasTan, maTi mosazrebiT, TviTmxilvelimowmeebis Cvenebebis Sefaseba imis mixedviT, Tu rogoriqceodnen isini momxdari danaSaulis Semdeg, anda rashyvebian, ara faqtis monawile pirTa moqmedebebis, ara-med _ SemTxvevis dros sxva pirebis iq yofna-aryofnis Se-saxeb, am SemTxvevaSi mizanSeuwonelia.

26. sakasacio palatas araerTxel ganumartavs, rom mow-meTa Cvenebebi, rogorc wesi, ver iqneba identuri da essruliad bunebrivia, vinaidan yoveli adamiani individu-alurad aRiqvams movlenas. aseve gasaTvaliswinebeliamtkicebulebebis formirebis pirobebi, kerZod: xilvado-ba, xalxmravali adgili, manZili mowmesa da SemTxvevis ad-gils Soris, aseve SemTxvevidan gasuli dro da a.S., racsxvadasxva mowmis Cvenebas Soris arsebul araarsebiT wi-naaRmdegobebs sruliad logikurad xsnis. Tumca, rode-sac a. b-is braldebis saqmeSi Tavad mowmis Cveneba SeicavsurTierTgamomricxav da aralogikur informacias da amav-droulad, igi ewinaaRmdegeba sxva mowmeTa Cvenebebsac,rasac emateba iseTi sayuradRebo garemoebebi, rogoricaris 11-wliani drois periodi, xangrZlivi patimrobisas

130

erT sakanSi yofna _ mimaCnia, rom swored am dros undaSemowmdes detalurad yvela garemoeba, maT Soris _ dana-Saulis Semdeg ganviTarebuli movlenebi, TviTmxilvel-Ta moqmedebebi da sxva mravali detali. amitom ver dave-Tanxmebi Cems kolegebs im sakiTxSic, rom mocemul sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeSi mowmeebis mier ZiriTad faqtob-riv garemoebebze miTiTeba sakmarisia am Cvenebebis gazia-rebisa da gamoyenebisaTvis.

27. Cemi poziciis marTebulobis dasadastureblad mo-vixmob ramdenime magaliTs uzenaesi sasamarTlos bolowlebis praqtikidan:

27.1. sakasacio palatis #570ap-16 gadawyvetilebiT(mosamarTleebi: g. SavliaSvili, p. silagaZe, n. gvenetaZe),t. p-i saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-4 nawiliT war-dgenil braldebaSi im argumentebze dayrdnobiT gamar-Tlda, rom policielebis Cvenebebi (romelTa Tanaxmadac,isini SemTxvevis adgilTan swored im dros imyofebod-nen, rodesac braldebuli afTiaqis kibidan yuTiT xelSiCamorboda da misi afTiaqSi yofnis faqti sadavo ar iyo)ar iyo utyuari, kerZod: mas Semdeg, rac policielebma t.p-i saeWvo pirad miiCnies da misi SeCereba gadawyvites,braldebulis sirbilis miuxedavad, mowme policielma v.g-ma ganmarta, rom mas ukan gahyva (mowme policielma d.s-ma Tavis mxriv miuTiTa, rom v. g-i braldebuls srafi nabi-jiT aedevna), amasTan, policielebma ar dauZaxes bral-debuls maSinac ki, rodesac igi ormxrivi gasasvlelis mqo-ne sadarbazoSi Sedioda (saidanac kvalis dakargvis alba-Toba izrdeboda). kvalis dakargvis Semdeg aRniSnulma po-licielebma ar uxmes damxmare Zalas, arc raciiT gadas-ces amis Sesaxeb da aseve damajereblad ver axsnes, Tu da-naSaulis Semdeg braldebulis saxlSi misvla-armisvlisfaqti ratom ar gadaamowmes.

anu, miuxedavad imisa, rom mowme policielebi praqti-kulad Seeswrnen danaSaulis faqts da ZiriTad faqtob-riv garemoebas (rom t. p-i, yuTiT xelSi, afTiaqis kibezeCamorboda) erTgvarovnad gadmoscemdnen, sakasacio pa-latam, maTi Cvenebebi mainc ar gaiziara swored maTi qme-debebis aralogikurobisa da danaSaulis Semdegi epizo-debis aRwerisas gamokveTili Seusabamobebis motiviT;

27.2. k. k-e _ #262ap-17 (saqme ganxilulia igive Semad-

131

genlobiT). aRniSnuli piri narkotikul danaSaulSi gamar-Tlda, sami mowme policielis Cvenebebis winaaRmdegob-riobisa da maTi qcevis aralogikurobis gamo, kerZod: mow-me s-em ganmarta, rom m-isa da c-is garda SemTxvevis ad-gilze sxva aravin iyo, maSin, rodesac c-em dabejiTebiTganacxada, rom maTgan 3-6 metris moSorebiT idga polici-is ekipaJi, romelic, misi azriT, icavda perimetrs. aseveSeusabamo iyo maTi Cvenebebi k-is dakavebis nawilSic _ m-eaRniSnavda, rom manqaniT mividnen T-is dasaxlebaSi, me-10 saxlis mimdebared, imoZraves 10-15 wuTi, Semdeg wavid-nen qvemoT, qalaqis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac SeniSnesda daakaves k-Ze. c-is ganmartebiT ki _ policielebma ga-dakveTes rkinigzis gadasasvleli da qalaqidan T-is da-saxlebis mimarTulebiT gaemgzavrnen, SeniSnes k-e da ma-Sinve daakaves. amasTan, mowmeebma ver axsnes k-is myisieridakavebis aucilebloba, maSin, rodesac operatiuli in-formaciis Tanaxmad, braldebuls mis xelT arsebuli nar-kotiki unda gaesaRebina mesame pirze.

sagulisxmoa, rom samive policieli miuTiTebda k-isa-gan narkotikuli nivTierebis amoRebis faqtze (anu Ziri-Tad faqtobriv garemoebaze);

27.3. c. z-e _ #397ap-14 (mosamarTleebi: p. silagaZe, g.SavliaSvili, m.oSxareli). c. z-em d. m-s jer muSti CaartyaxelSi, xolo Semdeg CanTa _ Tavsa da gulmkerdis areSi,ris Sedegadac miayena msubuqi xarisxis dazianeba jan-mrTelobis mouSlelad. miuxedavad imisa, rom mowmeebidanaSaulebriv faqts adasturebdnen, gansxvavebulad aR-werdnen ganviTarebul movlenebs, magaliTad: dazarale-bulis ganmartebiT, misi cemis Semdeg c. z-e wavida sve-ticxovlis Sesasvlelisken, xolo m. x-is ganmartebiT, z-egaemarTa sapirispiro mimarTulebiT; dazaralebulis gan-martebiT, misi cemis Semdeg ucxo pirebma misces damam-Svidebeli wamali, xolo mowme x-is CvenebiT, dazarale-buls wamali Tavad hqonda da sxvisgan ar miuRia da sxv.

sakasacio palatam ganmarta, rom erToblivad aRebulies winaaRmdegobebi damajereblobasa da sandoobas ukar-gavs maT Cvenebebs da ver akmayofilebs utyuarobis stan-darts, ris gamoc palatam isini ar gaiziara da braldebu-li z-e gaamarTla.

28. msgavsi araerTi praqtikuli magaliTis moyvana Se-

132

iZleba Cvenive SemadgenlobiT ganxiluli saqmeebidan,magram axla ufro konkretulad imis Sesaxeb, Tu ra arse-biTi mniSvnelobisa SeiZleba iyos is Seusabamobebi, rom-lebic ikveTeba a. b-is saqmis detalebSi da romlebic, Cemikolegebis mosazrebiT, ver iqneba xelis SemSleli S. S-is,g. m-isa da l. b-is Cvenebebis gaziarebis sakiTxSi, xoloCemi mosazrebiT, isini niadags aclis am CvenebaTa sando-obas:

29. mowme l. b-ma ganmarta, rom xuTi wuTis ganmavloba-Si idga `j-is~ ofisis win da iyureboda slotklub `g-is~mxares, ra drosac 20-25 metrSi SeniSna d. o-i da a. b-e, rom-lebic erTmaneTSi daZabulad saubrobdnen. am dros dai-naxa, Tu rogor daartya a. b-em dana d. o-s, ra drosac esukanaskneli Caikeca, Tavad ki daibna da sastumro `a-sken~Setrialda, 10-15 wamSi isev moixeda da dainaxa, Tu rogorkveTda quCas d. o-i. survili ar gasCenia, misuliyo d. o-Tan, rasac dabneulobiT xsnis. daaxloebiT naxevari wu-Tis Semdeg taqsiT datova iqauroba. momxdaris Sesaxeb ara-visTan araferi uTqvams da pirvelad gamoZiebas Cveneba2015 wels misca.

30. mowmis aseTi ganmarteba misi danaSaulis Semdegiqmedebis Sesaxeb TavSive ukargavs damajereblobas misCvenebas, vinaidan dainaxa, Tu rogor daartyes dana mismegobars da imis nacvlad, rom dainteresebuliyo momxda-riT da daxmareba gaewia daWrilisTvis, sastumro `a-sken~Setrialda, Semdeg ki saerTod datova SemTxvevis adgi-li.

31. aseve yuradsaRebia is garemoebac, rom b-is ganmar-tebiT, is faqtobrivad saxaWapuris mopirdapire mxaresimyofeboda da wesiT, igi j. m-s unda SeemCnia, rasac m-iuaryofs da aRniSnavs, rom b-i ar daunaxavs iseve, rogorcar daunaxavs arc S-e da arc m-e.

32. l. b-is msgavsad, S. S-is ganmartebac sruliad arabu-nebrivad da aradamajereblad gamoiyureba im nawilSi, sa-dac igi aRniSnavs, rom dabneulobis gamo ar mivida daWri-li d. o-is dasaxmareblad. saxlSi wavida da aRar ukiTxavsdaWrili megobris ambavi, man mxolod meore dRes gaigod.o-is gardacvaleba da es maSin, rodesac mTeli dakiT-xvis manZilze xazs usvamda Tavisi da d. o-is megobrobisambavs da imas, Tu rogori gansakuTrebulad kargi pirov-

133

neba iyo igi da rogor ganicdida mis gardacvalebas.33. mowme S.S-e aseve miuTiTebs, rom danis dartymis mo-

mentSi d.o-isa da a.b-sgan cota moSorebiT SeniSna g-i, ra-sac g-i uaryofs da misi ganmarteba, Tavis mxriv, sruladSeesabameba d. k-is Cvenebas, sadac igi miuTiTebs, rom g-marom gadmoirbina, eseni (o-i da -e) ukve gaqceulebi iyvne-no.

34. g. m-is ganmartebiT, is, rom Cxubi moxda mobilurisTaobaze, icis n. g-isgan, romelmac uTxra, rom afTiaqidangamosvlis Semdeg dainaxa, Tu rogor kamaTobdnen a. b-e dad. o-i da danis dartymis drosac iqve iyo. sruliad arada-majerebelia m-is aRniSnuli ganmarteba, radgan g-ma sasa-marTlos sxdomaze ganmarta, rom saerTod ar icnobs m-esda Tanac, am Temaze saerTod aravisTan usaubria.

35. mowme g-ma aseve ganmarta, rom afTiaqidan rodesacgamovida, SemTxveva ukve momxdari iyo, rasac adasturebsd. k-ec, romelic CvenebaSi aRniSnavs, rom g-ma roca gad-moirbina, b-e da o-i ukve gaqceulebi iyvneno. Cvenebis da-sasruls m-em saerTod Secvala Tavisive mowodebuli in-formacia da miuTiTa, rom vinme q-sgan Seityo, rom g-madainaxa Cxubis detalebi.

36. aq moyvanili faqtebis garda, mowmeebis: S. S-is, g. m-isa da l. b-is sasamarTloSi micemul CvenebebTan dakavSi-rebiT, pirveli da saapelacio instanciis sasamarTloebiyuradRebas uTmoben sxva Seusabamobebsac, magram vfiq-rob, rom am magaliTebis analizic sakmarisia arsebiTi wi-naaRmdegobebis naTeli suraTis warmosaCenad.

37. marTalia, mowmis Cveneba mis mier sasamarTloSi mi-cemuli informaciaa, magram mocemul SemTxvevaSi sainte-resoa S. S-is, g. m-isa da l. b-is mier gamoZiebisTvis miwo-debuli informaciac, kerZod:

38. S. S-em gamoZiebas ganumarta, rom dainaxa, rogor ga-movida slotklubidan d. o-i, romelsac ukan mohyveboda`a-o~. daWris faqtis danaxvis Semdeg gadawyvita, gahkide-boda b-es da gaiqca misi mimarTulebiT, magram sanam p-isquCa gadakveTa, daekarga TvalTaxedvis aredan. j-im mo-uyva Semdeg daWrili o-i rogor gadmoiyvana gzaze, gaaCe-ra gamvleli manqana da waiyvana saavadmyofoSi.

39. S. S-is Tanasaknelma g. m-em gamoZiebas miawoda Sem-degi informacia: dainaxa pokerklubidan rogor gamovid-

134

nen o-i da b-e. daWris faqtis Semdeg is da S-e gaekidnen b-es, magram sanam gza gadakveTes, a-i Sevarda ezoSi.

40. l. b-ma ki Semdegi Sinaarsis Cveneba misca: SemTxve-vis adgilze uceb Seikriba xalxi da isic wavida im mimar-TulebiT. dainaxa, rom o-i ramdenime biWma Casva manqanaSi.roca `p-Tan~ mivida, iq Sekrebili xalxi saubrobda, romdaWrili o-i ubnelma biWebma waiyvanes saavadmyofoSi.

41. bunebrivia, aseTi tipis ganmartebebi, rom maT dai-naxes daWris faqti da wavidnen SemTxvevis adgilisken,aris logikuri qceva da damajereblobas SesZenda maT Cve-nebebs, Tumca sasamarTloSi maT Secvales Cvenebebi, ker-Zod: S-em da b-ma moimizezes dabneuloba da miuTiTes, romgaecalnen iqaurobas. aqedan gamomdinare, logikuri xde-ba eWvi imis Sesaxeb, rom Tuki zemoxsenebuli mowmeebismier SemoTavazebuli versia ganviTardeboda imgvarad,rom isini gaemarTebodnen SemTxvevis adgilisaken, maSingamoZiebasa da sasamarTloSi mouwevdaT ufro konkretulkiTxvebze pasuxebis gacema, magaliTad: ra suraTi dax-vdaT iq? vin iyvnen SemTxvevis adgilze? ra moimoqmedesmaT da ase Semdeg. amasTan, isini aucileblad unda Seem-CniaT im pirebs, romelTa SemTxvevis adgilze yofnis faq-ti udavod dasturdeba (rac sadavo gaxda swored m-is Sem-TxvevaSi, roca man miuTiTa, rom faqtobrivad j-sTan er-Tad kveTda quCas, rac uaryo j. da kategoriulad ganmar-ta, rom iq m-e ar daunaxavs), SesaZlebelia, zemoaRniSnul-ma mowmeebma amitomac airCies SemTxvevis adgilidan gan-ridebis mogonili versia.

42. rogorc aRvniSne, dacvis mxare gamoTqvams eWvs S. S-isa da g. m-is mier gamoZiebasTan SeTanxmebuli Cvenebismicemis Sesaxeb, magram mimaCnia, rom am mosazrebas samar-Tlebrivi safuZveli ar gaaCnia da verc raime mtkicebu-lebas warmoadgenda braldebis mxare imis samtkiceblad,rom raime ukanono garigebas ar sTavazobda aRniSnul mow-meebs. amitom am nawilSi veTanxmebi sakasacio palatis mo-samarTleebs, Tumca es ar gamoricxavs maRal albaTobas,rom S. S-esa da g. m-es, piradi motivebidan gamomdinare,poziciebi SeeTanxmebinaT ara, magaliTad, braldebis mxa-resTan, aramed _ erTmaneTTan da Semdeg SeTanxmebuli,SemTxvevis adgilze yofnis mogonili, mcdari versia mie-wodebinaT gamoZiebisaTvis.

135

43. zemoaRniSnuli sakiTxebis gaanalizebis Sedegad mi-maCnia, rom mowmeebis: S. S-is, g. m-isa da l. b-is Cvenebebi arunda iqnes gaziarebuli da ar SeiZleba safuZvlad dae-dos gamamtyunebel ganaCens, vinaidan isini ver akmayofi-lebs utyuarobis konstituciur-samarTlebriv stan-darts.

44. rac Seexeba saqmeSi warmodgenil sxva mtkicebule-bebs da maTi sakmarisobis sakiTxs:

45. mowmeebi _ j. m-i da a. n-i miuTiTeben mxolod im faq-tobriv garemoebaze, rom dainaxes d. o-is konfliqti maT-Tvis ucxo pirTan. Sesabamisad, maTi Cvenebebi ar Seicavsinformacias a.b-is braleulobasTan dakavSirebiT.

46. mowmeebis _ m. l-is, z. m-isa da n. q-is Cvenebebi asevemiuTiTeben mxolod or pirs Soris arsebul konfliqtzeda raime informacias, rac braldebulis identificire-bis saSualebas mogvcemda, isini ar gvawvdian. metic, mow-me n. q-is ganmartebiT, pirs, romelic d. o-s ekamaTeboda,hqonda Cveulebrivi Tbilisuri aqcenti, maSin, rodesaca. b-e iyo a-dan da T-Si axali gadmosuli iyo sacxovreb-lad (daaxloebiT erTi wlis). amasTan, misi imJamindeli in-teleqtualuri ganviTarebis done Seesabameboda 9-12wlis bavSvis asaks (rasac aseve adastureben mowmeebi _ m.k-i da n. k-e). Cndeba kiTxva, Tu ramdenad SeeZlo mas kama-Tis dros esaubra Cveulebrivi, Tbilisuri aqcentiT.

47. n. g-is Cvenebis is nawili ki, sadac aRniSnavs, rom d.k-isgan Seityo rom `a-om~ daWra `u-a~-erTmniSvnelovnadiribi mtkicebulebaa (vinaidan n. g-i sasamarTlos awvdisinformacias, romelic sxva pirisgan moismina), ris gamoc,saqarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 22ianvris gadawyvetilebis Tanaxmad, ar akmayofilebs ut-yuarobis konstituciur-samarTlebriv standarts da veriqneba gaziarebuli, miTumetes imis gaTvalisiwinebiT,rom sasamarTloSi ar dakiTxula informaciis wyaro _ d.k-e.

48. aRsaniSnavia, rom d. k-is Cveneba arsebiTi mniSvne-lobisaa saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT a. b-is msjav-rdebis sakiTxis gadasawyvetad, vinaidan igi erTaderTipirdapiri mtkicebulebaa, romelic miuTiTebs persona-lurad a. b-is mier d. o-is mkvlelobis faqtze. Tumca, aqgasaTvaliwinebelia, rom es Cveneba garkveul epizodebSi

136

arsebiTad ewinaaRmdegeba sxva mtkicebulebebs, kerZod:49. d. k-is gamoZiebaSi micemuli CvenebiT dgindeba, rom

d. o-i megobarTan erTad imyofeboda pokerklubSi da Ta-maSobda aparatze. am dros pokerklubSi Sevida à-o~, ga-reT gamoiyvana d. o-i da mosTxova e.w. `Tavanis~ Cabareba,ra drosac maT Soris daiwyo Cxubi. Cxubis dasrulebis Sem-deg im adgilze SeniSna sisxlis laqebi. aRniSnuli Cvene-bidan gamomdinare, TvalSisacemi winaaRmdegobaa, erTimxriv, mowmeebis _ j. m-is, a. n-isa da n. g-is da meore mxriv_ d. k-is Cvenebebs Soris. j. m-i da a. n-i ganmartaven, rom d.o-i maTTan mivida telefonze darekvis TxovniT, uarismiRebis Semdeg ki gadavida `g-is~ mxares im imediT, romvinme telefonians ipovida. vinaidan n-sac undoda darek-va, akvirdeboda d. o-s, ra drosac dainaxa ucnob pirTanmokamaTe d. o-i. am ganmartebidan gamomdinare, d. o-islotklubSi saTamaSod ar yofila.

50. d. k-is Cveneba aseve ewinaaRmdegeba mowme n. g-is Cve-nebas, romelic acxadebs, rom afTiaqSi mimavals, ezoSiSexvda a. b-e da erTad wavidnen g-ias gamzirisken. slot-klub `g-Tan~ a. b-es Sexvda viRac piri, romelTanac daiwyodaZabuli saubari, Tavad ar gaCerebula da gadavida af-TiaqSi. rodesac iqidan gamovida, slotklubis win SeniSnaxalxmravloba. Semdeg Sexvda d. k-e da uTxra _ à-om~ daW-ra ù-o~, anu n. g-i acxadebs, rom gzaSi erTad mimavlebsSexvdaT piri, romelTanac a. b-em kamaTi daiwyo, xolo d.k-e ganmartavs, rom a. b-e slotklubSi Sevida da aparatzemoTamaSe d. o-i gareT gamoiyvana. Tuki d. o-i slotklubSiiyo da TamaSobda, igi n. g-Tan erTad mimaval a. b-es verSexvdeboda.

51. d. k-is Cvenebas ewinaaRmdegeba aseve sxva mowmeTaCvenebebic, kerZod: misi Cvenebis mixedviT, kamaTis mize-zi iyo a. b-is mier d. o-isaTvis moTxovnili e.w. `Tavani~.sxva mowmeebi ki (magaliTad, n. q-e) acxadeben, rom Cxubimoxda ara TavanTan dakavSirebiT, aramed _ telefonzedarekvis gamo.

52. Cemi kolegebis mosazrebiT, mkvlelis CacmulobisaRweris nawilSi mowmeebi _ d. k-e da n. q-e msgavs CvenebebsiZlevian da amiTac dasturdeba is faqti, rom mkvleli a.b-ea. xolo rac Seexeba konfliqtis dawyebis Temas, ro-melsac gansxvavebulad aRweren aRniSnuli mowmeebi, esec

137

bunebrivia, vinaidan konfliqti gamoiwvia mobilur tele-fonze darekvis survilma da am faqts, n. q-is garda, sxvamowmeebic adastureben. xolo `Tavani~, rogorc konfliq-tis dawyebis mizezi, mowme d. k-es SesaZloa, SecdomiT imi-tom daamaxsovrda, rom SemTxvevidan didi droa gasulida ubralod, ase darCa mexsierebaSi, n. q-em ki Cveneba Sem-Txvevidan maleve misca da mas ukeTesad amitom emaxsov-reboda.

53. ver daveTanxmebi Cemi kolegebis zemoaRniSnulmsjelobas da am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT minda gamovyoori garemoeba: erTi, rom konfliqtis mizezis aRweris na-wilSi am mowmeTa Cvenebebs Soris winaaRmdegoba arsebi-Tia, vinaidan aRniSnuli mowmeebi asaxeleben ara mxolodkonfliqtis Temas, aramed am Temis Sinaarssac gadmosce-men detalurad, rac, Cemi azriT, gamoricxavs drois faq-toris gavleniT d. k-is mier sakiTxis arasworad aRqmisversias. kerZod: d. k-e am nawilSi iZleva Semdeg Cvenebas:me mesmoda à-a~ da d. o-is saubari. à-m~ d. o-s hkiTxa, Turodis apirebda e.w. `Tavanis~ Cabarebas, razec d. o-ma upa-suxa, rom ramdenime TveSi Caabarebda. maT ar daukonkre-tebiaT `Tavanis~ saxiT ra Tanxa hqonda Casabarebeli d. o-s à-saTvis.~

54. xolo n. q-e imave situacias aRwers ase: ùcnobmaaxalgazrda biWma d. o-s kategoriuli toniT mosTxova te-lefonze darekva, rasac o-ma miugo aseve kategoriuli to-niT, rom ar daarekvinebda. axalgazrda biWma dauwyo o-slanZRviT laparaki `ras hqvia, ar damarekvineb, sadarba-zoSi gagiyvano~ da daemuqra ginebiT, rasac d. o-ma upasu-xa `wamodi, gavideTo~.

55. da meore garemoeba _ veTanxmebi Cemi kolegebis po-zicias im nawilSi, rom araviTari mniSvneloba ara aqvs kon-fliqtis dawyebis mizezs, radgan faqtia, rom konfliqtirealurad arsebobda. magram aq unda aRvniSno, rom kon-fliqtis mizezis gaanalizeba mniSvnelovania CvenebebisSefasebis miznebisaTvis, anu mTavaria is, Tu romeli Cve-neba unda gaiziaros sasamarTlom: d. k-is _ romelic ewina-aRmdegeba n. g-isa da sxva mowmeebis Cvenebebs, sadac isinigansxvavebulad aRweren d. o-isa da damnaSavis Sexvedrismoments, Tu n. q-is _ romelic damatebiT imasac aRniSnavs,rom o-Tan konfliqtSi myof axalgazrdas hqonda Cveuleb-

138

rivi, Tbilisuri aqcenti.56. mowme d.k-e aseve uTiTebs, rom Semdeg `a-o~ gaiqca p-

is gamzirze, man Tavze Camoifara `kepi~ da ise garboda.saqmeze dakiTxuli TiTqmis yvela mowme ki adasturebs,rom a. b-e wavida ara p-is gamzirze, aramed _ m-is quCis mi-marTulebiT.

57. miuxedavad imisa, rom d.k-is sasamarTloSi gamoq-veynebuli Cveneba pirdapiri mtkicebulebaa, romelic mi-uTiTebs a.b-ze, rogorc danaSaulis Camden pirze, igi arunda iqnes gamoyenebuli gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis safuZ-vlad, vinaidan dacvis mxares arc gamoZiebis etapze daarc sasamarTlo ganxilvis dros ar hqonia d. k-is gamokiT-xvis, dakiTxvis an misi Cvenebebis gaprotestebis adekva-turi saSualeba, rac Zalze mniSvnelovani iqneboda sasa-marTlosTvis sxva mowmeebis CvenebebTan dakavSirebuliSeusabamobebis gasaanalizeblad. mxaris mier dasmul kiT-xvebs am dros SeuZlia, ara mxolod mowmeTa sandoobis Se-fasebis sakiTxze moaxdinos gavlena, aramed naTeli moh-finos iseT garemoebas, romelic wardgenil braldebas-Tan mimarTebiT sasamarTlos saboloo daskvnaze moaxden-da gavlenas.

58. mowmeTa jvaredini dakiTxvis ufleba unda iqnes ga-gebuli SejibrebiTobis procesis WrilSi, rac samarTlia-ni sasamarTlos koncefciaSi devs da gulisxmobs, rom mo-sarCeles mieces mowmis gancxadebis an Cvenebis nebismieraspeqtSi Sedavebis SesaZlebloba. aq mniSvnelovania ase-ve zepirobis principi, romelic gulisxmobs sasamarTlosuSualo kontaqts pirebTan, romlebic Cvenebas iZlevianprocesze, kerZod, braldebuli unda daupirispirdesmowmes mosamarTlis TandaswrebiT, romelic iRebs sabo-loo gadawyvetilebas saqmeze, raTa SesaZlebeli gaxdesmowmis qcevis manerasa da sandoobaze yuradRebiT dak-virveba.

59. saqmeze, Al-Khawaja da Tahery gaerTianebuli samefoswinaaRmdeg, adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlosdidma palatam daadgina adamianis uflebaTa evropulikonvenciis me-6 muxlis darRveva vinaidan meore ganmcxa-debeli (batoni taheri) moklebuli iyo SesaZleblobas, Se-emowmebina T-s Cvenebis sandooba jvaredini dakiTxviT,aseve, vinaidan T erTaderTi mowme iyo, romelmac moisurva

139

da SeZlo eTqva, Tu ra naxa, ganmcxadebels ki ar SeeZlomoewvia sxva mowme, romelic daupirispirdeboda am Cve-nebas.

60. da bolos: a. b-is braldebis sisxlis samarTlis saq-meSi warmodgenili mowmeebis: S. S-is, l. b-isa da g. m-is Cve-nebebi ar unda iqnes gaziarebuli, vinaidan ver gaqarwyldaeWvi maTi SemTxvevis adgilze yofnis faqtTan dakavSire-biT da isini ar akmayofilebs utyuarobisa da sandoobismtkicebiT standarts; aseve ar unda iqnes gaziarebuli d.k-is Cvenebac, romelic, miuxedavad imisa, rom pirdapirimtkicebulebaa, ver moxerxda misi uSualod da zepiraddakiTxva, sxva CvenebebTan dakavSirebuli, arsebiTi Seu-sabamobebis axsnis mizniT; xolo rac Seexeba saqmeSi arse-bul sxva mtkicebulebebs, isini ar miuTiTeben persona-lurad a. b-is braleulobaze, ris gamoc ar aris sakmarisigamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamosatanad. Sesabamisad, pirismimarT wardgenili bralis dasadastureblad, zemoaRniS-nuli standartis mtkicebulebaTa bazis gamoyenebis praq-tikis damkvidreba uzenaesi sasamarTlos aqamde dadge-nili praqtikis erTmniSvnelovnad sawinaaRmdegod, mimaC-nia, rom xels Seuwyobs udanaSaulo pir(eb)is msjavrde-bis riskebis gazrdas da Seusabamoa sisxlis samarTlis sap-roceso kanonmdeblobasTanac, romlis mixedviT, gamam-tyunebeli ganaCeni unda efuZnebodes mxolod erTmaneT-Tan SeTanxmebul, aSkara da damajerebel mtkicebuleba-Ta erTobliobas, romelic gonivrul eWvs miRma adastu-rebs piris braleulobas. sssk-is 82-e muxlis 1-li nawilisTanaxmad, mtkicebuleba unda Sefasdes sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmesTan misi relevanturobis, dasaSvebobisa dautyuarobis TvalsazrisiT. amave muxlis me-3 nawilis Se-sabamisad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT piris damnaSavedcnobisaTvis saWiroa gonivrul eWvs miRma arsebul SeTan-xmebul mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba. sssk-is 259-e mux-lis mesame nawilis mixedviT ki, sasamarTlos ganaCeni da-sabuTebulia, Tu is emyareba sasamarTlo ganxilvis drosgamokvleul, gonivruli eWvis gamomricxav mtkicebule-baTa erTobliobas.

61. gonivrul eWvs miRma standartis Taobaze imsjelasaqarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlomac 2015 wlis 22ianvris gadawyvetilebaSi, romelSic aRniSna: gonivrul

140

eWvs miRma mtkicebulebiTi standarti uzrunvelyofsudanaSaulobis prezumfciis dacvas, arsebiTad amcirebsusamarTlo da dausabuTebeli gamamtyunebeli ganaCenissafrTxes, marTlmsajulebis ganxorcielebis procesSixels uwyobs Secdomis daSvebis safrTxis Tavidan acile-bas. msjavrdebuls ar unda Seeracxos danaSauli manam, sa-nam mtkicebulebebis sakmarisi da damajerebeli erTob-liobiT ar dadasturdeba danaSaulis TiToeuli elemen-tis arseboba mis qmedebaSi. amasTan, gonivrul eWvs miRmastandarti TamaSobs mniSvnelovan rols sazogadoebisndobis CamoyalibebaSi.saxelmwifos legitimuri ufleba,ganaxorcielos sisxlissamarTlebrivi devna, aRasrulosmarTlmsajuleba, ar unda iqnes dasustebuli iseTi mtki-cebulebiTi standartiT, romelic miukerZoebel adami-ans, sazogadoebas gauCens eWvs udanaSaulo piris msjav-rdebis Sesaxeb.

62. yovelive zemoTqmulidan gamomdinare, mimaCnia,rom saapelacio sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 4 oqtombris gana-Ceni a. b-is braldebis saqmeze aris kanonieri da ar arse-bobs misi gauqmebis safuZveli, vinaidan ar aris warmod-genili utyuar mtkicebulebaTa iseTi erToblioba, racsakmarisi iqneboda gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT ga-mamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamosatanad.

141

ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana da msjavrdebulisgamarTleba saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis 179-e muxliT wardgenil braldebaSi


#393ap.-17 3 ianvari, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi



ganixila msjavrdebulebis _ b. a-is, g. g-sa da l. a-is;msjavrdebul d. a-is advokatebis _ a. a-sa da s. b-is; msjav-rdebul r. j-is advokatis _ s. b-is; msjavrdebul a. g-isadvokatebis _ o. g-isa da m. r-is sakasacio saCivrebi quTa-isis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTapalatis 2017 wlis 24 maisis ganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. braldebis arsi:1.1. k. f-ze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis epizodir. j-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-

ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiTa da aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis mu-qariT, jgufurad, araerTgzis, didi odenobiT nivTis da-uflebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis `b~ qvepunqtiTa da me-3 nawilis `a~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT.

l. a-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiTa da aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis mu-qariT, jgufurad, araerTgzis, didi odenobiT nivTis da-uflebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis `b~ qvepunqtiTa da me-3 nawilis `a~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT.

142

r. j-isa da l. a-is qmedeba gamoixata SemdegSi:2015 wlis 25 agvistos, daaxloebiT 12:00 saaTze, q.q-Si,

S-os quCis #20-Si arsebul gazgasamarT sadgur Sps `...-as~ezoSi, cecxlsasroli iaraRebis msgavsi sagnebiTa da da-niT SeiaraRebuli, qurdobisaTvis nasamarTlevi r. j-e,motyuebiT qonebrivi dazianebisa da ZarcvisaTvis nasa-marTlevi l. a-e da gamoZiebiT daudgeneli sami piri Tavsdaesxnen gazgasamarTi sadguris mflobels, k. f-es. Tav-damsxmelebma dazaralebuls scemes xelebiTa da fexebiT,TavSi Caartyes cecxlsasroli iaraRis msgavsi sagnis kon-daxi, riTac miayenes janmrTelobis dazianeba da sicoc-xlisaTvis saSiSi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqariT misgangaitaces 1175 lari, 6300 larad Rirebuli oqros Zewkvi,1100 larad Rirebuli oqros jvari, `seikos~ firmis 1000larad Rirebuli saaTi, `reibanis~ firmis 10 larad Rire-buli saTvale, `nikes~ firmis 100 larad Rirebuli foto-aparati mexsierebis baraTTan erTad, `samsungis~ firmis480 larad Rirebuli telefoni simbaraTebTan erTad, mo-biluri telefonis 70 larad Rirebuli damteni da 25 la-rad Rirebuli yursasmeni, `orientis~ firmis 100 laradRirebuli saaTi, `bilainis~ 35 larad Rirebuli modemi,avtomobilis 100 larad Rirebuli gasaRebi, 60 larad Ri-rebuli tyavis safule, sxvadasxva dasaxelebis plasti-kuri baraTebi da piradobis damadasturebeli ID baraTi,sul _ 10640 larze metad Rirebuli qoneba, riTac daza-ralebuls miadga didi odenobiT ziani.

1.2. r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis epizodir. j-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-

ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiT, aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT, jgufurad, araerTgzis, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT,satransporto saSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odenobiTnivTis dauflebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebulisaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `a~, `b~,`g~ qvepunqtebiT.

a. g-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-

143

vis saSiSi ZaladobiT, aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT, jgufurad, araerTgzis, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT,satransporto saSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odenobiTnivTis dauflebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebulisaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `a~, `b~,`g~ qvepunqtebiT.

l. a-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiT, aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT, jgufurad, araerTgzis, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT,satransporto saSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odenobiTnivTis dauflebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebulisaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `a~, `b~,`g~ qvepunqtebiT.

d. a-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiT, aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT, jgufurad, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT, satransportosaSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odenobiT nivTis dauf-lebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~,`g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT.

g. g-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiT, aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT, jgufurad, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT, satransportosaSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odenobiT nivTis dauf-lebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~,`g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT.

b. a-es brali daedo yaCaRobisaTvis, ese igi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT Tav-dasxmisaTvis, Cadenili sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis saSiSi ZaladobiT, aseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT, jgufurad, binaSi ukanono SeRweviT, satransporto

144

saSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odenobiT nivTis dauf-lebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~,`g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT.

r. j-is, a. g-is, l. a-is, d. a-is, g. g-isa da b. a-is qmedebagamoixata SemdegSi:

2015 wlis agvistoSi d. a-e, g. g-e, b. a-e, motyuebiT qo-nebrivi dazianebisa da ZarcvisaTvis nasamarTlevi l. a-e,qurdobisaTvis nasamarTlevebi _ r. j-e da a. g-e danaSau-lebrivad daukavSirdnen erTmaneTs da moilaparakes, romdidi odenobiT qonebis (fulis, Zvirfaseulobis, avto-manqanis) marTlsawinaaRmdego dauflebis mizniT, yaCaRu-rad dasxmodnen Tavs ...-is raionis sofel m-Si mcxovreb r.x-as ojaxs. SeuTanxmdnen erTmaneTs yaCaRobis Cadenis de-talebze da 2015 wlis 1 seqtembers, daaxloebiT 24:00 sa-aTze, r. j-e da misi Tanamzraxvelebi, cecxlsasroli ia-raRebiT SeiaraRebulni, ucxouri warmoebis daudgeneliavtomanqaniT Cavidnen ...-is raionis sofel m-Si, ris Sem-deg fexiT mividnen r. x-as sacxovrebeli saxlis ukan mde-bare teritoriaze da daelodnen xelsayrel moments da-naSaulis Casadenad. 2 seqtembris daaxloebiT 4 saaTze,mas Semdeg, rac ojaxis xandazmuli wevrebi _ r. x-as mSob-lebi saxlidan gavidnen saojaxo saqmeebis gamo, Tavze ni-RabCamocmuli da cecxlsasroli iaraRiT SeiaraRebulir. j-e saxlis wina mxares arsebuli Ria fanjridan SevidasaxlSi, Signidan gauRo saxlis Sesasvleli kari sxva Ta-namzraxvelebs, ris Semdegac maT SeaRwies r. x-asa da misimeuRlis _ n. b-as saZinebel oTaxSi da mokvlis muqariTTavs daesxnen maT, amasTan, mosTxoves fulisa da Zvirfa-si nivTebis gadacema. imis gamo, rom r. x-a Seecada Tavdam-sxmelebisaTvis winaaRmdegobis gawevas, r. j-em da mismaTanamzraxvelebma scemes mas, xolo Semdeg TokiT Seuk-res piri da gaukres xel-fexic. vinaidan r. x-a da n. b-a mo-eqcnen sicocxlis mospobisa da janmrTelobis daziane-bis realuri safrTxis qveS, iZulebuli gaxdnen, Tavdam-sxmelebisaTvis gadaecaT ojaxis kuTvnili nivTebi _ sxva-dasxva dasaxelebis oqros ZvirfasTvliani da vercxlissamkaulebi, `aifonis~ modelis ori mobiluri telefoni,sul Rirebuli _ 23 640 larad, aseve sacxovrebeli saxlisezodan Tavdamsxmelebma gaitaces 11000 aSS dolarad, anu

145

25900 larad Rirebuli ̀ VOLKSWAGEN PASSAT CC~ modelis,... saxelmwifo nomris mqone avtomanqana. didi odenobiTqonebis dauflebis Semdeg Tavdamsxmelebi SemTxvevis ad-gilidan miimalnen. yaCaRobis procesSi ganxorcielebu-li fizikuri zemoqmedebis Sedegad r. x-as miadga janmrTe-lobis msubuqi da naklebad mZime xarisxis dazianebebi.

1.3 cecxlsasroli iaraRisa da sabrZolo masalismarTlsawinaaRmdego SeZena-Senaxvisa da tarebis epi-zodi

r. j-es brali daedo cecxlsasroli iaraRis marTlsa-winaaRmdego SeZena-Senaxvisa da tarebisaTvis, danaSau-li, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis ko-deqsis 236-e muxlis me-2 da me-3 nawilebiT.

a. g-es brali daedo cecxlsasroli iaraRisa da sabrZo-lo masalis marTlsawinaaRmdego SeZena-Senaxvisa da ta-rebisaTvis, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 236-e muxlis me-2 da me-3 na-wilebiT.

r. j-isa da a. g-is qmedeba gamoixata SemdegSi:r. j-em gamoZiebiT daudgenel drosa da viTarebaSi mar-

TlsawinaaRmdegod SeiZina 9 mm kalibriani ̀ SIG SAUER P239~modelis #... mokleluliani cecxlsasroli iaraRi (pis-toleti), rasac marTlsawinaaRmdegod inaxavda q.q-Si, ...gamziris #..-Si mdebare Tavis sacxovrebel binaSi.

r. j-e q. q-sa da saqarTvelos sxva administraciul-te-ritoriul erTeulebSi marTlsawinaaRmdegod atarebdamis mier marTlsawinaaRmdegod SeZenil 9 mm kalibrian `SIGSAUER P239~ modelis #... moklelulian cecxlsasrol ia-raRs, raSic policiis muSakebma amxiles 2015 wlis 5 seq-tembers, q.q-Si, ...-is q. me-... Sesaxvevis #-Si mdebare sac-xovrebeli binis mimdebare teritoriaze, sadac Catare-buli piradi Cxrekis Sedegad Sarvlis saTaveSi aRmoaCndazemoxsenebuli cecxlsasroli iaraRi.

a. g-em gamoZiebiT daudgenel drosa da viTarebaSi mar-TlsawinaaRmdegod SeiZina 7,62 mm kalibriani `naganis~ mo-delis cecxlsasroli iaraRi (revolveri) sami sabrZolovazniT, rasac marTlsawinaaRmdegod inaxavda.

a. g-e q.q-sa da sxva administraciul-teritoriul er-TeulebSi marTlsawinaaRmdegod atarebda mis mier mar-TlsawinaaRmdegod SeZenil 7,62 mm kalibrian `naganis~ mo-

146

delis cecxlsasrol iaraRs sami sabrZolo vazniT, raSicpoliciis muSakebma amxiles 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers, q.q-Si, b-is q. me-... Sesaxvevis #..-Si mdebare sacxovrebeli bi-nis mimdebare teritoriaze, sadac Catarebuli piradiCxrekis Sedegad Sarvlis saTaveSi aRmoaCnda zemoxsene-buli cecxlsasroli iaraRi.

1.4. sxvisi nivTis ganadgurebis epizodir. j-es brali daedo sxvisi nivTis ganadgurebisaTvis,

ramac mniSvnelovani ziani gamoiwvia, danaSauli, gaTvalis-winebuli saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 187-emuxlis pirveli nawiliT.

r. j-is qmedeba gamoixata SemdegSi:2015 wlis 2 seqtembers, r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tav-

dasxmis procesSi, r. j-em fizikuri Zalis zemoqmedebiTgatexa (daaziana) r. x-as kuTvnili `ASUS~-is firmis `X53U-SX197D~ modelis portatuli kompiuteri, riTac dazara-lebuls miayena 270 laris mniSvnelovani ziani.

1.5 sxvisi nivTis gaufrTxileblobiT dazianebis epi-zodi

r. j-es brali daedo sxvisi nivTis gaufrTxileblobiTdazianebisaTvis, ramac mniSvnelovani ziani gamoiwvia, da-naSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis kodeqsis 188-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT.

r. j-is qmedeba gamoixata SemdegSi:2015 wlis 2 seqtembers, r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tav-

dasxmis Semdeg, rodesac r. j-e TanamzraxvelebTan erTadmarTlsawinaaRmdegod daeufla r. x-as kuTvnil 11000 aSSdolarad, anu 25900 larad Rirebul ̀ VOLKSWAGEN PASSATCC~ modelis, ... . saxelmwifo nomris avtomanqanas da Sem-Txvevis adgilidan miimala, ...-os raionis sofel m-is te-ritoriaze zemoaRniSnuli avtomanqaniT moZraobisas verSeZlo saWis damorCileba, Seejaxa saavtomobilo gzisgverdulze arsebul betonis masas da gaufrTxileblo-biT daaziana r. x-as ojaxidan gatacebuli zemoaRniSnuliavtomanqana, riTac dazaralebuls miayena 450 laris mniS-vnelovani ziani.

1.6. narkotikuli saSualebis ukanono SeZenisa da Se-naxvis epizodi

l. a-es brali daedo narkotikuli saSualebis ukanonoSeZenisa da SenaxvisaTvis, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli

147

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 260-e muxlispirveli nawiliT.

l. a-is qmedeba gamoixata SemdegSi:l. a-em gamoZiebiT daudgenel drosa da viTarebaSi uka-

nonod SeiZina 0,0997 grami narkotikuli saSualeba `hero-ini~, rasac ukanonod inaxavda. 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers, q.-Si, k-as q. #-Si mdebare sacxovrebeli saxlis mimdebareteritoriaze, policiis muSakebis mier Catarebuli pira-di Cxrekis Sedegad l. a-es Sarvlis wina, marcxena jibeSiaRmoaCnda aRniSnuli narkotikuli saSualeba.

2. quTaisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 3 ivni-sis ganaCeniT:

r. j-e, _ cnobil iqna udanaSaulod saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 187-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT,188-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT, 236-e muxlis me-2 da me-3nawilebiT wardgenil braldebebSi da gamarTlda.

r. j-e cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-marTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis à~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT, 179-e muxlis me-2nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis à~, `b~, `g~qvepunqtebiT wardgenil braldebaSi da ZiriTadi sasje-lis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra:

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiTa da me-3 nawilis à~, `g~qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaT-vis _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis à~,`b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Cade-nisaTvis _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 59-e muxlisme-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, Tanabari sasjelebidan erTma sas-jelma STanTqa meore da r. j-es sasjelis saxed da zomadganesazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 59-e muxlisme-3 nawilis Sesabamisad, daniSnulma sasjelma STanTqaquTaisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 5 dekembris ga-naCeniT daniSnuli ZiriTadi sasjelis mouxdeli nawili _3 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa da sabolood, r. j-es Ziri-Tadi sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra Tavisufle-

148

bis aRkveTa 10 wliT. aseve daemata quTaisis saqalaqo sa-samarTlos 2014 wlis 5 dekembris ganaCeniT daniSnuli da-matebiTi sasjeli _ jarima 3000 lari.

msjavrdebul r. j-es patimrobaSi yofnis dro CaeTva-la sasjelis vadaSi da sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla daew-yo faqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2015 wlis 5 seqtembri-dan.

a. g-e, _ cnobili iqna udanaSaulod saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 236-e muxlis me-2 da me-3 nawi-lebiT wardgenil braldebaSi da gamarTlda.

a. g-e cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-marTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qve-punqtebiT, me-3 nawilis `a~, `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT wardge-nil braldebaSi da ZiriTadi sasjelis saxed da zomad ga-nesazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.

msjavrdbul a. g-es patimrobaSi yofnis dro CaeTvalasasjelis vadaSi da sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla daewyofaqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2015 wlis 5 seqtembridan.

g. g-e, _ - cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qve-punqtebiT, me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis da sasjelis saxed da zo-mad ganesazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.

msjavrdebul g. g-es patimrobaSi yofnis dro CaeTva-la sasjelis vadaSi da sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla daew-yo faqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2015 wlis 9 seqtembri-dan.

b. a-e, _ cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qve-punqtebiT, me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis da sasjelis saxed da zo-mad ganesazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 9 wliT.

msjavrdebul b. a-es patimrobaSi yofnis dro CaeTvalasasjelis vadaSi da sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla daewyofaqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2016 wlis 25 Tebervli-dan.

d. a-e, _ cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ qve-punqtebiT, me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis da sasjelis saxed da zo-

149

mad ganesazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.msjavrdebul d. a-es 2015 wlis 5 seqtembridan 2015 wlis

7 seqtembris CaTvliT patimrobaSi yofnis dro CaeTvalasasjelis vadaSi da sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla daewyofaqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2016 wlis 19 aprilidan.

l. a-e, _ cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawilis à~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT, 179-e muxlis me-2nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis à~, `b~, `g~qvepunqtebiT, 260-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT gaTvaliswi-nebuli danaSaulebis CadenisaTvis da sasjelis saxed dazomad ganesazRvra:

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT, me-3 nawilis à~, `g~ qve-punqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaTvis _Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.


saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 260-e mux-lis pirveli nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Cade-nisaTvis _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 3 wliT.

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 59-e muxlisme-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, daniSnuli sasjelebidan ufro mkac-rma sasjelma STanTqa naklebad mkacri sasjeli da l. a-ssasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra Tavisuflebis aR-kveTa 10 wliT.

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 59-e muxlisme-3 nawilis Sesabamisad, daniSnulma sasjelma mTlianadSTanTqa zestafonis raionuli sasamarTlos 2013 wlis 31ivlisis ganaCeniT daniSnuli ZiriTadi sasjelis mouxde-li nawili _ 1 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa da saboloodl. a-es ZiriTadi sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra Ta-visuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.

msjavrdebul l. a-es patimrobaSi yofnis dro CaeTva-la sasjelis vadaSi da sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla daew-yo faqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2015 wlis 5 seqtembri-dan.

3. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis

150

saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 24 maisis ganaCeniT quTaisissaqalaqo sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 3 ivnisis ganaCenSi Sevi-da cvlileba mxolod l. a-is saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis kodeqsis 260-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT msjavrde-bis nawilSi, kerZod, l. a-e cnobil iqna udanaSaulod sa-qarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 260-e muxlis pir-veli nawiliT wardgenil braldebaSi da gamarTlda. l. a.cnobil iqna damnaSaved da miesaja:

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiTa da me-3 nawilis `a~, `g~qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisaT-vis _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 10 wliT.


saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 59-e muxlisme-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, Tanabari sasjelebidan erTma sas-jelma STanTqa meore da l. a-es danaSaulTa erToblio-biT sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra TavisuflebisaRkveTa 10 wliT.

saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 67-e muxlisme-5 nawilis Sesabamisad, gauqmda l. a-is mimarT zestafo-nis raionuli sasamarTlos 2013 wlis 31 ivlisis ganaCeniTdaniSnuli pirobiTi msjavri. saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis kodeqsis 59-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Sesabamisad, bo-lo ganaCeniT daniSnulma sasjelma STanTqa l. a-is mimarTzestafonis raionuli sasamarTlos 2013 wlis 31 ivlisisganaCeniT daniSnuli sasjelis mouxdeli nawili _ Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa 1 wliT da sabolood l. a-es ganaCenTaerTobliobiT sasjelis saxiT ganesazRvra TavisuflebisaRkveTa 10 wliT.

msjavrdebul l. a-es sasjelis moxdis vadis aTvla da-ewyo faqtobrivi dakavebis dRidan _ 2015 wlis 5 seqtem-bridan.

4. sakasacio saCivrebis arsi:quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 24 maisis

ganaCeni sakasacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebulebma _b. a-em, g. g-em da l. a-em; msjavrdebul d. a-is advokatebma_ a. a-ma da s. b-ma; msjavrdebul r. j-is advokatma _ s. b-ma;

151

msjavrdebul a. g-is advokatebma _ o. g-em da m. r-em.4.1. msjavrdebulma g. g-em iTxova mis mimarT gamamar-

Tlebeli ganaCenis dadgena, Semdeg garemoebebze miTiTe-biT:

mis mimarT bralis wardgenis safuZveli gaxda erTader-Ti mtkicebuleba _ genetikuri eqspertizis daskvna, rom-lis Tanaxmad, g. g-is dedis, q. v-isagan aRebuli nerwyvisnimuSi da 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers SemTxvevis adgilidanamoRebul `bendenaze~ arsebuli biologiuri masalis ge-netikuri profili identuria q. v-is, anu g. g-is genetiku-ri profilisa. g. g-e kategoriulad uaryofs SemTxvevisdRes r. x-as ojaxSi yofnisa da yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi mona-wileobis faqts.

4.2. msjavrdebulma b. a-em iTxova gamamarTlebeli ga-naCenis dadgena, Semdeg garemoebebze miTiTebiT:

mis mimarT bralis wardgenis safuZveli gaxda geneti-kuri eqspertizis daskvna, romlis Sinaarsidan ikveTeba,rom b. a-is dedis, i. g-isagan aRebuli nerwyvisa da sisxlisnimuSebi da SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebuli rezinis xel-TaTmanis fragmentze arsebuli sisxlis laqebis geneti-kuri profili identuria i. g-is Svilis, anu b. a-is geneti-kuri profilisa. swored es erTaderTi mtkicebuleba da-udo safuZvlad gamoZiebam b. a-is mimarT usafuZvlo bra-lis wardgenas, rac SemdgomSi gaxda ukanono da dausabu-Tebeli ganaCenis dadgenis winapiroba. b. a-e kategoriu-lad uaryofs SemTxvevis dRes r. x-as ojaxSi yofnisa dayaCaRur TavdasxmaSi monawileobis faqts.

4.3. msjavrdebulma r. j-em da misma interesebis dam-cvelma, advokatma s. b-ma warmodgenili sakasacio saCiv-riT iTxoves r. j-is mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dad-gena, Semdeg garemoebebze miTiTebiT:

q.q-Si, ...-os quCaze arsebuli gazgasamarTi sadgomis, Sps`-as~ ezoSi momxdari yaCaRobis faqtze sasamarTlom ut-yuar mtkicebulebad miiCnia eqspertizis daskvnebi, rad-gan sxva mtkicebulebebi saqmeSi ar yofila da mxolod esgaxda gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotanis safuZveli. sa-samarTlom ar Seafasa is garemoebebi, rom dazaralebulk. f-is ganmartebiT, niRbebi, romlebic TavdamsxmelebsekeTaT, iyo Txeli qsovilis da ara naqsovi qudebi, rom-lebic gagzavnili iyo saeqsperto kvlevisaTvis. k. f-is

152

tansacmeli da xamuti, romlebzec aRmoCnda braldebu-lebis dnm-ebi, eqspertis daskvnis Tanaxmad, ar iyo kano-nis Sesabamisad daluquli da moTavsebuli iyo Cveuleb-rivi failis celofanSi, ris gamoc l. a-isa da r. j-isaganaRebul 10 ml sisxls aklda 2 ml sisxli, romelic gaixar-ja k. f-is maisuris da xamutis dasasvrelad. rac Seexebasigaretis namwvavebze aRmoCenil dnm-s, misi gaziareba arSeiZleba, radgan ar aris sarwmuno, rom yaCaRebi Tan siga-rets eweodnen, Tan k. f-es scemdnen da Tan nivTebs awyob-dnen. r. j-e awames policiis ganyofilebaSi, ris Semdegacmoawerines xeli aRiarebiT Cvenebaze da waiyvanes xonSisagamoZiebo eqsperimentSi monawileobisaTvis. sasamar-Tlom gaiziara dazaralebul r. x-as Cveneba braldebule-bis amocnobasTan dakavSirebiT, risi gaziarebac ar SeiZ-leboda, vinaidan, mowme n. b-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, rode-sac policiis TanamSromlebma mas da mis Svils _ r. x-asdakavebulebis fotoebi aCvenes, maT vercerTi ver amo-icnes. sasamarTlom aseve gaiziara satelefono saubrebi-sa da mimowerebis Sesaxeb informacia, saidanac ver dgin-deba, Tu vin flobda konkretulad im dRes aRniSnul sa-telefono nomrebs an ris Taobaze mimdinareobda sauba-ri.

4.4. msjavrdebulma d. a-em da misma interesebis dam-cvelma advokatebma _ a. a-ma da s. b-ma warmodgenili saape-lacio saCivriT iTxoves d. a-is mimarT gamamarTlebeliganaCenis gamotana, Semdeg garemoebebze miTiTebiT:

pirveli instanciis sasamarTlo d. a-is msjavrdebis na-wilSi daeyrdno mxolod or mtkicebulebas, romelTaganerTi _ satelefono saubrebi iribi mtkicebulebaa, rom-liTac dgindeba, rom d. a-e icnobda l. a-esa da g. g-es. meo-re mtkicebuleba aris r. x-as ezoSi 2015 wlis 24 oqtom-bers aRmoCenili polieTilenis parkSi Cawyobili samosi:Sarvali, maisuri, qamari, kedebi, windebi da lursmnebi,romelTagan mxolod Sarvalsa da maisurze aRmoCenilidnm daemTxva d. a-is dnm-s. kedebsa da windebze aRmoCeni-li dnm ki arcerTi braldebulis dnm-s ar damTxvevia. aR-niSnuli mtkicebulebis sasamarTloSi gamokvlevisas aR-moCnda, rom parkebi iyo talaxiani da Zalian dasvrili.amasTan, parki iyo gaxeuli da dazianebuli, magram masSimoTavsebuli maisuri iyo absoluturad sufTa, laqebis

153

gareSe, ufro metic, axali da Caucmeli. amasTan, parkSimoTavsebuli Sarvali da qamari ar iyo d. a-is zomisa, Sesa-bamisad, ver iqneboda misi sakuTreba. rac Seexeba imas, Turogor aRmoCnda d. a-is dnm Sarvalsa da maisurze, es aix-sneba imiT, rom sanam masTan eqspertebi mividodnen sak-vlevi nimuSebis asaRebad, manamde policielebi cemisa-gan Ronemixdils pirSi stenidnen dolbandebs. zemoaR-niSnuli celofanic swored maSin aRmoaCina n. b-em ezoSi,rodesac is policielebma Caagdes iq, winaaRmdeg SemTxve-vaSi, 55 dRis ganmavlobaSi mas aucileblad SeamCnevda vin-me, miTumetes imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom aRniSnuli peri-odis manZilze SemTxvevis adgili orjer daTvalierda,maT Soris erTxel sapolicio ZaRlis meSveobiT.

4.5. msjavrdebul a. g-is advokatebma _ o. g-em da m. r-emwarmodgenili saapelacio saCivriT iTxoves a. g-is mimarTgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gamotana, Semdeg garemoebeb-ze miTiTebiT:

sasamarTlom calmxrivad gaaanaliza sasamarTloSi ga-mokvleuli mtkicebulebebi, ganzrax aarida Tavi dacvismxaris sasargeblo mtkicebulebaTa analizs da damaje-reblad miiCnia braldebis mxaris mier warmodgenili mtki-cebulebebi, romlebic mxolod varaudzea agebuli. simar-Tles ar Seesabameba mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli policiis Ta-namSromlis _ g. f-is Cveneba imis Sesaxeb, rom TiTqos, a. g-e Seecada gaqcevas da amitom daagdes asfaltze da Cauta-res piradi Cxreka. sinamdvileSi iaraRmomarjvebulma po-licielebma manqanis gaCerebisTanave TviTonve gaaRes man-qanis kari, gadmoaTries manqanidan da daagdes asfaltzesaxiT Zirs, ris Semdegac raRac nivTebi Caudes jibeebSi.braldebis mxaris mtkicebiT, misgan amoiRes movercxlis-fro yelsabami, revolveri da 3 cali vazna, rac araswo-ria, vinaidan aRniSnuli nivTebi mas ar hqonia da isini po-liciis muSakebma Caudes. saqmeSi arsebul videoCanawer-Si Cans, rom cecxlsasrol iaraRebsa da narkotikul saSu-alebasTan erTad, a. g-isgan amoRebuli Zewkvic gaxsnilida dauluqavia. mas arc yaCaRobaSi miuRia monawileoba daarc yelsabami gautacebia. 2015 wlis 3 seqtembers mice-mul CvenebaSi n. b-as saerTod ar uxsenebia, rom misi sax-lidan gatacebuli iyo movercxlisfro yelsabami Tvle-biT, rac imas adasturebs, rom aRniSnuli yelsabami gata-

154

cebuli ar yofila da igi gamoZiebam gamoiyena imisaTvis,rom SemdgomSi misTvis daemtkicebinaT danaSaulSi Tana-monawileoba. rac Seexeba mis mier oqromWedel e. k-isTvismitanil oqros nivTebs, isini gadasca r. j-em, romelmacuTxra, rom es nivTebi iyo misi ojaxis sakuTreba da surdamaTi gayidva, raSic daxmareba sTxova mas. rac Seexeba sa-telefono zarebs da mobiluri operatorebidan gamoT-xovnil informacias, aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi adastu-rebs mis mier sasamarTloSi micemul Cvenebas, romlis Ta-naxmad, 2015 wlis 1 seqtembers is stumrad imyofeboda r.j-esTan da mobiluri telefoni masTan darCa.

4.6 msjavrdebulma l. a-em warmodgenili saCivriT iT-xova gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gamotana, Semdeg garemoe-baTa gamo:

k. f-ze Cadenil yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi mas monawileobaar miuRia. rac Seexeba k. f-is maisurze arsebul sisxliskvals, romlis genetikuri profili identuria l. a-is ge-netikuri profilisa, igi misi dakavebis Semdgom eqsper-tTan mitanamde aris datanili maisurze, rac imiT dastur-deba, rom nimuSisTvis specialistebma mas auRes 10 mg sis-xli, xolo eqspertizaze waradgines 8 mg.

sasamarTlom dadasturebulad miiCnia, rom, TiTqos-da, misi (l. a-is) sacxovrebeli binis Cxrekis dros amoRe-bul iqna ̀ NOKIA-s~ firmis mobiluri telefonis yuTi, ro-melze arsebuli imeikodi identuri aRmoCnda dazarale-bul n. b-as mier Tavisi disTvis naCuqari mobiluri tele-fonis imeikodisa. sayuradReboa, rom n. b-as ganmartebiT,telefonis carieli yuTis gatacebis Sesaxeb gaaxsendamxolod 5 seqtembers, e.i. mis sacxovrebel saxlSi Cxre-kis Catarebisa da misi dakavebis dRes, xolo 2015 wlis 3seqtembers dakiTxvisas mas gatacebul nivTebs Soris te-lefonis yuTi ar dausaxelebia, rac imas adasturebs, romis arc yofila gatacebuli da gamoZiebam gamoiyena mxo-lod imisaTvis, rom Semdgom misTvis daemtkicebina dana-SaulSi Tanamonawileoba.

5. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze msjavrdebulebma damaTma interesebis damcvelma advokatebma moiTxoves Ta-vianTi sakasacio saCivrebis dakmayofileba, xolo proku-rorma iTxova quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2017 wlis24 maisis ganaCenis ucvlelad datoveba.

155

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio palatam mxareTa monawileobiT ganixila sa-

kasacio saCivrebi, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civrebis safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom msjavrdebule-bis _ b. a-isa da g. g-is, msjavrdebul r. j-is advokatis _ s.b-is, msjavrdebul a. g-is advokatebis _ o. g-isa da m. r-issakasacio saCivrebi ar unda dakmayofildes, msjavrde-bul l. a-is sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawi-lobriv, xolo msjavrdebul d. a-is advokatebis _ a. a-sada s. b-is sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes da gasa-Civrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides Sesabamisi cvlileba l.a-isa da d. a-is msjavrdebis nawilSi.

1. k. f-ze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis epizodi1.1 sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs gasaCivrebuli

ganaCenis motivacias k. f-ze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis epizod-Si r. j-isa da l. a-is braleulobis Sesaxeb Semdeg garemo-ebaTa gamo:

1.2. dazaralebul k. f-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igimuSaobs q.q-Si, ...-os q.#-Si mdebare Sps `...-s~ gazgasamarTsadgurSi. 2015 wlis 25 agvistos imyofeboda samsaxurSi.rodesac saxlSi wasvlas apirebda, am dros klientma dau-reka da gadawyvita mas dalodeboda, ris gamoc wamowva iq-ve xis ZirSi mdgar rkinis sawolze da CaeZina. uceb cemamgaaRviZa da dainaxa, rom misken pistoletmomarjvebulikaci mirboda. CaTvala, rom winaaRmdegobis gawevas azriar hqonda, radgan ukve uyurebda niRbian xalxs, romle-bic mas urtyamdnen. misi varaudiT, Tavdamsxmelebi iyvnenxuTni, romelTagan TviTon sams xedavda. aqedan 2 iyo da-bali aRnagobis, xolo erTi ki _ danarCenebze maRali. isi-ni eubnebodnen, rom ukan ar miexeda, Torem cocxals ardatovebdnen. yvelas niRbebi da xelTaTmanebi ekeTa. maTigi miwaze daawvines guldaRma, TavTan pistoleti daug-des daSinebis mizniT da gulis wasvlamde scemes, Semdegwyali daasxes da wavidnen. Tavdamsxmelebma misgan gaita-ces fuladi Tanxa, oqros Zewkvi Tavisi jvriT, Sveicariu-li warmoebis meqanikuri saaTi, `SAMSUNG~-is firmis mo-biluri telefoni da sxva nivTebi, riTac sul 10 800 la-ramde materialuri ziani miayenes. rodesac azrze movi-da, xelebi plastmasis xamutebiT hqonda gakoWili, xolopiri ki _ `skoCiT~ akruli. xeli rom aiSva, am dros ori niR-

156

biani dabrunda. isini didi zomis Savtarian danas eZebdnen,romelic SemTxvevis adgilze darCaT, magram rom Sexedes,mas xeli hqonda gaTavisuflebuli da fexze iyo wamomdga-ri, ukan gabrundnen, ris Semdegac TviTon aiRo es dana davinaidan manqanis gasaRebi ver ipova, fexiT gaemarTa a-isdasaxlebis korpusebisken daxmarebis saTxovnelad. igimale SeamCnies da mis irgvliv xalxi Segrovda, romlebiccdilobdnen mis daxmarebas. am dros erTi cali xamuti isevxelze ekeTa, xolo kiserze `skoCi~ hqonda Semovlebuli.male saswrafo daxmarebac mivida da saavadmyofoSi gada-iyvanes.

1.3. mowme m. g-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 25agvistos ZmasTan erTad imyofeboda q.q-Si, a-is dasaxle-bis mimdebare teritoriaze, Txebis gadmosarekad. rocaukan brundebodnen, SeniSna, rom gazgasamarTi sadgurisSesasvleli WiSkris win idga 4 mamakaci, romlebsac muqiferis tansacmeli ecvaT da saxe dafaruli hqondaT. isinisigarets eweodnen da mzera sadguris Sida teritoriisa-ken hqondaT mipyrobili. igi dainteresda, vin iyvnen isinida maTi mimarTulebiT wavida. aRniSnulma pirebma daina-xes Tu ara, dauwyes gineba da ubrZanes gascloda iqauro-bas. amis gamo ukan gamobrunda, iqve arsebul betonis fi-las amoefara da iqidan akvirdeboda maT. erT-erTi maTga-ni danarCenebze maRali da susti iyo, mas saxe ar uCandada xelSi araferi eWira, muxlTan ki mimagrebuli hqondaSav budeSi Cadebuli dana. erTi iyo masze dabali da sus-ti, danarCeni ori ki _ aseve dablebi da SedarebiT msuqne-bi. mamakacebi WiSkridan ezoSi Sevidnen, saidanac 10 wuT-Si ukan gamobrundnen, gadaiares arxi da saiT wavidnen,aRar daunaxavs.

1.4. igive faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadastura mowme m.g-am misi Cvenebis adgilze Semowmebis mizniT CatarebulisagamoZiebo eqsperimentis drosac.

1.5. mowme j. k-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom is cxovrobsq.q-Si, ...-is dasaxlebaSi mdebare erT-erTi korpusis mer-ve sarTulze, saidanac kargad Cans mimdebare teritoria,maT Soris, S-os quCis nawili. 2015 wlis 25 agvistos Tavisisacxovrebeli binis aivnidan dainaxa axalgazrda mamaka-cebi, romlebic S-os quCaze mdebare gazgasamarTi sadgu-ris mxridan morbodnen da Senobebs miefarnen. maleve da-

157

inaxa maTi binis mimarTulebiT momavali k. f-e, romeliciTxovda policiisa da saswrafo daxmarebis gamoZaxebas.ezoSi Casulma naxa, rom igi dasisxlianebuli iyo, kiserzewebovani lenti hqonda Semoxveuli, xelze plastmasis Se-sakravi ekeTa da hyveboda, rom mas Tavs daesxnen yaCaRe-bi. am dros k. f-es xelSi eWira dana, romelic Tavdamsxme-lebs darCaT SemTxvevis adgilze.

1.6. mowme l. S-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom man 2015 wlis25 agvistos misi sacxovrebeli binis mimdebare terito-riaze naxa daSavebuli k. f-e, romelsac icnobda gazgasa-marTi sadguridan. mas xelSi eWira didi zomis dana da am-bobda, rom es dana Tavdamsxmelebs darCaT, romlebic masdaesxnen yaCaRurad Tavs da fuli da Zvirfaseuloba gas-taces. igi aseve hyveboda, rom Tavdasxmisas Zlierad sce-mes da TavSi Caartyes pistoleti. male saswrafo daxma-reba da policiac mivida, ris Semdegac k. f-e saavadmyo-foSi gadaiyvanes.

1.7. quTaisis saqalaqo sammarTvelos policiis pirve-li ganyofilebis deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZiebel l. Sa-lamberiZis mier 2015 wlis 25 agvistos Sedgenili SemTxve-vis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom Sem-Txvevis adgili mdebareobda q.q-Si, S-s quCa #-Si, Sps `...-as~ teritoriaze, romelic warmoadgenda Txevadi gazisgasamarT sadgurs, saidanac daTvalierebisas amoiRes: sis-xlismagvari laqebi, xamutebi da sanTebela, erTi xamutimowiTalo laqebiT, sisxlismagvari mowiTalo laqebi, ga-saRebebis asxma, eqvsi Reri sigaretis namwvi, webovani len-tis rgoli, xelis erTi kvali, celoidis boTli, patarazomis baliSi, 2 Savi qudi, xelTaTmanebi da sunis kvali,romlebic dailuqa saTanado wesiT da moxda fotogada-Reba. l. S-em daadastura SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalie-rebis oqmis siswore.

1.8. deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZiebel p. x-as mier 2015wlis 25 agvistos Sedgenili daTvalierebis oqmiT dadge-nilia, rom k. f-em warmoadgina didi zomis Savtariani da-na, romlis tarsac Semokruli hqonda webovani, gamWvirva-le lenti, Tavisi Savi qarqaSiT. k. f-is ganmartebiT, es iyodana, romelic SemTxvevis adgilze darCaT Tavdamsxme-lebs. manve warmoadgina moyavisfro webovani lenti daTeTri celoidis damWeri, e.w. `xamuti~, aseve tansacmeli,

158

romelic ecva Tavdasxmis dros _ molurjo jinsis Sarva-li, romelzec aRiniSneboda miwisa da balaxis fragmenti;molurjo moklemklaviani maisuri, romelsac wina mxaresaReniSneboda miwis fragmentebi. p. x-am daadastura mismier Sedgenili daTvalierebis oqmis siswore.

1.9. samedicino eqspetizis #... daskvniT, romlis sis-wore daadastura eqspertma g. g-em, dadgenilia, rom k. f-es daesva diagnozi: qala-tvinis daxuruli travma, Tavistvinis Seryeva, mcire zomis naxeTqi Wriloba kefis areSi,romlebic ganviTarebulia raime mkvrivi-blagvi sagnis(sagnebis) zemoqmedebis Sedegad da dazianeba Tavis tvi-nis Seryevis saxiT, izolirebulad aRebuli, miekuTvnebasxeulis dazianebaTa msubuq xarisxs janmrTelobis mo-uSlelad.

1.10. biologiuri (genetikuri, serologiuri) eqsperti-zis #... daskvniT, romlis siswore daadastura eqspertmaq. q-ma, dadgenilia Semdegi:

SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebul e.w. `xa-mutze~ arsebuli mowiTalo-moyavisfro laqa warmoadgensadamianis sisxls, romlis genetikuri profili Sereuliada ekuTvnis or pirs, kerZod, maJoruli wili identuriar. j-is sisxlis nimuSis genetikuri profilis, xolo mino-ruli wili identuria k. f-is genetikuri profilis.

SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebul erT-erT sigaretis namwvze arsebuli biologiuri masalis ge-netikuri profili identuria r. j-is genetikuri profi-lis, xolo amave paketSi moTavsebul meore sigaretis nam-wvze arsebuli biologiuri masalis genetikuri profiliidenturia l. a-is genetikuri profilis.

SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebul erT-erT sigaretis namwvze arsebuli biologiuri masalis ge-netikuri profili Sereulia, romlis maJoruli wili iden-turia r. j-is genetikuri profilis.

SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebul erT-erT sigaretis namwvze arsebuli biologiuri masalis ge-netikuri profili identuria l. a-is genetikuri profi-lis.

k. f-is mier warmodgenil e.w. `webovan lentze~ mikru-li Tmis genetikuri profili identuria r. j-is genetiku-ri profilis.

159

SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebul Saviferis naqsov qudze, ori naxvretiT, arsebuli Tmis gene-tikuri profili identuria r. j-is genetikuri profilis.

k. f-is mier warmodgenil maisurze arsebuli mowiTa-lo-moyavisfro laqa aRmoCnda adamianis sisxli, romlisgenetikuri profili identuria l. a-is genetikuri pro-filis.

1.11. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamokvleuli, braldebule-bis kuTvnil saabonento nomrebze 2015 wlis 22 agvisto-dan 28 agvistos CaTvliT drois monakveTSi ganxorciele-buli satelefono zarebisa da damakavSirebeli momsaxu-re anZebis Sesaxeb detaluri informaciiTa da misi daTva-lierebis oqmiT dasturdeba, rom 2015 wlis 25 agvistos,k. f-eze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis periodSi, r. j-is da l. a-ismflobelobaSi arsebuli saabonento nomrebi 5... da 5... da-fiqsirebulia SemTxvevis adgilis momsaxure anZebis da-farvis zonaSi.

1.12. zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebis gaanalizebisa daurTierTSejerebis Sedegad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia,rom dacvis mxaris pozicia braldebis am epizodSi r. j-isada l. a-is udanaSaulobis Taobaze usafuZvloa, vinaidanbiologiuri eqspertizis daskvna (romliTac dadginda,rom SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebul e.w. `xamutze~ aRmoC-nda r. j-isa da k. f-is sisxli, sigaretis namwvebze _ r. j-isa da l. a-is biologiuri masalebi, naqsov qudze ori nax-vretiT _ r. j-is Tma, dazaralebul k. f-is mier warmodge-nil webovan lentze aRmoCnda rogorc k. f-is sisxli, ase-ve r. j-is Tma, xolo mis mierve warmodgenil maisurze, ro-melic mas ecva masze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis dros, aRmoC-nda l. a-is sisxli), mowme m. g-s Cveneba (romelmac daadas-tura, rom Tavdamsxmelebi eweodnen sigarets) da sate-lefono zarebisa da momsaxure anZebis Sesaxeb detaluriinformacia (saidanac irkveva, rom k. f-ze yaCaRuri Tav-dasxmis periodSi r. j-sa da l. a-is saabonento nomrebidafiqsirebulia SemTxvevis adgilis momsaxure anZebisdafarvis zonaSi, rac imaze miuTiTebs, rom im droisaTvisisini swored SemTxvevis adgilze imyofebodnen) zemomi-TiTebul sxva mtkicebulebebTan erTobliobaSi, sakmari-sia gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT r. j-sa da l. a-is dam-naSaved cnobisaTvis.

160

1.13. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs msjavrdebul r. j-is advokatis _ s. b-sa da msjavrdebul l. a-is poziciasimis Sesaxeb, rom policiis TanamSromlebma isargeblesbraldebulebis mier policiis ganyofilebaSi moweuli si-garetis namwvebiT, romlebiTac Secvales nivTieri mtki-cebuleba da rom k. f-gan amoRebul nivTmtkicebebze ma-Ti sisxli datanil iqna maTTvis aRebuli nimuSebidan; ase-ve, r. j-is Tmac xelovnurad moaxvedres policielebmaSemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebul niRabze, vinaidan nivTi-eri mtkicebulebebi, romlebzec aRmoCnda r. j-is Tma, mi-si da l. a-is sisxli da biologiuri masala, mopovebuliasisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis moTxovnaTa dac-viT. dazaralebulis mier warmodgenili tansacmeli daSemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas amoRebuli niv-Tmtkicebebi adgilzeve dailuqa saTanado wesiT. kanonismoTxovnaTa dacviT iqna aRebuli braldebulebisgan sis-xlis nimuSebi, romlebic adgilzeve dailuqa maTi Tandas-wrebiT. aRniSnuli nivTmtkicebebi da nimuSebi aseTive da-luquli saxiT gaigzavna saeqsperto kvlevisaTvis da ro-gorc eqspertizis daskvnebidan irkveva, eqspertizazewardgenisas luqebis mTlianoba darRveuli ar yofila,rac gamoricxavs eWvs maTiT borotad sargeblobis, maTiSesaZlo gamocvlisa da maTi niSan-Tvisebebis arsebiTiSecvlis Sesaxeb.

1.14. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos2017 wlis 24 maisis ganaCeni k. f-ze yaCaRuri TavdasxmisepizodSi r. j-isa da l. a-is msjavrdebis nawilSi kanonie-ri da dasabuTebulia, ris gamoc unda darCes ucvlelad.

2. r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis epizodi2.1. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom r. x-as ojaxze ya-

CaRuri Tavdasxmis epizodSi r. j-is, a. g-is, g. g-isa da b. a-is mimarT wardgenili braldeba utyuaradaa dadasture-buli gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT piris damnaSaved cnobi-saTvis saWiro gonivrul eWvs miRma arsebul mtkicebule-baTa erTobliobiT, ris gamoc dacvis mxaris moTxovna ma-Ti udanaSaulod cnobisa da gamarTlebis Taobaze usafuZ-vloa, xolo l. a-isa da d. a-is msjavrdebis nawilSi, sakasa-cio palatis mosazrebiT, gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni dausa-buTebelia, vinaidan warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi ar

161

aris sakmarisi maTi braleulobis dasadastureblad, ker-Zod:

2.2. dazaralebulma r. x-am aCvena, rom 2015 wlis 1 seq-tembers meuRlesTan da SvilTan erTad imyofeboda q.q-Si, saidanac saRamos saaTebSi dabrundnen saxlSi, ...-is ra-ionis sofel m-Si. igi gvian RamiT dawva dasaZineblad. gam-Teniisas misi mSoblebi sakuTari avtomanqaniT wavidnen...-is bazrobaze, xolo mas, mis meuRles _ n. b-as da mcirew-lovan Svils _ a-s saZinebel oTaxSi eZinaT. mas ar gaugia,rogor Sevidnen saxlSi Tavdamsxmelebi. daaxloebiT 04:30saaTi iqneboda, rodesac raRac simZime igrZno da rogorcki Tvalebi gaaxila, mixvda, rom yaCaRebi daesxnen Tavs.amis gamo daiwyo yvirili, ra drosac erT-erTma Tavdam-sxmelma pirze daafara xeli da daartya. Semdeg gadmoaT-ries sawolidan da gametebiT dauwyes cema. isini cdilob-dnen gaeTokaT igi, ra drosac uwevda winaaRmdegobas, risgamoc erT-erTma Tavdamsxmelma aswia zemoT da ise ar-tymevina kedelze Tavi, rom kedeli mTlianad sisxliT iyodasvrili. sabolood erTianad Seborkes. dartymebis Se-degad periodulad gonebas kargavda, xolo azrze rom mo-dioda, isev urtyamdnen da iTiSeboda. isini iTxovdnenfuls da oqros. misma meuRlem Tavad gadasca Tavdamsxme-lebs Zvirfaseuloba. wasvlisas maT manqanis gasaRebic mo-iTxoves. n. b-am uTxra, rom qvemoT ido CanTaSi, ris Semde-gac erT-erTi Tavdamsxmeli Cavida da amoitana CanTa, ro-melSic misi kuTvnili nouTbuqi iyo moTavsebuli, rome-lic iqve gadatexa erT-erTma Tavdamsxmelma. maT CanTi-dan amoiRes avtomanqanis gasaRebi da misive avtomanqa-niT wavidnen. daaxloebiT 2-3 wuTSi misma meuRlem SeZlofanjarasTan misvla da mezoblebs dauZaxa saSvelad, rom-lebmac gaWres Toki da gaaTavisufles. man mezoblis te-lefoniT 112-Si dareka da ganacxada momxdaris Sesaxeb.male policia da saswrafo daxmarebac mivida, ris Semde-gac igi saavadmyofoSi gadaiyvanes, sadac Cautarda sakma-od mZime operacia. dazaralebulma ganmarta, rom Tavdam-sxmelebi daaxloebiT 5-6-ni iyvnen, ekeTaT niRbebi da ma-Ti saxeebi ar daunaxavs. maT gaitaces oqrouloba, misi damisi meuRlis `IPhone~-s firmis mobiluri telefonebi damisi kuTvnili, daaxloebiT 11 000 aSS dolarad Rirebuli`VOLKSWAGEN PASSAT~-is markis avtomanqana.

162

2.3. dazaralebul n. b-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015wlis 1 seqtembers Tavisi mcirewlovani Svili, a-a daax-loebiT 22 saaTze waiyvana dasaZineblad da bavSvTan er-Tad masac CaeZina. sibnele iyo, rodesac igrZno, rom sa-wolze raRac mZime daeca da dainaxa 5 an 6 adamianis silu-eti, romlebic mis oTaxSi midi-modiodnen. maT gaafrTxi-les, rom xma ar amoeRoT da fuli da oqro moiTxoves. amdros r-s gadauCurCula, rom ayaCaRebdnen da ar eyvira,rac man, savaraudod, ver gaigo. isini cdilobdnen r-is wa-moyenebas, romelic uceb ver mixvda, ra xdeboda. SemdegaanTes Suqi. iqve, mis mxares, sawolze midgmul bavSvis sa-wolSi, iwva maTi Svili, romelic amoiyvanes sawolidan dagverdiT oTaxSi gaiyvanes. paralelurad mimdinareobdar-is gakoWvis procesi. Tavdamsxmelebi cdilobdnen xel-fexi SeekraT misTvis, radgan ver imorCilebdnen. maT ga-afrTxiles, rom Tu iyvirebda an saSvelad dauZaxebda vin-mes, maTTvisve iqneboda cudi, bavSvsac esrodnen da r-sac. isini misgan moiTxovdnen fulis da oqros adgilsam-yoflis dasaxelebas, razedac eubneboda, rom etyodaT,oRond ar moeklaT r-i, romelsac ZiriTadad saxis mida-moSi urtyamdnen. gansakuTrebuli agresiiT gamoirCeodamaRali aRnagobis piri, romelic gametebiT scemda mis me-uRles. man Tavad aCvena Tavdamsxmelebs oqros samalavida gadasca karadaSi moTavsebuli zardaxSa, romelSic oq-ros nivTebi inaxeboda. garda amisa, mas da mis meuRlesSexsnes samkaulebi, romlebic maT ekeTaT. im periodSi,rodesac gverdiT oTaxSi iyvnen gasuli, esmoda misi me-uRlis misamarTiT naTqvami Seuracxmyofeli sityvebi. amdros r-i ukve gakoWili iyo da Zirs iwva Zalian nacemi. Sem-deg masac Seukres xel-fexi, pirze webovani lenti gada-akres, sawolze dasves da bavSvic gverdiT miusves. bolosTavdamsxmelebma uTxres, rom manqana sWirdebodaT, ra-zedac upasuxa, rom manqanis gasaRebi qvemoT inaxebodamisi meuRlis CanTis wina jibeSi. erT-erTi TavdamsxmeliTviTon Cavida da amoitana CanTa, saidanac amoiRo manqa-nis gasaRebi. imave CanTaSi ido r-is nouTbuqi, romelsacerT-erTma maTganma fexi daadga da daamtvria. Tavdamsxme-lebma gaitaces oqrouloba, misi da r-is kuTvnili ̀ iPhone~-s firmis mobiluri telefonebi, ris Semdegac Casxdnenmisi meuRlis kuTvnil avtomanqanaSi da wavidnen. saxli-

163

dan gasvlisas daibares, rom ramdenime xani ar eyviraT,winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi bavSvis mokvliT daemuqrnen. Tav-damsxmelebis wasvlis Semdeg man moaxerxa fanjris gaRe-ba da saSvelad mezoblebs uxmo. misi yvirili gverdiTmcxovrebma mezoblebma gaigones, romlebmac daxmarebaaRmouCines. r-ma, romelic drodadro gonebas kargavda,mezobels moatanina telefoni da TviTon gamoiZaxa ro-gorc policia, aseve saswrafo daxmareba. Semdeg igi saa-vadmyofoSi gadaiyvanes, sadac gaukeTda operacia. daza-ralebul n. b-as ganmartebiT, SemTxvevidan ramdenimedRis Semdeg daafiqsira, rom tansacmlis karadidan waRe-buli iyo ̀ NOKIA~-s firmis mobiluri telefonis yuTi, ro-melic man Tavis das aCuqa, xolo yuTi darCa saxlSi, risSesaxebac gamomZiebels acnobes. aseve saxlSi ver ipovavercxlisferi yelsabami, romelsac yurZnis forma daTeTri Tvlebi hqonda. garda amisa, n. b-am aCvena, rom Tav-dasxmidan maleve SeniSnes Sesasvlel oTaxSi waqceulskamTan Zirs dagdebuli lurji TeTr ornamentebiani `ben-dena~, magram Tavidan yuradReba ar miuqceviaT. Semdgomki, vinaidan maTi ar iyo, gamomZiebels gadasces. misive gan-martebiT, Tavdamsxmelebma daaxloebiT 23 000 laramdeRirebulebis Zvirfaseuloba, mobiluri telefonebi damisi meuRlis kuTvnili, 11 000 aSS dolarad Rirebuli av-tomanqana gaitaces.

2.4. dazaralebulebma TavianT CvenebebSi detaluradaRweres yaCaRobis Sedegad gatacebuli samkaulebis ga-regnuli niSnebi da miuTiTes maTi Rirebuleba, romelTanawilis sailustraciod r. x-am gamoZiebas saojaxo foto-suraTebic warudgina, romlebic sasamarTloSi gamoik-vlies.

2.5. mowme n. b-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 2seqtembers, dilis 04 saaTze, is da misi meuRle o. x. saku-Tari `opelis~ markis avtomobiliT wavidnen ...-is bazro-baze, sadac ewevian samewarmeo saqmianobas. roca bazarSisavaWro daxls Slidnen, am dros daurekes da Seatyobi-nes, rom maT ojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxma momxdara. saxlSimisuls Tavisi Svili, r. x-a iseTi nacemi daxvda, rom auci-lebeli gaxda misTvis operaciis gakeTeba. misive ganmar-tebiT, momxdari yaCaRobis Semdeg saavadmyofoSi uvli-da Svils da emociuri mdgomareobis gamo mTeli am perio-

164

dis ganmavlobaSi sakarmidamo nakveTi ar daulagebia. ro-ca r-i SedarebiT ukeT gaxda, Zalebi moikriba da ezos da-lageba gadawyvita, swored maSin ipova ezoSi polieTile-nis parkSi moTavsebuli ucxo tansacmeli, romelic misiojaxis wevrebs ar ekuTvnoda. amis Taobaze Seatyobina Ta-vis Svils _ r. x-as, romelmac, Tavis mxriv, policias acno-ba da aRniSnuli tansacmeli imave dRes amoiRo gamomZie-belma.

2.6. mowme o. x-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 2seqtembers, gamTeniisas, meuRlesTan erTad wavida -isbazrobaze. saxlSi darCnen misi Svili _ r. x-a, rZali _ n. b-a da SviliSvili. maleve daurekes da Seatyobines, rom misojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxma momxdara. saxlSi misulma na-xa, rom misi Svili iyo sastikad nacemi, xolo rZali da Svi-liSvili _ Zlier SeSinebulebi. miRebuli dazianebebis ga-mo r-s Cautarda operacia da masTan erTad saavadmyofo-Si dedamisi imyofeboda. saxls policielebi aTvaliereb-dnen, gamomZiebeli atarebda sagamoZiebo moqmedebebs daeqspertebi iRebdnen fotoebs. mowme o. x-am daadastura,rom SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas naxes, rom iqve,koridorSi waqceul skamze, egdo e.w. `bendena~, romelicmaSin gamomZiebelma ar amoiRo, radgan gasarkvevi iyo, aR-niSnuli `bendena~ xom ar ekuTvnoda misi ojaxis romeli-me wevrs. rogorc Semdgom gairkva, igi ar iyo ojaxis ar-cerTi wevris kuTvnileba, ris gamoc gamomZiebelma amoi-Ro. misive ganmartebiT, Tavdasxmidan ramdenime dRis Sem-deg policiis TanamSromlebma maTTan saxlSi miiyvaneserT-erTi dakavebuli _ r. j-e, romlisganac Seityo, sai-dan Sevidnen Tavdamsxmelebi da rom saxlSi fanjridanTavad r. j-em SeaRwia.

2.7. mowme z. b-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom is r. x-asmezobelia. 2015 wlis 2 seqtembers, gamTeniisas, gaaRviZan-is kivilma, romelic Svelas iTxovda. maSinve gaaRviZaTavisi meuRle d. b-e da oriveni saswrafod wavidnen mi-saSveleblad. x-is saxlSi, im saZinebel oTaxSi Sesvlisas,saidanac xma gamodioda, dainaxa fanjarasTan mdgomi n. b-a, romelic iyo xel-fexSekruli, iqve, sawolze, ijda misimcirewlovani Svili, xolo gasasvlel karTan, iatakze, iwvawels zemoT SiSveli, bawriT xel-fexSekruli r. x-a. massaxeze da pirze gadaxveuli hqonda e.w. `skoCi~ da sisxliT

165

iyo mosvrili. r-is meuRle yviroda, rom isini daayaCaRes,gaitaces oqros nivTebi da avtomanqana. misma meuRlem sam-zareulodan moitana dana, romliTac gadaWres Tokebi. mandazaralebulebisgan gadmocemiT icis, rom Tavdamsxme-lebi iyvnen 5 Tu 6 niRbiani SeiaraRebuli piri.

2.8. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadasturaTavis CvenebaSi mowme d. b-em.

2.9. sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis #... daskvniTdasturdeba, rom dazaralebul r. x-as miyenebuli hqondaSemdegi dazianebebi: marjvena da marcxena yvrimalisZvlebis kompleqsis motexiloba SecilebiT; qveda ybis sa-saxsre morCis motexiloba marjvniv SecilebiT; cxvirisZvlebis motexiloba SecilebiT; hematomebi saxis rbilqsovilebSi da Tvalbudis midamoebSi; subkoniuqtivalu-ri sisxlCaqcevebi orive Tvalbudis midamoebSi. imave das-kvnis Tanaxmad, aRniSnuli dazianebebi ganviTarebuli iyoraime mkvrivi-blagvi sagnis (sagnebis) zemoqmedebis Sede-gad. dazianebebi, hematomebisa da subkoniuqtivaluri sis-xlCaqcevebis saxiT, izolirebulad aRebulni, miekuTvne-bian sxeulis dazianebaTa msubuq xarisxs, janmrTelobismouSlelad. dazianeba cxviris Zvlebis motexilobis sa-xiT, izolirebulad aRebuli, miekuTvneba sxeulis dazi-anebaTa msubuq xarisxs, janmrTelobis xanmokle moSlisniSniT, xolo sxva danarCeni dazianebebi, izolirebuladaRebulni, miekuTvnebian sxeulis dazianebaTa naklebadmZime xarisxs, janmrTelobis xangrZlivi moSlis niSniT.

2.10. SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmiT dadge-nilia, rom r. x-as sacxovrebeli saxlidan amoiRes: xeliskvlebi; wiTeli laqebi; rezinis xelTaTmanis saTiTis frag-menti, romlis zedapiri da SigTavsi dasvrili iyo wiTelilaqebiT; lurji da wiTeli Tokis nawyvetebi; Savi plas-tmasis damWerebi, e.w. `Jgutebi~; webovani lentebis, e.w.`skoCis~ nawyvetebi da ruxi maisuri, romlis zedapirzecaRiniSneboda wiTeli laqebi. SemTxvevis adgilis daTva-lierebis oqmis siswore da masSi miTiTebuli garemoebebimowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas daadastures daTvalierebaSimonawile eqspert-kriminalistebma _ n. s-am da o. s-em.

2.11. avtomanqanisa da mimdebare teritoriis daTvali-erebis oqmis Tanaxmad, 2016 wlis 2 seqtembers w-os raio-nis sofel m-Si, ...-as ubanSi, Sida saavtomobilo qvaRor-

166

Riani gzis marjvena gverdulze, aRmoaCines ruxi`VOLKSWAGEN~-is modelis msubuqi avtomobili, saxelmwi-fo nomriT ... . avtomanqanis wina bamperis marjvena nawilsaklda oTxkuTxa formis plastmasis detali, aseve winamarjvena mxares iatakis qveda nawilze avardnili iyoplastmasis safari. amave oqmis Tanaxmad, daTvalierebi-sas eqspertebma amoiRes: ukana karis `Cixoli~, romelzecSeimCneoda mowiTalo laqebi; savarZlebidan, saWidan dasiCqaris gadamrTveli kolofis saxeluridan _ mikrona-wilakebi; ukana skamidan da iatakidan _ Tabaxis furcle-bi; mZRolis savarZlis qvemoT, iatakis zedapiridan _ pa-tara zomis oTxkuTxa formis furceli mowiTalo laqe-biT. mimdebare teritoriis daTvalierebisas avtomanqa-nidan 40 metris mocilebiT, gzis saval nawilze, ipovesavtomanqanis wina bamperis oTxkuTxa formis plastmasisdetali. oqmis siswore da masSi miTiTebuli garemoebebimowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas daadastura misma Semdgenma pir-ma _ Sss ...-is raionuli sammarTvelos deteqtivis Tana-Semwe-gamomZiebelma g. b-em.

2.12. nivTierebaTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTaeqspertizis #... daskvniT dadgenilia, rom avtomobilis`WOLKSWAGEN CC SPORT 2009~, sax. #..., ukana marcxena sa-varZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, ukana marjvena sa-varZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, wina marjvena sa-varZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, wina marcxena sa-varZlis dasajdomidan, amoRebul molurjo, araTanabradSeRebil bambis boWkoebs aqvT saerTo gvarobrivi kuTvni-leba eqspertizaze wardgenil l. a-is, d. a-is, r. j-isa da a.g-is jinsis Sarvlebis qsovilebis lurji narTis Semadge-nel Sesabamis boWkoebTan. daskvnis siswore daadasturamowmis saxiT dakiTxulma eqspertma n. a-ma.

2.13. sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmidan irkveva, romr. j-em misi Cvenebis adgilze Semowmebis mizniT Catare-buli sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis dros daadastura mis mi-er 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers micemuli aRiarebiTi Cvenebada aRwera r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis detalebi.misive miTiTebiT, sagamoZiebo eqsperimentSi monawile pi-rebi mividnen ...-os raionis sofel m-is teritoriaze da r.j-em miuTiTa adgili, sadac betons Seejaxa. mis mier miTi-Tebul adgilas aRmoCnda betonis didi naWeri, romelic

167

amovardnili iyo niadagidan da masze aRiniSneboda Camo-natexebi. iqve aRmoaCines da amoiRes savaraudod, avto-mobilis `bamperisa~ da qveda safaris plastmasis nawile-bi. sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmis siswore da masSi mi-TiTebuli garemoebebi mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas daadas-tures eqsperimentSi monawile ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZi-ebelma g. g-am da eqspertma g. t-em.

2.14. trasologiur-sasaqonlo eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dadgenilia, rom r. j-is monawileobiT CatarebulisagamoZiebo eqsperimentis dros sofel m-is teritoria-ze aRmoCenili avtomanqanis oTxi plastmasis natexi da-zianebamde warmoadgenda r. x-as kuTvnili `VOLKSWAGENPASSAT CC~, saxelmwifo nomriT ..., avtomobilis Zravas dam-cavis qveda safaris plastmasis Semadgenel nawilebs.

2.15. amocnobis oqmebiT dadgenilia, rom dazaralebul-ma r. x-am amoicno r. j-e, l. a-e, a. g-e, g. g-e, d. a-e da ganmar-ta, rom maT SemTxvevamde ramdenime xniT adre periodu-lad xedavda q.q-Si, Tavisi samuSao ofisis mimdebare te-ritoriaze, xolo a. g-e da l. a-e 2015 wlis 31 agvistos an 1seqtembers aseve nanaxi hyavs Tavisi sacxovrebeli sax-lis win, `BMW~-s markis avtomanqaniT gadaadgilebisas.

2.16. mowme e. k-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom is aris oq-romWedeli da saxelosno aqvs q-Si, ...-os quCaze. 2015 wlis4 seqtembers, daaxloebiT 15 saaTze, daureka meuRlis na-Tesavma a. k-em da Sexvedra sTxova. igi sakuTari avtoman-qaniT mivida mis saxelosnosTan, Tan axlda axalgazrdamamakaci `dabali wveriT~. rogorc a-m gaacno, is iyo misiqvisli, a. (...) g-e, romelsac gasayidi hqonda italiidan ga-mogzavnili oqro. mogvianebiT a. k-es da a. g-es Sexvda ka-zino `...-Si~, sadac a. g-em oqros fasebis garkvevisa da mo-laparakebis Semdeg gasayidad gadasca oqros nivTebi. amisSemdeg es nivTebi gadasadnobad waiRo Tavisi dis qmarTan_ b. m-sTan sofel z-Si, romelsac saxlSi aqvs oqromWed-lobisaTvis aucilebeli xelsawyo da gadaadno isini, xo-lo Tvlebi Seinaxa, radgan ukan unda daebrunebina a. g-isaTvis. Semdgom, imisaTvis, rom gadamdnari masa daeWrafirfitebad da daewminda, wavida q.q-Si, sakuTar saxelos-noSi. amis Semdeg daukavSirda a. g-es, romelic mivida mas-Tan saxelosnoSi da Tan miiyvana grZelTmiani, saSualo si-maRlis, Savwveriani biWi, romelic gaacno rogorc r. j-e

168

da sTxova oqros Tanxa am ukanasknelisTvis mieca, radganTavad qalaqgareT gasvlas apirebda. cota xanSi mividnenpolicielebi, romlebmac Caatares Cxreka da amoiRes gab-rtyelebuli oqros firfitebi, aseve _ misi kuTvnili sxvaoqros nakeTobebi. gamomZiebelma warudgina r. x-as saoja-xo fotoebi, romlebzec Canda ojaxis wevrebis oqros sam-kaulebi. mowme e. k-is ganmartebiT, man n. b-as fotosuraT-ze amoicno samgumbaTiani beWedi irgvliv TvlebiT, rom-lis identuri beWedi gadasca mas a. g-em kazino `...-is~ tua-letSi.

2.17. mowme a. k-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom a. g-e misiqvislia, xolo e. k-e _ misi siZe. 2015 wlis 4 seqtembersmobilur telefonze daureka a. g-em da sTxova, rom dae-kavSirebina vinme nacnob oqromWedelTan, radgan megobar-ma misca italiidan gamogzavnili oqro da undoda oqrom-WedlisTvis eCvenebina. amis gamo daureka e. k-es da Seu-Tanxmda Sexvedraze. isini k. `...-is~ tualetSi Sexvdnen er-TmaneTs, sadac a. g-em e. k-es gadasca oqros nivTebi.

2.18. mowme b. m-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, 2015 wlis 4 seqtem-bers masTan saxlSi mivida misi colisZma e. k-e da uTxra,rom sWirdeboda kompresoris aparati oqros gadasadno-bad. e-m isargebla aRniSnuli aparatiT, ris Semdegac lam-baqze darCa saiuveliro Tvlebi, romlebic Semdgom po-liciis TanamSromlebma amoiRes.

2.19. 2015 wlis 5 seqtembris daTvalierebis oqmiT dad-genilia, rom e. k-is monawileobiT daTvalierda slotklub`...-is~ Sida saTvalTvalo kamerebis Canawerebi. videoCa-naweris daTvalierebisas e. k-em ganmarta, rom klubis ho-lis bolos arsebul moajirTan 15:20:40-ze Cans a. k-e,15:21:30-ze moajirTan a. k-sTan erTad Cans a. g-e. e. k-is gan-martebiT, 15:21:53-ze igi piradad Semodis da pirdapir Se-dis sapirfareSoSi a. k-esa da a. g-sTan erTad. misive gan-martebiT, swored am dros gadasca sapirfareSoSi a. g-emmas oqros samkaulebi gadasadnobad.

2.20. 2015 wlis 5 seqtembris daTvalierebis oqmiT dad-genilia, rom ...-os raionis sofel z-Si, b. m-is sacxovre-bel saxlSi Catarebuli daTvalierebisas e. k-em warmoad-gina 16 patara zomis moTeTro mbrwyinavi Tvali da erTiSedarebiT didi zomis, moTeTro beWdis Tvali, romleb-zec ganacxada, rom swored aRniSnuli beWdis Tvlebi iyo

169

moTavsebuli a. g-is mier mitanil beWedSi.2.21. 2015 wlis 24 seqtembris daTvalierebis oqmiT das-

turdeba, rom dazaralebulebis, eqspertebisa da mowmee. k-is monawileobiT daTvalierda e. k-is mier warmodge-nili beWdis Tvlebi _ 14 mcire zomis moTeTro Tvali, 2 _saSualo zomis Tvali da erTi _ SedarebiT didi zomis Tva-li, romlebzec e. k-em ganmarta, rom isini iyo swored isTvlebi, romlebic man amoiRo a. g-is mier misTvis gadace-muli samgumbaTiani oqros beWdidan. misive ganmartebiT,swored es beWedi iyo aRbeWdili gamoZiebis procesSi mis-Tvis wardgenil erT-erT fotosuraTze, romelzec axal-gazrda qalbatons aRniSnuli beWedi ukeTia e.w. `kalico~beWedTan erTad da xelSi uWiravs mobiluri telefoni.daTvalierebisas dazaralebulebma _ r. x-am da n. b-am gan-martes, rom aRniSnuli Tvlebi iyo im beWdis Tvlebis iden-turi, romlebic yaCaRebma gaitaces maTi ojaxidan 2015wlis 2 seqtembers.

2.22. a. g-is piradi Cxrekis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom misiSarvlis wina, marjvena jibidan amoiRes TeTr qaRaldSiSexveuli movercxlisfro ornamentebiani Zewkvi aTiTvliT.

2.23. ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZiebelma g. f-ma daadastu-ra a. g-is piradi Cxrekis Sedegad misgan TeTr qaRaldSigaxveuli movercxlisfro Zewkvis amoRebis faqti, rome-lic adgilzeve dailuqa.

2.24. obieqtis (sagnis) amocnobis oqmiT dadgenilia, romdazaralebulma n. b-am amoicno a. g-is piradi Cxrekis drosamoRebuli yelsabami da ganmarta, rom is iyo misi kuTvni-leba, romelic Tavdamsxmelebma gaitaces misi saxlidan.

2.25. l. a-is sacxovrebeli binis Cxrekis oqmiT dadgeni-lia, rom aRniSnuli binis lojiaSi arsebuli patara zomismagidaze aRmoaCines da amoiRes `NOKIA~-s firmis tele-fonis muyaos yuTi, imeikodiT ... . Cxrekis oqmis sisworedaadastures mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma deteqtiv-gamom-Ziebelma m. S-am da ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblebma _ s. q-am da z. k-em.

2.26. mowme m. b-am, romelic dazaralebul n. b-as daa,aCvena, rom mas Tavisma dam, n. b-am aCuqa naxmari `NOKIA~-sfirmis mobiluri telefoni yuTis gareSe da, rogorc mis-Tvis aris cnobili, es yuTi n. b-as sacxovrebel saxlSi ina-

170

xeboda.2.27. 2015 wlis 21 seqtembris daTvalierebis oqmiT dad-

genilia, rom m. b-am nebayoflobiT warmoadgina misi kuT-vnili `NOKIA~-s firmis orsimbaraTiani mobiluri tele-foni, romelic, misi ganmartebiT, aCuqa dam _ n. b-am. imei-kodis dadgenis mizniT, telefonSi akrefil iqna Sesaba-misi kombinacia, ris Semdegac telefonis ekranze gamoi-saxa imeikodi _ ..., rac identuria l. a-is sacxovrebeli bi-nis Cxrekisas amoRebuli `NOKIA~-s firmis telefonis yu-Tis imeikodisa.

2.28. adgilmdebareobisa da tansacmlis daTvalierebisoqmiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 24 oqtombers Catarda...- is raionis sofel m-Si dazaralebul r. x-as ezos daTva-liereba, ra drosac daTvalierebaSi monawile pirebi, n. b-is miTiTebiT, gavidnen r. x-as sakarmidamo ezoSi samxreT-aRmosavleTis mxares, romelsac esazRvreba d. b-is ezo,sadac n. b-em miuTiTa liTonis konstruqciis RobesTan,miwaze dadebul moyviTalo-momwvano polieTilenis par-kze da aRniSna, rom es parki im dRes aRmoaCina. parkis daT-valierebis Semdeg masSi aRmoCnda: daxeul polieTilenisparkSi moTavsebuli ori Jangmokidebuli lursmani, SavipolieTilenis parkSi moTavsebuli lurji feris erTiwyvili kedi, warweriT `ALL STAR~, TiToeul kedSi moTav-sebuli TiTo cali Savi windiT. imave parkSi moTavsebuliiyo Savi tyavis fexsacmeli SigniT arsebuli warweriT`GBXR~ romelsac Zirze aReniSneboda cveTisa da talaxiskvali; moTeTro adamianis gamosaxulebiani polieTilenispaketi, masSi moTavsebuli mocisfro jinsis Sarvali, zo-miT 33/34, Sida iarliyze warweriT `REALITIST DENIMPOWVER 14 SA~, romelzec gakeTebuli iyo movercxlis-fro liTonis balTiani Savi qamari; imave parkSi moTavse-buli iyo molurjo-moSavo, muqi feris moklesaxeloebia-ni maisuri, warweriT ̀ NEW FOUNDLAND~, zomiT XL, romel-sac sayelosTan Sida mxridan ewera ̀ ZAAV COLLECTION~. aR-moCenil tansacmelsa da fexsacmels cveTis garda raimedazianebis niSnebi ar aReniSneboda, kerZod, Sarvalzeorive totis qveda nawilSi da wina, marjvena jibesTan aRi-niSneboda talaxis laqebi. analogiuri laqebi aRiniSne-boda fexsacmelebze. aseve, fexsacmelebsa da windebzeaRiniSneboda daobebis kvali.

171

2.29. biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspetizis #... daskvniTdadgenilia, rom dazaralebul r. x-as ezoSi aRmoCeniljinsis Sarvalze, qamarsa da muq moklemklavian maisurzearsebuli biologiuri masalis genetikuri profili da d.a-is genetikuri profili identuria.

2.30. 2015 wlis 5 seqtembris nivTebis daTvalierebisoqmiT dadgenilia, rom dazaralebulma n. b-am gamomZie-bels nebayofilobiT warudgina lurji Tavsakravi, e.w.`bendena~ TeTri ornamentebiT, romelic TavdamsxmelTawasvlis Semdeg ipova saxlis SesasvlelSi.

2.31. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma gamomZiebelma s. t-ma da-adastura, rom r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis faqti-dan ramdenime dReSi dazaralebulma n. b-am mas warudginae.w. `bendena~, romelic saxlis daTvalierebis Semdeg upo-viaT da ojaxis arcerT wevrs ar ekuTvnoda.

2.32. mowme f. g-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobsSss ...-is raionuli sammarTvelos deteqtiv-gamomZieblisTanamdebobaze. r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis Sesa-xeb Setyobinebis miRebis Semdeg, igi imyofeboda SemTxve-vis adgilze _ ...-is raionis sofel ...-Si, r. x-as sacxovre-bel saxlSi da atarebda sagamoZiebo moqmedebebs. SemTxve-vis adgilis daTvalierebisas TvalSi moxvda waqceul skam-ze gadakidebuli lurji Tavsakravi, e.w. `bendena~, rom-lis Sesaxebac hkiTxa o. x-as, Tumca man ver daudastura,iyo Tu ara aRniSnuli `bendena~ ucxo pirebis da ganumar-ta, rom SeiZleboda misi rZlis an SviliSvilis yofiliyo.

2.33. SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebaSi monawile eq-spertis, o. s-is mier mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas micemuliCvenebiT dadgenilia, rom mas kargad axsovs SemTxvevisdaTvalierebisas waqceul skamTan dagdebuli lurji `ben-dena~, romelic aseve moxvda SemTxvevis adgilis daTva-lierebisas gadaRebul fotoebSi da Caiwera diskze, ro-melic gadaeca gamomZiebels.

2.34. sasamarTloSi gamokvleul, 2016 wlis 2 seqtembersSemTxvevis adgilze gadaRebul erT-erT fotoze aRbeW-dilia r. x-as saxlis Sesasvlel oTaxSi, waqceul skamTan,iatakze dagdebuli lurji e.w. `bendena~ TeTri ornamen-tebiT.

2.35. biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dadgenilia, rom n. b-as mier warmodgenil e.w. `ben-

172

denaze~ arsebuli mowiTalo-moyavisfro laqebi warmoad-gens adamianis sisxls, romlis genetikuri profili da r.x-as genetikuri profili identuria. `bendenaze~ aRmoC-nda adamianis biomasala, romlis genetikuri profiliekuTvnis q. v-is (g. g-is dedis) biologiur Svils.

2.36. biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dadasturda, rom n. b-as mier warmodgenil `bende-naze~ moTavsebul aRmoCenili biologiuri masalis gene-tikuri profili da g. g-is genetikuri profili identu-ria.

2.37. biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dadgenilia, rom avtomanqanis wina marcxena savar-Zlis qvemoT iatakidan amoRebul qaRaldis fragmentzearsebuli sisxli da saZinebel oTaxSi iatakidan amoRebulrezinis xelTaTmanis fragmentze arsebuli sisxli ekuT-vnis i. g-is (b. a-is dedis) biologiur Svils.

2.38. biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dadasturda, rom avtomanqanis wina marcxena savar-Zlis qvemoT iatakidan amoRebul qaRaldis fragmentzearsebuli sisxlis genetikuri profili da b. a-is geneti-kuri profili identuria. saZinebel oTaxSi iatakidan amo-Rebul rezinis xelTaTmanis fragmentze arsebuli sis-xlis Sereuli genetikuri profilis erT-erTi wili da b.a-is genetikuri profili identuria.

2.39. biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... das-kvnidan irkveva, rom dazaralebul r. x-as mier Tavis saZi-nebel oTaxSi, sawolis leibis qveS napovn da gamoZiebi-saTvis wardgenil TeTri rezinis xelTaTmanis fragmen-tze arsebuli biomasalis genetikuri profili Sereulia.profilis ZiriTadi wili da b. a-is genetikuri profiliidenturia.

2.40. eqspertebma _ v. o-am da i. m-am daadastures maTmier Catarebuli biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizebisdaskvnebis siswore.

2.41. mobiluri operatorebidan _ Sps `...~, Sps `...~ da Sps`...~ miRebuli detaluri informaciis daTvalierebisa dagaanalizebis Sedegad dadginda Semdegi:

2015 wlis 15 agvistodan 5 seqtembris CaTvliT, r. j-issaabonento nomerze ... fiqsirdeba intensiuri kavSirebia. g-esTan, l. a-sTan, g. g-esa da b. a-esTan.

173

r. j-is kuTvnil, zemoaRniSnul saabonento nomerzeganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa da mokleteqsturi Setyobinebebis analiziT dasturdeba, rom 2015wlis 15 agvistodan 5 seqtembris CaTvliT, saabonento no-meri ... r. j-es yovelTvis moTavsebuli aqvs Tavis kuTvnil... imeikodis mqone mobilur telefonSi, Tumca 2015 wlis 1seqtembris 21:31:15 saaTidan aRniSnuli imeikodis mqonetelefonSi ukve moTavsebulia a. g-is kuTvnili simbaraTinomriT ..., rac miTiTebuli imei kodis mqone mobilur te-lefonSi fiqsirdeba 2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 22:57:17 saa-Tamde.

a. g-is kuTvnil saabonento nomerze _ 5 ... 2015 wlis 15agvistodan 4 seqtembris CaTvliT, fiqsirdeba intensiu-ri kavSirebi r. j-esTan, l. a-sTan, g. g-esTan, d. a-esa da b.a-esTan.

a. g-is kuTvnil, zemoaRniSnul saabonento nomerzeganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa da mokleteqsturi Setyobinebebis analiziT aseve dasturdeba,rom simbaraTi nomriT 5 ... a. g-es yovelTvis moTavsebuliaqvs ... imei kodis mqone mobilur telefonSi, Tumca r. x-asojaxze yaCaRur Tavdasxmamde ramdenime saaTiT adre, 2015wlis 1 seqtembris 21:31:15 saaTidan aRniSnul simbaraTi a.g-es moTavsebuli aqvs _ imeikodis mqone mobilur tele-fonSi, romliTac manamde sargeblobda r. j-e da aRniSnu-li imeikodis mqone telefonSi moTavsebuli hqonda misikuTvnili saabonento nomeri ... . swored am imeikodis mqo-ne mobiluri telefonia amoRebuli r. j-is piradi Cxre-kis dros.

2015 wlis 1 seqtembris 23:31:41 saaTidan 2015 wlis 2seqtembris 00:06:40 saaTamde periodSi a. g-s saabonentonomeri ... fiqsirdeba q.q-Si #... (e-i, S-os ...) #... (s-o, q-i, t-as ...) da #... (q., a-is ...) anZebis dafarvis zonaSi arsebulteritoriaze, rac warmoadgens avtoqarxnis dasaxlebas,romelzec gadis x-is raionisaken mimavali saavtomobilogza. 2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 01:03:00 saaTidan a. g-is saabo-nento nomeri _ fiqsirdeba #... anZis (romelic mdebare-obs m-is raionis sofel x-i da emsaxureba aseve x-s raionissofel m-s, sadac mdebareobs dazaralebul r. x-as saxli)dafarvis zonaSi arsebul teritoriaze, rac adasturebsaRniSnul teritoriaze a. g-is yofnis faqts. SemTxvevis

174

adgilis momsaxure #... anZis dafarvis zonaSi bolo kon-taqti a. g-is saabonento nomerze ganxorcielebulia 2015wlis 2 seqtembris 03:19:15 saaTze, ris Semdegac momdevnokontaqti aRniSnul nomerze fiqsirdeba 2015 wlis 2 seq-tembris 04:49:20 saaTze. sagulisxmoa, rom swored droisam monakveTebSi daiwyo da dasrulda r. x-as ojaxze yaCa-Ruri Tavdasxma.

2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 04:49:20 saaTze a. g-is saabonen-to nomeri _ fiqsirdeba #... . anZis (x. tv, ., T-is moedani ...)dafarvis zonaSi arsebul teritoriaze. x-is raionis so-fel m-dan q.-is mimarTulebiT moZraobisas unda gaiaroq.x.. aRsaniSnavia, rom a. g-is miTiTebuli nomeri fiqsir-deba swored aRniSnul anZaze da mas kavSiri aqvs g. g-sTan.amiT dasturdeba, rom a. g. x-is raionis sofel m-dan r. x-asojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis Semdeg miemgzavreba q.q-sa-ken, rasac is faqtic adasturebs, rom amis Semdeg a. g-issaabonento nomeri _ fiqsirdeba #... da #... anZis (x., sofe-li g.) dafarvis zonaSi arsebul teritoriaze, rac asevemdebareobs q.q-saken mimaval saavtomobilo gzaze, xoloSemdeg fiqsirdeba #... anZis (w., f-i, r. x-sagan gatacebuliavtomanqanis aRmoCenis adgilis momsaxure anZa) da #... an-Zis (a-a, q-i, a-is ...) dafarvis zonaSi arsebul teritorieb-ze, ra drosac kavSiri aqvs g. g-sTan.

Sps `...-s~ qselSi CarTul, a. g-is kuTvnil saabonentonomerze _ ganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa damokle teqsturi Setyobinebebis analiziT irkveva, rom r.x-as ojaxze ganxorcielebuli yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis saa-TebSi a. g-es saabonento nomeri _ gamorTuli aqvs, vinai-dan im dros Tavisi meore simbaraTi _ moTavsebuli aqvs r.j-is kuTvnil telefonSi da TanamzraxvelebTan sakontaq-tod iyenebs swored aRniSnul saabonento nomers, xolosaabonento nomers ..., a. g. rTavs 2015 wlis 2 seqtembers,05:47:41 saaTze. am dros a. g. imyofeba _ (q-i, wy-o ...) anZisdafarvis zonaSi arsebul teritoriaze, romelic mdeba-reobs w-os raionis sofel m-sa da m-as dasaxlebis maxlob-lad, sadac aRmoaCines r. x-sagan gatacebuli avtomanqana.

g. g-is kuTvnil, Sps `...-is~ qselSi CarTul saabonentonomerze _ ganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa damokle teqsturi Setyobinebebis analiziT irkveva, rom2015 wlis 15 agvistodan 05 seqtembris CaTvliT, mas aqvs

175

intensiuri kavSirebi a. g-sTan, r. j-sTan, l. a-sTan, d. a-sada b. a-sTan.

2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 02:42:17 saaTidan 03:19:16 saaTisCaTvliT, g. g-is kuTvnili saabonento nomeri _ fiqsirde-ba r. x-as sacxovrebeli saxlis momsaxure _ anZis dafar-vis zonaSi arsebul teritoriaze, ra drosac aqvs Semoma-vali da gamavali kontaqtebi a. g-is kuTvnil _ saabonentonomerze, romelic aseve imyofeba r. x-as sacxovrebelisaxlis momsaxure anZis dafarvis zonaSi arsebul teri-toriaze. garda amisa, aRsaniSnavia, rom 2015 wlis 2 seq-tembris 03:19:16 saaTidan 04:49:20 saaTamde drois monak-veTSi g. g-is kuTvnil saabonento nomerze ..., iseve rogorca. g-is kuTvnil _ saabonento nomerze, raime kontaqti arfiqsirdeba. swored drois aRniSnul monakveTSi iwyeba damTavrdeba x-is raionis sofel m-i r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuriTavdasxma. 2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 04:49:20 saaTze ki, g. g-is kuTvnili saabonento nomeri _ ukve fiqsirdeba #... an-Zis (x. .) dafarvis zonaSi arsebul teritoriaze, ra dro-sac aqvs gamavali zari a. g-is kuTvnil _ saabonento no-merze, romelic aseve imyofeba Sps `...-is~ swored miTiTe-bul teritoriaze ganTavsebuli anZis dafarvis zonaSi.

2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 05:01:00 saaTidan 05:19:52 saaTisCaTvliT, g. g-is kuTvnili saabonento nomeri _ ukve fiq-sirdeba r. x-sagan gatacebuli avtomanqanis aRmoCenis ad-gilis momsaxure #... (m.) anZis dafarvis zonaSi arsebulteritoriaze, ra drosac aqvs Semomavali da gamavali kon-taqtebi a. g-is kuTvnil _ saabonento nomerze.

l. a-is kuTvnil, Sps `m-s~ qselSi CarTul saabonentonomerze _ ganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa damokle teqsturi Setyobinebebis analizidan irkveva, rom2015 wlis 15 agvistodan 5 seqtembris CaTvliT, l. a-es aqvsintensiuri kavSiri a. g-sTan, r. j-sTan, g. g-sTan, d. a-sa dab. a-sTan.

l. a-is kuTvnil, zemoaRniSnul saabonento nomerzeganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa da mokleteqsturi Setyobinebebis analiziT aseve dasturdeba,rom 2015 wlis 1 seqtembers l. a. imyofeba q.q-Si da fiqsir-deba swored im anZebze, romlebzec _ misi sxva Tanamzrax-velebi. 2015 wlis 1 seqtembers bolo kontaqti l. a-is saa-bonento nomerze _ fiqsirdeba 20:55:03 saaTze, rodesac

176

misi telefoni aris _ (q.) anZis dafarvis zonaSi arsebulteritoriaze. aRniSnulis Semdeg l. a-s kuTvnili _ saabo-nento nomeri gamorTulia 2015 wlis 2 seqtembris 08:31:14saaTamde.

d. a-is kuTvnil, Sps `m-s~ qselSi CarTul saabonentonomerze _ ganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa damokle teqsturi Setyobinebebis analizidan irkveva, rom2015 wlis 25 agvistos 13:39:30 saaTidan 2015 wlis 4 seq-tembris 11:53:01 saaTamde d. a-is kuTvnil saabonento no-merze _ kontaqtebi ar fiqsirdeba, xolo manamde da masSemdeg hqonda satelefono kavSiri ZiriTadad hqonda a.g-sTan, g. g-sa da l. a-sTan.

b. a-is kuTvnil, Sps `...~ qselSi CarTul saabonento no-merze ..., 2015 wlis 24 agvistodan 4 seqtembris CaTvliT,aqvs kavSirebi a. g-sTan, l. a-sTan, g. g-sa da r. j-sTan.

b. a-is kuTvnil, Sps `m-is~ qselSi CarTul saabonentonomerze _ ganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavali zarebisa damokle teqsturi Setyobinebebis analizidan irkveva, rom2015 wlis 31 agvistos mas satelefono kontaqti aqvs22:10:40 saaTze _ g. g-is kuTvnil _ saabonento nomerze,xolo 2015 wlis 1 seqtembers, 15:47:40, 15:54:47, 16:14:43,16:21:08 da 16:59:30 saaTebze _ l. a-is kuTvnil _ saabonen-to nomerze.

b. a-is saabonento nomrebis analiziT dasturdeba, rom2015 wlis 1 seqtembers igi gamoemgzavra q.T-dan da saRa-mos saaTebSi imyofeba q.q-is momsaxure anZebis dafarviszonaSi arsebul teritoriaze. amasTan, q.q-Si yofnisas b.a-is saabonento nomrebi fiqsirdeba mobiluri operato-rebis swored im momsaxure anZebis dafarvis zonaSi, sa-dac imyofebian r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi bral-debuli sxva pirebi. aseve aRsaniSnavia, rom 2015 wlis 1seqtembris 20:30 da 20:47 saaTebis Semdeg raime saxis kon-taqti b. a-is saabonento nomrebze ar fiqsirdeba da mas,savaraudod, telefonebi aqvs gamorTuli.

2.42. braldebulebma _ r. j-em, a. g-em, l. a-em, d. a-em, g.g-em da b. a-em uaryves r. x-as ojaxze Tavdasxmis faqti. r.j-em ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers wavidnen oq-romWedlis sanaxavad, romelic im dRes gaicno a-sgan. Sem-deg iyo saubari masa da oqromWedels Soris Tu rodis mox-deboda misi kuTvnili oqros gayidva da Caiwera oqrom-

177

Wedlis nomeri. r-is xidTan gaaCeres taqsi da wavidnen b-is quCis mimarTulebiT. b-is quCaze gadavida a. fulis ga-dasaxurdaveblad. manqanidan gadasuli iyo j-ec, magrambankSi ar Sesula. bankidan gamosulebma Seuxvies CixSi, radrosac maTi manqana gaaCera ramdenime policiis manqanam,gadmoyares manqanebidan, dayares Zirs, erTi iaraRi a-s Ca-udes, meore ki _ mas. am momentSi braldebulebi yvirod-nen da xalxs mouwodebdnen, rom gadaeRoT. policielebiSediodnen binebSi da moqalaqeebs aSinebdnen da tele-fonebs umowmebdnen. r. j-is ganmartebiT, masze policiismuSakebi axorcielebdnen araadamianur fizikur Zalado-bas, emuqrebodnen gaupatiurebiTa da ojaxis wevrebis da-WeriT, ris gamoc man Tanxmoba ganacxada, aRiarebiT Cve-nebaze moewera xeli. a. g-em ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 4 seq-tembers, Sexvda r-s, romelmac uTxra, rom hqonda raRacpiradi oqros nivTebi da ainteresebda xom ar icnobda vin-me oqromWedels, romelic axlobeli iqneboda da ar mo-atyuebda arc fasSi da arc _ wonaSi. amis Semdeg daukav-Sirda qvisls _ a. k-es da hkiTxa, xom ar hyavda nacnobioqromWedeli, romelmac uTxra, rom hyavda nacnobi oq-romWedeli da SeeZlo daxmareba. Semdeg r-s gamoarTva oq-ros nivTebi da daitova. mividnen, magram oqromWedeli ardaxvdaT, amitom k-em daureka oqromWedels da uTxra, romsurdaT misi naxva. oqromWedelma Sexvedra dauTqva slot-klub `...-i~. mivida k., Sevidnen tualetSi da gadasca g-emoqro da gamoarTva telefonis nomeri. 5 seqtembers j-sTan erTad wavida oqromWedelTan, romelsac gaacno r..iqidan isev taqsiT gaemarTnen b-is quCisken, sadac gaaCe-rebines manqana valutis gadamcvlel punqtTan. undodafulis gadaxurdaveba. gadaaxurdava 200-lariani kupiurada dabrunda manqanaSi. daaxloebiT 2 wuTSi ki daakaves daraRac nivTebi Caudes. miiyvanes s-Si. iq scemdnen, awameb-dnen da iTxovdnen misgan yaCaRobis aRiarebas, razec uarsambobda, vinaidan ar Caudenia. braldebulma l. a-em gan-marta, rom 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers imyofeboda z-Si, di-liT misma biZaSvilma d. a-em daureka da uTxra masTan ga-suliyo, radgan daaxloebiT 2-3 kviris unaxavi hyavda, te-lefonzec ver daekontaqta, gaTiSuli hqonda da wavidamasTan saxlSi. rkinigzaze roca gadadioda, Sexvdnen nac-nobi T. b-i, z-is policiis ufrosi da kidev ori kaci, rom-

178

lebmac ganumartes, rom iyo narkologiuri Semowmeba. Ca-utares Cxreka. Cxrekis Sedegad amoiRes folgaSi gaxveu-li wamali. oqmis xelmoweraze ganacxada uari, vinaidan wa-mali misi ar iyo. daaxloebiT naxevari saaTis mere CasvesmanqanaSi da waiyvanes. mas aranairi danaSauli ar Caude-nia, masze Zaladobdnen policielebi da aiZulebdnen ya-CaRobis faqtis aRiarebas. braldebulma d. a-em ganmarta,rom 2015 wlis 5 seqtembers imyofeboda saxlSi. daurekal-s, romelic ar hyavda nanaxi 2-3 dRe, gamovida ezoSi,saxlis ukana mxares yavas svamda da ficarze iyo Camom-jdari, roca saxlSi Sevarda z-is policia. ikiTxa, Tu raxdeboda, razec z-is policiis ufrosma Caartya wixli gul-mkerdis areSi, ris gamoc amotrialda, gaukres xel-fexi,dasves ezoSi win, uflebebi ar gaacnes. dakavebisas sax-lSi iyo mxolod 4 policieli, xolo Semdeg Sevarda sam-marTvelos specrazmi. ganyofilebaSi policiis muSakebiscemdnen, iTxovdnen misgan yaCaRobis faqtis aRiarebas,mere moaTavses `kpzSi~, saidanac diliT gaaTavisufles dauTxres, rom arafer SuaSi iyo yaCaRobis faqtTan dakav-SirebiT. braldebuli Tavs udanaSaulod miiCnevs da ya-CaRobis faqtTan yovelgvar kavSirs uaryofs. bralde-bulma b. a-m ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 9 seqtembers mas dau-reka g. g-em da sTxova Sexvedroda q-Si, a-s quCaze. rocamivida, ramdenime wuTSi policia mivida da orive daaka-ves, gadaiyvanes samxareo mTavar sammarTveloSi, sadacscemdnen, ayenebdnen sityvier Seuracxyofas da iTxov-dnen misgan yaCaRobis faqtis aRiarebas, Semdeg ki mos-Txoves saqarTvelos datoveba, winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSidahpirdnen, rom axal wels cixeSi gaatarebda. roca mis-gan raime saxis informacia ver miiRes, gaaTavisufles. mangadawyvita TurqeTSi wasvla, radgan eSinoda, marTla arCaesvaT cixeSi. T-dan dabrunebis Semdeg daakaves. bral-debulma g. g-em ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 9 seqtembers daa-kaves, yaCaRobaSi sdebdnen brals, Tumca is kategoriu-lad uaryofs yaCaRobaSi monawileobas. rac Seexeba e.w.`bendenas~, igi misi saxlidan moipares policiis muSakeb-ma da r. x-as saxlSi miitanes, raTa Semdeg iqidan amoeRoT.

2.43. zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebis gaanalizebisa daurTierTSejerebis Sedegad sakasacio palata dadastu-rebulad miiCnevs r. j-is, g. g-is, a. g-sa da b. a-is mier si-

179

cocxlisa da janmrTelobisaTvis saSiSi ZaladobiTa daaseTi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqariT, jgufurad, binaSiukanono SeRweviT, satransporto saSualebis winaaRmdegda didi odenobiT nivTis dauflebis mizniT, r. x-as ojax-ze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis Cadenis faqts, kerZod:

r. j-is mier gamoZiebis etapze micemuli aRiarebiTi Cve-nebis adgilze Semowmebis mizniT Catarebuli sagamoZie-bo eqsperimentis dros r. j-em miuTiTa yaCaRobis drosgatacebuli, r. x-as kuTvnili avtomobiliT betonis kon-struqciaze Sejaxebis adgili w-os raionis sofel m-is te-ritoriaze, sadac aRmoCnda avtomanqanis plastmasis de-talebi, romlebic trasologiur-sasaqonlo eqspertizis#... daskvnis Tanaxmad, warmoadgens r. x-as kuTvnili av-tomanqanis Zravas damcavis qveda safaris plastmasis Se-madgenel nawilebs.

oqromWedel e. k-is CvenebiT dasturdeba, rom 2016 wlis4 seqtembers, anu yaCaRuri Tavdasxmidan ori dRis Sem-deg, mas daukavSirda a. g., romelmac sTxova daxmareba oq-ros nivTebis realizaciaSi da am mizniT slotklub ̀ ...~ tu-aletSi gadasca aRniSnuli oqros nivTebi. manve gaacno r.j. da sTxova, rom am oqros nivTebis realizaciis SedegadmiRebuli Tanxa r. j-sTvis mieca. e. k-em daadastura, rommis mier gamoZiebisaTvis wardgenili moTeTro ferisTvlebi a. g-is mier gadacemuli, swored im samgumbaTianioqros beWdidan amoiRo, romelic gamoZiebis procesSi mis-Tvis wardgenil erT-erT fotosuraTze xelze ukeTia da-zaralebul n. b-s. swored aRniSnuli Tvlebi amoicnes da-zaralebulebma _ r. x-am da n. b-am da ganmartes, rom isinimaTi ojaxidan yaCaRebis mier gatacebuli beWdis Tvle-bis identuri iyo.

2016 wlis 4 seqtembers e. k-is, a. k-sa da a. g-is slot-klub `...~ tualetSi Sexvedrisa da a. g-is mier e. k-saTvisoqros nivTebis gadacemis faqti dasturdeba aseve mowmea. k-s CvenebiT, slotklub `...~ videokamerebis Canawerebi-Ta da misi daTvalierebis oqmebiT.

a. g-is piradi Cxrekis Sedegad misgan amoiRes r. x-asojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis dros gatacebuli vercxlisyelsabami, romelic amoicno dazaralebulma n. b-m.

biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... da #... das-kvnebis mixedviT, SemTxvevis adgilze aRmoCenil da da-

180

zaralebul n. b-as mier gamomZieblisaTvis wardgenil e.w.`bendenaze~ aRmoCnda dazaralebul r. x-s sisxli da g. g-is biologiuri masala.

biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #..., #..., #... das-kvnebis mixedviT, r. x-as saZinebel oTaxSi aRmoCenili re-zinis xelTaTmanis fragmentebze aRmoCnda b. a-sa da da-zaralebul r. x-s sisxli, aseve yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis drosgatacebuli, dazaralebul r. x-as kuTvnili avtomanqani-dan amoRebul qaRaldis fragmentze aRmoCnda b. a-s sis-xli, xolo biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dasturdeba, rom dazaralebul r. x-as mier TavissaZinebel oTaxSi, sawolis leibis qveS napovn da gamoZie-bisaTvis wardgenil TeTr rezinis xelTaTmanis fragmen-tze aRmoCnda b. a-sa da dazaralebul r. x-as biologiurimasala.

mobiluri operatorebisgan miRebuli detaluri in-formaciebis gaanalizebis Sedegad irkveva, rom r. x-asojaxze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis periodSi r. j-is mobiluritelefoni, romelSic moTavsebuli iyo a. g-is simbaraTida g. g-s mobiluri telefoni, dafiqsirebulia r. x-as sac-xovrebeli saxlisa da yaCaRobis dros gatacebuli, misikuTvnili avtomanqanis aRmoCenis adgilis momsaxure an-Zebis dafarvis zonebSi, rac utyuarad adasturebs aRniS-nul teritoriaze maTi yofnis faqts.

2.44. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs msjavrdebul r. j-is interesebis damcvelis, advokat s. b-is pozicias imisTaobaze, rom r. j-is monawileobiT sagamoZiebo eqsperi-menti sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kanonis moTxovnaTadarRveviT mimdinareobda, vinaidan aRniSnuli ar das-turdeba saqmis masalebiT. amasTan, sagulisxmoa, rom sa-gamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmi xelmowerilia rogorc Ta-vad braldebul r. j-is, aseve advokat s. b-is mier, ra dro-sac maT raime gancxadeba an SeniSvna ar gamouTqvamT. amas-Tan, sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom sagamoZiebo esqpe-rimentis oqms ar afasebs rogorc r. j-is aRiarebiT Cvene-bas, vinaidan igi uflebamosilia, uaryos gamoZiebaSi mi-cemuli informacia, aramed iziarebs mas r. j-is braleu-lobis damadasturebel mtkicebulebad im nawilSi, rommis mier miTiTebul adgilas aRmoCnda gatacebuli avto-manqanis detalebi, rac mowmobs misi im adgilas yofnis

181

faqts.2.45. palata ar iziarebs msjavrdebul a. g-is interese-

bis damcvelebis miTiTebas, rom saqmeSi arsebul video-CanawerSi cecxlsasrol iaraRebsa da narkotikul saSua-lebasTan erTad, a. g-sgan amoRebuli Zewkvic gaxsnili dadauluqavia, vinaidan dacvis mxaris mier wardgenil, Ss sa-ministros oficialur vebgverdze ganTavsebul videoCa-nawerSi, kadrSi dauluqavi da gaxsnili Cans mxolod a. g-sa da r. j-sgan amoRebuli iaraRebi da vaznebi, aseve _ l. a-sgan amoRebuli narkotikuli saSualeba (raSic samive maT-gani gamarTlda), xolo Zvirfasi nivTebi da sxva nivTmtki-cebebi daluqulia paketebSi.

2.46. usafuZvloa aseve a. g-is ganmarteba, rom 2015 wlis1 seqtembers is stumrad imyofeboda r. j-sTan da mobi-luri telefoni masTan darCa, vinaidan mobiluri opera-torebisgan gamoTxovnili informaciiT dasturdeba, rom2015 wlis 1 seqtembris 21:31:15 saaTidan 2015 wlis 2 seq-tembris 22:57:17 saaTamde drois monakveTSi a. g-es aqvssatelefono kontaqti Tavis mSoblebsa da qvislTan. gar-da amisa, drois miTiTebul monakveTSi a. g-es satelefo-no kontaqtebi aqvs sazRvargareTis saabonento nomerTan_ ..., romelic ekuTvnis mis meuRles. amdenad, palatas da-dasturebulad miaCnia, rom drois am periodSi a. g. Tvi-Ton sargeblobda mobiluri telefoniT.

2.47. dausabuTebelia r. j-sa da a. g-is damcvelebis po-zicia im nawilSic, rom sagamoZiebo moqmedebebi, maT So-ris a. g-is piradi Cxreka, Catarebulia saproceso kanon-mdeblobis uxeSi darRvevebiT, vinaidan aseTi ar ikveTe-ba arc saqmis masalebiT da arc dacvis mxares warmoudge-nia aRniSnulis damadasturebeli raime mtkicebuleba.

2.48. usafuZvloa msjavrdebul g. g-is ganmarteba, romTiTqos, policiis TanamSromlebma g. g-is sacxovrebelibinis Cxrekisas moipoves misi kuTvnili `bendena~, rome-lic miitanes da dades SemTxvevis adgilze, vinaidan aR-niSnuli `bendena~ aRbeWdilia 2015 wlis 2 seqtembers Sem-Txvevis adgilis daTvalierebisas gadaRebul fotoebze,rasac am sagamoZiebo moqmedebaSi monawile pirebic adas-tureben.

2.49. palata ar iziarebs aseve b. a-is pozicias, rom misibraldeba efuZneba erTaderT mtkicebulebas da mas yaCa-

182

RobaSi monawileoba ar miuRia, vinaidan b. a-is braleulo-ba utyuaradaa dadasturebuli mtkicebulebaTa erTob-liobiT, kerZod: r. x-as saxlidan amoRebul xelTaTmanisfragmentze aRmoCenili sisxlisa da biologiuri masalisgenetikuri profili identuria b. a-is genetikuri profi-lisa; r. x-sagn gatacebuli avtomanqanidan amoRebul qa-Raldis fragmentze aRmoCenili sisxlis genetikuri pro-fili identuria b. a-is genetikuri profilisa; a-is kav-Sirs Cadenil yaCaRobaSi amyarebs aseve mobiluri opera-torebidan miRebuli informacia, romliTac dasturde-ba, 2015 wlis 24 agvistodan 4 seqtembris CaTvliT peri-odSi misi kavSirebi yaCaRobaSi braldebul sxva pirebTan.palata miuTiTebs, rom iseTi wonadi mtkicebulebebi, ro-goricaa genetikuri eqspertizis daskvnebi, romlebiTacutyuaradaa dadasturebuli a-is SemTxvevis adgilze yof-nis faqti, miT umetes im fonze, roca raime damajerebeliargumenti kvalis sxva viTarebaSi darCenisa msjavrde-buls ar warmoudgenia, sakmarisia bralis gonivrul eWvsmiRma samtkiceblad.

2.50. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, palatamiiCnevs, rom dacvis mxaris pozicia r. x-as ojaxze yaCa-Ruri Tavdasxmis epizodSi r. j-is, g. g-is, a. g-sa da b. a-isudanaSaulobis Sesaxeb dausabuTebelia, vinaidan ewina-aRmdegeba saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis sxdomaze sisxlis sa-marTlis saproceso kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT gamokvle-ul urTierTSejerebul da utyuar mtkicebulebebs.

2.51. rac Seexeba d. a-sa da l. a-es, sasamarTlo sxdoma-ze gamokvleul mtkicebulebaTa analizisa da urTierTSe-jerebis Sedegad, sakasacio palata mivida daskvnamde, rommaTi msjavrdebis nawilSi gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda ga-uqmdes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

2.52. saqarTvelos konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 na-wilis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebo-des mxolod utyuar mtkicebulebebs. yovelgvari eWvi, ro-melic ver dadasturdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, undagadawydes braldebulis sasargeblod. aRniSnuli konsti-tuciuri debuleba warmoadgens samarTlebrivi saxelmwi-fos erT-erT safuZvels, ganamtkicebs udanaSaulo pirismsjavrdebis Tavidan acilebis mniSvnelovan, sayovelTa-od aRiarebul princips _ `in dubio pro reo~, romlis Tanax-

183

mad, dauSvebelia piris msjavrdeba saeWvo xasiaTis bral-debebis safuZvelze da, amdenad, sisxlissamarTlebrividevnis procesSi adamianis uflebebis dacvis mniSvnelo-van garantias qmnis. konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 pun-qtidan gamomdinare, mtkicebulebiTi standarti valde-bulebas akisrebs sasamarTlos, rom saTanadod Seafasosmtkicebulebebi, samarTlianad gadaWras samxilebs Sorisarsebuli winaaRmdegobebi da am procesSi warmoSobili yo-velgvari gonivruli eWvi gadawyvitos braldebulis uda-naSaulobis, misi Tavisuflebis sasargeblod.1

2.53. adamianis uflebaTa evropuli konvenciis me-6 mux-lis me-2 punqtis Tanaxmad, yoveli piri, visac bralad ede-ba sisxlis samarTlis danaSaulis Cadena, iTvleba udana-Saulod, vidre misi braleuloba ar damtkicdeba kanonisSesabamisad. ganaCeni unda emyarebodes saqmeSi arsebulmtkicebulebaTa Tavisufal Sefasebas, daskvnebs, romle-bic gamomdinareobs faqtobrivi garemoebebidan da mxa-reebis mier wardgenili mosazrebebidan. mtkiceba SeiZ-leba gamomdinareobdes sakmarisad naTeli da dasabuTe-buli daskvnebis an faqtis Taobaze gauqarwylebeli vara-udebis erTobliobidan.2

2.54. gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT l. a-is msjavrdeba ume-tesad efuZneba im faqtobriv garemoebas, rom misi sac-xovrebeli binidan Cxrekis Sedegad amoiRes r. x-as ojax-ze yaCaRuri Tavdasxmis dros gatacebuli `NOKIA~-s fir-mis mobiluri telefonis yuTi, romelzec datanili imei-kodi daemTxva dazaralebul n. b-s mier Tavisi disTvis _m. b-sTvis naCuqar `NOKIA~-s firmis mobiluri telefonisimeikods.

2.55. sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis moTxov-nebidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palata gamamtyunebeli ga-naCenis dadgenisas xelmZRvanelobs gonivrul eWvs miRma

1 saqarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 22 ianvris#1/1/548 gadawyvetileba saqmeze „saqarTvelos moqalaqe zurabmiqaZe saqarTvelos parlamentis winaaRmdeg“.

2 ix. El Masri v The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia #39630/09,adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos 2012 wlis 13dekembris gadawyvetileba da Hassan v The UK #29750/09, adamianisuflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 16 seqtembrisgadawyvetileba.

184

standartiT, rac amave kodeqsis me-3 muxlis me-13 nawi-lis Tanaxmad, warmoadgens iseTi mtkicebulebebis erTob-liobas, romelic obieqtiur pirs daarwmunebda piris bra-leulobaSi. sakasacio palatisTvis, rogorc obieqturidamkvirveblisTvis, ar aris sarwmuno yaCaRobisas mobi-luri telefonis carieli yuTis gataceba da Semdgom misisami dRis ganmavlobaSi sacxovrebel saxlSi Senaxva, risgamoc miaCnia, rom aseTi mtkicebulebis safuZvelze pi-ris msjavrdeba ar akmayofilebs saproceso kanonmdeblo-biT dadgenil maRal samarTlebriv standarts.

2.56. l. a-is braleulobis dasadastureblad sakmarisiar aris nivTierebaTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTaeqspertizis #... daskvna (romliTac dadgenilia, rom av-tomobilis `WOLKSWAGEN CC SPORT 2009~, sax. #..., ukanamarcxena savarZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, ukanamarjvena savarZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, winamarjvena savarZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, winamarcxena savarZlis dasajdomidan amoRebul molurjo,araTanabrad SeRebil bambis boWkoebs aqvT saerTo gvarob-rivi kuTvnileba eqspertizaze wardgenil l. a-is, d. a-is,r. j-sa da a. g-is jinsis Sarvlebis qsovilebis lurji nar-Tis Semadgenel Sesabamis boWkoebTan), vinaidan mowmis sa-xiT dakiTxulma eqspertma n. a-ma ganmarta, rom l. a-is, d.a-is, r. j-sa da a. g-is jinsis Sarvlebis qsovilebis Semad-geneli molurjo feris, araTanabrad SeRebili bambis boW-koebi, romlebic SeRebilia indigoiduri saRebavebiT, arisfarTod gavrcelebuli da am konkretul SemTxvevaSi argaaCniaT saidentifikacio mniSvneloba.

2.57. rac Seexeba mobiluri operatorebisgan miRebulinformacias, romlis Tanaxmadac, 2015 wlis 15 agvisto-dan 5 seqtembris CaTvliT, l. a-es aqvs intensiuri kavSiria. g-sTan, r. j-sTan, g. g-sTan, d. a-sa da b. a-sTan, palatamiuTiTebs, rom misi kavSirebi SesaZloa, gamxdariyo misibralis gamamyarebeli mtkicebuleba sxva, mtkicebulebeb-Tan erTobliobaSi, calke aRebuli piris kavSiri sxva bral-debulebTan ki ver gaxdeba misi konkretul danaSauleb-riv qmedebaSi monawileobis damadasturebeli garemoeba.

2.58. rac Seexeba msjavrdebul d. a-s, misi msjavrdebaZiriTadad efuZneba biologiuri (genetikuri) eqspetizis#... daskvnas, romlis Tanaxmadac, dazaralebul r. x-as de-

185

dis, n. b-is mier maTi sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi napovnpolieTilenis parkSi moTavsebuli tansacmlidan jinsisSarvalze, qamarsa da maisurze aRmoCnda d. a-s biologiu-ri masala.

2.59. sakasacio palata daeTanxmeboda gasaCivrebuli ga-naCenis motivacias (miiCnevda mas d. a-is braleulobis ut-yuar mtkicebulebad), rom ara Tavad im mtkicebulebis(romlis safuZvelzec Catarda biologiuri eqspertiza)mopovebasTan dakavSirebuli garemoebebi, kerZod:

adgilmdebareobisa da tansacmlis daTvalierebis oq-miT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 24 oqtombers Catarda x-sraionis sofel m-Si dazaralebul r. x-as ezos daTvalie-reba, ra drosac daTvalierebaSi monawile pirebi, n. b-ismiTiTebiT, gavidnen r. x-as sakarmidamo ezoSi samxreT-aRmosavleTis mxares, romelsac esazRvreba d. b-is ezo,sadac n. b-em miuTiTa liTonis konstruqciis RobesTan,miwaze dadebul moyviTalo-momwvano polieTilenis par-kze da aRniSna, rom es parki im dRes aRmoaCina (sxva niv-TebTan erTad parkSi aRmoCnda maisuri da jinsis Sarva-li, romelzec d-i a-is genetikuri masala amovida).

sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs dacvis mxaris po-zicias, rom im viTarebaSi, rodesac SemTxvevidan gasuliadaaxloebiT 52 dRe da am drois ganmavlobaSi SemTxvevisadgili faqtobrivad orjer daTvalierda, erTxel, Sem-Txvevis dRes _ sapolicio ZaRlis monawileobiT, meoredki _ r. j-is monawileobiT Catarebuli sagamoZiebo eqspe-rimentis dros, bunebrivia, Cndeba eWvi mopovebuli mtki-cebulebis utyuarobis Sesaxeb. am eWvs kidev ufro aZli-erebs dacvis mxaris mier saapelacio sasamarTloSi saqmisganxilvisas warmodgenili, damoukidebeli sasamarTloeqspertizis centr `veqtoris~ mier gacemuli teqnikurieqspertizis #... daskvna, romlis Sefasebis Sedegad pa-latas miaCnia, rom 2015 wlis 6 seqtembers Catarebuli sa-gamoZiebo eqsperimentis dros gadaRebul #10 da #11 fo-tosuraTebze r. j. aRbeWdilia swored im adgilze, sadac2015 wlis 24 oqtombers mowme n. b-em aRmoaCina celofnisparki (fotosuraTebi #7 da #8), romelic, bunebrivia ma-Sin (sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis dros) SemCneuli unda yo-filiyo.

amdenad, warmoSobili eWvi aris gonivruli da palata

186

savaldebulod wyvets mas braldebulis sasargeblod.2.60. rac Seexeba mobiluri operatorebidan miRebul

informacias, d. a-is kuTvnil, Sps `...~ qselSi CarTul saa-bonento nomerze ... ganxorcielebuli Semaval-gamavalizarebisa da mokle teqsturi Setyobinebebis analizidanirkveva, rom 2015 wlis 25 agvistos 13:39:30 saaTidan 2015wlis 4 seqtembris 11:53:01 saaTamde d. a-is kuTvnil saabo-nento nomerze _ kontaqtebi ar fiqsirdeba. amdenad, rai-mes mtkiceba aRniSnuli informaciiT SeuZlebelia. racSexeba im faqts, rom miTiTebul periodamde da mas Sem-deg d. a-es hqonia satelefono kavSiri a. g-sTan, g. g-sa dal. a-sTan, palata ganmeorebiT miuTiTebs, rom mocemulSemTxvevaSi aseTi informacia damoukideblad ver iZle-va raimes mtkicebis safuZvels.

2.61. masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTa eqspertizis#... daskvna (romliTac dadgenilia, rom avtomobilis`WOLKSWAGEN CC SPORT 2009~, sax. #..., ukana marcxena sa-varZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, ukana marjvena sa-varZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, wina marjvena sa-varZlis sazurgidan da dasajdomidan, wina marcxena sa-varZlis dasajdomidan amoRebul molurjo, araTanabradSeRebil bambis boWkoebs aqvT saerTo gvarobrivi kuTvni-leba eqspertizaze wardgenil l. a-is, d. a-is, r. j-sa da a.g-is jinsis Sarvlebis qsovilebis lurji narTis Semadge-nel Sesabamis boWkoebTan) eqspert n. a-is ganmartebis gaT-valiswinebiT, rom jinsis Sarvlis qsovilis Semadgenelimolurjo feris, araTanabrad SeRebili bambis boWkoebi,romlebic SeRebilia indigoiduri saRebavebiT, aris far-Tod gavrcelebuli da am konkretul SemTxvevaSi ar gaaC-niaT saidentifikacio mniSvneloba, aseve ar aris sakmari-si safuZveli d. a-is braleulobis dasadastureblad.

2.62. rac Seexeba amocnobis oqmebs, romelTa Tanaxma-dac, r. x-am amoicno l. a. da d. a. da ganmarta, rom maT Sem-Txvevamde ramdenime xniT adre periodulad xedavda q.q-Si, Tavisi samuSao ofisis mimdebare teritoriaze, l. a.aseve nanaxi hyavs Tavisi sacxovrebeli saxlis win `BMW~-s markis avtomanqaniT gadaadgilebisas, palata miuTiTebs,rom aRniSnuli aris arapirdapiri mtkicebuleba, rac Se-iZleba amyarebdes braldebas, magram misi iuridiuli Za-lis gaTvaliswinebiT, igi damoukideblad ver daadastu-

187

rebs piris yaCaRur TavdasxmaSi monawileobis faqts.2.63. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-

cio palatas miaCnia, rom d. a-sa da l. a-is msjavrdeba arefuZneba utyuar mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobas, ris ga-moc isini unda gamarTldnen r. x-as ojaxze yaCaRuri Tav-dasxmisaTvis wardgenil braldebaSi.

3. da bolos, sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebsmsjavrdebulTa gancxadebebze, rom isini samarTaldam-cavi organos warmomadgenelTa mxridan gaxdnen araada-minauri mopyrobis msxverplni da miuTiTebs, rom moce-muli sisxlis samarTlis saqmis ganxilvis farglebSi, sa-Tanado gamoZiebisa da mtkicebulebebis gareSe, palatamoklebulia SesaZleblobas, Tavad Seafasos aRniSnuli sa-kiTxi, Tumca, imedovnebs, rom samarTaldamcavi organoe-bis mxridan moxdeba sakiTxis saTanadod Seswavla da Se-sabamisi reagireba.


is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiTda

d a a d g i n a:

1. msjavrdebulebis _ b. a-sa da g. g-is, msjavrdebul r.j-is advokatis _ s. b-is, msjavrdebul a. g-is advokatebis_ o. g-sa da m. r-is sakasacio saCivrebi ar dakmayofildes.

2. msjavrdebul l. a-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofil-des nawilobriv.

3. msjavrdebul d. a-is advokatebis _ a. a-sa da s. b-issakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes.

4. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 24 maisis ganaCenSi Sevides cvli-leba:

msjavrdebuli l. a. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da ga-marTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis`b~, `g~ da me-3 nawilis `a~, `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenilbraldebaSi (r. x-as epizodi).

msjavrdebul l. a-es saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `b~, `g~ da me-3 nawilis `a~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT (k.

188

f-is epizodi) ganesazRvros 10 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkve-Ta.

saqarTvelos ssk-is 67-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanaxmad,gauqmdes zestafonis raionuli sasamarTlos 2013 wlis 31ivlisis ganaCeniT daniSnuli pirobiTi msjavri. saqarTve-los ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Sesabamisad, bolo ga-naCeniT daniSnulma sasjelma STanTqas wina ganaCeniT da-niSnuli sasjelis mouxdeli nawili _ 1 wliT Tavisufle-bis aRkveTa da sabolood l. a-s sasjelis saxiT ganesaz-Rvros 10 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, romlis moxda aeT-valos 2015 wlis 5 seqtembridan.

msjavrdebuli d. a. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da ga-marTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis`b~, `g~ da me-3 nawilis `b~, `g~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenilbraldebaSi.

d. a. dauyovnebliv gaTavisufldes sasamarTlo sxdo-mis darbazidan.

gamarTlebul d. a-es ganemartos, rom ufleba aqvs, sa-qarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 92-emuxliT dadgenili wesiT moiTxovos zianis anazRaureba.

5. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 24 maisis ganaCeni sxva nawilSidarCes ucvlelad.


189

ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana da msjavrdebulisgamarTleba saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis 177-e muxliT wardgenil braldebaSi


#584ap-17 7 marti, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi



zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila msjavrdebul b. b-isinteresebis damcvelis, advokat j. m-is sakasacio saCiva-ri Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 13 seqtembris ganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. Telavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 9 ianvris

ganaCeniT b. b., _ ... nasamarTlevi, _ cnobil iqna damnaSa-ved saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à,~ `b~qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b,~ `d~ qvepunqtebiT, ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à,~ `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da amavemuxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT da ssk-is 19.177-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis à,~ `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b,~`d~ qvepunqtebiT.

2. sasamarTlom daadgina:b. b. Telavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 11 de-

kembris ganaCeniT cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelosssk-is 177-e muxlis meore nawilis à~ qvepunqtiT da mie-saja _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa sami wliT, rac saqarTvelosssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis safuZvelze CaeTvala pirobiT,imave gamosacdeli vadiT;

b. b-em 2016 wlis martSi ukanonod SeaRwia a-is raionissofel _ a-Si, g. x-sa da e. j-is sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSida amave ezoSi mdebare sardafSi, saidanac marTlsawina-aRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT daeufla `belarusis~ mo-delis traqtoris ukana or saTadarigo saburavs, or Sem-

190

duRebel aparats, xolo ezoSi mdgari `belarusis~ mode-lis traqtoridan moxsna da marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuT-rebis mizniT, farulad daeufla traqtoris eleqtroma-Suqs. aseve, sacxovrebeli saxlis ezodan b. b., garda zemo-aRniSnuli nivTebisa, marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebismizniT farulad daeufla SesaduRebeli aparatis sadgam-misabmelis erT saburavs;

b. b-m 2016 wlis martSi ukanonod SeaRwia a-is raionissofel _ a-Si, o. l-is sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi, saida-nac marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, faruladdaeufla o. l-is kuTvnil or saburavs diskiT, avtomobi-lis meqanikur amwevsa da Zalayins.

b. b-em 2016 wlis 27 aprils ukanonod SeaRwia a-is raio-nis sofel _ a-Si, g. x-sa da e. j-is sacxovrebeli saxlisezoSi, ra drosac Seecada, ezoSi mdgari `belarusis~ mo-delis traqtoridan marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebismizniT daufleboda traqtoris wina or saburavs, Zravasgamagrilebeli wylis avzis saxuravsa da 9 WanWiks, rac manver ganaxorciela, vinaidan igi daakaves Sss a-s raionulisammarTvelos TanamSromlebma.

2. b. b-es saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilisà,~ `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b,~ `d~ qvepunqte-biT miesaja _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 4 wliTa da 6 TviT;saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à,~ `b~ qve-punqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT _ Tavisufle-bis aRkveTa 4 wliTa da 6 TviT, xolo saqarTvelos ssk-is19.177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à,~ `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3nawilis `b,~ `d~ qvepunqtebiT _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 4wliTa da 6 TviT;

saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad,saqarTvelos ssk-is 19.177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis ̀ a,~ ̀ b~ qve-punqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b,~ `d~ qvepunqtebiT daniS-nulma sasjelma STanTqa danarCeni sasjelebi da danaSa-ulTa erTobliobiT b. b-es miesaja _ 4 wliTa da 6 TviTTavisuflebis aRkveTa;

saqarTvelos ssk-is 67-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanaxmad,gauqmda b. b-is mimarT Telavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014wlis 11 dekembris ganaCeniT daniSnuli pirobiTi msjavri_ 3 weli;

saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanaxmad,

191

axlad daniSnul sasjels nawilobriv daemata b. b-is mi-marT wina ganaCeniT daniSnuli sasjelis mouxdeli nawi-lidan _ 1 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa da sabolood, gana-CenTa erTobliobiT, b. b-es miesaja _ 5 wliTa da 6 TviTTavisuflebis aRkveTa.

b. b-es sasjelis moxdis aTvla daewyo faqtobrivi da-kavebis momentidan _ 2016 wlis 27 aprilidan.

4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra msjavrdebul-ma b. b-em da misma interesebis damcvelma, advokatma j. m-ma.

5. apelantebma iTxoves Telavis raionuli sasamarTlos2017 wlis 9 ianvris ganaCenis gauqmeba da b. b-is mimarTgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gamotana.

6. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 13 seqtembris ganaCeniTTelavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 9 ianvris gana-Ceni darCa ucvlelad.

7. kasatori _ msjavrdebul b. b-is interesebis damcve-li, advokati j. m. sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnavs, rom niv-Tieri mtkicebulebebis amocnobis oqmebi 3.5 _ dan _ 3.21-is CaTvliT (mtkicebulebaTa nusxaSi miTiTebuli), rom-lebiTac dazaralebulebma amoicnes nivTebi (rogorc ma-Ti sakuTreba), dauSveblad aris cnobili. gamoZiebisas arCatarebula piradi Cxreka, nivTebis amocnoba, daqtilos-kopiuri eqspertiza. saapelacio sasamarTlom qurdobismcdeloba dadgenilad CaTvala ori gamomZieblis _ a. c-sada z. b-is araTanmimdevrul Cvenebebisa da e. j-is irib Cve-nebaze dayrdnobiT. rac Seexeba saburavebs, isini b. b-esarc mouxsnia da arc misi marTlsawinaaRmdego miTvisebaucdia. misi damadasturebeli utyuari mtkicebuleba ararsebobs. saburavebis simZimis gaTvaliswinebiT, mis waRe-bas saSualo Zalis mqone adamiani ver SeZlebda. gamoZie-bis mier b. b-is sacxovrebeli binidan da damxmare saTav-sodan amoRebuli nivTebi aris misi ojaxis sakuTreba. sa-samarTlom ar miuTiTa, Tu romeli mtkicebulebiT das-turdeboda, rom b. b-is ojaxs sakuTrebaSi ar SeiZlebodahqonoda futkris gadasazidi lafeti da Sesabamisad _ sa-buravebi.

8. dacvis mxaris miTiTebiT, saapelacio palatam aras-worad ganmarta saqarTvelos sssk-is 125-e muxlis (daT-

192

valiereba) miznebi; ar aris dadgenili, o. l-m rodis da-karga nivTebi. b. b-is dakavebamde mas arsad ganucxadebiara nivTebi daekarga da aRniSnulis dadgena aucilebeliasasamarTlos mxridan ss devnis xandazmulobis Sesafaseb-lad.

samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam mxareTa monawileobis gareSe ga-

nixila sakasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Sea-mowma saCivris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom msjavrde-bul b. b-is interesebis damcvelis, advokat j. m-is sakasa-cio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilobriv Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:

2. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlosim nawilSi, rom msjavrdebulma b. b-em Caidina saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 19.177-e muxlis me-2 na-wilis `a,~ `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis`b,~ `d~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli qmedeba. saqmeSiwarmodgenilia erTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul, aSkara da da-majerebel mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba, romelic goniv-rul eWvs miRma adasturebs b. b-is mier qurdobis mcde-lobis Cadenas, kerZod:

3. dazaralebul e. j-is mier pirveli instanciis sasa-marTlo sxdomaze micemuli CvenebiT dgindeba, rom cxov-robs a-s raionis sofel m-Si meuRlesTan _ g. x-sTan er-Tad. mowmis CvenebiT, ojaxs sakuTrebaSi hyavs traqtori.2016 wlis 15 marts man aRmoaCina, rom saxlidan ikargebo-da sxvadasxva nivTi; yoveldRiurad ezoSi mdgari traq-toridan daudgeneli piri(ebi) iparavdnen sxvadasxva na-wils. dazaralebulma ganmarta, rom moparuli iyo traq-toris ukana ori saburavi, traqtoris nawilebi da eleq-troSesaduRebeli aparatebi. mowmem ganacxada, rom 2016wlis 27 aprils, gamTeniisas, daaxloebiT eqvs saaTze (Svi-di saaTi iqneboda dawyebuli), ezodan Semoesma xmauri, radrosac gamovida ezoSi da dainaxa policiis TanamSrom-lebi _ a. c. da z. b., romlebsac ecvaT policiis forma. ezo-Si dakavebuli daxvda b. b-e, ris Semdeg igi Sebrunda sax-lSi da ukan gamovida meuRlesTan erTad. am dros adgil-ze movidnen policiis sxva TanamSromlebic. e. j-ma gan-marta, rom ezoSi gamosvlisas dainaxa, rom traqtoris wi-

193

na ori saburavi iyo moxsnili da iqve eyara; aseve dainaxaiqve dayrili WanWikebi da traqtoris siaxloves dagde-buli b. b-is qurTuki, saidanac policiis TanamSromlebmaamoiRes WanWikebi da traqtoris radiatoris xufi. e. j-madasmul kiTxvaze upasuxa, rom traqtoris siaxloves ase-ve egdo saburavis mosaxsneli qanCi. e. j-is ganmartebiT,man policiis ganyofilebaSi monawileoba miiRo sxvadas-xva nivTis daTvalierebaSi, ra drosac daaTvalieres misikuTvnili nivTebi, vinaidan es nivTebi mas ekuTvnis mrava-li welia da maTi cnoba ar gasWirvebia.

4. e. j-is CvenebiT dgindeba, rom misi sacxovrebeli sax-lis ezoSi mdebare e.w `saraiidan~ farulad dauflebulitraqtoris ori didi saburavis fasia 1500 lari, e.w. `sa-kis~ _ 200 lari, ori eleqtro SemduReblis jamSi _ 1600lari, sawvavis tumbos fasia 150 lari, zeTis tumbosi _120 lari, haeris tumbosi _ 80 lari, e.w. magnitis fasia 50lari, traqtoris wina maSuqis _ 15 lari. mowmem ganmarta,rom traqtoris patara saburavebis fasi jamSi Seadgens400 lars, e.w. bizonis 9 WanWikis fasia 45 lari, xolo Zra-vas gamagrilebeli wylis avzis safareblis fasi _ 15 lari.

5. mowme g. x-is CvenebiT dgindeba, rom cxovrobs a-israionis sofel m-Si meuRlesTan _ e. j-Tan erTad. ojaxssakuTrebaSi hyavs `belarusis~ markis traqtori, romelicdgas maTive saxlis ezoSi. mowmis ganmartebiT, 2016 wlis27 aprils, diliT, ezodan Semoesma xmauri, ra drosac me-uRlesTan erTad sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi gavida dadainaxa policiis TanamSromlebi, romlebsac b. b. hyavdaTdakavebuli. mowmem ganacxada, rom ezoSi mdgar traqtor-ze moxsnili iyo saburavebi, rac eyara adgilze. misi gan-martebiT, 2016 wlis 27 aprilamde traqtoridan aseve mo-paruli iyo sxva nawilebic, rac swored b. b-s hqonda mopa-ruli. g. x-em Cvenebis micemis dros ganmarta, rom moparu-li iyo ori SemduRebeli (`svarkis~) aparati, traqtorispatara da didi saburavebi, dabali wnevis tumbo da sxvanawilebi; traqtors moxsnili hqonda TiTqmis yvela nawi-li. g. x. monawileobda sxvadasxva nivTis daTvalierebaSi,ra drosac misi kuTvnili nivTebi daTvalierda. maTi cno-ba ar gasWirvebia. mowmem ganacxada, rom mas bolo wlebia,mxedveloba aqvs daqveiTebuli da TiTqmis verafers xe-davs. advokatis SekiTxvaze _ konkretulad sad ijda b. b.

194

sasamarTlo sxdomis darbazSi, mowmem upasuxa, rom igidarbazSi b. b-s ver xedavs mxedvelobis problemebis ga-mo. aseve, ganmarta, rom daTvalierebis dasrulebis Sem-deg mas ar waukiTxavs saTanado oqmebi, vinaidan verafersxedavda.

6. gamomZiebelma z. b-ma daadastura mis mier da misi mo-nawileobiT Catarebuli sagamoZiebo da saproceso moqme-debebis siswore da kanonTan Sesabamisoba. mowmem ganmar-ta, rom 2016 wlis 27 aprils, gamTeniisas, Sesasrulebladdaewera p. n-is pataki, romelSic miTiTebuli iyo, rom a-israionis sofel _ a-Si, g. x-is sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSimdgari `belarusis~ markis traqtoridan saburavebs xsni-da b. b.. aRniSnulis safuZvelze daiwyo gamoZieba da a. c-Tan erTad gaemarTa patakSi miTiTebul misamarTze. mow-mis ganmartebiT, adgilze misvlisas maT SeamCnies, romezoSi mdgar traqtors qurdavda b. b., kerZod, xsnida na-wilebs. gamomZieblebma dainaxes, rom b. b-s moxsnili hqon-da traqtoris wina ori saburavi, romelTagan erT-erTieWira xelSi da moZraobas iwyebda WiSkris mimarTulebiT,ra drosac b. b-em SeamCnia isini, daagdo saburavi da Seeca-da gaqcevas. rodesac b. b. Seecada gaqcevas, a. c-ma mas xe-li Caavlo qurTukSi, b. b-em gaixada qurTuki da gaiqcaezoSi arsebuli `saraiis~ mimarTulebiT. mas kvlav dae-devna a. c. da adgilze daakava. mowmis ganmartebiT, b. b-isdakavebis Semdgom ezoSi gamovida e. j., xolo mogvianebiT_ misi meuRle g. x.. mowmis CvenebiT, b. b-is dakavebis oqmiman Seadgina adgilze, ris Semdegac dakavebuli policiisganyofilebaSi gadaiyvana, dabrunda adgilze da e. j-sada eqspertis monawileobiT daaTvaliera SemTxvevis ad-gili. daTvalierebis dros amoiRes: b. b-is zednacvami qur-Tuki, ori qanCi, qanCis mili, e.w. bizonis WanWikebi da traq-toris wina saburavebi.

7. mowme a. c-ma ganmarta, rom muSaobs Sinagan saqmeTasammarTvelos a-is raionul sammarTveloSi ubnis inspeq-tor-gamomZieblis Tanamdebobaze. mowmis ganmartebiT,2016 wlis 27 aprils, gamTeniisas, policiis ganyofileba-Si Sevida informacia imis Sesaxeb, rom a-is raionis sofel_ a-Si, e. j-is sacxovrebel saxlSi Sesuli iyo b. b., rome-lic traqtors xsnida nawilebs. mowmem ganmarta, rom in-formaciis gadamowmebis mizniT, daaxloebiT dilis eqvs

195

saaTze igi z. b-Tan erTad mivida miTiTebul misamarTzeda ezoSi dainaxa b. b., romelic traqtors xsnida saburavs.mowmem aseve ganmarta, rom rodesac b. b-em xelSi aiRo sa-buravi da daapira moZraoba WiSkris mimarTulebiT, man Se-niSna policiis TanamSromlebi, daagdo saburavi da See-cada gaqcevas saTavsis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac a. c. da-edevna da daakava. mowmis ganmartebiT, b. b-is dakavebisSemdgom ezoSi gamovidnen e. j. da g. x.. dakavebuli SinagansaqmeTa saministros a-is raionuli sammarTvelos adminis-traciul SenobaSi gadaiyvanes.

8. braldebulma b. b-em sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxvi-sas ganmarta, rom 2016 wlis 27 aprils, gvian RamiT, daax-loebiT sam saaTze, saxlidan wavida a-is raionis sofel _a-Si mdebare `furneSi~ puris sayidlad. mas Sexvda a. c.,romelmac SeaCera da iqve arsebul e.w `birJaze~ dauwyosaubari sofelSi momxdar qurdobebTan dakavSirebiT.braldebulma ganmarta, rom a. c. mas abralebda qurdobas.am dros a. c-ma daureka policiis sxva TanamSromlebs, rom-lebic masTan mividnen, Casves avtomanqanaSi da abraleb-dnen qurdobebs. b. b-is ganmartebiT, mas gaxades qurTukida daagdes avtomanqanis sabargulze. braldebulma aseveganmarta, rom Semdeg igi waiyvanes e. j-is saxlis mimarTu-lebiT. policiis TanamSromlebi Sevidnen ezoSi, xolo Ta-vad datoves manqanaSi, amasTan, misi qurTuki gadaitanesda daagdes ezoSi, traqtoris siaxloves, ris Semdeg Ta-vad policiis TanamSromlebma moxsnes saburavebi. am drosezoSi gamovida e. j.. b. b-em dakiTxvisas aseve ganmarta,rom misi sacxovrebeli binis Cxrekisas amoRebuli sabu-ravebi, eleqtroSemduRebeli aparatebi, Zalayini da am-we mas ar mouparavs da aRniSnuli nivTebi aris misi sakuT-reba.

9. dakavebis oqmis Tanaxmad, 2016 wlis 27 aprils, 06:10saaTze, a-is raionis sofel _ a-Si, e. j-is sacxovrebelisaxlis ezoSi, braldebulis saxiT daakaves b. b. (gamomZie-beli z. b., monawile pirebi _ a. c., e. j., g. x.).

10. sakasacio palata, ar eTanxmeba dacvis mxaris pozi-cias qurdobis mcdelobis nawilSi mtkicebulebaTa ara-sakmarisobis Taobaze.

11. mowmeebis _ z. b-sa da a. c-is Cvenebebidan gamomdina-re, dadgenilia, rom gamomZieblebma SemTxvevis adgilze

196

misvlisas b. b. qurdobis obieqturi Semadgenlobis ganxor-cielebis dros dainaxes. rodesac b. b-em policiis Tanam-Sromlebi SeamCnia, daagdo saburavi da gaqcevas Seecada.gamomZieblebis CvenebebSi asaxuli faqtobrivi garemoebebiSeesabameba dazaralebulis Cvenebas, kerZod, e. j-is gan-cxadebiT, rodesac ezodan Semoesma xmauri, gavida da dai-naxa policiis TanamSromlebi _ a. c. da z. b., romlebsac ezoSidakavebuli hyavdaT b. b.. mowmem dainaxa, rom traqtoriswina ori saburavi iyo moxsnili, iqve dayrili iyo WanWikebi,xolo traqtoris siaxloves b. b-s qurTuki egdo.

12. saqmeSi arsebuli arc erTi mtkicebuleba ar adasu-rebs braldebulis Cvenebis im nawils, rom policiis Ta-namSromlebma traqtors saburavebi Tavad moxsnes.

13. sakasacio sasamarTlo b. b-s mimarT saqarTvelos ssk-is 19.177-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT wardgenilbraldebas (qurdoba, Cadenili araerTgzis) dadastureb-lad miiCnevs Semdegi garemoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT:

Telavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 11 dekembrisganaCeniT b. b. cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is177-e muxlis meore nawilis à~ qvepunqtiT da miesaja _Tavisuflebis aRkveTa sami wliT, rac saqarTvelos ssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis safuZvelze CaeTvala pirobiT, ima-ve gamosacdeli vadiT;

ssip _ arasapatimro sasjelTa aRsrulebisa da proba-ciis erovnuli saagentos teritoriuli organos kaxeTisprobaciis biuros 2016 wlis 27 aprilis momarTvis Tanax-mad, b. b. k-is probaciis biuroSi aRricxvaze imyofeba 2014wlis 11 dekembris ganaCenis safuZvelze.

14. amdenad, sakasacio palatas dadgenilad miaCnia b.b-is mier saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 19.177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à~, `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis`b~, `d~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli qmedebis Cadena.

15. rac Seexeba saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2nawilis à~, `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b~, `d~ qve-punqtebiT, ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à~, `b~ qve-punqtebiTa da me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswine-buli danaSaulis Cadenas, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, romwarmodgenili mtkicebulebebiT braldebis es nawilebiutyuarad ver dasturdeba, ris gamoc aRniSnavs, rom dac-vis mxaris sakasacio saCivari am nawilSi unda dakmayofil-

197

des da b. b. unda gamarTldes, vinaidan:16. dazaralebul o. l-is mier sasamarTlo sxdomaze mi-

cemuli Cvenebis Tanaxmad, 2016 wlis martSi man aRmoaCi-na, rom misi saxlidan moparuli iyo ori saburavi TavisivediskebiT, amwe da Zalayini. mowmis ganmartebiT, diskebiiyo daJanguli, xolo saburavebi _ gacveTili da erT-er-Ti gverdze _ gaxeTqili; rac Seexeba amwes, igi iyo wiTelida yuri hqonda motexili; Zalayinic iyo wiTeli. mowmisganmartebiT, 2016 wlis aprilSi masTan mividnen policiisTanamSromlebi, romlebmac ganucxades, rom dakavebulihyavdaT b. b., romelmac aRiara misi kuTvnili nivTebis qur-doba. amis Semdeg mowme monawileobda xsenebuli nivTe-bis daTvalierebaSi da darwmunebiT ganacxada, rom es niv-Tebi swored misi sakuTreba iyo.

17. o. l-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom misi kuTvnili sax-lis ezodan farulad dauflebuli amwis Rirebulebaa 40lari, saburavebis Rirebuleba jamSi 300 laria, xolo Za-layinis Rirebuleba ki 5 lars Seadgens. Sesabamisad, qur-dobis Sedegad mas 345 laris materialuri ziani miadga.

18. b. b-is sacxovrebeli saxlis 2016 wlis 27 aprilisCxrekis oqmis Tanaxmad, sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi arse-buli fardulidan amoiRes ori `belarusis~ saburavi, e.w.`sakis~ saburavi, `belarusis~ wina maSuqi fari, erTi Zala-yini, ori `zil 130-is~ saburavi; aseve sacxovrebeli sax-lis ezoSi arsebuli boslidan amoiRes ori SemduRebelie.w. `svarkis~ aparati, xolo sacxovrebeli saxlidan _ wi-Teli domkrati.

19. 2016 wlis 27 aprilis daTvalierebis oqmebiT das-turdeba b. b-is sacxovrebeli saxlis Cxrekis Sedegad amo-Rebuli nivTebis daTvalierebis faqti.

20. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom braldebis am na-wilebSi qurdobis Cadenis damadasturebel mtkicebule-bas warmoadgens mxolod sacxovrebeli binis Cxrekis oq-mi da amoRebuli nivTebi, romlebic ver qmnis saprocesokanonmdeblobiT dadgenil gonivrul eWvs miRma mtkice-bulebiT standarts, miT umetes, rom daTvalierebis oq-mebi amoRebuli sagnebis dazaralebulebis mier amocno-bis nawilSi dauSvebel mtkicebulebebad aris cnobili. da-zaralebulebi ar warmoadgenen pirdapiri saxis mowmeebs,maT ar daunaxavT uSualod b. b-is mier qurdobis Cadenis

198

faqti, kerZod, e. j-is CvenebiT, 2016 wlis 15 marts manaRmoaCina, rom saxlidan ikargeboda sxvadasxva nivTi. manaseve ganacxada, rom ezoSi mdgari traqtoridan daudge-neli piri(ebi) iparavdnen sxvadasxva nawils, xolo o. l-isCvenebiT dgindeba, rom 2016 wlis martSi aRmoaCina, rommisi saxlidan moparuli iyo ori saburavi Tavisive diske-biT, aseve amwe da Zalayini.

21. amdenad, b. b-is mier qurdobis Cadena am nawilSi war-moadgens braldebis mxaris eWvs, romelic unda gadawydesmsjavrdebulis sasargeblod da Sesabamisi mtkicebule-biTi standartis ararsebobis gamo, b. b. am nawilSi undagamarTldes.

22. rac Seexeba sasjelis zomas, sakasacio palata mxed-velobaSi iRebs saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeq-sis 39-e da 53-e muxlebis Sinaarss, individualurad afa-sebs msjavrdebulis pirovnebas da sasjelis daniSvnis zo-gadsavaldebulo garemoebebs. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSib. b. nasamarTlevia analogiuri danaSaulis CadenisaTvis.

23. marTalia, msjavrdebulma, Caidina ganzraxi, mZimekategoriis danaSauli, magram amavdroulad palata iTva-liswinebs im garemoebas, rom b. b-es msjavridan ori qme-deba (saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~qvepunqtebi da me-3 nawilis `b~, `d~ qvepunqtebi, ssk-is177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~ qvepunqtebi da me-3 nawi-lis `b~ qvepunqti) unda amoericxos. mocemuli garemoebaki amcirebs b. b-is qmedebis saSiSroebis xarisxs.

24. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom bralad Seracxuliqmedebis sasjelis zomis minimumiTa da ganaCenTa erTob-liobiT nawilobrivi Sekrebis principis gamoyenebiT, b. b-is mimarT sasjelis miznebis miRwevis SesaZleblobebi uz-runvelyofili iqneba.


is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis pirveli nawilis `g~ qvepun-qtiT, me-3 nawiliT da

d a a d g i n a :

1. msjavrdebul b. b-is interesebis damcvelis, advo-

199

kat j. m-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes nawilobriv.2. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-

Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 13 seqtembris ganaCenSiSevides cvlileba:

3. b. b. cnobil iqnes udanaSaulod da gamarTldes sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à~, `b~ qvepun-qtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~, `d~ qvepunqte-biT, saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à~, `b~qvepunqtebiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiTwardgenil braldebebSi.

4. b. b. cnobil iqnes damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is19.177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis à~, `b~ qvepunqtebiTa da ama-ve muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~, `d~ qvepunqtebiT da miesajos 4wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.

5. saqarTvelos ssk-is 67-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanax-mad, gauqmdes b. b-is mimarT Telavis raionuli sasamar-Tlos 2014 wlis 11 dekembris ganaCeniT daniSnuli piro-biTi msjavri _ 3 weli;

6. saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanax-mad, axlad daniSnul sasjels nawilobriv daematos b. b-is mimarT wina ganaCeniT daniSnuli sasjelis mouxdelinawilidan _ 1 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa da sabolood,ganaCenTa erTobliobiT, b. b-es miesajos _ 5 wliT Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa;

7. b. b-es sasjelis moxdis aTvla daewyos faqtobrividakavebis momentidan _ 2016 wlis 27 aprilidan.

9. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 13 seqtembris ganaCenisxva nawilSi darCes ucvlelad.


200

ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana msjavrdebulissasikeTod

ganCinebasaqarTvelos saxeliT

#588ap-17 12 aprili, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi


p. silagaZe (Tavmjdomare),n. gvenetaZe,g. SavliaSvili

zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila msjavrdebul z. k-s in-teresebis damcveli advokatebis _ z. s-sa da b. v-s sakasa-cio saCivari Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlissamarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 20 seqtembris gana-Cenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. braldebulis saxiT pasuxisgebaSi micemis Sesaxeb

dadgenilebis Tanaxmad, z. k-s brali daedo ganzrax mkvle-lobaSi damamZimebel garemoebebSi _ ori piris mimarT daavtomaturi cecxlsasroli iaraRis ukanonod tarebaSi.

z. k-Tvis bralad Seracxuli qmedeba gamoixata Semdeg-Si:

1994 wlis 4 Tebervals, daaxloebiT 23:45 saaTze, Tbi-lisSi, ... quCebis gadakveTaze, usiamovnebis niadagze _ ur-TierTSekamaTebisas, z. k-m avtomaturi cecxlsasroli ia-raRidan gasroliT, romelsac igi ukanonod atarebda, mok-la ... Ssg-is TanamSromlebi _ z. m-e da g. v-i.

2. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiis 2016 wlis 7 noembris ganaCeniT z. k-a (da-uswreblad), _ dabadebuli 19..wels, nasamarTlobis armqo-ne, _ cnobil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 236-e muxlis me-2 nawi-liT (2016 wlis 12 ivnisamde moqmedi redaqcia) gaTvalis-winebuli danaSaulis CadenaSi.

z. k-s mimarT wardgenili braldeba saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 104-e muxlis me-4 punqtidan

201

(1960 wlis redaqcia) gadakvalificirda saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 206-e muxlze (1960 wlis redaq-cia).

z. k-a cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 206-emuxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia) da sasjelis saxed da zomadganesazRvra 2 (ori) wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac `am-nistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2012 wlis 25 dekembris ka-nonis me-16 muxlis Tanaxmad, Seumcirda 1/4-iT da sabo-loo sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra _ 1 (erTi) wli-Ta da 6 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.

3. aRniSnuli ganaCeniT sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiC-nia, rom z. k-m Caidina danaSaulis ganucxadebloba, imismier, visTvisac cnobilia saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis 104-e muxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia) gaTvaliswi-nebuli danaSaulis mzadebisa an Cadenis Sesaxeb, rac ga-moixata SemdegSi:

1994 wlis 4 Tebervals, daaxloebiT 23:45 saaTze, Tbi-lisSi, ...quCebis gadakveTaze, usiamovnebis niadagze _ ur-TierTSekamaTebisas, daudgenelma pirma cecxlsasroliiaraRidan gasroliT mokla ... Ssg-is TanamSromlebi _ z. m-e da g. v-i. danaSaulis Semswre z. k-m, romlisTvisac cnobi-li gaxda Cadenili danaSaulis Sesaxeb, ar ganacxada amisTaobaze, riTac Caidina danaSaulis ganucxadebloba.

4. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiis 2016 wlis 7 noembris ganaCeni saapela-cio wesiT gaasaCivres Tbilisis gldani-naZaladevis rai-onuli prokuraturis prokurorma g. mukbanianma da msjav-rdebul z. k-s interesebis damcvelma advokatebma _ b. v-ma da z. s-m.

• prokurorma saapelacio saCivriT iTxova ganaCenisgauqmeba da msjavrdebul z. k-s damnaSaved cnoba saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 104-e muxlis me-4 punqtiT (1960 wlis re-daqcia) da ssk-is 236-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT (2016 wlis 12ivnisamde moqmedi redaqcia), Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

sasamarTloze gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebiT dadas-turda, rom z. k-m Caidina ori piris ganzrax mkvlelobadamamZimebel garemoebaSi da avtomaturi cecxlsasroliiaraRis ukanono tarebis faqti, kerZod: TviTmxilvelmamowmeebma _ g. b-m da r. m-m ganmartes, rom g. m-s saxlSistumrobisas z. k-a SeiaraRebuli iyo avtomaturi cec-

202

xlsasroli iaraRiT. k-m sufraze miiRo didi raodenobiTalkoholi da gavida ... quCisken, raTa gaeCerebina avto-manqana samxedro nawilSi dasabruneblad. Semdeg maT gai-ges gasrolis xmebi da wavidnen ... quCis mimarTulebiT, sa-dac naxes z. k-a da maTTvis ucnobi ori piris gvami. Sem-Txvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom ...quCebis mimdebare teritoriaze nanaxi iqna z. m-sa da g. v-s gvamebi, cecxlsasroli iaraRis masrebi da z. k-s samxed-ro mowmoba.

• msjavrdebul z. k-s advokatebma _ b. v-m da z. s-m iT-xoves gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da mis nacvladgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgena saqarTvelos ssk-is206-e (1960 wlis redaqcia) muxliT Seracxuli braldebisnawilSi, Semdegi safuZvlebiT:

z. k-s gardacvlili policielebis TanamSromlebi dae-muqrnen, ris Semdegac igi iZulebuli gaxda, mimaluliyo,magram saqmeSi arsebuli gancxadebebiT naTelia, rom igicdilobda gamoZiebis organoebisaTvis obieqturi infor-maciis miwodebas. mas Tavis droze brali saqarTvelos ssk-is 206-e muxliT rom dasdeboda da ara _ 104-e muxliT, igiar miimaleboda da aRarc policielebi daemuqrebodnen.Sesabamisad, dairRva z. k-s ufleba, daecva Tavi misTviswardgenili braldebisgan. amasTan, saqarTvelos ssk-is 71-e muxlis Tanaxmad, piri Tavisufldeba sisxlissamar-Tlebrivi pasuxismgeblobisgan, Tu gavida eqvsi weli nak-lebad mZime danaSaulis Cadenidan. ssk-is 206-e muxliTgaTvaliswinebuli danaSauli ki miekuTvneba naklebad mZi-me danaSaulTa kategorias. maTive ganmartebiT, sasamar-Tlom moaxdina `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2007 wlis29 noembris kanonis araswori interpretacia, rodesac mi-uTiTa, rom z. k-a sagamonakliso muxliT aris pasuxisgeba-Si micemuli, rac mis mimarT gamoricxavs amnistiis kano-nis gamoyenebas. z. k-s brali ar miuZRvis imaSi, rom mas bra-li araswori muxliT waredgina, ris gamoc logikas mokle-bulia, sxvisi araswori qmedebis gamo dairRves piris ka-noniT miniWebuli SeRavaTebis miRebis ufleba.

5. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 20 seqtembris ganaCeniTTbilisis gldani-naZaladevis raionuli prokuraturisprokuror g. mukbanianis saapelacio saCivris moTxovna ar

203

dakmayofilda, xolo msjavrdebul z. k-s advokatebis _ b.v-sa da z. s-s saapelacio saCivris moTxovnebi dakmayofil-da nawilobriv. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2016 wlis7 noembris ganaCenSi Sevida Semdegi cvlileba:

z. k-a cnobil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda saqar-Tvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 236-e muxlis me-2 na-wiliT (2016 wlis 12 ivnisamde moqmedi redaqcia) gaTva-liswinebuli danaSaulis CadenaSi.

z. k-s mimarT wardgenili braldeba saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis kodeqsis 104-e muxlis me-4 punqtidan (1960 wlisredaqcia) gadakvalificirda saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis kodeqsis 206-e muxlze (1960 wlis redaqcia).

z. k-a cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sisxlis sa-marTlis kodeqsis 206-e muxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia) dasasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvra 2 (ori) wliT Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa, rac àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos2007 wlis 29 noembris kanonis me-2 muxlis me-2 nawilis Ta-naxmad, gaunaxevrda da ganesazRvra 1 wliT Tavisufle-bis aRkveTa, rac àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2012wlis 25 dekemberis kanonis me-16 muxlis Tanaxmad, Seum-cirda 1/4-iT da sabolood sasjelis saxed da zomad gane-sazRvra _ 9 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.

z. k-s sasjelis moxdis aTvla unda daewyos ganaCenisaRsrulebis mizniT misi Tavisuflebis aRkveTis momenti-dan.

6. msjavrdebul z. k-s interesebis damcveli advokate-bi _ z. s-a da b. v-i sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven gamamtyune-beli ganaCenis gauqmebasa da mis nacvlad gamamarTlebeliganaCenis dadgenas saqarTvelos ssk-is 206-e muxliT Serac-xuli braldebis nawilSi, an z. k-s mimarT àmnistiis Sesa-xeb~ saqarTvelos 2007 wlis 29 noembris kanonis me-4 mux-lis gavrcelebas, romlis Tanaxmad, sisxlissamarTlebri-vi devna unda Sewydes im pirebze, romelTa mimarTac 1995wlamde iqna gamotanili dadgenileba braldebulad sis-xlis samarTlis pasuxisgebaSi micemis Sesaxeb (garda saqar-Tvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis ..., 104-e, ... muxliT(1960 wlis redaqcia) gaTvaliswinebul danaSaulebSi gan-sasjeli pirebisa) da romelTa mimarTac gamocxadebuliaZebna am kanonis amoqmedebis momentisaTvis imave safuZ-vlebiT, razec uTiTebdnen saapelacio saCivarSi.

204


ma sakasacio saCivris motivebis safuZvlianoba, mousminamxareebs da daaskvna, rom saCivari unda dakmayofildesnawilobriv, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevidescvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:

2. sakasacio palata pirvel rigSi aRniSnavs, rom ar izia-rebs dacvis mxaris sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas z. k-s mi-marT saqarTvelos ssk-is 206-e muxliT Seracxuli bral-debis nawilSi gamarTlebis Sesaxeb da srulad eTanxmebasaapelacio palatis motivacias, rom sasamarTloSi gamok-vleuli mtkicebulebebiT utyuarad dasturdeba mis miermiTiTebuli danaSaulis Cadenis faqti, kerZod: saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 206-e muxliT (1960 wlisredaqcia) sisxlissamarTlebrivi pasuxismgebloba dawese-bulia danaSaulis ganucxadeblobisTvis, imis mier, visTvi-sac cnobilia saqarTvelos respublikis sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis 104-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis mza-debis an Cadenis Sesaxeb. aRniSnuli danaSauli gamoixate-ba damnaSavis pasiur qcevaSi (umoqmedobaSi), romelic arawvdis saTanado organoebs danaSaulis aRsakveTad an ga-moZiebis efeqturad warmoebisaTvis aucilebel informa-cias. danaSaulis SemadgenlobisaTvis aucilebelia, dana-Saulis subieqtma namdvilad icodes, rom mzaddeba an/daCadenilia danaSauli; aseve, danaSauli, romlis momzade-bis an/da Cadenis Taobaze utyuar informacias flobs da-naSaulis subieqti, unda miekuTvnebodes saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsiT gansazRvrul konkretul dana-SaulTa wres (am SemTxvevaSi saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis kodeqsis 104-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebul danaSauls).mocemul SemTxvevaSi, mxareebs sadavod ar gauxdiaT is faq-ti, rom 1994 wlis 4 Tebervals z. k-a imyofeboda SemTxve-vis adgilze da Seeswro z. m-sa da g. v-s mkvlelobis faqts.sadavo ar aris aseve is faqtic, rom z. k-s samarTaldamcaviorganoebisTvis ar Seutyobinebia momxdaris Taobaze. Se-sabamisad gamokveTilia, saqarTvelos ssk-is 206-e muxliT(1960 wlis redaqcia) gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis ganuc-xadeblobis aucilebeli yvela niSani.

3. rac Seexeba dacvis mxaris meore moTxovnas, kerZod,z. k-s mimarT `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2007 wlis

205

29 noembris kanonis me-4 muxlis gavrcelebasa da sasje-lisagan srulad gaTavisuflebas, mocemul nawilSi saka-sacio palata iziarebs kasatoris argumentebs Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:

4. àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2007 wlis 29 noem-bris kanonis me-4 muxlis Tanaxmad, sisxlissamarTlebrividevna unda Sewydes im pirebze, romelTa mimarTac 1995 wlam-de iqna gamotanili dadgenileba braldebulad sisxlis sa-marTlis pasuxisgebaSi micemis Sesaxeb (garda saqarTvelosrespublikis sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis ..., 104-e, ... mux-liT (1960 wlis redaqcia) gaTvaliswinebul danaSaulebSigansasjeli pirebisa) da romelTa mimarTac gamocxadebu-lia Zebna am kanonis amoqmedebis momentisaTvis.

5. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs saapelacio palatismsjelobas, rom mocemul SemTxvevaSi, vinaidan z. k-s mierCadenili qmedeba gamoZiebam daakvalificirda saqarTve-los ssk-is 104-e muxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia), aRniSnuligamoricxavs àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2007 wlis 29noembris kanonis gamoyenebas, radgan is faqti, rom kva-lifikacia ganaCenis gamotanisas Secvala sasamarTlom, ariZleva z. k-s mimarT miTiTebuli kanonis me-4 muxlis gav-rcelebis SesaZleblobas.

6. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom, marTalia, bralde-bulad sisxlis samarTlis pasuxisgebaSi micemis SesaxebdadgenilebiT z. k-s brali daedo saqarTvelos ssk-is 104-e muxlis me-4 punqtiT (1960 wlis redaqcia) gaTvaliswine-buli danaSaulis CadenaSi, Tumca rogorc pirveli, ise sa-apelacio instanciis sasamarTloebma misi qmedeba gada-akvalificires saqarTvelos ssk-is 206-e muxliT gaTva-liswinebul danaSaulze (1960 wlis redaqcia) da dadgeni-lad miiCnies, rom man Caidina am muxliT gaTvaliswinebu-li danaSauli, rasac sakasacio palatac srulad eTanxme-ba da iziarebs. àmnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos 2007 wlis29 noembris kanonis me-4 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli SeRa-vaTi srulad vrceldeba z. k-s mimarT msjavrad SeracxulsaqarTvelos ssk-is 206-e muxlze da is faqti, rom bral-debulad sisxlis samarTlis pasuxisgebaSi micemis Sesa-xeb dadgenilebiT z. k-s brali daedo saqarTvelos ssk-is104-e muxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia), ar unda ganimartosmsjavrdebulis sazianod, miT ufro im garemoebis gaTva-

206

liswinebiT, rom Tavad saapelacio sasamarTlom miiCniadadasturebulad, rom z. k-m Caidina saqarTvelos ssk-is206-e muxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia) gaTvaliswinebuli da-naSauli.

7. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, z. k-s mimarT saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 206-e muxliT (1960 wlis redaqcia) Seracxulbraldebaze srulad unda gavrceldes `amnistiis Sesaxeb~saqarTvelos 2007 wlis 29 noembris kanonis me-4 muxliT gaT-valiswinebuli SeRavaTi da mis mimarT unda Sewydes sisxlis-samarTlebrivi devna. rac Seexeba z. k-s saqarTvelos ssk-is236-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT (2016 wlis 12 ivnisamde moqmediredaqcia) wardgenil braldebaSi gamarTlebas, miTiTebulepizodTan dakavSirebiT sakasacio palata damatebiT aRarmsjelobs, radgan braldebis mxares saapelacio sasamar-Tlos ganaCeni sakasacio wesiT ar gausaCivrebia.


is 561-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `d~ qvepunqtiT, 568-e mux-liT da

d a a d g i n a:

1. msjavrdebul z. k-s interesebis damcveli advoka-tebis _ z. s-sa da b. v-s sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildesnawilobriv.

2. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 20 seqtembris ganaCenSiSevides Semdegi cvlileba:

3. z. k-s mimarT wardgenili braldeba saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 104-e muxlis me-4 punqtidan (1960wlis redaqcia) gadakvalificirdes saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis kodeqsis 206-e muxlze (1960 wlis redaqcia).

4. Sewydes sisxlissamarTlebrivi devna z. k-s mimarTsaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 206-e muxliT(1960 wlis redaqcia) Seracxul braldebaSi.

5. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 20 seqtembris ganaCenidanarCen nawilSi darCes ucvlelad.

6. ganCineba sabolooa da ar saCivrdeba.

207

Sebruneba sauaresod


#713ap-17 21 maisi, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi



zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila Telavis raionuliprokuraturis prokuror daviT gvelesianis sakasacio sa-Civari Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 22 noembris ganaCenze.

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. Telavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 21 ivlisis

ganaCeniT m. b. o-i, cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelosssk-is 120-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Cade-nisaTvis (ori epizodi) da miesaja:

saqarTvelos ssk-is 120-e muxliT (v. i-is epizodi) ja-rima _ 3000 lari; ssk-is 120 muxliT (f. a-is epizodi) jari-ma _ 3000 lari. saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis safuZvelze Tanabarma sasjelma STanTqa Tanabari dasabolood, danaSaulTa erTobliobiT m. b. o-is ganesaz-Rvra jarima _ 3000 lari.

saqarTvelos ssk-is 62-e muxlis me-5 nawilis safuZvel-ze, 2017 wlis 18 maisidan 2017 wlis 13 ivnisis CaTvliT pa-timrobaSi yofnis vadis gaTvaliswinebiT, m. b. o-is daniS-nuli sasjeli Seumsubuqda da sabolood ganesazRvra ja-rima _ 1500 lari.

2. m. b. o-is msjavri daedo janmrTelobis ganzrax msu-buqi dazianebisTvis, ramac misi xanmokle moSla gamoiw-via (braldebis ori epizodi), rac gamoixata SemdegSi:

2017 wlis 18 maiss, daaxloebiT 00:30 saaTze, T-is raio-nis sofel y-Si m. b. o-is SvilTan _ n. b. o-isTan hqonda kon-fliqti. konfliqtis ganmuxtvis mizniT, maT damSvidebascdilobda v. i-i, ra drosac m. b. o-i gaRizianda da SurisZi-

208

ebis mizniT ganizraxa v. i-is janmrTelobis dazianeba. gan-zraxvis sisruleSi moyvanis mizniT m. b. o-im ramdenjermedaartya dana v. i-s sxeulis sxvadasxva adgilze. aRniSnu-lis Semdeg v. i-ma miiRo janmrTelobis msubuqi daziane-ba, ramac misi xanmokle moSla gamoiwvia.

2017 wlis 18 maiss, daaxloebiT 00.30 saaTze, T-is raio-nis sofel y-Si m. b. o-is SvilTan _ n. b. o-isTan hqonda kon-fliqti. konfliqtis ganmuxtvis mizniT, maT damSvidebascdilobda f. a-i, ra drosac m. b. o. gaRizianda da SurisZi-ebis mizniT, ganizraxa f. a-is janmrTelobis dazianeba. gan-zraxvis sisruleSi moyvanis mizniT, m. b. o-im mas erTxeldaartya dana marcxena laviwis areSi. aRniSnulis Semdegf. a-ma miiRo janmrTelobis msubuqi dazianeba, ramac misixanmokle moSla gamoiwvia.

3. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 22 noembris ganaCeniT Te-lavis raionuli sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 21 ivlisis ganaCe-ni darCa ucvlelad.

4. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 22 noembris ganaCeni saka-sacio wesiT gaasaCivra Telavis raionuli prokuraturisprokurorma daviT gvelesianma da moiTxova ganaCenSicvlilebis Setana, kerZod, msjavrdebulisaTvis ufromkacri sasjelis gansazRvra vadiani Tavisuflebis aRkve-Tis saxiT, vinaidan gamoyenebuli sasjelis saxe da zomaaSakarad ar Seesabameba msjavrdebulis pirovnul maxasi-aTeblebs, mis mier Cadenili danaSaulis xasiaTsa da sa-zogadoebriv saSiSroebas, ris gamoc ver iqneba miRweulisasjelis miznebi.

samotivacio nawili:1. pirvel yovlisa, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom war-

modgenilia sakmarisi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi, rom-lebiTac gonivrul eWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom msjavrde-bulma m. b. o-im namdvilad Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCe-niT misTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedebebi, razec detalurmsjelobas palata ar miiCnevs saWirod, vinaidan sruladeTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos daskvnebs da amasTa-nave, dacvis mxares sakasacio saCivriT ar moumarTavs.

2. rac Seexeba prokuror daviT gvelesianis sakasacio

209

saCivars, saqmis masalebis Seswavlis Sedegad, sakasaciopalata mivida daskvnamde, rom prokuroris moTxovna sa-fuZvliania, misi saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilob-riv da gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides msjavrdebu-lis sauareso cvlileba, kerZod:

3. sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 39-e muxlisa da amave kodeq-sis 53-e muxlis Sinaarss, individualurad afasebs msjav-rdebulis pirovnebas, sasjelis daniSvnis zogadsavalde-bulo garemoebebs da miuTiTebs:

msjavrdebul m. b. o-is mier Cadenilia sazogadoebri-vad saSiSi, ganzraxi, Zaladobrivi xasiaTis ori damouki-debeli danaSauli civi iaraRis gamoyenebiT, ra drosacman Wrilobebi miayena massa da mis Svils Soris arsebulikonfliqtis ganmuxtvis mizniT masTan misul or pirs, maTSoris _ v. i-s man sxeulis sxvadasxva adgilze dana ram-denjerme daartya. aRniSnul garemoebaTa gaTvaliswine-biT, palatas miaCnia, rom m. b. o-isTvis Sefardebuli sas-jelis saxe da zoma (jarima _ 1500 lari) ar Seesabameba mispirovnebasa da mis mier Cadenili qmedebis xasiaTs, veriqneba damafiqrebeli misTvis da ver uzrunvelyofs sas-jelis miznebis miRwevas, ris gamoc unda Seicvalos vadi-ani Tavisuflebis aRkveTiT.

4. amasTan, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom m. b. o-i aRiarebsda inaniebs Cadenil qmedebebs, iTanamSromla gamoZiebas-Tan, mis mier Cadenili danaSaulebi naklebad mZime kate-goriis danaSaulebs miekuTvneba da Serigebulia dazara-lebulebTan, palatas mizanSewonilad miaCnia, rom mis-Tvis gansazRvruli vadiani Tavisuflebis aRkveTa saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 63-e muxlis Sesabamisad, pirobiT ar iqnasgamoyenebuli.

sarezolucio nawili:palatam ixelmZRvanela saqarTvelos sssk-is 301-e mux-

liT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT, me-2, me-3nawilebiT, 308-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT da

d a a d g i n a:

1. prokuror daviT gvelesianis sakasacio saCivari dak-

210

mayofildes nawilobriv.2. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-

Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 22 noembris ganaCenSi Se-vides cvlileba:

3. msjavrdebul m. b. o-is saqarTvelos ssk-is 120-e mux-liT (v. i-is epizodi) sasjelis saxiT ganesazRvros 1 wliTTavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac ssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis sa-fuZvelze CaeTvalos pirobiT, 1 wlis gamosacdeli vadiT;

masve saqarTvelos ssk-is 120-e muxliT (f. a-is epizo-di) sasjelis saxiT ganesazRvros 1 wliT TavisuflebisaRkveTa, rac ssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis safuZvelze CaeT-valos pirobiT, 1 wlis gamosacdeli vadiT.

4. saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-2 nawilis safuZ-velze Tanabarma sasjelma STanTqas Tanabari da sabolo-od m. b. o-is sasjelis saxed da zomad ganesazRvros 1 wliTTavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac ssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis sa-fuZvelze CaeTvalos pirobiT, 1 wlis gamosacdeli vadiT.

5. msjavrdebul m. b. o-is sasjelis vadaSi moxdilad Ca-eTvalos patimrobaSi yofnis dro _ 2017 wlis 18 maisidan_ 2017 wlis 13 ivnisis CaTvliT.

6. saqarTvelos ssk-is 65-e-66-e muxlebisa da `arasapa-timro sasjelTa aRsrulebis wesisa da probaciis Sesaxeb~saqarTvelos kanonis Sesabamisad, msjavrdebulis yofaq-cevaze kontrolisa da daxmarebis ganxorcieleba daeva-los saqarTvelos sasjelaRsrulebisa da probaciis sami-nistros sistemaSi Semaval ssip probaciis erovnuli saa-gentos probaciis biuros msjavrdebulis sacxovrebeliadgilis mixedviT.

7. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 22 noembris ganaCeni sxvanawilSi darCes ucvlelad.


211

saZiebeli

sakasacio ganaCeni

gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da mis nacvladgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgena .............................. 3; 18; 24; 39

ganaCenis gauqmeba dasisxlis samarTlis saqmis Sewyveta .............................................. 47

gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da mis nacvladgamamtyunebeli ganaCenis dadgena(gansxvavebuli azri) ........................................................................ 74

ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana damsjavrdebulis gamarTlebasaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 179-e muxliTwardgenil braldebaSi .................................................................. 141

ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana damsjavrdebulis gamarTlebasaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 177-e muxliTwardgenil braldebaSi .................................................................. 189

ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana msjavrdebulis sasikeTod ...... 200

Sebruneba sauaresod ....................................................................... 207

212

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTloTbilisi 0110, Zmebi zubalaSvilebis q. #32

tel.: (995 32) 299 0418www.supremecourt.ge

sisxlis samartlis procesi - supreme court of georgia · luri telefoni, sigareti, safule, wamlis...

Documents