*The Design of the Power Saving Mechanisms in IEEE 802.16e Networks (Defense) Student: Lei Yan ()Advisor: Dr. Ho-Ting Wu ()Date: 2009/07/23Institute of Computer Science and Information Engineering,National Taipei University of Technology

*OutlinesBackgrounds and motivationSpec-defined power saving mechanismProposed power saving mechanismPerformance evaluation Conclusion and future works

*Brief of IEEE 802.16Also called WiMAX (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access)The wireless last mile technologyLow cost and free to geographical limitsIncludes PHY/MAC solutionsHigher transmission rate than 3.5GIdeal transmission rate and coverage: 75 Mbps and 50 kmNow been merchandised in Taiwan

*Layering related to connectionsConvergence sublayerClassificationCommon Part sublayerEstablishmentChangeDeletionCall admission control (CAC)Bandwidth allocation (BWA)Packet schedulingSecurity sublayerEncryption/Decryption for dataMAC Common Part Sublayer(CPS)

*Frame structure of WiMAX

UL-BurstSS

DL-BurstSS

DL-Burst #5

Frame n-1

Frame n

Frame n+1

DL Subframe

UL Subframe

Preamble

FCH

DL-Burst #1

DL-Burst #2-4

DL-Burst #5

DL-Burst #6

TTG

RTG

Initialranging

BWrequest

UL-Burst #1

UL-Burst #2

DLFP

DL-MAP

UL-MAP

MAC messages, Mac PDUs

IE

IE

IE

IE

IE

IE

IE

IE

IE

IE

Preamble

FCH

DL-Bursts#1-4

DL-Burst #6

RangingOpportunity

BWrequest

UL-Burst #1

UL-Burst #2

Preamble(optional)

MACPDU

MACPDU

Pad

Preamble(optional)

MACPDU

MACPDU

Midamble(optional)

MACPDU

MACPDU

Pad

IE

IE

*OutlinesBackgrounds and motivationSpec-defined power saving mechanismProposed power saving mechanismPerformance evaluation Conclusion and future works

*Renaming for QoS metrics: Power saving class (PSC)

PSCReal-timeNon-Real timePSC INRTVR(nrtPS)BEPSC IIUGSRTVR (rtPS)PSC IIIERTVR(ertPS)

*States of a MS with power saving function

MS operation

ON-state (RF device ON)

Sleep mode (RF device OFF)

OFF-state (RF device OFF)

Listening interval (RF device ON)

(a)

(b)

Normal mode

time

Normal mode

Sleep mode

Normal mode

time

TS

TL

TS

TL

TS

TL

...

TL

TS

TL

TS

TL

TS

TL

TS

TL

TS

TL

TS

TS

TL

...

(c)

(d)

TS

TS: The sleep duration TL: The listening duration

*OutlinesBackgrounds and motivationSpec-defined power saving mechanismProposed power saving mechanismPerformance evaluation Conclusion and future works

*What our research work has done?Includes UGS/ertPS, rtPS, nrtPS, and BE for both UL/DL trafficsIntegrated consideration to CENTRALLY arrange calls to prolong sleep durationsComplete solution (CAC + BWA + packet scheduling)Reduction of ON-OFF alternations in MSQ: Why packet scheduling for power saving?A: Since BS can control all states for MS PRECISELY with time

*Structure of our research work

U1

R1

N1

B1

...

UM

RM

NM

BM

1st OFDMA frame

U1

R1

N1

B1

...

UM

RM

NM

BM

2nd OFDMA frame

...

U1 from 1st OFDMA frame

U1

R1

N1

B1

...

UM

RM

NM

BM

AMPth OFDMA frame

Packet scheduling algorithm adoption for power saving

U1 from 2nd OFDMA frame

...

U-cycle for 1st packet

U-cycle for 2nd packet

DUGS: The delay bound for UGS

A complete cycle duration C for the power saving function

*Assumptions for our research workFrame overflow is allowed (to schedule across the bound between frames)Merge the listening duration into ON-state duration

MS operation

ON-state (RF device ON)

Sleep mode (RF device OFF)

OFF-state (RF device OFF)

Listening interval (RF device ON)

*BWA and scheduling

ON state call A

ON state for call A

BR

BR i

BR i+1

GRANT i

GRANT i+1

*Judgment in the proposed BWA algorithm(5) determines the credit. (6) is the stabilized version of (7)

*Deployed packet scheduling algorithmRound-Robin fashion for the schedulingPros: In the algorithm itself, all MSs have intact sleep duration (intuitive design)Cons: No guarantee for UGS/ertPS delaySpecial assumption: all delay bounds are set and equal to DUGS (100 ms)

U1

R1

N1

U2

R2

N2

B2

BM

time

B1

UM

RM

NM

ON-state duration for MS 1

OFF-state for all MSs

OFF-state for all MSs

OFF-state duration for MS 1

*OutlinesBackgrounds and motivationSpec-defined power saving mechanismProposed power saving mechanismPerformance evaluation Conclusion and future works

*System structure of our research work

*Parameters for simulation

Number of BS1Number of MS20~200System capacity (Mbps)50Frame duration (ms)5Capacity per frame (byte)31250Amplification ratio5, 10, 15, and 20Simulation duration (sec)500Call duration (sec)Uniform(60,200)

*Parameters for simulation (cont.)

Service typeUGSertPSrtPSnrtPSBEDelay bound (ms)100100200300400Transmission rate required in call request (kbps)6464Uniform(48,60)Uniform(48,60)Uniform(48,60)Bandwidth request size per frame (byte)4040Uniform(30,50)Uniform(30,50)Uniform(30,50)Arrival rate0.440.440.030.020.20ON/OFF ratio for ertPS0.4/0.6

*The traditional WiMAX scheme we compare toNo BWA and scheduling (no packet dropping rate/delay)We amplified the negative credit to reduce packet dropping/delay

ItemsProposedTraditionalCAC algorithm in useTraditionalTraditionalAggregation for grant sizeYESNOAdaptively adjust the grant sizeYESNOFrame overflowAllowedNot allowedRF device is allowed to be turned offYESNO

*Three scenarios for our comparison

Traditional WiMAX scheme

Proposed WiMAX scheme

Proposed WiMAX scheme without BWA

Proposed WiMAX scheme with BWA

Simulation results

Call:Parameter generation

MS:Call generation

BS:CAC, MS generation, and management For calls

Proposed BWA/Packet scheduling algorithm

Traditional WiMAX scheme

WiMAX:Management for BS

main

*Flow chart of the program

Gen. a call

Perform CAC for each call

Is CAC admitted

Reject call

Is the first BR

Is the call sch. exceeding one frame duration

YES

NO

YES

NO

Is call expired

Start processing a call

1. Run sch. alm. for call2. Sch. time for BR/BWA

YES

NO

Is call finished shceduling

NO

Terminate call

Sch. the rest at next frame

YES

Is scheduling exceeding delay bound

NO

Drop the rest data

Is MS being awaken

NO

YES

YES

Are all calls in MSi finished scheduling

YES

NO

MS i sleeps

NO

YES

*Increase of sleeping ratioHeavier loading causes longer C but reduce number of cycle (number of granting for MSs) => avg. proportion in ON-state is decreased

Aggregated frames

data

Cycle C

Aggregated frames

data

Cycle C

Aggregated frames

data

Cycle C

...

Simulation duration

Chart1

0.9949110.994933

0.9955760.995764

0.9960240.995764

0.9964170.996361

0.9967390.99681

0.9970850.99681

0.9972840.99716

0.9975520.99716

0.9976520.997442

0.9978450.997611

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=5

Call Blocking

1000.9972710.9977590.9985170.9988840.999108

20000000

30000000

40000000

50000000

00000

7.134385.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.13445.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

00.02713180.2011320.3217020.404278

(100,1)(200,1)(300,1)(400,1)(500,1)

100200300400500

Call Blocking

0

0

0

0

0

Call blocking rate

MS

Call blocking rate

Tra parameters

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000.0502618

20406080100120140160180200

AMP=1

100.9952280.9953070.9972710.9975720.9977590.9956930.9956430.995660.9952910.9972710.997420.9975250.9975830.9975980.997759

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

4.737523.709187.134386.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134386.74836.361335.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.13446.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.13446.74836.361365.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361355.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361355.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361345.94025.460665.29366

00000.02713180000000000.0271318

(20,1)(40,1)(60,1)(80,1)(100,1)(120,1)(140,1)(160,1)(180,1)(200,1)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

AMP=5

100.9948830.9957970.996830.9972790.9978260.9949110.9955760.9960240.9964170.9967390.9970850.9972840.9975520.9976520.997845

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

15.541817.157220.685622.637224.248515.495116.882917.546419.123819.32721.413421.442122.650322.670723.0275

15.014617.387720.402922.739724.626715.472717.168917.330218.892519.233120.309220.677522.451823.04922.8459

15.251117.270220.561122.704124.468615.510317.074717.440519.01919.311120.830721.083222.575222.85822.9589

15.276717.295520.58622.728524.444515.536117.101917.463819.044319.333420.853621.103922.596322.877922.9362

15.303717.321320.612122.753224.467615.562217.12917.487819.069719.355820.876621.124822.617422.897922.9559

00000.03307390000000000.0317769

(20,5)(40,5)(60,5)(80,5)(100,5)(120,5)(140,5)(160,5)(180,5)(200,5)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9949330.9957640.9957640.9963610.996810.996810.997160.997160.9974420.997611

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

15.495116.905517.366218.859720.908921.27122.887423.293824.935224.9339

15.463817.103817.677619.180920.166420.814822.251922.952724.267224.6549

15.503717.020517.537319.054120.570821.087722.604523.121324.638124.8254

15.529617.046417.563219.0820.596821.113622.630423.147224.66424.8513

15.555517.072317.589119.105920.622721.139522.656323.173124.689924.8256

0000000000.0303814

AMP=5

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=5

AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=120

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=160

100.9948380.9957670.9966510.9972970.9977480.9951850.9957450.9960460.9963790.9967510.9970840.9972790.9974880.9976710.997844

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

28.664732.0839.005843.310648.684129.340832.999734.049735.89438.707140.679141.760242.600245.619144.4357

28.168933.723538.418945.161645.02930.093831.260934.499137.157138.376139.91740.707943.38443.948445.7795

28.375232.92638.81644.329647.135829.853532.057234.36936.614238.571240.359441.248543.083244.816945.1872

28.432832.982638.871644.383847.082129.914432.114534.426536.671638.625540.410841.294843.128344.860745.2301

28.492833.039138.928544.437847.132129.97532.172834.485536.729238.680140.46241.341643.173844.904845.2732

00000.02910740000000000.0257732

(20,10)(40,10)(60,10)(80,10)(100,10)(120,10)(140,10)(160,10)(180,10)(200,10)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9953440.9957290.9960550.9963350.9965770.996790.9969780.9972940.9974290.997609

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

29.915132.727834.563637.706837.254641.757742.291545.580148.126649.8969

29.430631.332434.11435.780640.659440.773144.685747.248249.208848.6267

29.779332.088134.396836.705339.014941.323443.632146.440948.749749.2924

29.837632.146434.455136.763739.073341.381743.690446.499248.80849.3508

29.895932.204734.513436.82239.131641.4443.748746.557548.866349.4091

0000000000.0323834

MS=160

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA (Pro)

Sleeping ratio without BWA (Pro)

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=10

MS=200

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

100.9948820.9959250.9966730.9973580.9978060.9952720.995720.9960270.9963970.9967930.9971380.9974240.997670.9977860.998037

50000.007521190.04514370.09758130000.005035220.01607020.02609070.04103570.04639490.05779380.0671182

100000.01807490.05822360.08777590000.002026770.00750690.01736740.02349790.04252480.0479950.0548966

150000.02635730.1061680.1901590000.00721660.02398120.04737610.07448160.1042860.1137470.141229

200000.02679920.1067960.1908570000.007388540.02429540.0478190.07500950.1047530.1142460.140127

000.02291210.1083720.1980440000.00751940.02448550.04798930.07430410.1030950.1137450.137903

40.92147.380155.869760.045162.940943.374846.968150.161155.348556.65357.661760.030759.2360.801660.561

42.114450.247956.261660.084262.674442.945747.209450.388951.316954.475956.408255.999159.297259.577260.5893

41.488649.07556.139360.121162.860643.311947.183950.357953.858155.666957.099758.338359.315160.266360.6195

41.578949.163456.204460.176262.909843.39947.27350.444553.938555.733257.155858.386959.361760.307460.6031

41.669249.25656.277960.227362.955243.488347.364250.533254.020555.800757.212458.435959.408660.349360.645

0000must rerun0000000000.0297542

(20,15)(40,15)(60,15)(80,15)(100,15)(120,15)(140,15)(160,15)(180,15)(200,15)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9951850.9957170.9959420.9963520.9966950.9969830.9971950.9973940.9975790.997851

0000.003425330.01379380.03706770.04944190.0751010.07595220.0930902

0000.003355940.01886020.02781220.05036650.06309290.1040930.104784

0000.007085560.03282590.06567330.1010080.139170.1809630.198824

0000.007440160.03332680.06666420.1017090.139990.1818680.199633

0000.007553960.03403520.06704980.1020110.1406980.1825140.198166

43.065547.909750.386354.344155.362258.062760.351861.747562.642861.5805

43.423245.799350.628553.360457.064658.385359.516960.973962.571364.4734

43.388247.155750.589554.026956.377258.282159.947461.408562.652662.9371

43.478947.246550.680254.100756.443958.328760.004761.461462.701962.9892

43.569647.337250.770954.185756.50258.399160.076761.518262.759862.9886

0000000000.0284421

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE witout BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MAP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

100.9954010.9962630.9977880.9982040.9956640.9960290.9964770.9969420.9972990.9975330.9977780.9979820.9981520.998305

500.0368420.09109290.1948790.3057870.04043130.06856020.116790.118010.1196570.1561570.1770660.195620.2051950.210251

1000.01578950.0585860.21950.2353190.03773580.04742970.05997350.1164010.1549580.1529720.1678860.1833650.2124040.219303

1500.05263730.1515790.4216880.5550710.07911910.09352330.1648950.245770.292090.3019270.3554940.4100970.4565010.465052

2000.05263730.1520970.4239740.5566610.0791190.09400650.1656870.2479690.2940480.3030320.3568350.4112830.4575630.466033

0.08988030.1265420.4343670.584790.08058680.09215240.165590.2491970.2930820.3023620.3584760.4088660.4519250.461197

51.567156.789763.457265.17253.302156.015357.925758.440959.936160.924761.88762.257263.026463.7377

53.444756.706963.103565.295353.252155.883657.027259.596360.288761.299961.746463.050463.649263.4556

52.245656.785863.315165.261253.392455.883257.580659.049360.182361.150161.855262.649663.36963.5788

52.360956.869463.339365.300653.505255.928757.642159.073560.210761.194961.888462.683863.402563.6137

52.475656.8963.384665.337453.619656.038157.718959.106260.25161.236461.916962.725363.433463.6458

000must rerun0000000000.0350422

(20,20)(40,20)(60,20)(80,20)(100,20)(120,20)(140,20)(160,20)(180,20)(200,20)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9956630.996010.9965110.9969210.9971610.9973740.9975680.9978140.9979640.9981360.9991170.999067

0.05658970.07769570.08207970.1052490.1420420.1717860.1840730.27430.2949840.3146270.2498520.237072

0.02155740.04196230.09622850.1311220.1512990.1786480.2253940.2182650.2359710.2325350.2281330.313265

0.0781440.1204790.179930.2388950.2957870.3522560.4108260.4726260.5333610.5495330.5039720.54951

0.07815170.1220110.1801410.2393710.2961810.3527950.4117280.4735440.5344860.5538480.5055660.550691

0.07958560.1233420.1822320.2402580.2971220.3550540.4143710.4749440.5359920.5489730.5051840.552165

53.195856.01757.235258.46360.495662.182963.33665.47266.244565.435764.399365.558

53.459755.741857.75259.546160.572261.775463.154463.786864.414965.778964.509865.6808

53.388555.990557.545659.03960.55562.012563.289564.335565.382365.609364.484165.6092

53.502256.03957.642159.123160.63862.088863.355464.398165.439565.712264.515765.6662

53.554156.096657.670759.192660.70562.116763.37564.451265.488365.669364.560265.7154

0000000000.03571430.3181430.3157

BWA(400,20)NOBWA(400,20)

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. packet delay (ms)

Avg. packet delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt .delay

Avg. pkt .delay for AMP-20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

0.9949110.9951850.9952720.995664

0000.0404313

0000.0377358

0000.0791191

0000.079119

0000.0805868

15.495129.340843.374853.3021

15.472730.093842.945753.2521

15.510329.853543.311953.3924

15.536129.914443.39953.5052

15.562229.97543.488353.6196

0000

0.9949330.9953440.9951850.995663

0000.0565897

0000.0215574

0000.078144

0000.0781517

0000.0795856

15.495129.915143.065553.1958

15.463829.430643.423253.4597

15.503729.779343.388253.3885

15.529629.837643.478953.5022

15.555529.895943.569653.5541

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA

UGS without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=20

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

BE with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=20

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS witout BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

0.9970850.9970840.9971380.997533

000.02609070.156157

000.01736740.152972

000.04737610.301927

000.0478190.303032

000.04798930.302362

21.413440.679157.661760.9247

20.309239.91756.408261.2999

20.830740.359457.099761.1501

20.853640.410857.155861.1949

20.876640.46257.212461.2364

0000

0.996810.996790.9969830.997374

000.03706770.171786

000.02781220.178648

000.06567330.352256

000.06666420.352795

000.06704980.355054

21.27141.757758.062762.1829

20.814840.773158.385361.7754

21.087741.323458.282162.0125

21.113641.381758.328762.0888

21.139541.4458.399162.1167

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=120

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt.dropping rate

Avg. pkt.dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

0.9975520.9974880.997670.997982

000.04639490.19562

000.04252480.183365

000.1042860.410097

000.1047530.411283

000.1030950.408866

22.650342.600259.2362.2572

22.451843.38459.297263.0504

22.575243.083259.315162.6496

22.596343.128359.361762.6838

22.617443.173859.408662.7253

0000

0.997160.9972940.9973940.997814

000.0751010.2743

000.06309290.218265

000.139170.472626

000.139990.473544

000.1406980.474944

23.293845.580161.747565.472

22.952747.248260.973963.7868

23.121346.440961.408564.3355

23.147246.499261.461464.3981

23.173146.557561.518264.4512

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleepnig ratio

Sleepnig ratio for MS=160

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

ertPS wit hBWA (Pro)

ertPS withour BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

0.9978450.9978440.9980370.998305

000.06711820.210251

000.05489660.219303

000.1412290.465052

000.1401270.466033

000.1379030.461197

23.027544.435760.56163.7377

22.845945.779560.589363.4556

22.958945.187260.619563.5788

22.936245.230160.603163.6137

22.955945.273260.64563.6458

0.03177690.02577320.02975420.0350422

0.9976110.9976090.9978510.998136

000.09309020.314627

000.1047840.232535

000.1988240.549533

000.1996330.553848

000.1981660.548973

24.933949.896961.580565.4357

24.654948.626764.473465.7789

24.825449.292462.937165.6093

24.851349.350862.989265.7122

24.825649.409162.988665.6693

0.03038140.03238340.02844210.0357143

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=200

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

*Scenario 1: AMP=15

Chart16

000

000

000

0.005035220.003425330

0.01607020.01379380

0.02609070.03706770

0.04103570.04944190

0.04639490.0751010

0.05779380.07595220

0.06711820.09309020

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

Call Blocking

1000.9972710.9977590.9985170.9988840.999108

20000000

30000000

40000000

50000000

00000

7.134385.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.13445.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

00.02713180.2011320.3217020.404278

(100,1)(200,1)(300,1)(400,1)(500,1)

100200300400500

Call Blocking

0

0

0

0

0

Call blocking rate

MS

Call blocking rate

Tra parameters

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000.0502618

20406080100120140160180200

AMP=1

100.9952280.9953070.9972710.9975720.9977590.9956930.9956430.995660.9952910.9972710.997420.9975250.9975830.9975980.997759

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

4.737523.709187.134386.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134386.74836.361335.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.13446.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.13446.74836.361365.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361355.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361355.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361345.94025.460665.29366

00000.02713180000000000.0271318

(20,1)(40,1)(60,1)(80,1)(100,1)(120,1)(140,1)(160,1)(180,1)(200,1)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

AMP=5

100.9948830.9957970.996830.9972790.9978260.9949110.9955760.9960240.9964170.9967390.9970850.9972840.9975520.9976520.997845

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

15.541817.157220.685622.637224.248515.495116.882917.546419.123819.32721.413421.442122.650322.670723.0275

15.014617.387720.402922.739724.626715.472717.168917.330218.892519.233120.309220.677522.451823.04922.8459

15.251117.270220.561122.704124.468615.510317.074717.440519.01919.311120.830721.083222.575222.85822.9589

15.276717.295520.58622.728524.444515.536117.101917.463819.044319.333420.853621.103922.596322.877922.9362

15.303717.321320.612122.753224.467615.562217.12917.487819.069719.355820.876621.124822.617422.897922.9559

00000.03307390000000000.0317769

(20,5)(40,5)(60,5)(80,5)(100,5)(120,5)(140,5)(160,5)(180,5)(200,5)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9949330.9957640.9957640.9963610.996810.996810.997160.997160.9974420.997611

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

15.495116.905517.366218.859720.908921.27122.887423.293824.935224.9339

15.463817.103817.677619.180920.166420.814822.251922.952724.267224.6549

15.503717.020517.537319.054120.570821.087722.604523.121324.638124.8254

15.529617.046417.563219.0820.596821.113622.630423.147224.66424.8513

15.555517.072317.589119.105920.622721.139522.656323.173124.689924.8256

0000000000.0303814

AMP=5

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=5

AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=120

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=160

100.9948380.9957670.9966510.9972970.9977480.9951850.9957450.9960460.9963790.9967510.9970840.9972790.9974880.9976710.997844

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

28.664732.0839.005843.310648.684129.340832.999734.049735.89438.707140.679141.760242.600245.619144.4357

28.168933.723538.418945.161645.02930.093831.260934.499137.157138.376139.91740.707943.38443.948445.7795

28.375232.92638.81644.329647.135829.853532.057234.36936.614238.571240.359441.248543.083244.816945.1872

28.432832.982638.871644.383847.082129.914432.114534.426536.671638.625540.410841.294843.128344.860745.2301

28.492833.039138.928544.437847.132129.97532.172834.485536.729238.680140.46241.341643.173844.904845.2732

00000.02910740000000000.0257732

(20,10)(40,10)(60,10)(80,10)(100,10)(120,10)(140,10)(160,10)(180,10)(200,10)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9953440.9957290.9960550.9963350.9965770.996790.9969780.9972940.9974290.997609

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

29.915132.727834.563637.706837.254641.757742.291545.580148.126649.8969

29.430631.332434.11435.780640.659440.773144.685747.248249.208848.6267

29.779332.088134.396836.705339.014941.323443.632146.440948.749749.2924

29.837632.146434.455136.763739.073341.381743.690446.499248.80849.3508

29.895932.204734.513436.82239.131641.4443.748746.557548.866349.4091

0000000000.0323834

MS=160

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA (Pro)

Sleeping ratio without BWA (Pro)

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=10

MS=200

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

100.9948820.9959250.9966730.9973580.9978060.9952720.995720.9960270.9963970.9967930.9971380.9974240.997670.9977860.998037

50000.007521190.04514370.09758130000.005035220.01607020.02609070.04103570.04639490.05779380.0671182

100000.01807490.05822360.08777590000.002026770.00750690.01736740.02349790.04252480.0479950.0548966

150000.02635730.1061680.1901590000.00721660.02398120.04737610.07448160.1042860.1137470.141229

200000.02679920.1067960.1908570000.007388540.02429540.0478190.07500950.1047530.1142460.140127

000.02291210.1083720.1980440000.00751940.02448550.04798930.07430410.1030950.1137450.137903

40.92147.380155.869760.045162.940943.374846.968150.161155.348556.65357.661760.030759.2360.801660.561

42.114450.247956.261660.084262.674442.945747.209450.388951.316954.475956.408255.999159.297259.577260.5893

41.488649.07556.139360.121162.860643.311947.183950.357953.858155.666957.099758.338359.315160.266360.6195

41.578949.163456.204460.176262.909843.39947.27350.444553.938555.733257.155858.386959.361760.307460.6031

41.669249.25656.277960.227362.955243.488347.364250.533254.020555.800757.212458.435959.408660.349360.645

0000must rerun0000000000.0297542

(20,15)(40,15)(60,15)(80,15)(100,15)(120,15)(140,15)(160,15)(180,15)(200,15)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9951850.9957170.9959420.9963520.9966950.9969830.9971950.9973940.9975790.997851

0000.003425330.01379380.03706770.04944190.0751010.07595220.0930902

0000.003355940.01886020.02781220.05036650.06309290.1040930.104784

0000.007085560.03282590.06567330.1010080.139170.1809630.198824

0000.007440160.03332680.06666420.1017090.139990.1818680.199633

0000.007553960.03403520.06704980.1020110.1406980.1825140.198166

43.065547.909750.386354.344155.362258.062760.351861.747562.642861.5805

43.423245.799350.628553.360457.064658.385359.516960.973962.571364.4734

43.388247.155750.589554.026956.377258.282159.947461.408562.652662.9371

43.478947.246550.680254.100756.443958.328760.004761.461462.701962.9892

43.569647.337250.770954.185756.50258.399160.076761.518262.759862.9886

0000000000.0284421

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE witout BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MAP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

100.9954010.9962630.9977880.9982040.9956640.9960290.9964770.9969420.9972990.9975330.9977780.9979820.9981520.998305

500.0368420.09109290.1948790.3057870.04043130.06856020.116790.118010.1196570.1561570.1770660.195620.2051950.210251

1000.01578950.0585860.21950.2353190.03773580.04742970.05997350.1164010.1549580.1529720.1678860.1833650.2124040.219303

1500.05263730.1515790.4216880.5550710.07911910.09352330.1648950.245770.292090.3019270.3554940.4100970.4565010.465052

2000.05263730.1520970.4239740.5566610.0791190.09400650.1656870.2479690.2940480.3030320.3568350.4112830.4575630.466033

0.08988030.1265420.4343670.584790.08058680.09215240.165590.2491970.2930820.3023620.3584760.4088660.4519250.461197

51.567156.789763.457265.17253.302156.015357.925758.440959.936160.924761.88762.257263.026463.7377

53.444756.706963.103565.295353.252155.883657.027259.596360.288761.299961.746463.050463.649263.4556

52.245656.785863.315165.261253.392455.883257.580659.049360.182361.150161.855262.649663.36963.5788

52.360956.869463.339365.300653.505255.928757.642159.073560.210761.194961.888462.683863.402563.6137

52.475656.8963.384665.337453.619656.038157.718959.106260.25161.236461.916962.725363.433463.6458

000must rerun0000000000.0350422

(20,20)(40,20)(60,20)(80,20)(100,20)(120,20)(140,20)(160,20)(180,20)(200,20)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9956630.996010.9965110.9969210.9971610.9973740.9975680.9978140.9979640.9981360.9991170.999067

0.05658970.07769570.08207970.1052490.1420420.1717860.1840730.27430.2949840.3146270.2498520.237072

0.02155740.04196230.09622850.1311220.1512990.1786480.2253940.2182650.2359710.2325350.2281330.313265

0.0781440.1204790.179930.2388950.2957870.3522560.4108260.4726260.5333610.5495330.5039720.54951

0.07815170.1220110.1801410.2393710.2961810.3527950.4117280.4735440.5344860.5538480.5055660.550691

0.07958560.1233420.1822320.2402580.2971220.3550540.4143710.4749440.5359920.5489730.5051840.552165

53.195856.01757.235258.46360.495662.182963.33665.47266.244565.435764.399365.558

53.459755.741857.75259.546160.572261.775463.154463.786864.414965.778964.509865.6808

53.388555.990557.545659.03960.55562.012563.289564.335565.382365.609364.484165.6092

53.502256.03957.642159.123160.63862.088863.355464.398165.439565.712264.515765.6662

53.554156.096657.670759.192660.70562.116763.37564.451265.488365.669364.560265.7154

0000000000.03571430.3181430.3157

BWA(400,20)NOBWA(400,20)

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. packet delay (ms)

Avg. packet delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt .delay

Avg. pkt .delay for AMP-20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

0.9949110.9951850.9952720.995664

0000.0404313

0000.0377358

0000.0791191

0000.079119

0000.0805868

15.495129.340843.374853.3021

15.472730.093842.945753.2521

15.510329.853543.311953.3924

15.536129.914443.39953.5052

15.562229.97543.488353.6196

0000

0.9949330.9953440.9951850.995663

0000.0565897

0000.0215574

0000.078144

0000.0781517

0000.0795856

15.495129.915143.065553.1958

15.463829.430643.423253.4597

15.503729.779343.388253.3885

15.529629.837643.478953.5022

15.555529.895943.569653.5541

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA

UGS without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=20

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

BE with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=20

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS witout BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

0.9970850.9970840.9971380.997533

000.02609070.156157

000.01736740.152972

000.04737610.301927

000.0478190.303032

000.04798930.302362

21.413440.679157.661760.9247

20.309239.91756.408261.2999

20.830740.359457.099761.1501

20.853640.410857.155861.1949

20.876640.46257.212461.2364

0000

0.996810.996790.9969830.997374

000.03706770.171786

000.02781220.178648

000.06567330.352256

000.06666420.352795

000.06704980.355054

21.27141.757758.062762.1829

20.814840.773158.385361.7754

21.087741.323458.282162.0125

21.113641.381758.328762.0888

21.139541.4458.399162.1167

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=120

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt.dropping rate

Avg. pkt.dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

0.9975520.9974880.997670.997982

000.04639490.19562

000.04252480.183365

000.1042860.410097

000.1047530.411283

000.1030950.408866

22.650342.600259.2362.2572

22.451843.38459.297263.0504

22.575243.083259.315162.6496

22.596343.128359.361762.6838

22.617443.173859.408662.7253

0000

0.997160.9972940.9973940.997814

000.0751010.2743

000.06309290.218265

000.139170.472626

000.139990.473544

000.1406980.474944

23.293845.580161.747565.472

22.952747.248260.973963.7868

23.121346.440961.408564.3355

23.147246.499261.461464.3981

23.173146.557561.518264.4512

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleepnig ratio

Sleepnig ratio for MS=160

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

ertPS wit hBWA (Pro)

ertPS withour BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

0.9978450.9978440.9980370.998305

000.06711820.210251

000.05489660.219303

000.1412290.465052

000.1401270.466033

000.1379030.461197

23.027544.435760.56163.7377

22.845945.779560.589363.4556

22.958945.187260.619563.5788

22.936245.230160.603163.6137

22.955945.273260.64563.6458

0.03177690.02577320.02975420.0350422

0.9976110.9976090.9978510.998136

000.09309020.314627

000.1047840.232535

000.1988240.549533

000.1996330.553848

000.1981660.548973

24.933949.896961.580565.4357

24.654948.626764.473465.7789

24.825449.292462.937165.6093

24.851349.350862.989265.7122

24.825649.409162.988665.6693

0.03038140.03238340.02844210.0357143

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=200

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

Chart17

000

000

000

0.002026770.003355940

0.00750690.01886020

0.01736740.02781220

0.02349790.05036650

0.04252480.06309290

0.0479950.1040930

0.05489660.1047840

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

Call Blocking

1000.9972710.9977590.9985170.9988840.999108

20000000

30000000

40000000

50000000

00000

7.134385.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.13445.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.313395.31662

00.02713180.2011320.3217020.404278

(100,1)(200,1)(300,1)(400,1)(500,1)

100200300400500

Call Blocking

0

0

0

0

0

Call blocking rate

MS

Call blocking rate

Tra parameters

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000.0502618

20406080100120140160180200

AMP=1

100.9952280.9953070.9972710.9975720.9977590.9956930.9956430.995660.9952910.9972710.997420.9975250.9975830.9975980.997759

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

4.737523.709187.134386.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134386.74836.361335.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.13446.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.13446.74836.361365.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361355.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361355.94025.460665.29366

4.737523.709187.134396.175745.293664.48323.95443.43762.902697.134396.74836.361345.94025.460665.29366

00000.02713180000000000.0271318

(20,1)(40,1)(60,1)(80,1)(100,1)(120,1)(140,1)(160,1)(180,1)(200,1)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

AMP=5

100.9948830.9957970.996830.9972790.9978260.9949110.9955760.9960240.9964170.9967390.9970850.9972840.9975520.9976520.997845

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

15.541817.157220.685622.637224.248515.495116.882917.546419.123819.32721.413421.442122.650322.670723.0275

15.014617.387720.402922.739724.626715.472717.168917.330218.892519.233120.309220.677522.451823.04922.8459

15.251117.270220.561122.704124.468615.510317.074717.440519.01919.311120.830721.083222.575222.85822.9589

15.276717.295520.58622.728524.444515.536117.101917.463819.044319.333420.853621.103922.596322.877922.9362

15.303717.321320.612122.753224.467615.562217.12917.487819.069719.355820.876621.124822.617422.897922.9559

00000.03307390000000000.0317769

(20,5)(40,5)(60,5)(80,5)(100,5)(120,5)(140,5)(160,5)(180,5)(200,5)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9949330.9957640.9957640.9963610.996810.996810.997160.997160.9974420.997611

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

15.495116.905517.366218.859720.908921.27122.887423.293824.935224.9339

15.463817.103817.677619.180920.166420.814822.251922.952724.267224.6549

15.503717.020517.537319.054120.570821.087722.604523.121324.638124.8254

15.529617.046417.563219.0820.596821.113622.630423.147224.66424.8513

15.555517.072317.589119.105920.622721.139522.656323.173124.689924.8256

0000000000.0303814

AMP=5

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=5

AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=120

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=5

MS=160

100.9948380.9957670.9966510.9972970.9977480.9951850.9957450.9960460.9963790.9967510.9970840.9972790.9974880.9976710.997844

50000000000000000

100000000000000000

150000000000000000

200000000000000000

000000000000000

28.664732.0839.005843.310648.684129.340832.999734.049735.89438.707140.679141.760242.600245.619144.4357

28.168933.723538.418945.161645.02930.093831.260934.499137.157138.376139.91740.707943.38443.948445.7795

28.375232.92638.81644.329647.135829.853532.057234.36936.614238.571240.359441.248543.083244.816945.1872

28.432832.982638.871644.383847.082129.914432.114534.426536.671638.625540.410841.294843.128344.860745.2301

28.492833.039138.928544.437847.132129.97532.172834.485536.729238.680140.46241.341643.173844.904845.2732

00000.02910740000000000.0257732

(20,10)(40,10)(60,10)(80,10)(100,10)(120,10)(140,10)(160,10)(180,10)(200,10)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9953440.9957290.9960550.9963350.9965770.996790.9969780.9972940.9974290.997609

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

29.915132.727834.563637.706837.254641.757742.291545.580148.126649.8969

29.430631.332434.11435.780640.659440.773144.685747.248249.208848.6267

29.779332.088134.396836.705339.014941.323443.632146.440948.749749.2924

29.837632.146434.455136.763739.073341.381743.690446.499248.80849.3508

29.895932.204734.513436.82239.131641.4443.748746.557548.866349.4091

0000000000.0323834

MS=160

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA (Pro)

Sleeping ratio without BWA (Pro)

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=10

MS=200

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=10

100.9948820.9959250.9966730.9973580.9978060.9952720.995720.9960270.9963970.9967930.9971380.9974240.997670.9977860.998037

50000.007521190.04514370.09758130000.005035220.01607020.02609070.04103570.04639490.05779380.0671182

100000.01807490.05822360.08777590000.002026770.00750690.01736740.02349790.04252480.0479950.0548966

150000.02635730.1061680.1901590000.00721660.02398120.04737610.07448160.1042860.1137470.141229

200000.02679920.1067960.1908570000.007388540.02429540.0478190.07500950.1047530.1142460.140127

000.02291210.1083720.1980440000.00751940.02448550.04798930.07430410.1030950.1137450.137903

40.92147.380155.869760.045162.940943.374846.968150.161155.348556.65357.661760.030759.2360.801660.561

42.114450.247956.261660.084262.674442.945747.209450.388951.316954.475956.408255.999159.297259.577260.5893

41.488649.07556.139360.121162.860643.311947.183950.357953.858155.666957.099758.338359.315160.266360.6195

41.578949.163456.204460.176262.909843.39947.27350.444553.938555.733257.155858.386959.361760.307460.6031

41.669249.25656.277960.227362.955243.488347.364250.533254.020555.800757.212458.435959.408660.349360.645

0000must rerun0000000000.0297542

(20,15)(40,15)(60,15)(80,15)(100,15)(120,15)(140,15)(160,15)(180,15)(200,15)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9951850.9957170.9959420.9963520.9966950.9969830.9971950.9973940.9975790.997851

0000.003425330.01379380.03706770.04944190.0751010.07595220.0930902

0000.003355940.01886020.02781220.05036650.06309290.1040930.104784

0000.007085560.03282590.06567330.1010080.139170.1809630.198824

0000.007440160.03332680.06666420.1017090.139990.1818680.199633

0000.007553960.03403520.06704980.1020110.1406980.1825140.198166

43.065547.909750.386354.344155.362258.062760.351861.747562.642861.5805

43.423245.799350.628553.360457.064658.385359.516960.973962.571364.4734

43.388247.155750.589554.026956.377258.282159.947461.408562.652662.9371

43.478947.246550.680254.100756.443958.328760.004761.461462.701962.9892

43.569647.337250.770954.185756.50258.399160.076761.518262.759862.9886

0000000000.0284421

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE witout BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MAP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=15

100.9954010.9962630.9977880.9982040.9956640.9960290.9964770.9969420.9972990.9975330.9977780.9979820.9981520.998305

500.0368420.09109290.1948790.3057870.04043130.06856020.116790.118010.1196570.1561570.1770660.195620.2051950.210251

1000.01578950.0585860.21950.2353190.03773580.04742970.05997350.1164010.1549580.1529720.1678860.1833650.2124040.219303

1500.05263730.1515790.4216880.5550710.07911910.09352330.1648950.245770.292090.3019270.3554940.4100970.4565010.465052

2000.05263730.1520970.4239740.5566610.0791190.09400650.1656870.2479690.2940480.3030320.3568350.4112830.4575630.466033

0.08988030.1265420.4343670.584790.08058680.09215240.165590.2491970.2930820.3023620.3584760.4088660.4519250.461197

51.567156.789763.457265.17253.302156.015357.925758.440959.936160.924761.88762.257263.026463.7377

53.444756.706963.103565.295353.252155.883657.027259.596360.288761.299961.746463.050463.649263.4556

52.245656.785863.315165.261253.392455.883257.580659.049360.182361.150161.855262.649663.36963.5788

52.360956.869463.339365.300653.505255.928757.642159.073560.210761.194961.888462.683863.402563.6137

52.475656.8963.384665.337453.619656.038157.718959.106260.25161.236461.916962.725363.433463.6458

000must rerun0000000000.0350422

(20,20)(40,20)(60,20)(80,20)(100,20)(120,20)(140,20)(160,20)(180,20)(200,20)

20406080100120140160180200

BWA

0.9956630.996010.9965110.9969210.9971610.9973740.9975680.9978140.9979640.9981360.9991170.999067

0.05658970.07769570.08207970.1052490.1420420.1717860.1840730.27430.2949840.3146270.2498520.237072

0.02155740.04196230.09622850.1311220.1512990.1786480.2253940.2182650.2359710.2325350.2281330.313265

0.0781440.1204790.179930.2388950.2957870.3522560.4108260.4726260.5333610.5495330.5039720.54951

0.07815170.1220110.1801410.2393710.2961810.3527950.4117280.4735440.5344860.5538480.5055660.550691

0.07958560.1233420.1822320.2402580.2971220.3550540.4143710.4749440.5359920.5489730.5051840.552165

53.195856.01757.235258.46360.495662.182963.33665.47266.244565.435764.399365.558

53.459755.741857.75259.546160.572261.775463.154463.786864.414965.778964.509865.6808

53.388555.990557.545659.03960.55562.012563.289564.335565.382365.609364.484165.6092

53.502256.03957.642159.123160.63862.088863.355464.398165.439565.712264.515765.6662

53.554156.096657.670759.192660.70562.116763.37564.451265.488365.669364.560265.7154

0000000000.03571430.3181430.3157

BWA(400,20)NOBWA(400,20)

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

MS

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

UGS (Tra)

MS

Avg. packet delay (ms)

Avg. packet delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

BE (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt .delay

Avg. pkt .delay for AMP-20

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

000

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for AMP=20

0.9949110.9951850.9952720.995664

0000.0404313

0000.0377358

0000.0791191

0000.079119

0000.0805868

15.495129.340843.374853.3021

15.472730.093842.945753.2521

15.510329.853543.311953.3924

15.536129.914443.39953.5052

15.562229.97543.488353.6196

0000

0.9949330.9953440.9951850.995663

0000.0565897

0000.0215574

0000.078144

0000.0781517

0000.0795856

15.495129.915143.065553.1958

15.463829.430643.423253.4597

15.503729.779343.388253.3885

15.529629.837643.478953.5022

15.555529.895943.569653.5541

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA

UGS without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=20

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

0000000000

UGS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

BE with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=20

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS witout BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=20

0.9970850.9970840.9971380.997533

000.02609070.156157

000.01736740.152972

000.04737610.301927

000.0478190.303032

000.04798930.302362

21.413440.679157.661760.9247

20.309239.91756.408261.2999

20.830740.359457.099761.1501

20.853640.410857.155861.1949

20.876640.46257.212461.2364

0000

0.996810.996790.9969830.997374

000.03706770.171786

000.02781220.178648

000.06567330.352256

000.06666420.352795

000.06704980.355054

21.27141.757758.062762.1829

20.814840.773158.385361.7754

21.087741.323458.282162.0125

21.113641.381758.328762.0888

21.139541.4458.399162.1167

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=120

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt.dropping rate

Avg. pkt.dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=120

0.9975520.9974880.997670.997982

000.04639490.19562

000.04252480.183365

000.1042860.410097

000.1047530.411283

000.1030950.408866

22.650342.600259.2362.2572

22.451843.38459.297263.0504

22.575243.083259.315162.6496

22.596343.128359.361762.6838

22.617443.173859.408662.7253

0000

0.997160.9972940.9973940.997814

000.0751010.2743

000.06309290.218265

000.139170.472626

000.139990.473544

000.1406980.474944

23.293845.580161.747565.472

22.952747.248260.973963.7868

23.121346.440961.408564.3355

23.147246.499261.461464.3981

23.173146.557561.518264.4512

0000

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleepnig ratio

Sleepnig ratio for MS=160

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

ertPS wit hBWA (Pro)

ertPS withour BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=160

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=160

0.9978450.9978440.9980370.998305

000.06711820.210251

000.05489660.219303

000.1412290.465052

000.1401270.466033

000.1379030.461197

23.027544.435760.56163.7377

22.845945.779560.589363.4556

22.958945.187260.619563.5788

22.936245.230160.603163.6137

22.955945.273260.64563.6458

0.03177690.02577320.02975420.0350422

0.9976110.9976090.9978510.998136

000.09309020.314627

000.1047840.232535

000.1988240.549533

000.1996330.553848

000.1981660.548973

24.933949.896961.580565.4357

24.654948.626764.473465.7789

24.825449.292462.937165.6093

24.851349.350862.989265.7122

24.825649.409162.988665.6693

0.03038140.03238340.02844210.0357143

5101520

00

00

00

00

Sleeping ratio with BWA

Sleeping ratio without BWA

AMP

Sleeping ratio

Sleeping ratio for MS=200

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for MS=200

00

00

00

00

UGS with BWA (Pro)

UGS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

ertPS with BWA (Pro)

ertPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

nrtPS with BWA (Pro)

nrtPS without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

00

00

00

00

BE with BWA (Pro)

BE without BWA (Pro)

AMP

Avg. pkt. delay (ms)

Avg. pkt. delay for MS=200

*

Chart18

000

000

000

0.00721660.007085560

0.02398120.03282590

0.04737610.06567330

0.07448160.1010080

0.1042860.139170

0.1137470.1809630

0.1412290.1988240

rtPS with BWA (Pro)

rtPS without BWA (Pro)

rtPS (Tra)

MS

Avg. pkt. dropping rate

Avg. pkt. dropping rate for AMP=15

Call Blocking

1000.9972710.9977590.9985170.9988840.999108

20000000

30000000

40000000

50000000

00000

7.134385.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.13445.293665.329215.313395.31662

7.134395.293665.329215.