the murphy report

8/13/2019 The Murphy Report

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-murphy-report 1/12

ZLD NTP[LU`yHdw Ugra ]uprdnd Mgurt, Cppdooctd J

[PD]EJEHB FT]ZEMD IPCHFchucry =;, 35



Gh Fch. =, E rdqudstdj tld rd•ebhctegu• gi - ~ ~ lchj ]cr&l Ng]lcc, tld jdputy mledt mguhsdo, gi t

nettdd (ldrdehcitdr J[M', Eh le• o d ~ ~ d r gi r d c e b

3_s wd jecmTE,.j tgjcy, E weoo `t rddebhehb ny

g d p c r ~ n d h t c o Mecmepoehcry Mgnnettdd diidmt evd Nwcrj tg ~ p d h j e h b ngst gi ny jcy• uhte o tldh mod•

eh tld gii emd chj `y tcaehb sgnd nugl hddjdjv c d

~ h j weooehb tg ldop d ~ i d m t e qnggtl t rchse t egh j''Gh c t 6 ~ • r • g h c o hgtd, wcht tg tlcha Ugur Lghg

sctediyehb chj iu o i e o o ehb deblt ydcrc cs tld Mg

wesl ygu c o o tld `dst ,it

' ' E odcrhdj tgjcy t6.lct Nead cdhteod lcs eh gt"ndjMledi Mguhd$3 tg tld Jedgepoeh•ry Mgnnettdd diic



Ct tld tend gi t l d 3 ~ 3dpcrctK r K s e b h ~ t e g h s , hd

c ~ t r ` ~ t • ~ ny rdqudst igr tlder r d ~ e b h c t e g h ~ tg

g l c r ~ d gi tlder juteds c t tld ~ ~ ; . Ns . Nm]ldc'•

stdps tcadh `y ldr eh Fuoy 35<< tg iehj gtldr d

nghtls tldrdci tdr , chbdrdj `U tld Fuoy prgngt

@rujed, Psq. , tg tls hdwoy mrdctdj~ g s e t e g h

gi F c ~ a 3 g h , Dsq . , tld JGM mlce rnch , c pgct mrdctdj

gh• , tl• r • wc3 cu`Btchteco mcusd tg mghmoujd tl

jghdj tld gpdrctegh gi tld GGM tg Ns. Nm]ldc. @

pgehtndht, ld wcs bevdh, tgbdtldr wetl N ~ . c•h t

M Y < ~ tl• JJM . [urtl or , Nr. @rujed wcs dxpxdcdoy

o ece3gh wetl tld Mgnnettdd. ~ l d vdstehb gi fg eh

jd•erc`od stdp, uhodss et e s rdquerdj `y hdmdd•

t dj eh tld JGM,

]3hdd ny rdqudst igr tld d s e b h c ~ e g h c gi N•. S



c ~ d c gi 30 lgurs, `dmcu•d ld rdbuocroy ic e odj tg

cppdcrdj c t gjj lgurs, ctcydj `redi oy, chj tl•h

ndn`dr gi tl• pu`oem wlg `doedvds tlct tld ]tctd

slddts , ch chhuco •c ocry gi $<;,;;; igr wgra gi

Nm]ldc, tldrd mch `d hg jgu`t tlc t cld ahdw gi N

giieSd, ch c ` ~ h g g h n ~ h t tlc t Coghd wcs suiiededhd

sdmghj, jurehb tld o c s t s ex ydcrs, Nr. B ~ h t e o dutgr gi tl ed mgurt wleml hcd fur esjemt egh g v d ~tld Jrghx. Jurehb tlg&• ~ e x ydcrs, c p ~ r e g j wldgcsds rdncehdj rdoct evdoy ctc`od, tld `cmaog1 gtld dhj gi 35<= tg gvdr o,FGG eh Jdmdn`dr 35<<,

dlct Nr. Bdhte od ' • rc•ebhctech wcc r d q u e ~ c : Hgi e ~ u r d s s u p p o e d ~ `y N ~ . Bdhteod gvdr tld y d c ~ puhjdr pdhcoty gi pdrfury, tl es mgurt lco lcj mg

pregr tg Nr. Bdhteod 's rdsebhctegh6



Socenc g prgidsseghco nesmghjumt eh ~ w g wlgooy

dom•ehb tld i e od , Nr. Bdhteod wrgtd c sdrve od o

vet ehb len tg d g h t ~ g t N ~ . Bdhteod1 c h ~ c od t td r

igr lcvehb i e odj tld dgnpoFehtc.

Eh tld cdmghj mcsd, ci tdr c pdte t egh lcj `ddh~ l ~ r d p G h ~ d h t chj lec c t ~ g r h d y . Zld rdspghjdht

e t egh ùt Nr. Bdhteoc ccej tlct tld g l c e r n ~ h . N

•pdhjdht's cmmdptchmd t c p u ` o e ~ mdhsurd. ie`dhcppdco tg Nr . Fcda$gh `dmcus• ld c g u o ~ hgt `doed

ce t egh, Nr, Bthte od chswdrdj tlct , e i tld puòe

wguoj cndhj tld pdte t egh grjdr tg cjj • • ~ ~ g uSdhteod l ~ j ahgwh w l • ~ ~ l ~ pdt e t egh wc• 9rcwh.•tctdnchts, Nr . =cgacgh enndjectdoy rcpujectdj

~ c a d htl• pgcetegh rdprdsdhtdj `y Nr. Bdhteod cteghcòy cmmdptcòd.



ice ourd tg `d dhbcbdj eh MJM wgxa eh ~ h y gtldrmguoj hgt mghtcmt Nr . Bdhteod. tgr hg ght ct tlK

Zldsd rdpgrtu t tld c`sdhmds chj h ~ h p r g j u m t e vmdrh upgh tld t e o ehb wetl t l ~ h g ~ eh Ggtg`dr 35

hdy Bdhdrco gi ~ l d ]tctd gi Hdw Ugra cbceh3t m.c i e o ehb ~ l c ~ wc• ncjd p u ` o e ~ ~ y tl• CttSrhdy B

tld prd••² Tpgh tlc t i e o ehb, Nr, Sdhte od , rdpdc

Mgurt tlct ld, Nr. BdhtOod 3 wcs sg irebltdhdj `

tlct ld wcs ehmoehd: tg r ehj c wcy mi cvge:ehb

mcsds cssebhdj hgt tg lensdoi `ut tg c JMM cttg

hdy wguoj eh tcmt lcvd hgml3h5 dg jg wetl et Z

chj jdtdrnehd tld m l c r c ~ t • ~ gi Nr. Bdht e od ' • pr

Cc tg Nr. Bdhteod'] pdrdghco fujbndht, brcvd j`dr 35<< wldh c jgnpocehcht `digrd tld JJM :rdw



Cs igr Ns. Ndsl••• tld mcusds gi l ~ r jedml•rbd

Nr. Bdht3o t 3 < c`chjghndht gi le• bu`oem giiemd

gr t l ~ Mgurt, pgrlcps `cmcus• e t l ~ S vddtdg ldr

mgnd smchjcoguo. E lcvd mcusd tg `doedvd tlct t

tdd n•n`•r•, dcbdr tg wgra, clcrdj ny m g h ~ d t h t

ncttdrs ghoy 04 lcj `ddh ldcrj eh coo gi 35<<,pchdos wleml sct c tg tc o gi 43 jcys. surdoy Nr.

tlc t ld lcj uct ghoy deblt j c y ~ eh 3 ~ < < . Jej

rdjumehb tl t `cmaogb7

Ngrd pdrsucsevd igr Ns. Nm]ldc's jecmlcrbd, l gNs. Nm]ldc igr l ~ t ~ r d « t n d h t gi tld odbco chj ocu jdputy gleg mguhsdo. E s c t igrtl ~ h i ~ o o c

j • • ~ ~ e ` d •h cdpdmt gi N&. N m e l ~ c ' u pdrsghcoety

l•r htw pg•t cd jdputy mle• t mguhudo. Coo mgnntldrdct tdr ldcrj w•r& mghsestdht wetl tld p•rcg



od o o ` ~ o j . dypd. ~ d c j '[•r•ghco Pctdrdhdd Ehquer

~ ~ ~ g h ~ ]dogw tlc t , eh tld gtlKrwecd `ocha cjj'Nr. Lgwcrj @dhfcneh' coghb wetl tld cjjrdsc t

9. scrcl csadj Nr. [l6o.o.Lps, 'Rlct slguoj wd

o eps rdspghjdj tlct e t slguoc `d bevdh tg Lgwcr]crcl rccpghjdj tg tld d t t ~ ~ t t l ~ t behmd Lgwcrjchj sld lcj cucuncj l es pgse t egh , cld slguoj te

2. Nr. [leoo epc rdspghjdj tloo ot tld igrn rdqud

t • t • r • h ~ • . chj wc• tl• td tmrd pdrsghco tg Nr. @d

c t chy rctd , Nr, @dhfcneh wcs • s t e o o gh tld pcy

Mledt Mguhsdo, Nr. ~ l e o o e p s ~ t c t d j tlct ld lcj

dhmd `dmcusd ld chj L g w c ~ j lcj ahgwh dcgl g t l m ~Lgwcrj's t e t o d .



gmltr tlehbs, o ec esgh wetl tlec Mgurt, wcs gi su

` d o e d v d ~ ldr sdvdrchmd j d d e r c ` ~ d Eh ny gpehegh

~ ~ w d r gvdr gtldrs clguo: `t 5rchtdj, chj sld lc

Nr . Bdhteod 's ehtdrdsmc. Cgcgrjehboy, t jej h ~ to d t t d r gi

rdsebhct egh stctdj, eh su`stchmd,tlc

rdsebhctegh chj lcvehb sdrvdj "lcppeoy u N ~ a o ) st end• tg ~ • • e 1 h eh grjdr • tg purtud h•w prgidsse

Cd E sct tlrgubl tld ~ c h . o rds ebhct egh ~ g h t d rN•. Nd]ldc, dcml ahdw chj dghmdcodj c icmd tlct

odcrhdj gh Fch. ' wldh t wcs : e c g g v • ~ • : tlct , j

JGM ocwydr cccebhdj e t s ncfgr mc•d• gi d x t ~ ~ g r j ediidmt evd ct t l ~ dhj ci Fchunry. gh Fch. :, N•.

gi tlt Mgurt chj lcj vgouhttdrdj eh tld prdschcdrdcebhdj `dmcusd tl• ` c ~ a ~ g b gi mcsds wcs " n • h ~



Zld Modra rdpgr tdj tlct mghvdrsctegh t nd ci t

stc tdj tlct , upgh t ~ o o e h b Nr. Bdhteod tlct ld ltlc t ld wguoj `d b3g•ehb tlK giiegd c t ] [.N.,ld wguoj hgt odcv• tld gii emd c t tlct tend `ut

`y len. Eh vedw gi tld rdpgrt gi Nr. Bdhteod 's

jegtehb gghjudt, E cjve dj Nr . Pdyhgojc tgdht erd stcii tl•h eh tld JGM gii emd tg odcvd c t

i e¢dr tldh gh juty ct tld JJM tg rcquddt chgtld

tld gtieSd wcs mogsdj . [rmve•egh i gr tld pgsteh

ieSd lcj `ddh ncjd `y tld Giiemd gi Mgurt Cjne

mghsdqudhmd gi Nt. Bdhteod 's mocen& tlc t E T M ~ c

cnghb gtldr tlehbd, Nr. Bdht e o9 wc3 eh :ch5dr g

lcg `ddh igoogwehb len igr nghtlc . Cmmgrjehboy,

pdccdtuo odcvehb gi tld JGM giiemd `y N . Bthtetldn gut . Hghd dtgg: `y dld jdsa gi Nr. BchtOot



gi chgtldr gp e hegh. •• Nr. B•hteod lcj `ouhjdrdjmgnpoceht eh ]tdeh`drb `d jednessdj.

Zld JGM neblt mghsejdt cppgehtehb c su`mgnnetttg ~ • c e j d wldtldr tld td•tenghy gi tlrdd pcr•gh

Cnds wlg w g u o ~ lcvd t d d t e t e ~ j tg ]tdeh`drb'& bo t•eh`drb•d ehvgmctegh gi le• preveodbd cbcehstchy qudsteghs m g h ~ • r h e h 5 ggmcehd , ehmoujehb l3clcvd m c u ~ d j tld JJM tg ngvd enndjectdoy tg suspd

Zends chc tld Hdw U M ~ a ~ c w Fgurhco, [rgi•EEMt Bdmlggo gi Ocw c ~ ~ c r d h d o y tlehas tlcd ducpdh3egh

tld gpehegh gi tld su`mgnnettdd, tld JGM slguojt• Fch, : ehtdrveKR gi Nr . B • h ~ e o K ~ l d r K Nr. G

lCj h•v•r n•t, E t e s quetd mgnngh igr jesbruht

dt tgr t tg ct tcma tlder ocwydrs' pdrigrnchmd," Z`drb t e o d tlct thd Hdvcots wdrd "jeiobrurtdodj."



ge sd e t c jesmrd t egh eh jesmlcrbehb JGM dnpogydd

[ut chgtldr w ~ y ygur mgnnetndht tg sdrvd tld pncjd b u ` f ~ t c nct t d r wlgo oy wetleh tld Mgu

wguoj `d tg Bcy tlct ygur cppgehtndht e s su`fdm

tld wcbdc ygu p y ygur •npogydds, c mghjet egh t

hgtlehb gi yg ur d n p o g y d ~ sLgwdvdr , slguoc ygu tleha tlc t E cn r eblt , mr

uhrdsgov `od, gr tlc t ygu w g u o ~ hcvd • x d r m e u ~ j`ut igr tl• cnd purpgsds, g r tlc t t l e ~ Mgnnett

t eghs gi Nr . Bdht e od c h ~ NF, Nm]ldc lcs slgwh w

tl es mgnnettdd tg rdvedw c j e s m rd t egh vdstdj `y

ehve td ygu tg r • • ~ n d tld wg r a gi ~ l ~ s Mgnnettdd

d` rd: `y Fhy gtldr j e s m e p o 3 ~ c r y ` g ~ y eh tld hc

j e r d m ~ e g hgi wlct e s

g h s t ~ ~ ~ t e v dchj

~ e t e v d ,strumtevd chj j3Ye<evd,

the murphy report

Documents