7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

1/1668

:

P\ECF\NCP :;

_FH P\E_F _J_OHCJ\O

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

2/1668

@JHOAJ EV\VCV

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

4/1668

0

EO^JCPAJCJ\

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

5/1668

6

P\ECF\:_J_OH EV\VCV@JHOAJ EV\VCV

EO^JCPAJCJ\

^FE^FHEHN LCA :?72!:?=2 @HFA:2

:?72!:?=2 @hfao ) R|ig( @|( Moeafp t`fao| U~(:6!0;Q ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :2

P|eoyf+`f I|`v wf ^oyj~fp ) @i( @|( Hv|fh Ajtn U~(0=!6>Q (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( ;:

hkocot Ejyhjecj|hj K|f P|eoyf+`feo 20E|f~fccffh @hyj+`j Jl!P|eoyf coeocf|ohoh _i|vacjhaj~ ) R|ig( @|( cmjh Pfefco !^fcoa ceoh U~(:=0!:?7Q (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( >:6

P|eoyf!Jw|vrj Lo|coo coeocf|o wf P|e!_vhjh ^i|vhcj| ) @i( @|( Mj~jh hjc U~(:?;!>;

P|eoyf!JL@ coeocf|ohf Kfhfc Lo| Lje -:?:?!

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

6/1668

7

P|eoyf+hoh I|pj`iv Ricopoej~4 Kfcooao wf Fpefhcf|o ) @i( @|( \jajtjh Ktfh U~(>!>>Q (((((((((((((((( 6:;

Nvamv|oyfp+oh ce @hfaoh`f Ace _jrhh Kfcooao -:?>0!>07Q ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 677

P|eoyf+`f Ajmjcc `j|fcf|oh Kfcooao ) _|`( @i( @|( Wfy~fc E( Locko U~(>0;!>67Q (((((( 6?77Q (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 7:2

P|e Mveve ^o~pfaoh`f j`jcjaj ) @i( @|( Pfavoh G( F|pjh U~(>7;!>;7Q ((((((((((( 7;?!0:=Q (((((((((((((((((( 70;

P|eoyf Nvamv|oyfpo+h`f ^jce Motafpcf|o ) _|`( @i( @|( Locjc Je U~(0:?!0>6Q ((((((((((( ;7!006Q (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( ;72

hh @hfaohoh Eyf tfc |fpafh _fpopo|af R|idf~o4 Ey Fh~popcf|o ) _|`( @i(@|( Jco Jpj _oop U~(007!060Q ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( ;=!0?>Q ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( =06

P|e Jhjyj~jcj|h`j ^i~yjc Mjecj|h Kfcooao wf _i|vav ) _|`( @i( @|( Khk| Pv|jhU~(0?0!620Q (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( =7= @hfaoh`f P|eoyf+hoh ^jhjyo Ricopoej~ ) _|`( @i( @|( _jj| ^faot U~(;:2!;:=Q(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

9/1668

?

Nvamv|oyfp @hfaoh`f P|eoyf+`f Fntjnce ) R|ig( @|( Jgogf Ajp U~(?0Q ((((((((((( :70;

P|e Pj|om |fpoao wf Af~fcfcf|o ) R|ig( @|( Av~pjgj ^jg|jh U~(?>6!?0

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

10/1668

:2

^FE^FHEHN LCA :?72!:?=2 @HFA

:?72!:?=2 @hfao ) R|ig( @|( Moeafp t`fao| U~(:6!0;Q

Einjfco howf|~opf~o epo~j`o wf `j|o Locoacf| Gjecpf~o ) P|eoyf

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

11/1668

::

Lv mj|fepj ^ocjmc Evwwfpcf|oaot# rj|pocf|o oohf `pecf|o vtcjajt `v|va`jh ev|pj|aje wf

rj|pocf| ~p pj|jg~t lo| o`j|fhoh hftj|fp wf mjefacoo jcph`j fh e~j tjajh`j `oc wf ~f|lf~p

~foacf| yjrp|j|je# o`j|fyo mjhko pj|jgj afh~vr icv|~j ic~vh ~foao ejtjhjhcj|j `fwo| wf pf~coa

fpafe tf|f ko|oao lvcvhajepj`|( -(/

^vljycj| fycfacf|ohoh molo| eoo wfyj k|vlj ej| yjrcaj`h hf ~|acf|~f `f# oepo`j|`jeo@Rcocf|o jej mf`fg jcacj|`|(

Meafp `j|lf~oho kf|fecfpo|fhcf|`fh jhnje >=ohoh yf| jcjloc`oo Aocco Lo|coe Eiaopf~o -ALE/

:> Ej~a :?72`jeo pj~goyf`fh ~ih|j ejcjh yfcf|nf Mjwjn# eoo`o|( J~ef|o Eiaopf yfcf|o# jcp wf i|pj

~hgcj|j afh~vr jocfcf|`fh yfpoaocf|`o|( = yfhoh ljlj~ ~vljy# 7~hh afav|# 7~hh f~hjg wf

tjhjjpej|# 0hh ~f|lf~p af~cfe# Ej~a :?72 kh kf|fecfpo|`oecf|o lo| o!`j|lf ocf ejcn j~ef| |fdoa yjhc~ ktefh

~vljycj|`jh :0h pj~goyf fpaocf|`o|(

ALE Fycfacf|o

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

12/1668

:

fopco af~cfe ef~oacf|ohoh -lj|icj|# lj~h# fafeco ~vljycj|# f~hjg ev|vcvcj|# kfhcoe# oo ~fh`oejcj|#

~jhjyo wf ponj|fp i`jcj|# |fpafh ev|vcvcj|# howf|~opf wf yj|k i|kjhcj|/ pfa~ocnocf|o jjajc

yiccj|`jh ~focaocf|`o( Lv yfcf|f jy|nj `fwcfp ljejh wf j~ef| eiaopf eihpfhdjhh`jh ko|fhcf|o wf

ljejhcj| ev|vcv yfcf|oho `f fecfafe kf|fe(

ALE ocf lo|coepf pircja

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

14/1668

:0

`j|`j l|jejh pvpva# :?7: Jhjyj~j~hh `jmj ljcjhkpj yj|j jcaj~hj yic jjh fh lye

fpefh`o|(

pf yjh`j# Lcfhp Pjh|h ogj`f~oycf# lv jhjyj~j `fwcfp nomjt ooh`f evwwfpcf| jy|c wf

`fhkf~o# yj|k lja~tc# tf|e ev|vacj| `fhkfcfaf~o# j~c hfaco~o jhjyj~j~hh ~phc wf

`faie|jpoe mveve `fwcfpo ocefcf|oho kwfhnfyf ljcjaj~ycj paycf ocf|o lo| j`a`( Pircvavh wflo|fyoh ~f|lf~pf kfcoflocaf~o yhh`fh `f ecj~oe wf ~oyj~o mjecj|j rj|jcfc icj|je ~i~yjc mjecj|h `j

kfho lo| feoc`f pjhhr kwfhnf jcphj jchaj~# `fwcfpoh lph fycfa wf ocfacf|ohoh yj|k

`fhfpoaohf ljcjhaj~# tk|ch ev|jc ~h|cjajcj|hh o~po~hj ~jycaj~# wl( hiepjcj|`jh colf|jc wf

ivcnv lo| faie|j~ohoh pfafc ompoyjcj|h ej|cjyjnje lo| ev|va~jc f|fwf kfpo|ocaopo(=

:?7: Jhjyj~j~ ocf kfpo|ocfh yfho ~oyj~ afejhotajcj| fkfafhcoe jhcjyh`j hfaco lo|

`fooecoe yjrap|(

P|e jhjyj~jnce mj|fefpoh`f :?

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

15/1668

:6

Lv rj|pocf| j|j~h`j e~j ~|f`f no``o lo| k mjcohf kfcfnfe wf :< Fycc :?=2 J~ef|o

A`jmjcf~ohf ej`j| P|eoyf ~oyj~fpohf `jakj~h wv|jnje icjh# J`jcfp Rj|po~o -JR/ `f yf|

jcajepj`|(

:: vljp :?7:`f ev|vcjh JRhoh Co`f|o# < Jv~pi~ :?72 kh Kfhfcev|ajy Ljejhch`jh

fafeco f`ocfh I|kfhf|jc \jkr Karjcj o`o( @Rhoh ao|j~hj pjcor icjh lv rj|pohoh h`f kfcfho~oacf|o j|j~h`j# Pjm~oh @fao|jy -f~eo Eyc Rj|po~o Kfhfc Ljejh/# Fpmfa Afhfafhnoicv

-|fpoa yf~o/# Nfw`fp Rf|oh -|fpoa yf~o/# Avmpj| _jtj| -!/# Eja|jh Fwcoyjicv -F~eo @R

Aoccfpwfeoco/# Afmafp _i|kjhnicv -F~eo @R Aoccfpwfeoco/# m~jh hjc -@iepi|/# Faoh Jnj| -Jwvejp/#

ohj~o I~aj-Fafeco Jcljy/ wj|`(::

:?7: P|eoyf~o ooh mjyco ocf|o lo| ~oyj~fp lfckf~o icjh JR R|ik|jah`j v ocefcf| `oeejpo

feafepf`o|4

j`j Kj|r af`fhoyfpo mvevevhj wf h~jh Mjecj| Fw|fh~fc Lfyjhhjaf~oh`f ogj`f~oho

lvcjh tomhoyfpf vykvh lo| nfaoyfp `tfho wf mveve `fwcfpohoh kf|fo kolo ev|vcaj~ wf pfefaac

fppo|ocaf~o kjyfaot o|(

jcaj ~jmj~hh wjpjh`jcj|j fh kfho c`f r|t~t feoc`f je pvpvcaj~ wf o

m||oyfpohoh avpcje ~v|fpcf ~jcjhaj~ cjta`|( @fwcfpocoe# jm~o pffll~h loppoo yf|`f ljcj|(

Jhnje# tj|v|fp mjccf|oh`f pjploe f`oco|( epo~j`o ejcehajat ooh yjljhn ~f|ajyfhoh pfwoeohf

pj|jgpj|t(

Cjoecoo# `oh jcfympj|c fecoh`f jhcjayi|vt( @fwcfpoh cjoe icaj~# wjpjh`jcj|h `ohcf|o ocf

jcjejcj|h ef~afe `foc`o|( Mf| wjpjh`j# afh~vr ic`vv `oh wf aftmfloh olj`fp feoccf|oho on|j`j

~f|lf~ppo|(

`j|o j`fa!o af|eftoyfpoh ~jaoao feoc`f pjploeoho# ajmjcco o`j|f goe|ohoh pjewoyf~oho#

nfaoyfpoaot`f hjta |ic iyhjyjh af~~f~fcf|oh avmpj| mjcf kfpo|ocaf~oho# `faie|j~ohoh pfaohjp

icj|je ejlvc f`oyi|vt( e af|efto ~o~pfaoh pf|e f`ocf|fe# pf`|onfh mjt|cjhjnje f~j~cj|j k|f avmopoh

ajmjcco ocf|oh`f avmpj| o`j|fyf ejwvpv|vcaj~h wf mf| ljea`jh afwtvjpath j`fa!o af|eftoyfp

onjrcj|hj ohpolje fppo|ocaf~oho o~poyi| wf lvhv aoccfp mjeoaoyfpohoh wf wjpjh ~jpmh`j opoajo kfcoafcf|ohlo| tj|v|fpo ~jyyi|vt(:

Kfhfc focoa icj|je ~oyj~ rj|po gjjcoyfpcf|ohf otoh wf|ocaf~o# ff| `j|lf`fh ~ih|j

ejrjpcajacj|~j wfyj gjjcoyfpcf|o kfono lo| ~|f `v|`v|vcaja~j# P|e |hfoh`f j~ef|yhfpoa`fh hi|ajc yhfpoaf kfo ~|fnohoh oce j`a icvyi|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

16/1668

:7

0(;~o ocf :6= Aoccfpwfeoco5

_PR iycj|h yt`f :>(7?v ocf 76 Aoccfpwfeoco5

NEAR iycj|h yt`f :>(;~o ocf 60 Aoccfpwfeoco(

ivhcve ~o~pfao vykvcjhjh Nvamv|oyfp ^fhjpi~vh`j ~jh`jcyf `jca `jmj gj|ec`|4

JR iycj|h yt`f>6(0 ocf ;: ~jh`jcyf5

NMR iycj|h yt`f >;(7 ~jh`jcyf5

_PR iycj|h yt`f :>(?v ocf

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

17/1668

:;

NEAR iycj|h yt`f :>(0 ocf :7 ~jh`jcyf(:0

:6 Feoa :?7: kfhfc ~foacf|o ocf ljcjyjh yfho `hfaoh ~i|vhcj|5 ~foacf|oh i|pjyj

eiy`vv pjlci`j ~jec`|( Lv ~i|vhcj|`jh lo|o# NMRhoh :?6; ~foacf|ohf k|f iy yopo|af~o`o|( Lo|

`of|o# ee wf i|pj eycch ljt ef~oacf|oho efh`ohf fefh wf `jmj ie NMRhoh

kf|ocfaf~oh`fh yj|j|cjhjh NEAR lo| yjhj l|jec|~j# @R iycj|hh ~foacf|`fh yjchtnj ? jyhnf ev|vcjh yfho oeo rj|po JR wf _PR j|j~h`j rjycjcj|je lcie mjcoh`f wj|ch

ei|vyjlocaf~o`o|( Lvhj lo| `f Fkf wf Je`fhot lckfcf|oh`f JRhoh :?6;`feo @R`fh `jmj ie iy

pircj` fecfhafco( @Rhoh `of| ao|j~~ _PR o~f lv lckfcf|`f tjyg# @iv wf Khfy`iv

Jhj`icv`j kc`|( JR wf _PR`fh oceo lye fmo| lv|dvwjto~oho# Ljp`jeo wf Khfy`feo

ejropjco~p ogpocf|o wf Evtfy Jhj`icv`jeo pph wf gh`e lckfcf|ohoh lye pnnj|h wf lo| j|jyj

pircj|efh# pfeo# @iv wf Khfy`iv lckfcf|oh`feo kf|o ejca jcjhcj|`j yjjyjh ~fafhcf|o

efh`o~ohf feafyo ljj|ap|(:6

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

18/1668

:=

!:?=:/ ^fhjpi Ljejhchj#

Gvjp ^o|afh -:=??!:?=:/ Aoccfp Afnco~o Ljejhchj kfpo|ocaocf|`o|(

JRcocf|oh I|`v pj|jgh`jh `jyjpcjh hf|ocf|o ejlvc fpafe `v|vavh`j l|jecajcj| tjajh

tjajh mjwjy kf|kohcfpo|aopo|( JR# oce hnf Nvamv|ljejhc ~foao ooh I|`vhvh j`jy I|kfhf|jc

Nfajc K|~fco `f~pfecfafe ti|vh`j ejca# j|`h`jh meafpoh ev|vcvvh`j ~i|vh eap|( ^foa

~ihvcj|hj k|f hi|ajc icjh# NMRhoh ej|~h`j yf| jcjh rj|pocf|oh eijco~yihj kopafcf|o o`o( Lvhj

|jafh oce meafp NMR!JR eijco~yihv fecoh`f icvpv|vcavpv|( K|hpf rj|cjafhpf| ~o~pfaoh

ev|jccj|hjvykvh`v|( ^foa`f fh ie ~jh`jcyf ejtjhjh -~jh`jcyf ivhcvvh`j aoccfpwfeoco ~jy~

jchyi|`v/ rj|pohoh co`f|o ~gjpycj NMR Kfhfc Ljejh meafp ev|ajy ~pcfhoyi|`v jaj# JRcocf|

lvhj ti|cj |jt f`ocao kolo kteyi|`v( Jhnje :?76f `i|v# I|`v`jh kfcfh lj~ecj| ejcehnjafnco~cf|`feo ~jh`jcyf ~jy~h`j `fooecoe icaj` mjc`f# NMRho avmjcfgfppf l|jejh meafpcf|

ev|vcjlocaopo|(

J~ef| yhfpoaoh co`f|o Nfajc K|~fcoh Nvamv|ljejh ~focaf~o wf NMR!JR Eijco~yihv

ev|aje tf|f hhy Ljljejh icj|je k|fwcfh`o|af~o ^ocjmc Evwwfpcf|`fh kfcflocfnfe yfho lo|

a`jmjcfyo# mo icajt~j e~j ~|f ooh f|pfcf|efh# jyh tjajh`j ~owoc yhfpoaf kfooh ~afp hh

kolo `fhfyoaco wf rj|cjafhpiyv I|`v`jh kfcfh jyjecjhaj ko|ooacf|ohf ej| ~jwvhajepj ej|j|c lo|

`fwcfp j`ja ktfpoaoh`f yjjhaj~ lye lo| jh~ icavpv|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

19/1668

:?

Nvamv|ljejhc wf Ljljejhce ajejacj|hh I|`v j~h`jh kwfhoco| eoocf|f# I|kfhf|jc

Nfajc K|~fc wf yohf f~eo lo| eiavpjh icjh#

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

20/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

21/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

22/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

23/1668

El|~ ~i|vhvh`j Jaf|oejh pvpvavhv pj|pajyj yf| l|jeajyjnje ej`j| ~iavp lo| looa`f

i|pjyj eiyav lvcvhjh Dimh~ih Afepvlvhvh :?77 ych`j P|e lj~hh`j yjyhcjhaj~ El|~

~i|vhvhv oeohno rcjhj opfnfe ej`j| fpeoco icav wf kfhfccoecf jy`h# tfccoecf ~ic fw|fcf|`f# meafpoh

otcf`oo ` ricopoej eihv~vh`j yivh lo| pj|paj i|pja jcap|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

24/1668

vljp :?76`f yjrcjh lpf

iycjaj~h`j hn hh Eijco~yihv `|c`(

^vjp Mjy|o |krc Eijco~yihv

Lo|f| yc j|j ocf ~vljy k|vrcj|hh ko|opoecf|o oeo jyjecjhajy fpeo~ot ecaj`j ^ocjmc Evwwfpcf|oh

~p ej`fafcf|o ocf lo|coepf hfaco |ic ~pcfhfh Ljljejh ~afp hh# P|eoyfyo j~ef| yhfpoa

pfmcoef~oh`fh -i jh ooh/ vtjecjp|`epjh ~ih|j# kfo `hfao ljljejhc k|fwoho ljj| ocf

pjajacjap( NMRocf Lja~tcj|`jh icvjh wf _PRhoh `j|`jh `f~pfecf`oo hn ~afp hh

Eijco~yihvhvh :?76 vljph`j lpf k|afcf|o ~|j~h`j `|caf~o ti| icajap( JR Kfhfc

Ljejh lycfnf ~afp Rjjy `fwo|fh j`ja m|fpoycf yfho ~foa ejarjhyj~hj ljcjyjnjep(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

25/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

26/1668

(; iy i|jhhj ~jmor

NEAR wf _PRhoh hfaco aoepj|`j iy yopo|afcf|ohf yic jap|( Lv ~foacf|`f NEAR iycj|hh lo|

lc ARhf kopaopo|( :?62 wf :?72c yccj|`j P|eoyf ~oyj~fpohoh ~f|p wf jho ecj|ycj hc

jm~oyfpo I~ajh Lceljhh AR~o I|pj Jhj`icv j Jaj~yj# _itkjp wf Hfwfmo|`f yt`f

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

27/1668

0

^cfyajh @fao|fc# V|gj`j mjcej ycf mopjr f`oyi|`v4

J~|cj|`| hf ~fhoh# hf invvhvh# hf `f mjywjhhh ej|h ~vyj `iyavpv|( Ihvh ooh ~fhoh lv

af~fcfho fh lye ~oyj~o af~fcf j``f`oyi|va# fh lye af`fho af~fcf j``f`oyi|va wf ~fh`fh#

kfcao kfao Meafpcf| j`hj# lph P|e ahfwwf|cf|o j`hj# af~cfepjcj|a j`hj t|

`ocoyi|va(

^jej|yj eihvaj~h`j# NMR co`f|o ~afp hhyf @R ocf JRhoh eec ljcj| eihv~vh`j ~f|plo| yjhp wf|oyi|`v4

Aoccfpoh yt`f 66oh`fh gjtcj~ icjh lv eopcfyf ej| lo| mhnht wj| a9 Je wf jcfho

~ycfyohot9 Lv eopcfyo ~vcv av j``f`oyi|~vhvt9 Wf|fnfohot nfwjlj k|f jcjnjht nfwjr icjnjep|(

Mf| wf~ocf ocf Lo|ohno @fao|e|jp# eohno @fao|e|jp# evy|ve# `e `oyf hf tjajhj ej`j| pftyog wf

pjmeo|f `fwja f`fnfe~ohot9 Hf tjajh P|eoyf`f aoccfpo pir yfevh icj|je ~fwor ocf|oyf ljeaj yicvhv

pvpjnje~ht9 -(/ hecjlh kfpo|`oo Jhjyj~j wf ejhvhcj| @faie|jp Rj|poyf |fy wf|ao icjhcj| ~vcv

~jya a9 ^oyj~o mjecj|h fccf|oh`fh jca wfyj e~pcja a9 -(/

@faie|j~ohoh pfafco mjce o|j`f~o`o|( Lo| pj|jgpjh ~foa yjrr fecfh `faie|j~o wj|a kolo

k~pf|or# `of| pj|jgpjh lj~e wf pf`mo v~vccf|oycf gooco `fwcfp o`j|f~o icjajt(

Efh`o aoccfpoho ev|v ejcjljce ~jyjhcj|j jn|a( Lph P|e wjpjh`jcj|hj ~f~cfhoyi|va4

Mfrohot kfcohot P|e aoccfpoho ~fwfcoa wf ihj `i~p icjca( Aoccfp o|j`f~ohf avpcje opjjpo jajt lo|

`~pv| icj|je jcjca( Mjecj|hj molo| |ojyfp~otcoe k~pf|afyfcoa( Ihj fc vtjpjca( Gjeo|coepfh#

~fgjcfppfh# nfmjcfppfh ev|pj|jca( J`fpcf|ohf# |g wf jhjhfcf|ohf# ajhfwoyjphj# avej``f~jphj#

ecp|hf# m|afpej| icjca( Ejlocoyfpohf# oh~jhchj opoajp f`fcoa( jcejhchj# yj|jpn knhf#

~ftoohf wf k|hf# pfnf``p wf pf|jeeo ~fwko~ohf opoajp f`fcoa( Pfajyccf|ohf# |fje~oyihcj|hj#

hfyo pj~wor f`or fpaf`oohf# j|tvcj|hj eyafp wf|fcoa# ~jykc icjca( v wfyj lv aje~jp ooh rfoh

meacf|cf lvhcj| ee k|afyf wfyj k~pf|afyf ejceajyjca( Efh`o aoccfpohoh mjecj|h

pjhajyjhcj|h j` hf`o|9 Lvhv `j eiyjca( Mf|mjc`f lvhvh j` tjcoa wf ti|lj icaje cjta kfco|(

Jtot wjpjh`jcj|a# aoccfpoh `f`oo icjnjep|5 lv lo| `|# hhf ejh ftfnfepo|(>6

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

28/1668

eyh`f# :?72pj 22 eyh`f fcfep|oe icjh P|eoyf`f yc`j

:222 eyf fcfep|oe mf`fgoycf of eiyvcjh ^cfyajh @fao|fc Meafpo# i `hfaoh fhf|do |fpoa

icjhjecj|ycj :?;2 ychj ej`j| < loh >=7 ey fcfep|of ejwvpv|avpv(

:?76pf ey wf eyc af~fcfcf|ohf locoa~fc lo| feoc`f ta kfpo|afe ooh ev|`v|`vv _ic ^v

Fcfep|oe -_^F/ Kfhfc A`|c ocf of ljcjyjh ^cfyajh @fao|fc5 :?7;`f _^F Pircjhp~h`j

lo|ohno jjajhh pjajacjh`h ycf ad`fcoyi|`v4

P|eoyf`f ey wf eyc af~fcfcf|ohoh hf|f~oh`fh ljcjyjca9

Ey wf eyc af~fcf~ohf fwwfcj eycy oh~jh yf|ohf eiyajecj ljcjyjnje~ht( Ey

af~fcf~oh`f eycy oh~jh yf|ohf eiyavyi| avyvt9 Af~fcf eiyj| kolo k|hr `f eiyaj`at

pje`o|`f no``ocfaopo|( Ihvh ooh`o| eo lvkh ooh`f lvcvh`vvavt af|mjcf P|eoyf`f eyaf~fcf~ohoh lo|ohno af|mjcf~ohoh mjccic`vv lo| `v|va`v|( _jho yv|`vavtvh mjhko ef~oh`f icv|~j

ic~vh eychh oh~jh yf|ohf eihaj~hh j|pe ahjejj~ lopaopo|( aop f`f|oa lopaopo|(

Lo| pj|jgpjh aefccfgoyfpcf| yecfyfnfe~ohot# l| pj|jgpjh mjecj|hj kfc`oohot tjajh lv

mjecj|hj cjye `foc`o| `oyfnfeohot( Lvhvh af`fhoyfpocoecf oh~jhoyfpocoecf molo| jcjej~

yiepv|(>7

:?76!:?;:`f JRhoh pfe ljhj oepo`j| `hfaoh`f P|eoyfhoh jepog `fr|fa mjpph`j lvcvhaj~

hf`fhoycf5 Wj|pi -:?77/# Kf`ot -:?;2/ `fr|facf|ohoh yj|jcj|h ~j|aje `j Meafpoh `ijc k|fwcf|oj|j~h`j icavpv|(

Wj|pi`j# ; Aj|p :?77 kh :0 loh eoohoh cahf yic jjh 6(7 o``fpoh` f lo| `fr|fa ic`v(

Jyh ych :? Jv~pi~vh`j o~f# 7(? o``fpoh`feo `fr|fa`f < loh >?0 eoo njh wf|aopo(

Kf`ot`f#

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

29/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

30/1668

>2

:?7< EljE|otohoh je lo| feoc`f wv|kvcjaj~h`jh ~ih|j# vcv~cj|j|j~ ricopoejhh yjr~ wf

vh~v|cj|h`j f~j~c `fooecoecf| i|pjyj eap|( :?7< Elj E|oto tf|ohf# JL@hoh# ai`j~ kfao

locf ic~j# P|eoyfhoh |tj~h jcaj`jh# P|eoyf`feo Dropf| Gtfcf|oho ~eafyf ej|j| wf|af~o#

P|eoyfhoh lv cef mjeeh`jeo rmfcf|oho j|pp||efh5 wf P|e!Jaf|oejh ocoeocf|oho lvcjh`||efh5

:?70 Dimh~ih Afepvlv# lvcjhe wf rmfno `v|vav l~lph kf|kohcof`hp|ap|(

:?72cj|h i|pj~h`jh opolj|fh wf tfccoecf JR `hfaoh`f ie pj|pcjh eoco Jhpcjajcj| eihv~v#

P|eoyfHJPIyj ejpc`epjh ~ih|j i|pjyj ejh lo| af~fcf`o|( P|eoyf @ocf|o Ljejhchh# :?62`fh hnf# >:o :?62!:?72 j|j~h`j wf Pfaavt :?7?`j# P|e!Jaf|oejh

^jwvhaj lo|coo Jhpcjaj~ oatjcjhap|(>?

:< Feoa :?7? Kfhfc ^foacf|o

~ph F|k`f|oh pf~ropcf|ohf k|f5 |fejlfpf `jyjc rj|po ~o~pfaohf :?07!:?62 `hfaoh`f

kfopfh opolj|fh oeo rj|pohoh fkfafhcoo P|e rj|po ~o~pfaohoh fh lfco|koh tfccoo icavpv wf :< Feoa

:?7? kfhfc ~foacf|oh`f `f P|e rj|po ~o~pfaohoh oeo rj|pohoh fkfafhcoo jcph`j icaj~ `v|vav

~|ap(

JR# ho~ro pfa~oc ~o~pfaohf |jafh# kfhfc iyvh yt`f 07(6oho jcap( \jeolo NMRhoh iy i|jh

yt`f

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

31/1668

>:

Lja~tcj|4 6::(2>> iy-yt`f 6(7 ~jh`jcyf -yt`f

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

32/1668

>>

:?76pf JRhoh pfe ljhj wf lye lo| tjgf| ejtjhj|je oepo`j|j kfcaf~oh`fh ~ih|j I|pjhh

^icv ~cikjhycj af|eftoh ~icvh`j yf| jcajyj jcjh NMRh`f ~foa yfhocko~ohoh `f fpeo~oycf lo|

`jckjcjhaj yjjhap|(

Lcfhp Fnfwop# :?77`j yjt` lo| eopjrpj# NMRhf e~fh iycj| ef~oa`f pircjajepj`|4

-:/ NMRhoh yjrp wfyj yjrjnj |fgi|acj|cj efh`o lo| c`f ~j|~cjnje icjh ljt NMRcocf|oh

iycj| Pir|je |fgi|avycj lo| e~a pir|jecj| jchjlocfnfe ljt lye pir|jeccj|5 pj|a~jc kfco|

wf|ko~oycf# oce `fgj wf|ko `fafyf ljcjyjh ljt ye~fe kfco|co ogpocf|5 wf|ko jecjaj~ `icjy~ycj

ie wf|ko `fafe ti|vh`j ejcjhcj|# lv j|j`j ~jycjloco|(

-/ NMRyo i|pjhh ~icvh`j# |fgi|anvcvepj# yfpf|o ej`j| nf~v|# ej|j|c wf ocf|o k|afyfh ljt

NMRcocf|oh iycj|(

Fnfwopf k|f lv ef~oa`fh ~jynj fh ee icjh lo|ohno~o`o|( eohno ef~oa`feocf|oh ~jycj|

`jmj iepv|( hn ef~oa`feocf|oh o~f mfa ~jycj| iepv|# mfa `f lvhcj|# NMR kolo `fw|oano lo|

rj|pohoh `ohjaoe knh pfeoc fppoecf|o ooh# `f~pfecf|oho f~o|kfafecf NMRyf wf|flocfnfecf|o tj|j|#

~jycj|ycj mf~jrcjhajyjnje ej`j| lyep|(0=

Rj|po`f ej|p k|vrcj| j|j~h`j o``fpco lo| mf~jrcjaj kh`fa`f`o|( Efh`o jhcjpacj|hj k|fI|pjhh ^icvh`j wf ^j`j yf| pvpjh oeo k|vr j|j~h`jeo anj`fcf`f Kfhfc Ljejh hh lo|ohnocf|oh

yjho yfhocoeocf|oh ~jgh`j icav wf ljcjpcjh `fooa mj|fefpoho `f~pfecfaopo|( I|pjhh ^icv

mj|fefpohoh ~tn~# NMRhoh hnf Kfhfc ^fe|fpf|coohf -:= Feoa :?77/ ~ih|j Kfhfc Ljejhchj

-:0 Ajy~ :?;

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

34/1668

>0

NMRcocf|oh# Feoa :?7=`feo :?( Ev|vcpjy`jh ~ih|j Lcfhp Fnfwopoh h`f|cooh`f I|pjhh ^icv

j`ycj ljcjppecj| rj|po!oo `ha5 :?7? ~foacf|o ooh yjyacj`ecj| loc`o|kf`f jej `tfh

`fooecoo fecoh`f j`cjh`|`ecj| wf yfho eoacoecf ~fafh ej|~hj epecj| locohafepf`o|( :?7?

~foacf|oh`f rj|po!oo mf~jrcjajcj|h yic jp lchaf wf jy|cajcj| yth`fh NMRhoh iycj|

yt`f

aoccfpwfeoco ~ieajy ljj|acj|`|( :?76`f lv ~jy :>0 o`o(

P|e Mj|fefp

:?72`j NMR ocf lo|coepf wj|ch ~|`|fh I~ajh Lcelj co`f|cooh`feo Nvamv|oyfpo Eyc

Aoccfp Rj|po~o -NEAR/# :?72cj|h i|pj~h`j eoacoe `fooao yjja5 :?7?`j o~f Aoccoyfpo Mj|fefp

Rj|po~o -AMR/ j`h jcj|je# P|ece jeahh |kpc ~oyj~jc kn eihvavhj ye~fcaopo|(

Ljcjhkpj ee pir|je ~jmolo wf f~hjgh ej|cj|h pfa~oc f`fh NEAR# I~ajh Lcelj wf

j|ej`jcj|hh :?7< ych`j jy|caj~ ocf fpeohcooho tjpfh yopo|aopo( eohno ~afp hhwf j|`h`jh ^vjp

Mjy|o |krc Eijco~yihcj|hj ejpcaj~ rj|poyo lo| ~|f `jmj yjjpjlocaopo( :?76pf yv|p `h`jh

~|kh`fh `hfh

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

35/1668

>6

Eynce

M||oyfpocoe wf jm~oyfpocoe

Kfcoafnocoe wf Mjcece

Fh`~p|onocoe wf Pfehoeocoe(

:?00 P|ece pfweogjphh# :?62cf|`f I|`v`jeo kotco gjjcoyfpcf|oh wf :?72`j j~ef|o

a`jmjcfhoh vhvpvcajt o~ao Jcrj|~cjh P|ef# lo| ~|f yv|p`h`j ~|kh`f ejc`epjh ~ih|j efh`o

ooh`f yjj`!kotco |kpcf|`fh rj|pocfafyf i|v!`fooa ~|fnoho -:?7?`j/ ycf jhcjpajepj`|4

-(/ h~jh `fofh j|pcj| ej|~h`j mfr jyh ej|j| tf|oh`f ohjp f`f|~f avwjggje icjajt(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

36/1668

>7

-(/ AMR Mj|fefpo `fhocfh o`ficidoe wf ~oyj~o kfcoafhoh ejyhj P|ece wf Pv|jhnch# eecf|o

Nvamv|oyfp hnf~ohf ko`fh goe|o# o`ficidoe wf ~oyj~o lo|oeoao`o|( -(/60

P|e pircvavhvh jcp ~i~yjc `ocoa`fh afy`jhj kfc`ooho ~ycfyfh wf oepo`j|h`j ~t eihv~v jcp

af~cfe `ocoaoho ei|ri|j~yihcj| mjcoh`f |kpcfyf|fe cefyo yhfpafyf pjcor icjh AMRhoh aoccoyfpocoe

`hnf~o f~j~ opolj|oycf :?00pfeo P|ecejeahh :?72cj|j yjh~aj~`|( @hyjhh hf|f~oh`fP|e wj|~j# P|e aoccoyfpocf|ohoh ockocf|o ooh`f`o|( @ P|ecf| ooh fc`fh hf kfco|~f yjrajy P|e

aoccoyfpocf|ohoh liyhvhj li| ~jyj|t# `fafe ~v|fpoycf o wf ` ejaviyvhj ~t wf|ocaf~o lv pvpvavh

je |hfo`o|(66P|ef# ` P|ecf| eihv~vh`j `hfaohoh ocf|o~oh`f lo| k|f ~jmor icav wf lv

eihv`jeo kjy|fpcf|o ocf P|e @hyj~h`j mjec lo| m|fp ejtjhap|(

:?76pfh :?7?j ej`j| kffh `|p yc NEARhoh AMR j`ycj `ha# rj|po`f yfho pftcf|oh

yf|cfaf~o# rj|po |kpcf|ohoh yv|p kfhfcoh`f kcfhor yjykhcjaj~ oyf jhcjaje kf|fe(

AMR j~c lye ~|jaj~h :?;2co yccj|`j -: Ho~jh :?;6/ Lo|ohno Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf Eijco~yihvhj

ejpcj|je yjrap|( :?;> ~foacf|oh`f ejtjh` > ~jh`jcyfyo :?;; ~foacf|oh`f :7yj ej|pa# cef

kfhfcoh`f yjecje : aocyihcve ~fafh eopcf~oho efh`o~ohf ljcjajy ljj|a# jepog lo| ~oyj~o hn

eihvavhj ye~fcaopo|(

~ph F|k`f|# AMRhoh :?;; ~foacf|oh`feo ljj|~ycj ockoco icj|je v `ff|cfh`o|afyo

yjrajepj`|4

:?;>!:?;; j|j~h`j lj~h pj|jgh`jh epcfh`oo mjc`f AMR# aoccoyfpocoe wf jhpo!eiahota ocf

~i~yi!feihiaoe `fooa `icjy~ycj o~poe|j|~tcjjh lo| pircva`j yjrcjh :?;; ~foacf|oh`f j|pn

lo| ljj| ejtjhap|( JRco ricopoejncj|h i|pje ei|evcj|h`jh lo|o~o# -eo lv co`f|cooh fcfpo|o~o looaohf

`f `hafepf`o|/# AMRhoh JRyo `f~pfecfyfh pjljh jh`|ajepj ljj|c icjnj5 wf ~foa hnf~o

wf ~ih|j~h`jeo ~j ejhjp eijco~yihcj|h`j iyhj` |ich AMRyo evwwfpcfh`o|fnfoy`o(67

^i~yjco~pcf|

:?72 mpocjcohoh ~ihvnv :?7: Jhjyj~j~ ocf ko|ocfh `faie|j~o i|pjah`j yf|jcph`jh ejh

^i~yjco~p mj|fefp# :?76 kfhfc ~foacf|oh`f P|eoyf o Rj|po~o -PR/ j`ycj oce eft rj|cjafhpi`j

pfa~oc oaejhhj ejwvavpv|( :> vljp :?7:`f lo| k|vr ~fh`oejn pj|jgh`jh ev|vcjh PR# ~pjhlvc

Mveve Gjecpf~o f~eo |fpoa yfcf|oh`fh Afmafp Jco Jylj|h -:?:2!:??6/ Kfhfc Ljejhcj

kfpo|ocaf~oycf ~oyj~fppf wj|ch mo~~fppo|afyf ljcjap|( Afmafp Jco Jylj|# efh`o~ohf kfhfc

ljejhce pfecogohoh yjrc` kfnfyo ycf jhcjpajepj`|4

_jpajyj mjt|cjhyi|`ve( Ejr jch`( Lv ~jjpf eoa icjloco|`o9 ^o|fp UfoQ yjh rfhnf|f`fh

ljep# pjhaj`a oh~jhcj|# rico~ wf lfeo `f wj| `f`o( Kfnfhoh i ~jjpcf|oh`f rico~co lfeoco toyj|fpocf|

mjy|c ocf| ooh kfcaftcf| Ejry jpa( j|`a( PRoh ev|vnvcj| -(/( Mjy|icj* Iylo|coo ocf ej|j|

jc`e4 Kfhfc Ljejhc ejlvc fpafhoto o~poyi|vt# `f`ocf| j|apa( Ljejhcj kfpo|ocafa yfho~vcjajcj|j ~jc`|cj|j yic hf`fh icjloco|( Lo| ~icnvhvh PRf ljejh icaj~hj kt yvaajtcj|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

37/1668

>;

Loc`oohot kolo mjeea`j eiahota r|irjkjh`j~h`jh jca oeo `jwj wj|( Lvhcj| rj|poyf ej|

evccjhjloco|cf|( Ej yjrjca `f|efh kt ej|pajyjca( Lo| eft `jmj `hh( hfaco lo| j`a jppht

yjte icaj~h# `oyf ejykcj|a lfco|pfh ~tcf| ~ycf`oa( -(/6;

PRhoh ?!:2 vljp :?70pf# tao|`f pircjhjh Lo|ohno Lye Eihk|f~oh`f ejlvc fppoo r|ik|jah

ljh`j P|eoyfLye Aoccfp Afnco~ohoh

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

38/1668

>=

Pir|je~t wf jt pir|jec eycyf pir|je wf|ocaf~o(

Pj|a`j eo|jnce wf i|pjech yie~vc eyc cfmohf tfhcfhaf~o(

~otcoe ~oki|pj~(

Rfp|ich aoccocfpo|ocaf~o(

Pj~j||vg lihicj|hh orpjco(

_jljhn ~f|ajyfyo pfwoe ejhvhvhvh orpjco(

wf|fhoh ciejwp mjeeh ejc`|jh wf k|fwcf|cf ockoco yj~je wf ~h|cjajcj| fh jtj oh`o|fh#

meafpoh yfpeo~oho e~pcjyjh `tfhcfaf(

Wf|ko yeh fafeo`fh ~f|ajyf wf pir|je ~jmolohf ejy`|jh `tfhcfaf(

Ey lckf ievccj| ev|vcaj~ wf oceievc |fhnocf|ohf `f|~ j|j wf kf|fcf|ohoh rj|j~t

wf|ocaf~o(6?

:?72cj| P|eoyf~oh`f lv p| ejhvh pfecogcf|o jccaj`e icjycj|`|( :6 ~i~yjco~p aoccfpwfeocohoh

rj|cjafhpi`j yf| jcjlocafcf|o locf ~oyj~fp ev|vav ooh pfe ljhj |fhecocoe wf njhcce icavpv|(

PR# ~jyc Jg Ejhvhvhvh ljt aj``fcf|ohoh Jhjyj~j

Ajmefaf~ohnf orpjco tf|ohf :< Pfaavt :?;0pf pjmcoyf f`ocaocf|`o|(72

~cjan Mj|fefp

:?72cj| ~ihvh`j P|eoyf Ponj|fp wf ^jhjyo I`jcj| Lo|cooh`feo jhcjajtcecj| yth`fh

~pjhlvc wf tao|`feo lye o fw|fcf|ohf ej| Jhj`icvhvh ee wf i|pj lyecepfeo oy f|o

~jmorcf|oho pfa~oc f`fh ef~oacf| jy| lo| ~oyj~ rj|po jp~ jcph`j pircjhaj kf|fo `vyavcj|`|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

39/1668

>?

:?7= ych`j Jhej|j# Ljcef~o|# Lv|~j# jhjeejcf# @fhotco# F`o|hf# F~eofmo|# fc# O~rj|pj#

Ejy~f|o# E|ecj|fco# Einjfco# Eihyj# Ajho~j# ^jej|yj# ^ja~vh wf Tihkvc`je( -(/ f~hjg wf `oh

`f|hfecf|ohoh Ugjjcoyfpo ljeah`jhQ kfcoao# ejropjco~pcfao wf gj|eccja occf|oaot`o|( -(/ ULvQ

occf|oaot`f f~hjg `f|hfecf|o ocf `oh `f|hfecf|o j|j~h`j k|cfh lv yjeh ocoeo# kfcoaf wf

ejropjco~pcfafyf ej| icvjh ~cjan pfreohoh pfafcoh`f f~hjg |kphh lo| e~ahh yjpp

wj|~jyah kcfh`o|afepf`o|(7:

AHR# = vljp :?;2`f Jhej|j`j# lo|ohno eihk|f~oho yjrap|( Rj|pohoh ev|vcv

lfyjhhjaf~oh`f5 Jccjmh# mjee pvpaj# oyoyo ~jcjaj wf epy afh fpaf yicvh`j lvcvhaje tf|f

~fpoo aapjt wf jtot aoccfpoaotUohQ -(/ j~|cj|`jh lf|o tcfyor Ulfecf`ooQ efh`o |vmvhvh

`f|ohcoecf|oh`fh kfcfh -(/ ajhj wf aj``f ~jmj~h`j yfho`fh `ivvh`jh ljej lo| fy icajyjh UAocco

Hotja Rj|po~ohohQ -(/ aoccfpoaotoh gp|jph`j afwnvp jmcje wf gjtocfpo evwwf`fh goocf ej|aje wf lv

~jyf`f nfaoyfpoaotf hotja# mvtv|# opoajo j`jcfp -(/ ~jj`fp wf ~fcjafp kfpo|afe kjyf~oycf

ev|vc`vv# lfco|pocf|fe5 Mjeeh yj|`aycj ie yjeh lo| kfcfnfepf# aoccfpoaotoh yfho`fh lph`hyjyj |hfe lye lo| af`fhoyfp ev|jnj# ad`fcfhaopo|(7

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

40/1668

02

Je# kotco wf avt| -tj|j|c/ o~|jgh hcfhaf~o5

^a|n gjotnocooh tj|j|cj|h`jh mjceath wf feihiaoaotoh ev|pj|caj~5

Wf|koyo ~ihvh`j gjeo|f yecfyfh ~o~pfaoh `fopo|ocaf~o5

E|f`o ~o~pfaohoh pjajahh -`fopo|ocf|fe/ -(/ jcaje o~pfyfh oh~jhcj|h mf| tjajh# ocf|ohoh

wf|oacocoecf|o `f|fnf~oh`f rj|j lvcjnjecj| lo| hotjah -`tfhoh/# kfpo|ocaf~o5

Pir|jepjh jtjao o~pogj`f-yo/ ~jcjyjnje yfho f~j~cj|-h/ -kfpo|ocaf~o/5

-(/ jcajy olj`fp je yjrjnje |vmvh omyj~5

Aocco pv|otaf -`hcf|fe/ aocco afgmj|oaot-oh/# fmopcf|oaot-oh/# fwcoyjcj|at-h/ -pjhhaj~/70

AHRhoh ev|vcvv ocf P|eoyf`f `oho avmjcfgfp oce `fgj efh`o ljhj i|pjyj eajepj`|( @R wfJR`fh gj|ec icj|je AHR# `oho avmjcfgfpo efh`o ~i~yi!feihiaoe pjljhhj `jyjh`|j|je |kpcfafyo

ljj|ap|(76

Hfnafppoh F|ljejh wf fw|f~o tfccoecf j| ~jhjyoohoh kfcopo|ocaf~oho ~jwvhvyi|cj|`( Jw|vrj

I|pje Rjtj|hj ko|ocaf~ohf `f ef~ohcoecf ej| o`ocf|( AHR : yc`jh lo|jt gjtcj yjjyjlocao5 :< Aj|p

:?;: j~ef| a`jmjcf~oh`fh mfafh ~ih|j gjjcoyfpcf|oh`f `oho h rcjhj jcj|je cjoecof jye|

`jw|jh` kf|fef~oycf ejrjpcap| -

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

41/1668

0:

anj`fcf~o wf|oyi|cj|`( Lv ljea`jh okjc kolo ejhvhcj|j jye| fycfacf|`fh gjtcj micjhayi|cj|`(

pf yjh`jh i|pi`ie~ focoacf|o pfa~oc f`fh ljt PR yhfponocf|o lo| oo ~hg rj|po~o icajy vavyi|

wf howf|~opf`fh# |fhno kfhcoepfh vtje `v|ajy pf|nom f`oyi|cj|`( l| k|vr o~f oceoh

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

42/1668

02`j# `|`at -Kfhfcev|ajy Ljejh wf Evwwfp Eiavpjhcj|/

Kfhfcev|ajy`j pircjh`e( Ei|kfhf|jc Efajc Pj|jh# mjt|cj` afpho iev`v( J|jat`j atjef|f

fppoe# afpho ie vtvh lvc`ve# of|oo `f lotoa o~pfecf|oaoto rfe ej|cjayi|`v( Lfh yfho lo|

a~wf``fyo yjtj|efh# Gj|ve Rjj -K|cf|/ wf I|jao|jc -Nfcjc/ Fyonficv yjhaj kfcf|fe yj|`anic`vcj|( Afpoh i|pjyj ep# `jepoci f`oc`o# oatjyj mjt|`( Afa`vm Rjj kfhf `f|oh lo| `hnfyf

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

43/1668

0>

`jc`# vtvh ~|f oatjcjaje o~pfaf`o# ktcf|o yjj|`( Mjec o`o `f# ~ihvhvh hf|fyf wj|jnj lfcco

icajyjh hfaco lo| j`a jpcjnjep( ^jjp :(22

mjlf|cf|ohoh ljh`j P|eoyfyf wf `hyjyj `vyv|vc`v( cf`fh ~ih|j :6(>2`j pfe|j|

Kfhfcev|ajy`j pircjh`e wf kfcoafcf|o pjeolf ljcj`e( -(/7=

:< Aj|p Avmp|j~ |j`yi`j ievh`vepjh < ~jjp ~ih|j# P|eoyfLye Aoccfp Afnco~o Kfhfc Ev|vcv#

~jjp :6pf ljcjap( Ipv|vav yhfpfh Ljejhwfeoco fcoh`feo ~j| tj|g jp# Eiavpjhcj|h ocfppoecf|o

Avmp|jy ievpjnjh ~ycf`o( Kfhfc Ev|vc`j lvt kolo lo| ~f~~otcoe ic`v( Afnco~ pj|omoh`f oce eft lo|

j~ef|o avmp|j e|~`fh ievhjnjep# yjchtnj lo| pfe eoo jyjj ejcep wf opo|jt fppo4

@faie|jpoe Rj|po K|vr Ljejh Wfeoco Mj~jh Ei|eajtnjh5 Pte jep|( Lv|j`j yj

Nvamv|ljejhc pftef|f~o ievhv|5 yj Ljljejhce pftef|f~o ievhv|5 yj Afnco~ Ljejhc pf~ef|f~o

ievhv|( I|`v pftef|f~o ievhajt# `oyi|`v( Jaj lv opo|jt nct lo| ~f~ icj|je ejc`( Avmp|j afpho

ievh`v5 lo| pfe fcAoccfpwfeoco Nfcjc Ej|kchh jce ~f~o `vyvc`v( Wf P|eoyf Lye Aoccfp Afnco~o

molo| fy icaja kolo kh`faoh`feo `of| aj``fcf|o k|afyf kfpo( Afnco~ yfhocao# lph

vavpcj| eap(

^cfyajh @fao|fc# yccj| ~ih|j# Afmafp Jco Lo|jh` wf j|ej`jcj|hh :< Aj|p Lfckf~fco ooh

eihvv|efh i khcf| ooh v `ff|cfh`o|afyo yjrap4

Lo| Nvamv|oyfpf wf lo| Rj|cjafhpiyj lo| eoo# oeo eoo ~jmor ej|je lo| yf|f wj|jajt~ht(

Khc o~pf| eo mf|ef~ jyjj ejce~h( -(/7?

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

44/1668

00

Fnfwopoh lv pvpvav ljcjhkpj oyo jhcjcjaja# -~ih|jeo yccj|`j/ :< Aj|p :?;: pj|omco I|`v

Avmp|j~hj o``fpcf ej| ejh fw|fcf|ohmfafh pjaja oce jh`j eiavpjhcj| `f~pfecf| ajmoyfppf

pvpva jcacj|`(

Av|jp Lfckfyf k|f# ~ic focoacocf|oh ljtcj| oce jh`j I|`vhvh oepo`j| fcf jch `f~pfecfyfh

loc`o|ocf| yjyacjap( ^ic# j~ef|o a`jmjcfyo e~afh efh`o ljj|~ icj|je yi|vacjaj yeaccmo~~fpao wf eopcfcf|oh iy mjee ocef~ohf ~jmor eajepj yfpf|~ot ejcap(;

:< Aj|p :?;: kh P|e ^ocjmc Evwwfpcf|o j`hj Kfhfcev|ajy Ljejh I|kfhf|jc Afa`vm

Pjaj# Ej|j Evwwfpcf|o Eiavpjh Gj|ve K|cf|# MjwjEvwwfpcf|o Eiavpjh Avm~oh Ljpv| wf @fhot

Evwwfpcf|o Eiavpjh Nfcjc Fyonficv oatjcj|ycj |j`yihvh :>(22 mjlf| lcpfhoh`f ievhjh avmp|j

ycf`o|4

-:/( Rj|cjafhpi wf Meafp ~|fkfcfh pvpva# k| wf on|jjp ocf yv|`vavtv jhj|o# ej|`f

ejwkj~# ~i~yjc wf feihiaoe mvtv|~vtcvecj| oohf ~ieav# Jpjp|eh lotf mf`fg wf|`oo j`j

vykj|ce ~fwoyf~ohf vcjaje ao`oho ejaviyvh`j yopo|ao wf Jhjyj~jhh hk|` |fgi|acj|

pjmjeeve fppo|fafao icvr# P|eoyf Nvamv|oyfpohoh kfcfnfo j| lo| pfmcoef oohf `|cap|(

-/( Lv mv~v~ ~|jpcf pjmjeeve fppo|ocfaf`oo pje`o|`f# P|e ^ocjmc Evwwfpcf|o ejhvhcj|h

efh`o~ohf wf|ao ic`vv P|eoyf Nvamv|oyfpoho ei|vaje wf eiccjaje k|fwoho yf|ohf kfpo|f|fe# o`j|fyo

`i|v`jh `i|vyj tf|ohf jcajyj ej|j|c`|(

Pfehie|jp Meafpcf|o

I|`v to|wf~o# avmp|j afphoh`fh jhcjcjnj tf|f efh`o `fyoaoycf jhj|o wf feihiaoe wf ~i~yjc

mvtv|~vtcvecj|`jh rj|cjafhpiyv wf meafpo lo|coepf ~i|vacv pvpvyi|# ta `f yohf jyh rj|cjafhpihvh

ooh`f j|yi|`v( I|`vhvh ~omo|co k pj`hj ohjhcjh gi|achf k|f5 pj|jg~t lo| Ljljejh oeo lye

rj|po`fh -JR wf NMR/ icvjnje lo| Pfehie|jpcj| Ejlohf~o ocf cef ~i|vhcj|hj ta lvcv|`v(

Rj|po~oh`fh lv jajcj o~pogj fppo|ocfh wf :? Aj|p :?;: kh rj|pocf| ~p Ljljejh icj|je

k|fwcfh`o|ocfhNMRco R|ig( Homj` F|oa -:?:

NMRco# : Aocc Lo|coe K|vlv -ALK/ yf~o ocf Rj|cjafhpi h`jh :0 pfehie|jp wj|`(;0

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

45/1668

06

Rj|pocf| ~p meafp# = Ho~jh`j kwfhiyv jc`epjh ~ih|j fh no``o wf ejcn fpeocf|o lvcvhjh

on|jjp pf I|`vhvh ktfpoao jcph`j rj|cjafhpi pj|jgh`jh kf|fecfpo|ocfh Jhjyj~j

`fooecoecf|ohoh hfacocf|o vhcj|`|4

Aocco Kwfhcoe Ev|vcvhvh jhjyj~jc eihvav kcfh`o|ocaopo|(

Ljejhcj| Ev|vcvhj ejhvh meah`f ej|j|hjaf ej|aj yfpeo~o wf|ocaopo|(

^eyhfpoao kf|fepo|fh v|vacj|h ejr~ja kfhocfpocaopo|(

Pfafc mjecj|h evccjhcaj~hj yfho ~h|cjajcj| kfpo|ocao# lv jajcj kfhfc lo| yj~jefecfhaopo|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

46/1668

07

Ajmefaf ej|j| icaj`jh ljt mjccf|`f kjtfpf pircjpcjlocaf~o(

Ktjcph`j pvpaj ~|f~o hnf ; ~ih|j :6 khf ej|cap|(

Afav|cj|h ~fh`oejcj|jyf icajcj| yj~jecjhap|(

Meafpf ejhvh knh`f ej|j|hjaf ej|paj yfpeo~o pjhhap|(

P\Phoh tf|ecoo ejc`|cap|(

howf|~opfhoh tf|ecoo ~h|cjh`|cap|(

@fwcfp Kwfhcoe Ajmefafcf|ohoh ev|vcaj~ hk|cap|(

I|`vhvh fcoh`feo ajccj|h `fhfpcfhaf~o v~vccf|ohf ^jypjyh lv eihv`jeo yfpeocf|oho

~h|cjyjh lo| kotcocoe vh~v|v kfpo|ocaopo|( ;;

Aapjt ^iy~jcj k|f# :?;: wf :?;>pf kf|fecfpo|ocfh Jhjyj~j `fooecoecf|o# `fwcfpoh pfafc

hopfcoecf|oho wf ocefcf|oho# ocf|oyf `he yi|vacj|j je lo| jhjyj~jycj `foc# ejcrcja wf

`v|kvhcja ev|jccj|cj ei|vaje jajnh k`yi|`v( _|pafyo kc `v|vaj kfpo|afhoh kf|o~oh`f#

j~c yjrcaje o~pfhfh fy# Jhjyj~j`jeo tk|cecf| `tfhohoh wf tf|e ev|vcvcj| afejhotaj~hh

yfho `fhkfcf| j|jaje ooh `foc# yf|cfoe `tfho -~pjpeiyv/ ei|vaje ooh evccjhcaj~h ~jcjajep(;=

Ecjyj @h

R|ig( Homj` F|oa# ::cf|oh o~pogj~h`jh ~ih|j :: J|jce :?;: kh oeohno meafpoho ev|av# gjejp

i `j !:?=;/# Nvamv|ljejh ~foc`o(

Jl`o rfeohoh# : Ho~jh :?;> khc ljyjt~h`j I|`v ocf Rj|cjafhpi j|j~h`j yjjhjh `fwcfp

e|oto ocf ockoco `ff|cfh`o|af~o ycf o`o4

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

47/1668

0;

Nvamv|ljejh ~foao# kfcfhfe~fc kcf| ocf yfho kcf| j|j~h`jeo anj`fcfyo ~iavpcjp|jh

lo| icjy hopfcooho ejtjhap|( Lv icjyh pfafcoh`f yhfpoa`feo j|cecj|h ei|vaje o~pfyfh ~owoc!j~ef|

jy`hcj|# l|ie|jpcj| ocf lv j|cj ~ih wf|afyo ocfyfhcf|oh jpaj~ wj|`|(= JRco# 7NKRco# > Lja~t wf Rj|cjafhpi `h`jh < pfehie|jppjhicvjh Hjoa Pjc Eijco~yihvhj NMRyf

wf|afaopo( Lv `v|va meafppf JRhoh fpeo~oho j|pp|`( Gf|op Afcfh Meafpohoh r|ik|jah`j locf

I|`vhvh o~pf`oo ljt |fgi|acj| yf| jcaefh# Pjcv Eijco~yihvhvh r|ik|jah`j j|pe |fgi|acj|`jh ~t

f`ocafafepfy`o( Eijco~yih efh`o~oho# cefyo ~foacf|f kp|fnfe kfono meafp fecoh`f

pjhpyi|`v(=>

P|eoyf Nvamv|oyfpoh`f yjecje oeo yc ~|fh :< Aj|p :?;: yhfpoao# 7 jyce lo| kfo

~|fnoh`fh ~ih|j hiepjcjhyi|`v(

~ajoc Nfaoh `f`oo kol# :< Aj|p# lph jcj|`jh ej|c ie rjmjcyj `fhao lo| `f|~

icj|je mjgtjcj|`j yf|oho jcap(=0

:?;> kfhfc ~foacf|oycf ljcjyjh# gjejp# :< Fycc :?=2`f lo| ljej j~ef| a`jmjcf ocf ~ihj

f|fnfe yfho lo| ~owoc `hfaf kfocoyi|`v(

:0 Feoa :?;> Kfhfc

^foacf|o:0 Feoa :?;> kh yjrcjh kfhfc ~foacf|f J`jcfp Rj|po~o -JR/# Nvamv|oyfp Mjce Rj|po~o

-NMR/# Nvamv|oyfpo Kwfh Rj|po~o -NKR/# @faie|jpoe Rj|po -@R/# Aoccoyfpo Mj|fefp Rj|po~o -AMR/#

Aoccfp Rj|po~o -AR/# Aocco ^fcjafp Rj|po~o -A^R/# P|eoyf Lo|coe Rj|po~o -PLR/ wf Lja~tcj|

ejpcacj|`(

:0 Feoa :?;> Aoccfpwfeoco ^foacf|oh`f Iycj|h wf ^jh`jcyfcf|oh @jca4

NMR 4 >(6;2(6=> iy -yt`f >>(>/ :=6 ~jh`jcyf -yt`f 0:(:/(

JR 4 >(:?;(=;? iy -yt`f

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

48/1668

0=

AR 4 7;; iy -yt`f 2(7/(

~ph F|k`f|# :?;> ~foacf|ohoh# P|e ~foa pj|omo ooh ie hfaco ic`vvhj oj|fp fpafepf`o|(

he lv ~foacf|`f# oeo lye rj|pohoh fkfafhcoo ~ihj f|aopo( eo hfaco ee rj|po# A^R wf @R #

~foacf|`fh no``o lo| iy i|jhycj eajy ljj|acj|`(=6

Ktcfanocf| wf ejaviyv# ^cfyajh @fao|fc ocf lo|coepf JR tjgf|o `cf|efh 062 ~jh`jcyf`fh

:0?vhv lv rj|po# :=6oho :?76pfh ~ih|j kfcopo|`oo af|eft!~ic jca wf :?; kfhfc ~foacf|ohf JRh`fh ljej eopcf `f~pfo lvcjlocfh rj|po `jmj ejpcap(

:?7?`j JRhf ej| Eihyj`j pfe ljhj lye lo| ~foa tjgf|o ejtjhjh Hfnafppoh F|ljejh

co`f|cooh`f AHRhoh -Aocc Hotja Rj|po~o/ Jhjyj~j Ajmefaf~ohnf ejrjpcaj~h`jh ~ih|j yohf jyh

fw|fcf|nf ev|vcjh A^R -Aocc ^fcafp Rj|po~o/ ocf JRh`fh jy|cjh ricopoejncj|h ev|`vv# Afnco~ F~eo

Ljejh Gf||vm Litlfyco co`f|cooh`f @R -@faie|jpoe Rj|po/ wf :?;2cf| ljh`j P|e pftcf|oycf

tfccoecf kfhcoe ef~oaoh`f pj|jgpj| lvcjh Jcrj~cjh P|efoh co`f|cooh`f AMR -Aoccoyfpo Mj|fefp

Rj|po~o/(

^j ejhjp ~fafhoh rj|pocf|f k|f `jcaj~ ~ihvnv JRhoh :0? ~jh`jcyf~o `h`j# A^R 0=#

@R 06# AMR > ~jh`jcyf ejtjhacj| ( ^j ejhjp rj|pocf|ohoh pircja ~jh`jcyf ~jy~ -:0?%0=%06%>/

iy ocf :> ~jh`jcyf# lo| af|eft rj|po~o k|hah`f icjh wf lye icj~cecj

kfcfhfe~fc NMR ~fafhoh`fh iy jcjh f~eo NMRco R|ig( Pv|mjh Gfytoicvhvh -:?-Nvamv|oyfpo Kwfh Rj|po~o/ :> ~jh`jcyf ejtjhap( Jcfwo ef~oaoh ~tnc ooh yicj ejh wf ljt

~i~yjco~p k|vrcj|cj olo|coo yjrj|je ~foaf ko|flocfh Av~pjgj Poao~o co`f|cooh`f PLR -P|eoyf Lo|coe

Rj|po~o/ o~f yt`f : iy ocf jhnje : ~jh`jcyf ejtjhjlocaopo(=7

P|eoyf ~oyj~fpoh`f :?;> kfhfc ~foacf|oh`fh :< Fycc :?=2 j~ef|o a`jmjcf~ohoh yjrc`khf ej`j| yjecje ; yc`j ; meafp k|fw jcap|4

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

49/1668

0?

Lo|ohno Fnfwop Meafpo: Aj|p :?;6

Lo|ohno Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf >: Aj|p :?;6! jy mj|njhap|( Lv ic`vej

vtvh lo| ~|f`o| wf ~oyj~jc lchach wf ~oyj~fppfeo fpoh jh!

cjajtcecj|h mjlf|no~o`o|( ^j ejhjppjeo rj|pocf|oh molo|o fh ie ~jh`jcyfyf ~jmor NMR ocf i|pje

meafp ev|j|je `of|cf|ohf r|irjkjh`j ajctfaf~o wf|afe o~pfafaocf|`o|( Jyh rj|pocf| oce jh`j

efh`o j|jcj|h`j `j jhcjjajacj|`|( JR co`f|o ^cfyajh @fao|fcf avmjcfgfp f`f|fe rj|po`fheirjhcj|h ev|`vv Gf||vm Litlfycohoh @R~o# @fao|fcoh ljejhch`jeo meafpf ko|afafepf#

lvhj ej|ce JR# @fao|fc `h`j lo| JRcohoh Ljljejh icaj~hj yjhjajajepj`|(==

Fnfwopoh Lo|ohno Eijco~yihv

Pj|paj wf lfco|~otcoe i|pjah`j NMR!A^R Eijco~yihv kh`faf kfcaopo|( ce ljepj j|pn

icjh lv Eijco~yih ai`fcoho ~jwvhjhcj| ycf lo| kf|fef hf ~|yi|cj|4 A^R# feihiaoe yie~vccve wf

ftocaocoecf|oho `ohf ~hj|je ko`f|afe o~pfyfh mjce ef~oacf|ohoh rj|po~o`o|( NMR ocf A^Rho

`f~pfecfyfh ~i~yjc wf feihiaoe ~hg wf pjljejcj| mfafh mfafh jyh`|( Gjejp# oeo rj|po ooh`f `fEijco~yihj `o|fhfh k|vrcj| wj|`|( Eoao NMRcocf|# A^Rhoh ~oyj~ jajcj| ooh `oh ~a|nc

yjrph# lv yt`fh Jpjp|e `fw|oacf|ohoh wf tfccoecf cjoecoe ocef~ohoh ej|~h`j yf| jc`h

~ycfyf|fe ej| eajepj`|( Eoao A^Rcocf| o~f ~ic`j yf| jcjh NMR ocf i|pjece o~pfafafepf`o|(

A^R hfyo pfa~oc fpafepf`o|9

Lf|hj|` Cf{o~oh Pmf Ricoponjc Cjhkvjkf ig O~cja j`c f~f|ohoh ljch`jh f~ohcfhor# A^Ryo#

P|eoyf`f# ~cjah ~oyj~o `oco `oyf j`cjh`|aje aaeh(=? ~cjah ~oyj~o `oco icj|je A^R

mj|fefpohoh ~jmhfyf e P|eoyf ~oyj~fpoh`f oeo evpvrcvcvepjh evpvrcvcvj kfooh `f ljcjaj~

jhcjahj kfco|(?2

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

50/1668

62

f|og Aj|`ohoh `f oj|fp fppoo kolo# `jmj :?;2`f# :; j|ej`jycj Aocco Hotja Rj|po~oho -AHR/

ev|jh Hfnafppoh F|ljejh# rj|po~ohoh# P|eoyf`f lfco|cfyono k|` jmcjeo ehpyf ~ih wf|afyf

ej|j|c# r|opfh ~cjan lo| yjrcjaj rj|po~o ic`vv oajd wf|afepfh ejhayi|(?:

Aocco ^fcjafp Rj|po~o -A^R/ o~f# AHRhoh Jhjyj~j Ajmefaf~ohnf ejrjpcaj~h`jh ~ih|j ihvh

yf|ohf# :: Feoa :?;

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

51/1668

6:

Jco _jj| ^j|ljyh `ff|cfh o|af~ohf k|f5 NMR!A^R Eijco~yihv# ejaviyvhvh lo|

lcah`f# Jpjp|e lo| rj|poycf `ohno lo| rj|pohoh lo| j|jyj hj~c kfcfloc`oo f|fwf~oh`f lo|

pj|pajyj hf`fh icv|efh5 Eijco~yihvh# A^Rcocf|nf tf|oh`f v|vcjh fh hfaco yjh# ~foacf yj~jaj

`tfyoh`f ejtjhcjh af|voyfpoh#

y|paf i|kjh tfyoh`f f ejtjhcaj icjhjhh iav lvcvhaj~ icavpv(?6

Lcfhp Fnfwopoh co`f|cooh`f ev|vcjh NMR!A^R i|pje meafpo oeo rj|po j~h`jh ejtjhc

ljcja~j `j lfecfhoc`oo kolo vtvh a|c icjajap(

: vljp :?;0 kh PLAAh`f Ljljejh Lcfhp Fnfwopoh iev`vv i|pje meafpoh

r|ik|jah`j oeo rj|pohoh mf| hf ej`j| hfcf|o yjrjnjecj| wf hfcf|o yjrjajyjnjecj| ocjh f`ocao~f

`f# i|pje meafpoh r|ipieich`f yf| jcjh wf :< Aj|p :?;:oh jp yj|jcj| ~j|aje jajnycj

ej|cjnje kfhfc jg pj~j|~ rj|cjafhpi`j iycjh|efh -:0 Ajy~ :?;0/ A^Rco ljt yfcf| ~j ejhjp

rj|pocf|oycf lo|coepf iy evccjhj|je vtcjajhh jpcjaj~hj yic jacj|`(?7

^cfyajh J|og Fa|fhoh `f ogj`f fppoo kolo5 evev~vt lv `jw|jh# oeo rj|po j|j~h`jeo i|pjece

r|ipieic wf meafp r|ik|jahh ohfhaf~o yjhh`j# A^Rhoh goeo| wf won`jh m||oyfpo# 0< aocyihvh

ej|`fcoo -:?;0pf P|eoyf hgv~v 0< aocyih`v|/ wf o lj| ~jwvhaje fecoh`f `ocf kfpo|`oo

k|cf|oycf fcoeo icvpv|vyi|`v(?;

El|~ Lj| Mj|fejp

:?;0 yjth`j P|eoyf# jn lo| icjycj ~j|~cap( Eiav _vhjho~pjh ocf Fkf ~i|vhv `icjy~ycjj|pjh kf|kohcoe wf j|`h`jh El|~pj _vhjhj~ef| |fdoaoh`fh `f~pfe jcjh |e FIEJncj|h `j|lf~o#

J`j`j yjjyjh P|ecf|oh mjecj|h ei|vajy P|eoyf @fwcfpohoh kh`faoh`f lj ~|jyj ipv|pavpv(

_ohf jyh khcf|`f Fnfwop Meafpohoh :< Aj|p :?;: yhfpoaohnf yj~jecjhjh mjmj feoaohf

nf~v| lo| pvpvacj yfho`fh otoh wf|af~o tf|ohf JL@hnf j~ef| yj|`ah ef~ocf|fe P|eoyfyf jalj|ki

ej|j| vykvcjhaj~# cef kfhfcoh`f :?7=`feo kolo Jaf|oej jcfympj| lo| `jckjhh yjykhce

ejtjhaj~hj yic jap(

wf ` fpefhcf|o wf El|~ P|e pircvavhj yhfcoe |e ~jc`|cj| `ff|cfh`o|fh Fnfwopco`f|cooh`f NMR!A^R Eijco~yihv# T|om wf Cih`|jjhpcjajcj|hj k|f hkocpf|focf lo|coepf yeacce

wf mjecj|h evccjhaje o~pfao# lv ejlvc f`ocafyohnf P|eoyf# oceo

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

52/1668

6

y||cf ko|af~o tf|ohf5 P|eoyf# J`j`j# :> vljp :?;6pf El|~ P|e Gf`f|f @fwcfpohoh

ev|vc`vvhv ocjh fpao5 j|`h`jh Pfaavt :?7? pj|omco P|e!

Jaf|oejh ^jwvhaj lo|coo Jhpcjaj~hh P|eoyf pj|jgh`jh gf~mf`oc`oo lo| hipj ocf Jaf|oejh

Meafpohf loc`o|ocaopo(:22

JL@ Eihk|f~ohoh P|eoyfyf yhfcoe ~ocjm jalj|ki~v ej|j|# 6 vljp :?;6pfh opolj|fhvykvcjh`epjh ~ih|j# jhnje#

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

54/1668

60

Aoccoyfpo Nfrmfhoh ev|vcvvh`j eocop |ic iyhjyjh o~oa -hnf JRco# i ~|j`j @Rco# ~ih|j yfho`fh

JRco/ ^j`fppoh Lockopo|( JR co`f|ohoh :?70pfeo ljejhce yj|h`jh lf|o avmjcogo ^j`fppoh Locko wf

j|ej`jcj| ff| lycf lo| meafp ev|vcaj~h lfhoa~faf~fcf|`o# Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf Eijco~yihv

ev|vcjajt`# `fafe yjhc `foc(

~pjhlvc Aoccfpwfeoco Hocgf| K|~iy# ^j`fppoh Locko wf = j|ej`jhh @R Kfhfc Af|eftohfyiccj`ecj| o~pogj afepvlv `hfaoh ~oyj~fp oecoaoho yjh~pjh pj|omo lo| lfckf icj|je jy|nj hfa

pjajepj`|4

M| `faie|jpoe |fdoacf|`f molo| fyoh jm~j wf ohjpcja j|pcj|j ljc ejcajaj~ kf|feo|(

oh`f lvcvh`vvavt j|pcj|# vtcjaj wf lj`jajy tj|v|o ecajepj`|(

P|eoyf eiahotaoh ie yhc pfm`o`o jcph`j`|( ie yhc pfm`op ooh`f`o|( ^ih tjajhcj|`j

afy`jhj kfcfh icjycj|# P|eoyf `fwcfpoho cef~o wf aoccfpoycf lchaft lo| lph icaj f~j~h`jh

jy|aj o~po`j` k~pf|afepf`o|( Lv j|pcj| avwjnfmf~oh`f lotcf|# -(/ NMR `h`j wf ~focao rj|poco lo|

rj|cjafhpi yf~ohoh ljejhch`j ev|vcjnje meafpo iycj|atcj `f~pfecfyfnfoaoto# lv

`j|lijt`jh kfflocafhoh j|p icj|je jtot aoccfpoaotoh ppcjcj|hj ~jykcj|atcj ~vhvyi|vt( Lv

~flfrcf|cf# meafpoh ev|vcaj~hj yj|`an icaje aje~j`ycj# @faie|jpoe Rj|po`fh jy|caj

tj|v|fpohoh `iav ic`vvhv j|t f`oyi|vt(:2>

Lo|ohno Aoccoyfpo NfrmfEijco~yihv >: Aj|p :?;6 pj|omoh`f oljhj kfao5 :< Ho~jh :?;6 kh

`f ^cfyajh @fao|fc co`f|cooh`feo JR!A^R!NKR!AMR!Lja~tcj| Eijco~yihvhj Afnco~pf ~jh`jcyf~ohf ej|ce < Ljejhce jcjh AMR# Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf`fh fh

jwjhpjdc ejh ~oyj~jc kp( Aoccoyfpo Nfrmfhoh ~jyf~oh`f AMR# Mjto|jh :?;; ~foacf|oh`f iycj|h

>7< loh`fh ?6: lohf# ^jh`jcyf ~jy~h >`fh :7yj ye~fcpfnfepo( Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf i|pjecj|h`jh NKR

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

55/1668

66

o~f :< Aj|p :?;:`fh ~ih|j jhnje ^j ejhjp rj|pocf|o j|j~h`j efh`ohf yf| lvcjlocaopo( NKR#

NMRh`fh Rj|pohoh r|ik|jah`jh wf `faie|jpoe v~vccf|`fh jy|cj|je ~i~yjcotayicvhj ~jrp|c`h

ocf|o ~|f|fe o~pogj f`fh 0; Aoccfpwfeoco wf ^fhjp|h :?7;`f icvpv|`vecj| Kwfh Rj|po~ohoh# `jmj

~ih|j yohf NMR`fh eirjh Nvamv|oyfpo Rj|po ocf lo|cfaf~oh`fh icvavpv( :?;> kfhfc ~foacf|oh`f

:># :?;;`f o~f > ~jh`jcyf ejtjhjlocaopo(

Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf rj|pocf|ohoh ~ic`jh iy jcajcj| ~t eihv~v icjajyjnjh`jh# j|jcj|h`j

eyj~yj anj`fcf f`fnfecf|o ef~oh`o( Lv hiepj# Eijco~yihvh fh tjyg mjcej~y`(

Jco _jj| ^j|ljyh pf~ropcf|ohf k|f5 ej`|icjajyj ocoeoh eijco~yih ooh`f ej|cec

fhkfccfafcf| wf ljt eihvcj|`j -meafp r|ik|jahj |jafh/ lfco|fh ricopoe pvpva gj|ecc i|pjecj|

j|j~h`j ocoeocf|o kf|kohcfpo|aopo(

|hfe icj|je5 Afnco~ Ljejhchj ~focfnfe j`jy tf|oh`f A^R wf JRhoh jhcjjajaj~5 Wjco

wf Fco jpjajcj|h`j yjrcjh rjtj|ch ~ihvcjhajaj~5 A^R co`f|o F|ljejhh ~cja Eihgf|jh~h`j

eihvaj o~pfohoh i|pjecj|nj |f``f`ocaf~o5 @fwcfp Kwfhcoe Ajmefafcf|ohoh ev|vcaj~ eihv~vh`j#

JR# A^R wf AMRhoh cjoecoecf ockoco ~vcj|h ejr~ja ` ejcaj~ focoaohf# Pv|mjh Gfytoicv

co`f|cooh`feo NKRhoh ej| icvv5 Lj~h!_jyh Kfhfc A`|chh A^Rco @fwcfp Ljejhhj

ljcjhajaj~5 A^Rhoh# Evtfy El|~pj lja~t lo| P|e `fwcfpo ocjh tjajhhh kfc`ooho meafp

j`hj ~ycfaf~o5 A^Rhoh# Goco~poh Ev|pvcv |kphh Jhej|j`j l|i jaj~ o~pfohf JRhoh ej|

eaj~ kolo eihvcj| tfccoecf A^Ryo `of| Eijco~yih i|pjecj|ycj jhcjajtce oohf `|ap(

Lvhvh tf|ohf JR# :?;; ~foacf|ohoh f|efhf jchaj~ eihv~vh`j A^Rhoh `o|fhaf~ohf |jafh#

avmjcfgfppfeo NMR ocf olo|coo yjrj|je eijco~yihv litavpv(:20

Aoccoyfpo Nfrmfhoh i|pjecj|# :?;2cf| P|eoyf~oh`f yf|cf|oho wf `fofh cef ~i|vhcj| tf|ohf

hfcf| `h`ecf|oho fp|jgcnj lfco|cfyflocao `foccf|`o( Lv j|j`j tfccoecf feihiaohoh `f mo oyo

kopaf`ooho lfco|pafe kf|feo|( @hyj rfp|ic e|otohoh fpeocf`oo goyjp j|pcj| :?;7`j fhgcj~yihv yt`f

2cj|j ej|pa# :?;;`f yt`f 02!62 `tfyohf g|cjpap( :?;>`feo rfp|ic goyjpcj| j|p

hf`fhoycf opmjc kl|f goyjpcj| mtcj ye~fcaopo( Meafp# :? Ho~jh :?;6 kh jc` lo| ej|j|cj fopco

porpf kl|f goyjpcj|h eoci ljhj 0> ocj :60 ev|v oh`o|afe ti|vh`j ejcap( Ljljejh @fao|fcoh

~tcf|oycf# Meafp ogpoyf yjecje 6 aocyj| PC mjtohf`fh ejyhje jepj|ap(:26

Ljljejh @fao|fc# :?76!:?;:`f JRhoh pfe ljhj oepo`j| `hfaoh`feo ej`j| icaj~j `j

Aoccoyfpo Nfrmf`hfaoh`f `f fhf|do wf ~vcjaj r|idfcf|oho ~|`|yi|`v(

7; eoo njh wf|aopo( @fr|faoh o``fpo 7(7 o`o(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

56/1668

67

jc`|jh wf Av|j`oyf`f - o``fpoh`feo `fr|fa gfcjefpoh`f o~f# >

loh =>; eoo mjyjph ejylfpao# 0?; eoo yj|jcjhap(

@ coeocf|`f _fho ^i|vhcj|

@ ricopoej`j tfccoecf _vhjho~pjh wf JL@ ocf jhcjajtcecj| ~|yi|`v( _vhjho~pjhh Fkf@fhotoh`feo ej|j~vcj|h :< aocf ej|aje o~pfaf~o# P|eoyfhoh epj ~jmjhch`j rfp|ic j|jaj

jcajcj|h`j lvcvhaj~# kf|kohcoo jmj `j p|ajh`|ap(

vljp :?;6pf R|ig( O|aje Meafpo `hfaoh`f ev|vcjh El|~ P|e Gf`f|f @fwcfpo `hyj

ejaviyvh`j pfreo ocf ej|cjhap( El|~c P|ecf|# lv yhfpoaoh#

ev|vcaj~h j|tv fppoecf|o Gf`f|jc El|~ Nvamv|oyfpohoh P|e ejhj`h icvpv|`vvhv

jecjacj|`( P|eoyf# El|~pj oeo ef~oaco# oeo lckfco# oeo pircvavh ~oyj~o fopcoohf `jyjhjh Gf`f|jc

Nvamv|oyfp pftoho ~jwvhvyi|`v( Lv pfafc ocefcf|# P|eoyfhoh El|~ ricopoej~hh jhj vh~v|cj| icj|jelfco|aopo(:27

Jaf|oejc _jeh @iv wf P|eoyfPj|omo R|igf~| ^pjhgi|` D( ^mj{f k|f# kf|fepf# El|~ wf

jgyih ~i|vhv# P|eoyfhoh Ljp ocf ocoeo~oho tf`fcfyfnfe ej`j| no``o `foc`o( Jhnje# tfccoecf Jaf|oej

Lo|cfoe @fwcfpcf|oh`f icaje tf|f jthce cilo~o lvhv ic`vvh`jh lye k~pf|`o( @oeejpf `ff|

lyecepf lo| Jaf|oejc!P|e ~fafh eopcf~ohoh lvcvhaj` Lo|cfoe @fwcfpcf|`f Jaf|oejc!_vhjh wf

Jaf|oejc!F|afho ~fafh eopcf~o Eihk|fyo eicjycecj fpeocfyflocoyi|`v( Lv p| lj~ecj|h ~ihvnv# :?;6

ljh`j P|eoyfyf pa Jaf|oejh yj|`a ef~oc`o( ^pjhgi|` D( ^mj{h ~tcf|oycf lv ej|j|# P|eoyf

ooh`f ricopoe j| vcj|h kcfhafcf|oho ~jcj`(:2;

6 Mjto|jh :?;; Kfhfc ^foacf|o

6 Mjto|jh :?;; pj|omoh`f yjrcjh Nvamv|oyfp ^fhjpi~v :)> yfhocfaf wf Aoccfpwfeoccoo kfhfc

~foacf|ohf ejpcaj i|jh ye~fepo -yt`f 77(=/( Nvamv|oyfp ^fhjpi~v e~ao yfhocfaf ~foacf|oh`f

lv i|jh# yt`f ;>(=`o|( Lvh`j meafpoh ejhjpcj| j|j~h`j kcfhfh |pc lo| lj~e yhfpoao

pfmcoef~ohf ej|# NMRhoh tfccoecf efh`o~ohf iy wf|ocaf~o j|~h`j lvcvhaj~ wf avmpfafc lo| ~ic

oepo`j| wf ~i~yjco~p k|vrcj|h gjjcoyfpoho fhkfccfafe ooh ~j ejhjp rj|pocf|oh i|pjecjj y|ppecf|o

ejarjhyjhh |ic wj|`|( NMRhf iy wf|fh kfho mjce ef~oao ocf ljt jy`h fw|fhoh yfho lo| Fnfwop

meafpo ocf jncj|h `oh`o|ocfnfo# mf| kffh kh `f|ohcffh yj|jcj|h ~j|cjnj vav`v `j |i c

iyhja icjloco|(

:?;; Aoccfpwfeoco ~foaoh`f rj|pocf|oh iycj| wf `jca ycf`o|4

NMR7(:>7(:;: iy&0:(> ~jh`jcyf&0;(2

JR6(07=(7(?:=? ~jh`jcyf&0

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

57/1668

6;

AMR?6:(600 iy&7(0:7 ~jh`jcyf &>(0

Lja~tcj|>;2(2>6 iy & ~jh`jcyf &2(;

@R7(?/ :=? ~jh`jcyf wf

AMR -yt`f 7(0/ :7 ~jh`jcyf ejtjhj|je iycj|h j|pp|acj|`|( ~foacf|oh`f 0= ~jh`jcyfyf ~jmor icjh @R`f`o| -yt`f :(= iy# : ~jh`jcyf/( PLR f~eo knhh

yj|~h`jh jtj ohao -loh`f 0/# oeohno eft ev|vc`vepjh ~ih|j ~foaf ejpcjh PR o~f wj|ce

k~pf|fafaopo| -loh`f :/( Lja~tcj| 0 ~jh`jcyf ejtjhacj|`|( Nvamv|oyfp ^fhjpi~v e~ao

yfhocfaf ~foacf|oh`f o~f ^fhjp|cecf|`fh ^foacf|oh`f @Ryo wf NMR wf lo| c`f

A^Ryo `f~pfecfao ~fafhcf|oh# NMRhoh ~foa tjgf|o ejtjhajcj| hh`feo fh lye fhkfc wf

~ffhfe icvpv|jh JRhf yhfcafcf|o# @fao|fcoh ~p|jpfdo~ohoh oyo ocf`oo k~pf|o|( eohno~o5 @fao|fc#

yfho`fh f~eo @faie|jpcj|h `f~pfoho ~jcjap|( :?;>pf @Ryf `f~pfe wf|fh ~fafhcf|ohivhcvv# yfho`fh JR ~jgcj|hj kfaopo|(:2?

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

58/1668

6=

JRhoh ~j ~fafh pjljhh`jeo `f~pfo# :?=2f `i|v j|pj|je ~|ap|(

Fnfwopoh NMRJthceMeafpo

:?;; ~foa ~ihvcj| ocf :?;>pfeo focoa rfeoaopo4 P|eoyf ~oyj~fpoh`f j|pe ~fafhcf|oh

yjecje yt`f 0

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

59/1668

6?

yfho ~jwcj|cj ejaviyv lvcjhyi|`v( Fnfwop lo| kh hnf @fao|fcoh rj|po~ohoh# mfa afacfefpo mfa

efh`o~oho gfcjefpf ~|ecf`ooho ao ~ycfao# f|pf~o kh @fao|fc `f|mjc yjhp wf|oyi|`v(::

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

60/1668

72

hn Fnfwop Meafpo `hfaoh`f fh p|jdoe pf|| icjy# ># yj|jc >22`fh gjtcj o`o(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

61/1668

7:

icj|je yhcfh`o|ono |ic iyhj` kh# `hfaoh Nvamv|ljejh Efhjh Fw|fhpj|jgh`jh

jpc|efh5 a|h lv lye r|idfyf j`jyjh amfh`o~ ~oyj~o yj~jec ic`vv kf|fef~oycf p|fhf

`jwfp locf f`ocafyfnfepo(

@ Gjep|h \ic

Eihyj`j# 7 Fycc :?=2 kh `tfhcfhfh lo| r|ipf~pi k~pf|o wf y|y :< Fycc :?=2 hnf~o

kfcoafcf|oh lo| ljej yhhf oj|fp fpaf~o ljeah`jh hfaco`o|(

Kfhfcev|ajy Ljejhc pj|jgh`jh ie lye pfreoycf ej|cjhjh Eihyj icjyhh kfcooao

Ei|evp tjch pjhechj k|f ycf`o|4

-~|joc pj|jgh`jh/ Ev`~h ljefhp ocjhh r|ipf~pi ooh Eihyj`j lo| aopohk yjrcaj~

ej|j|cjp|c` wf lvhvh ooh jy| lo| mfyfp ev|vc`v( Lv mfyfppfeocf|oh mfr~o lotoa efh`oAoccfpwfeoccf|oaot# yjho Eihyjc( Lvhcj| pf|porcoyi| aopohko# rj|po icj|je `foc( Tjpfh rj|po icj|je

yjrajat aaeh `foc( I tjajh Eihyj Lfcf`oyf~o `f lot`fh# Afmafp Effnocf| Lfcf`oyf

Ljejh( Effnocf| lo|jt a`fllo|# yjho pf`lo|co oh~jh`( I tjajh Lf`|fppoh @fao|fc `f Eihyj`j

I|`v Eiavpjhy`( Aopohk 7 Fycc`f# ycf lo| tjajh`j yjrc` eo# mjcj Nvamv|ljejhh

~ffafaoot# lo| `f meafpoh `

ricopoej~ycj pf|~ `at( Afnco~pf @ocf|o Ljejh Mjy|fppoh F|eafho kfh~i|v ocf

`|at( _jho ti| lo| `v|vavh ooh`fyot( Ljhj k|f lv aopohk# tjajhcjaj~ yjhc# eihv~v `i|v

lo| aopohk`o( -(/

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

62/1668

7; yv|ppj njh wf|ao# ytcf|nf yv|ppj `j yj|jcjhap|(:

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

64/1668

70

Vtjecj|`j# lo|lo|o j|`hj rjpcjyjh lialj yj `j `ohjaop ~f~cf|o Tjajh tjajh# mfafh

eihvpcj|ath yjehcj|hj ej`j| ~ievcjh# ej|jhc y|pjh ~ocjm pje|pcj|

J`jhj# ~jheo lo| aftj| ej|jhchj wf ~f~~otcoohf kaca# j`fpj ep jelfpoho lfecf| kolo#

~v~evh wf mthc

Mjajacj|h lvvcv# yjrejh wf livnv ~njech jh`|jh lo| yjt kfnf~oh`f lvhjcjh

oh~jhcj|# lo|jt hfgf~ jcaje ooh ejr hcf|ohf yj `j fwcf|oh `jacj|hj eaje o~poyi| Eoaocf|o |j~p

kfcf lo| ev|vhj mf`fg icajaje ooh lv o~pfoh`fh wjtkfor lvhjcajy yfcf|efh# eoaocf|o `f mf| p|c

pfmcoefyo ktf jcr j|yj jpyi| efh`oho

_f| yf|# ejrcj|h hh`f yj `j ooh`f ~v~evh# pf`o|koh oh~jhcj|h kckfcf|o er|`jyi|# o|oco#

vgjec

J|j ~|j jpcjh pfe lo| af|aohoh wtcp~ yj `j fw|fyf ca ev~jh lo| ipiajpoe ~ocjmh pje|p~litvyi| lv ~f~~otcoo

_j lo| ejr hh`fh yj `j lo| `ja`jh ye~fcfh cecj|

ccf|# ccf|# ccf|

Nfhjtfcf|# nfhjtfcf|# nfhjtfcf|

Kfop yjryi| ~jheo hat`fh lo|f|# lo|f|

Efhpcf| yjhyi|# fwcf| yjhyi|# oh~jhcj| yjhyi|

Ktyjcj|# me|ecj| Kf ye~fcfh jpcj|# jpcj|:/# ~(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

65/1668

76

7 I~ajh @i|v#

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

66/1668

77

(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

67/1668

7;

07 Cvnoccf [( Rfw~hf|# Pv|efy~ Ricoponjc N|o~o~# ~( 06 w`(

0; Jl`o rfeo# Co`f|cf| @oyi| eo# ~( ;2(

0= Lcfhp Fnfwop# I|pjhh ^icv#-~pjhlvc# Eoa _(# :?77/# ~( ;2!

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

68/1668

7=

76 Jco _jj| ^j|ljy# P|eoyf`f Ai`f|hcfaf @oh wf Rj|po Ricopoej~# A^R |hfe

Icjy# ~( :20!6(

77 Av|jp Lfckf# :?7= Kfhcoe Mj|fefpcf|o# N@PJ# nocp ># ~( =:2!::(

7; Jl`o rfeo# @ohjaotaoh Ej`f| _c# Aoccoyfp# -: Inje :?;2/(

7= Avm~oh Ljpv|# Jhcj| wf K|cf|# -~pjhlvc# Aoccoyfp _(# oeohno lj~e :?=6/# ~(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

69/1668

7?

=; Meafpcf| wf R|ik|jacj| OO# :?72!:?=2(

== Gf||vm Litlfyco# @faie|jpoe j -~pjhlvc# @f|kjm _(# :?;7/# ~(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

70/1668

;2

:2= ~ph F|k`f|# P|eoyf`f @fofh ^fafh @jw|jh |hpcf|o# ~( 20(

:2? ^jl|o ^jyj|# Pmf Pv|eo~m Rj|py ^y~pfa oh P|jh~opoih# Kiwf|hafhp jh` Irri~opoih# :>

-:?;=/# ~( 6>(

::2 Meafpcf| wf R|ik|jacj| OO# :?72!:?=2# ~( >0= wf >;:(

::: Meafpcf| wf R|ik|jacj| OO# :?72!:?=2# ~( >=2!=:(

::< Nhfyp J|njy|fe# @faie|j~ohoh ^ihljmj|# :?;;!:?;=# -Jhej|j# Locko _(# :?=6/# ~(

:0=(

::> Nhfyp J|njy|fe# A`jmjcfhoh Jyje ^f~cf|o# :?;=!:?;?# -Jhej|j# Locko _(# :?=6/#

~( >7:!7:(

::6 Nhfyp J|njy|fe# A`jmjcfhoh Jyje ^f~cf|o# :?;=!:?;?# ~( ;0!=2(

::7 P|eoyf~pjpo~poe _cc# :??0# -Jhej|j# @F _(# :??6/# ~(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

71/1668

;:

P|eoyf+`f I|`v wf ^oyj~fp ) @i( @|( Hv|fh Ajtn U~(0=!6>Q

Je`fhot howf|~opf~o Gfh!F`floyjp Gjecpf~o ) P|eoyf

I~ajhc arj|jpi|cvvhvh Ljp ej|~h`j ~|feco yfhocafyf ljcj` ]WOOO( ytyc`j yfhocko

hf`fho# j~ef|o jcjh`j kf|o ejcacecj jecjha# lv yfhockoyo hcfafe ooh Ljphh ~phcecf|oh`fh

oce eft i|`vhvh yj|j|cjhaj~ yicvhj ko`ocao# `icjy~ycj i|`v# Ljpc porf yjeh oce jy`h wf yfhocoeo

ev|va `v|vavhj kfcaf icjhjhj ejwvavpv|( Pircva`j jy`h wf yfhocoeo lo| eihvaj kfcafe

i|`vyj j~ef|o jcjh `h`j# ~oyj~jc wf yhfp~fc jcjhcj|`j `j Ljpccjajyhh`f lo| yjh`jh hnce

fpaf k|fwoho yecf|efh# pf yjh`jh `j ~vcpjhh wf ~j|jyh oce `jyjhj wf `jhaj yf|o icaj yfpeo

wf ~i|vacvcvvhv wf|aopo|(

Hf wj| eo# ]O]( ytycj kfcoh`ooh`f i|`vhvh pircvav Ljpccjp|aj`j hnce fpaf yfpeocf|o#

kf|fe ocfwo icjh cefyo ~jwvhaj ~i|vacvcvvhv ja# lv jeh yfpeoycf Ljpccjaj`j hnce

fpaf j|jnhh yf|oho# ~oyj~jy lfco|cfaf jajn jcap|( Hopfeoa lv ytyc`j oarj|jpi|cve# mc Ljp

ej|~h`j yfhocafepf# cef pir|jecj| koppoef ecafepf# pa lvhcj|j ej|h j~ef|cf| yivh lo|

looa`f ~oyj~fpcf ockocfhafepf`o|cf|( J|pe# i|`vhvh h`f kfcfhcf|o# Ljp ej|~h`j yfhockohoh hf`fhoho#

I~ajhc @fwcfpohoh ~oyj~jc kf|o ejcacycj jecja wf afacfefpo ev|pj|aje jajnycj lv eft `f#

Ljphh ~oyj~jc ~phch yjejcjajyj jcacj|`|(

Ljm|o ^jwn lv eihv`j vhcj| ~ycyi|4 hnfcf|o efh`oho rj`ojmh mveve mea|jho~ohoh

`f~pfo wf ~jwvhvnv~v ~jyj|efh# ~ih|jcj| Ljp ocf ocoeo ev|jh oce ~oyj~jc wf yhfp~fc ~feoh ef~oa

icj|je i|`v# tk|c wf mjcogf ~vcpjh oepo`j|hh ~h|cjh`|caj~ k|h ~jwvhavpv|(: Mjcogf~vcpjhh yfpeocf|oho ~h|cjh`|aj`j kf|feco icjh wf e~afh Ljpc |hfecf|ohf lfhtfyfh jhjyj~j#

:=;7`j l|ie|jpoe `j|lf `fhflocfnfe lo| ko|ooacf y||cf eihav wf O( Af|vpoyfp ocjh f`ocaopo|(

Jhnje :=;7 `j|lf~ohoh e~j ~|fco lo| yj| rj|cjafhpf| |fdoa ~jcjaj~h`jh icajc eo# :?2=`f

yjrcjh oeohno `j|lf# j~ef|o ef~oa`fh `jmj ie k jcajyj yhfcao# lycfnf j~ef| ~owoc

l|ie|jpcj|`jh `jmj ie# j~ef|cf|oh j|c lv `j|lf`f `vyva~jhap|( _jho :=;7`j j~ef|cf|oh

yjchtnj jy`h# yfhocoeo lo| l|ie|jp ef~oa icj|je `j|lfyo `f~pfecfafcf|ohf ej|h# :?2=`f ~ocjm

pfefcoho fcoh`f lvcvh`v|jh lo| ev|va icj|je i|`v# `j|lfhoh ooh`f yf| jcap|( ^ihvh`j jhjyj~j

yfho`fh y||cf eihav# rj|cjafhpi jca# OO( Af|vpoyfpocjh f`ocao wf oce eft ie rj|poco ~oyj~jc

yjjaj kfocaopo|( Hf wj| eo# ^vcpjh Jl`cmjaopoh o~pol`j`hj ej| tk|cecf| wjj`oycf `j|lfyo

yjrjh ppomjp wf Pf|jeeo Nfaoyfpo wf G|ej~# ~|ph i|`vyj `jyjyr oce on|jjp icj|je avmjcogcf|oho

~oh`o|afyf ljcjap|(pf# :?2= `j|lf~o# i|`vhvh wf ihvhcj ljcjjhcj|h knh oce eft ~iavp lo|

looa`f i|pjyj eiyajepj`|(

J~ef|cf|oh ~oyj~fpcf lv `fhco ockocfhaf~ohoh ~jehnjc lvcvhaj~ `hnf~oycf = Feoa :?:

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

72/1668

;! Ev|pvcv ^jwjh`j wf|ocfh j~ef|o anj`fcfyo l|cf|oh`fh jy|jh lo| ljej tfccoe o~f#

i|`vhvh vcv~jccjaj~`|( Lv ~jwjcj P|ecf|# oce eft efh`o t yjtkcj| lvy|vcpv~vh`j i|`v~vhv

evccjhap|( Lv `i|vcpv`j |kpcfhfh oeo i|`v poroh`fh ~t f`ocfloco|(

j! Efajco~p i|`v5 mjcej vykj|ce ecjwvtcvvh`j# `i|v yic k~pf|onocooh`f# ~feohno wf

j`jcjp|n `hnf`feo tfhco i|`v#

l! ^owoccf|oh |kpcf`oecf|o kf|occj poro# aoco~ knhf `jyjhjh fpf yj `j `tfh~ot i|`v(pf &:=# :?0>!07`j &:7`|(>Jy|nj OO(

yj~jaj `hfaoh`f i|`v wf eici|`v eiavpjhcj|hh mfafh mfafh pa aoccfpwfeoco`o|( Lvhvh `h`j

^jwvhaj# Ljyh`|ce wf Vcjp|aj Ljejhcj|hh j~ef| icaj~ lo| kfcfhfe mjcoho jca# Kfhfcev|ajy

Ljejhc `j Aj|p :?

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

73/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

74/1668

;0

E~jnj# :?:?!:?(0f ohfnfe#

lvhj ej|h :?

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

75/1668

;6

Pa lvhcj|j ej|h# oce oepo`j|j kfc`ooh`f @Rhoh j~ef|cf|f ej| ie `oeejpco lo| pjw| jcj|je

ihcj|`jh kfcfnfe lo| `o|fhaf ko|ooaoho hcfafe ejykcj| ooh`f ic`vv k|cafepf`o|( Lycfnf ljt

fafeco ~vljycj| ~jgcj|hj jcj|je j~ef|cf|f kwfh wf|afyf `f jcap|( :?07 Nvamv|ljejhc

~foaoh`f Gfwto jeaje j`jy k~pf|ao :?62cf|`f @Rhoh yhfpono ej`|icj| j|j~h`j `j J( G(

Nflf~iy# Gjm|o Lfcfh# ^fygo Ev|plfe# Pjm~oh _jtn# Pfeoh J|lv|vhyf| jcap|(

Jhnje j~ef| eefhcocf|oh koppoef rj|cjafhpi`jeo ~jycj|hh jtjcaj~ !eo ]( @hfa`f meafp

ooh`f j~ef| eefhco eoo mo yf| jcajap|! i|`v ocf meafpoh ej| ej|yj kfcaf~o ooh pfe hf`fh

icajap|( Jy`fao|f k|f Afh`f|f~oh

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

76/1668

;7

kolo lo| ocef yiepv|( Pja pf|~ohf ~owoc yhfpoaoh kc icaj~hh lo| hf`fho# lv |fdoacf|oh i|`vyv

efh`ohf ljac ecaj~ycj# yjho ~ocjmc j`jah ~ocjm~t j`jah fa|ohf ko|af~oycf# jece

ejtjhajepj`|( Ljpc |hfecf|oycf ej|cjp|c`h`j# @Rhoh i|`v ricopoej~ ooh ~p|jpfdoe icj|je

~jcec# jhnje pjepoe icj|je mjpjc fhfloco|(

^owoc yhfpoaf ljcce eihv~vh`j @R oepo`j| ycf~ohf ~jcec wf @R yhfponocf|o ycf~ohf ~owoctomhoyfpco`o|cf| eo# lv rj|pohoh oepo`j| `hfaoh`f Aocco ~pomlj|jp Pfeocjphj ~owoccf|oh# |hfoh

locoaj`jacj|hh jpjhaj~# lv ev|vavh ~owoc yhfponocf|oh`fh lo|o~o pj|jgh`jh yjecje >2 yc ~ih|j

yj`|kjhjnje# j~ef|cf| wj|efh ~owoccf|oh jpjhaj~h`jh `icjy Afh`f|f~ wf @R oepo`j|

fcfpo|ocfnfepo|(:2Jhnje# @Rhoh i|`v ricopoej~ pjepoe icj|je mjpjc `faopoa eo# K|~fc lfhoa mjpj

icj|je hopfcfh`o|afaf @Rhoh rf|wj~tc `oyi|# i `j vh`jh ejyhjecjhyi|4 ^owoc tomhoyfpco icaje#

`faie|jp icaje `foc`o|( @faie|jpce# ~owoccooh p|fwcf|oh`fh lo|o~o wf fh ti| ljj|cjh`|( @faie|jpoe

lo| oepo`j|# meafp fpaf ~|fnoh`f lo| pjea yfpeo wf ~i|vacvcvecj|cj `ihjpcap|( Iy~j @R# lv

`ihjhah yjchtnj yfpeocf|oho evccjha# ~i|vacvcvecj|h lye jrpj ~jw~jecjap|( ^i|vacvcvecj|~jw~jecjaje @Rhoh yjcht i|`v ricopoej~h`j `foc# l| ~owoc ev|va wf i|kjhcj|cj -|hfoh#

jhjyj~jyj ljcce# avmjcfgfpf mik|# rj|cjafhpi`j iy`jaj# lj~hj ~jyk wl(/ ocoeocf|oh`f `f

efh`oho k~pf|afepf`o|(

Jhnje vhvpvcajajc`| eo#

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

77/1668

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

78/1668

;=

|fdoaf ivcnv `faie|jpoe hopfcoe ejtjh`|jh `f|hfecf|# ~oyj~jc rj|pocf|# ~owoc pircva ev|vcvcj|# tk|

lj~h# yj~jcj|cj wj|ce ejtjhr yj~jcj|cj yie f`oc`oecf|o ooh fpeohcoecf|o wf |kpcfhafcf|o

`v|`v|vc`vvh`j ~owoc ~oyj~jc ev|va~jccjaj ~jcjhjajap|( Lv ev|vcvcj|h yf|oho kfcfhfe~fc jaj

mveve~jc icjajyjh lfhnoc iri|pho~p k|vrcj| jca# lycfnf jtkfcoao cef ~i|vhcj|hh yivhcvv

~ihvnv ~|feco mj|fefpcfhfh eopcfcf|# ~oyj~jc ejpcajhh icjjh yiccj| pejh`ej# yj icjjh `

~oyj~jc ejpcaj k~pf|aocf|# yj `j |j`oejc jeacj|h yj~j ` |kpcfhafcf|ohf ejpcacj|`|(

@icjy~ycj `faie|jpoe `fhkfhoh ~jcjhaj~ ooh kf|feco icjh vtcjajhh yf|oho kf|kohcoe jcap|(

^oyj~jc rj|pocf|# meafp fpaf yf|ohf oepo`j| pfefcoho fcohf kfo|af# avmjcfgfp fpaf yf|ohf afhgo

icaj# j|re jcejhcecj|h ejtjhacj|`|( L|ie|j~o ej|~h`j tjyg `acf|# `fwcfpcf icjh

ocoeocf|oh`f ei|eje wf lfnf|oe~ot# lo|lo|cf|ohf ej| ~jc`|kjh wf jnaj~t# oepo`j| ~jwjah`j ~jl|~t

wf owf`ono icavcj|`|( ^oyj~jc h`f|cf| yj ej|otajpoe yj `j `fajkidoe ej|jepf| k~pf|af `v|vavhj

ti|cjha# rj|po r|ik|jacj|ycj meafp on|jjpo# ocefcf|`fh ej|ncj `ha# lv pvpj|~tcecj|

ej|~h`j ~fafh f# mjhko rj|pohoh efh`o~ohf motafp ~vh`vv# mjhko~ohoh ej|cj|hj pf|~ phejw|jyjajyj|je ~oyj~jc rj|pocf|f kwfh~otcoe `vyavpv|( @icjy~ycj# jecn# pircvanv# ~|feco# pvpj|c#

ie ~f~co ~oyj~jc ev|va~jccjajhh icaj~ kf|fefh yf|oho# `vykv~jc# lfhnoc# pvpj|~t wf ~|fe~ot

o~pfa!~vhv fpeocfoaoycf# rj|potjh vvcpv jcap|(

E~jnj# @vwf|kf|oh lo| |fdoaoh `faie|jpoe ivcnv icjlocaf~o ooh# ihvh avmjcfgfpf yjchtnj

yj~jc `foc# goocco i|pja `j ~jcjaj~ kf|fepoo ~jrpjaj~ycj# :?:?!

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

79/1668

;?

6 Ajtn# = Jy`fao|# j(k(y(# ~( >(

:2 ^jljm# :: Mjto|jh :?=> Mo|ja Jlj~h jecjaj~hj let(

:: Ajtn# j(k(y(# ~( :>6(

:< Afpf Pvhjy# P|eoyf`f ^ic Jeacj| :?2=!:? Hv|fh Ajtn# Nfcjc Ljyj|4 Ljljejhce @hfao :?>;!:?>?# @f| _jyhfwo# ~p( :??7# ~(

:>(

:0 @i( @|( Hv|fh Ajtn# :?>2j Ej`j| Lj~h wf :?>: Ajplvjp Ejhvhv# Jpjp|e _icv

PPF @f|ko~o#Ej~a :??7# yc4 ?# ^jy4 :=# J( ( Lj~afwo# Jhe( :??=(

:6 Hv|fh Ajtn# hnf~o wf ^ih|j~ycj :?>> howf|~opf \fgi|av# Lo|oeoa# :??6 _jt(

:7 Hv|fh Ajtn#Mveve @fwcfpo ao _j~j @fwcfpo ao# Nvamv|oyfp :; Mjto|jh :?=?(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

80/1668

=2

hkocot Ejyhjecj|hj K|f P|eoyf+`feo

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

81/1668

=:

yjh~pph`jh ~t fppo( _ohf P|eoyf`feo ~oyj~o i|pjah ~jcec k|haf`oohf wv|kv yjrp# he

Afnco~ Pjmeoejp Eiao~yihvhj ~oyj~o co`f|cf|o pvpvecjaje `jmoc ~i|vpv|ajy eicjycjp|jnjh

`h` mf| o~pf`oo fyo yjrjlocaf~o yhh`f ie kfho yfpeocf| wf|ocaopo wf avmjcfgfp

Eiao~yihvh yfpeo~oho pjhajajepj ej|j|c k|hafepfy`o(6 Lv||i{~ a`jmjcf`fh lo| jy hnf

kh`f|`oo |jri|cj|`jh lo|oh`f ripjh~oyfc icj|je ompocjc i|pjahh wj| icjlocfnfoho `f lfco|ppo( Lv k|

tfccoecf

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

82/1668

=2 Ajy~pj Jhej|j`jeo Jaf|oejh fco~o# P|e meafpo ocf hi|ajc

ocoeocf|oh ljcjpcaj~ eihv~vh`j [j~mohkpihvh pjcoajph jc`(:7

hkocot @ocf|o Ljejhc

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

83/1668

=>

o~pfafafepf o`o(:; Jhej|j`jeo Ejhj`j# Rjeo~pjh wf Moh`o~pjh lyefcocf|o hkocot lyefco~o ocf

yjeh o|poljpcj|h ~|`|yi|cj|` wf efh`o meafpcf|ohoh pjhajy vtvh ~|f kfnoepo|afyfnfoho

pjmaoh fpafepf o`ocf|(

hkocot meafpo# >2 Ajy~ :?72`j hkocot @ocf|o Ljejhc Cih`|j`jeo P|eoyf

lyefcocooh`fh lo| afepvr jc` tjajh yfho P|e meafpoho pjh`( Lvhvh tf|ohf hkocot meafpoycf lo| nfwjr kh`f|`o4

hkocot E|jcoyfp Meafpo# P|e meafpohoh oeo cef j|j~h`j afahvhoyfp wf|ono `tfy`f kfcofh

ocoeocf|oh ~|`|caf~o o~pfohf pjajafh ejpc| wf ej|ce wf|o|(

hkocot Lyefcocoo lvhv g|~jp locf|fe @ocf|o Ljejhchj fh `f|oh ~jykcj|h ~vhj|(:=

hkocot Vcv~cj| Pircvcvv yfcf|o# Pircvcve coeocf|o L|i~v pj|jgh`jh kh`f|ocfh >2 Ajy~ pj|omco

lo| pfck|jgcj `v|va`jh mjlf|`j| f`oc`o( hkocotcf|oh yfho P|e meafpoho HJPI wf NFHPI`jeoappfgoecf|o ocf goeo| pfcjeeo~oh`f lvcvhaj`jh pjh`h lfco|pafe hfaco`o|( @ocf|o Ljejhc# El|~

k|afcf|o hf`fhoycf hkocpf|fhoh tfc lo| eihva`j ic`vvhv kjy|o |f~ao `tfy`f lfco|paf~oho

o~pfyfh pjcoajpcj| kh`f|aopo( hkocot meafpohoh El|~ k|afcf|oh`f hi|ajc ~|fno fh jt kfnoeaf

ocf ~|`|flocaf~o hfacoy`o(:? hkocpf|fhoh P|eoyf ocf ocoeocf|oh`f hnfcooh El|~j wf|oc`oo#

P|eoyf`feo ~oyj~o `v|vavh `jmj jt hfaco lo| af~fcf ic`vv `j lfco|pocafco`o|(

@ocf|o Ljejhc Jhej|j`jeo lyefcoyf# K|~fc ocf yjrjnj k|afyf ocoeoh `fpjyc

pjcoajpcj| kh`f|`o( Fco K|~fcf vhcj| ~ycfafcoy`o4

Fclfppf hkocpf|f P|eoyfhoh o ocf|ohf a`jmjcf fpaf hoyfpoho pjaj` wf lycf yjrajhh

kjyfp yf|~ot icjnjhh locohnoh`fy`o( _ohf `f ^wfy af~fcf~o# Lj`jp Rjephh ev|vcvvhvh oce

tjajhcj| O|jeompocjco wf El|~ e|otcf|o wj~pj~ycj ^jyh Afh`f|f~ !`jmj ~ih|j efh`o~ohf ^jyh Ti|cv

yj|`an icavpv! kf|fe lo| `i~p wf appfgoe wf P|eoyfhoh hkocpf|f ocf oppogjeh `f~pfecfaf`f P|e

vcv~vhvh `ff|co lo| ~tn~ icj|je mj|fefp fppo( hkocotcf|# P|eoyf`f pj|jgcj| j|j~h`j ~oyj~o

`ajhce ic`vv lycf lo| tjajh`j# lv `v|vavh f~eo co`f|cf| cfmohf lo| vh~v| icj|je

mjp|cjhjlocfnfoho wf yfho meafpoh ihcj|j ej| `jw|jhpj|th fpeocfyflocfnfoho h`(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

84/1668

=0

ocf P|e ^ocjmc Evwwfpcf|ohf ajctfaf jcacj| -~jwj kfaocf|o/( Lph lvhcj| hkocpf|f ocf P|eoyfhoh

`hyj ~i|vhcj|hj ocoeoh i|pje yjecjahh yjh~ajcj| hopfcooh`f o`o( Lyefco# yfho meafpoh `

ricopoej~hh pfafc`f jyh otko`f `fwja f`fnfoho |fhafepfh tfccoecf afahvh ic`vvhv

wv|kvcj`(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

85/1668

=6

Lv |jri|vh# Lyefco ocf P|e @ocf|o Ljejhc j|j~h`jeo ocoeoyo i|pjyj eiy`vv

lfco|pocafco`o|( \jri|# Jhej|j Lyefcocoohoh P|eoyfhoh o wf ` ricopoej~ mjeeh`j hkocot @ocf|o

Ljejhch hnf`fh lockocfh`o|`ooho f k~pf|afepf`o|(

J~ef|o yhfpoa j`hj oce ejaviyv jecjaj~ Jcljy P|ef

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

86/1668

=7

yf|fc yfpeococf| wf rico~ afav|cj| wf yic~vtcveicjycj|hj lvcjjh lo| e~a o j`ja wj|`(>:Lvhcj|h

iv Mjto|jhh ljh`jh opolj|fh j`j`j pvpvc`v(

_j|kcjaj hnf~o ~i|vpv|ajcj|# yfcf|oho j~ef|o |fdoaoh ~fpoo >: eoocoe lo| tfc _e~fe

^i|vpv|aj Ev|vcvpj|jgh`jh yjrc`( Ev|vc# `fcoccf|o pircjaje wf o``oj ajeja ooh `jwjcj| mjt| mjcf

kfpo|afe jajnycj j|j wf|afe~otoh jcp( ^vcjhjh 6?< eoohoh ajmefaf~o# Ev|vcvh lv jcaj~hpjajacjyjlocaf~o ooh `|p jy`jh gjtcj lo| ~|f f|pfcfh`o(>>

Jhjyj~jyj k|f ca nftjcj| ALEpj|jgh`jh ihjycjhajcy`( _j|kcjaj ~|fnohf ipi|opfcf|oh

a`jmjcf`f lvcvhaj` ~ycfhfaft( Mjeoacf| wf ~jwncj| `i|v`jh ALEhh icvpv|`vv meafp

pj|jgh`jh jpjhap( Jhej|j`jeo hkocot lyefco~o ajmefafcf|oh ev|vcaj~hh `fooe ~flfrcf|o

ic`vvhj `oeejp fepo( Fh hfaco hf`fh avmpfafcfh a`jmjcfyo mjec ecaj j|tv~vy`v( Lyefco#

P|ecf|oh mvevevh `fpjycj|hj hfa wf|fh lo| mjce ic`vv yi|vavhv yjrp(>0

Lv o~jlfpco lo| pjmcoc`o# he ~pjhlvc howf|~opf~oh`fh mveve `jch`jeo |fpoa yfcf|o !\fep|

R|igf~| ^``e ^jao Ihj| `jmoc! AELyj `j|lfyo mveveo lo| tfaohf ipv|pajcj| pjw~oyf~oh`f

lvcvh`vcj|( @j|lf yjrc`h`j# `j|lfno ~vljycj|h hoyfpo jy ooh`f yfho ~foacf|o yjraje wfj|ej~h`jh `j oepo`j| ~owoc meafpf `fw|fpafepo( Jej`fao~yfhcf|# f~eo meafpoh ljejhcj|hh wf

@faie|jp Rj|po yfcf|ohoh yfho ~foacf| yjrcaj`jh hnf yj|kcjhajcj| eihv~vh`j `j|lf co`f|cf|oho

pfwoe fppocf|( Ihcj|j k|f# jyfp lv eoocf| ~foacf|`fh hnf yj|kcjhr ~vcv lvcvhajtcj|~j yfho`fh

~focafyf mje ejtjh|cj| wf `jmj ~ih|j pfe|j| oepo`j|j kfcfloco|cf|`o( Meafpo ev|ajcj| ocf

yj|kcjhajcj|hh ~ihj f|af~o j|j~h`jeo `hfa`f `j|lfyf ejpcjh j~ef|o k|fwcocf|o

pvpvecjyjloco|cf|`o( Jej`fao~yfhcf|oh mveveo ~|fnoh kf|fo kolo pjeor f`ocaf~o yhh`feo pjw~oyf~o

ajmefafhoh :: jy kf ~ihvcjhaj~hj yic jp( ALEyfcf|ohoh# e~j ~|fh lo| ajmefaf ~ihvnvh`j

f~eo meafp yfcf|ohoh `jmj jlve lf|pj|jg f`ocflocfnfecf|oho `h`ecf|o jhcjcajepj`|(_j|kcjajhh vtjyr ej|j|h eajaj~ ~foacf|oh f|pfcfhaf~ohf wf ~owoc |fdoaf `hh `jmj

~ih|jyj l|jecaj~hj hf`fh ic`v(

Ljt fhpfcfepfccf|oh P|eoyf`feo j~ef|o `j|lfyo `i|v`jh `f~pfecf`oo wf ihcj|h pjw~oyfcf|ohoh

lj~op lo| `j|lfyo lo| ompocjcf `hp|` ~ycfhfloco|(>6 ALE# afwnvp jhjyj~jy y||cepfh ejc`|`

wf lo| eiao~yih pj|jgh`jh yfho lo| jhjyj~jhh mjt|cjhaj~h fa|fppo( Ihcj|# hnfeo jhjyj~jyj k|f

efh`ocf|ohoh ~vcv ic`vvhvh gj|ehj wj|`cj|# jhjyj~jy `fopo|`ocf| wf i|`vhvh mfa hnfeo mfa `f

afwnvp jhjyj~jyj k|f wjpjh ~fwf| icajhh kf|fecf|oho yf|ohf kfpo|afepfh pfyf lo| fy yjraj`h

o``oj fppocf|(>7Lycfnf ljcjhkpjeo j|lfyo mveveo lo| tfaohf ipv|ppvcj|(

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

87/1668

=;

J~ef|o meafpoh mj|fefpcf|ohoh mf|mjhko lo| eoohoh wfyj ~hgh cfmohf yj `j jcfymohf

icaj`h ogj`f f`fh oce ejaviyv jecjaj~>;ocf _j~~j`j ajmefafcf|ohoh yjrcaj~ j|j~h`j lo|

pftjp ~t eihv~vy`v( Lv|j`j pfe ~vcjhjh f~eo oepo`j| rj|po~o yfcf|o wf `f~pfeocf|oy`o( Lv# `j|lfhoh

j~ch`j ef~ohcoecf @faie|jp Rj|poyf ej| yjrc` jhcjahj kfcafepfy`o( Lvhvhcj lo|coepf j~ef|o

meafpoh lj Kfhf|jc K|~fc#f~eo ljejhcj|`jh mo lo|ohoh o`ja f`ocafyfnfohoh jcph ot`o(

hkocot meafpo P|eoyf`feo kfcoafcf|oh jc` yh`fh hfaco c`f ejykcy`( mpocjc`fh

mfafh ~ih|j wf `v|vajcj|h ljcjhknh`j lyefco# yj|kcjajcj| wf avmpfafc ej|j|cj| !tfccoecf

`f f~eo Ljljejh wf `of| ljejhcj|j ocoeoh icjhcj|! mjeeh`j `tfhco |jri|cj| kh`f|`o( hkocot

lyefco~o =

@ocf|o Ljejh ^j|rf|# Jhej|j`j yjljhn pfa~ocnocf|cf yjrp pircjhp`j ihcj|j P|e

mj~~j~oyfpcf|oho `oeejpf jcj|je# af~fcfhoh fh oyo looa`f hj~c fcf jchjlocfnfo eihv~vh`j

pjw~oyfcf|`f lvcvh`v( hkocot @ocf|o Ljejhchh Khfy @jo|f~o ljejh \( G( K( ^j|fcc# ^j|rf|oh

pjw~oyfcf|oho pvppvv hippj ycf tfpcf`o4

-P|e meafpo ocf yjrcjnje mf|mjhko lo|/ _jtaj`j ca nftj~ eihv~v kh`faf

kfpo|ocafafco`o|# he lv jm~fh o`jacj|j ej| ic`vvhv ef~oh lo| `occf ogj`f f`fh K|~fco ~j`fnf

tf| wf |jmjp~t f`f|( I# ^j|rf|f lvh`jh pfyf lo| fy ~i|ajyjnjh lfco|pf|fe ca nftjcj|h`jh

mf|mjhko lo|ohoh ogj f`ocaf~o `v|vavh`j o~pogj fpafyf ej|j| wf|or wf|af`ooho ~i|`v ^j|rf| ca

nftj~ wf|ocaf~o ompoajcohoh yt`f fcco ic`vvhv wf ca nftj~ wf|ocaf~o mjcoh`f =2)?

@of| lo| @ocf|o Ljejhc locko hipvh`j vhcj| lfco|poc`o4

ie ockoh( Faohoa eo ^j|rf|oh pjw~oyfcf|ohf vyajcyt( Ljljejh lv hipv k|afe o~pfyfloco|(

Lvhvh tf|ohf Ljljejhj v pjw~oyf`f lvcvhvc`v4

Jhcjc` ej`j|ycj kfcoafcf| v jh`j o~pf`ooaot `i|vcpv`j`|( Ljejhch k|# ^j|rf|oh

pjw~oyfcf|oho ef~ohcoecf pjeor fpafaot kf|fepoo yhh`f`o|(02

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

88/1668

==

Lv||i{~ lv k|f ejpc`h ogj`f fppo4

_jljhn lj~hj yjrcjnje lo| yi|vavh# ff| P|e mj~~j~oyfpcf|oho |fhno`f fpafafe jajnycj oyo

lo| tjajhcjaj wf tfhcf ~focao ogj`fcf| evccjhcj|je yjrc|~j# kfhfc icj|je Ljp `hyj~hh

`hnfcf|ohoh lfco|pocaf~o j~h`jh fh fpeoh yiccj|`jh lo|o icjlocfnfohf ohjhajepjya(0:

Lv||i{~# NMRhoh h`f kfcfh kfh yfcf|oh`fh wf rj|pohoh kjtfpf~o Vcv~vh khce ef

yjtj|cj|h`jh Fnfwop ocf yjrp k|af`f v jecjajcj|`j lvcvh`v4

Ajmefafcf| eihv~v mfafh mf| k|af`f ic`vv kolo lv k|af`f `f kh`faf kfc`o wf

ihj yjljhncj|h yj|kcjajcj|h ~ihvnvhj ocoeoh goeo|cf|ohoh P|e yfpeococf|o fpeocfyor fpeocfafyfnf oho

~i|`va( Aocco Lo|coe Eiaopf~o -ALE/ yfcf|o wf `of| yfpeococf|oh# ` lj~h`j yjtcjhcj|h yjljhn

cefcf|`f icvjh ejhjjp tf|oh`feo fpeo~o eihv~vh`j hfp lo| goe|f ~jmor ic`vecj| wf lvhvh ihcj|

hjtj|h`j lo|c`f hfao ic`vvhv ~ycf`o( _ohf `f mf|mjhko lo| |f~ao yjljhn a`jmjcf icaj~

`v|vavh`j lvhvh lye ompoajccf ihcj| |jmjp~t f`flocfnfo wf ihcj|h o`jacj| yf|ohf kfpo|afe

eihv~vh`j `jmj ej|j|c yjrjlocfnfo k|h`fy`o( -Lv||i{~j k|f/ Fnfwopoh `jmj hnf ff|

o`jacj| yf|ohf kfpo|ocaft~f `faie|j~oyf kfooh hfaco c`f eicjycjjnjh ogj`f fpaf~o# lv

k|h jmj ockoh ecap(0

Lv||i{~ of|`feo kfcoafcf|f ocoeoh lockoyo kfhfccoecf ^j|rf|`fh jcajepjy`( Jhej|j`jeo hkocot

`orciajpcj| wf @ocf|o Ljejhc# ^j|rf|oh wf|`oo lockocf|f wf j~ef|o meafp wf K|~fcoh

ricopoej~hj ocoeoh pjw~oyfcf|ohf lfc ljcjacj|`( Lv||i{~vh hf|ocf|o @ocf|o Ljejhchnj

lfhoa~fh`o wf f~eo Ljljejh wf oeo f~eo ljejhh o`jacj|h hcfafe jajnycj ALEyj `i|v`jh

a`jmjcf fpafepfh ejhc`(

@ocf|o Ljejhc# hkocot k|hh lfcco f`ocaf~o ooh Ljljejh`jh K|~fcf lo| afepvr

kh`f|ocaf~ohoh yfpf|co icjnj k|h`fy`o( Ej~a :?72pj Ljljejh Ajnaoccjh# _j~~j`j

yj|kcjajcj|hj ocoeoh Jhej|j`jeo lyefco wj~pj~ycj ocfpocfnfe lo| jm~o afepvlvh K|~fcf

kh`f|ocaf~oho ihjycj`( Lyefcoyf af~jd`j o~pf`oo `fooecoecf|o yjraj yfpeo~o wf hf tjajh wf

hj~c K|~fcf af~jdh ocfpocfnfo eihv~vh`j oho~oyjpog wf|oc`o( Lv||i{~ ? jy lfecfyf|fe lv af~jd 0

Jv~pi~ :?7:`f# yj|kcjajcj| ~ihj yjecj|efh wf icva~vt mea wf|ocaf~o ompoajco `i`vv lo|

tjajh`j ocfppo( Af~jdh of|`oo ljcnj k|cf| vhcj|`4

Lv P|eoyfhoh lo| o mveve af~fcf~o`o| wf yj|kcjajcj| wf ej|j|cj|j ocoeoh yi|va yjraje lotf

`aft( Ljljejh ~j`fnf# o`jacj|h Lo|cfoe E|jccepj yjrjnj avmpfafc fpeocf|f Kfhf|jc K|~fcoh`oeejpoho feafe o~pf|( Lot P|eoyf ocf `i~pcve wf oppogjej lye hfa wf|afepfyot( ^jyh Afh`f|f~ wf

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

89/1668

=?

o j|ej`jcj| P|eoyfhoh Ljp ljcjhp~ ocf HJPI wf NFHPIhvh ~j`e ~jwvhvnvcj| icj|je

pjhhacj|`( Ihcj| El|~ jhcjaj~hh yjrcaj~h`j lye |ic iyhj`cj|( Lv eoocf|oh o`ja f`ocaf~o#

Lo|cfoe E|jccepj# P|eoyf wf hkocpf|fhoh -fe~oe/ Ljp pircvavhvh ye~fe o`fjccf|o ocf vyvaj`

fecoh`f `ff|cfh`o|ocfloco|(00

Lv||i{~# Ljljejhh af~jdhh hfaco eiavpjhcj| j|j~h`j yjykh looa`f ievh`vvhvloc`o|`o(06@ocf|o Ljejhc af~jdh hfaco c`f fpeo l|jeph lfco|pfh oyoa~f| lo| yi|va yjrp(

@ocf|o Ljejhc Lv||i{~j eihvyj a`jmjcf fpaf~oho# jhnje lv a`jmjcfhoh P|eoyf

pj|jghh ` a`jmjcf ~vcjajcj|h`j lvcvhj|je yj|j|`jh ie tj|j| kfpo|af~oh`fh ejhaje

jajnycj aaeh icjh ~ih jhj ej`j| lfecfaf~oho pjw~oyf fppo(07 Ljejhce yjt~h`j lfco|poc`oohf

k|f# |f~ao yjty P|eoyfhoh Ljp `hyj~h`jeo `i~pcj|h fpeocfyflocfnfe kf|fe~ot yf|f ~f|p

nacfcf|f `jyjh`|aj pfmcoef~ohf ej| Lv||i{~vh mf| mjcej|`j hcfa jcaj~ pjw~oyf f`oc`o(

hkocotcf|oh lv pjw|hh# hkocpf|fhoh pfaj~pj lvcvh`vv Jhej|j`jeo yjljhn ao~yihvh wf JL@

meafpo `jmoc `of| meafpcf|oh kfhfc yjecja ocf jyh `i|vcpv`j ic`vv jhcjcajepjy`(

Lv||i{~vh ljcnj appfgoe cefcf|`fh af~cfepjcj| ocf i|pjecjj jcaj~ o~pfh`o wf @ocf|o

Ljejhc ihj Jhej|j`jeo |jhlyefco~o ocf `f yjeh ocoeo ooh`f icaj~h pjw~oyf fppo(0;

Ajnaoccjhh af~jd vcjp|caj`jh locf hnf# hkocot meafpo mf| g|~jppj P|e yfpeococf|f

`hnfcf|oho ogj`f fppo(0=J|jce :?72`j# oa`oeo Ajcoyf Ljejh wf f~eo @ocf|o ljejh ^fc{yh

Cciy`# IFN@ pircjhp~ f~hj~h`j P|e @ocf|o Ljejh ^j|rf| ocf k|p( Cciy` ^j|rf|f

ajmefafcf|o mjeeh`j ~i|v ~i|`v( ^j|rf|# ~jhecj|j efh`ocf|oho ~jwvhajcj| ooh lph oaejhcj|h

~jcjh` wf yj|kcjajhh j`oc ic`vvhv ~ycf`o( Cciy` yj|kcjajcj|h ~ihvcj|h `j ~i|vpv|`v(^j|rf|# Kfhf|jc K|~fcoh `f ooh`f lvcvh`vv kc lo| lj~e k|vlvhvh ca nftjcj|hj ej|

ic`vvh`jh ljm~fppo( Ajcoyf Ljejh lvhv `vyajecj |jmjpcj`h# he ejh `ecaf~ohoh mf| tjajh

pfe|j| ejh `ecaf~ohf yic jph wf ff| mf|mjhko lo| o`ja ohgjt f`oco|~f lvhvh P|eoyf ooh lo|

p|jdf`o icjlocfnfoho ~ycf`o( _ohf yj|kcjhjhcj|h tjajhh`j Ljphh oyo `i~pcj| ic`vecj|hj wv|kv

yjrp( ^j|rf| lv ~tcf|f pjajafh ejpc`h wf mo lo| ca nftj~hh ohgjt f`ocafyfnfohf `jo|

Ljejhj kwfhnf wf|flocfnfoho `h`h ~ycf`o(0?

hkocot lyefco~o# ajmefafcf|oh ~ihvh`j ca nftj~ wf|ocaf~o ompoajcohf ocoeoh appfgoe

cefcf|oh Jhej|j`jeo `orciajpoe ao~yihcj| ocf ~e lo| i|pje jcaj yjrp( Lvh`jh ljej# @ocf|o

Ljejhc `j appfgoe cefcf|oh Cih`|j`jeo lyefcocoecf|o ocf o|poljp ev|`v( Gf`f|jc Jcajh lyefco~o

; Ej~a :?72`j @ocf|o Ljejhc A~pfj| Miyj| Aoccf| ocf k|p( Mf| oeo~o `f tjajh~t l o|

a`jmjcfhoh yjhc icjnj wf mf|mjhko lo| |f~ao oejyfppf lvcvhvcaj~hh lv p| lfckfcf|oh fh fpeoco

icjlocfnfo i|pjyj ep jhj ej`j| f|pfcfhaf~o tf|oh`f k| lo|coohf wj|`cj|( Miyj| Aoccf| lv

wf~ocf ocf# Gf`f|jc Jcajh meafpohoh lo| tjajh lv

~i|vhv# Jcajhyjhh P|eoyfocf feihiaoe ocoeocf|o ocf jcjejcjh`|`h hkocotcf|oh `h`h

fecf`o( Miyj| Aoccf|# oeo af~fcfyo lo|lo|o ocf ocoeocfh`o|afhoh yjhc icjnj wf lv p|`fh lo| lj~ehhefh`o efh`oho litkvhj v|jpn lo| hopfcoe pjyjlocfnfoho `hafepfy`o( Gf`f|jc Jcajh lyefco~o

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

90/1668

?2

lvhv jhcj`h ogj`f fppo wf Jcajh ipi|opfcf|ohoh oa`o lv `hnfyo lo| efhj|j l|jepecj| otcfhoaoho

wf|`o(62

Jhej|j`jeo Jaf|oejh lyefco~o Gcfpnmf| [j||fh# a`jmjcfhoh `jmj oce khcf|oh`f efh`o~ohoh

K|~fcf o`jacj|h Jaf|oejh yjecja tf|oh`f icva~vt fpeo yjrjlocfnfo wf lvh`jh `icjy

Jaf|oejh yhfpoaohoh P|eoyfyf yjrcjnje yj|`a ooh Eihk|fhoh ihjyh jcaj~h `jmj `jti|cjp|jnjh ~ycf`ooho loc`o|`o( Lv||i{~# Jcajh wf G|jh~tcj|h lv eihv`j P|ecf|o I|pje Rjtj|

k|afcf|o wj~pj~ycj fpeocfafyf jcjlocfnfecf|oh`fh ~t fppo( Lv feihiaoe ~joeoh lv of

ejpcaj~hh lye lo| mjpj ic`vvhv `h`hf oj|fp fppo( J~ch`j Jaf|oejh lyefco~ohoh lv oeo

eihvhvh jy|caj~ kf|fepooho o`|je f`or fpaf`ooh`fh rmf f`fh Lv||i{~ vhcj| fecf`o4

P|ecf|# ej|n lo| pj|t`j feihiaoe ejykcj|h kh`faf kfpo|ocaf~ohf ej| f|fgcf|oho

~jwvhajepjh micjhcjnje ej`j| `ivcv lo| tomhoyfpf ~jmorpo|( Af`fho lo| aoccfp icj|je ihcj|h

r|f~podohf mopjr fpafe `jmj ljj|c icjloco|(6:

Lv||i{~vh lv ejhjjpo P|ecf|oh kfhfc tfccooho fh oyo jhcjpjh lo| ogj`fy`o(

P|e meafpo `orciajpoe ao~yih ljejhcj|hj `v|vajcj|j ejpcajcj| ooh `jwfpoyfcf|

kh`f|`o( @ocf|o Ljejhc lv `v|va mjeeh`j Jhej|jyj lo| yjt yjt`( Lv yjt`j lyefcohoh

`i~p!appfgoe cef `orciajpoe ao~yihcj| ocf# tfccoecf Jaf|oejc af~cfepjycj# vyvacv `jw|jhaj~hj

wv|kv yjrcap4

Fe~fcjh~cj|hh `v|vajcj|j jm~fh ejpcaj~hh vykvh ic`vvhv `hayi|va !lv pjw~oyf

`fohocfh p|`fh lo| vyvavh ~jcjhaj~ `v|vavh`j kt`fh kfo|ocfnfepo|!# gjejp lyefcocoe

rf|~ihfcoh`fh lo|ohoh ktcfano icj|je ~oto pfa~oc fpaf~oh`f lo| ~jehnj k|ayi| wf mjppj lvhvh ljt

jwjhpjdcj| ic`vvhv `hyi|va( Lv pj|t ejpca# P|e yfpeococf|f ej| mf|mjhko lo| hftjefp~otcoe

yjrajepjh ~jehajht wf ~otoh `jwj ~|fno mjeeh`j# `v|vajcj|h wf lvhcj|h ~ihvh`j wf|ocfnfe

meacf|oh ihjycjh`h oaj fpafe~otoh `i|v lo| `ff|cfh`o|af yjrjlocafhoto aaeh ecjnjep|( 6 Aj|p :?7:`fP|e @ocf|o Ljejhh`jh ie evwwfpco lo| orvnv f`oh`ooh`fh ~t fppo(^j|rf|# f~eo Nvamv|ljejh# Ljljejh wf `of|cf|ohoh _j~~j`j`jeo yj|kcjaj~ ~ihvnvh`j ca

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

91/1668

?:

nftj~hj j|rp|c| wf lv nftj ohgjt f`oco|~f lvhvh yv|p `h`j hf`fh icjnj icva~vt oajd mjeeh`j

E|jcofhoh 7 Aj|ppj Jhej|jyj yjrjnj toyj|fppf K|~fccf k|p tjajh jm~fh lo|fycf|

~ycfaf~ohoh ie gjy`jc icjlocfnfohoh jcph ot`o( Lv||i{~# E|jcofhoh lv p| lo| af~fcfyo kh`faf

kfpo|af~ohoh ie ~|j ` lo| fy icjnjh `h`h# gjejp efh`o~ohoh ^o| M( Aoccf|j lv eihv`j

jm~o lo| af~jd kh`f|fnfoho ogj`f fppo( ^j|rf|# lycf lo| pfecogo efh`o~ohoh kfpo|`oohoh locohafaf~ohoh

jm~ j~h`jh mjyjpo hfaf ~jmor ic`vvhv wv|kvcj`(6>

^j|rf| @R meafpo `hfaohoh fh ~feoh `orciajpcj|h`jh lo|oy`o( @j|lfhoh mfafh ~ih|j~h`j

j~ef|o yhfpoa ihv @ocf|o Ljejh yjrp( I# vcv~cj|j|j~ ev|vcvcj| wf yjljhn cefcf| mjeeh`j

fhkoh lo| `fhfyoa ~jmoloy`o(60jm~fh ca nftjcj|hj ej|y` wf lv nftjcj|h vcv~cj|j|j~ jcjh`j

P|eoyfhoh m|fpo tf|oh`f yjrjlocfnfo icva~vt fpeohoh gj|eh`jy`( Lv||i{~wf Aoccf| ocf yjeh lo|

ocoeo ev|avpv( ^j|rf| ie avmpfafcfh lv p|jdoe `v|vavh hcfhaf~o jajnycj hkocotcf|cf lo|coepf

jcajhh aaeh ic`vvhj ohjha icjloco|`o( Lv||i{~# ^j|rf|oh > Aj|ppj efh`o~ohf lfco|ppoecf|oho

v feoc`f jhcj`h @ocf|o Ljejhhj loc`o|`o4

Ljej lo| `fwcfp ljejh pj|jgh`jh -o`jacj| eihv~vhj ocoeoh k|cf|o ogj`f f`fh/ lo|

jecjajhh Kfhf|jc K|~fcf ocfpocaf~o mf| fy`fh `jmj fpeoco icjloco| wf ca nftjcj|hh

mjgogcfpocaf~oho ~jcjyjnje lo| ej|j|h jchaj~ jlj~h`j ihv kcfh`o|floco|( -^j|rf|/# Kfhf|jc

K|~fcoh lv pj|t lo| k|afyo aaeh ecajy vavyi| yj `j o~poyi| icjlocfnfo otcfhoaoho locf wf|`o#

he K|~fc kotco lo| eihvajhh yjrcjlocaf~o ooh mjwjjcjhh`jeo |f~fr~oyih i`j~h`j lvcvhjnje

eoocf|oh ~jy~hh ~h|c pvpvcaj~ -E|jcof# F`ohlv|km @e UE|jcofhoh einj~ R|fh~ RmocorQ# ^jyh

^j|rf| wf ~ot/ o~pfoho efh`o~ohf loc`o|`ooho ~ycf`o(66

Lv||i{~ vhcj| `j fecf`o4

^jyh ^j|rf|oh hf|o~o tf|oh`f hfacf `hafaot kf|fepoo ejhjjpoh`fyoa( I# Kfhf|jc

K|~fcf yjeh`| wf lv mj~~j~ eihv`j hfyoh fh yj|j|c icjnjh locafe j~h`jh fh oyo eihva`j

icjh eoo`o|(67

E|jcofhoh yvej|`j `fohocfh looa`f K|~fc ocf lvcvaj~# E|jcofhoh vjhh Cih`|j`jh

Pjm|jhj ko`f|efh Jhej|j mjwjjcjhh`j aicj wf|`oo tjajh kf|fecfpo( 7 Aj|p :?7:`f E|jcof#

mjwjjcjhhh ~jcihvh`j K|~fc ocf e~j lo| k|af yjrp(K|af`fF`ohlv|k @e# Miaf Eihpv-hkocot @ocf|o Ljejh/ wf ^fcoa ^j|rf| `f mjt| lvcvhavpv( P|eoyfhoh ~oyj~o `v|vavhj ocoeoh

~i|vyj K|~fc# rcjhcj|hh j|tvcjhjh yh`f kfcopooh`fh ~t f`f|fe nfwjr wf|`o( Ihj k|f4

Mvevevh kf|fecf|ohoh yf|ohf kfpo|ocaf~ohf a`jmjcf f`ocfaft`o( ^jhecj|j oyo jwvejpcj| pfaoh

f`ocaopo wf mjeoacf| P|eoyfhoh fh oyo mjeoacf|oy`o( Af~fcf ihcj|h won`jhhj l|jecajcy`( Gjejp

ej|j| efh`o~o wf Aocco Lo|coe Eiaopf~o pfayot f`fnfepo( Lv jjaj`j# ff| kf|feo|~f wf lv `i|v o~f#

efh`o~o ~vcvcj|j af|mjafp k~pf|ocaf~o j`hj a`jmjcf fpaf g|~jph lvcjnjep(6;

K|~fc fclfppf yj|kcjajhh ~ihvnvhv pjmaoh f`faft`o# gjejp meafpohoh ejh~t lo| ompocjc yjrph wf ihv ejh jepaj`jh ei|vaje o~pf`ooho ocf|o ~|`( R|fh~ Rmocor nftjcj|h oh`o|ocaf~o

7/30/2019 Trkler-Cilt-17 Cumhuriyet (TRK TARiHi ZERiNE ALMALAR VE GENEL DEERLENDiRMELER)

92/1668

?7 ych`j ~pjhlvc`j Efajc

Jpjp|e ocf lvcvavpv# jhnje i tjajh`jh lv yjhj molo| hkocot e|jc P|eoyfhoh mjcj ~j`f lo| yf|

hopfcooh`feo ljefhpo Jhej|jy toyj|fp fpafaopo( E|jcof jyh tjajh`j j~ef|o `j|lf`fh lf|o

P|eoyfyo toyj|fp f`fh oce yjljhn `fwcfp ljejhy`(7:

@ocf|o Ljejhchh Lv||i{~vh k|afyf ejpcjhcj|h ~jy~hh ~h|cjhaj~hj ocoeoh

hf|o~ohf wf f~eo rj|cjafhpf|cf|oh yj|kcjhaj~ wf ihcj|j ca nftj~ wf|ocaf~o ompoajco mjeeh`jeo

hkocot lje j~hj ocoeoh wf|`oo goe|f vykvh `jw|jh` lfco|pocafco`o|( hkocpf|f`fh ljej mo lo| cef

`fwcfp ljejhhh j~ef|o yhfpoa`fh f~eo aoccfpwfeoccf|o ooh af|mjafp k~pf|ocaf~o pjcfloh`f

lvcvhajaj~ `j hfaco`o|(

Lv||i{~# Ajnaoccjhh af~jdh ocfpafyo 0 Jv~pi~ :?7:f ej`j| `ievt jy f|pfcf`o( Lv af~jd

^j|rf|oh lo| yjljhn cef `ocf|o ljejhh`jh jc` oeohno yjtc af~jd`( ^j|rf|oh lyefcoyf

~ycf`oohf k|f# Jcajhcj|h af~jd eihvyj hkocotcf|oheoh`fh lo|jt gj|ec lo| lje j~h`jh

yjecjap( _ohf `f ^j|rf|# Jcajh af~jdhh `j jyh c`f fpeoco wf ripjh~oyfc icj|je gjy`jc

ic`vvhv `h` otcfhoaoho wf|`o(7

Nvamv|ljejh Ljyj|# Ljljejh Afh`f|f~# @ocf|o Ljejh Ti|cv wf Ajcoyf Ljejh Ricjpejh`(

Mea wf|oc`oo tjajh ;= yjh`j icjh Ljyj|# yjc icaj~ hf`fhoycf ohgjt`jh ev|pvc`v( 70

Lph ca nftjcj| P|e Nftj Ejhvhvhvh :07( aj``f~ohf `jyjhcj|je wf|ocaopo( Lv aj``f

ca nftjcj|hh P|eoyf Nvamv|oyfpo jhjyj~j~h evwwfp evccjhj|je `fopo|afyf# yf|ohf ljej~h

kfpo|afyf wfyj i|pj`jh ejc`|ajyj jcjhcj| ooh wf|ocfnfo meah