university of oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éf`{znoàiaf% ù Àõüiû ø dûnù...

21

Upload: others

Post on 25-Mar-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

� ����� ����� ������ ���������� � � ������������ � ��� ��� �!" ��#�����%$���&'��( ) *+$��,#(������ - ����#. �0/#�

12*43 3 ��� �5* 1+���

6'798;:57=<=<?>�@BADCFEFGIH4J'KL8NMFG;OPHRQ#S'HRQUTLGI@ V�7?WLWNGITYXZOPH[]\L^�\N_a`cbed�[�fYdgfYhYijbjk�lmin\No�prqPsmftp�huin_av�fewI_R\uxRyUw�zL`{w�ftfeia`|w�z~}�b�`|few�b�f

����x�\Lij���mw�`|��feijd?`{_?��q����5���N�����

�5�P�j�������e������N�j ¢¡Y£�¤=¥?¦n§¨¥?��¥?©�§e¥Uªu«|�j¬�­I¡e«|£N¥?®{«|£Nªt§e¦=«¯§e£L¥P¦?�j­�¦?��¤9�j£L¥n§¨¥=«|¡Y£�¤±°j§e£�²I��¡Y²�¥n§�«{£����

³ ¦?¡Y ´«| �§eµY��¤ ³ ¡Y¦R§�¶�¤9� ³ ¶N·r°g·¯§Y¤?¤U¡ ³F¸Y¹ ¤= ¢¡L¡Y¥g©5¡Y²�º=��°a¥�»½¼U©���°g·c§u¤?¤U¡ ³ ¤=¶�¦ ³ §Y°a��¤�§e¦g�¥g©�¡L¤=��µY�j£��j¦n§¨¥?����§Y¤¾¥?©����j£NªY�a·|¡Y­I��¡ ³ §�¤=­�©��j¦g��¡ ³ ªt§e¦g¿Y«|£�µ¢¦n§Y�u«|¶�¤�¤9¬À�j­�¥Á§�·|¡Y£�µ�§¨£§tÂL«c¤Ã»r¼¾©N«c¤�°g·c§Y¤g¤½«{£�°g·|¶��N��¤R°j§¨£�§�·r¤=¶�¦ ³ §Y°a��¤�§¨£��5¤=¶�¦ ³ §Y°a��¤U¡ ³ ¦?�jªY¡e·{¶�¥=«|¡Y£�»¼U©��~¦?�j­�¦?��¤=�j£N¥n§e¥=«{¡Y£�¤Ä§e¦?�~°a¡Y Ä­�¶�¥?����ÅD¶�¤Æ«|£�µ'¡Y£N·|¿'«|  §eµY� «|£ ³ ¡Y¦? �§¨¥=«|¡Y£�Å ³ ¦?¡Y 

¥g©���¤=¿N Ä Ä�j¥g¦?¿�¤=�j¥U¡ ³ ¥g©���¡Y²�º=��°a¥�ÇȤ½¡u¶�¥=·É«|£��Y»½¼U©��j¿5§e¦?�ÁªY«{�j¬�­�¡e«{£L¥?®{«{£Lªe§e¦=«c§e£N¥½¶�£��N�j¦¬U��§eÊN®¯­��j¦a¤=­���°a¥=«{ªY��«|  §eµe«|£�µ�ÅN§e£���Ëu¶�§Y¤Æ«{®{«|£Lªe§e¦=«c§¨£L¥U¥?¡Ä§e£��aÂ�°a�a·É·{�j£L¥R§¨­�­�¦?¡�ÂL«|  §e¥=«|¡Y£¶�£��N�j¦D­��j¦n¤=­I��°a¥=«|ªY�]«| �§eµ¨«|£�µ�»Ì¼Í¡�¥?©N«c¤U§e­�­�¦?¡�ÂN«| �§e¥9«|¡Y£�ÅY¥g©���­N·c§e£�§e¦�§�ÂN«c¤±¡ ³ §�°j§e£�§�·¤9¶�¦ ³ §u°a�Á«c¤U¦?��°a¡eªY�j¦?��� ¶�­�¥?¡Ä§e£�§�Î�£���§¨ �²N«{µY¶N«|¥=¿ ³ ¦?¡Y 2­��j¦n¤9­���°a¥=«|ªu��«| �§¨µY��¤j»ÏPÂ�§e Ä­N·|��¤�§¨¦?�½µe«|ªY�j£�¡ ³ ¥?©��±¦?�j­�¦?��¤=�j£N¥n§e¥9«|¡Y£�¤I¡Y²�¥n§�«{£���� ³ ¦?¡u %¦?��§�·Y«{ �§eµY��¤jÅì�©N«c°g©

�N�j ¢¡Y£�¤=¥?¦n§¨¥?��¤=¥a§e²N«É·É«|¥=¿�§¨£���¡u²�ºÐ��°a¥��u«c¤?°a¦9«| �«|£�§e¥9«|¡Y£�Å ³ ¡Y¦Á²�¡Y¥?©�°j§e£�§t·Ñ¤=¶�¦ ³ §Y°a��¤�§¨£��¤9¶�¦ ³ §u°a��¤U¡ ³ ¦?�jªu¡e·|¶�¥=«|¡u£�»rÒÍ«{£�§�·É·|¿YÅu¥?©���¦?�j­�¦?��¤=�j£N¥n§e¥9«|¡Y£�¤U§e¦?��¶�¤=����§Y¤±¥?©���²�§Y¤Æ«¯¤ ³ ¡u¦¾§ ¢¡Ó�N�a·|®¯²�§u¤=���5¡Y²�ºÐ��°a¥U¦?��°a¡Yµu£N«|¥=«|¡Y£5¤=¿�¤=¥?�j �»

Ô Õ¾ÖØ×UÙÁÚ'Û�Ü;Ý]×DÞtÚØÖßÁkàf�hu`|vá\Yx�_ak�`cd¢âÁ\Liaã�`¯dÄ_a\'ft�I_nijhNb�_¢��`{ftâ�pÍ\L`{w�_aä�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�_��IfYdab�ia`{pà_a`{\Lw�d¢\Yx��Ns�dgv�\�\N_nk\L^�å?fYb�_ædÑx�ia\Lvçdg`{wàzNè{f�`|v~hYzNfYd���ßÁk�fYd?f��IfYdab�ia`{pà_a`{\Lw�dUâ�`{è|èI^�f�o�dgfY��hNdRdgk�hYp�f��If¨dab�in`{p�_n\NijdU`|w�hv�\��Ifeè|äÆ^,hNdgf¨�0infYb�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Lw�dg�àdg_aftv'�Àé,\Li�hÄb�\Nv�p�è|fe_afeè|��zNftw�feijhYè�\N^�å?fYb�_tq�huw,�0â�`|_ak5w�\Ä\N_nk�fei`|wIx�\Ninv~hY_a`|\Nw½qN`|_±`cd±w�\L_Up�\�dad?`{^�è|f�_a\�infYb�\Y��feiFd?k�hup�f�\NiÀ`{w��NhYia`chuw�_U�If¨dab�in`{p�_n`{\Nw,dÑx�ia\Lv#h�dg`{wàzNè{f`|v~hYzNf�ê=d?fefmx�\Li�fe��hYv�pàè{f�ëíì�q�îIqÌ�eïNðPx�\Li��Ns+p�\L`{w�_�dgfe_ædÃñj��ò�\uâRfe��feitq�`ÉxF_ak�f��Ls+d?_aino�b�_aoàiafÄ`¯dójô�õ�ö�÷=ønù�ú¯õÍûnü qI_nk�few�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�_��IfYdnb�ia`|p�_a`|\Nw�d�behYw�^ÍfÄ\L^�_jhY`{w�fY�Ì�Áòmftiaf�âRf b�\Nw�d?`¯�Ifei�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd^�feè|\Nw�zL`{w�z�_n\�h~p�huin_a`¯b�o�è¯hYi�b�èchNdndý\YxRzNfew�ftijhuè|`{þef¨�'b���è{`|w��IfeiÄê?l¢ÿ�ñ ëÉ��ð=�ÄßÁkàf�b�è¯hLdad�b�\Lw�dg`cdg_æd\Yx�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd~zNfewàfeijhY_afY�ZhNd~_akàf;few���feè|\Np�f'\Yx�h ö�����û�øÃû \Yx5�Lhuin�I`|w�z%ijhL�I`{o�d�d?âÁfep�_�hYè{\Nwàz_nk�f�b���è{`{w,�Ifei�hu��`¯d~ê�â�k�`¯bjk%w�fefY�;wà\N_�^Íf�d?_aijhY`{zLkI_�ñj�%yU��hYv�pàè{fYd `|w�b�è{o,�If~p�`|pÍf¨d \Ni5_aoà^Íf¨dê��ÉbehYw�huè�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd�� ñ�â�kàfeiaf�_akàf�dgp�kàfeiaf�ijhL�I`{o,d `¯d5b�\Lw�dg_æhuw�_eqRhuw��%dgoàigxÐhNb�fYd \ux�iafe��\Lè{o�_n`{\Lw½qâ�kàfeiaf�_ak�fýhu��`¯dD`cd�h¢è{`|w�f��ÀßÁk�`¯dRb�è¯hLdadDzLfew�feiæhu_nfYdÁhÄè¯huinzNf�w�o�v5^�fei�\uxÀb�\Nv�v�\Lw�è{�5\�beb�o�iain`{w�zv huw�oIxÐhLb�_ao�infY�~\N^�å?fYb�_jd��ßÁk�f5ã�ft�~`¯�If¨h0k�ftiaf `cd]_nk�hu_ýdg`{w,b�fÄ_ak�f�� fewI��ftè{\Np�f�\YxR_ak�f�p�ia\�è{f��`¯d�_ak�f�p�ia\�è{f�\uxR_ak�f

ftwI��feè|\Np�f��rë� ��Nð½_nk�f `|v~hYzNf�p�ia\Nå?f¨b�_a`|\Nw'\Yx�_akà`¯d�b�è¯hLdad�\ux�dgo�i?xÐhNb�f�`¯d�huw�few���feè|\Np�f�\ux�b�`|ijb�è|fYd������������������ ��!"$#��&%� �(')"*�+�-,$!./'/��0���1

Page 2: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

�Á��`{w���fein_a`{wàz¢_nk�`¯dÁpàia\�b�fYdnd�� iafYb�\Y��fein`{w�z�b�`|ijb�è|fYd¾x�in\Nvç_ak�fÄp�in\+�è|f�� _nk�f�p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{\Lw~\uxÀ_ak�fhY�I`cd�huw���_ak�f�dnbehuè|`{w�z x�o�w,b�_a`|\Nw�behuw�^�f¢ft�I_nijhNb�_afY�0x�in\Nv�_akàf¢`|v~hYzNf���Uiaft�I`|\No�dUâÁ\Liaã�\Nw~ft�I_nijhNb�_a`{wàz lÄÿ��íd¾x�in\Nv�`|v~hYzNfYdUk�hLdÁk�hN���I`��Ìfeinfew�_D\LiÁv�\Ninfmè|`{v�`{_af¨�

zL\�hYè¯d�� �iædg_tq±ijhY_ak�fti¢_nk�huwBpÍftijdgp�fYb�_a`{��fÓqÑ_nk�f�âÁfYhYã�pÍftijdgp�fYb�_a`{��f5`|v~hYzN`|w�z�hYp�p�ia\Y��`{v hu_n`{\Nwk,hNdDzLfew�feiæhuè|è{� ^�feftw�o�d?fY�'êÐdgfef ë� ��Iq���Yð=q�â�k�feinfmfYhYiaè|`{feiUinf�x�feinfew�b�fYdÀhuiaf�zN`|��fewPñ�Id?fYb�\Lw��Pq�_ak�fzL\�hYè�k�hNd½^�fefew�iafYb�\Lw�dg_niao�b�_a`{\LwÄijhu_nk�feiF_ak�hYw5iafepàiafYd?fewI_æhu_n`{\NwrqYhuw�� _nk�`¯dPinf ��oà`{iaf¨d½h]inf�x�feiaftw�b�fb�ia\�dndgäÐdgfYb�_a`{\Lw5_a\�^�f��I`cdg`{^àè{fU`|w _akàfÁ`{v huzLfÄë �Nð�Y_akà`{ij�ÌqN_ak�\ÓdgfRv�fe_nk�\���d±_nk�hu_Àk�he��fDpàia\��Io�b�fY�`|wI�LhYia`¯hYwI_ædUo�w��Ifei�p�feiædgp�fYb�_n`{��f�ë �L��ð�k�he��f�\Nwàè{�5o�_n`{è{`|þefY�5h�w�o�v5^�feiU\uxFp�\L`{w�_jdU\Nw~_nk�f�`{v huzNf\Lo�_aè|`{w�f�� w�\L_�_ak�f�few�_a`|iaf5b�o�ia��f����9w�_akà`¯dmp�hYp�feieqF`{w�b�\Lv�v�\Nw�â�`{_nk;_nk�f�hu^�\Y��f�q½\Nw�è|��_ak�fpàia\+,è{fÄ`¯dÁo�d?fY���w�\�o�d?f¢`cdÁv~hL�IfÄ\uxRd?o�igxÐhLb�fÄv~hYiaã�`{w�zÓdÁ\Ni�_afe��_aoàiaf��ßÁk�fR_a\�\Lè�fev�p�è{\Y��fY�mkàfeiaf�`¯d½_akàf ö������ûæ÷=ø��]öYûj÷ ë��Yð=qLdg_no��I`{f¨�¢^�� l�`{^�è|`{w����ÁijhLdadgft_a_�ë � NðÐq

â�kà`¯bjk¢`cdÑ_nk�fÁè|\�b�o�d±\YxÌb�few�_ainfYdP\uxÍb�`{iæb�è{fYdP^à`{_jhYw�zNftwI_F_a\�hmp�èchuw�f�b�o�ia��fÓ�½�Uiafe��`{\Lo�d±d?�Iv�v�fe_ain�hYw�huè|��d?`¯d k�hLd0èchuinzNfeè|�%b�\Nw,b�few�_aijhY_afY��\Nwft�I_nijhNb�_a`{wàz�^�`{èchu_aftijhuè�êÆinf���fYb�_n`{\LwPñ�\Li�in\N_jhY_a`|\Nw�hYèd?�Iv�v�fe_ain`{fYdÑx�in\Nvç`{v huzLfYdU\uxFp�èchuw�hYi�\N^�å?fYb�_æd�q�\Ni�x�ia\Lv h�dg`{wàzNè{f�dg`|è{k�\Lo�fe_n_af�\uxÀ�NsZ\N^�å?fYb�_æd�q��`{ftâÁfY�~`{w h0x�ia\LwI_n\Nä�p�huiæhuè|è{feèFp�è¯hYw�f�ëÈ�Iq���q NïNðÐ�mßÁkàf v�fe_ak�\��àd��Ife��feè|\Np�fY��x�\Ni�_ak�\Ódgf5bthNdgf¨dbthuw'wà\N_�^Íf hup�pàè{`{f¨� ` xÀ_akàf ��`{feâ�p�\N`|wI_�`cdÁw�\N_�x�ia\Nw�_a\LäÆp,huijhYè{è|feèFdg`|w�b�f�qIx�\Li�h5p�è¯hYw�hui�\N^�å?fYb�_tqinf���fYb�_a`{\Lw�huè¾dg��v�v�fe_ain`{fYd�hYiaf�_ak�ftw ö���û� Dûnü ^���`{v huzN`|w�zBë �t�IqU�Yì�q� NîNðÐ� é�\Ni�h��Nsçdgv�\�\N_nk\L^�å?fYb�_�hL���I`{_n`{\Lw�huè��I`cdg_n\Nia_n`{\Lw�d0\�btb�o�i!� _ak�f�b�\LwI_n\No�i5zLfew�feiæhu_n\Ni�"�v�\Y��fYdÄ\Nw_nk�f�dgo�i?xÐhNb�fhLd~�I`|feâ�`{w�z�p�\�d?`{_a`|\NwZbjk�huwàzNfYd��#�=w _akà`¯d�behNd?f�`{_~`cd�w�\N_Øh ���fY� dgp�hLb�f�b�o�in��f'â�k�`cbÃk�`¯dpàia\Nå?fYb�_afY�Pq�hYw��~_ak�f�`|v~hYzNf�pàia\+,è{fÄbehYw�bÃk�hYw�zNf�ijhN��`¯behYè{è{�5â�`|_ak~��`{ftâ�pÍ\L`{w�_eqà�If�x�fYhY_a`{wàz5huw��d?`{v�p�è{fýhup�p�è|`¯behY_a`|\Nw�\uxRd?ã�feâÁf¨�~dg��v�v�fe_nia���

$ %'&)(¢Ú�Ù+*�=w�_ak�f x�\Lè{è|\uâ�`|w�z�âÁf b�\Nw,dg`¯��fei�_?âÁ\�_?�Ip�fYd�\Yx�`{v huzLf�pàia\Nå?fYb�_a`{\Lw,��p�feijd?p�fYb�_a`|��f5hYw��;âÁf¨huãp�feiædgp�fYb�_n`{��f��-�=w~^�\N_nk�behLdgfYd�_ak�fÄbthuv�feijhÄhNd?p�fYb�_Áiæhu_n`{\ v5o,dg_�^�f�ãIwà\uâ�wrqI_akà\No�zLk~w�\5\N_nk�fei`|wI_nia`|w�dg`cb±p�huiæhuv�fe_aftijdFhuiafRiaf ��o�`|iafY�P�Fòm\YâRfe��feieq�v5o�bjk¢\Yx�_akàf�b�\Lw�dg_niao�b�_n`{\Lw o�d?fYdÑ\Lw�è{��h/.~w�f\Limpàia\Nå?fYb�_a`{��f�p�in\Np�feia_n`{fYd�q�huw���_ak�`cdÁ`¯dÁv hN�IfÄfe��p�è|`¯b�`|_e�

02143 5 687:9<;=68>�?A@�68B,C�DFEG6ÿ�\Lw�dg`c�Ifei�d?âÁfefepà`{w�z�h�dgp�kàfeiaf�\ux��Lhuin�I`|w�z;iæhN�I`|o�d5huè|\Nw�z�_akàf'hY�I`cd5b�o�in��fH��_nk�f�iafYd?o�è{_n`{w�zd?o�igxÐhLb�f�`¯dU_ak�f�ftwI��feè|\Np�f�\uxr_ak�f�dgâRfep�_�d?p�k�feinf��:I�_UfYhNbjk5p�\N`|wI_�_akàfmp�in\+�è|f�\uxF_nk�f�dgp�kàfeiaf�`¯dhÄb�`|ijb�è|f�qLhuw��5_ak�f�pàia\+,è{f�\uxr_ak�f�d?o�igxÐhLb�f�`¯d±_nk�f�few���feè{\LpÍfR\uxr_ak�f�b�`|ijb�è|fYd��F�mw,�Ifei�h/.~w�f�pàia\Näå?f¨b�_a`|\Nw _nk�f�b�fewI_niafR\uxÌ_ak�f�dgp�kàfeiafRp�ia\Nå?f¨b�_jd±_n\�_akàf�b�few�_ainfÁ\Yx�_ak�f�b�`{ijb�è{f��±ÿ�\Lw�dgfJ��o�ftwI_nè{��qY_ak�fb�`{ijb�è{f�� dUb�few�_ainfÄdgâRfefep�d�\No�_�_nk�f�p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{\Nw \uxF_akàf hY�I`cd��ÀßÁk�`¯d�b�\Lw�dg_niao�b�_a`{\Lw~`¯dÁ`|è{è|o�dg_nijhu_nfY�dnbÃkàfev~hY_a`cbehuè|è{�5`{w��zLo�iaf��L�

Km\Yâ�b�\Lw�dg`c�IfeiU_?âÁ\ýdgo�bjk5b�`|ijb�è|fYd��rhNdU_ak�f�dnbehuè|`{w�zýhuia`cdg`|w�zmx�ia\Lv#âRfYhuãÄp�feijd?p�fYb�_a`|��fÁ`cd±_ak�fdnhuv�fm`|w�^�\L_ak�behLdgfYd�q�_ak�f�ijhY_a`{\Ä\YxFb�`|ijb�è|fÁijhL�I`{`�f ��o�hYè¯dU_ak�f�iæhu_n`{\ \Yx½iæhN�I`|`�\uxF_nk�fmzLfew�feiæhu_n`{w�zd?p�k�feinfYd���ßÁkàfmo�d?f�x�o�è|w�fYdad�\uxF_nk�fYdgf�iaf¨dgo�è|_jdD`cdU_ak�hY_Á_akàfÄb�`{iæb�è{f¨dUbehuw ^Íf�iafYb�\Y��feinfY�ýx�in\Nvç_ak�fpàia\+,è{f�^���b�\Nw,dg_aino�b�_n`{w�z�_ak�fÄd?�Iv�v�fe_ain�5dgft_eqI_nk�f�è|\�b�o�dD\YxÀb�few�_ainfYdU\uxÀb�`|ijb�è|fYdU^�`{_æhuw�zLfewI_�_n\_nk�fÄp�ia\�è{fÓ��ßÑ\ dgo�v�v huia`|þefH�L ���� 0�!.NM � ��% "$���,*!. ' ��0��PO��� 0*�RQ.$�TS�� 0 "*, "$� "*����&���(� �-Q.$��U #&��1

Page 3: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

h

^ béF`{zNoàiaf%���� ù����Àõ�üIû�ø Dûnù � �ÍûÃøæö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû �Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ ÷/��û �Ìøaô��{û � ú �5ù� Iû�ô���÷��Éú¯õÍû�� ô� ùö�����ûÃøÃû ú ö�ù�ótú¯øaó��{û��5ù�õàü ÷/��û�ö�����û�øjû�ó�û�õI÷ÐøÃûØú ö �Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷?ûnü�÷=ô�÷ ��û óeú¯ønó��{ûØó�û�õI÷ÐøÃû�� ��� ��� ��ûö���ø��tù�ó�û�ú ö� Iû�õÍûÃøaùN÷?ûnü�ùuöØ÷ ��û�û�õ��uû �Éô ��û�ô��ù;ö�����û�øjû�ö� Dû ��÷5ù!�Éô�õ! �ù�õ ù#"Lú ö�$%� � ó&�'� ��ûö���ø��tù�ó�û �Ìønô��{û ú ö( Iû�õ�û�øaùN÷?ûnü ùuö�÷/��û�û�õ��Yû)�Éô ��ûBô��ùótú¯øaó��{û�ö� Dû���÷ ù!�Éô�õ! +*,� ��û�øjû'÷/��ûú �5ù� �û�ó���ø��uû-* ú ö ÷ ��û �Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ;ô� ÷ ��û ù#"Lú ö ó���ø.�uû/$%�0� ��û�1 ���øÃû0ú����2�Nö�÷=ønùN÷gûnö�÷ ��û�ójùuöYû�tô�ø�ù�ójô�õ�ö�÷Ðù�õI÷Uønù�ü�ú��Óö�ö�����û�øjû43 ù�ójù�õ�ù!�Iö���ø5�tù�ó�û��6� ��û �Ìøaô��{û]ú öÁö�÷Ðú����� IûÃõÍû�øaùN÷?ûnü � �ÉôYójù!��� � �ùuöý÷ ��û5û�õ7�uû)�Éô ��û�ô��ótú¯øaó��{ûnö� ���û�õ'÷ ��û�ö�����ûÃøÃûÄønù�ü�ú��Óö8�eù�ø�úÆûnö9�

Page 4: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

� ú��uûÃõ�ù Dûnù � ��û�øaö��Íûnó�÷=ú��uûýú �5ù� IûÄô�¢ù0ö��Iø��tù�ó�û% �û�õÍû�ønùN÷gûnü � �ÉôYójù!��� � �Øùuö�÷/��û5û�õ��Yû)�Éô ��û5ô�¢ùö�����ûÃøÃû�ô���eù�ø��Nú¯õ ;ønù�ü�ú��Óö�� ê���ñ � Uú{÷/� ó�û�õI÷ÐøÃûaöØô�õ�ù�� �Éù�õÍû ó���ø��uû6$ ê���ñ � ÷/��û�ù#"Lú ö&���Ä÷/��ûö�������ûj÷Ðø�� öYûj÷���ójôH� � ��÷?ûnü �tøaôH��÷ ��û�ú �5ù� �û �Ìøaô��{û����àùuö�÷ ��û1�tô!���ÉôH Uú¯õ �Ìøaô ��û�øj÷=úÆûnö��

� ��� ��û�ójô�õ�÷=ù�ó�÷Rô�ýú �5ù� IûÄótú¯øaó��{ûnö� Uú{÷/�~÷/��û �Ìønô��{û�ú¯üIû�õI÷Ðú �ûaö ójô�ø�øÃûaö��àô�õ�ü�ú¯õ! ���ô�ú¯õ�÷ öýô�õ÷ ��û�ö���ø5�tù�ó�û��Rú��¯û��)�àô�ú¯õI÷ ö �àú¯ó�� �ÉúÆû�ô�õ'÷/��û�ötùH��ûÄóeú¯ønó�� � ù�ø óeønôuöjöÆöYûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ �

� ��� ��ûÄó���ø��Yû�ójô��uû�øÃûnü � ��ótú¯øaó��{û�ó�ûÃõI÷=øjûaö)� * ê �Nñ �¾ú ö� Uú{÷/�àú¯õ�ù � �Éù�õÍû�ù�� õÍûÄ÷Ðøaù�õ�ö��tô�ø��5ù�÷=ú¯ô�õ�ô�Ä÷/��û�ó���ø��Yû $ ê��Dñ �

� ��� ��ûÁötójù!�Éú¯õ! ����õ�ó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ �tô�ø�øaù�ü�ú¯úÌô��ú �5ù� Iû�ótú¯øaó��{ûnö)��� ê �Nñ ��û����Iù!�Èö�÷/��ûÁötójù!�Éú¯õ! ����Iõ�ó�÷=ú¯ô�õ�tô�ø~øaù�ü�ú¯ú�ô��÷/��û �û�õÍû�ønùN÷=ú¯õ! ;ö�����ûÃøÃûaö�� ê���ñ �tô�ø~ójô�ø�øÃûaö��àô�õ�ü�ú¯õ! ��ô�ú¯õ�÷ ö)� $ ê���ñ ù�õ�ü* ê �Nñ �4� ��÷Ðô�ù�õ�ô��uû�øaù!� �Pötójù!�{û�ùH� � ú ���ú{÷F� �

Km\L_af�qL\Nw�è|�¢_nk�f�dgf¨b�\Nw�� `|_afev iaf ��o�`{infYd½_ak�hY_U_ak�f�hY�I`cd±^�f�p�è¯hYw�huit�UßÁk�f�\L_ak�ftiUp�ia\Lp�feia_n`{fYdkà\Nè¯�~`ÉxU_nk�f�hu��`¯dÁ`¯d�h�dgp,hNb�f�b�o�in��f��ßÁk�f b�o�in��fYd�� * ê �Nñ�� � ê��Nñ���huiaf h0��`{ftâ�pÍ\L`{w�_aä�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�_�iafepàiafYd?fewI_æhu_n`{\Nwr� $ ê���ñR`¯d��Ife_aftiaäv�`{wàfY�¢o�p5_n\Ähuw�h/.~wàf�huv5^à`{zNoà`{_?��qLhuw��5b�\Lw�dgfJ��o�ftwI_nè{�Äh/.~w�f�`|wI�LhYia`¯hYwI_ædÑ\Yx $ ê��DñÑhuiafRf ��o�huè_n\�hJ. w�f5`|wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_ædm\ux * ê �NñæqPhYw�� _nk�fYd?f5huinf5�I`|feâ�p�\N`|wI_näÆ`|wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_t� � ê��Dñ�`cdm�Ift_afeinv�`|w�fY�oàp'_a\�dnbehuè|f���ßÁk�fÄp�hYijhuv�fe_nia`{þ¨hu_a`|\Nw�\ux * ê �NñU`cd��IfYdab�ia`{^�fY�~`|w'd?fYb�_n`{\Nw �� ���

021�0 ;=68>�?A@�68B,C�D�E 6��w��Ifei�p�feijd?pÍf¨b�_a`|��f¢pàia\Nå?fYb�_a`{\Lw'_nk�f p�in\+�è|f \Yx�h�dgpàk�feiaf5`cdmhYw�feè{è|`{p�d?f�q�hYw��'_akàf5b�few�_ainfÄ\ux_nk�f�dgp�kàfeiaf���\�fYd0wà\N_5p�in\Nå?fYb�_�_a\�_akàf ftè{è{`|p�dgf b�few�_ainf���òm\YâÁfe��ftieq½`{w%p�iæhNb�_n`¯b�f�q½x�\Ni �wà`{_af`|v~hYzNf�p�èchuw�f¨d¾_nk�`¯dUf��ÌfYb�_U`¯dUfe��_ainfev�ftè{�Äd?v~hYè{è��½_nk�f�hLdgp�fYb�_�iæhu_a`|\Ä\uxFhÄd?p�k�feinf��íd±pàia\+,è{f�`¯dUhY_âR\Niædg_ �I�íî ��q½hYw�� `|_jd�b�few�_ainf�`¯d��I`¯d?p�è¯hLb�fY��hu_�v�\�dg_�^I���L�& �� \Yx�`{_æd��I`¯hYv�ft_afeitq�fe��few�hu_�_ak�f^�\Lij�Ifei�\ux�h5â�`¯�Iftä=hYw�zNè|f è{ftw�dÁâ�`{_nk�h���ï�� �feè¯�~\Yx��I`|feâÄ�RßÁk�`¯d�`¯d�huw�fe��hYv�pàè{fÄ\uxRh ����ùuötú ú¯õ7�eù�ø�ú¯ù�õ�÷ ë uð=�ÀßÁkIo,d�qI_nk�fÄd?�Iv�v�ft_aia� dgfe_�â�`|è{èÌdg_n`{è{èà^Ífýhuw~fe�àb�feè|è{few�_Àhup�p�in\Y�I`|v~hY_a`{\Lw�\YxF_ak�fpàia\Nå?fYb�_afY�5hY�I`cd���òm\YâÁft��feieqY_ak�f�_aiæhuw�d=x�\Ninv~hY_a`{\Lw~^�fe_?âÁfeftw�_nk�f�hY�I`cd�huw���`|v~hYzNf�b�o�in��fYd±â�`{è|è^�fÄp�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��f�q�ijhY_ak�ftim_nk�huw�hJ. w�f���ß½\ dgo�v�v~hYia`|þefH�� ú��uûÃõ ù ��û�øæö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû�ú �5ù� �û�ô��ùýö���ø5�tù�ó�û Iû�õÍû�ønùN÷gûnü � � ôuójù!� � � �0ùuö�÷/��û�û�õ7�uû)�Éô ��ûÄô�]ù¢ö�����û�øÃûô� �tù�ø��Lú¯õ! 5øaù�ü�ú��Nö!� ê���ñ � Uú{÷/��ó�û�õ�÷=øjûaö�ô�õ�ù � �Éù�õÍû�ó���ø��uû4$ ê���ñ � ÷/��û�ù#"Lú ö&���À÷ ��û�ö������ûæ÷=ø��öYûæ÷ ��ójôH� � ��÷gûnü �tønôH� ÷/��û�ú �5ù� Iû �Ìønô��{û � � ù ���Ìøaô#"uú �5ùN÷gû)� � � �àùuöÄ÷/��û �tô!��� ôH Uú¯õ! �Ìøaô ��û�øj÷=úÆûaö��

� ��� ��û�ójô�õ�÷=ù�ó�÷Rô�ýú �5ù� IûÄótú¯øaó��{ûnö� Uú{÷/�~÷/��û �Ìønô��{û�ú¯üIû�õI÷Ðú �ûaö ójô�ø�øÃûaö��àô�õ�ü�ú¯õ! ���ô�ú¯õ�÷ öýô�õ÷ ��û�ö���ø5�tù�ó�û � ú��¯û��)�àô�ú¯õI÷ ö¢ô�õ'÷ ��û�ötùH��ûýóeú¯øaó����Éù�ø�óeøaôuöjöÆöYûnó�÷=ú¯ô�õ � �

� ��� ��û�ó��Iø.�uû�ójô��uû�øjûnü � �5óeú¯øaó.�{û�ó�û�õI÷ÐøÃûaö)�1* ê��Nñ �Àú ö Uú{÷/�àú¯õ'ù � �Éù�õ�û �Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷=ú��uû�÷=ønù�õ�ö��tô�ø"�5ùN÷=ú¯ô�õ�ô�Ä÷/��û�ó���ø��Yû $ ê��Dñ �

ßÁk�f�b�oàia��f#� * ê��Óñ$�~`¯d�h ��`{feâ�p�\L`{w�_aä�`{w��NhYia`chuw�_¢infep�infYdgfew�_jhY_a`|\Nw½� $ ê��DñÄ`cd �Ift_afeinv�`|w�fY�oàp _a\%h�p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��f�huv5^�`|zNo�`|_?��q�huw,� b�\Nw�d?f ��o�few�_aè{�%p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��f�`{w��Lhuin`¯huw�_jd5\ux * ê��Óñ0huiaf��`{ftâ�pÍ\L`{w�_aä�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�_e�Ré�o�ia_nk�feiav�\Ninf�q�`{_�`¯d�dgkà\uâ�w�`{w dgfYb�_n`{\Lw �à�& �_nk�hu_�x�\Ni�behYw�huè�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYdâ�`|_ak�hu_�è{f¨hNdg_5_?âR\�`{w ��f¨b�_a`|\Nw�d�q $ ê��Dñ�`¯d5��fe_afeinv�`|w�fY��o�p_n\�huw hJ. w�f�huv5^�`|zNo�`|_g�ÓqUfe��fewoàw��Ifei�p�feiædgp�fYb�_n`{��fÄ�I`cdg_n\Nia_n`{\Lw½�

Page 5: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

c

p

p

α

δ

δ

/

/

éF`{zNoàiaf � � ��û�ø�ú ��� ô�õ ����ê �Nñ������|ê �Nñ�� ú ö Iû�õÍû�ønùN÷gûnü � �5ö� Dûjû��Ìú¯õ! �ù �Éú¯õÍû�ô�8�eù�ø��Lú¯õ! �{û�õ N÷ ���ö���ó��B÷ �àùN÷�÷/��û � ú¯õÍû�� ö �5ú¯ü� �àô�ú¯õI÷ �ÉúÆûaöØô�õ;÷/��û ù#"Lú ö6$ �¢ù�õ�ü'÷ ��û �Éú¯õ�û~ú öØô�øj÷ �àô) �ô�õ�ù!�À÷=ô'÷/��ûù#"uú ö9���Ãõ Iû�õÍûÃøaù!��÷ ��û5ö�������ûj÷=ø���öYûj÷Äô��÷/�àú ö�÷��(��û�ô� ø�ú ��� ô�õ Uú�����õ�ôN÷Äójô�ú¯õ�ótú¯üIû Àú{÷ ��÷/��ûù#"uú ö9�rô�ø û "LùH� � �|û �R÷ ��û�ó�û�õ�÷=øjû���ô��÷ ��û�ö�������ûj÷=ø��¢öYûj÷�ùN÷� � � ü�ôNûaö�õ�ôN÷4�ÉúÆû�ô�õ $ �

021�� ��� >���7PB-6���� 7:?A?�7���� � @�68B8D 7���� � ?ßÁkàf�dgoàigxÐhNb�f�b�è¯hLdad�q"!�q�b�\Lw�dg`c�IfeinfY��k�ftiaf�b�\Nw�d?`¯dg_æd0\Yx�_ak�\Ódgf�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd�zLfew�feiæhu_nfY�hLd�_ak�fftwI��feè|\Np�f�\uxÀh d?p�k�feinfÄdgâRfep�_�huè{\Lw�z�h¢pàè¯huwàfÄb�o�in��f��Ué�\NiR_ak�f¨dgfÄd?o�igxÐhLb�fYd�q�^I��b�\Nw�d?_aiao,b�_a`|\Nw½qh�dgpàk�feiafRâ�`{_nk h�b�`|ijb�è|fU\ux�p�\L`{w�_jd½_jhuwàzNfew�_±_n\m_nk�f�d?o�igxÐhLb�f�`¯d½\Nw�fR\ux�_nk�f�zNfewàfeijhY_a`{wàz�d?p�k�feinfYd�qhYw��;â�`|è{è�k�he��f�`|_jdÄb�few�_ainf5\Nw�_nk�f�hY�I`cd��'ÿ�\Nw,dgf ��o�few�_aè|��q½_ak�f�p�ia\Lå?fYb�_af¨�;hY�I`cd huw,�;p�ia\�è{fd?�Iv�v�fe_ain�~d?fe_�b�\N`|w�b�`c�If��l�few�ftijhuè|`{þef¨��b���è{`{w,�IfeijdÌhuinfD\Yx�_afew��If��w�fY��`{wÄ_nfeiav dÍ\YxÌdgâRfefep�`|w�z�h�p�è¯hYw�huiFb�ia\�dndgäÐdgfYb�_a`{\Lw

hYè{\Lw�z�huw�hu��`¯d ë ��ðÐ��òm\YâRfe��feieq�`ÉxRh~d?o�igxÐhLb�f5`¯dmzLfew�feiæhu_nfY�'^I��d?âÁfefepà`{w�z b�`{iæb�è{f¨dÁ\ux��LhYia��`{w�ziæhN�I`|o�d~\Nin_ak�\LzN\Nw,huè _n\�h pàè¯huw,hui�hu��`¯d�q]_nk�fewZ_ak�f�b�fewI_niaf�\ux�h%d?p�k�feinf�â�`{_akZh%b�`|ijb�è|f�\uxp�\L`{w�_jd _jhYw�zNftwI_5_n\;_nk�f�dgoàigxÐhNb�f â�`|è{è õ�ôN÷ q�`{wBzNfew�ftijhuèÐqÁb�\N`{w,b�`¯�If�â�`{_nk%_ak�f�hu��`¯d���ß½\�dgfef_nk�`¯d�q�b�\Lw�dg`c�Ifei5_akàf'`{w�_aftijdgf¨b�_a`|\Nw�\Yx�dgo�bjk h�dgoàigxÐhNb�f'â�`{_nk%_ak�f�p�è¯hYw�f�\uxÄ_nk�f�hY�I`cd�� ßÁk�f`|wI_nfeijd?fYb�_n`{\Nw�`cdmh�p,hu`{i�\ux¾p�è¯hYw�f5b�oàia��fYd�q����Iê �Nñ$�#���|ê �Nñ���â�k�`¯bjk�huiaf5zLfew�feiæhu_nfY� ^���_ak�f�few���d\Yxrh�dgâRfep�_Fè{`{wàf��FßÁk�fÁè|`{w�f�`¯d½\Nin_ak�\LzN\Lw�huè�_a\�_ak�f�hu��`¯d�qLâ�`{_ak�`{_ædÑv�`¯�Iä�p�\N`|wI_F\Nw5_nk�f�hY�I`cd�q�hYw��_nk�f�è{`{wàf�è{few�zL_ak~�LhYia`{f¨dDhLbeb�\Lij�I`|w�z _n\¢_nk�f�ijhN��`{o�d�\uxF_akàf�b�`|ijb�è|f��-�=w�zLfew�feiæhuè=q�_nk�f�d?�Iv�v�fe_ain�d?fe_5\ux����Iê��Nñ��#���{ê��Óñ$� â�`|è{è õ�ôN÷ b�\L`{w�b�`c�If~â�`|_ak%_ak�f�hY�I`cd���ÿ�\Lw�dgfJ��o�ftwI_nè{��qU_nk�f�b�few�_aiaf \uxýhd?p�k�feinf~â�`{_nk�h�b�`{iæb�è{f�\ux�p�\N`|wI_æd _jhYw�zNfew�_5_a\�_nk�f�dgo�i?xÐhNb�fØbehuw%w�\L_5è{`{f�\Nw%_nk�f�hu��`¯d�� Imwft��hYv�p�è|fm`cdÁd?k�\Yâ�w `|w ,zNo�inf ��:I x�o�è|èP��`¯dab�o�dad?`{\Nw \uxÀ_ak�f Ns behLdgf�`cdDzN`|��few�^I� �±\Nw,b�f�ë� ���ðâ�kàfeiafÄ_akàf¢è|`{w�fýhuw���b�`{iæb�è{f�dgfe_ædmhYiafÄ_aftiav�fY� �Áia\�\Lã�d�huw,� �Áè{oàv in`{^�^�\Nw,d]infYdgp�fYb�_n`{��feè|���ßÁâR\�dgp�fYb�`chuèÀbehNd?fYdm\Yx�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd�`{w$!�qÍâ�k�`cbÃk huinf5�If ,w�fY� ^���hN����`{_a`|\Nw�hYè�b�\Lw�dg_nijhu`|wI_æd�q

hYiaf b�\Nw�d?`¯�IftiafY��_ak�in\No�zLk�\No�_Ä_nk�f infYdg_�\uxR_akàf p�hYpÍftie� �=w'_akàf¢x�\Nè|è{\Yâ�`{wàz�âRf è{`cdg_�h0w�o�v5^�fei\YxRp�ia\LpÍftia_a`|fYdÁx�\Ni�_nk�fYdgf behNd?fYd�â�k�`¯bjk��I\ w�\N_�kà\Nè¯�~x�\NiÄhYw�o�w�b�\Lw�dg_nijhY`{w�fY��v�ftv5^Íftim\Yx%!��ßÁkàfYdgf�pàia\Np�fein_a`|fYd�huinf�o�dgf¨�~�Io�in`{w�z5_nk�f�`{v huzLf�p�in\�b�fYdad?`{w�z�ê�zNin\No�p�`|w�z�huw,� d?�Iv�v�fe_ain��dgfe_ft�I_nijhNb�_a`{\LwPñjqÌhuw,� `{w�_ak�f b�\Nw,dg_aino�b�_n`{\Nw�\Yx�h�behYw�\Nwà`¯behYèÑx�iæhuv�f�� �Á\N_ak�_nk�fYd?f5dgp�fYb�`¯huèFbthNdgf¨dbthuw�huècdg\�^Íf�zNfewàfeijhY_afY�~^���dgâRfefep�`|w�z5b�`|ijb�è|fYd��

&('*)+'-, .0/�12/�3�4658769:/ �<; 4ò�feiaf�_akàfeiafR`¯dFhuw5hL���I`|_a`{\Lw�huèàb�\Lw�dg_nijhu`|wI_Fâ�k�`cbÃk�`¯d½_ak�hY_±_nk�f�dnbehuè|`{w�z�x�o�w�b�_n`{\Lw `¯dFh�b�\Lw�dg_æhuw�_e�ßÁkàfYdgf�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd~hYiaf�huècdg\�behYè{è{f¨� ÿ�`{iæb�o�èchui��Uè¯hYw�huiØ[]`|zNk�_'l�few�feiæhuè{`|þefY� ÿ��Iè|`{w��Iftijd5â�`{_akb�\Nw�d?_jhuw�_�b�ia\ÓdadgäÐdgf¨b�_a`|\Nw½�

Page 6: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

γ

éF`{zNoàiaf5� � rô�ø ù�ójù�õ�ù!�½ö��Iø��tù�ó�û� Àú{÷ � ù � �Éù�õ�ù�ø5ù#"uú ö)��ú¯õ���ûnó�÷=ú¯ô�õ�ö ú¯õ ÷/��û �Ìønô��{û ôYójó��Iø�ú¯õ�àù�ú¯øaö �tô�øýûnù�ó(��ú¯õ���ûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ'ô��÷/��ûÄù#"Lú ö9� � ��û�ú¯õI÷?û�øaöYûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ'ô�ýù �àù�ú¯ø�ô�ýú¯õ���ûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ ÷Ðù�õ! IûÃõI÷ öüIûæ÷gû�ø��5ú¯õÍûaö�÷/��û �eù�õ�ú ö(�àú¯õ! �àô�ú¯õI÷�ô�5÷/��û ÷Ðù�õ! IûÃõI÷ �Éú¯õÍû0ùN÷Á÷/��û�ù#"Lú ö�ú¯õ���ûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ � �- UôØö���ó���tù�õ�ú ö(�àú¯õ! �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö�üIûj÷?û�ø��5ú¯õ�ûÄ÷ ��û6�eù�õàú ö(�àú¯õ! �Éú¯õÍû ��� �Rô�Ä÷/��û � �Éù�õÍû�ô�Ä÷/��ûÄù#"Lú ö9� � �àú ö �Éú¯õÍûójù�õ � û �ÓöYûnü�÷=ô �ønô�� �(���Iøj÷/��û�ø �Ìøaô��{û�ú¯õ���ûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ÷=ù�õ Iû�õI÷¯ö � ú��¯û���÷ ��û �àù�ú¯øaö�ô��÷Ðù�õ! IûÃõI÷ ö� �Nö�÷�ú¯õ�÷gû�øaöYûnó�÷�ô�õ'÷ �àú ö/� ú¯õÍû�� ��L���mw��Ifei5âRfYhuãBpÍftijdgp�fYb�_a`{��f p�ia\Nå?f¨b�_a`|\Nw½q�_ak�f�_?âÁ\�dg`c�IfYd \YxÄ_ak�f�p�ia\�è{f�hYiaf'p,huijhYè{è|feèb�o�ia��f¨dÁ\uxR_ak�f dg��v�v�fe_nia� dgfe_�êÆ_nk�f p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{\Lw'\ux¾_ak�f hu��`¯dÃñæ��ßÁk�`¯dÁx�\Nè|è{\Yâ�dm��`{iaf¨b�_aè|�x�ia\Nv _ak�f�p�in\+�è|f�b�o�ia��f¨d�^�fe`{w�zB_ak�f�few���feè{\LpÍf�\ux b�\Lw�dg_æhuw�_aä�ijhN��`{o�d�b�`{iæb�è{fYd�dgâRfep�_huè{\Lw�z�_ak�f�dg��v�v�fe_nia� dgfe_t�

�� �9w ��fYb�_n`{\Nw,d0`|w _ak�f�hY�I`cd0p�in\��Io�b�f�`{w ��fYb�_n`{\Nw�p�hu`|ijd�\Lw _ak�f�pàia\+,è{f�� ßFhuw�zLfew�_jd~hY_b�\NiniafYd?pÍ\Lw��I`|w�z�p�ia\�è{f5`|w ��fYb�_n`{\Lw�d êÆ\Lw;f¨hNbjk�dg`¯��f5\uxR_ak�f5pàia\+,è{fNñ�`|wI_nfeijd?fYb�_�\Nw�_ak�f�NhYw�`¯d?k�`{wàz�è{`|w�f'\Yx _nk�f�hu��`¯d b�o�ia��f �íd p�èchuw�f�� ßÁâR\%dgo,bÃk `|wI_nfeijd?fYb�_a`|\Nw�d5��fe_afeinv�`|w�f_ak�f��LhYw�`¯d?k�`{w�z5è|`{w�fÓqIhYw��~k�few�b�fm_nk�f�fe��_aiæhNb�_n`{\Nw \ux¾hJ. w�fÄb�o�in��fmv�fYhLdgo�infev�ftwI_æd��dgfef�zNo�inf��I�%ßÁk�`cd iafeèchu_a`|\Nw�d?k�`{p%`cd fe��hLb�_!� `{_�`¯d¢wà\N_ h ��o�hLdg`|äÆ`|wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_t� Km\L_afH�~_nk�`¯db�\Nw�d?_aiæhu`{w�_�huècdg\�hYp�p�è|`{fYdÁ_n\�è|`{w�fÄd?fezNv�few�_jdÁ\Lw'_akàf¢pàia\+,è{f~êÐh è{`|w�fÄ`¯d�h��É�IfezLfew�feiæhu_nf��`{w ��f¨b�_a`|\NwPñæq�dg\ behYw ^�f hup�p�è|`{fY��_a\ h0p�`|fYb�feâ�`cdgf�è{`|w�fYhui�hY�I`cd��

&('*)+' & � 58769:/ �<; 4�� 9�7 ;� ��3 5� ����1ò�feiaf�_ak�fýhN���I`|_a`|\Nw�hYè½b�\Lw�dg_nijhu`|wI_R`¯d�_ak�hY_Á_akàfÄhu��`¯d�`¯dÁd?_aiæhu`{zLkI_t�Áÿ�\Nw�d?f ��o�few�_aè{�Óq�_nk�fÄdnbehuè|`{w�zx�oàw�b�_a`|\Nw�`cdm_ak�f5v�\�d?_�`{w�x�\Niav hu_n`{��f b�\Nv�p�\Nw�few�_�\Yx�_akàf5�I`|feâ�p�\N`{w�_aä�`{w��Lhuin`¯huw�_�iafep�infYdgftwI_æhuä_n`{\Lw½�8I�dgo�i?xÐhNb�f�\YxPinfe��\Nè|o�_a`|\Nw�`¯dFh�dgp�fYb�`chuèàbehNd?f�\uxrh¢}�_nijhY`{zNk�_�òm\Lv�\LzNfewàfe\No�d�lmftw�feijhYè{`|þefY�ÿ���è{`|w��Ifeit��L��ß±hYw�zNfew�_jdRhu_�b�\NiniafYd?pÍ\Lw��I`|w�z p�\N`|wI_ædD\Lw�_nk�fm_?âR\5dg`c�IfYdU\uxr_ak�f�p�in\+�è|f5êÆ`Ð� f��Y`{v huzLfYdU\uxpÍ\L`{w�_jdU\Nw _ak�f�dnhuv�f�b�`|ijb�oàè¯hui¾b�ia\ÓdadgäÐdgf¨b�_a`|\NwPñF`{w�_aftijdgf¨b�_±\Lw�_nk�f�p�ia\Nå?f¨b�_afY�5d?�Iv�v�fe_ain�hu��`¯dÄë� ��uðÐ�

�� �9w�p�huin_a`cb�o�è¯hYieqÌb�\NiniafYd?p�\Nw��I`|w�z�p�ia\�è{f�^�`{_æhuw�zLfew�_jdm`|wI_nfeijd?fYb�_�hu_ýhuw�`{v huzLf p�\N`|wI_ qâ�k�`¯bjk~`¯d�_ak�f�`{v huzNf�\ux��5qI_nk�f�p�\N`|wI_�\YxF`{w�_afeiædgfYb�_n`{\Lw�^�fe_?âÁftfew�_nk�f�\L^�å?fYb�_�hY�I`cdÁhYw��p�è¯hYw�fYd�^�`{_æhuw�zLfew�_�_a\�_akàf�dgo�i?xÐhNb�f�����`¯d���`{feâ�p�\N`|wI_näÆ`|w��Ifep�few,�Ifew�_5ëÉ�N��ðÐqFhuw�� behuw^ÍfÄ`c�Ifew�_a` ,fY��`{w�hYwI�~`|v~hYzNf��

����ßÁk�f~p�in\+�è|f�behuwB^ÍfØdgfep�hYijhY_afY�;`|wI_n\'_?âÁ\ �Éd?`¯�IfYd��{q½â�k�`cbÃkBhuinf~iafeèchu_nfY� ^��Bh p�èchuw�hYik�huinv�\Lw�`¯bmkà\Nv�\Nè{\LzN�Bë �Yì�qÌ�/�NðUê�`=�Èf���h p�ia\Nå?f¨b�_a`|��f�_aijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_n`{\Nw��~d?o�bjk _nk�hu_�� "��

ï

Page 7: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

p

sss

pp

3

32

1

pp

p1

2

3

21

éF`{zNoàiafG�A� � �àøÃûjû�ô��÷/��û �÷�÷gûnü5ótú¯øaó��{ûnö,�tô�ø�ù�ö��Iø��tù�ó�û�ô��øjû.�eô!�2��÷Ðú¯ô�õ ���ýôN÷gû�÷/�àùN÷½÷ ��û�ó�ûÃõI÷=øjû�� ö�àôuötú{÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ô�õ ÷/��û ù#"Lú ö�ô��ö������ûj÷Ðø���� � ��ú ö0õ�ôN÷�ù �5ô�õ�ôN÷=ô�õàú¯ó ���Iõàó�÷=ú¯ô�õBô�5ü�ú ö�÷Ðù�õ�ó�û�ù!� ô�õ! ÷/��û �Ìøaô �{û ���,�

� ë� �ìYðÆñj� ��p�in\Y�I`c�IfYd p�\N`|wI_�_a\�p�\N`{w�_ b�\NiniafYd?pÍ\Lw��Ifew,b�f�^Íft_gâRfefew%_akàf�dg`c�IfYd \YxÄ_ak�fp�ia\�è{f�q�_nkIo�d�zNiaf¨hu_aè|��dg`{v�p�è|` x���`{w�z�_nk�f�p�ia\�b�fYdad?`{w�zà� �¾in\Y�I`c�IfY�_akàf �feèc��\Yx5��`{feâ`¯d¢wà\N_ _n\�\�è¯hYiazNfÓq ��`¯d hYp�p�in\u��`{v hu_nfeè{� hJ. w�f�ëÉ� �Nð�F_ak�`cd¢`cd huwà\N_akàfei fe�àhuv�p�è|f�\Yx�h��o�hLdg`|äÆ`|wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_t�

021�� ���R>AE 6 ;=7P>�7�� 6 C > D� 78C�D�ÿ�\Lw�dg`c�Ifei5_nk�f�v�\N_n`{\Lw�\Yx�b�`{iæb�è{f b�few�_ainfYdmx�\Ni h'pÍ\L`{w�_ p�in\NzLiafYdndg`{wàz�huè{\Lw�z�_akàf~p�ia\�è{fÓ� �Æx_nk�f�b�`|ijb�è|f¢iæhN�I`|o�d�`{w�b�iafYhLdgfYd�qP_ak�ftw�_ak�f�b�ftwI_niaf5bthuw�iaft��feijd?f5�I`|iafYb�_n`{\Lw�huw,� � �I\No�^àè{f5^�hLbÃã �\Lw%`{_jd?feè xn� ßÁk�`¯d5�I\�f¨d w�\N_5\�beb�o�i x�\Ni behuw�hYè�dgo�i?xÐhNb�f¨d~ê=b�\Lw�dg_æhuw�_5ijhN��`{o�djñ�^�o�_5â�`|è{èR\�beb�o�i`|w%zNfew�ftijhuèÐqÁhYw���`cd5b�è{f¨huiaè|���Ifev�\Nw�d?_aiæhu_af¨��`{w �zLo�iaf �à� ÿ�\Liaiaf¨dgp�\Nw���`{w�zLè{��qÁ_nk�f�b�few�_ainfYd\YxR_ak�f dgp�k�ftiafYd�zNfewàfeijhY_a`{wàz~_ak�f dgo�i?xÐhNb�f�êÐh��Ls d?�Iv�v�fe_ain��dgfe_�ñ���\No�^�è|f ^�hLbÃãÌ��ßÁkàfeiaf huiaf_nkIo,dm_?âÁ\�p�huiæhuv�fe_ain`{þYhY_a`|\Nw�dm_n\�^Íf�b�\Nw�d?`¯�IfeinfY��� �ijd?_eqP_nk�f�p,huijhYv�ft_aia`|þYhu_n`{\Lw�\uxR_ak�f�hY�I`cd�q�RqÄêÆâ�kà`¯bjk `¯d�h v�\Nwà\N_a\Lw�`¯b x�oàw�b�_a`|\Nw \Yx5��`¯dg_æhuw�b�f�huè{\Lw�z%_ak�f hu��`¯d�\Yxnq]x�\Li~fe�àhuv�p�è{f�q�hd?o�igxÐhLb�f5\ux�iafe��\Lè{o�_n`{\LwPñ�Ìhuw���dgf¨b�\Nw��ÌqÑ_nk�f5p�hYijhuv�fe_nia`{þ¨hu_a`|\Nw�\ux�_nk�f�dg��v�v�fe_nia��dgft_e��ßÁk�`¯dèchu_n_afei�p�hYijhuv�fe_nia`{þ¨hu_a`|\Nw�`¯dUw�\L_�h¢v�\Nwà\N_a\Lw�`¯bÁx�o�w�b�_a`{\Lw�\Yx!�Rq�`|w�zLfew�feiæhuèÐ��ßÁk�f ,zNo�infYdDzL`{��finfYdgoàè{_jd�p�hYijhuv�fe_nia`{þtfY�~^I�#�R� �Ðxnq�`|w�dg_nfYhN�ÌqPd?�Iv�v�ft_aia�Ødgfe_�p�huiæhuv�fe_ain`{þYhY_a`|\Nw'âRfeiafÄo�d?fY�Pq�`{_âR\No�èc��he��\L`¯�5_ak�f��I\Noà^�è{`|w�zÄ^�hNbjã5`{w �zNoàiafYd�î hYw����/�Iq�_ak�\Lo�zNk _ak�feinfmâR\No�èc��d?_a`|è{è�^�f�b�o�dgp,d`|w�_ak�fÄzNiæhup�kr�

021� � 6%�:� ��� B B�� � ? D�ßÁkàf'��`¯dab�o�dad?`{\Nw�_a\�_nk�`¯d p�\N`|wI_5k,hNd5w�\N_ b�\Nw,dg`¯��feiafY�%behLdgfYd â�kàfeiaf�_akàf'd?o�igxÐhLb�f�\�beb�è|o��IfYd`|_jd?feè x�o�w��Ifei�p�ia\Lå?fYb�_a`|\Nw½�'}Ó`{w�b�f�_akàf�hu��`¯d $ `cdýpàè¯huw,huieqU_nk�f~p�\N`|wI_æd¢\Lw�_nk�f�`{v huzNf¨��hu��`¯d* hYiaf�qFhu_ÄâR\Nijd?_eqFh�p�èchuw�f�p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��fÄ_aiæhuw�d=x�\Niav hu_n`{\Lw�\uxRp�\N`|wI_ædý\Lw;_nk�f hu��`¯d����Uia\Y��`¯�IfY�_nk�f hu��`¯d�`¯dÄh�dgv�\�\N_nk%b�o�in��f�q½_ak�few�`{_ædm`{v huzLf�`cdÄhuè¯d?\�d?v�\�\L_ak%d?`{w�b�f�h�p�è¯hYw�f�p�ia\Nå?f¨b�_a`|��f

ì

Page 8: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

N

θr

c

N

V

1

12

2p

p p

p

éF`{zNoàiaf � ��� ù�õ�ü ��� ù�øÃû�õ�ô�ø��5ù!� öÄ÷Ðô�÷/��û �Ìøaô �{ûÄó���ø.�uûaö�ùN÷2 Zù�õ�ü � øjûaö���ûnó�÷=ú��Yû)� � ��� ú ö÷/��û/��õ�ú{÷4�uûnó�÷Ðô�ø�ô�øj÷ �àô) �ô�õàù!�P÷Ðô ��$ � ���+óeú¯øaó��|û � ú{÷Ðù�õ! Iû�õ�÷�÷=ô5÷ ��ûýó���ø��uûnö�ùN÷U÷/�àôuöYû �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö�àùuö]ó�û�õI÷ÐøÃû%� ùN÷±÷/��û�ú¯õI÷?û�øaöYûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ~ô� � ù�õ�ü ��� � Uú{÷/� � � � � ù�õàü� � � � �% � ù�õ�ü " ú���� �Óö÷ÐøaùN÷?û�ójô�ø�øjûaö��àô�õ�ü�ú¯õ! �ù�õ�ü5õ�ô�õ ?ójô�ø�øÃûnö���ô�õàü�ú¯õ! �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö�øÃûnö��Íûnó�÷=ú��uû � � ���õÍû ��ôuöjötú � �{ûG��ûnùuö���øÃûô�ýójô�ø�øÃûaö��àô�õ�üIû�õàó�û�ú ö � ��� � � � � � ��÷�÷/�àú öÄú ö�ú¯õ�öYûÃõ�ötú{÷=ú��Yû�ù�õ�ü�øjû�����ú¯øÃûaö�õ�ô�ø��5ù!�Éú��tùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ �Fötú¯õ�ó�ûú{÷ �eù�ø�úÆûaö� Uú{÷/����� �� � ����� � ��ûýú � � �{û���û�õ�÷gûnü=��ûnùuö��IøjûÄú ö�� d?`{w �� d?`{w � � ���

_nijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_a`|\Nw �I\�fYd w�\L_5`{w�_aia\���o�b�f�b�o,dgp�d���ÿ�\Nw,dgf ��o�few�_aè|��q±_nk�f�dg��v�v�fe_nia�Bdgfe_�\ux�_ak�fpàia\+,è{f~â�`|è{èU^�f�d?v�\�\L_ak½q�fe��few�` x�_ak�f�p�ia\�è{fØb�\Nw�_jhY`{w�d�b�o�dgp,d���ê��=_ `cd¢hLdad?o�v�f¨� _nk�hu_�_ak�fd?�Iv�v�fe_ain�~d?fe_m`cd��Ife_nfeiav�`{w�f¨�0x�ia\Lv b�\NiainfYb�_nè{� b�\NiniafYd?pÍ\Lw��I`|w�z�p�\L`{w�_jd�\ux�_nk�f p�in\+�è|fÄfe��fewâ�kàfew�_ak�fÄp�in\+�è|f d?feè x�ä�`{w�_aftijdgf¨b�_jd�q�x�\Ni�ft��hYv�p�è|f�qI`|w�h5dgâ�hYè{è|\uâ�_æhu`|è=� ñé�\NiØhuw\Lp�h��o�f�\L^�å?fYb�_eqRp�huin_jd�\Yx _nk�f�b�\Nw�_a\Noài�zLfew�feiæhu_a\Li�huinf'\�beb�è{o��If¨�Pq�huw,� b�\Nw�ä

d?f ��o�few�_aè{� p,huia_æd'\ux _ak�fBp�ia\�è{f%hYiaf � v�`cdad?`{w�z � ê=b�\Nv�p�huinfY� _a\ _nk�f�p�in\+�è|f�\uxØhd?fev�`{ä_nijhYw�dgp�hYiafew�_�\L^�å?fYb�_�ñæ�RImzÓhu`|w½qÍpàia\Y�I`c�IfY��_ak�f dg��v�v�fe_ain��dgft_�`¯d��Ife_nfeiav�`{w�f¨� x�\LiÄb�\Liaiaf¨b�_aè|�b�\NiainfYdgp�\Lw��I`{wàz�p�\N`{w�_jd5\Nw�_ak�f�p�ia\�è{fÓqD_nk�f�d?�Iv�v�ft_aia� dgfe_5â�`|è{è�^�f�d?v�\�\L_ak½q�^�o�_ dg\Lv�fp,huia_æd�\uxR_ak�f�hY�I`cdmv h¨��w�\L_ÄhupàpÍf¨huiÄ`{w�_nk�f5`{v huzLf~êÆ`Ð� f���_nk�f�dg��v�v�fe_nia��dgft_�v~he��b�\LwI_æhu`{wzÓhup�d�b�\Liaiaf¨dgp�\Nw���`{w�z~_n\5_ak�f � v�`cdadg`|w�z���p�huin_jd�\ux�_nk�fÄp�ia\�è{fLñj�é�\Ni�h5d?o�igxÐhLb�fÄ\uxÀiafe��\Lè{o�_n`{\Lw�dgfeèÉx�äÆ\�btb�è{o�d?`{\Lw \�btb�o�ijd�d?`{v5o�è|_jhYw�fe\No,dgè{��êÆ`Ð� f���hY_�_ak�f�dahYv�f

b�`{ijb�o�è¯hYi�b�ia\Ódad�d?fYb�_a`|\NwPñR\Nw�^�\N_ak�d?`¯�If¨d]\YxÁ_nk�f pàia\+,è{f���ßÁk�`cd]`cd]w�\L_�_akàf5behLdgf�q�`{w�zNftw�feijhYè=qx�\Li�h5bthuw�hYèUd?o�igxÐhLb�f��

� ����×UÙ���Ý�×�ÞuÖ�� ×P&)( � *�� � (Ä×UÙ * � (Ä×

�2143 � D�C D 7�� ; > B 68? ? D �"!y��IzLfYdUhYiaf�fe��_aiæhNb�_nfY��_a\Äd?o�^�ä�p�`{��feèàhNbeb�oàijhNb��¢o,dg`{wàzÄhmè{\�bthuè�`{v�p�è{fev�few�_jhY_a`{\LwÄ\ux�_nk�f�ÿRhuw�w��f¨�IzNf�\Np�feiæhu_a\Li�ë �Yð=�~ßÁkàfYdgf�hYiaf�è{`|w�ã�fY�'`{w�_a\�fY��zNfeè|ä=bjk�hu`|w�d�^I��h�dgf ��o�few�_a`chuèUè|`{w�ã�ftimâ�k�`cbÃkft�I_nijhup�\Lè¯hu_nfYd�\Y��fei�d?v~hYè{èFz�hYp�d���I�beb�o�iæhu_af b�o�in��f w�\Liav huè¯dÄhYiaf�b�\Lv�p�oà_afY��hY_�fYhNbjk�p�\N`|wI_\YxR_ak�f�fY�IzNftè{äÐbÃk�hY`{w�^I��è{\�bthuè{è|���_a_n`{w�z�h ��o�hL�IijhY_a`cb¢o�d?`{w�z�è{f¨hNdg_�d4��o�hYiafYdminfezNinfYdad?`{\Lw�â�`{_akb�fewI_nijhYè±l�huo�dndg`chuw�âÁft`{zNk�_a`|w�z \Lw�h5_ak�`|ia_nfefew~p�\N`|wI_�wàfe`{zLkI^�\Noàiak�\�\��P�

Page 9: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

éF`{zNoàiaf ï � � ����û�ø ��ú �5ù� Iûaö%�tønôH� ö�� � ö�÷Ðù�õI÷=ú¯ù!� � ��ü�ú �Äû�øÃû�õ�÷/�eúÆû� �àô�ú¯õI÷¯öØô�5÷/��û0ötùH��û0ójù�õ�ù!�ö���ø��tù�ó�û � �Ìú���û � � ���FôH DûÃø ��÷/��û��Ìøaô �{ûaö�ù�õ�ü�û "¨÷=ønù�ó�÷gûnü¢ö�������ûj÷Ðø��möYûj÷¯ö9���ýôN÷gû�÷/��û�ønù�ü�ú¯ójù!��� �ü�ú �ÄûÃøÃû�õI÷�ö(�àù ��ûaö ô��÷/��û �Ìøaô��|ûaö ù�õ�ü ö������ûæ÷=ø���öYûj÷ ö9���ýôH Dû.�uû�ø ��ú¯õ�ù�ójù�õàô�õ�ú¯ójù!���tøaùH��û÷/��ûÄ÷/�àøÃûjûmö�������ûj÷Ðø��¢öYûj÷¯ö ù�øÃû-�eú¯øÃ÷���ù!��� ��ú¯üIû�õI÷Ðú¯ójù!�23�öYûjû 1 �Iøjû��Yó#�

�21�0 � 7 � 7���� � >���7:B-68?)+' &('-, � � �/�1� ; 1 � � 7 � 3 ; 4ßÁkàf p�in\�b�fY�Io�inf¢x�\LimzLfew�feiæhu_a`|w�z�_ak�f dg��v�v�fe_ain��dgft_m`|wI��\Lè{��fYd�âÁ\NinãI`|w�z�huè|\Nw�z _gâR\~b�o�ia��fYd�q huw�� �¯q�dg`|v5o�è{_æhuw�fe\Lo�dgè|���UßÁkàf5hu`|v `¯dÁ_n\ ,_�h�b�`|ijb�è|fmâ�kà`¯bjk `cdÁ_jhYw�zNfew�_�dg`{v5oàè{_jhYw�fe\Lo�dgè|�_n\�pÍ\L`{w�_jd � huw�� � �F\Nw�fYhLbÃk�b�oàia��f����Æx�d?o�bjk�h b�`{ijb�è{fÄfe��`¯dg_ædm_akàfew;`|_jd�b�fewI_niaf�è{`{f¨dm\Nw�_ak�f`|wI_nfeijd?fYb�_n`{\Nw�\ux�_nk�f~w�\Liav huècd hu_ � hYw�� � �¯q�huw���`cd¢f ��o�huè|è{���I`cdg_æhuw�_¢x�ia\Lv � huw�� � �¯��ß½\��fe_afeinv�`|w�fÄd?o�bÃk�p�\N`|wI_æd�q�h � b�\NiniafYd?pÍ\Lw��Ifew,b�fÄv�fYhLdgo�inf���`¯d�b�\Nv�p�o�_af¨� hLd

� ê � � � � ñ � � � � � � � � � � � � � dg`{w �� d?`{w � � � d?fef �zNoàiaf �I�é�\NiRhÄzN`{��ftw5p�hu`|iD\Yx½p�\N`|wI_æd�q�_akàfmw�f¨huiaftiD_n\Äþefeia\Ä_nk�f�v�f¨hNdgoàiaf�q�_akàf�b�è|\�d?feiU_akà\�dgf�p�\N`|wI_æd

hYiaf�_n\%b�\NiniafYd?p�\Nw��I`|w�z�� I p�\N`|wI_�\Nw _nk�f�dg��v�v�fe_nia�%d?fe_~`cd�zNfewàfeijhY_afY�^���dgfeè|fYb�_a`|w�zBhp�\L`{w�_eq � q�\Nw~\Lw�fÄb�o�in��f�q�hYw���_akàfew��Ife_nfeiav�`{wà`{w�z�_nk�f�pÍ\L`{w�_Á\Lw~_ak�f�\N_nk�fei�b�o�ia��fÓq � � q�â�k�`cbÃkv hu_æbÃkàfYdmv�\�dg_�b�è|\�d?feè{��hNbtb�\Niæ�I`{w�z�_n\ _nk�f5�Lhuè|o�f5\ux�� ê � � � �{ñæ�5ßÁk�f dg��v�v�fe_ain��dgfe_Äp�\N`|wI_`cdÁbehYè¯b�oàè¯hu_nfY��huw�hYè{��_a`¯bthuè{è|� ^��5`{w�_afeiædgfYb�_a`{wàz¢_nk�f�w�\Ninv~hYè¯dD\YxF_ak�f�è{fYhLdg_Rd4��o�huinfYdG��o�hN�Iiæhu_n`¯bedhLdad?\�b�`¯hY_afY��â�`{_ak�p�\N`|wI_æd � huw,� � �c�ßÁk�f�b�\Nw�d?_aiao,b�_a`|\Nw\Yx�_ak�f�â�k�\Nè|f�dg��v�v�fe_ain�%dgft_�p�in\�b�fefY�àd�^I��d?feè{fYb�_a`{wàz�dgo�beb�fYdad?`{��fp�\L`{w�_jdm\YxÁ^�\L_ak�b�o�in��fYd�huw,�'zNfew�ftijhu_n`{w�zØh~dg��v�v�fe_nia��d?fe_mp�\L`{w�_mx�ia\Lv f¨hNbjk�hNd��IfYdab�ia`{^�fY�hY^�\u��fÓ�Dÿ�k�fYbjãàd½huiaf�`|w�b�è|o��IfY��_a\�few�dgoàiafÁ_nk�hu_Àdg��v�v�fe_nia�Äd?fe_FpÍ\L`{w�_jdUhYiafRp�ia\LpÍftiaè{�Ä\Lij�IfeinfY�PqhYw�� _nk�hu_�w�\5p�hY`{in`{w�z�\uxÀp�ia\�è{fÄp�\N`|wI_æd]zLfew�feiæhu_nfYdÁv�\LiafÄ_ak,huw'\Lw�f�dg��v�v�fe_nia� dgfe_�p�\N`|wI_t�yU�àhuv�p�è{fYd�\Yx�fe�I_nijhLb�_afY��d?�Iv�v�fe_ain��dgft_jdýx�\Li5behYw�huèRd?o�igxÐhLb�fYd hYiaf dgk�\Yâ�w�`|w ,zNo�inf�ïI�

ßÁkàfDpà`{p�fYd½o�dgfY��k�ftiaf�qYhYw��¢`|w d?o�^�d?f ��oàfewI_½`|v~hYzNfYd�qek�he��f�p�`{fYb�feâ�`¯d?fUb�\Lw�dg_æhuw�_±iæhN�I`|o�d½ijhu_nk�fei

î

Page 10: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

_nk�huw b�\Nw�d?_jhYwI_5iæhN�I`|o�d���ßÁk�fYd?f~^�feè{\Lw�z'_n\�h'è¯hYiazLfei5b�èchNdndý\YxÄd?o�igxÐhLb�f�qF^�o�_ pàia\Y�I`c�IfY��_ak�fiæhN�I`|o�d�`¯d�b�\Nw�d?_jhuw�_Ä`{w�_ak�f�w�fe`|zNk�^Í\Lo�iakà\�\��;\ux�hu��`¯d�`|w ��fYb�_n`{\Lw�d¢êÐdg\�_ak,hu_Ä�Lhuw�`cdgk�`|w�z�è{`{wàfYdbthuw�^�f��Ife_nfeiav�`{w�f¨�Íñ�_ak�f�_ak�ft\Niaft_a`¯bthuèFiafYd?o�è{_æd]\Yx�d?fYb�_n`{\Nw ��í���{�5hYiaf5d?_a`|è{èF�NhYè{`c�P��òm\YâRfe��feieqft�I_nijhNb�_a`{wàz�h�d?�Iv�v�ft_aia�Ødgfe_�`cd]v�\Ninf b�\Nv�p�è{`cbehu_nfY�~`{w�_ak�`cdmbthNdgfÓq�dg`{w,b�fÄ_ak�f�p�ia\�b�f¨dad�v5o�dg_b�\Np�f â�`|_ak�hu^�ino�p�_�bjk�huwàzNfYd�`{w�ijhL�I`{o,d��

�21�� ��� >���7PB-68? "��� 6 E � � C D �ßÁkàf ft�I_nijh'b�\Nw�d?_aijhY`{w�_jd5he�Lhu`|è¯hu^àè{f~`|w�_ak�`cd behLdgf�huinf~o�d?fY��_a\�dg`|v�pàè{` x���hYw���`{v�p�ia\Y��f�_ak�fpàia\�b�fYdndg`|w�z��5ßÁkàf5`{v huzNf¨��hu��`¯dm`cd�b�\Nv�p�o�_nfY���I`|iafYb�_nè{��x�in\Nv _ak�f5p�in\+�è|f�qPâ�`|_ak�\Lo�_ �_a_n`{w�zb�`{ijb�è{fYd��UßÁk�f�dabthuè{`|w�z¢x�oàw�b�_a`|\Nw�`¯dÁ\L^�_jhY`{w�f¨� x�in\Nv iæhN�I`|`½\uxÀ^�`{_æhuw�zLfew�_�b�`{iæb�è{fYdUâ�`|_ak�b�few�_ainfYdb�\Nw�d?_aijhY`{w�f¨�Ø_n\�_nk�f�hu��`¯d��

)+'*)+'-, .0/�3 � 583 / ����1 ��9��� ; /�� �-4��w��Ifei�âRfYhuã�p�feijd?pÍf¨b�_a`|��f _akàf5_gâR\�dg`¯��fYdm\ux�_ak�f5pàia\+,è{f�huinf�infeè¯hY_afY�'^���hYw�h/.~wàf5_aijhYw�dgäx�\Liav hu_n`{\Nw�â�`{_nk�_nk�iaftf��IftzNiaftfYdU\uxPx�infefY�I\Lv ë �Yìeð=�ÀßÁk�fYd?fminfep�iaf¨dgfew�_U_akàf�d?ã�feâÁfY�5d?�Iv�v�fe_ain�è|`{w�f ê� �s¢��éDñRhuw���_ak�f�b�\LiainfYdgp�\Nw,�Ifew�b�f��I`|iafYb�_a`{\Lw�êa��s¢��éDñ��Y�ßÁk�f�hJ. w�f�_aiæhuw�d=x�\Niav hu_n`{\Lw � � �� �� � â�kà`¯bjk¢infeè¯hY_afYd½b�\NiainfYdgp�\Lw��I`{wàzmp�\N`|wI_æd � � huw�� �

\Lw5_ak�fR_?âÁ\�p�in\+�è|f�d?`¯�IfYdF`¯dF�Ife_aftiav�`{w�fY��^���� �iædg_tqN\N^�_æhu`|w�`{w�zýhuw�hupàp�ia\Y��`{v hu_af�dg\Lè{o�_n`{\Nw5^����fe_afeinv�`|w�`{wàz�pÍ\L`{w�_Ub�\NiainfYdgp�\Lw��Ifew�b�fYdÑx�ia\Lv ^�`{_æhuw�zLfewI_Àb�\LwI_æhNb�_Fp�\N`{w�_jd��dgfYb�\Lw��PqYwIoàv�fein`¯behYèv�`{wà`{v�`{þYhY_a`{\Lw�\YxU_nk�fÄdT��o�hYiafY���I`cdg_æhuw�b�f¨dÁ^Íft_gâRfefew~\Lw�f�dg`c�If�\uxÀ_akàf�p�ia\�è{f�hYw��~_ak�fÄ\N_nk�fei_nijhYw�d9x�\Liav�fY��^�� � � � � ��q�v�fYhNd?o�iafY��hu_ h w�o�v5^�fei5\YxÄp�\N`{w�_jd�huè|\Nw�z�_akàf'p�in\+�è|f è|few�zL_ak½�ß½few�pÍ\L`{w�_jd5zN`|��f'hYw fe�àb�feè{è|few�_¢v hu_æbÃk�x�\Li~_ak�f�few�_a`|iaf�p�in\+�è|f�� ßÁk�`cd��Ift_afeinv�`|w�fYd p�\N`|wI_b�\NiainfYdgp�\Lw��Ifew�b�fYd]^�fe_?âRfefew~_nk�fÄ_gâR\�dg`c�IfYdÁ\ux¾_ak�fÄp�in\+�è|f��:�=_�behuw�^Íf�d?k�\Yâ�w%ë �Yìeð½_nk�hu_�_ak�fd?�Iv�v�fe_ain�~hY�I`cdÁ`¯dÁzN`|��few�^I�

������ � ������ � ������� ������� � �

â�kàfeiaf / hYw�� � ê � hLd�hu^�\Y��fNñRhuinfÄ_ak�f�ft`{zNftwI��fYb�_a\NiædU\ux � êÐhuw���k�he��fmfe`|zNfew��Lhuè|o�fYd �ÄhYw��� ��iafYd?p�fYb�_a`|��feè{��ñj�

)+'*)+' & .0/�3 � 583 / ����1 ��9��� ; 4 � /�3 � 1� 9:521 � � ��1é�\LiUfYhNbjkÄp�\N`{w�_eq qN\Lw5\Nw�f�d?`¯�If�\YxP_nk�fÁpàia\+,è{f�qN_nk�f�b�\NiainfYdgp�\Lw��I`{wàz�p�\N`{w�_eq �¯qL\Nw _nk�f�\N_nk�feid?`¯�If�`¯d��Ife_nfeiav�`{wàfY�0o,dg`{wàz5_ak�fÄh/.~wàf¢_nijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_a`|\Nw � � � � ���Áÿ�`|ijb�è|fYd�q�â�`|_ak�b�few�_ainfYd�b�\Nw�äd?_aiæhu`{wàfY�0_n\�_akàf�d?�Iv�v�ft_aia��hY�I`cd�q�hYiaf �_a_nfY� _a\Ä_akàf�_ak�`|ia_aftfew5p�\N`{w�_Up�in\+�è|fmwàfe`{zLkI^�\Noàiak�\�\��\Yx hYw�� � q�o�d?`{w�z h v�\���` �fY����feijd?`{\Lw~\uxR�Uiæhu_a_ �íd�b�`{iæb�è{f �_n_a`{wàz~hYè{zN\Lia`|_ak�v ë � Yð=��yU��hYv�äpàè{f b�`{iæb�è{fYdÄhYiaf�d?k�\Yâ�w�`{w ,zNo�inf ��� I�v�fe_ak�\���x�\Ni5v�fYhNd?o�ia`|w�z'_nk�f~dnbehuè|`{w�z�x�o�w�b�_n`{\Lw�`¯d��fYdab�in`{^�fY�~`{w�d?fYb�_a`|\Nw ���|�N�� I�

��� ' "*�� ��������� ��,NQ�� 0�"�. ��"*�&���&,�0���.$.*� 0�"���"*�+��% !+%�� ��.8O � �! RQ���.*, Q � 0 "*� M�� "*��:Q+.*��U�#�� ,*�"� � ,-�(.$� .$��# �("$���#%$ � � �&.*.$��.), $ � � � "*. $'&)(�*,+ 1 ���+� .*� ,*"*.$� 0�"*��� ��-�%� "*. ��%,/' ��.*����"*�&��% �&, !,*���/. ��%# $ � %� � � .*�-Q��(. ��� ��"*� .��% "*��&,�0��(,$� "*���(% � � �&.*.$��. , $ � � ��"*. $�01# � 0���!,*� "$��8Q.*�0�� ,*, �&, "*�� % "$��#&��.��(% "�"*�+Q � .*,NQ�� 0�"$� M�� �32�� 0�"$, �(,� ��, 0 .*� # ��� �&%�,$� 0�"$��� %54176+1 4+1

�/�

Page 11: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

D1

D3

L1

L3

L2D2

B3B1

B2

h ^ béF`{zNoàiafÄìH� � ��û�÷Ðøaù�õ�ö��tô�ø��5ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ~ô�ýù ö�������ûj÷=ø��ýöYûæ÷Áú¯õ�÷=ô~ù�õ�ù�� õÍûýójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!�#�tønùH��û�� � ù��� ønô��{û�ó���ø.�uûaö ù�õ�ü ö�������ûj÷=ø��0öYûj÷�ô � ÷Ðù�ú¯õÍûnü �tøaôH��ù Dûnù � �ÍûÃøæö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû�ú �5ù� Iû�� ��� ����ú ö÷Ðú¯õ! ���ú ö(��ûnü �Éú¯õÍûaö�ù�õàü ÷ ��û�ú¯ø�ú¯õI÷gûÃøæöYûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ö)��÷/��û�÷ �àøjûjû�ü�ú ö�÷Ðú¯õ! ���ú ö(��ûnü ��ô�ú¯õ�÷ ö9� � ��û�÷=ønù�õ�ö��tô�ø"�5ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ú ö%�tô��Iõ�ü= �àú¯ó�� �5ù ��ö ÷ ��û ü�ú ö�÷=ú¯õ ��Iú ö(��ûnü �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö)� ��� � ��� " ��� � � ��ô�õI÷=ô�÷ ��û � ùuötú ö�àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö)� � � � � � " � � � � � � ó ��� ��û�øjûaö����í÷�ô��ù ��� � �Nú¯õ ;÷/�àú ö�÷=ønù�õ�ö��tô�ø��5ùN÷=ú¯ô�õ�÷Ðô;÷ ��û= ��àô!�{ûö�������ûj÷Ðø��0öYûæ÷�(� ��û � ùuötú ö���ô�ú¯õ�÷ ö ù�øÃû�ö(�àôH Àõ�ùuö�óeønôuöjöYûaö9� � ��û�øjû�ù�øÃû�ötú "�ö������ûj÷Ðø�� öYûj÷¯öö�� ��û�ø�ú � ��ôuöYûnü ��û�øjû�� � ��ûaöYû0ù�øÃû5û "Y÷Ðøaù�ó�÷gûnü8�tønôH� �ûnù � ��û�øæö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû ú �5ù� Iûaö Uú{÷/� �tù�ø��Lú¯õ! �túÆû� �àô�ú¯õI÷Äô� �Ìú���û � � ÷/��û5÷/�àøÃûjû �tønôH� 1 ���øÃû���ù�õ�ü ÷/�àøÃûjûÄötú �5ú��Éù�ø�� � � ��û��'ù�øjû �tú¯øÃ÷��Iù!� � �ú¯üIûÃõI÷=ú¯ójù!� ��üIû��5ô�õ�ö�÷ÐøaùN÷Ðú¯õ! �÷ ��û�ö�÷Ðù � ú��Éú{÷F�~ô��÷ ��û�ù�� õÍû �tønùH��û��

� Þ�(� ��Ú~ÞYÖ�×��,Õ¾Ö�� �5Ù]Þ ��ÖØ×�� (��;Ù (�� ( Ö�×��5×DÞtÚØÖ���%'& (�� ��Ö ÚØÖ��ÞYÝ ������Ù�� � ( � ÚØÖ��À×UÙ]Ü�Ý�×DÞtÚ~Ö

I4behuwà\Nw�`cbehuèPx�iæhuv�f `¯d�h5v�fe_nk�\�� \YxRhJ. w�fØë ���Lð±\Limpàia\Nå?fYb�_a`{��f0ë� N�YðUb�o�ia��fÄw�\Liav huè{`|þYhu_n`{\Lw½�ßÁkàf�w�\Ninv~hYè{`|þYhu_n`{\Nw�`¯dRhNbjk�`{ft��fY� `{w�_?âÁ\5d?_jhYzNfYd��Áé±`|ijd?_eq�h¢w�o�v5^�fei�\ux ü�ú ö�÷Ðú¯õ! ���ú ö(��ûnü �àô�ú¯õI÷¯öê�\Ni�è{`|w�fYdÃñRhYiaf dgfeè|fYb�_af¨��\Nw�_ak�f�b�o�in��f��Rsm`¯d?_a`{wàzNo�`cdgk�fY�~p�\N`|wI_ædmhYiaf�\Nw�fYd�â�k�`cbÃk�behYw'^�f è|\Näbthu_af¨��^�f�x�\Ninf�hYw��~h¨x�_nfeiÁ_nk�f�_aijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_n`{\Nwrq�dgo�bjk~hLd�b�\Ninw�feiæd]ê�_jhYw�zNfew�_���`¯dab�\Nw�_a`{w�o�`|_a`{f¨dÃñjq`|w ��fYb�_a`{\Lw�d ê�þefeia\Ódm\ux]b�o�in�NhY_ao�infNñjqrhuw���^�`{_æhuw�zLfew�_Äb�\Nw�_jhLb�_�p�\N`|wI_æd���}ÓfYb�\Nw,�PqP_akàf�behuw�\Lw�`{äbthuè½x�ijhuv�f `cd��If �wàfY� ^���dgfeè|fYb�_a`|w�z5p�\�d?`{_a`|\Nw�d�x�\Ni�h�wIoàv5^Ífti�\uxR^�hNd?`¯d�p�\N`{w�_jd�\Ni�è{`{wàfYd�qIx�\Li`|w�dg_æhuw�b�f¢_nk�fÄ_ak�infef���fein_a`cb�fYdD\Yx�hYw'f ��o�`|è¯hu_nfeijhYè�_aia`chuw�zLè{fÄ`{w�_nk�f�hJ. w�f�behNd?f���ßÁk�f�b�o�in��f�`¯d_nk�few�_aiæhuw�d=x�\Niav�fY��d?o�bjk;_nk�hu_�_ak�f �I`¯d?_a`|w�zNo�`cdgk�f¨�;p�\N`{w�_jd�v hup�_n\'_nk�f�^,hNdg`cd¢p�\N`|wI_æd�� Imè|èb�o�ia��fYdÁâ�kà`¯bjk'hYiaf�f ��oà`{�Lhuè|fewI_Ro�p'_n\�huw hJ. w�f _nijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_a`|\Nw�v hup�_a\�_ak�f dahuv�f�b�o�in��f���=w�_akàf¢pàia\Nå?fYb�_a`{��f�behLdgf�qIx�\Lo�imp�\L`{w�_jdÁ\Ni�è{`|w�fYdRhuiaf�iaf ��o�`|iafY�P�

� 143 �! � 6#" >�7�� 6$+' ,�'-, .0/�12/�3�4658769:/ �<; 4ßÁkàf ��`¯dg_n`{w�zLo�`¯d?k�fY�0x�f¨hu_aoàiafYd�o�dgfY�~_n\��If �w�f�_ak�fÄbthuw�\Lw�`¯behYèPx�ijhYv�fÄhYiaf�_nk�fÄ_ak�infef�dg_aiæhu`|zNk�_d?fezNv�few�_jdm\Yx�_nk�f~d?�Iv�v�fe_ain�'d?fe_�ê � fe�I_nfew��If¨� `{w ��fYb�_n`{\Nw,d � ñæ�5ßÁk�f dg��v�v�fe_nia��dgfe_ædmx�\NiÄ_ak�f\L^�å?fYb�_æd0`|w_akàf'v�\��Ifeè{ä�^�hLdgf�k�he��f�hY_~v�\�dg_5x�\Noài�dgo�bjkè|`{w�f¨d�� x�\Li�huw��%zN`{��ftwp�`|pÍfÓqÁ_ak�fdnhuv�f�_ak�infef�v5o�dg_5^�f�d?feè{f¨b�_afY�Ì����ij�Iftia`{wàz�`¯d p�in\u��`¯��fY�%dg`{v�p�è|�;^���_akàf'd?�Iv�v�fe_ain��d?fe_e�ßÁkàf¢`|wI_nfeijd?fYb�_n`{\Nw�\uxÀ_akàfYdgf�_nk�iaftf�è{`|w�fYdDzLfew�feiæhu_nfYdÁ_ak�infefÄ�I`cdg_n`{w�zLo�`¯d?k�fY��p�\N`|wI_æd�q�â�k�`cbÃkØhuiafv hupàpÍf¨�'_a\~��fein_a`cb�fYdÁ\ux�hYw�`¯dg\Ódab�ftè{fYd�_ain`¯huwàzNè{f�`{w�_ak�f�behYw�\Nwà`¯behYèÑx�iæhuv�f�qPhLdm`{è|è{o�d?_aiæhu_af¨� `{w,zNo�infYd]ì¨h&%�bL�ÁßÁk�f�^�hNd?`¯dDp�\L`{w�_jdÁbjk�\Ódgfew���\ w�\L_��I`��Ìfei�v5o�bjk0x�in\Nvç_ak�f�hu��`¯dRb�o�in��fYdU\uxF\Noài

�N�

Page 12: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

s

rr

s1

1

2

2

éF`{zNoàiaf � � � ��û~ù�� õÍû � ùuötú ö%�tô�ø�ù ö���ø5�tù�ó�û0ô� øÃû.�eô!� ��÷Ðú¯ô�õ%ú ö üIû�RõÍûnü�ô�õ;÷/��û~ú �5ù� �û~ù#"uú ö� �'÷� Uô��àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö)� � � ù�õ�ü � " � �àú¯ó(�%ù�øjû5÷ ��û ó�û�õ�÷=øjûaö�ô�Øóeú¯ønó��{ûaö ÷=ù�õ Iû�õI÷ ùN÷m÷/��û � ú{÷=ù�õ Iû�õI÷ójô�õ�÷=ù�ó�÷)�àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö9� � ��ûaöYû � ùuötú ö��àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö�ù�øÃûR÷/��û��Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ5ô��÷/��û�ó�û�õ�÷=øjûaö�ô�Áö�����û�øjûaö�÷Ðù�õ! IûÃõI÷÷Ðô'÷/��û ö��Iø��tù�ó�û ùN÷m÷/��û�óeú¯ønó��{û ô��ójô�õI÷Ðù�ó�÷Äô� ÷ ��û � ú{÷Ðù�õ! IûÃõI÷Äójô�õÍû���� � õÍû ójôYô�øaü�ú¯õ�ùN÷?ûaö ô�õ÷/��û�ù#"Lú ö üIû�Rõ�ûnü Àú{÷ � øÃûnö��Íûnó�÷D÷Ðô�÷/��ûaöYû �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö5ù�øjû �eúÆû� �àô�ú¯õI÷ ?ú¯õ��eù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷ �

ft��hYv�p�è|f p�`|p�fYd�½_akà`¯d�he��\N`c��d��I`cdgp�in\Np�\Nin_a`|\Nw�hY_af�few�è¯hYiazLfev�ftwI_�\NiÄb�\Nw�_aijhLb�_a`|\Nw�\Yx�dgf¨b�_a`|\Nw�d\Yx�hYwI�Ødg��v�v�fe_ain�~d?fe_�`{w�_nk�fÄbehYw�\Nw�`cbehuèPx�iæhuv�f���é�\Ni�âRfYhuã~p�feiædgp�fYb�_n`{��f�`|v~hYzNfYd�q�d?_jhu^à`{è{`|_?�\Y��feiR�I`|feâ�p�\N`|wI_�`cdÁfe��b�feè{è|fewI_��dgftf ,zNo�inf0ì¨bN�

$+' ,�' & � 58769:/ �<; 4�� 9�7 ;� ��3 5� ����1I bthuw�\Lw�`¯behYè�x�ijhuv�f�`{w5_nk�`¯d�behLdgf�d?`{v�p�è{��iaf ��o�`{infYdFhuw hJ. w�fmp,huijhYv�ft_aia`|þYhu_n`{\Lw x�\Ni�_ak�f�hY�I`cd�qhYw��%h w�\Liav huè|`{þYhY_a`{\Lw;x�\Ni�_ak�fØdabehYè{`{wàz x�o�w�b�_a`{\Lw½��ßÁk�f�x�\Nè{è|\Yâ�`{w�z b�\Nw�d?_aino�b�_a`|\Nw�inf ��o�`{infYd\Lw�è{��\Nw�f�^�`|_jhuwàzNfew�_�\Nw�_ak�f�p�in\+�è|f��8I�w�hJ. w�fmp,huijhYv�ft_afeiU\Lw�_nk�f�hu��`¯d±inf ��oà`{iaf¨d±_?âÁ\�^�hLdg`cdp�\L`{w�_jd�U_nk�fYd?f~hYiaf~_nk�f~b�fewI_niafYd�\ux�_akàf~b�`|ijb�è|fYdm^�`|_jhYw�zNfew�_�hu_�_ak�f�^�`{_æhuw�zLfew�_ è{`|w�f�b�\LwI_æhNb�_p�\L`{w�_jd���ßÁk�f�w�\Ninv~hYè{`|þYhu_n`{\Nw�`¯d��Ife_nfeiav�`{w�f¨��^I��d?fe_a_n`{w�z�_ak�f dgo�v�\Yx�_ak�f b�`{iæb�è{f�ijhN��`{`F_a\ hb�\Nw�d?_jhuw�_Ä�Lhuè{oàf��~}�fef �zLo�iaf �I�~}�_æhu^�`|è{`{_?��\u��fti��I`|feâ�p�\N`|wI_ÄhYw����I`¯dnb�ia`|v�`|w�hu_n`{\Nw�^�fe_?âRfefew\L^�å?fYb�_æd�huiaf��Iftv�\Lw�dg_nijhu_nfY� `|w��zNo�infYd�î�huw����/�5iafYd?pÍf¨b�_a`|��feè{���ßÁk�f�o�_n`{è|`{_?�'\Yx�_nk�f�dabthuè{`|w�z'x�o�w�b�_a`{\Lw%hNd5h'infep�infYdgfew�_jhY_a`|\Nw;x�\Li�h'zNfew�ftijhuè�dgo�i?xÐhNb�f \ux

infe��\Nè|o�_a`|\Nw�`¯d�b�è{fYhYiaè|��è{`|v�`|_afY��� ,ijdg_tq�^Íf¨behuo�d?f�dgfeèÉx�äÆ\�btb�è{o�d?`{\Lwp�in\NzNinfYdad?`{��feè|��feiæhNdgf¨d�_ak�fx�oàw�b�_a`|\Nw,�d?fYb�\Lw��Pq�^�fYbehYo�dgfÄ_akàf¢infep�infYdgfew�_jhY_a`|\Nw�`¯dÁ^�`chNd?fY��huz�hY`{w�d?_ � dgp�kàfeia`cbehuèrdgo�i?xÐhNb�fYd�� �hLd�_akàf'd?o�igxÐhLb�f'\YxÄiaft��\Nè{oà_a`{\Lw�hup�p�in\�hLbÃk�f¨d~h;d?p�k�feinf�qÁ_nk�f�dg��v�v�fe_ain�%dgft_�infY�Io�b�f¨d _a\Bhp�\L`{w�_eq�huw,� _akàf dnbehuè|`{w�z x�oàw�b�_a`|\Nw�_a\ h5dg`|w�zNè|fÄ�NhYè{o�fÓ�

� 1�0 ; > �� 68B,C�D�E 6 " >�7�� 6�=w�zNfewàfeijhYè=qUhYw�hY�I`cd b�oàia��f�behYw;\Lw�è{��^�f~infYb�\Y��feiaf¨� o�p�_n\�h~p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��f5_aiæhuw�d=x�\Ninv~hY_a`{\Lwx�in\NvçhÄpÍftijdgp�fYb�_a`{��f�`|v~hYzNf���ò�\uâRfe��feitq¨x�\Li�behYw�huèÌdgoàigxÐhNb�fYd�q�_ak�f��Lhuw�`cdgk�`|w�z è|`{w�f�\YxF_ak�f�hu��`¯db�o�ia��fÄp�èchuw�f�behYw'^�f��Ife_nfeiav�`{wàfY��x�ia\Nv�p�in\+�è|f5`{w �,fYb�_a`|\Nw�_jhYw�zNftwI_ædm^I��_nk�f�b�\Nw,dg_aino�b�_n`{\Nw\Yx �zLo�iaf��I�:�Æxr_ak�f��Lhuwà`¯dgkà`{w�z�è{`{wàfÁ`¯d�d?fewI_�_n\¢`|w �w�`|_?��qN_akàf�behuw�\Lw�`¯bthuè�x�ijhYv�f�b�oàia��f�`¯d�hYz�hu`|wâ�`|_ak�`|w�hYw�hJ. w�f�_nijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_a`|\Nw%\ux�_nk�f hu��`¯d�qU`Ð� f��rhJ. w�f�pàia\Np�fein_a`|fYd behYw�^�f~v�fYhNd?o�iafY�x�in\Nv _nk�f5p�feijd?pÍf¨b�_a`|��f `{v huzLf��5ßÁk�f5wàfYb�fYdndahuin��p�ia\Lå?fYb�_a`|��fÄ_aijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_n`{\NwB`¯d�b�\Lv�pào�_afY�x�in\Nv�_akàf¢x�\Nè|è{\Yâ�`{wàz�_?âÁ\�iafJ��o�`|iafev�few�_jd�� �ijd?_eqP_nk�f �Lhuwà`¯dgkà`{w�z�è{`|w�fÄv~hYp�dm_a\ `{w �wà`{_?��qPê�`=�Èf��_nk�f�_ak�`|ij�mkà\Nv�\NzNftw�fe\No,d±è{`|w�fUb�\�\Nij��`{w�hY_afÁ`cdPþefein\Iñ�Ldgf¨b�\Nw��Ìqu_nk�fU_akàiafefR�I`cdg_a`|w�zNoà`¯dgkàfY�mp�\N`|wI_ædhYiafÄv hup�p�fY��_a\�_ak�f�hJ. w�f�behYw�\Nw�`cbehuèPx�iæhuv�fÄ^�hNd?`¯dÁp�\N`|wI_æd��

Page 13: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

100

200

-150 -50 50 150 250

100

200

-150 -50 50 150 250

100

200

-150 -50 50 150 250

100

200

-150 -50 50 150 250

éF`{zNoàiaf�î � �àô ��øaôH !�� Dûnù � �ÍûÃøæö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû�ú �5ù� Iûnö ô�5÷/��û ötùH��û �eùuöYû5÷Ðù ��û�õ �tønôH� ü�ú �ÄûÃøÃû�õI÷�túÆû� �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö9���½û � �?ôYójó��2�Nötú¯ô�õ ú¯õ�óeøÃûnùuöYûnö �|û���÷�÷Ðô%ø�ú ��÷���½ûnójô�õàüøaôH !�û "Y÷Ðøaù�ó�÷gûnü �Ìøaô��{ûnö9�� �àú¯ønü�ønôH ��ötójù!�Éú¯õ! � �ÉôN÷�÷?ûnü ù� Óù�ú¯õ�ö�÷�ù�õ�ù�� õÍû�ù#"Lú ö��àù�øaùH��ûj÷?û�ø������Óö���ö¢ú¯õ'÷ ��û �ønù ����ù�øÃû �û�õÍû�ønùN÷gûnü�ùN÷ �àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö ���û�øÃû�÷/��û �Ìønô��{û�û.�tô!�2��÷?û�� ��� óeønôuöjöYûaö�÷ ��û�ö������ûj÷Ðø��;ù#"Lú ö9� � ��ûójôH� �àù�ø�ú ötô�õ~ô��÷ ��û�÷/�àøÃûjû�ójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!�ró��Iø.�uûaö¢üIû��5ô�õ�ö�÷ÐøaùN÷?ûaömö�÷Ðù � ú��Éú{÷F�5ô��uû�ø/�eúÆû �àô�ú¯õI÷� ��ú ��YûÃøÃû�õ�ó�ûnö�ù�ø�ú öYû%�tønôH� öYû)� �?ôYójó��2�Nötú¯ô�õ� �àú¯ó�� �Ìøaô) �øÃûnöjötú��uû)� ��û�øaôYüIûaö ÷ ��û%����õ�ó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ �tøaôH� ÷/��û�|û���÷�

�e�

Page 14: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

100

200

300

-100 0 100 200 300 400 500

100

200

300

-100 0 100 200 300 400 500

éF`{zNoàiaf��/� � � øaù ����ö ô� ötójù!�Éú¯õ ;ù� Óù�ú¯õ�ö�÷�ù�õ�ù�� õÍû�ù#"Lú ö �àù�ønùH��ûj÷gûÃø � � ��û0øÃû��ÌøjûaöYû�õI÷ÐùN÷=ú¯ô�õó.�{ûnù�ø�� �~ü�ú ötóeø�ú �5ú¯õ�ùN÷gûnö � ûæ÷� DûjûÃõ ÷/��ûÄ÷� Àô �tùuöYûaö9�

h ^ béF`{zNoàiaf��N��� � ù�� � � õÍû ójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!� �tøaùH��û �tô�ø¢ö������ûæ÷=ø��0öYûj÷¯ö �tønôH� ötú " Dûnù � ��û�øaö��Íûnó�÷=ú��uûú �5ù� �ûaö � ùuö ú¯õ81 ���øÃû �Yó �Øù�õ�ü~öYû.�uû�õ�ú �5ù� Iûaö Uú{÷ ��ötú �õ�ú Rójù�õ�÷��ÍûÃøæö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû�û �Äûnó�÷¯ö9� �ÄôN÷?û÷/��û�ü�ú ö�÷Ðô�øÃ÷Ðú¯ô�õ �tô�ø ÷ ��û � ùN÷Æ÷?û�ø�ó��Iø.�uûaö9� ��� � � ønô�Yûnó�÷Ðú��uû5ójù�õàô�õ�ú¯ójù!���tøaùH��û �tô�ø ÷/��û5÷ �àú¯øj÷?ûjû�õö�������ûj÷Ðø��'öYûj÷¯ö8�tô�ø~÷/��û~ötùH��û �Ìú���û(�NöYûnü%ú¯õ � ù�� � � ��û�ó���ø��Yûaö ù�øÃû(�tú¯øÃ÷��Iù!� � �%ú¯üIû�õI÷Ðú¯ójù!� �û �Éú �5ú¯õ�ùN÷Ðú¯õ! �÷ ��û ��û�øaö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû�ü�ú ö�÷Ðô�øÃ÷Ðú¯ô�õ ö(�àôH Àõ�ú¯õ;÷/��û�ù�� õÍû �tøaùH��û�� � ó ��� � ��û�ø�ú � �àôuöYûnüö�������ûj÷Ðø��]öYûæ÷ ö�ô���Ìú���ûaö � ù�õ�ü�� � �Ìú���û���ú öÁö(�àôH Àõ�ú¯õ 1 �Iøjû ��� �ýú¯õ�ù �Ìønô�Yûnó�÷Ðú��uû�ójù�õàô�õ�ú¯ójù!��tønùH��û�� ��õ+ûnù�ó(� ójùuöYû'÷/��û�øÃû ù�øÃû�÷� Dû �2�uû%ó��Iø.�uûaö9� � �àú ö üIû��5ô�õ�ö�÷ÐøaùN÷?ûaö�ü�ú ötóeø�ú �5ú¯õ�ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ� ûæ÷� DûjûÃõ�ô � �Yûnó�÷ ö �tøaôH� ÷/��û�ú¯ø�ójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!� �tønùH��û5ó���ø.�uûaö9� � ��û�ü�ú �Äû�øjû�õ�ó�û � ûæ÷� DûjûÃõ ÷/��û5÷F Uôó��Iø.�uû�öYûj÷¯ö ú ö���ûnùuö���øÃûnü �Nötú¯õ! �ù0ö�÷ÐùN÷=ú ö�÷Ðú¯ójù!�Fó��Éùuöjötú �ûÃø �

���

Page 15: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

éF`{zNoàiaf%� ��� "LùH� � �|û�ú �5ù� Iûaö ù�õ�ü �Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷Ðú��uû ójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!�,�tønùH��ûaö/�tô�ø ÷/�àøÃûjû ójù�õ�ù!�mö���ø"�tù�ó�ûnö)� �Ìú���ûaö � � � ù�õ�ü � � �ýôN÷?û�÷/��û Uú¯üIû��eù�ø�ú¯ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ú¯õ+�eúÆû� Àú¯õ! �àôuötú{÷Ðú¯ô�õ � røaôH� ÷Ðô �%÷Ðô� ôN÷�÷ÐôH�8�5÷/��û�ójù�õ�ô�õàú¯ójù!� �tønùH��ûaö�ójô�õI÷Ðù�ú¯õ ö�������ûj÷Ðø��'öYûj÷¯ö �û�õÍû�ønùN÷gûnü �tøaôH� ötú "��44�uû ù�õ�ü÷F Dû)� �uû%ú �5ù� IûnöBøÃûaö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû)� ��� ��÷ �{ûnùuö�÷ �àù!� �Bô�%ûnù�ó�� öYûj÷5ö(�àôH ötú �õ�ú Dójù�õI÷ ��û�øaö��Íûnó�÷=ú��uûü�ú ö�÷Ðô�øj÷=ú¯ô�õ�ö�3 õàôN÷gû5÷/��û �eù�ø�ú¯ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ú¯õ��Ìú���û� Uú¯üN÷/�Bú¯õ�÷ ��û �5ú¯ü�ü �{û�ójô!�2� �5õ�ü���û5÷=ô ��û�øæö���ûnó ÷Ðú��uû���� ��û�û�õ�ü�9ü�ú¯ùH��ûj÷gûÃø~ô� �Ìú���û � ú ö ��� ��� 3÷/��û0ötùH��û0ü�ú¯ùH��ûj÷gûÃø~ùuö �Ìú���û � � �Ìú��Íûnö �ù�õàü � � ôN÷ � �àù��Yû�ù�õû�õ�ü�?ü�ú¯ùH��ûæ÷gû�ø�ô� ��� ��� � � ��û5ö.�Éú ��÷ ú¯õ�ö�÷=ù � ú�� ú{÷�� �ÌøjûaöYû�õI÷�÷ÐôH Uù�ønüuö÷/��û�û�õ�üuö ô��÷ ��û ójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!���tøaùH��ûýó��Iø.�uûaö0ù�øÃû�ü���ûÄ÷=ô'û�ø�øaô�øaö�ú¯õ'÷/��û�û�"Y÷=ønù�ó�÷?ûnüØö������ûæ÷=ø��öYûæ÷G �àú¯ó�� ôYójó���ø ��û�øÃûÄ÷/��û �Ìú���û�ønù�ü�ú��Óöýó��àù�õ! Iûnö9�

� �

Page 16: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

éF`{zNoàiaf��e� � � ��ûRójô�õ�ö�÷Ðø���ó�÷Ðú¯ô�õ �NöYûnü¢÷ÐôÄô � ÷Ðù�ú¯õ0÷/��ûRú¯õ��eù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷ �Éú¯õÍû �{û�õ! N÷/��ö�� ú¯õ ÷/��û�ójù�õàô�õ�ú ójù!���tønùH��û�� �ýú¯õÍûýøaùH�¨ö�ù�øjû�ójùuö�÷ �tønôH��ù �àô�ú¯õI÷:�5ú¯ü�� UùH� � ûj÷F Dûjû�õ ÷F Uô~ô��÷/��û�ü�ú ö�÷Ðú¯õ! ���ú ö(��ûnü�àô�ú¯õI÷¯ö9� � ��û(�tù!�2�,û�øjûnójô�øaüIûnü�ú ö�÷/��û �|û�õ! N÷/� ô��÷ ��ûØøaùH���'� ��û�ønùH�¨ö �àù��uû'û����Iù!��ù�õ! � �Éù�øöYû ��ù�ønùN÷=ú¯ô�õ �

��õ��tù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷ � ��õ��eù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷ � ��õ��tù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷ ���ûnù�õ ö9�|ü � ��ûnù�õ ö9�|ü � ��ûnù�õ ö9�|ü �

�Ìú���û � � � � � � I���íî��� ���|�/���� �e�����&���e� ���|�eï�ìÓ� � ��&�L�I� ���{���à�uì�Ìú���û � � � � � I��� ���Lî ��� �NîNî�� � Lî��&�L�� ���|� �I��� � �� �à�/� ���{�eîL���Ìú���û � � � � � N���íî��� ���|�e��L� �e�����í�L�Nï ���|� �Nï � � �� ���Nî ���{�eïL�I��Ìú���û � � ��� � � ��� �� ���|�/��ì¨î �e����� � �� ���|�uìNì¨� � ��&�Lî� ���{�uìJ�I�

ßFhu^àè{fÄ�� ��õ��tù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷¯ö�ójôH� � ��÷?ûnü �Nötú¯õ! 5ù Rú ö(��û�ø��Éú¯õÍûnù�ø�ü�ú ötóeø�ú �5ú¯õ�ù�õI÷ � ùuöYûnü¢ô�õ�÷ ��û�ójù�õàô�õ ú¯ójù!���tønùH��û ��ûnùuö��IøjûaöÁö(�àôH Àõ ú¯õ 1 �Iøjû � � � � ��û � øaù�ó ��ûæ÷Æ÷?ûnü�õ7� � � û�øaöýù��÷gû�øÄûnù�ó�� �Ìú���û Óú��uû÷/��û õ�� � � ûÃø�ô��ú �5ù� �ûaö�ójô�õI÷Ðø�ú � ��÷?ûnü �tô�ø~÷/�àùN÷ �Ìú���û�÷=ô�÷/��û�ójôH� � ��÷=ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õZô�'÷/��û�Rú ö(��û�ø�¢ú ötóeø�ú �5ú¯õàù�õI÷G�5ùN÷Ðø�ú " �

}�_æhu^�`|è{`|_g��`¯dUp�\�\NiR` xFhYw~h/.~wàf]x�iæhuv�f ê�_ak�infef�dg��v�v�fe_nia�5d?fe_�è{`|w�fYdÃñr`¯dUo�dgf¨� x�\LiDp�feiædgp�fYb�ä_n`{��f�`|v~hYzNfYd��dgftf �zLo�iaf��N�thI�Ròm\YâÁfe��ftieqN`ÉxFh¢pàia\Nå?fYb�_a`{��f�x�ijhYv�f�êÆ_nk�iafef�dg��v�v�fe_nia� dgfe_Rè{`{wàfYdhYw���_ak�f5�Lhuwà`¯dgkà`{w�z~è|`{w�fLñÁ`cdmo�dgf¨�Pq½dg_æhu^�`|è{`|_g��`cdmfe�àb�feè{è|few�_/�d?fef �zLo�iaf��L��^½�5ßÁkà`¯d�d?_jhu^à`{è{`|_?�\YxÀbehuwà\Nw�`cbehuè�x�ijhuv�f�b�o�ia��f¨d¾`cd�huw~`|w��I`{infYb�_�`{w,�I`¯behY_a`|\Nw�\uxF_akàfmp�èchuw�hYia`|_g�5\YxF_ak�fýhu��`¯d�b�o�in��f��yU�àhuv�p�è{f¨dD\uxÀp�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��fÁx�ijhYv�f¨d¾x�\Ni�\L_ak�fti�p�`{p�fYdRhuw����I`cdab�in`{v�`{w�hY_a`{\Lw�^�fe_?âRfefew~_nk�fev huiafzL`{��few `{w��zNoàiafYdÄ�N�tb huw,�;� ��

� Þ�(� ��Ú~ÞYÖ�×��,Õ¾Ö�� �5Ù]Þ ��ÖØ×� (�����Ü Ù+( � ( Ö�× � ��ÕUÖ�� �5Ù]Þ ��Ö�× �ßÁkàfÁp�infe�I`|\No�dFdgf¨b�_a`|\Nw5��fYdab�in`{^�fY��_akàf�b�\Lv�p�oà_jhu_n`{\Lw \uxÌ��`{feâ�p�\L`{w�_aä�`{w��NhYia`chuw�_ ó��Iø.�uûaö �Àòmfeinf�qâRf~b�\Nv�p�o�_af ú¯õ��eù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷¯ö x�in\Nv _nk�f~b�o�ia��fYd�� Imw�`{w��NhYia`chuw�_¢`cdÄh w�o�v5^�feiÄâ�k�\�d?f �LhYè{o�f�`¯doàw�hJ�ÌfYb�_nfY�~^I� �I`|feâ�p�\N`{w�_e�

�=w��NhYia`chuw�_jd�hYiaf�\N^�_æhu`{wàfY� x�ia\Lv v�fYhLdgo�infev�fewI_æd]\Lw;_nk�f�behYw�\Nw�`cbehuèFx�ijhuv�f�b�o�in��f `|è{è{o,dgä_nijhY_afY�~`{w��zLo�iaf��t�I�RßÁk�`¯d�b�\Lw�dg_niao�b�_a`{\LwBë� �Lð½`¯d�d?`{v�`{è¯hYiÁ_n\5_ak�f �tôYôN÷ �Ìø�ú¯õI÷¯ö \ux�½huv ��huwrq ûj÷ù!� � ë ���Lð=q�huè|_ak�\Lo�zNk�k�ftiaf�è{few�zL_ak�dRhuinfmv�fYhNd?o�iaf¨��ijhY_ak�fei�_nk�huw�huinfYhNd���ßÁk�f���fYb�_a\NiÀ\uxF`{w��Lhuin`{ä

�eï

Page 17: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

129.0

129.5

130.0

130.5

131.0

-25 -24 -23 -22 -21

éF`{zNoàiaf����A� �ÌójùN÷Æ÷?û�ø � � ôN÷�ô��÷/��û%Røæö�÷�÷F Uô;ú¯õ7�eù�ø�ú¯ù�õ�÷ öØójôH� � ��÷?ûnü8�tøaôH��÷ ��û �Ìú��Íû0ú �5ù� Iûaö9�� ú���ûaö ��� ��ù�øjû�øÃû��ÌøjûaöYû�õI÷?ûnü � �~÷=ø�ú¯ù�õ! !�|ûaö)��ö ����ù�øÃûaö)�]óeú¯øaó��|ûaö�ù�õ�ü~ö�÷=ù�øaö øÃûaö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû)� � � � �àú öüIû �5ô�õ�ö�÷=ønùN÷gûnö�÷ ��û'öYûÃõ�ötú{÷=ú��tú{÷�� ô� ÷ ��û�ü�ú ötótø�ú �5ú¯õ�ù�õ�÷&3÷/��ûBójù�õ�ô�õ�ú¯ójù!�,�tønùH��û�ó���ø.�uûaö �tô�ø�Ìú���ûaö � � � ù�øÃû�ù!� �5ôuö�÷�ú¯üIûÃõI÷=ú¯ójù!� �hYwI_Àè{`{wàfÁè{ftw�zN_nk�d � `cd±w�\N_�o�d?fY�5�I`|iafYb�_nè{�mx�\LiR�I`¯dnb�ia`|v�`|w�hu_n`{\Nwr�,�=w�dg_nfYhN�Pq�hYw ú¯õ�üIû " �uûnó�÷Ðô�ø��`cdÁb�\Lw�dg_niao�b�_afY�0x�in\Nv � o�d?`{w�z h d?_jhu_n`¯d?_a`¯bthuè½b�è¯hNdndg` �fei�\Y��feiRhuè{èÌfe��_aijhLb�_af¨��behYw�\Nwà`¯behYèÍx�ijhYv�fb�o�ia��fYd���ßÁk�feinf�huinf�_gâR\�hL�I�Lhuw�_jhuzLfYd5\ux�_ak�`cd�� ,ijdg_tqU_ak�f�`|w��Ife��`cd v�\Liaf��I`cdab�in`{v�`{w�hY_a`|w�z_nk�huw �íijheâ �½è{ftw�zN_nk�d��d?fYb�\Nw,�Pq±_nk�f~��`{v�few�dg`|\Nw�\ux�_nk�f�`|w��Ife��â�`|è{è�zNftw�feijhYè{è|�'^�f~è{f¨dad�_ak�hYw_nk�f��I`{v�few�d?`{\Lw \Yx � q�dg`|v�p�è|` x���`{w�zÄ`|_jdÁo�d?f `{wØh0infYb�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Lw'd?��d?_afev��ßÁk�f é±`¯d?k�fei�è|`{w�fYhYi��I`cdab�in`{v�`{w�hYwI_ýë ���Nð=q�â�k�`cbÃk~`cdmhYw'\Lp�_a`|v~hYè½è{`{wàfYhui�b�èchNdndg` ,feieq�`¯d�o�dgfY�x�\Lim_nk�f5b�\Nv�p�o�_jhY_a`|\Nw'\Yx�_akàf¢`|w��Ife�Ì�RßÁk�f5�I`cdab�in`{v�`{w�hYwI_Rv�`|w�`{v�`¯d?fYdD_nk�f �í`|wI_nijhuäÐb�èchNdad��Lhuin`{ähYw�b�f��àêÆ_ak,hu_Á`cdU\u��fti�dgfe��ftijhuè�fe�àhuv�p�è{f¨d±\uxF_nk�f�dahYv�f�p�`{p�fNñÀhYw���v hu��`{v�`¯dgf¨dÑ_nk�f � `{w�_afeinä=b�è¯hNdndd?fep�hYijhu_n`{\Lw���êÆ_ak,hu_Á`cdÑx�\Ni��I`��Ìfeinfew�_Up�`{p�fYdjñj� �9_R�I\�f¨dDd?\ ^�� _nijhuw,d9x�\Ninv�`|w�z _n\�hýwàfeâÄq�\Nia_nk�\NzLä\Lw�huè�^�hLdg`cd�q � ��� � qPâ�k�ftiaf5_akàf5v~hY_aia`|� � `¯d�b�\Nv�p�o�_nfY� x�ia\Lv x�fYhY_ao�inf5v�fYhLdgo�infev�fewI_æd_æhuã�few5\Y��fei¾huè{èà_ak�f�behYw�\Nwà`¯behYèIx�ijhYv�fYd��UßÁk�f�`{w��Lhuin`¯huw�_jdÀhuiaf�_akàf�b�\Nv�p�\Nw�few�_jdU\YxP_nk�f���fYb�_a\Li� ��Rhuè|o�fYd½\ux�_nk�fYd?fÁ`{w��Lhuin`¯huw�_jd½hYw�� _akàfe`{i½�Lhuin`¯hYw�b�fYdPx�\NiU_nk�fDx�\Lo�iFp�`{p�fYd½\ux�,zNo�infYdUï�huw��~�

hYiaf�zN`{��ftw `|w�_jhu^àè{f��N��ßÁkàf5dabthu_a_nfei�p�è{\L_�\ux��zLo�iaf ������fev�\Lw�dg_nijhY_afYd�_ak�hY_m_nk�f¢x�\Lo�i�p�`{p�fYdb�\No�èc�~huè|v�\Ódg_Á^�fÄ��`¯dg_n`{w�zLo�`¯d?k�fY�~d?\Nè|feè{�5o�d?`{w�z5_nk�f �iædg_R_gâR\ `|wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_æd��8�=w~pàijhNb�_a`¯b�fm_nk�iafef`|wI�LhYia`¯hYwI_æd�iafeè|`¯hu^àè{��êÆo�p�_a\�_?âÁ\�d?_jhuw,��huiæ���Ife��`¯hY_a`{\Lw�dÃñ��I`cdg_n`{w�zLo�`¯d?k�huè{è�_nk�f�ft��hYv�p�è|fYd�\ux,zNo�infYd¢�L��^ huw���� I�

� � ( Ý�Ú �ØÖ�Þt×DÞtÚØÖ��^�å?fYb�_~iafepàiafYd?fewI_æhu_n`{\Nw oàp _n\h�è|`{w�fYhYi�_aijhYw�d9x�\Liav hu_n`{\NwZ`¯d�d?o .�b�`{few�_0x�\Li�iafYb�\LzNw�`|_a`|\Nw½��=w���fefY�PqÀh v�\��Ifeè{ä�^�hLdgfY�;infYb�\LzNw�`|_a`{\Lw%dg�àdg_nfev k�hLd ^Íftfew�^�o�`|è{_�x�\Ni�p�è¯hYw�hui5\L^�å?fYb�_ædýo,dg`{wàz\Lw�è{��p�in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��f�pàia\Np�fein_a`|fYd ë �Lð=��ßÁk�f�dnhuv�f5dg�àdg_nfev huiæbÃk�`|_afYb�_ao�infÄbehuw�^�f o�d?fY� _n\�^�oà`{è¯�

�uì

Page 18: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

h ^

éF`{zNoàiaf�� � ��� úÆû� �àô�ú¯õI÷ ?ú¯õ��eù�ø�ú¯ù�õI÷ øÃûnójô) �õ�ú{÷Ðú¯ô�õ � � ù�� � ��û�ú �5ù� Iû�ójô�õ�÷=ù�ú¯õ�ö ô�õÍû �Ìú��ÍûØú¯õ÷/��û=�5ôYüIû)�%�Éú � ønù�ø�� � ÷/��û(�Éù�ø� Iû �Ìú���û�ô�õ÷/��û(�{û���÷ �9� ù�õ�ü�÷� Uô%ôN÷/��û�øaö�÷ �àùN÷ ù�øÃûØõ�ôN÷5ú¯õ÷/��û� ú � øaù�ø�� �]ùuö Dû)����ùuö ôN÷ ��ûÃø�ô � �Yûnó�÷ ö9� ��� � � ��û �Ìú��Íû0ú¯õ;÷ ��û �Éú � øaù�ø���ú ö ójô�ø�øjûnó�÷�� ��øÃûnójô) �õ�ú öYûnüù�õàü'ú¯üIû�õI÷Ðú �ûnü�ùuö �Ìú���û � � � ��û � �Éù�ó � ó���ø��uû�ö(�àôH Ñö�÷ ��û��Ìøaô�Yûnó�÷gûnü=�5ôuüIû �Ñö�������ûj÷=ø��0öYûj÷ �� ��û�ôN÷/��û�ø �Ìú���ûaöýù�øÃû�õàôN÷Áøjûnójô) �õ�ú öYûnü ��� �����ÌønôYó�ûaöjötú¯õ! 5ú öýù���÷ÐôH�5ùN÷Ðú¯ó#���ýôN÷gû�÷ ��û�ötú �õ�ú Dójù�õI÷��û�øaö���ûnó�÷Ðú��uû�ü�ú ö�÷=ô�øj÷Ðú¯ô�õ'ô�Ä÷/��û/�{û���÷ �Ìú��Íû��

h5iaf¨b�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Nw�d?��d?_afevç^�hNd?fY� \Lw'_nk�f5l¢ÿ `{w��NhYia`chuw�_jd��ßÁk�ftiaf�huinf5_?âÁ\�d?_jhuzLfYd�`{w�^�oà`{è¯��`{w�z h�iaf¨b�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Nw�d?��d?_afev=� �ijd?_eqFhNb���o�`cdg`|_a`{\Lw½q�â�k�feiaf

bthuw�\Lw�`¯behYèÑx�iæhuv�f5b�oàia��fYd�q�huw��'_nk�fe`{i�`|wI�LhYia`¯hYwI_æd�qÌhuinf5dg_n\NinfY� `|w�h�v�\��IfeèFè{`|^�ijhYia� �dgfYb�\Lw��PqinfYb�\LzNw�`|_a`{\Lw½qÁâ�k�ftiaf�_ak�f dg�àdg_nfev `¯�Ifew�_a` �fYdÄâ�k�`¯bjk%v�\��Iftè ê�` xýhuw��Íñ�`¯d5`{w h p�feiædgp�fYb�_n`{��f`|v~hYzNf��[�fYb�\LzNw�`|_a`{\Lw pàia\�b�fef¨��d~^I� � êa�Yñ~b�o�ia��fYd huiaf�d?feè{f¨b�_afY� hLd~pÍ\L_afew�_a`chuè|è{�^�feè|\Nw�zL`{w�z%_n\

pà`{p�fYd�^I��è|\�behu_n`{w�z b�\Nw,dg`¯d?_afew�_Äd?fe_jdÄ\ux�d?_aiæhu`{zLkI_�è{`|w�f5p�hu`|ijd�q±\N_nk�fei�b�o�in��fYd�hYiaf �I`¯dnbehuiæ�IfY��ê �ñ�b�\Nv�p�o�_a`|w�z dg��v�v�fe_ain��dgft_jd]x�\LiÄhuè|èUd?feè{fYb�_afY��b�o�in��fÄp�hu`|ijd�Àê=��ñ]b�\Nv�p�o�_n`{w�z�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�_jdx�\LiUfYhLbÃk�d?�Iv�v�ft_aia��d?fe_�b�o�in��fH�ê �Iñro�dg`|w�zÄ_ak�f�`|wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_æd±hLdDhYw ú¯õàüIû " _n\ÄhNbtb�fYdadF_ak�f�v�\��Ifeèè|`{^�iæhuin� � ` xFhYw~`{w��Lhuin`¯huw�_Á�LhYè{o�fÄb�\NiainfYdgp�\Lw���dÁ_a\5\Lw�f�\YxU_nk�f�è{`|^�ijhYia�5�Lhuè|o�fYd�q�h iaf¨b�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Nwk���pÍ\L_ak�f¨dg`¯d�`¯dmzLfew�feiæhu_af¨��Uê���ñ���fein` x���`{w�z5_nk�f5iafYb�\NzNwà`{_a`|\Nw�k��Ip�\L_ak�fYd?`¯dm^���b�\Nv�p�hYia`{wàz~_ak�f_æhuinzNfe_�dg��v�v�fe_nia� dgfe_�_n\�h0è|`{^�iæhuia� b�o�in��f��

IinfYb�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Lw~d?��d?_afev4k�hNdU^�fefew5^�oà`{è{_Àâ�k�`¯bjk�behuw�`¯��fewI_n` x��Äh�p�`|p�f]x�in\Nv�h�p�feiædgp�fYb�_n`{��f`|v~hYzNf�� ßÁk�f'`|v~hYzNf�behYw b�\LwI_æhu`|wZdgfe��feiæhuè�\L^�å?fYb�_jd x�ia\Lv _nk�f'è|`{^�iæhuia��hLd�âÁfeè|è�hNd~\N_nk�feioàw�v�\���feè{è|fY� \L^�å?fYb�_jdÄê � b�è{oà_a_afti � ñæq�hYw��'_ak�f��I`|feâ�p�\N`|wI_�`¯d�o�w�b�\Lw�dg_nijhY`{w�fY�Ì� I]_�p�infYdgftwI_�_ak�fv�\��Ifeè�è|`{^�iæhuin��b�\LwI_æhu`|w�d¢x�\No�i5pà`{p�fYd��%[�fYb�\LzNw�`|_a`|\Nw�fe�àhuv�p�è|fYd hYiaf�dgk�\Yâ�w�`{w �zNoàiafYd~� �hYw��;�tïI�

� � Þ ��Ý�Ü�� ��ÞeÚ~Ö��f'k,h¨��f��Iftv�\Lw�dg_nijhu_nfY�h���`{feâ�p�\N`|wI_näÆ`|wI�LhYia`¯hYwI_�iafepàiafYd?fewI_æhu_n`{\Nw%x�\Ni�lÄÿRd0\Yx�h;b�feia_æhu`{wb�è¯hNdnd !���ßÁk�f�iaftp�iafYd?few�_jhu_n`{\Lw~`¯d�dg_æhu^�è|f�\Y��fei��I`|feâ�p�\N`|wI_tq��I`cdab�in`{v�`{w�hY_afYd±^�fe_?âRfefew�\N^�å?fYb�_æd�qhYw���behYw�^Íf5infeè{`chu^�è|�~fe��_aiæhNb�_nfY�Øx�in\Nv `|v~hYzNfYd��R�=w��NhYia`chuw�_jd�^�hNd?fY� \Lw�_ak�f�iafepàiafYd?fewI_æhu_n`{\Nwk,h¨��f�^�fefew dgo�btb�fYdad=x�o�è{è|� o�d?fY�~hLdD`{w,�Ife� x�o�w�b�_a`{\Lw�dU`{w�h�v�\��Ifeè|äÆ^�hLdgfY��iafYb�\LzNw�`|_a`|\Nw�d?��d?_afev��

�/�

Page 19: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

h ^

éF`{zNoàiaf��eï � � ù�� � ��û ú �5ù� Iû ójô�õI÷Ðù�ú¯õ�ö�÷F Uô �Ìú���ûaö�ú¯õ;÷/��û �5ôYüIû)�,� ú � øaù�ø���ùuö Dû)� ��ùuö ôN÷/��û�øô � �Yûnó�÷ ö�� �Ìú���û � ô�õ0÷/��û%�{û ��÷ � �Ìú���û��~ô�õ�÷/��û�ø�ú +��÷ � ��� ����ôN÷/� �Ìú���ûaö�ù�øjû�ójô�ø�øÃûnó�÷�� ��øÃûnójô) �õ�ú öYûnü �

Imè|_ak�\Lo�zNk�_akàfe\Ninfe_a`cbehuè|è{��b�\NiniafYb�_U\Nw�è|� x�\Ni�p�infYb�`¯d?f�few���feè{\LpÍf¨d±\uxÑdgp�k�ftiafYd�q�_nk�f�v�fe_ak�\��àdhYiaf~wà\N_5_a\�\�d?few�d?`{_a`|��f5_a\��Ift�I`chu_a`|\Nw�dmx�in\Nv _ak�f~`c�IfYhYè=��é,\Li fe�àhuv�p�è|f�q±_nk�f~b�ia\�dndgäÐdgfYb�_a`{\Lw\Yx�p�`|p�f'��`¯dÄhNb�_no�huè|è{��feè{è|`{p�_n`¯behYè=q�â�`{_akBhuw hNdgp�fYb�_¢iæhu_n`{\'�LhYia��`{w�z�^�fe_?âÁfeftw �I� �Lî'hYw���N� �Iqiæhu_nk�fei�_ak�hYw~o�w�`Éx�\Ninv�è|�5b�`|ijb�o�èchuit�Dÿ�è{f¨huiaè|��qN^�fYbehYo�dgf�\uxÀd?feè x�ä�\�beb�è|o�dg`|\Nw½qL_ak�f�iafepàiafYd?fewI_æhu_n`{\Nw`cdÁè{fYdndÁo�dgf�x�o�èPx�\Ni�d?o�igxÐhLb�fYd�\uxÀiafe��\Lè{o�_n`{\Nwr���fÄhuinfÄb�o�iniafew�_aè|�5few�èchuiazL`{w�z�_ak�f�v�\��IfeèPè|`{^�iæhuin��q�huw��~`{w���fYd?_a`{zÓhu_n`{w�zÄ`{w��Lhuin`¯huw�_jdUâ�k�`cbÃk

hYiaf5è|fYdad�d?few�d?`{_a`|��fÄ_a\�v�`cdad?`{w�z�b�\Nw�_a\Noàijd���ßD��p�`cbehuè|è{��b�\LwI_n\No�iýdgfezLv�few�_jd�huiaf5v�`¯dndg`|w�z��Io�f_n\A�Ux�fYhu_no�iaf �É�Iin\Np'\Lo�_ �|qI\�beb�è{o�d?`{\Nw~x�in\Nv \L_ak�fei�\N^�å?f¨b�_jd�q�huw,�'dgftè x�ä�\�beb�è{o,dg`{\Lw½�UßÁkàfeiaf�huinf�hw�o�v5^�fei�\Yx�huè|_afeinw�hu_n`{��f v�fe_nk�\���dýx�\LiÄfe�I_nijhLb�_a`|w�z�hJ. w�f�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�_jdmx�ia\Lv _ak�f5infev hu`{wà`{w�zd?�Iv�v�fe_ain� d?fe_Rb�o�in��fÁp�\Nin_a`{\Lw�d��:�=w�p�huin_a`cb�o�è¯hYieq�d?fev�`{äÐ�I`��ÌfeinfewI_n`¯hYè�b�o�ia��f�`|wI�LhYia`¯hYwI_æd�ë� Lîuð���\wà\N_�iafJ��o�`|iafÄd?o�bjk�h ia`cbÃk�b�o�ia��f�zNfe\Lv�ft_aia� hNd�_ak,hu_�iafJ��o�`|iafY� x�\Ni�h5bthuw�\Lw�`¯behYèPx�ijhYv�f�q�d?`{w�b�fx�ftâÁfeiR`{w ��f¨b�_a`|\Nw�d�hYiafÄw�fefY��fY�P�

� B�9 � �� � 6���!+6 � 6 � C�?ßÁkàf�hYo�_ak�\Lijd�huinfm��ftia�ÄzNiæhu_af�x�o�è�x�\NiR�I`¯dnb�o�dndg`{\Lw�dUâ�`{_nk��±fe_aftiÁl�`{^�è|`{w½qNâ�kà\¢v hN��f�hýw�o�v5^�fei\Yx�`{v�p�ia\Y��fev�few�_jdÁ_n\�huw�fYhYiaè{`|feiÄ�Iiæh¨x�_�\ux�_nk�`¯d�p�hYp�feieqÀhuw���hYè¯d?\'_a\=�Á`|è{è:�Áino�b�f�q,I�w��Iiaftâ�Áèchuã�f�q�[�\N^�fein_a\�ÿ�`{p�\Nè|è¯h hYw��'�N\�f��'o�w,�I����é±`|w�huw�b�`¯huèrdgo�pàpÍ\Lia_�â�hLdÁp�ia\Y��`¯�IfY��^I��_ak�f��¢}I�`{iRé�\Nijb�f �G.�b�f�\YxÁ}�b�`{few�_a` Ìb�[�fYdgfYhYijbjk�zLijhYwI_Rw�\�� I�é¾�Ä}�[�äÐîI��äF�N�LïI�LqPy��Á}�[mÿ�q�yÁ}���[ �?ß�Uin\Nå?fYb�_�ï ��H� � � � �:I �|qNhYw�� _nk�f��mw�`|��feijd?`{_?�5\uxR����x�\Lij�P�

� (��H(ÄÙ ( Ö�Ý ( �ë ��ð �Á`|wIx�\Niæ��ß�� ���{q � �=wIx�feinia`{wàz }�oàigxÐhNb�fYdmx�ia\Nv �=v~hYzNfYd��{� ��øÃ÷Ðú Róeú¯ù!����õ�÷gû)� �Éú Iû�õàó�û qD��\Lè=�F�uìÓqpàp½�) � �&% ��àqD�tî���N�ë� Yð �Á`|wIx�\Niæ� ß��É����huw�� Pfe��`{_n_'ß��É}��{q����o�hNd?`{äF�=wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_æd��%ßÁk�fe\Lia�ZhYw�� yU��p�è¯hYw�hu_n`{\Lw��{�� ønôuó9� ��ù�ø���ù ���� q�p�p½�����eî&% �� LîIq��eîLîN�I�

�eî

Page 20: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

ë �Yð �Áè|o�v�ò��{q�� �Á`{\Lè{\LzN`¯bthuèP}�k,hup�f�hYw�� ��`¯d?o�huè½}�b�`|few�b�f�ê=�UhYia_ �añ(�|��� ��÷ ��ûnô�ø�� �]ú¯ô!��� qI��\Lè=�L���qpàp½�) � �&% ���ìÓqD�tî�ì¨�I�ë �Lð �ÁiæhN�I� ���Ìhuw��=I�dahL��h~ò �|q �{}�v�\�\N_nk�fY� P\�behuèÁ}Ó�Iv�v�ft_aia`|fYdÁhYw��'_akàfe`{i �=v�p�è{fev�few�_jhYä_n`{\Lw��{� � ��û �ÃõI÷gûÃø�õ�ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ù!� � ô���ø�õ�ù!�½ô���]ô � ôN÷=ú¯ójö���ûaöYûnù�ønó�� qI��\Lè=�à�Iq�w�\à�P��q�p�p½���Nï %�ï��Nq�tî� ���

ë��Yð �Áino�b�f���� � �|qIl�`{^�è|`{w �±�í����hYw�� l�`{^�d?\Nw'ÿ��Él��{q��{}���v�v�fe_nia��dgft_jd �|q � ønôYó#�Ìô���]ôH�Nù!� �Íôuó9�ô� � ü�ú¯õ � ��ø� � q½�/�I��I q½�eïL�uän�/�LïIq��eî����I�

ë ïYð �Áino�b�f���� � �Rhuw,� l�`{^�è|`{w �±�í��� ����ø.�uûaö ù�õ�ü �Ìú¯õ! ����Éù�ø�ú{÷=úÆûnö �ýÿRhYv5^�ia`c�IzNf��mwà`{��feiædg`{_?��UinfYdad�qP}�fYb�\Lw��'y��I`|_a`{\Lw½qP�tîNî I�ë ìtð �Áoàiaw�d���� ���{q ��fe`¯dndÁ[Ä� }��àhuw���[�`¯d?fev~hYw~y�� ���{q��ÉßÁk�f Km\Nw�ä�fe��`¯d?_afew�b�fm\YxÁl�few�ftijhuè|ä=bthNdgf

��`{feâ�äF�=wI�Lhuin`¯hYwI_æd �{� �=w�ëÉ�/�Yð=�ë �Yð0ÿRhYw�w��5���{q�� Iÿ�\Lv�p�oà_jhu_n`{\Lw�huè�I�p�p�ia\ÓhNbjk5_a\�y��IzNf�smft_afYb�_n`{\Lw��{� � � � � �àøaù�õ�ö9� � ��� � q��\Lè=� �Iq�w�\���ï�q�p�p½��ï�ì¨î&%�ïNî��q��eî�LïI�ë îYð0ÿ�è|fev�few�dFs �íß��YhYw��5��hNb�\L^�dUs � � �{q�� �'\��Ifeè�lmin\No�p �=w���fe�I`|w�zÁx�\Ni¾[]fYb�\NzNwà`{_a`|\Nw��|� � � � �

�àøaù�õ�ö9� � ��� � q���\Nè=�Ì�e��qÍw�\à�½�/��q�p�p½�½�/����ì %��/���Nì�q��eîLîI�L�ëÉ�/�Yð s�o���h�[Ä� ����huw,�ò�hYia_ �±�íy�� � ùN÷�÷gû�ø�õ � �Éùuöjötú RójùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ ù�õ�ü �Ìó�û�õÍû ��õ�ù!� �eötú ö � � `|è{fe��q�tî�ì¨�I�ëÉ�N��ð é�\Lijdg��_ak s � I��{q �'oàw��I����� U�{q���`cdad?feiav huw½q�I���huw,�'[�\N_ak�âÁftè{è±ÿ�� I �{q)�É[�fYb�\LzNw�`cdg`{wàz5ia\Nä

_æhu_n`{\Nw,huè{è|� d?�Iv�v�ft_aia`cb�dgo�i?xÐhNb�fYd5x�ia\Nv _ak�ft`{i�\No�_nè{`{wàfYd �|� � øaôYó#� � � � �½q ,K¢ÿ�} �����q}Óp�ia`|w�zNfeinä ��feinè¯hYz�q½�eîLî� ��ëÉ� Yð0l�`|^�è{`|w�F�í���Àhuw�� �ÁijhNdndgfe_n_~}�� I��{q�� P\�behYè¢}Ó�Iv�v�ft_aia��\Yx��Uè¯hYw�f�ÿ�o�ia��fYd��{� � ��û�ø�ú¯ójù�õ

� ùN÷ ��û �5ùN÷=ú¯ójù!�� ô�õI÷ � � � q���\NèÐ��î Iq�w�\��½���Iq�p�p½��ï�Lî&%àì ��ìÓqU�eî������ëÉ�e�Yð�ÄhYw�hN�If ß��{q � []fYb�\u��ftia�5\uxDßÁk�iafef�sm`|v�ftw�dg`|\Nw�hYèU}�k�hup�f5\Yx�hYw;��^�å?fYb�_Áx�in\Nv�h~}�`{wàzNè{f

��`{feâ �|� ��øj÷=ú Rótú¯ù!� ��õI÷?û)��� ú Iû�õ�óeû qP��\Lè=�½�uìÓq�w�\�d��±��%���qÍp�pr�A�H�Nî %H�Óï�IqÀ�eî���N�ëÉ���Lð ½hYv~�àhuw �5�|qD}�bjkIâ�huin_aþ����íß���hYw�� ��\NèÉxÐdg\Nw ò �í���|q �|�m^�å?f¨b�_5[�fYb�\LzNw�`|_a`{\Lw^�� I2. w�f

�=w��Lhuia`chuw�_ ��hu_æbÃk�`|w�z��|� � øaôYó#� � � � � q�p�p½���L��� %�� ����qU�tî���I�ëÉ� �Yð P`|o~���É}��{q �'o�w��I� ��� U�{qÓé,\Lijd?�I_nk~s � I �{q���`¯dndgfeinv~hYw I ��hYw���[�\N_nkIâRfeè{èÌÿ�� I �|q � y .Øb�`|fewI_

[�fYb�\LzNw�`|_a`|\NwZ\ux�[�\N_æhu_n`{\Nw,huè{è|�2}���v�v�fe_ain`¯b�}�o�igxÐhLb�fYd�huw,�+}�_aiæhu`|zNk�_'ò�\Nv�\NzNftw�fe\No,dl�fewàfeijhYè{`{þtfY� ÿ���è{`{w,�Ifeijd��{q � ønôYó#� � � � � qÌ�eîLîN�I�

ëÉ�eïYð �'\ÓdgfYd�� �±hYw����mè|è{v huw%}��{q � P`|v�`|_jhu_n`{\Lw�d�\ux Km\Lw �'\���feè{äF��hNd?fY��[�fYb�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Lw�}��àdgä_nfev d �{� � øaôYó#� � � � �½q ,K¢ÿ�} ����qÑ}Óp�ia`|w�zNfeinä ��feinè¯hYz�qP�tîNî I�

ëÉ�uìtð �'oàãIk�ftiÆå?fef s �í�F�{q���`¯dad?feiav huw I��5huw�� �ÁijhL�I����� ���{q �{}�k,hup�fx�ia\Lv dg��v�v�fe_nia�H���fe_afYb�_a`{wàz�huw,� ft�Ip�è|\N`|_a`{wàz'd?�Iv�v�fe_ain�;`|w%hJ. w�f~`|v~hYzNfYd��{�FßÑ\�hYp�p�fYhuitq � øaôYó#���]ôH�Nù!��Íôuó9� q½�eîNî ���

Page 21: University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/...h ^ b éF`{zNoàiaf% ù ÀõüIû ø Dûnù ÍûÃøæö ûnó ÷Ðú uû Ìøaô Yûnó ÷Ðú¯ô õ ÷ / û {û ú 5ù Iû ô ÷ Éú¯õÍû

ëÉ�/�Yð �'oàw��I�%��� U�Uhuw,� ��`¯dndgfeinv~hYw I � �±�{q � ûnôH��ûj÷Ðø�ú¯ó ��õ��tù�ø�ú¯ù�õ�ó�ûØú¯õ ��ôH� � ��÷gûÃø � ú ötú¯ô�õ �� �?ßZ�UiafYdnd�q½�eîLî� ��

ëÉ�eîYð K�huè{â�h � �{q � P`|w�f5��ijheâ�`{w�z�`{w�_aftiap�infe_jhY_a`{\Lw,� �Á`{è¯hY_afeiæhuèrdg��v�v�fe_ain� � � � � � � ��� � q���\Nè�L�NqF�/��q½�N�N�Yìeän�N� ��q��eî��NîI�ë �Yð �F\Nw�b�f ���{q � �9w��Lhuin`¯huw�_�p�in\Np�feia_n`{fYd�\ux�d?_aijhY`{zLkI_�k�\Nv�\NzLfew�fe\Lo�dmzLfew�feiæhuè{`|þefY��b���è{`|w��Ifeiæd �{�� � � � � ��� � qI��\Lè=�½�N�Lq�w�\���î�qÍpàp½��î���� %�îLï���qU�eî��NîI�

ë I��ð �F\Nw�b�f����|q �|��wZbÃk�hYijhLb�_afein`{þe`|w�z�ia`{^à^Í\Lw�d~hYw�� ,w��I`{wàz%dgã�feâRfY�d?�Iv�v�fe_ain`{fYd��{� � øaôYó#��]ô � ôN÷=ú¯ójö�ù�õ�ü � ��÷ÐôH�5ùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ q���\NèÐ�P�NqA�Óîuä � �àqU�eî��NîI�

ë � Yð �Uiæhu_a_ �5�|q+�És�`{iaf¨b�_ PfYhLdg_näg} ��o�hYiafYdFé±`{_n_a`|w�z�\ux I�è{zNft^�ijhY`¯bD}�oàigxÐhNb�fYd �|� ��ôH� � ��÷gû�ø � øaù ��� ú¯ójö q���\Nè=�) ��Nq�w�\à�A��q�p�p½�½�����&%,� ���NqU�tî��ìÓ�

ë N�Yð [�\N_nkIâRfeè{è�ÿ�� I��{q ��`¯dndgfeinv~hYw�I �|qYé�\Nijd?�I_nk�s � I��Yhuw�� �'o�w,�I�5��� U�{q��{ÿRhuwà\Nw�`cbehuèàé�ijhuv�fYdx�\Li��Uè¯hYw�hui���^�å?fYb�_F[�fYb�\NzLw�`{_n`{\Lw��{� � øaôYó#� � � � �½q ,K¢ÿ�} ����Iq�}�p�in`{w�zLfeiaä ��feiaèchuz�q��eîLî� ��

ë �Lð [�\N_nkIâRfeè{è�ÿ�� I �{q���`¯dndgfeinv~hYw I �|q±é�\Lijdg��_ak�s � I �Fhuw�� �'o�w,�I����� U�{q��É�Uèchuw�hYi~�m^�å?f¨b�_[�fYb�\LzNw�`|_a`|\Nw�o�dg`|w�z �¾in\Nå?fYb�_n`{��fÄ}�k�hYpÍf []ftp�iafYd?few�_jhu_n`{\Lw��{�àßÑ\ hup�p�fYhYieq � � � �½q½�eîLî ���

ë ��Yð [��àb�ia\Yx�_Ä���íy�� � � ûnôH��ûæ÷=ø�ú¯ójù!� ��õ��Yûaö�÷=ú ÓùN÷=ú¯ô�õ%ú¯õI÷Ðô ÷/��û � ønô�Yûnó�÷=ú¯ô�õ�ö�ô��� ��ø5�tù�ó�ûaö0ù�õ�ü� ��ù�ó�û ����ø.�uûaö q��Uk½��s ��ßÁk�f¨dg`¯d�q��mw�`|��feijd?`{_?�5\ux�P`{��feinp�\�\Nè=q½�tîNî I�

ë NïYð0}�b�\N_n_Dl�� U�|qYßÑoàiaw�feiU},�NhYw�� ��`cdadgftiav huw�I �{q�É��d?`{w�z�h �'`{��fY� �Bhe��f � s�`��Ìo�dg`|\Nw �¾in\�b�fYdnd_n\�y¾è|`¯b�`|_m_nk�f~}���v�v�fe_nia��}�fe_ �{� ���5ù� Iû�ù�õàü � ú ötú¯ô�õ ��ôH� � ��÷Ðú¯õ! q½��\NèÐ�ÑìÓqÑpàp½�½ïN� %�ìJ�Iq�tî�LîI�

ë �ìtð0}Óp�ia`|w�zNfei�ÿ�� y��{q!� ûnôH��ûj÷Ðø��5ù�õ�ü ��õ�ù!� �¨ötú ö ô� � øaô�Yûnó�÷Ðú��uû ���àù�ó�ûaö �àé�iafefev huwrqP�eîLï �à�ë �Yð ��è{o�p�`|w�huiFéR�{q��É�Ffeijb�ftp�_a`|\NwÄ\uxÌ�Yä=s }Ók�hup�fDx�in\Nv uäÐs��=v~hYzNf�\uxrÿ�\Nw�_a\Noàijd �|� � � �Z÷/��ûaötú ö)�

�Àõ�ú��uûÃøæötú{÷F�~ô���Ìô���÷ ��û�ø�õ ��ù!�Éú �tô�ø�õ�ú¯ù q½�eîLîI�L�ë NîYð �RhYw l�\�\Lè U� ���{q �'\�\Lw�d~ß��|qU�UhYoIâRfeè¯d�y]��hYw����\�dg_nfeiaè|`{w�bjã I �{q��{}Ófev�`�sm`��Ìfeinfew�_a`¯hYè

�=w��Lhuia`chuw�_jd��{�A�=wBë ���Nð=�ëÈ��Yð ��ftiaia\Lo�z ����hYw�� Kmft�NhY_a`ch [Ä�{q � ��dg`|w�zÄ`{w��Lhuia`chuw�b�fÄhuw�� ��o�hNd?`{ä�`{w��Lhuia`chuw�b�f]x�\Li�_ak�fÄd?fezNä

v�few�_jhY_a`{\Lw�hYw��'iafYb�\u��ftia�~\Yx�b�o�ia��fY�~\L^�å?fYb�_jd��{� �=w �'o�w����'��� U�{q ��`¯dndgfeinv~hYw I �{q�hYw��é�\Lijdg��_ak s � I �|qPfY�I`|_a\Lijd�q � ��� �Éú¯ójùN÷Ðú¯ô�õ�ö�ô� �Ãõ��eù�ø�ú¯ù�õ�ó�û�ú¯õ ��ôH� � ��÷gû�ø � ú ötú¯ô�õ q ,K¢ÿ�}� ���qÑ}�pàia`{wàzNfeinä ��feinè¯huzàq½�eîLî ���

I�