university of birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 q^ ª£ _zyjur jutfpqk +¤ djpqy ) + pqyfn p...

23

Upload: others

Post on 17-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

������� ������ ���������������� �������� "!$#&%(')���+*

,.-0/2143657-98;:=<>/�1 ,?-A@B<DCFEG,.H2<>/21IKJML7N�OQPQRSJUTVP$WYX[Z\W]RSL7^_P`JMOba�cMdeJUTfcgJ

hKTfdjiYJMOlkldjPnm)WYXporqeqedsT_W]dek\N�Pth$Olu7NYTfNwvxZ�yfNYRSL7NYdjz]T{g|_}_~��f����|�|F�7~��f�7�6�_���p���>���>���r�F�Y�

���6�����4�6�S�����Y�����

� �V¡9¢�£7¤w¥4¦]§�Pnm�L>J¨k`m�k`P`JURSkM©fªbqjzYW]q«vnqede¬YJ�qeNYT_z]^fN�zYJUkM©AdeTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJY©AafZ\o�©_Pnm�LDJ®deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ

Page 2: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

����������� ������������������������ �"!$#&%�')(�*+���-,

,.-0/2143657-98;:=<>/�1 ,?-A@B<DCFEG,.H2<>/21IKJML7N�OQPQRSJUTVP$WYX[Z\W]RSL7^_P`JMOba�cMdeJUTfcgJ

hKTfdjiYJMOlkldjPnm)WYXporqeqedsT_W]dek\N�Pth$Olu7NYTfNwvxZ�yfNYRSL7NYdjz]T{g|_}_~��f����|�|F�7~��f�7�6�_���p���>���>���r�F�Y�

. cgP`WYu>JMO0/�©1/�23254607�8:9�;=<5>?9

@3ACBCDFE?GHDJIKGMLONPBPDJQRNPSPN?TVUWBCDRX:QYTZX:QRX:BVG[X]\_^�` acb�d e�X�AVf=gch5iVEPj�SkNPB5lnmoX�X:B�jYDRprq3IsX:q EPjtEnmVEPjYIKj�TZN?QtIsBCDRX�QRTZX�QJX�BrG[X[uTZQJX�X]v5QJN?lPQJE?wxwxIsB5l5y�z IkDRi{G[SsX:E?B5X�Q�QJX:E?jRN?BVIkBVl+v5QRNPvrX:QYDJIsX:j�E�BVq{jYX:w|E�BCDRIKG:j�DRirE�B�DRQFE?q3IkDRIsNPBVE�S5IswxvoX�QFE=DJIk}PXSKE?B5l?pVE?l?Xcj[~��Mi5IKj�vVE?vrX:Q|w|E��PX:j|^�` aHu�mVEPjYXcq�SKE?B5l?pVE?l?Xcj wxNPQRX{v5QFE?GHDJIKG�E�SMm�A�IsBCDRQJN3q3pVG�IkBVl�E�QJX�}�IKjYXcq}PX�QFjYIsNPBxN�T��npVE�B5l�E�BVq�e X:qVq3Ao� jOD�A�vrX�QJX:G[NPBVjYDRQJpVGHDJIkNPB|jYA3jYDRX:w�d �nen�?�=h�z IkDRi|D�zON�jYIsl?BVI��oG�E�BCD1Iswxv5QJN=}?X�uwxX:BCDJj�~���IsQFj�D:y5zOX]X�SsIswxIsBVE=DJX DRiVX+B5X�Xcq|TZNPQ X[�3v5SsIKG[IkD�G�NCX:QJG�IsN?B0NPvrX:QJE�DRNPQJjOIsB0DJX�QJw|j[~���SkDJi5N?p5lPi|DJi5IKj G�E�BSsXcE?q{DRN0wxN?QJX�G[N?wxvVSkX��0v5QJIsBVG[IsvVE?S�D�ACvVIkBVlPj�yrz�X�IsBPDJQRN3q3prG[X�jRN?wxX+wxIsB5N?Q QJX:jYDRQJIKGHDJIkNPBVjMN?B�DJi5X IsB3TZX:QRX:BVG[XjRA3j�DJX�w�DRN��?X�X:v{DRi5X D�ACvVIkBVlPj w|E?BVE�lPX:E�mVSkX?~�@�XcG[N?Brq�yoz�X G�N?BVjRIKq3X�Q�EPq5q3IsB5lxSsX[DRu_moN?p5Brq�voN?SsA�wxN?QJv5i5IKjRw�~@3pVGFi�E�wxN3q3Ik�rG�E�DRIsN?B]E�v5voX:E?QJj�DRN�moXOB5NPBCDRQJIk}�IKE�S_~o��X�v5QJN?voNPjRXOE�B5X�z�E?v5v5QJNPEPGFi+z i5IKGFi E?q5q5QRXcjRjRX:j�IsjJjRp5X:jN?T�moN�DJi�vrNPSkA�wxNPQRv5iVIsjRw�E�BVq�IsBPDJX�QRTZX�QJX�BVG�X�G�N?BCDRQJN?S_~�@�N?wxX�X[�5E�wxvVSkXcjOjRi5N=z�DRi5X+p3DJIsSkIkD�A�N�T�N?p5Q�jRA3j�DJX�w�~^�` a�G:E�B�mrX+E?qVE�v3DJX:qxDJNxE z IKq3X�}�E?QRIsX�D�A�N?T�SKE�BVl?pVE?l?X:j�yPE?BVq0NPp5QODRX:GFiVB5IK�PpVX:jMjYiVN?p5SKqxmoX+E�v5v5SsIKG�E?m5SsXMDRNE?B�A0jYprGFi�SKE�BVl?pVE?l?Xnz IkDJi$^�` a[u�mVE?jRX:q0IkBCDJX�QRTZX�QJX�BVG�X�G�N?BCDRQJN?S_~

  %��������|¡¢����������

. T_J=WYX\PQyfJ=RSNYdeT�c yfNYqeqjJUTfzYJUk¨deT OQJUNYkQW]TfdeT_z�N�u>W]^_P®deRL>JMOlN�PQdjiYJ�LfOQWYzYO NYRSk¨dek0£_JUNYqedeT_z¥¤$djPQy�deTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJY©¤�yfdscly�W�cMcM^_OlkO¤�y_JUT®PQy_J�J�¦�JUcM^_PQdeW]T®WYX7W]T_J2LfOlWYzYOlNYR L7y_OlNYk`J�NC§DJUcgPQk�PQy_J\W]^_PQcgW]RJ\WYX7NYT_WYPQyfJMO�¨4orTFP`JMOQX­JMOlJUTfcgJcMNYT N�LfL>JUN�O=deT R=NYTVm X¯WYOlRSkM©�NYqeq�WYXx¤$yfdecly deTVi�NYqedZ£7N�P`J P`OlN3£fdjPQdjW]T7NYq�OQJUNYk`W]TfdsT_z�P`JUcly7TfdZ©�^_JUk=¨ o�P)LDW]kQJUk=NL7N�OQPQdscM^fqeN�O clyfNYqeqeJUT_zYJ X¯WYO L7N�OlNYqsqjJUq�k`m�k`P`JURSkU©$kQdeT7cgJ PQy_J cgW]TfcM^fOQOQJUTFPBJ�¦�JUcM^_PQdjW]T WYX deTVP`JMOlX­JMOldsT_z?LfOlWYzYOlNYRL7y_O NYk`JUk¢¤\W]^fqZ£�m�djJUqZ£ deTª£_JMP`JMOlR=deTfN�P`J�OQJUkl^fqjPQk=¨&«2iYJUT¬¤�WYO k`JY©tdjP=cMNYT&u>J�©�^fdjP`J�£fdK­)cM^fqjP�X¯WYO)u>WYPQy ^7k`JMOlkNYTª£�R=NYclyfdeTfJUk�P`W�£_JMP`JUcgP deTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJ3¨¢®fWYO J�¦�NYRLAqjJY©0L7N�OlNYqsqjJUqedK¯UdeTfzBcgW]RLAdeqjJMOlkKWYX¯P`JUT?deRSL7qjJURJUTFP�RSNYTVmcgW]RL7qeJ�¦ k`PQN�PQdsc�NYTfNYqjm�k`JUk�P`W)£fJMP`JUcgP�PQy_J�L>W]kQkldju7deqedePnm�WYX[deTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJ3¨

° yfJ2J�¦_NYRL7qjJ\LfOQWYzYOlNYR deT0®�dez]^_OQJ�/�± N3£_WYLfP`J�£�X¯OQW]R³² ´�JMmª4�µC¶_· deqeqe^fkQP`OlN�P`JUk k`W]RSJ�WYXfPQyfJ�LfOlWYu7qjJURSk=¨�± ° y_JLfOQWYzYO NYR"k`m�TFPQNC¦?dek¨T_JUN�O qjm PQy_J)kQNYRSJ)NYk®PQyfN�P®WYX�¸�¹�º=»�©�NYk{£fdeklcM^fkQk`J�£�dsT.a�JUcgPQdjW]T½¼o¨�· ° y_J=LfOQW�cgJ�£f^_OQJ¾ ~�¿ N�LfL7qedeJUk�djPQk�N�OQz]^fRSJUTVP+À P`W�JUNYc y?JUqjJURSJUTVP�WYX�N�qsdeT_¬YJ�£ qedekQP�WYX�dsTVP`JMzYJMOlk ��~VÁ_~ ¨¢Â�OQW�cgJ�£f^_OQJ$à �_�VÄF~_� ¾OQJURW6iYJUk�N¨T_W�£_J$X­OQW]R ��~VÁ_~ NYT�£)deT7k`JMOQPQk2deP�deTFP`W�Årà ��� ©FN¨qsdek`P�WYX9X¯OQJMJKT_Wo£fJUk=¨M®fWYO\kldeRL7qedscMdjPnmY©5¤\JbOQJMLfOQJUk`JUTFPqedekQP$T_W�£_JUkb^fkQdeT_zBN�OQOlN�m�k ¿ à �VÆ NYTª£ �f�rÇrÁ ©�¤�yfdec y cgW]TFPQNYdeT PQy_J�deTª£7decgJUk�WYX2PQy_J�LfOQJMi�djW]^fk�NYT�£ TfJ�¦�PKT_W�£_JUk=¨° y_J�z]qeWYu7NYq9i�N�OldeN�u7qjJUk ��~VÁ�~ NYTª£�Årà ��� k`P`WYOlJ�PQy_J�deTª£7decgJUk�WYX4PQyfJxÈ7Olk`PtTfWo£_JUk�WYX�PQy_JUdeOtqedek`PQk=¨

° yfJtcMNYqeq�± ¾ ~�¿ à �_�VÄF~_� ¾ £fN�PQNr·pRSN�m�N�L7LDJUN�O2P`W�u>JtN�OQJUNYk`W]TfN�uAqjJ+¤\N�m�P`W�£_JUqjJMP`JtNYqsq_JUqjJURJUTFPQk[WYX Ä����CÁ ¨É�^_PM©fkQdeT7cgJxà �f�5ÄF~f� ¾ RSWo£fdKÈ7JUk �f�rÇVÁ�ÊM��Ë ©FPQyfJ�k`JUcgW]Tª£�T_W�£_J�PQyfN�P ¾ ~3¿ P`OldjJUktP`WOQJUcMqeNYdeR³¤�dsqeqDuDJUqeW]T_z�P`WSqedek`P

/

Page 3: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

RSN�L����7L�¨��AdW¨ OQJUcMqeNYdeR����AdW¨��� ± d��� ·� ��4��� ��� ± LfOQJMit± d ·���� ·� ��4���L�d�� T_J�¦�P�± LfOQJMit± d ·[·$§ � TfJ�¦�P�± d ·

RSN�L�L�T_J�¦�P�± d · ���¯¦U����­¦�� £fN�PQN�§ � T_J�¦�P�± d ·��

¦�� ��� ��� ± T_J�¦�P�± d ·���� ·� �� ���LfOQJMit± T_J�¦�P�± d ·[·$§ � L7OQJMi�± d_·���¯¦U�

¦�� ���T_J�¦�P�± d ·b§ � X¯OQJMJ �X­OlJMJS§ � d

®[djz]^_OlJ¢/�§�«�¦_NYRL7qjJ�L7OQW�cgJ�£7^_OQJUk ¾ ~�¿ NYTª£¥Ã �_�VÄV~f� ¾

Årà ��� ©DT_WYP ��~VÁ�~"! ° WBJUTfkQ^_OQJ cgWYOQOQJUcgPQT_JUklkM©9PQy_J�N�OQz]^fRJUTFPQkbP`WBNBX ^fTfcgPQdjW]T kQy_W]^fqZ£ T_WYPKdeTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJ�¤�djPQy PQy_JX ^fTfcgPQdjW]T djPQkQJUqjXR¨�É�^_Pt^7T_X­WYOlPQ^fTfN�P`JUqjmBdjPtdek�T_WYP�NYqZ¤\N�m�k�WYuFi�djW]^fk+¤$y_JUT PQyfdek�cgW]Tª£7djPQdjW]T y_W]qZ£7k=¨

orT�/�254�µ�©�´$JMm�TfW]qZ£fk�LfOQWYL>W]k`J�£�a�m�TFPQNYcgPQdec®Z\W]TFP`OQW]q9WYX�orTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJY©fWYOx¸�¹�º¢² ´�JMmª4�µC¶�©ª¤�y7decly k`m�TFPQNYcgPQd«vcMNYqeqjmKOQJUkQP`OldecgPQkpN�qeNYT_z]^7N�zYJ2P`WbLfOQJMiYJUTFPp^fT�£_JUkQdjOQJ�£�dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ3¨ ° y_J2LfOldeTfcMdeL7qjJUk>WYXt¸�¹�º�kQ^_zYzYJUkQP4z]^fd £_JUqedeT_JUkX¯WYO�k`P`Ol^7cgPQ^_OldeT_z�L7OQWYzYOlNYRSk�kQW¨PQyfN�P\djP�dek2cMqeJUN�On¤�y_JMOlJ�deTFP`JMOQX­JMOlJUTfcgJ�RSdjz]yFP�W�cMcM^_OU©�RSN�¬�dsT_z�OQJUNYk`W]T7deT_z�N�u>W]^_PLfOQWYzYO NYRSk�R®^7cly JUNYkQdeJMO�¨ .$#&% JUN�OlT('*),+.-k¨SqeN�P`JMO|£_JMiYJUqeWYLDJ�£�¸�¹�º=» ² .  °�° 2 /P¶�©4NYT JUqjJMz]NYTFP�Pnm�L>JSk`m�k`P`JURNYTª£ k`JURSNYTFPQdecMkpX­WYO�¸�¹�ºC¨4orTFP`JMOQX­JMOlJUTfcgJgv�X­OlJMJ�ªbqjzYW]q�NYqek`Wbu>JUcMNYRJ�PQyfJ�X¯W]^fTª£fN�PQdeW]T�X¯WYO�´$J�£ª£_m # k WYu10rJUcgPrv�u7NYkQJ�£k`JURSNYTFPQdecMk{² ´�J�£�2 2C¶�¨

° yfJ¨P`JUcly7TfdZ©�^_JUktWYX]¸�¹�º�cMNYT u>J¨N3£fN�LfP`J�£ P`W NSi�N�OldjJMPnm�WYX�qeNYT_z]^fN�zYJUk=¨,3 J®u>JUqedjJMiYJ¨PQyfN�P$djPbcMNYT kQJMOQiYJNYk�N�X¯W]^fTª£fN�PQdjW]T)X¯WYO�PQy_Jx£_JUkQdjz]T NYTª£ k`PQ^ª£fm=WYX4RSWYOQJ�N3£_iwNYT7cgJ�£ qeNYT_z]^fN�zYJUkM©fkl^fcly NYk�PQy_W]kQJ�¤$yfdecly N3£ª£fOQJUkQkOQJMX¯JMOQJUTfcgJUk WYO�k`m�Tfc y_OQW]TfdK¯UN�PQdeW]T�¨É\^fPBX¯WYO ¸�¹�º�P`W�z]NYdeT&¤�d £_JMOBNYcMcgJML7PQNYTfcgJY©�LfOlNYcgPQdecMNYqbP�mFL>J deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJNYqjzYWYOldePQyfRSk�R ^fk`P�u>J)£fJUkQdjz]T_J�£ P`W NYqeqjW?¤ k`PQN�PQdec=Pnm�LDJUc y_JUcQ¬�deT_z WYX�LfOQWYzYOlNYRSk0¤�yfdec y�£_W�TfWYP�LfOQW6i�dZ£fJ=NYTVmJ�¦�L7qedecMdjP�P�mFL>J�deT_X¯WYOlRSN�PQdjW]T�¨ta_^fcly NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR=k�yfN�iYJ�qeW]T_z=u>JMJUT�N�iwNYdsqeN�u7qjJ�X¯WYObX¯^fT7cgPQdjW]TfNYq qsNYT_z]^fN�zYJUk�¤�djPQyk`PQN�P`J kQ^fcly�NYk5476 NYTª£ % NYk`¬YJUqeq�©_u7^_PtdeT PQy_J�N�uAk`JUTfcgJ�WYX[NYTFmBdeTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ¨cgW]TFP`OQW]qW¨

% ^fNYT_z=NYT�£¥´�J�£ª£fm¢È7OlkQPtk`PQ^ª£fdjJ�£ PQyfJ�LfOQWYu7qeJUR(WYXpP�mFL>J�OQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T�X­WYO0¸O¹�º=» ² % ´�2 2C¶�¨�É�JUcMNY^7k`JWYX PQyfJKdsTVP`JMOlNYcgPQdeW]T uDJMPR¤�JMJUT�PQy_J�Â�NYklkQdsÈAcMN�PQdjW]T NYTª£�Z�W]TVP`OlNYcgPQdeW]T Ol^fqjJUk�WYX�¸�¹�º=» ©�PQyfJMOQJ�RSNUm)J�¦�dsk`P�RSNYTVmL>W]kQkQdjuAqjJ2P�mFL>J�£_JMOldeiwN�PQdjW]T7k�X­WYO�NYTFm®P`JMO R¥¨�o�P�cMNYTu>J�kQy_WP¤�TPQyfN�P]¸�¹�º=» £_WFJUk2T_WYP�yfNUiYJ�LfOldeTfcMdeL7NYq]P�mFL7dsT_z]k=¨% ^fNYT_z®NYT�£)´$J�£ª£_m$¤\JMOQJbN�uAqjJ�P`W�deT_X¯JMO2LfO deTfcMdjL7NYq�P�mFLAdeT_z]k\deTSPQy_JUdeO�¸�¹�º=»98;k`m�kQP`JUR u�mSJ�¦�P`JUTª£fdeT_z¢¸O¹�º=»

¼

Page 4: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFPQk+¤�djPQy������������� )�� +���� )� �PQyfN�P�k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ�cgW]Tª£fdjPQdjW]T7k�^fTª£_JMO+¤�y7decly NP`JMO R dek]¤\JUqeq«v�Pnm�L>J�£�¨. ^fOn¤\WYOQ¬SdeRLfOlW�iYJUk2^fLDW]TSPQyfdek2kQm�k`P`JUR deT=PY¤\W deRSLDWYOlPQNYTVP�¤�NUm�k=¨ ®[djOlkQPM©VPQy_J � ¤w£��.£ �� NYTª£)¥4��¤6��� ���

WYL>JMOlN�P`WYOlk�N�OQJtJ�¦�L7qedecMdjP[deTSPQy_JtP`JMOlR k`m�TFPQNC¦WYX�¸O¹�º=» 8�¨ ° y_JMm�N�OQJ�^fk`J�£SX­OQJ�©�^_JUTFPQqjmY©VuA^_P�kQdeTfcgJ�PQyfJMm�kQJMOQiYJW]Tfqjm)P`WLfOQW6i�dZ£fJbP�mFL>J�deTfX­WYOlR=N�PQdjW]T9©�PQy_JMmBkly_W]^fqZ£Bu>J�RSN3£_J�deRLAqedecMdjP�X¯WYOtLfOlWYzYOlNYRSRSdeTfz cgW]TFiYJUTfdjJUTfcgJ3¨ 3 JkQy_WP¤;y_WP¤;PQy_JUk`J�cgW�JMOlcMdjW]T�P`JMOlRSktcMNYT�u>JbOlJURW�iYJ�£ X­OlW]R�PQy_J�qeNYT_z]^7N�zYJ3¨

a�JUcgW]T�£9©fPQy_JMOQJ®dektT_WSL7OQW�i�dekQdjW]T X¯WYO�L>W]qjm�RWYOQLAyfdekQR(deT ¸�¹�º=» 80¨�ª�£�£fdeT_z ÄF�5Á P`JMOlRSk$deT PQy_J % deTª£7qjJMmVv4 deqeT_JMO�k`P�m�qjJ�dsk�T_W]T�v�P`Oldji�deNYq ©Fu>JUcMNY^fk`J�Pnm�L>J|©F^7NYTVPQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T dek�cgW]RL7qsdecMN�P`J�£ uFmBPQy_J�T_JMJ�£ P`W¢£7dekQcly7N�OQzYJ�PQy_J¬�deTª£ScgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQk�deT 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVPQk�¨ ®7^_OQPQy_JMO RWYOQJY©VPQyfJ$kQ^_uAk`PQdjPQ^_PQdjW]T_v�u7NYk`J�£SN�LfL7OQW]NYcly)X¯NYdsqek�deT=PQy_J�LfOlJUk`JUTfcgJWYXtdeTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ3¨ 3 J�£7dekQcM^fkQk¨N�PQyfdjO:£�N�LfLfOQW]NYc y�¤$yfdecly?cMNYT?u>J=^fkQJ�£�P`W kl^_LfL>WYOQP�L>W]qjm�RWYOQL7yfdskQR NYqjW]T_z¤�djPQy dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�cgW]TFP`OQW]qW¨

° yfJ�T_J�¦�P4k`JUcgPQdeW]T¨WYX_PQyfdsk9L7N�L>JMO OQJMi�djJ=¤�k PQy_J2L7OldeTfcMdjLAqjJUk>WYXt¸O¹{º�NYTª£�L7OQJUk`JUTFPQk PQy_J ¸O¹{º=» P�mFL>J�k`m�k`P`JUR¥¨a�JUcgPQdjW]T��o¨Z/=deTFP`OQW�£f^fcgJUkKW]^_O®J�¦�P`JUT�£_J�£�k`m�k`P`JUR ¤$djPQy�deRLAqedecMdjPKcgWFJMO cMdjW]Tfk�NYTª£.qjJMPrv�u7NYk`J�£�LDW]qem�RWYOlL7yfdekQR�¨orT)a�JUcgPQdjW]T��_©r¤�J�W]^_PQqedeT_J�NKOQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T=NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR NYTª£Sdeqeqs^fk`P`OlN�P`J\PQy_J�k`m�k`P`JUR¤$djPQyk`JMiYJMOlNYq7J�¦�NYRLAqjJUk=¨Z\W]TfcMqs^ª£fdeT_z OQJURSN�Ol¬�ktN�OlJ�z]djiYJUT�deT�a�JUcgPQdjW]T7/o¨

����� � 5���<��Y57E! -0C]8

. ^_O�¤\WYOQ¬®dek�^fT7dZ©F^fJ2deT PQyfN�P[djP�dekpPQy_J�W]T7qjm�W]T_J�P`W�N3£ª£_OQJUklkpdsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�cgW]TFP`OQW]q ©Yu7^fP4PQy_JMOlJ�N�OlJ\WYPQyfJMO�qedeT_JUkWYX\OQJUk`JUN�Olc y ¤�yfdec y N�OQJL7N�OQPQdeNYqsqjm OQJUqeN�P`J�£�¨ orT J�§DJUcgP¨kQm�k`P`JUR=k)² 6#"xµ3µ_© °%$ 2���¶�©0P�mFL>JUk�N�OQJS^7k`J�£ P`W�k`L>JUcMdjX¯m± u7^_PKT_WYPKcgW]TVP`OlW]q ·�PQy_J kldZ£_J¨J�§>JUcgPQkKPQyfN�P�RSN�m�W�cMcM^fOKdsT�LfOlWYzYOlNYR L7y_OlNYk`JUk�¨ ° y7dek�deTfX­WYOlR=N�PQdjW]T�cMNYT NYdZ£ NcgW]RL7dsqjJMO2deT £_JMP`JMOlRSdeT7deT_z�cgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVPQk�W]TSPQyfJ$WYO�£fJMO2WYX9J�¦�JUcM^_PQdjW]T)WYX9P`JMOlRSk\deTSN®L7N�OlNYqeqjJUq7k`m�kQP`JUR ² 6p^fc�µ54?¶�¨

3�N3£fqeJMO)LfOlJUk`JUTVPQk)N?k`JMP)WYX�qedeT_JUN�OSP�mFL>J�kQm�k`P`JUR=k)NYdeRSJ�£ N�P £fJMOldji�deT_z deT_X¯WYOlRSN�PQdjW]T N�uDW]^fP=dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOkQyfN�O deT_z$dsT¨LfOlWYzYOlNYRSk]² 3�N3£�2 � ©.3�N3£�2�/�¶�¨4hKTfqedj¬YJ ¸O¹{º=»�©YPQy_J�qeNYT_z]^7N�zYJUk[cgW]TfkQdZ£_JMOlJ�£®N�OQJ\L7^_OlJUqjm�X¯^7TfcgPQdjW]TfNYqNYTª£ £_W�T_WYP{£_JUNYq�¤�dePQy�kQdZ£_J=J�§DJUcgPQk=¨ 4 ^fc y?OQJUkQJUN�Olcly yfNYk®X­W�cM^fk`J�£ W]T.J�¦�P`JUTª£fdeT_z�X¯^fT7cgPQdjW]TfNYq�qeNYTfz]^fN�zYJUk¤�djPQy�k`PQN�P`J�² 6OÂ�2 /�©ªÂ 3�2&�_©Dao´�oH2�/�©Dao´$oF254F©>Z . 2��3¶�¨�oxT PQyfJUk`J®k`m�k`P`JURSkU©fPQy_J¨k`PQN�P`J dektkQdsT_z]qjJgv�PQy_OQJUN3£fJ�£�NYTª£OQJMX¯JMOQJUTfcgJUk$cMNYTfT_WYPtJUkQcMN�L>J�PQyfJ�PQy_OQJUN3£9©_u7^fPtdeTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJ¨RSNUm k`PQdsqeqDW�cMcM^_O ¤�djPQyfdeT NPQyfOQJUN3£�¨

. ^fO0¤\WYOQ¬�deTfcgWYOQL>WYOlN�P`JUk®k`W]RJBdZ£_JUNYk®X­OQW]R PQy_J=P�mFL>JBdeT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ=NYqjzYWYO djPQyfR £fJUkQdjz]T_J�£?X­WYO�º('�¹{»�©[NYTdeRL>JMOlN�PQdeiYJ?qeNYR®ut£7N cMNYqecM^fqs^fk ² )�´�254P¶�¨"oxT;L7N�OQPQdecM^7qeN�OU©�PQy_JUdeO k`m�k`P`JUR kQ^_LfL>WYOQPQk�deRL7qedscMdjP cgWFJMOlcMdeW]T WYXP`JMOlRSk�u>JMPY¤\JMJUT kQPQN�P`JgvY£_JML>JUTª£_JUTFP NYTª£ k`PQN�P`JgvndeTª£_JML>JUTª£fJUTVP�P�mFL>JUkM©0¤�yfdec y cgWYOQOQJUk`L>W]Tª£7k�cMqjW]k`JUqjm�P`W PQy_J� ¤6£��?£" ���NYTª£�¥4��¤6��� ��� SWYL>JMOlN�P`WYOlk�WYXn¸�¹�º=»�¨

Page 5: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

, ����� !$#&%ª� ���0��� !|�0�������

3 J)dsTVP`OQW�£f^fcgJ�PQy_J)cgW]TfcgJMLfPQk®WYX ¸�¹�ºdeT PQyfJScgW]TVP`J�¦�P®WYX�NYT�ªbqjzYW]q«vnqsdj¬YJX¯^7TfcgPQdjW]TfNYq[qeNYTfz]^fN�zYJ¢¤�djPQy?k`PQN�P`JNYTª£BcMNYqeq«v�u�mVvnT7NYRJ�JMi�NYqe^fN�PQdjW]T�¨ ° y_J�P�mFL>JUk�WYX0PQy_J$qsNYT_z]^fN�zYJKN�OQJ�£7dji�d £_J�£deTFP`W®PR¤�W�qjJMiYJUqek=¨ ° y_J � + )�+ )����1' � OQJML7OQJUk`JUTFP$k`P`WYOlN�uAqjJ�i�NYqe^_JUkM©DkQ^fcly NYk � � NYTª£�£9£ �R¨��� � +� �' )����1' ��_©7z]djiYJUT u�m PQy_J¨X¯W]qeqjWP¤�deT_zSN�u7kQP`OlNYcgPk`m�TVPQNC¦>©7N�OQJ¨PQy_J�Pnm�L>JUktWYX�N�OQu7djP`OlN�Olm)P`JMOlR=kM§

�S§j§ � ������� ¤o² � ¶ � � £���� � ��������� � ���������

° y_JbL7y_O NYk`J$P�mFL>JUk � ± k`W]RJMPQdeRJUk]¤�OldjP`P`JUTB�! � ² � ¶�·�N�OQJKPQy_J$P�mFL>JUk�WYXpk`PQN�P`JgvY£_JML>JUTª£_JUTFP�J�¦�LfOlJUkQkQdjW]Tfk�¤�yfdsclym�djJUqZ£ � v�Pnm�L>J�£ i�NYqe^_JUk�¨�"�N�O deN�u7qjJUkbN�OQJ®cgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeT_J�£ k`W=PQy7N�P$W]TfqemBi�NYqe^_JUk�WYX[Pnm�L>JUk � RSN�m�u>J¨k`P`WYOQJ�£�¨ ° y_Ju7NYk`J�P�mFL>J � £���� dekbPQy_J�Pnm�L>J®WYX�iwNYqe^fJUk�PQyfN�P�RW�£fdjX¯m PQy_J�z]qjWYu7NYqpk`PQN�P`J3¨ ° m�L>J cgW]TfkQP`Ol^fcgP`WYOlk#��NYTª£$�N�OQJ¨NYk�deT Pnm�L>J�£�qeNYR®ut£7NcMNYqecM^fqe^fk�¨

a�W]RSJ¨Pnm�L7decMNYq4P`JMOlRSk$WYX2ªbqjzYW]q qsNYT_z]^fN�zYJUkKN�OQJ z]djiYJUT�u�m PQy_J®X­W]qeqeW?¤�deTfz=k`m�TVPQNC¦t¨,3 J�NYkQkQ^fRSJ&%�O NYT_zYJUkW�iYJMOKNk`JMPtWYX[cgW]TfkQPQNYTVPQk$NYTª£('2O NYT_zYJUk�W�iYJMO { /*)�¼ � §

+ §j§ � % �*,� � ,.- + � +/�0+1� �2 +/��)3+4�65 �*798 + � ��� +/� ��4���4+1�����¯¦U�:+4; � ¤6� � + � ¥4£=< �6> � ,?- + �¦�� ��� � +@�$§ � +4� �*A � r±CB�· � +/���3+4� � �4�F¢< �6> � ,?- +

° y_J uANYkQdec cgW]RSRSNYTª£7k�deTfcMqe^�£_J ¦ � � � ©�NYkQkQdjz]T7RJUTVPQk�NYTª£�iwN�O deN�u7qjJ £_JMOQJMX¯JMOQJUTfcMdsT_z�¨ ° y_J�D��FE WYL>JMOlN�P`WYOk`J�©�^_JUTfcgJUkbcgW]RSRSNYTª£7k=¨�®[deT7NYqeqjmY©"�4�V¢< ��> � ,.- + J�¦�JUcM^_P`JUkbPQy_J®cgW]RSRSNYTª£+ N�X­P`JMObu7deTª£7deT_z , P`WBN=T_J=¤�qemNYqeqjW�cMN�P`J�£ i�N�OldeN�u7qeJ�WYX4P�mFL>J ��� ¤�² � ¶R¨ ° y_J�kQcgWYL>J�WYX , dsk�PQy_J�P`JMOlRG+ ¨

° yfJ�X ^fTfcgPQdjW]TfNYq�kQdZ£_J�WYX�PQyfJ qeNYTfz]^fN�zYJ dek �_vncMNYqscM^fqe^fk=J�¦�P`JUTª£fJ�£ ¤�dePQy L7NYdjO kM©�cgW]Tª£fdjPQdjW]T7NYqekSNYTª£&PQy_JOQJUcM^_O kQdjiYJ )bvncgW]R¨u7dsTfN�P`WYO�¨ ° y_JP`JMOlR ¥p£H< ��> � ,.- + NYqeqjW?¤$k�cgW]RL7^_PQN�PQdeW]Tfk|¤�y7decly W]Tfqem RSNYT7djL7^fqeN�P`JqjW�cMNYqk`PQN�P`J P`W uDJ=JUR¨u>J�£ª£_J�£ deT.N � v�Pnm�LDJ�£ P`JMO R¥¨ ° y_JBcgW]RSRSNYTª£1+ dek¨J�¦�JUcM^fP`J�£ ¤$djPQy , u>W]^fTª£?P`W N T_J=¤i�N�OldeN�u7qjJ�WYX\Pnm�L>J ��� ¤o² � ¶Y¨ ° yfJOQJUkQ^fqjPKWYX�PQy_JP`JMOlR dek�PQy_J � v�Pnm�L>J�£�i�NYqe^_JSk`P`WYOQJ�£?deT , ^_L>W]T cgW]RLAqjJMPQdjW]TWYX�+ ¨ orT.PQy_J)OlJUcgW]RSRJUTª£_J�£ ^fkQN�zYJY©I+ kQy_W]^fqZ£.T_WYP�cMNY^fk`J NYTVmJDlkQdZ£_J)J�§DJUcgPQk3E½± c yfNYT_zYJUk�P`W T_W]T�vnqjW�cMNYqi�N�OldeN�u7qjJUk�WYPQyfJMO�PQyfNYT , ·:¨

K#��� L�M:N �

° y_J�uANYkQdec�N�LfLfOlW]NYclyWYX�¸�¹�º�dek[P`W�X¯W�cM^7k�W]TSPQy_J�X¯OQJMJ�dZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMOlkpWYXAP`JMOlR=k=¨[ª$k�N�È7Olk`P�N�LfL7OQW�¦_deRSN�PQdjW]T0©]PY¤\WP`JMOlRSk�dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJ�djX[PQy_JMm yfNUiYJSNYTFm cgW]RSRSW]T X­OQJMJdZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMOlk=¨�®fWYO�J�¦�NYRSL7qjJY©9PQy_J�P`JMOlRSk , § � A � V±COP·QP�/NYTª£R § � A � V±COP·bdeTFP`JMOQX­JMOlJ®u>JUcMNY^fk`J , dsk$X¯OQJMJdeT u>WYPQy P`JMOlRSkM©0NYTª£ PQy_JNYkQkldjz]TfRJUTFPKP`W , cMNYT WYuFi�djW]^fkQqemNC§>JUcgP�PQy_J�OlJUkQ^fqjP�WYXpPQy_J¨NYkQkQdez]TfRJUTFP�P`W�R�¨

Page 6: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

° JMOlRSk¥¤$djPQy�£fdek�0`W]deTFP kQJMPQk WYX®X¯OQJMJ?d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMOlk�¤�deqeqbT_WYP�deTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJ W]Tfqjm djX0¤\J�cMNYT z]^7N�OlNYTVP`JMJ?PQyfN�P���� )�������)�d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMOlk]£_WST_WYP�dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJ3¨[orT W]^_OtJ�¦_NYRL7qeJ�qeNYT_z]^fN�zYJY©fPQyfJ�W]Tfqjm�¤\N�m�k�P`WSu7deTª£ dZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMOlk�N�OQJi�deN � �F¢< �6> NYT�£ X¯^fT7cgPQdjW]T N�LfL7qedecMN�PQdeW]Tfk=¨ � �F¢< ��> NYqZ¤\N�m�k$cgOQJUN�P`JUk�N�X¯OQJUkQy k`P`WYO N�zYJ®qjW�cMN�PQdjW]T9©_k`WSPQyfJMOQJ�cMNYTu>J�T_WNYqedeNYkQdeTfz�¨�®7WYO�N�LfL7qedscMN�PQdjW]TfkM©�¸O¹{º�OQJ�©�^fdjOlJUk�PQy7N�P + NYTª£�� £_WT_WYPtdeTFP`JMOQX­JMOlJKdsTBNYTFm=P`JMO R ± + ��· ©k`WBPQyfN�PbPQy_J qsNYR¨u�£fNwv�u>W]^fTª£ d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMO�WYX�PQyfJ¨X ^fTfcgPQdjW]T+ cMNYTfT_WYPbu>J®NYqedeNYkQJ�£�P`W NYTVm�X­OQJMJ�dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO ktdeT+ ¨�®fWYO�J�¦_NYRL7qeJY©fdeT PQy_J�P`JMOlR

±�� ,?-3, § � A � r±CO?·?P&/.� R § � A � r± �?·.P�/?·�R

PQy_JbX¯^7TfcgPQdjW]T=NYT�£)N�OQz]^7RJUTVP�deTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJY©�NYTª£=i�N�OldeN�uAqjJUk , NYTª£ R=N�OQJKNYqedeNYkQJUkn¤�dePQyfdeTPQy_JKN�u7k`P`O NYcgPQdjW]TBuDW�£_m3¨° y7dek�u7NYkldec £_J�ÈDTfdjPQdjW]TWYX0dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJKdek2P`WFW�OQJUk`P`O decgPQdjiYJ3¨M´�JMm�T_W]qZ£fk�£_JUkQdjz]T7N�P`JUk\N kQ^_uAk`JMP2WYX9PQy_JbPnm�L>JUk

NYkQ��+� � ��� '�Pnm�L>JUk=¨ ° JMO RSk�¤�djPQy L7NYkQkQdeiYJ\P�mFL>JUk[N�OQJ�z]^fN�O NYTVP`JMJ�£STfWYPpP`W�y7NUiYJtNYTFm DlkQd £_J�J�§>JUcgPQk3E�NYT�£ cMNYT7T_WYPdeTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJ|¤�djPQy�WYPQy_JMO$LANYkQkQdjiYJ�P`JMO RSk=¨ � ®7^fOQPQy_JMOlRWYOlJY©ANYqeq9X¯OQJMJ¨d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMOlktdeT�NSL7NYkQkldjiYJ�P`JMOlR N�OQJ®kQNYd £ P`W ����� � ��+� � ��� ' - �3¨ ª X­OlJMJ�d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMO , dskbN �1+� ���� '���� ' � )�� ��' �BdeX�JUNYcly WYX\djPQkbW�cMcM^fOQOQJUTfcgJUk�dek�¤�dePQyfdeT k`W]RJL7NYkQkldjiYJ�kQ^_ufP`JMO R¥¨ . PQy_JMO�d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMOlk�N�OQJ9+ � )���� ' � � ' � )�� ��' � :¨

orT W]^_O�u7NYkQdec qeNYT_z]^7N�zYJY©0PQy_J�Pnm�L>JUk � N�OQJL7NYklkQdjiYJ3¨|®fWYO�X ^fTfcgPQdeW]T P�mFL>JUkM©?��� � ��� dekbL7NYkQkQdjiYJds§1��� dekL7NYkQkldjiYJ3¨ ° y_J$N�Olz]^fRJUTFP�P�mFL>J�����dek\deTfcgW]T7k`J�©F^fJUTVPQdeNYq�©]u>JUcMNY^fk`JKdjX>PQy_J�u>W�£_m�WYX9PQy_J$X ^fTfcgPQdeW]T=yfNYk\N�L7NYklkQdjiYJPnm�L>JY©fPQy_JUT�dePtcMNYTfT_WYP�yfN�iYJ¨NYTFm4DlkldZ£_J�J�§>JUcgPQk=¨FE

®7^7TfcgPQdjW]Tfk$N�OQJ®WYX¯P`JUT OQJMz]N�O�£_J�£ NYk�X¯OQJMJ�X¯OQW]R DlkQdZ£_J¨J�§DJUcgPQk3E djXpPQy_JMm�£_WBT_WYP$c yfNYT_zYJ z]qjWYu7NYq iwN�OldsN�u7qjJUkM©JMiYJUT djX�PQy_JMm&cMNYT cMNY^7k`J k`PQN�P`J clyfNYT_zYJUk i�deN.PQy_JUdjO N�OQz]^fRJUTFPQk=¨ ° y_J �VÁ��A���Y� X ^fTfcgPQdjW]T � % - % �3% dekBNYTJ�¦_NYRL7qjJ�WYXpPQyfdek=¨[oxPtdek�L>W]kQkQdeu7qjJbP`WSOQJMz]N�O�£�kl^fcly P`JMO RSktNYk�L7NYklkQdjiYJ�P`JMOlRSkU©fu7^_P]¤\J¨R®^7k`PtcMN�LfPQ^_OQJ�dsT PQy_JUdjOPnm�L>JUk�PQy_J=dsT_X­WYO RSN�PQdjW]T PQyfN�P�PQy_JMm £_W�TfWYP¨clyfNYTfzYJSz]qjWYu7NYq[i�N�OldeN�uAqjJUk=¨�®fWYO¨PQy7dekKL7^_OQL>W]k`JY©�¤\J=N3£ª£?N T_J=¤Pnm�L>J®cgW]TfkQP`Ol^fcgP`WYO:D ! E�¨ ° yfJ¨Pnm�L>J ! �)OQJMLfOQJUkQJUTVPQk$iwNYqs^_JUk�WYX[P�mFL>J �=PQyfN�P�£_WBT_WYP$c yfNYT_zYJ�z]qjWYu7NYq iwN�OldsN�u7qjJUk=¨° y_J�P�mFL>J�WYX � 5Á��A���]� ©�PQy_JUT9©�¤\W]^fqZ£ u>J ! ± � £�� � � � £�� ��·:¨ �

° yfJ�P�mFL>J�k`m�TVPQNC¦ WYX7W]^_O[qeNYT_z]^7N�zYJ�dsk J�¦�P`JUTª£_J�£�¤�dePQy�D ! E�©VNYT�£®LANYkQkQdjiYJ�Pnm�L>JUk�cMNYT�uDJ\X¯WYOlRSNYqeqjm|£fJ�ÈAT_J�£�¨± P�mFL>JUk:· � §j§ � ������� ¤�² � ¶ � � £���� � ��������� � �*��� ��� � ! �± L7NYklkQdjiYJ�Pnm�L>JUk:·�� §j§ � ��� � � ��� � � � ��� � ! �

3 J�X¯WYOlRSNYqedZ¯MJ�PQy_J�N�u>W�iYJtdeTFPQ^fdjPQdeW]Tfk deT)¸�¹�º=»�©3¤$y_W]k`J\Pnm�LDJ�Ol^7qjJUk4N�OlJ�kly_W?¤�T�deT�®[djz]^_OQJ+¼o¨ ° y_J�k`m�k`P`JUR¤\J�£fdekQcM^fklk4dek[kldeRSdeqeN�O4P`W�PQy_J�W]T_J�LfOQJUkQJUTVP`J�£SdsT�² .  °�° 2 /P¶�©Vu7^_PpJ�¦�P`JUTª£fJ�£$¤�djPQy PQy_J�T_J=¤�P�mFL>J�cgW]Tfk`P`Ol^7cgP`WYO

���������������! "������#$�%���'&(#*)!+%,$-��/.103254�6%�!�"07�!08+%,$�����/97+:#�2;01-���#$&=< >@?A�=�=BDCFE�GH032�B*I$JLKM >N F)A��6�OP01�=Q�RLSUTVS*W(XY98#*)!)�01�ZOP#$�[2\��#@�!�"0'O",*�!�!�/]�0=&( ���98���/#*�\��6;OP08�ASUT_^US*W"���:GH086��"#D-�2F�1` �aO�)�08�!08���b,$���/#*�c< GN0d6"e$f$JLKhg72F2F���"i

,ji*08�"08)��/9lk1Q mn91#*���Z�!)! "98��#$)N�/��,o ��!08&( �-p��#*�b,$���/#*�",*-p91#*�;]�0d�"�/08�"910*K

/

Page 7: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

ª ¦�deW]R��, §3��� , §3�

� ��� ) , §3���(+ §$� Â�NYklkQdsÈAcMN�PQdjW]T�&) , §3� ��� �(+ §$�

�&) , §3� ��� �#+ §3��� ª$cgPQdji�N�PQdjW]T� ��� ) , §3��#+ §3� �

� ��� �(+ §3�3 JUN�¬YJUTfdsT_z

� )��� ��� ) � ���#+ §3��&) , §3��) , � §3� ��� �#+ §3� � Z�W]TVP`OlNYcgPQdeW]T� ) , §3� ��� �#+³² ,� �, �k¶�§3���

� ��� �#+ §3��� � ��� � � §3������

� ��� � 2 +J)3�$5 §3��� ������ ��� �#+ §3�*�0� ���

��� 8 ± ' � /*)�¼5·� ��� � 7 8 + §3� 8

� ��� ) , §3�����(+ §3������

� ��� � � , §3��� - + §3��� � ���� � ��� ���#+ §3�*� � ��� � � ��� ��� � §3�*�

���� ��)�� � ��� �6) � ���#+V� §3���

� � �#+ §3� Â�OQW]RWYPQdjW]T� � � � ¤w£��.£ ��+ § ! �

� ��� �#+ § ! � IbJMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T� ��� � ¥p�F¤w��� ��� + §3�

®[djz]^_OQJ0¼�§ ° m�LDJ�O ^fqjJUk�X¯WYOx¸O¹{º=»

D ! E�¨ ° m�L7deT_z 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFPQk�N�OQJWYX2PQyfJ X¯WYOlR�� ��� �$+ §3��¤�yfJMOQJ + dekKNBP`JMOlR © NYT�£� dek�dePQk$P�mFL>J3¨ ° y_JcgW]TFP`J�¦�PSdek¨L7N�OQPQdjPQdeW]T_J�£.dsTVP`W PQy_J��1+� ���� '�� � '� © ¤�yfdec y?cgW]TFPQNYdeTfk L7NYkQkQdeiYJ)dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO kM©pNYT�£?PQy_J + � )���� '

� � ' � ©�¤�yfdec y RSNUm cgW]TFPQNYdeT�NYTFm ¬�dsTª£BWYX�d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMO�¨° yfJ�Â[NYkQkQdKÈAcMN�PQdjW]T Ol^fqeJ$kQN�m�k�PQy7N�P�NYqsqAX¯OQJMJ�dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO k�deTBN L7NYkQkQdeiYJbP`JMO R(W�cMcM^_O�L7NYklkQdjiYJUqjm3¨�ªbcgPQdji�N�PQdjW]T

NYqeqjWP¤�kt^fktP`W=djz]T_WYOQJ�PQyfJ�X¯NYcgP�PQyfN�P , dek�NL7NYkQkldjiYJ�dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOU©�¤�y7decly dek�T_JUcgJUkQkQN�OQm X¯WYO�N�u7k`P`O NYcgPQdeT_z , ¤�djPQy����¨ 3 JUN�¬YJUT7deT_z®NYqsqjW?¤�k�X­OQJMJ$dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk�P`W�u>JtN3£ª£fJ�£P`W¨PQy_JtcgW]TFP`J�¦�P=¨�oJ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMO2kQyfN�OldsT_z�dek�NYcly7djJMiYJ�£Si�deNZ\W]TFP`OlNYcgPQdjW]T9©�¤�yfdscly�NYqsqjW?¤�k$PY¤\W ��+� ���� '�X¯OQJMJ�dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk , NYTª£ , � P`WBu>J®kQy7N�OQJ�£�¨tªbk$NBcgW]Tfk`J�©�^_JUTfcgJY©>djPdek�L>W]kQkQdeu7qjJbX­WYOtLANYkQkQdjiYJ�X¯OQJMJ�dZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMOlk\P`W=W�cMcM^_O�deT u>WYPQy PQy_J�WYL>JMOlN�P`WYObNYTª£ WYL>JMOlNYTª£ WYX�NYT�N�L7L7qedecMN�PQdjW]T�¨

° yfJ)Ol^7qjJ1��� NYqeqjW?¤$k ^7T_OQJUk`P`OldscgP`J�£.dZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMO kQy7N�OldeT_z uDJMPR¤�JMJUT PQyfJ cgW]RSLDW]TfJUTVPQk�WYX$PQy_J L7NYdjO�¨ É�^_PX¯WYO(� �=©tPQy_J ¯MW]T_JUk�� ��)��0�*) � � ) � ��R ^fk`P NYqeqtu>J £fdek�0`W]deTFPSP`W.L7OQJMiYJUTVP deTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ uDJMPR¤�JMJUT £7dek`PQdeTfcgPdZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO k=¨\ªbTFmBP`JMO R RSN�m u>J�J�¦�LAqedecMdjPQqjm)LfOQW]RWYP`J�£ P`W)N=L7NYkQkQdeiYJ¨Pnm�L>J®^fkldeT_z$Â2OlW]RWYPQdjW]T�deX�deP�cgW]TVPQNYdsTfkT_W NYcgPQdjiYJ X­OlJMJBdZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMOlk*�[PQy�^fk � kly_W]^fqZ£ u>JBJURLfP�m3¨ ° yfJ)IKJMOQJUqedscgPQdjW]T?O ^fqjJ=dek T_JUcgJUkQklN�OQm?deT.WYO�£_JMO P`WN�LfL7qem=PQy_J�JUqsdeRSdeTfN�PQdeW]T=Ol^7qjJUk�P`W=NLfOlW]RWYP`J�£ P`JMOlR¥¨

oxP[dek�¤�WYOQPQyTfWYPQdeT_zKPQyfN�P[cM^_OQOQm�deT_z�£_W�JUk�T_WYP[y_W]qZ£�deT ¸O¹{º=»�¨�oxT�RW]kQP[X¯^fT7cgPQdjW]TfNYq�qeNYT_z]^fN�zYJUkM©V¤�J]¤\W]^fqZ£J�¦�LDJUcgP$PQyfN�PtPQy_J®N�LfL7qedecMN�PQdeW]T�± + 2 � )�� 5H·�dek�J�©�^fdji�NYqjJUTFPtP`W�± �6� Ãoà } ± +·j���]·:¨]É�^_P�djX�kQ^_ufP`JMO RSk:� NYTª£

2

Page 8: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

§ ��� § ��� ¤�² � ¶=� � � � £���� A � � § ��� ¤�² � ¶?� ������ § �£9£ �=��� ��� ��� ¤w� ��� § ! ± � � �r· � �¥p£H< ��> § ! ± ��� ¤�² � ¶?� � £�� ��· � � �4�F¢< �6> § ± ��� ¤�² � ¶.� � £�� ��· � � £�� �� § � £�� � � � £���� � � £���� � § � £�� � � � £�� � � � £�� �¦�� ��� § � £�� �

®[djz]^fOQJ ��§\Z\W]TfkQPQNYTVPQk�X¯WYO|¸�¹�º=»

�&dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJ�deT ¸�¹�º=» ©fPQy_JUT PQyfJ�X­WYOlRSJMO�N�LfL7qedscMN�PQdjW]T RSNUm u>JKPnm�L7N�u7qjJ¨JMiYJUT�¤�y_JUT PQyfJ¨qeN�P`P`JMO�dek�T_WYP=¨° y7dek�u7NYkldecSP�mFL>J k`m�kQP`JUR dsk¨JUT_W]^fz]y.P`W £_J�ÈATfJ)RSNYTFm?ªbqjzYW]q�cgW]Tfk`P`Ol^fcgPQk�NYk�cgW]Tfk`PQNYTFPQkM©2NYk�kQyfW?¤�T deT

®[djz]^_OQJ �o¨,3�djPQy deTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJ®cgW]TFP`OQW]q ©t¤�J cMNYT T_W?¤GN3£ª£ N £_JMP`JMO RSdeTfN�P`J®L7N�OlNYqeqjJUq4cgW]RL>W]kQdjPQdjW]T�WYL>JMOlN�P`WYOD � E�©�¤$yfdecly dsk�RWo£fJUqeqjJ�£ u�m)X ^fTfcgPQdjW]T N�L7L7qedecMN�PQdjW]T�¨° W�deqeqe^7k`P`OlN�P`J�¸�¹�º=» ©3¤�J�J�¦�L7qeNYdsT®y_WP¤�P`W|£_JMOldjiYJ�NbPnm�L7deTfzbX¯WYO[PQy_J ¾ ~�¿ L7OQW�cgJ�£7^_OQJ\X­OQW]R�®[djz]^fOQJx/�¨poxP[dek

kQdeRSL7qjJ�JUTfW]^_z]y P`W�P`OlNYTfkQqeN�P`JKPQy_JKJ�¦_NYRL7qjJKLfOlWYzYOlNYR�deTFP`W)¸�¹�º=» kQm�TFPQNC¦�¨�ª$T N�OQOlN�m)WYXpdeTFP`JMzYJMO�iwN�OldsN�u7qjJUkM©kQ^fc y�NYk �7�rÇVÁ ©_cMNYT�u>J�P`OQJUN�P`J�£�NYk$N�X¯^7TfcgPQdjW]T WYX�Pnm�L>J � � � ��� ¤�² � � �¶�¨

RSN�L � ¤6� � ± � ¤6£��?£" ���±��ARSN�L - �7L - �Ad -��� ± d � � ·� �� ���.¦�� ������¯¦U�BL�d �fR=N�L�L A � V± T_J�¦�P�± d ·H·[·H·

«�iYJUT PQy_W]^_z]y �f�rÇVÁ £_WFJUk\T_WYP�yfN�iYJKN L7NYklkQdjiYJbPnm�LDJY©_djP�dek�W]TfqjmS^fkQJ�£)LANYkQkQdjiYJUqjmSNYT�£BcMNYT N�LfL>JUN�O�deT)PQy_JL7NYkQkldjiYJx¯MW]T_JY§

'Q§ � � � T_J�¦�PM§ � � � ��� ¤�² � � =¶ � A � V± TfJ�¦�P?± 'F·H· § � � Â[NYkQkQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T'Q§ � � )AT_J�¦�PM§ � � � ��� ¤o² � � =¶ � � A � V± T_J�¦�P?± 'J·H· § � �

° y_JbOQJUk`P\WYX0PQy_Jx£_JMO djiwN�PQdeW]T)dek\k`P`OlNYdez]yVP`X¯WYO[¤�N�O�£�¨ Â2OlW]RWYPQdjW]T cMNYTBuDJKN�LfL7qsdjJ�£=N�X¯P`JMO����f©�u>JUcMNY^fk`J �7�VÇrÁ dekPQy_J�W]T7qjm=X¯OQJMJ�i�N�OldeN�u7qeJY©�NYT�£�djPtdek�deT PQyfJ�L7NYkQkQdeiYJx¯MW]T_J3¨

����� ,� § � � 0� � � ¤o² � � =¶ � ��7R=N�L�¨��fL1¨��7dW¨=¨=¨�§�±H± � � � � £�� ��· � � � 0� � £�� ��· ��± � � � � £���� · � � � � � £���� Â2OQW]RWYPQdeW]T�� ,� § � � 0� ��� ¤�² � � �¶ � �� ¤w£��.£ �� ±F¨=¨�¨:·�§ ! ±H±H± � � � � £���� · � � � � � £���� · � ± � � � � £�� ��· � � � 0� � £�� ��· ´�JUc

�� ,� § � � � ��� ¤�² � � =¶ � � ¤w� � ± � ¤w£��.£ 6��±F¨�¨=¨c·H· §�± � � � � £�� ��· � � � 0� � £�� �

�������³%����?�����n�� �

orT PQyfdek)k`JUcgPQdjW]T9©+¤\J cgW]T7kQdZ£_JMO)PQy_J deklkQ^_J�WYX�P�mFL>J dsT_X­JMOlJUTfcgJ�X¯WYO�¸�¹�º=» ¤�djPQy&deRL7qedscMdjP{£fJMOQJUqedecgPQdjW]T&NYTª£L>W]qjm�RWYOQL7yfdskQR¥¨ 3 J�È7Olk`P0L7OQJUk`JUTFPpNbk`W]^fTª£®NYTª£¨cgW]RSL7qjJMP`J\OQJUcgW]Tfk`P`Ol^7cgPQdjW]T®kQm�k`P`JUR ¤�yfJMOQJ�W]Tfqjm�¥p��¤6��� ��� =dek

4

Page 9: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

deRLAqedecMdjP=¨ ° y_JUT9©>J�¦�P`JUTfkQdjW]T7k�¤$yfdecly NYqeqeW?¤ � ¤w£��.£ 6��P`W u>J R=N3£_JdeRL7qedscMdjP�deT cgJMOQPQNYdeT L7qsNYcgJUk�NYTª£ LDW]qemVvRWYOQLAyfdekQR(N�OQJ0£7dekQcM^fkQkQJ�£�¨

®fWYO�cMqeN�O djPnmY©r¤�J$W]RSdjP�cgOlW]kQk�LfOlWo£f^7cgPQk�X¯OQW]R W]^_O�£fdekQcM^7kQkQdjW]T9©]kldeTfcgJtPQy_JMmSN�OlJ$T_WYP\deRSRJ�£fdsN�P`JUqjm®OlJUqjJMiwNYTFPP`W PQy_JSdeklkQ^_J WYX\deRSL7qedecMdjP�LfOQW]RWYPQdjW]T NYT�£ £_JMOQJUqedecgPQdeW]T�¨�oxP�dekKk`P`OlNYdjz]yFP`X­WYO�¤\N�O�£�P`W�N3£ª£ LfOQW�£f^fcgPQkKdeTFP`W W]^_Ok`m�k`P`JUR¥¨ ° y_J�OQJUN3£_JMO�dsk�OQJMX­JMOlOQJ�£ P`W�² % ´�2 2C¶4X­WYOtX ^_OQPQyfJMO�£_JMPQNYdeqek=¨

�#��� N���� ������� ��5_CV5������ � �n-0/

° y_J deT_L7^fP�P`W)PQy_J Pnm�L>J®deTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ®NYqjzYWYOldePQyfR dekbNSL7OQJMP`JMOlR deT�¤�y7decly�PQy_J®P�mFL>J{£_JUcMqeN�OlN�PQdjW]T7k�WYX2qsNYR¨u�£fNwvu>W]^fTª£�d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMOlk�NYT�£ ¥p�F¤w��� ��� =WYLDJMO N�PQdjW]Tfk�N�OlJ®W]RSdeP`P`J�£�¨ ° yfJ®cgW]TFP`J�¦�Prv�X¯OQJMJ�zYOlNYRSRSN�OKX¯WYO$L7OQJMP`JMOlRSkbdekNYktX¯W]qeqjWP¤�kM§

� §j§ � % ��,� � ,?- � � � � � � � � ¤w£��.£ �� �

± 3 J�^fk`J � P`W OQJMLfOQJUk`JUTFP P`JMOlRSk�deT.PQy_JBdsRL7qedecMdeP�qeNYT_z]^fN�zYJY© ¤�y7deqjJ + OlJMLfOQJUk`JUTFPQk P`JMOlRSk WYXtPQy_J J�¦�L7qedecMdjPqeNYT_z]^7N�zYJ�WYX[a�JUcgPQdjW]T�¼o¨�·

° yfJ NYqjzYWYO djPQyfR kQ^fcMcgJMJ�£fk deX�PQy_JMOQJ dek k`W]RJ ¤�NUm P`W ÈDqeq$dsT PQy_J RSdskQkQdeT_z.deT_X¯WYOlRSN�PQdjW]T&P`W WYufPQNYdeT N¤\JUqeq«v�Pnm�L>J�£¥¸�¹�º=» P`JMOlR¥¨ ° yfJ�NYqjzYWYOldjPQy7R ¤�deqsq�LfOQW�£f^fcgJtN ��������� � ��+.- )���� ������¤�yfdsclyOQJML7OQJUk`JUTFPQk�NYqeqfLDW]klkQdju7qjJ¤�NUm�ktPQyfN�PtPQyfJ¨RSdekQkldeT_z�deT_X¯WYOlRSN�PQdjW]T cMNYT u>J�ÈAqsqjJ�£ deT�¨

a�dsTfcgJ�LfOldeTfcMdeL7NYq0P�mFL7dsT_z]k�¤�deqeqpdeTFiYW]qjiYJPnm�L>J�iwN�OldsN�u7qjJUkM©�¤\JSR®^7k`P�J�¦�P`JUT�£ PQy_JPnm�L>JSk`m�TFPQNC¦ LfOQJUk`JUTFP`J�£deT PQy_J qeNYk`PSk`JUcgPQdjW]T�¨ orT N3£ª£fdjPQdeW]T9©�¤\J�¤�deqeq\OQJUkQP`OldecgPSW]^_O)N�P`P`JUTVPQdjW]T P`W )�+���� +�� � )����1' ©]¤�y_JMOQJ PQyfJ/D ! EcgW]Tfk`P`O ^fcgP`WYO$RSN�m u>J�N�LfL7qedjJ�£ N�PbRW]k`PtW]T7cgJ¨P`W)NYTFm Pnm�L>J3¨ ° yfJMOQJ¨dektTfW=qjW]kQk�WYX�J�¦�LfOQJUkQkldjiYJUT_JUkQkM©AkQdeTfcgJ�X¯WYONYTFmBLANYkQkQdjiYJ�P�mFL>J_�4©ª¤\J¨cMNYT�kQyfW?¤ PQyfN�P ! ���� �O¨\a�deTfcgJ ! �Sdsk�NL7NYkQkQdeiYJ�Pnm�LDJY©�¤�J¨y7NUiYJ ! ���� ! ! ��¨

� §j§ � !����� §j§ � ������� ¤�² � ¶ � � £���� � � � � � � ���� §j§ � � � / � '

° y_JBPnm�L>JUk � OlNYT_zYJ W�iYJMO=Pnm�LDJUk�¤$djPQy_W]^_P�NYT W]^_P`JMOlRW]k`PD ! E"cgW]Tfk`P`Ol^fcgP`WYO?¨ a�PQNYTª£fN�O:£?P�mFL>JUk � RSNUm.WYORSN�mBT_WYPtcgW]TFPQNYdeT�NYT W]^fP`JMOlRW]k`P D ! E�¨ 3 J�cgW�iYJMO�u>WYPQy cMNYk`JUk$^fTfdjX¯WYOlRSqem�dsT)PQyfJ�Pnm�LDJ�k`m�TFPQNC¦Bu�mB^7kQdeT_z PQy_JT_WYPQN�PQdjW]T !�� ©ª¤�yfJMOQJ ��� { � )�/ � dek�NYT +����� )�+ )�� ��M¨ ° y_JKPnm�L>J ! � � £_JUT_WYP`JUk !�� ©ª¤�y7deqjJ !���� £_JUT_WYP`JUk � ¨ ° mFL>Ji�N�OldeN�u7qjJUk � OlNYT_zYJ�W6iYJMO � v�Pnm�LDJ�i�N�OldeN�uAqjJUkM©o¤�yfdeqjJ +����� )�+ )����� �.+�� ��+��*- ' �©fOlNYT_zYJ�£ W6iYJMO�u�m 'l©fk`PQNYTª£ X¯WYOtPQy_J� NYTª£�/�NYTfT_WYPQN�PQdjW]Tfk�WYX�D ! E�¨

° yfJ�kQ^_u7k`JMP�WYXpL7NYkQkldjiYJ�Pnm�L>JUk5� RSNUm u>J�OQJ�£_J�ÈDT_J�£ NYktX¯W]qeqjWP¤�kM§

� §j§ � !�� ��� !�� ± �&� �t· � ! � �

µ

Page 10: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

À�± ! � � · � ± � � /���ÀO± � ·H·À�± � · � P`Ol^fJÀ�± � £���� · � X NYqek`JÀ�± � � ¤o² � ¶W· � X NYqek`JÀ�± �*� � ����· � ÀO± ����·

®[djz]^_OlJ �_§ ° y_J|£_J�ÈDTfdjPQdjW]TBWYX�À

3 J�OQJML7OQJUk`JUTFP\PQyfJ�£7dek`PQdeTfcgPQdeW]TSu>JMPY¤\JMJUT L7NYkQkQdeiYJbNYTª£ zYJUTfJMOlNYqDPnm�LDJUk�u�m=N LfOQJ�£7decMN�P`J�ÀO± �r·�PQyfN�P�dek\P`Ol^_Jds§ �dek�L7NYklkQdjiYJ3¨ ° y_J|£fJ�ÈATfdjPQdjW]TBWYX�PQy_J�L7OQJ�£fdecMN�P`J¢± WYPQy_JMO$PQyfNYT X¯WYOtPnm�L>J�i�N�OldeN�u7qjJUkc·2dsk�z]djiYJUT�deT�®[djz]^fOQJ ��¨° W0£_JMP`JMOlRSdsT_J�PQy_JtL7NYklkQdji�djPnm WYX>Pnm�LDJ�iwN�OldsN�u7qjJUkM©5¤\J�R ^fk`P�OlJUqjm®W]T)N � ����� +� � � � ���9' � )�¨ % WP¤�JMiYJMO�©�N$¸O¹�º=»P`JMOlR cMNYT�Pnm�LDJ�c y_JUcQ¬�^fT�£_JMO+£fds§>JMOQJUTVP�¬�deTª£BNYkQkQdjz]T7RJUTVPQktX­WYOtdjPQk�P�mFL>J�i�N�OldeN�u7qeJUk=¨M®fWYOtJ�¦_NYRL7qjJY©fcgW]TfkldZ£_JMOPQy_J�L7OQJMP`JMOlR

� ¤6£��?£" ���±�� , ·

®fWYObdjP�P`WSPnm�L>J¨clyfJUcQ¬D©7PQy_J�X¯OQJMJ�i�N�OldeN�u7qeJUk�� NYTª£ , R ^fk`P�u>J�^fkQJ�£ L7NYkQkQdjiYJUqemY©fk`WSJUdjPQy_JMO

/�¨tu>WYPQy�� NYT�£ , yfN�iYJ�L7NYkQkldjiYJ�Pnm�L>JUkM©fWYO

¼o¨0±�� , ·�yfNYktNSL7NYkQkQdjiYJ�P�mFL>J3¨

° yfJ\OlJUcgW]Tfk`P`Ol^fcgPQdeW]TNYqjzYWYOldjPQyfRG^fkQJUk � ����� ����� )�� +���� )� �P`W�OlJMLfOQJUk`JUTFP�PQy_J�cMqeNYkQk�WYX>NYqeq�¬�deT�£®NYkQkldjz]TfRJUTFPQk^fTª£fJMO�¤�yfdec y¨N�P`JMOlR dsk0Pnm�L7N�u7qeJ3¨ ° yfJ2cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVPQkpN�OQJ\uDW�W]qjJUNYT�L7OQJ�£fdecMN�P`JUk4z]djiYJUT®uFm�PQy_J�X­W]qsqjW?¤�dsT_ztk`m�TVPQNC¦>§

� §j§ � P`O ^_J � X¯NYqsk`J � ÀO± �r· � À�± � · � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � �

ª cgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVP�dek% + )��� �� +��*- '�djX9PQy_JMOlJ$dek�k`W]RJb¬�deT�£=NYkQkQdez]TfRJUTFP�^fTª£fJMO�¤�yfdec y=djP\cMNYTBuDJ$kQdeRL7qsdsÈ7J�£�P`W P`Ol^_J3¨3 JOQJMz]N�O�£ PR¤�W cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFPQk�NYk�J�©�^fNYq © � � � � �®deX�X­WYO�NYqsq4P�mFL>JSkQ^fu7k`PQdjPQ^_PQdeW]Tfk��©�� ± � �=·���� ± � �?·:¨�3 JX¯JMJUq9X­OlJMJ�P`W¢¤tOldeP`J � � � X­WYO � � NYTª£ � � /�X­WYO0/� � ¨

´$JMPQ^_OlTfdeTfz�P`W PQy_J N�u>W�iYJ J�¦_NYRL7qjJY©2Pnm�LDJ c y_JUcQ¬�deT_z cgW]TfkQd £_JMOlN�PQdjW]Tfk WYX{±�� , ·®kQ^_zYzYJUk`P�PQy_J X¯W]qeqjWP¤�deT_zk`PQNYTª£7N�O�£ Pnm�L>JUk�X¯WYO�� NYTª£ , §

� § ! 8 ± ! � � � !���� ·, § !�� �

° y_JUT�PQyfJ�cgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFP�^fTª£_JMOM¤�y7decly � ¤6£��?£" ���±�� , · Pnm�LDJUc y_JUcQ¬�k\deT ¸O¹�º=» dek+±kÀO± ! 8 ± ! � � � !���� ·H·��nÀO± !�� � ·H·��ÀO± ! � � · ©ª¤�y7decly kQdsRL7qedsÈAJUk2P`W�± ' � /���À�± ! � � ·H·���ÀO± ! � � ·:¨

2

Page 11: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

�bWYP`JSPQyfN�P¨deXn¤\JPnm�LDJSc y_JUcQ¬�N P`JMO R X­OlW]R PQy_Ju>WYP`P`W]R ^_L0©�¤\JScMNYTfT_WYP¨P`JUqeq�PQyfN�P�PQyfdek�cgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFP�dekT_JUcgJUkQklN�OQm�^fTVPQdsq�PQy_J � ¤6£��?£" ���WYL>JMOlN�P`WYOpdek0k`JMJUT�¨ ° yfdek9kl^_zYzYJUk`PQk4PQyfN�P�¤\J2R®^7k`P0NYkQk`W�cMdeN�P`J2¬�deTª£�cgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFPQk¤�djPQy X¯OQJMJ¨d £_JUTVPQdKÈ7JMOlk�NYk�¤\JUqeq9NYktPQyfJ�P`JMOlR¥¨

° yfJ�0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVPQk�deT W]^_O�T_J=¤ k`m�kQP`JUR ©7cMNYqeqjJ�£�������' ��' ��� '��$� � ��' �9' � )� ©7N�OQJ¨WYXpPQyfJ�X­WYOlR�§

, �6§3����² � ��� � �[¶ ) - - - ) , � §3� � ² � � � � � ¶ � � §3��²���¶

a�W]RJMPQdsRJUk$¤\J OQJMLfOQJUk`JUTFPPQy_J�NYklkQ^fRLfPQdeW]Tfk�^fkQdeT_z iYJUcgP`WYOBT_WYPQN�PQdjW]T9©�kQ^fc y NYk�, § ��¬² �� � �� ¶�©\WYO � ² �� � �� ¶¤�y_JUT�¤\J¨N�OQJ¨W]Tfqjm)dsTVP`JMOQJUkQP`J�£�deT �� NYT�£ �� ¨

3�djPQy�JUNYc y X­OQJMJ\dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO ,98 dek NYklk`W�cMdsN�P`J�£ N ��+� � � � ��+ )����� � �� )�� +���� )� 8 NYTª£®N ���� )�� + ��)����� � �� )�� +���� )� 8 ¨ ° y_JBcgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFP�� dek®cMNYqeqjJ�£?PQy_J � - ���+.- � �� )�� +���� )�¨�3 J NYqek`W OQJMX¯JMO®P`W PQy_JUk`J NYk¨PQyfJ)Â�vncgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFPM©Z�vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPM©�NYTª£ "bvncgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFP OQJUk`L>JUcgPQdjiYJUqjm3¨ ° y_J Â�vncgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVP�� 8 WYX�N X­OQJMJBdZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO , 8 deT�£fdecMN�P`JUkPQy_J cgW]Tª£fdjPQdjW]T7k�^fTª£fJMO�¤�yfdec y , 8 cMNYT�u>J¨OlJMz]N�O�£_J�£ NYk�L7NYklkQdjiYJ �>dW¨ J3¨j©AdjX[NYqeq W�cMcM^fOQOQJUTfcgJUk$WYX , 8 N�OQJ�deT k`W]RJL7NYkQkldjiYJ=kQ^_u7P`JMOlR¥¨)´$JUcMNYqeq�PQy7N�P®deT�N�¤�JUqsq«v�Pnm�L>J�£ P`JMOlR ± + ��· ©pNYqsq[X­OlJMJ=dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk¨cgW]RSRW]T�P`W+ NYTª£� kQy_W]^7qZ£ u>JSL7NYkQkldjiYJY©[k`W�PQyfN�PZ\W]TFP`OlNYcgPQdjW]T cgW]^fqZ£.yfNUiYJBu>JMJUT?N�LfL7qsdjJ�£�deT½¸�¹�º=»�¨ ° y_JBcgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFP � 8deTª£7decMN�P`JUk�PQy_J¨cgW]T�£fdjPQdjW]T�^7Tª£_JMO+¤�yfdscly�NYqeq0W�cMcM^_OlOQJUTfcgJUktWYX[PQyfJ�X­OlJMJ¨dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO ,98 cMNYT u>J�cgW]TVP`O NYcgP`J�£�¨$a�W_©¤\J)¤\W]^fqZ£ J�¦�L>JUcgP¨P`W y7NUiYJ � 8�� � 8 NYk NYT?deTFiwN�O deNYTVP=¨�®[deTfNYqeqemY© PQy_J��bvncgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVP®cgW]TVPQNYdeT7k¨cgW]Tª£fdePQdjW]TfkN�OldekldeT_z�X­OlW]R�LfOQW]RWYPQdeW]TfkM©_deRL7qsdecMdjP]£_JMOQJUqedecgPQdeW]TfkM©�NYTª£ Z�vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQktWYXpuDW]^7Tª£BiwN�OldsN�u7qjJUk=¨

ª 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVP�� � � §3� ²���¶�cMNYT u>J OlJUN3£ NYk:D ° y_J�P`JMOlR � yfNYkKP�mFL>J � ^fTª£_JMObPQy_JNYkQkQdjz]T7RJUTVP��®©0NYkqjW]T_z�NYk¨PQy_J=cgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFP���NYTª£�NYqsq�cgW]TVP`O NYcgPQdjW]T?cgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQk¨deT��(y_W]qZ£�¨$®7^_OQPQy_JMO�© NYqeq[X¯OQJMJSdZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO k ,¤�y_W]kQJL7NYkQkQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFPQk�deT�� y_W]qZ£ N�OlJL7NYkQkQdjiYJ�X¯OQJMJSdZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO k=¨FE ®7WYOlRSNYqeqjmY©4PQy_JSk`JURSNYTFPQdecMk�WYXdeT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVPQktdsk+£_J�ÈAT_J�£ NYk�X­W]qeqeW?¤�kM§

� ��� � � � £ ��� /�¨,6 JMP � u>J�NLfOQJMP`JMO R ¤�djPQyfW]^_Pt¥4��¤w��� ��� =NYTª£�Pnm�LDJ�£_JUcMqeN�OlN�PQdjW]T7k�X­WYO �_v�u>W]^fT�£ dZ£_JUT�vPQdKÈ7JMOlk=¨ ° y_JUTBN,0`^�£_zYJURJUTFP � � � � � §3��dek � �0� - � �(� ) - �� ' �����.+��*- '�djX9PQy_JMOQJ�dek\N�£_JMOldji�N�u7qjJ|¸O¹�º=» P`JMOlR� � � �#+ §3�¨kQ^fcly�PQy7N�P � dek�OlJUqeN�P`J�£P`W + uFm PQy_J�� � + *'�OQJUqeN�PQdjW]T �VPQyfN�P�dekU© � dek�WYu7PQNYdeT_J�£u�m¨JMOlNYkldeT_zP�mFL>J0£fJUcMqeN�OlN�PQdjW]Tfk�NYTª£ ¥4��¤w��� ��� SX¯OQW]RG+ ¨

¼o¨�ª 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFP � � � � � §3� �� dek�NYT ���� )�+���� '�WYX�NYT�deTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVP��, § ���² �� � �� ¶ � � §3� � ²���¶�dK§PQyfJMOQJ¨dek�NSkl^_u7k`PQdjPQ^fPQdjW]T � X­WYO�PQy_J�Pnm�L>J�iwN�O deN�u7qjJUk�deT PQyfJ�qeN�P`P`JMO$kQ^7cly PQyfN�P

± NV·BPQyfJ50Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFP�� ±��, § ���)��� § �� � � � � §3� � ·�dek�PQy_J®kQNYRSJ NYk��&) � � � §3� �� X­WYOKk`W]RJ��� NYT�£ �� � � ±�¤�yfdsclyOlJMLfOQJUk`JUTFP�¤\JUN�¬YJUTfdeT_zr· ©

/ �

Page 12: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

ª ¦�djW]R, § ! � � ² ÀO± ! � � ·��`P`Ol^_J�¶�� , § !�� � ²s±�� � ·Y¶

�� § ���² �� � �� ¶ ) , §3����² � ��� � �H¶ � � §3���¢²���¶ ����� § ���² �� � �� ¶ � � ,?- � § ! � ± ��� � ����·x²�� � � �[¶�� § ���² �� � �� ¶ � � §3���)²���¶ � � �

�� § ���² ��9� �� ¶�� � ,?- � § ! � ± �*� ������·x²���¶± , T_WYP�dsT �� ·

�, § ���² �� � �� ¶ ) �RA§ ��*��² �� ��� �� ��¶ � � �6§ !�� ± � � � !���� ·|²�� �[¶ �, § ���² �� � � �� � ¶ )��� § ����¢² ��H�.� �� �c¶�� � ��§3� � ²�� �:¶ � ��, § ���²s± �� � �� � ·���ÀO± !���� ·���± �� � �� � · �{ÀO± !���� ·Y¶ ) �RA§ �����² �� � ��ÀO± !���� ·�� �� � �0ÀO± !���� ·Y¶ )

�� § ����¢² ��=� ��ÀO± ! � � ·�� �� ����À�± ! � � ·Y¶ � � � � ��§ ! � � ²��&��� � � � ±�� � ·Y¶�, § ���² �� � �� ¶�� � § ! � � ²���¶ Â2OQW]RWYPQdeW]T

�, § ���²���� �P`Ol^_J ����� �P`O ^_J�¶�� � ¤6£��?£" �� � § ! � � ²�� � ± ��{·Y¶

®[djz]^fOQJ /�§ ° mFL>J�orT_X­JMOlJUTfcgJx´$^fqeJ

± u�· � ± ��·�NYTª£ � ± � 8 ·�N�OQJ¨P`Ol^_J�X¯WYO�NYqeq , 8 ©fNYTª£± c?·BPQyfJ¨cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVP�� ± � 8 ·�dek�P`Ol^fJ�X­WYO�NYqsq , 8 § � ± � 8 ·�deT �{¨

�o¨�ªbT�deTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ,0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVP¨dskn�.+.- � ��djX�NYqeq2djPQkKzYOQW]^fTª£ dsTfk`PQNYTfcgJUk¢±�¤$y_JMOQJ DQzYOQW]^fT�£ E RJUNYTfkx¤$djPQy T_WP�mFL>J�i�N�OldeN�uAqjJUk:·�N�OQJ¨deRSL7qedecMdjPQqem¢£_JMOldji�N�u7qjJKdeT ¸�¹�º=»�¨

ªbTdeT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�k`m�k`P`JUR X¯WYO�i�NYqedZ£�deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFPQk[dek[kQy_WP¤�TdeT{®[djz]^_OQJ,/o¨M®fWYO�� �=©FPQy_JtdZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOqedekQPQk��R�NYTª£ �� N�OQJ�£7dek�0`W]deTVP=¨ oF£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk cgW]RSRW]T.P`W u>WYPQy?yFmFL>WYPQy_JUk`JUk�N�OQJBOQJMLfOlJUk`JUTVP`J�£.u�m �, ©[u7^_P®PQy_JcgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVP\deT_X¯WYOlRSN�PQdjW]T)RSNUm¢£7ds§DJMO\deTSJUNYc y yVm�L>WYPQy_JUkQdek=¨MÉ\WFW]qeJUNYT)WYL>JMOlN�PQdeW]Tfk�W]TBcgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVP�iYJUcgP`WYOlk�cMNYTu>J|£_J�ÈAT_J�£ kQP`OlNYdjz]yFP`X­WYO[¤�N�O�£fqem3¨[o�X �� � � ��) - - - ) � � NYT�£ �� � � � �� ) - - - ) � �� ©_PQy_JUT

�� ��À�±��O· � � � ��ÀO±��O· ) - - - ) � � ��ÀO±��O·�� � �� � � � � � � �� ) - - - ) � � � � �� �� � � � � �H� � - - - � � �

ªbqek`W_©���� �P`Ol^_J�dsktNiYJUcgP`WYObWYX4P`Oldei�deNYqsqjm=kQN�PQdekHÈAN�u7qjJ�cgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVPQk�¨° yfJMOQJ=N�OQJBPY¤\W dsRL>WYOQPQNYTVP®NYk`L>JUcgPQk¨WYX�PQy_JBk`m�k`P`JUR §�deTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJ)cgW]TFP`OQW]q�NYT�£.deRSL7qedecMdjP�£_JMOQJUqsdecgPQdjW]T�¨

®fWYO deTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJUT7cgJScgW]TVP`OQW]q�© Ol^fqeJUk�ª�¦_djW]R NYTª£ � � ¤�JUN�¬YJUT?PQy_J=cgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQk�deT PQy_JSNYkQkl^fRLfPQdjW]T7k=¨ ° yfdek

/3/

Page 13: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

JUTfkQ^fOQJUk�PQyfN�PtdjX0PQyfJ�P`JMOlRSk , WYO�± � � � ��·\yfN�iYJ�L7NYkQkldjiYJKPnm�LDJUkU©_PQy_JUT PQy_JxÂ2v[NYT�£�Z�vncgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVPQk�X¯WYOtNYqeq>X¯OQJMJdZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO k�WYX�PQy_J¨P`JMOlRSk+¤�dsqeq>y_W]qZ£�¨ ° yfdsk\cgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFP�¤\JUN�¬YJUTfdeT_z=dsk�OQJ�£f^fTª£7NYTVP�X¯WYO ���)NYTª£ ��� � ¨

a�dsTfcgJ PQy_J X¯^7TfcgPQdjW]T NYTª£�N�OQz]^fRSJUTVPWYXKNYT�N�LfL7qedscMN�PQdjW]T P`JMOlR kQy_W]^7qZ£.TfWYPSdeTVP`JMOlX­JMOQJY©�PQy_J Ol^fqeJ(� �

RW�£fdsÈ7JUk$PQy_J=Z�vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQk$WYX\NYqeq�kQyfN�OQJ�£ dZ£fJUTVPQdsÈAJMOlk �, ¨ ° y_JSZ�vncgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVP�y_W]q £fk�± NYT�£?Z\W]TVP`O NYcgPQdjW]T dekL>W]kQkQdjuAqjJP·�W]Tfqjm djX �, N�OQJ)NYqsq�L7NYkQkQdjiYJ)dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk=¨ ° y_J¢Â2OlW]RWYPQdjW]T Ol^7qjJJUTfkQ^_OlJUk�PQyfN�P¨NYqeq�X­OQJMJ)dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlkWYX � W�cMcM^fO®L7NYklkQdjiYJUqjm uFm�N3£�£fdeT_z�NYqeqnÂ�vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQk¨WYX�PQy_JBNYkQkQ^fRSLfPQdjW]T�qedsk`P�P`W PQyfJ "$vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFP=¨ ° y_JOl^fqeJ0����NYqek`W�RW�£fdsÈ7JUk[PQyfJ "$vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFP=¨\a�deTfcgJ , dsk�OQJURW6iYJ�£ X­OlW]R PQy_JKNYkQkQ^fRSLfPQdjW]TfkM©FdjPQk�Z\vncgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFPcMNYTfT_WYP�uDJ�X ^_OQPQyfJMO+¤�JUN�¬YJUT_J�£�¨

´$JMz]N�O�£fdeT_z £_JMOQJUqedscgPQdjW]T9©�T_WYP`J PQyfN�P®PQyfJMOQJBdsk®T_W IKJMOQJUqedecgPQdjW]T.Ol^fqeJ)deT?PQy_JBTfJ=¤ k`m�k`P`JUR¥¨ oxP yfNYk u>JMJUTRJMOQzYJ�£½¤$djPQy?PQyfJBO ^fqjJUk ª�¦_djW]R ©�� � NYT�£ Â�OQW]RWYPQdjW]T0©�¤�yfdec y.NYqsqjW?¤�N Pnm�L>JBWYX$PQy_J X­WYO R ! � � deT PQy_JcgW]TfcMqe^7kQdjW]T ± deTfk`P`JUN3£BWYX !�� � WYO ! � � ·2P`WdeTª£fdscMN�P`JbNYT deRLAqedecMdjP�£_JMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]TBk`P`JML�¨ 3 J�T_JMJ�£ T_WYP�cgW]TfkldZ£_JMO�PQy_JL>W]kQkQdjuAdeqedjP�mWYX�£_JMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T N�X¯P`JMO�PQy_J¨WYPQy_JMO�k`P`JML7kU©fu>JUcMNY^fk`J�WYX�PQy_J�X¯W]qeqjW?¤$deT_z�LfOQWYL>JMOQP�mA§

'\� ��� ��� oxT NYTFm�¸�¹�º=» £_JMO djiwN�PQdeW]T9©AJMiYJMOlm £_JMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T k`P`JML W�cMcM^_OlkKN�X­P`JMO�JUdePQy_JMO�NYT ª�¦_djW]R ©�Â�OQW]RW�vPQdjW]T9©9WYO�JUqsdeRSdeTfN�PQdeW]T k`P`JML X¯W]qeqjWP¤�J�£ u�m�¯MJMOlW WYO¨RWYOQJk`P`Ol^7cgPQ^_OlNYqpOl^fqjJ�k`P`JML7k$± 3 JUN�¬YJUT7deT_z_©�Z�W]TVP`OlNYcgPQdeW]T9©Â[NYkQkQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T9©_WYO$ªbcgPQdji�N�PQdjW]T�·:¨ �

«n¦�NYRLAqjJUk�WYXM£_JMOldji�N�u7qjJ$± NYTª£ i�NYqedZ£�·2dsT_X­JMOlJUTfcgJ 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVPQk$N�OQJ�p§ ! 8 ± ! � � � ! � � ·�² ' � /���ÀO± ! � � ·��`P`Ol^_J=¶ ) , § ! � � ² ÀO± ! � � · ��À�± ! � � ·��`P`O ^_J=¶� � , § ! � � ² � �� ��� �� ¶

�p§ ! 8 ± ! � � � ! � � ·�² P`Ol^_J �`P`O ^_J�¶ ) , § ! � � ² P`O ^_J �`P`Ol^_J�¶� � ¤6£��?£" ���±�� , · § !�� � ²s±H± ' � / ��ÀO± !�� � ·H·���À�± !���� ·H·�� ±�� ��W·Y¶

° y_J�qeN�P`P`JMO�P�mFL7dsT_zBdsk�£_JMO djiwN�uAqjJ¨X¯OQW]R PQy_J�X­WYO RJMOKuFm�Â�OQW]RWYPQdjW]T�¨��$WYP`JPQy_J�N3£ª£fdePQdjW]TfNYqpcgW]T 0`^7TfcgP���deT PQy_J "bvncgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFPQk�WYX\PQy_JUk`J 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVPQkU©1¤�yfdscly ¤�NYk�T_WYP¨RJUTFPQdjW]T_J�£ dsT PQy_JSLfOQJMi�djW]^fk�£fdskQcM^fkQkQdeW]T WYX� ¤6£��?£" ���±�� , ·:¨ ° yfdek�cgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFPtN�Oldek`JUktX­OQW]R PQy_J�L>W]kQkQdju7dsqedjPnmWYX £_JMOlJUqedecgPQdeT_z , uDJMX¯WYOQJ � dektN�L7L7qedjJ�£�¨

° ¤\WSJ�¦_NYRL7qjJ�dsTfk`PQNYTfcgJUk�WYXpPQy_JUk`J0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVPQk�deT ¸O¹{º=» N�OQJY§�p§ ! ±H± � � 0� � £���� · � ± � � � � £�� ��·H· ��, §�± � � � � £���� ·�� � , § � � � � £�� �

�p§ ! ±H± � � 0� � £���� · � ± � � � � £�� ��·H· ) , § ! ± � � � � £���� · � � � ¤w£��.£ 6��±�� , · § ! ± � � � � £�� ��·° yfJ�OQJ�©F^7dekQdjP`JKLfOQWYL>JMOQPQdeJUk�WYX4PQy_J®deRL7qedscMdjP�£_JMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T k`m�k`P`JUR N�OlJ¨NYktX¯W]qeqjWP¤�k=¨

� � ��£7¤w� � ���c¸9£�� �4¥ �4�F¦�¦�� ªbqeq�£_JMOldeiwN�u7qeJbdeTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ�0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVPQk�N�OQJ�i�NYqedZ£�¨ �

/�¼

Page 14: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

'\� ��� ��� o�X�NYT deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVP � ² �� � �� ¶ � � §3� ²���¶�dek £_JMO djiwN�uAqjJY©fPQy_JUT)ÀO± �r· � � � � 8 yfW]qZ£fk�X¯WYONYqeq � 8 deT ��¢¨ �

'\� ��� ��� o�X�NYT deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVP � ² �� � �� ¶ � � §3� ²���¶pdek�£_JMOldji�N�u7qjJY©_PQyfJUT � 8 � � 8 X­WYOKNYqeq � 8 ) � 8 deT�� NYTª£ �� ¨ �

'\� ��� ��� o�X , §3��² � � � ¶ ) , � §3��² � � � � � ¶ ) � � + §3� � ²���¶®dek¥£_JMO djiwN�uAqjJY©KPQy_JUT , §3��² � �� � � � � � ¶ ) � �

� ² , �, � ¶�§3� � ²���¶ dsk+£_JMOldji�N�u7qjJY©�X¯WYO�k`W]RJ � vncgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVP � � � ¨ �

� � ��£7¤w� ��� �c¹ £�� � �¯� ����4��¦U¦���«2iYJMOlm 0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVP�dsRL7qedecMdePQqjm)£_JMOldeiwN�u7qeJKdsT ¸O¹{º=» dek$NYT�deT7k`PQNYTfcgJ�WYX�N£_JMOldeiwN�u7qeJKdsT_X­JMOlJUTfcgJ 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVP=¨ �

��¤w£9£ � o�X�� � � �1+ §3� NYTª£ � � +� �'=± � ) +· ©4PQy_JUT?PQy_J=cgWYOQOlJUk`L>W]Tª£fdeT_z deTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ 0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVP®dek�WYX�PQy_JX¯WYOlR � � � ������� ²���� �P`Ol^_J ����� �P`Ol^_J�¶ ) ��� � ������� ² �� ����� �P`O ^_J�¶�� � §3� ² P`Ol^_J=¶�©5¤$y_JMOQJ � � � ������� £_JUT_WYP`JUk[PQyfJ�cgW]TVP`J�¦�P�� OQJUk`P`O decgP`J�£k`WPQyfN�PtdePQk+£_W]RSNYdeT cgW]TFPQNYdeTfk�W]T7qjm=PQy_J�X¯OQJMJ�i�N�OldeN�u7qeJUk�WYX � ¨ ° y_JKLfOQW�WYX4dek�u�m)dsTª£f^fcgPQdjW]TBW]T PQy_J�yfJUdjz]yVP�WYX¸�¹�º=» £fJMOldji�N�PQdjW]T NYTª£ LfOlW�cgJMJ�£fktuFm cMNYk`J¨NYTfNYqem�kQdsk�W]T�PQy_J�qeNYkQPtk`P`JML�¨ 3 J kQy_W?¤ k`JUqjJUcgP`J�£�cMNYkQJUk=¨

� �,+� �� � ��+ )�����

� ��� ) , §3� �#+ §$� Â[NYkQkQdKÈAcMN�PQdjW]T� ) , §3� ��� �#+ §$�

É\m�deT�£f^fcgPQdjW]T�yFm�LDWYPQyfJUkQdekM©�� � � ������� ²���� �P`Ol^_J ����� �P`Ol^_J�¶ )O± � ) , §3�r· � � ������� ² �� ����� �P`O ^_J�¶ � � §$��² P`Ol^_J�¶�¨MÉ\m 6 JURSRSN �_©�� � ��� �P`Ol^_JY©ª¤$yfdecly z]deiYJUktPQy_J�cgW]TfcMqs^fkQdjW]T�¨

��� � )�� + ��)�����

° yfdek�X¯W]qeqjW?¤$k�X­OQW]R 6 JURSRSN92�NYTª£ 6 JUR=RSN /o¨

� ���

� � ��� � �:+ § ! � ± � � ! � � · � � ��� ��� � §3�� �

� ��)��0� ��� ��) � ���#+ �.§ ! � �É\m deTª£7^fcgPQdjW]T9©

� � � � ����� � � ²�����P`Ol^_J ����� �P`Ol^_J�¶ ) � � � ������� � � ² �� � �����

�P`Ol^_J�¶ � � � § !�� ± �&� !�� � ·x² P`O ^_J�¶�0� � � ����� M � ²����

�P`Ol^_J ����� �P`Ol^_J�¶ ) � � � ������� M � ² ��=�.������P`Ol^_J�¶ � � ��§3��² P`Ol^fJ�¶

/ �

Page 15: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

3 J cMNYT�£_JMO djiYJKPQy_J�X¯W]qeqjW?¤$deT_zdeT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFPtX¯OQW]R�PQy_W]k`J¨PY¤\W�¨

� � � � ����� � � ²�����P`Ol^_J ����� �P`O ^_J�¶ )� � � � ����� M � ²����

�P`Ol^_J ����� �P`Ol^_J�¶ )� � � � ����� � � ²

�� � �{ÀO± !���� ·������ �P`Ol^_J=¶ ) � � � � ����� M � ² ��H� ��À�± !���� ·�������P`O ^_J=¶

� ± � � � ��· § ! � � ² � � ¶®7OQW]R PQyfdskM©�¤�J®cMNYT zYJMP�PQy_J�cgW]T7cMqe^fkQdjW]T�¨

��� ' � '*- ����)�����

hKk`J 64JURSRSN)¼�©ANYTª£ cgW]TfkQdZ£fJMOtPQy_J�LfOQJUcgJ�£7deT_zk`P`JML�WYPQyfJMO�PQyfNYT¥Â[NYkQkldsÈAcMN�PQdjW]T�¨

��� O��� �

ª ¦�djW]R� � § ! � � � � § ! � � IbJMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T� � § ! � � � ¥p�F¤w��� ��� � § ! � �WYO ª ¦�djW]R� � § ! � � � � § ! � � Â[NYkQkQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T

� § ! � � � � � § ! � � IbJMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T� § ! � � � � ¥p�F¤w��� ��� � § ! � �

a_deTfcgJ]ÀO± ! � � · � P`Ol^_JY©�¤\J¨cMNYT�£fJMOldjiYJ � § ! � � ² P`Ol^_J �`P`Ol^_J�¶�� � § ! � � ² P`Ol^_J�¶0u�m ª ¦_djW]R¥¨

��� ' +�� ' �������

� ��� �6) � � �#+ § ! � �3 JUN�¬YJUTfdeTfz

�&)�� � ��� �6) � ��) � � � ) � � � �(+ § ! � � Â[NYkQkQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T�&)�����) � �6) � � � ��� �*) � � � �(+ § ! � � IKJMOQJUqedecgPQdjW]T

� )� � ) � � ) � � � ��� ��) � � � � ¥4��¤w��� ��� + § ! � �° y_JUT OQJMWYO�£fJMOtPQy_J�k`P`JML7k�¨

� ��� �6) � � �#+ § ! � � Â[NYkQkldsÈAcMN�PQdjW]T� ) � � ��� � �#+ § ! � � IKJMOQJUqedecgPQdeW]T

�&) � � ��� � � ¥p�F¤w��� ��� + § ! � �3 JUN�¬YJUTfdsT_z

� )� � ) � �6) � � � ��� ��) � � � � ¥p�F¤w��� ��� + § ! � �É\m deT�£f^fcgPQdjW]T yFmFL>WYPQy_JUkldekM©�PQy_J?cgW]T7k`J�©F^fJUTVP WYXPQy_J £_JMOlJUqedecgPQdjW]T k`P`JMLGdek�NYT deTfkQPQNYTfcgJ�WYXSN£fJMOldji�N�u7qjJ�deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFP=¨ ° yfdsk�z]djiYJUk�^fk�PQyfJ¨cgW]TfcMqe^fkldjW]T�¨

/ �

Page 16: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

�#� K N���� ������� ���=CV- � - � ��-0/

orT PQyfdek�k`JUcgPQdjW]T9©�¤\J�cgW]TfkQd £_JMO�PQy_J�dekQkQ^fJUk�WYX�RSN�¬�deT_z � ¤6£��?£" ���deRSL7qedecMdjP=¨ �$WYP`J¨PQyfN�P�P`WSN�LfL7qjm � ¤w£��.£ ��A©NYqeq9PQyfJ�X­OlJMJ®dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO k�R®^fkQPtu>J�L7NYkQkQdjiYJ3¨ ° yfdsk�qjJUN3£fktP`W)N=qeN�OQzYJ®TF^fR®u>JMOtWYX[cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVPQk�± k`JMJ0®[djz]^_OlJ�/5·:¨oxX � ¤w£��.£ ���WYL>JMOlN�P`WYOlk�N�OQJ=P`W u>J=qjJMX¯P®dsRL7qedecMdePM© PQy_JUT.PQy_J)dsT_X­JMOlJUTfcgJ)NYqjzYWYO djPQyfR R ^fk`P�NYcMcgW]^fTFP�X­WYO PQy_JL>W]kQkQdjuAdeqedjP�mWYX4LfOlW]RWYPQdjW]T�N�PtJMiYJMOlmBP`JMO R L>W]kQdjPQdjW]T�¨ ° yfdek�qjJUN3£fk�P`W=J�¦�cgJUkQkldjiYJUqjm qeN�OQzYJ�cgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFPQk=¨

ª LfOlNYcgPQdecMNYq�k`W]qs^_PQdjW]T dekbP`W�NYqeqjWP¤ deRL7qedscMdjPtLfOQW]RSWYPQdjW]T X­WYO�N X¯J=¤ k`JUqjJUcgP`J�£ WYL>JMOlN�P`WYO k=¨�®7WYO�J�¦�NYRSL7qjJY©¥p£H< �6> NYTª£ ¤6� � N�OlJSzYWFW�£�c y_W]decgJUk�u>JUcMNY^fkQJPQy_JMm PQN�¬YJ)N�OQz]^fRSJUTVPQk¨WYX D ! E�Pnm�LDJUk¨NYTª£9© deT L7OlNYcgPQdecgJY© PQyfJUk`JWYL>JMOlN�P`WYOlkbWYX¯P`JUT W�cMcM^_OKdeT cgW]R¨u7dsTfN�PQdjW]T�¤�djPQy � ¤w£��.£ ���¨ ° yfJ¨X¯W]qeqjW?¤$deT_zSP�mFL>J Ol^fqjJUk$NYqeqjW?¤ W]T_J P`W�¤tOldjP`J¥p£H< �6> � deTfkQP`JUN3£ WYXp¥p£H< ��> ± � ¤6£��?£" �� � ·�NYTª£ ¤w� � � dsTfk`P`JUN3£ WYX[¤6� � ± � ¤w£��.£ �� � · §

�, § ���² �� � �� ¶�� � § ! � ± ! � � � ! � � ·x²���¶ ´�JUc�, § ���²���� �P`O ^_J ����� �P`Ol^_J=¶�� ¤6� � � § ! � � ²�� � ± � � /�� ± ��{·H·�� ±�� ��·Y¶

�, § ���² ��9� �� ¶�� � § ! � ± ! � ��� ¤�² � ¶ � ! � � £�� ��·x²���¶ ¥p£H< ��>�, § ���²���� �P`Ol^_J ����� �P`Ol^fJ=¶�� ¥p£H< �6> � § ! � � ²�� � ± � � /�� ± ���·H·Y¶

° y_J uANYkQdec dZ£_JUN WYX PQy_JUk`J�O ^fqjJUk dek P`W cgW]R®u7deTfJ Â2OQW]RWYPQdeW]T ¤�djPQy�Ol^7qjJUk X­WYO�N�L7L7qjm�deT_z�¤6� � NYTª£;¥4£=< ��>OQJUk`L>JUcgPQdjiYJUqem3¨ ° y_J�cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdsTVPx± � � / ��± ��{·H·�OQJMLfOQJUkQJUTVPQk�PQyfJKdsRL7qedecMdeP�LfOQW]RWYPQdeW]T WYX � ¨ ° yfN�P�dekM©_djX � dekT_WYP�NYqeOQJUN3£_mBWYXpNL7OQW]RWYP`J�£ X ^fTfcgPQdjW]T P�mFL>JY©ª¤\J�LfOlW]RWYP`J¨djPtdeRSL7qedecMdjPQqem3¨

É\m clyfNYT_z]dsT_z PQy_J$£_J�ÈATfdjPQdeW]T�WYX � � +� *'F©9PQyfJ�kQW]^fTª£fT_JUklkbNYT�£ cgW]RL7qjJMP`JUT_JUklkKPQy_JMWYOQJURSk�dsT a�JUcgPQdjW]T �o¨Z/cMNYT�u>J�cMN�OQOldeJ�£ W�iYJMObP`WSPQyfdek�J�¦�P`JUTª£_J�£�k`m�kQP`JUR¥¨

� ��� � � � £ ��� ®fWYO�NYTFm P`JMO R + NYTª£ L7OQJMP`JMOlR � © � � + *' dek¨N�OQJUqeN�PQdeW]T�kQ^fc y�PQyfN�P � � +� *'�± � ) +·Kds§ � dekWYufPQNYdeTfJ�£ uFm JMOlNYkQdsT_z�T_WYP�W]Tfqem ¥p�F¤w��� ��� )NYTª£ Pnm�L>J)£_JUcMqeN�OlN�PQdeW]Tfk�X¯OQW]R + u7^_P�NYqek`W *' - ' � )���� ' - � JMOlNYkldeT_z� ¤6£��?£" �� ¤$y_JUT djPtdek�^fkQJ�£�deT ¥p£H< �6> ± � ¤w£��.£ ��+ � ·\WYO�¤w� � ± � ¤6£��?£" �� + � ·:¨ �

� � ��£7¤w� �����c¸9£�� �4¥ �4�F¦�¦��]¹®£�� � �­� ���� ��¦U¦���ªbqeqO£_JMOldji�N�u7qjJ�deTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFPQk$N�OlJ®i�NYqedZ£ NYTª£�JMiFvJMOQm 0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVP�deRL7qsdecMdjPQqjm £_JMOldji�N�u7qjJ=dsT ¸�¹�º=» dek NYT deTfk`PQNYTfcgJBWYX�N £_JMOldji�N�u7qjJ)deT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ 0Q^ª£_zYJURSJUTVP=¨�

ªbk�NYT J�¦_NYRL7qjJ�WYX2PQyfJ�TfJ=¤ ¤6� � Ol^fqeJY©>cgW]T7kQdZ£_JMOKJMOlNYkQdsT_z PQy_JJ�¦�LAqedecMdjP � ¤w£��.£ ���WYL>JMOlN�P`WYO�X¯OQW]R PQy_J

/�/

Page 17: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

¾ ~�¿ £_J�ÈATfdjPQdeW]T z]djiYJUT�deT�a�JUcgPQdeW]T�¼o¨Z/�¨ ° yfJ�qeNYk`Ptk`P`JML�dsT PQy_J|£_JMOldeiwN�PQdjW]T WYX�PQyfdsk�P`JMOlR N�LfL>JUN�Olk�u>JUqjWP¤�§ ;

�� ,� § ! 8 ± � � � ! � � � ¤o² � � =¶_·x² P`O ^_J �`P`Ol^_J�¶ � �7RSN�L - �7L - �Ad - - -§�±H± � � � !�� � £�� ��· � � � 0� � £���� · � ±H± � � 0� !�� � £�� ��· � � � 0� � £���� ·x² P`Ol^fJ�¶ ´�JUc

�� ,� § ! 8 ± � � � ! � ��� ¤�² � � ?¶_·�² P`Ol^_J �`P`O ^_J�¶�� ¤w� � ±��7RSN�L - - - · §�± � � � !�� � £���� ·�� � � 0� � £�� � ² P`Ol^_J�¶a�dsRSdeqeN�OlqemY©�PQy_J\X­W]qsqjW?¤�dsT_z$deTfX­JMOQJUT7cgJ 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFP�X­WYO�PQy_J�à �f�VÄV~f� ¾ X ^fTfcgPQdeW]T¨WYXª®[djz]^fOQJ�/\cMNYT�u>J�£fJMOldjiYJ�£9§

�� ,� § ! � ± � � � ! � ��� ¤�² � � =¶_·x² � � /�� � � /.�`P`Ol^_J�¶ )À�� ��� § !�� ± � � 0� ! � ��� ¤�² � � =¶_·x² � � /���À � /.�`P`Ol^fJ�¶ )��� � � § !�� ��� ¤�² � � ?¶�² � � /.�`P`Ol^_J=¶ ) �� � § !�� � � ¤o² � � =¶�² � � /.�`P`O ^_J�¶

��à �_�VÄV~f� ¾ §�± !�� � � 0� � £���� ·

�#� � ��-���� � -9C ��� �n3 �

orT 476 vnqedj¬YJ�qeNYTfz]^fN�zYJUkM©fL>W]qjm�RWYOQL7y7dekQR dsktRSN3£_J�N�iwNYdeqsN�u7qjJ�i�deN�PQy_J ÄF�5Á cgW]Tfk`P`Ol^7cgP=¨2ª P`JMOlR�WYX�PQy_J�X¯WYOlR

ÄF�5Á � � � � ��� � �

dek¨Pnm�LDJBcly_JUcl¬YJ�£ uFm�NYqeqeW?¤�deTfz � P`W PQN�¬YJBN ©�^fNYTVPQdKÈ7J�£ Pnm�L>J)kQ^7cly NYk�� �I- ��¨ oxP®cMNYT.uDJ)kQy_W?¤$T�PQyfN�P PQy_JJ�§>JUcgP WYXtkl^fcly�©F^7NYTVPQdsÈDcMN�PQdjW]T.dsk�PQy_JBkQNYRJ NYk¨OQJMz]N�O:£fdeT_z PQy_J)N�u>W�iYJ ÄF�5Á P`JMOlR NYk u>JUdeT_z�J�©�^fdji�NYqjJUTFP�P`W� �5² � � � ¶�± cgXJ¨�² 4 djP�254P¶_·:¨

hKT_X¯WYOQPQ^fTfN�P`JUqjmY©YT_JUdePQy_JMO WYXfPQyfJUk`J\kQW]qe^_PQdjW]Tfk4dek1£7djOQJUcgPQqjm�N�LfL7qsdecMN�u7qjJ[P`W�¸O¹{º=»�¨ ° y_J�Pnm�LDJ]©�^fNYTVPQdKÈAcMN�PQdjW]TdZ£_JUN Ol^7Tfk®dsTVP`W PQy_J LfOlWYu7qjJUR PQyfN�PPQy_J Pnm�L>J iwN�OldsN�u7qjJBP`W uDJ¥©�^fNYTFPQdsÈ7J�£�± � · R=djz]yVP�W�cMcM^_OSdeT PQy_J ¬�deTª£cgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVPQk�¨�®7WYO®J�¦_NYRL7qjJY©pPQy_J)LfOldeTfcMdeL7NYqpPnm�L7deT_z�WYX � ��RSdjz]yFP®deTFiYW]qjiYJ=N�¬�dsTª£�cgW]Tfk`P`O NYdeTVP¨WYX�PQy_JSX¯WYOlRÀO± � · ��À�± � ·:¨ �$W�kQdsT_z]qjJ2¬�deTª£ NYkQkQdez]TfRJUTFP4P`W � cgW6iYJMOlk�NYqeq�L>W]kQkQdeu7deqedjPQdeJUk=¨ ° y_J�kQ^_u7k`PQdePQ^_PQdjW]T¨d £_JUN$dsk4^fT7k`W]^fTª£X¯WYOx¸O¹{º=» u>JUcMNY^fk`J|£fJUkQ^_z]N�OldeTfzWYX ÄF�5Á � � � � ��� � ��NYk

±�� � - � � · � �

OQJ�©�^fdjOQJUkbPQyfN�P�� � - � �NYTª£ � � kly_W]^fqZ£ T_WYP�deTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJ3¨ ° y_JMOQJMX¯WYOQJY© ÄF�VÁ � � � � ��� � �dek�TfWYP�J�©F^fdeiwNYqjJUTFPKP`W� �5² � � � ¶ X¯WYOtPnm�L>J¨clyfJUcQ¬�deT_zSL7^fOQL>W]k`JUk=¨

% JMOQJY©�¤\J®kl^_zYzYJUk`P$N=PQyfdjO�£ N�L7LfOQW]NYcly NYk$NSP`JUTVPQN�PQdjiYJ�k`W]qe^fPQdjW]T�¨n´$JML7qeNYcgJ NYqeq � W�cMcM^_OQOQJUTfcgJUk$WYX � deT � �u�m 7 � � � ) - - - ) 7 � � � NYTª£�cMNYqeq9PQyfJ�OQJUkQ^fqjPQdsT_z�P`JMOlR � � � ¨ ° y_JUT ÄF�5Á � � � � ��� � ��dek�J�©�^fdji�NYqjJUTFP�P`W

ÄF�5Á � � � 2 � ��) - - - ) � � 5 �6� � � �� ��#j+%,���0 0��F,$+\O�-�01�=01,*�Z6l��#j)�03,D2PE���0�����-/-[)�08+:# ]�0\Q �7&()�#$+ ,*-/-p#$&a�!�"0@0 ��, +\O"-/01�1K

/�2

Page 18: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

¤�yfdscly dektdsT PQ^_OlT J�©�^fdji�NYqjJUTVP�P`W±�� � � - � � � · 2 � ��) - - - ) � � 5 ±H/?·

° mFL>JKcly_JUcl¬�deTfz ÄV�VÁ � � � � ��� � �$dsk�J�©�^fdji�NYqjJUTFP�P`W P�mFL>J�clyfJUcQ¬�deT_z�±H/?·:¨ 4 WYOQJ�LfOQJUcMdsk`JUqjmY©o¤�J�^fk`JKPQy_JKP�mFL>JOl^fqeJY§��

�, § ���² �� � �� ¶�� ±�� � � - � � � · 2 � ��) - - - ) � � 5 §3��� ²���¶ ÄF�5Á � ± � W�cMcM^_Olk�X¯OQJMJ�deT � �?·�, § ���² �� � �� ¶ � ÄF�VÁ � � � � �6� � ��§3���M²���¶± X­WYO ' � /*) - - - � ©_JUNYc y 798 � � W�cMcM^_Olk�LfOQJUcMdek`JUqemSW]TfcgJ®dsT � � � ·

3 JKk`PQdeqeqfTfJMJ�£=P`W®Pnm�LDJKclyfJUcQ¬ � � NYTª£=LfOQJMiYJUTFP\deTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ$uDJMPR¤�JMJUT � � NYTª£ � � JMiYJUT djX � dek2T_WYP�X­OlJMJ$deT � � ¨�, § ���² �� � �� ¶�� ±�� � - � �P· � �6§3��²���¶ ÄF�5Á �$± � £_W�JUkQT # P�W�cMcM^_OtX¯OQJMJ¨dsT � �?·

�, § ���² �� � �� ¶�� ÄF�VÁ � � � � �6� � ��§3� � ²���¶®fWYO$J�¦�NYRSL7qjJY© ÄF�5Á ' � � � ,.-3, �6� 2 ' � � )9' � ± RD§ � �5· 5�cMNYT�u>J�Pnm�LDJ�c y_JUcQ¬YJ�£ NYktX¯W]qeqjWP¤�kM§RD§ ! 8 ��� ¤�² � � =¶�² ' � /.�`P`Ol^_J=¶�� ±�� � � - 2 ± 7 � � � · � )1± 7 � � � ·�± RD§ � �5· 5H· 2 � ,.-3, ) � ,?-3, 5 § ! � � � � � £���� ² P`Ol^_J�¶

RA§ ! 8 ��� ¤o² � � ?¶�² ' � /.�`P`Ol^fJ=¶�� ÄF�5Á ' � � � ,.-3, �6�$2 ' � � ) ' � ± RD§ � �5· 5 § ! � � � � � £���� ² P`Ol^_J�¶° y_J�P�mFL>J�OQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T=NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR deT=a�JUcgPQdjW]T��®deRL7qjJURSJUTVPQkpPQy_JtJ�§>JUcgP2WYXDPQyfdek�Ol^fqjJ�deTN�cgW]RSLDW]kldjPQdjW]TfNYqX NYkQyfdjW]T�¨

� ��n ��������������t�:����������� ���[� � �

° y_J¨Pnm�LDJ¨OQJUcgW]Tfk`P`Ol^7cgPQdjW]T�NYqjzYWYO djPQyfR dek £fdjOQJUcgPQqjmBu7NYk`J�£�W]T�PQy_J¨Ol^fqjJUk+¤$yfdecly�N�OQJ0£_JUkQcgO dju>J�£ deT a�JUcgPQdjW]T��o¨orT X¯NYcgPM©fPQyfJ�Pnm�LDJ�O ^fqjJUk�yfNUiYJ¨uDJMJUT¥£fJUkQdjz]T_J�£ k`WPQy7N�P�PQy_JMm)JUklk`JUTVPQdsNYqeqjm=X¯WYOlR�NDlqjWYz]dscKLfOQWYzYOlNYR�E�X¯WYOtP�mFL>JOQJUcgW]TfkQP`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T�¨ ° y_JMm�N�OQJk`m�TVPQNC¦�vY£fdjOlJUcgP`J�£ NYTª£ N�OQJcMqjW]k`J�£ ^fTª£fJMO$P�mFL>JkQ^_u7kQPQdjPQ^_PQdjW]T�¨�a�NYRLAqjJ®cMqeNY^7k`JUkWYX>PQy_JtOQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T=NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR N�OQJ$kQyfW?¤�TSdsT�®�dez]^_OQJ 2�NYT�£$®[djz]^_OQJ�4�^fkQdeT_z�deRSL7qedecMdjPpL7N�P`P`JMOlT)RSN�PQcly7deT_zk`P�m�qjJ3¨ 3 J®NYkQkQ^7RJ�u>W]^fTª£ dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk�N�OQJ�£fds§>JMOQJUTVP�X¯OQW]R�W]TfJ¨NYT_WYPQy_JMO�NYT�£ X­OlJMJ�dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk=¨

´$JUcMNYqeq4dsT�PQy_J Ol^fqjJ ÄV�VÁ �6©�¤�J T_JMJ�£ P`WBdsT_X­JMObNSP�mFL7dsT_z=X¯WYO$PQyfJ � v�PQ^_LAqjJ|¤�y_W]kQJ®cgW]RL>W]T_JUTFPQkbOQJMLfOQJUk`JUTFP£fds§>JMOQJUTFP�deTfk`PQNYTFPQdeN�PQdjW]TfkbWYX�N ÄV�VÁ v�u>W]^fT�£ P`JMO R¥¨®orT_X¯JMOQOldeTfz)N Pnm�L7deTfzBX¯WYO�PQy_J � v�PQ^_LAqjJ NYT�£ N�LfL7qjm�deT_zBPQy_JN�LfL7qsdecMN�PQdjW]T Ol^fqjJ dekdeTfJ�­)cMdjJUTFP=¨?orTfk`P`JUN3£9©�¤�J ¬YJMJML P`O NYcQ¬ WYX�P�mFL>J�deT_X¯WYOlRSN�PQdeW]Tfk�NYkQk`W�cMdeN�P`J�£ ¤�djPQy JUNYc ydeTfkQPQNYTVPQdeN�PQdeW]T deT PQy_J¨k`JUcgW]T�£�cgW]RL>W]T_JUTFPtWYX�PQy_J�OQJMPQ^_OlT i�NYqe^_J�WYX � ¨

° yfJSOQJUcgW]Tfk`P`O ^fcgPQdjW]T?NYqezYWYOldjPQyfR � PQN�¬YJUk�N�P`JMO R NYTª£.NYT DQJUTFi�djOlW]TfRJUTFPM©FE�¤$yfdecly?dek�N�cgW]qsqjJUcgPQdjW]T�WYXPnm�L7deTfz]kKX­WYO0£7dek`PQdeTfcgP ÄF�5Á v�uDW]^7Tª£ dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMOlk=¨®o�P�OlJMPQ^_OlTfk�N P�mFL7dsT_z�0`^ª£fzYJURJUTVP�NYT�£ N k`JMP�WYX&DldeTfk`PQNYTFPQdeNwvPQdjW]TfkU©FE�¤�yfdec y N�OQJ¢± dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO � ©7Pnm�LDJ�NYklkQdjz]TfRJUTFPM©�"$vncgW]TfkQP`OlNYdeTFP:·\PQ^_L7qjJUk�X¯WYOtJUNYc y ÄF�5Á v�uDW]^7Tª£ dZ£_JUTFPQdsÈ7JMO� � #$ �)=����&(08)�08��9107�Z6;�Z��08+ E��!��08)�07�/�A��#o)! "-/0�& #*) ���L�! �O�-�0*K��� ����!�"0�)! "-/01��& #$)�98)�#D�!�'OF)�#�2; �98�=93, � 03,$�!��-�6\4P0@i*08�"0d)b,*-/��.1012:&(#*)

���L�! �O"-/01�1K

/?4

Page 19: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

� §"Â2OQJMP`JMO R �¥«\TVi�� $ ^�£_zYJURJUTFP �@DQoxT7k`PQNYTVPQdsN�PQdjW]Tfk3E� ± , )���· ���� � � , § ! 8 � ²���¶ � � � ��� 2 ± , § ! 8 � ² ÀO± ! � � � ·��`P`Ol^_J�¶ � , § ! � � � ² � �V¶_· ) { ± , ) � � ) � � · � 5

¤�y_JMOlJ � � ) � � ) � � N�OQJ � ) � ) �GOQJUkQLDJUcgPQdeiYJUqjm¤$djPQy NYqeq>Pnm�L>J�i�N�OldeN�u7qjJUk�kl^_u7k`PQdjPQ^fP`J�£ uFm T_J=¤ P�mFL>J�i�N�OldeN�u7qjJUk

���¯¦U� 2 ± , § ! 8 � ² ÀO± ! 8 � ·��`P`O ^_J�¶�� , § ! � � ² � 'W¶_· )�� 5� ±�� ,.- � ) ��· �

��� � ± � )��· � 2 ± � ) , §3��² � � � � � � � ¶ � � §3� � ²���¶_· )�� 5 � ��� 2 ± � � � ,?- � § ! � ± � ��� � ·x²�� � � � � ¶_· ) � 5���¯¦U� ��� � ± � )��· � 2 ± � � � §3� � ²���¶_· )�� 5 ¤�y_JMOlJ , � IKW]R�± � · � ��� 2 ± � � � ,?- � § !�� ± ! 8 � ��� � ·�²���¶_· )�� 5

� ±H± � � � �?· )���· ��¯� � ± � ��)��· � 2 ± � � � � �U§3��²�� �[¶_· )��6� 5

� ± � �*)��· � 2 ± � ��� � �6§ !�� ± � � ! 8 � ·x²�� �:¶_· )�� �65� � � � ��� ¡�± { � � � � � ��, §3� � ² � � � � � ¶ � � � ) , §3� � ² � � � � � ¶ � � � � ·� ��� £ � ��± �6��)� �?·� � ¥ � ¦ � � � � r±��.�F¤ A ��± � ± � �=· ) � ± � �?·H· )3À�± � ± ! 8 � ·H·H·

� � 2 ± � � ± � � � �?· § � ± ! � � ·|² � ± � � � � �=· � � ±�� 'J·Y¶_· )�� ± ��· 5� ± ¤w� � � )���· �

�¯� � ± � )��· � 2 ± � � � § ! 8 ± ! � � � ! � � ·|²���¶_· )�� 5� � 2 ± ¦U� � ¤ �4�t± � ·��B¤w� � � § !���� ²�� � ± � �o· � ± ' � /�� � �4¥�± � ·H·Y¶_· ) � 5

� ± ÄF�5Á , � � � �6� � �*)���· ���� , dskQT # P�NX¯OQJMJ�iwN�O deN�u7qjJ�WYX � � � ��� � ±H±H±�� ,?- � �P· � �=· )���·���¯¦U�

�¯� � ± � ��)��· � 2 ± � � � � �U§3��²�� �[¶_· )��6� 5� � � ��� { ± � � � , §3��²�� ��¶_· �� ± � � )� � · � 2 ± � � ) , §3��² � � � ¶ � � � §3� � ²�� � ¶_· )�� � 5± , ) � � ) � � · � � �� ��� £ � ��±H± � � � { ± , ) � � ) � � · � · ) � � ·� � � � ��� ¡ { � � � ��� �*, §3� � ² � � � � � ¶ � � � ) , §3���¢² �H�.� � �c¶ � � � �� � ¥ � ¦ � � � � r±��.�F¤ A ��± � ± � � · ) � ± � �?·H· )3À�± � ± � � ·H·H·

� � 2 ± � � ÄF�VÁ , � � � �6� � ��§ � ± �r·x² � ± � � � � � � � ·Y¶_· ) � ± �o· 5

®�dez]^_OQJ 2�§ ° mFL>J�OQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T�NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR

/�µ

Page 20: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

�.�F¤ A ��± � ��) � �?· � { ± , §3� ² � � � �H� � � � � �=��¶_· �*, §3��² � ��� � ��¶ � � �6) , §3��² �H�.� � �c¶ � � � �� { ± , §3��² � ��� � ��¶_· ��, §3��² � ��� � ��¶ � � ��) , � IKW]R�± � ��· �� { ± , §3��² �H�.� � �c¶_· ��, � IKW]R�± � �=· ) , §3��² �=�.� � �c¶ � � � �

� � ��� �F¤ A ��± � ��) � �?· ��¯� � � � � ��� ¡n± �*� � ��� ��, §3����²�� � � � ��¶ � � �6) , §3���¢²�� ��� �=�c¶ � � �=·� � { � ± , §3� ² � � � �H�.� � � � � �c¶_· ��, §3��² � ��� � ��¶ � � �6) , §3� � ² �=�.� � �c¶ � � � �

� { � ± , §3��² � ��� � ��¶_· �*, §3��² � � � � �[¶ � � �6) , � IKW]R�± � �?· �� { � ± , §3��² �H�.� � �c¶_· �*, � IKW]R�± � �=· ) , §3��² �=�.� � �:¶ � � � �

¥ � ¦ � � � � r± � ) �x· � { ± , §3� ² � � ��� � � � ¶_· ��, §3��² � � � ¶ � � �

� £ � �n± � � )� � · � { ± , )�� � ��� �F¤ A �t± � � ) � � · ) � � � � � · � ± , ) � � ) � � · � � � )O± , ) � � ) � � · � � � �� { ± , ) � �6) � ��· � ± , ) � �6) � ��· � �6��)�± , ) � ) ��· � � �$± X­WYObNYTVm � ) ��· �� { ± , ) � � ) � � · � )1± , ) � � ) � � · � � � )O± , ) � ) ��· � � � ± X­WYObNYTVm � ) ��· �

� � ¥�± � · � { � � ± , §3��² � � � ¶_· � � �¦�� � ¤�� ��± � · � { , §3��² P`Ol^_J �`P`Ol^_J�¶ � ± , §3��² � � � ¶_· � � �

®�dez]^_OQJ�4F§ ° mFL>J�OQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T�NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR ±nZ�W]TVPQdeT�^_J�£�·

� ¨ «2iYJMOQm W�cMcM^_OQOQJUTfcgJ=WYX\N ÄF�VÁ v�u>W]^fTª£ i�N�OldeN�u7qeJ$¤�deqeqpOQJUcgJUdjiYJ)N�k`JML7N�OlN�P`JBdeTfk`PQNYT7cgJWYX�dePQk�Pnm�L7deT_z�dsT PQy_JJUTFi�djOlW]TfRJUTFP=¨�± ° y_J�P`JUc yfTfdZ©�^_J�dek�X¯OQW]R ² � 4�4 2�/�¶�¨�·

� � ��£7¤w� � ��� � ± � ) �5· � ± � � � §!��²���¶_·�djX0NYTª£)W]TfqjmSdjX9PQy_J 0Q^ª£_zYJURJUTFP�dek2PQyfJ$LfO deTfcMdjL7NYqfPnm�L7deT_z®X­WYO � ¨ �

� ��� �SCF< � � ����<�� M -0/\3 ��E�5_CV<�� ��-0/\3

®[djz]^_OQJ�µ kQy_W?¤$k¨J�¦_NYRL7qjJUk WYX�RSW]k`P®zYJUTfJMOlNYq\Pnm�LDJUk LfOlWo£f^7cgJ�£�u�m�PQy_J NYqjzYWYOldjPQyfR�¨ É\JUcMNY^fk`J WYX�dsRL7qedecMdePLfOQW]RSWYPQdjW]TSNYTª£¢£fJMOQJUqedecgPQdjW]T0©]PQy_JtOQJUkl^fqjPQdeT_zKP�mFL>J�NYTª£=cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFPQk�u>JUcgW]RJUk�cgW]RL7qedscMN�P`J�£)©�^fdjP`J�WYX¯P`JUT�¨ 3 JkQ^_zYzYJUkQP�k`W]RJ�P`JUc yfTfdZ©�^_JUk�P`W=OQJ�£f^fcgJ�PQy_J®kQdK¯MJ�WYX�cgW]Tfk`P`OlNYdeTFPQk=¨

3 J yfNUiYJ�PQyfJ�X­W]qsqjW?¤�dsT_zdek`W]RWYOQLAyfdekQRSkU§! � �� �

! ± �*�0������· �� ! ��� � ! ���! ± �*��@����· �� ! ���� ! ���

° y�^fkM©�Pnm�L>JUk�WYX PQy_JKX¯WYOlR ! �4© ! ± ��� �:���=· ©fNYT�£ ! ± ����� ���=·�N�OQJ�OlJ�£f^fTª£fNYTFP=¨ ° y_JMOQJKdek�T_WqjW]kQk�deT)LfOQW]y7dju7djPQdeTfzPQy_JUR¥¨ ° mFL>JUkKWYX\PQy_JX¯WYOlR ! ��� ¤o² � ¶\N�OlJSNYqek`W�©�^fdjP`J^fk`JUqjJUklkKuDJUcMNY^7k`JPQy_JMOQJSN�OQJSTfWBi�NYqe^_JUk�WYX�kQ^fc y Pnm�L>JUk± WYPQy_JMO�PQyfNYT ^7Tª£_J�ÈAT_J�£�iwNYqs^_JUk:·:¨ a�dsRSdeqeN�OlqemY©7Pnm�L>JUkbWYX2PQy_J�X¯WYOlR ! � £���� k`JMOliYJUk�T_W ^fk`JMX ^fq LA^_OQL>W]k`J3¨¨a�W_©

/�2

Page 21: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

� � � - � ,?- �{±�� , · § ! 8 ± ! � � � ! � � · � ! � � � ! � �²s±�� ��W·�� ±�� ���· � ±�� ��· � ± � � / �:' � / ��ÀO± � ·H·Y¶

�p§ ! 8 ±H± ! � � � � � £���� · � ! � ± ! � � � � � £���� ·H·x² P`Ol^fJ �`P`Ol^_J=¶ )�RD§ ! � ��� ¤�² � � =¶�² P`Ol^_J �`P`O ^_J�¶ �ÄV�VÁ �� 'C% � � � � - � ,?- ��±�� , · �6� 7 � ± �� 'C% � � 2 � ) R)§ � /65H·

§ ! � � � ²s±kÀ� 'J· � ±�� �o·�� ± � ���· � ± � � / ��À � /?·�� ±�� �5·Y¶

, § ! 8 ��� ¤�² � � =¶�² P`Ol^_J �`P`O ^_J�¶ � ¥p£H< � � > ��� ����� � - � ����� � § � µ�� , § � / � § � � ² ' � /c¶

®[djz]^_OQJ0µ�§�«n¦�NYRSL7qjJUk

¤\JBcMNYT LfOQW]y7dju7djP�kQ^7cly.Pnm�LDJUk�NYk{¤\JUqeqW¨ ° yfJUT?PQy_JBW]Tfqjm�^7k`JMX¯^7q ! cgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgP`WYOlk�N�OQJBPQy_W]k`J N�LfL7qsdjJ�£�P`W$�Pnm�L>JUkM©7NYTª£ P�mFL>J�i�N�OldeN�uAqjJUk=¨

hKkQdeT_zPQy7dek�X¯NYcgPM©�¤�J�X¯WYOlR ^fqeN�P`J�PQyfJ�X­W]qeqeW?¤�deTfz�N�u7ufOQJMi�deN�P`J�£�T_WYPQN�PQdjW]T0§� � � � � � ! � ± � ��� � ·� � � !�� �

3�djPQy PQy_JUkQJ¨kQdeRLAqedsÈAcMN�PQdjW]T7k�NYTª£�T_WYPQN�PQdjW]TfkM©_PQyfJ�Pnm�L>JUk�WYXM®�dez]^_OQJ0µ�cMNYT�u>J�J�¦�LfOQJUkQkQJ�£�NYk�X¯W]qeqjW?¤$kM§� � � - � ,?- ��±�� , · § ± � � � 8 � � · � � � � � �

²s±�� ���· � ±�� ��· � ±�� ��·�� ± � � / �:' � / ��ÀO± � ·H·Y¶

�p§ � � � � £���� � 8 � � � � £�� � ² P`Ol^_J �`P`O ^_J�¶ ) RD§ � � ¤o² � � =¶�² P`O ^_J �`P`Ol^_J�¶ �ÄF�5Á �� 'C% � � � � - � ,?- �{±�� , · ��� 7 �C± �� 'C% � � 2 � ) R)§ � /65H· § � � ² ' � /c¶

, § ��� ¤o² � � ?¶�² P`Ol^_J �`P`Ol^_J�¶�� ¥p£H< � � > � � ����� � �- � ����� � § � µ�� , § � / � § � � ² X¯NYqsk`J�¶

�bWYP`J¨PQyfN�PtPQyfJ�qeNYk`P�P`JMOlR dek�T_WYPtP�mFL7N�uAqjJ�NYTVm RWYOlJ�uDJUcMNY^7k`J�PQy_J "$vncgW]T7k`P`OlNYdeTFP�dek�X NYqek`J3¨

� #����� �c�����:���

° yfdsk$LAN�LDJMOKJ�¦�P`JUTª£fk�PQyfJLfOQJMi�djW]^fkbOQJUk`JUN�Olc y W]T Pnm�L>JSdeT_X¯JMOQJUTfcgJ�X¯WYO�¸O¹�º=»=v�u7NYk`J�£ qsNYT_z]^fN�zYJUk=¨$3 J=yfN�iYJkQy_WP¤�T y_WP¤ PQy_J�cgW�JMOlcMdjW]T WYL>JMOlN�P`WYOlk � ¤w£��.£ �� NYTª£ ¥p�F¤w��� ��� =R=NUmBuDJKOQJURSW�iYJ�£�X¯OQW]R(PQy_J�P`JMO R k`m�TVPQNC¦>©NYTª£�dsTVP`OQW�£f^fcgJ�£ N�P`JUc yfTfdZ©�^_J�X¯WYO$N3£ª£7deT_zqjJMPrv�u7NYk`J�£�LDW]qem�RWYOlL7yfdekQR P`WSPQy_J�qsNYT_z]^fN�zYJ3¨

Â�W]kQkQdeu7qjJKN�OQJUNYk�X¯WYO�X¯^_PQ^fOQJ�¤\WYOQ¬BdeTfcMqe^ª£fJ$deTFiYJUk`PQdjz]N�PQdeTfz�yfW?¤ Pnm�L>Jx©F^fNYTFPQdsÈAcMN�PQdeW]TBR=NUmBuDJ�deTFP`OQW�£f^fcgJ�£deTFP`W PQyfJBk`m�k`P`JUR¥¨ oxP dsk ^7TfcMqjJUN�O�y_W?¤(P`W NYcMcgW]^fTFP X¯WYO�PQy_J�£fds§>JMOQJUTVP L>W]kQkQdjuAqjJ¬�dsTª£fk®WYX ©F^7NYTVPQdsÈAJ�£?P�mFL>J

¼ �

Page 22: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

i�N�OldeN�u7qjJUk�¨ o�P ¤�W]^7qZ£&NYqsk`W?u>J dsTVP`JMOQJUkQPQdeT_z?P`W k`PQ^ª£fm�J�¦�P`JUTfkldjW]Tfk)WYX�¸O¹�º�P`W dsTfcMqe^ª£_J OlJMX­JMOQJUT7cgJUkM©$NYkBdeTº(' ¹ ² ao´�oH2�/Y©Aao´$oF254?¶�¨

� � � �4£�¢9�¯�F¥ A � �.��� �¦ 3 J]¤�W]^fq £¨qedj¬YJ�P`WKPQyfNYT_¬�h�£fNUm|´$J�£ª£_m�X¯WYO4W�§>JMOldeTfzbRSNYTFm�i�NYqe^fN�u7qjJ\kQ^_zYzYJUk`PQdeW]Tfk=¨

������n���n�� ���

² Z . 2���¶ �$¨tZ�y_JUT NYTª£(4�¨ . £fJMOlk`¬�m3¨ ª P�mFL>J k`m�k`P`JUR X­WYO N qeNYR®ut£7N?cMNYqecM^fqs^fk¢¤�dePQy&NYkQkldjz]TfRJUTFPQk=¨orT 4�¨ % N�z]djm]N NYTª£ $ ¨�Z�¨ 4 dePQcly_JUqeq�©[J�£fdjP`WYOlkM©��. 1' ���'*)�����+.- � C�1' � )� � � �0�h� ) ' ���� � )�� + � 'M©iYW]qe^7RJ�4�µ32WYX�� � �7©_L7N�zYJUk ���r4�� � 2���¨0a�LfOldeT_zYJMOQv "[JMOlqeN�z_©�/�232���¨

² % ´�2 2P¶ % ¨ % ^fNYT_z�NYTª£�h{¨�a�¨�´$J�£ª£_m3¨ ° mFL>J OQJUcgW]TfkQP`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T�X¯WYO a7Z\o:¨ orT�I�¨ �{¨ ° ^_O T_JMOU©2J�£7djP`WYOU© '� ����)����� +.- � � �&� +�� � ����������- + � �����������©5«\qjJUcgP`OQW]Tfdec 3 WYOQ¬�kQy_WYL7k�deT�Z\W]RL7^_PQdsT_z�¨�a�L7OldeT_zYJMO`v"[JMOlqsN�z_©1/�232 2o¨

² � 4�4 2�/c¶ÂM¨SZ�¨ ��NYTfJUqeqeN�¬�dekM© % ¨ "{¨�4 NYdjOlkQW]T9©BNYT�£ $ ¨Z�¨�4 dePQcly_JUqeq�¨ hbT7dsÈAcMN�PQdjW]T NYTª£ 476 P�mFL>JOQJUcgW]T7k`P`Ol^fcgPQdjW]T�¨DorT $ ¨ v�6n¨ 6pNYkQk`J=¯KNYTª£"�¨VI�¨VÂ\qjWYP`¬�dsT9©]J�£fdjP`WYO kM© � �0�h� )�+ )����� + -��� �&� ��� � +*�� ����� ��� � � � - +���� ��(��� ��7©AL7N�zYJUk%�&�&��� �r4�µo¨ 4 o ° Â2OQJUkQkU©�/�232�/�¨

² 6#"|µ3µP¶ $ ¨ 4�¨ 64^fcMNYkQkQJUT=NYTª£=I{¨ �¢¨ "Kds§>WYO�£�¨tÂ�W]qjm�RWYOQL7y7dec�J�§DJUcgP�k`m�k`P`JURSk=¨>orT � � B��9� �0�! ��:� �������" � � � � � + �# $� +����% e©fLAN�zYJUk%�r4���/54F©M/�23µ3µo¨

² 61Â]2 /P¶ $ ¨ 64NY^fTfc yVuA^_OQm�NYTª£)a�¨ 6�¨5Â�JMmFP`W]T $ W]T_JUk�¨>a�PQN�P`JbdeT % NYk`¬YJUqeqW¨$&' (�#�� C��+������ ��� � - ��� � �0�h� )) s©µ�± �r· § ¼32&�"� ���ª/�©�/�232 /o¨² 64^7c�µ54?¶ $ W]yfT 4 ¨ 6p^fcMNYkQk`JUT�¨ �����1' +���� �!* ' ��)� ,+-� �� + � �� )� �'/. � ) '��&� + )�� �� �0 �� ��� )�� �� +.- +����

. �0�1' � + )���� ' � � �&� +�� � �����3¨0Â�y_I PQyfJUkQdekM© 4 o ° 64N�u>WYOlN�P`WYOQm�X­WYO¨Z\W]RLA^_P`JMO�a_cMdjJUTfcgJY©9ª$^fz]^fk`P/�23µ54r¨ ° JUc yfTfdecMNYq�´$JML>WYOQP6�Zta ° ´tv�� � µo¨

² 4 djP�254?¶ $ ¨AZ�¨ 4 dePQcly_JUqeq�¨1 ��� ��� + )�� �� �0� � � � + � � �����2� +����[�"+ � ' :¨ 4 o ° Â2OQJUklkM©�/�23254r¨² .  °�° 2 /P¶0ÂM¨ 3 ¨ .�#&% JUN�OlT9©�ª0¨ $ ¨�Â�W?¤\JMOU© 4�¨ ° N�¬YJMm]NYRSN�©�NYT�£ ´0¨9I�¨ ° JUTfT_JUTFP=¨Ba�m�TFPQNYcgPQdec=cgW]TFP`OQW]q�WYXdeTFP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ OQJMi�dekQdeP`J�£�¨.orT a�¨�É\OQW�WY¬YJUkM©�4�¨ 4 NYdeT9©\ª0¨ 4 JUqjP`W]T9©�NYTª£ 4 ¨ 4 dekQqjW6iYJY©�J�£fdeP`WYOlkM©

B + )� �' � + )�����+ -$ ��� ��� + )�� �� � � � �&� + � � �����3� ' � + � + )���� 54���- 'D� ' � )� � ���h� + - � ���*' � ' ����'M©iYW]qe^7RJ /BWYX��- ' ��)�� ������2 ) ' ���6�. �' �� � �0�h� )) 7��� �) M«\qek`JMi�djJMOU©+/�232 /o¨ ±nZ�yfN�L7P`JMO�/�µ�WYX² . ° 2546u�¶_·:¨² . ° 254wNC¶ ÂM¨ 3�¨ .�#&% JUN�OlT NYTª£ ´0¨>I�¨ ° JUT7T_JUTVP=¨ � - � .-98 - ��� ':� + ���"�"+ ��' ;�#<�.-= >��¨0É�djOl¬�y@?NY^7k`JMOU©tÉ�W]kQP`W]T9©/�23254r¨² . ° 2546uª¶ ÂM¨ 3�¨ .�#&% JUN�OlT NYTª£ ´0¨>I�¨ ° JUT7T_JUTVP=¨ � - � .-98 - ��� ':� + ���"�"+ ��' ;�#<�.-= BA5¨0É�djOl¬�y@?NY^7k`JMOU©tÉ�W]kQP`W]T9©/�23254r¨²  3 2&�P¶ a�¨ 6n¨�Â�JMmFP`W]T $ W]T_JUkKNYTª£ ÂM¨ 3�N3£fqjJMO�¨KorRL>JMOlN�PQdjiYJ X¯^fT7cgPQdjW]TfNYq4LfOQWYzYOlNYRSR=deT_z�¨boxTC���' � )���'�)�

� � �- � � BD� �����E ��� � �����" � � � � � + �# $� +����% 7ª�Z�4.©O/�232&�o¨² ´�J�£�2 2P¶ h{¨�a�¨ ´�J�£�£_m3¨ "KqjWYu7NYq�k`PQN�P`J cgW]TfkQdZ£fJMOQJ�£�^fTfT_JUcgJUklkQN�OQmD§ ªbT deTFP`OQW�£f^fcgPQdjW]T P`W�WYu10rJUcgPrv�u7NYkQJ�£

k`JUR=NYTVPQdecMk�¨7&' @�#�� C� +����#� ��� � .- � � � �0�h� )�+ )�� �7©t2�§�4���4.2�©M/�232 2o¨² ´�JMmª4�µP¶ $ ¨�Z�¨V´$JMm�TfW]qZ£fk=¨0a�m�TVPQNYcgPQdecbcgW]TFP`OQW]q7WYX0dsTVP`JMOQX¯JMOQJUTfcgJ3¨>orT � � B��9� �0�! #��:� �������F � � � � � + �#

� +����� s©fL7N�zYJUk �32"� � 2o¨Dª�Z4?©1/�254�µo¨�±nZ�yfN�LfP`JMO�/ � WYX+² . ° 254wN�¶_·:¨² ao´$oF2�/c¶ "{¨2ao¤\N�O ^_L0©[h{¨�at¨�´$J�£ª£_mY©2NYT�£ «�¨�o�OQJUqsNYTª£�¨�ªbkQkQdjz]TfRSJUTVPQk X¯WYOSN�LfL7qedecMN�PQdeiYJBqeNYTfz]^fN�zYJUk=¨?orT

´�¨ $ ¨54 ¨ % ^_z]y_JUkM©�J�£fdeP`WYOU© � ����� ���G �� ����)����� + -0� � � � + �# �� +����% +���� � �0�h� )) � � � ' s©iYW]qe^7RJ /3¼&�WYX�� � �7©_L7N�zYJUk�/�23¼"�o¼�/ ��¨0a�LfOldeT_zYJMOQv "[JMOlqeN�z_©�/�232�/�¨² ao´$oF254?¶ "{¨2ao¤\N�O ^_L0©[h{¨�at¨�´$J�£ª£_mY©2NYT�£ «�¨�o�OQJUqsNYTª£�¨�ªbkQkQdjz]TfRSJUTVPQk X¯WYOSN�LfL7qedecMN�PQdeiYJBqeNYTfz]^fN�zYJUk=¨?orT

� -�� -98 - ��� 'H� +����"�"+ ��' I��< .-J K� ² . ° 254wN�¶�©fc yfN�LfP`JMO�2�©fL7N�zYJUk�¼&� /"�o¼54�¼o¨

¼�/

Page 23: University of Birminghamudr/papers/scirk2.pdf · 0 Q^ ª£ _zYJUR JUTFPQk +¤ djPQy ) + PQyfN P k`L>JUcMdjX¯m=PQyfJ cgW]T fdjPQdjW]T7k ^fT _JMO y7decly N P`JMO R dek]¤ \JUqeq«v

² °%$ 2���¶ $ ¨ v�Â�¨ ° NYqjL7dsTBNYT�£�Â�¨ $ W]^_iYJUqjWYP=¨ ° y_JKPnm�LDJ®NYTª£ J�§DJUcgP�£fdekQcMdjLAqedeT_J3¨$. ���5 � �0�h� )) s©1/3/3/3±�¼5· § ¼�� /"�¼32 2�© $ ^fT /�232���¨² 3�N3£�2 � ¶ ÂM¨ 3�N3£fqjJMO?¨�6pdeT_JUN�OKPnm�L>JUk�cMNYT�clyfNYTfzYJSPQy_J�¤�WYO qZ£ ! orT 4�¨�É\OQW6m NYTª£?Z�¨�É�¨ $ W]T_JUkM©9J�£fdeP`WYOlkM©

� � �&� +�� � ����� � ���� ' � )� 7+���� B '*)� �� :¨ �bWYOQPQy�v % W]qeqeNYT�£9©�ª$R=k`P`JMO�£fNYR ©�/�232 � ¨¬±�Â2OQW�c�¨�oR®�oJ° Z�¼ 3 WYOQ¬�dsT_zBZ\W]T_XJ¨j©Aa�JUN�WYX "KNYqedsqjJMJY©_oxkQOlN�JUq ·:¨² 3�N3£�2�/c¶ ÂM¨�3�N3£fqjJMO�¨ oxkBPQy_JMOlJ�N ^7k`J X­WYO�qedsT_JUN�OBqeWYz]dec�� orTJ� � �" :� ���0�! �� �,+��*)�� +.-��\�.+.-��"+ )�� �

+������ ' � +�� )���� I8�� +� *' �(� � � � + � B +���� �h�1- + )�� �7© L7N�zYJUk�¼ / /"�o¼54 �o¨pª�Z�4.©�/�232�/�¨�±na�o "� 6pª���bWYPQdecgJUkM©Da�JML�¨�/�232�/?·:¨

² )�´�254?¶ % ¨ )2NYTfzBNYTª£ h{¨9a�¨�´�J�£�£_m3¨�orRL>JMOlN�PQdjiYJ qeNYR¨u�£fN=cMNYqecM^fqe^fk$OQJMi�dekQdjP`J�£�¨thbT7djiYJMOlkQdjP�m WYX[oxqsqedeT_W]dekN�PthbOQu7NYT7NwvxZ�yfNYRL7NYdez]T9©�/�23254r¨

¼3¼