vd chap- road loads
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
1/41
Road Loads
Aerodynamics (Mechanics of air flow around a vehicle,
Pressure distribution on a Vehicle, Aerodynamic Forces,
Drag Components, Aerodynamics Aids, Drag, Side Force,Lift Force, Pitch Moment, Yawing moment, Rolling
Moment, Crosswind Sensitivity)
Rolling Resistance(Factors affecting rolling resistance,
Typical coefficient) Total road Loads and effect of Road loads on Fuel
economy.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
2/41
Aerodynamics Aerodynamics makes its major impact on modern cars and
trucks through its contribution to "road load." Aerodynamic
forces interact with the vehicle causing drag, lift (or down load),
lateral forces, moments in roll, pitch and yaw, and noise.
These impact fuel economy and handling .
The aerodynamic forces produced on a vehicle arise from two
sources form (or pressure) drag and viscous friction.
First, the mechanics of air flow will be examined to explain thenature of the flow around the body of the vehicle. Then, vehicle
design features will be examined to show the qualitative
influence on aerodynamic performance.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
3/41
Mechanics of Air Flow Around a Vehicle
The gross flow over the body of a car is governed by the
relationship between velocity and pressure expressed in
Bernoulli's Equation (Bernoulli's Equation assumesincompressible flow, which is reasonable for automotive
aerodynamics, whereas the equivalent relationship for
compressible flow is the Euler Equation.)
The equation is:Pstatic + Pdynamic = Ptotal
P s+ 1/2 V2 = Pt
where:
= Density of air
V = Velocity of air (relative to the car)
1
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
4/41
Bernoulli's equation states that the static plus the dynamic pressure of the air
will be constant (Pt) as it approaches the vehicle. Visualizing the vehicle as
stationary and the air moving (as in a wind tunnel), the air streams along lines,
appropriately called "streamlines." A bundle of streamlines forms a stream
tube. The smoke streams used in a wind tunnel allow stream tubes to be
visualized as illustrated in Figure
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
5/41
At a distance from the vehicle the static pressure is simply the ambient, orbarometric, pressure (Patm)
The dynamic pressure is produced by the relative
velocity, which is constant for all streamlines approaching the vehicle.
Thus the total pressure, Pt, is the same for all streamlines and is equal to Ps
+ V2. As the flow approaches the vehicle, the stream tubes split, some going
above the vehicle, and others below. By inference, one streamline must go
straight to the body and stagnate (the one shown impinging on the bumper
of the car). At that point the relative velocity has gone to zero.
With the velocity term zero, the static pressure observed at that point on thevehicle will be Pt. That is, if a pressure tap is placed on the vehicle at this
point, it will record the total pressure.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
6/41
Consider what must happen to the streamlines flowing above the hood. As they
first turn in the upward direction, the curvature is concave upward.
At a distance well above the vehicle where the streamlines are still straight, the
static pressure must be the same as the ambient.
In order for the air stream to be curved upward, the static pressure in that
region must be higher than ambient to provide the force necessary to turn the
air flow.
If the static pressure is higher, then the velocity must decrease in this region in
order to obey Bernoulli's Equation.
Conversely, as the flow turns to follow the hood (downward curvature at the lip
of the hood) the pressure must go below ambient in order to bend the flow, and
the velocity must increase. These points are illustrated in Fig. showing flow
over a cylinder.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
7/41
Pressure and velocity gradients in the airflow over a body
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
8/41
In the absence of friction the air would simply flow up over theroof and down the back side of the vehicle, exchanging
pressure for velocity as it did at the front.
In that case, the pressure forces on the back side of the vehicle
would exactly balance those on the front, and there would be
no drag produced.
The drag is due in part to friction of the air on the surface of
the vehicle, and in part to the way the friction alters the main
flow down the back side of the vehicle. Its
explanation comes about from understanding the action of
boundary layers in the flow over an object. Consider a uniform
flow approaching a sharp-edged body as shown in Fig.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
9/41
Development of boundary layers
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
10/41
Flow separation in an adverse gradient pressure
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
11/41
Because of the low pressure, the flow along the sides of the car will
also attempt to feed air into this region and may add to the potential for
separation. The general air flow patterns over the top and sides of a carare shown in Figure
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
12/41
Pressure Distribution on Vehicle
Pressure co-efficients plotted normal to surface
Pressure distribution along centre line of a car
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
13/41
Note that a negative pressure is developed at the front edge of the
hood asthe flow rising over the front of the vehicle attempts to turn and
follow horizontally along the hood.
The adverse pressure gradient in this region has the potential to
stall the boundary layer flow creating drag in this area. Near the base of the windshield and cowl, the flow must he turned
upward, thus high pressure is experienced.
Over the roof line the pressure again goes negative as the air flow
tries to follow the roof contour. The pressure remains low down over the backlite and on to the
trunk because of the continuing curvature.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
14/41
Aerodynamic lift and drag on different vehicle styles
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
15/41
Effect of separation point dirt deposition at the rear
The high degree of turbulence in the separation zone entrains moisture and dirt kickedup from the roadway by the tires. If the separation zone includes these items, dirt will
be deposited on these areas and vision will be obstructed. Figure illustrates this
phenomenon.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
16/41
Aerodynamic forces
As a result of the air stream interacting with the vehicle, forces and
moments are imposed. These may be defined systematically as the three forces
and three moments shown in table below, acting about the principal axes of the
car. The reactions are as follows:
Direction Force Moment
Longitudinal (x-axis, positive rearward) Drag Rolling Moment
Lateral (y-axis, positive to the right) Side force Pitching Moment
Vertical (z-axis, positive upward) Lift Yawing Moment
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
17/41
Drag Components
Drag is the largest and most important aerodynamic force
encountered by passenger cars at normal highway speeds.
The overall drag on a vehicle derives from contributions of
many sources. Various aids may be used to reduce the effects of
specific factors. Table lists the main sources of drag and the
potential for drag reductions in these areas estimated for cars in
the 1970s.
D ffi i t C t T i l l
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
18/41
Drag co-efficient Component Typical values
Forebody 0.05
Afterbody 0.14
Underbody 0.06
Skin Friction 0.025
Total Body Drag 0.275
Wheels and wheel wells 0.09
Drip rails 0.01
Window Recesses 0.01
External mirrors 0.01
Total protuberance Drag 0.12
Cooling system 0.025
Total internal drag 0.025Overall total drag 0.42
Vehicle of 1980s
Cars 0.30-0.35
Vans 0.33-0.35
Pick up tricks 0.42-0.46
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
19/41
For the vehicle represented in the table, approximately 65% (.275/.42) of the
drag arises from the body (forebody, afterbody, underbody and skin friction)
The major contributor is the afterbody because of the drag produced by theseparation zone at the rear.
It is in this area that the maximum potential for drag reduction is possible.
Fig. below shows the influence of rear end inclination angle on the drag for
various lengths of rear extension (beyond the rear edge of the roof line)
Influence of rear end inclination on drag
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
20/41
Forebody drag is influenced by design of the front end and windshield
angle.
Generally the "roundness" of the front end establishes the area overwhich the dynamic pressure can act to induce drag. Fig. shows the
influence of the height of the front edge of the vehicle
Influence of front end design on drag
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
21/41
The location of this point determines the location of the
streamline flowing to the stagnation point.
This streamline is important as it establishes the separation of
flow above and below the body.
Minimum drag is obtained when the stagnation point is kept
low on the frontal profile of the vehicle.
A well-rounded shape, in contrast to the crisp lines traditionally
given to the frontal/grill treatment of passenger cars, is equally
important to aerodynamics.
A rounded low hood line can yield reductions of 5 to 15% inthe overall drag coefficient.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
22/41
The windshield establishes the flow direction as it approaches
the horizontal roof.
Thus its angle has a direct influence on drag, particularly on
trucks.
Shallow angles reduce drag, but complicate vehicle design by
allowing increased solar heating loads and placing more critical
demands on the manufacturer of the windshield to minimize
distortion at shallow angles.
Fig. shows the change in drag as the windshield angle is
increased from the nominal angle of 28 degrees.
With a steep angle, the air velocity approaching the windshield
is reduced by the high pressure in that region. With a shallow
angle, the wind speed will he higher, adding to the
aerodynamic loads on the windshield wipers.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
23/41
Influence of windshield angle on drag
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
24/41
The underbody is a critical area generating body drag. Suspensions,
exhaust systems and other protruding components on the underbody are
responsible for the drag.
The air flow in this area is a shear plane controlled by zero air speed on the
road surface, and induced flow by drag of the underbody components.
The recognized fix for minimizing underbody drag is the use of a smooth
underbody panel.
Protuberances from the body represent a second area where careful designcan reduce drag.
The wheels and wheel wells are a major contributor in this
class. Significant drag develops at the wheels because of the turbulent,
re-circulating flow in the cavities. Fig. illustrates the complex flow patterns
that occur around a wheel. The sharp edges of the wheel cutout provide opportunities to induce flow in
the horizontal plane, while the rotating wheel tends to induce circulation in
the vertical plane.
These effects allow the wheel to influence more flow than simply that which
is seen because of its frontal area presented to the flow.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
25/41
Air flow re-circulation in a wheel well
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
26/41
The cooling system is the last major contributor to drag.
Air flow passing through the radiator impacts on the engine and the firewall,
exerting its dynamic pressure as drag on the vehicle. The air flow pattern inside a typical engine compartment may be very
chaotic due to the lack of aerodynamic treatment in this area. Fig. below
illustrates this situation compartment before spilling out through the
underside openings.
The momentum exchange translates directly into increased drag.
Air flow pattern in a typical engine compartment
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
27/41
Aerodynamic Aids
Bumper Spoilers : Front bumper spoilers are aerodynamic surfaces extending downward
from the bumper to block and redirect the shear flow that impacts on the
underbody components. While the spoiler contributes pressure drag, at
least with a shallow depth the reduction in underbody drag is more
significant. As spoiler depth is increased, eventually the increasing pressure drag
outweighs further reduction in underbody drag and the overall drag
increases. The low pressure produced also has the effect of reducing
front-end lift.
Air-Dams : Air dams are flow-blocking surfaces installed at the perimeter of the
radiator to improve flow through the radiator at lower vehicle speeds.
The improvement derives from the decreased pressure behind the
radiator/fan, and may reduce drag by reduction of pressure on the
firewall.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
28/41
Deck-lid Spoilers :
Spoilers and air foils on the rear deck may serve several purposes.
By deflecting the air upward, as shown in Figure 4.18, the pressure isincreased on the rear deck creating a down force at the most
advantageous point on the vehicle to reduce rear lift.
The spoilers may also serve to stabilize the vortices in the separation
flow, thus reducing aerodynamic buffeting. In general, they tend to
increase drag.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
29/41
Window and Pillar Treatments :
Drip rails and offsets between windows and pillars on acarbody are always
sources of drag. Disturbance to the air flow in these regions may cause small separation zones.
The disturbance to the air in the high-velocity air stream causes momentum
loss which creates drag.
Smooth contours are important not only for drag reduction, but also for
reduction of aerodynamic noise.
Optimization :
Adaptation of streamlined shapes from other disciplines (e.g., ship building)
at the turn of the century.
Application of the knowledge of fluid mechanics from aircraft aerodynamicsaround the 1930s.
Current efforts to optimize the numerous details of the design to obtain good
air flow characteristics.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
30/41
Drag :- Because air flow over a vehicle (or any other body for that matter)is so complex, it is necessary to develop semi-empirical models to represent
the effect. Therefore, aerodynamic drag is characterized by the equation:
The term 1/2 V2 in the above equation is the dynamic pressure of the air,
and is often referred to as the "q," typically expressed in units of pounds persquare foot. The drag coefficient, CD, is determined empirically for the car.
1
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
31/41
Air Density : The air density is variable depending on
temperature, pressure, and humidity conditions. Density at other conditions can be estimated for the
prevailing pressure, Pr, and temperature, Tr, conditions by
the equation:
2
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
32/41
Drag co-efficient : The drag coefficient is determined
experimentally from wind tunnel tests or coast down tests. Thedefinition of CD comes from Eq.
The drag coefficient varies over a broad range with different
shapes. Fig. shows the coefficients for a number of shapes. In
each case it is presumed that the air approaching the body has
no lateral component (i.e., it is straight along the longitudinalaxis of the vehicle).
Note that the simple flat plate has a drag coefficient of 1.95.
3
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
33/41
Drag co-efficient of various bodies
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
34/41
This coefficient means that the drag force is 1.95 times as large as the dynamic
pressure acting over the area of the plate.
The extreme drag produced by the plate results from the fact that the air spilling
around the plate creates a separation area much larger than the plate itself.
In practice, a vehicle driving along a road experiences atmospheric winds
in addition to the wind component arising from its speed.
The atmospheric wind will be random in direction with respect to the vehicle's
direction of travel. Thus the relative wind seen by the vehicle will consist of the large component due to
its speed, plus a smaller atmospheric wind component in any direction. Fig.
illustrates how the relative wind will vary randomly.
Relative wind seen by motor vehicle on the road
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
35/41
When the atmospheric wind blows toward the vehicle a
"headwind" is present, and the total velocity used in is:
4
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
36/41
Side Force The lateral wind components will also impose a side force on
the vehicle attempting to change its direction of travel.
The exact effect depends both on the vehicle and the nature of
the wind.
In strong crosswinds, the side force is typically greater than thedrag force, such that the angle of the overall wind force is
much greater than the relative wind angle.
The aerodynamic shape of the vehicle and even the steering
system characteristics affect performance in this sense. Crosswind behavior is an important enough aspect of
aerodynamics that it is discussed separately in a later section.
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
37/41
Under steady-state wind conditions, the side force imposed on
a vehicle in a crosswind is given by:
5
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
38/41
Fig. shows typical characteristics of CS as a function of wind angle.
The side force coefficient is zero at zero relative wind angle, and grows
nearly linearly with the angle for the first 20 to 40 degrees.
The slope of the gradient varies somewhat with vehicle type, but will
typically he in the range of 0.035/deg to 0.06/deg.
Side force co-efficient as a function of yaw angle for typical vehicles
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
39/41
Lift Force The pressure differential from the top to the bottom of the vehicle causes
a lift force.
These forces are significant concerns in aerodynamic optimization of a
vehicle because of their influence on driving stability.
The lift force is measured at the centerline of the vehicle at the center of the
wheelbase. The force, LA, is quantified by the equation:
6
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
40/41
As seen in Figure, the lift force is dependent on the overall shape
of the vehicle. At zero wind angle, lift coefficients normally fall in the range
of 0.3 to 0.5 for modern passenger cars but under crosswind conditions
the coefficient may increase dramatically reaching values of 1 or
more
-
7/31/2019 VD Chap- Road Loads
41/41
Lift can have a negative impact on handling through the
reduced control forces available at the tires.
Front lift, which reduces steering controllability, is reduced by
front bumper spoilers and by rearward inclination of front
surfaces.
Lift at the rear of the vehicle, which also reduces stability, is
the most variable with vehicle design.
In general, designs that cause the flow to depart with a
downward angle at the rear of the vehicle create rear lift. Lift
can be decreased by use of underbody pans, spoilers, and achange in the angle of attack of the body (a 3-degree cant on
the body can decrease lift force by 40 percent).