x-401 pages. 8, α 3 g.p. harnwell, w.e. stephens, ,atomic physics: an atomic description of...

2
BOOK REVIEWS M. E. RosE, Multipole fields (John Wiley & Sons, New York and Chapman and Hall, London 1955. viii-99 pages. [ 2). This is not, unfortunately, the much needed monograph on multipole fields and their applications, which the title and the distinguished author's name would lead one to expect. The author has rendered a great service to nuclear studies by devoting considerable effort and care to developing this subject and its various aspects; it cannot be said that he has devoted much care to the composition of this book -- if, indeed, he has not just "composed" it by collecting stray notes from his drawers and sending them straight to the printer. Neither the preface not a careful reading of the book has made it clear to me exactly the author set out to do. There is nowhere any clear statement of the physical problems concerned or of the methods for subjecting them to mathematical analysis. It seems that the author wanted to present elaborate calculations of fields, intensities, matrix elements and the like, performed by means of a uniform tech- nique; but he has not attempted either any exhaustive, systematic discussion of this mathematical technique. The book therefore, is clearly of no use to the student. As to those physicists who already know all about the subject, they will find in it a compendium of the basic definitions and formulae pertaining to multipole fields, a summary exposition of their main properties and, filling the latter half of the small volume, a derivation of the formulae governing internal conversion and multipole emission. The author's mode of exposition is not felicitous; all too often, excessive brevity leads to obscurity, and no sufficient attention is paid to the order in which the parts of an argument should be presented to make their significance clear from the start, without forcing the reader to retrace his steps repeatedly. The uncouth "Physical Review dialect adopted by the author does not improve matters. The treatment of internal conversion and emission, in particular, is completely topsy-turvy: the reader is constantly referred to results which are going to be derived in the next stage of the argument, until he begins to wonder whether his own brain, or the author's, has undergone a time-inversion. Yet, there is plenty of good stuff in this small, but extremely competent treatise: many nice points are made -- about pitfalls in the choice of a special gauge for the potential (sec. 26), the essentials of angular correlation, alignment and orientation problems (sec. 32), etc. -- which are both inetresting and useful. It is all the more a pity that they should be presented in such an uninviting fashion. The list of references is proudly described as "complete"; and, indeed, it starts promisingly enough with Abraham (Max). But, believe it or not, the name of Rubinowicz does not occur in it. The book is neatly printed, although the omission of punctuation marks after displayed formulae is a typographical mannerism which has nothing to co/nmend it. The price is too high. L. R. G. P. HARNWELL and W. E. SXEP~ENS, Atomic physics: an atomic description o] physical phenomena (McGraw-Hill Book Co, New York, Toronto, London 1955. x-401 pages. 8, c~ 3). This textbook, whose subject is outside the scope of the journal, can only be briefly reviewed. After two introductory chapters (93 pages), there is an elaborate 379

Upload: lr

Post on 02-Jul-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: x-401 pages. 8, α 3 G.P. Harnwell, W.E. Stephens, ,Atomic physics: an atomic description of physical phenomena (1955) McGraw-Hill Book Co,New York and Chapman and Hall, London

BOOK REVIEWS

M. E. RosE, Multipole fields ( John Wi ley & Sons, New York and C h a p m a n and Hall , L o n d o n 1955. viii-99 pages . [ 2).

This is not, un fo r t una t e l y , t he m u c h needed m o n o g r a p h on mul t ipo le fields and thei r appl icat ions , wh ich t he t i t le and t he d i s t ingu i shed a u t h o r ' s n a m e would lead one to expect . The a u t h o r ha s rendered a g rea t service to nuc lear s tud ies by devo t ing considerable effort and care to deve loping th i s sub jec t and i ts va r ious aspects ; i t c a n n o t be said t h a t he ha s devo ted m u c h care to t he compos i t ion of th i s book - - if, indeed, he ha s no t j u s t " c o m p o s e d " i t b y col lect ing s t r a y no tes f rom his d rawers and send ing t h e m s t r a i g h t to the pr in ter .

Ne i the r t he preface no t a careful r ead ing of t he book has m a d e i t clear to me e x a c t l y t he a u t h o r set ou t to do. There is nowhere a n y clear s t a t e m e n t of t he phys ica l p rob lems concerned or of t he m e t h o d s for sub j ec t i ng t h e m to m a t h e m a t i c a l analys is . I t seems t h a t t he a u t h o r w a n t e d to p re sen t e labora te ca lcula t ions of fields, in tensi t ies , m a t r i x e l emen t s and the like, pe r fo rmed by m e a n s of a un i fo rm tech- n ique; b u t he ha s no t a t t e m p t e d e i ther a n y exhaus t ive , s y s t e m a t i c d iscuss ion of th i s m a t h e m a t i c a l t echn ique . T he book therefore, is clearly of no use to t he s tuden t . As to those phys ic i s t s who a l ready know all a b o u t t he subject , t h e y will f ind in i t a c o m p e n d i u m of t h e bas ic def in i t ions and fo rmulae pe r t a in ing to mul t ipole fields, a s u m m a r y expos i t ion of the i r m a i n proper t ies and, filling t he l a t t e r ha l f of t he smal l vo lume , a de r iva t ion of the fo rmulae govern ing in te rna l convers ion and mul t ipole emiss ion .

The a u t h o r ' s mode of expos i t ion is no t felicitous; all too often, excess ive b rev i ty leads to obscur i ty , and no suff ic ient a t t e n t i o n is pa id to t he order in which t he pa r t s of an a r g u m e n t shou ld be p resen ted to m a k e thei r s ignif icance clear f rom the s tar t , w i t h o u t forcing t he reader to re t race his s t eps repea ted ly . The u n c o u t h "Physical Review dialect adop t ed b y t he a u t h o r does no t i mprove ma t t e r s . The t r e a t m e n t of in t e rna l convers ion and emission, in par t icular , is comple te ly t o p s y - t u r v y : the reader is c o n s t a n t l y referred to resu l t s which are going to be der ived in t he n e x t s t age of t he a r g u m e n t , un t i l he begins to wonde r w h e t h e r his own brain, or t he au tho r ' s , h a s u n d e r g o n e a t ime- invers ion .

Yet , t he re is p l en t y of good s tu f f in th i s small , b u t ex t r eme ly c o m p e t e n t t reat ise : m a n y nice po in t s are m a d e -- a b o u t pi t fal ls in t he choice of a special gauge for the po ten t i a l (sec. 26), t he essent ia l s of angu l a r correlat ion, a l i g n m e n t and o r ien ta t ion p rob lems (sec. 32), etc. -- wh ich are bo t h ine t res t ing and useful . I t is all t h e more a p i t y t h a t t h e y shou ld be p resen ted in such an u n i n v i t i n g fashion.

The l is t of references is p roud l y descr ibed as " c o m p l e t e " ; and, indeed, it s t a r t s p romis ing ly e n o u g h w i t h A b r a h a m (Max). But , believe it or not , t h e n a m e of Rub inowicz does no t occur in it.

The book is nea t l y pr in ted , a l t h o u g h the omiss ion of p u n c t u a t i o n m a r k s a f te r d i sp layed fo rmulae is a t ypograph ica l m a n n e r i s m which has no th ing to co /nmend it. The price is too high.

L. R.

G. P. HARNWELL and W. E. SXEP~ENS, Atomic physics: an atomic description o] physical phenomena (McGraw-Hil l Book Co, New York, Toronto , L o n d o n 1955. x-401 pages. 8, c~ 3).

Th i s t ex tbook , whose sub jec t is ou t s ide the scope of t he journal , can on ly be brief ly reviewed. Af ter two i n t r o d u c t o r y chap te r s (93 pages) , the re is an e labora te

379

Page 2: x-401 pages. 8, α 3 G.P. Harnwell, W.E. Stephens, ,Atomic physics: an atomic description of physical phenomena (1955) McGraw-Hill Book Co,New York and Chapman and Hall, London

380 nOOK nEVIEWS

treatment of atomic and molecular spectroscopy in 3 chapters (186 pages), including the quantum theory of radiation and hyperfine structure. The last two chapters (108 pages) discuss the properties of mat ter in bulk, or more accurately the influence of the quantal features of the elementary processes on such properties. The book is thus meant as a complement to some more elementary exposition of the atomic theory of matter. The t reatment is theoretical, but with the emphasis on the physical rather than the mathematical features. There are numerous interesting problems and good references for further study at the end of each chapter.

L. R.

R. S. SHANELAND, Atomic and nuclear physics. (The MacMillan Company, New York 1955. xv-529 pages. 44 s.)

This textbook provides a sound general introduction to a vast subject. The material is set out in a clear and concise manner and by concentxating on essentials the author has succeeded in compressing a considerable amount of information within a book of manageable proportions. In addition, he has found space to describe recent important developments in such fields as the fine structure of the hydrogen spectrum lizLes and the production of the transuranic elements to quote but two examples. Where the t rea tment is more superficial as for example in the chapter on the solid state of matter, adequate references to the original papers on the subject are given. The book is well indexed and is supplemented by a comprehensive list of physical constants.

Cr. N. FOWLER