zambales chromite mning vs ca

8/14/2019 Zambales Chromite Mning vs CA

1/5

GRSI Copyrightregno N94-027G.R. No. L-49711 November 7, 1979

!"#!L$S C%R&"I'$ "INING C&. v(. C&)R' &* !++$!LS

Repbi o/ the +hiippine(

S)+R$"$ C&)R'"ni

S$C&N IISI&N

G.R. No. L-49711 November 7, 1979

!"#!L$S C%R&"I'$ "INING C&., G&N!L& +. N!!, I&L! S. N!!,*$$RIC& S. N!!, +$RL! N!!, %&N&R!'& +. N!!, !L$3!NR& S.

N!!, +)RI*IC!CI&N SIS&N, !. '&R$SILL!S, G)I& !INC)L!, +$R&

!NG)L& n '&"!S "!R!"#!, petitioner(-ppent(,

v(.

C&)R' &* !++$!LS, S$CR$'!R5 &* !GRIC)L')R$ !N N!')R!L

R$S&)RC$S, IR$C'&R &* "IN$S, GR$G&RI& $. "!R'IN$, !L$3!NR&

"$N$, NIC!N&R "!R'5, IC$N'$ "IS&L$S, G)ILL$R"& 5!#)',!NR$S R. *I!G&5, "IG)$L !. "!NI!G&, C!SI"IR& N. $#I&, $NRI6)$

RI$R!, S$$RIN& "I!, $L$NI'& #. "!R'IN$, L)C!S $)R!IN,

*$LI"&N $NCI&, $"ILI& IL&C&, I&S!& "IS&L!, $RN$S'&

!L$R$, +!#L& +!#IL&N!, !R"!N& "IN!S, #!R'&L&"$ "!R!$n C$CILI& &&ILL!, re(ponent(-ppeee(.

'ore(i !vin /or petitioner(-ppent(."rino ". Lo8 /or privte re(ponent(-ppeee(.

!6)IN&, 3.p

'hi( i( mining (e. 'he petitioner( ppee /rom the (eon ei(ion o/ the Cort o/

!ppe(, rever(ing it( /ir(t ei(ion n hoing tht it :( improper /rom #en;min ".Go8on, ( Seretry o/ !gritre n Ntr Re(ore(, to //irm hi( o:n ei(ion (

iretor o/ "ine(.

'he Cort o/ !ppe( /rther he tht the tri orten in the tri ort=. 'he nteeent proeeing( re ( /oo:(

?1@ In "ine( !mini(trtive C(e No. -227, iretor Go8on i((e n orer te

&tober A, 19B0 :herein he i(mi((e the (e /ie by the petitioner( or prote(tnt(

?mbe( Chromite "ining Co., In. or the grop o/ Gon8o +. Nv@. In tht (e,


2/5

they (oght to be ere the right/ n prior otor( n po((e((or( o/ (ity-nine

mining im( ote in Snt Cr8, mbe(.

&n the b(i( o/ petitioner(< eviene ?the privte re(ponent( i not pre(ent nyeviene n they /ie emrrer to the eviene or motion to i(mi(( the prote(t@,

iretor Go8on /on tht the petitioner( i not i(over ny miner nor (t>e n

ote mining im( in orne :ith :.

In tht (me orer, iretor Go8on re tht the mining im( o/ the grop( o/ Gregorio

"rtine8 n +bo +bion, no: the privte re(ponent(-ppeee(, :ere y oten regi(tere ?pp. 224-2D1, Reor on !ppe@.

?2@ 'he petitioner( ppee /rom tht orer to the Seretry o/ !gritre n

Ntr Re(ore(. Ehie the ppe :( pening, iretor Go8on :( ppointe

Seretry o/ !gritre n Ntr Re(ore(. In(te o/ inhibiting him(e/, he eiethe ppe, !NR C(e No. 21A1, on !g(t 1B, 19BD ( it he :( ;iting the (e

/or the /ir(t time.


3/5

Seretry Go8on


4/5

bi(e, be ere voi n tht the (e be retrne to the Seretry o/ !gritre n

Ntr Re(ore( /or nother revie: o/ iretor Go8on


5/5

! (en(e o/ proportion n on(iertion /or the /itne(( o/ thing( (ho hve eterre

Seretry Go8on /rom revie:ing hi( o:n ei(ion ( iretor o/ "ine(. %e (ho hve

(>e hi( ner(eretry to nert>e the revie:.

+etitioner(-ppent( :ere eprive o/ e proe((, mening /nment /irne((, :hen

Seretry Go8on revie:e hi( o:n ei(ion ( iretor o/ "ine(. ?See !mo( 'ret Co. v(. Seritie( n $hnge Commi((ion, D0B *. 2n 2B0, 2B7.@

E%$R$*&R$, :e (et (ie the orer o/ the Seretry o/ !gritre n Ntr

Re(ore( te !g(t 1B, 19BD ( //irme by the tri ort ( :e ( the /ir(tei(ion o/ the Cort o/ !ppe(.

Ee //irm it( (eon ei(ion, retrning the (e to the "ini(ter o/ Ntr Re(ore(,

:ith the iretive tht petitioner(< ppe to the "ini(ter be re(ove e novo :ith the

e(t ey ( provie /or in +re(ienti eree No. D09, =e(tbi(hing re( nproere( /or the (peey i(po(ition or (ettement o/ on/iting mining im(=.

Ee rever(e the (eon prt o/ tht (eon ei(ion (tting tht =there/ter, /rther

proeeing( :i be t>en in the tri ort=. 'ht portion i( n:rrnte be(e the triort oe( not retin ny ;ri(ition over the (e one it i( remne to the "ini(ter o/

Ntr Re(ore(. No o(t(.S& &R$R$.

!ntonio, Snto( n !b Snto(, 33., onr.

Conepion 3r., 3, too> no prt.

Seprte &pinion(

#rreo, 3. onrring

Conr bt :i(h to tht the re(on :hy the ner(eretry o (> i( be(e :henthe (eretry i( i(Fi/ie, he (ho be eeme ( b(ent or inpitte to (>, hene

the ner(eretry (ho be orre(poningy eeme ( the (eretry /or the prpo(e( o/

the (e in Fe(tion. Neee(( to (y, the ner(eretry (ho (> in (h :y ( to

voi ny inition tht he h( been itte pon ty by the (eretry.

zambales chromite mning vs ca

Documents