๑ ทศวรรษแห่งการปฏิรูปการเมือง :...

473
·ÈÇÃÃÉ áË‹§¡Òû¯ÔÃÙ»¡ÒÃàÁ×ͧ : ลงาน ปั ญหา และ ปสรรค ·ÈÇÃÃÉ áË‹§¡Òû¯ÔÃÙ»¡ÒÃàÁ×ͧ : ลงาน ปั ญหา และปสรรค

Upload: uthaisak-yutthapan

Post on 06-Apr-2016

255 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

โดย วิทยาลัยการเมืองการปกครอง สถาบันพระปกเกล้า .................................................................................... งานวิจัย เรื่อง หนึ่งทศวรรษแห่งการปฏิรูปการเมือง : ผลงาน ปัญหา และอุปสรรค์ เป็นงานวิจัยที่มีคุณค่าอย่างยิ่งต่อการสร้างการรับรู้และความสำรวจสถานะของสถานการณ์ทางการเมืองของประเทศไทย โดยนักวิจัยกำหนดวัตถุประสงค์ในการศึกษาไว้ 2 ประการ ได้แก่ เพื่อศึกษาและทบทวนเจตนารมณ์และวัตถุประ

TRANSCRIPT

  • :

    :

  • 1

    .......................................................................................................................................... 22

    ............................................................................................................................... 24

    1.1 .................................................................................................. 33

    1.2 ............................................................................................................................. 36

    1.3 .................................................................................................................. 37

    1.4 ................................................................................................................ 37

    1.5 .......................................................................................................... 38

    1.6 ................................................................................................................................ 40

    1.7 ....................................................................................................................... 42

    1.8 ........................................................................................................... 42

    1.9 ................................................................................................................... 42

    2 .......................................................................................... 43

    2.1 ...................................................................................... 43

    2.1.1 ...................................................................................... 44

    2.1.2 ................................................................................................. 44

    2.1.3 ...................................................................................... 45

    2.2 (constitutionalism) ....................................................................................... 45

    2.2.1 ............................................................................................. 45

    2.2.2 .................................................... 47

    2.3 ............................................................................................... 48

    2.3.1 .................................................................................................................................. 48

  • 2

    2.3.2 .................. 49

    2.3.3 ........................................................... 51

    2.3.4 .......................................................................................................... 51

    2.4 ........................................ 63

    2.4.1 ........................................................ 64

    2.4.2 ...................................... 66

    2.4.3 ............................................... 67

    2.5 ..................................................................................................................... 70

    2.5.1 :

    . 11 .. 2543

    .............................................................................................................................. 70

    2.5.2

    11 .. 2543 ...................... 72

    2.5.3

    ( ) ( , 2546) ....................................................................................................................................... 73

    2.6 ........................................................................................................................................ 82

    3 ........................................................................................................................ 85

    3.1 ......................................................................................................................... 85

    3.2 ...................................................................................................... 85

    3.3 .......................................................................................................... 86

    3.4 ................................................................................. 101

    3.5 .................................................... 101

    3.5.1 .................................................................................................. 101

  • 3

    3.5.2 ........................................................................ 102

    3.6 ............................................................................................... 103

    4 .................................................................................... 104

    4.1 .................................................................................................................................... 104

    4.1.1 ................................................................................................. 104

    4.1.2 ............................................................................................ 111

    4.2. .................................................................................................. 112

    4.3 ........................................................................................................ 117

    4.4 .. 2540

    ................................................................................................................................................. 119

    4.4.1 .......................................................................................... 119

    4.4.2 ...................................... 123

    4.4.3 .............................................. 126

    4.5 ........................................................................ 131

    4.5.1 .................................................................................................... 131

    4.6 ............................ 142

    4.6.1 .............................................. 143

    4.6.2 ............................................................ 146

    4.6.3 .................................... 148

    4.6.4

    .................................................................................................................................. 152

    4.6.5 153

    4.7 ............. 156

    4.7.1 ............................................ 156

  • 4

    ......................................................................................................................................... 163

    4.7.2 ....................................................................................................... 164

    5 ................................................................ 181

    5.1. ................................................................................................................................... 181

    5.1.1 ............................................................................ 181

    5.1.2 ..................................................................... 194

    5.2 ................................................................................................... 195

    5.2.1 ................................................................................................................................. 195

    5.2.2 ................................................................................................................................. 195

    5.2.3 .............................................................................................................................. 196

    5.2.4 ............................................................................................................ 197

    5.2.5 ................................................................................................................ 198

    5.2.6 ............................................................................................................................ 199

    5.2.7 ................................................................................................................... 199

    5.3 ........................................................................................................ 200

    5.3.1 ................................................................................. 200

    5.3.2 .................................................................. 201

    5.3.3 ................................................................................................... 201

    5.4 .. 2540

    ................................................................................................................................................. 202

    5.4.1 .......................................................................................... 202

    5.4.2 ...................................... 207

    5.4.3 .............................................. 211

    5.5 ........................................................................ 217

  • 5

    5.5.1 .................................................................................................... 217

    5.5.2 ............................................... 223

    5.5.3 ...................... 225

    5.5.4 ......................................... 227

    5.6 ............................ 228

    5.6.1 .............................................. 228

    5.6.2 ............................................................ 231

    5.6.3 .................................... 233

    5.6.4

    .................................................................................................................................. 235

    5.6.5 236

    5.7. ............ 239

    5.7.1 .......................................................................................................... 239

    5.7.2 ......................................................................................................... 241

    6.1 .................................................................................................................................... 245

    6.1.1 ................................................................................................. 245

    6.1.2 .......................................................................................... 248

    6.2. .................................................................................................. 248

    6.2.1 ................................................................................................................................. 249

    6.2.3 .............................................................................................................................. 250

    6.2.4 ............................................................................................................ 250

    6.2.5 ................................................................................................................ 251

    6.2.6 ............................................................................................................................. 252

  • 6

    6.2.7 ................................................................................................................... 253

    6.3 ........................................................................................................ 253

    6.3.1 ................................................................................. 253

    6.3.2 .................................................................. 254

    6.3.3 ................................................................................................... 254

    6.4 .. 2540

    ................................................................................................................................................. 255

    6.4.1 .......................................................................................... 255

    6.4.2 ...................................... 260

    6.4.3 .............................................. 262

    6.5. ........................................................................ 267

    6.5.1 .................................................................................................... 268

    6.5.2 ............................................... 274

    6.5.3 ...................... 276

    6.5.4 .......................................... 277

    6.6 ............................. 278

    6.6.1 .............................................. 278

    6.6.2 ............................................................. 279

    6.6.3 ..................................... 280

    6.6.4

    .................................................................................................................................. 282

    6.6.5 283

    6.7 ............. 284

    6.7.2 .......................................................................................................... 284

  • 7

    6.7.2 ......................................................................................................... 286

    7 ........................................................................................ 291

    7.1 .................................................................................................................................... 291

    7.1.1 ..................................................................................................... 291

    7.1.2 ............................................................................................. 293

    7.2. ........................................................................................ 294

    7.2.1 ................................................................................................................................. 294

    7.2.2 ................................................................................................................................. 295

    7.2.3 .............................................................................................................................. 295

    7.2.4 ............................................................................................................ 296

    7.2.5 ................................................................................................................ 297

    7.2.6 ............................................................................................................................. 298

    7.2.7 ................................................................................................................... 298

    7.3. ........................................................................................................ 299

    7.3.1 ................................................................................. 299

    7.3.2 .................................................................. 299

    7.3.3 ................................................................................................... 300

    7.4 .. 2540

    ................................................................................................................................................. 301

    7.4.1 .......................................................................................... 301

    7.4.2 ...................................... 306

    7.4.3 .............................................. 309

    7.5 ........................................................................ 314

    7.5.1 .................................................................................................... 314

  • 8

    7.5.2 ............................................... 321

    7.5.3 ...................... 323

    7.5.4 ......................................... 325

    7.6 ............................ 326

    7.6.1 .............................................. 327

    7.6.2 ............................................................ 328

    7.6.3 .................................... 329

    7.6.4

    .................................................................................................................................. 330

    7.6.5 331

    7.7 ............. 333

    7.7.1 .......................................................................................................... 333

    7.7.2 ...................................................................... 335

    8 ................................................................................... 340

    8.1 .................................................................................................................................... 340

    8.1.1 .................................................................................................................... 340

    8.1.2 ......................................................................................... 368

    8.2 .................................................................................................. 370

    8.2.1 ................................................................................................................................. 370

    8.2.2 ................................................................................................................................. 371

    8.2.3 .............................................................................................................................. 371

    8.2.4 ............................................................................................................ 373

    8.2.5 ................................................................................................................ 374

  • 9

    8.2.6 ............................................................................................................................. 375

    8.2.7 ................................................................................................................... 375

    8.3 ........................................................................................................ 376

    8.3.1 ................................................................................. 376

    8.3.2 .................................................................. 377

    8.3.3 ................................................................................................... 377

    8.4. .. 2540

    ................................................................................................................................................. 378

    8.4.1 .......................................................................................... 378

    8.4.2 ...................................... 382

    8.4.3 .............................................. 385

    8.5 ........................................................................ 391

    8.5.1 .................................................................................................... 391

    8.5.2 ............................................... 398

    8.5.3 ...................... 402

    8.5.4 ......................................... 403

    8.6 ............................ 404

    8.6.1 .............................................. 404

    8.6.2 ............................................................ 406

    8.6.3 .................................... 408

    8.6.4

    .................................................................................................................................. 410

    8.6.5 411

    8.7 ............. 412

  • 10 9 ............................................................................................. 419

    9.1 ................................................................................................................................... 419

    9.2 .................................................................................................. 419

    9.2.1 ................................................................................................................................. 419

    9.2.2 ................................................................................................................................. 420

    9.2.3 .............................................................................................................................. 421

    9.2.4 ............................................................................................................ 422

    9.2.5 ................................................................................................................ 423

    9.2.6 ............................................................................................................................. 424

    9.2.7 ................................................................................................................... 424

    9.3. ........................................................................................................ 425

    9.3.1 ................................................................................. 425

    9.3.2 .................................................................. 426

    9.3.3 ................................................................................................... 427

    9.4 .. 2540

    ................................................................................................................................................. 428

    9.4.1 .......................................................................................... 428

    9.4.2 ...................................... 433

    9.4.3 .............................................. 437

    9.5 ........................................................................ 445

    9.6 ............................ 446

    9.6.1 .............................................. 446

    9.6.2 ............................................................ 447

    9.6.3 .................................... 448

  • 11

    9.6.4

    .................................................................................................................................. 449

    9.6.5 450

    9.7 ............. 451

    9.7.1 ........................................................................................................ 451

    9.7.2 ....................................................................................................... 453

    10 ............................................................................................................................ 457

    10.1 ................................................................................................................................ 457

    10.1 ........................................................................................................................ 460

    10.1.1 1.

    ..................................................................................................................... 460

    10.2.2 2

    .............................................................................................. 467

    10.3 .................................................................................................................................... 467

    ................................................................................................................................... 468

  • 12 1 ........................................................... 85 2 ............................................................ 102 3 ...................................... 112 4 ...................................... 113 5 ............................................................. 113 6 ................................... 114 7 ...................... 115 8 .................................. 116 9 ........................ 117 10 ..... 117 11 ............... 118 12 ...... 118 13 ............ 120 14 ..................... 122 15 ..................................................................................................... 124 16 .................................................................................................................................... 125 17 ............. 126 18 ...................................................................................................................... 127 19 ...................................................................................................................... 129 20 ...................................................................................................................... 130 21 .............................. 132 22 .................................... 133 23 ................................... 134

  • 13 24 ......................................... 135 25 .................................. 136 26 ............................... 137 27 .......... 138 28 ............... 139 29 ............................................................................................. 141 30 ...................................................................................................................... 142 31 ...................................................................................................................... 143 32 ...................................................................................................................... 146 33 ....................................................................................................... 148 34 .......................................... 152 35 .................................................................................. 153 36 .......................................... 163 37 ......................................... 178 38 .. 2552 ........................................................................................ 182 39 2551 ......................................... 184 40

    2531 .. 2550 2552 ( ) ...... 185

  • 14 41 6 2544 6 2548 23 2550 .................................................................................................................................... 187 42 6 2544 6 2548 23 2550 .......................................................................... 188 43 19 .. 2550 ............................................................................ 191 44 ............... 195 45 .............. 195 46 ............. 196 47 ............ 198 48 199 49 ........... 199 50 .. 200 51 .. 200 52 .................................................................................................................................... 201 53 ....................................................................................................... 202 54 ....................................................................................................... 204 55 206 56 ................................................................................ 208 57 ....................................................................................................... 210

  • 15 58 ....................................................................................................... 212 59 ....................................................................................................... 213 60 ....................................................................................................... 215 61 ................................................................................................. 216 62 ..... 218 63 ...... 219 64 ......... 220 65 ............... 221 66 ........ 222 67 .................................................................................................................................... 223 68 .................................................................................................................................... 224 69 ....................................................................................................... 225 70 ................................................ 226 71 ....................................................................................................... 228 72 ............................................................................................ 231 73 ....................................................................................................... 232

  • 16 74 .............................................................. 234 75 ............................... 236 76 ............................................. 238 77 ................. 240 78 ................ 243 79 .................................... 249 80 .................................... 249 81 .................................. 250 82 ... 251 83 .................... 252 84 ...................... 253 85 .............................................. 253 86 ............................... 254 87 ..................... 255 88 ................................................................................ 256 89 ............................................................................................................... 259 90 ........................................................... 260 91 .................................................................................................................................... 262 92 ............. 263 93 .. ................................ 292 94 ........................................ 294

  • 17 95 ........................................ 295 96 ...................................... 295 97 ................................ 296 98 ................... 297 99 .................................... 298 100 ........................ 298 101 ....... 299 102 ........... 300 103 .................................................................................................. 301 104 .............. 302 105 ....................... 305 106 ......................................................................................................... 306 107 . 308 108 ............... 309 109 ............ 310 110 .......................................................................................................................... 311 111 ............................................................................................................. 313 112 ................................. 315 113 ...................................... 316 114 ..................................... 317 115 ......................... 318 116 .................................... 319 117 ................................. 320 118 .......................... 322

  • 18 119 ................. 323 120 .................................................................................. 324 121 ................................ 326 122 .......................................................................................................................... 327 123 .... 329 124 .... 330 125 ............................................................. 331 126 ........................................................................... 332 127 ............................................ 334 128 ............................................ 337 129 .............. 341 130 29 .. 2553 .................................................................................................................................... 350 131 .. 2551-2554 ..... 357 132 GROSS PROVINCIAL PRODUCT AT CURRENT MARKET PRICES 2002-2008 ............................................................................................................................ 358 133 .................................................................................................................................... 362 134 23 .. 2550 ............................................................................................................................ 364 135 .................................................................................................................... 364 136 .............................. 369 137 ................................... 371 138 ..................................... 371

  • 19 139 ................................... 372 140 ................................ 373 141 ................... 374 142 ............................... 375 143 ....................... 375 144 .... 376 145 ...... 377 146 .................. 378 147 ............. 379 148 ...................... 381 149 ...................................................................................................... 383 150 .................................................................................................................................... 385 151 ................. 386 152 ....................................................................................................................... 387 153 ....................................................................................................................... 388 154 ....................................................................................................................... 390 155 ........................... 392 156 ................................... 393 157 ................................... 394 158 ..................................... 395 159 ............................ 397 160 .............................. 398

  • 20 161 ....................................................................................................................... 399 162 .............. 401 163 ............................................................................... 402 164 ....... 404 165 ....................................................................................................................... 406 166 .................................................................................................................................... 407 167 .......................................................................................................... 409 168 ............................................................ 410 169 .......................................................................... 411 170 ................................................ 413 171 ............................................... 416 172 .................................................... 420 173 ................................................... 420 174 ................................................. 421 175 ................... 422 176 .................................... 423 177 ............................................... 424 178 ...................................... 425 179 ...................... 425 180 ..................... 426

  • 21 181 ............................................................................................................... 427 182 ........................... 429 183 .................................... 432 184 .............. 436 185 ............................. 437 186 ....... 439 187 ... 440 188 .................................................................................................................................... 442 189 ..................................... 443 190 .............................. 445 191 .................................................................................................................................... 447 192 ............. 448 193 ......................................................................................................................... 449 194 .......................................................................... 449 195 ........................................................................................ 450 196 ...................................................................................... 452 197 ...................................................................................... 454

  • 22

    1. 2.

    1. 2. 3. ? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

    ( 70.5) ( 63.75)

    ()

  • 23

    2

    ,

  • 24

    .. 2535 (Constitutionalism) .. 2539 .. 2540

    () .. 2550 (constitutionalism) (rationalized parliamentary system)

    1. 2. 3.

    8

  • 25 11 .. 2543 1. 2. 3. 4.

    (classical parliamentary system) (rationalized parliamentary system) . 1. 2. 3. 4.

  • 26 5.

    2

    1.

    1.1

    1.1.1

    3.02

    75.5

    (3.62 90.5)

  • 27

    3.05 76.25

    1

    ()

  • 28

    1.1.2

    3.00 75

    ( )

    2.67 68

  • 29

    1.2.3

    4 1.

    2.

    3.

    4. 4

    .. 2550 .. 2540

    2550

  • 30

    1.

    2. 3.

    ?

    1. 2.

    3. 4.

    5.

    1.2

    (

    70.5) ( 63.75)

    1.3

    5

  • 31

    1.

    2.

    ..

    3.

    8

    4.

    5.

    4

  • 32

    (

    )

    1.2.2

    ,

  • 33

    1

    1.1

    .. 2475 .. 2516 .. 2535

    2530 ( ,2551) .. 2535 (Constitutionalism) .. 2539 .. 2540

    21 .. 2535 1.1 (.) . .. 2538 ( ,

  • 34 2545) 26 .. 2538 1.1.2 211 (.) 2539 12 ( 112 211 )

    11 2539 ... 1.1 ... 1.2 ... (.) 99 1 76 8 8 7 23 26 2539

  • 35 ( , 2540; , 2551)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    1 19 .. 2549 () .. 2549 .. 2550

  • 36

    3

    1.2

    1.2.1

    1.

    2.

    3.

    1.2.2

  • 37 1.3

    1.3.1

    1.

    2.

    3.

    1.3.2

    1.4

    1

    1.

    2.

    2.1

    2.2

    2.3

    3.

    3.1

  • 38 3.2

    3.3

    3.4

    4.

    4.1

    4.2

    4.3

    4.4

    4.5

    1.5

    () .. 2550 (constitutionalism) (rationalized parliamentary system)

  • 39

    1.

    2.

    3.

    8 11 .. 2543

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

  • 40

    (classical parliamentary system) (rationalized parliamentary system) .

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    1.6

    (., 2540) (, 2538) (, 2538)

  • 41 (Rationalized Parliamentary) (, 2538)

    (self-determination)

    .. 2540

  • 42

    1.7

    500 5 .. 2553

    1.8

    1.9

  • 43

    2

    2.1

    (.) () 2550

    (., 2540) (, 2538) (, 2538) (Rationalized

  • 44 Parliamentary) (, 2538) ( , 2540) ( , 2543) 3

    2.1.1

    19

    2.1.2

  • 45

    2.1.3

    .. 2538 (constitutionalism) .

    2.2 (constitutionalism)

    2.2.1

    (Constitutionalism): (2537) .. 2540

  • 46 (.)

    (dualism)

    (monism)

    1.

  • 47

    2.

    3.

    (rationalized parliamentary system) (constitutionalism)

    2.2.2

    1.

  • 48

    2.

    3.

    (.) (constitutionalism) (, 2538)

    ()

    2.3

    2.3.1

    (2538) (.)

    .

  • 49

    . ( 5) 2538 211 .

    .

    2.3.2

    .

    ()

  • 50

  • 51 2.3.3

    . . (, 2538)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    2.3.4

    2.3.4.1

  • 52

    .. 2534

    2.3.4.2

    .. 2492 .. 2511 .. 2534

  • 53

    1) 9

  • 54

    2) impeachment (...) 9

    3) .. 2534 ( 5) .. 2538

  • 55

    4)

    5)

    6) (ombudsman)

    .. 2540 8 8

  • 56 2.3.4.3

    . (classical parliamentary system) (rationalized parliamentary system) .

    .. 2517

    ()

    ( ) (rationalized parliamentary system)

    .

  • 57

    1) .

    . (3 ) 200,000 .. 1 .. (single member constituency) ( ) 35 100 ()

  • 58 ( )

    ()

    (2 )

    .

    2)

  • 59 .. .. .. .. 2521 2534 .. ..

    3)

    .

    .. 100

  • 60

    4)

    ..

    .. 1 5 114

    4 . ( , 2538)

    1.

  • 61

    2.

    3.

    1

    (.. )

    ..

    5)

  • 62

    .

    .

    .. 45 10 ()

    (legislative emergency)

    1

  • 63 .. 1 5 ..

    6)

    2 3 1 3 1 3 1 3

    2.4

    (2545) 3

  • 64 2.4.1

    .. 2540 .. 2534 30 53

    (1)

    . ( 4, 26 28)

    . ( 31) 48 ( 237)

    . ( 34) ( 53) ( 80)

    . ( 38) ( 73)

    . ( 244-245) ( 245)

    . ( 241) ( 256)

    . ( 57)

  • 65

    . ( 46 71) ( 290) ( 56 )

    . ( 56 79)

    (2)

    . ( 5) ( 30)

    . ( 5, 30)

    . ( 29 ) 1 3 ( 190)

    . 1 1 ( 99, 102) ( 105 )

    . 2 ( 109 (8) (11) 126 (4) 335 (7) ( 118 (7) 127 204)

  • 66 2.4.2

    (1)

    . ( 27) ( 26)

    . ( 29)

    . ( 28) ( )

    . ( 56 )

    . ( 197) ( 200) ( 197 264) ( 276)

  • 67 ( 264) .. .. ( 262) ( 266) ( 198)

    (2)

    . ( 71, 72) ( 73) ( 76) ( 78) ( 84) ( 85) ( 86) ( 87)

    . 3

    - ( 88)

    - ( 89)

    - 50,000 ( 170)

    2.4.3

    (1)

  • 68 1 ( 121,123)

    .. 1 ( 126 (1) (2))

    . 1 ( 127)

    . .. 1 ..

    .

    . .. 1 ..

    ( 138) ( 296) ( 199) ( 255) ( 277) ... ( 197)

    (2)

    - ( 56)

  • 69

    - ( 57)

    - ( 89)

    - ( 145 327 (7))

    - ( 199) ( 190)

    (3)

    ( 282-290)

    .

    . ( 56 57)

    (4)

  • 70

    . ( 58) ( 60)

    . ( 59)

    . 50,000 ( 170) ( 214)

    . ( 46 79)

    . 50,000 .. .. ( 303,304) ...

    2.5

    2.5.1 : . 11 .. 2543

    2540

  • 71 7 3 4 1) 2) 3) 4)

    1) . 2534

    2)

    3)

    4)

    5.)

    6)

  • 72 2.5.2 11 .. 2543

    .. 2540 8 (.) (.)

    1)

    2)

    3)

    4)

    5)

  • 73 5

    2.5.3 ( ) ( , 2546)

    ..2540 2,000 42 4

    2.5.3.1

    47.7 52.3 90 90 83

  • 74 80 ( ) 90

    90 80 90 80 70 60 80 68 28 38 47-48 10 2

  • 75

    2.5.3.2

    63% 9.5 28.3 38.2 6.3 48.6 47.4 3 61.2 50.4

  • 76 47.3 2.3 4

    2.5.3.3

    70 5 ( 81.3) (76.6) ( 75.2) ( 66.7) ( 66.7) 5 () 30

  • 77 3 20 24.5 22.8 22.0 87.4 84.4 79.6 76.1 77.1 74.3 88.5 84.7 94 92.3 81.8 79.7 79.4 75.4 90

    2.5.3.4

  • 78

    74.4 63.0 56.4 6.0 51.6 25.1 25.3 26.2 52.3 46.1 40.1 38.6 (...) 38.4 50 52.3 18.3 19.9 (...) 21.1 22.1 85.3 80.0 79.7 75.0 74.3 (...) 66.8 72.4 (...) 72.5

    2.5.3.5

  • 79 - -

  • 80

    2.5.3.6

  • 81

    (1)

    (1.1) /

    (1.2) / ..2540

    (1.3)

    (2)

  • 82

    (3)

    (4)

    (5)

    (5.1) (5.2)

    (6)

    2.6

    2.6.1

  • 83 2.6.2 .. 2540 ( , 2545)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    2.6.3 8 11 .. 2543

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    2.6.4

  • 84 (classical parliamentary system) (rationalized parliamentary system) .

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

  • 85

    3

    3.1

    (Quantitative Study)

    3.2

    500 ( 18 )

    1

    (*5)

    67,096,390 100 500 500

    6,868,484 10.23 51.18371 51

    ( .) 15,934,817 23.74 118.7457 119

    12,152,660 18.11 90.56121 91

    22,821,815 34.01 170.0674 170

    9,318,614 13.88 69.44199 69

  • 86

    3.3

    (Questionnaire) 4

    1 (close and open-end)

    1. ( )

    2. ( )

    3. ( )

    4. ( )

    5. ( )

    6 ( )

    7. ( )

    8. ( )

    2

    1. ( 2.1)

    2.1

  • 87

    2. ( 2.2)

    2.2

    3. ( 2.3)

    2.3

    3 .. 2540 .. 2540

    1.

    (1) 11

    1. 1.

    2. 48

    2.

    3.

    3.

    4.

    4.

  • 88

    5.

    5.

    6. 6.

    7.

    7.

    8.

    8.

    9.

    9.

    10.

    10.

    11.

    11.

  • 89

    (2) 4

    1.

    1.

    2. 2.

    3. 1 3

    3.

    4. 1 1

    4.

    2.

    (1) 5

  • 90

    1.

    1.

    2.

    2.

    3.

    3.

    4.

    4.

    5.

    5.

    (2) 4

    1.

    1.

    2.

    2.

  • 91

    3. 50,000

    3. 50,000

    3.

    (1) 2

    1. 1. .. 2540

    2. (2550) (2540)

    (2) 4

    1.

    1.

    2.

    2.

  • 92

    3.

    3.

    4.

    4.

    (3) 3

    1.

    1.

    2.

    2.

    3.

    3.

  • 93

    (4) 4

    1.

    1.

    2.

    2.

    3. 50,000

    3.

    4.

    4.

    4 8

  • 94

    1.

    1.1

    :

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    1.2

    : ()

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

  • 95 1.3

    :

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    1.4.

    :

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

  • 96 1.5.

    :

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    1.6

    :

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    2.

    2.1

  • 97

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    2.2

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    3.

    1.

  • 98

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    5 4

    1. 3

    1. ..

    2.

    3.

    2. 3

    1.

    2.

    3. ..

  • 99 3. 3

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4. 2

    1.

    2.

    5. 3

    1.

    2.

    3.

    6

    1.

    1.

  • 100

    2.

    3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.

    9.

    2.

    1.

    2. 3. 4.

    5. 6. 7.

    8. 9.

    10. 11.

  • 101

    12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19.

    3.4

    1.

    2.

    3.5

    3.5.1

    (pre-test) 50 3

  • 102 ( 18 )

    (objectivity)

    3.5.2

    (reliability test) (alpha) 0.70 (Fraenkel R. Jack& Wallen E Norman, 1993)

    2

    0.917

    0.987

    0.748

    0.874

    ()

  • 103 3.6

    3.6.1

    3.6.2

    3.6.3

    3.6.4

    3.6.5

  • 104

    4

    4.1

    4.1.1

    4.1.1.1

    17 ..2552 11,770,233 5,806,550 5,963,683 1,632,548 241,847 ..2552 5 (..2548 2552) ..2552 3.0

    4.1.1.2

  • 105 (: )

    (Gross Regional Product: GRP) ..2552 862,657 9.5 (GDP) (132,098 ) (11,062 ) ..2552 71,105 135,281 159,537 47,752 15,727 20,904 (20,048 ) (7,936 )

    4.1.1.3

    23 ..2550 10 5 88.90 .. 1

  • 106 80.40

    4.1.1.4 .. 10

    ... .. 2541 6 ..2544 .. 52 17 6 2548 70 .. 17 5 ..2548 .. 377

    .. ... ...

  • 107 ... ..2544 1 30 ..2548 .. ... ...

    4.1.1.5 19 2549

    19 ..2549 (.) ... (.) () .. 2549 34

  • 108 ... 3

    1. ... ...

    2. ...

    3.

    .. 2540 () .. 2549 (.) 2550 19 ..2550 25,978,954 45,092,955 57.81 42.19 2550 18

  • 109 ... ... ... 5 ..2549 ... (.) . 51

    ... 23 ..2550 .. 233 ...

  • 110 ... .. 77 .. () 45 .. .. ...

    ... ... () .. .. ... .

  • 111

    4.1.2

    17

    1. 2. 3.

  • 112 3

    4.2.

    4.2.1

    42 49 46.2 53.8

    3

    49 53.8

    42 46.2

    91 100

    4.2.2

    29 43 30-39 32 40-49 10

  • 113 50-59 5 60 1 47.3 , 35.2 , 11 , 5.5 , 1.1

    4

    29 43 47.3

    30-39 32 35.2

    40-49 10 11

    50-59 5 5.5

    60 1 1.1

    91 100

    4.2.3

    5

    4 4.4

    / 15 16.5

  • 114

    (NGOs) 1 1.1

    7 7.7

    // 19 20.9

    / 1 1.1

    5 5.5

    / 25 27.5

    / 9 9.9

    - -

    5 5.5

    - -

    - -

    91 100

    4.2.4

    6,001-12,000 6,000 ..2552 71,105 6,000

    6

  • 115

    6,000 28 30.8

    6,001-12,000 38 41.8

    12,001-18,000 14 15.4

    18,000 24,000 5 5.5

    24,000 30,000 4 4.4

    30,000 50,000 2 2.2

    50,000 85,000 - -

    85,000 - -

    91 100

    4.2.5

    .

    7

    2 2.2

    3 3.3

    3 3.3

    2 2.2

  • 116

    /. 19 20.9

    /./. 12 13.2

    44 48.4

    5 5.5

    1 1.1

    91 100

    4.2.6

    89 97.8 94.7

    8

    89 97.8

    - -

    2 2.2

    - -

    91 100

    4.2.7

    34 37.4 29 31.9

  • 117 9

    4 4.4

    24 26.4

    34 37.4

    29 31.9

    / - -

    91 100

    4.3

    4.3.1

    72 79.1

    10

    1. 9 9.9

    2. - -

    3. 72 79.1

    4. 1 1.1

    5. - -

  • 118

    6. 9 9.9

    91 100

    4.3.2

    66 72.5

    11

    1. 66 72.5

    2. 2-3 19 20.9

    3. 4 4.4

    4. 2 2.2

    91 100

    4.3.3

    64 70.3

    12

  • 119

    1. 12 13.2

    2. 1 1.1

    3. 64 70.3

    4. 5 5.5

    5. - -

    6. 9 9.9

    91 100

    4.4 .. 2540

    ..2540 3 1. 2. 3.

    4.4.1

    4.4.1.1

    1. () 2 2. 48 3 1. 9.

  • 120 11.

    2. () 2 6. 5.

    3. (+) 74.0 (+) 26 48

    13

    ()

    (means)

    1. 17.6 54.9 19.8 7.7 2.82

    2. 48

    18.7 50.5 22.0 8.8 2.79

    3.

    23.1 51.6 23.1 2.2 2.95

    4. 37.4 59.3 2.2 1.1 3.32

  • 121

    5.

    50.5 38.5 11.0 - 3.39

    6.

    59.3 34.1 5.5 1.1 3.51

    7.

    15.4 56.0 25.3 3.3 2.83

    8.

    26.4 47.3 23.1 3.3 2.96

    9.

    2.2 44.0 46.2 7.7 2.40

    10.

    4.4 56.0 35.2 4.4 2.60

  • 122

    4.4.1.2

    1. () 1. 3. 1 3

    2. () 2.

    3. (+) 73.6 (+) 26.4 47.2

    14

    11.

    12.1 54.9 25.3 7.7 2.71

    24.3 49.7 21.7 4.3 2.93

  • 123

    1.

    8.8 54.9 31.9 4.4 2.68

    2. 34.1 45.1 19.8 1.1 3.12

    3. 1 3

    12.1 53.8 29.7 4.4 2.73

    4. 1 1

    30.8 54.9 11.0 3.3 3.13

    21.4 52.2 23.1 3.3 2.91

    4.4.2

    4.4.2.1

    1. () 3.

    2. () 2

  • 124 3. (+) 75.8 (+) 24.2 51.6

    15

    1.

    8.8 57.1 31.9 2.2 2.72

    2.

    27.5 52.7 19.8 - 3.07

    3.

    22.0 57.1 16.5 4.4 2.96

    4.

    26.4 46.2 24.2 3.3 2.95

  • 125

    5.

    19.8 61.5 16.5 2.2 2.98

    20.9 54.9 21.8 2.4 2.93

    4.4.2.2

    1. () 1.

    2. () 3. 50,000

    3. (+) 65.5 (+) 34.5 31 16

    1.

    5.5 47.3 40.7 6.6 2.51

  • 126

    2.

    7.7 57.1 30.8 4.4 2.68

    3. 50,000

    16.5 62.6 20.9 - 2.95

    9.9 55.6 30.8 3.7 2.71

    4.4.3

    4.4.3.1

    .. 2540 .. 2540 .. 2550

    17

    1 . .. 2540

    7.7 56.0 26.4 9.9 2.61

  • 127

    2. .. 2550

    6.6 39.6 44.0 9.9 2.42

    4.4.3.2

    1. () 1. 2.

    2. () 3.

    3. (+) 61.82 (+) 38.18 23.64

    18

    1 .

    9.9 37.4 42.9 9.9 2.47

  • 128

    2.

    5.5 38.5 46.2 9.9 2.39

    3.

    22.0 61.5 14.3 2.2 2.51

    4.

    12.1 60.4 23.1 4.4 2.80

    12.37 49.45 31.62 6.56 2.54

    4.4.3.3

    1. () 3 1. 2. 3.

    2. () 3.

  • 129 3. (+) 82 (+) 18 64

    19

    1.

    9.9 72.5 15.4 2.2 2.90

    2.

    14.3 65.9 17.6 2.2 2.92

    3.

    22.0 61.5 14.3 2.2 3.03

    15.4 66.6 15.76 2.24 2.95

  • 130

    4.4.3.4

    1. () 4.

    2. () 3. 50,000

    3. (+) 62.64 (+) 37.4 25.24 20

    1.

    6.6 49.5 39.6 4.4 2.58

    2.

    15.4 51.6 28.6 4.4 2.78

  • 131

    3. 50,000

    16.5 52.7 24.2 6.6 2.79

    4.

    11.0 47.3 28.6 13.2 2.56

    12.4 50.3 30.2 7.1 2.67

    4.5

    8

    4.5.1

    4.5.1.1

    3 (2546)

  • 132 52.3 46.1 40.1 38.6 21

    1. 3.3 51.6 36.3 8.8 2.49

    2. 4.4 57.1 29.7 8.8 2.57

    3. 6.6 53.8 29.7 9.9 2.57

    4. 13.2 63.7 16.5 6.6 2.83

    5. 16.5 64.8 16.5 2.2 2.95

    6. 13.2 70.3 13.2 3.3 2.93

    7.

    8.8 37.4 37.4 16.5 2.38

    8. 5.5 42.9 37.4 14.3 2.39

    8.9 55.2 27.1 8.8 2.63

    4.5.1.2

    3

  • 133

    22

    1. 2.2 45.1 42.9 9.9 2.39

    2. 4.4 50.5 34.1 11.0 2.48

    3. 4.4 50.5 33.0 12.1 2.47

    4. 9.9 62.6 23.1 4.4 2.78

    5. 11.0 68.1 18.7 2.2 2.87

    6. 12.1 63.7 22.0 2.2 2.85

    7.

    5.5 39.6 40.7 14.3 2.36

    8. 5.5 45.1 35.2 14.3 2.41

    6.9 53.1 31.2 8.8 2.57

    4.5.1.3

    2 2

  • 134

    23

    1. 4.4 39.6 39.6 16.5 2.31

    2. 1.1 49.5 33.0 16.5 2.35

    3. 4.4 47.3 33.0 15.4 2.40

    4. 8.8 53.8 30.8 6.6 2.64

    5. 6.6 57.1 29.7 6.6 2.63

    6. 7.7 58.2 28.6 5.5 2.68

    7 .

    4.4 34.1 42.9 18.7 2.24

    8. 4.4 36.3 39.6 19.8 2.25

    5.22 46.98 34.6 13.2 2.43

  • 135 4.5.1.4

    2 3 ..2549

    24

    1. 4.4 41.8 40.7 13.2 2.37

    2. 3.3 50.5 33.0 13.2 2.43

    3. 5.5 46.2 35.2 13.2 2.43

    4. 8.8 59.3 28.6 3.3 2.73

    5. 6.6 64.8 26.4 2.2 2.75

    6. 8.8 63.7 25.3 2.2 2.79

    7 .

    4.4 33.0 45.1 17.6 2.24

  • 136

    8. 5.5 38.5 37.4 18.7 2.30

    5.9 49.7 34.0 10.4 2.50

    4.5.1.5

    2

    25

    1. 6.6 51.6 33.0 8.8 2.56

    2. 1.1 47.3 40.7 11.0 2.38

    3. 5.5 52.7 33.0 8.8 2.54

  • 137

    4. 4.4 58.2 29.7 7.7 2.59

    5. 4.4 58.2 29.7 7.7 2.59

    6. 6.6 56.0 31.9 5.5 2.63

    7 .

    5.5 36.3 46.2 12.1 2.35

    8. 2.2 40.7 42.9 14.3 2.30

    4.53 50.12 35.9 9.5 2.49

    4.5.1.6

    2 3 26

    1. 2.2 52.7 37.4 7.7 2.49

    2. 1.1 51.6 37.4 9.9 2.43

    3. 6.6 49.5 31.9 12.1 2.50

  • 138

    4. 5.5 69.2 18.7 6.6 2.73

    5. 7.7 75.8 13.2 3.3 2.87

    6. 9.9 74.7 13.2 2.2 2.92

    7 .

    4.4 40.7 42.9 12.1 2.37

    8. 4.4 39.6 44.0 12.1 2.36

    5.2 56.7 29.8 8.3 2.58

    4.5.2

    4.5.2.1

    2

    27

  • 139

    1. 5.5 59.3 29.7 5.5 2.64

    2. 4.4 61.5 27.5 6.6 2.63

    3. 9.9 53.8 28.6 7.7 2.65

    4. 8.8 73.6 16.5 1.1 2.90

    5. 13.2 70.3 15.4 1.1 2.95

    6. 13.2 73.6 11.0 2.2 2.97

    7 .

    7.7 41.8 39.6 11.0 2.46

    8. 4.4 46.2 38.5 11.0 2.43

    8.4 60.0 25.8 5.8 2.70

    4.5.2.2

    ( (2546) 28

  • 140

    1. 3.3 41.8 42.9 12.1 2.36

    2. 3.3 53.8 29.7 13.2 2.47

    3. 3.3 49.5 37.4 9.9 2.46

    4. 4.4 65.9 24.2 5.5 2.69

    5. 8.8 65.9 20.9 4.4 2.79

    6. 5.5 69.2 19.8 5.5 2.74

    7 .

    2.2 38.5 48.4 11.0 2.31

    8. 1.1 42.9 44.0 12.1 2.32

    4.0 53.4 33.4 9.2 2.51

    4.5.3

    4.5.3.1

    2

  • 141

    29

    1. 7.7 50.5 34.1 7.7 2.58

    2. 2.2 52.7 35.2 9.9 2.47

    3. 4.4 58.2 27.5 9.9 2.57

    4. 8.8 71.4 16.5 3.3 2.85

    5. 13.2 68.1 15.4 3.3 2.91

    6. 12.1 68.1 17.6 2.2 2.90

    7 .

    2.2 42.9 45.1 9.9 2.37

    8. 1.1 46.2 42.9 9.9 2.38

    6.5 57.3 29.2 7.0 2.62

    4.5.4

  • 142

    8 2.82 2.81

    4.6

    .. 2540

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5. 6.

    7.

    8.

    2.46 2.46 2.51 2.74 2.81 2.82 2.34 2.34

    0

    0.5

    1

    1.5

    2

    2.5

    3

    30

  • 143 .. 2540

    4.6.1

    31

    1.

    6.6 36.3 47.3 9.9 2.39

    2.

    3.3 36.3 53.8 6.6 2.36

    3.

    2.2 51.6 39.6 6.6 2.49

    4.0 41.4 46.9 7.7 2.41

    1. (+) 42.9 (+) 57.1 14.1

  • 144 (2546) ( ) 3 20 24.5 22.8 22

    2. (+) 39.6 (+) 60.4 20.8 (2553) () ..2548/49

  • 145 (2552) ..2548/49 20,756.98 ( 2552) 5.25 3,955.34

    3. (+) 53.8 (+) 46.2 7.6 2540 (...) ... ... .. 2541 ... ... ... ... ( , 2546)

  • 146 4.6.2 32

    1.

    6.6 39.6 45.0 8.8 2.43

    2.

    3.3 29.7 51.6 15.4 2.20

    3. ..

    1.1 37.4 42.9 18.7 2.20

    3.7 35.5 46.5 14.3 2.27

    1. (+) 46.2 (+) 53.8 7.6

  • 147 2. (+) 33 (+) 67 34 3

    3. .. (+) 38.5 (+) 61.6 23.1 .. .. .. .. .. ..

  • 148

    4.6.3 33

    1.

    4.4 30.8 46.1 18.7 2.20

    2.

    4.4 35.1 41.8 18.7 2.25

    3.

    7.7 44.0 38.5 9.9 2.49

    5.5 36.66 42.08 15.76 2.31

    1. (+) 35.2 (+) 64.8

  • 149 29.6 (Party-List Proportional Representation) ..2541 1 100 ..2550 10 8 .. 80 6 ..2544 .. 2540 (.) 2,753 6 7 2544 5 .. (: )

    1 / 35.49

    2 / 25.82

    3 17.75

  • 150 4 / 6.45

    5 4.83

    2. (+) 39.5 (+) 60.5 21 "" (Area Sampling) 5,748 15 22 ..2544 6 ..2544 (: )

    1 / 43.51

    2 31.65

    3 17.68

    4 5.24

    5 1.46

    3. (+) 51.7 (+

  • 151 ) 48.3 3.4 (2547)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    ..

  • 152 4.6.4 34

    1.

    12.1 50.5 30.8 6.6 2.68

    2.

    7.7 34.0 48.4 9.9 2.39

    9.9 42.3 39.5 8.3 2.53

    1. (+) 62.6 (+) 37.4 25.2 (, 2545)

  • 153

    2. (+) 41.7 (+) 58.3 16.4 2550 89 3

    4.6.5 35

    1.

    8.8 54.9 27.5 8.8 2.63

  • 154

    2.

    9.9 54.9 26.4 8.8 2.65

    3.

    15.4 49.5 25.3 9.9 2.70

    11.36 53.1 26.4 9.14 2.66

    1. (+) 63.7 (+) 36.3 27.4 2550 127 ( )

  • 155 ..

    2. (+) 64.8 (+) 35.2 29.6 19 ..2549 ...

    3. (+) 64.9 (+) 35.2 29.7

  • 156

    4.7

    . . 4.7.1

    1 (+) 52.8 (+) 47.2 5.6

  • 157 4 5

    2 (+) 71.4 (+) 28.6 42.8

    3 (+) 73.6 (+) 26.4 47.2 ..2550 37

  • 158 45 63

    4 (+) 67 (+) 33 34

  • 159 (+) 33

    5 (+) 83.5 (+) 16.5 67 (+) 16.5

    6 (+)

  • 160 82.4 (+) 17.6 64.8 (+) 17.6

    7 (+) 68.1 (+) 31.9 36.2 (+) 31.9

  • 161

    8 (+) 78 (+) 22 56

    9 3

  • 162 9 (+) 53.9 (+) 46.1 7.8 (+) 46.1

  • 163 36

    1

    7.7 45.1 26.3 20.9 2.39

    2

    18.7 52.7 20.9 7.7 2.82

    3

    17.6 56.0 23.1 3.3 2.87

    4

    22.0 45.0 27.5 5.5 2.83

    5

    16.5 67.0 16.5 - 3.00

    6

    13.2 69.2 15.4 2.2 2.93

    7

    14.3 53.8 29.7 2.2 2.80

    8

    13.2 64.8 22.0 - 2.91

  • 164

    9

    7.7 46.2 38.5 7.6 2.53

    14.0 55.0 24.0 7.0 2.78

    4.7.2

    1 (+) 91.2 (+) 8.8 82.4 (2552)

  • 165

    2 (+) 94.5 (+) 5.5 81

    3 (+) 93.5 (+) 6.5 87

    4 (+) 94.5 (+) 5.5 88.9

  • 166 (2549) 200 (.)

    5 (+) 79.1 (+) 20.9 58.2

  • 167

    6 (+) 71.5 (+) 28.5 43

  • 168 (2524) 28.5 19

    7 (+) 75.8 (+) 24.2 51.6 24.2 19

  • 169

    8 (+) 78 (+) 22 56

    9 (+) 89 (+) 11 78

  • 170 ..2540

    10 (+) 76.9 (+) 23.1 53.8

  • 171

    11 (+) 78 (+) 22 56

    1. (Iron Cage)

    2. (...)

    12 (+) 82.4 (+) 17.6 64.8

  • 172 19 2549 2540 2550 2540 2540 ..2542 50,000 10,000 2540

    13 (+) 97.8 (+) 2.2 95.6

  • 173 ..2534 ..2549

    14 (+) 95.6 (+) 4.4 91.2 (..)

  • 174

    15 (+) 95.6 (+) 4.4 91.2

  • 175

    16 (+) 94.5 (+) 5.5 89

  • 176

    17 (+) 90.2 (+) 9.8 88.4

    18 (+) 83.6 (+) 16.4 67.2

  • 177

    19 (+) 92.4 (+) 7.6 84.8 ... ..2550 ... .. 2548

    19 (+)

  • 178 13 97.8 14 15 95.6 (+) 6 28.5 7 24.2 (+) 19 70

    37

    1

    40.7 50.5 8.8 - 3.31

    2

    40.7 53.8 5.5 - 3.35

    3

    48.4 45.1 5.5 1.1 3.40

    4

    44.0 50.5 4.4 1.1 3.37

  • 179

    5

    24.2 54.9 17.6 3.3 3.00

    6

    23.1 48.4 24.2 4.4 2.90

    7

    25.3 50.5 19.8 4.4 2.96

    8

    23.1 54.9 15.4 6.6 2.94

    9

    18.7 70.3 8.8 2.2 3.05

    10

    18.7 58.2 22.0 1.1 2.94

    11

    27.5 50.5 20.9 1.1 3.04

    12

    26.4 56.0 15.4 2.2 3.06

    13

    53.8 44.0 1.1 1.1 3.50

    14

    44.0 51.6 3.3 1.1 3.38

  • 180

    15

    34.1 61.5 3.3 1.1 3.28

    16

    34.1 60.4 4.4 1.1 3.27

    17

    42.9 47.3 9.9 - 3.32

    18

    38.5 45.1 13.2 3.3 3.18

    19

    42.9 49.5 6.6 1.1 3.34

    34.59 52.78 11.05 1.58 3.18

  • 181

    5

    5.1.

    5.1.1

    105.5 1 3 (, 2553) -

    19 1 77

    - (, , )

    105.5 1 3 2552 21 1 12.7 0.2

    1 3 .. 2553

  • 182 1.52 4.6 900,000 3

    38 .. 2552

    21,495,825 10,729,679 10,766,146

    4,254,001 2,090,335 2,163,666

    17,241,824 8,639,344 8,602,480

    4

    2 http://www.bot.or.th/Thai/EconomicConditions/Thai/Northeast/EconomicReport/Pages/EcoStruc.aspx 3 , Retrieved from URL http://www.apecthai.org/

    apec/upload/RS230610.pdf 4 ()

    Retrieved from URL http://www2.sac.or.th/archives/2552/ethnic/Content/order.html 19 Retrieved from URL http://www.isan.clubs.chula. ac.th/webboard/index.php?transaction=post_view.php&room_no=0&id_main=1311&star=

  • 183 () () () " "5

    -

    57.9 ( ) - (GDP) 6 (Gross Regional Product: GRP) 2551 957,974

    5 2

    12 http://www.thatphanom.com/so_019.php

    6 http://www.bot.or.th/Thai/EconomicConditions/Thai/Northeast/EconomicReport/Pages/EcoStruc.aspx

  • 184 10 (Gross Domestic Product: GDP) 19.7 20.4 17.4 42,292 72,172 29,793 2 39 2551

    2551

    () ()

    188,447 19.7

    195,655 20.4

    166,222 17.4

    113,970 11.9

    65,008 6.8

    38,215 4.0

    190,457 19.8

    957,974 100.0

    2552 671 186 142 25 23 37 2 1

    2552 399,345 39 57

  • 185 4 403,677 55 19 26

    2531 .. 2550 2552 3 40 2531 .. 2550 2552 ( )

    2550 2551p 2552p

    4,256,564 4,361,396 4,263,363 1,879,259 1,911,107 1,861,388 384,749 418,922 393,817 690,373 713,291 676,093 164,347 163,375 165,502 351,343 354,288 360,416 424,552 433,186 443,719 361,942 367,228 362,428 424,552 433,186 443,719 70,222 69,607 69,336 23,576 24,616 25,431 21,047 21,260 22,186 20,596 20,885 21,809 31,613 32,076 33,221 8,865 8,994 9,374 19,477 20,164 20,808

  • 186 5,526 5,313 5,631 6,902 6,896 7,159 70,623 74,965 73,081 31,795 31,800 33,441 12,303 12,726 12,931 14,531 15,006 15,861 15,917 16,062 16,488 21,842 22,159 23,190 17,200 17,415 18,515 17,116 17,464 18,391 9,654 9,837 10,541 5,748 5,942 6,327 p

    -

    10 34 15 52 27 40 800,000 20

  • 187

    - 6 2544

    .. 2540 100 400 6 2548 .. 2540 .. 2550 480 400 80 8 10 3 4

    41 6 2544 6 2548 23 2550

    ..

    (

    )

    )(

    )(

    2544 14,805,238 68.15 2.56 2 .06 2548 15,227,466 67.66 2 .59 0 .71 2550*

    2544 14,805,238 68.14 9.78 1 .20

    2548 15,227,466 67.65 5 .68 1 .66

    2550 14,748,832 71.81 2.09 4.00

  • 188

    * .. 2550

    - .. 10

    10 3 2 6 2544 6 2548 23 2550 5

    42 6 2544 6 2548 23 2550

    6 25447 6 2548 23 2550 8 5 2 5

    10 6 6

    15

    1

    1 2

    9 91 126

    10 96

    7 21 Retrieved from URL http://www.parliament.go.th/parcy/member21/ 8 http://www.tdw.polsci.chula.ac.th/?q=party/

    9 30 2550 111 5

    10 9 25 4 1 2550 . . . .2551

  • 189 6

    6

    96

    11 18

    12

    23 2550

    49.0 32.1 1 5 18.9 12 15 19

    3 ( ) 4 ( ) 20 13 4 2 1

    .. 2540

    5

    11http://www.tdw.polsci.chula.ac.th/?q=party/%E0%B8%9E%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%84%E0%B8%A0%E0%B8%B9%E0%B8%A1%E0%B8%B4%E0%B9%83%E0%B8%88%E0%B9%84%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%A2

    12 .. Retrieved from URL http://www.thaipost.net/news/270910/27988

  • 190 2 2 13

    - 19 2549

    ... 14 3

    13 ,

    8 ( .. 2550)"" Retrieved from http://www.polsci.tu. ac.th/polsci2550/ local_government.pdf

    14 .(2548). : , ,24, (2), 99-122 . Uhlig,Harald. 1955( ).The Problem Region Northeastern Thailand. In Volker Grabowsky(Ed), Regions and National Integration in Thailand 1892-1992 (pp.130).Germany: Harrassowitz Verlag.

  • 191

    (1) 19 .. 2549 28 .. 2549 41 () 35 13 15

    (2) 19 .. 2550 .. 2550 6 1 43 19 .. 2550

    () () 57.81 49.12 36.62 61.57 51.81 45.85 66.29 31.85 86.51 11.40

    15 .. 2549 Retrieved from URL http://th.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E0%B8%A3%

    E0%B8%B1%E0%B8%90%E0%B8%9B%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B0%E0%B8%AB%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A3%E0%B9%83%E0%B8%99%E0%B8%9B%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B0%E0%B9%80%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%A8%E0%B9%84%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%A2_%E0%B8%9E.%E0%B8%A8._2549

  • 192 64.50 34.38 1 19 .. 2550

    16

    16 ,

    2550:

  • 193 (3)

    ... 17 (.)

    18 (.) 19

    8 (..2550)"" Retrieved from URL http://www.polsci.tu. ac.th/polsci2550/ local_government.pdf

    17 http://www.thzaa.com/thread-3975-1-1.html 18 .- .- Retrieved from URL

    http://www.matichon.co.th/news_detail.php?newsid=1274024863&grpid=no&catid=19 19 . 24 Retrieved from URL http://www.thairath.co.th today/ view/94084

  • 194 5.1.2

    11 8 7-10 1 5

    (1) (2) (3) (pre-test)

    (4)

    (5)

    3 (1)

    1 30 60

    (2) 15

    (3)

  • 195

    5.2

    5.2.1 90 80 47 53 - 44

    80 47.0

    90 53.0 170 100.0

    5.2.2 29 55 30-39 45 40-49 37 50-59 28 60 5 32, 26, 22 , 16 3 45

    29 55 32.0

  • 196 30-39 45 26.0 40-49 37 22.0 50-59 28 16.0 60 5 3.0 170 100.0

    5.2.3 / 38 37 22.4 21.8 // 30 17.6 / 14 8.2 / 12 7.1

    / 46

    38 22.4 / 14 8.2 (NGOs) 1 0.6 14 8.2 // 30 17.6

  • 197 / 6 3.5 5 2.9 / 37 21.8 / 12 7.1 3 1.8 3 1.8 1 0.6 6 3.5 170 100.0

    5.2.4 6,000 61 35.9 6,001-12,000 51 12,001-18,000 17 24,000 30,000 15 30,000 50,000 12 30.0, 10.0, 8.8 7.1

    ( 272,986 ) ( 6,000 ) 6,000 50,000 /

  • 198 47

    6,000 61 35.9 6,001-12,000 51 30.0 12,001-18,000 17 10.0 18,000 24,000 7 4.1 24,000 30,000 15 8.8 30,000 50,000 12 7.1 50,000 85,000 5 2.9 85,000 2 1.2 170 100.0

    5.2.5 55 32.4 /. 27 15.9 21 12.4

  • 199 48

    1 0.6 21 12.4 21 12.4 12 7.1 /. 27 15.9 /./ 17 10.0 55 32.4 14 8.2 2 1.2 170 100.0

    5.2.6 168 98.8

    2 1.2 49

    168 98.8 2 1.2 170 100.0

    5.2.7 72

    42.0 51 42 30.0 25 .0

  • 200

    50

    5 3.0 42 25.0 51 30.0 72 42.0 170 100.0

    5.3

    5.3.1

    110 64.7 33 12 10 4 1 19.4, 7.1, 5.9, 2.4 0.6 (Free TV)

    51

  • 201 1 33 19.4 2 10 5.9 3 110 64.7 4 4 2.4 5 1 0.6 6 12 7.1 170 100.0

    5.3.2

    123 72.4

    52

    1 123 72.4 2 2-3 32 18.8 3 8 4.7 4 7 4.1 170 100.0

    5.3.3

    89 52.4 38

  • 202 22 22.4 12.9

    53

    1 38 22.4 2 9 5.3 3 89 52.4 4 12 7.1 5 22 12.9 170 100.0

    5.4 .. 2540

    .. 2540 3 1. 2. 3.

    5.4.1 5.4.1.1

    () 78.03

  • 203 21.98 () () 71.2 62.4

    () 53.0 () 47.0

    ( 10 11)

  • 204

    54

    ()

    (means)

    1. 37.1 43.5 15.3 4.1 3.14 2. 48

    46.5 31.2 12.9 9.4 3.15

    3.

    41.2 41.8 11.2 5.9 3.18

    4.

    62.4 32.9 4.1 0.6 3.57

    5.

    58.2 30.0 9.4 2.4 3.44

  • 205 6.

    71.2 24.7 4.1 0.0 3.67

    7.

    27.6 41.8 24.7 5.9 2.91

    8.

    31.8 41.2 20.6 6.5 2.98

    9.

    18.2 38.2 32.9 10.6 2.64

    10.

    18.2 50.0 28.2 3.5 2.83

    11.

    25.9 44.7 22.4 7.1 2.89

  • 206 39.85 38.18 16.89 5.09 3.13

    5.4.1.2 () 78.83 () 21.18 () 1 1 57.1 53.5 1 2550 55

  • 207

    1.

    29.4 35.9 22.9 11.8 2.83

    2. 53.5 32.4 11.8 2.4 3.37 3. 1 3

    33.5 39.4 22.9 4.1 3.02

    4. 1 1

    57.1 34.1 5.9 2.9 3.45

    43.38 35.45 15.88 5.3 3.17

    5.4.2 5.4.2.1

    () 77.28 () 22.68 () 41.2 39.4

  • 208 ( ) 28.2 18.8 56

    1.

    20.6 42.9 28.2 8.2 2.76

    2. 37.1 44.1 14.1 4.7 3.14

  • 209 3.

    41.2 44.1 10.0 4.7 3.22

    4.

    39.4 37.6 18.8 4.1 3.12

    5.

    30.0 49.4 13.5 7.1 3.02

    33.66 43.62 16.92 5.76 3.05

    5.4.2.2

    () 59.27 () 40.80 () 22.4 50,000 21.8

  • 210 50,000 57

    1.

    21.8 36.5 26.5 15.3 2.65

    2.

    17.6 42.4 27.1 12.9 2.65

    3 . 50,000

    22.4 37.1 30.0 10.6 2.71

    20.6 38.67 27.87 12.93 2.67

  • 211 5.4.3

    5.4.3.1 .. 2540 .. 2540 ( 79.4) .. 2550 ( 73.6) .. 2540

  • 212 58

    1. .. 2540

    41.2 38.2 13.5 7.1 3.14

    2. .. 2550

    5.9 20.6 41.8 31.8 2.01

    5.4.3.3

    () 65.3 () 34.7 () 23.5 21.2 () 60.73 () 39.27

  • 213 59

    1.

    21.2 37.6 27.1 14.1 2.66

    2.

    18.8 32.9 32.4 15.9 2.55

    3.

    17.1 41.8 29.4 11.8 2.64

    4.

    23.5 50.0 18.2 8.2 2.89

  • 214

    20.15 40.58 26.78 12.5 2.69

    5.4.3.4

    () 78.63 () 21.37

    ( ) 40.6 37.6

  • 215 60

    1.

    21.2 47.1 24.1 7.6 2.82

    2.

    40.6 44.7 14.1 0.6 3.25

    3.

    37.6 44.7 13.5 4.1 3.16

    33.13 45.5 17.23 4.1 3.08

    5.4.3.5

    () 66.78 () 33.22

  • 216

    () 31.2 50,000 27.6 61

    1.

    20.6 41.8 25.3 12.4 2.71

  • 217 2.

    27.6 47.1 18.2 7.1 2.95

    3. 50,000

    31.2 38.8 20.0 10.0 2.91

    4.

    24.7 35.3 25.3 14.7 2.70

    26.03 40.75 22.2 11.05 2.82

    5.5

    8

    5.5.1 5.5.1.1 64.02

    35.94 ,

  • 218 ( 2.91) ( 2.85) ( 2.85)

    62

    1. 18.2 42.4 27.6 11.8 2.67

    2. 19.4 39.4 27.1 14.1 2.64

    3.

    23.5 44.7 24.7 7.1 2.85

    4. 24.1 43.5 22.9 9.4 2.82

    5. 23.5 48.2 18.2 10.0 2.85

    6. 27.6 45.3 17.6 9.4 2.91

    7.

    25.9 30.6 30.0 13.5 2.69

    8. 25.9 30.0 31.2 12.9 2.69

    23.51 40.51 24.91 11.03 2.77

    5.5.1.2 65.01

    34.98 ,

  • 219 ( 2.83) ( 2.83) 63

    1. 14.7 47.1 23.5 14.7 2.62

    2. 18.8 40.6 30.0 10.6 2.68

    3.

    18.8 48.2 25.3 7.6 2.78

    4. 20.6 48.2 18.2 12.9 2.76

    5. 21.2 50.6 18.2 10.0 2.83

    6. 21.2 50.6 18.2 10.0 2.83

    7.

    22.4 36.5 24.1 17.1 2.64

    8. 23.5 37.1 24.7 14.7 2.69

    20.15 44.86 22.78 12.2 2.73

    5.5.1.3 57.37

    42.65 ,

  • 220 ( 2.81) ( 2.69) 64

    1. 21.2 34.7 27.6 16.5 2.61

    2. 19.4 38.2 29.4 12.9 2.64

    3.

    22.4 44.1 25.3 8.2 2.81

    4. 18.2 38.8 31.2 11.8 2.63

    5. 21.2 37.1 30.6 11.2 2.68

    6. 19.4 41.2 28.2 11.2 2.69

    7.

    20.6 31.2 31.8 16.5 2.56

    8. 20.6 30.6 34.7 14.1 2.58

    20.38 36.99 29.85 12.8 2.65

    5.5.1.4 66.44

    38.32 ,

  • 221 ( 2.81) ( 2.81) 65

    1. 12.4 39.4 32.9 15.3 2.49

    2. 16.5 40.6 29.4 13.5 2.60

    3.

    21.2 47.1 21.8 10.0 2.79

    4. 22.9 44.1 21.8 11.2 2.79

    5. 25.3 41.8 21.8 11.2 2.81

    6. 23.5 44.7 21.2 10.6 2.81

    7.

    20.6 36.5 27.6 15.3 2.62

    8. 20.0 37.1 29.4 13.5 2.64

    20.3 41.41 25.74 12.58 2.69

    5.5.1.5 57.5

    42.51 ,

  • 222 ( 2.79) ( 2.76) 66

    1. 28.8 32.9 27.1 11.2 2.79

    2. 20.0 37.6 26.5 15.9 2.61

    3.

    20.0 44.1 28.2 7.6 2.76

    4. 12.4 43.5 32.4 11.8 2.56

    5. 12.9 43.5 32.4 11.2 2.58

    6. 11.8 45.9 28.8 13.5 2.56

    7.

    17.1 36.5 30.6 15.9 2.54

    8. 16.5 36.5 32.9 14.1 2.55

    17.44 40.06 29.86 12.65 2.62

    5.5.1.6 59.91

    40.09 , ( 2.77) ( 2.7)

  • 223 67

    1. 12.4 37.1 34.7 15.9 2.46

    2. 17.6 37.6 29.4 15.3 2.57

    3.

    17.1 48.8 25.3 8.8 2.74

    4. 19.4 43.5 25.9 11.2 2.71

    5. 20.6 44.1 25.3 10.0 2.75

    6. 19.4 48.2 22.4 10.0 2.77

    7.

    23.5 33.5 28.8 14.1 2.66

    8. 21.2 35.3 30.0 13.5 2.64

    18.9 41.01 27.73 12.35 2.66

    5.5.2 5.5.2.1 66.24

    33.76 ,

  • 224 ( 2.95) ( 2.91) 68

    1. 19.4 44.1 27.1 9.4 2.74

    2. 23.5 42.9 23.5 10.0 2.80

    3.

    24.7 44.7 22.4 8.2 2.86

    4. 30.6 35.3 25.3 8.8 2.88

    5. 33.5 37.1 20.6 8.8 2.95

    6. 31.2 37.6 22.4 8.8 2.91

    7.

    26.5 35.9 27.1 10.6 2.78

    8. 24.1 38.8 26.5 10.6 2.76

    26.69 39.55 24.36 9.4 2.84

    5.5.2.2 58.61

    41.41 ,

  • 225 ( 2.75) ( 2.74) ( 2.872) 69

    1. 14.1 36.5 33.5 15.9 2.49

    2. 18.8 38.8 26.5 15.9 2.61

    3.

    20.6 40.6 27.1 11.8 2.70

    4. 22.9 39.4 24.1 13.5 2.72

    5. 25.3 37.1 25.3 12.4 2.75

    6. 24.1 39.4 22.9 13.5 2.74

    7.

    20.0 35.9 29.4 14.7 2.61

    8. 22.4 32.9 29.4 15.3 2.62

    21.03 37.58 27.28 14.13 2.66

    5.5.3 5.5.3.1 64.74

  • 226 35.26 , ( 2.88) ( 2.85) 70

    1. 20.6 43.5 25.3 10.6 2.74

    2. 19.4 44.1 24.7 11.8 2.71

    3.

    22.4 47.1 22.9 7.6 2.84

    4. 31.2 34.7 24.7 9.4 2.88

    5. 29.4 37.1 23.5 10.0 2.85

    6. 27.1 40.6 21.8 10.6 2.84

    7.

    20.0 41.2 25.9 12.9 2.68

    8. 20.0 39.5 28.2 12.4 2.67

    23.76 40.98 24.63 10.66 2.78

  • 227 5.5.4

    8 3.14 3.13 2.61

  • 228 71

    5.6 .. 2540 .. 2540

    5.6.1 53.1 46.9 44.7

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    2.61 2.98 3.14 3.09 3.13 3.13 2.98 2.98

    00.5

    11.5

    22.5

    33.5

  • 229 52.9 62.3 55.9 20 21

    20 : 4 ... ? Retrieved from URL

    http://www.manager.co.th/Politics/ViewNews.aspx?NewsID=9520000066079 21 "3G"- 23..4. 9 .. 2552

  • 230 2

  • 231 72

    1.

    17.1 38.8 37.6 6.5 2.66

    2.

    6.5 40.6 40.0 12.9 2.41

    3.

    10.0 27.6 47.6 14.7 2.33

    11.2 35.67 41.73 11.37 2.47

    5.6.2 56.47

    43.53 60.0 65.3 .. 55.9

  • 232 ..

    .. ..

    ..

    73

    1.

    16.5 39.4 35.3 8.8 2.64

  • 233 2.

    10.6 29.4 44.1 15.9 2.35

    3. ..

    8.2 26.5 47.1 18.2 2.25

    11.77 31.77 42.17 14.3 2.41

    5.6.3 52.54

    47.46 51.2 58.3 51.8

    2550

  • 234

    74

    1.

    8.8 42.4 34.7 14.1 2.46

    2.

    10.6 37.6 35.9 15.9 2.42

    3.

    21.8 36.5 30.0 11.8 2.68

    13.73 38.83 33.53 13.93 2.52

  • 235 5.6.4

    60.3