99 8 7 3G

AHP

- 13G3.5G Mobile Devices2006 2008

(Netbook)

OTA (Over The Air)CTIA

- 2CTIA?CTIA-The Wireless AssociationCTIACTIACTIA

- 3OTA?OTA (Over The Air) (3 Dimension)(TRP)(TIS)

CTIA(TECHNICAL Provider, TPIntel, Broadcom, Qualcomm)

RDODM

CTIA OTAOTA

- 4

CTIA Compliance OTA Chamber- Satimo Stargate 24

CTIA Compliance OTA Chamber- ETS Lindgren AMS-8500

CTIA OTA ChamberOTA ChamberCTIAOTA ChamberC (ETC)2010ETS-Lindgren * 1 (Sporton) 2005ETS-Lindgren * 1 * 3 * 2 * (ATL)2006ETS-Lindgren * 3 * 1 (CCS)2009ETS-Lindgren * 1 *1SGS2005Satimo Stargate24 ETS-Lindgren * 2 *1 (ADT)2009ETS-Lindgren * 1 (QuieTek) 2007ETS-Lindgren * 1 * 1

- 1AHP 1971 Saaty Uncertainty AHP1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.

- 2 Dickson(1966) 23 Webber et al(1991) Dickson 23

Dickson(%)Dickson(%)Dickson(%)68089193259391031541592335311681732022184121720144211131322340111193

- 3 Ellram(1990)() Patton(1996) (2007)(AHP)ODM(2004)AHP

- 4

(2004)

0.027 70.028 70.307 10.307 10.040 60.040 60.074 50.078 50.243 20.199 30.102 40.079 40.185 30.247 20.022 80.021 8C.I=0.0050 C.R.=0.0035

- 1AHP 3G ()

- 2OTA Chamber>3Sporton, ATLSGS,

C

1010C.I

AHP

hourly rate

Report fee

debug consult

Brand Company

Tech. Provide

Carrier

3GCTIA3G performanceOTA (Over the Air)Notebook3GCTIAOTACTIA

()

3G CPK

OTA

3Gdebug consult

3GHourly Rate Hourly Rate

Report Fee Report Fee

a.b.

3GBrand Company

Tech. Provider

Carrier

3G

report

CI0.37110.01

Level 1Level 2RanK (0.371) 0.191 (0.170) 0.1332 (0.371) 0.0933 (0.371) 0.0874 (0.144) 0.0595 (0.129) Hourly rate 0.0566 (0.126) Tech. Provider 0.0517 (0.129) Report fee 0.058 (0.144) debug consult 0.0459 (0.144) 0.0410 (0.126) Brand Company 0.03911 (0.126) Operator 0.03712 (0.170) 0.03613 (0.129) 0.02314 (0.061) 0.02314 (0.061) 0.0215 (0.061) 0.01816

Level 1Level 2Rank (0.371) (L: .514) 0.191 (L: .235) 0.0874 (L: .251) 0.0933 (0.129) Hourly rate (L: .432) 0.0566Report fee (L: .386) 0.058 (L: .181) 0.02314 (0.144) debug consult (L: .311) 0.0459 (L: .285) 0.0410 (L: .404) 0.0595 (0.126) Brand Company (L: .304) 0.03911Tech. Provider (L: .403) 0.0517Operator (L: .293) 0.03712 (0.170) (L: .788) 0.1332 (L: .212) 0.03613 (0.061) (L: .300) 0.01816 (L: .378) 0.02314 (L: .323) 0.0215

AHP

AlternativesLevel 1 PrtyRankATLATL Summary282 (L: .129) 5.3 (L: .144) 4.8 (L: .371) 6.6 (L: .170) 5.8 (L: .061) 2.6 (L: .126) 3SGSSGS Summary27.93 (L: .129) 4.7 (L: .144) 4.8 (L: .371) 7.4 (L: .170) 6.1 (L: .061) 2.1 (L: .126) 2.9SportonSporton Summary44.11 (L: .129) 4.4 (L: .144) 6.7 (L: .371) 17 (L: .170) 7.6 (L: .061) 2.7 (L: .126) 5.8

(Dynamic Sensitivity)

(Performance Sensitivity)

(Performance Sensitivity) 12.9%76.6%SportonATL

-1AHP

-21.2.--3.--4.5.6.

-3SportonSportonSportonAHP

Q & A

**