ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - ksu · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 77 –
�� �������� ���� ����� ,30 ����� ,�1�" " , 77 − 100 ,2018��1439� � �$�%:7677 −1658�
���� � ��� �� �� ������ ���� ������ ������� ���� � !���
"�#! ���$%&�'() *� '�+$ � '���&� �
,$-� )� . /+ 0� �1.214
��)��� ��$�* � + ,-�� ��.11�01�1439;� ,-�� 01.2 + 15�04�1439� �
&�5�6�*:3)45 6�$ �7��$ 89 :�;� <=1�� >� ?��@)@A�� B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ JK��� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� ,�����Q��� + H�%�I$ R$ 0@�=C�� S��T UN�A52E�F�� G��C��V B�CD WX :�;� <=1�� YC.�2?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON H�%��P�� ���1Z ,1437 ,�� 2016 ,�
�����Q�� G@��C�� S%�[2V H�I\T2H�%�I$ 3)45 6�CQ$ ]T 0@�=C�� ^_�CN��@)-5 `�K�5a� H�%��I$2 ,��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� H�%��I$2 ,��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ,�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$2 ,]2��C��2JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��:���C�� W�X d�� 89.5% ,75% ,40.8% ,33% ���X 0Af�2 ,
5 �1QN Ug� ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ��)C� h%i� H�%�I�� 3)4JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON H�%��P�� 58.6V% ?��@)@A�� B��CD �I-)4�C� j k�C�� H�%��I�� ]T2 JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON k H�%�P��lG��C��� m�@P=C� R��no� h$ ]2��C�� m@P=C 6�C=�� G �Q�p2 ,l� 0�; �D%�f��� + 6��C=�� G �Q��HqAf��p ,
2lH�@r����� G�X H�P@1bC 6�C=�� s15��pV
'�8��9&� �:��� :E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ ,�@t%��� uCA�� 0@�v , ��ON��H�%�P V _________________________________________________________________________________
The Extent of Integrating Self-Learning Skills in the Chemistry Book for the Students of
Third Secondary Grade who are on the System of Courses in Saudi Arabia Abdullah Awad Al Harbi(1)
Majmaah University
(Received 01/10/2017; accepted 02/01/2018) Abstract: The current research aimed at finding out the extent of integrating the self-learning skills in the chemistry book for the
students of third secondary stage who are on the system of courses in Saudi Arabia where the analytical tool included the self-learning skills.
The current research limited the study to the chemistry book for the students of third secondary grade who are on the system of courses,
edition 1437 AH, 2016 AD. The results of the analysis showed that the degree of integrating the skills of evolving the chemical concepts,
skills of biological applications, skills of communication and cooperation, and skills of sustainable development in the chemistry book of the
third secondary grade who are on the system of courses were respectively 89.5%, 75%, 40.8%, and 33%. In general, the percentage of
integrating the four mentioned skills in the chemistry book of the third secondary grade who are on the system of courses reached 58.6%
whereas the skills which were not included in this book were as follows: the content contributes in attaining cooperation with others to
achieve learning, the content contributes and aids in solving problems, and the content is tied to the applications of mathematics.
Keywords: analyzing school books, self-learning skills, courses' system. _________________________________________________________________________________
�1� w%�f�� ������ x�%�5 y�Z2 ^ �-�� z�CtT��)��� ��$�* ,�@�� �@�D ,V ������ ,�����Q�� �@���� �A�)�� ,"V B�66� M��{�� |$��� ,�11952V�
(1) Associate Professor of Science Education, College of Education,
Majmaah University
Majmaah, Saudi Arabia, P.O. Box (66) Postal Code (11952).
}2A�~� ��{��: [email protected] e-mail:
![Page 2: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 78 –
'��%�:
R��=N <��@� ,H���$����� Y��X + ]o� �@���N � m7�C��2 +���� %��cNa� 6�T MF���2 ,0_��� E�$����
��PC�� 89k)���� m_��Z2 u@��tT %�I\2 G��C�� �)C�5 J@\�5 WXu��b�� H�%�I$2 H�%�. G��C��� m�@P=C�
B��b��V ]9 ��bC�� h���� �gC��2 +���� % + ���� MF���
���5 + GItT ��@�� �-��X W�X `�K;� H�2�T2 u@��tT�$����� ,���� ���P5 �f�2 ]�P�� �@�� �@-��� �@�2��� �-
�����2�T2 ���@5�$����� S%���L�� ]T 89 R�,�����2 M����;�+ ��O-�� S����X9 u��bC5 ��@*���-AC�� ������� ��$�O-��
��@5�$����� ��)Av 01PCQ�� Bq�b�� ��@� RA)� <@= �,h@% 2000� V �����5 H�t%�� k-1C a9 mP=C� a �F 2
%�� T�1$ WX �D�5 E�z 0Af� G��C�� �@�)�� Bqb�� �t ���T2 ,��@����� ����� ���C�� �2%� G T R$ �%�1CX� Y���� H��1�bC$ ��I@�9 U�X� k�C�� ������ H������ W�X H��DT �KK�C�� H��CA��2 H�@�i� ]T2 ,:�;�
6�� ��@��5 �@�T2 �)@.Bqb���t%��� G��n� ���)
(Mok & Cheng, 2001; Billett, 2010)V ��L��;� u@���ti� R$ ���� E�F�� G��C�� ]�7 �F� ,��@)@��C�� 0������ h@� + G��C�� H�@�)X + ��X�c��2
2 �@7 ]�A� u��b�� � �%���� s@�b�C�� RX `2�Q��2��� %�@Cn���I)��5 + u���� k�C�� ��@)���� S�� V R�$2
0����$ h�@� + ��P@1b5 �@N�A$9 B��ti� �F H�|@�G@��C��, �0D ,M��)��� ���CQ�$2 ��@�P��� ��5%�. uQ�
�� MF��2���c) �@)@��C�� H�Z�f-�� u��b�� �@7 �%�� , >��� i� ��=N ���I�C$ �n� ��fN 89 ��fN R$ 0PC-�2
%��P��2 ���= S��=�� �@)@��C�� ,�1t�-5 kC�� �X���2 ��-@�CQ��$ G������ H������%92 E�F���� G��PC���� ����z + �I@*�52�5 �,��@;� 2003�V
,��c�C��� j����� `2� + ��@��;� ^ �-�� �)C�52�@�t%�$ u�CD k�-15 W�X ��@���� `2��� �I-$2 � ���5
�@)t��� H�I�� ]T u�� %��� B�CA�� ]�7 ��F�2 , �� ��P �@�@5��t� ?��r + S%��� 04�7T + Bq�b�� �
j���� �=r�2; G� T �� B��CA�� ]T ��-7�X �z9 ����n��K$ Bq�b�� �1Q�-�� ��7����2 G��C��� %�}��)f���, 2010� V0��Q��D�$ ���DT2 �Maxwell, 1985 � W��X ]T
�¡���5 �@��t%��� u��CA������@)@��C�� ���@�)��� + 6����2 , ]%�[2T�Osborne, 2014� �@�t%��� ������� uCD ]T
]�7 :�C��2 ,���ti� ¢�Z2 �f.�-�� WX Bqb�� h�f5G��%�QcCt�2 GICf.�-$E�F��� G��C��� WX G �X�Q5 V
��A�)�� M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD ����2 ��@t2 �I7 ,�@t%��� uCA�� ��5 ��T �����Q�� �@����
�@)���� �7�PL�� 0PN2 G��C�� 0_�t2 R$ �$� V m��C� �@72E�F�� G��C�� ��Ic) ���)� j 3L��1��2 ?����� ]�7 WX
��C�� ��£ J���5 ���C G��c���5 H���5 �P7 ,E�F�� G
![Page 3: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 79 –
Ha���� R$ ��� E�F�� G��C�� ]T �D ,����� �%���� U��X�-52 H�����5 �F��� ,M����� B�i� + ���L��;� �F�� �����5 h��*��2 ,������� H���@�i� + ���5�c���5
3L��1�� H� �¤� ���5 89 H�c���C��, `2�-5 R$ GI-)7 qX <�@� R�$ E�F��� G��C��� 0_��t��� ��C.��@)@��C��
<�@� R$ ��2�-5 R$ GI-$2 ,�L��;�u���b�� ��C.qX , <@� R$ ��2�-5 R$ GI-$22 �P_��Z ���5�1@��tTV
6����2 M2���-b��2 k-@,�����(2006 G��C���� ]T �� E�F�� ��I@7 ���P� k�C�� ��@)@��C�� u@���ti� ���T
¥1K��2 ,�7���� WX `�K;� + {Di� %2��� u��b��� �����gC$ W�X �b@Q���2 � %�£ V ¥@�r�5 R�A)�2
u���b�� � ��P� k)@��5 ��fN �N� E�F�� G��C�� ��Ic$ �� ,�Q�c- �Q�cN G���� u��b�� ]T MT ,�QcN ?�P�5 R$ ��X�)� `q�n R�$ ,��I�$�A52 �C@K��� ��@)-5 mP¦ ��)��5 ?��-¡T ��§ ��)� k�C�� �bfNi�2 �@)��C�� J.����
E�F��V ��Dz2 �@�Z� �2009� ��7��� T E�F��� G��C��� ]T �$�X �I-$ ,�)CQ��� G��C��� H����X2 H�%��I$ B�QCD�
G@���5 �@�2�Q�$ u��b�� 0)v2 ,E�F�� G��C�� ������ 3Qv2 ,S�@;� 6�$ �)CQ�� G��C�� m@Pv2 ,�Qc- �QcN h�$ B2���C��2 ,� ���¤2 ,%��)Ct� ���g��� H�%�I��
R��A� ,0��)��� y���t H����gC$�$���X �2005 � `2���-C� ���%T + � ���¦2 �n� %�O-$ R$ E�F�� G��C�� >�� T
k >�� T : ,E�F��� G��C��� s@b�C��� �b15�$ >�� T
,�Ic@\�52 H�$����� %��K$ ����Ct� m��C5 >�� T2 ���b15�$ >���� T2 ,E�F���� G@@PC���� ���b15�$ >���� T2
3)��C�� H� �¤�V E�F�� G��C�� �@�T R)A52 R�$ ���n�$ 0K� �
E�F��� G��C��� m_��Z ¨�-5 + GItT MF��2 ;k-P5 % ��b5 0�* �� �F 2 ,u��b�� 6��3L���1��]��$�P� ?��*�� �@)���� H�t�%���2 ��=1��,E�F�� G��C�� `�� + �P7
q�7 ,�����7 ���Q$ G��C�� ]T G��C�� H���ON H�DT �� ���CQ� ]T u��b���@5�F�� �5�%�.cC�� + �Q� ]T2 ,�A
,G��C��� k��@b1� "��c�� �7��� �� ,����c�� �CX© m72������c�� y2���c�� ����*qX ����P�2 �9%�-A��t2 ,M2�|���
1994 V� R$ �0D m7�22�,M2qCc�� 2004 ;,�$�X 2005� �� 0��5 �$%�-At� M2�|�2 1994)�� ]T E�F��� G��C�
�I-$ ;���|$ S�X k�X��� <�@= ,�����c�� y2�c�� S�X��$ ��@�)X `qn R$ Bqb�� ����c�� y2�c�� E�F�� G��C�� ,��c�Cª G���5 Ha���) ¥)Q�5 <�@� ,G@��C�� ���c5 ,��5�%�. m�72 ���qn R�$ �C�t�%� + u���b�� ��PC�2
G��C�� + �CX©2 ,�5�%�I$2 V R$ ]T �D����|$ F�n�� �NT �5�$�C �2 �5�%�.2 �5�1�%2 u��b�� H�*�� %�1CXa� +
PC� ��t�D �bfNi�2 �%��� ^I-�� ��@1Z �_�r + %� �*%� «.T 89 0@K=C�� WX ��X�Q� �NT2 ,�Cv ���b-��
�����c�� ��@)@��C�� ��5�*�� m���Z R�X �-A� �,RQ�� 1994�V
![Page 4: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 80 –
R�$ k�C�� H�%��I�� R�$ �X�)� E�F�� G��C��2 ��DqC$� ]92 ,��@5�z G��C�� m@Pv u��b�� h@bCQ� ��qn
H�%�I�� �F� `���Z2 ,H�.2i� 0D + G��C�� R$ �-A¬ ��@�� >���� �$ � 2 ,�I*%�n2 �t%��� 0n�� �)���
�@�Z �DF�2 ,S�)CQ�� �2009 � ��$�X H�%��I$ w�- ]T H�%��I$ k� 2 ,��§ u���b�� ��2|5 u� E�F�� G��C�� S��cC�ta�2 ,E�F��� G��PC�� H�%�I$2 ,MT��� �D%�f��
S�7��C�� Hq@IQC�� R$ ����C�ta�2 ,��@�=�� ���@1�� + G��C�� V���� ��¦ �D �1987 � H�%��I$ R�$ ��X�)�
��@_��P�� `��@�� k�)-5 kC�� ���®� E�F�� G��C��, k� 2 ��C7��$ m��Z RX ��z2 ,B�CA�� 89 `����� H�%�I$ ,�IQ��tT2 ,���I_��1$2 ,���t�Ic��2 J@-K��C�� m��_��b
a�2 ,B�CA�� ����Ct� H�%�I$2 ,� �_��72,�-$ S��cCt G@ ��c�� ��@)-5 H�%��I$ ��7��$ ��@�T 89 ��N��P� �F 2 H�%���I$2 ,���@5�@;� H���P@1bC�� H�%���I$2 ,���@_�@)@A�� B�CD + �$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$2 ,]2��C��2 `�K5a�
�����v ?�@)@A��V ���N�L�� �%���� ]T ������ R$2 l ���ONH�%�P��p��� ¯���1$ W�X |D�5 �����Q�� ,E�F��� G��C
N ����� ��z2 ���D�@ 2 �7�� � ,G@��C�� + �@X�N ��P ,�-@$�4��$2 �1@����tT2 <��@= °�Q��� ±��� ���@)-5 89
0L$ ,u��b�� �@5�@;� H�%�I�� : H�%��I$2 E�F�� G��C�� h��$ 0��X�cC��2 ,k��X��� 0��)���2 0�����C��2 ]2����C��
�Z9 + ,�no� MT��� `�1.2 �f.�-��2 %��;�2 R��no� %
RZ����2 h�)C�)�� ��@���� ¥��K��2 �Df�� G@P�� R$ �G@��C�� S%�[2�����Q�� , 1433V�
���ON �%���$ >��� T ���X ��2 ,m1t ��2 |�D�5 ��²T ¥4�5� ,�����Q�� + H�%�P��W�X ]2���C��
��)X ^�� ��DT ��D ,G��C��� ��@�)X `q�n �D%�f��2x.���2 k��Cc��2�2015 � �bf��NT 3)4��5 ���@�T W��X
6�� `�K5a� GX�5 H�%�1�� ���N�L�� ������ + ?�@)@A�� 2T ,G���� h$ 2T ,]��.i� 3 0���C�� m@P=C� ,Bqb��
h��)C��� h�$ R��) ����¦ ]T u���b�� h@bCQ��� <�@= ;,S�X�Q��� ���� �$�-X 3�CQ� ��7��$ 89 ��N��P� �F� 2 B��CD + H�%�I�� �F mPv?��@)@A�� JK��� <���L��
M�N�L�� N���O ,H�%��P�� ]T u�� m1�t ��$ ?��r +2 G��C��� ��$[q�� H�%��I�� G� T ?�@)@A�� B�CD R)4C�
E�F��; ��4��T2 ,��X 0Af �@_�@A�� G@ �c�� �@�i ���ON ��t�tT ���� ?�@)@A�� B�CD 6�C£ ]T m�b-$ R$ �Qc5 +
��t%��� 0�n�� u���b�� ��*��5 k�C�� �@)���� � ��O��� °�C�2 ,�I*%�n2 J�.��)�� ��C���$2 ��Q�c5 ]��A
G@ ���c)�� ���D�%�9 ]���A� ]T ��� a ,��=@=��� ���@)���� G@ ��c�� h$ �)I7 mcC� °C� ,��=@=� ��D�%�9 �@_�@)@A��
)@A��@?������� 6���� �����1P�� ���@)���� ���@_� V �F�� R��$2 H�%�I$ H�%�I���@)-5 R$ ���5 kI7 ,�@_�@)@A�� G@ �c��
<�@� ,?�@)@A�� x�%�5 >�� T m�P=C� �$��-X G��C��� h�$ ¥�r�2 0Af� S������ �7���� s� u��b�� ��P�
![Page 5: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 81 –
0�1. R�$ ��q@L) ��� H�z ���4. 2T G@ �c$ �,�)f�. 2002� V ��1�b�� B�Q�D9 89 ?�@)@A�� x�%�5 °�Q� �F�
� ��O�� 2T ?�@�i� R$ �LD RX S���C$ �@_�@)@D G@ �c$ u�K�� R$ �NT �*22 ,�@c@\2 S%�K �@�@1b�� G��� ]T
��c�C��� G����� ¨2�7 + �@)���� G@ �c�� h@)� �1�b��; z9 ,� ���@P�52 �ICZ�Q�� ���*%� + H2���cC5 G@ ���c�� ]9
�J�r2 ���*2 ��X 2T S�A1$ ����$ + G@ �c�� w�%�9 ��b®� G�Ic�� �11�t ]�A� �. u��b�� �-X �P�b$ ��Ic$
(Birk & Kurts, 1999) V H��@P@1bC�� H�%��I$ ���5 �D;��@5�@ + �I-@)4�5 u�� k�C��2 ,��)I�� H�%��I�� R$
?�@)@A�� B�CD; �@t�ti� %�A7i�2 G@ �c�� m��C5 �²i ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ���N�L�� ������ Bqb�� �It%�� kC��
R��$ Bq��b�� ���I*��� ��� S³���1$ ���.qX ���� k��C��2 ]2���C�� H�%��I$ ]T ��D ,��@$�@�� G��@� + HqAf$
�K5a�2 �v ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ` H�{®� `��1C� ����7 mPBqb�� 3� ��)X ^��x.��2 ��)X ^�� k�Cc��2,
2015� ��@)-C�� H�%��I$ E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ R$2 , Y-�� �T �� %��T kC��2 ,�$��CQ���)£2 �2017� �²�
u��b�� H�%�I$2 >%��$ ���bC� °�Q5 kC�� �@)-C��V � G��C�� kO� m1t �� ��1D ��C � `�[�$2 E�F�
R$ �%�1CX� 3L��1�� R$T �����5 m�Pv kC�� G@��C�� ¨��N �F�� ,G��C��� + ��C1�%2 ,�@5�F�� G��C�� H�%�. h$ mcC� E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ H��t�%��� R�$ ���X U�2�-5
�t�%� �I-$2 ,?�@�i�2 ������ uCD + �-)4C�� H��@1Xk�1X|��2� 2005 �9 U7�� k�C�� H�%���I$ ?�K�PCt� 8
H�%���AC�� �LDT ]T 3152 ,������ uCD + E�F�� G��C�� `�� + UN�D E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I�RC�� ,�bf�Ni� G¡ ,
,��)C� �¡qL�� uCA�� + G��PC�� ���tT G¡U-@2 �t�%� ¥��c�� �2015 � �@5�@;� H�%�I�� R)4C5 ������ uCD ]T
]T �D ,�bt�C$ �*%� 0AD S%�I$ MT R)4C5 j uCA��H�F�� S%��9 H�%�I$ R$V ¥��c�� m7�22�2015 � ���@CN
-�2 �t�%��Winter, 2007� %�K�. 89 H%���T kC�� R��$ ]T ���-7�X �z9 ,�$��CQ���� ���@)-C�� m��@Pv + ^ ���-��
�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$ �@5�@;� H�%�I��V ��4�T2��|��2 G@���� �t�%� H|D% �2015 �X W
JK��� ?�@�i� B�CD + �-)4�� E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 0@�c5 6�$2 ,�����Q�� G@KP�� �Pb-) M�N�L�� `2i� 89 ^_�C-�� U���5 �.2 ,H�%�I�� ��C� ?�@�i� H���$ h�@)� M�N��L�� `2i� JK��� ?��@�i� B��CD R)45 H�*%��2 <�=1�� + S���=�� E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$
�c�Cª 3)45 G����� 0�@��2 ,u���b�� B�CD R$ 0D + S��c-$, m���C� �@�7 �t�%��� �F ^_�CN mcC52 ,��)C�2
,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ WX u�%�C�� 89 H����� �*�=�´i� �t�%� h$ �1997� kC�� 3�)���� ]T 89 H%���T
��*%�2 E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ WX B%�C�� 89 �*�=���@��X V�%� H���DT22 ]���4���� ���t k��1@�|��2 h��f����
![Page 6: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 82 –
�2015 �2 ?��|@c�� uCD ]TT ���N�L�� ������ + G���� ��� ���4�P�� h�$ 0�$��C�� ��¦µ H�����%9 ��T R$ U�n
��@�)C��� �@)���� �S.S.I V�}���)��� ��t�%� U7�� 2 �2005 � u�CD + E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ WX JfA��
���N�L�� ����)�� H�@r�����, U���52 ]T 89 �t�%���0.T H�@�r����� u�CD + ���7���5 E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$
��)C� �qL��6�C=�� RC$ +V E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�) m��C� �@72
,?�@)@A�� B�CD +U7� ��t�%� ��r��� ��1X2 RQ�� �2016 �0��@�v 89 <����L�� JK���� ?���@)@A�� B���CD
st�C�� � ���P72 y����� +���4�P��@*���-AC��2 G�����
22 h��)C�������@1��� S.T.S.E� ]T ���t�%��� H���I\T2 , �1Q�- �$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� ���4�. R)45 ?�@)@A�� B�CD
%��P) �@N�C$ 22% ?��@)@A�� B�CD ]T �-7�X �z9 ���n , Bq�b�� �X�Q�5 �²T �c�� R$ �@�)X �bfNT R)4C�
MT���� ?��92 �D%�f��2 �P-�� WX�^��2 {���,��)X 2016� V �t�%� H%��T �D]�-�� �2006 � G@ �c�� ]T 89
h�$ u�t�-C5 a ?��@)@A�� B��CD + �-)4C�� �@_�@)@A�� |D% ?�@)@A�� B�CD ]T2 ,�L��;� H� �¤a�2 H�%�bC�� 0)f� a B�CA�� ]T2 ,WXT �1Q- �@_�@)@A�� m_�P;� WX
�Q@_��� �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� 0D Vm7��C5 �D ��t�%� ^_�CN ]�-�� �2006 �]��X�P�� ��t�%� ^_��CN h$ �2005 � k�C��
u�CD + S�%����� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� 0�@�v 89 U7�
G��P52 ,]�%i� + �bt�C��2 �@t�ti� ����)�� ������ ��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� 0@�v G5 �.2 ,�§ ���®� H������
c@-K�52 ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ���v <@� R$ ��@c@D2 �I µ���-X h��@� ]T 89 ���t�%��� U�����52 ,���I��[�5 W��X U�K��� ���t�%��� ���@-��� �@��t�%��� H��������
�)X ^� �t�%� H�DT �D ,�bt�C$ H����P5 �)X ^�x.�2 kCc��2 �2015 � ���X�� H���CQ��� 3� ][���C
�@N���2 �@����� + ?�K�PCta� H�%��I$ R�$ S%��I$ 0�A������ ?�@)@A�� uCD�����Q�� + ���N�L�� V
��r�X m1�t �� , H��t�%��� G�O�$ ]T ¥4�C�?��@)@A��2 ������� + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ WX H|D%
��X 0Af<��1�� �� j2 , − �)�X �2�� + − ��t�%� H�%�I� U.�b5�@)-5 H��P@1bC��2 ,��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c��
�$��CQ���� ���@)-C��2 ,]2����C��2 `�K��5a�2 ,���@5�@;� + B�CD?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P��
�����Q��V �<1� '��=�:
%��K$ G T R$ �@t%��� uCA�� ���5H��$����� ��I-$ �)CQ� <@� ;��|D��� ����� �)ONi� + �Q@_��� + G��%�. %�bC5 ��qn R$2 ,�@)���� GIC7�P¡ Bqb��
�P�� z��¶�2 `����2 k�)���� �AcC�� + �1�t�-�� H�%���@$�@�� G��@� �]���4�� ,]2��n�2 2015� , U��2T2
�-�2 �t�%��Winter, 2007� u�CA�� ����b5 S%2·
![Page 7: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 83 –
,�@t%��� + H�@r�����2 ������ ���b5 ¨2,$ |D% �F� k�C�� �@t�ti� H�%�I�� u��b�� B�QD9 WX �����Q��
,�@-I��2 �@�)��� S�@;� H�1�bC$ wqC$� R$ �-A¬ m@Pv2 ~�2 RA)C�� 0*T R$ G@��C�� T�1$ H�%�I�� �@)-52 ,]�P5
0L$ ,u��b�� �@5�@;� : ]2���C�� H�%��I$2 E�F�� G��C�� R���no� h�$ 0�X�cC��2 ,k�X��� 0�)���2 0���C��2
�f�.�-��2 %��;�2 �G@���C�� S%�[2�����Q��� , 1433� VP5 j :��;� U�.��� + G@��C�� �)I$ ]T �D�� �F 2 Y�C
��@)-5 89 ���z °�b�C5 0 ,�@)@��C�� S���� 0@Kv WXH�$����� WX `�K;� ��qn R$ RA)� kC�� H�%�I��
��T ,��� 2011�V ]��-�� ��t�%� U��2T �D �2006 � u� kC�� �Q@_��� �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� �)_�. ���X9 �@��
?�@)@A�� B�CD + �I-@)45 V+ G@���C�� GQ�. �f�� ��D ���%��7�Florida Department of Education, 2017 �
H�%��I$ ������� ^ ��-$ R)4�C5 ]T �@�T 89 ]2���C�� `�K5a�2 V2T �@)���� H�t�%��� ±� H�DWX %�K.
E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I� ��X 0Af ������ uCD 3)45 �,¥��c��2015 ,]�-�� ; 2006� V 3)4�5 ��@�i ����ON2
G��C�� H�%�I$B�CD + E�F��?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� + ���t�tT ����5 �²T m�b-$ R$2 ,
,u���b�� ��*��5 kC�� �@_�@)@A�� �@)���� � ��O�� �Qc5GC�� �<��=1�� B���CA H�%���I�� ����5 3)4��5 6���)
?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��V
�<1� >��?@:
:�;� <=1�� >� 89 : 1 − <��L�� JK�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD S?��.M�N�L��
�@�@�v S?��. H�%�P�� ��ONV 2 − G��C��� H�%�I) �P��C$ �)_�. ���X9E�F���
B�CD + �I-@)45 RA)� kC��2?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��V 3 − H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �7��$G��C��� E�F��� �P��C�� �@)-Cc����@_�@)@A�� G@ � ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC��2
�$��CQ�� �@)-C��2 ]2��C��2 `�K5a�2 B�CD + ?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��V
�<1� '�AB@:
H��v ��Af$ <=1�� + `��Q�� ¹@_��� Eo� :�$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C�� E�F�� + B�CD ?�@)@A��
JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� + �A�)�� �@���� ?�����Q�� �.2 UPL1N� �-X ���ti� �@X�c�� �@5o�: 1 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� �@�7
m����C� ���@)-C G@ ���c�� ���@_�@)@A�� + B���CD ?���@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��
2 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� �@�7 m��C� H�P@1bC�� ��@5�@;� + B��CD ?��@)@A�� JK���
<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� 3 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C�� E�F��� �@�7
![Page 8: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 84 –
m��C� `�K5a� ]2���C��2 + B��CD ?��@)@A�� JK��� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��
4 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� �@�7 m��C� �@)-C�� $��CQ��� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L��
M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� �<1� '�C@ :
� �@7 �@�i� R)A5 : 1 − �7��<=1�� k�bb�� ���*�% ���Fg5 :�;�
<�@= ,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ `��) m��C� �@7 ^ �-�� B��CD %����9 S���X9 ��-X ���_�CN R$ S��cCta� RA)�
�L�� <��L�� JK�� ?�@)@A��H�%�P$ ��ON M�N V 2 − ?�@)@A�� k)��$ ��2|5 + <=1�� �F G �Q�
?��@)@A�� B��CD �I-)4�5 kC��2 ,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ R$ ��-A)C� kA� ,H�%�P$ ��ON M�N�L�� <��L�� JK�� :��C��2 ,G�§qb� %��P�� GIQ��%�5 ?��-¡T ��z S�X��$
GI)��5 3Qv V 3 − �@�T BqZ ���N�L�� ������ BqZ ���n2
B�Q�CDa ��*�= G� R�F��� ,M�N�L�� <��L�� JK�� �������� H���1�bC� ������C��t� ;E�F���� G��C���� H�%���I$
�@�$���V �<1� ��<�D��:
��� �� �� : � ��P� MF�� k)@��C�� ��f-�� � ��X�7�$ G��C�� �5�����C�t� ��@)-5 >��§ �@5�F�� �C1��
��1@�CQ$ �5�%�.2 �5�N�A$92 m�P¦ �� ��5�$�C �2 ����@� ���)C� h$ ¥*�-�� 0X�cC��2 ,�I�$�A52 �C@K�� �@)-5
��5�%�P ��PL��2 �Q�cN WX ��CXa� m��Z RX �,k�X�$ 1998�V >���5 �-@ E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$��²� ��X�)�
`��@�� k�)-5 k�C�� ����®� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ R$�@_��P�� �,��� 1987�V
>���52 �F� + ���@_��*9 E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ �P��C�� H�%�I�� R$ �X�)� �²� <=1�� �@)-C G@ �c��
,]2���C��2 `�K�5a�2 ,�@5�@;� H�P@1bC��2 ,�@_�@)@A�� ���%�I$ ¨�)�2 ,�$��CQ�� �@)-C��221S%�I$ V
��E����EE����� ��EE� �EE��� � !�EE�� "�EE#!
���$%&� : ��@_��*9 >����2?�@)@A�� B�CD �N�3 G5 MF�� ������2 H�@r����� x�%�5 ���b5 ¨2,$ R)r �c@��5 ,`�K�7 �Q�» B��CA�� M��¦2 ,�����Q�� + �@�@1b��
k� : ,���@_�@)@A�� H����gC��2 ���.�b��2 ,S������ Ha���� ,k_���@)@A�� ]�|��5a�2 ,���@_�@)@A�� HqX���cC�� ���X©2
qX�c52 �@N��D2%�@�� H�1D��� H�PCf$2 ���1Z2 ,�� k B�CA��1437−2016�����Q�� ,G@��C�� S%�[2 ,V
���$E%&� "�#! : ��N� ���O-�� �F >����2 0�A@ �t%�� wf$ ^$�N� R$ ]�AC� M�N�L�� G@��C�� ���*
3K�K¶ R�%�Q�$ 89 ¨�cC�2 ,Bqb�� h@�; �����T u��b�� ��C� ,�@�@1b�� ������ �no�2 �@N�QN~� ������
�t�%��� ����� �I�A@ + �b®� �F °-1C52 ,����T +
![Page 9: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 85 –
,�--P�� �@t�%��� H�X�Q�� ��ON �I�T R$ S���X uN��*2 ,$���AC�� ^I-���� ����ON2 ,k��)D��� `������ ����ON2���PC�� H�2�T2 G��C���2 G@���C�� + ��@X�N u@���tTG� �G@��C�� S%�[2�����Q�� , 1433�V
�<1� F�G�:
:��;� <=1�� �)CX� @��=C�� kc����� ^I-���Content Analysis ,6�C=�� 0@�v B��tT `qn R$ ,
�@72� 0�@�=C�� `q�n R�$ S� �O�� ¼_�Kn Y� GC������ uQ-��2 H�%��AC�� B�Q= k)A��V
�<1� 'G�.H I��J: B��CD R�$ <�=1�� ��-@X2 h)C� 0L¬?��@)@A��
JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON ,H�%��P�� ���1Z 1437−2016`2�* 31�2 , 1 B��CD 6��C£ �2%�2 `�K�7
?�@)@A��JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��:
KH�L2 1 :4��� ������� ���� � �M NH�)H K �O ���� � !��� "�#! ���$%&�P
K �O
����� NH��� Q� G. ��<9��
`2i� ,�1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� ,Bz��C�� 6�. ,H�[�g���@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5 43-10 }�L�� M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�Q� ,��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� ,S%��;� ,�.�b�� 83-54
<��L�� 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ,0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$����� ,k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON 111-92
h���� ��� ]�|5a� ����]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� ,k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� ,kA@$�-� 153-120
x$�®� H��)@��1�� ,���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5 ,0@N��A�� H�1D�$ ,H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A�� ,0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@�� 193-162
�<1� R�)@ : �?���*9 R�$ m1�t �$ ?�r +2 <���1�� ���. H
G T ���=C ��z2 ,�@�2i� �ICg@K ���P5 �)_�. ���X� R��$ ���X�)� R)4��C5 ]T R��A)�� R��$ k��C�� Ha������ h�%i� + H�%��I�� H���v2 ,E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$
Ha�� :�@)-5 H�%�I$ H�%��I$2 ,��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ,]2����C��2 `�K��5a� H�%���I$2 ,���@5�@;� H���P@1bC��
�I$2�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%V
$(�%�� '�S�T ��1UH V�W : W�X �I�r�X G5 ���PC�� �)_�. y�� R$ �D�C�� y��Z2 ^ ��-�� + 3K�K�C�� 3�)A=�� R$ �X�)� ,G�q���52 G��O�q) ����T R�F��2 ,������ x�%�5 0����5 G�5 ;3)A=�� Hq���52 H�O�q$ h� ��2
H�?��*~�2 ,���PC�� �)_�.k ]�f�� �F + U¬ kC�� : S%�I$ >F� �@1��i� 6T%l h$ ut�-C� � G��C�� m@Pv
���� W�X G��C�$ 0D S%�.p S%��I$ ��F�D2 ,l GIQ��
![Page 10: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 86 –
G��C�� 6�� �@�7���� S���[ WX 6�C=��p �²i ;− uQ� G½T%− 0� ,��@�v ����� 6�C=�� �P��C$ S%�I$ ��5 a
G�52 ,��5�z G��C��� �P��C$ k ��@1��T 6T%2 ,�I7F�� ��)�D `��1C�t� 0�L$ ,H�%�I�� ±� 0���5 3)A=��
lH�X�r���p�� l6�C=��p ����PC�� ��)_�. U�N�A52 , R$ Hq���C�� ��21 ,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ R$ S%�I$
G.% `2��� ¥r�$ � �D 2V
KH�L2 2 :4���� � ��� �� �� ������ ������� ��� ���� �� !�� "�#! ���$%&�P
K�X&� " R���&� �����&� )�.
1 6�C=�� G �Q�+ �t%���@t�ti� G���� H�%�I$ V 2 ���Cc$ ���tT ¢�Z �@N�A$9 6�C=�� ¥@C�V 3 G �Q� 6�C=�� B��@Ct� G@ �c�� �@_�@)@A�� kC�� �7��C� �� J���5 k)�X 4 G �Q� 6�C=�� B��@Ct� G@ �c�� �@_�@)@A�� kC�� �7��C� �� J���5 �g��� ��|@��N~�V 5 R)4C� 6�C=�� ��L$T 2T R�%�¬ �X�Q5 WX �7��$ ��Ic�� k_�@)@A�� �����V
������ '�S������ ��?�9&� '��G�
6 R)4C� 6�C=�� ��Fg5 ��*�% `�� 6�CQ$ G��C��V
6
7 R)4C� 6�C=�� �a��� ��P$ HqAf� �@5�@� �@�.�2V 8 S�@;� R$ �@�.�2 ��L$T 6�C=�� R)4C�V 9 R)4C��@�2�Q�� 0)v H�%�I$ 6�C=�� V
'����-� ��%�1D�� ������
10 �@�.�2 �@_�@)@D HqAf� ��P$ a��� 6�C=�� R)4C�V
4
11 G��C�� 6�C=�� �X�Q� WX�5�z G@P� ]TV 12 G �Q� 6�C=�� m@P=C ]2��C�� h$ R��no� m@P=C� G��C��V 13 ���ti� ¢�Z 6�C=�� ¥@C�R��no� WX V
QH� ��H K���Y� ������
14 HqAf�� 0; �D%�f�� + 6�C=�� G �Q�V
4
15 k)���� ?�KPCta� WX 6�C=�� �X�Q�V 16 � 6�� J�4��2 S�P�� ��PN 6�C=�� [{�G��C�V 17 M�=C��2 <=1�� "�7 6�C=�� ¥@C�V 18 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC�%i� G�XV 19 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC?�@�i� G�XV 20 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC?��|@c�� G�XV
'����*&� '��G�� ������
21 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC H�@r����� G�XV
7
Z �X&� 21
![Page 11: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 87 –
�. 0@�=C�� H�1¡ R$ �D�C��2 ��CX�� <���1�� �� B���ti� ;����PC�� ��)_�. H��1¡ u@��tT R$ 3��tT B��CD <���1�� 0�� �@72 ,R$|�� {X H�1L�� � `2i�
0�@�=C�� R�$ h@�tT �¡q¡ �� 0@�=C�� ��XT2 ,?�@)@A�� �2�D �����$ ���Ct�2 ,`2i�Cooper 0$��$ B�Q;
H�1L��:
H�1L�� 0$��$ =3 y�c5a� H��$ ��X }�L��2 `2i� 0@�=C�� ×100 y�c5a� H��$ ��X +>qCna� H��$ ��X
{��X H���1L�� B�Q��� G��5 }���L�� B����ti� +2 ��n� ¼C�ª 0�1. R$ �QcN B�CA�� 0�� <@� ,���7i� Hq$��$ Á���Ct� G52 ,������ x�%�5 y�Z2 ^ �-)
X Ug� kC��2 ,������� xcN ����Ct� H�1L�� :��C�� W0.902 ,0.94V
'�S��EE8[� 'EE\� &� : :���;� <��=1�� ���C��t� H�%��I$ 3)45 6�$ �7��� ������ uQ-��2 H�%��AC��
?�@)@A�� B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L�� ��ON H�%�P��V
����$L] �<1�:
m@P=C� >� <=1�� 0�L)C��2 + ��7��$ 6��$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C�� F��E� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK��
<����L�� M�N���L�� ����ON H�%���P�� ���A�)�� ���@���� ;�����Q�� ��@P5 <=1�� s��4�� �@��C�� : 1 − ¨qZa� WX H�t�%��� �P�Q��� ���=1��2
H���@�i�2 ���@���� ���@1-*i�2 k��C�� U���2�-5 H�%���I$ G��C�� E�F�� + uCD ������ ?�@)@A��2V
2 − 0@�v B�CD �?�@)@A� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L��
��ON H�%��P�� >��§ ��7��$ 6��$ 3)4�5 H�%��I$ G��C�� E�F�� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L��
��ON H�%�P��V 3 − U�L¬ �-@X 0@�=C�� R�$ h�@� H�X��r��� �-)4C�� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON H�%�P�� ��1Z 1437−2016V 4 − ���)CX� <��=1�� S���Ac�� �¦Y���� S�����D
,0@�=C�� ��z2 <=1�� RX H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� + ¼-�� H�$�t���2 `�A��i�2 �bf�Ni�2 S���*��� +
B�CA��V 5 − 0)���� �0���@�=C�� ¼-����� H�$����t���2
`�A�i�2 �bfNi�2 S��*��� + B�CA��V 6 − j 0)f� �0�@�=C�� Ãm��q���,H�=�bK��� `2���2 M%2��� µ�-��� V� 7 − 0)X ¥Q$ B�CA� ?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L��
M�N�L�� ��ON ,H�%�P�� ��z2 �5?��P S?��. ,�@N�C$ G�52 S��X9 �5?��. S�$ 6�nTV
![Page 12: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 88 –
���=T�G�H �<1� FS��!:
KH^� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:
��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �$+ ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� �@)-C?��@)@A�� B��CD JK���
<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ :�C�� `2��� 31� B���CD + ���@_�@)@A�� G@ ���c�� ���@)-C ���P��C�� E�F����
?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��:
KH�L2 3 :4��� �� �� ������ ���� ��� + '%� �&� '��G���?�9&� ������� ���� � '�S������ � !��� ���� ������$%&� "�#! P
a� ��$��%c a� ��$��%c
'G���� de 'G���� � R����
6
R����
5
R����
4
R����
3
R����
2
R����
1 ��. f &� g�9�
5 * * × * * * H�[�g��
5 * * × * * * � 6�.Bz��C�
5 * * × * * * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 4�16.7
20�83.3
5 * * × * * * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5
g�
9�KH
^�
5 * * × * * * �.�b��
5 * * × * * * S%��;�
6 * * * * * * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 2�8.3
22�91.7
6 * * * * * * + �gC�� B�Q�M%��;� 6�C=��
h���
g�9�
6 * * * * * * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON
6 * * * * * * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$����� 0�0 18�100
6 * * * * * * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. �
��� g
�9�
5 * * × * * * kA@$�-���� ]�|5a� ����
6 * * * * * * k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� 2�11.1 16�88.9
5 * * × * * * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$
� g�
9�
5 * * × * * * 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��
6 * * * * * * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��
5 * * × * * * 0@N��A�� H�1D�$
5 * * × * * * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5
4�13.3
26�86.7
5 * * × * * * H��)@��1��
i��j
� g�
9�
102c89.5 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�
12c10.5 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�
![Page 13: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 89 –
R�$ ¥4C�`2���� 3 G��C��� H�%��I$ ���X ]T ��P��C�� E�F�� ��@)-C + �-)4�C�� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c��
B�CD?�@)@A�� M�N��L�� <��L�� JK�� H�%��P�� ���ON k 102 � %��. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ 89.5%, ���X �-�@
k �-)4C�� �� H�%�I��12� %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ %10.5V ]T 89 �-)4C�� H�%�I�� S�LD u1t ���� �%2
,?�@)@A�� G��5 + 0n��� k �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c��]T ��D ��C£6� ?���@)@A�� ���)C�� ����C��X� ��³���1$ W��X G@ ���c��
,�@_�@)@A�� :�C��2 ?�@)@A�� B�CD �I-)45 V ��D ¥4�C�R$ ?�@)@A�� B�CD `�K7 �LDT ]T �QcN `2��� JK��
<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P����� H�%��I� �-)4C�� C G�� ��P��C�� E�F�� ��@)-C 0K�c�� �� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c��
�L�� <�l��@_�@)@A�� HqX��cC�� �X©p R)4�5 <�@� ,�� H�%�I$C �1Q�- E�F�� G��100% + u1Q��� �����2 ,
MF��� ��@���� 0K�c�� �� <���L�� 0Kc�� ]T 89 ��z~� �g��� J���5 �7��5 R)45 H�=�bK$ 0A� ��|@��N
S����� �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c���@7V B��CD `�K�7 0�.T �-@ ��� H�%��P�� ���ON M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� ?�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ��@)-C ��P��C�� E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I� �-)4C��
@_�@)@A��i� 0K�c�� �� �`2 lS����� Ha���p <�@� , %��P) �@7 �-)4C�� �� H�%�I�� �1QN H?�*16.7V%
�DR�$ ¥4C�%��I$ ��LDT ]T �Q�cN `2���� H�)4�5 ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��@ + ��-
?�@)@A�� B�CDJK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� S%�I$ ;�@5o� H�%�I�� k l WX 6�C=�� G �Q��t%�� �@��t�ti� G������ H�%���I$p S%���I$2 ,l 6���C=�� ¥@��C����Cc$ ���tT ¢�Z �@N�A$9p S%�I$2 ,l 6��C=�� G �Q�
Ct� J����5 ��� �7���C� k�C�� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� B��@k��)�Xp S%���I$2 ,l 6���C=�� R)4��C� R�%���¬ 2T ����L$T
������ k_��@)@A�� ��Ic�� �7��$ WX �X�Q5p S%��I$2 ,l 6�C=�� R)4C�G��C��� 6�CQ$ `�� ��*�% ��Fg5p,
� %��. ����$ �1Q- S%�I$ 0D H?�* <@�100%, �-�@ S%�I$l6�C=�� G �Q� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� B��@C�t�
���|@��N~� ��g��� J����5 �� �7��C� kC��p + U-)4�5 ?�@)@A�� B�CDJK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P��
� %�. ����$ �1Q-36.8% �z9 ����n �@N�C$ �1QN k 2 , + GIC��t�%� ]��)A@��t R�F���� Bq��b�� ]T ���-7�X
@t �@1b��2 �@t�-��2 �@)���� H�KK�C�� �F ]�t%����|@��N~� �g��� �@_�@)@A�� H�=�bK�� V �F� m�cC52
G@����2 ��|�� �t�%� h$ ��@C-���2015 � H%���T k�C�� h�@)� M�N��L�� `2i� JK�� ?�@�i� B�CD R)45 89 H�*%��2 <�=1�� + S���=�� E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ G����� 0�@��2 ,u���b�� B�CD R$ 0D + �c�Cª 3)45
S��c-$��)C�2 ,V + ?��* ��$ WX 0@�=C�� ^_�CN �D�52 89 H%����T k��C��2 ,���t�%��� H���@�T G@ ���c�� ���@�T
)@A��@ ,�@_�2 ��t�tT ��5 �²T ��@)���� � ���O�� �Qc5 +
![Page 14: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 90 –
�*��5 kC��u���b�� ��C���$2 ��Q�c5 ]��A� °�C�2 , ��=@=� �@)���� J.��)��V
h��� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:
$ 3)45 6�$ �$ ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I?��@)@A�� B��CD + �@5�@;� H�P@1bC�� JK��� <���L��
M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ :�C�� `2��� 31� ?��@)@A�� B��CD + ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� ��P��C�� E�F��
H�%�P�� ��ON M�N�L�� <��L�� JK��:
KH�L2 4 :4�� ���� ��� ������� ���� � '����-� ��%�1D��+ '%� �&� ��� �� �� ����� !��� ���� ������$%&� "�#! P
a� ��$��%c a� ��$��%c
'G���� de 'G���� � R����4 R����3 R����2 R����1 ��. f &� g�9�
4 * * * * H�[�g��
2 × * × * Bz��C�� 6�.
3 × * * * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 5�31.2
11�68.8
2 × × * * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5
g�
9�KH
^�
3 * × * * �.�b��
4 * * * * S%��;�
3 × * * * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 4�25 12�75
2 × × * * M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�Q�
h���
g�9�
4 * * * * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON
4 * * * * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$�����
2�16.7
10�83.3
2 × * × * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ���
� g�
9�
3 * × * * kA@$�-���� ]�|5a� ����
3 * × * * a� + S�¡��� 0$�����k_�@)@A�� ]�|5
2�16.7
10�83.3
4 * * * * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$
� g�
9�
2 × × * * 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��
3 × * * * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��
2 × × * * 0@N��A�� H�1D�$
4 * * * * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5
6�30
14�70
3 * × * * �1��H��)@�
i��j
� g�
9�
57c75 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�
19c25 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�
*'G����P ×'G���� de P
![Page 15: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 91 –
R$ ¥4C�`2��� 4 E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ ��X ]T ?��@)@A�� B��CD + �-)4�C�� ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� �P��C��
M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� k� H�%��P�� ���ON 57 ,S%��I$ � %�. ����$ �1Q-75%, �-)4�C�� ��� H�%�I�� ��X �-@
k 19 � %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ 25 V% `2���� 3�1� ��D B�CD `�K7 �LDT ]T �QcN?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L��
��ON H�%�P�� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I� �-)4C�� <��L�� 0Kc�� � �@5�@;� H�P@1bC��l HqX��cC�� �X©
�@_�@)@A��p h���� 0Kc��2 ,lk_��@)@A�� ]�|5a�p�1Q�- , � %�. ����$83.3 %0K7 0A�V ]T �QcN `2��� 31� �D
��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ �LDT ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ��-@)45M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� ���ON
$ ;�@5o� H�%�I�� k H�%�P�� S%��Il 6��C=�� R)4�C��@�.�2 �@5�@� HqAf� ��P$ �a���p H?��* <�@� ,
� %��. ����$ �1Q-100% ]T 89 ���z <���1�� 2|���2 , ?��@)@A�� B��CD + �@)���� H�X�r���JK��� <���L��
M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� S��@;� ��P��C$ H�X��r�$ k� H���1D���2 ���.�b��2 ,S������ Ha���� 0��L$ ,����X 0Af��
�@N��D2%�@�� V S%�I$ H?�*2l ���L$T 6��C=�� R)4C�S�@;� R$ �@�.�2p � %�. ����$ �1Q- 89.5% ��D�� �F 2 , H�X�r�$ ]T?��@)@A�� JK��� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON
H�%�P��S�@;� �P��C$ , S%�I$ ]T �c� �$ �F 2 l R)4C��@�.�2 �@5�@� HqAf� ��P$ �a��� 6�C=��p H?�* ,
1Q-� 100 V%`2����� ��-5?��. +2 4 ���N ¨��r�$ ]TlBz����C�� 6���.p ¨���r�$2 ,l 0��X�cC�� ���X© 3N����.
k_�@)@A��p �§ R)4C5 j S%�I$ lR)4C� 6��C=�� ���L$T ���@�.�2 R��$ S���@;�p V B���CD + ��-@)4��5 H�%���I�� 0��.T2
?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� S%��I$ k l���� 6��C=�� R)4C� ��@_�@)@D HqAf�� ���P$ �a
�@�.�2p � %��. ����$ �1Q- 3)4C�� 6�CQ$ ?�* <@� ,52.6% j ����1��P5 H�X���r��� JK��N ]T k��-�� �F�� 2 ,
�F� ��@�T <���1�� 6��� �-�@ ,�P�Q��� S%�I�� R)4C5 B�CD + R)4C5 ]T u� <@= S%�I��?�@)@A�� JK���
<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��$ �1Q- ���n2 ,�@��X ����HqAf)�� ��P$ �a��� ��P5 �²T 0��� �� �@_�@)@A��
z G��C��� �t%��� 3 s��� + S%�I�� �F G �Q52 ,°-�$ G½�� �1�Z 0@ �5 + ��4�T G �Q5 <@= ,�@�.���� S�@;�2 ,G�§ s@�¦ MF��� h�.���� GI7 + �1t�-�� �@)���� S%�P��
��@bCQ� :�C��2]�P5 0�A� �=@=� �@)�X H��Qc5 G�G ��� �*��5 2T GII*��5 �@_�@)@D ��Af$ R�$ ]T ��D ,
±�� �@)-5 � M�N�L�� G@��C�� + H�%�P�� ��ON >�� T �@5�@;� H�%�I���,�����Q�� G@��C�� S%�[2 1433�V
���� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:
��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �$�K5a�?��@)@A�� B�CD + ]2��C��2 ` JK��� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��
![Page 16: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 92 –
KH�L2 5 :4 ���� � QH� ��H K���Y�+ '%� �&� ��� �� �� ������ ���� ���������� ��� ���� � !��� "�#! ���$%&�P
��$�� a�%c ��$�� a�%c
'G���� de 'G���� � R����
4
R����
3
R����
2
R����
1 ��. f &� �9�g
2 × * × * H�[�g��
1 × × × * Bz��C�� 6�.
1 × × × * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 10�62.5 6�37.5
2 × * × * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5
g�
9�KH
^�
2 × * × * �.�b��
2 × * × * S%��;�
1 × × × * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 10�62.5 6�37.5
1 × × × * M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�Q�
h���
g�9�
2 × * × * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON
2 × * × * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$�����
7�58.3
5�41.7
1 × × × * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ���
� g�
9�
2 × * × * kA@$�-���� ]�|5a� ����
2 × * × * k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� 6�50
6�50
2 × * × * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$
� g�
9�
2 × * × * 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��
1 × × × * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��
1 × × × * 0@N��A�� H�1D�$
2 × * × * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5
12�60
8�40
2 × * × * H��)@��1��
i��j
� g�
9�
31c40.8 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�
45c59.2 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�
*'G���� P ×'G���� deP
R�$ ¥4C�`2���� 5 G��C��� H�%��I$ ���X ]T
�P��C�� E�F�� B��CD + �-)4�C�� ]2���C��2 `�K�5a�?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%��P�� k� 31
� %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$40.8%, H�%��I�� ���X �-�@
k �-)4C�� ��45 � %��. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ 59.2%, H�%���I$ 3)4��5 6�CQ��$ ]T ����X 0Af�� ���q�2
B����CD + ]2�����C��2 `�K���5a�����@)@A��? JK����� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��,s�t�C�� ]2� 3�1� ��D
![Page 17: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 93 –
B��CD `�K�7 �LDT ]T �QcN `2���?��@)@A�� JK��� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� G��C��� H�%��I� �-)4C��
h����� 0K�c�� �� ]2���C��2 `�K�5a� �P��C�� E�F��lk_���@)@A�� ]�|��5a�p 3)4��5 6�CQ��$ d��� <��@� ,
H�%�I�� � %��. �����$ �1Q�- �@750% 0K�c�� ��@��2 , <����L��l���@_�@)@A�� HqX���cC�� ���X©p d��� <��@� ,
��@7 3)4C�� 6�CQ$41.7 V% + G@���C�� GQ�. �f��2���%��7 (Florida Department of Education, 2017)
]2���C�� H�%�I$ WX ������ ^ �-$ R)4C5 ]T �@�T 89`�K5a�2V
�DR�$ ¥4C�`2���� H�%��I$ ��LDT ]T �Q�cN + ��-@)4�5 ]2���C��2 `�K�5a� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��
B�CD?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� S%���I$ k�� l���5�z G@��P� ]T G��C���� 6���C=�� �X�Q���p ,
3)4C�� 6�CQ$ d� <@�100% ��z <��1�� 2|��2 , B���CD ]T 89?���@)@A�� JK���� <����L�� M�N���L�� N����O
H�%�P�� ��D ,���X 0Af 0Kc�� ��*��� ���tT R)45 ,B��CA�� `�K�7 R�$ 0K7 0A� �@)��P5 ���tT R)45 R�$ 0K7 0D ���² + R-P$ %�1Cn� WX ��4�T �_��C�a2 + G �Q�Ct ��c�C��� ���ti� �F ]T2 ,B�CA�� `�K7
G����2z G@��@P5 + ���1�b�� S�X�Q��$ V 6�CQ��$ d��� �-��@E%�I� 3)4C�� lQ�� h�$ ]2���C�� m@P=C 6�C=�� G
G��C�� m@P=C� R��no�p2 ,l �D%�f�� + 6�C=�� G �Q�
HqAf��� 0;p 00.0 % ]T ���z `���2 ,S%��I$ 0�A�2T ]2��C�� R$ ¨�N MT R)4C� j ?�@)@A�� B�CD �D%�f��
,G��C��� m�@P=C� GIQ�cNT �1�b�� 3 HqAf�� 0� +���5 W�X 3)_�P�� �X�� �F 2 J@B��CA���*��$ 89 ��C
G��C��� m�P=@� ;R��no� h$ ]2��C�� H�%�I� �-@)452 0�)��� |��|�5 + G �Q�� °�C�2 ,��1�b�� 3� }2��C�� ����@)���� H�f���.�-�� R���$ S��cC���ta�2 k���X���
i�2 G@ ��c�� G���5 ?��-¡T GC�5 k�C�� ����Ac�� H��2�Z °Q@X �D��2 ,�@)���� m_�P;�2 °Q�@X k�-2 S�1� �T2
�2016 �WX ��$2 ������� ^ ��-$ + ��O-�� S���X9 �@�T ��I_��C�� S%2· WX �@D�C��2 ;�@)�X S��$ R$ �-)4C5 �����Ac�� �D%�f���� ���t%�� ¥@��C5 k��C�� �bf��Ni� W��X
��)X ^�� m1�t �$ h$ mcC�2 ,?�KPCta�2 ��)X ^��x.�2 kCc��2� 2015 � ?��@)@A�� �bfNT 3)45 �@��
`�K5a� GX�5 H�%�1�� �����7 m�P=@� ,Bq�b�� 6��GI-@ H�{®� `��1C� V
I+�$� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:
��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �$?��@)@A�� B���CD + �$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� JK��� <����L��
M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��
![Page 18: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 94 –
KH�L2 6 :4�*&� '��G��+ '%� �&� ��� �� �� ������ ���� ������$%&� "�#! � !��� ���� ��� ������� ���� � '���P
a� ��$��%c a� ��$��%c
'G���� de 'G���� � R����
7
R����
6
R����
5
R����
4
R����
3
R����
2
R����
1 ��. f &� g�9�
3 × × × × * * * H�[�g��
3 × × × × * * * 6�.Bz��C��
3 × × × × * * * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 14�50 14�50
5 × * × * * * * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5
g�
9�KH
^�
3 × × × × * * * �.�b��
3 × × × × * * * S%��;�
4 × × * × * * * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 18�64.3 10�35.7
0 × × × × × × × Q�M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�
h���
g�9�
3 × × × × * * * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON
3 × × × × * * * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$����� 12�57.1 9�42.9
3 × × × × * * * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ���
� g�
9�
1 × * × × × × × �-���� ]�|5a� ����kA@$
0 × × × × × × × k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� 16�76.2 5�23.8
4 × × × * * * * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$
� g�
9�
0 × × × × × × × 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��
3 × × × × * * * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��
0 × × × × × × × 0@N��A�� H�1D�$
3 × × × × * * * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5
29�82.9 6�17.1
0 × × × × × × × H��)@��1�� i
��j� g
�9�
44�33 �@�A�� H�%��AC�� ������� �1Q-�� 89�67 �@�A�� H�%��AC�� ������� �1Q-��
*'G���� P ×'G���� deP
R$ ¥4C�`2��� 6��X ]T H�%���A5 H�%��I$ C�� B�CD + �-)4C�� �$��CQ�� �@)-C�� �P��C�� E�F�� G��
?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%��P�� k� 44 � %��. �����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$33%, ���X �-�@ H�%���A5
k �-)4C�� �� H�%�I��89� %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$
67% H�%��I$ 3)45 6�CQ$ ]T ��X 0Af �q�2 ,���@)-C�� B���CD + �$��CQ���� ?���@)@A�� JK���� <����L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��,st�C�� ]2� `2���� 3�1� �D
B��CD `�K�7 �LDT ]T �QcN?��@)@A�� JK��� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I� �-)4C��
![Page 19: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 95 –
`2i� 0K�c�� �� �$��CQ��� �@)-C�� �P��C��l Ha���S����p�$ d�� <�@� , 3)4�C�� 6�CQ50% 0�.T �-�@ ,
�� �$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� H�%��I� ��-@)45 B�CA�� `�K7 3)4�C�� 6�CQ�$ d�� <@� ,x$�®� 0Kc��17.1% ,
0K�c�� �F + 3)4C�� 6�CQ$ ��c�N� u1t ����2 ,���.qZ9 0K�c�� �F� �I-)4C� j H�%�I�� ±� ]T 89
S%�I$ k 2l 6�C=�� s15�� H��P@1bC%i� G��X�p , S%���I$2l 6���C=�� s15���� H���P@1bC?���@�i� G���Xp , S%���I$2l 6���C=�� s15���� H���P@1bC?����|@c�� G���Xp ,
S%�I$2 l 6�C=�� s15�� H��P@1bCH�@�r����� G��Xp , B��CD + x$��®� 0K�c�� 6��C£ ]T °-�)?��@)@A��
JK���� <����L�� M�N���L�� ����ON H�%���P�� y���bC� j k�� 2 ;6���ni� �������� H�K��K�C� ,�%i� G���X
��4���T �D%�f���2 ,H�@��r�����2 ,?����|@c��2 ,?���@�i�2 <��L�� 0Kc��l�@_�@)@A�� HqX�cC�� �X©p ,MF��2 j
� ��4�T R)4C��C��@)���� ����� V ^ ��-$ 89 `�����2 G�5 <�@= ,��@��;� ^ �-�� + �O-�� S��X9 �|�� ��$�AC$
3� +����� �� ��C£ + h)¤ �P��b �I)@)K5 G@ ��c$ �-7�X �z9 ���n ,H�@r�����2 �t�-��2 �@-PC��2 ������������� x�%��5 + ���I$ � �%2� u���5 ������� uCD ]T
�Lee, 2014 V� �DR�$ ¥4C� H�%��I$ ��LDT ]T �Q�cN `2����
B��CD + ��-@)45 �$��CQ�� �@)-C�� �P��C�� E�F�� G��C��
?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON ��H�%��P k� H�%�I��lk�)���� ?�K�PCta� W�X 6��C=�� �X�Q�p ,
2lG��C��� 6��� J�4���2 S��P�� ��PN 6�C=�� [{�p ,2lM�=C��2 <=1�� "�7 6�C=�� ¥@C�p H?�* <@� ,
3)45 �1Q- S%�I$ 0D68.4% u1t ]T <��1�� 6��2 , B�CD + H�%�I�� ��5 3)45?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L��
M�N�L�� ��ON �H�%�P� B�CD 6�C£ ]T 89 ���� ?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� M��¦ l �z��$HT���.?p <��=1��2 ?�K��PCta� W��X �X�Q��5 k��C��2 ,
�@5�F�� �5�%�. JfACQ� ]T u��b�� h@bCQ�2 ,M�=C��2 ����C�� R)4�C5 ��D ,¢2�b�� `Å�QC�� RX ��*~� +
¨�r�$ �@_�@)@A��l?�KPCta�p72 , S��A7 ¢��Z GC� �@�@)�X,m�)XT 0Af� �I@7 <=1�� u��b�� R$ u�b��2 V
�6�CQ��$ H�%���I�� ±��� U��g� �-��@4��c�-$ �� R��$ S%�I$ k 2 ,3)4C��l 6�C=�� s15�� H��P@1bC G��X
�%i�p S%���I$2 ,l 6���C=�� s15���� H���P@1bC G���X?����|@c��p 3)4��C�� 6�CQ��$ d��� <��@� ,10.5 % 0��A�
�1Q�N {C�52 ,S%�I$ S%��I$2 ,�4�c�-$ �����$l s15���6�C=�� H�P@1bC ?��@�i� G�Xp 6�CQ�$ d�� <�@� ,
3)4��C��5.3 V% B���CD R)4��C� j �����nT2?���@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� S%��I� ���.qZ9
l 6��C=�� s15�� H��P@1bCH�@�r����� G��Xp <�@� , 3)4C�� �1QN Ug�00.0%�T 89 ��z �X�� �� , ]T ��@
![Page 20: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 96 –
�@r����� G@ �c�� %�1CXa� 3� Fn��5 B��CD J@��5 �-X�222 `[���CN�7 ����DT ���$ h��$ ����z m��7��C�2 ,?���@)@A��
(Vantassel & Wood, 2010) Áz���)N ���@�X�7 W��X �@t�%��� H������2 ^ �-�� G@)K5 + ��$�AC�� ^ �-��
���N�L�� ������ +V ��I$ 3)4�5 6�CQ$ ��c�N� m��C� �@72 H�%
Ug� kC��2 ,�$��CQ�� �@)-C��33% 2|��� <��1�� ]�7 ,JK��� ?�@)@A�� 6�C£ ]T 89 ��c�Na� ��z <���L��
M�N�L�� ��ON 6��� WX G��C�� mP=@� �c@��5 G5 H�%�P�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD 3)45 + ��[%� ��C a� RA� j2 ,�KP��
JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON C�� H�%��I$ H�%�P�� ��@)- M���=C��2 <��=1��2 k��)���� ?�K��PCta� + �$��CQ���� 89 �f�� �F� 2 ,6��ni� �@)���� ������ ¨2�c �b%2
�@�t%��� u�CA�� ����b5 ��@�T�Winter, 2007���D , ¢��.� RQ��� ���r��� ���1X2�2016� 89 ���@�T w�³9
?��@)@A�� ^ ��-$ ���X9 ]�� + 3KC��� V ��qN ��D
��X 0Af�N >qC�n� H�%��I�� Ha��� 3)4�5 uQ �)X ^�2 {�� �5 ��F� ;?�@)@A�� B�CD + h%i�
�2016 � ?��@)@A�� B��CD + H�%��I�� h��[�5 �@�T WXM2�QC$ 0AfV
`2����� R�$ m1t ��2 32 ,42 ,52 ,6 ¥4�C� , ���P��C�� E�F���� G��C���� H�%���I$ 3)4��5 6�CQ��$ ]T
1bC��2 �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� �@)-C `�K5a�2 �@5�@;� H�P@ ?����@)@A�� B����CD + �$��CQ����� ����@)-C��2 ]2�����C��2
JK���� <����L�� M�N���L�� ����ON d��� H�%���P��58.6% , E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ 3)4�5 ���X 6�CQ$ d� �-@ ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC��2 ��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� �@)-C �P��C��
+ �$��CQ�� �@)-C��2 ]2��C��2 `�K5a�2 ?�@)@A�� B�CD JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P��41.4% 3�1�2 ,
`2���7 H�%��I�� h@)� ��X 0Af 3)4C�� 6�CQ$ h%i�:
KH�L2 7 :4��� ������� ���� � ��� �� �� ������ ���� � �*� ���� � !��� "�#! ���$%&�P
'G���� 'G���� de �����&�
��$�� % �$��� %
�@)-5 H�%�I$ �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� 102 89.5 12 10.5
�@5�@;� H�P@1bC�� H�%�I$ 57 75 19 25 ]2��C��2 `�K5a� H�%�I$ 31 40.8 45 59,2
�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$ 44 33 89 67
�����&� I�m 234 58.6 165 41.4
![Page 21: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 97 –
�<1� ��8n%�H ���W �:
� � <=1�� ��: - � ]T <����L�� JK���� ?���@)@A�� B���CD R)4��C
��ON M�N�L�� �� ��$ W�X H�%�P�� : ���$�AC�� ^ ��-��STEMH�%�I$2 , �@)-C�� H�%�I$2 ,�$��CQ�� `�K5a�
E�F�� G��C�� �@�)X 3Q=C� ,]2��C��2V - ����@�T �7�����5 J������5 ����g��� �����|@��N~�
H�=�bK��)�� ���@_�@)@A�� + B���CD ?���@)@A�� JK���� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� V - ?���@)@A�� B���CD 6���C£ G �Q���� ]T S%2·
]2���C�� m@Pv + H�%�P�� ��ON M�N�L�� <��L�� JK�� s15�� ]T2 ,HqAf�� 0; GI�$ �D%�f��2 R��no� h$ G���C��� m�P �¦ k�A� H�@r����� G�X H�P@1bC 6�C=��
E�F��V ���¡�� ��@)�X H��t�%� ?���*9 <�=1�� ¢P�2
������gC$ ]���A52 ,���@��;� ���t�%��� : ?���@)@A�� B���CD1,2,4,5 ?���@)@A�� B���CD2 ,H�%���P�� ����ON l ����O-��Kc��pV
* * * H �)��&� '�S�TIL�$&�
oYH@ :'�+$ � IL�$&�:
�T ������)£ |���7 , �2011 V� ��@)-5 + ������ �bf�Ni� %2��@5�@;� H�%�I��V � ��$�P$ 0�)X ��.%2 �¬��)� M�-Q���
����®� �%���)�� <��L��: kX��b. 3� �D�,��� y��7�
"���®�2 ������� G@����C�� ,9-10�4�2011] ����X ,: S%�[2G@��C��2 �@��V
3�t�� ,��)£2 ;U��$ ,Y-�� �T�2017 V��$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� :���³�$2 � ���T2 �I$�Ic$ VS� �P�� : �@���� �X�)���
,-��2 u�%�C��V �n ,�´i��� �1997 V� G���)�� E�F��� G��C��� H����cD + �$�P$
�����V mf$� ��$�* ���, 13�1�, 32-20V 9��)£ ,M�2|�2 ;`�D ,%�-At �1994 V� ��@*���-AC�� + ��$�P$
�@)@��C��V]�X :h�[�C��2 ,-�� ¢qc�� �1CA$V 3Q�� U- ]�[�t ,�)X ^�2 ;�´T U- ����� ,{�� �2016 V�
cC�� H�%�I$ B��CD + �-)4�C�� �bf�Ni� + ��.�-�� ��A M�N��L�� }��L�� JK�� ?�@)@A��l��@�@�v ��t�%�pV ����
,G@KP�� ��$�* �@Qc-��2 ����� ������ 9�2�,458-421V ���)£ ��)£ ,��@;� �2003 V��5�@�@5��t�2 x�%��C�� m�_��Z V
S�=C�� �@���� H�%�$~� :k�$��� B�CA�� %��V ���t ,���)X ^���S����N ,x.���2 ;]�[����1X ,k��Cc��2 ; �2015 V�
i� + �@t�ti� ?�KPCta� H�t 3)45 6�CQ$ �bf�N����N�L�� ����)�� ?�@)@A�� uCD + �@�)���V ���� ���$�*
�� R��=1�� ,�@Qc-��2 ����� ����3�16�,516-487V ��1X2 ;��@1X �´T ,RQ� m�7�$ ,��r��� �2016 V� B��CD 0�@�v� JK�� ?�@)@A�� G����� ���4�. m�72 WX st�C�� <��L�
��@1��2 h)C���2 �@*���-AC��2 �S.T.S.E�V ���� ���$�* �� ���g,�@Qc-��2 ����� ��=151,458-436V
m��� �)£ ,RQ� �1994 V�Y��� H��gC$2 E�F�� G��C��V ����@��,�b. ��$�� 111�23� ,46-52V
`����N ,����|��2 ;�����n ,G@������ �2015� V H�����$ 0��@�c5 6���$ ?��@�i� B��CD + �-)4�� E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I� ?�@�i�
![Page 22: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 98 –
G@K�P�� ��Pb-) M�N�L�� `2i� JK��V H��t�%� ����,xc-�� G�X2 �@�� + �@�X65�9�,188-159V
�´T ,h@% �@);��1X �2000 V��$�®� ?�-¡T G��)�� �@-I�� �@)-C��V Qc-��2 ����� ��=1�� ����@ �� [i� ���$�*,88,187-
155 V UcX ,M2�-b��2 ;M[�7 ,k-@,���2006 V��@)@��C�� Hq����� :
�@5�$����� YX + E�F�� G��C�� 0n�$ VS� ��P�� : |�D�$,-�� B�CA�� V
�@��t ,}��)f��� �2010 V� �@�t�ti� H�Q��� 3)4�5 6�CQ�$?�KPCtq�JK��� ?���|@c�� uCD + �@�)��� �bfNi� +
�����Q�� �@���� �A�)�� + M�N�L�� }�L��V ��@�2��� ���������� ��=�,31,151-122 V
��)£ ,k�1@�|��2 ;�I7 ,h��f��2 ;�´T ,]���4�� �2015 V� 6��$ �����Q��� �@���� �A�)�� + ?��|@c�� uCD 6�C£ 3)45
��§ 3�)���� k�X2 6�CQ$2 �@�)C��� �@)���� ���4P��V � ��� �@Q�c-��2 ������ ������−,R���=1��2�16�,197-
161V ��K��X ���)£ ,���@�Z �2009 V� G��C����2 G@����C�� H�@�@5���t�
`��c��. ��X] :h�[�C��2 ,-�� ?�©~� %��V >2Å���� ��1X y%��Z ,�$��X�2005 V�E�F��� G��C��� l��)@ �c$
2�QtT2 1@��tT�pVS� �P�� :h�[�C��2 ,-�� �@����� %����V X����1X `qZ ,k1X|��2 ;0)C� }� ,H��@1 �2005 V� H�%��I$
R�$ 82i� �qL�� >�cK�� ������ uCD + E�F�� G��C����I@)��$ ��ON ��*22 � ��C£ 0@�v `qn V ���$�* ����
���n ��������� ������ ,3�5�,92-6- V �� �1X �´T ,��� �1987 V�bC��2 ����O-�� 3 E�F�� G��C��m�@1 V
U��A�� :0tqQ�� H�z H�%�f-$V
j��t ��)£ ,}��)��� �2005 V� u�CD + E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ �� ��C£ 0�@�v `q�n R�$ ���N�L�� ����)�� H�@r����� ��@���� ��A�)�� + w��15 ��Pb-) ��I@)��$ �ON �I*22
�����Q��V ,��5�$ ���$�* ,S%�f�-$ ��� �CQ*�$ ���t% i�]�%V
u��� ,°Q@X�T2 ;�)£ R GL�@ ,°Q�@X k�-2 ;���-�9 ,S��1��2016 V� WX 3)_�. 3@Q�%�5 3*z�)N ����Ct� �@���7
������� G���5 ��=N �1�b�� �@�7�� + k_�-1�� °=-��V ���� ,����. ]�b�Q��� ���$�* �@Q�c-��2 ����� H�t�%���
10�1�235-222V N�b�t ,¥��c���G�t�. U- �2015 V� u�CD 3)4�5 6��$ ����X
���ON ���I*2 R��$ ���@5�@;� H�%���I)�� �b��t�C�� ���������������� ���-��) �������� H�����$V ������� �������
,�KK�C�� 40�4� ,64-8V �@It ,M2qCc���G\��D RQ£ �2004 V� ����X9 + G@���C�� ����c5
M����� G���PC��2 ���@P�� + Áz��)NT G����� 0�@ �52 V]�X :y2,�� %��V -� ,]�X�P���)£ G@ ��9 ]� �2005 V� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� 0�@�v
+ �b�t�C�� �@�t�ti� �����)�� ������ uCD + S�%����i� ��I*2 R$ �§ ���®� �@t�%��� H������ G��P52 ]�%
������ k)��$ �ONV ���$�* ,S%�f-$ �� �CQ*�$ ���t% �5�$]�%i� ,V
X ,�)f. �2002 V�H�@�@5�t� ����Ct� �¡T)@ ��c�� �@gC�� k G@ ��c�� ±�1�� ���$��� ��1�Z H�%�K�5 ¥@=K�5 WX
?�@�i� + �@)����V ���$�* ,S%�f�-$ �� ��%�CD� ���t% ,x)� 3X�@���� Y$ ��%�I�.
�´T m@7�5 ,kX�$ �1998 V�G@��C�� ���c5 V ��X] :�Ac�� %��V
![Page 23: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �
– 99 –
RQ� ]�@�t ,]�-�� �2006 V�@A�� G@ �c�� G��P52 0@�v + ��@_�@)]���Q�� ���N�L�� ������ ?�@)@A�� S��$ H�%�P$V ����t%
�������� ]���Q���� ����$�* ,S%�f��-$ ���� �CQ��*�$�@*���-AC��2V
G@����C�� S%�[2 �����Q���� �1433 V� ����ON M�N���L�� G@����C�� 0��@��H�%�P$V,x$��®� %����~� ������� : ����� ¨2,�$
@��C�� ���bC� |�|����1X R ���1X����� GV o��!�U :'�1GL^� IL�$&�:
Al-Ahmed, K. (1997). Introduction in the competencies of
self - learning for the Arab teacher. (in Arabic).
Journal of University of Damascus, 13(1), 20-32.
Al-Dalaan, A., & Al-Shayah, F. & Al-Zoghyby, M. (2015).
The extent of inclusion the content of physics books
in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia the social scientific
issues and the level of awareness about it with
teachers. (in Arabic). Journal of King Saud
University for Educational and Psychological
Sciences, 2(16), 161-197.
Al-dghaim, K. & Al-Zayd, N. (2015). The extent of
activation of the biology teachers of the self-
learning skills which included in the biology book
for the first grade secondary in Al- Qassiem region.
(in Arabic). Journal of Arab Studies in Education
and Psychology, 65(9), 159-188.
AL-Faleh, S. (2015). The extent of inclusion science books
which is taught in intermediate stage to life skills
from the point of view of science teachers in
Riyadh city. (in Arabic). Journal of Specialized
Educational, 40(4), 8-64. Al-Jabr, L., & Haj Omer, S. (2016). Critical Thinking Skills
in the Activities which included in the Book of
Chemistry for the Second Secondary Grade
"Analytical Study. (in Arabic). Journal of
Educational and Psychological Sciences Qassiem
University, 9(2), 421-458.
Al-Shamrani, S. (2010). The level of inclusion of the basic
features of the survey in practical activities in the
second grade secondary physics books in Saudi
Arabia. (in Arabic). The International Journal of
Educational Research, 31, 122 -151.
Billett, S. (2010). The Perils of Confusing Lifelong
Learning with Lifelong Education. International
Journal Of Lifelong Education, 29(4), 401-413.
Birk, J., & Kurtz, M. (1999). Effect of Experience on
Retention and Elimination of Misconceptions about
Molecular Structure and Bonding. Journal of
Chemical Education, 76(1), 124 - 128.
Essa, G., & Abou Libdah, E. & Beni Essa, H. (2016). The
effectiveness of using two instructional models
based on the constructivist approach in the student
motivation towards science learning. (in Arabic).
Journal of Educational and Psychological Studies
Sultan Qabous University, 10(1), 222-235.
Florida Department of Education. (2017, March 12).
Mathematics, Science & STEM Programs.
Retrieved from
http://www.fldoe.org/academics/standards/subject-
areas/math-science/stem.
Haj omer, S., Bucks, N., & ALmufti, A. (2015). The level
of inclusion of basic survey features in practical
activities in the books of chemistry for the
secondary stage. (in Arabic). Journal of the
University of Bahrain for Educational and
Psychological Sciences, 3(16), 487-516.
Hassan, A. & Abdu -Alreda, M. (2016). Analysis of the
book of chemistry for the third grade intermediate
according to the issues of science and technology.
society and the environment (S.T.S.E). (in Arabic).
Journal of Baghdad University for Educational and
Psychological Research, 51, 436-458.
Hassan, M. (1994). Self-learning and time variables. (in
Arabic). Journal of Education, University of Qatar,
111(23), 46-52.
Lee, Y. (2014). Comparative Analysis of the Presentation
of the Nature of Science in U.S. High school
Biology and Korea High school Science Textbooks.
National Teacher Education Journal, 7(2), 11-19.
Maxwell, J. (1985). The future of textbooks–Can they help
individualize education: A Bulletin Special.
National Association of Secondary School
Principals, 68–74.
Mok, C. & Cheng, C. (2001). Theory of Self Learning in a
Human and Technological Environment:
Implications for Education Reforms. International
Journal of Education Management, 15(4), 172-186.
Obaidat, H. & Al-Zouhby, T. (2005). Self-learning skills in
science books for the first three grades through
analyzing their content and the point of view of
their teachers. (in Arabic). Journal of King Khalid
University for Educational Sciences, 3(5), 6-92.
Osborne, J. (2014). Teaching critical thinking, New
directions in science education. Perspectives on the
science curriculum, 95(352), 53-62.
Rabiah, A. (2000). Professional development of the teacher
![Page 24: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l](https://reader034.vdocuments.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051908/5ffc3c3a3b92b928fe0f01d5/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV
– 100 –
during service. (in Arabic). Journal of Educational
and Psychological Research Al-Azhar University,
88, 155-187.
VanTassel, J. & Wood, S. (2010). The Integrated
Curriculum Model (ICM). Learning and Individual
Differences, 20(4), 345-357.
Winter, C. (2007). Edr-rcation for Sustainable Development
and the Secondary Curriculum in English schools:
rhetoric or reality. Cambridge Journal of
Education, 37(3), 317- 354.
* * *