,17(5)$ $200$ø,1 ø,*˘1’,5($ 6,67(0,& -...
TRANSCRIPT
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
215
,17(5)$ $ 20-0$ù,1 ù,�*Æ1',5($�6,67(0,& �,,�
[de la (e-)sisteme B-D-E / Belief-Desire-Emotion
la (e-)sisteme A-I-A / Awareness-Insight-Action; VSUH�R�WH] GH�GXDOLWDWH�D�DFHVWRUD@
Nicolae Bulz [email protected]
Abstract: Human-Machine Interface (Systems) is a prominent specialization into the Automatic Systems domain. Meantime, Computer Science contains a very connected specialization: Computer-Human Interaction. Here, after an interdisciplinary analysis, it is proposed a new insight into the basis of these specializations: the cross over between Belief-Desire-Emotion (e-)systems and Awareness-Insight-Action (e-)systems. Into this context, new types of structure are proposed: Internetron, Planetron, Sociotron – the last being as equivalence with four new types of neural networks, and their co-ordination. ÌQ� QXP UXO� DQWHULRU� DO� UHYLVWHL� 12(0$� D� IRVW� SXEOLFDW SDUWHD� vQWDL� D�DFHVWXL�VWXGLX���FX�XUP WRDUHOH�SDUDJUDIH� ���([LVW R /RJLF D GHYHQLULL�FLEHUQHWLFH�RP-PDúLQ "���([LVW IRUPH�HOHPHQWDUH�úL�GH�FRPSR]L LH�SULPDU DOH�LQWHUIH HL�RP-PDúLQ " >DSRUWXO�VLQWDFWLF��VHPDQWLF�úL�SUDJPDWLF�DO�0RGHO ULL�Interactive] ���([LVW úL�DOWH�IRUPH�GH�FRPSUHKHQVLXQH�DOH�GHYHQLULL�FLEHUQHWLFH�RP-PDúLQ " >(QWLW L 8QLYHUVDOH versus�7HQVLXQHD�8PDQExisteQ B5HIOHFWDUH@�
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
216
4. Conceptul de Responsabilitate. Constructul de (meta)responsabilitate - GH�VPXOV�GLQWUX�XQLYHUVXO�FXQRDúWHULL��SULQ�JkQGLUH�VLVWHPLF � SHQWUX�FXSULQGHUHD�LQWHUID D RP-PDúLQ
)LH� GRX úLUXUL� GH� FRQVWUXFWH�PHQWDOH�� FH� VH� GHGLF DOWRU� SRsibile úLUXUL� GH� FRQVWUXFWH�� GH� F XWDW� SkQ OD� GLPLQXDUHD� VHPQLILFDWLY D KLDWXOXL��JDS��GLQWUH�XUP WRDUHOH�S11 úL�S12:
�6����� DERUGDUHD� VHFYHQ LDO�� PLWXO� FD� úL� JkQG�� ³5D LRQDOLWDWHD�3XU ´�� HPLVIHUD�GUHDSW D FUHLHUXOXL� XPDQ��SURFHVDUHD�TXDVL-FDOLWDWLY ;GHVFRSHUL�� ³3HUVRDQ ´�� (GPXQG� +XVVHUO� SULQ� LQWHQWLRQDOLWDWH� �versus"'HVFDUWHV�úL�.DQW��LQWUR-deschidere; … ; HYROX LH� úL� �6�����DERUGDUHD�JOREDO��PDJLFXO�FD�úL�JkQG��³5D LRQDOLWDWHD�3UDFWLF ´��HPLVIHUD� VWkQJ D FUHLHUXOXL� XPDQ�� SURFHVDUHD� TXDVL-cantLWDWLY �LQYHQ LL��³)LLQ ´��*HRUJ�:�)��+HJHO�SULQ�GLDOHFWLF �versus� /HLEQL]�úL�Kant; deschidere; … ; securitate .5HSOLFkQG� OD� WRDWH� DFHVWH� SULQ� FRPSOHPHQWDULWDWHD� GLQWUH� 6��� úL�6����V VPXOJHP�QR LXQLOH�FRPSOHPHQWDUH��HYROX LH�úL�securitate� úL�DVWIHO V DWLQJHP�VPXOJHUHD�QR LXQLL�GH�responsabilite, drept reuniunea celor de mai sus – SULQ� DFFHSWDUHD� FRJQLWLY úL� SUD[LV-ul cu "caracteristica de responsibilitate pentru un sistem (S) : meta_Echilibru , m_Eq_S .Echilibrul sistemului este localizabil (doaU�� OD� LQWHUIHUHQ D GLQWUH�VXEVLVWHPHOH��GHFL]LRQDO��LQIRUPD LRQDO�úL�DF LRQDO���Eq_S .
Fiecare YDULHWDWH� �9�� GH� JkQGLUH� VLVWHPLF –într-un sistem- este DVRFLDW FX� R� DERUGDUH� VLVWHPLF � o cadrare întru (discursiv, intuitiv / reflexiv, empiric), asfel înckW V ILH� GH� FXSULQV� PHQWDO� XUP WRDUHOH�SRVLELOLW L ��DQDOLWLF��KROLVWLF��H[SHULPHQWDO��H[SHULHQ LDO [19]:
Tabelul 3.1 moduri cognitive DISCURSIV INTUITIV REFLEXIV Analitic Descartes Holistic Platon EMPIRIC Experimental Bacon ExperLHQ LDO�Bergson
$FHVWD�HVWH�XQ�WDEOH�SODQDU��QX�VH�LQVLVW DVXSUD�XQHL�SRVLELOH�LQWUR-deschideri cu alte cinci tipurile de hiat între cele patru moduri cognitive.
Tabelul 3.2 � 9DULHWDWHD� GH� JkQGLUH� VLVWHPLF DUH� SURSULLOH� YDULHW Lversus balansul echilibru / metaechilibru� ��úL�YHFLQ W L – cu fondatori de renume )LHFDUH� YDULHWDWH� GH� JkQGLUH� VLVWHPLF �DVRFLDELO XQXL mod cognitiv� SUHFXP� úL� XQXL tip de determinism� SURPRYHD] R H[SOLFD LH� ��
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
217
vQ HOHJHUH�D�5HDOLW LL�GH]LUDELO�VLVWHPLFH��DWkW�([LVWHQ FkW�úL�5HIOHFWDUH� În DFHVW�WDEHO��DFHDVW H[SOLFD LH���vQ HOHJHUH�HVWH�SUH]HQWDW VLQWHWLF�UHODWLY�OD�FRQVWUXFWHOH�GH�HFKLOLEUX�úL�PHWDHFKLOLEUX�
Spinoza/ Russell Analitic Determinism probabilistic
Metaechilibrul sistemului este un subiect extern noX � &DUDFWHULVWLFLOH�OXL� 'XPQH]HX� H[LVW vQ� DFRUG� FX�WRDWH� SRVLELOLW LOH�� 1RL� OH� SXWHP�UHOHYD�SH�FDOH�ORJLF �
/Apa poate fi un simbol propriu.
(V_Spinoza; Russell) H[LVWEq_SM (m_Eq_SM _ ext.)
Goethe Holistic Determinism structural| Selectiv
1DWXUD� QRDVWU �VLVWHPXO� PDMRU��HVWH� VLPSO � ³/XPHD� QX� DU� SXWHD�FRQWLQXD� GDF QX� DU� IL� IRVW� DúD� GH�VLPSO �´� 6WDELOLWDWHD� HL� HVWH�DVLJXUDW PRUIRJHQHWLF�������
/3 PkQWXO poate fi un simb.propriu
(V_Goethe) FRH[LVWPB(TB60��ù,��Eq_SM
Leibniz Experimental Determinism Dinamic
1X� WRDWH� SRVLELOLW LOH� H[LVW � 'DU�H[LVW vQFUHGHUH� vQ� echilibrul �ORFDO��� GH� DWLQV� SULQ� FRQVWUXF LD�LQGXV GH� OD� ORFXV-XO� LQL LDO��SDV�FX�SDV�� F WUH� R� DSURSULDW úL� SRWULYLWYHFLQ WDWH�HWF������������������ /Focul poate fi un simbol propriu.
(V_Leibniz) H[LVW doar Eq_SM
Cusanus ([SHULHQ LDO Determinism Euristic/mixt (om-WHKQLF �
2ULFH� FRLQFLGHQ D RSR]L LLORU�DQWHULRDUH� SRDWH� V DSDU vQWUX�Dumnezeu. Orice cuplu este de S VWUDW� vQWUX� FRQúWLLQ D QRDVWU �Lumea este un act ludic (un joc).
/Aerul poate fi un simbol propriu.
(V_Cusanus) H[LVW cuplaj: (Eq_SM; m_Eq_SM )
$FHVW� WDEHO� ³GHWDOLD] ´ HOHPHQWXO� GLQ� VWkQJD-sus (gandirea VLVWHPLF � DO��7DEHOXOXL��� 7DEHOXO�����SUHLD�SODQDULWDWHD�SURSULH�7DEHOXOXL���úL�7DEHOXOXL�����
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
218
(tabele conceptual diferite), dar propune o viziune în mai multe dimensiuni (modul de gândire, tipul de determinism asociabil, FkWH� R� PHWDIRUGLDIRULF ).
Prin ultima varietate de gândire, V_Cusanus – care permite un cuplaj larg, � GLQ� DFHDVWD� úL� QXPDL� SHQWUX� UHVXUVHOH� FRJQLWLYH� DOH� DFHVWHLD��propune, aici, o revenire la începutul tabelului, reparcurgerea acestui tabel – varietate cu varietate – pe un grad 2 al V_Cusanus� LDU úL�UHYHQLUH�la început etc. grad 3, 4, … . $U� IL� DFHDVWD� R� WHQVLXQH� GH� UHYHGHUH� D� 7DEHOXOXL� �"� 1X�� DFHDVW“explozie –�JUDG�FX�JUDG´�QX�DVLJXU UH-configurare în sensul non-planar al Tabelului 1.
&RQVWUXFWXO�GH�/XPH�D�6LVWHPLFLW LL�úL�,QGLYLGLFLW LL��/6,� Fie conceptele primare de "Sistem� úL� GH� �6XELHFW�5D LRQDO", în LQWHUGHSHQGHQ D GDW GH� FRQVUXFWXO� GH� �Element Obiectiv��� 6 SUHIHU P
conceptul de "Entitate� FDUH� DU� SHUPLWH� RULFH� UHOD LH� vQWUH� �Sistem� úL�"6XELHFW�5D LRQDO" (suprapunHUH�LGHQWLWDWH�� VHSDUDUH�� LQWHUVHF LH�� LQFOXGHUL�GLIHULWH��� )LH� F HQWLWDWHD� HVWH� FDUDFWHUL]DELO GH� XQ� QXP U FkW�PDL�PLF� GH�caracteristici dezirabile: sinergia� S U LORU�� non-entropia� ID GH� PHGLXO�exterior, efemeralitatea (a face din ce în ce mai bine cu din ce în ce mai SX LQ� –�H[SULPDELO –pe scurt-�SULQ�HILFLHQ DVFHQGHQW �7DEHOXO� XUP WRU� FXSULQGH� VLWXD LL� GLIHULWH� GH� FRPELQDUH� D�caracteristicilor –� FX� GHQRPLQDUHD� HQWLW LL� UHVSHFWLYH�� PDL� PXOW� VDX� PDL�SX LQ�VLVWHPLFH��IXQF LH�GH�JUDGXO�GH�UHJ VLUH a respectivelor caracteristici). Tabelul 4 )RUP WDEXODU SHQWUX�/6,� 3URSULHW L��'HQRPLQ UL�� sinergia S U LORU non-entropia (ILFLHQ D$VFHQGHQW1. integron * * * 2. metatron 0 * * 3. netron * 0 * 4. Internetron * ==> 0 0 0 ==> * 5. tranzitron * * 0
... individicitate 0 0 0
���$ERUGDUHD�DQDOLWLF úL�DOJHEULF D QXFOHHORU�PHQWDOH�GH�UHVSRQVDELOLWDWH�úL�PHWDBUHVSRQVDELOLWDWH
Fie un interval previzibil de armonizare între: 0DWHPDWLF � PHWD-0DWHPDWLF � /LQJYLVWLF � PHWD- /LQJYLVWLF (toate acestea versus Tabelele 1-4). 3kQ OD� DWLQJHUHD� DFHVWHL� DUPRQL] UL�� ILH� R� DUPRQL]DUH� vQWUH�
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
219
0DWHPDWLF � )LORVRILD� 0DWHPDWLFLL�� /LQJYLVWLF � ùWLLQ HOH� &RJQLWLYH��������������������������������������������������������������������������(4)
Fie� LQWXL LD��DFFHSWDUHD�úL adaptarea spectrului contemporan al FRPSOH[LW LL�OXPLORU�QRDVWUH: OXPHD��LSRWHWLF���UHDO � PRGHOHOH�GUHSW�PHWD-lume, lumea trans-UHDO � OXPHD� SUH-UHDO �PDQDJHULDO � – ca un inel (referitor la ciclul acestor lumi –� úL� DOH� DOWRUD� SRDWH��� 6 FRQWH[W PSRVLELOLWDWHD� UHSUH]HQW ULL� DFHVWXL� LQHO� � SULQ� �0 �� úL� �0 �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������(5)
Fie constatarea QDWXUDOH HL� FRQVWUXFWHORU� PHQWDOH� DULWmetice úL�respectiv geometrice� >FHHD� FH� DU� FRUHVSXQGH� SUHYDOHQ HL� XQRU� FRQFHSWH�PHQWDOH� SHQWUX� QR LXQL� DULWPHWLFH� úL� UHVSHFWLY� DOJHEULFH� vQ� VHQVXO� UHOD LHL�(1)].
Fie constatarea HODERU ULL�vQ�GHYHQLUHD�XPDQLW LL�D�FRQVWUXFWHORU�PHQWDOH�GH�$QDOL] 0DWHPDWLF úL�UHVSHFWLY�$OJHEU � ÌQ�FRQWH[WXO�UHOD LLORU���������������úL�����V DFFHSW P FRQVWUXFWHOH�GH�0LQWH�$QDOLWLF [3], [4], [5], [6], [19], [22], [23], [33] respectiv 0LQWH� $OJHEULF [1], [9], [14], [21], [23], [28], [29], [33]. 3ULQ� WRDWH� DFHVWH� FRQVWDW UL� úL� DFFHSW UL� SXWHP� UHSUH]HQWD�UH]XOWDWHOH�IRFDOL] ULL�FHUFHW WRULORU�SULQ�QXFOHH�GH�(meta)responsabilitate – SH� XQ� GRPHQLX� ODUJ� DO� YDULHW LL� PLQ LL� RPHQHúWL� �GUHSW� SXWHUH� QDWXUDO úL�GHYHQLW FD�UHSUH]HQWDUH���
Tabelul 5.1. � )RUP WDEXODU SHQWUX�YDUietatea gândirii întruLSI: )RFDOL]DUHD�PHQWDO/ domeniul propriu FHUFHW WRUXOXL
Responsibilitate DVXPDW Meta_responsabilitate DVXPDW0LQWH�$QDOLWLF GEOMODERNITATE
vs. Interdisciplinaritate
TRANS DISCIPLINARITATE vs. Manifestul Transumanist
Minte $OJHEULF FUZZIFICARE vs. Co-disciplinaritate
STRUCTURAL–FENOMENOLOGIE YV��ùWLLQ ,QWHJUDWLY
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
220
Tabelul 5.2. )RFDOL]DUHD�PHQWDO/ domeniul propriu FHUFHW WRUXOXL
Responsibilitate DVXPDW Meta_responsabilitate DVXPDW0LQWH�$QDOLWLF GEOMODERNITATE DVRFLDW JOREDOL] ULL�³UD LRQDOLVWH´���FRPSOH[LW LL�
prospectate
TRANS DISCIPLINARITATE DVRFLDW JOREDOL] ULL�“empiriste” / VLPSOLW LL�H[SHFWDWH�
0LQWH�$OJHEULF FUZZIFICARE $VRFLDW 3RVW-modernismului / FRPSOH[LW LL�constatate
STRUCTURAL–FENOMENOLOGIE $VRFLDW ³WHQVLXQLL�filosofice” / sentimentului cosmic DO�XQLW LL�
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
221
Tabelul 5.3. Promotori români úL�VWU LQL.Precursori români
Responsibilitate $VXPDW Meta_responsabilitDWH�DVXPDWMircea Malitza;
Paul Flondor; Gheorghe Paun, Cristian Calude
Basarab Nicolaescu; Solomon Marcus; 0DULDQD�%HOLú� Boldur-Eugen % UEDW�
Diane-Gabrielle Tremblay; Yves Kodratoff; Valerie Moller; Lauren Langman
Daniel Dubois; Sjoerd L. Bonting; Mariano L. Bianca, Bhajan Greawal
0LQWH�$QDOLWLF
Tudor Arghezi, George Bacovia;
Stefan Milcu
Lucian Blaga; Romulus Vulcanescu; Edmond Nicolau
Constantin Virgil Negoita; Horia-Nicolai Teodorescu; Marcel Stoica;
0LKDL�'U JDQHVFX��*KHRUJKH�ùWHIDQ� Gorun Manolescu;
Lotfi A. Zadeh; Robert Vallée; D. & Kazimierz Turkiewicz
Goro Kato, Menas Kafatos; Richard Amoroso;
0LQWH�$OJHEULF
Ion Barbu; Paul Constantinescu; Victor Sahleanu
Constantin Noica,Mircea
Vulcanescu, Mircea Eliade
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
222
Tabelul 5.4 )RFDOL]DUHD�PHQWDO/ domeniul propriu FHUFHW WRUXOXL
Responsibilitate $VXPDW Meta_responsabilitate DVXPDW0LQWH�$QDOLWLF GEOMODERNITATE
Prin 0DWHPDWLF �/LQJYLVWLFîntru Lumea 6LVWHPLF
TRANS DISCIPLINARITATE Prin 0DWHPDWLF � PHWD-/LQJYLVWLFÎntru Lumea Trans-6LVWHPLF
0LQWH�$OJHEULF FUZZIFICARE Prin meta-0DWHPDWLF �/LQJYLVWLF întru Lumea Meta-6LVWHPLF
STRUCTURAL–FENOMENOLOGIE Prin Meta-0DWHPDWLF �meta-/LQJYLVWLFÎntru Lumea A-6LVWHPLF
7RDWH�DFHVWH�WDEHOH�VXQW�SODQDUH��QX�VH�LQVLVW DVXSUD�XQHL�SRVLELOH�intro-deschideri cu alte cinci tipurile de hiat între cele patru IRFDOL] UL / domenii.
'DU�R�WHQVLXQH�GH�FRPSDUDUH�FX�7DEHOXO���H[LVW � /XPLOH�GLQ�DFHO�tabel au asociate procedurile pull-back / back_back / tech / before - deci sunt mai “altfel”. Aici nu sunt asociate aceste proceduri ci unele deschideri spre meta-úWLLQ H��>'HVLJXU�F V-DU�SXWHD�LPDJLQD�R�IRUP GH�WUHFHUH�FD�vQWUH�7DEHOHOH� ����� úL� ����� �'DU� QX� VXV LQ� F DFHDVWD� QH-ar apropia de contextul Tabelului 1.] ���([LVW R IRUP WUDQVGLVFLSOLQDU SURSULH�XPDQLW LL"� [Poate fi sportul un exemplu?]
)LH�XUP WRUXO�TXDGUXSOX�– GUHSW�R�5( ($�&21&(378$/ '(�,175 5,�úL�,(ù,5,�� ,QWU UL��(;,67(1 >WLQ]kQG�OD��0 �@��35235,(7 ,
[într-R UHOD LH�– tinzând la (M*)]; ,HúLUL��,17(1 ,21$/,7$7(�[12];(META)RESPONSABILITATE.
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
223
ùL�ILH�WUHL�SDúL�GH�H[SDQGDUH�D�DFHVWHL�UH HOH��- pentru CINCI NIVELURI ASCUNSE: (;,67(1 => ********** <= 35235,(7 ,
********** ********** ********** � ,17(1 ,21$/,7$7( <= ********** => (META)RESPONSABILITATE
$FHDVWD�HVWH�R�UH HD�FRQFHSWXDO vQFKLV – FDUH�SRDWH�IL�XWLOL]DWFD�RULFH�WLS�GH�UH HD�QHXURQDO � vQ�DSOLFD LL��FX�DQXPLWH�LQWU UL�– reale sau simulate) –�RE LQkQG�LHúLUL�
I: Primul pas de expandare: (;,67(1 =>fiind => a FI<=> a AVEA <= având <= 35235,(7 ,
a COMBINA a CONCORDA a CONDUCE ,17(1 ,21$/,7ATE <= fiind => a FI <=> a AVEA <= având => (META)RESPONSABILITATE
$FHDVWD�HVWH�R�UH HD�FRQFHSWXDO GHVFKLV – care poate fi XWLOL]DW FD�RULFH�WLS�GH�UH HD�QHXURQDO � vQ�DSOLFD LL��FX�DQXPLWH�LQWU UL�– UHDOH�VDX�VLPXODWH��FX�³LQWHUSUHWDUHD���GHVFKLGHUHD´�GDW GH�XWLOL]DWRU�SHQWUX�VHPQLILFD LD�QLYHOXULORU��– RE LQkQG�LHúLUL� ,,��3HQWUX�DO�GRLOHD�SDV�GH�H[SDQGDUH�V DVRFLHP� /2*,& �� !�/2*,& � (7,& � (67(7,& � $;,2/2*,(��ETOLOGIE� 35$;,2/2*,(��«��ù7,,1 ( «
,0$*,1$ ,(�� � !�,0$*,1$ ,(��/,7(5$785 � ),/262),(��TEOLOGIE, ARTE, MANAGEMENT (;,67(1 => ********** <= 35235,(7 ,
********** IMAGINATION & ** ****Q*****
********** LOGIC & * ,17(1 ,21$/,7$7( <=********** =>
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
224
(META)RESPONSABILITATE
Unde Q – UHSUH]LQW FRQVWUXFtul de QUALIA :: LOCUL �³/,36$�'(�67$5(´��'(�,03/2=,(�$�,175$5,/25�ù,�,(ù,5,/25�UH HOHL�FRQFHSWXDOH�LQL LDOH��&RQVWUXFWXO�4�HVWH�³IL[DW´�SH�YHUEDOLWDWHD�GH�FRQFRUGDQ �DWkW�FD�H[LVWHQ FkW�úL�FD�UHIOHFWDUH�� 3ULQ�DFHDVWD��UH HDXD�FRQFHSWXDO SURSXV QX�HVWH�QXPDL�LPSOLFLW�GHVFKLV �FL�úL�H[SOLFLW� $VWIHO��vQ�DFHDVW H[SDQGDUH�FRQFHSWXDO � TXDGUXSOXO�SULPDO�UHOHYun dipol dual asociat la ,0$*,1$ ,(��/2*,& �([LVW XQ�QXFOHX�YHUEDO�LQWHUQ��D�&21&25'$��1XFOHXO�H[WLQV�YHUEDO�HVWH�aCOMBINA; a CONCORDA; a CONDUCE. Acesta este dependent de fluxul dual verbal: a FI <=> a AVEA.ÌQ�DFRUG�FX�SDVXO�DO�GRLOHD�GH�H[SDQGDUH��H[LVW XQ�FRUSXV�TXDVL-VIHULF�GH�YHUEH�úL�VXEVWDQWLYH�
În acord cu linia "a COMBINA; a CONCORDA; a CONDUCE" , úL�FX�LQYHUVXO�DFHVWHLD���a CONDUCE; a CONCORDA; a COMBINA"� VLPDJLQ P XQ�SURFHV�GH�WLS�LPDJLQH�0|ELXV�– VXV LQkQG�GXDOLWDWHD�FRQFHSWXDO SUH]HQWDW DQWHULRU��vQWUH�TXDGUXSOXO�DVRFLDW�OD��EXISTENCE; 35235,(7 ,��,17(1 ,21$/,7$7(� (META)RESPONSABILITATE�úL�GLSROXO�DVRFLDWHG�OD�,0$*,1$ IE; /2*,& , dar UHSUH]HQWkQG�R�FRQFHSWXDO HFKLYDOHQ FX�R�TXDVL-EDQGMöbius. )LH�F DFFHSW P DFHDVW TXDVL-EDQG GUHSW�XQ�FRQVWUXFW��GHGLFDW�H[SOLF ULL���vQ HOHJHULL�XQGHUVWDQGLQJ�vQWUX�TXDGUXSOXO�FRQFHSWXDO�SUH]HQWDW�úL��UHVSHFWLY��GLSROXO�– în sensul�GH�D�LGHQWLILFD�R�SRVLELOLWDWH�GH�UHOD LRQDUH�WUDQVGLVFLSOLQDU FLUFXODU vQWUH�ù7,,1 � /,7(5$785 � ),/262),(��TEOLOGIE ARTE; MANAGEMENT, drept un fundament pentru a propune úL�SURED�un inel al lumilor noastre: REAL; METAREAL; 75$165($/�úL�35(5($/.6 GHnumim toate acestea drept un argument de tip Möbius referitor la lumile noastre. Acest argument s-DU�VLQWHWL]D�vQ�XUP WRDUHOH�3URSR]L LL� 3URSR]L LD��� /XPHD�QRDVWU FRQ LQH�R�eterogenitate de lumi.$FHDVWD�VXJHUHD] R HWHURJHQLWDWH�XQLYHUVDO �3URSR]L LD 2� ([LVW XQ�KLDW�vQWUH�([LVWHQ úL Reflectare 3URSR]L LD��� /XPLOH�QRDVWUH�SUH]LQW R VWUXFWXU GH�WLS�Entitate (Caracteristici).3URSR]L LD��� $FHVW�WLS�GH�VWUXFWXU UHIHU XQ�Atribut (denominare, YDORDUH�QXPHULF � GUHSW�WLS�GH�IXQF LRQDOLWH�
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
225
3URSR]L La 5� ,GHDOXO�EDODQV�VWUXFWXU -functionalite propriu lumilor noastre tinde spre o omogenitate a lumilor noastre.>$FHVWH�FLQFL�3URSR]L LL�VXQW�FRQFHSWXDO�DVRFLDWH�FX�� 1 - (;,67(1 ;2 -�35235,(7 ,;3 - ,17(1 ,21$/,7$7(;4 - (META)RESPONSABILITATE;5 – un proces de tip Möbius: linia "a COMBINA; a CONCORDA; a CONDUCE"���úL�UHYHUVXO�HL��a CONDUCE; a CONCORDA; a COMBINA" - dependent de fluxul dual verbal : a FI <=> a AVEA.]
3ULQ�SDVXO�,,�GH�H[SDQGDUH�D�UH HOHL�LQL LDOH�FRQFHSWXDOH�DWkW�R�SDUWH�D�LQWU ULORU�úL�LHúLULORU��FkW�úL�QLYHOXULOH�DVFXQVH�VXQW�GHVFKLVH�LQWHUSUHW ULL�XWLOL]DWRUXOXL� ,,,��3HQWUX�DO�WUHLOHD�SDV�GH�H[SDQGDUH�V DVRFLHP� III.1. un multi-TXDGUXSOX�FRQFHSWXDO�OLQJXDO��DVRFLDW�OD�UH HDXD�FRQFHSWXDO GHVFKLV �
a FI .................................................................deschidere........................................ -------------(;,67(1 ----------------------------------------AFINITATE------ .................................................................psyche.............................................. -------------&21ù7,,1 -----------------------------------&21ù7,(1 ------- .................................................................creier................................................ -------------MORALITATE-----------------------------------DREPTATE--------- �����������������������������������������������������������������LQLP ������������������������������������������������ -------------AGREGARE------------------------------------AVÂND/AVERE---- .................................................................minte................................................ -------------CUVINTE---------------------------------------) &Æ1'�)$&(5(-- .................................................................entitate.............................................
a AVEA [într-XQ�VSD LX�TXDVL-RUWRJRQDO�GXEOX�GLUHF LRQDO@�� ,,,����PDL�DVRFLHP�R�GHVFULHUH�D�VSD LXOXL�³D�IL���D�DYHD´�
a FI || PREREAL POSIBILITATE DETERMINISM CAUZAL || || METAREAL qualia EURISTICI ||
|| REAL TRANSREAL PROBABILITATE ||===============================================
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
226
&RQWLQXXP���H[LVWHQ � DWULEXLUH�� a AVEA
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- III.3. mai asociem Tabelul 6:
O agregare a
DERUG ULORU�OXL�3ODWRQ�úL�Aristotel
INTRO_entitate cu
frontiere
EXTRO_entitate cu
frontiere
Frontiere
DESCHISE
pentru entitate
���(;,67(1 3: POZITIVITATE
Frontiere
ÎNCHISE pentru
entitate
2: NEGATIVITATE 4: REFLECTARE
'DF FLQHYD�GRUHúWH��SRDWH�vQORFXL�FX�����,8%,5(������3 &$7�.7DEHOXO����vQWUX�³OXPHD�FXYLQWHORU�QRDVWUH´��QH�G R VXJHVWLH�DVXSUD�FRQVWUXFWHORU�PHQWDOH�³,1752´�úL�³(;752´�� %HQHILFLDU� HVWH� 7DEHOXO� ��� úL� IUDJPHQWDUHD� VSD LX-timpului FRQWHPSRUDQ�SULQ�YDULHWDWHD�GH�UHWUDJHUH�SURSULH�UHIOHFW ULL��GH�QHVHSDUDW�GH�H[LVWHQ – dar inducând fragmentarea acesteia, mai mult ca eterogenitatea LQL LDO �� Fie (în cadrul complex al acestui pas III de axpandare) toate
formele de focaOL]DUH�FRQFHSWXDO � GRPHQLLOH�GH�FHUFHWDUH�GLQ�7DEHOHOH�5 – drept un tot, un întreg mental contemporan -� GH�� FX�� úL� vQ�DQWLFLSDUHD� úL� HIRUWXO� QRVWUX� FXUHQW�� DO� VRFLHW LORU� QRDVWUH�� úL� DO� OXPLL�globale. Acest set mental contemporan întru complexitate ar fi o IRUP(SDWWHUQ�� GH� JULM ID GH� YLLWRU� �IRUHVLJKW�� > úL� GH� DF LXQH� VRFLDOXOWHULRDU @� )LH�DFHDVWD�R�SURSXQHUH�GH�SURFHGXU FRQWHPSRUDQ D XPDQLW LL�de a rezolva prin (e-)sisteme problema FDSDFLW LL� KROLVWLFH� úL� D� eco-FRQúWLLQ HL.2 UHOD LH�FRQFOX]LY �
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
227
*ULM ID GH�YLLWRU��IRUHVLJKW���VDUFLQD�SURVSHFWLY � H[WUDSRODUHD��IRUHFDVWLQJ��� �XUP WRUXO�� HIRUW� � GH� JULM ID GH� YLLWRU� � !� DERUG ULOH�WUDQV�� LQWHU�� úL� PRQR-GLVFLSOLQDUH� � !� vQWUHDJD� DQWLFLSD LH� SURGXV �SURFHVDW GH�� FX�� úL� vQ� QRL�� úL� DFFHSWDW GH� VRFLHWDWH� GUHSW� XQ� VLVWHP� GH�anticipare, drept anticiparea unei “Lumi Noi”.2 SUREOHP DJUHJDW GHVFKLV �(YROX LD� ,QWHUQHW-ului (spre Internet X –OHJ WXUL� JHQHUDOL]DWH�vQWUH�WRDWH�ILLQ HOH�XPDQH��UHIHULWRU�OD�WRDWH�LQWU ULOH�QRDVWUH�SHUFHSWXDOH-úL� FKLDU� DO L SRVLELOL� SDúL� GH� HYROX LH� PHQWDO úL� HYHQWXDO� ELRORJLF � DU�³VFKLPED´� vQWUHJD� DQWLFLSD LH� GH�� FX�� úL� vQWUX� QRL�� úL� DFFHSWDW GH�VRFLHW LOH�QRDVWUH�úL�GH OXPHD�JOREDO " >VDX��SURFHGXUD�GH�DQWLFLSDUH�DU�IL�VWD LRQDU � GH�R�FUHúWHUH�³OLQLDU ´@ 2 VROX LH�
Comprehensiune asupra (e-)LUMII ca sistem (ipotetic) real / model / ideal -�GXS � SHVWH���vQ�DFRUG�OD�PLATON
3ULQ�DFHDVW FRPSUHKHQVLXQH�VH�DUH�GUHSW�FDGUX�LQWHUID D��,'((�� !�),,1 80$1 � !�0$ù,1 – drept un procesor (virtual) dintr-un sistem de anticipare (computerial), prin: * (re)construirea / (de)construirea unei imagini a (e-)LUMII din forme lingvistice;
* ordonarea acestor forme într-XQ� VSD LX� LPDJLQDU�“a FI” X “a AVEA”;
* asocierea { dimensiunii de ³D�DSDU LQH�OD´�a (e-)Lumii; RSHUDWRUXO�GH�DSDUWHQH ∈ ; a AVEA };* asocierea { dimensiunii de ³H[LVWHQ ´ a (e-)Lumii; operatorul
(quantificatorul) de “H[LVWHQ ´ ∃ ; a FI }; SURLHF LD� FR-SODQDU D FHORU� GRX GLPHQVLXQL�� GH�³H[LVWHQ ´ úL�
de�³D�DSDU LQH�OD´�rezultând o LPDJLQH�SODQDU D�H-)Lumii;* fragmentarea acestei imagini planare în acord cu trecerea de la
inelul circular uman: ^LQIRUPD LH�-decizie-DF LXQH-LQIRUPD LH�` la fluxul propriu LQWHUIH HL�RP-PDúLQ , flux liniar { awareness uman; insight XPDQ��DF LXQH�VRFLDO �RP-PDúLQ � `;
* punctarea (jalonarea)� IUDJPHQW ULL� LPDJLQL� SODQDUH� � SULQ�comprehensiune; FRPSUHKHQVLXQH� GXS � SHVWH� �� vQ� DFRUG� OD� PLATON prin SXQFWDUHD� �MDORQDUHD�� FX�QXPHOH�XQRU� IDLPRúL�JkQGLWRUL� DL�XPDQLW LL�–relativ la FHORU� GRX GLPHQVLXQL� ale (e-)Lumii: de ³H[LVWHQ ´ úL� GH “a DSDU LQH�OD´�– ambele dimensiuni fiind dual exprimate prin { awareness XPDQ��KXPDQ�XPDQ��DF LXQH�VRFLDO �RP-PDúLQ � `;
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
228
în acest context, s-ar traduce awareness prin perceptibilitate, iar insight prin LQVSLUD LH�
În urm WRUXO�WDEHO��VH�H[SULP WHQVLXQHD�GH�D�FXSULQGH�³QXPHOH´�imaginii LUMII ca sistem (ipotetic) / model / ideal. ,PDJLQHD��WDEHODU � VH�ED]H] SH�SURLHF LD�FR-SODQDU Ddimensiunii de ³D�DSDU LQH�OD´�a Lumii; RSHUDWRUXO�GH�DSDUWHQH ∈ ; a AVEA
PLATON RE-Ì1 (/(6�GH� CUSANUS; SPINOZA; GOETHE
PLATON EXPLICAT PRIN “RE-TRANSLARE �&5($7,9 �´�GH� ARISTOTEL; ROUSSEAU; GÖDEL
dimensiunii de ³H[LVWHQ ´ a Lumii; operatorul (quantificatorul) de “H[LVWHQ ” ∃ ; a FI
PLATON APROFUNDAT CREATIV de: 6I QWXO�$8*867,1��6I QWXO�720$6�GLQ�$48,12�����������HEIDEGGER
PLATON “RE-75 ,7´�35,1758�
LEIBNIZ; KANT; POPPER - respectiv DQWH��LQWHU�úL�VDX����������������post-complementarii cu: (Newton; Cantor); (Berkeley; Hegel;
Schopenhauer; Nietzsche; Eminescu); (Frege, Bretano / Husserl; Russell; Wittgenstein; Bruwer / Heyting).
* tuturor religiilor lumii, iar pentru contextul de devenire HXURSHDQ LQL LDO OXL�Christos, Sfântului Apostol Pavel,* inWURVSHF LHL�SULQ�EDODQ D Descartes <=> Bacon,* efectului macro-social, macro-LVWRULF�� úL� DVXSUD� FRQúWLLQ HL�úWLLQ LILFH�PRGHUQH�SURSULX�WH]HORU�OXL�Marx,* efectului macro-social, macro-LVWRULF�� úL� DVXSUD� FRQúWLLQ HL�úWLLQ LILFH� PRGHUQH� SURSULX� FDGUHORU� psihanalizei (post-)Freud - versus
alternativelor lui Jung úL�UHVSHFWLY�Adler��GH�FH�QX�úL�Odobleja úL Wiener), * dezbaterii directe din 1975 între Chomsky� �LQQHLVP�� úL�Piaget
(dobândire), LQWHUGLVFLSOLQDULW LL� FRUSXV-ului ùWLLQ HORU� &RJQLWLYH� úL�Bioingineriei (“între” )LORVRILD�$QDOLWLF FRQWHPSRUDQ � ����� úL� SOHLDGD� GH�
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
229
FHUFHW WRUL� DQJDMD L vQWUX� FRQVWUXFWHOH� SH� WHUPHQ� OXQJ� DOH� 9LH LL� úL ,QWHOLJHQ HL�$UWLILFLDOH). Tabelul 7.1
Dimensiunea de ³D�DSDU LQH�OD´�aLumii; conexiuni la:
LUMEA ca sistem (ipotetic) real / model / ideal
&RPSUHKHQVLXQH�GXS �peste / în acord la PLATON
CUSANUS awareness uman
SPINOZA insight uman
GOETHE DF LXQH�VRFLDO(om-PDúLQ �
6I QWXO�AUGUSTIN
AwarenessUman
LEIBNIZ Husserl
GÖDEL
6I QWXO�TOMAS din AQUINO
Insight Uman
Berkeley
KANTFrege Bruwer ROUSSEAU
Newton
Dimensiunea de “exis 7HQ ´ aLumii;
Conexiuni la:
HEIDEGGER �$F LXQH�6RFLDO
(Om-0DúLQ �
ARISTOTEL Wittgenstein
POPPER
(VWH�GH�DúWHSWDW�R�³DVXPDUH´�,17(5���75$16',6&,3/,1$5 úL�INTERCULT85$/ D �0(7$�5(63216$%,/,7 ,,� SULQ� FR-SODQDULWDWHD�SUH]HQWDW �³H[LVWHQ ´ úL�³D�DSDU LQH�OD´). ÌQ� DFRUG� FX� DúWHSWDWD (META)RESPONSABILITATE, în FRQWH[WXO� DFHVWD� SULYLQG� IRFDOL] ULOH� GDWRUDWH� ³PLQ LORU� DQDOLWLFH´� úL�respectiv “algebrice”� VH�SURSXQH�XUP WRDUHD�LQWHUID KROLVWLF �,'((�� !�),,1 80$1 � !�0$ù,1 – drept cadru de reprezentare úL� UH]ROYDUH�D�SUREOHPHORU�SURSULL�FDSDFLW LL�KROLVWLFH�� HFR-FRQúWLLQ HL� úL�respectiv, “schimbarea” de anticipare . 'HFL��DFHDVW LQWHUID SRDWH�IL�XWLOL]DW GUept un (virtual) procesor relativ la sistemele (computeriale) anticipative:
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
230
Tabelul 7.2 Dimensiunea de ³D�DSDU LQH�OD´�a (e-)Lumii;
conexiuni la: (e-)LUMEA ca sistem (ipotetic) real / model / ideal
comprehensiuQH�GXS �peste / în acord la PLATON
awareness uman
insight uman
DF LXQH�VRFLDO(om-PDúLQ �
Awareness Uman
5($& ,81( (ex. MXGLFLDU �
avQ HOHJH A AVEA
Insight Uman
a „trece” din nou
QUALIA a explica
Dimensiunea de ³H[LVWHQ ´ a(e-)Lumii; Conexiuni la: $F LXQH�6RFLDO
(Om-0DúLQ �
A FI D ÄWU L´�din nou
$& ,81(� (ex. Industrial-ILQDQFLDU �
Ce are� QHFHVDU� úL� VXILFLHQW� un procesor (virtual) dintr-un sistem (computerial) anticipativ? 3URSR]L LD� �: Un cadru suficient pentru un procesor (virtual) dintr-un sistem (computerial) anticipativ ar fi agregarea elementelor setului ^ &219,1*(5(� �&812ù7,1 Ì1� &21),50$5(�� �� %(/,()� ��Ì1 (/(*(5(���81'(567$1',1*���(;3/,&$ ,(���(;3/$1$7,21�� PRAXIS }, referitor la la ansamblul problemelor de reprezentat / rezolvat.
În contextul Internet-ului, se poate constitui D QRX VWUXFWXU � Vo denumim “Internetron´ �D� VH� YHGHD� 7DEHOXO� ���� 2ULFH� VHF LXQH�“procese_produse”, întru lumile noastre (LSI), aU FRQ LQH�OHJ WXUL�FHO�SX LQ�YLUWXDOH� vQWUH� HQWLW LOH� FH� DU� FRQVWLWXL� ,QWHUQHWURQL� �SOXUDOXO� GH� OD�Internetron). 3URSR]L LD��: Un cadru necesar pentru un procesor (virtual) dintr-un sistem (computerial) anticipativ ar fi agregarea elementelor setului { Belief-Desire-Emotion (B-D-(��� 3UD[LV�� &812ù7,1 Ì1�CONFIRMARE-,1)250$ ,(� '(� 35263(&7,9 -(02 ,(�� 35$;,6�`�� UHIHULWRU� OD� OD� DQVDPEOXO� úL� OD� ILHFDUH�GLQWUH�SUREOHPHOH� GH� UHSUH]HQWDW� ��rezolvat. [31]
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
231
În contextul lumii contemporane, al e-DFWLYLW LORU��DO�SURiectului e-(8523(��FDGUXO�3URSR]L LHL���DSDUH�GUHSW�HFKLYDOHQW�F XW ULORU�SUH]HQWDWH�vQ�7DEHOXO���� LGHQWLILF ULL� XQXL�FRUS�YLUWXDO�FX�R� VLQJXU ID FDUH�SRDWH� VPHQ LQ FLUFXODULWDWHD���D��E��F��G��D��«�� D��/XPHD�UHDO � pull-back ; b: Lumea meta-UHDO / pull-tech ; c: Lumea pre-UHDO � pull-back_back ; d: Lumea trans-UHDO � pull-before .ÌQ�DFHVW�FRQWH[W��HYLGHQW�úL�SULQ�FRQWH[WXO�,QWHUQHW-ului, se poate constitui aQRX VWUXFWXU � V R GHQXPLP� ³,QWHUQHWURQ� vQWUX� VSD LX-timpul contemporan”, sau mai pe scurt “Planetron”. ÌQ� DFHVW� FRQWH[W� DSUHFLHP� HFKLYDOHQ D FRQVWUXFWHORU� %-D-E cu FRPSOH[LWDWHD� XPDQ D UHIOHFW ULL� DVXSUD� UHIOHFW ULL (ceea ce ar atinge constructul de FRQúWLLQ ) – SULQ�XWLOL]DUHD�FRQFHSWXDO D WUHL�WULDGH�XPDQH : T1(a putea-drept capabilitate; a trebui-drept necesitate; a voi-drept VXILFLHQ �, 7��SUHMXGHFDW � VXUSUL] � HYLGHQ ��� 7��H-Concepte; expectare-prevedere; timp admisibil).
(FKLYDOHQWXO� FUHúWLQ�� GH� GRX PLOHQLL�� SHQWUX� 7�� DU� IL��7��FUHGLQ -GUHSW�FDSDELOLWDWH��VSHUDQ -drept necesitate; iubire- drept VXILFLHQ �� 3URSR]L LD� �: Un cadru necesar� úL� suficient pentru un procesor (virtual) dintr-un sistem (computerial) anticipativ ar fi agregarea elementelor setului ^ DZDUHQHVV�XPDQ��LQVLJKW�XPDQ��DF LXQH�VRFLDO �RP-PDúLQ � �$-I-A)} >3HUFHSWLELOLWDWH� XPDQ -,QVSLUD LH� XPDQ -$F LXQH� RP-PDúLQ @�
Prin implementarea acestui cadru necesar�úL�suficient DU�WUHEXL�VSXQHP�vQ�HYLGHQ constructul de Qualia. Deci procesorul (virtual) dintr-un VLVWHP� �FRPSXWHULDO�� DQWLFLSDWLY� DU� WUHEXL� V ³LPSORGH]H´� WRDWSHUFHSWLELOLWDWHD�QRDVWU � WRDW HPHUJHQ D QRDVWU � SUHFXP�úL�V ³H[SORGH]H´�vQWUX� R� XQLIRUPL]DUH� WRDWH� VW ULOH� QRDVWUH�� WRDW GHYHQLUHD� LQRYDWLYLW LL�noastre – FHHD�FH�DU�IL�TXDOLD�QRDVWU �XQ�GDU�QDWXUDO�vQWUX�&RVPRVXO�QRVWUX��DLFL�úL�DFum –�FHO�SX LQ�SHQWUX�QRL�� 'HILQL LD��� 4XDOLD�QRDVWU LQGLYLGXDO HVWH�WUDVHXO�QRVWUX�FXOWXUDO��LDU� TXDOLD� VRFLDO �SRDWH� GRDU� TXDOLD� VRFLHWDO � HVWH� � DJUHJDUHD� VHWXOXL� ^�&219,1*(5(� �&812ù7,1 Ì1� &21),50$5(�� �� %(/,()� ��Ì1 (/(*(5(���81'(567$1',1*���(;3/,&$ ,(���(;3/$1$7,21���PRAXIS } prin fluxul linear {humankind awareness; human insight; social action}.$FHVW� IOX[� OLQLDU� ³GHVIDFH´� �SULQ� IUDJPHQWDUHD� úL� FR-planarizarea proprie Tabelului 7.2) inelul circular uman: ^LQIRUPD LH�-decizie-DF LXQH-LQIRUPD LH�`. Constructul de qualia –pentru tabelul 7.1 si 7.2-
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
232
LQWURGXFH���UHSUH]LQW ORFXO��³OLSVD�GH�VWDUH´��GH�LPSOR]LH�D�LQWUDULORU�úL�LHúLULORU�UH HOHL�FRQFHSWXDOH�LQL LDOH� 6 GHQXPLP� VWUXFWXUD� SURSULH� 'HILQL LHL� �� GUHSW� ³Internetron liniarizat” sau mai pe scurt “Sociotron´��7LSXO�GH�IXQF LRQDOLDWDWH�DO�DFHVWHL�structuri este reprezentat prin Figura 1� SUHFXP� úL� SULQ� vQWUHJ� FRQWH[WXO�constructelor de PHWDLQIRUPD LH�úL�metadecizie.$FHDVW VWUXFWXU � FX� XQ� DVWIHO� GH� WLS� GH� IXQF LRQDOLWDWH, ar fi FRPSDWLELO FX� VXLWD� GH� UHOD LL� ���� OD� � ����� U VSXQ]kQG� VSHFLILF� GH�SURSULHW LOH��0 ��úL��0 �� ÌQ� >��@� VXQW� DPLQWLWH� SRVLELOLW LOH� GH� D� DYHD� R� DOWHUQDWLY � OD�VWUXFWXULOH�,QWUDUH�1LYHOXUL�DVFXQVH�,HúLUH�DOH�PRGHOHORU�GH�UH HOH�QHXURQale DUWLILFLDOH�� SULQ� H[SDQGDUHD� SURFHVHORU� �IOX[XULORU�� LQIRUPD LRQDOH� SURSULL�structurii ierarhice (tip “Sociotron´���3RW� IL�SXVH� vQ�HYLGHQ � vQ� IDSW�GUHSW�HFKLYDOHQ H DOH� ³Sociotron”-XOXL� SDWUX� WLSXUL� GH� H[SDQG UL�� ÌQ� DFHODúL�FRQWH[W� SRW� IL� HYLGHQ LDWH� úL� DOWH� WLSXUL� GH� FRRUGRQ UL� DOH� SURFHVHORU�LQIRUPD LRQDOH� – FHHD� FH� SRDWH� IL� GH� DVHPHQHD� R� DOWHUQDWLY ID GH�DERUGDUHD�DXWRJHQHUDWLY �
În loc de concluzii:
Constructul de “Sociotron” [“Internetron liniarizat”] (în juxtapunere cu cele de “Internetron´ úL� UHVSHFWLY� ³Planetron”) sunt U VSXQVXULOH� OD� vQWUHEDUHD�� ([LVW R IRUP WUDQVGLVFLSOLQDU SURSULH�XPDQLW LL"�
[Poate fi sportul un exemplu? Da – FHO� SX LQ� VSRUWXO� ROLPSLF���$FHDVW LQWXL LH� –GHRFDPGDW DU� U PkQH� GUHSW� XQ� HFKLYDOHQW� ID GH�reglarea fuzzy-QHXURQDO D XQXL�FXSWRU�PHWDOXUJLF�GLQWU-un “Sociotron”, sau FRQVWUXFWLELOLW LL� IX]]\-neuronale a XQHL� FRPXQLW L YLUWXDOH� vQWU-un “Sociotron”. ] 8UP WRDUHOH�LGHL�VXQW�FRPSOHPHQWDUH�DILUPD LLORU�GLQ�7DEHOHOH���
* O SRVLELO HFKLYDOHQ între Tabelele���úL�7DEHOXO���DU�IL�versus abordarea lui John 6HDUOH�SULQ�,QWHQ LRQDOLWDWH�>��@. ([LVW XQ� SRVLELO� LQVLJKW� KROLVWLF�� ^� VLVWHP� SUREDELOLVWLF�� VLVWHP�fuzzy, entitate (intro-�GHVFKLV � DUWHIDFWH`��$LFL��GRDU�FD�XQ�VWLPXO�SULPDO��V-a utilizat ordonarea� GXS WUHL� SURSULHW L VLVWHPLFH� � versus contextului datorat lui Richard B. Fuller [12]. (QWLW LOH��QRQ�VLVWHPLFH���LQWHJURQ���PHWDWURQ-netron-Internetron-tranzitron...individicitate ar putea fi “rafinate” versus agregarea SUHIHULQ HORU�LQGLYLGXDOH��în sensul lui Kenneth Arrow [2].
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
233
$QWLFLSD LD� FRQHF LRQLVW � �0(7$�RESPONSABILITATEA / PHWDHFKLOLEUXO_� PHWDLQIRUPD LD_PHWDGHFL]LD� �� GHWHUPLQLVPXO� VXEWLO� �� KLDWXO�VRFLHWDO� _� KLDWXO� ([LVWHQ DB5HIOHFWDUHD� �)RFB$S � DU� SXWHD� IL� ³UDILQDWH´� versus abordarea cRQVLVWHQ HL� úL� FRPSOHWLWXGLQLL�� vQ� VHQVXO� OXL� .XUW�Gödel [15]. )OX[XO�FRJQLWLY�DO�XPDQLW LL��VLVWHP�– 6XELHFW�5D LRQDO�– entitate – YDULHW L GH� JkQGLUH� VLVWHPLF – PRGHOH� FRQúWLLQ � U X – &RQúWLLQ8QLYHUVDO úL� 5 X DU� SXWHD� IL� ³UDILQDWH´� versus abordarea ùWLLQ �7HKQRORJLH�úL�)LORVRILH��vQ�VHQVXO�OXL�0DULR�%XQJH�>�@. 2� LSRWH] GH� IX]]LILFDUH� DU� IL� EHQHILF SHQWUX� WRW� FHHD� FH� DU�vQVHPQD� �VHFYHQ LDO� úL� vQ� SDUDOHO�� REVHUYD LH�� GHFL]LH�� DFW�� VROX LH� auto-UHIOHFWDW pentru o� SUREOHP FRQVWLWXLW � UtilL]DUHD� PXOWLSO D IXQF LHL�FDUDFWHULVWLFH� �GH� DSDUWHQHQ QXDQ DW � vQ� DVRFLHUH� FX� vQWUHJ� VSD LXO�H[LVWHQ LDO� úL� FRJQLWLY� DU� IL� GH� DVRFLDW� FX� "a FI"� úL� "a AVEA"; ceea ce SRDWH� FRQGXFH� OD� SURSXQHUHD� GH� RSHUDWRUL�� 6XELHFWXOXL� 5D LRQDO�� SULQ�HIHFWHOH�0RGHO Uii Interactive, i-DU� UHYHQL� �PHWD�UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD� XWLOL] ULL�multiple de IXQF LL�FDUDFWHULVWLFH�úL�FRQWH[WXOD�SHQWUX�DOWH�YHUEH�>³D�IDFH´�–drept act (uman) în primul rând]. Aici, drept un stimul primal, este de generalizat elementele de 6RFLRFLEHUQHWLF � YHUVXV�DERUG ULOH� OXL�Dorien DeTombe [8] úL�Felix Geyer [13]. $F LXQHD�XPDQ � vQWUX�LPEULFDUHD�OXL�"a FI"�úL�"a AVEA" drept operatori ar fi un pas pentru implicarea la un nivel mai general (?):... OBSERVATOR ... ACTANT ... DECIDENT ... MINTE REFLEXIVYHUVXV� DERUG ULL� OXL� Daniel Dubois pentru sisteme anticipatorii cu LQFXUVLXQH�úL��K\SHULQFXUVLXQH�>��@��>��@.
* Insight-XO�XPDQ�DVXSUD�UHOD LHL�FHORU�1�SURSULHW L GH]LUDELOH�vQWU-R HQWLWDWH��vQ�FDUH�RPXO�VH�FRQIUXQW FX�SUREOHPH���ID GH�PD[LPXP�1�– 1 SURSULHW L SH� FDUH� OH� SRDWH� ³JHVWLRQD´� FRJQLWLY� � N – 1/ N <=> (17,7,7 , VLVWHPLFH� úL� QRQ-sistemice, ar putea fi cuprins (?) întru o DSDUHQ �UHDOL]DUH� VWUXFWXUDO-IHQRPHQRORJLF PXOWLSOX� XPDQ � &253�# MINTE # SUFLET # SPIRIT. Prin aceasta SRDWH�F V-ar atinge o altfel de modelare a insight-XOXL�XPDQ�DVXSUD�FRQúWLLQ HL�SURSULL���U XOXL��úL�SkQ OD�&RQúWLLQ D 8QLYHUVDO úL� 5 XO� YHUVXV� DERUG ULOH� OXL� I. Sanders prin “Strategic Thinking” [25],�úL�Vladimir Dimitrov prin “sublimarea întru vQ HSFLXQH´�[30]. &RPSOHPHQWDULWDWHD� VHVL]DW SHQWUX�HOHPHQWHOH�SUH]HQWDWH�DQWHULRU��QX� OH� SODVHD] FKLDU� �vQ� VHQV� GHWHUPLQLVWLF� GLQDPLF�� vQIDUD� RULF UHL�DSDUWHQH H ID GH�7DEHOHOH����vQ�VHQV��³SXU´��SULQ�DFHDVWD�–FD�R�SHUVSHFWLY -UHOD LRQDUHD� VSUH� 7DEHOXO� �� HVWH� úL�PDL� GLILFLO – dar poate revelatoare de LQWHUVHF LL�H[LVWHQ LDOH�úL�FRJQLWLYH�SRVLELOH�
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
234
*** $QDOL]D�SUH]HQWDW SULYLQG�,QWHUID D RP-PDúLQ úL�JkQGLUHD� VLVWHPLF �D LQWHQ LRQDW� SUH]HQWDUHD� XQRU� FRQVWUXFWH� FDUH� V ILH� SDúL� SHQWUX� XQ�WUDVHX� úWLLQ LILF� úL� WHKQRORJLF� LQIRUPD LRQDO� � GH� OD� H-sisteme B-D-E / Belief-Desire-Emotion la e-sisteme A-I-A / Awareness-Insight-Action; B-D-( ��&XQRúWLQ vQ�FRQILUPDUH-,QIRUPD LH�GH�SURVSHFWLY -(PR LH�--- A-I-$ ��3HUFHSWLELOLWDWH�XPDQ -,QVSLUD LH�XPDQ -$F LXQH�RP-PDúLQ �$QDOL]D� UHVSHFWLY D SURSXV� WUDQVODUHD� FRJQLWLY GH� OD�� DJUHJDUHD�elementelor naturale cu cele artificiale (relativ la un stadiu curent); FRQVRQDQ D FUHDWRDUH�vQWUH�QDWXUDO�úL�DUWLILFLDO��UHODWLY�OD�XQ�VWDGLX�SUHYL]LELO��úL� LPSOHPHQWDUHD� SURJUHVXOXL� GUHSW� WHQGLQ HUJRGLF � OD� FXSULQGHUL�elementare ale: JkQGLULL� VLVWHPLFH�� �PHWD�HFKLOLEUXOXL� FRQúWLLQ HORU��“Parteneriatului Creativ”� >ùL� DFHDVWHD� ID GH� FXSULQGHUL� HOHPHQWDUH� DOH��VLVWHPDWLFLL� úWLLQ HORU, setului de GHVFRSHULUL� úL� LQYHQ LL�� � VW ULL� VWDWice a WHKQRORJLHL�úL�ILLQ HL�XPDQH.]
Asupra gândirii sistemice D IRVW� � LQWURGXV VLQWH]D� FRQFHSWXDOSURSULH�7DEHOHORU��� úL������DVXSUD� �PHWD�HFKLOLEUXOXL�FRQúWLLQ HORU�ar fi de UHY ]XW�EDODQVXO�GLQWUH�7DEHOHOH���úL��, LDU�vQ�VIkUúLW�DVXSUD “Parteneriatului Creativ”�DU� IL�GH�YDORULILFDW FRPSOHPHQWDULWDWHD� LQYRFDW vQWUH�HOHPHQWHOH�Tabelelor 5.1-� úL�LGHLOH�SUH]HQWDWH�FKLDU�DQWHULRU�vQ�ORF�GH�FRQFOX]LL� 6H�FRQVWLWXLH��SULQ�SURSXQHUHD�VWUXFWXULL�úL�IXQF LRQDOLW LL�XQXL�DúD�zis “Internetron liniarizat” / A-I-$��XQ�DOWIHO�GH�FDGUX�DO� ,QWHUIH HL�2P-0DúLQ � DVWIHO�vQFkW�SULQ��PHWD�UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD�XPDQ V VH�LPSOHPHQWH]H�GLVWLQFW� GRDU� SULQ� DF LXQL� VRFLDOH� HIHFWHOH� QDWXUDOH� DOH� SHUFHSWLELOLW LL� úL�LQVSLUD LHL�XPDQH�
Dualismul dintre sistemele B-D-( úL�$-I-A�DU�SXWHD�IL�VXV LQXW�FHO�SX LQ� GDF R ³WUHFHUH´� GLQVSUH� 7DEHOXO� �� VSUH� 7DEHOXO� ���� DU� IL� SXV vQ�HYLGHQ úL�R�WHKQRORJLF�LQIRUPD LRQDO DU�IL�LGHQWLILFDW �5HIHULQ HOH�
[1] Amoroso Richard L. (1999). A Brief Introduction to Noetic Field Theory. The Quantization of Mind. Brain and Consciousness. Rakic, Kostopoulos, Rakovic, and Koruga (eds), ECPD: Belgrade 297-302 [2] Arrow Kenneth J (1963). Social Choice and Individual Value. Wiley, New York. [3] Bailey Kenneth (l997). System and conflict: towards a symbiotic reconciliation. Quality & Quantity 31, pp. 425-442. Kluwer Academic Publishers. Malitza Mircea (1998). Ten Thousand Cultures, One Single Civilization: Toward Geomodernity of the XXI Century (in Romanian). Editura Nemira, Bucuresti. [4]� % ODFHDQX� � &RQVWDQWLQ�� 1LFRODX� � (GPRQG� �������� Personalitatea umana O interpretare cibernetica. (The Human Personality. A Cybernetic Interpretation.)
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
235
Editura Junimea. Iasi. Sahleanu Victor (1996). De la omul necunoscut la omul cognoscibil. (From the Unknown Human toward Cognitive-known Human.) Editura Ramida. Bucuresti. � >�@� %HOLú� � 0DULDQD� �������� Bioingineria sistemelor adaptive si instruibile (The Bio-engineering of the Adaptive and Instructive Systems). Editura Stiintifica si Enciclopedica. Bucuresti. Belis Marianne & Snow Paul (2002). Comment cerner le hasard. Edition Supinfo Press, Paris. [6] Bonting Sjoerd L. (2001). Need and Usefulness of a Revised Creation Theology: Chaos Theology. Science and religion Antagonism or Complementarity? / Science and Spiritual Quest – International Symposium, November 8-11, 2001, Bucharest, Romania/ A programme of the Center for Theology and Natural Sciences, Berkeley. [7] Bunge Mario (1977). Philosophical richness of technology. Philosophy and Social Action 2 (Editors: F. Suppe, P.D. Asquith). [8] DeTombe Dorien http://www.sepa.tudelft.nl/webstaf/detombe .
[9] Draganescu Mihai http://www.racai.ro/~dragam .[10] Dubois Daniel (1998). Modelling of anticipatory systems with incursion and
hyperincursion. Proceedings of the 15th International Congress on Cybernetics, pp. 306-311 (Editor: J. Ramaekers). Rosen Robert (1985). Anticipatory Systems.Pergamon Press. [11] Dumitriu Anton (1944). Paradoxele stiintelor (Science's Paradoxes). Imp. Nationala. [12] Fuller B. Richard (1969). Utopia or Oblivion: the Prospect for Humanity.Bantam Books. [13] Geyer Felix http://www.unizar.es/sociocybernetics .
[14] Goguen J.A. (1969). The logic of inexact concepts. Synthese 19 325-373, D. Reidler Publishing Co. (Editor: Jaakko Hintikka). Teodorescu Horia-Nicolai, Jain L. C. K., Kandel A., Kacprzyk J. (Editor) (2001). Hardware Implementation of Intelligent Systems. Springer Verlag. [15] Gödel Kurt (1931). Uber formal unentscheidhare Sätze der Principia Mathematica und verwandter Systeme I. Monatshefte für Math. u. Physik. Bd. 38, pp. 173-198. [16] Irtem Ali (1977). Simulation of consciousness. Modern trends in cybernetics and systems, vol.III. Springer Verlag / Editura Tehnica. pp.729-734 [17] Juilland Alphonse, Edwards P.M.H., Juilland Ileana (1965). Frequency Dictionary of Rumanian Words, Mouton & Co. [18] Lasker George (1998). Synergistic effects of local and global developments on our lives and our future. Proceedings of the 15th International Congress on Cybernetics, pp. 587-���� �(GLWRU�� -�� 5DPDHNHUV��� % UEDW� %ROGXU-Eugen (2002). Sisteme inteligente orientate spre agent� (GLWXUD�$FDGHPLHL�5RPkQH��%XFXUHúWL�
[19] Marcus Solomon (1974). Linguistics as a pilot science. Current Trends in Linguistics 12 (Editor: Th.A. Sebeok). (1990). Controverse in stiinta si inginerie,Editura Tehnica, Bucuresti. [20] Morãrescu Jeana, Bulz Nicolae (2000). Pentru abordarea extins-matematica a paradoxurilor si limitarilor (Toward extended-mathematical approach of the
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
236
paradoxes and limitations). Academica XI 1-2 (121-122), pp.44 (director: Mircea Mâciu, Romanian Academy); and the parallel manuscript from Stoica Marcel, Morãrescu Jeana. [21] Negoita Constantin Virgil, Ralescu Dan A. (1975). Application of Fuzzy Sets to Systems Analysis. Birkhäuser Verlag. [22] Nicolescu Basarab (1996). La Transdisciplinarité. Manifeste. Editions du Rocher. [23] Pãun Gheorghe (1977). Generative grammars for some economic activities, Foundations of Control Engineering, 2,1 pp.15-25; (1995) Artificial Life: Grammatical Models. Black Sea University Press. Calude Cristian (1995). Matematici constructive, Editura Stiintifica, Bucuresti, 1995. [24] Simon Herbert.A.(1957). Administrative Behaviour, Free Press, New York. [25] Sanders I. (1998). Strategic Thinking and the New Science / Planning in the Midst of Chaos, Complexity, and Change. The Free Press. [26] Searle John (2000). The Three Gaps. From the Classical Theory of Rationality toward Consciousness Approach. Analytical Philosophy Insight – Conference, The New Europe College, Bucharest, May 19, 2000. [27] Smith Martin (1995). The prospects for machine consciousness. Proceedings of the 15th International Congress on Cybernetics, pp. 306-311 (Editor: J. Ramaekers). [28] Vallée Robert (1995). Cognition et Système / Essai d'Epistémo-Praxéologye.L’Interdisciplinaire / Système (s). Lyon-Limonest. [29] Zadeh L.A. (1965). Fuzzy sets. Information and Control 8, 338-353 (I.E.E. Transactions). [30] Dimitrov Vladimir (2004), http://members.tripod.com/cht_co, www.zulenet.com/VladimirDimitrov/pages/home.html >��@� � /XFU ULOH� SHQWUX� CASYS’01, and ’03, Fifth and Sixth International Conference on Computing Anticipatory Systems, Liege: Amoroso Richard L., Amoroso Paul J. (2003). The Fundamental Limit and Origin of Complexity in Biological Systems. Turkiewicz Kazimierz, Turkiewicz Domenika B. Formalised Synthetic Modelling of Subject-Object Relation (2003). Feasibility and Conditions for Application of Anticipatory Systems into Changes in Social Structures (2001). Florea Adina Magda, Kalisz Eugenia. Behaviour Anticipation Based on Beliefs, Desires and Emotions (2003). Anticipatory Attributes of Agent Behavior in MAS (2001). Otlacan Eufrosina (2003). The Synergy and the Chaos Identified in the Constitutive Equation of a Dynamic System. Stoica D. Marcel, Ruxanda George, Oprea Ioana G., Oprea Dan I. The Synergy of Subtle Reverberated Information Transfer (2003). Stoica D. Marcel, Hancu Daniela. Entropy Reducing Strategies for Technology Transfer (2001). � >��@� � /XFU ULOH� SHQWUX� ICAES XVth Congres of the International Union of Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences, session 18: The transdisciplinary flow of our worlds; dedicated In Memoriam Romulus Vulcanescu – Interdisciplinary Scientist (1912-1999), Florence:
Nicolaie Bulz _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________ NOEMA VOL VI, 2007
237
Baiculescu Sorin. Anthropology and mathematics biology - researches, methods, results Belis Marianne. Is the ethical evolution of mankind positively influenced by the progress made in sciences and arts ? Bonting Sjoerd L. (2002). Chaos Theology / A Revised Creation Theology. Novalis, Saint Paul University. Ottawa. Bulz Adriana-Carolina. The street children: a challenge for the new political culture. Bulz Nicolae. A transdisciplinary case study: the sport. Chirnoaga Marcel. The labyrinth; The Redeemer and the wine Maksimovich-Binno Tiyana. Energy healing - synergy at individual and collective levels. Pana Laura. The intelligent environment as an answer to complexity. Stoica Marcel, Morarescu Jeana. I. The operator of act. ; Bulz Nicolae. II. The (humankind) act. (A long term debate.) Tremblay Diane-Gabrielle. Knowledge development in a context of nomadic boundaryless careers: new challenges for learning and working ?; Employment security and insecurity as a determinant of health Turkiewicz Kazimierz, Turkiewicz Domenika B. The quest for the natural sources and rules of morality; Holistic analysis of the physical nature of democracy and terrorism [33] *** /XFU UL� DOH� PHPEULORU� *UXSXOXL� GH� 6WXGLL� ,QWHUGLVFLSOLQDUH� GLQ� FDGUXO�'/0)6�GLQ�&5,)67��$FDGHPLD�5RPkQ :* Agentii si logicele modale (epistemica, doxastica, teleologica, a acceptarii) - prof.dr. Cornel Popa * Reprezentarea cunostintelor si codisciplinaritatea - prof. dr. Paul Caravia * Multimi fuzzy - prof. dr. Paul Flondor * Modelarea artei cu ajutorul multimilor subtile - prof.dr.ing. Marcel Stoica * Globalizarea ca functie vectoriala a lumii - prof.dr. Eufrosina Otlacan * Geomodernitatea mileniului trei si unitatea omului – prof.dr. George Stefan * O Antropologie Academica - prof.dr. Petre Popescu-Gogan * Constiinta , Qualia , Arhitectura – prof. dr.ing. Gorun Manolescu * Gandirea metaforica - prof.dr.ing. Stefan Trausan-Matu * Naturalizare si reductionism in Stiintele Cognitiei - conf. dr. George G. Constandache * Infosfera ca mediul intelectual specific zilelor noastre - conf.dr. Laura Pana * O noua paradigma filosofica: gandirea, teoria categoriilor si modelarea structural-fenomenologica - conf.dr. Catalin Ionita * Conceptul de deconstructie in compozitia muzicala – dr. Fred Popovici * Dinozaurii rationalitatii – dr. Alexandru Giuculescu * Premize "structural-fenomenologice" in filosofia romaneasca – Jeana Morarescu * Proiect pentru un creier: limba naturala / limbaj artificial - ing. Aurel Jula * Act, actiune – universale, planetare, individuale ? - prof.dr.ing. Nicolae Bulz