2014 에너지기후행동캠프 자료집
DESCRIPTION
2014 에너지기후행동캠프 자료집 2014 에너지기후행동캠프 그린라이트를 켜자 일시 : 2014년 8월 27~28일 장소 : 도봉숲속마을 주최 : 2014 에너지기후행동캠프 기획단 녹색교통운동, 녹색연합, 방물단, 생태지평, 서울시그린캠퍼스홍보대사, 에너지기후정책연구소, 에너지노동사회네트워크, 에너지정의행동, 탈핵학교, 투명사회를위한정보공개센터, 하자작업장학교, 한살림서울, 환경운동연합, 환경정의 주관 : 에너지정의행동 후원 : 서울특별시 목차 CONTENTS >>> 인사말 > 2014 에너지기후행동캠프 한눈에 보기 > 세션에서 나눌 이야기 미리보기TRANSCRIPT
-
2014 , , , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
/ 2014 8 27~28
/
/ 2014 / /
2014
2014
2014
/ 2
01
4
/
-
CONTENTS
i
>>> > 2014 >
-
iii
2014
. 5,000 1/100 50 . 300 , 46 .
, 1 . , . ?
200 TOE(Ton of Oil Equivalent : 1 ) . , . .
1 , 2 . 1 . , . . 4% 2020 20% .
-
iv
. . . . , , , . .
. , , , .
, . , .
. . , .
.
2014.8.27.
-
v
2014
2014 .
. . 2009 12 15 (COP15) . .
2011 3 23 . , .
Camp for Climate Action 2009, 2010 . , , .
2014 . 2014 . .
2014.8.27.
2014
-
2014
2014
-
2014 3
2014
2014
2014 8 27 ()
10:00~ / /
11:00~11:20 (/)
11:20~12:30 ( )
12:30~13:30
() 1 2
13:30~15:00(90)
15:00~15:30(30) OX/
15:30~16:00
16:00~17:30(90)
COP21,
17:30~18:00(30)
OX/
18:00~19:00
19:00~20:00(60)
20:00~21:30(90)
21:30~
-
4 2014
2014 8 28 ()
07:30~08:30 /
08:30~09:30
09:30~10:00
10:00~11:00
11:00~12:00
- - - - .....
-
2014 5
2014
_ ,
. , , .
.
. , , .
13:3013:4014:4015:4016:40
| | | | | SH
* 40 10 .
-
6 2014
,
2014
_
. 2012 6 .
, 4 . , .
, . .
- : ( ), ( ), ( ), ( ), ( )
- : ()
13:30~13:5013:50~14:30
14:35~15:15~15:30
1. . (20m) 2. (, 40m)
5 3. (, 40m) 4. (15m)
-
2014 7
2014
_
, . , , .
1
( )
16:00~16:0516:05~16:2516:25~16:4516:45~16:50
/ ppt ,
2
16:50~17:1017:10~17:30
/
-
8 2014
2014
_
, , , , , . , , , .
, . , .
-
- .
13 30 ~ 14 20 - -
14 30 ~ 15 20 - - * ( , )
-
2014 9
COP21, - COP21 -
2014
_
- COP21 post-2020 . UNFCCC
- COP21 . COP15 .
- COP13~COP15 COP . .
- COP21 -
: ()
16:00~16:30 1.COP21 ()
16:30~17:00 2. COP ()
17:00~17:30
-
10 2014
- () -
2014
_
- , , .
- , , .
- .
- -
: ()
16:00~16:30 1. ()16:30~17:00 2. 17:00~17:30 *
*
- ( ) - - -
-
2014 11
2014
_ ,
- : - : . , - : .
- () - [, , ] - () - -
[ ] - (), () - , ,
[ ] - - , ,
-
12 2014
/
2014
_
Mister Meier and the Ecological Footprint | 2010 | 11 | . ,
. , . . . . . .
, ! Saga City | 2011 | 1623 | .
, . , . , .
Creamen , | 2013 | 12 | crimen
. . . .
-
2014 13
That Which Once Was | 2011 | 1950 | 2032 ,
. , . , . .
To Put Together a Helicopter | 2012 | 38 | 17 .
, . . . .
The Safest Nuclear Power Station in the World | 2012 | 28 | 1978 ,
. , . . , .
-
14 2014
2014
_
handz .handz , , .
.handz , , ,
.
- : , , - : / , ,
- : / , , - : , , /
-
2014 15
- : ,
- : E - :
? ?
- (, appropriate technology) , , .
- .
(2014)
- , / - , / - / - / - / YWCA /
- / ,
- : www.handz.or.kr - : 070-4222-1899- : [email protected] - : 200 203
-
16 2014
* !
1.
. , . , . [ 35]
2.
. , . . [ 6]
3.
. , . [ 7() / 10()]
4.
. . 30~40% . [ 3]
-
2014 17
5.
. . . .[ 5]
6. , (), , .
2014 ,
( ) . , . 2 .
-
18 2014
-
2014 19
-
20 2014
-
2014 21
-
22 2014
-
2014 23
-
24 2014
-
2014 25
2014
_
-
26 2014
-
2014 27
-
28 2014
-
2014 29
/ OX, .
2014
_
- , , , . 2008 2009 2010 .
- / OX .
- / OX, .
- 2 .
- OX // .
- .
- , , , , .
-
30 2014
2014
_ 2014
. ? ~~
.
1. E.O : , . , , ~.
2. E.O : , , , . .
3. E.O : ,, , , .
: 50ml : , , , , (E.O)
: , , : .
50g
E.O 10 20
10
-
2014 31
1, 1
2014
- : 2014 8 28 11- : - : 2014 ,
. , 30 37 1 , 1 .
, .
, 3% . , .
- . - 1 : - 2 : - 3 : - -
-
32 2014
- : () / () - : NO- : NO-
-
2014 33
2014
Koule Kan! ! , ! , , !
(Koule Kan) ' ' , .
'' , - . , .
- : (15) - (15) - (20) - (10) 60
- : 5 ~ 60 ( )- : (), (),
- , .
- . , .
-
34 2014
- . .- , .
- : (Emmanuel Migaelle Sanou) - : (Burkina Faso) 16 -
. , , , / /// .
- : (Amidou Balani)- : (Burkina Faso)5 (, , , , )
. 1 (2008), , , // .
-
1.
_ , 2. , _ 3. _ 4. _ 5. COP21,
_ 6.
_ 7.
_ ,
2014
-
37
2014
,
1.
-
38 2014
-
39
-
40 2014
-
41
-
42 2014
-
43
-
44 2014
-
45
-
46 2014
-
47
-
48 2014
-
49
-
50 2014
-
51
-
52 2014
-
53
2.
-
54 2014
-
55
-
56 2014
-
57
-
58 2014
3.
, ...
1) ! ?
? (1) ? ( ) - (2) - (3) - (,,) 2) ! ?
(1) (2) 3 : , ,
3)
: (1) (2) (3)
-
59
4.
-
60 2014
-
61
-
62 2014
-
63
-
64 2014
-
65
-
66 2014
,
2014
- -
! , ( ).
. ( )1)
1. 2 (1962-1965) 50, 20 . 2004 2) . 3) .
2. , . . .4)
1) , . . 13 (1891) , , , . (2004) . 2 20 1985 , (1992) . 2 (1965) 3 . . .
2) , , 23) , 104) , , 3
-
67
3. . , . , , , , , , , , , , . , . , . , .
1. 5)
4. ( , ) . , .
5. . , ,
, . , , . , . , , , . () , , . , . , , .
6. . ( ) . . () , . . .
5) , 1, 3, , 4, ; , 2415-2418( )
-
68 2014
7. () () . . . . , , .
8. , , , , , . , , . . . .
9. .
10.
. . , . . , , , , . . . , .
11. . , . . . ? . , , , . ? , . . . , .
-
69
12. , , , , . . , . .
13. . . , , , , , () . (, , , ) .
. , , , .
14. . . , . . .
, 15. .
. . . , .
16. . , . , , , , .
17. , , .
-
70 2014
. .
18. , , , . , . , , . .
19.
, . , , , . , , . , .
. , . . .
20. .
. , . , .
21. . , , . .
-
71
22. , . , , . . , . , .
23. . , , , , , . .
24. ,
. . . . . , ( ) . , .
25. , , . . , . . , . . ( ) .
26. . .
-
72 2014
27. .
, , . .
28. , , , . , , , .
29. , . , , , . .
30. () ( ) , , , , , , .6)
2. 7) 31. , , , , , ,
. .
32.
. . , , .
33. , . ,
6) , 2, 10 , , , .
7) , 1, 4, VII , VIII '
-
73
. . . , . , , . .
34. .
, .
35. . . .
36.
. , , .
37. , , , , . . , ? ( ) .
38. . . . , .
-
74 2014
39. . .
. , . . .
40. , , . , , , . . . . .
41. . . .
42. () , , , ( ) .
.
43. (, , ) . , , . , , , . . . . (, , , ) . , , , .
44. . , . . .
45. . ,
-
75
. , , , . , , , . , , , , , , .
46. . . , . . , . . .
. . , . .8)
47. . . . , , . . . 60% , . , . .
48. . ( , ) . . . . , . , . , , . , , .
49. .
8) , 469
-
76 2014
. , . . , . . , . , .
-
77
2012 2 28 - . , , , , , , , NNAA(No Nukes Asia Actions) .
/ YMCA / / (EYCK) / / / (, , , , , (), , , , , , )
. 1919 3.1 , 1970 , 1980 . . 3.1 93 , , .
2012 3 11 1 . 3 26-27 (Nuclear Security Summit) . . (Technocracy) . ( 2:15, 6:12) , ( 9:6, 25:2, 6:15) , ( 1:1) ( 3:16) ( 49:15).
() . 1945 10 1 . .
-
78 2014
. . 30 . . . . . . .
(nuclear weapons) (nuclear power plant) . , . () , 238 239 . , . . . . . . . . . 1 . . . , . , , . . , , . . .
1979 1986 , . . . ,
-
79
, . , . 3 1 3 2 30 () . , . . , , 1 , . , . . 2% . 13% . . 100% . . . , , . . . , .
. 1 . . . 100 40. . 1 1,370 . 2016 . . . . . . . .
-
80 2014
. 9 1991 2,312kWh 1 2005 7,403kWh 3 , , , . 2010 4 9,493kWh . , , . . , . , . 1950 . 1978 18 1 21 . 18 1 . 1 6,000 . . . . . 2011 3 , . . .( 7:13-14) .
. 2030 40 . 2010 , 2011 20 80 3 . 2014 . 3 26-27 . . . . ( 14:27) . . .( 121:1-2) .
-
81
, . , . . . .
(IAEA) , 441 , 557 . 1978 21 , 5 ( 104 1, 58 2, 54 3, 31 4), 1. 54 , 14 27 . . . , . 2,000 30 1,000 . . .
. . . . , . . CP-1 . . , , , , .( 28:2). , . . . .
-
82 2014
. . ( 2:15, 6:12) , ( 9:6, 25:2, 6:15) , ( 1:1) ( 3:16) ( 49:15). 41:1-34 . ( 13:14) . (WCC) 6 , , . . (necrophilia) .
. , . 40 , , , ( 30:19) . . ( 8:22) . .
1. , . , , .
2. , .
3. . , 3.7% .
4. .
-
83
.
5. .
6. .
7. .
8. . .
9. , . .
10. 2013 (WCC) 10 . WCC 10 , .
2012 3 1
-
84 2014
(, )
. . . . . .
1.
. . .
1)
.
. , .
, . .
3 , , , . .
2)
, , .
-
85
. , . . .
, .
.
3)
. , , , .
, . , , .
, .. ().
4)
, , .
, . . , .
1 . , . .
-
86 2014
2.
() . . .
.
() .
3.
1)
6~8Km ( ) 1986 8 26, 1 2002 6 .
1988 10 . . 12 10 . 1989 4 26 3, 4 .
. . .
2)
2002~2003 . .
-
87
. 2003 7, . .
3)
2003 10 . 2011 3 . . 2011 9 . 2012 2012 11 26 . 21Km .
.
4.
.
4 .
2013 5 , 100 100 .
.
, , , . . . .
-
88 2014
2014
( )
1.
.
65 180~270ppm 1995~2005, 10 1.9ppm . (1965~2005, 45 1.4ppm )
. 1960 .
-
89
18 19 , () .
1850 , .
. , , , , .
, 2010
-
90 2014
(NOAA)
9 100
2010 2 .
-
91
2.
(Net Import) 1 , 4(176.26MTOE) 10(213.77MTOE) .
( : IEA, Key World Energy Statistics, 2007)
, 9 CO2 1. OECD 1990 2005 .
CO2 (: , IEA 2007 )
-
92 2014
3.
, CO2 .
97% , .
/ . TOE .
/ 2008 35,339TOE 20% .
( : TOE, : )
(CO2) 19.4% 1 .
CO2 (:tCO2,%, :,)
-
93
20% . 4() 94.9%
.
(:KTDB newsletter 2011.10)
/ 2020 .
34.2, BAU(business as usual, 34.3% . (34.3%), (26.9%), (26.7%), (25.0%), (18.5%), (12.3%), (5.2%) .
(ITS), , .
( : , 2020 )
-
94 2014
4.
10,000,000 , ( : , 2007.5, )
/ . ?
-
95
8%, CO2NOX . . .
( UPI Report, )
, . 2010 1% . ( 0.76%)
30%, 25% 2.4% .
-
96 2014
(%) (: ECF)
26.3%, 26.8%, 35.9% 69.4% 78.6% . 10 6 .
.
, ITS .
( : )
-
97
.
- , (Eco-Driving) , -
-
, -
( )
, - ,
,
, , , ,
5. ( , 2009)
, .
10% 1 5,040,546 .
1 409kg//
-
98 2014
. 1 91 . ( )
(kg)// 3.9
(kg)// 409 91 1 ( 1 91 )
()/
()1)
5% 801,807
17,817
10% 1,603,614
35,635
()2)
5% 2,615,396
58,119
10% 5,230,791
116,239
1) 1 5 6.8km() , 2)
? . .
, .
.
6.
. . , . . .
. , . (?) . .
-
99
, . .
-
100 2014
2014
()
1.
' ' ' ' . 30 . '' . .
. 10 , '' . .
2.
( ) .
- - ( ~ ) - () - ( ) - , , - ( ) - () () ()
( )
-
101
- , , . 280ppm 2005 379ppm 30% . 1960~2005 1.4ppm .
- . .
- . ' ' . .
3.
.
100(1906~2005) 0.74 . 100 1983 . 1 '' . 2003 35,000 . , 1 10 1,000 . 6 40 15,000 .
. . . . (WMO) 2005 , , , ' ' .
2005 , , , , , , , . . 0.74 .
: 100 0.74 . , .
: .
-
102 2014
1 30% . .
: 2 ( 100 1.5) . 3( 40 22cm), 3( 100 1.1~1.6) . , , , .
, . . 10 . , . , .
. , , . , , .
4. ?
. . . . , . . . . .
-
103
COP21 1)
2014
( )
1. Post-2020 COP 19
2009 (UNFCCC COP15) Post-2012 , UNFCCC (multilateralism) . . . CAN2) CJN3) . , (COP 16) (COP17) . post-2012 (COP15) , post-2012 post-2020 . post-2020 UNFCCC .
, , . UNFCCC COP . IPCC 5 , . post-2020 UNFCCC COP
1) 19 (COP 19) , 2013, ENERZINE FOCUS 52 .
2) Climate Action Network. NGO .
3) Climate Justice Now! Jubilee South 3 NGO( ) Focus on the Global South NGO .
-
104 2014
()
COP 1 1995. 3 Berlin
Mandate
2000 (Ad hoc Group on Berlin Mandate) , 3 , 2000 GHG
COP 2 1996. 7 . IPCC SAR " " .
COP 3 1997. 12 Kyoto Protocol
Annex I , (ET, JI, CDM) . Annex I 2012 1990 5.2% GHG .
COP 4 1998. 11
Buenos Aires Plan of Action
. . COP 6 . non-Annex I
. post-2020 2011 (Durban Platform) 2015 (COP21) . (Conpenhagen Accord),2009' (Cancun Agreement, 2010)' post-2020 , (COP19) (COP20) .
. , . , 2020 . .
post-2020 COP21 , . - .
2. UNFCCC COP
[] UNFCCC COP
-
105
()COP 5 1999. 11 COP 6
COP 6 2000. 11 2002 , Umbrella (EU)
COP 6.5 2001. 7 Bonn
Agreement
, ? EU . , ,
COP 7 2001. 11 Marrakesh Accords
.
COP 8 2002. 10 The Delhi Ministerial
Declaration
, , . ,
COP 9 2003. 12
? ? ? . CDM . (Speacial Climate Change Fund) (LCDs : Least Developed Countries)
COP 10 2004. 12
SBSTA , , 5 . 1 (2008~2012)
COP 11 2005. 11
19 1 . 2012 1 . 2012 (two track apprach - AWG & dialogue)
COP 12 2006. 11
2 (2013~2017) . COP 13 . CCS CDM
-
106 2014
()
COP 13 2007. 12 Bali Action
Plan,
Post-2012 . , , (MRV) . 2009 COP 15
COP 14 2008. 12 COP 15
COP 15 2009. 12 Copenhagen
Accord
Post-2012 ( )
COP 16 2010 Cancun
Agreement
post-2020
COP 17 2011 Durban Platform
post-2020
COP 18 2012 COP 19 2013 COP21
UNFCCC COP . 2010 (Copenhagen Accord) UNFCCCC (agreement) . post-2012 . , post-2012 . (2011) . 2005 (COP11) . 2020 , . . (2012) post-2020 . 2020 post-2020 , , 2 . 2015 post-2020 .
-
107
[] UNFCCC COP (2009) (2010) (2011) (2012)
- 2
- 2015 1.5
- 2
- 2050 ( )
- 1 2
-
2015 COP21 post-2020
2020 . (2012 )
AWG
1)
2 (2013 1 8)
- 2014
- Kyoto Protocol 4)
- 2010. 1. 31 2020
- , 2010. 1. 31 ( )
-
-
- : 2020 1990 25~ 40%
- -
- - 2020 BAU
3. UNFCCC
UNFCCC post-2020 , , , , , post-2020 .
[] UNFCCC post-2020
( : UNFCCC )
4) Austraila, the EU, Japan, Liechtenstein, Monaco, Norway, Switzerland Unit . Hot air , .
-
108 2014
1) post-2020
2 , . (bottom up) (top down) . . . . EU , . , . 1.5 post-2020 . . 2020 .
2)
(GCF) . 2020 , GCF . , GCF . GCF , . .
, . .
3)
. pre-2020 . 2020
-
109
. , , , 2 .
EU (HFCs) , pre-2020 . EU . .
/ , . , UNFCCC .
4. COP21
. , . 7 . , NAMA( ) . GCF GCF .
7 .
-
110 2014
COP - -
2014
( )
1.
1) 2014 (UNFCCC COP) , COP20 COP . , .
2) 2000 COP , COP 2000 . COP 2007 COP13 .
3) Post-2012 2009 COP15 , 2010 .1) . COP16 COP17 COP () Post-2020 COP . . .
4) (?) COP21 COP . COP20 COP21 ,2) COP21 , COP20 3) .
5) 2007 COP , COP13 COP19
1) . .215(2010 ). pp.116~134; . . . . 2011. pp.393~428.
2) . 2014 / . ENERZINE FOCUS 53(2014. 2. 13).3) . : , .ENERZINE FOCUS 28(2011. 6. 15).
-
111
, COP20 . . , COP , . , COP20 : , .
2. (Solidarity for Climate Justice)
1) 1990 , 3 , , .4) 2002~2007 . COP , , 1989 COP (CAN) (CJN/CJA) .
2) 2005 .5) 2007 COP13 , , , , ,6) 2011 .7) , COP . [ 1] .
4) Patrick Bond. Climate Justice: Movement Below. Politics of Climate Justice: Paralysis Above, Movement Below. University of KwaZulu-National Press. 2012. pp.185~214.
5) , , , , 21 COP , .
6) . COP16 . 11 . 2010; . . 2010 . ?( , 2010. 3. 17).
7) . , . ( 13 , 2011. 5. 25) .
-
112 2014
[ 1]
2001 8) -
2002 (6)+10(8~9) (10) COP8
2004 (10) COP10 -
2005 COP11 (~2006)
2007 COP13(CJN) COP13 9)
2008 COP14 ()COP14 10)
2009
(1~2) (, 9~10)(CJA) ()(MJC) () COP15
2009(10)11) COP15 12)
2010 (4) 2010 (, 11) COP16
2010(10)13)G20 (11) COP16 14)/COP16 15)
2011 (3) COP17 (5)16)
2012 +20 COP18GGGI (2015 )
2013 GCF (, 12) COP19 BIG ASK( )
2014 (, 10) COP20 2014(8)
2015 COP21 -
8) .. . . 2012. p.322.9) , , , , , , , ,
, .10) , , , , , , ,
, , , , , ? , , .
11) 2009 : , , , ,
-
113
3) COP16 . . . , COP16 . , .17) . . - .18) , , .19)
4) (2011 5) . , , , , ,
, , .12) , (, , , , ),
, (, , , , , , , (), , YMCA, , , ), , , , .
13) 2010 : , , 21 , , , , , , .
14) , , , , , (, , , , , , , (), , YMCA, , , ), , , , , , , .
15) , , .16) 2011 5, 21 , , , ,
(ViaCampesina) , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .
17) . .18) . . 2010 . ?(
, 2010. 3. 17).19) . COP16 . 11 .
2010. , , , , (. . . 2012. 5 15).
-
114 2014
, , , , . , , , , .20) . .
5) . 2011 . .21) . , , 2011 , 2012 , , . , , , ( ), . , , , . 2 , , () , , . COP17~COP19 . , COP (, ).
6) () . . 2009~2012 22) COP18 (GCF) 23)
20) . ! : . 101(2011 7/8). pp.8~16; . : , .ENERZINE FOCUS 28(2011. 6. 15).
21) 130115.22) (2010.5)(, ); (2012. 2).23) 2010. 6);
-
115
(?) , , .
7) , COP , COP , (, , ) .
3. COP20 :
1) Anti COP . COP , COP , , .24) (geography of climate justice) , , .25) COP .
2) , , .26) . 2009 , .27) (Camp for Climate Action) , . , , .28) . , .
>(2011. 5)24) Lee, Jung-Pil. Triple Strategies beyond UN Climate Regime. Climate Justice Strategy: Beyond UN Climate
Regime and Global Green New Deal. ECPI. Durban COP17 Special Publication. 2011. pp.2~5.25) Susannah Fisher. The emerging geographies of climate justice. The Geographical Journal.
2014(http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/geoj.12078/pdf).26) . . . . 2012.
pp.188~190.27) Russell, Bertie Thomas. Interrogating the post-political: the case of radical climate and climate justice
movements. PhD thesis, University of Leeds. 2012(http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/3348/). 28) .. . . 2013. pp. 188~189.
-
116 2014
? ? ? .
3) Big Ask( ) . . , .29) , . , ? .
4) , ? ( ) ? ? , , , , , , , , 4, , , () , , , , , , , , , Car Free City , .30) , , , ? , ?
5) COP20 . , COP21 , (COP ) , , NGO .31) .
29) . .60(2014 ). pp.208~228.30) . NGO . 2010 .
?( , 2010. 3. 17).31) . 19 (COP 19) . ENERZINE FOCUS 52(2013. 11. 11).
-
117
. ?6) . 2014 5,
. , , , , (GCF) , .32) GCF . GCF , GCF .33) , COP GCF .
32) . .33) . , ? ( 1 ,
2012. 11. 27)
-
118 2014
- * -
2014
1)
( )
1.
, , , . (//// ) , . 10 . 2007 2 5 , 5 2012 5 2,500 .
, , . , . , . , , , , . . . ( , 2007)
, . .
* 2014 6 3 , (/), (), (), (), (), (/) . , 2014 9 23 , .
-
119
2.
2-1.
1953 UN (Atoms For Peace)' , 1955 , 1956 , 1958 .
(62) , 1 .
, , 10% .
1990 , .
1 2010 42.1% . 2003 12 3 46.7% 44.7%, 2020 43.4% .
2007 3 2011 , .
MB 2008 1 (2008~2030) 2008 24% 2030 41%, 36% 59% . 2010 5 , 34 4~6 . , 2009 12 UAE 2010 1 .
, 1988 1990 , 1995 2000 12 , 2005 .
, 2004 , . (, 2012)
-
120 2014
1955. 1956. 1958. ,
53,UN Atoms For Peace
57 IAEA
1962. (TRIGA-MARK-) 1966. 1978. 1 (587,000MW, 21 )
78 79
/
1985. 214 , 1987. (CE)
10% (8 ) (87 )
86
//
95 , 03 2000 , , //
IMF
MB (08) 2030 40%, 41% , , , 1 ,
, 11 UAE
: (2012)
2-2.
(), (, ), (, KPS ), ( ), , () .(, 2013)
: (2013)
-
121
2012 21 3,909 (GDP) 1,272.5 1.68% . 2003 10 , 10%, 10.9%, 9.5%, 8.5%, 3.7%, 22.5% .
, . , 2012 21 3,909 2011 19 8,719 1 5,190 7.6% . 16 1,407 2011 14 2,170 1 9,236 13.5% , 5 2,502 56,549 4,047 7.2% .( 2014)
, 2012 144, 1,000 , , , PS, , 9. , 100 1,000 , GS , SK, , , , , , , , 26 .
( : )
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 20031) 2,364 2,139 2,074 1,734 2,169 1,919 2,030 2,095 2,2272) - - 4,450 5,812 6,598 7,578 7,807 8,146 8,832 - - 6,524 7,546 8,767 9,497 9,837 10,241 11,059 76 115 124 131 162 167 158 148 139 23,441 24,740 23,006 21,218 20,698 20,646 20,798 20,736 20,951 10 11 12 14 16 16 16 18 18 N/A 2 6 6 4 4 4 2 2
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2,291 2,215 2,305 2,504 3,765 3,973 4,782 5,655 5,250 9,009 10,075 10,495 10,311 10,829 11,463 11,977 14,217 16,141 11,300 12,290 12,800 12,815 14,594 15,436 16,759 19,872 21,391 138 131 105 103 131 149 157 174 144 21,201 21,120 20,784 20,810 21,460 23,297 23,835 26,200 28,195 19 20 20 20 20 20 20 21 23 1 4 4 6 6 6 8 7 5 : , 1~18
1) , , , , NDT , , , , , , .
2)
-
122 2014
, 2012 , , 2 337(38.7%), 8,845(16.8%), 6,628(12.6%), 5,096(9.7%), 3,808(7.3%), 2,485(4.75%) . , 2012 , 100 35(28%), 100 90 (72%).
(2012 )
: (2014)
, , (66.5%), (44.2%), (19.7%), (17.7%), (17.1%), (4.3%), (1.2%) .
-
123
( : , %)
: (2014)
, 2012 28,195 26,200 1,995 7.6% .
: (2014)
-
124 2014
, 28,195 25,591(90.8%), 2,604(9.2%).
, ( : , %)
: (2014), 18
(5,922), (3,988), (3,920), (3,840), (3,339), NDT (2,708), (2,699), (1,779) .
( : , %)
: (2014), 18
-
125
2-3.
.
, NDT, ( ), ,
NSSS, T/G
, , ,
, , , NDT NDT
: , 18
2012 (), () (), () (), KPS(), , 9 , 1,000 .
, , , , , , 7 , 271 125 . , 62 27 , 21 , , 3 , , 4 , , , 7 .
-
126 2014
, 2003 2 2,269 2012 52,502 10 3233 10% , 2012 . 10%, 10.9%, 9.5%, 8.5% , 3.7%, 22.5% ( ).
( : , %)
: , 18
, 5 (//KPS//) , 2012 2 8,667 (5,250) 54.6% . MB 5 (23,423) 47%(11,004) .
5 ( : )
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007
5 11,003,476 2,866,673 2,719,320 2,316,484 1,845,874 1,255,124 930,513
-
127
: "" , . , ., .
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 32,666,392 7,856,769 6,669,497 6,150,985 6,279,481 5,709,660 4,089,542
2007 () 1.92 1.63 1.50 1.54 1.40
21,738,719 5,647,086 4,367,013 3,959,124 4,003,313 3,762,183 2,045,6682007
() 2.76 2.13 1.94 1.96 1.84
3,520,297 978,079 978,079 739,250 467,526 357,364 151,9642007
() 6.44 6.44 4.86 3.08 2.35
10.78% 12.45% 14.66% 12.02% 7.45% 6.26% 3.72%
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 47,092,228 10,433,442 10,104,552 10,004,558 9,278,579 7,271,097 5,649,098
2007 () 1.85 1.79 1.77 1.64 1.29
1,989,016 475,385 475,385 488,821 450,188 99,237 91,6542007
() 5.19 5.19 5.33 4.91 1.08
4.22% 4.56% 4.70% 4.89% 4.85% 1.36% 1.62%
-
128 2014
KPS ( / )
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 4,343,766 1,006,609 925,497 842,544 805,243 763,873 681,395
2007 () 1.48 1.36 1.24 1.18 1.12
1,711,687 388,996 369,653 324,948 316,661 311,429 267,1712007
() 1.77 1.68 1.48 1.44 1.42
39.41% 38.64% 39.94% 38.57% 39.32% 40.77% 39.21%
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 963,876 238,627 232,869 183,312 169,265 139,803 110,891
2007 () 2.15 2.10 1.65 1.53 1.26
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2,818,601 785,586 663,335 580,154 442,234 347,292 308,833
2007 () 2.54 2.15 1.88 1.43 1.12
1,829,764 370,206 465,258 463,313 306,970 224,017 196,0342007
() 1.89 2.37 2.36 1.57 1.14
()
08~12 2012 2011 2010 2009 357,336 58,288 133,382 46,783 118,883
2009 () 0.49 1.12 0.39
-
129
2008~2013, ( )(:)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 3,4 349,481 1,867,714 151,136 96,301 186,035 61,567 2,712,233 82,566 52,732 96,207 89,513 70,880 41,164 565 351,061 106,259
88,159 10,491 35,638 151,063 13,855 12,982 312,188 79,386 - - - 477 34,126 316 34,919
2-4.
2008 2012 __ , 537 , 4,631, 4 2,110 . .
( : )
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 4,631 3,559 911 184 953 229 874 129 620 99
:
2-5.
MB 5 , 2 _ (2001~2012)
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
20125 2500
20072 5040
: (1997~2014)
-
130 2014
2012 21,909 (GDP) 1,272.5 1.68%. , , 5(//KPS//) 2012 2,867 (5,250) 54.6% . MB 5 (23,423) 47%(11,004) .
, 2012 144, 1,000 , , , PS, , 9. , 100 1,000 26 /.
_ (17.9%)
2012 28,195 26,200 1,995 7.6% . 28,195 25,591(90.8%), 2,604(9.2%). , 20 (36), 30 (496), / 20 (194) .
_ R&D
2012 UAE 1 4,900 . 1993 5 200 1 , , 1997 ( ) AECL 3(PHWR, 700MW 2) . 2012 IAEA, OECD 2 , , , , , 48 637 207 . 2009 12 UAE (APR1400 4, 186 ).
2012 IAEA, , , , , , , , , , , , , 13, 52, 9,255 . 2012 - UAE , KPS, , , PS, , , , , , , . (, 2012)
-
131
- 537 , 4,631, 4 2,110-
2008
AB
2009201020112012
2008~2012 :
3. ()
3-1.
. , (), (), (), () () .
, , , KPS, , , , , GS, SK, , , , , . , .
2 2( ) 3 , . ( ) . ,
-
132 2014
, .(, 2014)
, . , . 2008 2014 100 . ( 6. )
.
(2008~2014)
3-2. -
, . , , -- .
, (1 ) 59, 2013 5 6 3,931( 15 808 42.4%) . , KPS(463 ) 2013 5 2 , (179 ) 2012 4 2 , YPP( ) 67(238) .(, 2013)
(2013.10.14), (1) 59 5 6 3 931
( 15 808 42.4%) KPS(463 ) 5 2 (179 ) 4 2 YPP( ) 67(238)
-
133
3-3.
, , . , , , .
, 18 , (SKKPS) , . , .
18~19 1
2008-11-28 ,,,,,
()/()/()/(SK)/,(KPS)/()
2008-11-28
2010-12-23 ()/()/() 2013-02-07 ()
2006-05-25 ()
2011-11-03 ()
2008-11-28 ()/()/
() 2008-11-28
2013-11-15 ()/()*
(2014), , 2009 , 47 569 , 9 (OB) 206 2,791 5 5 56.6%, 64.5% . (55)
-
134 2014
3-4. R&D
1997 2010 2 2,464 .
( : ) 97~03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
19,664 8,248 1,587 1,564 1,688 1,694 1,598* 1,678 1,607 4,869 2,048 417 444 287 369 400 442 462 24,533 10,296 2,004 2,008 1,975 2,063 1,998 2,120 2,069
(08 137) 3)
3-5.
(2014), , . , . , 3 . , , . ()3 3 . 3 1974 6 , , , , . ()3 . . , . .() 3 , . , .
3) , , 1.
-
135
4.
, , ( ) ( ) . , . , .
? , . , . , . , , , , .
.
, , , , R&D , .
, , . (, 2014)
(2012), , ENERZINE FOCUS 41(2014), , (2014-6-29) (2007-09-02), , , (2007)(2013.12.), (2014), 18 (1997~2014), 1~18(2014), (2013), 1 59 6,
-
136 2014
1.
: (2014), 18
-
137
2. 2012
: (2014), 18
-
138 2014
3. ( : )
10
#1,2 #1,2 6,104 5,090 1,014
#1,2 #1,2 9,737 8,903 834
#3,4 #3,4 10,883 10,354 529
#1,2 #1,2 16 15 1
7,034 6,710 324
7,993 7,746 247
41,767 38,818 2,949
11
#1,2 #1,2 3,131 2,653 478
#1,2 #1,2 8,323 7,337 986
#3,4 #3,4 14,581 12,754 1,827
#1,2 #1,2 4,999 4,732 267
#5,6 #3,4 67 65 2
#3,4 #1,2 16 16 0
7,242 7,147 95
8,068 8,475 -407
S/Y 789 756 33
47,216 43,935 3,281
12
#1,2 #1,2 1,128 755 373
#1,2 #1,2 6,250 4,653 1,597
#3,4 #3,4 12,420 11,601 819
#1,2 #1,2 6,946 6,551 395
#5,6 #3,4 105 110 -5
#3,4 #1,2 43 45 -2
8,115 7,861 254
9,650 9,465 185
S/Y 2,978 2,747 231
47,635 43,788 3,847
:
-
139
(VAT)() 1 () 3 4,120,002,000 2 () 2 789,500,000 3 () 9 10,459,135,171 4 () 7 62,254,195,400 5 () 1 739,320,000 6 () 25 38,502,143,321 7 () 14 20,692,198,000 8 () 21 10,016,582,299 9 () 2 526,423,000 10 () 45 24,594,510,869 11 () 2 4,827,099,919 12 () 3 1,932,424,780 13 () - -14 ENEC - -15 ENEC BRAKA - -16 Fugen21c - -17 GS 2 95,744,000 18 KEPCO INGS - -19 YPP 67 23,824,935,591 20 () 16 5,162,427,180 21 ENC( ) - -22 - -23 179 2,480,043,346,498 24 () 5 15,760,360,000 25 () 9 21,304,008,674 26 () 8 60,182,202,720 27 () 37 36,584,112,628 28 3 391,477,000 29 161 57,153,502,581 30 - -31 6 8,714,310,000 32 68 18,781,094,349 33 19 5,716,729,996
4. ( 5)
-
140 2014
(VAT)() 34 38 112,544,911,499 35 32 15,248,488,532 36 - -37 19 74,134,064,848 38 PM - -39 1 28,500,000 40 () 200 760,301,472,488 41 22 200,730,387,190 42 463 2,272,312,576,333 43 ()44 () 68 44,648,535,903 1,557 6,393,116,722,769
: (2013)
-
141
1953.01 ,
46.03.02 45.09.11 2003 45.01.31 - 2006 46.09.01 - 2006
48.02.10 2006
51.01.25 - 2006
55.05.03 ) - 2008
47.12.06 ) )
2009
51.01.14 ) )
2016
KPS 1962.8.23 () KPS 1960.11.9 () 2008KPS 1967.7.7 () 2008KPS 1946. 4. 7 () () 2008
KPS '70.02.27 () '09.12.08
KPS 1967.06 () () 2011.09.20
~
KPS 1956.01 () ()
2012.02.03~
KPS 1970.04 () 2012.02.03
~
KPS 1969.02 () 2013.03.29
~
54. 5.30, ,
) 08. 8. 6
62.10.17 , ) , ) 10.3.19
60.12.19 KAIST ) 09. 3.26
61. 1.29, ,
) ), 07. 7.12
1940.03.20. , ) )
2013.03.18
1953.09 )10), 2013.07.11
5.
-
142 2014
1967.01 ) 1
2014.03.31
1969.07 ) )
2014.07.21
1959.09 ) )
2015.03.27
1955.01 ) ) 2015.10.18
52.08.17
()
54.06.14
() () ()
44.04.27
(6)
1945.05.19, ,
, 2008
1949.02.11 2, 2008
1950.02.27, , ,
, KOTRA
1950.03 () , ,
2012
1955.12 ,
2013
'36.05.09 ) , ) 2007
46. 2.10 , 2004
41. 1.27 , 2002
43. 8.13 4, 2003
1957.09 2, 2103
'48.10.10 , 2008
'45.02.12 ) , ) 2007
-
143
2008~2013 , 6 2009~2014 ,, 6 2008~2012 () 5 2010~2014 4 2008~2012 , 4 08~09/11~12 , 4 2010~2012 , 3 2012~2014 () 3 2011~2013 KPS() 3 2012~2014 3 2011~2013 3 2009/2012~2013 , 3 2010~2012 ,, 3 2009~2011 3 2011~2014 3 2008/2010 2012 3
2008~2010 3 2011~2013 () 3 2009, 2011, 2013 3 2011~2012, 2014 , 3 2011~2013 (), 3
2009~2011 , 3 2011~2013 () 3 2010~2012 3 2012~2013 , 2 2013~2014 2 2012~2013 ,2 2 2012~2013 2 2009, 2014 , 2 2008~2009 , 2 2012, 2014 2 2008~2009 2 2012, 2014 ,BG 2
6. (2008~2014)
-
144 2014
2008, 2011 , 2 2010~2011 2 2011 1 2012 GS 1 2008 KPS 1 2014 1 2013 1 2014 KPS 1 2009 1 2014 1 2013 1 2014 1
2014 1 2008 1 2013 1 2009 1 2013 1 2011 1 2012 1 2011 1 2014 1 2011 1 2011 1 2014 1 2009 1 2008 1 2012 1 2008 1 2008 - 1 2012 1 2014 1 2009 1 2011 1 2008 1
-
145
2013 1 2014 1 2014 1 2008 1 2014 1 2012 1 2014 1 2008 1 2014 1 2013 1 2013 1 2014 1 2009 1 2013 1 2013 1 2009 1 2008 1 2010 1 2012 1 2012 1 2009 1 2008 1 2014 1 2008 1 2014 1 2014 1 2013 1 2014 1 2014 1 2013 1 2009 KPS 1 2009 1 2010 1
:
-
146 2014
[, ]
2014
,
.
. 23 . . .
. . ., , .
. . . ..., ..., ... . ..., ... .
(), () . , , , . . .
, ?
-
147
.
, .
[ ]
- (), () - , ,
[ ]
- - , ,
.
[ ]
1. () - (, , , , , ) - ( , ) - ( . )
2. () - ( ) - ( )
[ ]
1. [ , ] -
. : ? : ? : ?
-
148 2014
2. 4 [ ] - 4 . [, , , ] - : () ? - : ? - : ? - : ?
-
149
< >
-
150 2014
< >