!"#$

%!#

&%!#'(%!

! ! "# $%&' # ( ) * + ! ** * , - . /0 - $%&'1 2!3!,* * /(3* 0+ )*#0 $4 5# $%&'1 3 * * /(5 0+ + $%0 $%&61 ,*# 0*7 # 0! 8 -, $%&90

*!,#&!,!$9/910$%&404'9:499-,,-,,***

*# , #0;.0.0!.#0

* # &! ,! $9/910 $%&40! * # @,0 0 0 * 0 8!2 2 A ?,0 # # /(B.-*+1*! C# 0 , 0 3./! /,0$%%'10%0,1/A2A000$%&D0120/64E6D0$%&&1

* 2 2 * / @1*#B7/5*1** *# * !0 *# ,* * # * * *#,!*-?02#3##*

*0!,*,,#0*#*0*#:**0* 0 * * * ? !# !0 * *0 * # # , 00!!*,

, 0 , ,0 (!2,*+0#0** #*# # !$ 0 , !!# 0!# # * !" 3 ! ! ,, 80 ! ! * * !* ,, 2 * A , ! , ! # ** # ** !*# @ ! # ** * **,,#

C*#2#2!*#**),0#2,0!2***#!*#0 ! * * * !,*,F?C $ ***!:!*!:0#0#*#!!!,!/1

2 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

*! G @!2C!*2*,*#0*

!0!*#0!***?##:#*:!#!,,*#***#!2!:#:!#,,**#*# ** @ #, ,, ** #*#,0 *0 *3 * **0 ! 5! *# ,# ! ! 2***#*00!,,*0 7,: *0!! , ! : # ,,*!*0

000

5 " 0 (*+ 0

#0 * *(*+*!" *!,* 3 # & 4& +5 *# !* !2**# ! * : !* #**#*!!,*0#**, *(***, + (0+ 0 , , *0**83#&4&+56# * (5 * **, 0 ***, + : !* * * *!#/$1#3*C#0/G1 * 3 # /#1*' -*00( +

G -/$%&90-*91/$%&D0-*41*!' (*0+0**!*#!20 0 (*+ @ ** ! * * #*#!)!!*0!02*!!*0*#*!(**,

3van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

: !2 ! * * : !*0 0 (+ : **,# !

?# ! *F ?# *3 ! , *F ! ! C A *,!*)!*0,0,0&0 * * C * ! * ***#)!* * ! 2 * *!***@!*

**!)/$1#*E*#0/G1*#*#*0#**! * # ! @ ! 0 !0 * !* # *

A # ! /**1 * * , 0 0 ** *72, *!2 # # !** * # 2 5 2 ,0!0 * , * * , * !# *, *0* C /0 0 ! ** # ! ,1 0 2*#!**

!,*0" *3#&4&+5****,:! !2 ** * * ! ,*****,7H7 **, *6 , ,

+ * #,* * (+ (*+6 5**0/$%&61

4 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

C ! ,# ,**0 !2 *,##*!0!/*00,00 ,#0 21 * 0 !# , C !29 "0 * !20 ,80 * ! * *!0!0!*#*#?20" 30**(3!+4

@#*,, : !2 !,!2:*## !# 0 # 2 * #0 /1 !2 ! ,, ! , # * * * ,0 0 ! *

*,*

!"#

,*,0#,**#5" #0,!** / * !1 # * *2*"*#0*#,! * : 2, , * ** : 2 C#!20** * * * , *D

9 -/$%&$1!2#/*0*00*10C!#4 B,-3,#0**#*#0!**0*#, * / # ! !21 # (##+ /,, !, 3 *1 (*+ /, *3*1--/$%D%10-*6;!0#*,,#*#C5*##*D !0 ! # !* * ! *#0*****,0 0*,# /0$%&91

5van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

C0 0 ! *# ,!0 0*:*#:!***,*#,!" *,* $&9% 3 , 0 , ** #**) *#,!!!*!*,00*!** 80!* * * * 20*# **! 8 *#:!*! ,:! 8 C *# / (, +1 *# / ( *+1 * - *C *#* * / * 1 , /*1 0**, *0 *C0!*C * * # , *3 * 0#*0!,* 0##!23!,0!,*0*#*#!,!2!0 # * #, !2 ;**C!**#! * * * ,# #**" 3#0*(,+**!#0!0**" ,,**/*1* * , * , *0 **, *0***#*&

,!0!0**#**C 8 *# 0 * *!*00* & 5****(,0+**!7,7,0 . /$%&'1 - " , 2 " 3 !2 */*#1 *, / # , 1 * * *,*@*##/0 $%&IJ $%&'1 "0 , ! C# # * * :

0" 3 *,* !**)**7*C*0,***!**!#****,,0#0!0/$%%90*41

6 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

## * * **0 !**C*#2,** , "0 ! # *0*,*C*!# 8*#! # # * *0 8 # * * , !2, / ! *,*0*,# F1 # !* *, *C 8 2 * # * !,

-##K!*#! ,# 7 *C #0 C0!*# *#0 * !*#

0 2# # 0#!!# *2 #(*+!#"0# 8 /!* 2 1 , *C / * 7* (# +10 * ! 8 *##********800 ,!***?,*0*,!**#,,!, * * * , /;!,!,** *1,0*,***!0 #*#0* 8C#0 * , *0 ,* (,+ * * ** **7 8,*%

0**,*3#* !"0 * * #*,,A0,*2 * , * ! , *

**#*, 0 #*0

% # ?8L*2 - /$%D$1J - /$%D'J $%&G1 5

, * * " ! * ! * *0/$%&'1J/$%&90-*'GG9$'1

7van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

# 0 , !* #! 2 ! #0 *!2 (*+ 2#* 8 * * *0 0 * !# *, 0 *2#*FA*0** , C# !2! 0 !**,0 **#!**,!,@!#02#*, &****

,#

$%&

@*,*, ,*C*0# * *2 *,! 2!* #* * * ) * /#1**,*# , *0 ! # , *#,*#,!*#

@ 0 ! * !# #, * ,*) * !# ,, ! 0 !00*00!#/1* A# * *00**#*!# # * #* * *0*#!8*#**,0 *** * * 2 # * *0 0 # ! **0 * *, *! * !!

* **#

/$1# **0/G1** *, * * *#

8 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

**!,*2*# 0 ! * * *$I *0 !0!! *2 # " !2" 0C** * !0 0 *# ? # 0! , *0 ! # * * 0!*#***?2*

*0 ! C ! **,*

'() !"

*##**, # ! * 0 *0 *@ * *#(**+!**#,* # * ** *0 !0 ,!(**+

- *!,# * **! * 5 0 , (* *+ # *!!2!20,#*!#***A# !#*!20* # * 0 ! @#3 *# 0 , 0 # .7=0

0 ! * *0 50 !*#*,,*/, *1:*#@ $G *# * * ,!, ,?$'

*!02#*

(* *+ * /* 1 *0 # **, *0 ##*#/#*,*0 *2 !*0 ** 1 (, *+ 0! *0* (,*+/!,*,#0*20*10 !* * ! * *#$60 * *C* * ! ! # )! !*2 *0,!#*,

*+ ,-./

2# 7*5

:!# #**,*: # ,8 ! ( + #

!,)!**/!*20,,1,*0***, ! *, *# ! ! !!2, / * * *0 !20*1 ,0 *C*!!*@27,**,,0** ! 2 * # * 2 , !,0 7* # "0 * ,*, , !7!2!#,*A*0 , , *0 , $G/$%$&0&$1$'-0 0/$%D'J$%&90'1J2/$%D%1J/$%&G1J"/$%&'1J#/$%&615 #**0@,/$%&90G1$6A-C**!

10 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

*, # 0 3 ** * !2,/2(!+1!2,/(,+3 !21 ! 27 , *00! * !! * !2 !! # "0 ! # *#2,0* C!2,

00,*250*# ! # *80 , @**8 , ,! * *0 #, * ##!20! ! # # ! ,2/*7!20 *# !,0 *# ,0 *10 ,!2#*!#!C#0,*20,!,,*!!2! ! *"0!:! * # : !, ** * #0*0*(*+ / , 10*0!,#!(+$9

0+ 1"-./

C#0 * *! * *#0 #!#,*,* , 8 * ** " 8,,**!3!72!(**+)

!,*CC,:!*0*20,:!$4-*,!# *, C#**##* #$D @ ** ! " * , 0 !* 0 0 $9>

,* 8

* ! ! * * * *3 *0 ! * , * **

A*0!*,#0*0*0!#(+,/* 1$II***00 ,*#* @!0 20 , * * # * 0 * 8 * *0 *

*/!C ,1! ,* C#0 " * * *#

,* 8*#3* **, ) ,,0 0 * * * 3>***,0**2**0 *!2,,0* * @ # * (*+!2*,**# * #3 *# / * 0 !* 2 * **1

*0 ,**!**#0!(*+*

, * # !,#!$&

?****#,2 * , C * @ ! # * * !2 * ) # * , * , : , *# 27, * : ! * * A *0 * *0 * * /! (+F10 * # # *

$&,2-/$%&G1,***!**0!*/$%&'1* B!2*0#, / #1 #!20#**2/1B,*0*,)##!20,,/**1

12 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

*22 , * * , ,0 ! ! *

!,C * * ** 0 !0 *,#0 *20 * *0 * * *0 # ! , * * (+!,*#!!;!*#**,*F

*!C!#C*# !# , ! * /* * 0,10 !# !**, ,0 !* ! * * 0#,0!0**,* , ** *3 , * !*#*@!!**#*/0#0 *1 ! *# 5 !23* , ! #!,*0!,!2/!*!* ** 1 ,! 5!, *0*#!,!2/**#!#0*!**,7C#!,

* 1C#0 * ,*!0* #0 ** ,8 *, C# !2 # * ,# C *

,!*#*, *# ! ! * # *# * ? ,#0 #0 C*,**0**,**,*0!*,,?! ,!*#0!0!! # 8 ,** , !* , * /*# *#1 ,!,! ,*# *!**#*,,/#*,#!1

13van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

*, 0 * *! # ! *

2,&&31!14

( *+ #7 ** ! */, 1 * *, , ** *#$% 5 , *,#0 , *!*0,/1*0** * /*C#1 **,* /1A0*0!*,#*# 0 ** / 2 , 1 ! * ,0 * * 0!0*/*1!2,#*/0*/*1 *0 * *#! * !0*2*#*0##7# *0 * /!,1 #*!/#0**1

*#,,*,#*,#**)*

$ 8*/* 1* , * , /(5 &*$1J

G 8,/ $1J

' 8,/ *1:!*00 8, :*!,/(./$1J

6 8C#0 #, * *0 * , / *# ,1* ,!/3!*$1

$%***#* ,0***2*

14 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

** ! * /61 *# !! **! * /G1 /'1 5 ** *#!#000 ,0**#, *# , *! # ,**0 8,C#/*/611!**#C 8,!*2* /*/'11 0 *,#*#*, 0!*

* # * : 0 * # #*#/C#1 * , * * *# ,0 8, C# /* /611 **# C 8, # /* /G11 A *,**,5,$

5+ 6"". -./

K * *#3 * * .**# / #1**!*!*, ! # " , ,#,/0!"C.1 I $II *0 !23 * # *!*#I0/,,*C*1 **K!*,#

*/ #*.10* * , * * * ,, , * / *1 * 0 8 * * / * *1 *!*0** .0 ! # !0 *!**) !," *0,.! I #,0!0 ** ! *0 . ! $II* !!I$II*0**

15van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

! *# * ." 0 2 *

5,$**!2 , * C *#3*0,0#" **/'1),* , 0 , , 8 *#3K,2****2,!!!0C#?*/'1,0!0 ( +! *! , , ! ! C #@#C,8 **0*/'1!20*!20*,* !0 , , !2, # , , C# !2 *# / *1,!/5,G10*,#,*000 #*, , 2 !, * , 2 *, **,0/ 1*,,#2: ! ** * /'1 : !2, # 2,!,C#!22,0**,!2)#!2*,!2GI

GI5 * ,! (( .8 /$%&I0 $6G:$991J/$%&90-*G1

16 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

K **K3 **. ,,,,.M .*,#3*." .

/$1 ,!7*/G1 !*/'1 " */61 C#7*

,4

7" 6"".

17van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

K$0 KG **$0G.$0 .G ,,,,$0G.M .*,#3*

/$1 ,!7*/G1 !*/'1 " *

,47!#8&..

18 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

C#0" */'1**0,!0#0!#G$ -***! /#0 #* * ( ,!+1 *# ** . *#***!,/05,G!1***#

C#,*#,/?, # *2 ! !# 0,#*F1/,1,!*002#***" **,0*0C!!)(5***,0***,N+

,818/9

-0 # ! (" + * /'1 # *50#0***/'1# 5 , ( +#*,*#3!**0

7*0 0 !20 * ,,*!#)*7,*27#*#2#,,(+*,#,,#,*#2!2,00 *# * ,! (+0 0 *! , ! C ,C##**/61@ ! # : ,# " : 00!#*C0*#3*#!#

*,,,*/'1 #*C#7H7!2, C# !20

G$*,)(!!0#*!,,+/7=$%D%04'1.

19van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism

3!##

,,!* :!* *# * / 1 ! , -0 0 ! /,C#1# !*! ## * A * * # * ,!*/'1/G1 0(" +*/'1C#C###!!*0!(!+*/G1CC#,0*! C# !2, @ 0 0 ! *C#58A*0 0 8 * * ,**00*(,!7+*/$10!0*#,!0C* * /0 21 0*#* (" + * /'1 ! 0 *#0*,!0*#07! # 3 ,#

** 0 *! */'1! */G1/$1

-* * , 0 #0 *2 ! ,! *# , ,!0

#(" +*/'10#**#7,7C#7,* # # B, * /$1 8,,!0 0 !,; , 7) !, , 8 ,# * , , , * ,:,,** ,!

0** #0*0* ! * # * # # 8, :8,,##, ** #*#

20 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol1/iss1/art6

, *, #3 0 *#2/*1C#!#2,!*#,**

@,2,*:*

*C* , , * # ***!** /* ,1!*##*#**0!**" !2!#!* * * * : *#0 7, ** *, * ! *, * **,!:!** & !0 ! *#0!200,*0#*,00 * * ! , ** # * # 0 # , # # : * * #C#0!2*#0*3,*!**#,

"

7=0 . /$%D%1 ( ?*!* ?*,,) B $ .5 0&19&*:&G'06I:4'

#0 /$%&61,,!#-5:&9/;)*#A,8

@,0 7"0 ># /1 /$%&91(3* ) B

>0 ?2, $0 ,)

;?B#0>**!0/$%DG1 &!#6A )A B#0=/$%&G1%!&=0#6"*)

?2-*#0 /$%&'1 * *C 0 -*

)

# -0 ?2, G$'0 B# 0 >)>**

0@ /$%&$1 >

,&,!6)B!

-0/$%D'1(A#7*,*,0++

5#&9!#,DI0G$I%:G$GG

-0 /$%&G1 ( * # " 3,0+,&)6%0$$:$&

-0 # /$%D%1 ( 50+ 5 ; " ; /1 +&&! )&!6A )A B#0$%D%

-0 /$%&G1--*O00B#"*)>**

0 /$%&61 (5 7**#!50++$&064':6%G

0/$%&D1(-*@7 F+!/1.)/ )-,

0/$%&910 5) 5 0 ?2, &9I$0 B

0/$%&61(?/#,1*#?,?F++&&'60&9:$IG

0/$%&91(" 030) R

;3