7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

1/22

1390127-148

*

.

.

.

..

..

.

.

.

://.

* Hmg100@yahoo.com26/5/90:1/4/90:

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

2/22

128

1390

1

2)Lewis Carroll(

)What the Tortoise Said to Achilles?(

. 34

..

.

.

.1

.:

][!

:!

5.

. ...

:

: !

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

3/22

129

1390

:

.!

ABZ:

(A) .(B) .(Z).

ZABABZ.

AB

ABZ::.AB

.

AB::

:.

: Z

.::

Z.: Z

AB....

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

4/22

130

1390

.C: :

(C)ABZ. .:

: .C :

.:

(A) .(B) .(C)ABZ.(Z).

.ZD: .ABCZ:

ZABC.:.

ZABC: A

BC Z:

. :

(D)ABCZ.:ABCDZ.

: AB.CD Z.

:Z!

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

5/22

131

1390

ABCDZ.:!

E: :(E)ABCDZ.

.Z.... :

:

. .

.2

:(A) .(B) .

:

(Z).

:ab

(A) ( x)( y)( z)[(x=z & y=z) (x=y)]

(B) ( x)(a=x &b=x)

(Z) a=b

AB

Z. :

sab) .

(B)s(.a=s & b=s

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

6/22

132

1390

(a=s & b=s) a=b)(

a=b)(

(Z).(C)

:

(C) (A) & (B) (Z)

:(Z)

(A) .(B) .(C)(A) & (B) (Z)

:

(Z).

:(D)(D) (A) & (B) & (C) (Z)

:

(A) .(B) .

(C)(A) & (B) (Z)

(A) & (B) & (C) (Z) (D)

.

(n+1)(A) & (B) & (C) & (D) &..&(n) (Z)

:

(Z).

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

7/22

133

1390

2.1

:

)1380:9(.

.

.

):7(.

.

)rules of inference(

.

.

.

.

.

.

)modus ponens(: P

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

8/22

134

1390

QQP .

2.2

.)The Principles of Mathematics(

.6

)(.K

7.

.

..

. . xFxGxaFx

FaGa..

)

(

)independence(

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

9/22

135

1390

)Russell, 1903: 35(.

..

..)proposition(

)asserted()unasserted(..

.)judgment(

)complex concept(

.)()quality(.

.

..

P

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

10/22

136

1390

)()inference(.

QPP)therefore(Q.

K) .)

K .QQ.PP:

QPQPQ.8P

.

!9

.

.10

)(.

.

.

..P

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

11/22

137

1390

. .

2.3

)rule(

. )The Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to Philosophy(

1958

.

..)A.J.Ayer( )John Stuart Mill(

)Vilfredo Pareto()Max Weber( )scientistic(.

)Ludwig Wittgenstein( )R. D. Collingwood(.:

)Implicit rules(

)forms of life( .

.

)laws of nature(

.

).Winch, 1958: 113-115()understanding(

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

12/22

138

1390

)Internalistapproach( .

)ibid: 108(.

.

:

...

)ibid: 33(.

.

()explicit()Axiomatic Sciences((

.

)(

.

.

( (. .

..

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

13/22

139

1390

.

.

.

11

!

.

.

.

.

.

. :

.)Fallacy of begging the question(

.

:

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

14/22

140

1390

:.

.

.

)(

.

.

.

:

.

)Quine, 1936: 351(.

.

. .

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

15/22

141

1390

.

.

3.

:.i(P).(

ii(PQ.)(Q)(

:.

iii(P)PQ(Q.

. :iv(P]P[Q]P]P[[QQ. Q

.

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

16/22

142

1390

. : Q

Q.QPQ

P).(

:.P~Q]P[Q~

)(

.

.

:

)Bergson, H., 1911:308(.

:

..

.

.

.

)1989(

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

17/22

143

1390

4.:

.

.

. .

.

.

)material logic()formal logic(.

)critical logic(

)criticism(

.

)validity( )

) .

.

)(. :

P

.QPQ

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

18/22

144

1390

.

.

.

.

.

. FF. .

..

)Hofstadter, 1979: 170(

.

..

. .

.

.

.

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

19/22

145

1390

. .

.

.:

.P&Q

.RP&QR.

..

.

.

.

:1.2.((.3 .

:

)( .

)(

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

20/22

146

1390

:

)(.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.12

.1)(

)1384:3.(

2. Lewis Carroll (/krl/,KA-rl)

)Charles Lutwidge Dodgson.1832-1898(

.21865

.

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

21/22

147

1390

4. Achill

:

.

(p

q)

.

d3

es

...

.

.

Aristotle

...

..

(

d.

Cl.(

, Physics VI:

Solvitur am

"Diogenes th

.

(

)90

d23

.)ark, 2002: 1

, 239b15

.

bulando

e Cynic"

.

)

:

d1

d2

.

:

Impl

.

.

.3

d4

. 5

ication .6

.7

.8

7/29/2019 Ashil be Lakposht chi goft.pdf

22/22

148

1390

.9 .

10..

.

11. Learning to infer is not just a matter of being taught about explicit logical relations

between propositions; it is learning to do something (Winch, 1958:57).

.12

Isashiki Takahiro (1999)

.

..1:

.2.

..3. .

.:1380.)1989(

:).1380( .)1384(.: .

Aristotle's (2006). Physics by Aristotle translated by R. P. Hardie and R. K. Gaye, Physics,

Ebook edition Digireads.

Bergson, H. (1911). Creative Evolution, A. Mitchell (trans.), New York: Holt, Reinhart and

Winston.

Carroll,Lewis (1895).What the Tortoise said to Achilles,Mind, New Series, Vol. 4. Apr, No. 14.

Clark, M. (2002).Paradoxes from A to Z, Routledge.

Hofstadter, Douglas (1979). Gdel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid, Basic Books Inc.

Quine, W.V. (1936). Truth by Convention, in Benacerraf and Putnam (eds) The Philosophy of

Mathematics.Russell, B. (1903). The Principles of Mathematics, New York: Norton publisher.

Winch, P. (1958). The Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to Philosophy, London: Routledge

& Kegan Paul.