attas on nozick
TRANSCRIPT
!"!#$
%& '(( &(& )% ( &* ( &( ) +(& &( , ' &&(+ )-(' .( ( & /+ 0 &1 && & 2)(& &( *( +' ( )3 ( + (&+ & ( ) (( ( /( ( )-(' ( ( (, ( ( (+*( ( '&(, ( ( (&(*( 4 ( '&(, ( ( (2(&(*&& ()5 (/&+(&)( ( ( (+ &( && + ) ' ) (
((( (( 6 7 &) ( + ( ' 1
% + 8%&Ω)"
9:;:3%::%< =>=?== = @##= )=>=.=A@
" -& 6:, &19 &% "!BB7@C=&))(69 &+1 & %
-(&'( 05 & /+( (/ ')3 / 2&+Ω(( '%48)& ( + &&(, +& +( & &)( (+ &(& ( ' &( ' ) /++ & ' .
( &( +( +(. ( )&(&Ω((( &% +(8(( & +(. ( ) + +(& & ( )@( ( + (( (, & D& (&)( ( & ( ( & )( &+ ( /&&&+& )(& + ( + ) .&, D&( (, && 2(&)(( ,&( ((( ( ),+4 (& ( &+, (1( &( &(() &(( ((
+ &) ( (+( (+( ( & & .+ &&)= ( +
=>>
"!!#7 =@> ( ( & ( %&+Ω %4 8) ( & ( (Ω & 8)Ω ( ( ( *Ω )( Ω&81&++4 + 6 7 + ( 8( D6'7)9)E6"A!A7 ))F + 69 &+19 &+ .% "!!"7B#)&F)-)3)+ 6"B@"7 ))5)69 &+19 &+ % "!!"7BB)
@ );)D 69 &+19 &+ % "!!#79()>/ &)
= 3 2 ( . ( F)) 9( !" #$%# %&69 &+19 &+ % "!!$7*&G3 &&.: ( 4 %6@###7".@=)
1 & ( ( &((, ( +(&( ( 6 )7( &+& ) ( + , ( ( +&( ( (( + / &)> ( (( ) ( ( ( + (( %
+2 8&+ &)(&./(/ ( (+ )( +( +((+& ) (( ( ( 6 7) ( & +( & . ( )( 2( & ( ( ( )& ( 6 7) 3 & ( ( / &+++(( +( )3 ( ((& ( /+& ( ( + (/&&, +( & 67)
/4( +22(, +(((+ &(&(( G+(&+& ( )4$(& (&D/&( &(/( & ( / % )C &+ D/1 G(
=>$
> , -& "A".!"*)%)G/% 4'"C6"!CC7@#A.@#*&; D/ # # %(6< /155/"!A>7"A>.B)
$ (/) 69 &+19 &+ % "!C#7@BB
C / G +(&+&))))4(( &-& @"#." /&+ /+ , ( &( ((( +))(&DG-(: +
(( &' (( )45 (+ G/4 .))) ((( &)4A
((/& &&( (+D& 6& . 7)&+& &4'(&+)B
( (( )((&( (( + &&, & ( (/& & , +( ( ( )(( ( , ( ( & )-& (/4( + &&&( &+ +(. ) +F&(/& & (/&(, )5 .& & ( ):( +(& (+ &.& +(&&+ .( ( ( ( ,& ( ( ) ++ & / ( +()!
+(/+ &(/+ // & (( ( & &+ & ( ' 2.)
=>C
&%04 6"!!#7$#>."B*&(& ( * *+! ,%6%(& (1 % "!BB7C!.A"&&, &&D/4 )
A D/ "A$
B (/& ++& /G(.: ( % 1 & & / % 4 % 6"!!$7"BC.@"B) /4 . ( ( & , & + ( )(& ( /&H&( (+ &&)( &+/ H&4 G & 4(( ( . ( )( . .( .& , +( ,( )
! D/ @=B
"# -& @B=
( + &( 4 2 +(2( ( )9&(( D/(G&2( '2I/J 40""-( +( ( ( D/0+ +( & ( + & + )( 9( (
+ &&(( ( +(( . &'(& +();+(, &,&( (. ( )(( +( ( &(( ( +()9( &(/( '( );( (&+( +()
&(&' +( &( +((&(( +(4&& (( &(/ ( +& ( &)5((2 &/ ( ( & * ( &4 . . & +( .)-( ( ( ( +( +( +( +(4&)
(( &/ (( )59( &( & ( ((( + . )( . ( & ( + ( , ( & (+ +. ( )-& 4 ( (. (
+(( 2 ((&&) . /+(& + &&.) 9( 4 ( ( 4 & +( ( ( (
=>A
"" D/ "AB
"@ (9( 6< /1:, & % "!!>7C#."
& K ( (( +)+( ( & + &( /( .( )5( ( (( 6&(/(7
/( +2)(+ ' (( . + &+ )&&( (+ ) ( (( -& & 9( ( & 16"7&.& (& ( ( .& +(* & 6@7 ( +( ( &(( ,&+. ( ) + ( 2( (( ( ( ((+& (6@7 )& .& &&& &((&+ &6"7)(( + ( (
+(8 & ( 8)(+& + ( & +2 )"=(Ω &++((+ /+4, )5(( +( ( ( +( &( )( ( . (&( & ( )
++ 2( +( &(+&( ( + ((+( &)
+ ' & 2( ( ,. ( ( ' (
=>B
"= ( + /4 + ( & ( 6@BC7)
"> D/ "AB
)"$((( (( . +()( && &+( .& (++)&( (&)-((( (& ) ( 2 && & +&( +( ( G ;4 4& ( )
(&( &+( &/(+ ' (( &( . )& ( (+( ( &&((+( &)& (+ ( & ( &) ( ( ( 2 (( & ( ( (, ( .&) , 4 & & +( ( ( )-( ( ( &+Ω && ( ( ) .4 &( '& +((&&, (((&. && )( ( ( (+&
)"CF & , ++( 4 & /+(+ ) ((++ (, &+ +( &( 4 . (& &( 8((+ 8,()5(& 1 ( (+ ( ( +
=>!
"$ ( + +(9(4,( ( D/4& 6 !" A>)7)
"C F &G % ;+(4-6"!AC7AB)*)9)5/ . $ % 6&1 ;&+ & E+ % "!AA7 >>*-& *EAAB".=)D/( !#.C)
%&)&& 4 &( .(
&&( +(& 1/ (& (+((& / ( )))) & +(((+ ( +(( +( )
+ ( . K&. K( ( ( (( & 2 (( + &&)( ((+&F &F & /)( ( F &4(( & & ) 3 ( ( &(&2 ('. +()
&& ++(++ ) 4 /(& 4 ( 2 ( 2&( & (&( ( )
( F &4 +)3 (&&&&( & &)( (('&( ( ( &)- ( & /+ & &'&(/& '((, ( '((( &&(& )& ( ++ ( &&
( +( &)( +(&( +( & )& ( & 4 K( K(&)( ( +(& ( +(1 ( &(, &( +((& ( ( & )F &
=$#
"A F &G % ;+(4AB
"B F)3)F&))/ G % ;+(% 04 6"!!#7>!"
((, &((, +(&++) ((&(F & ( &+
( && ( & &/ ( ) 2. &)-& ( (F &1( +(( 2 +(&( &( (G & +)4"!
% +( & & )% , + ( +( ,( (&()( +() (( (&. + ( ( +((,) ( / ( ( ( , + & & ()( + +( )&& (( ( 4 +( ( (( +6( + ((& &(&)7)( +(( & (&((+)F&/((+&-& 4 )
( & ( + & ( ( & , ( )
( (& ( ( ( & & , ( +)-( & )(&( +& + ( ( & ) ( ( +( ( + +)
( &+ (, &(/& ,&&& )3 4G 4 +(, ), , ( +))2 ( +(( +(((+( +D)(((
=$"
"! -& @C$.A"
@# F&/G % ;+(% 04>!@
( &&((+( +( .K(&%( &(+)&(++1( / 4 )-( & & &(( 4'&+&( )( ( ( 2 (( ( &% ( ((, & 42.& ( (G+4()(&( &( & ,)@" +1 ( ( (& & &( )-( ( (&& ( / ( (+ & && &&) (& +&K((& +( )-((, ( ( 4 +(( +(+*/ +((( K&+ )(+(( '(F./, (
( ., (-& 4. )@@ (K + & +D+ / (& .++ ( K+ &+( , ) (+ & & 2 &)5/ +(&)(+ , & ( +( + ( , 1( + &(&+(& &+) & ( , 1 /+ + &
+ +( G + .+ ( )4@=( (/ , ( )&4 +&4 4 &)L( ) & (42( (&& 6( ( 7
=$@
@" )) G: + 2 % % 4 % & % &) 69 &+1 9 &+ % "!!>7B@B=)
@@ &)B=
@= &)
(( & );+ + +( &)(' &&) (/(+ &)3 + /+( ( +(& + & ( ( (( && . )& /+'& +(& &( * ( & )-( 4& ++ ( ( & && ( (+(( ( (& 6 , + ((7& ')@>( ( ((+( +((, + + ((+ +)@$
F &&-& ) +((/& )( /&( ( +&( ( ( &()(E /(&&21
5 ( &( + (++(&( ()))):( &((/ +((+((+(&+ (( +(+ (& &*&( & +)
: ( + )-(&&& ' + +( + &(( ()+ ' + (2& +(. .
=$=
@> 9)D/ "B@)
@$ : & /, && ( )3 ,. &&+ &(2 & +(( &(+ &((( &()9(((& ( /(+( (6 ( . 7 &( ++(+( &)( &&(+ + (&&(&() +& &+ ( +& ( & +()(&(6&( 7& +)-( +(+( ( ( (( &&& ( & +()&(/& (+ )
@C EB@
+ ) ( ( ( ( & & & ( ( &&)( . / (& (+( ( . ( ) -( (( +(2(( )
!"#
/4 (&( +(&+& ( )D/(/(( ( (4 &)( ( )5 ( , +)( ( G +4 4 & +(&)D/&( /(/ ( ( &)(+( ( +()5/( ( .(+( )/( +&& (/ )-( &(&(&
+((( & +&+ .+)((&( / && + )( & )&(, ++. ( ( + & & +(( &&/ && ( /& ( ()-( ( ( (
(/& ( &+((( )D/&( / &+(&( /& & + +() & (( ( , &+ ( D& 1
6"7 ? ( & 4 &&& . ) ( & ( ( (&( .+ &( +( &):( (&
=$>
& +(( (&+K
(+(( & +(
/ )@A
6@7 ? (4 ( (
( &( ( 4 )-(
( (( && +(&(
+( +()D/ G +(
(+( +()4@B
( & @!
& ( & ( ) 5 (
( ( & ( & ( ( (
+( 2 ((
&( (.
& (
) (/(, (% 8&+
Ω&(;( +&(+ &) ( ( +
;4 & )5( 2
&+(& &&& &1
6"7 (;& 06@7-((/;
06=7-(+(;06>7 (
;4 &0 6$7 ( & ;4
0
=$$
@A D/ 1G )4 "$$.C>)
@B &)@=B)D/( +(&)"A!)* *+ ,%"B$.A* ) ;( & % 0 6 % / 91 &"!A#7AC* 6:, &15/"!!>7B#."#C)
@! ( ( ( ( +( ) 3 D/ 1 G( ((&( '2 , ' )))) ( ,&4 + & / ( & ,& ( (+46 "A!7)& ( ( ( ( (+( 2 ( ) (( 6 +7( & & & & 2) (( ( & & / ( +2 0
( && )((
((;& )-( % 8;
+ 8&
+ 8)5 &8
& & )( (
( ( ( ( )5
(+(& ( )D/++
(( +8(+( +(
6& 78& 41
+ & 9&&((+ &)5( ( + & (&((): + &(( (+) . ( (+ &( ( + & +( ( ( +( ( (+ )
(+(;4 ( &%4 8
( ( &( .
8(((6 7 %4
8 &( ;4.+6((
(( 7)( ((&K(
;6 7 (
(.+( &( 2 &K(
;4 ( &&%4 8&)="
( ( 6 + & &/7 (
&( (;4 &
1
$%&'+ (+( 6 .
78)
%&'6"7&+ (+( 6
7' 8)
%&'6"7& + (.+)
=$C
=# D/ "A$
=" (D/ ( ( .+ + )9 .& +(& &( 1( (((( ( )
(+ &+( ( &( )(+ D/4(+((( & + ( (( +( ( &6 + 7&(&(( +( ( 6/ 7)(GD +./ +4 &((( + (&&D/(/ ( )( + &)H <4 (G+(&+&4 ((<4 &&& ( + )(84 <(( 84 &&( *&/( )5G((/ 2 D /2/ H( +* (+( H + ( ( )4=@
D/ + ( ) 3 ( D +./ +& ( (&) (2+(&"M( ( ( ( )== ( ( D / ( ( & ( 2 ( ( &4 )=>&( +(& (/ ( + )HG+(&+&4(( D / )(+ ("M H4 *&(+(@M <&H4 &)-(D/ (D +./ +( .& .&( + +(. . )=$
=$A
=@ D/ "AC
== : / & + (K(&+(, (&&=)
=> (+( & + & 4( ( + +( 2 ( ( &4 6 @=$)7)
=$ 9( !" !"*(-+/0.# % 69 &+1%% "!!"7"#B)
(6"7 (& ):8 & ( ( 8& ( )5(D +./ +6"7 ( ("M )((( &(+( +&&(( 6 +(. 7)3 . & & & (& ) & ++ 6 &(&&=7&/(( "M( '(+/(& & /)-6"7( (/ & .
(+( ( ( &&+&)6:( ( &( +& 07(&. & & ( ) ( . ((/& +( ')( (&&(( ( )( & & ) ( (
(&; )( ( (&& (;4 & 1
$%&1%+8)
%&16@7&%&+Ω)
%&1( +% 8&+Ω)
( ( +6@7(%4 ( 8(&/;4 )( + ( & 4 & & + ) (+(( ( (+ &. ( (&2 (+( ( )( (( ( & .&+ +) &( & ((& + ): ( ( &+ )6@7 / & ) (
/ ( (( /( ( ( ( )% ( ( (
=$B
( +( / ( 6 &7 (4&(4( )(&6@7)Ω/8 ((+( ) ( Ω / 8 ( &+ ( & ( ( 8'&)( ( &&() &++ * & ( .&&+ ()( &&( 2 ++)( ( (&&((( +(+ ) &&& / ((( ( &4 &( ) ( 4 ( & ( (&+ ((+ (()&(( 2 .( ( )=C
6@7( & ( ( ' )' (&+ + + 2 ( & )/ &&)(D/& (+ &( )/1
( ( 6( + &&'7 &++ .& 0
(+++( & (( 4& &+)( -6@71(( & &( + +2.)( ( )( 2 )% ( ++ & '&) ((D/4 /+ &( + . &( ) ( (( (( ('%+8 ( (8 +& + +)5 (/ '
=$!
=C 9)9( B$)
=A D/ "AA67
)=B-6@7 + 2
& +( ' & +
+)=!
/+/( )' (
(&& &( /
)(-6"7&-6@7(
&&(( + (
)(' 4
+(/& &&(, &
) ( -6"7 & /&
+ 6 +7 & (
( 6 &&.
7&2(( ( (
/+ ( &(+)
+ +(-6"7( '(
-6@7( &
&/+ &'(
()( + +
(( (( )(( &&% + )(
(&&( (&& )((
( ( ( + &&
&1
%&1 )
%&1-6=7&& )
=C#
=B &((, '( 1G ++ 2( +(&( ( )))+ &46D/ "AB&&&7)
=! (D/4& /( (') ( & -6@7) 6( ==#)* *+ ,%BA.!=)7:( ( D&D/ & +(+& 6 ( & )7)6) ( G; 2& 41 % 6"!BA7==A.>B*9( C@)75( ( ) ( ( + + + ( & 2& )D/4 ( &+ ( ( ( ( ) ( ( (/ & )9 + &(&)
$%&16=7&& )
(6=7 (&&6=7 &&)-(-6=7 ( ( & + ( 6=7 &. ( &6=7&. ( )( (( )( (+ (
+ & -6=7)+( ((/ ( ( &( & ( ( (& ) 6=7/ & 2 & +( + ) 4 2 &-6"7 + + K & K( &4 ( ) '( 6"7 ( ( + & ( "M ) (2( & + (, ( )>#
++&(G( &, &&4 ( /+ ( + ( ( )>"( &, && (((& & & (&&) ((& (&,+&& & & ( ( ( & (,&( &)( ,&( (&&(,(
=C"
># 9)- G9 % ;+(/% & ( 3 F 4( 6"!!$7A!".B"B ++ ( ( ( 2 + &&+4 /(& + )+ ( (( +()-(( (&( & ) & &. ( &(( + ( .)9)))& G&(2% 42% * %+6"!BA7=AA.B)
>" : G( .& % 4 / % % 6:, &1:, & % "!B>7=$".B#)))/ ## %1 6 < /1 :, & % "!BA7 ">$) ++ ( ( &,/ ( , ')
+( ( (
((&&(&(( ,&)(
& +(&,++ )/+
& +( &
( ( ,+
&& & ( (&( ,& (
. ) ( ( &
&&(&,& ( &
(&/ ( .+&
& ) ( 6=7 &2 .
(-6=7)( 8 G+ 4
&&, &;";>)&(
8 &(&&(&, &
;4" ;4>);"N;4" ;@N;4@ &;=N;4= ( & (
;".=,&( &(+&)5 ( (
G+ 4( 1 &(&,
>,( & &+
& &( );>≠;4>((( &
;>4 )9;& (
&;N;4( ;( (&
,8 &&;4( (&,8
&)6=7/& (( &
)>@ ( (&& ,((
&);>,& (. .
( & (
(;4>K( & &)
( 1 ( & / ( ;>≠;4>0 : + 1(( (&(
,(& 0 &
( 6=7 / & ( ( &
K((&,& .
( & )(& ((
;> ;4>;>≠;4>)>=
=C@
>@ ( + % 4 % .+% ) % =!)
>= +% 4-&% .+% 6&)=!C)7 (.&((&( +6=B".!#7)
( && / ( &)>>(((& ( ( 6( ( +. &7 (( 6((% + &7 ( ( ( ( )-6=7 (
( / ) 6=7 ( ( ( + ( 6(6"77 &&++ + ( 6(-6"77)5(( ((/& ')( & . (&( + (& K('(. .+( )5( 6=7&&( && 6=7( (&)&6=7/ )( (&+ )((
( (( ;4 ( 8 & &)(( (;4 & 1
%)&18 +&)
%)&1-6>7 & (&+)
$%)&16>7 ( (& (&+)
(/ ( ( & & D/)(& & &()>$
( & ( (8 +&& (
=C=
>> : ( &+ ( + ; ( G ( 4 6(; 6:, &1:, & % "!A@7"=!7)
>$ D/ "B") F))9( G.: ( - &.: ( &243 /)(&) %&2 %6(19 % "!BC7"@=.$*)9( !" AC.B ( .& ( & *+ ,%C!.A" &&)
((&&&&)( .& ,&(( ( ( ( +()5((+D/& &
++(6>7 ) &+(& ;4 ( ((%++(( &%(& &8) +(& & 4 & &( &((&) ( G ( /(& ( ( &( (* (+(& ( +( ( ))))4>C & ( G((( + &( ()(++ + +( ( ,(+&(/(/.&+( & && )4>AD/&4 ( + + & ((&4 &)-(4(( ( + &( && &(0&( & & (&4( + ;4 ( 0>B
=C>
>C D/ "B"
>A &)"B@
>B +( +&(( &( (-6>7/ )%4 /; (. ((G( 4(;4&( & (&L &8&)5 +D &.( & (((%(+;2 + (G( )4(/( + +)3 ( ( + 67%+(;&( ((& );( ( +67%/ ;)%4(( ;((()(&( . &( . & +&( & &)&/(.&.+(+(&( %&&4,K&;4 0(&(;4 & (&%,& ( ;4 & %4 ()( %4.,L&(+&&; (& &(%4.,&
( ;4 ( &(%4 L&/ 8( + &( ( (2(( %(&& 8)-6>7 &( K ( K (+ &6 ;4 ((( 4 7 ++( )9 ( (6>7(%+(
( &(&% &8& / . ): &/((( (. ;4 && &( & 6& 7)5( + )>!( & & &. & ) ( ( ( ( & (( ) /( (6>7& 6>7)&( )3 ( & +(( . &(( ( (.)& ( && + (( +( , (( (.)3 , (%&( .&8(%"&(&)%"4 ;(%4 ( &+6>7%4 &)5 %"4 &( ;(&4(&()3 &. & .((%@ 8%"&4 ;(( %4 &;4%@ &8&%4 &+) +( %@& (( /%=&%)( (. & ((& ; ( %4 ( (+(
=C$
;)(( %4 L4 & ;& &;+&( ()
>! 9) 9( G.: ( 4 "@C) ;( & 4 G/ .: ( 1 &4 %*6"!!"7>>)&9(4 !" B=)
%" %." & ; %4 & & &) 6>7 & 6>7 )6>7&6>7 )((
/ ( % &+((+((( & (-6>7 ( ( & ( ( ( ( + ( & ( &)9& (+, 1 ( % L 8%& ( ( &L& (&)$#
% L
# #
% A $
L $ A
5( +% ( . 4 & )5L46(+&%4 .7 & ( %4 & K& K( /(( ):&(+ &)-(.
+ &/ (+&& (& );G( +&( )49 (( +&& ( )(,. 2( &)5(+, ( ( L /%4 . 1
=CC
$# (, ++& 1)
% L
# #
% "# $
L C !
& (( ( (& (
( (& &
+ )-((&% (
& (L& & & ((
& ( .
0( (2 (( (
% ')(& &( (
-6>7K . K( .
) &&& ( 2 6>7&6>7 (
&( (%
(,& )
% L
# #
% C >
L C "#
-( (, %4 &+
% &L4 0((
-6>7( %
(& ( ( '(
+ 6>7 & 6>7 ( ( + &
% )( % .
&( 6>7&6>7& % .
&(&& (&)( (
-6>7( )
=CA
-6>7 (
( ( (/)6>7((
+( + K(
. + &)(( (/&
')56>7
6>7&6>7/ )((&& )((
(( ; & ) ( ( ( ;4
& 1
%(&1( )
%(&1-6$7 ( && &;4 )
$%(&16$7 ( && (;4 )
((
( ( ( &+
( /& ( ( )
5 ( (
, ( )), &.
+(&&1( &
( ( +&)( 4 +.
)(( &-6$7 (
( (( &+
& )5+ /
& + ( )(+
( ++ &.
&4 )(
( 1 (
6& + (& (2/&7*&
(+ + (+ ( +
6(+ +(
& &7*( & &
&(+&&6
&&+ 7* (( 2& 64
( 47)$"( &&
6$7)
=CB
$" D @A>)
&& (& G( ( ( ((& & , (I(J( &&( + (/. &( +()4$@(((+ ( (0: &((&(((&(( + &0D/+( 1
:/(4 ( (/ ( + ((&( 6( & + . &7GG( )44
+ ( , ((( & &)6$7( . &( )( ( $>&(/2(( (G .4 + +()(( . ( +( ( & + ( & (, & ) (( 2 6$7(4 &( +(,+(&(( &.+ )( ( ( ((&( ( ( 1( + ( 0 & (& &&) (( ((& & )(( (& (2 1 (& (&( & / ( & ( ( &(+& 0 ( ( + & ( + ( +( + ( ( (( &&& +& ( ( & & ( ) ((( & ( , & (( 0
=C!
$@ D/ "B#
$= &)
$> (& K&& (((+)( ,& (( ( ))) OG: .( 40 *3 %6:, &19 &% "!BA7"CB
9(+( /((&( ( + & (& &( 6'(6>7 6>77 &( &&6(-6>77) +( (+ (((' & (( (2(& )( ((& +;( )6$7( ( (&&( + & +( ( ( ( +(( )( (&& +
/+(( &&;4 ( ((((& )( (((+(+ ( &;4(( ( ) % &((( ( /& /)(( ((+ & ;) ( ; + && &( /%4 );4 ( & (, ( & ( ; (& ( & &&)+;4 (& && .(((&(( & &( 0( &6$7&()(/ ( ((+((+( &+ ) 3 ( &(&(()( "#@# =# +) , &'&+((+&(&) & & (&2 () +&( (&4 +D ( + & )&(&&+ &( &(4 (((+ ) (+((+ && (+(+ &( )3 ( ((/(G, 4 / ( & ) ( / (, %4 ( & (+ , ;(2 & &( /)(( ( ;4/( ;4 && ( .
=A#
&;(+( ( ( )-6$7 (
( ( (/)6$7& ( (&(&(&( . &( (( )(((+& +( && ((/& ')6$7 ( ( +( & &( (((((& )%2 &'6$7 6$7 +()(/( +(&' 1( + &&&& ( &&(( & )( +;4 %4 ( ( +( +2 &)+ + +D .
( + ')( +( +((& &( +&( + &)( ( ( &( & ( ( )&& ( ( ( ( & .( . & (/ . (+(/)+ (/& ( ( ( & ( + )(/ .( &(( /&&4 )(( ( ( +( K ( & & K+ & . )((( ( . && ( .+) (' + ( & ( + ((()3 ( + +(( (
( &/( / )5 ( 2 ( & ( &+(&(( &&&.( (( ((()% ( ,+( &(
2 & +( '((
=A"