ccswp13 shiller

20

Click here to load reader

Upload: mustapha-derouich

Post on 10-May-2017

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CCSWP13 Shiller

!"

#$$%&'()%$* (%"+%*(,-".)*/01'/)$2"'$3"4$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"!"

8626*("!9:";99<"

=>".%?,-("@A"B7)CC,-";"

4$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5")*"'"3,C)D'(,"%-2'$)*EA"#("$,,3*"(7,"-)27(",$&)-%$E,$("(%"

FC%6-)*7A"17,-,"'-,"*)2$)F)D'$("3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*")$"(7,",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"

,$&)-%$E,$(:"'$3"(7,*,"3)FF,-,$D,*"%627( (%"7'&,"'"C%("(%"3%"G)(7"(7,)-",D%$%E)D"*6DD,**A"

#"G)*7"(%"'-26,")$"(7)*"5'5,-"(7'("G7)C,"D6C(6-'C"3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*"7'&,"

*%E,(7)$2"(%"3%"G)(7"(7,"3)FF,-,$D,*")$",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5:"(7,-,")*",&)3,$D,"(7'("(7,*,"

D6C(6-'C"3)FF,-,$D,*"E'>"?,"%&,-*('(,3"'*"3,(,-E)$)$2"(7,"3,2-,,"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"%F"'"

D%6$(->A"H%-,")E5%-('$("'-,"(7,"F'D(%-* %F",D%$%E)D"*)(6'()%$ G)(7)$"'"D%6$(->"(7'("

*(-,$2(7,$"%-")$7)?)(",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5A"

I)27"%$"(7,"C)*("%F"*6D7"F'D(%-*")*"(7,"5,-D,5()%$"%F"-)*/"(%",$(-,5-,$,6-*"'$3"

)$&,*(%-*")$"(7,EA"176*:"3,&,C%5)$2"$,G")$*()(6()%$*"(7'("E'$'2,"(7,"-)*/"%F"

,$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5")*"D,$(-'C"J)$3,,3:"-)*/"('/)$2")*"G7'(",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5")*"'CC"'?%6(KA"

17,-,"7'*"?,,$"2-,'("5-%2-,**")$"(7,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F")$*()(6()%$*"(%"E'$'2,"

,$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"-)*/")$"-,D,$(">,'-*:"(7,"'3&,$("%F"E%-,"*%57)*()D'(,3"E,(7%3*"%F"5-)&'(,"

!"L-,5'-,3"F%-"(7,"@%)$("M%$F,-,$D,"%F"M4B)F%"'$3"(7,"M,$(,-"%$"M'5)('C)*E"'$3"B%D),(>:"NL,-*5,D()&,*"%$"(7,"L,-F%-E'$D,"%F (7,"M%$()$,$(O*"4D%$%E),*:P"Q,$)D,"#$(,-$'()%$'C"R$)&,-*)(>:"B'$"B,-&%C%:";!0;;"@6C>:";99<A"

;"L-%F,**%-"%F"4D%$%E)D*"S'C,"R$)&,-*)(>:"M%GC,*"+%6$3'()%$"F%-".,*,'-D7")$"4D%$%E)D*"'$3"#$(,-$'()%$'C"M,$(,-"F%-"+)$'$D,:"'$3"M7),F"4D%$%E)*(:"H'D-%H'-/,(*"TTMA

Page 2: CCSWP13 Shiller

;"

,U6)(>"'$3"&,$(6-,"D'5)('CA""#$"(7,"F6(6-,:"(7,-,"%627("(%"?,"F6-(7,-"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"-)*/"

E'$'2,E,$(")$*()(6()%$*"(7'(",$D%6-'2,",$(-,5-,$,6-*:"'$3"G,"'-,")$"(7,"5-%D,**"%F"

*,,)$2"(7)*"7'55,$A" 17,"F6-(7,-"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"-)*/"E'$'2,E,$("D%$(-'D(*"(7'("*,((C,"%$"

,D%$%E)D")$3)D,*"G)CC"7,C5"5-%E%(,",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"?>"'CC%G)$2",$(-,5-,$,6-*"(%"

5-%(,D("(7,E*,C&,*"'2')$*("E%-,"'$3"E%-,"%F"(7,"-)*/*"%F"3%)$2"?6*)$,**A"

8C*%"%$"(7,"C)*("F%-"5-%E%()$2"(7,"/)$3"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"F%-"5-%E%()$2"

,D%$%E)D"2-%G(7")*"(%"3,&,C%5"?,((,-")$*()(6()%$*"F%-",$D%6-'2)$2"?'*)D"*D),$()F)D"

-,*,'-D7A"B6DD,**F6C"?'*)D"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7")*"'$",$(,-5-)*,"E6D7"C)/,"'$>"?6*)$,**"

,$(,-5-)*,A"V,"7'&,"(%"D%$*(-6D("'*"G,CC"'*"G,"D'$"'"E'-/,(5C'D,"G7,-,"*D),$()F)D"

-,*,'-D7"D'$"D%E5,(,:"'$3"(%"5-%&)3,"-)*/"E'$'2,E,$("*%C6()%$*"(%"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7"

)$*%F'-"'*")*"5%**)?C,A!

"#$%#&'$!()**+&+,-+.!%/'%!0**+-% 1,,23'%)2,!',4!5,%&+6&+,+#&./)6"

17,-,")*"'"C%("%F"5%56C'-"('C/"'?%6("3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*")$"(7,)-"'(()(63,*"

(%G'-3*"?6*)$,**A"+%-",W'E5C,:")(")*"G)3,C> 'CC,2,3"(7'("RABA 8E,-)D'$*:"=-)()*7:"

8-E,$)'$*:"M7)$,*,:"'$3"@'5'$,*,"7'&,"6$6*6'CC>"*(-%$2 (-'3)()%$*"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5:"

(7'("'-,")$7)?)(,3"?>"7)*(%-)D'C"F%-D,*"F-%E"()E,"(%"()E,:"?6("(7'("$%$,(7,C,**"5-%&)3,"'"

*%6$3"?'*,"F%-"(7,*,"D%6$(-),*"(%"?6)C3"65%$"

17,-,"'-,"%F"D%6-*,"E'$>"D6C(6-'C"3)FF,-,$D,*"?,(G,,$"D%6$(-),*A"17,"3)FF)D6C("

U6,*()%$")*"7%G")E5%-('$("'-,"(7,*,"3)FF,-,$D,*")$"5-%E%()$2",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5A"M6C(6-'C"

3)FF,-,$D,*"('/,"E'$>"F%-E*A"+%-",W'E5C,:")(")*"D%EE%$C>"'CC,2,3"(7'("*%E,"D%6$(-),*"

'-,"E%-,")$(,CC,D(6'C"'$3"*%E,"E%-,"5-'D()D'C")$"(7,)-"%-),$('()%$A

Page 3: CCSWP13 Shiller

X"

M%6$(-),*"(7'("7'&,"'"5-'D()D'C %-),$('()%$:")(")*"'CC,2,3:"'-,"E%-,"*6DD,**F6C")$"

?6*)$,**A"#$"F'D(:"7%G,&,-:"5-%E%()$2"7)27C>"*6DD,**F6C",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5:"(7,"/)$3"(7'("

C,'3*"(%"E'Y%-"$,G"F%-D,*")$"(7,",D%$%E>:"3,5,$3*"%$"'"2%%3"?'C'$D,"?,(G,,$"(7,"

)$(,CC,D(6'C"'$3"5-'D()D'CZ"'"*(-%$2")$(,-,*(")$"3,,5"56-*6)(*"D%65C,3"G)(7"'"5-'D()D'C"

)$(,-,*(")$"F)$3)$2"'55C)D'()%$*"%F"(7,*,"56-*6)(*A"[6-"E%3,-$",-'"%F"-'5)3",D%$%E)D"

2-%G(7"*,,E*"(%"3,-)&,"F-%E"'"?,((,-"-,D%2$)()%$"%F"(7)*"F'D(A"R$()C"(G%"D,$(6-),*"'2%:"

6$)&,-*)(),*"'-%6$3"(7,"G%-C3"G,-,"F%D6*,3"C'-2,C>"%$"(7,%C%2>"'$3"(7,"*(63>"%F"\-,,/"

'$3"T'()$"DC'**)D*A"17,*,"G,-,"2,$(C,E'$C>"56-*6)(*A"BD),$()*(*]3%)$2",W5,-)E,$(*")$"

(7,)-"C'?%-'(%-),*"(%"C,'-$"*%E,"5-'D()D'C"F'D(*"'?%6("7%G"(7)$2*"G%-/]G,-,"%F(,$"

D%$*)3,-,3"(%%"E6$3'$,"F%-"(7,"6$)&,-*)(>:"6$()C"E%3,-$"()E,*A"

8-)*(%D-'()D"(,$3,$D),*"7'&,"5-%&)3,3"'$"%?*('DC,"(%",FF,D()&,"5-'D()D,*"(7'("E)27("

F%*(,-"5'(7?-,'/)$2")$$%&'()%$*"F%-"?6*)$,**A"17,"+-,$D7".,&%C6()%$"-,5-,*,$(,3"'"

7)*(%-)D"?-,'/"G)(7"(7)*"'-)*(%D-'()D"5'*(:"?6("3)3"$%("6$,U6)&%D'CC>"*6DD,,3")$")E5-%&)$2"

(7,"'(E%*57,-,"F%-")$$%&'()%$A"B%E,"3-'*()D"*(,5*"G,-,"('/,$Z")$"!^_X:"'CC +-,$D7"

6$)&,-*)(),*"G,-,"'?%C)*7,3A"17,>"G,-,"-,5C'D,3"?>"5-%F,**)%$'C"*D7%%C*"F%-"(,'D7,-*:"

3%D(%-*:"'$3",$2)$,,-*A"=6("(7,"-,*6C()$2"*D7%%C*"G,-,"5,-7'5*"'"C)((C,"(%%"5-'D()D'C"(%"?,"

%5()E'CA"17,"+-,$D7"6$)&,-*)(>"G'*",&,$(6'CC> -,*(%-,3 )$ !`_<A"

#("G'*"$%("6$()C"G,CC")$(%"(7,"!_"(7"D,$(6->"(7'("'"E%-,"5-'D()D'C"F%D6*:"(7'("G%6C3"*56-"

,W5'$*)&,"'$3"5-%36D()&,"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7:"?,2'$")$ 46-%5,:")$ (7,"\,-E'$"

6$)&,-*)(),*A"17,"5-)$D)5C,"%F"N5),/+)%!32,!72&.-/#,8!#,4!9+/&+:P"N6$)(>"%F"-,*,'-D7"'$3"

,36D'()%$:P"D7'E5)%$,3"?>"8C,W'$3,-"&%$"I6E?%C3("J!^<^0!`XaK: ?-)$2)$2"5-'D()D'C"'$3"

)E5C,E,$('?C,"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7")$(%"D%$('D("G)(7"3,,5")$(,CC,D(6'C"3)*D%6-*,:"?,D'E,"

(7,"7'CCE'-/"%F"(7,"\,-E'$"6$)&,-*)(),*:"G7)D7:"'*"(7,)-"*(-,$2(7*"D'E,"(%"?,"'55-,D)'(,3:

Page 4: CCSWP13 Shiller

b"

G,-,")E)('(,3"'-%6$3"(7,"G%-C3:"G)(7"2-,'(,- %-"C,**,-"*6DD,**"3,5,$3)$2"%$ (7,"$'()%$'C"

D6C(6-,A"X"

17,"R$)(,3"B('(,*"F-%E")(*"?,2)$$)$2*"7'3"'"2,$,-'C D%$(,E5("F%-"'-)*(%D-'()D"

5-)&)C,2,:"'$3"'("(7,"*'E,"()E,"'$ '3E)-'()%$"%F"5-'D()D'C"5,%5C,A" 17)*"G'*"C%$2"'2%"

$%(,3"?>"=,$Y'E)$"+-'$/C)$"J!^9<0_9KA"#$"'"!^`b"'-()DC,"N#$F%-E'()%$"(%"(7%*,"G7%"

G%6C3"-,E%&,"(%"8E,-)D'P"7,"G-%(,Z"

N17,"$'(6-'C"2,$)6*,*"(7'("7'&,"'-)*,$")$"8E,-)D'"7'&,"6$)F%-EC>"U6)((,3"(7'("D%6$(->"F%-"46-%5,:"G7,-,"(7,>"D'$"?,"E%-,"*6)('?C>"-,G'-3,3A"A"A"A"Nc)$"8E,-)D'd"5,%5C,"3%"$%(",$U6)-,"D%$D,-$)$2"'"*(-'$2,-:"G7'(")*"7,e"?6("G7'("D'$"7,"3%e"#F"7,"7'*"'$>"6*,F6C"'-("7,")*"G,CD%E,f"'$3")F"7,",W,-D)*,*")(:"'$3"?,7'&,*"G,CC:"7,"G)CC"?,"-,*5,D(,3"?>"'CC"(7'("/$%G"7)Ef"?6("'"E,-,"E'$"%F"U6'C)(>:"G7%"%$"(7'("'DD%6$("G'$(*"(%"C)&,"65%$"(7,"56?C)D:"?>"*%E,"%FF)D,"%-"*'C'->:"G)CC"?,"3,*5)*,3"'$3"3)*-,2'-3,3AP"

=6(:"(7)*"5-'D()D'C"%-),$('()%$ 3)3"$%("E'/,"(7,"RABA"'$")$$%&'(%-:"$%("6$()C")("C,'-$,3"

F-%E"\,-E'$>"'?%6("7%G"(%"-,*(-6D(6-,")(*",36D'()%$'C"*>*(,EA"#$"%$,"%F"(7,",'-C),*("

)E)('()%$*"%F"(7,"\,-E'$"6$)&,-*)(>"E%3,C:")$"!`<b:"(7,"H'**'D76*,((*"#$*()(6(,"%F"

1,D7$%C%2>"'3%5(,3"'"*,'C"(7'("*7%G,3"'*")(*"E%((%!:+,.!+%!:',#.:" NH)$3"'$3"I'$3:P"

'$3"*7%G,3"'"*D7%C'-"'$3"'"C'?%-,-"G)(7"'"7'EE,-"'$3"'$&)C"*('$3)$2"(%2,(7,-A"

17,"\,-E'$"6$)&,-*)(>"E%3,C",&,$(6'CC>"F%6$3"'$",&,$"E%-,"D%$36D)&,",$&)-%$E,$("

)$"(7,"RABA"(7'$")("3)3")$"\,-E'$>A""V)(7"(7,)-",E57'*)*"%$"(7,"5-'D()D'C:"'$3"G)(7"$%"

'-)*(%D-'()D"(-'3)()%$*"(7'("G%6C3")$(,-F,-,"G)(7"(7,"5-%E%()%$"%F"?6*)$,**0%-),$(,3"

-,*,'-D7"'("(7,"6$)&,-*)(),*:"(7,"RABA",&,$(6'CC>"5-%E%(,3"*6D7"-,*,'-D7")$*()(6()%$*"F'-"

?,>%$3"\,-E'$>"3)3A" 17)*",&)3,$D,"*622,*(*"(7'("(7,"D6C(6-'C"3)FF,-,$D,*"?,(G,,$"(7,"

R$)(,3"B('(,*"'$3"46-%5,"E'/,"(7,"RABA"5%**)?C>"'"E%-,"F,-()C,"2-%6$3"F%-"5-'D()D'C"

?6*)$,**,*:"C,**"F,-()C,"F%-"2-,'("G%-/*"%F"'-("'$3"(-,'()*,*"%$"57)C%*%57>A"

X"B,,"=,$0g'&)3:"!_^^A

Page 5: CCSWP13 Shiller

a"

17,-,"'-,")$3)*56('?C>"D6C(6-'C"3)FF,-,$D,*"(7'("-,C'(,"(%"?6*)$,**A"=6("(7,-,"'55,'-*"(%"

7'&,"?,,$"-,C'()&,C>"C)((C,"-,*,'-D7"%$"7%G"5,-&'*)&,"'$3"7%G"*,-)%6*"(7,>"'-,:"'$3"(7'("

(7,>"-,'CC>"'-,"E,'$)$2F6C")$"6$3,-*('$3)$2"3)FF,-,$D,*")$"*6DD,**"%F",D%$%E),*A"

8"$6E?,-"%F"-,*,'-D7,-*"7'&,"'((,E5(,3"(%"-,C'(,"3)FF,-,$D,*")$",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"

*6DD,**"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*"G)(7"3)FF,-,$D,*")$"'(()(63,*A"g'&)3"HDMC,CC'$3"'$3"7)*"

D%CC,'26,*"c!_<!d"3,&)*,3"E,'*6-,*"%F"'D7),&,E,$("E%()&'()%$:"'$3"D%E5'-,3"(7,*,"

'D-%**"D%6$(-),*A"\,,-("I%F*(,3,"c!_`9d"E,'*6-,3"3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*")$"

6$D,-(')$(>"'&%)3'$D,A"+-)(h"\',$*C,$"c!_`<d"E,'*6-,3")$3)&)36'C)*E")$"&'-)%6*"

D%6$(-),*A"17,-,"'-,"&'->)$2"%5)$)%$*"'?%6("7%G"*6DD,**F6C"(7,)-"E,'*6-,*"%F"76E'$"

'(()(63,*",W5C')$"3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*")$",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"*6DD,**f"E>"-,'3)$2")*"

(7'("(7,)-"*6DD,**,*"'-,"%$C>"E%3,*(A"b"

V7,$"#"'((,$3,3"'"D%$F,-,$D,"%$"(7,"RABA",D%$%E>")$"H%*D%G")$"!_`_:")$"(7,"C'*("

>,'-*"%F"(7,"B%&),("R$)%$:"G7,$"'"(-'$*)()%$"(%"'"E'-/,(",D%$%E>"G'*"7,'(,3C>"

3)*D6**,3:"'("(7,"#$*()(6(,"%F"V%-C3"4D%$%E)D*"'$3"#$(,-$'()%$'C".,C'()%$*"J#H4H[K:"#"

F%6$3"(7'("(7,-,"G'*"E6D7"('C/"'?%6("(7,"3)FF,-,$D,*"?,(G,,$".6**)'$*O '(()(63,*"(%G'-3*"

?6*)$,**"'$3",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"G)(7"G,*(,-$"D%6$(-),*A"17,"B%&),(",D%$%E)*(*"#"E,("

*,,E,3"2,$,-'CC>"(%"7'&,"'"5%%-"%5)$)%$"%F"(7,)-"%G$"5,%5C,O*"'?)C)(>"(%"5-%E%(,"

*6DD,**F6C"?6*)$,**"3,'C)$2*A"=6(:"G7,$"#"U6,*()%$,3"(7,E:"$%$,"%F"(7,E"7'3"'$>"*%C)3"

,&)3,$D,"'?%6("(7,"3)FF,-,$D,")$"'(()(63,*"?,(G,,$".6**)'$*"'$3"5,%5C,"%F"%(7,-"

D%6$(-),*A"

b"M%E5'-)$2 ,'%)2,'$ )$3)D'(%-*"%F"'(()(63,*"E)*C,'3"6*")$",&'C6'()$2"(7,"5-%*5,D(*"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"*6DD,**"%F"$'()%$*A"T'E%$("c!__;d"'$3"\)'$$,(()"'$3"B)E%$*%$"c;99Xd"7'&,"F%6$3",&)3,$D,"%F"E'Y%-"&'-)'()%$*"'D-%**"-,2)%$*"G)(7)$"46-%5,'$"D%6$(-),*")$"'(()(63,*"-,C'()$2"(%",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"*5)-)(A".,2)%$'C"%-"D6C(6-'C"5%D/,(*"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"h,'C"E'>"*,-&,"(%"*655C>"'"D%6$(->"G)(7"E'$>",$(-,5-,$,6-*")F",D%$%E)D"D%$3)()%$*"F'&%-",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5A

Page 6: CCSWP13 Shiller

<"

8("(7)*"D%$F,-,$D,"#"E,("'">%6$2",D%$%E)*(:"H'W)E"=%>D/%"%F"#H4H[:"'$3"G,:"

(%2,(7,-"G)(7"(7,"R/-')$)'$"*%D)%C%2)*("QC'3)E)-"i%-%?%&:"3,D)3,3"(%"3%"'"*(63>"

D%E5'-)$2"'(()(63,*"?,(G,,$".6**)'$*"'$3"5,%5C,"%F"%(7,-"D%6$(-),*A"[6-"E,(7%3"G'*"(%"

G-)(,"U6,*()%$$')-,*"'?%6("?6*)$,**"'(()(63,*:"(-'$*C'(,"(7,*,")$(%"&'-)%6*"C'$26'2,*"'*"

G,CC"'*".6**)'$:"'$3"(->"(7,"U6,*()%$$')-,*")$"&'-)%6*"D%6$(-),*A"V,"G,-,"(76*"'?C,"(%"

D%E5'-,"'(()(63,*"(%G'-3*"?6*)$,**"'D-%**".6**)':"R$)(,3"B('(,*:"R/-')$,:"4'*("\,-E'$>:"

V,*("\,-E'$>:"'$3"@'5'$"cB7)CC,-:"=%>D/%"'$3"i%-%?%&"!__!:"!__;dA"

V,"F%6$3"'"$6E?,-"%F"3)FF,-,$D,*")$"'(()(63,*"(7'("-,C'(,"(%"?6*)$,**"'D-%**"(7,*,"

D%6$(-),*:"?6("$%("'*"*7'-5"'$3"*)2$)F)D'$("'*"(7,")3C,"3)*D6**)%$*"%F"(7,"B%&),("

,D%$%E)*(*"G%6C3"*622,*(A"[6-"%&,-'CC"D%$DC6*)%$"G'*"(7'("(7,"3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"

D%6$(-),*"G,-,"E%-,"*)(6'()%$'C"J-,FC,D()$2"(7,"D%$*(-')$(*"'$3"%55%-(6$)(),*")$"(7,"

C%D'C",D%$%E>K"(7'$"'(()(63)$'C"J-,FC,D()$2"'(()(63,*"(%G'-3*"?6*)$,**KA!

53)4+,-+!2,!()**+&+,-+.!),!0%%)%#4+.!;2<'&4.!=).>"

[$,")E5%-('$("F'D(%-"(7'("(7,".6**)'$",D%$%E)*(*"E,$()%$,3"(%"E,"G7,$"#"&)*)(,3"

H%*D%G")$"!_`_")*"(7'("(7,>"F,'-,3"(7'(".6**)'$*"7'3"C%*("(7,)-"-)*/0('/)$2")$*()$D(:"

'F(,-">,'-*"%F"C)&)$2"6$3,-"'"D%EE6$)*("-,2)E,"(7'("E'$'2,3",&,->(7)$2"F%-"(7,EA"

=6(:")$"E>")$(,-$'()%$'C"*6-&,>*"G)(7 =%>D/%"'$3"i%-%?%&:"G,"G,-,"6$'?C,"(%"F)$3"

'$> *)2$)F)D'$("3)FF,-,$D,"?,(G,,$".6**)':"R/-')$,"'$3"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*")$"

F6$3'E,$('C"'(()(63,*"(%G'-3*"-)*/"('/)$2A"

[6-"E,(7%3"G'*"(%"'*/"'?%6("?%(7 '%%)%#4),'$ '$3!.)%#'%)2,'$"F'D(%-*"-,C'(,3"(%"

?6*)$,**")$"U6,*()%$$')-,*"(7'("G,-,")3,$()D'C"J,WD,5("F%-"(-'$*C'()%$")$(%"(7,"C%D'C"

C'$26'2,K"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*A"8(()(63)$'C"F'D(%-*"-,C'(,"(%"(7,")$3)&)36'CO*"5*>D7%C%2>:

Page 7: CCSWP13 Shiller

^"

*)(6'()%$'C"F'D(%-*"'-,"'*5,D(*"%F"(7,")$3)&)36'CO*"5,-D,)&,3",D%$%E)D",$&)-%$E,$(A"

.)*/"'&,-*)%$:")F"E,'*6-,3"DC,'-C>"'*"'"('*(,"F%-"-)*/:")*"'(()(63)$'CA"V,"'*/,3Z"

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e"

!"#$%&'("%)*#(%

+,$%'-,*.%)*#(% /0)-"1%#*2"%

30##*'% 45% 67% 894%:()'*;"% <8% =>% >?%:;*&".%/&'&"#% 4>% 68% 88>"

L,%5C,")$"'CC"(7,*,"D%6$(-),*"*,,E"&)-(6'CC>")3,$()D'C")$"7%G"(7,>"G%6C3"3,'C"G)(7"*6D7"

'"5,-*%$'C"5-%?C,EA"17,",&)3,$D,"7,-,"*622,*(*"$%"3)FF,-,$D,"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*")$"

F6$3'E,$('C -)*/"'&,-*)%$A"

8$",W'E5C,"%F"'"U6,*()%$"(7'("5-%?,3"*)(6'()%$'C J'*"G,CC"'*"'(()(63)$'CK"F'D(%-*"

)*"(7,"F%CC%G)$2Z"

B655%*,"(7'("'"2-%65"%F">%6-"F-),$3*")*"*('-()$2"'"?6*)$,**"(7'(">%6"(7)$/")*"&,->"-)*/>"'$3"D%6C3"F')C]?6("(7'("E)27("'C*%"E'/,")$&,*(%-*")$"(7'("?6*)$,**"-)D7A"V%6C3">%6"?,"(,E5(,3"(%")$&,*("'"*6?*('$()'C"5%-()%$"%F">%6-"*'&)$2*")$")(eP"

!"#% +,%/0)-"1%/*2"%

@"#&%A")B';1% 86% 5<% 8=7%C'#&%A")B';1% 75% ?7% 87?%30##*'%DE,#F,GH% 48% 6>% 877%30##*'%DIB#(H% 67% 45% 89=%:()'*;"% 66% 4<% 784

Page 8: CCSWP13 Shiller

`"

:J/J%D+"G%!,)(H% ==% <?% 88?%:J/J%DK,;&*;";&'LH% =9% ?9% 877"

I,-,"G,"*,,"*%E,"*)2$)F)D'$("3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*A"j%('?C>:"(7,"V,*("\,-E'$*"

G,-,"(7,"C,'*("C)/,C>"(%"G'$("(%"('/, %$",$(-,5-,$,6-)'C -)*/*:"'"D%$DC6*)%$"(7'("'DD%-3*"

G)(7"*%E,"5%56C'-"D7'-'D(,-)h'()%$*"%F"(7,EA""=6("(7,"3)FF,-,$D,*"G,-,"$%("'CG'>*"(7,"

%$,*"G,",W5,D(,3"?'*,3"%$"D%$&,$()%$'C"*(,-,%(>5,*A"17,"H%*D%G".6**)'$*:"$%("(7,"

8E,-)D'$*:"G,-,"(7,"E%*("C)/,C>"(%"*'>"(7,>"G%6C3"('/,"(7,"-)*/*A"4'*("\,-E'$*"J'("(7,"

()E,"%F"(7)*"U6,*()%$$')-,"Y6*(",E,-2)$2"F-%E"'"*%D)'C)*("3)D('(%-*7)5K"G,-,"E%-,"C)/,C> (%"

G'$("(%"('/,"?6*)$,**"-)*/*"(7'$"(7,"V,*("\,-E'$*A"

17,"3)FF,-,$D,*"'D-%**"D%6$(-),*"'55,'-"?>"(7,*,"E,'*6-,*:"'*"G,CC"'*"%(7,-"

E,'*6-,*")$"%6-"*(63>:"(%"-,C'(,"(%"5,-D,)&,3"-)*/*:"-'(7,-"(7'$"'(()(63,*"(%G'-3*"-)*/*A"

V7>"(7,".6**)'$*"%-"4'*("\,-E'$*"F,C("(7,"5,-D,)&,3"?6*)$,**"-)*/*"C,**"'("(7,"()E,"%F (7,"

?-,'/65"%F"(7,"B%&),("R$)%$")*"'"E>*(,->"(7'("G,"E'>"$,&,-"?,"'?C,"(%"6$-'&,CA"=6(:"(7,"

2,$,-'C"5-)$D)5C,"7,-,")*"(7'("5,-D,)&,3"-)*/*"'55,'-*"(%"?,"'"*)2$)F)D'$("?'--),-"(%"

,$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5:"'$3"(7'(")F"G,"%&,-D%E,"(7,*,"?'--),-*:"(7,-,"E'>"?,"$%"3)FF,-,$D,")$"

G)CC)$2$,**"(%"('/,"?6*)$,**"-)*/*A!

?&2@2%),8!:','8+@+,%!2*!A#.),+..!=).>.B!C+,%#&+!"'6)%'$"

17,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"%6-"F)$'$D)'C")$*()(6()%$*"%&,-"(7,"D,$(6-),*"7'*"E'3,")("

)$D-,'*)$2C>",'*>"F%-"5,%5C,"(%"('/,"?6*)$,**"-)*/*"G)(7"'"7%5,"%F"-,G'-3"'$3">,("$%("

*6?Y,D("(7,E*,C&,*"(%",WD,**)&,"-)*/A"17,-,"7'*"?,,$")E5%-('$("5-%2-,**"%&,-"(7,"C'*("7'CF"

D,$(6->")$"(7,"G'>",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5")*"F)$'$D,3A

Page 9: CCSWP13 Shiller

_"

17,"G%-C3O*"F)-*("&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"F)-E:"8E,-)D'$".,*,'-D7"'$3"g,&,C%5E,$(:"G'*"

,*('?C)*7,3")$"!_b<"?>"H'**'D76*,((*"#$*()(6(,"%F"1,D7$%C%2>"5-,*)3,$("i'-C"M%E5(%$:"

'C%$2"G)(7"\,%-2,*"+A"g%-)%(:"'"5-%F,**%-"'("(7,"I'-&'-3"=6*)$,**"BD7%%CA"17,)-"

-,&%C6()%$'->")3,'"G'*"(%"*,("65"'"56?C)DC> (-'3,3"D%E5'$>"(7'(")$&,*(,3")$"'"C%("%F"&,->"

7)27"-)*/"7)27"(,D7"*('-(65*:",W5,D()$2"E%*("(%"F')C:"?6("?,$,F)()$2"F-%E"(7,"C%$2"-)27("(')C"

%F"(7,"3)*(-)?6()%$:"(7,",$%-E%6*"*6DD,**"%F"(7,"*E'CC"$6E?,-"(7'("*6DD,,3A"17)*"G'*"'"

F6$3'E,$('CC>"3)FF,-,$("E,(7%3"(7'$"(7'("G7)D7"D%EE,-D)'C"?'$/*"6*,")$"(7,)-"3,'C)$2*"

G)(7",$(-,5-,$,6-*A"17,"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"F)-E*"D%6C3"%FF,-"(,-E*"(%"(7,"F)-E*"(7'("(7,>"

)$&,*(,3")$"(7'("G%6C3"5-%(,D("(7,",$(-,5-,$,6-*"F-%E"E6D7"%F"(7,",$%-E%6*"-)*/"(7'("

*6D7"&,$(6-,*",$(')CA"

#$ (7,"*)W(>">,'-*"*)$D,"(7,)-")$D,5()%$*:"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"F)-E*"7'&,"2-'36'CC>"

C,'-$,3"7%G"(%"E'$'2,"(7,"-)*/*"%F"(7,)-"D%E5'$),*"'$3"(%"3,'C"G)(7"(7,"'2,$D>"5-%?C,E*"

(7'("E'>"?,"&,->"*(-%$2"*)$D,"(7,"*6DD,**"%F"7)270(,D7"&,$(6-,*"E'>"?,"*%"7'-3"(%"Y632,A"

17,>"7'&,")$&,$(,3"*('2,3"F)$'$D)$2"(7'("/,,5*"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C)*(*"%$"'"C,'*7"G7%*,"

C,$2(7")*"'DD6-'(,C>"D%$(-%CC,3:"(7,>"7'&,"3,&,C%5,3"*>$3)D'()%$"E,(7%3*"(7'("'CC%G"(7,"

&,$(6-,"D'5)('C)*("(%"2,("*,D%$3"'$3"(7)-3"%5)$)%$*"'?%6("(7,"*6DD,**"%F"(7,)-")$&,*(E,$(*:"

(7,>"C,'-$,3"(7-%627"()E,"7%G"(%"5'-()D)5'(,")$"(7,"?%'-3*"%F"3)-,D(%-*"%F"(7,"D%E5'$),*"

)$"*6D7"'"G'>"'*"6*,"(7,)-"E%-,"2,$,-'C"/$%GC,32,"(%"7,C5"56-*6,"%55%-(6$)(),*"F%-"(7,"

?6*)$,**,*"(7,>"7'&,")$&,*(,3")$:"(7,>"C,'-$,3"7%G"(%"'G'-3",U6)(>"%-"%5()%$*"2-'$(*"(%"

E'$'2,-*"(%"?,((,-"'C)2$"(7,")$(,-,*(*"%F",E5C%>,,*"'$3")$&,*(%-*:"(7,>"3,&,C%5,3"2-'36'C"

&,*()$2"5-%2-'E*"(%"D%$(-%C"(7,"()E,"5'((,-$"%F"E'$'2,-)'C"C%>'C(>"(%"(7,"F)-E:"(7,>"

C,'-$,3"(,D7$)U6,*"(%"F'D)C)('(,"(7,"G,'$)$2"%F"(7,")$&,*(,3"F)-E*"F-%E"(7,"&,$(6-,

Page 10: CCSWP13 Shiller

!9"

D'5)('C)*("'$3"5C'D)$2"%F"(7,E")$(%"56?C)D"E'-/,(*"G)(7%6("2,$,-'()$2"'3&,-*,"*,C,D()%$"

5-%?C,E*"cB,,"\%E5,-*"'$3"T,-$,-";99!dA"

17,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"5-)&'(,",U6)(>"'$3"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"7'*"?,,$"E%*(C>"'**%D)'(,3"

G)(7"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*A"17%627"(7,*,")$*()(6()%$*"7'&,"?,,$"2-%G)$2")$"46-%5,:"(7,>"7'&,"

$%("7'3"'*"*(-%$2"'$")E5'D("(7,-,A 17,"5,-F%-E'$D,"%F"46-%5,'$"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"F)-E*"

!__X0;99X"7'*"?,,$"3)*'55%)$()$2:"'$3"(7,"5,-F%-E'$D,"7'*"?,,$"5'-()D6C'-C>"?'3"F%- (7,"

D-)()D'CC>")E5%-('$(",'-C>0*('2,"&,$(6-,")$&,*(E,$(*"cH'D7'3%".%*'"'$3".''3,";99<dA"

B%E,"%F"(7)*"3)*'55%)$(E,$(")*"36,:"5,-7'5*:"(%",--%-*")$"Y632)$2"(7,"7)270(,D7"?6??C,"%F"

(7,"!__9*:"?6("(7'("E,E%->"C)$2,-*"%$"'$3")$7)?)(*"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C",&,$"(%3'>A"

T'6-'"=%(('hh)"'$3"H'-D%"g'".)$"c;99;d"7'&,"'-26,3"(7'( (7,"U6'C)(>"%F"

46-%5,'$"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C:"%&,-'CC:")*"$%(">,(",U6'C"(%"(7'(")$"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*A 17,>"

D%$DC63,"(7'("46-%5,'$"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"F)-E*"7'&,"5-%36D,3"F,G,-"N*65,-*('-P"

D%E5'$),*:"'$3:"E%-,"2,$,-'CC>:"'-,"$%("*>*(,E'()D'CC>"'**%D)'(,3"G)(7"E%-,"3>$'E)D"

D%E5'$),*A"j%("%$C>")*"(7,"(%('C"U6'$()(>"%F"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"C,**:"?6("(7,"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"

(,$3*"(%"?,"*5-,'3"%6("E6D7"E%-,"'D-%**"F)-E*")$"46-%5,:"E6D7"*E'CC,-"'E%6$(*")$&,*(,3"

5,-"D%E5'$>A" 17,>"*5,D6C'(,"(7'(:"3,*5)(,")(*"-'5)3"2-%G(7:"46-%5,'$"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C"

*6FF,-*"F-%E"'"-,C'()&,"*7%-('2,"%F"U6'C)F),3",W5,-),$D,3"5-%F,**)%$'C*A"

17,"46-%5,'$"M%EE)**)%$"7'*"$%(,3"(7,")E5%-('$D,"%F"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C:"'$3"7'*"

'*"'"-,*6C("(-'$*F%-E,3"(7,"46-%5,'$"#$&,*(E,$("+6$3"J4#+K")$(%"'"E'Y%-")$&,*(%-")$"

&,$(6-,"D'5)('CA"17,"4#+")*"'"56?C)D05-)&'(,"5'-($,-*7)5"%G$,3"?>"(7,"46-%5,'$"

#$&,*(E,$("='$/"J<;kK:"(7,"46-%5,'$"R$)%$"JX9kK"'$3"46-%5,'$"?'$/*"'$3"F)$'$D)'C"

)$*()(6()%$*"J`kKA 17)*")*"'"C'63'?C,",FF%-("(%"5-%E%(,"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C )$"46-%5,A =6(:"(7,"

(%('C"5%-(F%C)%"%F"(7,"4#+"'*"%F";99a"G'*"%$C> lXA;"?)CC)%$A"#$"D%$(-'*(:"(7,"(%('C"'E%6$("%F

Page 11: CCSWP13 Shiller

!!"

&,$(6-,"D'5)('C")$&,*(E,$(*")$"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*"E'3,")$";99a"'C%$,"G'*"m;;A;"?)CC)%$A"a"

M-,'()$2"'"U6'*)02%&,-$E,$("F6$3"E'>"$%("?,")$"(7,"(-6,"*5)-)("%F"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C:"'$3"

5,-7'5*"%(7,-"G'>*"%F"5-%E%()$2"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C")$"46-%5,"*7%6C3"?,"56-*6,3A!

?&2@2%),8!:','8+@+,%!2*!A#.),+..!=).>.B!1,4+DEA'.+4!(+&)3'%)3+."

[(7,-"3,&,C%5E,$(*")$"D'5)('C"E'-/,(*")$"-,D,$("3,D'3,*"7'&,"?,,$"(7,"-'5)3"

3,&,C%5E,$("%F"3,-)&'()&,*"E'-/,(*A"17,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"(7,"F)-*("F)$'$D)'C"F6(6-,*"'$3"

%5()%$*"E'-/,(*:"'*"G,CC"'*"*G'5*"?,2'$")$"(7,"!_^9*"'$3"!_`9*A"

V,"'-,"*,,)$2"$%G"(7,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F")$3,W0?'*,3"3,-)&'()&,*:"'$3"(7,"

5-%C)F,-'()%$"%F"(7,*,"3,-)&'()&,*")*"*%E,(7)$2"(7'("D'$"7,C5",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"?>"

5-%E%()$2"7,32)$2"'2')$*("'"E6C()(63,"%F"*5,D)F)D"-)*/*"(7'(")E5)$2,"%$"(7,"*5,D)F)D*"%F"

(7,"&,$(6-,A"8$>")$3,W"%F"(7,"%6(D%E,"%F"'$",D%$%E)D"-)*/"D'$"?,"(7,"?'*)*"%F"*,((C,E,$("

%F"-)*/"E'$'2,E,$("D%$(-'D(*A"8$>"()E,"(7,"6$D,-(')$(> -,C'(,3"(%"56-*6)$2")$$%&'()%$")*"

-,36D,3:")("?,D%E,*",'*),-"F%-",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"(%"5-%D,,3A"

#"G)CC"2)&,"%$,",W'E5C,"%F"(7,",FF,D(*"%F"(7,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"'"$,G"-)*/"E'-/,("%$"

,$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"(7'("#"'E"5'-()D6C'-C>")$&%C&,3")$Z"(7,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"3,-)&'()&,"

5-%36D(*"F%-"-,'C",*('(,"-)*/*:"5'-()D6C'-C>"-)*/*"(%"(7,"&'C6,"%F"%G$,-0%DD65),3"7%E,*A"

[G$,-0%DD65),3"7%E,*"'-,"'-26'?C>"(7,"?)22,*("'**,("DC'**"%F"'CCA"#$"(7,"R$)(,3"

B('(,*:"D6--,$(C>:"-,'C",*('(,"%G$,3"?>"7%6*,7%C3*"'E%6$(*"(%"'?%6("m;9"(-)CC)%$A"17)*")*"

C'-2,-"(7'$"(7,"*(%D/"E'-/,(A"17,"-)*/*"(%"(7)*"'**,("DC'**"'55,'-"*6?*('$()'CA"17,"E'-/,("

&'C6,"%F"7%E,*"7'*"D,-(')$C>"?,,$"&%C'()C,")$"-,D,$(">,'-*A"8$3">,(:"(7,-,"7'*"?,,$"

&)-(6'CC>"$%")**6'$D,"%F"3,-)&'()&,"5-%36D(*"(7'("G%6C3"7,32,"(7,"-)*/*"%F"(7,*,A"#(")*"(-6,"

(7'(")$"!__!"(7,"T%$3%$"+6(6-,*"'$3"[5()%$*"4WD7'$2,"'((,E5(,3"(%"D-,'(,"F6(6-,*"

a"L-)D,G'(,-7%6*,M%%5,-*"n"j'()%$'C"Q,$(6-,"M'5)('C"8**%D)'()%$"H%$,>"1-,,"o".,5%-(:"!;nX!n;99aA

Page 12: CCSWP13 Shiller

!;"

E'-/,(*"F%-"(7,*,:"?6("(7'(",FF%-("U6)D/C>"F')C,3A"#(")*"(-6,"(7'(")$"(7,"R$)(,3"i)$23%E"

3,-)&'()&,"5-%36D(*"F%-"D%EE,-D)'C"-,'C",*('(,"7'&,"?,26$"(%"5-%C)F,-'(,")$"(7,"5'*("F,G"

>,'-*:"'$3"(7,-,"'-,"\%C3E'$"B'D7*"D%&,-,3"G'--'$(*"(-'3,3"%$"(7,"T%$3%$"B(%D/"

4WD7'$2,:"?6("(7,*,"'-,"*()CC"U6)(,"*E'CC")$"(%('C"&'C6,A"

#$"(7,"C'(,"!_`9*"E>"D%CC,'26,"i'-C"M'*,"'$3"#"(7%627("(7'("(7,"%?*('DC,"(%"

3,&,C%5)$2"2%%3"3,-)&'()&,"E'-/,(*"F%-"*)$2C,"F'E)C>"7%E,*"G'*"(7'("(7,-,"G'*"$%"2%%3"

E,'*6-,"%F"(7,)-"&'C6,A"V,"(7,$"3,&,C%5,3"'"G,)27(,30-,5,'(0*'C,*"E,(7%3%C%2>"'$3"

?,2'$"5-%36D)$2"7%E,"5-)D,")$3)D,*"(7'("G,-,"F'-"?,((,-"'$>"%(7,-"'&')C'?C,A"17,")$3)D,*"

G,"D-,'(,3"G,-,"*5,D)F)D'CC>"3,*)2$,3"F%-"D%$(-'D("*,((C,E,$("c*,,"B7)CC,-"!__X:";99Xd"'$3"

7'&,"?,,$")E5-%&,3"%&,-"(7,">,'-*"'$3"'-,"$%G"5-%36D,3")$"D%CC'?%-'()%$"G)(7"+)*,-&:"

#$DA"J'"F)$'$D)'C"*,-&)D,*"F)-EK"'$3"B('$3'-3"p"L%%-O*"J'"F)$'$D)'C")$3,W"5-%&)3,-"'$3"

-'()$2"'2,$D>KA"

17,"F)-E"(7'("#"D%0F%6$3,3"G)(7"8CC'$"V,)**:"'$3"B'E"H'*6DD):"H'D-%H'-/,(*"

TTM:"7'*"(,'E,3"65"G)(7"(7,"M7)D'2%"H,-D'$()C,"4WD7'$2,:"+)*,-&:"#$DA:"'$3"B('$3'-3"p"

L%%-O*"(%"D-,'(,"F6(6-,*"'$3"%5()%$*"E'-/,(*"F%-"*)$2C,0F'E)C>"7%E,*"%$",'D7"%F"(,$"

R$)(,3"B('(,*"E,(-%"'-,'*A"17,*,"'-,"D'*7"*,((C,3"?'*,3"%$"(7,"BpLnM'*,"B7)CC,-"I%E,"

L-)D,"#$3)D,*A"17,*,"?,2'$"(-'3)$2"H'>";;";99<"J*,,"7((5Znn7%6*)$2ADE,AD%EK"'$3"'*"%F"

8626*(";99< (7,"F6(6-,* %5,$")$(,-,*("(%('C,3"m<^"E)CC)%$"3%CC'-*:"'$3:")$DC63)$2"(7,"

6$3,-C>)$2"&'C6,"-,5-,*,$(,3"?>"(7,"%5()%$*:"(7,"D%E?)$,3"D%$(-'D(*"*(%%3"'("%&,-"m!99"

E)CC)%$"3%CC'-*A"17,"$,W("*('2,")$"(7)*",$(,-5-)*,:"(%"?,"5-%E%(,3"?>"H'D-%H'-/,(*"TTM"

'$3"%(7,-*:")*"(%"3,&,C%5"-,'C",*('(,")$3,W0C)$/,3"$%(,*"J)$DC63)$2"(7,"41+0C)/,"H'D-%"

B,D6-)(),*"(7'("V,)**"'$3"#")$&,$(,3K: '*"G,CC"'*"*G'5*"'$3"%(7,-"%&,-0(7,0D%6$(,-"

5-%36D(*A

Page 13: CCSWP13 Shiller

!X"

V,"3%"$%(">,("/$%G"7%G"*6DD,**F6C"(7,*,"$,G"-)*/"E'$'2,E,$("3,&)D,*"G)CC"?,:"

?6("(7,"/)$3*"%F")$(,-,*("'$3",W5C%-'()%$*"(7'("(7,*,"$,G"E'-/,(*"7'&,"*()E6C'(,3"*622,*("

(7'("(7,"'?)C)(>"(%"E'$'2,"-,'C",*('(,"-)*/"D%6C3"6C()E'(,C>"D-,'(,"'"E6C()(63,"%F"$,G"

,$(,-5-)*,*A"V,",W5,D("(%"*,,"$,G"/)$3*"%F"E%-(2'2,"C,$3,-*:"G7%"5-%&)3,"3%G$5'>E,$("

)$*6-'$D,"(%"7%E,"?6>,-*"G%--),3"'?%6("(7,"&'C6,"%F"(7,)-"7%E,*:"'$3"7,32,"(7,"-)*/*"(7'("

(7,>")$D6-")$"G-)()$2"(7,"E%-(2'2,*"%$"(7,"$,G"3,-)&'()&,"E'-/,(*A" V,",W5,D("(%"*,,"$,G"

/)$3*"%F"7%E,%G$,-*")$*6-'$D,"5-%&)3,-*:"G7%"5-%(,D("7%E,%G$,-*"'2')$*("-)*/*"(%"(7,"

&'C6,"%F"(7,)-"7%E,*"'$3"$%("Y6*("'2')$*("57>*)D'C"3'E'2,"(%"(7,)-"7%E,*:"'$3"(7,$"7,32,"

(7,"-)*/*"(7'("(7,>")$D6-")$"G-)()$2"(7,"5%C)D),*")$"(7,"$,G"3,-)&'()&,"E'-/,(*A"V,",W5,D("

(%"*,,"'"5-%C)F,-'()%$"%F"7%E,"?6)C3,-"'D()&)(),*:"*56--,3"?>"*6D7"$,G"D%$D,5(*"'*"'"

7%E,?6>,-"5-)D,"G'--'$(>:"'D()&)(),*"(7'("G)CC"(7,$"?,"7,32,3")$"(7,"$,G"3,-)&'()&,"

E'-/,(*A"V,",&,$",W5,D("*%E,3'>"(%"*,,"(7'("(7%*,")$3)&)36'C*"G7%"?6>"'$3"F)W"65"

7%E,*"F%-"-,*'C,"J'"&,->"5%56C'-"F%-E"%F"E)D-%",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5K"G)CC"2,("'"*7%(")$"(7,"

'-E"G7,$")("?,D%E,*"5%**)?C,"F%-"(7,*,"5,%5C,"(%"56-*6,"(7,)-"?6*)$,**")$"'"E'$$,-"(7'(")*"

7,32,3"'2')$*("'22-,2'(,"-,'C",*('(,"-)*/A"#$"'CC"(7,*,"D'*,*",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5")*"F'D)C)('(,3"

?>"3,'C)$2"'$,G"G)(7"-)*/*"(7'("7'3")$7)?)(,3"'D()%$"?,F%-,A!

?&2@2%),8!F-)+,%)*)-!5,%+&6&).+"

BD),$()F)D",$(,-5-)*,:")F")(")*"2%)$2"(%"D%$()$6,"(%"56*7"?'D/"(7,"F-%$(),-*"%F"

/$%GC,32,:"-,U6)-,*"'"/)$3"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"(7'(")*"$%("3)**)E)C'-"F-%E"(7'("%F"

?6*)$,**A"1,D7$%C%2)D'C"5-%2-,**")*"(7,"E')$"3-)&,-"%F",D%$%E)D"2-%G(7:"'$3"(7)*"

5-%2-,**")*"(7,"%6(D%E,"%F",$(,-5-)*,"Y6*("'*"E6D7 '*"5-%2-,**")$"?6)C3)$2"'6(%E%?)C,*")*A

Page 14: CCSWP13 Shiller

!b"

H'Y%-"?-,'/(7-%627*")$"?'*)D"*D),$D,"E'>"-,U6)-,",W5,$3)(6-,*"%F"E'$>"76$3-,3*"

%F"E)CC)%$*"%F",6-%* %&,-"'"5,-)%3"%F"E'$>">,'-*"(%"'D7),&,"'$")E5%-('$("E)**)%$A"17,"

5-%Y,D(*"E'>")$&%C&,"(7,"D%%-3)$'()%$"%F"C'-2,"(,'E*"%F"-,*,'-D7,-*A"BD),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7"

-,U6)-,*"C%$2"()E,"5,-)%3*"(%"D%E,"(%"F-6)()%$A"

H%-,%&,-:"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7"(7-)&,*"%$"D%E5,()()%$:"Y6*("'*"3%"?6*)$,**,*A"17,"

D%E5,()()%$"'CC%G*"(7,"E%*("D'5'?C,"(%"*6-&)&,:"'$3"'((-'D("F6-(7,-"F6$3*"(%"'CC%G"(7,"

-,*,'-D7"(%"F6$D()%$A"I)27C>"-)*/>"&,$(6-,*"$,,3"(%"2,("F6$3)$2:"'$3"(7,"F6$3)$2"$,,3*"(%"

('/,"'DD%6$("%F"(7,"$'(6-,"%F"(7,"-)*/*:"(%"D%$*)3,-"(7,"5%**)?)C)(>"%F"3)&,-*)F>)$2"-)*/*"?>"

)$&,*()$2")$"E'$>"*E'CC"5-%Y,D(*A"

17,-,")*:"7%G,&,-:"'$")E5%-('$("%?*('DC,"(%"(7,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"E'-/,(*"F%-"

*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7Z"BD),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7:"5'-()D6C'-C>"?'*)D"*D),$D,"-,*,'-D7:"F6$D()%$*"

*6?*('$()'CC>"'*"'"56?C)D"2%%3A 17,"3)-,D("-,(6-$*"(%"(7,")$3)&)36'C"-,*,'-D7,-:")F"'$>:"'-,"

%F(,$"3G'-F,3"?>"(7,",W(,-$'C)(),*"(7'("(7,"-,*,'-D7"2,$,-'(,*A".,*,'-D7,-*"7'&,"(%"?,"

G)CC)$2"(%"*7'-,"(7,)-"-,*6C(*"F-,,C>")F"*D),$D,")*"(%"5-%2-,**:"'$3"3%)$2"*%")$7)?)(*"(7,)-"

'?)C)(>"(%"5-%F)("F-%E")(A"+%-"(7)*"-,'*%$:"(7,"-,*,'-D7"-,U6)-,*"2%&,-$E,$("F6$3)$2A"

\%&,-$E,$("F6$3)$2")*"E%*(",FF,D()&,")F")("D'$"*%E,7%G"D-,'(,"(7,"*,E?C'$D,"%F"'"

E'-/,("F%-"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7:"'CC%G)$2"*D),$()*(*"(%"-6$"(7,)-",$(,-5-)*,*"'*")F"(7,>"G,-,"

D%CC,D()$2"(7,"5-%F)(*"(7'("'DD-6,"(%"(7,)-"3)*D%&,-),*A"17,"*>*(,E"(7'("7'*"(%"?,"

D%$*(-6D(,3")*"%$,"(7'("'CC%G*"-,*,'-D7,-*"(%"D%E5,(,"'$3"?,"-,G'-3,3"F%-"E'Y%-"$,G"

)3,'*A"

#$"(7,"!_"(7"D,$(6->:"\,-E'$>"C,3"(7,"G'>")$",FF,D()&,C>"*5%$*%-)$2"*D),$()F)D"

-,*,'-D7:"G)(7"(7,")$&,$()%$"(7,-,"%F"(7,"2-'36'(,"*D7%%C:"G7)D7"G'*"'$"'D'3,E)D"

-,*,'-D7"%-2'$)h'()%$"?6)C("'-%6$3"(7,"(-')$)$2"%F">%6$2"-,*,'-D7,-*A"17)*"2'&,"\,-E'$>

Page 15: CCSWP13 Shiller

!a"

'$")$(,CC,D(6'C",32,"F%-"*%E,"()E,A"#(")*"*)2$)F)D'$(:"F%-",W'E5C,:"(7'("(7,"F),C3"%F"

,D%$%E)D*"G'*"*6?*('$()'CC>"3%E)$'(,3"?>"\,-E'$>"36-)$2"(7'("5,-)%3:"'$3"(7'("E%*("%F"

(7,"F%6$3,-*"%F"(7,"8E,-)D'$ 4D%$%E)D"8**%D)'()%$"G,-,"(-')$,3")$"\,-E'$>A"I%G,&,-:"

(7,"'3&'$('2,"(7'("\,-E'$>"7'3"G'*"C%*("*%E,()E,")$"(7,"(G,$(),(7"D,$(6->A"B)$$"c;99Xd"

5%)$(*"%6("(7'("\,-E'$*"G,-,"5-%E)$,$("%$"(7,"C)*("%F"j%?,C"5-)h,"G)$$,-*")$"*D),$D,")$"

(7,",'-C>";9"(7"D,$(6->:"'$3"(7'("(7,)-"$6E?,-*"3-%55,3"*7'-5C>"?>"(7,"C'(,"(G,$(),(7"

D,$(6->A"

17,"*>*(,E"(7'(")*")$"5C'D,")$"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*"7'*"?,,$"'"E%3,C"F%-"E6D7"%F"(7,"

G%-C3A"17,"R$)(,3"B('(,*"j'()%$'C"BD),$D,"+%6$3'()%$"G'*"F%6$3,3"%$"(7,"'3&)D,"%F"

Q'$$,&'-"=6*7")$"7)*"F'E%6*"!_b^"?%%/!F-)+,-+G!%/+!5,4$+..!7&2,%)+&A"17,"E%*("?'*)D"

)3,'")$"7)*"?%%/"G'*"(7'("(7,"F6$3)$2"%F"*D),$D,"*7%6C3"D-,'(,"'"E,D7'$)*E]#"G%6C3"*'>"

'"E'-/,(5C'D,]F%-"*7)F()$2"2%&,-$E,$("F6$3*"(%"(7,"E%*("*6DD,**F6C"*D),$()F)D"

-,*,'-D7,-*A"17,-,"G%6C3"?,"$%"2%&,-$E,$("*D),$()F)D"'2,$3'"?,>%$3"-,G'-3)$2"(7,"E%*("

F-6)(F6C"-,*,'-D7A"

I%G"(%"D-,'(,"*6D7"'"E'-/,(5C'D,"F%-")3,'*e"=6*7O*")$&,$()%$"G'*"(%"D-,'(,"

D%EE)((,,*"%F"(7,"E%*("*6DD,**F6C"*D),$()*(*"G7%"G%6C3"'$%$>E%6*C>"-,&),G"5-%5%*'C*"

*6?E)((,3"(%"(7,E"?> )$3)&)36'C"*D),$()*(*"J$%("*D),$()F)D"%-2'$)h'()%$*KA"#$"(7)*"

,$&)-%$E,$("(%5"*D),$()*(*"'-,"'?C,"(%"C,("(7,)-"D-,'()&,"*5)-)(*"-6$"6$-,*(-)D(,3"?>"

)$*()(6()%$'C %-"5%C)()D'C -,*(-')$(*"'$3"-,G'-3"(7%*,"G7%"5)U6,"(7,)-")E'2)$'()%$"'$3"%$C>"

(7%*,A"H%-,%&,-:"=6*7"*(-,**,3:"(7,"-,G'-3"*7%6C3"?,"-,C'()&,C>"C%$20(,-E"'$3"*('?C,"

F6$3)$2:"'$3"C'-2,",$%627"F%-"*,-)%6*",$(,-5-)*,:"(%3'>"G,"E)27("*'>")(")*"C)/,"(7,"F6$3)$2"

(7'("D%EE,-D)'C",$(,-5-)*,*"-%6()$,C>"-,D,)&,"F-%E"(7,)-"&,$(6-,"D'5)('C)*(*A

Page 16: CCSWP13 Shiller

!<"

17,"RABA"j'()%$'C"BD),$D,"+%6$3'()%$"G'*"7)27C>"*6DD,**F6C")$"*()E6C'()$2"

)E5%-('$("-,*,'-D7A"+-,,3"F-%E"C)$/)$2"(7,)-"-,*,'-D7"(%"2%&,-$E,$("%-"?6*)$,**"'2,$3'*:"

-,*,'-D7,-*"5-%36D,3"U6'C)(>"-,*,'-D7"(7'("6C()E'(,C>"5-%E%(,3"?6*)$,**")$(,-,*(*A"

17,"RABA"j'()%$'C"BD),$D,"+%6$3'()%$ G'*")E)('(,3"?>"E'$>"%(7,-"D%6$(-),*:"'$3"

(7,*,"$'()%$'C"*D),$D,"F%6$3'()%$*"(>5)D'CC>"F%CC%G"(7,"*'E,"5'((,-$"%F"5,,-"-,&),G"(7'("

(7,"RABA"jB+"3%,*A"17,*,"7'&,"%F"D%6-*,"7'3"E'$>"*6DD,**,*A"

=6("E'$>"%F"(7,*,"$'()%$'C"*D),$D,"F%6$3'()%$*"7'&,"'"5-%?C,E")$7,-,$(")$"(7,"

F'D("(7'("(7,>"'-,"%-2'$)h,3"?>"D%6$(-),*"E6D7"*E'CC,-"(7'$"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*Z")(")*"

3)FF)D6C("(%"E')$(')$"'$%$>E)(>")$"(7,"5,,-"-,&),G"5-%D,**A"i$%G)$2"(7,"(%5)D"%F"(7,"

5-%5%*'C"'$3"(7,"F'D("(7'(")("5-%?'?C>"D%E,*"F-%E"G)(7)$"(7,"D%6$(->:"(7,"5,,-"-,&),G,-"%F"

(7,"5-%5%*'C"5-%?'?C>"/$%G*"(7,"5-%5%*,-:"'$3"D'$$%("E'/,"'"5%C)()D'CC>"6$D%$*(-')$,3"

Y632E,$(A"H%-,%&,-:"(7,"5-%5%*,-")*"E%-,"C)/,C>"(%"?,"'?C,"(%"26,**"(7,"$'E,"%F"(7,"

-,&),G,-A"V)(7"(7,"C%**"%F"'$%$>E)(>:"(7,"5-%D,**"%F"D'$3)3"'**,**E,$("%F"*D),$()F)D"

D%$(-)?6()%$"?-,'/*"3%G$A"

[G,$0BE)(7",("'CA:")$"'"*(63>"%F"C)F,"*D),$D,*"-,*,'-D7"D%E5'-)$2"(7,"RABA"'$3"

46-%5,:"D%$DC63,3"(7'("(7,"(,$3,$D>"F%-"F6$3)$2"*%6-D,*")$"46-%5,"(%"?,"$'()%$'C"-'(7,-"

(7'$"46-%5,'$"7'*"C,3"(%"$'()%$'C DC6*(,-*"%F"*5,D)'C)*(*")$"46-%5,"(7'("7'&,"(,$3,3"(%"

,&%C&,")$"*6D7"'*"G'>"'*"(%"3,,5,$"'C-,'3>"$'--%G"D%E5,(,$D),*"-'(7,-"(7'$"?-%'3"

,W5C%-'()%$A"#$"D%$(-'*(:")$"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*:"(7,"-,2)%$'C"DC6*(,-*"(,$3,3"(%"3,&,C%5")$"

E%-,"2,$,-'C)*("3)-,D()%$*:"56-*6)$2"E6C()5C,"(7,-'5,6()D"'-,'*:"E%-,")$(,2-'()&,"%F"N2%'C0"

%-),$(,3"(7,-'5,6()D"-,*,'-D7"G)(7"F6$3'E,$('C"?)%C%2)D'C")$&,*()2'()%$AP"17,>"D%$DC63,3"

(7'("(7,"C'((,-"/)$3"%F"-,*,'-D7"(7'(")*"E%-,"D%$36D)&,"(%"D%%5,-'()%$"G)(7"D%EE,-D)'C"

&,$(6-,*A

Page 17: CCSWP13 Shiller

!^"

17,"*%C6()%$"F%-"46-%5,")*"(%"D-,'(,"'"$'()%$'C"*D),$D,"F%6$3'()%$"%F"*6FF)D),$("

*D'C,:"F6$D()%$)$2"C)/,"(7,"RABA"j'()%$'C"BD),$D,"+%6$3'()%$"F%-"'CC"%F"46-%5,A"17,"

46-%5,'$"R$)%$*")*"'?%6("(%"3%"(7)*:"?6("(7,"*D'C,")*"$%("C'-2,",$%627A"17,"M%6$D)C"%F"(7,"

46-%5,'$ R$)%$"-,'D7,3"'$"'2-,,E,$(:"5,$3)$2"(7,"46-%5,'$"L'-C)'E,$(O*"%5)$)%$:"(7'(:"

'*"5'-("%F"(7,"B,&,$(7"+-'E,G%-/"L-%2-'E"J+L^K"'"$,G"46-%5,'$".,*,'-D7"M%6$D)C"

J4.MK"G)CC"?,"D-,'(,3A"

=6(:"(7,"4.M"(7'(")*"?,)$2"D-,'(,3")*"(%%"*E'CCA"17,"RABA"j'()%$'C"BD),$D,"

+%6$3'()%$"7'3"'"?632,("%F"maAb`9"?)CC)%$")$"F)*D'C">,'-";99a:"%F"G7)D7"mbA;Xb"?)CC)%$"

G,$("(%"-,*,'-D7"'$3"-,C'(,3"'D()&)(),*A"#$"D%$(-'*(: (7,"4.M"G%6C3"-,D,)&,"'"(%('C"%F l^Aa"

?)CC)%$:"F%-";99^0!X:"%-:"%$"'$"'$$6'C"?'*)*:"'?%6("%$,"U6'-(,-"(7,"*)h,"%F"(7,"RABA"

j'()%$'C"BD),$D,"+%6$3'()%$"?632,(A 4&,$"'F(,-"(7,",*('?C)*7E,$("%F"(7,"4.M:"(7,"?6C/"

%F"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7")$"46-%5,"G)CC"?,"7'$3C,3"?>"-,2)%$'C"$'()%$'C"*D),$D,"F%6$3'()%$*A"

+%-",W'E5C,:"(7,"g,6(*D7,"+%-*D76$2*2,E,)$*D7'F("Jg+\K"7'3"'";99a"?632,("%F l!AX_9"

?)CC)%$: (7,"H'W"LC'$D/0\,*,CC*D7'F(")$";99X"7'3"'"?632,("%F l!A;Xb"E)CC)%$A"17,"

I,-E'$$"&%$"I,CE7%C(h0\,E,)$*D7'F("g,6(*D7,-"+%-*D76$2*h,$(-,$",A"QA"7'*"'"-,D,$("

'$$6'C"?632,("%F l;A;"?)CC)%$A"#$"#('C>:"(7,"M%$*)2C)%"j'h)%$'C,"3,CC,".)D,-D7,"JMj.K"7'3"

'";99;"?632,("%F l_`9"E)CC)%$A"[?&)%6*C>:"(7,"$'()%$'C"-,*,'-D7")$*()(6()%$*"3G'-F"(7,"

46-%5,'$".,*,'-D7"M%6$D)CA!

"2,-$#.)2,"

#(")*"$'(6-'CC>"7'-3"F%-"'$>"D%6$(->"(%"D%$(-%C"(7,"C,&,C"%F",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"G)(7)$"

)(*"?%-3,-*A"4$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5"-,C),*"%$"(7,"N'$)E'C"*5)-)(*P"%F")(*")$7'?)('$(*:"G7)D7")*"

)E5%**)?C,"(%"C,2)*C'(,A"=6(:"#"7'&,"'-26,3"(7'("(7,-,")*"'"C%(")$&%C&,3")$"(7,",D%$%E)D

Page 18: CCSWP13 Shiller

!`"

,$&)-%$E,$("(7'("D'$"E'/,"%-"?-,'/",$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5")$3,5,$3,$("%F"(7,"$'(6-'C"'(()(63,*"

%F"(7,"5%56C'()%$A"

j%('?C>:"(7,"-,&%C6()%$"(7'("7'*"?,,$"%DD6--)$2"%&,-"-,D,$("3,D'3,*")$ &,$(6-,"

D'5)('C"'$3"5-)&'(,",U6)(>"$,,3*"(%"D%$()$6,A""17,*,")$*()(6()%$*"'-,")$$%&'()$2"-'5)3C>")$"

(7,"5-%&)*)%$"%F -)*/"E'$'2,E,$(:"'*"G,CC"'*"*%57)*()D'(,3")$D,$()&,"5'D/'2,*A"+%-"

,$(-,5-,$,6-*:"(7)*")*"'"F6$3'E,$('C"3,&,C%5E,$("(7'("$,,3*"(%"?,"5-%E%(,3")$",&,->"

D%6$(->A"

17,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F"3,-)&'()&,"E'-/,(*:"G7)D7 7'*"?,,$"5-%D,,3)$2"'("'"-'5)3"

5'D,:"7,C5*"5-%E%(,"?6*)$,**"'D()&)(),*"'("'CC"*('2,*:")$DC63)$2"(7,"?,2)$$)$2"*('2,*"%F"

,$(-,5-,$,6-*7)5A"[F"5'-()D6C'-")$(,-,*("2%)$2"F%-G'-3")*"(7,"5-%C)F,-'()%$"%F"E'-/,(*"F%-"

,D%$%E)D")$3)D,*:"(7'("G)CC"'CC%G")$3)&)36'C",$(-,5-,$,6-*"(%"C)E)("(7,"*5,D)F)D"-)*/*"(7'("

(7,)-"&,$(6-,",$(')C*A"

17,"3,&,C%5E,$("%F")$*()(6()%$*"F%-"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7"(7'(")$",FF,D("D-,'(,"'$"

'$%$>E%6*"E'-/,(5C'D,"F%-"F6$3*"*655%-()$2"2,$6)$,"?'*)D"-,*,'-D7"$,,3*"(%"?,"56-*6,3"

F6-(7,-A"='*)D"*D),$()F)D"-,*,'-D7")*"(7,"6C()E'(,"*%6-D,"%F"E6D7"%F"%6-",D%$%E)D"2-%G(7A"

8CC"(7,*,"(7)$2*"'-,"'C-,'3>"7'55,$)$2A"=6(:"5-%2-,**"D%6C3"?,"E6D7"F'*(,-")F"

2%&,-$E,$(*"-,D%2$)h,3"(7,)-"*)2$)F)D'$D,"'$3"5-%E%(,3"(7,E"E%-,A

Page 19: CCSWP13 Shiller

!_!

=+*+&+,-+."

=,$0g'&)3:"@%*,57:!"+,%+&.!2*!9+'&,),8B!A&)%'),G!7&',-+G!H+&@',I!',4!%/+!J,)%+4!F%'%+.:"j,G"S%-/Z"HD\-'G0I)CC:"!_^^A"

=%(('hh):"T'6-':"'$3"H'D-%"g'".)$:"NQ,$(6-,"M'5)('C")$"46-%5,"'$3"(7,"+)$'$D)$2"%F"#$$%&'()&,"M%E5'$),*:P!5-2,2@)-!?2$)-I:"!^JXbKZ;;_:";99;A"

+-'$/C)$:"=,$Y'E)$:"N#$F%-E'()%$"(%"(7%*,"G7%"G%6C3"-,E%&,"(%"8E,-)D':P!;/+!A2.%2,!:'8'K),+:"[D(%?,-"!^`b:"55A"!0aA"

\',$*C,$:"+-)(h:"NM6C(6-,"'$3"g,D)*)%$"H'/)$2")$"M7)$':"@'5'$:".6**)'"'$3"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*:P!L2&$4!?2$)%)-."X_Z^`0!9X:"!_`<A"

\)'$$,(():"H'-)'**6$(':"'$3"8$3-,) B)E%$%&:"Ng%,*"L-,*()2,"H'((,-"H%-,"(7'$"L-%F)(*e"4&)3,$D,"F-%E"4$(-,5-,$,6-)'C"M7%)D,*:P"M4L."g)*D6**)%$"L'5,-"j%A"b!a^:"B(%D/7%CE"BD7%%C"%F"4D%$%E)D*:"g,D,E?,-";99XA"

\%E5,-*:"L'6C:"'$3"@%*7"T,-$,-:"N17,"Q,$(6-,"M'5)('C".,&%C6()%$:P!M2#&,'$!2*!5-2,2@)-!?+&.6+-%)3+.:"!aJ;KZ!ba0<`A"

I%F*(,3,:"\,,-(: "#$%#&+N.!"2,.+O#+,-+.B!1,%+&,'%)2,'$!()**+&+,-+.!),!L2&>E=+$'%+4!C'$#+.:"=,&,-C>"I)CC*:"B'2,"L6?C)D'()%$*:"!_`9A"

I*6:"g'&)3"IA:"'$3"H'-()$"i,$$,>:"N[-2'$)h)$2"Q,$(6-,"M'5)('CZ"17,".)*,"'$3"g,E)*,"%F"8E,-)D'$".,*,'-D7"'$3"g,&,C%5E,$(:"!_b<0^XP"6$56?C)*7,3"5'5,-:"V7'-(%$";99bA"

T'E%$(: H)D7qC,:!:2,+IG!:2&'$.G!',4 :',,+&.B!;/+!"#$%#&+!2*!%/+!7&+,-/!',4!0@+&)-',!J66+&E:)44$+!"$'..:"M7)D'2%Z"R$)&,-*)(>"%F"M7)D'2%"L-,**:"!__;AA"

H'D7'3%".%*':"M'('-)$'"g'$('*:"'$3"i-)*())$'".''3,:"NL-%F)('?)C)(>"%F"Q,$(6-,"M'5)('C"#$&,*(E,$(")$"46-%5,"'$3"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*:P"46-%5,'$"M%EE)**)%$:"g)-,D(%-'(,0\,$,-'C"F%-"4D%$%E)D"'$3"+)$'$D)'C"8FF')-*:"4D%$%E)D"L'5,-"j%A";ba:"H'-D7";99<A"

HDMC,CC'$3:"g'&)3"MA:!;/+!0-/)+3),8!F2-)+%I:"L-)$D,(%$Z"Q'$"j%*(-'$3:"!_<!A"

[G,$0BE)(7:"@'*%$:"H'**)E%".)DD'?%$):"+'?)%"L'EE%CC):"'$3"V'C(,-"L%G,CC:"N8"M%E5'-)*%$"%F"RABA"'$3"46-%5,'$"R$)&,-*)(>0#$36*(->".,C'()%$*")$"(7,"T)F,"BD),$D,*:!:','8+@+,%!F-)+,-+"

L%G,CC:"V'C(,-"VA:"'$3"@'*%$"[G,$0BE)(7:"NR$)&,-*)(),*"'$3"(7,"H'-/,("F%-"#$(,CC,D(6'C"L-%5,-(>")$"(7,"T)F,"BD),$D,*:P!M2#&,'$!2*!?2$)-I!0,'$I.).!',4!:','8+@+,%:"!^Z;aX0^^:"!__`n

Page 20: CCSWP13 Shiller

;9"

.%32,-*:"g'$),C"1A:!0%$',%)-!"&2..),8.B!F2-)'$!?2$)%)-.!),!'!?&28&+..)3+!08+:"=,CC/$'5"L-,**:";999A"

B7)CC,-:".%?,-("@A: :'-&2!:'&>+%.B!"&+'%),8!1,.%)%#%)2,.!*2&!:','8),8!F2-)+%IN.!9'&8+.%!5-2,2@)-!=).>.:"[WF%-3Z"[WF%-3"R$)&,-*)(>"L-,**:"!__XA"

rrrrrrrr:!;/+!P+<!7),',-)'$!Q&4+&B!=).>!),!%/+!RS!.%!"+,%#&I:"L-)$D,(%$Z"L-)$D,(%$"R$)&,-*)(>"L-,**:";99XA"

B7)CC,-:".%?,-("@A:"H'W)E"=%>D/%"'$3"QC'3)E)-"i%-%?%&:"sI6$()$2"F%-"I%E%"B%&),()D6*Z"B)(6'()%$'C"&,-*6*"8(()(63)$'C"+'D(%-*")$"4D%$%E)D"=,7'&)%-:s!A&22>),8.!?'6+&.!2,!5-2,2@)-!0-%)3)%I:"55A"!;^0_b:"!__;0#A"

rrrrrrrr:"sL%56C'-"8(()(63,*"1%G'-3*"+-,,"H'-/,(*Z""17,"B%&),("R$)%$"'$3"(7,"R$)(,3"B('(,*"M%E5'-,3:s!0@+&)-',!5-2,2@)-!=+3)+<:"`!ZX:"X`a0b99:"@6$,"!__!A"

B)$$:"I'$*"V,-$,-:!1.%!(+#%.-/$',4!,2-/!K#!=+%%+,T"RCC*(,)$:";99XA