ebm- case reportdlweb01.tzuchi.com.tw/dl/edu/ebm/interncase/pdf/9608/一般外科-2.pdf · although...
TRANSCRIPT
EBM- Case Report
Supervisor:Dr.魏昌國
Presenter:Int.江元宏
2007. Aug. 10
Patient data
Name:謝○財
ID: Q100632702 Age: 56 years old
Sex: Male
ECOG: Gr. 1~2
Date of transfer : 2007/07/27
Date of operation: 2007/07/27
Chief complaint:
incidental finding of liver tumor for 1 month
Brief history
Under lying disease: DM, HTN.
2007. March: ESRD with CAPD;
Dx of HCV infection
2007. June.12: AFP-122ng/ml
� PE: No specific findings
� a series of image studies
Non-Contrast CT
Contrast CT- Arterial phase
Contrast CT- Portal venous phase
Contrast CT- Venous phase
Angiography
Diagnosis: HCC over S7~8 (2.5cm nodule)
Operation: S7-8 segmentectomy on 7/27
Clinical problem:
Does ESRD affect the outcome (surgical morbidity, mortality and long-term survival ) of patient with HCC treated with hepatectomy?
The Structure of The Question
Patient / Problem Patient with HCC treated with liver resection
Exposure (prognostic/ risk factors)
Status with ESRD
Comparison (control) Status without ESRD
Outcome Morbidity and mortality rates
after surgery, long-term survival rate
Key words:
Hepatocellular carcinoma, HCC
End stage renal disease, chronic renal failure,
=> (Hepatocellular carcinoma OR HCC) AND (End stage renal disease OR chronic renal failure)
Screen Results:
A
B
Methods and PopulationsRetrospective study
1982 to 2001,
1224 consecutive HCC p’ts under surgeryy
at the Department of Surgery, CGMH, Taipei, Taiwan.
26 of 1224 (2.1%): ESRD-HCC (25 HD, 1 PD)
1198 of 1224 (97.9%): HCC only
67 of 1198 (HCC group) : loss of follow-up (excluded from
survival analysis)
All other 1157 p’ts(1224 -67)were followed regularly until death.
Retrospective study
1989 to 1999
468 patients with primary HCC who had undergone curative liver resection for HCC
12 of 468 (2.6%): ESRD-HCC (12 HD)
456 of 468 (97.4%): HCC only
All patients were followed-up until December 2000
A B
Data collectionPre-OP:
- Demographics
- Symptomatology
- Physical examination
- Laboratory data
- Presence of cirrhosis
OP findings and extent of resections
Post-OP:
- Pathological features
- morbidity
- surgical mortality
- long-term survival rate
- long-term disease free survival rate
Pre-OP:
- Demographics
- Laboratory data
- Presence of cirrhosis
OP findings and extent of resections
- the process of OP
Post-OP:
- Pathological features
- morbidity
- surgical mortality
- long-term survival rate
- long-term disease free survival rate
A B
Results: DemographicsA
Results: lab. dataA
Results: (OP, Pathology, Post-OP complication)A
Results AnalysisA
Univariate analysis:ESRD-HCC:↑ associated disease (HTN, DM)
↑ physical signs of anemia,
↓ HBV positivity, ↑HCV positivity,
↓ Hb and PLT, ↑ BUN, Cre
↓ AFP(>400ng/ml) levels,↓ tumor size,
↑ complications, and ↑ stay at hospital
Multivariate logistic regression analysis:elevated BUN and Cre were the only two independent factors differentiating ESRD-HCC from HCC
Results: long-term follow-upA
n=1131
n=1131
All the 1157 p’ts(1224 - 67)were followed regularly until death.
Duration of follow-up::::26 ESRD-HCC:0.01 to 97.6 mo (median = 15.0 mo)1131 HCC: 0.01 to 213.5 mo (median = 14.6 mo)
Overall survival rates (OS):ESRD-HCC:1-, 3-, and 5-years: 82.0%, 38.1%, 38.1%HCC: 1-, 3-, and 5-year: 70.6%, 48.6%, 34.8%P= 0.7034
Disease-free survival rates (DFS):ESRD-HCC: 1-, 3-, and 5-years: 63.1%, 49.1%, 16.4%HCC: 1-, 3-, and 5-years: 55.2%, 35.4%, 26.9%P=0.6123
Results: long-term follow-upA
Elevated BUN and Cre values were the only two independent factors differentiating ESRD-HCC from HCC patients
ESRD should not be a contraindication of hepatic resection in HCC patients; however, careful operative techniques and perioperative care are crucial to
achieving lower morbidity and mortality.
The long-term results of HCC patients with and without
ESRD were also not significantly different
Summary:A
ResultsB
A+
A+A+
A-
ResultsB
A+
A+
A-
ResultsB A-
ResultsB A-
ResultsB
P=0.54
P=0.31
All patients were followed-up until December 2000
Disease-free survival rates (DFS):ESRD-HCC: 5-years: 67.8%
HCC:5-year: 53.3%
P=0.31
Overall survival rates (OS):ESRD-HCC: 5-years: 35%
HCC:5-year: 34.2%
P= 0.54
Results: long-term follow-upB
Background and pathologic character: similar in both group, except Hb and Cre
The long-term results of HCC patients with and without
ESRD were also not significantly different
SummaryB
EBM Analysis
Source population well described?
Eligible population well described?
Participants represents of eligibles?
Eligible population at common point in
course of condition (stage of condition)?
Were relevant personal (prognostic)
characteristics in participants reported?
Population~ Representative
~
x
x
x
~
x
x
x
x
A B
~
EBM Analysis
Exposure and comparison measures well described and valid?
Were exposure & comparison groups similar at baseline? Appropriately adjusted?
Were exposure / comparison status
change during follow-up?
All participants accounted for at study
conclusion?
Exposure & Comparison~
~
~
x
x
A B
~
~
x
x
++
EBM Analysis
Outcome measures well described & valid?
Outcome assessment blind?
Outcome measurement complete?
Outcomes~ Measured well
x
~
A B
+
x
+
-
EBM Analysis
Similar follow-up time in exposure & comparison groups?
Was follow-up time meaningful?
Intention to follow analysis?
(Effect) estimates given or calculable?
(Precision of effect) estimates given or
calculable?
Time
+
A B
x
~
~
Results
~
A B
+
~
x
~ ~
EBM Analysis
Internal vaild?
Are results precise enough to be
meaningful?
External valid? (applicability)
Summary~
~
+
-
~
~
-
A B
Big Problem
My Conclusion
Population continues to be the big problem in
the future.
Until know, there was no other more evidence
study.
Although there were many poor EBM levels in
these 2 studies, they could render a hint or
reference to our clinical practice.
Thanks for your attention!
★
★
Comment
Dr.李宜恭:所以你認為這兩篇Journal最大的問題在於?
Ans: 最大的問題在於選取的樣本數未清楚交代,易產生selection bias
Dr.李宜恭:你的結論跟想法?
Ans: 基本上這兩篇的evidence層面都不是很強,但是已經是目前發表出來最大型且最高證據強度的文章,因此我的看法是”目前來看,沒有答案,但是對於surgeron的角度來看,臨床上目前沒有證據認為這是不好的prognostic factor”
Dr.尹文耀:這篇文章的確以EBM角度來看,不足以成為practice guideline,但是他在臨床上可以”encourage”外科醫師去幫這類病人開刀,才不會使得有些curable的patient因為ESRD而沒有被適當處置。