ecj decisions greece

75
Δέσποινα Δ .Φερεντίνου INKWELLS 1 Summertime by Mary Cassatt, c. 1894 Saturday, 28 January 2017 ΑΠΟΦΑΣΕΙΣ ΤΟΥ ΔΙΚΑΣΤΗΡΙΟΥ ΠΟΥ ΑΦΟΡΟΎΝΤΗΝΕΛΛΑΔΑ A) Απόφαση στην υπόθεση C- 584/14:Επιτροπή κατά Ελλάδας B) Απόφαση στην υπόθεση C- 167/14:Επιτροπή κατά Ελλάδας C) Απόφαση στην υπόθεση C- 292/14:Ελληνικό Δημόσιο κατά Στρουμπούλη D) Απόφαση στην υπόθεση T- 450/12 Αλέξιος Αναγνωστάκης κατά Επιτροπής E) Απόφαση στην υπόθεση C- 431/14 Ελλάδα κατά Επιτροπής

Upload: despina-ferentinou

Post on 08-Feb-2017

108 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • . INKWELLS

    *Summertimeby Mary Cassatt, c. 1894

    Saturday, 28 January 2017 C-584/14: C-167/14: C-292/14: T-450/12 C-431/14

  • La Via del fuoco, 1881 Telemaco Signorini

    I) H 10 30 000 . (s.3-6)II) H 10 3,64 .(s. 7-11) III) 80/987 . (s.12-16) IV) T . . (s.18-24) V) 425 . (s.26-54)

    . (s.55-75)

    *

    *

  • : . 87/16 , 7 2016 C-584/14 2009 , 10 30 000 .

    *Portrait of Eleonora Tommasi, c. 1884

  • http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016-09/cp160087el.pdf 10 2009 , , . , , , , . , , , .

    *

  • C-584/14:

    , , , , . . , , , 30 000 2009, 2009. , , , , , 10 .

    *

  • C-584/14:

    2014 , 25 2013, 2009, , . 2009., 25 2013, ( ) .

    *

  • : . 126/15 , 15 2015 C-167/14: Hills in Settignano Telemaco Signorin

    , 10 3,64 . 2007.

    *

  • http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2015-10/cp150126el.pdf ( ). , , 15 000 31 2000 . , . 30 15 000 , 2006 . 25 20073, 23 / .

    *

  • C-167/14: 2007 6 23 ( , , , , ), , 2014, . , 47 462,40 2007 5 191,20 2007 .. v , 2007, , (25 2011), .

    *

  • C-167/14: 2007, . , . , , , , , 2007. , .

    *

  • C-167/14: , , 2007. , , . , , , 20 000 , 3,64 , 2007. , , , , 10 .

    *

  • : . 19/16 , 25 2016 C-292/14:

    Vincent van Gogh: Starry Night Over the Rhone Arles September 1888

    .

    .

    *

  • http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016-02/cp160019el.pdf

    , Montego Bay 1982 , . . 1994 , , . , , , . 1994. . , 1994. , . , , . , ( ),

    *

  • C-292/14: , , . , . , 80/987, . , , , . , 80/987 . .

    *

  • C-292/14: . , . , . , , , .

    *

  • http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EL/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A31980L0987 80/987/EOK 20 1980

    Intrieur(1880 Gustave Caillebotte)

    2321

    136 - 23.06.1995

    file:///C:/Users/Guest/Downloads/document%20(40).pdf*

    *

  • http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EL/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12012E/TXT - - - - - 13 2007 - Sangliers dans la neige, orWild boars in the snow. Rosa Bonheur 1870

    Le monarque de la meute,The Monarch of the herd

    *

  • . 108/15 , 30 2015 T-450/12 View of the Forest of Fontainebleau(1830) Jean-Baptiste-Camile Corot

    , , . , , .

    *

  • http://webtv.ert.gr/ert3/nees-agrotikes-kinitopiisis-sta-diodia-malgaron/

    The Bridge at Narni,1826

    The Yellow Fiel)ds at Gennevilliers1884

    *

  • http://webtv.ert.gr/ert3/10dek2016-agroweek/

    Potato Planters, 1861

    Woman Baking Bread, 1854

    *

  • http://webtv.ert.gr/ert3/26noe2016-agroweek/ Country Girl Leaning Against a Ladder, c. 1885: Silvestro Lega

    Shepherdess seated on a Rock,1856

    *

  • http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2015-09/cp150108el.pdf , , , , , ( ). , , . , . , , , 13 2012. , , , . ( 119 144 ).

    *

  • T-450/12 : 6 2012, . . , . . , . . 122, 1, , , , , , . , . , . , , , , .

    *

  • T-450/12: 122, 2, , , ad hoc . , , . , , , , 2 122 . , 136 , . , , 136 .

    *

  • : . 26/16 , 8 2016 C-431/14 P Portrait of Rosa Bonheur1857 Edouard Louis Dubufe

    425 .

    *

  • http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016-03/cp160026el.pdf 2009, () 800.000 425 2008 . , , 145 2008 2009. , , , 500 . 7 2011 , , , , . , , .

    *

  • C-431/14: . 2012, , . , , 2014, . , , . .

    *

  • C-431/14

    , , , . , , , , , . , , , 2009, , . , , , . , , . , , , 6 , , , , . .

    *

  • C-431/14: , , . , , , , , , , , . , .

    *

  • http://curia.europa.eu/juris/liste.jsf?language=el&jur=C,T,F&num=431/14&td=ALL

    The Sower, 1850 Jean-Franois Millet

    *The Sheepfold.

  • ( ) 8 2016 () 2008 2009 107, 3, , : , 16 2014 (T52/12, EU:T:2014:677, : ) 2012/157/ , 7 2011, () 2008 2009 ( L 78, . 21, : ).

    *Going to Work, 185153

  • 4.1 , , 17 2008 ( 2009, C16, .1, ), : , , , , [ ] [] [107], 3, [, ]. 4.2.2, , : [ ] [] [107], 3, , [], :) [].

    *

  • 7 :[...] [ 2002, C119, .22], , , :) , 17 2008) , .[...]5 31 2009 (C261, .2, : ). 1 :[...] , 4.2 [ ], [] . , , .[...] [] .6 4.2.2, , : [ ] [] [107], 3, , [], :[...])[...] [] ( ) 15 000 [] [...].7 28 2009.

    *

  • 11 , 2009, , 2008 , , 262037 , 30 2009, , ( 155/2.2.2009, : ), 425 . , , , .12 20 2009, , , 2008, 386986648, . , 88353000, 444 , , , .13 27 2010 ( C 72, .12), , 108, 2, , C 3/10 ( NN39/09), 2008 2009 ( : ). 7 2011, .

    *

  • : 11. [] 2008 2009 .2. [] 2008 [] , 349493652,03[] , , 91500[] , . 2008 [] .3. [] 27614905[] 2009 [ ] [] . [] 387404547[], 28 2009, [] , , , () 1535/2007 [ , 20 2007, [107 108 ] (de minimis) ( L 337, . 35)].

    *

  • 2The Angelus, 185759

    1. [ ] , , 1 .2. .[]4. , .

    *

  • , , , , , 186000000 , .27, , 107, 1, , , . , 117 120 , , , , (., , Steinike & Weinlig, 78/76, EU:C:1977:52, 22 PreussenElektra, C379/98, EU:C:2001:160, 58 , C482/99, EU:C:2002:294, 23, 24 37, Doux levage Cooprative agricole UKLARREE, C677/11, EU:C:2013:348, 35 ).

    *

  • 28 , 121 129 , . , 122 ( , C355/00, EU:C:2003:298, 81), 2008, , . , , . , 130 133 , 2009 , .

    *

  • 29, 107, 1, , , . , , 59 64 , , . , 66 68 , , , 107, 1, , ( , C251/97, EU:C:1999:480, 37 , C409/00, EU:C:2003:92, 48, France Tlcom , C81/10P, EU:C:2011:811, 17 ).

    *

  • 30, 102 . , , , . , (. , C372/97, EU:C:2004:234, 44, Forum 187 , C182/03 C217/03, EU:C:2006:416, 131 ). , , , , , (., , , C114/00, EU:C:2002:508, 47, , C278/00, EU:C:2004:23, 69 70).

    *

  • The Potato Harvest: Millet 1855

    31, , , , ., , , ., , , .

    *

  • 32 , , 2009 , , , , , . , , 29 30 , , , (C75/97, EU:C:1999:311, 66 67), (C310/99, EU:C:2002:143, 98 99), (EU:C:2004:234, 104), .

    *

  • 33, , 107, 29 30 , , , , . 2 3 . 107, 3, , , , , , . , , , .

    *

  • The Gleaners Millet 1857

    34, , , . , , , . , , , , .

    *

  • Hunting Birds at Night, 1874 Millet

    35 , 107, 3, , , . , 107, 3, , , 2009, . .

    *

  • 36 , 159 160 , , 107, 1, ( , C277/00, EU:C:2004:238, 20 ). , 161 , , 107, 3, , , ( .. Kronofrance, C75/05P C80/05P, EU:C:2008:482, 59 ). , , ( DM Transport, C256/97, EU:C:1999:332, 16 ).

    *

  • 37, , .. Kronofrance (EU:C:2008:482, 60 61 ) Holland Malt (C464/09P, EU:C:2010:733, 46 47), 186 187 92 , (C288/96, EU:C:2000:537, 62), , , , , . , , , .

    *

  • 38 146 189 , , 107, 3, , . , , 148 166 , , 168 184 , , , ( 2009, C261, .2), , 28 2009, . 185 189 , 107, 3, , .

    *

  • 39, , , , 107, 3, , . , , , . , , , . , , .40, , , , , , , , .

    *

  • 41, , , . , , , . , , . 175 179 , , , .

    *

  • 42, , , , , , , 190 203 , . , , 194 , 1535/2007, , , 198 , , , , .

    *

  • 43 , , , , . , , , , .44 , , , , .

    *

  • 45 , , , , , ( , C142/87, EU:C:1990:125, 66 ). , 14, 1, () 659/1999 , 22 1999, [108] ( L83, .1), [] , []. [ ].

    *

  • 46 , , , . , .47 fumus boni juris. , . , :1) .2) .

    *

  • INKWELLSAmong the Vines Louveciennes, 1874Alfred Sisley

    Sentier de la Mi-cote, Louveciennes, 1873 Alfred Sisley

    *

  • Berthe Morisot,Portrait de Mme Morisot et de sa fille Mme Pontillon ou La lecture(The Mother and Sister of the Artist - Marie-Josphine & Edma) 1869/7

    COUNCIL REGULATION (EEC) No 855/84 of 31 March 1984 on the calculation and the dismantlement of the monetary compensatory amounts applying to certain agricultural productshttp://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:31984R0855&rid=1 (Regulation: 855/84) ...differing prices in the various Member States; whereas these price differences must, for the purposes of trade, be compensated for by the application of monetary compensatory amounts; .. Article 3: 1 . Any special aid granted to German agricultural producers under the conditions referred to below shall be deemed to be compatible with the common market. 2. The Federal Republic of Germany shall be authorized to grant separately the special aid by payment mentioned in the invoicing and/or the VAT declaration using the VAT as an instrument. The aid may not exceed 3 /o of the ex-VAT price paid by the purchaser for the agricultural product.

    ..

  • 5.10.1999 C-251/97 5 1999 http://curia.europa.eu/juris/showPdf.jsf?text=&docid=44754&pageIndex=0&doclang=EL&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=507469 Teaby Mary Cassatt, 1880

    ...13 ; 1 :, de minimis, 100 000 ECU , 92, 1, 61, 1, 92, 2 3, 61, 2 3, . ...

    *

  • NIAL FENNELLY 26 1998 22. . . , , , . . , ( ), . http://curia.europa.eu/juris/showPdf.jsf?text=&docid=43741&pageIndex=0&doclang=EL&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=507469

    *

  • ( ) 13 2003 - - C-409/00, http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&docid=48053&pageIndex=0&doclang=EL&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=512143

    Les orangers (1878)

    5.. , , .6. , , , 70 % . 85 000 (ESP) ESP, 511 6 010 . 8,5 %.7. . , . , , . . , ' .

    *

  • SIEGBERT ALBER 10 2002

    http://curia.europa.eu/juris/showPdf.jsf?text=&docid=47634&pageIndex=0&doclang=EL&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=523467

    40. , , , , 6 2000, C-287/95 C-288/95 , Solvay ( 2000, . -2391, 49 . . , , 15 1997, C-355/95 , TWD ( 1997, . -2549, 21) .43. , . . . MME , .

    *

  • C-409/00 SIEGBERT ALBER ) 72. de minimis , . , . . 2) 74. 87, 1, . 75. , 87 . , , . 14 1997, C-169/95, ( 1997, . -135, 34) 5 2000, C-288/96, ( 2000, . -8237, 26), 7 2002, C-310/99, ( 2002, . -2289, 46).

    *

  • C-409/00 SIEGBERT ALBER 114. de minimis . 115. 19 2000, , , . . . [ 11 1987, 259/85, - ( 1987,.4393, 24), 21 1991, C-303/88, ( 1991, . -1433, 27)]3) 118. de minimis , . de minimis , .

    *

  • NIILO JSKINEN 8 2011 C81/10 P France Tlcom SAPortraits la campagne(1876) Muse Baron Grard,

    86. , . , , 249 , . , ,

    ......*

  • NIILO JSKINEN47. 87 E, (16). [ : . AdriaWien Pipeline Wietersdorfer & Peggauer Zementwerke, ( 41), 13 2003, C409/00, ( 2003, . I1487, 47), 11 2008, C428/06 C434/06, UGTRioja .. ( 2008, . I6747, 46), 22 2008, C487/06P, British Aggregates ( 2008, . I10515, 82).]23. , , , 1991 1993 . , ( 22 33 53 ).27., France Tlcom, , , ( 42 ).

    *

  • NIILO JSKINEN190. . , .194., , , . , , , , , .195. , , , , 14, 1, 659/1999, .

    *

  • ( ) 13 2003 C-409/00Caillebotte in his greenhouse (February 1892, Petit Gennevilliers

    47: , 92, 1, , , , , , ( 8 2001, C-143/99, Adria-Wien Pipeline Wietersdorfer & Peggauer Zementwerke, 2001, . -8365, 41 ., , , 1 1998, C-200/97, Ecotrade, 1998, . -7907, 41, 17 1999, , , 26). , .

    *

  • ( ) 8 2001.Adria-Wien Pipeline GmbH Wietersdorfer & Peggauer Zementwerke GmbH Finanzlandesdirektion fr Krnten. : Verfassungsgerichtshof - . - - . C-143/99.

    , , 92 (, , 87 ), , . 41 92 , , , (. 7 1988, 57/86, , 1988, . 2855, 10). , , , 92, 1, , , (. 17 1999, C-75/97, , 1999, . I-3671, 28 31).42 , , , (. 2 1974,173/73, , 1974, . 351, 33, , 33).http://curia.europa.eu/juris/showPdf.jsf?text=&docid=46829&pageIndex=0&doclang=EL&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=572807

    *

  • ADRIA-WIEN PIPELINE WIETERSDORFER & PEGGAUER ZEMENTWERKE JEAN MISCHO 8 2001Flower Myth(Blumen mythos) 1918

    28. , 3, , ' , , , .

    *

  • ADRIA-WIEN PIPELINE WIETERSDORFER & PEGGAUER ZEMENTWERKE JEAN MISCHO 8 200129. , , . 30. , , , , ' . 31. , , , 0,35 % , 92 .

    *

  • ADRIA-WIEN PIPELINE WIETERSDORFER & PEGGAUER ZEMENTWERKE JEAN MISCHO 8 200135. 19 1999 C-6/97, 4, : , , , ' , , , 92, 1, .36. , , , , , , ( 3 ).55. , ' .

    *

  • ; JEAN MISCHO

    66. Philip Morris 17 1980, 730/79 , , , . 67. , , . 2 1974, , 36. .68. , , 0,35 % , ' , .69. , . .

    *

  • ; JEAN MISCHO70. , 47 Maribel bis/ter, , , , . . 72. , 0,35 % , , , . 73. , , ' , , , , , .

    *

  • ; JEAN MISCHO74. , Adria-Wien . , . 75. , , , .76. , , , . . 77. , 92 , . , 0,35 % .

    *

  • ; JEAN MISCHO81. , , Adria-Wien, . 92, 1, . 82. , Verwaltungsgerichtshof: 1) , , , , 92, 1, (, , 87, 1, ). 2) , .

    *

  • THANK YOU! Despina Ferentinou La Pergola, 1868, Milan.Silvestro Lega

    Royale ala maison: Rosa Bonheur

    *

    *

    *