eddy current chapter 4 procedures

102
Electromagnetic Testing - Eddy Current Testing Procedures 2014-December My ASNT Level III Pre-Exam Preparatory Self Study Notes 外围学习中 Charlie Chong/ Fion Zhang

Upload: cc-chong

Post on 06-Jul-2015

650 views

Category:

Engineering


9 download

DESCRIPTION

Eddy current chapter 4 procedures

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Electromagnetic Testing -Eddy Current Testing Procedures2014-DecemberMy ASNT Level III Pre-Exam Preparatory Self Study Notes外围学习中

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhanghttpmicrowavesoftcomeddycurrenthtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy Current Signals

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- Calibration

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- OD Crack

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 2: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhanghttpmicrowavesoftcomeddycurrenthtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy Current Signals

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- Calibration

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- OD Crack

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 3: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy Current Signals

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- Calibration

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- OD Crack

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 4: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy Current Signals

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- Calibration

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- OD Crack

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 5: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- Calibration

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- OD Crack

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 6: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals- OD Crack

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 7: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Calibration Signalsig_ectcalavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 8: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pit - Singlesig_idpit_1avi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 9: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID Pits Multilplesig_idpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 10: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-ID pit at supportsig_idpit_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 11: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Pit Singlesig_odpitavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 12: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Cracksig_odcrkavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 13: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-OD Crack at Supportsig_odcrk_supavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 14: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Damage at Supportsig_support_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 15: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-MIC damagesig_micavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 16: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Eddy current signals-Vibration Damagesig_vibration_damageavi

httpwwwndecomect_signalshtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 17: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 18: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

同桌的你

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 19: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 20: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Fion Zhang at Shanghai2014November

httpmeilishouxihublog163com

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang Shanghai 上海

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 21: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Greek letter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 22: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

4 TESTING PROCEDURES41 Influence of defect position and orientation

Eddy currents induced by a changing magnetic field concentrate near the surface adjacent to the excitation coil The depth of penetration decreases with test frequency and is a function of electrical conductivity and magnetic permeability of the specimen This phenomenon is known as the skin effect and is analogous to the situation in terrestrial heat conduction where daily surface temperature fluctuations are not appreciable below the earthrsquos surface Skin effect arises as follow the eddy currents flowing in the test object at any depth produce magnetic fields which oppose the primary field thus reducing net magnetic flux and causing a decrease in current follow as depth increases Alternatively eddy currents near the surface can be viewed as shielding the coilrsquos magnetic field thereby weakening the magnetic field atgreater depths and reducing induced currents

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 23: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

411 Eddy current pathEddy currents are closed loops in induced current circulating in planes perpendicular to the magnetic flux They normally travel parallel to the coilrsquos winding and parallel to the surface Eddy current flow is limited to the area of the inducing magnetic field Test frequency determines depth of penetration into the specimen as frequency is increased penetration decreases and eddy current distribution becomes denser near the specimenrsquos surface Test frequency also affects the sensitivity to changes in material properties and defects FIG 41 shows the relationship of eddy current distribution with depth into the specimen and increasing phase lag with depth Both the eddy currents and magnetic flux get weaker with depth because of lsquoskin effectrsquo In addition to this attenuation eddy currents lag in phase with depth Eddy currentsrsquo phase lag is the key parameter that makes eddy current testing a useful testing method

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 24: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

412 Penetration depth amp phase lagEddy current density decreases exponentially with depth The depth at which eddy current density has decreased to 1e or 368 of the surface density is called the standard depth of penetration The word lsquostandardrsquo denotes plane wave electromagnetic field excitation within the test sample The standard depth of penetration is given by

Wheref = frequencyσ = IACSμr = relative permeabilityρ = resistivity mW-cm

(41a)

(41b)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 25: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 26: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Depth of Penetration amp Current Density

httpwwwsuraguscomencompanyeddy-current-testing-technology

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 27: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Standard Depth Calculation

Where μ = μ0 x μr

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 28: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The applet below illustrates how eddy current density changes in a semi-infinite conductor The applet can be used to calculate the standard depth of penetration The equation for this calculation is

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 29: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

1e or 37 of surface density at target

(1e)3 or 5 of surface density at material interface

Defect Detection Electrical conductivity measurement

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 30: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Alternatively

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 31: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The skin depth equation is strictly true only for infinitely thick material and planar magnetic fields Using the standard depth δ calculated from the above equation makes it a materialtest parameter rather than a true measure of penetration

FIG 41 Eddy current distribution with depth in a thick plate and resultant phase lag

(1e)

(1e)2

(1e)3

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 32: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Sensitivity to defects depends on eddy current density at defect location Although eddy currents penetrate deeper than one standard depth (δ) of penetration they decrease rapidly with depth At two standard depths of penetration (2δ ) eddy current density has decreased to (1 e)2 or 135 of the surface density At three depths (3δ) the eddy current density is down to only (1 e)3 or 5 of the surface density

However one should keep in mind these values only apply to thick sample (thickness t gt 5r ) and planar magnetic excitation fields Planar field conditions require large diameter probes (diameter gt 10t) in plate testing or long coils (length gt 5t) in tube testing Real test coils will rarely meet these requirements since they would possess low defect sensitivity For thin plate or tube samples current density drops off less than calculated from Eq (41) For solid cylinders the overriding factor is a decrease to zero at the centre resulting from geometry effects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 33: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

One should also note that the magnetic flux is attenuated across the sample but not completely Although the currents are restricted to flow within specimen boundaries the magnetic field extends into the air space beyond This allows the inspection of multi-layer components separated by an air space The sensitivity to a subsurface defect depends on the eddy current density at that depth it is therefore important to know the effective depth of penetration The effective depth of penetration is arbitrarily defined as the depth at which eddy current density decreases to 5 of the surface density For large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ the eddy currents being attenuated more than predicted by the skin depth equation

KeywordsFor large probes and thick samples this depth is about three standard depths of penetration Unfortunately for most components and practical probe sizes this depth will be less than 3δ

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 34: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface The generation of eddy currents can be thought of as a time dependent process meaning that the eddy currents below the surface take a little longer to form than those at the surface Disruptions in the eddy currents away from the surface will produce more phase lag than disruptions near the surface Both the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

KeywordsBoth the signal voltage and current will have this phase shift or lag with depth which is different from the phase angle discussed earlier (With the phase angle the current shifted with respect to the voltage)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 35: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag is an important parameter in eddy current testing because it makes it possible to estimate the depth of a defect and with proper reference specimens determine the rough size of a defect The signal produced by a flaw depends on both the amplitude and phase of the eddy currents being disrupted A small surface defect and large internal defect can have a similar effect on the magnitude of impedance in a test coil However because of the increasing phase lag with depth there will be a characteristic difference in the test coil impedance vector

Phase lag can be calculated with the following equation The phase lag angle calculated with this equation is useful for estimating the subsurface depth of a discontinuity that is concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack that spans many depths must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 36: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase Lag 相位滞后

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surfaceδ = standard depth of penetration

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 37: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwazomcomarticleaspxArticleID=10953

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 38: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase and current density change with depth of penetration

httpwwwndtnetarticleecndt027474htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 39: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

At one standard depth of penetration the phase lag is one radian or 57o This means that the eddy currents flowing at one standard depth of penetration (δ) below the surface lag the surface currents by 57o At two standard depths of penetration (2 δ) they lag the surface currents by 114o Therefore by measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be estimated On the impedance plane the liftoff signal serves as the reference phase direction The angle between the liftoff and defect signals is about twice the phase lag calculated with the above equation

As mentioned above discontinuities that have a significant dimension normal to the surface will produce an angle that is based on the weighted average of the disruption to the eddy currents at the various depths along its length

Keywords By measuring the phase lag of a signal the depth of a defect can be

estimated Weighted average

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 40: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase lag - More reading

Phase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material Phase lag is the shift in time between the eddy current response from a disruption on the surface and a disruption at some distance below the surface

The phase lag angle is useful for estimating the distance below the surface of discontinuities that concentrated at a specific depth Discontinuities such as a crack must be divided into sections along its length and a weighted average determined for phase and amplitude at each position below the surface For more information see the page explaining phase lag

KeywordsPhase lag is a parameter of the eddy current signal that makes it possible to obtain information about the depth of a defect within a material

httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 41: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpswwwnde-edorgGeneralResourcesFormulaECFormulaPhaseLag1PhaseLaghtm

Example The phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument Therefore choosing a frequency that results in a standard depth of penetration of 125 times the expected depth of the defect will produce a phase lag of 45o and this should appear as a 90o separation between the liftoff and defect signals

Whereβ = phase lagX = distance below surface in mmδ = standard depth of penetration in mm

Phase lag can be calculated using the equations to the right The second equation simply converts radians to degrees by multiplying by 3602π or 573

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 42: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

KeywordsThe phase lag calculated with these equations should be about frac12 the phase rotation seen between the liftoff signal and a defect signal on an impedance plane instrument

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 43: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

413 Zone of probe action

Eddy currents are closed loops of induces current circulating in a plane perpendicular to the direction of magnetic flux Their normal direction of travel is parallel to the coil winding and parallel to the surface See FIG 42a and FIG 42b Pancake type surface probes are therefore insensitive to poor bonding of coating and flaws parallel to the surface of sample

FIG 42a Directional properties of a surface probe

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 44: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 42b Directional properties of a surface probe for a given crack size

When testing for flaws such as cracks it is essential that the eddy current flow be at a large angle (preferably perpendicular) to the crack to obtain maximum response If eddy current flow is parallel to the defect there will be little or no disruption of currents and hence no coil impedance change When testing for flaws parallel to the surface such as laminations a horseshoe shaped probe (a gap probe with a very large gap) may have reasonable sensitivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 45: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

42 Influence of material temperature

Temperature is an important test variable particularly when eddy currents are used to establish a basic conductivity range for an alloy Consideration must be given to (1) the temperature of the test material (2) the difference in temperature between the test sample and the reference sample and (3) type of eddy current instrument being used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 46: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

421 Influence of temperature on the resistivity

Higher temperature increases the thermal activity of the atoms in a metal lattice The thermal activity causes the atoms to vibrate around their normal positions The thermal vibration of the atoms increases the resistance to electron flow thereby lowering the conductivity of the metal Lower temperature reduces thermal oscillation of the atoms resulting in increasedelectrical conductivity The influence of temperature on the resistivity of a metal can be determined from the following equation

whereRt = resistivity of the metal at the test temperatureR0 = resistivity of the metal at standard temperatureα = resistivity temperature coefficientT = difference between the standard and test temperature (degC)

(43)

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeMaterialsPhysical_ChemicalElectricalhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 47: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

From Eq (43) it can be seen that if the temperature is increased resistivity increases and conductivity decreases from their ambient temperature levels Conversely if temperature is decreased the resistivity decreases and conductivity increases To convert resistivity values such as those obtained from Eq (43) to conductivity in terms of IACS the conversion formula is

IACS = 17241 ρWhereIACS = international annealed copper standardρ = resistivity (unit)

NotemS ndash meter per Siemens Reciprocal of conductivityThe SI unit of electrical resistivity is the ohmmeter (Ωm)

(44)

httpenwikipediaorgwikiElectrical_resistivity_and_conductivity

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 48: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of how well a material accommodates the movement of an electric charge It is the ratio of the current density to the electric field strength Its SI derived unit is the Siemens per meter but conductivity values are often reported as percent IACS IACS is an acronym for International Annealed Copper Standard which was established by the 1913 International Electrochemical Commission The conductivity of the annealed copper (58001 x 107 Sm) is defined to be 100 IACS at 20degC

All other conductivity values are related back to this conductivity of annealed copper Therefore iron with a conductivity value of 104 x 107 Sm has a conductivity of approximately 18 of that of annealed copper and this is reported as 18 IACS

An interesting side note is that commercially pure copper products now often have IACS conductivity values greater than 100 IACS because processing techniques have improved since the adoption of the standard in 1913 and more impurities can now be removed from the metal

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 49: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Unit for Electrical Conductivity

The SI units for conductivity are Siemens per meter (Sm) A Siemen is the reciprocal of an ohm sometimes referred as a ldquomhordquo Conductivity is a function of the inverse of the unit for resistance because conductivity is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity Conductivity is the measure of the quality of a substance to conduct electricity It is a general term measuring the quality of a substance as opposed to a specific conductorrsquos ability to conduct Sometimes conductivity is written micro-Siemens per centimeter However you may need it in SI units to use a table or calculator in Sm

KeywordsConductivity (1Ω or mho) is defined as the reciprocal of resistivity

IACS = 17241ρ ( or 17241 x Conductivity)

httpwwwehowcomhow_5907956_convert-conductivity-unitshtml

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 50: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 51: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 52: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 53: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang httpwwwcenturionndtcomTechnical20Paperscondarticlehtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 54: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

422 Deviations

The conductivity of standards in usually determined at a specific temperature 20degC is most commonly used Typical conductivity values are allowable conductivity ranges also established at approximately this temperature If all instrument calibration and conductivity measurement could be performed at this temperature errors in conductivity measurement related to temperature variation would not occur andor temperature compensation would not be required In field applications testing temperatures can conceivably be anywhere in the range of ndash20 to 50degC Unless precautions are taken in selection of standards calibration of the instrument and testing error can be obtained in the measured conductivity values

Two ways in which erroneous readings occur are

(1) difference in temperature between standards and test part andor (2) difference in temperature at which conductivity of the standard was

originally established and the temperature at which instrument calibration and conductivity measurements are performed

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 55: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

To prevent errors from differences in temperature between standard and test part the instrument and standards should be allowed to stabilize at the test part temperature before calibration and conductivity measurements are performed In no instance should measurements be taken if the part and standard temperatures differ by more than 5degC Even though standards and test part are at the same temperature error in determining conductivity value occurs when the measuring temperature differs from the temperature at which the conductivity of the standards was originally established The magnitude of the error becomes larger as this difference in temperature increases

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 56: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Two other factors also contribute to errors caused by temperature differences

(1) Increased difference in conductivity between the upper and lower reference standards and

(2) Differences in the temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity between references and the test part

These two sources of error can be reduced by decreasing the range between the conductivity standards and using standards of the same or approximately the same temperature coefficient of electrical resistivity as the test part Because all aluminum alloys have approximately the same rate of change of electrical resistivity with temperature change aluminium conductivity standards are preferred for aluminium alloys Conductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

KeywordsConductivity measurements should not be performed under conditions where the relative humidity exceeds 85

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 57: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

423 Compensation

The eddy current conductivity should be corrected by using Equations (43) and (44) In aluminium alloy for example a change of approximately 12 IACS for a 55degC change in temperature using handbook resistivity values of 2828 micro-ohm centimeters and a temperature coefficient of 00039 at 20degC If the conductivity of commercially pure aluminium is 62 IACS at 20degC then one would expect a conductivity of 55 IACS at 48degC and a conductivity of 69 IACS at ndash10degC

IACS = 17241 ρ

(43)

(44)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 58: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)

The most accurate results will be obtained using a high signal to noise ratio A high signal to noise ratio will allow easy identification of a relevant discontinuity with low electronic background noise Background noise can be produced from variables that have no interest to the examiner This would include material configuration surface roughness lift-off permeability andconductivity Abrupt changes in surface curvature result in changes to eddy current signals as probes traverse them It causes changes in coupling creating a large lift-off signal and the curvature also changes eddy current flow distribution creating an effective resistance change yielding a signal at an angle to the lift-off direction The appearance of this type of signal will not change significantly when rescanned at higher and lower test frequency

httpwwwndtnetarticlewcndt00papersidn669idn669htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 59: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Such signals can be difficult to analyze because they depend on how well the probe follows complicated surface curvatures Basically the direction of the impedance change obeys the following rules when using surface probes

(a) Decreasing radius of curvature on an external surface eg ridge produce change in the direction of increasing resistivity

(b) Decreasing radius of curvature of an internal surface eg groove produces a change in the direction of decreasing resistivity

The most troublesome parameter in eddy current testing is lift-off (probe-to-specimen spacing) A small change in lift-off creates a large output signal A particular condition such as lsquowobblersquo can be suppressed by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degaway from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 60: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

431 Choice of test frequency

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control Material properties and geometry are normally fixed and probe choice is often dictated by test material geometry and probe availability Choice of a suitable test frequency depends on the type of inspection Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface defects Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations in material properties and serious defects The above factors show choice of test frequency is usually a compromise

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 61: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Keywords

Test frequency is often the only variable over which the inspector has appreciable control

Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Testing for defects requires penetration to possible defect locations bull surface defects can be detected at higher frequencies than subsurface

defects bull Maximum penetration requires a low frequency which still permits

clear discrimination between signals from harmless variations inmaterial properties and serious defects

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 62: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discussion

Subject Testing for diameter variations normally requires maximum response to fill-factor which occurs at high frequencies (How)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 63: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

432 Phase angle discrimination

In the majority of cases no detailed knowledge of the discontinuity types shapes depths and orientations exists before the start of the eddy current examinations Consequently the majority of the data analysis depends on the phase angle analysis to determine discontinuity parameters

It is important however to detect and to identify discontinuity signals and to separate them from non-relevant background signals before any crack depth analysis can be performed The phase angle discrimination technique is ideally suited for this separation The phase angle discrimination technique depends on the proper choice of test frequencies for providing optimum phase angle separation among different variables For a given test material phase angle orientations among the variables shift because of changing test frequencies This capacity to obtain different information at different frequencies is used

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 64: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Phase angle discrimination

httpwwwndtnetapcndt2001papers224224htm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 65: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The most common practice involving the phase angle discrimination is to rotate the liftoff fill-factor variations to horizontal and monitor the remaining variables Based on this concept of maintaining the lift-offfill-factor as horizontal a detailed comparison of phase angle separations among variables can be determined

It should be emphasized that the selected frequency might not necessarily be the ideal frequency for estimating discontinuity depths The concept of detection first followed by discontinuity analysis has been an excepted (除外) evaluation method

Eq (42)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 66: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

433 FilteringTo accentuate desired frequencies and to eliminate undesired frequencies electronic filtering is employed Three types of filters can be used the high pass the low pass and the band pass High pass filtering utilizes a resistance-capacitance circuit which removes the low frequency components of the eddy current signal from the bridge This type of filtering can eliminate the effect of gradual variations in conductivity or dimensions on the eddy current inspection response Low pass filtering employs signal averaging circuits to remove rapid (high frequency) response from electronic noise and from harmonic frequencies related to variations in magnetic permeability Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range The effects or each type of filter on the recorded appearance of eddy current signals is illustrated in FIG 43

KeywordsBand pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 67: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Band pass filters use combinations of both types of circuitry to promote response over a specific range of frequencies and suppress frequencies above and below this range

httpenwikipediaorgwikiBand-pass_filter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 68: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (12)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 69: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 43 Effects of Filtering (22)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 70: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Other illustration

Unfiltered signal with low frequency variation and high frequency noise

High pass filter employed to remove low frequency variation

Low pass filter employed to remove hig frequency noise

Filtered signal

httpswwwnde-edorgEducationResourcesCommunityCollegeEddyCurrentsProceduresSignalFilteringhtm

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 71: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

434 Magnetic saturation

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations Without saturation the initial permeability of steel products can range from 50 to over 500 Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Keywords Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or

impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 72: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (12)

Eddy current inspection of magnetic materials for defects is difficult or impossible because of random permeability variation In addition there are skin depth limitations

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 73: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Discuss on Eddy current testing of Ferromagnetic materials (22)

Since depth of penetration is inversely proportional to the square root of permeability and test frequency to obtain equal penetration requires a reduction in frequency by the same factor of 50 to over 500 Unfortunately lowering frequency will move the operating point to where there is poor signal separation between lift-off permeability and resistivity as well as reduced sensitivity to defects Therefore magnetic saturation is required to suppress effects of usually harmless permeability variations which could be mistaken for or obscure defect signals

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 74: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Whereδ = Standard Depth of Penetration (mm)π = 314f = Test Frequency (Hz)μ = Magnetic Permeability (Hmm)σ = Electrical Conductivity ( IACS)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 75: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

44 Coupling influence

441 Vibrations

Vibrations during probe motion can make undesirable signals or so called lsquoprobe wobblersquo The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together The resulting sum will result in cancellation of the responses and thus a zero signal for that particular condition

Keywords Coupling influence Wobble- The multi-frequency technique can suppress this effect can by making the amplitude of its response at the first frequency equal and its phase 180 degrees away from the response at the second frequency and then adding the two signals together

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 76: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

442 Lift off

When a surface coil is energized and held in air above a conductor the impedance of the coil has a certain value As the coil is moved closer to the conductor the initial value will change when the field of the coil begins to intercept the conductor Because the field of the coil is strongest close to the coil the impedance value will continue to change until the coil is directly on the conductor Conversely once the coil is on the conductor any small variation in the separation of coil and conductor will change the impedance of the coil The lift off effect is so pronounced that small variations in spacing can mask many indications The lift off effect is regularly used to measure the thickness of non conductive coatings The angle of orientation (tilt) of the probe will also have a significant impact of coupling efficiency The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

Keywords The lift off effect The angle of orientation (tilt angle) effect

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 77: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

443 Centering fill factor η (Eta)

In an encircling coil or an internal coil fill factor ldquoη Etardquo is a measure of how well the conductor (test specimen) fits the coil It is necessary to maintain a constant relationship between the diameter of the coil and the diameter of the conductor Again small changes in the diameter of the conductor can cause changes in the impedance of the coil This can be useful in detecting changes in the diameter of the conductor but it can also mask other indications

For an external coil

Fill Factor η = (D1D2)2 (45)

For an internal coil

Fill Factor η = (D2D1)2 (46)

whereη = fill factorD1 = part diameterD2 = coil diameter

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 78: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Thus the fill factor must be less than 1 since if η = 1 the coil is exactly the same size as the material However the closer the fill factor is to 1 the more precise the test The fill factor can also be expressed as a For maximum sensitivity the fill factor should be as high as possible compatible with easy movement of the probe in the tube Note that the fill factor can never exceed 1 (100)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 79: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

444 Sensitivity

The distribution of eddy currents on a round bar using an encircling coil is such that the field is maximum at the surface and is zero at the centre of the bar The distribution of eddy currents on a flat plate using a surface probe is such that the field is maximum at the surface directly below the coil windings and is zero at the centre of the coil

445 Compensation

To optimize probe coupling numerous techniques can be employed these include

(a) The use of mechanical guideholders and spring loaded probes can assist in reducing the effect of lift off

(b) Appropriate probe diameter to maximize fill factor

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 80: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

45 Influence of relative partprobe speed

451 Instrument frequencies according to speed

Eddy current instruments and recording instrumentation have limited frequency response This means they require finite time to respond to an input signal Frequency response sometimes called speed of response is defined as the frequency at which the output signal falls to 0707 (-3 dB) of the maximum input signal A test coil with an effective sensing width W passing over a localized defect of width w at a speed s will sense the point defect for a duration of ws seconds This signal is approximately equal to one wavelength with a frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 81: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

The Response Frequency (Fr) is the inverse value of the time taken for the probe to cross the fault and can be shown by the formula

whereS = speed of probe movement (mms)W = probe width (mm)w = crack width (mm)

NOTE For practical purposes crack width can be considered as Zero

(47)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 82: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

For example at a probe speed of 05 ms and probe sensing width of 2 mm Fr = 250 hertz If the instrumentation has a frequency response of 250 hertz the output signal is reduced to 0707 the input signal and the X-Y signal is distorted If the instrumentation frequency response is 500 hertz the output signal decreases only slightly For this example the eddy current instrument should have a frequency response equal to or greater than 500 hertz to obtain undistorted signals Or inversely if the instrument frequency response is only 350 hertz the maximum inspection speed should be reduced to 025 ms

KeywordsFInstrument gt FresponseFInstrument = 2 x Fresponse (desirable)

CommentFInstrument is an equipment characteristic determined by the equipment manufacturer by experiment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 83: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

452 Frequency response of apparatus according to testing speed

Some standards specify maximum permissible scanning speed For example according to the Article I-40 of ASME Article 8 Appendix 1 the maximum scanning speed of eddy current probe can be 0356 ms for 100 Hz frequency response system If an eddy current system with a frequency response of 450 Hz is used it allows and scanning speed of 16 ms

Comments

There are 2 response frequencies Instrument response frequency Scanning response frequency

The scanning response frequency lt Instrument response frequency

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 84: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

46 Reference standards used in eddy current testingAnalysis of eddy current signals is for the most part a comparative technique Referencestandards are necessary for comparing signal amplitude and phase (shape) of unknown defectsto known reference defects Reference signals are also used for standardizing instrumentsettings ie sensitivity and phase rotation

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 85: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

461 Function of reference samples

Existing national specifications and standards only supply broad guidelines in choice of test parameters They cannot be used to establish reliable eddy current test procedures for most inspection The effect of the following can be established

(a) Varying electrical resistivity(b) Varying thickness(c) Surface geometry (curvature)(d) Defect length for constant depth(e) Defect depth for constant length(f) Increasing subsurface defect size for constant defect depth(g) Increasing distance of subsurface defects from the surface with constant

defect size(h) Varying thickness of a non-conducting layer (lift-off)(i) Varying thickness of conduction layer(j) Ferromagnetic inclusions

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 86: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 44 High frequency reference block

More than one reference plate would be required to cover a complete range of materials

Standard Calibration Block

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 87: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

FIG 45a illustrates eddy current signals obtained with an absolute surface probe from some of the reference sample defects FIG 45b illustrates signals from the same defects using differential surface probe

(a) (b) FIG 45

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 88: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

462 Choice of reference sample

The reference sample shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined It shall be of the similar nominal dimensions and the same nominal composition as the product beingexamined The reference sample shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference sample shall not be less than the length of the sensing unit of theinspection equipment

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 89: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

463 Fabrication and reproducibility of various types of reference samples

Most reference standards consist of drilled holes of various diameters andor various depth from the external surface Some reference samples have EDM (electric discharge machining) notches in the circumferential and axial directions and on both internal and external surfaces

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 90: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 91: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 92: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 93: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 94: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 95: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

47 Inspection method

471 Range of Inspection

Eddy current inspection encompasses a large range of specific inspection techniques these include but are not limited to

a) Surface crack detection in plate like and complex geometry components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using high frequency small diameter probes

b) Surface crack detection in fastener holes utilizing manual as well as rotating probes Using high frequency small diameter probes

c) Subsurface and second layer crack detection in plate like components utilizing surfacepancake coils generally using low frequency larger diameter probes

d) Conductivity measuremente) Coating thickness measurementf) Material thickness measurementg) Tube and bar inspection utilizing encircling internal or multi coil probe

arrangements

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 96: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

472 Recording of indications

The recording of indications is dependant on equipment and procedures used Techniques previously discussed in Section 373 can be used to record the results of the inspection Depending on the inspection procedures used and the qualification level of the inspector the degree of data analysis and interpretation will differ For most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

KeywordsFor most crack detection inspections a secondary NDT method is commonly employed to confirm results

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 97: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

473 Data analysis and interpretation of results

As in any other NDT method the eddy current method relies on evaluating received eddy current signals containing information about the material characteristics It is necessary to use applicable reference samples to properly inspect and analyze signals of interest The reference samples used therefore must be made of similar materials with similar electrical and mechanical properties as those materials to be examined This interpretation of eddy current signals to ascertain the integrity of the test parts thus depends largely on the selection and choice of suitable reference samples

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 98: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1

ISO9712 (2005) defines the responsibilities of inspection personnel as followsLevel 1 An individual certified to level 1 shall have demonstrated competence to carry out NDT according to NDT instructions and under the supervision of level 2 or level 3 personnel Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 1 personnel may be authorized by the employer to perform the following in accordance with NDT instructions

(a) set up NDT equipment(b) perform the tests(c) record and classify the results of the tests(d) report the results

Level 1 certified personnel shall not be responsible for the choice of test method or technique to be used nor for the assessment of test results

Keywordsnor for the assessment of test results (reporting the result)

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 99: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Level 2

An individual certified to level 2 shall have demonstrated competence to perform nondestructive testing according to established procedures Within the scope of the competence defined on the certificate level 2 personnel may be authorized by the employer to

(a)select the NDT technique for the test method to be used(b)define the limitations of application of the testing method(c) translate NDT codes standards specifications and procedures into NDT

instructions adapted to the actual working conditions(d)set up and verify equipment settings(e)perform and supervise tests(f) interpret and evaluate results according to applicable codes standards

specifications or procedures(g)prepare NDT instructions(h)carry out and supervise all tasks at or below level 2(i) provide guidance for personnel at or below level 2 and(j) report the results of non-destructive tests

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 100: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Therefore all level 1 personnel are required to work according to written instructions prepared by a minimum of a level 2 and authorised by a level 3Typical details of written inspection requirements are given in Section 63

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 101: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Introduction to Eddy Current Machine

httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=S34yt8-zgns

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck
Page 102: Eddy current chapter 4  procedures

Charlie Chong Fion Zhang

Good Luck

  • 4 TESTING PROCEDURES
  • Eddy Current Signals
  • 41 Influence of defect position and orientation
  • 42 Influence of material temperature
  • 43 Influence of structure and geometry of tested parts (noise)
  • 44 Coupling influence
  • 45 Influence of relative partprobe speed
  • 46 Reference standards used in eddy current testing
  • 47 Inspection method
  • 48 Preparation of written instructions for level 1
  • Good Luck