imc 637 final project -- express scripts case study
TRANSCRIPT
Case Study: Layoffs and Dissatisfaction Creates Internal Chaos at Express Scripts
Jamie Huggins
IMC 637
Week 9: Case Study
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !1
image credit: bloomberg.com
Table of Contents
I. Company Background……..………………………………..……………3 II. Company-Wide Layoffs and the Company’s Response…………….…….4 III. Poor Internal Company Culture and the Company’s Response.………….6 IV. Internal Communications Versus External Branding Efforts…………….7 V. Recommended Changes for the Future…….…………………………….8
• Intranet Implementation………..……….…………………………….8 • Leadership Commitment to Transparency……………….………..10 • Encouragement of Social Communication………………………..10 • Create An Atmosphere of Growth by Reducing Layoffs…………11
VI. Measurement of Results…………..……….…….…………………….12 VII. References……..……………………………………………………….13
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !2
Every organization is vulnerable to suffering from serious internal issues. These issues
could range from a crisis, to poor internal communications, to layoffs, and even mergers. They
can suddenly strike, or they can be the result of years of bad decisions, but the worst thing a
business can do in these types of situations is not be prepared. Express Scripts is one of
America’s largest managers of prescription drug services. The corporation has tens of millions
of customers, thousands of clients, and fills over a billion prescriptions per year. However, even
with those impressive numbers, Express Scripts has a very poor internal communications record
due to massive layoffs and employee dissatisfaction. This case study will briefly discuss Express
Script’s company background, issues the company faces, recommendations for the future, and
methods to measure results.
Company Background
Since Express Scripts founding year of 1986, the company states that it has been their
mission to help make the use of prescription drugs safer and more affordable. Throughout the
years, Express Scripts has grown to be one of America’s largest managers of prescription drug
services. Today, the corporation manages “prescription benefits for tens of millions of
Americans on behalf of thousands of clients, including health plans and plan sponsors.
Employers, unions and government organizations throughout the nation rely on their
services” (About Us, 2015). Furthermore, after acquiring Medco Health Solutions in 2012, the
company fills a staggering 1.4 billion prescriptions per year.
Express Scripts currently employs approximately 30,000 employees (About Us, 2015).
Express Scripts claims that their employees truly make a difference in peoples’ lives, because of
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !3
the company’s commitment to excellence and pride in a job well done. In addition, they state
that they are one of the fastest growing companies in the United States (You Belong Here, 2015).
Furthermore, Express Scripts states that they provide their employees with “the resources,
rewards, recognition and development opportunities that empower them to maximize their
performance, career potential and financial success” (You Belong Here, 2015).
Express Scripts is involved in mediocre marketing efforts, which include monthly
financial statement press releases and a small-scale social media presence. Express Scripts has
created a company Facebook page, a Twitter account, and LinkedIn account. Their Facebook
page only has 1,337 “likes,” which seems small for the amount of customers, employees, and
growth they claim they are experiencing. Posts seem to center around showcasing employees or
events that the company is hosting. However, their “Posts to Page” section is filled with
negative comments from customers bashing the company for high overcharges and poor
customer service. Express Scripts’ Twitter account has 12,700 followers. Their Twitter account
seems to post less about the company and more about general health and pharmacy-related news.
The small amount of posts that do cover company news, typically contain comments from upset
customers complaining about Express Scripts’ policies. Finally, Express Scripts’ LinkedIn
account appears to be a place where the company shares internal career opportunities.
Company-Wide Layoffs and the Company’s Response
Though Express Scripts’ claims that they are one best and fastest growing companies in
the United States, this is quite contradictory to the truth. Express Scripts was actually rated one
of the worst companies to work for in the United States. After it acquired Medco Health
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !4
Systems, "Express Scripts began a major workforce consolidation that included layoffs after it
closed the deal in early 2012” (McIntyre, Sauter, Hess, & Weigley, 2013). However, these
massive layoffs did not stop in 2012. In early 2014, "Express Scripts notified the State of Florida
that it would lay off close to 400 people at its facility on Hillsborough Avenue in Tampa, due to
lower prescription volume” (Huff, 2014). Those 400 jobs in Tampa were part of close to 1,900
nationwide Express Scripts layoffs and 2 corporate facilities closings. Brian Henry,
spokesperson for Express Scripts, previously stated that the reason for these layoffs was because,
“the company needed to 're-balance its resources’” (Liss, 2014). As of last month, Express
Scripts layoffs continued — this time, with an additional 256 employees laid off at its Tampa
Bay location. “This cut leaves pharmacists, pharmacy technicians and administrative staff out of
work. 'We're currently overstaffed in these areas,' said David Whitrap, the company's corporate
communications director. A remaining 150 employees will now transition to call center jobs and
work from home, he said, leaving the entirety of the company's bay area operation at just 180
people” (Crosby, 2015).
As stated previously, Express Scripts officials responded to the layoffs with mixed
answers and reasoning. For example, in the company’s late 2014 layoff, spokesperson Brian
Henry stated, “‘We are looking across the organization to find ways to be more efficient and
effective. And that means we will move resources to where client and patient needs are
greatest.’ Asked why the company is cutting jobs when it had promised to add employees, Henry
said, ‘We have met or exceeded all commitments we have made, and we expect that to
continue’” (Liss, 2014). In other words, it seems that these layoffs were a “profit over people”
decision for Express Scripts.
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !5
Even worse, the company offered its employees little-to-no notice about the upcoming
layoffs. Consider this former employee’s review on Glassdoor about the recent Tampa layoff:
“We were all hired on November 10, and our probation ended on February 10. They had
another group of 75 start in November. Today, we all lost our jobs. All associates hired in
October and November no longer have jobs. No real explanation was given today. After our
meeting, we had minutes to grab our stuff and get out” (Express Scripts Reviews, 2015). The
fact that no warning given was given is alarming, and it seems to show that there is a lack of
proper protocol and internal communications channels being implemented at Express Scripts.
Poor Internal Company Culture and the Company’s Response
In addition to these massive layoffs, there are other reasons employees do not like
working for Express Scripts. “Employees are dissatisfied with the company. They feel
pressured to reach key metrics and often complain that reaching these numbers was more
important to the business than adequate customer service or employee well-being” (McIntyre et
al., 2013). Because of this, the employees, who are left, feel overworked. Actually, “too heavy
of a workload” is the top cited employee complaint about Express Scripts. “One aggrieved
employee wrote that the company gives 'the appearance of a work/life balance . . . but the truth is
everyone is overworked’” (McIntyre et al., 2013).
Express Scripts often chooses to not respond to employee and consumer claims of poor
internal culture. For example, on social media, negative Facebook comments and Twitter posts
often go ignored by the company. Those that they do choose to respond to, often harness
unsympathetic, generic remarks that do little to soothe the upset party. Furthermore, there is
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !6
even a Facebook page called “Express Scripts/Medco Worst Company Ever,” where employees
and consumers alike regularly post complaints about the company.
Glassdoor’s employee review section gives a first-hand insight on what it is really like to
work for this company. One recent reviewer in February states, “No input from employees is
taken into consideration. Managers are always right. HR always sides with management.
Working there seems like modern day slavery with a pay check. If management messes up, they
get to take management classes to better their skills . . . as many times as needed. If an employee
messes up, they’re fired . . . no warning” (Express Scripts Reviews, 2015). This review shows
once again that Express Scripts fails to give change warning to its employees — both before
layoffs and before firing employees. Sadly, Express Scripts does not appear to hold employees
or their overall satisfaction in high regard, and this decision is seriously affecting their company.
Internal Communications Versus External Branding Efforts
It can be seen from the aforementioned information that Express Scripts’ internal
communications do not align well with their external branding efforts. “The intrinsic part of a
brand's value, brand equity, may be positive or negative, meaning that a brand name can be used
to increase overall utility of a choice, or may detract from the overall utility of a
choice” (Measuring Brand Value, 2013). Express Scripts’ brand equity would certainly be
considered negative. Interestingly enough, even though the company tries to promote positive
brand equity across its website and social media pages (i.e. a fast growing company, happy
employees, and a strong mission statement), Express Scripts cannot shake their negative brand
connotation. For example, Express Scripts may share a picture on Facebook about great
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !7
company culture, but beside the picture, are a slew of employee posts complaining about layoffs.
On their website, Express Scripts may share that their employees are happy and loyal to the
company, but a quick Google search reveals that employees hate working for the company.
What Express Scripts is trying to promote to the world, and what the company is doing internally
are two very opposite things.
Recommended Changes for the Future
Intranet Implementation
Since there is no evidence of a company-wide intranet, it is recommended that Express
Scripts create and implement an intranet as soon as possible. “An intranet is a network designed
to serve the internal informational needs of an organization using Internet concepts and tools.
Intranets create a common communications and information-sharing system and can be used on a
'push' basis, where information is presented to employees, and on a 'pull' basis, where employees
may seek out and retrieve information for themselves” (Averwig, 2008, p.3).
Once developed, it is recommended that Express Scripts publish daily or weekly intranet
updates under a heading designated for upcoming changes (i.e. any future layoffs). This will
give all of their employees a fair warning that change is coming, and it will give the employees
the ability to ask any questions they may have about the upcoming change. Best of all,
employees can figure out about changes before the outside world knows of them. Finding out
about company layoffs in the local news is not good for employee morale or trust in the
organization. “One organization facing mass layoffs developed an intranet website titled,
'Straight Talk.' This site included the most current information about the budget, layoff policies,
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !8
plans and outplacement resources. Even if the employee couldn’t find a manager to speak with,
they could count on this site for the most up to date information. Granted, it doesn’t replace the
need for face to face conversation, but it is a tool that can help a company to put out a consistent
message” (Green, 2015).
Besides helping increase layoff transparency, the company-wide intranet would offer
Express Scripts other advantages to help improve its internal culture. These advantages include:
a fast system of communication, less rumor growth, help improve managerial productivity, help
eliminate the latency of information in the enterprise and make the flow of information need-
driven rather than availability-driven (Pujari, 2015). Furthermore, an intranet could help Express
Scripts improve their poor customer service reputation. “Customer service often becomes an
area of emphasis in intranet development. In 1996, MCI upgraded an application that supported
8,000 customer service representatives from a text-based IBM terminal interface to a browser-
based intranet interface. In March 1997, the firm introduced Webster, which provided these
employees with web access to more than 600 products and services. Because the new interface
was simple to follow, and users could create and update customers' data, the department
estimated that it reaped a $12 million return in 1997 on its investment” (Korzeniowski, 1998, p.
62).
Leadership Commitment to Transparency
It is imperative that the leaders of Express Scripts be committed to consistent and
ongoing communication throughout any current or future layoff processes. Supervisors should
be told first. After that, all other employees must be told in person. “Employees should hear the
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !9
news in person from a manager and not via outsiders, email, telephone, mail, or the
media” (Amme, 2014). This way, Express Scripts’ employees will know that leadership told
them as early as possible, and there would be no more surprise meetings. Future layoff
announcements should be spoken with sincerity, compassion, and respect towards those affected.
Express Scripts could also consider conducting weekly CEO webcasts since their offices
are spread all across the United States. “The organizational leader needs to be seen and heard and
should be sharing his/her thoughts and plans as often as possible. The longer the leader remains
silent and faceless, the greater the resentment employees will have” (Green, 2015). These
meetings should be followed up with weekly Town Halls. “When they are held consistently over
time, employees know that they can count on an opportunity to hear the latest developments
related to the change and they have an opportunity to be heard themselves” (Green, 2015).
Encouragement of Social Communication
Socialization is a main component of happiness, and Express Scripts should find ways to
encourage social connections among its employees, rather than making them feel alienated. For
example, Express Scripts could consider social media’s role in their future internal
communications efforts. Since Express Scripts already has a Facebook page, it might be wise for
them to also create a closed Facebook group only for Express Scripts employees. "Closed
Facebook groups are getting more and more popular for organizations. Several companies have
either found unsanctioned groups, or they have established them as a formal means of facilitating
communication. Facebook is already a primary venue for images; roughly half of any newsfeed
is made up of photos and graphics. In a closed group, employee communications could share a
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !10
wide range of images, create albums, and encourage employees to share” (Holtz, 2013). This
would help build a sense of employee camaraderie among Express Scripts employees and help
them feel more connected to the company.
Create an Atmosphere of Growth by Reducing Layoffs
Considering all of the layoffs and bad press that Express Scripts has suffered, it is
imperative that the company focus on creating an atmosphere of internal growth within its own
walls. Thus, it is recommended that Express Scripts should consider other alternatives to their
layoffs if possible. “Although a company's stock price often rises in response to a massive
layoff, the long-term results of eliminating the people who spent years building corporate assets
adversely affect the firm's revenue stream and reputation” (Genn, 2001, p.40). Some alternatives
to company-wide layoffs are as follows: offer extra days of unpaid leave, exchange workers with
other employees, institute shorter work weeks, cut part-time staff and contractors, consider a
virtual office, or consider wage and benefit cuts. Though not all ideal alternatives, they would
help decrease the cost of how much these layoffs are going to cost Express Scripts in the long
run — i.e. severance packages, alienating employees, litigation, massive morale hits, and
possible recruitment and training of new employees in the future (What are Alternatives to
Layoffs, 2015).
Measurement of Results
• Statistical Measurement: Once a company-wide intranet is implemented, Express Scripts can
measure its results with statistics. “Monitoring the stats will help a company come to an
understanding of how people currently use the intranet, if they interpret the numbers with
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !11
appropriate context” (Intranet Metrics & KPIs, 2014). Express Scripts should measure the
following areas of its intranet: tasks/workflows completed, profiles created, internal goals,
contribution numbers, contributor engagement levels, and even page views.
• Surveys: Express Scripts should implement both electronic and hard-copy surveys to gain
employee feedback on changes the company implements — i.e. social communication efforts,
leadership transparency levels, the new intranet (usability, feedback), and internal growth
efforts within the company. It may be wise to also survey employees, who were laid-off, to
see where Express Scripts could have handled the process better.
• Focus Groups: Express Scripts can use focus groups to gain group feedback about
implementing the changes recommended in this case study. Express Scripts can ask
employees what they think are other options to the layoffs, what leadership can do better, and
what changes they would like to see happen at the company. This would hopefully increase
engagement and sense of belonging and purpose.
In conclusion, Express Scripts is a company plagued by serious internal issues resulting
from frequent layoffs and employee dissatisfaction, but there is hope. If Express Scripts can
make drastic internal changes such as: implementing and measuring an intranet, committing its
leadership to transparency, encouraging internal social communication among employees, and
creating an internal culture of growth by finding alternatives to the layoffs — it is believed that
this company will have a valiant chance at improved employee retention and internal growth.
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !12
References About Us. (2015). Express Scripts. Retrieved March 9, 2015, from https://www.express-
scripts.com/aboutus/
Averwig, U. (2008, January 18). Developing an Intranet Towards Knowledge Sharing: A
Practioner-Based Inquiry. South African Journal of Information Management, 10.
Retrieved March 9, 2015, from http://www.sajim.co.za/index.php/SAJIM/article/view/7/7
Crosby, R. (2015, February 18). Express Scripts lays off 256, reduces Tampa operation to at-
home work. Tampa Bay Times. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://
www.tampabay.com/news/business/express-scripts-plans-more-layoffs-in-tampa/2218098
Express Scripts Reviews. (2015). Glassdoor. Retrieved March 9, 2015, from http://
www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Express-Scripts-Reviews-E2212.htm
Genn, A. (2001, September 28). Creating Alternatives to Layoffs. Long Island Business News,
48. Retrieved March 9, 2015, from http://search.proquest.com.www.libproxy.wvu.edu/
docview/223624025?pq-origsite=summon
Green, M. (2015). Laying Off? Communicate Early and Often. Outplacing. Retrieved March 3,
2015, from http://www.outplacing.com/laying-communicate-early/
Holtz, S. (2013, October 8). Six Ways to use Social Visual Media for Internal Communications.
Holtz Communications. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://holtz.com/blog/content/
six-ways-to-use-social-visual-communications-for-internal-communications/4214/
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !13
Huff, P. (2014, April 30). Express Scripts' Lower Volume Leads to Close to 400 Tampa Layoffs.
Tampa Bay Business Journal. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://
www.bizjournals.com/tampabay/news/2014/04/30/express-scripts-lower-volume-leads-
to-close-to-400.html
Intranet metrics & KPIs – Only Measure What You Mean to Act Upon. (2014, May 15).
Intranetizen. Retrieved March 9, 2015, from http://www.intranetizen.com/2014/05/15/
intranet-metrics-kpis/
Korzeniowski, P. (1998, October). Intranets Are “In.” Utility Business, 1. Retrieved March 9,
2015, from http://search.proquest.com.www.libproxy.wvu.edu/docview/195770602?pq-
origsite=summon
Liss, S. (2014, April 30). Express Scripts to cut 1,890 jobs, Close two Facilities. St. Louis
Business Journal. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://www.bizjournals.com/
stlouis/ blog/health-care/2014/04/express-scripts-to-cut-1-890-jobs-close-two.html?
page=all
McIntyre, D., Sauter, M., Hess, A., & Weigley, S. (2013, July 19). America’s Worst Companies
to Work For. 24/7 Wall St. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://247wallst.com/special-
report/2013/07/19/americas-worst-companies-to-work-for-2/2/
Pujari, S. (2015). Intranet: Advantages and Disadvantages of Intranet for Business Enterprises.
Your Article Library. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !14
networks/intranet-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-intranet-for-business-enterprises/
10460/
What are Alternatives to Layoffs? (2015). The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved March 9, 2015,
from http://guides.wsj.com/management/recruiting-hiring-and-firing/what-are-
alternatives-to-layoffs/
You Belong Here. (2015). Express Scripts Careers. Retrieved March 9, 2015, from http://
careers.express-scripts.com
Jamie Huggins Week 9: Case Study !15