1

2008/06/14 @ ┬

ver. 6.6

┬

E-mail: priestley.joseph@hotmail.com

Joseph Priestley, 1733-1804 William Paley, 1743-1805 ッ Evidences of Christianity Theophilus Lindsey, 1723-1808

㈳㈰

ふ

1 ふ Obserbations on the Increase of Infidelity 2

ぜ Trinity

3 1534

1 Priestley[1832], p.294-296. [] 2

㈳㈰

┷ Priestley[1797b], p.41-42. 3 Priestley[1815], p.189.

2

4 ┞

┘

5 Test Act1673Corporation Act 1661

1828

々

┘ ㈻ ㈻

6

々

7

Richard Cumberland, 1631 1718John Gay, 1685 1732

4 ┞ [2001] レ 5 see Dickinson[1977], p.84 ゼ 82 . 6 [1996] 48 7 welfarismsonsequentialism Sen[1987], p.39. ゼ

66-67

3

18さ 8

9

ふ 10

㈻ ♣ ぜ

11 ♣ ↓

ぞ

↓

12

♣

Ⅵ

13 8 Scarre[1995],p.60. [2005] 135 137

[ Abraham Tucker, 1705 1774 ]

Ⅴ

ソ

ぞ ┘

ぞ っ Ⅵ

Ⅵ ぞ

9 Waterman[2004] ぜ Waterman

ぜ p.6 10

Crimmins[1989] レ 11 Priestley[1772 1774], p.43. 12 Priestley[1772 1774], p.25. 13 Priestley[1772 1774], p.27.

4

っ

ぜ

∽

─

♣

┘

14

さ

22 3739

practical uses 15 ぞ

├

ぞ ″ 16

Ⅴ

17 Ⅵ

14 Priestley[1772 1774], p.26 27. 15 Priestley[1787b], p.134-135, p.121. 16 Priestley[1787b], p.140. 17 Priestley [1772-1774], p.347-348.

/

よ

14 13

/ ┘

7 16 17 ぜ

5

HeavenⅥ Hell

18 Ⅵ

よ

ふ

19

↓ よ

↓

20 a greater sum of happinessa greater number21

22

/ ┘

21 ┸ ┘て /

┘て / / 12 3

1343 18 Priestley[1772-1774],p.28, p.348. 19 Priestley[1787b], p.142. 20 also see Canovan[1984]. 21 Priestley[1772-1774], p.18. 22 88

[1989]

6

↓

Ⅵ よ

God AlmightyⅥ

┑ 23

ッ レ

よ

ぜ

duct glandhumour ↓

よ

24

negative 25

┘ ↓

┘

ぜ

ぞ

11

┞ ┞

23 ┞ ソ

ギ 12 ┞

ば┞ ば

11

♡ ㌱ 12

23 Paley[1785], p.39. 24 Paley[1785], p.41. 25 LeMahieu[1976], p.122.

7

ふ さ

felicity さ ┘ ┘

┫

┘

Ⅴ

Ⅴ 26 ┘

㈻ 27

さ ┘

┘

┘

28 ↓ ┘

ふ ↓

ぜ ┘

29 ┘ さ

26 Paley[1785], p.22. 27 engagement

c.w. 5:349

ふ

㈻ c.w. 7:132 28 Paley[1785], p.21. 29 LeMahieu[1976], p.119-120.

8

30

blissッ

31 ♣

┘

┑

├

1 1601

17 1722ス

さ ス

1832

18 19

よ

30 Paley[1785], p.21. 31 LeMahieu[1976], p.120. 32 see Cowherd[1977], p.1-2.

9

33

┞ ふ

Ⅵ ゝ

34 Ⅵ

セ

⊿

35

さ

″

ぜ

ぜ

⊿ 36

33 [2008], 156

┞ さ

34 Priestley[1768], p.85. 35 Kramnick[1977] p.14 36 Priestley[1803], p.226.

10

37

さ

┷

ば

ぜ 38

さ

さ ヽ

ふ さ

39 ふ

┈ 40 さ

㈳㈰

37 Priestley[1803], p.226. 38 Priestley[1803], p.226. 39 [1983] 290

[1983] 292-294 40 Priestley[1787a], p.319.

11

㈶ ス

ゝ letters

41

1790

ゝ 10 42 モ

ぜ

ッ

rates

43 1787 さ

∟

44 Ⅵ

41 Priestley[1803], p.223-224. 42 Priestley[1790], p.290 . 43 Canovan[1983], p.31. 44 Priestley[1787a], p.315.

12

45 Ⅵ

Ⅵ

↓

Ⅵ

ス

Ⅵ

↓

ぜ

46 ♣

┘ ぜ さ

ぜ㎲

Ⅵ

ぜ㎲ 47

╉

㈻

♣

48 ♣

inferiors

45 Priestley[1787a], p.315. 46 Priestley[1787a], p.316. 47 Priestley[1787a], p.316. 48 Priestley[1787a], p.318. also see Fitzpatrick[2007], p.126.

13

superiorsッ

Ⅵ

さ 49 Ⅵ

─ benefits↓

Ⅵ さ ┐ ㎘㎟ ㍇ servants

Ⅵ ↓

↓

50 professional assistance

⒢

さ

┘ リ

さ /

51

Ⅵ Ⅵ

49 Paley[1785], p.133 50 Paley [1785], p.134-135 (Book3, Part2, chapter2). 51 Paley[1785] ,p.138.

14

ゝ

ぞ

さ ソギ

ソギ

㍇

Ⅵ

Ⅵ ぞ

52 pecuniary bounty

ぞ

53

❻

12

❻ ┷

り

ふ 54

52 Paley[1785], p.138-140. 53 Paley[1785], p.141. 54 Paley[1785], p.140-149 (Book3 part2 chapter5).

15

ふ ふ

↓

55

56

57

∞

↓ ぜ

55 ↓

↓ ↓ ㌹

[2005] 309-310

see [1991] 163↓

Locke[1690], §36

Ibid, §36

↓ Ibid, §37

Ibid, §38 56 Priestley 1768 p. 57 レ よ 1961 ぜ

16

↓ ↓

Ⅴ 58 ♣

59

ッ 60

61

さ

ゝ

㈶

Supreme Being ば

─

├

/ ㈶

ば

ぜ

62 ぜ

├

58 Priestley[1791], p.167. 59 Priestley[1768], p.26. 60 Priestley[1803], p.307. also see Priestley[1768], p.37-38, Priestley[1803], p.228, and Mudroch[2001] (especially p.75). 61 Priestley[1801], p.121. 62 Priestley[1797a], p.501.

17

さ

㈳㈰

63

㌹ ♣

64

─

65 ふ

″

Ⅴ

labourersゝ ゝ

traders Ⅵ playerservants

farmer66

ゝ

63 Priestley[1801], p.121. 64 Priestley[1803], p.225. 65 Priestley[1808], p.245.

Ibid., p.258. 66 Priestley[1803], Lecture50.

18

─

┷ ─ ふ

67

68

ぜ 99

ぜ

ぜ

ぜ

ぜ

99ぜ

ぜ

┈

69

├ ↓ レ

さ Ⅴ さ

67 Priestley[1801], p.175. 68 [1991] 144 163 69 Paley[1785], p.63-64.

19

70

♣

ス □┢ 71 ↓

ョ

72 99↓

ぜ

┘

♣

♣

㊪

ぜ

┞

っⅤ

70 Paley[1785], p.64. 71 Paley[1785], p.70. 72 Paley[1785], p.63.

20

ぞ

73

ふⅤ ぜ

73 [1992] 51-53

21

Paley, William [1785] The Principles of Moral and Political Philosophy, Liberty Fund(rep. 2002). http://oll.libertyfund.org/index.php Priestley, Joseph 1768 An Essay on the First Principles of Government;, 2nd ed.1771, in Theological and Miscellaneous Works of Joseph Priestley , ed. with notes by Rutt. J. T., Bristol, 1831(rep. 1999), vol.22. Priestley, Joseph[1772 1774]Institutes of Natural and Revealed Religion, the Edition of 1782, in Ibid, vol.2. Priestley, Joseph[1787a] An Account of a Society for Encouraging the Industrious Poor, in Ibid, vol.25. Priestley, Joseph[1787b]“The Duty of Not Living to Ourselves” in Discourses on Various Subjects, Including Several on Particular Occasions, in Ibid, vol.15. Priestley, Joseph[1790] Familiar Letters, Addressed to the Inhabitants of Birmingham, in Ibid, vol. 19. Priestley, Joseph [1797a] The Case of Poor Emigrans, Recommended, in Ibid, vol.16. Priestley, Joseph [1797b] Obserbations on the Increase of Infidelity, 3rd ed., in Ibid, vol.17. Priestley, Joseph [1801] Letters to The Inhabitants of Northumberland And Its Neighbourhood, 2nd ed., in Ibid, vol.25.

ル

p. 124. Priestley, Joseph [1803] Lectures on History and General Policy, in Ibid, vol.24. ∟ 1788 ∟ ∟ Priestley, Joseph [1805] Letters to the Bishops upon the Subject of the Controversy with Dr. Horsley, in Ibid, vol.25. Priestley, Joseph [1832] Life and Correspondence, 1787-1804; in Ibid, vol.1, part2. Locke, John [1690] Two Treatises of Government, ed. by Laslett, P., Cambridge, 1960. Canovan, Margaret[1983] “Paternalistic Liberalism – Joseph Priestley on Rank and Inequality” in Enlightenment and Dissent, 2. Canovan, Margaret [1984] “The Un-Benthamite Utilitarianism of Joseph Priestley” in Journal of the History of Ideas, 45. Cowherd, Raymond G. [1977] Political Economists and English Poor Laws, Ohio

22

University Press: Athens. Crimmins, J. E. [1989] “Religion, Utility and Politics: Bentham versus Paley” in Religion, Secularization and Political Thought, ed. by J. E. Crimmins, Routledge: London and New York. Dickinson, H. T. [1977 Liberty and Property: Political Ideology in Eighteenth-Century Britain, Methuen. ┐ゼ ゼ

∟ 2006 Fitzpatrick, Martin [2007] “Joseph Priestley, Political Philosopher” in Joseph Priestley, Scientist, Philosopher, and Theologian, ed. by Isabel Rivers and David L. Wykes, Oxford University Press. Kramnick, Issac [1977] The Rage of Edmund Burke, Basic Book: New York. LeMahieu, D. L., [1976] The Mind of William Paley: A Philosopher and His Age, University of Nebraska Press: Lincoln and London. Mudroch, Vilem [2001] “Joseph Priestley on morals and economics”, in Enlightenment and Dissent, 20. Scarre, Geoffrey [1995] Utilitarianism, Routledge. Sen, Amartya [1987] On Ethics and Economics, Blackwell. ゼ ∟ 2002 Waterman, A. M. C. [2004] Political Economy and Christian Theology Since the Enlightenment, Palgrave Macmillan.

[1992] ゼ フ ♣ [1991]

[2005] ♣

[2005] [1983] ㊰ ♣

オ [1989] ┷

よ ♣ [1961]74 3 4 [1996] ∟

[2001] OH!

23

[2008] 72