!"#$#%&'()*+,-

./0”!"#$#%(ENSO)-like” 12

34567869108:;$"<=

!"#$%&

'()*+,2012-07.10/!

>?(@A=

I. BCDE/BF?GHIJ-(KL-

M I-A. !"#$#%378:;$"<

I-B. 108:;$"NO(ENSO-like decadal variability)

I-C. 45!"#$#%3Annual ENSO<

II. P-Q

I-A: 012,2345-67,18

I-1. 9:;<=>?@420ABCDE1970-FGH8!

=9:;<I>?JKLM,NJOPQRS012,23JTU

$$$=9:?VM,N(e.g., Walker 1923)$

$$$W=9:;<XY(Davis 1976; Weare et al. 1976)

012,23Z[4\1,]J^_`abcdJefghijk8 $$=Gl=mlnobcdpqbcdGrs!

Weare et al. (1976)

qbcd9:;<XYJ EOFt1u,v!

012,23

9:;<4w8!

9:;<4x8!

5-67,1yk

42z`7-{|8!

012,23 012,23 012,23

I-2. 9d}l=>?9d~'�$4E1980-FGH8!

=;�M,NOPQRS012,23JC�Z[J��

$WWWW=bcd�����KL;�(=x;=������Wyrtki 1975; 1985)

=>?9d����Z[���J012,23J�!

$$$=���=9:?V=�����(Bjerknes 1966; 1969; 1972) $

=012,23J����(>?�R�9dJ� ¡¢J£¤¥) $$$W=¦012,23=§,¨©(Russmusson and Carpenter 1982)

012,23ª«!012,23¬­

[®l��bcdEml��bcd] $=9d}l4x;=���8=9:;<=>?@¯jk $$$4TRITON/TAO°±²³´¯;G)µ¶,·?[)µ¶,8!

x;

4¸8!

w;

4¹8!

9;�

4º8!

»�¯>¼½¦¾¿i012,23ÀÁÂQÃLiÄS©!ÂÅÆÇ012,23ÈÉJÊQË¡

4R&CÈOP�ÌM,N| ÀÍf012,23�F=ÉJÊQÎf012,23�F8 ÏKLÐ6ÑÒJÓÔ=¡¢À?ÕÐ6ÑÒJÖOQ×ØÙÚÛ!

012,23Z[QÜj�Ì9d}lJyk!

Ý!

012,23�!

4ÞßßàáÞÞ8!

â!

c-ã!

äÞÞ.å!

Ýæâ!

c-XY!

9:;<! ��;<4noçf8!

èééê!

éê!

warm pool

Nino3-index>0

x!

w!

¸! ¹!

noëì!

mí!

warm pool

mí!

îJ���XY! ïJ���XY!

?[ðM,N(ñÐ6ÑÒ(ODAS)

bcdno�J>?�9d!

���

4m�8!

òóô¡�4õö÷ø8!

ºf9:;<!

��Jx;!

¹�Jw;!

w;Jëì!

NOAAJù,Ò\,úRû!

warm pool

012,23Z[QÜj�Ì>?9d����!

���ÍüS!

��Jx;Èmíýk!

ml9:;<þì!

òóô¡�Èmíýk!

ÿ!ââJù,Ò\,úRû!

012,23¬­J"#2$ÒÀ%!ïJ&',v()*!

I-3. 012,23J+k"#2$Ò,-41980-FÊD8!

¦012,23!.2,2/!012,23===©+k40ý8"#2$ÒJ12

[34]¯KL56Ð6ÑÒJ76489=:;=TOGA/TAO8=KL56J<õ

$$$W$ : =>uM1J6�ñ4Cane and Zebiak model; CZ model; Zebiak and Cane 1986)

==>uM1=Ö?@12QRS,-JAB

$$$=delayed action oscillator model (CD+kEÖ?; Suarez and Schopf 1988)

=no�Fx;4;<G�JH�IJ=ïJ���XY8Èm�

$$$$$$=noëìJÍñ!Glno�=mlno�J9:;<þì!012,23ª« $$$$$$=���JÍñ=�KLÐM°,Jyñ!noN6O,P(cold Rossby)JQR

$$$$$$=cold RossbyPJ®SÄTU(Vq5s-7s8!®lno�QWX

$$$$$$=çYKelvinP���no�íTU $$$$$$=no�Fw;4;<G�JH�þJ=îJ���XY8Èm�

$$$$$$=noëìJÎñ¯012,23J¬­=.2,2/ª«

9duM1Z�!

>?uM1Z�!

[\]^_`WabcW[d^efgWäÞßhhå!=>~'uM14ijWê^cfk8�!$$9duM1¯��bcdJ^!

delayed action oscillator modelJlm!

[d^efgWabcW[\]^_`nWÞßhh!

Cold Kelvin

Cold Rossby

®�XY!

Nino 3 SST !"#$!

!

"

no!

d T / dt = a* T - b* T(t-"-#) - $* T^3

T : Nino 3 (mlnobcd) J SST XY

$: opqr, a(>0), b(<0)sr!

" 5N

5S

Cold Rossby

¼t!

CD� !

Pk4���8TU=¼tÈuØ!

I-4. delayed action oscillator modelz`J¡¢$41990-FÊDE2000-Fvw8!

=®l��bcdQÎx

$$$=western Pacific oscillator model (Weisberg and Wang 1997)

yJuM1Èz{Z6@i|SzÀ}?G!

=��bcdÂ~iJVq���FÎx

$$$=recharge-discharge oscillator model (Jin 1996; Jin 1997a;b)

=warm poolJm®ýk=mYiJPk¼tFÎx

$$$=advective-reflective oscillator model (Picaut et al. 1997)

=�rJ"#2$ÒÈ(�Q��iÄS¾�FA�

$$$W=unified oscillator model (Wang 2001)

KLQRS��!

[d^efgWabcW[\]^_`nWÞßhh!

Cold Kelvin

Cold Rossby

®�XY!

Nino 3 SST !"#$!

!

"

no!

d T / dt = a* T - b* T(t-"-#) - $* T^3

T : Nino 3 (mlnobcd) J SST XY

$: opqr, a(>0), b(<0)sr!

" 5N

5S

Cold Rossby

¼t!

CD� !

Pk4���8TU=¼tÈuØ!

\^ê_kf�W�!�Wt�u,v4������8!{|À�RÉ���-4�8!

h�áhà! ßÞáß�!ßè! ßàáßh!h�áh�!

¼���ûJTU!

â!

Ý!

i!

�!

éW-!

�-!

Þ�é-!

��-!m�!

®�!4-8!

¼���ûJTU¯�ÿ[!QÜq!

®l��bcdQ��SW!�iWXYJÎñ!

®l��bcd(WTP)

mlnobcd!

012,23¡�| ���!

ENSOQÜq�ÌOHCTU�¥!

VbcdiÀTU a!

I-5. KL4OHC8QRS¡¢W42000-Fvw8!

western Pacific oscillator modelJlm!

Cold Kelvin

&'£¤µ9¯

m�XY!

®�XY!

Nino 3 SST !"#$!

! no!

"

qbcd���4no¥;10N-20N¦§8J¨©Qª«

®YiJ¼tÀ×Ø��_f

>?@F¬­�noPFQR!

15N

Cold Rossby

î�ܯ>! �ܯ®!

4!�iXY¯Îñ8!

¯>?°±¯9d°!

®l��bcd(WTP)

OHCJ� yñ���KL#,14WSC8J�Üqr!

îJ²[i4º?V¥³´8!%!

�µêabWc^¶b¶fkk·b¸!¹!

;<G�¹s4¹8!¹!

!�iXY¯º»!

®lno¥��bcdJ>?9dyk�¥!

recharge-discharge oscillator modelJlm!

®�XY!

Nino 3 SST !"#$!

no!

PkTUÀ�Q×Ø_�

6¼1v.)½��4no��no¥Jx;�=���J¾¿8!

5N

(À?V¥>?@)

#ÁSÄ6¼1v.)½��!

(À?V¥>?@)

#ÁSÄ6¼1v.)½��!no�Â~iÀ���oÂ!

5S

“discharge”

ÃfÄÅW!�iWäè[æèÿnWÞèé�æßé²å$!

ÿ·b^æ�W�!

Æno�Â~J!�iykÆ!

ÃfÄ!ÿ·b^æ�W·bcf�!

ÇÈXYi£Éñ!

ÃfÄ!ÿ·b^æ�W·bcf�!

ÃfÄW±Wÿ·b^æ�W·bcf�RûÊ��4�ÿ[!{|JËÌÍJ�8Î�!

ÏQ§fÐÑ!Ò{|JÞáèW$!$WJ��Y!

012,23| 4ïJÿ·b^æ�W·bcf�8!$$±ÃfįoÂÓS!.2,2/| 4îJÿ·b^æ�W·bcf�8!

$$±Ãfįº»ÓS!

delayed action oscillator

model

western Pacific oscillator

model

unified oscillator model

®lbcdJ�ÎÔJ��!

®YÕÖiJnoPJ¼t!

Vq��!

recharge-discharge

oscillator model

advective-reflective

oscillator model

mYÕÖiJnoPJ¼t!

=¶aeêW_^^kJýó!

unified oscillator modelJlm!

�ÿ[!QÜq×S!¼���ûJTU!

=>_PkTUiÀ_f!>?9d����FØÙTU!+ÚJÎñ_yÈÛ`¿S!

noþJm�:delayed action oscillator model

no¥JTU&®l��bcdJ>?yk:western Pacific oscillator model Vq���:recharge-discharge oscillator model

ÜuM1J�ÝÀKLi{4�l8¡¢Þ¿Ì

�z�pÜuM1J�ÝJÎÍÈßàJ²¼µáiâ_S!

ãããW^ä\·kkaå^eWê^cfkQÀ!Øü¿_fuØ_Øæ¯!¦012,23Já£ç,©!

è$W®�(,6á4éê!áë[ì8!èÒx;½,1m�!èÒ012,23ª«!

®�(,6á=MJO/ISVJÃL=ÖO

4²µvd=9>í=bcd®lJefgh¯:;=RAMA/TRITONî²8!

Þ`Qp

ïJ9ð�J4��8�� $=WWB=MJO

$=²µvd9ðì<

$=²µvdñ²ò,1

$=bcdGrs4PDO=¶îñ*Ð3µ¯20-80-67,18

Ï"#2$ÒJÞ`_SOóJÌôQ¯ # KL4� õSQºOösz÷!|i;G=9:=>?� $$î², ø.²ñ,8= # rãuM14ùús6û=!|.µ8=(ñM,N=:;

ßàJENSOi�ÝÈâ_Sü

ÏÜ012,23i�ÝÈâ_SpÖOÀüýÙÁÂpÃL{D-þþÎÀÿ�f

!Oó_Z�4bcd}8 $=&'£¤µ94western Pacific oscillator8¯Z@KLÈ"�f

$$$4&'£¤µ9î²Fü8 $=Vbcdz`J��

$$$4KL"�f¯SPICE/post SPICE_y�Jj#8

N²Ò67,1 iJ����

$=��}67,1=5-67,1=10-/r$-67,1=±ú,ÒÐ&á

$$4%�p®�(,6áWWB/MJOp012,23pQuasi-decadalp

±ú,ÒÐ&á etc.8

2-B. ��10-67,1ykW4ENSO-like decadal variability8!Hasegawa and Hanawa (2003 GRL)

ENSO-like_!{|4decadal8yk!

* qbcd&~¯$PDO (Pacific Decadal Oscillation)20-z`50-{|

* ��bcdÈ&~¯ 8-z`15-{|4ENSO-like Quasi-decadal variability: QD8

SST&SLPbcd'N,µ: $PDO (20yr)

$QD (10yr)$ $ENSO (4yr)

$QB (2yr)

(Tourre et al. 2001Rû8!

20yr!10yr! 4yr! 2yr!

20yr! 10yr! 4yr! 2yr!

y¿{”ENSO-like”

Ìý�p

GrsQ��S ¨©JÎÞI

���Q��SVqÚ

_yÈâ_S!

9d����� (OHC)

bcd'N,µ (wavelet'(,8: $PDO (20yr) $QD (10yr)$

$ENSO (4yr)

$QB (2yr)

(Hasegawa and Hanawa 2003Rû8!

ENSO: 4yr!

QD: 12yr!

PDO: 20yr!

Glno�

IIV)i ¨©4>8!

Grs=*+=,+

¶îñ*Ð3µ5- ¨©4>8!

&'£¤µ9

®lno� Glno�

mlno�i ¨©4>8!

ÜN²Ò67,1iTUJ5-= 9�Q��S+ÚJÎÞÈ â_S!

â!

Ý!

i!

�!

â!

Ý!

i!

�!

�ÿ[!! ��-67,1!

ä.eå! ä.eå!

qbcd���ip¼���ûJTU!$æW�ÿ[!WÅWÌ-!$æWÞé-67,1ä/�åyk¯Þ�-!WWæWÞé-67,1ÀVbcdi{TU¨©F0×$$!$$$$4�ÿ[!ÀV1]i�z0Þ_f8!

mlno�i¨©>! mlno�i¨©Í!

ef\]ae¸fæc·ä\]ae¸fW^ä\·kkaå^eWê^cfk@+S2f!

Hasegawa and Hanawa (2003 GRL) PDO (Pacific Decadal Oscillation)�Àâ_SZ[!

3ÍJQDykW4Hasegawa et al. 2012 revised in JC8 Argo&N,á+á.²áµM,N445Þ6��ÉEñM,N8!

QDJwarm phase¯ ��3ÍÈx;½,1iÀ<ñ ;<�Àâ_S'N,µü

(155E¦§iÀjk)

QD3Íyk¯M,NÙ7ý8Ì

!á.²áµ=°19È~10-<õ !À­ô�OP!

2-C. ��012,234Annual ENSO8!

Annual ENSO:;<4Tozuka and Yamagata 20038

x;J��¶²*1¯ Kessler (1990)!

Warm SST!Cold Rossby!

“Annual ENSO”

(=->û?Þ¿S) *É{É{J¦012,23©È

$=-12.J\1,]ì<Z[@ ɾQPkTUI>?9d����

QRS� ¡¢F»A!

12.z`5.:012,23@!

�.z`�Ê.¯.2,2/@!

��}=��=5-=È10-_yBà_N²Ò67,1i

CD×S4but �ÝJ�lÈâ_S8Z[ÈbcdQ�E×S

ßàJZ[QÜq×S¨©JFûÍ�ÀGHQÀIÿi|SÈp

ºOös4J  and/or � Kî²8JKLF!| 

4ZE¯LMM,N100-=î²10-8 NO×S¾�ipßàJ+S2fIyk"#2$Òp

N²Ò67,1 ����_yJRû¹fFPS¾�ÈiÄS

QRST4?[=?ÕÃL8JÌôQpþTFÚU�×S

VW=KL=12J¡¢=NOÈ×Ø

ü�ô!

END!

K$L¯!�iXY!

%&'!()!

no!

Þé"[!bcd®Y!4X,.а>í8!

bcdmY!4°"£#>í8!

Þé"ÿ!

�é"ÿ!

*+,!

*+-!

îJ!�iXY!

îJ!�iXY!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

cfka.fcW^ä\·kkaå^e!

¶fäåfebW[a\·`·\W^ä\·kkaå^e!

ef\]ae¸fW^ä\·kkaå^e!

ïJ!�iXY! ïJ!�iXY!îJ!�iXY! îJ!�iXY!ïJ!�iXY!

012,23!

îJ!�iXY!

îJ!�iXY!

.2,2/!

Î$ñ!

®l��bcd!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

îJ!�iXY!

cfka.fcW^ä\·kkaå^e!

ïJ!�iXY!îJ!�iXY!

��bcd!

KL~\�,-J]^!

[[ÃW?Õã48!Þ.J[[Ãc_ã4�`a�Æ�`a`8$4ê��âWifbåfeAb8!

�a�ÀG=ºrsi°cá*N)½!

®lno�4è[æèÿnWÞèéæÞ�é�8!

!�i!

[[Ã!

!�i!

[[Ã!

mlno�4è[æèÿnWÞ�é²æßé²8!

éf·bfbWabcWé\[]acfbWä�éééå!$äê·bWÞßßàJ<Q»d8!

recharge-discharge oscillator modelJlm!

PkTUÀ×a�{×ØiÀ_f4Vq��ÈuØ8!

�`ee! �`f�!�`a�!

gÝÃKL<$4ê��âWifbåfeAb8!

�`fe!�`a�!

K$L¯!�iXY!

%&'!()!

no!

Þé"[!bcd®Y!4X,.а>í8!

bcdmY!4°"£#>í8!

Þé"ÿ!

�é"ÿ!

*+,!

*+-!

îJ!�iXY!

îJ!�iXY!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

cfka.fcW^ä\·kkaå^e!

¶fäåfebW[a\·`·\W^ä\·kkaå^e!

ef\]ae¸fW^ä\·kkaå^e!

ïJ!�iXY! ïJ!�iXY!îJ!�iXY! îJ!�iXY!ïJ!�iXY!

012,23!

îJ!�iXY!

îJ!�iXY!

.2,2/!

Î$ñ!

®l��bcd!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

!�i!YZ!

îJ!�iXY!

cfka.fcW^ä\·kkaå^e!

ïJ!�iXY!îJ!�iXY!

��bcd!

d T /dt = a* T + b* h - $* T ^ 3

dh / dt = - c* T - d * h

ef\]ae¸fW^ä\·kkaå^eWê^cfk!

T : Nino 3 (mlnobcd) J SST XY

h: ®lnobcdJ;<G�¹s

$: opqr!

=W89KLh:<$(Wyrtki and Kilonsky 1984)

$$$=i(²=Nj¨ (160Wçf)49ó�_y8

rãuM1=(ñuM1=Triton/TAO°±²

$$=Guilyardi et al. (2003); Kug et al. (2003); Meinen (2000)

EUC8!

SEC SEC ECC NEC

kl

úM)á!kl

úM)á!

5N 10N 20N 17S SEC(Vno9ó)

EUC(nomó8 ECC4no¼ó8 NEC(qno9ó8!

I-5. KLÞ¿Ì���J124nÌ_oÛ=uM1J��841990-FE8!

=TU�¥4delayed action oscillator model)

$$$=Kessler (1990), Zhang and Levitus (1996; 1997),

Hasegawa and Hanawa (2003)

=no�Â~J���yk (recharge-discharge oscillator FpÔ)

$$$=Meinen and McPhaden (2000;2001), Kessler (2002),

Hasegawa and Hanawa (2003), Meinen (2005); Hasegawa et al. (2006)

=®l���Jyk (western Pacific oscillatorFpÔ)

$$$=Kessler (1990), Wang et al. (1999)p Hasegawa and Hanawa (2003)

=�rJ"#2$ÒÈ(�Q��iÄS (unified oscillator model)

$$$W=Hasegawa and Hanawa (2003)

OHC(����;<G��x;�8JykÀqàQOó!

Ü,-¯���JuØ¥

$�z�p1990-FþC¯M,N))áÈÈrÞ¿�f_z8Ì!