maurizio de luca md department of surgery – regional hospital of vicenza – italy department of...

21
Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso Nazionale SICOb Cagliari, 25-27 Aprile 2013 Mini Gastric Bypass: l’opinione degli esperti La gestione delle complicanze. Esperienza personale e letteratura a confronto

Upload: karly-stevenson

Post on 12-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca MD

  Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – ItalyDepartment of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy

 

XXI Congresso Nazionale SICOb

Cagliari, 25-27 Aprile 2013

Mini Gastric Bypass: l’opinione degli esperti

La gestione delle complicanze. Esperienza personale e letteratura a confronto

Page 2: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Vicenza Padova Background

Our Series before Mini Gastric Bypass

Our Primary Surgery

  Sept 1993 Dec 2012 : Gastric Banding → 2400 Patients  

 0 moratility 5.4% complication requiring reoperation Mean %EWL 49% at 12 years 25% of GB with %EWL < 30 (failure)

APPROPRIATE BARIATRIC OPERATION – POSSIBLE ROLE OF STAGED SURGERYM DE LUCA, G Segato, L Busetto, D Asthon, F Favretti.Obesity Surgery, 18, 4, 153, 471-472, 2008

Page 3: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Our Series before Mini Gastric Bypass

Our Remedial Surgery from Dec 1995 to January 2011

Duodenal Switch (DS) →  155  Patients (F/M  98/57) open/VLS  41/114 VLS from Jan 20010,7% mortality  (1 case for malignant hypertermia)16.7% post-op surgical complication (fistula, bleeding, internal hernia)      5.5% post-op medical complication (non fatal PE, pneumoniae, ARDS, MI)          3%  surgical revisions (diarrhea, low protein,excess WL, poor WL)                        12.5% metabolic complication requiring rehospitalization                                     

arthralgia, peripheral edema, vomiting, diarrhea, nutrients deficiences39% of patients proctitis, alitosis, acid sweating            

75% EWL 13 years follow up             Comorbidities resolution 94% hyperlipemia, 91% Type II Diabetes                                

ADJUSTABLE GASTRIC BANDING WITH DUODENAL SWITCH (BANDINARO): SEQUENTIAL TREATMENT IN A FAILED RESTRICTIVE PROCEDURE (LAPAROSCOPIC PRELIMINARY EXPERIENCE)  DE LUCA M, Segato G, Busetto L, Ceoloni A, Banzato O, Enzi G, Favretti F  Obesity Surgery, 16,4,2006, 400.

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Vicenza Padova Background

Page 4: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass

Mini Gastric Bypass : Vicenza Hospital /Padova University Series

Antrophometric Data

• April 2011 – December 2012  (20 months experience)• 42 Patients (F/M 26/16)

• Primary Surgery /Remedial Surgery for Band Failure 4/38

• Age 39.7 ± 10 (19-62)• Weight kg 138.7 ± 26.8  (93-182) • BMI 45.6 ±  8.1 (35-61)• Lap/Open  42/0• Skin-to Skin Time  110 ± 4.65 (85-190)

No published data

Page 5: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass - Technical Details

Performed by Laparoscopy (4-5  Trocar)

20-30 ml Gastric pouch (vertical gastrectomy)

Gastro-jejunal anastomosis with a stoma diameter of 1.5-2 cm

L-L anastomosis 

Antireflux Stitches 

Omega Loop 220 cm 

Antecolic anastomosis 

One Anastomosis Gastric Bypass: a simple, safe and efficient surgical procedure for treating morbid obesityM Garcia Caballero and M CarbajoNutricion Hospitalaria, XIX, (6) 372-375, 2004

Page 6: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass as Remedial Surgery Weight Loss (38 Pts)

Kg

months

Page 7: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass as Remedial Surgery Weight Loss (38 Pts)

% EWL

months

Page 8: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass (42 Pts)

Comorbidities

Diabetes

12 obese Pts DM2 3 years, HgA1c > 7.5%Failure previous medical treatment

Mean Follow-up: 13 .1months (±2.3)

Dyslipidemia

11 obese Pts with hypercolesterolemia and/or hypertrygliceridemia

Mean Follow-up: 12.4months (±1.9)

 

Complete Remission: 9 pts (75%)

Improvement: 12 pts (100%)

Complete remission 10 pts (90.1%)

Page 9: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

OSAS                                  5 pts Complete resolution        100%

Sonnolence                       7 pts Complete resolution        100%

Hypertension                  19 pts Complete resolution          78%Partial resolution                10%

Hyperuricemia                  3 pts Complete resolution       100%

Fatty liver                        10 pts   Ultrasound at 0 and 12 months

Improvement                     90%

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass (42 Pts)

Comorbidities

Page 10: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Vicenza Padova Series

Dolen K et al. A clinical and nutritional comparison of biliopancreatic diversion with and without duodenal switch. Ann Surg 2004; 240-51

Slater GH, Serum fat-soluble vitamin deficiency and abnormal calcium metabolism after malabsorptive bariatric surgery.  J Gastrointestinal Surg 2004; 8: 48-65

APPROPRIATE BARIATRIC OPERATION – POSSIBLE ROLE OF STAGED SURGERYM DE LUCA, G Segato, L Busetto, D Asthon, F Favretti.Obesity Surgery, 18, 4, 153, 471-472, 2008

Nutritional Deficiences

IronCalciumZincVitaminDVitamin A Vitamin KProtein

Page 11: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Vicenza /Padova Series

Complication of MGB

Short Term Complications   Leakage  0 4.7%  Omega loop  Bleeding 0 2.3%  abdominal, intraluminal, thoracic  Major atelectasis 0 0  Deep vein thrombosis 0 0  Death  0 0

Long Term Complications (0 redo)  Stomal Ulcer 0 0  Bile Reflux 0 2.3%  Excessive Weight Loss (malnutrition) 2.3% 0  Bowel obstruction 0 0

 Total Redo Surgery (1 Pts 1° day post-op) 2.3%

    Primary MGB  4 Pts      Revisional  38 Pts        

Not published data

Page 12: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Vicenza /Padova Series

Side Effects of MGB

  Asthenia 0 7.7% <0.001  Diarrhea 2.3% 2.3% <0.001  Bloating 0 4.7% <0.01  Epigastralgia  2.3% 4.7% <0.05  Vomiting 0 2.3% <0.01

  Major metabolic consequences 0 0

    Primary MGB  4 Pts      Revisional  38 Pts        

Not published data

Page 13: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass - Literature

Complication of MGB

Short Term Complications (6 redo) 2.7% 11% <0.001  Leakage  0.4% 3.8% <0.001  Gastrojejunostomy,  gastric tube, gastric remnant  Bleeding 1.6% 6.4% <0.68  abdominal, intraluminal, thoracic  Major atelectasis 0.21% 1.29% <0.09  Deep vein thrombosis 0.1% 0% <0.77  Death  0 0

Long Term Complications (7 redo) 0.69% 5.2% <0.03  Stomal Ulcer 0.65% 0 <0.102  Bile Reflux 0 5.2% <0.001  Excessive Weight Loss (malnutrition) 0,4% 0 <0.001  Bowel obstruction 0 0 <0.562

    Primary MGB  923 Pts      Revisional  77 Pts        

ONE THOUSANDS CONSECUTIVE MINI-GASTRIC BYPASS. SHORT AND LONG TERM OUTCOMENoun R, Skaff J, Riachi EObesity Surg, 22, 697-703, 2012

Page 14: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass - Literature

Complication of MGB

Short Term Complications  1.4%  Leakage  0.9%  Gastrojejunostomy,  gastric tube, gastric remnant  Bleeding 0.3%  abdominal, intraluminal, thoracic  Gastric Perforation 0.1%  Death  0.1%     1 pulmonary thromboembolism/  1 gastric wall necrosis

Long Term Complications  0.8%  Stomal Ulcer 0.4% Gastrojejunal stenosis 0.4%

Total Redo Surgery 1.3%

    Primary/Revisional MGB 1126 Pts      

BYPASS GASTRICO LAPAROSCOPICO DE UNA SOLA ANASTOMOSIS (BAGUA) ASISTIDOCON BRAZO ROBOTICO:TECNICA Y RESULTATOS EN 1126 PACIENTESCaballero MAC, De Solorzano JO, Garcia-Lanza CCirurgia Endoscopica, 9,1, 6-13, 2008

Page 15: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Page 16: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Lee WJ et al.Laparoscopic Roux en Y Gastric Bypass vs Mini Gastric Bypass for the treatment of Morbid Obesity: a 10 Years experienceObesity Surgery 22: 1827-1834, 2012

Lee GBP vs MGP: 10 year results - Complication

Page 17: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Lee WJ et al.Laparoscopic Roux en Y Gastric Bypass vs Mini Gastric Bypass for the treatment of Morbid Obesity: a 10 Years experienceObesity Surgery 22: 1827-1834, 2012

Lee GBP vs MGP: 10 year results Weight Loss

Page 18: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Lee WJ et al.Laparoscopic Roux en Y Gastric Bypass vs Mini Gastric Bypass for the treatment of Morbid Obesity: a 10 Years experienceObesity Surgery 22: 1827-1834, 2012

Lee GBP vs MGP: 10 year results

Page 19: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Conclusion 1

 Less Surgery compared  to GBP and  BPD

 Quicker Surgery compared to GBP and BPD

 Low peri-operative complications compared to GBP and BPD

 Long Term Weight Loss as BPD (75% EWL at 10 yrs)

 Remission /improvement of Diabetes in 85-90 % of cases 

 Remission of  hyperlipidemia in 85-95% of cases

 Absence of some BPD side effects (like diarrhea, hemorrhoids, proctitis etc.)

 Reduction of  metabolic consequences of BPD (protein malnutrition) 

Page 20: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass – Conclusion 2

 In our series first choice operation is Gastric Banding (72% of Pts)

 First option for Bile Reflux Obese Pts is GBP

 First option for Diabetic or Hyperlipemic Obese Pts is MGB

 First option as remedial surgery is MGB

 Current studiies show that MGB is an effective, low-risk and low-failure bariatric procedure

 MGB can be revised in GBP or reversed if necessary

Page 21: Maurizio De Luca MD Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy Department of Surgery – Regional Hospital of Vicenza – Italy XXI Congresso

Maurizio De Luca

Results of Mini Gastric Bypass

Thank You for your attention