migrating from postgresql to mysql at cocolog

Migrating from PostgreSQL to MySQLat Cocolog

Naoto Yokoyama, NIFTY Corporation

Garth Webb, Six Apart

Lisa Phillips, Six Apart

Credits:Kenji Hirohama, Sumisho Computer Systems Corp.

Agenda

1. What is Cocolog

2. History of Cocolog

3. DBP: Database Partitioning

4. Migration From PostgreSQL to MySQL

1. What is Cocolog

What is Cocolog

NIFTY Corporation

Established in 1986

A Fujitsu Group Company

NIFTY-Serve (licensed and interconnected with CompuServe)

One of the largest ISPs in Japan

Cocolog

First blog community at a Japanese ISP

Based on TypePad technology by SixApart

Several hundred million PV/month

History

Dec/02/2003: Cocolog for ISP users launch

Nov/24/2005: Cocolog Free for free launch

April/05/2007: Cocolog for Mobile Phone launch

2008/04

700 Thousand Users

Cocolog (Screenshot of home page)

Cocolog (Screenshot of home page)

TypePadCocolog

Cocolog template sets

Cocolog Growth (User) ■Cocolog ■Cocolog Free

phase1 phase2 phase3 phase4

Cocolog Growth (Entry) ■Cocolog ■Cocolog Free

phase1 phase2 phase3 phase4

Technology at Cocolog

Core System

Linux 2.4/2.6

Apache 1.3/2.0/2.2 ＆ mod_perl

Perl 5.8+CPAN

PostgreSQL 8.1

MySQL 5.0

memcached/TheSchwartz/cfengine

Eco System

LAMP,LAPP,Ruby+ActiveRecord, Capistrano

Etc...

Monitoring

Management Tool Proprietary in-house development with PostgreSQL, PHP,

and Perl

Monitoring points (order of priority) response time of each post

number of spam comments/trackbacks

number of comments/trackbacks

source IP address of spam

number of entries

number of comments via mobile devices

page views via mobile devices

time of batch completion

amount of API usage

bandwidth usage

DB Disk I/O

Memory and CPU usage

time of VACUUM analyze

APP number of active processes

CPU usage

Memory usage

Hard

DB

Service

APL

2. History of Cocolog

Phase1 2003/12～(Entry: 0.04Million)

Register

Postgre

SQL

NAS

WEB

Static contents

Published

Before DBP

10servers

TypePad

Podcast

Portal

Profile

Etc..

Phase2 2004/12～ (Entry: 7Million)

Rich templatePublish Book

Tel Operator

Support

NAS

WEB

Static contents

Published

Postgre

SQLRegister

TypePad2004/12～

2005/5～

Before DBP

50servers

http://www.cocolog-nifty.com/csp/nunobari.html

Phase2 - Problems

The system is tightly coupled.

Database server is receiving from multiple

points.

It is difficult to change the system design and

database schema.


NAS

WEB

Static contents

Published

Web-API

memcached

Podcast

Portal

Profile

Etc..

Postgre

SQL


Tel Operator

Support

RegisterTypePad

Before DBP

200servers


Web-API

Static contents

Published

memcached

Atom

Mobile

WEB


Tel Operator

Support

Register

Typepad

Postgre

SQL

Before DBP

300servers

Now 2008/4～

Web-API

Static contents

Published

memcached

Atom

Mobile

WEB

Typepad


Tel Operator

Support

Register

Multi

MySQL

After DBP

150servers

3. TypePad Database Partitioning

Steps for Transitioning

• Server PreparationHardware and software setup

• Global WriteWrite user information to the global DB

• Global ReadRead/write user information on the global DB

• Move SequenceTable sequences served by global DB

• User Data MoveMove user data to user partitions

• New User PartitionAll new users saved directly to user partition 1

• New User StrategyDecide on a strategy for the new user partition

• Non User Data MoveMove all non-user owned data

Storage

TypePad Overview (PreDBP)

Database

(Postgres)

Static Content (HTML,

Images, etc)

Application

Server

Web

Server

TypeCast

Server

ATOM

ServerMEMCACHED

Data Caching servers to

reduce DB load

Dedicated Server for

TypeCast (via ATOM)

https(443)

http(80)

http(80) : atom apimemcached(11211)

postgres(5432)

Mail

Server

Internet

nfs(2049)

ADMIN(CRON)

Server

smtp(25) / pop(110)Blog Readers

Blog Owners

Mobile Blog

Readers

smtp(25) / pop(110)

Cron Server for periodic

asynchronous tasks

TypePad

TypePad

TypePad

Non-

User Role

Why Partition?

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

All inquires (access) go to one

DB(Postgres)

After DBPCurrent setup

Inquiries (access) are divided among

several DB(MySQL)

TypePad

TypePad

TypePadTypePad

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Non-

User Role

Server Preparation

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

New expanded setup

DB(MySQL) for partitioned data

Current Setup

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

User information is

partitioned

Maintains user mapping

and primary key generation Stores job

details

Server for

executing Jobs

※Grey areas are not used in current

steps

Asynchronous Job Server

Information that does not

need to be partitioned

(such as session

information)

Global WriteCreating the user map

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

①

②

Explanation

①：For new registrations only, uniquely identifying user data is written to the global DB

②：This same data continues to be written to the existing DB




and primary key generation

※Grey areas are not used in current steps

Global ReadUse the user map to find the user partition

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：Migrate existing user data to the global DB

②：At start of the request, the application queries global DB for the location of user data

③：The application then talks to this DB for all queries about this user. At this stage the global DB points

to the user0 partition in all cases.




①

Migrate existing

user data


②

③


Move SequenceMigrating primary key generation

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：Postgres sequences (for generating unique primary keys) are migrated to tables on the global DB that

act as “pseudo-sequences”.

② Application requests new primary keys from global DB rather than the user partition.




①


Migrate sequence

management


②

User Data MoveMoving user data to the new user-role partitions

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：Existing users that should be migrated by Job Server are submitted as new Schwartz jobs. User data is

then migrated asynchronously

②：If a comment arrives while the user is being migrated, it is saved in the Schwartz DB to be published later.

③：After being migrated all user data will exist on the user-role DB partitions

④：Once all user data is migrated, only non-user data is on Postgres


Stores job

details

Server for

executing Jobs



User information is

partitioned

①

②


③

Migrating each

user data


④

New User PartitionNew registrations are created on one user role partition

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：When new users register, user data is written to a user role partition.

②：Non-user data continues to be served off Postgres




User information is

partitioned

①

②



New User StrategyPick a scheme for distributing new users

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：When new users register, user data is written to one of the user role partitions, depending on a set

distribution method (round robin, random, etc)

②：Non-user data continues to be served off Postgres




User information is

partitioned

①

②



Non User Data MoveMigrate data that cannot be partitioned by user

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(PostgreSQL)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：Migrate non-user role data left on PostgreSQL to the MySQL side.




User information is

partitioned

①


Migrate non-User

data




(such as session

information)

Data migration done

Non-

User Role

TypePad

User Role

(User0)

DB(Postgres)

User Role

(User1)

User Role

(User2)

User Role

(User3)

Global

Role

Non-User

Role

Job Server

+ TypePad

+ Schwartz

Schwartz

DB

Explanation

①：All data access is now done through MySQL

②：Continue to use The Schwartz for asynchronous jobs


Stores job

details

Server for

executing Jobs



User information is

partitioned

①


①

②Asynchronous Job Server



(such as session

information)

Storage

The New TypePad configuration

Database

(MySQL)

Static Content

(HTML,

Images, etc)

Application

Server

Web

Server

TypeCast

Server

ATOM

ServerMEMCACHED

Data Caching servers to

reduce DB load

Dedicated Server for

TypeCast (via ATOM)

https(443)

http(80)

http(80) : atom api

memcached(11211)

MySQL(3306)

Mail

Server

Internet

nfs(2049)

ADMIN(CRON)

Server

smtp(25) / pop(110)

Blog Readers

Blog Owners

(management

interface)

Mobile Blog

Readers

smtp(25) / pop(110)

Cron Server for periodic

asynchronous tasks

Job

Server

TheSchwartz server for

running ad-hoc jobs

asynchronously

4. Migration from PostgreSQL to MySQL

DB Node Spec History

Time OS(RedHat) CPU Xeon MEM DiskArray

2003/12

2007/11

7.4(2.4.9) 1.8GHz/512k×1 1GB No

ES2.1(2.4.9) 3.2GHz/1M×2 4GB No

ES2.1(2.4.9) 3.2GHz/1M×2 4GB Yes

AS2.1(2.4.9) 3.2GHz/1M×4 12G

B

Yes

AS4 (2.6.9) 3.2GHz/1M×4 12G

B

Yes

AS4 (2.6.9) MP3.3GHz/1M×4

〔2Core×4〕

16G

B

Yes

History of scale up PostgreSQL server, Before DBP

DB DiskArray Spec

[FUJITSU ETERNUS8000]

Best I/O transaction performance in the world

146GB (15 krpm) * 32disk with RAID - 10

MultiPath FibreChannel 4Gbps

QuickOPC (One Point Copy)

OPC copy functions let you create a duplicate copy

of any data from the original at any chosen time.

http://www.computers.us.fujitsu.com/www/pro

ducts_storage.shtml?products/storage/fujitsu/

e8000/e8000

History of scale up PostgreSQL server, Before DBP

Scale out MySQL servers, After DBP

A role configuration

Each role is configured as HA cluster

HA Software: NEC ClusterPro

Shared Storage


Postgre

SQL

FibreChannel SAN

DiskArray

…

heart beat

MySQL

Role3

MySQL

Role2

MySQL

Role1

TypePad

Application


Backup

Replication w/ Hot backup


Postgre

SQL

FibreChannel SAN

DiskArray

…

heart beat

MySQL

Role3

MySQL

Role2

MySQL

Role1

MySQL

BackupRole

TypePad

Application

mysqld mysqld mysqld

rep rep rep

opc

mysqld

mysqld

mysqld

Troubles with PostreSQL 7.4 – 8.1

Data size

over 100 GB

40% is index

Severe Data Fragmentation

VACUUM

“VACUUM analyze” cause the performance problem

Takes too long to VACUUM large amounts of data

dump/restore is the only solution for de-fragmentation

Auto VACUUM

We don’t use Auto VACUUM since we are worried about

latent response time

Troubles with PostgreSQL 7.4 – 8.1

Character set

PostgreSQL allow the out of boundary UTF-8

Japanese extended character sets and multi

bytes character sets which normally should

come back with an error - instead of

accepting them.

“Cleaning” data

Removing characters set that are out of the

boundries UTF-8 character sets.

Steps

PostgreSQL.dumpALL

Split for Piconv

UTF8 -> UCS2 -> UTF8 & Merge

PostgreSQL.restore

dump Split UTF8->UCS2->UTF8 Mergerestore

TypePadTypePad

Migration from PostgreSQL to MySQL using TypePad script

Steps

PostgreSQL -> PerlObject & tmp publish

-> MySQL -> PerlObject & last publish

diff tmp ＆ last Object （data check）

diff tmp ＆ last publish （file check）

PostgreSQL

Document

Object

tmp

Document

Object

lastFile check

data check

http://www-jp.mysql.com/

Troubles with MySQL

convert_tz function

doesn't support the input value outside the

scope of Unix Time

sort order

different sort order without “order by” clause

Cocolog Future Plans

Dynamic

Job queue

Consulting by

Sumisho Computer Systems Corp.

System Integrator

first and best partner of MySQL in Japan

since 2003

provide MySQL consulting, support, training

service

HA

Maintenance

online backup

Japanese character support

Questions