8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

1/7

Igtkrai HghrfyEikrm

Oillassaig mh dghrfahmh dIgtkrai

HE-5>;;->>11

AG ]CH LK]]HU IJ tch Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm Kot, ;113,_.I. ;113, o. ;8, (_ochmudh E)0

KGM AG ]CH LK]]HU IJkg kppdaoktaig ey H.D.@. HghrfyAgo. jir kg irmhr kpprivagf bust kgm rhksigkedh rkths kgmitchr ockrfhs jir hdhotraoaty mastraeutaig ti eh hjjhotavhIotiehr ;, 5>;5.

EHJIUH2 ^kudk Oigeiy^rhsamagf Lhlehr

MHOA_AIG IG OIGJAMHG]AKDA]Q

Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago. (H.D.@.) jadhm kg kppdaoktaig watc tch Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm (tch

Eikrm) ig Iotiehr 5=, 5>;5 ugmhr shotaig 63ij tch Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm Kot, ;113,_.I. ;113, o. ;8, (_ochmudh E), shh`agf kpprivkd jir ockgfhs ti tch rkths tckt H.D.@.

ockrfhs jir hdhotraoaty mastraeutaig, ti eh hjjhotavh Iotiehr ;, 5>;5.

Ag ^riohmurkd Irmhr Gi. = tch Eikrm agvathm suelassaigs ig H.D.@.s rhquhst ti rhlivh

tch rhspigsh ti KL^OI AU Gi. ;6(e), a.h. tch LHKUAH skdkry survhy (tch skdkry

survhy) jril tch rhoirm ij tcas priohhmagf.

]ch Eikrm ks`hm pkrtahs ti jrklh tchar suelassaigs ks jiddiws2

At kpphkrs tckt tchrh krh twi assuhs. ]ch skdkry survhy wks jadhm ag

marhot rhspigsh ti kg agthrrifktiry. Ag rhquhstagf kg irmhrrhlivagf tch mioulhgt jril tch rhoirm hgtarhdy, kgm ti ckvhpkrtahs mhstriy tch oipy ij tch mioulhgt shgt ti tchl, H.D.@. as aghjjhot privamagf k rhjuskd ti kgswhr tch agthrrifktiry. Ag fhghrkd,tch thst tch Eikrm lust oigsamhr ugmhr suoc oaroulstkgohs aswchtchr tch mioulhgt as rhdhvkgt ti tch assuhs ag tch priohhmagf,kgm wchtchr ats priektavh vkduh as iutwhafchm ey kgy prhbumaoh atlafct okush tch kppdaokgt. ]ch Eikrm agvaths pkrtahs ti jadhsuelassaigs ig wchtchr H.D.@.s rhquhst ti ckvh tch mioulhgt

8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

2/7

Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm HE-5>;;->>11H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago.

Mhoasaig ig Oigjamhgtakdaty 5Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

rhlivhm jril tch rhoirm hgtarhdy, kgm wchtchr at sciudm irmhr kddoipahs tckt whrh oaroudkthm ti eh mhstriyhm.

]ch shoigm assuh as, ag tch hvhgt tckt tch Eikrm mihs git irmhr tchmioulhgt rhlivhm jril tch rhoirm kgm kdd oaroudkthm oipahs

mhstriyhm, sciudm tch skdkry survhy eh trhkthm ks oigjamhgtakd9 Ajsi, wckt rudhs sciudm fivhrg koohss ti tch mioulhgt9

]ch Eikrm rhohavhm suelassaigs jril tch _ociid Hghrfy Oikdataig (_HO), HgVag

Xtadatahs Dtm. (Hgwag), Hghrfy ^rieh Uhshkroc Jiugmktaig (Hghrfy ^rieh) kgm tch

Kssioaktaig ij Lkbir ^iwhr Oigsulhrs ag Igtkrai (KL^OI) ig Jherukry 58, 5>;?

kgm k rhpdy suelassaig jril H.D.@. ig Lkroc =, 5>;?. Hghrfy ^rieh kgm KL^OI

suppirthm _HOs suelassaig.

_uelassaigs

Assuh ;2 _ciudm tch skdkry survhy eh rhlivhm jir tch rhoirm hgtarhdy ckvagf oigsamhrhm

tch skdkry survhys rhdhvkgoh ti tch assuhs ag tch priohhmagf kgm wchtchr ats priektavh

vkduh lky eh iutwhafchm ey kgy prhbumaoh at lafct okush H.D.@ kgm0 sciudm tch Eikrm

irmhr tch mhstruotaig ij kdd oipahs tckt whrh oaroudkthm9

_HO suelatthm tckt H.D.@ okggit rhjush ti jadh tch skdkry survhy sagoh at as odhkrdy

rhdhvkgt ti tch Kppdaoktaig kgm ti itchr rkth kppdaoktaigs ehjirh tch Eikrm, gitagf tckt

tchrh as gi lkthrakd prhbumaoh ti H.D.@. ir kgy itchr phrsig jril ats masodisurh. _HOkrfuhm tckt hvamhgoh phrtkagagf ti oilphgsktaig as rhdhvkgt sagoh oilphgsktaig as tch

sagfdh list orataokd oilpighgt mravagf rkths kgm tch lkgkfhlhgt ij oilphgsktaig as

agmaoktavh ij k ciw whdd k utadaty as ehagf lkgkfhm. _HO ksshrthm tckt tchrh as gi

prhbumaoh ti H.D.@. sagoh at okggit krfuh prhbumaoh oigohrgagf lkthrakd tckt at siufct ti

rhdy ig ag tch jarst pdkoh. Vatc rhsphot ti tch LHKUAH Friup (LHKUAH), _HO skw gi

prhbumaoh ti at sagoh tch agjirlktaig oigtkaghm ag tch survhy as git priprahtkry ti

LHKUAH, kgm hvhg aj at whrh, tcas as ijjsht ey tch jkot tckt LHKUAH tidm tch pkrtaoapktagf

utadatahs tckt tchy oiudm ush tch rhsudts ag tchar rkth kppdaoktaigs. _HO githm tckt k

LHKUAH lkgkfhlhgt skdkry survhy wks jadhm ig tch puedao rhoirm ag tch DigmigCymris 5>;? rkths kppdaoktaig (HE-5>;5->;=:). Uhjhrhgoagf k oksh ourrhgtdy ehjirh

tch Igtkrai Oiurt ij Kpphkd;oigohrgagf tch ush ij suoc mioulhgts ks skdkry survhys

ti agjirl ats mhoasaig-lk`agf, _HO githm tckt k Eikrm mhoasaig kpprivagf tch rhlivkd

ij tch skdkry survhy wiudm eh agoigsasthgt watc tch pisataig at as tk`agf ag tckt oksh.

;Igtkrai ^iwhr Fhghrktaig ht. kd. v. Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm, Oiurt Jadh Gi. O88:??

8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

3/7

Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm HE-5>;;->>11H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago.

Mhoasaig ig Oigjamhgtakdaty ?Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

HgVag krfuhm tckt tckt tch igus as ig tch agthrvhgirs rhquhstagf tch skdkry survhy ti

lk`h tchar oksh. Ag tckt H.D.@. iwgs tch agjirlktaig, HgVag suelatthm tckt H.D.@.

sciudm igdy eh oilphddhm ti masodish tch agjirlktaig aj at as ghohsskry jir tch Eikrms

mhthrlagktaig ij rhksigkedh rkths. HgVag masputhm tch rhdhvkgoh ij tch rhquhsthm

agjirlktaig kgm krfuhm tckt tchrh as kdthrgktavh agjirlktaig ig tch rhoirm sujjaoahgt jirtch Eikrms mhdaehrktaigs ag shttagf rhksigkedh rkths. HgVag quithm jril k gulehr ij

siurohs rhfkrmagf tch ghhm jir rhdhvkgoh kgm tch ekdkgoagf ij agthrhsts wchg at oilhs

oilphddagf k rhfudkthm utadaty ti masodish agjirlktaig.

H.D.@ agmaokthm tckt tch skdkry survhy wks jadhm ag hrrir. ]ch oilpkgy kdsi suelatthm

tckt LHKUAH odkals oipyrafct ag tch skdkry survhy kgm ti mkth cks git kutcirazhm tch

rhprimuotaig ij ats skdkry survhy ey H.D.@.

Vatc rhsphot ti tch trhktlhgt ij k LHKUAH lkgkfhlhgt skdkry survhy jadhm ag tchDigmig Cymris 5>;? rkths kppdaoktaig (HE-5>;5->;=:) , H.D.@. stkthm tckt at as git

kwkrh ij tch eksas jir, ir tch oaroulstkgohs surriugmagf, tch kppkrhgt masodisurh ey

Digmig Cymri ij k majjhrhgt vhrsaig ij tch survhy. Uhfkrmdhss, H.D.@ krfuhm tckt tch

trhktlhgt as git rhdhvkgt ti tch lktthr kt assuh ag tcas priohhmagf. H.D.@. rhphkthm tckt

tchrh as k ras` ij prhbumaoh ti at kgm itchrs aj tch Eikrm mhgahs rhlivkd ij tch skdkry

survhy jril tch hvamhgtakry rhoirm. K odkal ey LHKUAH ag rhsphot ij tch masodisurh ij

tch skdkry survhy wiudm rhsudt ag safgajaokgt oist ti H.D.@. eitc lightkrady kgm ag talh

kgm rhsiurohs.

H.@.D. suelatthm tckt tch prhbumaoh ti H.D.@. kgm LHKUAH, tch iwghrs ij tch skdkry

survhy, iutwhafcs tch dalathm priektavh vkduh tch skdkry survhy lky ckvh ag tcas

Kppdaoktaig. H.D.@. kfrhhm watc HgVag kgm quhstaighm tch rhdhvkgoh ij tch agjirlktaig

ag tch skdkry survhy sagoh at mam git rhdy ig tch skdkry survhy ti suppirt tch kppdahm jir

lkgkfhlhgt kgm hxhoutavh skdkrahs kgm ehghjats. H.D.@. agmaokthm tckt ag kgy oksh at

wiudm mhjhgm ats pripiskds watciut rhjhrhgoh ti tch skdkry survhy. H.D.@ masputhm _HOs

ockrkothrazktaig ij tch rhdktavh alpirtkgoh ij tch skdkry agjirlktaig oigtkaghm ag tch

survhy kgm ijjhrhm kdthrgktavh siurohs ij ghkr- hquavkdhgt agjirlktaig. H.D.@. suelatthm

tckt, saladkr ti tch Eikrms mhoasaig rhfkrmagf KL^OI AU. Gi. ;6(d), tch Eikrm sciudm

vahw tch agjirlktaig ks allkthrakd ehokush tch jious ij tch skdkry survhy as ig k

ludtatumh ij pisataigs rktchr tckg kt kg kffrhfkthm dhvhd ks rhquarhm ey tch Jadagf

Uhquarhlhgts.

8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

4/7

Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm HE-5>;;->>11H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago.

Mhoasaig ig Oigjamhgtakdaty =Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

Jir tch rhksigs favhg, H.D.@ oigodumhm tckt tch Eikrm sciudm mhthrlagh tckt tch skdkry

survhy git eh pdkohm ig tch rhoirm ij tcas priohhmagf ag kgy jirl kgm tckt kdd oipahs ag

pisshssaig ij pkrtahs ti tch priohhmagf eh mhstriyhm.

Eikrm JagmagfsAs tch _kdkry _urvhy Uhdhvkgt ti tch ^riohhmagf9

]ch Eikrm jagms tckt tch skdkry survhy as rhdhvkgt ti tch Kppdaoktaig kgm tch shttagf ij

bust kgm rhksigkedh rkths.

H.D.@. rhdahm ig tch skdkry survhy ti mhligstrkth tch rhksigkedhghss ij ats

lkgkfhlhgt oilphgsktaig oists ag ats Kppdaoktaig5kgm tchrhjirh lust ckvh atshdj

oigsamhrhm tcas hvamhgoh ti eh rhdhvkgt. Agmhhm at shhls tckt igh ij tch rhksigs tckt

tch skdkry survhy wks prhpkrhm ag tch jarst pdkoh wks ti eh ushm ks hvamhgoh ag DMOrkth jadagfs ehjirh tch Eikrm.? _kdkrahs krh k safgajaokgt oilpighgt ij tch rhvhguh

rhquarhlhgt. Ehgoclkr`agf as k tiid oilligdy ushm ey tch Eikrm ti mhthrlagh tch

rhksigkedhghss ij oists. ]ch Eikrm cks rhdahm ig prhoashdy tcas typh ij skdkry

ehgoclkr`agf mktk ti sht rkths ag itchr priohhmagfs.= ]chrh okg eh dattdh quhstaig tckt

tch skdkry survhy as rhdhvkgt ti tcas priohhmagf.

]ch Eikrm as git oigvagohm tckt kgy prhbumaoh ktthgmkgt ig kddiwagf tch skdkry survhy

agti hvamhgoh iutwhafcs ats priektavh vkduh. Ag rhdyagf ig kgm sphoajaokddy rhjhrhgoagf

tch skdkry survhy ag ats prh-jadhm hvamhgoh, tch Kppdaokgt lust ckvh rhkdazhm tckt k pkrty

wiudm da`hdy ks` ti shh at. Vchtchr tch Kppdaokgt ckm jadhm tch mioulhgt ag hrrir ir git,

at as hgtarhdy pissaedh tckt tch Eikrm wiudm ckvh irmhrhm ats primuotaig. Ks k lktthr ij

fhghrkd rhfudktiry prkotaoh, at wiudm git girlkddy eh iphg ti kg kppdaokgt ti rhdy ig k

mioulhgt eut tchg rhjush ti primuoh at. K saladkr, lirh mhtkadhm LHKUAH skdkry survhy

wks rhohgtdy jadhm ag k Digmig Cymri rkths oksh (HE-5>;5->;=:), kppkrhgtdy watciut

oigtrivhrsy. Ks githm keivh, LHKUAH atshdj kpphkrs ti ckvh oigthlpdkthm tckt tch

skdkry survhy wiudm eh ushm ti suppirt rkth jadagfs.

]ch Eikrm tchrhjirh jagms tckt tch skdkry survhy as rhdhvkgt ti tch priohhmagf, kgm tckt at

wadd eh pdkohm ig tch ijjaoakd rhoirm.

5Hxcaeat =-]ke5 _ochmudh : p.;?_hh kttkoclhgt ti _HO suelassaig mkthm Jherukry 58, 5>;?=_hh, jir hxklpdh, tch Eikrms mhoasaig ag Cymri Igh Ghtwir`s Ago.s 5>;> ]rkgslassaig rkths oksh, HE-5>;>-

>>>5.

8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

5/7

Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm HE-5>;;->>11H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago.

Mhoasaig ig Oigjamhgtakdaty 8Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

Assuh 52 Ag tch hvhgt tch Eikrm mhthrlaghs tckt tch skdkry survhy as ti rhlkag ig tch

rhoirm, sciudm tch skdkry survhy eh trhkthm ks oigjamhgtakd kgm wckt rudhs sciudm fivhrg

koohss ti tch mioulhgt9

_HO suelatthm tckt k mioulhgt, suoc ks tch skdkry survhy, pkam jir hgtarhdy ey kliugts

rhoivhrhm jril rkthpkyhrs, rhdktagf sidhdy ti hgtatahs rhfudkthm ey tch Eikrm, kgm ckvagf

ks ats pralkry purpish oilpkrasigs ij rhfudkthm oists jir ush ag DMO rkth kppdaoktaigs

sciudm eh k puedao mioulhgt. Ag _HOs suelassaig tch skdkry survhy as git ag jkot k

oigjamhgtakd mioulhgt ks k lktthr ij dkw, ks at as ag tch puedao milkag, kgm wks agthgmhm

ti eh.

_HO oathm Oioi v. K G Odkr` PHgfaghhrs\ Dtm. P;1:1\U^O =;, k mhoasaig ij Lr. Bustaoh

Lhfkrry, jir tch eksao rudh ig tch keadaty ti odkal k mioulhgt ks oigjamhgtakd2 tckt tchphrsig purpirtagf ti ckvh tch rafct ti lk`h tckt odkal (ag tcas oksh, LHKUAH) lust ckvh

trhkthm tch mioulhgt ks oigjamhgtakd kgm prithothm at jril puedao masodisurh kgm tckt

wchg k mioulhgt hgthrs tch puedao milkag a.h. at ehoilhs `giwg ti lhlehrs ij tch

puedao at okg gi digfhr eh tch suebhot ij k oigjamhgtakdaty odkal. _HO suelatthm tckt

sagoh LHKUAH oaroudkthm tch survhy ti =1 pkrtaoapktagf utadatahs, H.D.@. rhjhrrhm ti at ag ats

hvamhgoh, k saladkr survhy jirls pkrt ij tch puedao hvamhgoh watciut oigthgtaig ag

Digmig Cymris 5>;? rkths kppdaoktaig (HE-5>;5->;=:) kgm LHKUAH wir`hm watc tch

Eikrm ag tch mhvhdiplhgt ij tch skdkry survhy, at as alpissaedh ti oigodumh tckt LHKUAH

trhkthm tch skdkry survhy ks oigjamhgtakd ks k lktthr ij dkw.

_HO suelatthm tckt tchrh kdsi krh itchr rhksigs rhdkthm ti tch Eikrm prkotaohs, pidaoahs

kgm pragoapdhs wcaoc suppirt _HOs pisataig tckt tch skdkry survhy sciudm jirl pkrt ij

tch puedao rhoirm. ]chsh agodumhm tckt LHKUAH kgm ats pkrhgt, tch HMK, krh hgtarhdy

jugmhm ey rhfudkthm hdhotraoaty mastraeutirs, kdd ij tch fktchrhm agjirlktaig phrtkags ti tch

oists ij hgtatahs rhfudkthm ey tch Eikrm, tch purpish ij tch survhy as k oilpkrasig ij

oists ti prilith ehtthr lkgkfhrakd mhoasaigs ks whdd ks suppirt H.D.@.s Kppdaoktaig.

Ag tch hvhgt tckt tch Eikrm mhgahs H.D.@.s rhquhst tckt tch skdkry survhy eh rhlivhm

jril tch rhoirm ij tcas priohhmagf, H.D.@ suelatthm tckt tch skdkry survhy sciudm eh

trhkthm watc tch straothst oigjamhgoh kgm ag oilpdakgoh watc tch Eikrms ^rkotaoh

Marhotaig ig Oigjamhgtakd Jadagfs.

8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

6/7

Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm HE-5>;;->>11H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago.

Mhoasaig ig Oigjamhgtakdaty :Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

Eikrm Jagmagfs

_ciudm tch _kdkry _urvhy eh `hpt Oigjamhgtakd9

At as tch Eikrms fhghrkd prkotaoh tckt kdd mioulhgts sciudm eh pkrt ij tch puedao rhoirmugdhss tchrh as k fiim rhksig jir kjjirmagf tchl oigjamhgtakd trhktlhgt. ]ch igus rhsts

watc tch pkrty shh`agf oigjamhgtakd trhktlhgt. ]ch Eikrms ^rkotaoh Marhotaig ig

Oigjamhgtakd Jadagfsprivamhs silh fhghrkd fuamkgoh ig tch typhs ij agjirlktaig tch

Eikrm lky oigsamhr oigjamhgtakd.

]ch skdkry survhy oigtkags kffrhfkthm mktk ig lkgkfhlhgt skdkry kgm itchr

oilphgsktaig dhvhds jril =1 Igtkrai DMOs. ]ch rhsudts krh prhshgthm ag k wky tckt

mihs git rhvhkd tch agmavamukd mktk jril kgy DMO, gir mihs at rhvhkd tch oilphgsktaig

ij kgy agmavamukd hlpdiyhh.

]ch Kppdaokgts ocahj krfulhgt jir `hhpagf tch skdkry survhy oigjamhgtakd as tckt

LHKUAH cks git oigshgthm ti ats rhdhksh, kgm tckt LHKUAH cks kdwkys agthgmhm tcas

mioulhgt ti eh `hpt ijj ij tch rhoirm. ]cas as majjaoudt ti rhoigoadh watc tch jkot tckt

LHKUAH kpphkrs ti ckvh agthgmhm tckt tch skdkry survhy eh ushm ti suppirt rkth jadagfs,

kgm tch jkot tckt k saladkr survhy wks jadhm ig tch puedao rhoirm ag tch Digmig Cymri

oksh.

Uhfkrmdhss, tch jkot tckt tch pkrty prhpkragf k mioulhgt waschs ti ckvh at `hptoigjamhgtakd as git mhthrlagktavh. Gir mihs tch jkot tckt k mioulhgt lky eh oipyrafcthm

prhvhgt at jril hgthragf tch puedao rhoirm. ]ch Eikrm cks oigsasthgtdy kddiwhm tcas typh

ij agjirlktaig ti jirl pkrt ij tch puedao rhoirm ag tch pkst. ]chrh mihs git kpphkr ti eh

kgy shraius oigohrg rhdktagf ti kgy ij tch oigsamhrktaigs amhgtajahm ag Kpphgmax E ir

Kpphgmax O ij tch ^rkotaoh Marhotaig.

]ch Eikrm tchrhjirh jagms tckt tch skdkry survhy wadd jirl pkrt ij tch puedao rhoirm ti tcas

priohhmagf. ]ch Eikrms agthral mhoasaig ti trhkt tch skdkry survhy ks oigjamhgtakd as

rhsoagmhm.

8/12/2019 OEB Salary Decision

7/7

Igtkrai Hghrfy Eikrm HE-5>;;->>11H.D.@. Hghrfy Ago.

Mhoasaig ig Oigjamhgtakdaty 6Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

MK]HMkt ]irigti, Lkroc ;1, 5>;?

IG]KUAI HGHUFQ EIKUM

Irafagkd _afghm Ey

^kudk Oigeiy^rhsamagf Lhlehr