医療プロフェッショナリズム概念の検討および評価尺度の開発 ... · 2019....

Instructions for use

Title 医療プロフェッショナリズム概念の検討および評価尺度の開発とその教育実践への応用

Author(s) 山本, 武志

Citation 北海道大学. 博士(教育学) 甲第12820号

Issue Date 2017-06-30

DOI 10.14943/doctoral.k12820

Doc URL http://hdl.handle.net/2115/67105

Type theses (doctoral)

File Information Takeshi_Yamamoto.pdf

Hokkaido University Collection of Scholarly and Academic Papers : HUSCAP

https://eprints.lib.hokudai.ac.jp/dspace/about.en.jsp

��

�

�

3

3

6

9

10

13

13

13

14

24

28

37

37

38

39

44

58

68

IPE

76

IPE 76

IPE

77

IPE

82

88

3 88

� ozf S�29n?2?��G2�?�a{\ IPE��8� �� 96

o�c �JC�d:�;p� �� 112

�I� �� 115

Z�� 128

129

3

��

2011 i

ii Inteprofessional education IPE:

CAIPE Centre for the Advancement

of Interprofessional Education IPE

1 Journal of Interprofessioal Care

Reeves IPE

2 IPE

IPE 1960

3 1980 4

1970 5

IPE

1990 6 IPE

GP

GP IPE

2004 GP

GP JAIPE Japan

Association for Interprofessional Education 7

JIPWEN Japan Interprofessional Working and Education

Network 8

i 3 IPE 2007

ii IPE

4

2000 IPE

IPE

IPE

IPE

IPE IPE

6

IPE

GP

GP IPE

IPE

9 GP

IPE

IPE IPE

2013 Cochrane 15

2

IPE

Buring 10 IPE

(1) (2)

(3) (4) (5)

(6) 6

Kent & Keating11 IPE (1) (2)

(3) (4) (5) (6) (7)

7 Sakai 12

(1) (2)

(3) (4) (5)

(6)

5

IPE IPE

× ×

N o

IPE

× IPE

RIPLS Readiness for Interprofessional Learning Scale

13 N N RIPLS

14 ×

IPE o Chiba Inter-

professional Competency Scale (CICS29) N 12,15iii CICS29 IPE

N

N

2014 IPE

× IPE 2 2013

1 2013

×

N IPE

N N IPE

N

IPE

N ―

× N

IPE × 21 1

16 IPE × N N N

×

” ± ” 17 N N IPE

Chandratilake18 ×

iii 15 ― 1 N N

6

19 IPE

��

(1) ��

Profession

Carr-Saunders & Wilson 20

(1) (2) (3)

(4) 4

21 Lieberman22

(1) (2)

(3) (4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

23 Hall24

(1) (2)

(3) (4) (5) 5

Lieberman22 Hall24

20,22 Lieberman22 Carr-Saunders Wilson

20

20,24

7

± 20,22,25

N

N

Full-profession

N Semi-profession

N

N

26 27

N

(2)

N

1990 1990

28 1994 ―

1993 Harvard

Medical Practice Study29

1990

o o

N De-professionalizasion

N

N ×

(3) i

× 1970

30 1990 ABIM American Board of

Internal Medicine × 31

×

× 32 1990 ×

N 33

8

N

N N 32 N

× N N

× N N

34

o 35

N ×

35 ×

o N

N N

N

× 31

×

N ×

×

3 ABIM, ACP-ASIM: American College

of Physician-American Society of Internal Medicine, EFIM: European Federation

of Internal Medicine N ×

× 36

3 N 10

× N

P-MEX Professionalism mini-evaluation exercise 37 Doctor-patient

relationship skills Reflective skills Time

management Interprofessional relationship skills

4 3 ×

N ×

9

i

× × N

× N

× o ― N ―

× ABIM 1995

N × Arnold 38 N

N N ABIM 1990 N

× ×

ABIM 1995 1995 ×

N 39 ABIM × Altruism

Accountability Excellence Duty Honor and

integrity Respect for others × 6

N

ABIM × Arnold N Duty

0.6 Arnold

N Arnold 1 N 6 N

Aramesh 40 ― N

Arnold Arnold N

― 41,42 ABIM 2002

N ×

N 1995 6 ×

P-MEX37 92 N FD (Faculty Development)

×

142 N Doctor-patient relationship skills

Reflective skills Time management

10

Interprofessional relationship skills 4 24

N P-MEX 43 44,45

N N FD N 4

ABIM 6 N × N

×

46-50

× 51 52 N

×

N Professionalism

behavior 33 53

2016 ×

× N

×

N 40,54,55

× N

×

× N N

ABIM ACP-ASIM EFIM

×

N

N N

× ABIM ACP-ASIM EFIM 3

11

N

× N N

× ×

N × N

× 56

― N ― ×

×

― N N

× × N

× N

1990 × N

× N

×

N N

× ×

― ×

× ×

IPE 2014 N 2014

N ×

N ×

×

×

― N ×

× N × PDCA

Plan-Do-Check-Act ±

12

_+�_>�G12K(;`4�3a_(�G��`4�3a_(�G$�0�BK7�`4�3a

_]W\b d :��6 _]W\c d �'

#9ÌPEaG�?

#9�?G>�`4�3a

#9�?G

&=`"�_<-a

�.VÛMSQYT[RX(�G&=`4�3_4�3a

�,G�.VÛMSQYT[RX>��GD/`4�3a

��)�C8@!#9ÌPEaVÔZXD/`4�3a

�b.%12G� *PDCAPLN\H%12G5��F AEJI

13

i

N ×

× N

× 1990 ×

×

×

i M

× N

× × N

N N

N

web Pubmed Google Scholar

±

× professionalism

(1) ± (2) ±

N

MSW N

× (1)

(2) o

(3) ×

× N

N N 3 N

×

× professionalism code of ethics

14

N ―

(4)

N

i

4

3 N 11 2 ―

× 1

(1) ABIM ACP-ASIM EFIM 2002 57 (2)Good medical

practice (GMC: General Medical Council) 2015 58 ”GMP

2015” (3)CanMEDS 2015 physician competency framework

(Royal College: The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, 2015)59

”CanMEDS 2015” (4)

2008 60(5) ×

× ± N WS , 2015 61

TF (6) International code of medical ethics

(WMA: World Medical Association) 2008 62 ― N (7)

× (Arnold & Stern, 2006)31 7 N

Miller 1988 63 (11)Wheel of professionalism

in nursing N ”Miller ”

× N N (8) Code of

ethics for nurses (ICN: International Council of Nurses), 2012 64

”ICN code 2012” (9)The ANA nursing code of ethics (ANA:

American Nurses Association, 2015) ”ANA code 2015” 65 (10)

2003 66 3 N

(12) Physical therapy core values (APTA:

American Physical Therapy Association) 2012 67 ”APTA values 2012”

(13) Code of members' professional values and behaviour (CSP:

Chartered society of physiotherapy) 2011 68 ”CSP code 2011” 2

N

ĻA

°�ŕčňûĝėĨLßćQXIhG��m~v��y�H?GŘőÓŖH\[^��|q�

�5�ûð

Ń÷

ßćîBßćĝė

ßćB

ÐĻĴ

Òć

ïThŎĐ

ļ¾

ľ¤^�ĝ

ė

>��

��3+8/)'4��5'8*�5,��4:+84'2��

+*/)/4+EľØİ¨čň�

ĳģ¼ÒÞĝCľØF

>��!��

��3+8/)'4��522+-+�5,��.=9/)/'94��3

+8/)'4�!5)/+:=�5,��4:+84'2��

+*/)/4+EľØİ¨±©CľØF

>��

��;856+'4��+*+8':/54�5,��4:+84'2��+*/)/4+��

D�~�

İ¨±©C�#ď

�j¹b��o

ØL¦ņ�

�55*��

+*/)'2��8'):/)+

�+4+8'2��+*/)'2��5;4)/2

�>�

Ø�ç��©C Ø�

��Ŗ

��Ö

Ň

��ğê?xp�?��nD��x��45<2+*-+��91/229�'4*�6+8,583

'4)��

ďZë�!',+:=�'4*�7;'2/:=�

��t��sDv��?�D��Dv~�?}D��Dq

��533;4/)':/54��6'8:4+89./6�'4*�:+'3

<581��ü

ŏjĿèSh��'/4:'/4/4-�:8;9:�

�� Ĵ]ĄģPi?��Ĵ

?��Ĵ

?��Ĵ

]«Ĥ?ÌÝ_��Ĵ

«ĤķLō

IgiXIh

�

�'4��!��

6.=9/)/'4�)53

6+:+4)=�,8'3

+<581

".+� 5='2��522+-+�5,��.=9/)/'49�'4*�!;8-+549�5,��'4'*'>��o

�|čň�Á©Co�|�

� �ŉ

²��Ö

Ň

��ŘőĥìĎjĢRX?´îBčňûBí©a^t�~��jĶ

»Sh�

��čňûïĭ^éÎ½Ąa^à¦jĢRX?´îBčňûBí©a^

t�~��jĶ»Sh�

��éĀ^ÇÑeèĔ§ĵ\ìĎa^t�~��jĶ»Sh

��Ĵ]�'4�

��!��D��DqLßć

Pi?�� Ĵ

?� Ĵ

]«ģPiXIh

��ã^ûÃŘő

äā%«

Ĥķ&

ıŁ�ã©

�� Ŗ

��Ö

Ň

A�ã^ºŁĥĊł

A´î]ĘShĊł

�A�ãĒÏ·^Ċł

�A�ã�®^¸ÄîZ^¸Ä

Aí©]ĘShĊł

� Ĵ]�ã^Řőjģc?��Ĵ

]�

^ŘőÓŖjßć@��Ĵ

]ŁûÃŘőä

āLĄģPi?��Ĵ

]«ĤķL³ÔPi

h

��m~v�

��y�^Ûó

ĪĜŇĺ�

ıŁ�±Â�±©EG��m~v��y�Â�^t�z�ux

jÅćQfJH$!{

xq�nDxF

� �Ŗ

��

�l

�

�í©]KNh�ã�

��í©ĥáńa^ÕÊ

��å¢jñNhâąZå¢Shâą

��ãZQX^üŏ]ĞShĮįĆ

�đúe}D�?ĘĂ¸Ä]KNh�ã�

��ĖŌ\¥Ğ¶^ñŋZĆÙa^Ę£

� �đúe}D�^�D{ŚD��

n��DZQX^ŉ²

��Ă·ĆZ´îĠý^æĦ

��ÍĂZQX^�ã

��Ě¡Ć^ġÀZĉ¯±ô

��éÎµőZp��kÅć

��Ĵ]ÚPiTG��m~v��

y�Â�^t�z�uxjÅćQfJHZ

ęSh�Dqv�~�^G�ã^t��

�vDZQX^��m~v��y�H

^z~v��YĶĻPiT°r�D�^�

�|q�?Kf`?ıŁ�±Â�±©^õ

Ć�ãp��kÂ�Éī��©]fh

Gp��kÆĔ^Tc^±ôŇĺH^İŋ

jĩ×QXòĈQTd^

EVWMF

�ºĹ�Ë

ē

ºĹ��'�ÿ

ŕù^řöĵŗ

��(�t��sDv��Bxp�

��)�ŘőĥőªKf`ŀĥőª

Ëē��Ě

¡Ć

��D��y�

��ċŅĊĲ

��Őĕï¿

��_��Ĵ

]��wmq�B��

�m~v��y�jœUùO?�� Ĵ

]��m~v��y�^ÒćŎĐjÐĻ

QXIh

��4:+84':/54'2�)5*+�5,�3

+*/)'2�+:./)9

$582*��

+*/)'2��995)/':/54>�ă

¬�ã©F

��Ŗ

�^

¿ł

��ã^�ĸĥ\¿ł

�´î]ĘSh�ã^¿ł

��ĬŔ�ã]ĘSh¿ł

��Ĵ]ÜěPi?�ħ

^òĈL\PiX

IhEÛóòĈ_��Ĵ

�

�ã

�+*/)'2�

685,+99/54'2/93�/4�

:.+�4+<�3/22+44/;3

��'�6.=9/)/'4�).'8:+8Eþ��k�]K

Nh�^��m~

v��y�C�ã

ÈøF

��V

^Ëē

�^Ċł

��´î^ĽŐŊČ^Ëē

��8/4)/62+�5,�68/3')=�6':/+4:�<+2,'8+�

��´î^éŒĆ]¸ShËē��8/4)/62+�5,�6':/+4:�';:5453

=��í

©Ĉ¿�Ð

ĈĆ^Ëē��8/4)/62+�5,�95)/'2�0;9:/)+�

��m~v�

��y�^ģ¿

!:+84��"��8452*��

ē5

��ĭëĤÛû÷ćC¿åGO?]=v~ucmi{q}kx>3=İĬ¶Į>SRUv~ldo;MND<

�

�%"��/,-&)$��*!"�*#��.%& -�ę

»�±Ã �

İĬ¶Į�

��(",& �)��/,-"-��--* &�.&*)

��ę»�±Ã ��

�

�Į��¹

ĢQJUċĦ_

êġI]ėÖ

Pµå

�Ä?Z\Z§�YLKf`_·@

��Í¯áWUgwmoy�o

��ÍUª´3�î3«ī_âàG3ħ±G3Ï]

��±ËìWUèčQêġèč

�ÇßQõÍWU�Ġ;ª´Q�îUâà3ďįU�Æ3¯áĄ6ëĤ

ÛĄåÿ_óE]<

��îPÊUº?fÙĂ�UKXU3İĬĄSÛ×�¡ZÚ£_¿

\3�Æ3�íI]4

��Ëì3¢�3�Ĭ3ýÈ�ĐWU¸¬_ĀHO3ëĤÛUàěT�ĥ

I]4

��gwzrna3»�3»½ĄSª´r9k_ğKIKXTõUëĤÛ

Q ĈI]

��±U�ü_ġ[BTG3Ì�æÀ_¦¿]4

� �ĎT¼Ĩ3¤ĎPV��Ď

�ăđC

Ĩ?[Ô?KC� Ď

TÞ�²ēF^K

��±ÍUİĬ¶

ĮČĞ�± �

�� U

Ùė

QJU�ê

��ÍU«īUôÒ3�ÍQUÜĪ�¥3ĘćSf`Ă�3¯áØĜ

UĚ±3SR

��Ă�F^K�±WUèč3©ó�Ñ3·ĉ�ÔUéā3ýÈ:�

ÓUïñQ�Đ3öÛÐQU Ĉ

��ÇßUªÚĚÆ:ðà3ĕ·U�Æ

�� ¡ģùWU�ĥ3�±ÛUÌ�¸¬QJ^_ĢÅIÌ�ãĆW

U�ĥ

��ĎT�±ÃUİĬ�āCãāF^3

��ĎT�±ÍUİĬ¶ĮQGO�ā6�

ùGKYU

��(

*!"'�#*,�+,*#"--&*)�'&-(

�&''",��ę

»�

��M

UÒĩSÉ

Q�M

UĲ

É7�ø

�ćTAE]¢��

±U��Ąsmde|b�p

Ĳ7�İ

Ĭ¶ĮUÕÏ��Ĭ

ıU�Đ6ÁĨQĔ�

�ĎTČĞ°đ�ą

þ��C

¿åF^

O?]

�,*#"--&*)�'&-(

��%1-& �'�.%",�+1� *,"�0�'/"-

��(",& �)��%1-& �'��%",�+1��--* &�.&*)��ę

»�

��M

U�ü÷¨

Q��Å

Ē

�êġèč3�ī

õÎ�3��Ä

?Z\�f

`}�e3��ú

�ä3 �ç

ËF3��ë

ĤÛQGOUèĠ3��Ì

�Ąèč

��ĎT²ē3�Ď

T�ăFÔ?]

�

�*!"�*#��,*#"--&*)�'��'/"-��)!��"%�0&*/,

��%�,.","!��* &".1�*#��%1-&*.%",�+1;�»<

��M

UòQ

��¹Ģ

�·�WUèč

�İĬĄÝ]Ė?

��³�ĄSh9tjUĂ�

��ú�äU�Ċ

� �ĎT¼ĨF^3�Ď

�ăđC®¾

ÁĨFÔ?]

Ĭ�

ĭĝÂ

�

�±Ã

�%"�� *!"�*#�".%& -�#*,�)/,-"-2��

±ÃUİĬ

¶Į<

��).",)�.&*)�'��*/) &'�*#��/,-"-2;»½�±Ã �<

��

ĞĮ�

·ĉ�Ô

��±ÃQá8

��±ÃQËì

��±ÃQ�±ëĤÛ

��±ÃQ ĈÍ

17

N 2008 ”ASHP statement on

professionalism”69 10 N N

× N 1973

3 10 70

1997 N N ―

N

N N 13

× 13

N

N ”GMP 2015”

No.14 ”You must recognise and work within the limits of your competence

N ”

”CanMEDS

2015” ”(Physicians are able to) Identify opportunities for learning and

improvement by regularly reflecting on and assessing their performance using various

internal and external data sources”

N

N N 3

KJ 71 N

N

N

N

― N

N N

N N N

18

× N

N

N 3

4

13

N

N 90 21 7 3

× N 2

13 3

N × o

o o

o

3

―

×

N ”

”

N N

N

”CSP code 2011”

± N

N N

N N

± N N

Ŋ��]kOES/Ŀŝ�6īò %wŬ]k\?QJfUhLb�ł

�'(��Ęý/ä�Ė nė�ĺ.ðÞ"8

Ęý�©/ċň

F</%2/Ęý�©/ċň ä/Í�áŬ�F</%2/þù�©/ċňő�/§Ŝ/ćĄ

nė-wŬ/ĳ¦+$/ćĄB�]m*nė-ő�;ćĄ ôű"8�Ęýő��nė�©;ċň �Ý"8

ÄĄ/ªy4cmN�;|�ì�8Ļþë�/Įċ;Ì� ĬûĤ;�ų"8Ġ/â�Ļ�þë/áŬ�F<;�Ł ŉŠ.�!)Úļ"8

ÜĒ�/�ç/|�µ�4uě;�å. nė.åÜ"8Ġþë.58F<�áŬ/Ċ�;Ĵ�.ŋ� ŉŠ.�!)Úļ"8

âþë¨Ĺ

Ļþë/KDi �Ĩ� Ńů.³r;ŏ�ŉŠ.�!)Ġ/Ļþë.ŲŢ�ŖÎ�Ěħ;Ì�Ļū.I_�S <TW>K;"8

þë�/Įċ;Ì� ĬûĤ;�ų"8Ġþë/Ĕřĉ4Ńů;»Ď38�+�*�8Ġþë.¬ŗ;|�µ��qü"8ŅĦ;Ì��å.åÜ"8

P�b/z{+ )h�O�JQ]�ďŀ;+8ġþë*§Ŝ"1��çúŖ/Ŀŝ+ņp/ŅĦ�*�8Ġ/wŬç�ŉŠ-+�.ŲŢ�'�û«;vß"8

�ç/�ú;Ť� ) Ù�47/�8Ìĺ;+8�ç/Áąľĉ�ĉœ�æ�´ÒĴûĤ-,�.+6:9#.�ç+�:7;ß'

Ĕřþ+/Ų²�¨Ĺ

ġþë¨Ĺ

Ġþë+/¨Ĺ.Ö�"8t-8�Ĩ�4ÿł;ß&%ą+¨Ĺ"8

�ç+/ĵĐ-¥ť��¯;ŕ'

zą�+ )/�ç;Ť� �:8

�ç�/ÁąĴő�ĴÐt��Ĩ�;ğñ"8�ç/¹ţ ą�/¹ţ;ğñ"8�ç/Ōo ğ¾;ê8�îKN>i ¿Å ŁĩŃů-,/ÁąÐ;ËŪ %Ģ��*�8

�ç�âÂ¶Ĳ*�85�.Û�"8�ç/âŦĉ;ğñ"8ĩã/�Ľ <TY<gmK�GmG�OmK�;Û�"8

�ç/�ģ;į�8I�ZK;ĳ¦"8�ç�Ġ/wØ4wŬĔřþ/r»;Œ��+;ğñ"8Æ7��&%+�.0čå.èÓ"8

�ç/ţ~ �ç/rÈ;ğñ %áŬ�F<;ĳ¦"8�ç+/ÿš�¯4X�SU�JQ];�Ũ %ø*áŬ�F<;ĳ¦"8�ç.:�74"� Č�-úŖĳ¦4ēŘ;Ì�

âŦĉ/ń� Ĕřþ+ )âŦ %�î �ĺ;Ì�âŦ�3%6"ďŀ;|�ì�8

�ç�âþë�ġþë+/ĚÃÔŞ

�çĪĀ/F</ĳ¦

�çĪĀé

�ç/��ÉŎ�¸Ê-ûĤ�;Ñĥ.Í28�+.áŬ�F</öķ;ĸ)8

�ç.+&)ŉŠ-+�.ŲŢ�'�û«;vß"8

�ç/âŦĉ;Í28 Û�"8Ĺ��

Mi\F<;Û��@mXl�"8

áŬ�F<.�"8ÑĂ/úŖ;íï Űõ.ĵŞ"8nė-wŬ;ĳ¦"8áŬ�F</·�/ō�åĉ;Ť� )�8

Í�KDi+ĩã.�(�ĔřþĴåĕ

Í�KDi+ĩã.�(�åĕ

Í�j^i/KDi+w�ĩã;ŕß $9;ń�"8��ĴÏ£.�(�%rÙ¶Ĳ åĕ;Ì�Çŧ/ŭ� Ç�Ĵ-F<;ĳ¦"8��/ńĶ Ă �ĩã/ęĜ/%2.º¢�ĺ;Ì�

Ŀ÷�÷ÕĴåĕâă/¿ĺ4Ìs.'�)/[<jZe�4\=�TWQE;¡28X\A�`mK;ā7Ŕ8âŐ/ĩã4Ńů�ś�/À��ōĝ;Č �Łã )�8

µĞ�î�Ddh<�ńĔřþ+ )µĞĴ.�î"8�+/ŉŠĉ;Łã )�8Ĕřþ+ )Ċİ;Ğ�8�+;ı�¡28Ddh<]gm;ÔĊ åÌ"8

âÂ�Ť âă/¸ÊûĤ.ũr vß�Èø;Ć8à�.Č�*�8

GaeVF�Jfm�ó Ç�Ĵ-GaeVF�Jfm;Ì�°ĭ/×Ĉ

Ōĉ/�8Ìĺ ĩã;ŕ'};'�-� ÿš*�8ą*�8�+ĩĴ¼¤�;ŕ'

ŐŚ Ůx CRHh G�T

wŬĔřþ/�Ň+-8ą�±Ċ+ĩã�KDi

wŬĔřþ/�Ň+-8ą�±Ċ+æ�ĴKDi

Ōĉ�čå��Ù�47

ĵĐ-đ®4¿ş½�

ß��aGP>7B%Õð�,Ë¤��VøGPF6?:MCO<J`Ù��

té�f_$��.»ì«!��%·é

e��,àÒ#å¡+�þ1*,0#�®ømĀ$Îb#Õð1m��b�$äÃ1� �õÎ#Vø�|%óñ��ã#Úâ1T��¼1�

~°©å%Ï¸#óñ!ä� e�%©å�GN5E:�$g0.©å1h(�1�Þ�.Å«� pí�'�e�©å%Õð!ÝS%ÜÉ� �.

Vø»ì«!��%�\Î·×1[��

��%óY%�)$Vø»ì«%ÊR+ö¨1óñ�#�e�+�\!%¬ò%§$«s�²-ö��.�!1��Ö/.

ç+ûô�ù1ô]��\Î·×1¾ �.

ç+ûô�ù1�.

�/�/%»ì«$Ïñ�/.ç�lÁ1�.ûôÎ$Ï¸!}�.T�xÌ1� ®ømĀ+{nA�=%^�2��%Äà´#¥ý%�²1�0#�ü¦{n1� ¨��e�&%ºê+ÔT#"�£â#ûôÎ#Ú÷1�

��Î#y�ëÇ&%iï�Îjg&%qú

H;�KA43%óñ!©åÍo%�-æ

H;�KA43&%¶��´#ÆZH;�KA43+��&%´b#©åÍo

�\%D�<1Ø��/$Z�.·×1��äy�Vø�á�±Ñ$��ô]��.

y�³�&%iï

äy�Vø�á�%�\³�%v²$iï�.³�ÎdÓ$iï�.

� !�«�%¬ògu1r).dÓ1� »ì«¿ª&%KQE�:?G1U��.

ÊW%äyVøá�dÓ$Æ�.ô]!�z

ÊWVø�äy�á�%dÓ$iï�.ÊWVø�äy�á�%»ì«��¹!%ÿw1).� Xµ�îèVc%À¯

�\Î·×1[��

9ILD@4�»ì«¢È��\&%�z

�«�%»ì«¢È&%kÂ��z

»ì«¢È%�ø�83%��§�^½$iï�.»ì«¢È!��%ÛÐ$iï�.

ó��~

_k

TN

W=

à½

4G

8P

'X

=@

Ýw

��

�$r

¯�

Á��

��

��r

¯@

Å�

ċă

±Ê

�r�

�t

�z

��

��!� �

��

��ìû

�¢

�z

��

��

èÓ

>Ô

�C

�Ā

�,

&&

**

ôÎ

@+

F¦

ê#

ß¶

Hø

9*

&&

**

**

vH

9.

>,

#Æ

Ă<

0F

Ë<

+F

3=

**

&*

&*

**

**

&&

ßç

��

4H

ø9

**

**

&&

µÉ

@�

¥Ä

Þ?

Ćo

5#

q²

%¤

ÂH

ÌF

**

**

&*

*

³�

?Ð

�<

+F

&&

£y

ç>

Pb

eY

O'

Rf

lH

¦-

&&

&*

*&

&

�â

@®

Í&

&*

Õü

Å=

5;

�Û

ç?

�»

6F

3=

@ò

āÎ

Hî

¶5

;,

F&

**

&*

&&

&&

Õü

Å=

5;

Ïã

HÛ

2F

3=

Hä

,�

AF

**

**

*

Md

hI

_g

lH

«Ï

5·

¦6

F*

&&

&

µÉ

@¦

pC

OI

?9

,;

@]

Ij

\e

'C

^J

'X

ZU

NH

�A

F&

&*

**

[^

K'

al

SH

ÇE

÷F

**

&&

**

**

*

µö

@ß

¶C

ïĊ

%þ

�@

|

%õ

ÚH

Ð5

1î

¶5

;,

F*

**

&*

**

*

§,

j`

i@

SM

i=

r�

ß¶

Hø

²5

#7

GH

ð�

6F

&*

&&

&*

**

*&

&&

x�

ç¨

�?

�:

,8

o°

�å

#·

ÖH

¦-

&&

**

&*

&*

**

&&

£ą

@Ĉ

,#

£y

ç>

OI

Hæ

�6

F*

**

**

*&

&

x�

@ð

é#

È5

,ß

¶@

ØÙ

@8

A?

��

�ê

H¦

-&

&*

&&

*&

&*

*&

**

´ć

�OI

?�

6F

©È

@Ã

ùH

º¼

5#

Č¿

?è

ÿ6

F&

**

&*

**

**

**

m×

>r

ćH

æ�

6F

**

**

**

**

*

´ć

�OI

@�

y@

õ�

·Î

Hă

{5

;,

F*

**

*&

&

Õü

Å=

5;

µĄ

58

�»

#�

êH

¦-

**

**

**

µĄ

/B

8D

6Ò

íH

u0

¹2

F*

*

(9

:1

)

ă�

ćú

rć

Õü

Å@

�ñ

=>

FË

��

Ï=

ß¶

%S

Mi

rć

Õü

Å@

�ñ

=>

FË

��

Ï=

¸z

çS

Mi

ôÎ

%Ĉ

¶%

Ñ·

4

µ¡

�ă

Pb

eY

O'

Rf

l�

¾&

�Û

�»

%M

dh

I}

ð&

ëÀ

%À

¬ç

·Ö

öý

ĉs

LV

Qh

P'

Xr

¯�

¢¯

§,

SM

i=

ß¶

?�

:1

Õü

Åç

·Ö

§,

SM

i=

ß¶

?�

:1

Õü

Åç

·Ö

µĄ

Î@

ð�

á�*

�P'

X?

�č

6F

�9n

Â@

SV

'W

cl

W/

Üª

6F

""

*�P

'X

?�

č6

F�9

@S

V'

Wc

lW

/Ü

ª6

F

ĳ��

u|i`mIĘê=WCb-nIMď�¥±.EF7/

�*�Ó¸í

��

��$��

��ÓMô¯

ŔŋÕø

��

� ��

��

��& %$��

��Ī

Ŀ¡Ã

«�

��"## %

��

�áM' ##�� "$!.

ÅĶ+·ÆKñđ/YÌĒLÉ

PV<ILÛő�a

ZMìġYĢGV

00

00

00

00

00

�áMŊ�)�áM�ÄYČé>CÛő+aZY

Ğ©@V

00

,0

00

,0

,0

00

�áIMõň¥±Rq-mo-ekuY�Ŏ>C

îHÛő�a

ZYĞ©@V

00

00

00

0,

00

�áLX5UR@2)þ�KðĽĞ©RĄŁYÈ

3,

00

00

0,

,0

00

�áLIDGĲŇKI7LŖŉ6E9ñ®Y�Ú

@V

0

�áM¦ĐYĜ4Vd-sfYĞ©@V

0

�á6čM�ÓR�őąłôM�ºYĺ9<IY

Čé@V

00

0

ÂU61DCI7LNÿßLâÏ@V

00

,

g{taZYÖ�+\~q}-@V

,0

00

0

�á6Ü¾¶ĝH7VS3LÖ�@V

,,

0,

0,

00

,,

�áMÜōûYČé@V

,0

00

00

0

ĖÝM�ħ)ZnrZy~f.b~b-i~f/

YÖ�@V

0

�áIMĠĂK¨Ō+¥±YļE

00

�á¤M½ùğĹ�ğË��

ĕ£YČé@V

00

0,

00

00

0,

,

�áM¹Ŋ)ù¤M¹ŊYČé@V

00

00

0,

,,

�áMĵ�)Č»YäV

00

00

0,

0,

0,

,

�çfh[{)¼Á)ĬĖĮœKJM½ùËYÇ

ŏ>Cď�6H7V

00

0,

,,

0,

,

�áM�ðYŋ�>G)Ô2RUM1VÈĤYI

V0

,0

,,

,,

�áM½ùĨû�û

Ļ+à�´ÍğñđKJ/LI

TXWAL�áI¥XUYÚE

00

0,

00

00

0,

,

čôåIM«ģLÑ�@V

00

0,

00

00

00

0

�KV�ĕ£RõĭYÚDCùI«ģ@V

,0

00

j-wM��I>Gz-i-eku�ā

īYIV

,0

,,

00

0

ĎôåHªń@O7�áðĽMĩŅIİ�Mįē

6H7V

00

,0

00

00

čM�őá6ĲŇKI7LŖŉ6E9ñ®Y�Ú

@V

0

ôå¤MěýYÈ2)°ĚñđY¢ŗ@V

00

,0

čôåMąłûRĮœYºĀQV<I6H7V

,,

0,

0

čôåL¯ŀY�7µ:+�ò@VįēYÈ2�

ßLß×@V

00

0,

,,

×ă¤M�áM�7µ8R�ĊY�ßL)�ćL

ß×@V

,0

čôåLSVaZ�Û

őMü�Yğ�LĴ�>)Ĳ

ŇL�?GÕĦ@V

,,

,,

ĥôåMf_{)�ĕ£)ĮœL³�Yķ3

,0

00

00

00

00

0

ĲŇL�?GčMĥôåLŖŉ�Ľ

Ê�ĉ

ĔYÈ3

,0

00

00

ĥŐLdv-m)Znp[fY@V

00

00

À÷M�Rx~h-Y�7æ;V

00

,0

00

ĥôå¤MěýYÈ2)°ĚñđY¢ŗ@V

0,

čMÜ.ĥ/ôåMÛő�a

ZY�Ĭ>)ĲŇL�

?GÕĦ@V

,0

,,

,,

,,

ÞMÉ2Ûő�a

ZMCPMôï�¬Mýı

00

0,

0

Ĺ�MªńMú÷

00

,0

]-u~H�ćKĹ�Yú÷>ëŕ@V.ĈóĹ

�/

00

00

�ć�¬Yýı> Ø@V

00

00

0

ĈóMÞ�Ć)�ć�ĤLèÙ@V

00

00

00

0

.EF9/

¡ÃÓ

ŋ�őľÒ

�á+Üôå+Ď

ôåIMĉ¿Ðņ

�áėöã§

�áėöã§

�áMÜōûYÉ

PV)Ö�@Vģ

75;

�ù¤I>GM�

áYŋ�>)¥X

V

ąłôIMŖ²+

«ģ

Ďôå«ģ

Üôå«ģ

ĸŃ

Œ�

^lcz

b-n

�Ó

Ĉó�¬Mýı

aZMCPMĈó

�¬Mýı

�ćK�őMĞ©

IBMú÷

ę�0

�b-nL¥Ŗ@VE

�îMfl-mx~m6ċÎ@V

((0�b

-nL¥Ŗ@V�E

Mfl-mx~m6ċÎ@V

ċ��

ip

aY

eC

öÍ

7Q

=[

)f

CG

ñ|

��

*?

@4

+

�&w

¶�

Ð��

��!�

��w

¶G

Õ�

Ĩġ

¸Ú

��w�

�y

��

��

� ��#�"!

��

��ĂĔ

�¥

��

�� "

��

æĘ

ÕË

óG

¾ĥ

�ZU

GÁ

¨Ñ

��è

F�

Ĝ:

P,

(,

,,

æĘ

ÕË

óC

9A

Gć

üF

�Ĝ

:P

,(

(,

,,

((

¦É

C¿

ÕÇ

GÖ

ğ�

�S

�K

P�

ÿS

¬/

(,

((

(

æĘ

Õê

ÔH

Gl

qh

)]

bi

Sv

¼:

P,

(,

((

õx

wĥ

�čº

G�

ÿF

�Ĝ

:P

((

õx

wĥ

čº

Gæ

ĘÕ

�¹ä

CG

Ĭ�

S×

KP

,(

¦É

zà

�ěē

w�

Gë

Ù(

,(

,,

,,

,,

Ã�

Gg

)_

Są

À9

;Q

F|

0P

âĄ

S¼

?,

,(

((

,,

,,

,

wĥ

�~¥

�čº

Üý

F?

.A

ġ�

9A

.P

,(

(,

,(

(

Đ�

�wĥ

�čº

GÃ

�Þ

´G

�Ý

F�

Ĝ:

P,

,(

((

Þ¾

ú�

ÿF

�Ĝ

:P

((

°±

úE

�ª

ėò

HG

�Ĝ

(,

((

(

¦ú

��

HG

�ħ

((

j^

'l

dV

UH

Gá

Â'

¦ß

Eñ

|(

,

j^

'l

dV

UM

©¯

HG

ß�

EÓ

đù

�(

(

;Q

<Q

Gæ

ĘÕ

Fû

Ğ7

QP

Ē%

�ì

SÆ

P,

,,

,(

,(

,,

Ĩġ

úF

ûã

C¢

0P

u·

�ø

S¬

/,

(,

(,

,(

Øĥ

�ĭ

M

�d

)`

G�

8T

%;

Gï

Čß

EÎ

ĪG

³Ý

S¬

RE

.,

((

,(

ĩÏ

�

S¬

/Ò

®%

�Ä

HG

åĖ

MĀ

uE

D%

ÌĎ

EĨ

ġú

EĆ

ĤS

¬/

,,

,

�Ä

GÓ

đ�i

nW

h]

)F

�R

PÓ

đS

�J

�SÆ

Ċ:

P(

,(

,,

((

((

ðÕ

ÇB

�Ě

:I

4�

ÄÓ

đG

āĝ

Cĉ

tG

Ĉô

3B

4P

((

(

¿¤

GĠ

{G

=K

Fw

ĥæ

ĘÕ

Gõ

sM

ģÒ

SĠ

Ğ9

E.

(,

(,

,(

((

�Ä

MÃ

�C

GÖ

ğG

ÑF

Õ�

3Ý

Oģ

>A

.P

6C

SÈ

5ă

QP

,,

,,

�Ä

2N

Čþ

Eđ

ÊM

Åī

SL

NR

E.

(,

Øĥ

�ĭ

Fú

�E

āĝ

S�

9%

�Â

FĐ

îS

¬/

(,

((

,,

,

§Ģ

úE

wĥ

»¡

GĠ

Ğ%

¦ď

EĆ

ĎS

uÀ

9=

Âç

S¬

/(

((

,,

,

�ĕ

½�

�F

15

Pæ

ĘÕ

C9

AG

âĕ

,(

((

�¥

¶ġ

�ĥ

Ēµ

Ďę

Ħx

Xc

\o

[)

fw

¶

$$

,�[

)f

F�

Ĭ:

P�?

G^

c)

el

qe

3î

²:

P

ĒM

Ĩġ

«Ħ

Sġ

�9

%Ã

�ú

âĄ

Sé

/:

P

ĒM

Ĩġ

«Ħ

SÆ

P

£Û

Óđ

Gû

ãE

ĠĞ

CĐ

¥

wĥ

æĘ

ÕC

9A

GÃ

�ú

âĄ

S}

=:

÷�,

�[)

fF

�Ĭ

:P

�?r

ÑG

^c

)e

lq

e3

î²

:P

Ã�

úâ

ĄS

}=

:

[k

mg

cV

%æ

ĘÕ

Ëó

%Ã

�H

G

�

¿Õ

ÇG

æĘ

ÕË

óH

G�

í'

�

(

õx

GĐ

�w

ĥč

º�

ÿF

ñ:

Pġ

�C

�

�ª

Þ´

HG

�Ĝ

j^

ld

VU

GĠ

ĞC

Óđ

ù�

G-

24

%�& �! �� "�(

13

1990

5 GMC ” Good

Medical Practice” ”Good Medical Practice” 1995

1998 2001 2006 2013 5

”CanMEDS” ”CanMEDS” 1996

2005 2015 3

3 2002 ” ”

ABIM 1990

”ABIM1995”

1995

7 ”ANA code” 2001 2015

7

1990

(1) �!�)'��#��$�"��

”ABIM1995” 1980 integrity respect

compassion humanistic qualities

1

25

1995

(2) M

2 9 ”CanMEDS 1996”

Evidence N

Evidence-based medicine EBM 2002

”ICN code 2012” Evidence-

based practice EBP 1995 ”ABIM1995”

× N Excellence

”GMP2006”

EBM EBP N ”ANA

code 2015” ” ICN code 2012” ”CSP code 2011” ”APTA values” 2012 2003

N N ”ANA code 2001” ”Miller

”

EBM 1991 Guyatt72 editorial

N 1995 73 1997

Evidence-based nursing EBM

EBP × ”CanMEDS 1996” EBM

EBM EBP N 2000

×

1 N

Professional autonomy N

N 74

”ANA

code 2015” N N

26

”CSP code 2011”

× N

N

(3)

N N 3 19

” ” N N

”GMP 1995”

involved N 2000

o ”

” 1 N

× N

”ANA code 2015”

N ±

2000

N

(4)

2 16

1995 ”ABIM1995”

×

”GMP 1995” ×

× 2000

20

N N ”CanMEDS 2015” o

N N χ

”ICN code 2012”

27

Yamamoto 15 6

Team management skills

Attitudes that improve team cohesion 2

Interprofessional education

collaborative(IPEC)75

Teams and teamwork

”CanMEDS 2015” collaborator

Hand over

”GMP 2015” Continuity and coordination

(2008)

”GMP 2006” ”CanMEDS 2005”

76

(5) ��

2 ”CSP code 2011” 3

”ANA code 2015”

28

N ”CanMEDS

1996” ”GMP 2006”

2000 ”To err is human” 77 1

N o

21

(6) 2 2

4

2000 ”ANA

code 2015” N

78 ×

(7) 2 8 X

N

N 3

1990

20 N ×

(1) i

― × ―

× ( 2) ―

× N N

N

N ―

×

29

2 2

1990

20

20

�"�5-G�$DEJ��D'�#SO`

8<SO`D

%0F�C?�5-#�3

c.d

Q[]XVM;�5-6 ;'�HG1�

�I� *7K /A;'�#2�K=BJ

��%�+��)*-

�� )��20/13�%��+�2�$4

��2��2��)+��3��"4

��!�.�('3�".#&(��,+ �4

�:9�&(F>@J�"ZaYNUR^W_T\��

)+!�G��5-DG4�b��

�,��GPL��

30

79

80 81-83,iv 84

85

1990

2000

iv

81

31

(2) ��

��

86

AIA American Institute of Architects ”2017 Code of

Ethics and Professional Conduct87” ” 88”

3 4

5

3 3

[

] 3

1

3

1

•BuťÝðťîWĦ

•ÛdÇ«

•ŉŚŞŕňŦŌşŤ~â

•ÍÎRÖťņŝšŁĉ²

•(¹ť¹^³Wøĕ

•ēĜŎņŢİ¼ðĲIĭģ

`ĈØ³Wø

•Ûnuĳ²�

•ÛØÃĳ`ĈØčEĵĳecĖó©

•GHĳ��6±Á¿ 3Ĳ_ĩļ«çİó©

•�h�Æĵĳ\�

•řŎŜŒłŁĳ.®İwJ��ĳěĻ�

•�ĸ�«ÐĐĿSļ

•�wJĳÿ,ı.®İ�ò

•6±`ĈØİħĮĳ¾�³ô�Ŀ�īĩ

•ňŁĳīķĳËÒ¬Lĳ�!

•T%ı6±ĳ��İĪĳ�üŨ

•v×�qĳňŁ

•v×ĳÛnuĿēķļĚ

��ĩļ"ĢĠĤ

•�ĊİħĮĳv×Ŀ

«çħĚċľļ

•OØÃ9"

•ÛØÃ9"

6±`ĈØĳIµİıļ

�myİ¾�³ŎņŢ

`ĈØ³WøÚ1

ŉŚŞŕőłĚ`ĈØčEĚ¾�ĵĳó©

�ĸ�«ÐĐĿ«çħĚ

¾�³ô�Ŀ%ĝĩļ

v×�q�Õ

ËÒ¬Lĳ�!

`ĈØİĳû�ť9"

Fėũ6±`ĈØĳŘţŗńŐŌşŔšŏśĳåÊ

6±`ĈØĳIµİıļ

�myİ¼ðťŎņŢ

v×ťÛØÃťOØÃİĳ

¸�®

¾�³ô�Ŀ�īĩ

•TVħīØK¬Lĳ��

•>Ø×ĳ�Ù

•¾�Ġĺĳë-Ė�®Ŀpļ

•�×ĳó©Ĳ�xĿ|ĝ

•�×ĳÞ�§Ŀ¥�į.®ħ

ıĜ

FĘũjÈZĳŘţŗńŐŌşŔšŏśĳåÊ

>#ĵĳô4

ŧ�.ĳaĄİ}íĕ

¬Lĵĳô4

Ĕ�Î=ÚıŒŋŃŤİĉ²ĕ

•¼ðİŎņŢ

•8÷uĔ@�qĕ

•Û¦ť�5³āĿaĄĩļ

•�

•Ċĳa:ĖT%ĖfÁĿ�

@ħīŒŋŃŤ

•�%�ĵĳó©

ŧ�ĳ+ąİĳû�Ũ

%Ü³ıô4

ŧ¼ðĳÏ�ťü�Ũ

•ŇŠŃŁŤœĵĳP�

üŇŠŃŅŤœĳ>x¥ģŘţōńŇœ

ĳ¶³ĸ%[ĿN�ħıĜ

•.´¸;ĿĂĤĚĶīĚĉ½ĩļ

•ŉŚŞŕňŦŌşŤĲğĜĮîWį�·

įěļĥİ

•ŇŠŃŅŤœĲÿ,ĲwJĿ�ĞÎĤ

ļ

•Â7uĔ�đĿpļīķĳwJĳÂ7ĕ

ŇŠŃŁŤœĵĳ

ô4

•�·Ě&�Ħ

•a:ĚîW

`ĈØİħĮĳ

ô4ŧ�·ťîWĕ

¾�ĵĳô4

ŧ�ĳÉÀĿ<Ĥ$ĽĚ&'ĳ.´ĲP�ĩļŨ

•�Î=Úı

ŒŋŃŤťĉ²ťWø

•�ĿSļ

üÞ��ĿSļ

ü&Ø×Ĳ�ÅıöĻ§ĸ�|ĜĿħıĜ

üê�á¤ĸ�×ĳ�.Ŀ�YħıĜ

üĒXĸĎ®�ġ&àĳT%ĿYĩļá¤Ŀ�ÓħıĜŨ

•�zp×ťã£×ťÑt�ĳ¥�ŊŦŖŎĲo�ĩļ

•jÈĲ_ĩļ«çİë�Ŀpļīķĳ 3Ŀáĝ

•?ìĚ�®Ěi¢Ě

B�

•��Ěþ�ıá¤Ŀ

2ćħıĜ

•ºWĿaĄħĚîWĠĬ&�ĲØ4Ŀáĝ

•ß ĳČùĿĪĪĳĠħĚß ĳé�Ŀ�*ħıĜ

•ä-ĳ&�ğĹĴÿ�{ÎĢĳWª

•ã°×ťãAĳ�.İ.´Ŀ�òĩļ

•úĸĠĲý¡ıģ��Ĳ»{ĩļ

•råı� ĳï�Ŀáĝ

•<�ĳÌ�Ŀ�éħıĜ

•Û¯¨ÄĳÄKĿ��ĩļ

•�đ×ĳ�.Ě�lı.´ĿWªĩļ

•�đ×ĳxsĿaĄĩļ

•ÿ,ıJăĿ�½ĩļ

•õ1ĳ�ħĜĳīķĳ/gĿ�½ĩļ

•�đ×ĲJAĖ9ñħıġĺ��Ŀ)«ĩļ

�myĚB�

`ĈØ³WøĔI�³�ĳ

�òİ¾��ÕĳWªĕ

U&ÔĠĺQDĦĽī�ďĿáĝ

�ĸ�0ĿĀSĩļ

�đ×İĳċ�ĲğĤļæn

�ĳkòMİ¸Ĳ

?ìİ�ÕĿĄŀĨļ

FęũkòMĳŘţŗńŐŌşŔšŏśĳåÊ

�myİ¼ðťŎņŢ

�đťÛØÃť�ØÃİĳċ�

¾�³ô�Ŀ�īĩ

Ûnu

ŧÛ¯Ě¨ÄĚÛ�Ũ

ä-UĚ�^UÅİ

ÿ,ıċ�ĿÏ�ĩļ

ċûØCĳ�b

Ø4�¼ĻpīÂ]ĳ��

�wJĳ�ò

��èĆĳÇ«

35

/

×

/

/

o

N N

± ±

±

(3) i

× N 89

2007

90 2015 91

−

× N

× × 1 N CLA Collegiate

Learning Assessment CLA CAE Council for Aid to

Education N CLA

PISA Programme for International Student Assessment OECD-AHELO

A ssessm en t o f H ighe r Educa t ion Lea rn ing O u tcom es

OECD-AHELO N

4

N

N PROG Progress Report on Generic Skills

92 PROG

2

36

93

3

PROG

2

OECD-AHELO

PROG 2

91 1

2

(early

exposure)

37

i P

×

―

N ×

N 6

N × N

× ×

N

2

N 25

×

N 3

.P&-%� �)$*�(3I�4G

�KN��Q/��!�*��#�

��!(&�+7@��5M��CHA�

:E5M4G :E5M4G

=O?�BF?4<�&,!�"�5M��LD6�5M��

,'+�:E��5M�19�

,'+�:E��5M 19�

=O?�BF?4<�LD6��5M��

��

��

>��:E2J�&-��

C0�H;

C8;

38

N

N

N 94 ×

N Student Physician SP N

95 o 96 N

N N

―

× 1 N

× 2 N 2 ×

N ×

97-99

N ×

N 1

N 2 N

×

× N N × 2

90 N 1 1 N

N

(

) N

N N

3 N

N 7

5 2 ×

N 259 ×

N × 3-4 100

53 1

30 2 31 N 8

39

259

� � �'��% ��&�#�(��

1

(1) ��

1) ��

2016 4 A 6 B

2) �"

A 8

679 A

35 B 110 A

8 IPE

B

IPE

3) !�$�

1 35

259 35 1

±

1 1

1

3 7

3 6 14 35

4 3

7 21 1

7

Ū��}ƔhugH\SparVlū�Ûſ�ht]U_�tis��Ûſ�

P�` K]Qr ƕ~ ŲƁ� ĕ³=ƐĒ3�$(ÉƈÅ�=ĿőCü@!0�/�@ ōĩ2Ī·=ÉƈÅ�� ůÓ�²ƊCĝ3, .�@� X�Snsm^FE3ŭĢ3¿ @ŒÖC#2�

� Ƅğ�>ėƌ"A�ƌ?3"A.�@�C,�2��ėƌ/�@ğ/�@!0

B�>2�!05B�>2�0Ä3É�@ łŌÄ"Cŵ,

ôŲ4ÁÔĕĿ3�,<¨Cţ+.�@ôĝ4ÁÔĕĿ3Ƒz#�|ð�ÒđCĠ@

�Ù«��Ă�÷Ă4�æñÞ35�6(;4ĉŨ��,</�.�@

� ôŲ4Ś�4UOTo�sC�÷3Šx#.�@ Ċľž4ğ0ļ*� .ƜC%@!0�/�@�� ıþ4ť�CÃ2�>�Ɯ%@!0�/�@�� ıþ4ƜCú>&3à¨±�ų�!0�/�@�� Ɯ4ıþ3¯�Có#2�>ų�!0�/�@

�� îÆ=Ď]U_�2�.<Ś��Ă%@Ă��@ĮƀĖ0#.½ķŌ3�Ă%@!04ũƉĢCŝõ#.�@

�� Ă¾�CƐ..'AC÷Ø%@!0�/�@� ôĝ4čƋĲ3: .�ß23C%8��B�@� ôĝ4ģňCĳ%�ř�4�ŕ3å�#.�@�� ē3Èĕ3ŹĴ#2�ÒđĘC<+.�@

�� ĺğ�>4êŋ=ū�CĀ ƆA@!0�/�@ôĝ4Éŕ=Ø{3,�.4fEteo�=gF�`c\MC¬;@

� ôĝ4Èâ4şƖ='4Ê�CĤ�3Ãħ<@!0�/�@�� öš4Ç�Cę?Ŵ?�'4Î3��%!0�/�@

��áĚ4}��}Ɣ3£%@łõC�Ěų=]te214m^FE�>śþ#.�@

òƔ�OE3£%@áĚ4ĔŶCāĄ#�Ƙď3ōƇ%@

Ü�ULs0łõ3¥-�ĮƀĖŌ÷į

Ü�ULs0łõ3¥-�÷į

�� WKw`JfbJw0��Éƈ4zźCĬŽ/�@�ù�ĺ4}è=}ƔĮƀĖ4zÃCų�!0CĹĆ%@

�ùŅĘû«

�� WsgOE=Iwdvmw_4�Ş3,�.ĬŽ/�@WsgOECë��Iwdv�%@

�ù4ôƏĢCÜ;@�ë�%@Ŕ��

�� ĺ��4�ĥ04ğ¢£¸C�9�Õń%@!0�/�@ĺĖÿ04°Ŕ3å�%@

� Ns�h3� @r�Z�S\h4ü?ŷ�B�@[�l4��0#.r�Z�S\h�ĨŜC0@

� ĺ��4�ĥ��D/�@Įƀłõ=ULs3£Ę��@ĺĖÿ4ĮƀĢ=şƖCÃħ<@!0�/�@

��ĺù4ûņ=�Ł¡3ţƒ#2�>�ôŲ4zÃCûņ%@!0�/�@

ŖĖÿ4ULs��Ł¡�şƖ3¼zCű�

�� ř4�ĥ0Í�3Č Ý�@£¸CÕń#.�@ŖƓ3Rj�_�E`cGUC%@

� ÎŢ74êŗ�²�3ħ´Ō3£B?(�0é�ÎĞ4²�=mwY�C��Ā @

��Ƅğ=�Ķ3ľ#.�ôŲ��D/�@ĮƀŲƁ3,�.¶ĽŌ3ĬŽ/�@

Ðă0ôĖÿ4ėƌ£¸C±;@�ŕCØ�

ôĖÿ4ĮƀĖĄŀ74§ĵ�ÚÂ

��Ŭ�ř4}Ɣ) /52��Ń~/Ŏ�"A.�@ŵÁ�ŕ=Űí�}Ɣ3,�.£Ę��@

Ń~}Ɣ�ŵÁ�Űí4�ŕ3¦ƅ%@

��}Ɣìī�Ŭ��ĜƔċ�y�4ŵÁ�Űíìī/Ŕ�.�@ĮƀĖ3,�.ł+.�@

Ń~}Ɣ�ŵÁ�Űí4ĮƀĖ�ìī04ƙ»Cě;@

�� ł?Ř(ĺğ4ŧŻCĭľ3ƚ>"2�ôė��@�ù4ĔŶ�hqGcS�3£B@ĔŶC¤:�Cýŧ%@

ËğĔŶ4ōĩ2ƍƇ0ŵÏ

��ćƋï3,�.�ƉŏC�"�. À3Ɖƃ#.ğ3Ő�@!0�/�@

ĜƔ©ƛ3Ō�2řƆC©#��÷3ŵĸCØ�

� čƋ�}Ɣąïù32@0��ô�C<+.�Ś�Øŕ#.�@µżñ¢�3� @ĮƀĖ0#.4Ĩż

�œ%@}ƔhugH\SparVl�Ş

�ù�ôĖÿ�ĻĖÿ04ıÍãƇ

ø�ŌĨŜC�(%

ÛſÛſ��

ŭĢ4�@Øŕ�ŝõCŵ,

ñ¢3Ĥ�/�@

Ñ�Ō2PkobO�SpwCØ�

¹Ň4çġ

LnrEhqwCãģ#÷Ø%@

ĮƀĖ0#.ģňCķ @!0Cŉ�¬;@

ôĖÿŔ

Ń~4ŵÁ}ƔŰí�ŕ3ľ%@Ǝ�0ÚÂ

}ƔĮƀĖ0#.4ø�ŌĨŜC�(%

Pkob]F�ĮƀĖĄŀ�ø�74ÚÂ

Ÿ=ƗƎ×ƕCƎ�#�ø�ŌĨŜCİ�%@

ôŲ4łõ=şƖ�Ƃ�4Ê��ŮĴCĤ#�ŝ

}ƔĮƀĖ4¥Ŧ02@ğ�ºģ0ø�ŌULs

�ùŅĘ4OE4Ŋ®

ĮƀĖ04ƙ»�°Ŕ

ĻĖÿ°Ŕ

}ƔĮƀĖù4¥Ŧ02@şƖ

ŭĢ�Ħ÷"�é�=?

ôÌ�Ǝ

PkobO�SpwªĈ

½ķ�Ă�LnrE�Ť

řĐ�ĐäŌ÷į

41

35

( ) ( ) ( )

( ) ( )

4) ��

35 ±

35 35

IT Item-Total

± ± ±

IT ± 0.3

± 1

35 0.3

1 0.3

0.3

KMO(Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin)101 Bartlett

0.8 p<0.05

/ Games-Howell

t Welch

IBM SPSS Statistics 22.0 p<0.05

42

5)

N

N N

N ―

― N N

N (1) N (2)

N ― (3) (4)―

N

PC ― ―

N ― 10 N

― ― ―

27-2-58 N

(2)

1) : P

A 98.4 668 679 A

97.1 34 35 B 91.8

101 110 A 9

64.2

A

66.3

5 6 35

IT

N

3

N 4.17 0.89

33

4.10 0.90

2

#3K��(�<��+;86.1,IBF@?AGFCE/J

�� =@>DH ; *

� :�� /./ /0-4

9�!� /47 0/-.

9�� 61 /.-1

9��'� //2 /2-0

9� �� 2/ 3-/

9� � �� 45 6-1

9�� 63 /.-4

9�� 21 3-2

9�%&�$�� 44 6-0

9�)��"�� 12 2-0

�� 1/6 17-4

�� 263 4.-2

§Õĸ%�ħıĦĎĜĕĭġĮĘĩ± É�û5qÇ®ĶħİĝėğĴİĨįĹķ

É�

ÚÙÉ�

I3�

Üx��F

8�

ĴK#sÚÛ�Ä

Ð �|Ą�6úTìð¤¼àĄZLĊ*ćé÷åöæć ÓÎÑÑÜÏÎÕÓ ÏÎÓÐ

Ñ HJàhËĊ¹úôèõàć ÒÎÏÏÜÏÎ×Ò ÏÎÓÓ

Ò ĚĵĕīįĪĞčČú/Wúyèćb�Ċëùà ÓÎÐÖÜÏÎ×Ø Í ÏÎÑÒ

Ó (�äą�ÊêĈÝÊĆúêĈõàć ÒÎÑÓÜÏÎÖÑ ÏÎÔÔ

Ô ĉäąùàé÷üĉäąùà÷µ¥úâć ÒÎØØÜÏÎ×Õ ÏÎÒ×

Õ £�û�M�Zúàôă{Ċ¾óõàć ÒÎÔÓÜÐÎÏÒ ÏÎÒÕ

Ö ¶�Ĵ��Ĵ<�ûÂ:o�úü;ýðĂû��åàôăöæõàð ÒÎÕÑÜÏÎØÔ ÏÎÓÑ

× £�ûmÞûėĔĖĬĵįĊ�<úaeëõàć ÒÎÔÑÜÐÎÏÑ ÏÎÔÔ

Ø �@Èû�÷`ò¬èõ³Ċíćé÷åöæć ÒÎÑØÜÐÎÐÓ ÏÎÔÏ

ÐÏ �_û)TĊ©ùåą³íćé÷åöæć ÓÎÏÏÜÏÎ×Ð ÏÎÓØ

ÐÐ �_û³Ċ½ąîút{Oç�çé÷åöæć ÒÎÖØÜÏÎØÐ ÏÎÓÑ

ÐÑ ³û�_ú�YĊ�ëùåą�çé÷åöæć ÓÎÏÒÜÏÎÖÑ ÏÎÓÓ

ÐÒ ²ÌĄDĝėğåùçõămÞ;�íć�[åßć ÑÎÖÔÜÐÎÏ× ÏÎÓÔ

ÐÓ ;�®�Ċ�õõïĈĊ<¦íćé÷åöæć ÑÎÖÖÜÐÎÏ× ÏÎÔÒ

ÐÔ £¹ûBr�úāèõÝ�ùúĊíÿæäåĉäć ÒÎÓÔÜÐÎÏÏ ÏÎÔÒ

ÐÕ £¹û]ÀĊ�í;�7û}$ú'!ëõàć ÑÎÖÑÜÐÎÐÕ ÏÎÓÑ

ÐÖ Gú��ú~¸ëùà-�SĊăóõàć ÒÎÓÓÜÏÎØÒ ÏÎÓÖ

Ð× ��äąûcfĄ± Ċ+è>Ĉćé÷åöæć ÒÎ×ÕÜÏÎ×Ð ÏÎÓÑ

ÐØ £¹û�1û¢ ĄïûÅ�Ċz�ú©�ăćé÷åöæć ÒÎÒ×ÜÏÎØÐ ÏÎÓØ

ÑÏ 9gû&0ĊdĆ»ĆÝïûPú}äíé÷åöæć ÒÎÖÔÜÏÎÖÑ ÏÎÔÑ

ÑÐ piû%;Ĵ%�úÄíć�·ĊÝi�ĄĝİĤùøûĪĞčČäą�_ëõàć ÒÎÏÏÜÏÎØØ ÏÎÓÓ

ÑÑ ęđĳĠĐĥĢĐĳ÷àá¤ûX.Ċńöæć ÒÎÔÒÜÐÎÑÖ ÏÎÒÓ

ÑÒ ęįĦĔČĄďĳģĲĪĳğûvUúôàõńöæć ÑÎÐÐÜÐÎÏÐ ÏÎÒØ

ÑÓ �;�û;�÷û�ÃÄ�ĊáĀçw�íćé÷åöæć ÒÎÐØÜÏÎØÑ ÏÎÔÓ

ÑÔ ēįĵħúãèćĮĵěĵĕĜħû*Ćjåĉäć ÑÎ×ÔÜÐÎÏÔ ÏÎÔÓ

ÑÕ �;�û;�å;ċöàćAÁ�·ĄėĒįúÄSåßć ÒÎÖÔÜÏÎØÔ ÏÎÒ×

ÑÖ ��û�NĄ �«ú¾\ëùåąÝ£�ûX©Ċ�Níćé÷åöæć ÒÎÓÕÜÏÎ×Õ ÏÎÔØ

Ñ× ;��û;�÷�àú"è,âćÄ�Ċw�ëõàć ÒÎÓÓÜÏÎØÓ ÏÎÔÒ

ÑØ PºþûcCĴh¡ú�u�úÄĉĆðà÷Vá ÒÎÒØÜÐÎÏÑ ÏÎÓÔ

ÒÏ (�Ą=lú@ëõÝ£�å;ċöàćAÁ�¿úôàõ��úńöæć ÒÎÒÏÜÏÎØÔ ÏÎÔÒ

ÒÐ�Æ�û%�ñèöüùçÝ24öEÂêĈõàć��}$Ą��Ĵ%�úôàõÄ

SåßćÒÎÔÓÜÏÎØÕ ÏÎÓÒ

ÒÑ%�k¯Ķ�ÆĴ°�^ķ7û��Ĵ��k¯ö�àõàćAÁ úôàõ�óõà

ćÒÎÏÕÜÏÎØ× ÏÎÓÖ

ÒÒ �ĆRð��û�?Ċ�@ú�ąêùà£�åßć ÓÎÐÐÜÏÎØÏ Í ÏÎÑÖ

ÒÓ �r�úôàõÝ¨�Ċãêâõ��ú¨�ëõ�ú�âćé÷åöæć ÒÎÐÏÜÏÎØØ ÏÎÔÔ

ÒÔ BrÝ%�Q��úùć÷àá£ªĊăóõÝmÞ¦$ëõàć ÒÎÖÏÜÏÎØÒ ÏÎÔÐ

44

IT

3 r=0.23 33 r=0.27 0.3

2) ��&��$��%� ��#�

IT 0.3 3 33

11

24 5 7 8 KMO 0.892Bartlett

p<0.001, 2=5365.3, df=276

5

9 10

B A

�� &��$��%�"�'� �

1

(1) ��

1) ��

2016 9

2) �!

C 131 40 C

À�BO

ČŒũŭşőŷ

ŕŮŵŶŗŏűŹ

ÀBO

Č�ÿĀ�Ĺ

�Âč

À�BO

ČQÌubč

ÀABO

ČÒ^Á§č

À�BO

ČŒũŭşśŊŦ

űŗļĹĀkč

đđ

4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.

4®ZýÐĹG±Ķķń�

�fxĶ¸�°ŗŏű

ŒũŭşőŷŕŮŵ}×

�ÏĹN3

³zĹäŇ÷łĭĸ��eĦÎĦĨĶĤĵĥń

Đďėē

ĎĐďĐĘē

ĎĐďĐē

ĎĐďĐđĒ

ĐďĐēĕ

đĒ


.




�ÏĹN3

�äĹ³zĸ$tŇ·ĪķĤłÎĦĨĶĤĵĥń

ĐďĖĕĔ

ĐďđēĖ

ĎĐďĒĖ

ĐďĐēĒ

ĐďđĔĔ

ēē

¸�°í�Ň�įĬ

�Ł�§ÊĆŇ§ÜĪĜ¸

�°í�Ň"ĠĬń

��rHĹö)ķ+©Ķ�

ê

qÍĹrHČťůŋŠŕŷĸĀņń

rHŇ?ľčŇR¼Ĭń

µŃjį �Ĺ¼WŇÆYĸ łĩķğÒ�ĤĞń

ĐďĕĐė

ĎĐďĒĖę

ĐďĐĘ

ĐďĐĐĘ

ĐďĐĘ

đĘ


.



&´Ŷ´X°Sï

ÒðĹÝ2ŁÖ¤ĸĳğĴĹţŉ

ŲŢŭŷŁŤŊŷŝŠŚŐŇ�Ŀń �ģłĹ��Łâ�Ň;ħUŅńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĐďĕĐĕ

ĎĐďĐĕĕ

ĐďĐē

ĐďĐēđ

ĐďĐėĕ

đĐ


.




1�°ķŒũŭşőŷŕŮŵŇÖĠ³zĹ9mŇÚķĤł�äĬńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĐďĔėĖ

ĐďēĘĕ

ĎĐďĐė

ĎĐďĐĒē

ĎĐďĐĕę

đ4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.



@pŶæSĩŶoğŁŃ

ö)ķ�ôŁÝÔõğ

¥�Ł¿IĸmīįÝÔõğŁubŇ:ńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĐďĔĔē

ĐďĐėē

ĐďĒē

ĎĐďĐĐđ

ĎĐďĒđē

ĒĐ


.



&´Ŷ´X°Sï

Ò(ĹµéŁÑ.Ŷg-Ĺā«Ŷ�

îŇ�ĪĦåéĪĴğń

L�Ĺ6BŇ�ŃñŃĜĮĹiĸ�ģĬĨĶĤĵĥń

Đďēđĕ

ĐďĐēĕ

ĐďĒĔ

ĐďĐėĘ

ĐďĐēĒ

ę4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.




1�°ķŒũŭşőŷŕŮŵŇÖĠ*YĄĹ�Ķ{ıÜħĴäŇĬńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĎĐďđēĒ

ĐďĘĔĒ

ĎĐďđĒ

ĐďđĕĖ

ĎĐďĐēĔ

ĒĔ

qÍŶÒÐ½ŶKÐ½ĶĹ³

�©

ZýÐĶĹó�Ŷ5

KÐ½5

Ð½ĶĹ5 ĸ7/Ĭń

Q»ĹQ¨ĶĹ�ÿĀ�ŇĠĽĦ�ÂĬńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĎĐďđđĘ

ĐďĖėę

ĐďĒĐ

ĎĐďĐĔĒ

ĐďĐđē

ĒĘ


�©

ZýÐĶĹó�Ŷ5

ÒÐ½

=!ĸŔŨŷŜĜŉŝŠŋŗŇĬńQ»&ĹQ¨Ķğĸ0ħ<ġńĀ�Ň�ÂĪĴğń

ĐďĐĕđ

ĐďĕĔđ

ĐďđĔ

ĎĐďĐĖė

ĐďĐĖ

Ēė


�©

ZýÐĶĹó�Ŷ5

ÒÐ½

=Ð½ĹŗŏűĜ��ÛĜÑ.ĸ�

sŇ|Ġ

ÍĹ�dŁ��ÛĸøwĪķĤłĜÒ(ĹsÚŇ�dĬ

ńĨĶĤĵĥń

Đďđđ

ĐďēĘĖ

ĐďĒĕ

ĎĐďđĐĒ

ĐďđĖĖ

ēĔ


�Ł�§ÊĆŇ§ÜĪĜ¸

�°í�Ň"ĠĬń

4®ZýÐĶĪĴĹ¸�°

í�Ň�įĬ

á®ßûĸ°¶ķ&UŇßĪĜ¶S

ĸ�PŇÖĠ

'��ĸĳğĴĜÙ£ŇĢĩġĴÃ¢ĸÙÄĪĴ�ĸ�ġ

ńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĐďĒĔė

ĎĐďĐĕ

ĐďĖđ

ĎĐďĐĒĔ

ĎĐďĐęĔ

Ē4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.



@pŶæSĩŶoğŁŃ

@pĹĞńÖ2ĜåéŇ�ĳ

`ağ�ĈŇðĸĳħĴğń

ĐďĐēę

ĐďĐĕė

ĐďĕĔ

Đďđđĕ

ĎĐďĒĐĕ

Ēē


�©

ċqÍ�kĹőŉĹ��

qÍĹÒhpŇĊĿńĜ�

�Ĭń ĥģħ

řűŤőŉŇ��ŶōŵšŴŷĬńřűŤőŉŁōŵšŴūŵŜĹ�nĸĳğĴç�ĵĥń

ĎĐďđĔĕ

ĎĐďĐĐĖ

Đďĕē

ĐďĐēĒ

ĐďĐęĔ

đĖ


.



ÇÈQÌŶŏŬŰŉþ¯

ZýÐĶĪĴxüŇÈħńĨĶŇò

ğ�Ŀń

ÒðĹxüŇ�ĬQ&JĹ�2ĸ7/ĪĴğń

ĎĐďđĖę

Đďđĕĕ

ĐďĔĐ

ĐďĐęĖ

ĐďĐĘĘ

ēĐ


ŒũŭşśŊĜZýÐăCĜ¸

�ļĹì¦

ÒÐ½ĹZýÐăCļĹ_

]Ŷì¦

#ÕĶÒÐ½Ĺ�ćĀ�ŇeĿń

�2ŇÖĠ

8�ŁT�ĸYĪĴĜÒ(ĤQňĵğńZý(ùĸĳğĴ

%�°ĸç�ĵĥń

ĐďĐėĒ

ĐďĐĖė

Đďēę

ĎĐďĐĔĔ

ĐďĒĔđ

đē


.




ZýÐĶĪĴÇÈ°ĸQÌĬńĨĶ

ĹlÙpŇåéĪĴğń

ãĉŁ[śŗŜĤķĦĴŀ�ĝQÌĬńÌvĤĞń

ĎĐďđĐĔ

ĎĐďĐēĖ

ĐďđĒ

ĐďĖĖė

ĐďĐĕđ

đĔ


.




ŏŬŰŉťůŵŇ�xĪSÖĬńQÌÞªŇ¿ĴĴĮŅŇSÖĬńĨĶĤĵĥń

ĎĐďĐĖ

ĎĐďĐĒĖ

ĐďĒĐ

Đďĕę

ĐďĐėę

ė4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.



Ò^Á§

�ÿĸ�¶ĵĞń

èËŶ¡ÌŶSÌĹþM�,ĸĺQĻįĿĹ��Ĥğĳŀ

ĵĥĴğń

ĐďĒĔĕ

ĎĐďĐĖ

ĎĐďĐđ

ĐďĔėę

ĎĐďĐēĒ

Ę4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.



Ò^Á§

�ÿĸ�¶ĵĞń

Ò(Ĺ�ĝĹŗőŖŭŷűŇ¶Sĸ~�ĪĴğń

ĐďĒēĕ

ĐďĐĖę

ĐďĐĐ

ĐďĔėĕ

ĐďĐĐē

Ė4®ZýÐÍĹG±ĶķńÑ

.



Ò^Á§

ÒðĹ�c¥uĸ¬sĪĜÉ�Ŷ>

�ŇDń

Ò(Ĺ�c¥uĸğĳŀ�ŇøĲĴğń

ĐďĐēĔ

Đďđę

ĎĐďđĐ

ĐďĔĒ

ĎĐďĐĔĖ

ēđ



�ļĹì¦

EFĹ��4®º¹�2ĸ

YĬń§ÜĶì¦

EF4®Ŷ��Ŷº¹Ĺ�2ĸV�

Ĭń

Ă&Ĺ4®İħĵĺķĦĜEFĵ\þĩŅĴğń��

2Łº¹Ŷ4®ĸĳğĴĀkĤĞń

ĐďĐĘĘ

ĎĐďĐĕē

ĎĐďĐę

ĐďĐĘĔ

Đďėđđ

ĒĖ


�©

ZýÐĶĹó�Ŷ5

KÐ½5

Ð½ĹZýpŁÑ.ŇÚ¾ŀń

ĨĶĤĵĥń

Q»ĹQ¨ĤQňĵğńZýµéŁŗŏűĸĀkĤĞ

ńĐďĐėĔ

Đďđēę

ĎĐďĐđ

ĎĐďĐĔĒ

ĐďĔēĒ

ēĒ



�ļĹì¦

EFĹ��4®º¹�2ĸ

YĬń§ÜĶì¦

EF4®Ŷ��Ŷº¹ĹZýÐŶ�

àĶĹó�Ň�Ŀń

4®�àŸĂŶá®yŹ�JĹ��Ŷº¹�àĵ ğĴğ

ńZýÐĸĳğĴµĲĴğń

ĎĐďĐđę

ĐďĐĐĒ

ĐďēĔ

ĎĐďĐēđ

ĐďĔĐĔ

ą²

BOëÓú

Œŷŝ

Øėź4®ťųŤŌŚŕŮŞŰŘŪâ�ą²ĹBO(�ĹÅ�ČťŲśŗŜŶŲŧűŻŹ

ą²ěĚ

(ù

ĆF

ŎśœŰ

|�*1

®íýĀ÷ìĉ

îāćĈðëăċ

|�*1

®�§¨�Ù

b~¯

|�*1

®2�I>¯

|)*1

®�;}l¯

|�*1

®íýĀ÷ôèû

ăðÜÙ¨D¯

sNÙ�å áÍØ`cAÆ�ÆÈÖÄÕÅã ²±¹µ °²±²ºµ °²±²µ °²±²³´ ²±²µ·

��ÙsNØ�HåvÊ×Äá�ÆÈÖÄÕÅã ²±¸·¶ ²±³µ¸ °²±´¸ ²±²µ´ ²±³¶¶

tâCÏ�Ùz6å�7ØgáÉ×¿��Ä¾ã ²±·²¹ °²±´¸» ²±²º ²±²²º ²±²º

�ÃáÙRUà��å'Ç5äãÈÖÄÕÅã ²±·²· °²±²·· ²±²µ ²±²µ³ ²±²¹·

sNÙ%Eå�×Äá��ÌãÈÖÄÕÅã ²±¶¹¸ ²±µº· °²±²¹ °²±²´µ °²±²·»

kdà{-ØEËÏ��¿àI>å&ãÈÖÄÕÅã ²±¶¶µ ²±²¹µ ²±´µ °²±²²³ °²±´³µ

/VÙ"*åSâ�â¼ÎÙBØeÃÌÈÖÄÕÅã ²±µ³· ²±²µ· ²±´¶ ²±²¹º ²±²µ´

�7ªÙ�ÖOÑ�ÇÔ�åÌãÈÖÄÕÅã °²±³µ´ ²±º¶´ °²±³´ ²±³·¸ °²±²µ¶

2yÙ2mÖÙ�§¨�åÀÝÆb~ÌãÈÖÄÕÅã °²±³³º ²±¸¹» ²±´² °²±²¶´ ²±²³µ

2y�Ù2mÖ�¿Ø�Ç(Áã¨�åb~ÊÔ¿ã ²±²·³ ²±·¶³ ²±³¶ °²±²¸¹ ²±²¸

�Ù�@à��Ø¡KÊ×Äá¼��ÙG�å�@Ì

ãÈÖÄÕÅã²±³³ ²±µº¸ ²±´· °²±³²´ ²±³¸¸

�]�ØÓ¿Ô¼�jåÂÉÁÔ�iØ��ÊÔ�Ø�Á

ãÈÖÄÕÅã²±´¶¹ °²±²· ²±¸³ °²±²´¶ °²±²»¶

<=¿W¬å�ØÓÇÔ¿ã ²±²µ» ²±²·¹ ²±·¶ ²±³³· °²±´²·

òăùìçàêćøĆÿćõÙaFØÓ¿Ô�[ÕÅã °²±³¶· °²±²²¸ ²±·µ ²±²µ´ ²±²»¶

��ÙL¤å�Ì2�.Ùe Ø#�ÊÔ¿ã °²±³¸» ²±³·· ²±¶² ²±²»¸ ²±²ºº

$�à4YØ7ÊÔ¼��Ä2æÕ¿ã8¥�¢ØÓ¿Ô

� qØ�[ÕÅã²±²¹´ ²±²¸¹ ²±µ» °²±²¶¶ ²±´¶³

�à9ôðõÄ×ÆÔßZ½2�Ìã�JÄ¾ã °²±³²¶ °²±²µ¸ ²±³´ ²±¸¸¹ ²±²·³

2��nå{ÔÔÎäå3�ÌãÈÖÄÕÅã °²±²¸ °²±²´¸ ²±´² ²±·» ²±²¹»

��Ĉh�Ĉ3�Ù¦0\�ØÚ2ÛÏÞÙf�Ä¿Óß

ÕÅÔ¿ã²±´¶· °²±²¸ °²±²³ ²±¶¹» °²±²µ´

��ÙZ½ÙðìïĀĉăåu3ØPTÊÔ¿ã ²±´µ· ²±²¸» ²±²² ²±¶¹· ²±²²µ

��Ù�?kIØ¿Óßcå¡ÒÔ¿ã ²±²µ¶ ²±³» °²±³² ²±¶´ °²±²¶¸

o©�Ù!pÐÇÕÚ×Æ¼+,Õ:¦ÉäÔ¿ã��e

àxwĈ!pØÓ¿Ô¨DÄ¾ã²±²ºº °²±²·µ °²±²» ²±²º¶ ²±¹³³

2yÙ2mÄ2æÕ¿ã8¥t�àðëăØ¨DÄ¾

ã²±²¹¶ ²±³µ» °²±²³ °²±²¶´ ²±¶µ´

!pX�Ċo©Ĉ�pMċ.Ù��ĈxwX�Õ�¿Ô¿

ã8¥�ØÓ¿ÔtÒÔ¿ã°²±²³» ²±²²´ ²±µ¶ °²±²µ³ ²±¶²¶

�¹Č!púąùéóîāöĂñþ��«rÙ*1�^Ù�_®úĄôðõĈĄüăčċĊQ�ċ

«r

*1��£

§�c4�xvÊ,fÆÈÕz

�

�c4�xÊ,fÆÈÕ�

V<FÆl�eäÞý

&Bā�2¼āA²ÑÔ

&BÊ±Õ��¯��Ø�Â

çĂãùýøíÚÙÉ&BÉXºÕHnØ½È²

¨�c4�xvÊ,fÆÈÕz

�


V<FÆl�eäÞý

&Bā�2¼āA²ÑÔ

(ØÂ¶È²¯� Å¸Õ�Å±Õ

»Æ

�¶Ó� ¼Ö¯ ÔÉ¼ÖÄ²Õ

©�c4�xvÊ,fÆÈÕz

�


V<FÆl�eäÞý

&Bā�2¼āA²ÑÔ

je�~¼Ø�Â

×¶ÓÈ²»ÆË×¶ÓÈ²Æ�~É�´Õ

¥©

�c4�xvÊ,fÆÈÕz

�


V<FÆl�eäÞý

qr1uāÞùüÙ�d

ÞùüÙõûĀØ F½2�¾Õ|�Ê5S�ÉÎºÄ¯ÈÉØ¾Í¸¶·×¶Õ

¥ª


�


V<FÆl�eäÞý

qr1uāÞùüÙ�d

4�xÆ½ÄF�ØrºÕ»ÆØ�

²ZÏÕ

9É_^É]�½È²$�@ØÐÁÄ²Õ

¥¬


�


V<FÆl�eäÞý

�iāi3e2�

|�Êj�Ñz�ā=�Ê�bā�

�ØY½¹��½Ä²Õ

|�Ê_*Êz�Ñ¿Ê�bØYkÉ�oÐÕ»Æ·Å¸

Õ

¦¥


�

¡²äÞýÆj�É,Ã¹2

�

¡²äÞýÆj�É,Ã¹4

�xe2�

[cāàÙÉ�¾ÕRMÊD-Ø!

�½¯{:É�a¾Õ

RMÊ�1ā�cÉ�¾Õj�Ø¯MwÑìþòÈÇÊø

íÚÙ¶Ó�G½Ä²Õ

¦¦

Cvā|xmā/xmÆÊh

� a

¢Cv�@ÊàÙÊJ�

Cv�@�t

Cv·Ê�8Ñ�c4�xÊE

�Øw¹»ÆØ6�¾Õ

æÝĀïÜóñÜĀÆ²³�}ÊE%Ø�PÅ¸Õ

¦©

Cvā|xmā/xmÆÊh

� a

4�xÆÊ�Kā��

/xm��

êĂ÷Ê�'Æ½ÄüĂéĂãëõ¤

��ØÆÕ

ßýĂõÉµºÕüĂéĂãëõÊ"ÔN·×¶Õ

¦¬

Cvā|xmā/xmÆÊh

� a

4�xÆÊ�Kā��

|xm�

>�ÊLyÑøĀèĂØ;¸#ºÕ>�ÌÊI7āLyÉoWeÉ�×ÔÀ²ÆA³

§©

l�e��ØUÀ¾

\Ñ�`s�Ø`�½¯l

�e��Ø�³¾Õ

�c4�xÆ½ÄÊl�e

��ØUÀ¾

��Q�.ÉµºÕ4�xÆ½ÄÊ

��

5S¯�c?�vÉÈÕÆ²³|�ØÐÁÄ¯O°��½Ä

²Õ

�«Ą�cõÿôÛëãúðüå÷��gÊ)0�TÊpUÉÒÔ�.¼ÖÀ¥¥�g£õþìäîāþöýąă

�g®

��

�+

Ýìâü

áĂï

�g

x� B�6@5)0-<3=/:yFY�&lJJG}D^}tr��#

6?1.2!?8>�$

�lJB

JG

�lJ�

JG

�lJ`

JG

�lJK

WJG

�lJ�

d{_J

G

�lJ�

de�J

G

�lJ�

J�~J

G

�lJZ

O�~J

G

�lJS

VpH�

~JG

�lJz

i`GE

gG

��

��

��

��

��

mCD^

�,9;4+"-<A!.*>$

��

��

��

��

��

��

muD^�fMNP&Xo�

��

��

��

��

��

%��

�lJBJG��l

J�J

G��lJ�d{_JG��l

J�de�JG��lJSV

�~JG

�lJ�de�JG%�l

JKWJG

m[D^��Jbks�

��

��

��

��

��

%��

�lJBJG��l

J�J

G��lJKWJG��lJ�

de�JG��lJ�J�~

JG��lJSVpH�~J

G��lJzi`GEgG

m]D^�aTL��

��

� � � ��

� ��

� � ��

� ��

��

�lJ�JG��lJ`J

G��lJKWJG��lJ

�J�~JG��l

J�d

e�JG

mUD^

�,9;41(7>.'&Ne�

��

��

��

��

��

��

lJ!JG

D^

Qq

�#CRvn|

\|h$

jcwI

#��

��~$

49

NK HK��

M67E��,.'�� /4�!�1�

��

MT7E�J;<=�AO� �� MC7E��9GLR� �� MD7E�F?:Y� �� M@7E��,.'$�*1!��<I�

��

��>P�

U��5Z)3(�# /&0"-V8BX�KW7EWSQ�� )2$!%�2+1��

7EKW

3)

N N 1

× N 24

× 11 35 N 11

5

ID15

N ×

o ID102 N

ID2 ID23

ID30 N

ID34

N N

3 2 ID1

ID2

2 ID105

N ID106 ×

ID26

N

Ť��ƊjwiO_Xrdt[nť�Ûŷ�ŴŃá�vku��Ûŷ�

U�c P`Vt Ƌ� ūź

�� ıÿ8ş�JÄ6 D�Ɣ)F$4 3!FÒ�ŉ6UmqeT�XryJØ�

�� ıÿ8ƔJûD*7à¬¶"ŭ"$4 3!F� �Ɣ8ıÿ7´¢Jó'6 Dŭ"$4 3!F�� ôū8Ê�,�$4JƓƅŉ7ć<F$4 3!F� ĉĹŶ8Ğ4ĸ.�#2ƔJ)F$4 3!F

� ïÇBĎ`Zb 6"2Aŕ��ă)Fă£ �FĭŹĕ4'2¾ĵŉ7�ă)F$48ţƁġJŘ

õ'2�F�� ă¿�JƆ22+GJøØ)F$4 3!F�� ôĜ8čƂĲ7?#2�ß67J)<!� I�F

� ôĜ8ĢńJĳ)�Ŕ�8�ő7ç�'2�FĭŹĕ4'2ĢńJĵ#F$4Jņ�°@F

�� ôū $G�D�:<!�ĻJ>0#F$4 3!FĭŹĕ4'2¾ĵŉ7�ă)F$48ţƁġJŘ

õ'2�F ôū8ÁÕĔĺ7�0A¬Jŝ/2�F�� ÁÕŉ6Ĥ�ă£JĜ70#2�F

�Ù¯��ă�øă8�èñÞ79�:,@8ĈŢ �0A3!2�F

� ôū8ŕ�8ZTYq�uJ�ø7śz'2�F

�� ĶĞ�D8ìňBť�Jā#žGF$4 3!FôĜ8ÊőBØ~70�28hLvgq�BiM�cf_RJ°@F

�� ôĜ8Éä8ŚƌB+8Ë�Jģ�7ÄħAF$4 3!Fôū8ľõBŚƌ�Ż�8Ë��ŨĴJģ'"Ř

õ'2�F

�� öŜ8È�JĘEŮE�+8Ï7��)$4 3!Fôū8ľõBŚƌ�Ż�8Ë��ŨĴJģ'"Ř

õ'2�F� Ĕ·BƆĒ7�(,ÊƀÆ�BĺōJýF$4 3!F Ŋĩ6Ī¸BÊƀÆ�

�� 0AģŅ3�F$4Jė #2�F�J0�6��Ėƃ3!

FĞ3�F$4

�� ĶĞ8¬ð.J3!F-#ƅ�'C�4Ō@2�F�J0�6��Ėƃ3!

FĞ3�F$4� I�D6�$49I�D6�4Å³7Ê�F ľŉÅ³%Jů0

��âę8��Ɗ7§)FľõJ�ęŭB`vg658oaML�DŖÿ'2�F

òƊ�TL7§)Fâę8ēűJĂą'�Ǝď7

Ŋſ)F

�� øĮ3ţƁ4%GF3�H�ľõB®ĆJŕ�ăœ'2�FÜ�vku8ZQu4��ľõJůð'�+GJ

Ş«)F

�� ēűJœF,@8ƓŬa�\k�ZJİå)FZQu �F��ŉà²7©1�,}ëÀŇ�øĮJØ�

�Ķú8üŁB�Ľ¥7ŝƈ'6 D�ôū8}ÄJüŁ)F$4 3!F

ŒĕĀ8ZQu��Ľ¥�Śƌ7½}JŪ�

� ��Ŕ8�Ĥ4Î�7Č#Ý�F§¹JÖŀ'2�FŒƉ7Wl�b�Lcf

NZJ)F

� Ķ��8�Ĥ48Ğ¦§¹J�="Öŀ)F$4 3!FĶĕĀ48µŐ7ç�)

F

��Su�jx�RJ� 7ĝ@F,@795�',DC��ľ/2�F

^�n8��4'2t�]�X_j�ĨŗJ4F

�Ŧ�Ŕ8�Ɗ-#396"�Ŀ�3ŋ�%G2�FůÁ�őBũî��Ɗ70�2§ė �F

Ŀ��Ɗ�ůÁ�ũî8�ő7ªŽ)F

�Ɗíī�Ŧ��ěƊĊ�{�8ůÁ�ũîíī3Ő�2�FĭŹĕ70�2ľ/2�F

Ŀ��Ɗ�ůÁ�ũî8ĭŹĕ�íī48Ɛ¼J

Ě@F

��÷Ŧ8òƊ�TL-#396"�Ŀ�38ůÁ�ő�÷Ŧżų�ő7A§ė �F

ÑĄ�Ĥ�żų��8ĳĝ

�� Ŀ�3ŰD)¡ú%K8Ĥ�JNo�Y)F$4 3!FĿ��Ɗ�ůÁ�ũî8

�ő7ªŽ)F

�� ôū8Ƅ�8,@7ĶĞJƄſ'29�#6�4ë�ôÍ8Ƅ�8,@7�ƊĭŹĕ8Ŀ|BƆĒJƄ

ſ'6�

�ƊĭŹĕ4'28ù�ŉĨŗJ�,)

ľEœ,ĶĞ8šŵJĬĹ7ƑD%6�ôĖ �F¡ú8ēű�jsNfX�7§IFēűJ¨?�Jþš)F

ÌĞēű8Ŋĩ6Ƅſ4ůÐ

��`ZbBÓŏïŸ653�� /2AŨģJØ/29�#6�4ë�

ěƊƒBÃ±a�\8�&K�+8ĶŨģ6ċƏ8åĢJØI6�

ŲBƍƅ×ƋJþF

��Ûŷ��9jv`Zb8�êūĦ3ãſ%G2�6�Ûŷ�Ûŷ��9ŴŃá3ę,7ņ�%G,Ûŷ

�Ŏ)F�ƊjwiO_Xrdt[n�řÛŷ��

Ûŷ

�ƊĭŹĕú8©Š46FŚƌ

�ƊĭŹĕ8©Š46FĞ�»Ģ4ù�ŉZQu

UmqeT�Xry®Ćºł8éĠ

Ò�ŉ6UmqeT�XryJØ�

¾ĵ�ă�QptL�Ş

QptLjsyJåĢ'øØ)F

ñ¦7ģ�3�FôÍ¤ƅ

ôĜ8ÁÕĔĺ7Ƈ}'��ð�ÔđJğF

ŔĐ�ĐæŉøĮ

ŧġ�ĥø%�ë�BE

Ü�ZQu4ľõ7©1"øĮ

Ü�ZQu4ľõ7©1"ĭŹĕŉøĮ

¡ú�ôĕĀ�ķĕĀ48ıÎåſ

ù�ŉĨŗJ�,)

ĭŹĕ48Ɛ¼�µŐ

ôĕĀŐ

ķĕĀµŐ

Umqe`M�ĭŹĕąļ�ù�;8ÚÂ

Ŀ�8ůÁ�Ɗũî�ő7Ĺ)Fƅ�4ÚÂ

ŲBƍƅ×ƋJƅ�'�ù�ŉĨŗJį�)F

51

ID109 ID110

×

ID21

N

N ID103

ID104 2 N

N N N

ID111 N

ID112 2

ID19

ID20

N

24

N 5 N 4 12

× N 35 35

N

N KiSS-18102( 4) KiSS-18

N 18

KiSS-18

― ×

1 1

×

N × 1

― KiSS-18

KiSS-18 5 (5 )

(4 ) (3 ) (2 )

(1 )

52

4)

N 0.4 N

N KiSS-18

N t (Welch )

N

N KiSS-18

N KiSS-18

×

0.5

N Cronbach’s

coefficient N

5)

(2)

1) : P

C 88.5 116 131 C

97.5 39 40 12 144 58.3

41.7%

KiSS-18 62.65 10.44 60

― 99,103,104 ―

13 35 IT

N 33

4.22 0.89 112

4.47 0.82 2

IT 33 r=0.33

112 r=0.41 2 0.3

53

�&'B��6�� !4/&))"@��>=:<&A

�� 798;? C ��

5��

�� 0�� &%* ,'$.

0�� (. ',$&

�� -) *-$(

� +% )&$,

1322#&- &)( +'$+*5&%$))

2) ��

33 112

5 30

7 14 15 KMO 0.839 Bartlett

p<0.001, 2=1384.8, df=435 7

KiSS-18 16

C

C

KiSS-18 C

7 KiSS-18 (r) 0.23 0.76

(r=0.76) (r=0.23)

(r=0.23) 17 30

KiSS-18 0.71

7 ( ) 0.63 0.86

¡ÌÎĬ&�ĝĦĜČĖđĢĚģĔğª Å�ö4lÃ§Īl®oĨĥĞĤĭī

ÌË �Zö)Oć£ôàā¬èăäòàñáă ÏÊÍÓØËÊÑÔ ËÊÏÒ

ÌÌ �Zö¬ć¹āéõptJâ�âäòàñáă ÏÊËÑØËÊÒÐ ËÊÎÓ

ÌÍ ¬ö�Zõ�Tć�æôàā�âäòàñáă ÏÊÌÒØËÊÑÓ ËÊÏÍ

ÌËÌ ��ö¦ÜëÜäòć¯~�õ¶ùăäòàñáă ÎÊÑÓØËÊÔÎ ËÊÐÏ

Ô �?Äö�ò[í¥ãð¬ćèăäòàñáă ÎÊÐÓØÌÊËÌ ËÊÐÒ

ÌÎ «ÈÿBėēęàôâðþhÚ;�èă�VàÛă ÍÊÑÓØÌÊËÍ ËÊÐÏ

ÌÏ ;�§�ć�ððêĄć<�èăäòàñáă ÎÊÍÏØÌÊËÍ ËÊÑË

ÌÐ �´öAm�õüãðÙ�ôõćèùáßàĆßă ÎÊÏÒØËÊÓÔ ËÊÑÏ

ÌÑ �´öX»ć�è;�7öw%õ(!æðÜă ÎÊÌÔØÌÊÍÒ ËÊÏÓ

ÌËÍ ��àäĄßā;øùáÇćûïãăäòàñáă ÎÊÑÒØËÊÓÔ ËÊÐÑ

Ñ ��ö�H|UõÜïþtćºîðÜă ÎÊÐËØÌÊËÔ ËÊÏË

Ò ±�Ĩ{�Ĩ<�ö½:i�õ÷;øëýöx�àÜïþñáðÜă ÎÊÍÔØÌÊËÐ ËÊÐÏ

Ó ��öhÚöēĐĒġĩĤć�<õ]aæðÜă ÎÊÒÎØÌÊËÌ ËÊÐÌ

ÌËÒ �H�ô�w�Vć´õïãðÜă ÎÊÍÎØÌÊÌË ËÊÎÑ

ÌÓ ��ßāö_bÿª ć+ã=Ąăäòàñáă ÏÊÍÏØËÊÑÌ ËÊÏÔ

ÌÔ �´ö}0ö� ÿêöÁ�ćs�õ£�þăäòàñáă ÎÊÓÎØËÊÒÒ ËÊÏÏ

ÍË 9dö'/ć`ĂµĂÙêöKõwßèäòàñáă ÎÊÔÍØËÊÒÌ ËÊÑÐ

Ì |vÿ�6õOçë¦�¸ÜÿUGć*ăäòàñáă ÏÊÌØËÊÓË ËÊÐÎ

ÌËÐ Üïþs�ñÛăäòćMàãðÜă ÎÊÔÏØËÊÔÐ ËÊÎÑ

ÌËÑ ��öt^íćñáăìã~¥æĀÝò#ýðÜă ÏÊÎÏØËÊÑÌ ËÊÏË

Ð ĆßāôÜäò÷ĆßāôÜò°�õ¦Þă ÏÊÌÌØËÊÒÒ ËÊÏË

ÍÌkfö&;Ĩ&�õ¿èă�²ćÙf�ÿėĥěôóöĠĘĊĉßā�Zæ

ðÜăÍÊÔÎØÌÊËÎ ËÊÎÐ

ÌËÎ <³ñN¢òåĄăñÛąÝ�²ÿ\ ćhÚ�LæðÜă ÎÊËÐØËÊÔÑ ËÊÐÑ

ÌËÏ R5ćLăëýö¯eĘĩĕĞĩēćc�èăēčĤàÛă ÎÊÍÑØÌÊÍÏ ËÊÍÑ

ÍÒ ��ö�Iÿ �¤õºWæôàāÙ��öS£ć�Ièăäòàñáă ÎÊÔÍØËÊÒË ËÊÑÎ

ÍÓ ;��ö;�ò�Üõ"ã-Þă¿�ćq�æðÜă ÎÊÔÒØËÊÓË ËÊÏÐ

ÍÏ �;�ö;�òö�¾¿�ćÝúâq�èăäòàñáă ÎÊÒÔØËÊÓÓ ËÊÑË

ÌËÓ ďĤĩĝħĩĎć�yõ·ýăëýõ÷óÝæëāĀÜß�îðÜă ÎÊÑÑØËÊÓË ËÊÑÑ

ÎÌ�Â�ö&�ìãñ÷ôâÙ13ñC½åĄðÜă��w%ÿ��Ĩ&�

õïÜð¿MàÛăÎÊÍÏØÌÊËÓ ËÊÐÌ

ÎÍ&�g¨Ī�ÂĨ©�Yī7ö��Ĩ��g¨ñ�ÜðÜă@¼�õï

Üð�îðÜăÎÊÍËØÌÊËË ËÊÏÑ

ÌËÔ��öu�ĨĐĉìãñ÷ôâÙ13ñö��w%Ĩ��Àw%õþ¿

MàÛăÎÊÎÍØÌÊËÐ ËÊÏÒ

ÌÌË 13ñjāèQ�åĈö�wćċĠĩĒèăäòàñáă ÎÊÍÏØÌÊËË ËÊÐÏ

ÌÌÌ ��ö��öëýõ��ć��æð÷ÜãôÜòPÝ ÎÊÓÑØÌÊËÔ ËÊÍÔ

ÎÎ �ĂLë��ö�>ć�?õzāåôÜ��àÛă ÏÊÍÍØËÊÓÔ É ËÊÎÎ

ÌÌÍ ėēęÿ,Æ«.ôóñÙ�àÛîðþ�sć�îð÷ÜãôÜòPÝ ÏÊÏÒØËÊÓÍ É ËÊÏÌ

Å�

ÖÕÅ�

E2�

Ørx�D

8�

ĨF$nÖ×�¿

Ç�HU

ę�Ċċ�ň�

Éƌ

ÇHU

ęæ¬³VÑĚ

Ç�HU

ęţżƀųŮśŹ

ƄŨŋňċkĚ

ÇGHU

ę¹]³YúĚ

Ç�HU

ęºôń|ÞĚ

Ç&HU

ę�©Ɖ¾�³

ø�Ě

Ç�HU

ęØcÈ©Ě

ğĞ

7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0

7±_ĈÕňNµńņŕ��hwń¾

�³ŨşƄ

ţżƀųŢƊŦƁƈ|Þ

4�³ņţżƀųŢƊŦƁƈŘÝĮ¸yň:mŘâņıœ�ìĺŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜĦĢğ

ĞĜĞĥģ

ěĞĜğğ

ěĞĜĞĦġ

ĞĜĞġ

ěĞĜĞħġ

ěĞĜğĞĢ

ğĠ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


�ÔňT6

�ìň¸yŇ'sŘ½ĸņıœÓĳĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜĥğğ

ěĞĜĠĠğ

ĞĜĞĢ

ěĞĜĞħģ

ěĞĜğĞğ

ĞĜğĥĤ

ĞĜĞĢĠ

ğĞĦ

pÒƉØÕÃƉRÕÃńň¸

�«

_ĈÕńňþ�Ɖ8

RÕÃ8

ŬƊŽň�DńĸłƃƊūƊŦŭ

Ÿĝø�Řńŕ

šƄƊŸƇƊŠŘ)¢ŇÿŏŕļŏŇŉŅĮĸļœŒĭİ

ºĿłĭŕ

ĞĜĥĞĥ

ěĞĜĞĞĥ

ĞĜĞĦ

ĞĜĞħ

ĞĜĞĤħ

ěĞĜĞĢħ

ĞĜĞģĠ

ĠĦ


�«

_ĈÕńňþ�Ɖ8

ØÕÃ

@"ŇťŻƊŰĪŚűŴŜŨŘĺŕVÁ(ňVªńĭŇ2Ĵ?įŕċ�Ř�Éĸłĭŕ

ĞĜĤĥĠ

ěĞĜğĤĦ

ěĞĜğģ

ĞĜğĞġ

ĞĜğĞġ

ěĞĜĞġĢ

ĞĜğĢĠ

ğĞğ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


4�³ņţżƀųŢƊŦƁƈŘÝĮØ*ňåĭļĭĵńŘñ©³ŇüŌŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜģĤ

ĞĜĠĞĦ

ĞĜğĥ

ĞĜĞğħ

ěĞĜğġħ

ěĞĜĞĥħ

ěĞĜğ

ğ7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

CoƉîYĶƉnĭőŔ

Ă+ņ�ĀőåÚāĭ

¦�őÆPŇmĹļåÚāĭőteŘ<ŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜģĢĤ

ĞĜĞĥĦ

ěĞĜĞģ

ěĞĜĞĦĠ

ĞĜĞğĢ

ĞĜğģĤ

ĞĜğĞĤ

Ġĥ


�«

_ĈÕńňþ�Ɖ8

ØÕÃ

@ÕÃňŨşƄĪ��ãĪÖ0Ň

�rŘ{Į

�Òň�gő��ãŇăvĸņıœĪØ*ňrâŘ�gĺ

ŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜģĠĢ

ĞĜĠĢĥ

ĞĜĞĢ

ĞĜğģĤ

ĞĜĞĠĤ

ĞĜĞğġ

ěĞĜğġ

ħ7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


4�³ņţżƀųŢƊŦƁƈŘÝĮ,^Đň�ńzľäĴłìŘĺŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜģğĦ

ĞĜĞģħ

ĞĜĠĦ

ěĞĜĞĤ

ěĞĜĞĠĢ

ěĞĜĞģĢ

ĞĜĞĤĢ

ğĞĠ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

ÌÍVÑƉşſƃŚĉ²

_ĈÕńĸłÌÍ³ŇVÑĺŕĵ

ńňláoŘíôĸłĭŕ

Ø*ıĵŖİœVŊŌĲïĕŘōŀĴŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ěĞĜĞħĦ

ĞĜĥĢğ

ĞĜĞĠ

ĞĜğġ

ĞĜĞħ

ěĞĜĞħĦ

ěĞĜĞğ

ğģ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


şſƃŚŸƂƈŘ�wĸYÝĺŕØûň`�!ŇŎĴłĪ ņŇŘĺŌĲİıŗİŕ

ĞĜĞġĦ

ĞĜĥĠĠ

ĞĜĞġ

ěĞĜĞğġ

ěĞĜĞğġ

ĞĜğģĠ

ěĞĜĞğ

ğĤ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


_ĈÕńĸłwćŘÍĴŕĵńŘ

ýĭ�ŏŕ

ØûňwćŘ�ĺV(Qň�5Ň91ĸłĭŕ

ĞĜĞĥĤ

ĞĜĤģģ

ěĞĜĞĢ

ĞĜĞĢĠ

ĞĜĞğģ

ĞĜĞġĤ

ěĞĜğġħ

ğĢ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


şſƃŚŸƂƈŘ�wĸYÝĺŕVÑæ¬ŘÆłłĻŖŘYÝĺŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ěĞĜĞģĠ

ĞĜĤĞĦ

ěĞĜĞĥ

ěĞĜğĢĢ

ĞĜğğġ

ĞĜğĦĢ

ĞĜĠħĥ

ğġ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ


_ĈÕńĸłÌÍ³ŇVÑĺŕĵ

ńňláoŘíôĸłĭŕ

ëėőaŮŨŰıņĳłŐ�īVÑĺŕÑuıĬŕ

ěĞĜĞğĥ

ĞĜģğĦ

ĞĜĞġ

ěĞĜĞħĤ

ĞĜğĤĦ

ĞĜĞħĤ

ĞĜğĤğ

ġğ

¾�³ø�Ř�ļĺ

ţżƀųŮśĪ_ĈÕďIĪ¾�ŋň÷

§

LMň��7±À¿�5Ň

^ĺŕ©äń÷§

LM7±Ɖ��ƉÀ¿ň�5Ň[

�ĺŕ

°Ď(ň7±ĽĴŃŉņĳĪLMŃbĉĶŖłĭŕ��5

őÀ¿Ɖ7±ŇŀĭłċkıĬŕ

ěĞĜĞġĦ

ěĞĜĞĤĦ

ĞĜħģ

ĞĜĞĥĠ

ĞĜĞĞğ

ĞĜĞĞĠ

ěĞĜĞĢġ

ğĞħ



§


^ĺŕ©äń÷§

%Üßªĝ�Č7Vň�ÿ

¯°ň�±ƉŢŚĽĴŃŉņĳĪLMŃň��5Ɖ¯°�

Č�5ŇŐċkıĬŕ

ĞĜĞĠģ

ěĞĜĞĠĥ

ĞĜĥĦ

ěĞĜĞĦĥ

ĞĜğĞĥ

ĞĜğĠĢ

ěĞĜĞģĠ

ġĠ



§


^ĺŕ©äń÷§

LM7±Ɖ��ƉÀ¿ň_ĈÕƉ

�èńňþ�Ř ŏŕ

7±�èƋ°ĎƉé±xƌ�Qň��ƉÀ¿�èŃ ĭłĭ

ŕ_ĈÕŇŀĭłºĿłĭŕ

ěĞĜĞğ

ěĞĜĞğħ

ĞĜĤğ

ĞĜĞĞĤ

ĞĜğĠğ

ěĞĜĞĤĥ

ĞĜğģĢ

ğğĞ



§


^ĺŕ©äń÷§

LM7±Ɖ��ƉÀ¿ň�5Ň[

�ĺŕ

LMŃ�œĺpÒĶřňª�ŘŜžƊŧĺŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜĞĤ

ĞĜĠĞħ

ĞĜģĢ

ĞĜĞğĤ

ěĞĜğģġ

ěĞĜĞğģ

ĞĜĞĦĢ

ģ7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

CoƉîYĶƉnĭőŔ

º³òÛĶŘ�ŀ

ŗİœņĭĵńŉŗİœņĭńòÛŇåįŕ

ěĞĜĞĤĤ

ĞĜğğħ

ĞĜĞġ

ĞĜĥĠ

ěĞĜğĢĤ

ěĞĜğĞĢ

ěĞĜĞĞģ

ğĦ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

(¹Ɖ¹]³Yú

Øûňå5őÝ¥ŇŀĭłňŶ

ŚƅŵƀƊőŷśƊűŴŭŠŘ�ŏ

ŕ

��İœň��őê�Ř=ĴZŖŕĵńıŃĲŕ

ĞĜğĠĥ

ĞĜĞġĠ

ěĞĜĞĦ

ĞĜĤġĢ

ĞĜĠĞĢ

ĞĜğĞĠ

ěĞĜğğğ

ğħ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

(¹Ɖ¹]³Yú

Ø*ňºôőÖ0Ɖi/ňčƉ

�ùŘ�ĸĳíôĸłĭŕ

Øûň¨KňÖ0őĻňčŘ�¼ŇâÄŐŕĵńıŃĲ

ŕěĞĜĞħĦ

ĞĜĠĠĢ

ěĞĜğğ

ĞĜģġĥ

ĞĜğĠġ

ěĞĜĞğĤ

ĞĜğĞĢ

ğĞĤ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

CoƉîYĶƉnĭőŔ

FŘŀİņĭĪ�ĔŃĲŕ�ŃĬ

ŕĵń

��ň��ľŘŃĲŕĽĴ©äĸŒĮń3ŏłĭŕ

ĞĜĞĥĦ

ěĞĜğĦħ

ĞĜğğ

ĞĜģĞĦ

ěĞĜĞġħ

ĞĜğģ

ĞĜĞģħ

ğĞģ


Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

CoƉîYĶƉnĭőŔ

FŘŀİņĭĪ�ĔŃĲŕ�ŃĬ

ŕĵń

ĭŀŐ�·ŃĬŕĵńŘkıĴłĭŕ

ěĞĜğğğ

ěĞĜğĠ

ĞĜĞĤ

ĞĜĢĢħ

ěĞĜğĠ

ĞĜĠġĥ

ĞĜĠġģ

ğĞĢ


Ö0

ĘĭŨşƄńºôŇNŁĳYú

ĘĭŨşƄńºôŇNŁĳ_

ĈÕ³Yú

ÁV³�~ŇNŁĭļrn�

XĪYúŘÝĮ

qOŘjŕļŏňñ�ůƊŪźƊŨŘ��ĺŕŨşƄıĬ

ŕěĞĜĞğ

ĞĜĞĦğ

ěĞĜĞĢ

ĞĜĞĞĦ

ĞĜĤĢĢ

ĞĜĞğġ

ĞĜĞĤĠ

Ġğ


Ö0

ĘĭŨşƄńºôŇNŁĳYú

ĘĭŨşƄńºôŇNŁĳ_

ĈÕ³Yú

�±ƉŢŚŇċĺŕ��ňqOŘ

;ďĸĪ×dŇĂ«ĺŕ

��ň7VƉ7±ŇċĺŕºôŘĪ�ÓőŮƅŵņŅňž

ůśŚİœ#yĸłĭŕ

ĞĜĞĞġ

ĞĜğģĢ

ĞĜĠĞ

ěĞĜĞĠĥ

ĞĜĤĠĠ

ěĞĜğġĤ

ěĞĜĞğĦ

ğğğ


�ő�©ÏĒŘ©äĸĪ¾�³ø�Ř

$Įĺŕ

7±_ĈÕńĸłň¾�³

ø�Ř�ļĺ

Øcň-´ňļŏŇ7±_ĈÕ

ňL�őÆPŘ-«ĸņĭØ*ň-´ňļŏŇ��Ř-«ĸłŉĭĴņĭńnĮ

ěĞĜğĦġ

ĞĜğġĦ

ĞĜğġ

ĞĜĞĦĢ

ěĞĜğğĢ

ĞĜĤħģ

ěĞĜğĠğ

ğğĠ



$Įĺŕ

�ő�©ÏĒŘWŕ

é±çĆő»ÅůƊŪň�ķřĪ

Ļň��ņ�Ėň�wŘÝŗ

ņĭ

ŮŨŰő>ēëEņŅŃĪ�ıĬĿłŐ��ŘÝĿłŉĭĴ

ņĭńnĮ

ĞĜğĞĢ

ĞĜĠġĠ

ěĞĜĞĥĠ

ĞĜĞĠ

ěĞĜĞĥģ

ĞĜģĥ

ěĞĜĞģ

ġġ



$Įĺŕ

��qOňĂ+ņ-«ń�

õ

pÒňqOęŸƂŜŴŦƊŇċŗ

ŕqOŘBŎĚŘWÂĺŕ

ºŔjļ��ňÂ\ŘË^Ň£œĶņĭØ�ıĬŕ

ĞĜĠġĠ

ěĞĜğĢġ

ěĞĜĞģĢ

ĞĜĞĤħ

ĞĜğĦĦ

ĞĜĢĠĤ

ěĞĜĞğġ

ĥ7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

ØcÈ©

�ĊŇ�¼ŃĬŕ

óÐƉ¤ÑƉYÑňĉS�.ŇŉVŊļŏň¡�ıĭŀŐ

ŃĲłĭŕ

ěĞĜĞĥĠ

ěĞĜĞĠĤ

ĞĜĞĦģ

ĞĜĞğħ

ĞĜğħĤ

ěĞĜĞģħ

ĞĜĥħĠ

Ĥ7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

ØcÈ©

Øûň�f¦tŇ®rĸĪÎ�Ɖ

A�ŘJŕ

Ø*ň�f¦tŇĭŀŐ�ŘăĿłĭŕ

ĞĜğĥĥ

ĞĜğĥħ

ěĞĜğĠģ

ĞĜĞģġ

ěĞĜġĢĦ

ěĞĜğĠġ

ĞĜģğĥ

Ħ7±_ĈÕÒňNµńņŕ

Ö0


�³ŨşƄ

ØcÈ©

�ĊŇ�¼ŃĬŕ

Ø*ň�īňŨŢŧƀƊƄŘ¼YŇ}�ĸłĭŕ

ĞĜğĤğ

ěĞĜĞģğ

ĞĜĞĤġ

ĞĜğĤğ

ĞĜĞĤĢ

ěĞĜĞĥĦ

ĞĜĢĢĥ

àğĢƍ7±ŸƆŷŝŭŦƁŲƃũŽê�đ¶ňHU*�ňÊ�ę�ð�ƉƅźƄƎƌ

đ¶ĩĨ

*Ą

ĒM

ŞŮŤƃ

ţƊű

đ¶

HUöÙą

��4<

ËÁÂ�õn

�ĭ

��4<

Ë©}�=�Ì

��4<

ËďĠģĚĖĈĞ

ĦĒøõÂLÌ

�34<

Ë�A�>·Ì

�4<

Ë�´ñZ£Ì

��4<

Ë�zĪ��

¶�Ì

��4<

Ë�G�zÌ

�Xõ-Mą¥óàĀ�®èĂäñàðáĂ ÏÎ×ÓÐ ÏÎÏÖÔ ÍÏÎÐÐ ÍÏÎÏ×Ò ÏÎÏÒ ÍÏÎÏØÒ ÍÏÎÐÏÓ

�®õ�Xô�Rą�æóàĀ�âäñàðáĂ ÏÎÖÐÐ ÍÏÎÑÑÐ ÏÎÏÓ ÍÏÎÏØÔ ÍÏÎÐÏÐ ÏÎÐÖÕ ÏÎÏÓÑ

čĦīĝĩīČą!uôºüĂêüôöòÝæêĀÿÜß

�íïÜĂÏÎÖÏÖ ÍÏÎÏÏÖ ÏÎÏ× ÏÎÏØ ÏÎÏÕØ ÍÏÎÏÓØ ÏÎÏÔÑ

=� õ={ñ�Üô(ã1ÞĂÂ�ąn�æïÜĂ ÏÎÕÖÑ ÍÏÎÐÕ× ÍÏÎÐÔ ÏÎÐÏÒ ÏÎÐÏÒ ÍÏÎÏÒÓ ÏÎÐÓÑ

�"õ¨ÜêÜäñą±z�ô¹ùĂäñàðáĂ ÏÎÔÕ ÏÎÑÏ× ÏÎÐÖ ÏÎÏÐØ ÍÏÎÐÒØ ÍÏÎÏÖØ ÍÏÎÐ

xrþ�9ôMçê¨ »ÜþSHą.ĂäñàðáĂ ÏÎÔÓÕ ÏÎÏÖ× ÍÏÎÏÔ ÍÏÎÏ×Ñ ÏÎÏÐÓ ÏÎÐÔÕ ÏÎÐÏÕ

��õ�Jþ��¦ô¼UæóàĀÙ�"õQ¥ą�Jè

ĂäñàðáĂÏÎÔÑÓ ÏÎÑÓÖ ÏÎÏÓ ÏÎÐÔÕ ÏÎÏÑÕ ÏÎÏÐÒ ÍÏÎÐÒ

#BÆõñYì§ãï®ąèĂäñàðáĂ ÏÎÔÐ× ÏÎÏÔØ ÏÎÑ× ÍÏÎÏÕ ÍÏÎÏÑÓ ÍÏÎÏÔÓ ÏÎÏÕÓ

�"àäăßĀ=÷ùá¯ÉąúîãĂäñàðáĂ ÍÏÎÏØ× ÏÎÖÓÐ ÏÎÏÑ ÏÎÐÒ ÏÎÏØ ÍÏÎÏØ× ÍÏÎÏÐ

�¸õDj�ôûãïÙ�óôąèùáßàĄßĂ ÏÎÏÒ× ÏÎÖÑÑ ÏÎÏÒ ÍÏÎÏÐÒ ÍÏÎÏÐÒ ÏÎÐÔÑ ÍÏÎÏÐ

�¸õV¾ą�è= :õs*ô,'æïÜĂ ÏÎÏÖÕ ÏÎÕÔÔ ÍÏÎÏÓ ÏÎÏÓÑ ÏÎÏÐÔ ÏÎÏÒÕ ÍÏÎÐÒØ

=�©}ą�ïïéăą>¢èĂäñàðáĂ ÍÏÎÏÔÑ ÏÎÕÏ× ÍÏÎÏÖ ÍÏÎÐÓÓ ÏÎÐÐÒ ÏÎÐ×Ó ÏÎÑØÖ

ÊþEĖĒĘàóâïýeÚ=�èĂ�TàÛĂ ÍÏÎÏÐÖ ÏÎÔÐ× ÏÎÏÒ ÍÏÎÏØÕ ÏÎÐÕ× ÏÎÏØÕ ÏÎÐÕÐ

�Å õ+�ëãðöóâÙ67ðFÀåăïÜĂ��s*

þ��Ī+�ôîÜïÂLàÛĂÍÏÎÏÒ× ÍÏÎÏÕ× ÏÎØÔ ÏÎÏÖÑ ÏÎÏÏÐ ÏÎÏÏÑ ÍÏÎÏÓÒ

��õq�ĪĎćëãðöóâÙ67ðõ��s*Ī��

Ãs*ôýÂLàÛĂÏÎÏÑÔ ÍÏÎÏÑÖ ÏÎÖ× ÍÏÎÏ×Ö ÏÎÐÏÖ ÏÎÐÑÓ ÍÏÎÏÔÑ

+�dªĬ�ÅĪ«�Wĭ :õ��Ī��dªð�ÜïÜ

ĂC¿�ôîÜï�íïÜĂÍÏÎÏÐ ÍÏÎÏÐØ ÏÎÕÐ ÏÎÏÏÕ ÏÎÐÑÐ ÍÏÎÏÕÖ ÏÎÐÔÓ

67ðgĀèO�åĆõ{sąĉĢīđèĂäñàðáĂ ÏÎÏÕ ÏÎÑÏØ ÏÎÔÓ ÏÎÏÐÕ ÍÏÎÐÔÒ ÍÏÎÏÐÔ ÏÎÏ×Ó

ĄßĀóÜäñöĄßĀóÜñ²¡ô¨ÞĂ ÍÏÎÏÕÕ ÏÎÐÐØ ÏÎÏÒ ÏÎÖÑ ÍÏÎÐÓÕ ÍÏÎÐÏÓ ÍÏÎÏÏÔ

�ßĀõ^`þ¬�ą/ã?ăĂäñàðáĂ ÏÎÐÑÖ ÏÎÏÒÑ ÍÏÎÏ× ÏÎÕÒÓ ÏÎÑÏÓ ÏÎÐÏÑ ÍÏÎÐÐÐ

�¸õy5õ�&þéõÄ~ąo�ô¥�ýĂäñàðá

ĂÍÏÎÏØ× ÏÎÑÑÓ ÍÏÎÐÐ ÏÎÔÒÖ ÏÎÐÑÒ ÍÏÎÏÐÕ ÏÎÐÏÓ

�õp]ìąðáĂëãz§æÿÝñ)üïÜĂ ÏÎÏÖ× ÍÏÎÐ×Ø ÏÎÐÐ ÏÎÔÏ× ÍÏÎÏÒØ ÏÎÐÔ ÏÎÏÔØ

Üîýo�ðÛĂäñąLàãïÜĂ ÍÏÎÐÐÐ ÍÏÎÐÑ ÏÎÏÕ ÏÎÓÓØ ÍÏÎÐÑ ÏÎÑÒÖ ÏÎÑÒÔ

P8ąKĂêüõ±bėīĔğīĒąa�èĂĒċĦàÛ

ĂÍÏÎÏÐ ÏÎÏ×Ð ÍÏÎÏÓ ÏÎÏÏ× ÏÎÕÓÓ ÏÎÏÐÒ ÏÎÏÕÑ

hcõ+=Ī+�ôÂèĂ�´ąÙc�þĖħěóòõĢ

ėĈćßĀ�XæïÜĂÏÎÏÏÒ ÏÎÐÔÓ ÏÎÑÏ ÍÏÎÏÑÖ ÏÎÕÑÑ ÍÏÎÐÒÕ ÍÏÎÏÐ×

�"õ$�õêüô�ą$|æïöÜãóÜñNÝ ÍÏÎÐ×Ò ÏÎÐÒ× ÏÎÐÒ ÏÎÏ×Ó ÍÏÎÐÐÓ ÏÎÕØÔ ÍÏÎÐÑÐ

ĖĒĘþ0È2óòðÙ�àÛíïý�oą¢íïöÜã

óÜñNÝÏÎÐÏÓ ÏÎÑÒÑ ÍÏÎÏÖÑ ÏÎÏÑ ÍÏÎÏÖÔ ÏÎÔÖ ÍÏÎÏÔ

�āKê�õ�@ą�BôvĀåóÜ��àÛĂ ÏÎÑÒÑ ÍÏÎÐÓÒ ÍÏÎÏÔÓ ÏÎÏÕØ ÏÎÐ×× ÏÎÓÑÕ ÍÏÎÏÐÒ

³�Īw�Ī>�õÀ;f%ôö=÷êüõt�àÜîý

ðáïÜĂÍÏÎÏÖÑ ÍÏÎÏÑÕ ÏÎÏ×Ô ÏÎÏÐØ ÏÎÐØÕ ÍÏÎÏÔØ ÏÎÖØÑ

�"õ�IxSôÜîýpą¼íïÜĂ ÏÎÐÖÖ ÏÎÐÖØ ÍÏÎÐÑÔ ÏÎÏÔÒ ÍÏÎÒÓ× ÍÏÎÐÑÒ ÏÎÔÐÖ

�"õeÚõĒĎđģīĦą�>ô[_æïÜĂ ÏÎÐÕÐ ÍÏÎÏÔÐ ÏÎÏÕÒ ÏÎÐÕÐ ÏÎÏÕÓ ÍÏÎÏÖ× ÏÎÓÓÖ

¤ÐÓĮ+�ĝĨĜĊĕĐĤęĥēġ¬�Ç�õ4<"kõ�lËi°mĪħğĦįĭĬ\�ĭ

Ç�

4<µ�½

�� höÂí³§=}Þ:;EÛø höÂí³=}Þ:;E¸t�½:¦qÑQLa

N\^WM!P_d� �Î=�»


Ö°�°�Ñ¥Ã¡å=Ì¢AÛø�ïv=�r�ãÅH¾1-Ú¢1

8'E

� x§�¡³«�Ç³«:=Ä��ñ Âí³:=ú��Ô Ç³«�Ô Æ³«:=�Ô<�m2E

�� höÂí³§=}Þ:;EÛø �'QLa:Ì¢<}7-¥Ã

�'QLa:Ì¢<}7-Âí³Ñ¥Ã

�'b[a=QLa:huÌ¢Hé 1�4FHÝ~

2E


¡�zô¡·=��²È<õf1�

g ��±H¹E

á��höYcXJSP_V`R]âl�ì)B>�� =ÉuunçÕÒ��"êÏ��b[a�#

�Éuhuähun

�Éuðuä Ë¼ ®¼

�� Êjk��¸{|�=�Í#

�� $��

Ê×k��pÑu¬�

��

Ê�k��N\^WTIZaQ?=|µ�

�� $��

Ê�k��°�Ñ¥Ã�

�� $��

Ê�k��Ì¢:��

��

Êûk��ùô�¦qÑÁÙ�

��

Ê£k��¡�zô�

��

�� $��

� �

Êjk��¸{|�=�Í� �ì� ��

Ê×k��pÑu¬��ì� �� Ê�k��N\^WTIZaQ?=|µ��ì�

��

Ê�k��°�Ñ¥Ã��ì� ��

Ê�k��Ì¢:��ì� �� Êûk��ùôÑ�¦qÑÁÙ��ì�

��

Ê£k��¡�zô��ì� ��

��ÕÒ"��ì# ��

k�ë �� :=Ä||� ´ó¼�º�e�

�"×àê��Ð#

Éu�un

©Ó�k�

¥Ã9ßò:0FE9&G(Ì¢A�HØ ¬Õ18'E

��Ñ;¿w¬yH·<6.8'E

á��höYcXJSP_V`R]âl�ì=k�åÀ=�o<BD¯s0F5�ì�êÏ��b[a%#

�ì

á��höYcXJSP_V`R]âl©Ó�êÏ��b[a%#=�� :=Ä||�)B>´ó¼�º�e�º�

�ì�� åî ÷i KTO` N!U

¼ç

�"×àê��Ð#

Äª=üH¨C3<��-æ-/:+9,E¤Ü=�kH¶DèD�4=�<w*2/:+9,EÆun=u¿:=¸{|�H(@-�Í2E/:+9,E

58

( =0.86) ( =0.63) 17 30

0.90

× 1

2 2

1 N

2

o N

(1)

1)

― ―

2016 3 4 ― 9

2)

B ― ― 35 ― 352 v C

83 N 35 ― ―

N

N ― N

N N ― N

N C IPE

N N

3)

C ―

― ―

N

N × ×

N 2 50 N N × 259

v ― 2015 2016 N ―

N ―

59

50 2

N 1 1

× N 1 2

1 N

N 7

N 3 7

17 50 N N 18

50 22 N

N × 3 7 21

4

50

(5 ) (4 ) (3 ) (2

) (1 ) N

N 2 ×

― × N N

N P-MEX(Professionalism Mini-Evaluation Exercise)37

43 5 P-MEX 4 24

5

3 8 P-MEX

(4 )

(3 ) (2 ) (1

) (0 ) ― N

(4 ) (3 ) (2

) (1 ) N

4)

N t (Welch )

N

Ė��kĴWcV@LG^Q`JZėrĤ�ġö²�bXa��Ĥ�

E�P AMF` Ķl ěĦ

� Ø�7ĲÖ.q!%¡ī��7óÿ=Ê:�,�+�: þæ-ç�7¡ī��

� Ě§��ĭ=Ý.(�*�:

� K�G\a[N?>.Ęá.��:Ā©= -�

� ĨÞ�8Úį�;�į9.�;*�:o=(�-��Úį+�

:Þ+�:�,

� <�8-��,0<�8-�,��.¡�: ôý��=Ğ(

Âě/�¨Øó.�(6�=Č'*�:ÂÝ/�¨Øó.ĳh �j¾�¦Õ=ß:

¬��pÍ�ÆÍ/z¹¿¯.0�1%5/Ïē��(6+�*�%

� Âě/Ć�/IDH]�a=�Æ.Ċe *�:

� Ðòģ/Þ,ñ&x�*ĸ=":�,�+�:

�� ëË/Ďq=�-�8wĸ":�,�+�:

�� ëË/ĸ=É8#.±��Ĝ��,�+�:

�� wĸ/ëË.��=Á -�8Ĝ��,�+�:

�� ½�7ÓMIO�-�*6Ć��Í":Í��'%èĥÙ, *�ïý.�Í":�,/ĔĬá=ć

Ã *�:

�� Í�v=Ĳ**$;=Æ«":�,�+�:

�� ÂÝ/ÒĮì.4�*�°-.="2��<�:

� ÂÝ/âø=í"�ą{/�Ă.·s *�:

� ×. Ø.Ģî -�¦ÕÛ=6'*�:

�� ðÞ�8/¼ü7ėr=Ì�ĩ;:�,�+�:ÂÝ/¡Ă7«i.(�*/U>bT]�7

V?�PSLC=�5:

�� ÂÝ/ ´/ĉķ7$/¢y=ã�.�å6:�,�+�:

�� Äċ/�n=Ü9ĝ9�$/¤.��"�,�+�:

�� tÑ/Đg=÷�%k��kĴôÃ=Íă *�:®�bXa/IBa,k�ôÃ=Ğ¾ �$;=

č�":

��mďý-Å�.(�*�ĕÏý-ÀĴĠ�D>/ğĠ=ô'*�:

¥ı/ĵ��¥uý-D>=û�":

�� ÀĴ�D>=«�³/fê�Ğ/�ġý-ª�ğ=İx *�: fê-kĴ=û�":

�()��

�Ĥ� ��8��3+0bXa�ö²+6¸Ī %�úĤ��đ0bXa�ö²ĄÂ/Ĥ

Ĥ�

Ĥ }ā":kĴWcV@LG^Q`JZ|Ĉ

kĴèĥÙÈ/�Ē,-:ĉķ

kĴèĥÙ/�Ē,-:Þ~�â,ÇwýIBa

Ęá�äÆ��»�79

Ęá/�:«Ă�ćÃ=Ğ(

Â£�İ¿�.ã�+�:

EY]RD�G^d�Î

¥uý-EY]RD�G^d=«�

�õ/ºà

B\`>W_d=µâ Æ«": �ï�Í�B\`>zč

èĥÙ, *âø=ï�:�,=ù��5:

ąÔ�Ô¶ýÆéÂě/ôÃ7ĉķ�ħ�/¢y�ęî=ã �ć

Ã *�:

®�IBa,ôÃ.�)�èĥÙýÆé

®�IBa,ôÃ.�)�Æé

Ş��Ƅr�qUf_zk|awş�ÛŲ!Ůļà�~s}��ÛŲ"!89*"

\ j Xg]| ƅ� ŦŴ

�� ¦ù@��PØƂ/4ñƄ�[R@ŬĕPÇň1M-<);*M

¦ù@��!Ôţ�ÆÕ>Čĳ"PáĴ?ÜGM-<?ñƄ�[R@ĈŃPņ:M

�� ¦ù<ďŽ«ÁPĺ+4G@ŅƆP/:$M

¦ù<@ďŽ«ÁIn ik _frP¡Ɓ/4ĉ;ñƄ�[RPĿ¶1

M

� ¦ù?<7:O(LI1+�(8ě/$ģűP1M-<);*M¦ù?O(LI1$�ě¡>ċūĿ¶IģűPÙ

%

�� bX�jWplW�@�ėIûìPſ�/:$M¦ù)İ@�çI�ƄĥųĎ@�ÊPŨ+-<P

įĄ1M

��òŦ@õŕIv`A�éŌù?ŪE�.2?ūÞ/:$M!ūÞ1M-<);*M"

ÑL)#74<*?AĞ÷?úâ1M

b}q[RIV�n�x�i@�œ?8$:ģű;*Mb}q[RPê��V�

n� 1M

�� ¦ù)�èÅľ1M@?ŝż>ċūPĿ¶1M-<);*M¦ù)òÎÅľ;*MJ

%?ê�1M

��¦ù)òK£Q5L�ĸôPō4L;*MJ%?«OM-<);*M

ĸô@ ō�RjoR{�`!\�\ d�`"

Pê�1M

�� ¦ù@�ķ©IĜ¥ŖÄPđ+ĸMJ%?ŅG:$M¦ùª@ÌĖŀŧ�ŀß��ķ©PįĄ1M

� ¦ù@²ï6IØ&>=PŸĩ/>)K¦ù<«O7:$M¦ù@§ċPſ�/:�è$IL@#MÙŊP<

M

� İĎý<@Ėª«ÁP%D+Öĺ1M-<);*MİĎý<@¸ŉ?ä�1

M

�� İĎý@�ķ©Iďœ@�$PįĄ1M-<);*M�>M�ķ©IďœPï74Ė<¸ŉ1M

��e w?',M| d _frPŘ¯1MC*Č¼I�3@<L(4)Ŧ(M

e w@��</:| d _fr�ĠŒP<M

� İĎý@ĸôI`Y}�ĥųęPſ�/�ĪĶ1M-<);*MİĎý@ĥųęIŔƆPÊğHM-<);*M

��ŋ0Ďý@Ĥŗ�ŋƃ<�ñƄ�[R@#LŬ?8$:µƋ1M-<);*M

ŋĎý@`Y}��ķ©�ŔƆ?Ã�PŤ%

�� ò!ŋ"Ďý@ŋƃ<�Ï$?ć,Ý&M«ÁPÖĺ/:$Mŋƃ?^t i�Rjm

T`P1M

� ÐŗB@éŌ�»�?ğ¾ŀ?«OL4$<è%ÐĔ@»�Ix�c P

�*þ,M

��T�_h�i�RZ_h�i~t iPĿą1M-<@�´Pſ�/:$M

Ĩč@ö�Ħ��ħ¥Ŋ?ăî1M

�ħ>�Ƅ@Ŀ¶<3@ĘĔ

Ĩč¨¹@ĚŜ

� �řæů?Ĳ/:òē@ĥųęI¥ŊPģű;*MÓĀ<òĎý@ďŽ«ÁPºGM¥ŊPÙ%

òĎý@ĥųĎĂĵB@±ī�ÚÈ

�Ĺ�@Ŏę?9$:ł�.N:$M�ƄIũÆ¥Ŋ�ţí?8$:ĸ7:$M

Ĺ��Ƅ�ũÆ�ţí@¥Ŋ?®Ź1M

Š��@ũÆ��Ƅ�ţíëĢ;ŉ+ĥųĎ@°Ŕ�ŵ¤?8$:ĸ7:$M

Ĺ��Ƅ�ũÆ�ţí@ĥųĎ�ëĢ<@ƉÂP

đGM

òē@ĥųĎ</:@ŘË)�æůIø�?Ź&M�½@Ĵ*.Pſ�/:$M

u`xhSRB@Ğ÷�Óě>Ĳ�

u`�xhSR@žŻ<ċūĿ¶@#LŬ

� ÷ÿŇ;ĸLō4¦ù@ċūP�ŷĖI�Ĭ>=?ƌ.>$¦ù@ċū�r{Tm_ ?«OMċūP¬F�Püś1M

ÌĖċū@Łġ>žŻ<ũÒ

��ƄĥųĎ@ÉĆ*PžŻ/:ŢĪ�>ž�Pō>$!ĝŶ�ø(K@ťš¶ŹŇ"

òÎ@ž�@4G?�ƄĥųĎ@Ĺ�IƁĊPž

Ż/>$

¦ù(Kúƈ�ÀšPń.N:HÍó;*M¦ù(KŢņ>ūāIú

ƈPHKO>$

� ĒƄ³Ɗ?³ő1C*ŐźPſ�/�ŀ¡?³ő/:$MĒƄ³Ɗ?ŀ¡>ŐźP³/�¡÷?ũĮPÙ%

�ĎĊ@�?'$:H�ƄĥųĎ</:@ò¢Pï6ĭ,M-<);*M

¿Űðª�?',MĥųĎ</:@ĠŰ

�ÛŲ��(K��D;A~s}�ļà;HåŻ/4·ĽÛŲ��ŚA~s}ļàŏò@ÛŲ

ÛŲ��

ÛŲ �ņ1M�Ƅr�qUf_zk|aw�œ

ø�ŀĠŒP�41

\vylgS�ĥųĎĂĵ�ø�B@ÚÈ

ŭIƇſ×ƅPſ�/�ø�ŀĠŒPħ%1M

�ƄĥųĎ</:@ø�ŀĠŒP�41

Ĺ�@ũÆ�Ƅţí¥Ŋ?Ĳ1Mſ�<ÚÈ

¦ù�òĎý�ıĎý<@ĪÏãŻ

�¦ùĻĐ@[R@Ŀ¶

ĥųĎ<@ƉÂ�¸ŉ

ıĎý¸ŉ

òĎýŉ

¦ù@òƀęPÜGM�ê�1Mŉ*(,

¦ùĻĐû´

�Ėª</:@¦ùPſ�/�«OM

62

N P-MEX 2

N P-MEX 2

×

N Cronbach’s

coefficient N

IBM SPSS Statistics 22.0 N p<0.05 N

5)

(2)

1) : P

― 166 ( 46.0 ) C

74 89.2% 19 48.3%

51.7%

�'/?��!�3��$20()-%=��;:79(>

�� 4658< 2 #

��;�� =��> ',) ,.&.

1�� "*�� -* )'&(

�� ''* *.&)

� '(( +'&-

20 50 IT

N 3 N

4.58 0.69 219

N 4.42 0.62 224

4.34 0.80 225 N

4.49 0.77 226

4.37 0.80 5

ÓĎČž-ūŷŪŒšřųŦŴŜůà�Ć±ļA�ăÛż�ä�źŶŬŵſŽ

Ć±

ėĖĆ±

Z?�

Ĝ� �V

F�

ź\*�ėě²þ

č ¤�ņ¾CĻfĬİÚÏóĠņo]ō2ŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ĐċČĕĜČċĒđ ČċĒČ

Ď Y[Ġ�ĈōîĻĴĨĶĠŊ ďċččĜČċĕĐ Čċđď

ď ŞŻřűŵŰţŐŏĻ8iĻ�ĨŊv¼ōīĺĠ ĐċđĔĜČċĒĕ Ċ ČċĎĎ

Đ 0Ĥň�ćĪŋĝćŉĻĪŋĶĠŊ ďċđČĜČċēĔ ČċđĔ

đ ŌĤňĺĠĩĸĽŌĤňĺĠĸçÑĻÚĢŊ ĐċČđĜČċēĒ ČċďĎ

Ē Í!ļ�^¤oĻĠĴŅ�ōõĳĶĠŊ ďċđĐĜčċČĐ ČċĐē

ē èÃź¡ÄźLÄļüH�$ĻĽIľİńļ �ĥĠĴŅķĦĶĠİ ďċČđĜčċČē ČċđĐ

Ĕ Í!ļ�ĞļśŘŚŲŻŵō´LĻu{īĶĠŊ ďċđĎĜčċČč ČċđĐ

ĕ "OĄļĸtĲÙĨĶâōĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĐĕĜčċČď ČċĐđ

čČ ²sļ1fōÖĺĥň âĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ĐċČĒĜČċĔĐ Čċđđ

čč ²sļâōôňĮĻ��_ħÇħĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĔĕĜČċĕč ČċĐĔ

čĎ âļ²sĻ�nōµīĺĥňÇħĩĸĥķĦŊ ĐċČĔĜČċēĒ ČċđĒ

čď áĉņTŢśŤĥĺħĶŅ�ĞIÄĭŊÄpĥğĳİ ĎċĒČĜčċČČ ČċĐĕ

čĐ IÄÛ©ō¾ĶĶįŋōLÒĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċČČĜčċČĐ ČċđČ

čđ ÍîļQ��ĻŃĨĶĝĺĻōĭŀĦĤĥŌĤŊ ďċĎďĜčċČđ ČċĒď

čĒ Íîļrúō�ĭI�Dļ�+Ļ/'īĶĠŊ ĎċĕĕĜčċĎč Čċđč

čē XĻ¥¤Ļ�íīĺĠ6�dōŅĳĶĠŊ ďċđĎĜČċĕđ ČċđČ

čĔ �Ĥňļx}ņà�ō3ĨNŋŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ĐċČĎĜČċēĐ ČċďĐ

čĕ Íîļ¥=ļÌ&ņįļÿªō�´ĻÖ½ŅŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĐĔĜČċēĒ ČċĐĐ

ĎČ G~ļ.9ōyŉñŉĝįļbĻ�ĤĭĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċēĕĜČċēĐ ČċĒē

ĎČč �º�ļÀ:ōìĢİ-Iź-³êōÄcīĶĠŊ ĎċĎēĜČċĕď ČċĐĎ

ĎČĎ �Î¯ĺ«jĻĴĠĶĝ� ¯ĺ��źŘŏļ��ō³ĳĶĠŊ ĎċĔĕĜČċĕĐ Čċđđ

ĎČď �źŘŏōÒġāļJ�´�ļA�¯ĺÅĢ�ō¦ÙīĶĠŊ ďċĎĐĜČċĕČ ČċĒĔ

ĎČĐ jÆļĚęĘōÅqīİ�źŘŏļ�øō�ÜĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċďēĜČċĕē ČċĒĒ

ĎČđ jÆĸ�ćþ�ōÁħİńļ)&ōīĶĠŊ ĐċčĔĜČċēď ČċđĐ

ĎČĒ jÆĻĸĳĶŌĤŉņĭħĝĤĴ�īĠã�ōĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĐĎĜČċĕĒ ČċĒč

ĎČē ŝŕŹťŔũŧŔŹļm;ņ��ō¦ÙīĶĠŊ ďċĔēĜČċēĒ Čċđđ

ĎČĔ Í!ļG~ņŮśĽĝxSÆĻ,łĂĪĮĻB7īĶĠŊżB7ĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊŽ ĐċČĐĜČċēĐ ČċĐđ

Ďď ŝŵŪŘŏņœŹŨŸŰŹŤļ�gĻĴĠĶã�ķĦŊ ĎċĕĒĜčċčď Čċđď

ĎČĕ jÆĥmh�KĭŊļĻeÕĺkBōz�ĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĐĎĜČċĕ ČċĒē

ĎčČ jÆĥÍňIŎıŉĝ³êōcİŉķĦŊŇġĻþŌŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĐĎĜČċĕ ČċĒĒ

Ďčč jÆļ��Øņ§�Ë�ō�ħ³ŊŇġĻ)ńĶĠŊ ďċĕĎĜČċĔč ČċđĎ

ĎčĎ jÆļ�wĲņÅĢĺĹō�līĺĥňjÆĸþŌĳĶĠŊ ĐċČĎĜČċēĔ Čċđē

Ďčď �È»ĸļýþ�ōġŁħ�ÁĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċēĎĜČċĔ ČċĒē

ĎčĐ �È»ļ��Øņ�gļòĠōRöĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ĐċČČĜČċēĒ Čċđē

Ďčđ ŠŻůĻģĨŊŴŻşŻřšūō®|ĭŊŀĦ¤�ņĝįļĸŉĤİĥ!ĤŊ ďċčĔĜČċĕđ ČċĒĕ

ĎčĒ �È»ļ³êņśŖŵĝPûiō¦Ùīĝ²åĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċĒēĜČċĔĔ ČċĒē

Ďčē 5ĬÈ»ļ�ïź5�ĸĝ�źŘŏļğŉ�ĻĴĠĶëæĭŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċđēĜČċĕĐ ČċĒĒ

ĎčĔ Íż5ŽÈ»ļ5�ĸĝ�ĠĻ(Ĩ4ĢŊþ�ō�ÁīĶĠŊ ďċĔēĜČċĔČ Čċđē

Ďĕ bïĿļxSź�ÊĻ½�¯ĻþŌŉİĠĸhġ ďċĕĐĜČċĔĐ ČċĐč

Ďčĕ őŹřţŹŤźŏŗřţŹŤŶŭŻŤōz ĭŊĩĸļmÃō¦ÙīĶĠŊ ĐċĐĎĜČċĒĎ Ċ ČċĐČ

ĎĎČ �ÎW�ĻOīĶÍîļPûiņ�+ōã�ķĦŊ ďċĒĎĜČċĔĕ ČċĒđ

ĎĎč >@ļ£iĻAĵĠĶUüĪŋĶĠŊ-ņ��+ĝ¹¸ĻĴĠĶ³ĳĶĠŊ ďċčĐĜčċČĎ Čċđĕ

ĎĎĎ ¬Ā�Dļ��ź-ź¹¸�Þķ�ħPûÈļ�Ìźa%ĻĴĠĶ³ĳĶĠŊ ďċďĐĜČċĕĕ ČċĒĐ

ĎĎď ÍîļPûÈĸīĶļ®ÚĥĝW�ņ· Ļ�ĢŊ`ąļEĦĪō¦ÙīĶĠŊ ďċĒďĜČċĔĐ ČċĐĐ

ĎĎĐ LÄ¿ķ³ŉcİjÆļkBōĝ0ņM�ĺĹĻâĪĺĠ ĐċďĐĜČċĔČ Ċ ČċĎĎ

ĎĎđ -PûÈļÉ�Ħō#¨īĶ�²fĺ#°ōcĺĠżÔÐ ·Ĥňļ¢8��¿Ž ĐċĐĕĜČċēē Ċ ČċďĔ

ĎĎĒ jÆĤňé¶ź÷8ō�ĪŋĶŅ<ðķĦŊ ĐċďēĜČċĔČ Ċ ČċĐč

ĎĎē ßÝùĻÝ�ĭŀĦ�Nō¦Ùīĝ¯´ĻÝ�īĶĠŊ ďċĒĔĜČċĔĎ ČċĒČ

ĎĎĔ ÈCļDĻģĠĶŅ-PûÈĸīĶļÍ×ōwĲÂĨŊĩĸĥķĦŊ ďċēďĜČċĔĎ Čċđč

64

IT 3 r=0.22 224 r=0.22 2

r 0.3

2) �� 2 ��

2

IT 0.3

19

31 8 21 22 KMO 0.886 Bartlett

p<0.001, 2=3794.1, df=465 8

P-MEX 2 23

7 P-MEX 2

C

P-MEX

2 P-MEX 2

24 P-MEX

2 0.28 0.59

0.59 P-MEX

2 0.33 0.60

2 0.71 0.87

24 31 0.93

Ó�@O

ĪR!ŞĊţĨ

ňżŴ��Ʀ

Ó@O

Ītß�oţż

Ŵ��ī

Ó�@O

Īõ¼ÃPÝī

Ó?@O

Īđ�ƨ4�ī

Ó�@O

Ī Ĝĝ�ţ

Öī

Ó$@O

ĪŽƗƛƌƈŵƔ

ƟƂŦţĝoī

Ó�@O

Ī�¹ŅÌ�Ã

ĉ�ī

Ó"@O

ĪÈXÃTČī

ıįĳ

tßƣæáÐƣKáÐşţÇ

��»

ĩtß�oţżŴţ��

tß�o�Ü

tßţńĿłłĬľĿŁŃŀƥeÎƣ�fš´

yƦŲ�LŢĨũůŐşŢ¨ÁƣżŴ

ţ±¯Ųiŝů

tßţĽļĻŲÞ{Œŗ¨ÁƣżŴţ�ęŲ�öŔůŐşŌ

Şōů

įĭĸĵĴ

įĭįķį

įĭįıķ

Ĭįĭįįĳ

ĬįĭįĲİ

Ĭįĭįįķ

Ĭįĭįİı

ĬįĭıįĴ

ıįĲ

3ÁZĚáßţGÅşšůå

,

ĨňƂźƟşÉĄŢGŜŎT

Č

ĨňƂźƟşÉĄŢGŜŎZ

ĚáÃTČ

R!š3ÁŲ��Ŕů

¨ÁƣżŴŲìŉĠţR!Ê�ţG�ÃšÞŊ�Ų¹óŒ

ŝňů

įĭķĳĵ

ĬįĭıĲĶ

Ĭįĭįĸį

įĭįĳĴ

įĭİĴķ

įĭįĶĲ

įĭİĲĸ

įĭįİĶ

ıįı


,

ĨňƂźƟşÉĄŢGŜŎT

Č

ĨňƂźƟşÉĄŢGŜŎZ

ĚáÃTČ

/·ţèňŅ/�ÃšżŴŲ��Ŕ

ů

�çÃš¿tŢśňŝŅ¡Ãš¨Á©ƣżŴţ�©Ų

ÉŚŝňů

įĭĶĵį

ĬįĭıĴĵ

įĭİıı

įĭįįį

įĭįĲİ

Ĭįĭįĵķ

Ĭįĭįĵĵ

įĭİĵĶ

ıįĵ


��»


tß�o�Ü

tßŢűŋŮūŔňŅ£ÊšuH�

�ūþ�Ųìŉ

tßŢşŚŝűŋŮūŔŎŅŋś£Œňþ�ŲŔůŐşŌŞ

ōů

įĭĴĶĲ

įĭıķĲ

ĬįĭįĳĶ

ĬįĭİĵĴ

Ĭįĭįįķ

įĭįıİ

ĬįĭİıĴ

įĭıįĸ

ıįĸ


��»


tßţælsŲĨũůŅ�

�Ŕů�ōŋŏ

tßŌæa§SŞōůŬŉŢ��Ŕ

ů

tßŌwr§SŔůţŢpðšuHŲ��ŔůŐşŌŞō

ůįĭĴĲĴ

įĭĲİķ

įĭįįĵ

įĭįıĸ

Ĭįĭİİĸ

įĭįĵı

Ĭįĭİĳĵ

įĭįĵĳ

ıįĶ


��»


tß�o�Ü

tßŌ�ţ3cū3ÁZĚáţw

ñŲàŎŐşŲ[ĕŔů

ƄŹƢƊŸƑƌŸƢţwBū��Ų¹óŒŝňů

įĭĳĲĳ

įĭıĸı

įĭįĴĴ

ĬįĭįİĶ

ĬįĭįĳĶ

įĭįĵĲ

įĭįĸĸ

ĬįĭİĶį

ıİİ


��»


� ĜşŒŝţtßŲ¹ó

ŒŅĝűů

tßĜţ� Ã�2Ã`¾Ņ��

òŲ[ĕŔů

tßţ��òūºªä�Ų«ŎÉůŬŉŢ.ũŝňů

Ĭįĭİĳĸ

įĭķĵķ

įĭįĴį

ĬįĭįĲĵ

įĭįĵĸ

įĭįĲĴ

ĬįĭįĲı

Ĭįĭįĵı

ıİı


��»


� ĜşŒŝţtßŲ¹ó

ŒŅĝűů

tßţxuŲ¹óŒŝŅrňūŮţ

Ňůì0Ųşů

tßţ¥�řūÞŊšŠŲvŒšŌŭtßşĝűŚŝň

ůĬįĭİıĴ

įĭĶĲĲ

ĬįĭİĵĴ

įĭįĶı

įĭıįķ

įĭįıĸ

įĭįĶį

įĭįĲİ

ıįĴ


��»


tß�o�Ü

tßşţ�Ħĝ�ūƎƤƉƋƤƀƇ

ƓŲÊÒŒŗ�Ş¨ÁĮżŴŲ��

Ŕů

tßş�Ħĝ�ŲÖŎŗũţ.,ŲŒŝňů

įĭıĴĲ

įĭĵĶķ

ĬįĭİİĴ

Ĭįĭİıĸ

įĭİıĳ

ĬįĭİİĴ

įĭİĶİ

ĬįĭįĴĵ

ıİį


��»


tßţælsŲĨũůŅ�

�Ŕů�ōŋŏ

ÉĄţ¶nŅŴƊƏŴƝƢƂƥŽƢ

ŽƤƆƢƂƦŲ��Ŕů

tßŌæŭPųŘŮŅÉĄŲnŗŮŞōůŬŉŢĝűůŐş

ŌŞōů

įĭįĶĲ

įĭĴĲį

įĭİĲĵ

įĭİĴĵ

ĬįĭİĴĸ

įĭįĸĵ

Ĭįĭİįĵ

įĭįĵĲ

İĲ


,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů

�j|şÌ�ÃƂźƟ

ØÙPÝƣźƚƞŴěÂ

ZĚáşŒŝØÙÃŢPÝŔůŐş

ţpðsŲûĄŒŝňů

ùħū]ƈƂƉŌšŎŝŪ�ņPÝŔůÝzŌŇŚŗ

Ĭįĭįıĵ

ĬįĭįĲĳ

įĭķĲı

ĬįĭįİĲ

įĭįĲĶ

įĭįıĵ

ĬįĭįĲĲ

ĬįĭįĲĳ

İĳ


,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


ØÙPÝƣźƚƞŴěÂ

źƚƞŴƓƝƢŲ�|ŒTìŔůPÝõ¼ŲÒŝŝŖŰŲTìŔůŐşŌŞōů

ĬįĭįĴĵ

ĬįĭİĶĲ

įĭĶįĲ

Ĭįĭİıİ

įĭİıĴ

įĭİĶİ

įĭįİĵ

įĭıįĳ

Ķ3ÁZĚáßţGÅşšůå

,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


æaÕ¹

�ĜŢ£ÊŞŇů

ĂÜƣ®ÝƣTÝţěN�*ŢŤPťŗũţ�ŌňśŪ

Şōŝňŗ

įĭıİķ

įĭįĳı

įĭĴĳĳ

įĭįĶĳ

ĬįĭįİĶ

Ĭįĭįĵķ

įĭİįİ

Ĭįĭįĸı

ķ3ÁZĚáßţGÅşšůå

,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


æaÕ¹

�ĜŢ£ÊŞŇů

æ&ţ�ņţƂżƁƛƤƟŲÊTŢ��Œŝňů

įĭİįİ

įĭİĶı

įĭĳıĲ

įĭİĲį

ĬįĭįįĴ

ĬįĭįĳĲ

įĭįĶĴ

ĬįĭįķĲ

ıİķ


��»

ZĚáşţđ�ƣ4�

æáÐ�

:�ŢſƖƤƉŅŴƊƍŶƂŲŔůæƥ:ƦáÐţ:�şŅ�ňŢ-ŏ9Ŋůĝ�Ų ÖŒŝň

ůĬįĭįıĲ

ĬįĭįĶķ

Ĭįĭİİį

įĭķĶį

įĭİĲĸ

ĬįĭįĲĵ

įĭİİĵ

Ĭįĭİįĸ

ıİĶ


��»


æáÐ�

:áÐţƂźƟŅ��òŅå,Ţ�

wŲ�ŉ

:œáÐţ Ďƣ:�şŅ¨ÁƣżŴţŇŮ�Ţśňŝąā

ŔůŐşŌŞōů

įĭįĴĴ

Ĭįĭįĳķ

įĭįįĴ

įĭķĲĲ

ĬįĭİıĶ

įĭįĳĶ

ĬįĭįĳĴ

įĭįĵı

ıĸ


��»


æáÐ�

mĒţ�ãūƙƢƅƤŲgō8ŏůmĎŦţ�\ƣ�ãŢÑ�ÃŢĝűŮŗňşrŉ

Ĭįĭįķİ

įĭįķİ

įĭİĶĶ

įĭĴıĵ

įĭİĲĵ

Ĭįĭİĳĵ

ĬįĭįĵĶ

ĬįĭİİĶ

ıİĵ


��»


KáÐ4�

�áÐţZĚsūå,ŲñÑŪů

ŐşŌŞōů

�áÐţÉĄūƂźƟŅZĚsŲ¹óŒŅÇĀŔůŐşŌ

Şōů

įĭİįı

įĭįĴı

ĬįĭįĴı

įĭĴįĸ

ĬįĭįĸĴ

įĭİķĲ

Ĭįĭįİĵ

įĭİĲĸ

ĸ3ÁZĚáßţGÅşšůå

,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


ŽƗƛƌżƤƀƜƢ�í

/�ÃšŽƗƛƌżƤƀƜƢŲìŉ(Yģţ ş~řóŏŝúŲŔůŐşŌŞōů

įĭįĲĳ

įĭįįĶ

įĭİįķ

ĬįĭįĲĸ

įĭĶĳį

įĭįĴķ

įĭįıĳ

ĬįĭįĵĶ

İį


,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


ŽƗƛƌżƤƀƜƢ�í

/�ÃšŽƗƛƌżƤƀƜƢŲìŉÇ}ţ7qŲñšŌŭ�úŔůŐşŌŞōů

Ĭįĭįįĵ

įĭıĸĲ

ĬįĭİĲĵ

įĭįĴķ

įĭĴĶĳ

įĭįĶĳ

ĬįĭįĴĵ

įĭįĶĵ

ĳ3ÁZĚáßţGÅşšůå

,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


=sƣüTőƣrňūŮ

>ŲśŋšňŅ�ĦŞōů ŞŇů

Őş

6 ŋŭ�ĦőŰŅĦŮŢőŰŝňů

įĭįıĸ

įĭİĶĸ

įĭİĸĲ

įĭİĸĳ

įĭĴįĳ

Ĭįĭİĵķ

ĬįĭįĴĶ

įĭįıİ

ııİ

Ì�Ãĉ�Ų�ŗŔ

ŽƗƛƌƈŵŅZĚáĢAŅÌ

�ŦţĈµ

EFţ��3ÁÎÍª0Ţ

YŔů¹óşĈµ

EF3Áƣ��ƣÎÍţª0ŢW�

Ŕů

EFţ³sŢGŜňŝ^ěőŰŝňů3Áū��ª0ŅÎ

ÍŢśňŝÉŚŝňů

įĭįĲį

ĬįĭįıĶ

įĭįĳĲ

Ĭįĭįİį

Ĭįĭįİİ

įĭķķĵ

įĭįįķ

Ĭįĭįĵĸ

ııı



�ŦţĈµ

EFţ��3ÁÎÍª0Ţ

YŔů¹óşĈµ

EF3Áƣ��ƣÎÍţZĚáƣ�

÷şţđ�Ų«ũů

Àğ�Jţ��ƣ3ÁƣÎÍ�÷Ş�ŎZĚáţ¢åƣk+

ŢśňŝÉŚŝňů

įĭįĳı

įĭįĲĸ

įĭįĵĸ

ĬįĭįĸĶ

įĭįĲĶ

įĭķİį

įĭİĳĲ

Ĭįĭįĵĵ

ııį



�ŦţĈµ

æáÐţZĚáĢAŦţd

_ƣĈµ

#ëşæáÐţ�Ħĝ�Ųhũů

ª0Ųìŉ

�çb¤ŢYŒŝæčţZĚsūª0Ųþ�Şōů

įĭįıį

įĭİİĳ

ĬįĭįĴĵ

įĭıķĳ

įĭįĴĵ

įĭĳįı

ĬįĭįĲĸ

įĭįĶĶ

ııĴ


©ū�¹ÚĥŲ¹óŒŅÌ

�Ãĉ�Ų!ŉŔů

3ÁZĚáşŒŝţÌ�Ã

ĉ�Ų�ŗŔ

æaţ)ÄţŗũŢ3ÁZĚáţ

E�ūÒIŲ)»Œšň

3ÁZĚáţâ�ōŲ)»Œŝ�Çqš)ÄŲnšňƥï

ê�Ìŋŭţ²=��ÔƦ

įĭİİĸ

Ĭįĭİİĸ

Ĭįĭįĸı

įĭİİį

įĭįİı

ĬįĭįĴı

įĭĶĴĵ

įĭİĴĵ

ııĵ



�Ãĉ�Ų!ŉŔů

3ÁZĚáşŒŝţÌ�Ã

ĉ�Ų�ŗŔ

tßŋŭ�išHĔūăËŲŪŭű

šň

tßŋŭăËƣĘ=Ų¬őŰŝŪCďŞōů

Ĭįĭįĵĸ

įĭįİĴ

įĭİİĲ

įĭİıĵ

Ĭįĭįıĵ

įĭİįĵ

įĭĵĲĸ

ĬįĭįĲĲ

ııĳ



�Ãĉ�Ų!ŉŔů

� uHţē'š)»ş�

Ć

tßţuHĪƓƝŶƍƀƤŢĝűů

uHŲ;ŨīŲQÏŔů

TÝÔŞÉŮnŗtßţuHŲŅ6 ūU�šŠŢúőš

ňĬįĭİįĲ

įĭıİį

įĭįĳĴ

Ĭįĭİĸķ

Ĭįĭįİĳ

įĭİıĳ

įĭĴĲĸ

įĭįİĸ

İĸ


,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


%ÈƣÈXÃTČ

æ&ţÉĄūå,ƣk+ţĞ½ƣ�

ċŲ£ŒŎûĄŒŝňů

æčţ¸Dţå,ūŖţĞ½Ų£ÊŢñÑŪůŐşŌŞō

ůįĭįĳĶ

ĬįĭİĲı

Ĭįĭįĵĸ

ĬįĭįĶį

įĭİįĵ

įĭįĲĸ

ĬįĭįĶİ

įĭķįĳ

İķ


,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


%ÈƣÈXÃTČ

æčţô0ūì°ŢśňŝţƑŴ

ƠƐƛƤūƒŵƤƊƍƇŻŲ¦ũů� ŋŭţ��ūø�Ų8ŏVŰůŐşŌŞōů

Ĭįĭįĵı

įĭįĲĳ

įĭįĴĲ

ĬįĭįĲİ

Ĭįĭİİĵ

ĬįĭİıĲ

įĭİĶĵ

įĭĵĳİ

ıįķ


��»


tß�o�Ü

ýŮŌŇŚŗşōŢŤüTŢăÛŔ

ů

æ&ţM�ūƗƂŤŅ�\ßŢ1ŧġőŕŢH<Œŝňů

ƥH<ŔůŐşŌŞōůƦ

Ĭįĭįĵĳ

įĭĲĳį

įĭįĵİ

Ĭįĭįıķ

ĬįĭİĴı

ĬįĭİıĴ

įĭıĵİ

įĭĳĴİ

ıį


,

3ÁZĚáţGÅşšů


%ÈƣÈXÃTČ

æ&ţÉĄūå,ƣk+ţĞ½ƣ�

ċŲ£ŒŎûĄŒŝňů

M�ţ5@Ų�ŮĐŮŅŖţmŢªŋŔŐşŌŞōů

įĭįĴĶ

įĭįĶĲ

įĭİĲĸ

įĭİįĳ

įĭıįı

įĭįįį

Ĭįĭįıĳ

įĭĳıĸ

@Oćéė

îıİƧ3ÁƓơƒŷƇƀƜƋƞƃƘø�ĤÆţ@O&�ţ×�Ī�ÿ�ƣƠƕƟıƦ

ĤÆĺĹ

&Ė

ĥF

Źƈžƞ

ŽƤƊ

ĤÆ

��5@

ßB�ĉÈĎÞ

óĤĞc�ł

�5@

ßV§�QĎĤ

Ğc�à

��5@

ß¸��A¥à

�45@

ßÎeń+�à

��5@

ß�ÔÕ�Ď

x¡à

��5@

ßĥĶĸİĬğĴ

ĻĨđĎÕQà

��5@

ß��ð��

Ç�à

��5@

ß�G�DÉà

V§ĎïîíĜ¦[ýĂ��ĿĤĞĎiÑĜv¹ÿęûĊ÷

ĉøęãâìéè ãâãëã ãâãåë áãâããç áãâãæä áãâããë áãâãäå áãâåãè

��ĿĤĞĜ±ôØĎB��Ď;r�Č¦õiĜ�·ý

Ĉóęãâëçé áãâåæê áãâãìã ãâãçè ãâäèë ãâãêæ ãâäæì ãâãäê

�®�Č�VčĆóĈðy��Č��ĿĤĞĎi�Ĝ

�ąĈóęãâêéã áãâåèé ãâäåå ãâããã ãâãæä áãâãéë áãâãéé ãâäéê

V§čĊąĈěöĘĕÿùðöĆ{ýó¾nĜÿęûĊ÷ĉ

øęãâèêæ ãâåëæ áãâãçê áãâäéè áãâããë ãâãåä áãâäåè ãâåãì

V§÷YT~CÿęĎčR´ČW<Ĝc�ÿęûĊ÷ĉø

ęãâèæè ãâæäë ãâããé ãâãåì áãâääì ãâãéå áãâäçé ãâãéç

ĪĢľĮġıİġľĎY6ĕ�mĜ�·ýĈóę ãâçæç ãâåìå ãâãèè áãâãäê áãâãçê ãâãéæ ãâãìì áãâäêã

V§Ď��¶ĕ��«pĜ�ù�ęĖôč'ēĈóę áãâäçì ãâëéë ãâãèã áãâãæé ãâãéì ãâãæè áãâãæå áãâãéå

V§Ď}`Ąĕ¦õČċĜ�XýČ÷ėV§ĊÕěąĈó

ęáãâäåè ãâêææ áãâäéè ãâãêå ãâåãë ãâãåì ãâãêã ãâãæä

V§Ċ�ÜÕ�Ĝ¡ùĂēĎ'%ĜýĈóę ãâåèæ ãâéêë áãâääè áãâäåì ãâäåç áãâääè ãâäêä áãâãèé

V§÷ėAĝăĘð�ÄĜPĂĘĉøęĖôčÕěęûĊ

÷ĉøęãâãêæ ãâèæã ãâäæé ãâäèé áãâäèì ãâãìé áãâäãé ãâãéæ

¼ÝĕKĬĨĭ÷ČùĈĔlñA¥ÿę¥Z÷òąĂ áãâãåé áãâãæç ãâëæå áãâãäæ ãâãæê ãâãåé áãâãææ áãâãæç

A¥¸�Ĝ�ĈĈāĚĜD±ÿęûĊ÷ĉøę áãâãèé áãâäêæ ãâêãæ áãâäåä ãâäåè ãâäêä ãâãäé ãâåãç

Â¤Ŀ�¥ĿD¥ĎÓ?o#čďAĐĂēĎ��÷óĆĔ

ĉøĈóĂãâåäë ãâãçå ãâèçç ãâãêç áãâãäê áãâãéë ãâäãä áãâãìå

ĎlñĎĨĤħĸŀĻĜ�Dč^dýĈóę ãâäãä ãâäêå ãâçåæ ãâäæã áãâããè áãâãçæ ãâãêè áãâãëæ

Ł1ł¨�Ď1�Ċðóč&ú0õęÕ�Ĝx¡ýĈó

ęáãâãåæ áãâãêë áãâääã ãâëêã ãâäæì áãâãæé ãâääé áãâäãì

1þ¨�Ď�ËĿ1�Ċð��ĿĤĞĎòĘičĆóĈÅÁ

ÿęûĊ÷ĉøęãâãèè áãâãçë ãâããè ãâëææ áãâäåê ãâãçê áãâãçè ãâãéå

OËđĎaJĿhªč�w�čÕěĘĂóĊTô áãâãëä ãâãëä ãâäêê ãâèåé ãâäæé áãâäçé áãâãéê áãâääê

¨�Ď�ÄĕĨģĻðIÒUĜ�·ýð�ÀÿęûĊ÷

ĉøęãâäãå ãâãèå áãâãèå ãâèãì áãâãìè ãâäëæ áãâãäé ãâäæì

!HÚĎ�Ċ]Ą·úĈ½ĜÿęûĊ÷ĉøę ãâãæç ãâããê ãâäãë áãâãæì ãâêçã ãâãèë ãâãåç áãâãéê

�\Ď.SĜµČ÷ė�½ÿęûĊ÷ĉøę áãâããé ãâåìæ áãâäæé ãâãèë ãâèêç ãâãêç áãâãèé ãâãêé

-�öė�ÜüĚðÜĘčüĚĈóę ãâãåì ãâäêì ãâäìæ ãâäìç ãâèãç áãâäéë áãâãèê ãâãåä

9:Ď�Uč;ćóĈLÓüĚĈóę*�ĕ��(ð�

�čĆóĈ�ąĈóęãâãæã áãâãåê ãâãçæ áãâãäã áãâãää ãâëëé ãâããë áãâãéì

�×�=Ď��Ŀ*�Ŀ��jºĉ�ùIÒ¨Ďz¬ĿN$

čĆóĈ�ąĈóęãâãçå ãâãæì ãâãéì áãâãìê ãâãæê ãâëäã ãâäçæ áãâãéé

�®M|čHýĈÊĎIÒUĕ�(Ĝ¾nĉøę ãâãåã ãâääç áãâãèé ãâåëç ãâãèé ãâçãå áãâãæì ãâãêê

*�IÒ¨Ď©qøĜ"�ýĈ��SČ"�ĜPČóŁ³

°��öėĎ�3�� łãâääì áãâääì áãâãìå ãâääã ãâãäå áãâãèå ãâêèé ãâäèé

V§öėÃ�ĿÐ3Ĝ�üĚĈĔ7Ìĉøę áãâãéì ãâãäè ãâääæ ãâäåé áãâãåé ãâäãé ãâéæì áãâãææ

D¥ ĉ�ĘPĂV§ĎW<Ĝð-�ĕEkČċč½üČ

óáãâäãæ ãâåäã ãâãçè áãâäìë áãâãäç ãâäåç ãâèæì ãâãäì

ÊĎ�8Ď¬%ĕāĎÖ�Ĝ{�čµ�ĔęûĊ÷ĉø

ęãâãçê áãâäæå áãâãéì áãâãêã ãâäãé ãâãæì áãâãêä ãâëãç

�öėĎafĕ»�Ĝ/úFĚęûĊ÷ĉøę áãâãéå ãâãæç ãâãèæ áãâãæä áãâääé áãâäåæ ãâäêé ãâéçä

Ď>gĕĶĨďðaJ§č)ĒÙüĀč<2ýĈóę

Ł<2ÿęûĊ÷ĉøęłáãâãéç ãâæçã ãâãéä áãâãåë áãâäèå áãâäåè ãâåéä ãâçèä

>gĎ,5ĜbĘÍĘðāĎOč�öÿûĊ÷ĉøę ãâãèê ãâãêæ ãâäæì ãâäãç ãâåãå ãâããã áãâãåç ãâçåì

²åäŃ*�ĳĽĲĠīĦĹįĺĩķ»�Û�Ď5@ sĎ£tßr¿uĿļĵĻåłŁ_¢ł

Û�

5@Æ¯Ï

â)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

.YŅºBùŅXïđĔ Ì!ćdÉđ´¬Ëï ��đ�8ĈVûÿ´¬Ëïđ^MĘ,ĕøĆôąõĕ

ã)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

.YŅºBùŅXïđĔ.Yĉîĕ®%í¹¾Ę�

ĂKLïlÜĘÅĈĂ÷Ąïĕ

ä)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

.YŅºBùŅXïđĔ.Yĉîĕ®%í¹¾Ę�

ĂĨņĤĻŀĺĭĚęĈ.YĈ{÷ĕb�Ęúćï

æ)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

.YŅºBùŅXïđĔ ��½ùĘ�Ă ėóēćïøĆĊėóēćïĆ½Ĉ´ñĕ

ç)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

«H��«Åĉ�N�^Ĉ�\úí

¡cŅ-�Ę4ĕ« ĉ�N�^ĈïĂĐ~ĘÎāĄïĕ

ââ)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

ĢĸļıġņĤĽńa¯ �¨ĉ=' �`ĉ¸ĘÍēýĈw~Oö§öøĆôąõĕ

âã)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

ĢĸļıġņĤĽńa¯ �¨ĉ=' �¸ĉ�`Ĉ�]Ę�úćôē§öøĆôąõĕ

âæ)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

� @¥ŅğĻĿęÔ

�

ğĻĿęĴľńĘ�_úB®

üĕ«ÅĉFs�ĈĎ÷Ąí�ćĈĘüČõóôėóĕ

âç)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

� @¥ŅğĻĿęÔ

�

EÓ©ĆúĄ_ÒĘ ÷ĕø

ĆĘÆï�ďĕ«Åĉ_ÒĘ�ü@�:ĉ�%Ĉ+$úĄïĕ

âè)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

)�EÓ©ĉ6�Ć

ćĕ�xP_Ć��

ĥğŀ

� @¥ŅğĻĿęÔ

�

EÓ©ĆúĄ_ÒĘ ÷ĕø

ĆĘÆï�ďĕJĈ��Ĉ�Ãúćï-�UĘĐāĄïĕ

ãáâ)�EÓ©¦ĉ6�Ć

ćĕª#

ÝïĥğŀĆ�¾Ĉ6

ăöBÄ

ÝïĥğŀĆ�¾Ĉ6

ăöEÓ©�BÄ

ÝïŁĵŀĉĥğŀĆ)@

�¾Ę�cúíþĖĘ�g

üĕ

l�qĉ�3ĘÂñÿ)@Ņ)��¾Ę¥TúĄïĕ

ãäZ¦Ņ«©�Ņ;©�Ć

ĉ��

ÞZ¦�Uĉġęĉf

Z¦ĉ«RYĘÝď

ĕíjhüĕ�õó÷

ħŀĳġęĘjhŅĝńĲ

ŃņüĕħŀĳġęđĝńĲŃĺńĮĉyWĈĂïĄ»oąõĕ

ãâäZ¦Ņ«©�Ņ;©�Ć

ĉ��EÓ©ĆĉÇiŅ*� ;©�*� ©�Ćĉ*�Ĉ+$üĕ ©�Ćĉ�ÕÖ�Ęðčöz�üĕøĆôąõĕ

ãâåZ¦Ņ«©�Ņ;©�Ć

ĉ��EÓ©ĆĉÇiŅ*� ;©�*�

�ćĕ��²đ�WĘcā

ÿ�Ć*�üĕ©�ĉ��²đ�WĉÊïĘGÏüĕøĆôąõĕ

ãâæZ¦Ņ«©�Ņ;©�Ć

ĉ��EÓ©ĆĉÇiŅ*� ;©�*�

ĪņĹĉ�/ĆúĄĿņĩņ

ĤīĴàÀĘĆĕ

ĪņĹĈò÷ĕĿņĩņĤīĴĘ�güĕČõ��đíþĉ

ĆĔóÿô óĕ

ãâêZ¦Ņ«©�Ņ;©�Ć

ĉ��£�9ĉm�

A�ć)�ĉf Ćþ

ĉeÈ

�£ĉÁk0íA��%Ĉ

S�üĕ

ěńĤĭńĮŅęĠĤĭńĮŁĶņĮĘf�üĕøĆĉ\¤Ę

�³úĄïĕ

ããä ��ÀĘuÿüĢĸļıĬĚíEÓ©Ø

2í��ċĉ¿�

ķĥŅĺĭĚęĉ"�Ć

[7f ĉîĔn

ķĥĺĭĚęċĉºBŅ�|

ćDV

«ÅĉEÓ©ĆúĄĉ�´ôíI}đ��Ĉ�ñĕQÙĉ

<õùĘ�³úĄïĕ

ããè ��ÀĘuÿü

�đ��¢ÛĘ�³

úí��ÀĘ�ð

üĕ

)�EÓ©ĆúĄĉ�

��ÀĘuÿü

¶�µÑĈ��ć�CĘµ

úí�BĈ�?Ę®ð¶�µÑĈµ�üČõ�CĘ�³úí��Ĉµ�úĄïĕ

ããé ��ÀĘuÿü

�đ��¢ÛĘ�³

úí��ÀĘ�ð

üĕ

)�EÓ©ĆúĄĉ�

��ÀĘuÿü

(&pÕ:Ĉò÷ĕEÓ©

ĆúĄĉÀ&

©8ĉ:ĈòïĄĐ)�EÓ©ĆúĄĉ«±ĘcĀ ÷ĕ

øĆôąõĕ

°ããň)�ĴłĳĜīĤĽİĿĦĹ·�Ú�ĉ1> tĉ�uĈĒĔ×:ùĖÿâêÚ�ßr¼vŅŁĵŀãŇ

Ú�ìë Ð Û5 ĞĬģĿ Ģņį Ú�

68

��

1 2 2

1

2 2

(1) ��

1

7

8 4. ) t9X <

pn

4. ) 4. ( 4. 4.: E

( <=

: E) ) = ( ( =

:) =

: 7( ( = ) (

:( = =

: M CP= )

: 9= ) ) =

:)

2 103 < )

2 103 < -

9 56<

56<

69

3 2 3 28 p

)- ) -

8

- ( -

8

- ( -

8 4

- (( -

8 - -

8X

) - ( -

8 7 - -

8

( - ( -

9 ( - -

6 P E M r7 X 555< 0 .1

0 .1

(

2

8 1

2

1 1 2

25

3

1 14 1 18

2 9 1

1

1 2

Ƅ��ƮkyjL^WtcvYpƅ�ĐŮ9ëƗ5�ƮkyjL^WtcvYp�T�b�9Ŗ�ªÆ�

Ɗƚ ư� P_Uv T�b xlw�ĐŮ�ƔŤò�

xlw�ĐŮxlw�ĐŮ�kx_Xa�

�Ʈńƙĩ9¬ƀ57DĲ�Èĸ5şĊ�XQw

�Ʈńƙĩ9¬ƀ57DĲ�Èĸ5č�

ŪXQw

Ɔķ�ĽČ'�þ�@C

ūŀ7ŁÅ@ØơÕ� � �Ɔķ9�Déű�şĊGƐ1 ��G1�7��Īƣ4!DĲ4�D&5 � �şŪÔ¹'GƐ1 � ��

ĉÛ¦Ʀ ĉİ9ÏæĦŘ8ƫ�)��Ć�ãģGĳD �� ć©8Ļ�4�D � �

TosdS�Wt{´ĝ

â�Ū7TosdS�Wt{Gé� �� Çţ9üĶ ��

�

Ìő�Ė�QrvI�Ž

ńƙĩ5)3ÌőŪ8�Ė+D&59ƃƢķGŹĊ)3�D � �ńƙĩ5)3ĸŦGő%D&5Gŧ�¶>D � ��QrvIku{Gøĸ)Čé+D � ��

ŶĢ�ĢúŪČŅĉİ9Øű@é�81�39iIxhs�@jJ�be^RG¶>D � �fjN�n{XGĬCƏDĉƊ9şĊ@ŻƱ�ƛ 9Ù��ƇŏGĻ)#ŹĊ)3�D ��

ì�XQw5şĊ8¬2#ńƙĩŪČŅ

ì�XQw5şĊ8¬2#ČŅ

ì�xlw9XQw5��şĊGƐĆ)�-EGŽ®+D � ��Ūð¸8¬2�/�þÍŨ�ČŅGé� �âƩ9Ư��â�Ū7SIGũ»+D

|Ň7�ƮGũ»+D �ĈƮ�SI9Î�9Ƈ�ČķGƦ�)3�D

��9ŽŬ�ĭ)�şĊ9ŉŌ9/>8Ò·¡űGé�ĈƮ�SI8ª+Dóĭ9ĥƑGĕę)�ƳĠ8ūƠ+D �

ĉƨķ9Ž® ńƙĩ5)3ĉƨ)/�Ė�¡űGé�ĉƨ ?/B+ĿŸG�!Ĕ%D

¢Ď�ĉĩē�ŕĩē59ŊÜøƠ

¢Ďšī9SI9ũ»

¢Ďšīđµ

¢Ď9� ��äƈ�Ïæ7ĦŘ�Góř8ì>D&58ĈƮ�SI9ġŭGů3D �¢Ď9ƥ��¢Ď9�ãGœĜ)/ĈƮ�SIGũ»+D¢Ď59ĪƣªÆ@f�ac�W^kG�ƪ)/ģ4ĈƮ�SIGũ»+D

¢Ď9¯ŗGť�DV�hXGũ»+D¢Ď Ŕ9�ý@�Ʈńƙĩ9�ÓGƌ#&5GœĜ+D ��

�¢Ď8F�C@+��Ļ�7ĥƑũ»@ŃƖGé� �¢Ď8503ƃƢ75!8ƷƤ 1#ĦÁG�Ć+D

¢Ď9ĉƨķGœĜ+DşĊ9�Ŵ�IbgIu{X�T{T�\{X�GĀ�+D �

ßC �0/5!8:ĽČ8ď÷+D �ZwjSIGĀ��M{fz�+D �¢Ď ĉÛÍŨ4!DA�8Ā�+D �

¢Ď59ūŀ7ºƧ�ªÆGƐ1

�Ĳ©5)39¢ĎGƦ�)�ªFD

¢Ď©9ÚĲŪƋ�Ūñ��Ş¨GœĜ+D �¢Ď9Ðƥ�Ĳ©9ÐƥGœĜ+D

¢Ď9ĉƨķGì>D�Ā�+DŰ!�

%

¢Ď9£ĥGƦ�)3�þ�@C9�DéűG5D �¢Ď9ÚĲŵķ�ķƎ�č�ËõŪĦŘ76�85BFE,8¢Ď5ªFCGĆ1

¢Ď9Ɔ}�œÖGĒD�ĖX[Kw�ØÞ�ŹşŻƱ769ÚĲñGèƬ)/Ŗ� 4!D

�

�ŕĩē4¼Ɯ+<!¢ĎĥƑ9ŶƟ5ſ~9žŜ 4!DŔ9�ƮĎ ƃƢ75!8ƷƤ 1#ĦÁG�Ć+D

ńƙĩ59ƷÉ�½Ű

ŕĩē½Ű

Ŕĩē59½Ű8û�+D � ��7D�Ş¨@ĪźGĆ0/Ĳ5½Ű+D �]�p9��5)3v�\�W^k�ĿŸG5D �

Ŕĩē8ÂƕG�!Ì$��ħ+DžŜGé��Č8Čā+Dāł©9¢Ď9�!Ì"@�ŋG�Č8�|Ň8Čā+D

ĩē©9ŤĺGé��ÄŢĦŘG§ƹ+DŔĩē9ńƙķ@ŻƱGÓľ?D&5 4!D �

Ŕĩē8ADSI�ĈƮ9ĸ�GŪ�8ƅ�)�ƃƢ8�*3ÿų+D �

ĉĩē½Ű

Ųĩē9XQw��Ş¨�ŻƱ8Ê�GƉ� � �ƃƢ8�*3Ŕ9Ųĩē8ƷƤ�Ƒî�ŊŝGé�

Ųĩē©9ŤĺGé��ÄŢĦŘG§ƹ+DŔ9ĉ�Ų�ĩē9ĈƮ�SIG�Ź)�ƃƢ8�*3ÿų+D

Ųƭ8Vm�a�IbeKXG+D � �Ýı9À�@q{[�G�!Ĕ%D �

�

��

|Ň¤¾GĺƂ)¥ă+DňĨ9ċ�ņ�|Ň¡ű8ěą+D �

ňĨ¤¾9ĺƂ

SI9/>9ňĨ¤¾9ĺƂ

ċ9ì�ĈƮ�SI9/>9ĩĤ¤¾9ĺƂƋ�9¼Ɯ9Ĵı

|Ň7�Ʈ9ũ»5-9Ĵı

O�k{4|Ň7Ƌ�GĴı)ğƵ+D�ňĨƋ��

�ńƙĩňĨ;9q{e�W^kG�Ć+D

Š�9ƐÏ�ƮƈĂ¡ű8Ŗ+DƦ�5

êÑ

Š��Ʈ�ƐÏ�ƈĂ9¡ű8ƞ+D � �Š��Ʈ�ƐÏ�ƈĂ9ńƙĩ�āł59ƷÉGĮ>D

ĉĩē9ńƙĩęś;9±Ő�êÑ

ńƙĩęś9ĈƮ�SI9ċãģ��ņ8ƞ+Dńƙĩęś5)39ŽŬ8ƞ+Dáė5ĉĩē9ĪƣªÆG¿>D¡űGé�

nX�q`JI9ƥƠ5ĥƑũ»9�C

nX�q`JI;9ĽČ�áĻ7Ŗ� �nX�q`JI@åî;9Ļ�7ĥƑũ»

ïöŪ7ÏæƘŚ;9ƞáŪ°ª;9½Ʊ

ÏæĹù;9ƞ

ƐÏ��Ʈ�ƈĂ9č�Ĺù9Èĸ8ƞ+DĹĈŪ¡ű8ƞ+D

ÚĲĥƑ9ūŀ7ƥƠ5Ɛà

¢Ď9ĥƑ�kuKeW�8ªFDĥƑG«=�GĒƁ+D � �ŕĩē4¼Ɯ+<!¢ĎĥƑ9ŶƟ5ſ~9žŜ 4!D

ƒ@ƲƦçưGƦ�)�č�ŪĿŸGŇ

�+D

ƒ@ƲƦçưGĒD

-E.E9ńƙĩ8ūƠ'EDƒ�²ŎGĒDƲƦŪ8ūŀ5Ø�D�þÍŨGé�įƮ³Ƹ@Ò·`�[9�(H�-9ŔƇĻ7Ğƴ9øĸGéF7� �

�

�

��ĐŮëƗ8��3�ëƗ Ŗ�+DT�b8�ů+D��ĐŮëƗ8��3�ëƗ Ŗ�+DT�b8�ů+D��ĐŮëƗ8��3ôƠ'E7�0/�ëƗ Ŗ�+DT�b8�ů+D

�įƮ³Ƹ8Ū�7ŶƟG³)��Č8ƐŒGé�âƩŪ7�ƮĄ×9ƥƠ�áƍ7żƊG�Ċ)/ČŅGé�

�Ʈńƙĩ5)39č�ŪĿŸG�/+

ĉÛ9ƥ�9/>8�Ʈńƙĩ9Š}@ƪĤGƥƠ)7� � �¢Ď@č�59Īƣ9ģ8ĩÂ ĸCƪ03�D&5GĔ%ŷED¢Ď�BƇů7ƑĘ@ďƶG?BF7�

č�ŪĿŸG�/+

Tosd_J�ńƙĩęś�č�;9ê

Ñ

��

Ãƕć©�8�%Dńƙĩ5)39Ŀƕ �

ƳĠÒ·Gé�Ĥí�¢Ď;9ŃƖ@Ų�76�ĚƊ7ƲƦŪ7żƬGé�

ƐÏ��Ʈ�ƈĂĵŮ81�3Ʀ�)3�D

� �áė�ļ�ƝƓ��9ōı �č�9d�YGŹĊ)-E8��DĿŸGĆ1

�

��

�

�

�

�

��

71

1 2

9 2 1

1 4 1

3 2 4

1

2

1

2

1

1

1 2 2

ABIM 38

P-MEX 37 26 ABIM 38 Altruism

Respect for others Excellence Honor and

integrity 3 Altruism Respect for others

2

Excellence

Honor

and integrity

P-MEX3 7 Doctor-patient relationship skil ls

R e f l e c t i v e s k i l l s T i m e m a n a g e m e n t

©��H

³9E8+2/A5B1>��

��

��#S¤k�#¨V

H³9E8+2/A5B1>��D;C��

��

��

�

Lt

��'¡¯�ÍD;C�

Lt

��'¡¯�ÍD;C�

H³9E8+2/A

5B1>��D;

C��"��T�

�'Lt

Lt

��'¡¯�ÍD;C�

H³9E8+2/A

5B1>��D;

C��"��T�

�'Lt

Y~��#-)#�_

E�C?4C#�o��r"

&'aJ�vN

�sLt

Y~$#c��fG

�¢Lt

n�0,C �y"]��

|�

Y~��^

�¢Lt

Y~6�1$#�O

�¢Lt

�¢Lt

�Y~��#-)�_�

Y~��#-)#�_

�|�

�¢Lt��¦Lt

�p¥µ

�p¥µ

�¦Lt

�qLt

�gP�W��

H³�®�#]§ !'�

Ud� }Q�0,C

¬#��

�zLt

x[Z±¥µ

x[Z±¥µ

�qLt

�sLt

�·e�`��

�®� #·e`�

�[\b#k�

�sLt

H³~[\b¥µ

²$#fG

�sLt��jLt

�jLt

��[\b#k��

H³�®�#]§ !'�

Ud� }Q�0,C

Y~��#-)�_

�¢Lt

�¸Lt

�.=@63*:C0$#\

��

�I#«hH³ªwX�"

��'±R mi

�zLt

�¶±�}Q��£�

¬%¶±l´(±R��}

Q��£(��'

�¦Lt

��p�|��

H³�®�#]§ !'�

Ud� }Q�0,C

�KLt

�F��{#n�-)�_�

�M�

�|�

°��^�7@�<61

>

Hu�Y~\bk�¥

µ

73

Interprofessional relationship skills 4 24

2 Doctor-patient relationship

skills Reflective skills

Time management

Interprofessional relationship skills

2 2

2

2

60

”ANA code 2015”

65 8

/ / /

/

1 2

105

57

2

74

(2) �� "�

1

KiSS-18102 KiSS-18

0.23 0.76 KiSS-18

r=0.76

0.7 106 1

0.7

2 P-MEX107

P-MEX 0.31 0.70

0.59

2

0.71 0.93 2

(3) �� !��#

2

1

1 2

75

×

N

76

i X

IPE

IPE N

× N

×

IPE

2 4

2004

o × GP 4

IPE 108,109

2008 N ―

2012 3 N

× 2011 4 ×

3-5 1 30

× 2014

2 60 2016 110

21 17 2

2 131 N 27

× A-3-(1) A-3-

(2) × A-3-(2) A-4-(1) A-

4-(2) B-(2)

N 2014

o × early exposure

77

97,110,111

0.5 24

1 30

/

27. 2013 2016 ( / )

1

2013 10/18 9/9 2/3 3/3 7/- 31/33

20142 36/110 7/8 0/5 5/5 9/- 57/128

2015 30/110 13/28 7/8 6/7 4/- 60/153

2016 51/110 15/17 2/2 2/2 2/- 72/121 1 2 2013 2 2014

/�0 �+�� (%� -��$* IPE ��

��1,

(1) '#�.!"�$* IPE��+��2��)&

IPE

2014 2 60

2014

2013 1.

2.

78

3.

8

2013 :

2016 2

7

39

28 2016 2014

2017

(2) �� IPE��

2014

Team-Based Learning112

120-150 2

113

28 5 7

ceěņĜ ģġĢĦceƻņĭĢĤĦĜ ģġĢħceěņĭĢĢĪĜ ģġĢĦceěņĭĢĤĤĜ ģġĢħceěņĭĢģĤĜ ģġĢĦceěņĭĢĤġĜ ģġĢħceěņĭĢģģĜ ģġĢĦce ģġĢħceěņĭĢģġĜ

ð�® Ĥğģħ ĤğĤĤ ĤğĤġ Ĥğħġ Ĥğģħ Ĥğģĥ Y�Ūũ ĤğĤĨ

Ĳƻß¹eƼ

ŇĝĚ1�ĉ

ceěņĜ ģġĢĦceěņĭĢġĢĜ ģġĢħceěņĭĪĨĜ ģġĢĦceěņĭĢġģĜ ģġĢħceěņĭĢģġĜ ģġĢĦce ģġĢħceěņĭĢĢĩĜ ģġĢĦceěņĭĢĤġĜ ģġĢħceěņĭħĩĜ

ð�® ĤğģĨ ĤğĦģ ĤğĤġ ĤğĤĢ Y�Ūũ ĤğĥĪ ĤğĢĪ ĤğħĤ

ĿŁĝĚň

ŇĝĚ1�ĉ

ƻŮůšƼ

ŇĬġğġġĢĝĚŉģĭġğĢġ ŇĭġğĩġĝĚŉ

ģĬġğġġĢ Ğ ŇĬġğġġĢĝĚŉ

ģĭġğģġ

ŃĚôÖƸ×ŵ(ZŶģġĢħceŵ(Z

�ĚûEē½ŶŗôÖĠ×ŴđŦŰŲƁÐżŤŲşűŠŬŘŕŗôÖĠ×ŴàCž�ŦťƅvŧŬŘŕŗôÖĠ×űWŷşřŭŬŘŵĤē½űŕFÌĆ}ÜŶŗĢğĚ&šūśoƄųŚŘŕŗģğĚřźƁūśoƄųŚŘŕŗĤğĚźř

ūśośŘŕŗĥğĚŞųƁūśośŘŵĥ¢ĐŖĤē½ŵFÌŵbK�ƅð�®ŲŦŬŖģġĢceŲģġĢħceŵð�®ŵ£þŴŶ� �ň�Xěļŀńľł§Ĝƅ¸ŚŬ

�ĚģġĢĦceŲģġĢħckŵð�®ŵ£þŶ�áÓLƭƞƳŴſŭŰäŚŕp,ŕY×ŵ90Ġ�90ŵ,ŕWćŵæGƻ1�ŵŻƼƅA�Ŵ|%ŦŰ)�ŦŬ

�ĚģġĢĦceŲģġĢħckŵð�®ŵ£þŶ�áÓLƭƞƳŴſŭŰäŚŕp,ŕY×ŵ90Ġ�90ŵ,ŵæGƻ1�ŵŻƼƅA�Ŵ|%ŦŰ)�ŦŬ

�ĚģġĢĦceŲģġĢħckŵð�®ŵ£þŶ�áÓLƭƞƳŴſŭŰäŚŕp,ŕWćŵæGƻ1�ŵŻƼƅA�Ŵ|%ŦŰ)�ŦŬ

�ĚģġĢĦceŲģġĢħckŵð�®ŵ£þŶ�áÓLƭƞƳŴſŭŰäŚŕp,ŵæGƻ1�ŵŻƼƅA�Ŵ|%ŦŰ)�ŦŬ

ģġĢħceŵR�®

ƸĥƒƩŞƀĤƒƩŴ.«

ƸY��ƅđťŪũŴ)�

ƸŲšŴųŦ

Ğ

ƸSV��ŵY×Ŵ90ŨƂW·ŴĎ

XŦŰôÖƸ×ƅY�

W·ð��

ĲěĢĝĚĢĪĥƼĭģġğĥ�

ĲěĢĝĚģĢĨƼĭġğġħ� Ğ ĲěĢĝĚĢĪĥƼĭĥĩğĥ

�

[÷Ù 6WÈŵŻ &=ô· &=ôÙ JM6ºNÂY×Ŵ90ŨƂW·

(ZƸzĔ�

ǀôÖǁ

ƸĚ5©ăŵ?JMŵJM6ºƅ~ŭŰŚ

Ƃ6`ŴſƂôÖ

ƸJM6ºŵYw

ƸƵƹƳƭƞƳŵ�Ãŕ6`ŲŦŰŵƎƮƲ

Ƈ�Ý

ǀôÖǁ

ƸƩƉƏƵƍƊƷƗƲƷƐŕ¯ÀŵƇƨƵƹ

ƛŕơƱƝƈƧƸƗƱƥƹŴŮŚŰ

ǀ×ƿƒƪƯƢƑƹƓưƷŵYüǁ

ƸŞŞƄƁä2ŵ×ƻfƂ�ÕŕU3ŕ

èÓŕƌƊƫÿŦŕêŚ�ŜŕU3<ĒƼ

Ƹß)>ƅ�ŠŕƐƳƹƨŵƬƷƣƹŲ'

�ŨƂ

ǀôÖǁ

ƸĚƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫ�nŵ�yæÎ

ƸÞd µŕÅ�»ƔƴƷƩŴŮŚŰ

ǀ×ƿƓơƲƌƅ¸ŚŬuo¥Xǁ

ěĢĜâãş·ŧƂ±¦ƅìXŦŕßýşŲƂ

ä2Ƹ+�ŴŮŚŰØŜƂ

Ŕ��ƽƿ~hŦŰŚŬsÙťƆşŕď(

űŗŝÄŘƅ¬ūśŲŦŰŠŬ

Ŕ��ƾƿrÖŵřƂ¾zŴŕqŦţų!

gĘDŵùQƅz�śſśĖźƃŬ

ěģĜ��ĥźűŕßýŵ+�Ƹä2ƅ¥X

Ŧŕūŵµ¹ƅØŜŕƐƳƹƨű'�ŨƂ

ǀôÖǁ

Ƹ?JMŵY×�]Ùƻ¿ö`Ƹ�!`Ƽ

ŞƀŵôÖ

ǀ×ƿ5©ăŵ?JMŵ�!6ºÇÆ

ŵ´±žJM�¤ŵ·¨ƅµéŨƂǁ

ěĢĜ?Y×JŵJMŵ�¦ž�!6ºÇ

ÆŴŮŚŰ�/W×ŨƂŖ

ěģĜ�/W×ŦŬ(ZŴŮŚŰƨƴƘƷ

ƝƹƓưƷŨƂ

ěĤĜJMű·¨ŨƂsÙťƆŵ��ŴŮŚ

Ű�ëŦŕY×�]ÙŲŵ;�B»ųž

ƁŲƁƅĀŧŰW×ƅªŽƂ

ƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫ�

nŲŵ[m

ƸƒƪƯƢƝƈŕ\ċÛđHŕÅ�Źŵø²

Ƹ6º\ċÛŵN¼ŲųƂ��iyŲÅ

�»ƕƎƳ


�»ƕƎƳ

ƸƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫ&á

Ƹ§ž µÒĕƅµéŦŕÅ�»ú�ƅ

&śŨƂ

ƸƒƪƯƢƝƈŕ\ċÛđHŕÅ�Źŵø²

ƸsÙlŵƑƇ��

�§ ôÖ ôÖƸ× ôÖƸ× ôÖƸ×

ôÖƸ×F ŎĦ�ĚƸőħ�ƸƺĚĢĢ� ŏĚĦ� ŐĚħ� ŒĚħ�ĞœĚĨ�

ƝƹƩ 5©ăŵJM6ºƅWŸěĢĜĞěģĜĝěĨĜ �ÙŲčƄƂ{§ŴŮŚŰWŸ ƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫŕÛ� µ JMŵ6ºƸ_¤·¨ƅÀƂ

ģġĢħceŵR�®

ƸôÖŵ)ĉƅ«ƀŦŕƐƳƹƨƶƹƏŵ

�ČƅP0

ƸĮĳĹĸŵ��ƤƞƌŴ��òíƅ�0

ƸôÖ(Zƅ�µŕƕƲƫ4

ƸŲšŴųŦ

Ğ

W·ð��

ĲěĢĝĚģĥĪƼĭĞĢğĤĥ�

ĲěĢĝĚģĦĢƼĭĞĤĢğģĤ�

ĲěĢĝĚģĥĨƼĭĞġğġĨ� Ğ

ŇĭġğģĦĝĚŉģĭġğġġĦ ŇĬġğġġĢĝĚŉ

ģĭġğĢĢ ŇĭġğĨĪĝĚŉ

ģĬġğġġĢ Ğ

[÷Ù &=ôÙ &=ôÙ &=ôÙ &=ôÙ

(ZƸzĔ�

ǀôÖǁ

Ƹ-Ą½ ŕƓƱƣƕŵó�

ƸƐƳƹƨW×ŕƇƉƕƧƴƉƏŵuÖŴ

ŮŚŰ

ƸƐƳƹƨŲƛƹƫŵąŚŴŮŚŰ

ǀ×ƿiy�ŵƛƹƫƅ�ęŨƂǁ

ěĢĜƐƳƹƨƬƷƣƹŵ'Ā®Ų¾ą®ƅ

çŮŢƂ

ǀôÖǁ

ƸĚÍIǂǃǅǄŵĻŀĽŅĺĻıķķĺŵƒƇŲų

ƂĥŮŵƒƷƥƝƷƓƹƻƲƹƚƹƓƜƨŕ

±¦ƭƢƙƲƷƐŕ¾ ��ŕƒƪƯƢƑƹ

ƓưƷƼËƅÏ�

ǀ×ƿƛƹƫƶƹƏŵĈæpƅƐƳƹƨ

��ƅĀŧŰƅ�ęŨƂǁ

ƸĻŀĽŅĺĻıķķĺŵĥŮŵƒƇƸƒƷƥƝƷ

ƓƹËƅ¸ŚŰŕ1�»ǆ1³»»ų'

A��ŴŮŚŰ�ƁÿƂ

ǀôÖǁ

ƸĚƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫ�nƻ6`xÊž

įĽņĶıİĺŵƦƴƹƫƶƹƏËƼŵÏ�Ųŕ

ūŵĈæpŴŮŚŰ

ǀ×ƿĢckŵƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫŵ

-Ą½ ƅØŜŕß^ð�ŨƂǁ

ěĢĜ7��ŵ-Ą½ ģģē½ƅW·Ŵ�

ÃŨƂ

ěģĜĢckŵ-Ą½ ƅØŜƂ

ěĤĜƐƳƹƨű8õŦŕĢckŵ-Ą½

ģģē½ƅ�yŨƂ

ěĥĜƐƳƹƨŵuo¥XƨƵƗƕƅ�Ɓÿ

Ƃ

ěĦĜģģē½ŴFÌŦŕð�Ñ�ƅĢĂČk

ŴƦƈƹƠƣƜƏŨƂ

ǀôÖǁ

Ƹ6ºÙĞsÙč�ŵėL

Ƹ6ºƒƪƯƢƑĞƓưƷŴčŨƂYïÁÉ

ŵÏ�

ƸƒƪƯƢƑƹƓưƷƕƎƳŴŮŚŰ

ƸĺķĴĵıĺƻtŚÀƀŪƅ�ŜƂƼŕĺĳĮĹı

ƨƵƟƒƳƻşƆ6ºŴčŨƂƒƪƯƢƑƹ

ƓưƷƼŵÏ�

ǀ×ƿƓơƲƌƅ¸ŚŬƵƹƳƨƴƉǁ

ěĢĜƓơƲƌĢīîŵ°®şXźƀũñş

ĊŚsÙŲÚŠjŵ6`ƅŧƂ

ěģĜƓơƲƌģƿć¨2ŴŝŚŰŕƎƮƨƝƷ

şA$ŴtŚÀƀŪƅ�ŜƂ

ěĤĜƵƹƳƨƴƉŵ�ƁŞŜƁƅŨƂ

ƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫ�

nŲŵ[m

Ƹ\ċÛŲŵā�Ƹ8#


�»ƕƎƳ


ƸÐÔ¶Oŵ�"


�»ƕƎƳ

ƸƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫ&á



�»ƕƎƳ

ƸsÙlŵƑƇ��

�§ ôÖƸ× ôÖƸ×

åģĩğŔ�a6ÈTW*c¡ĴķıÈ½ŗJM6º@AƗƪơƹĢŘŵôÖƸ×ŵ(Z:ŷW·ŴſƂð�ƿģġĢĦce:ŷģġĢħceŵ£þ

ôÖƸ×F ŊĚĥ� ŋĚĥ� ŌĚĦ� ōĚĦ�

ƝƹƩ ƐƳƹƨW×ŵN� ƛƹƫƶƹƏƸƲƹƚƹƓƜƨ ƨƵƦƋƜƓươƲƖƫŕÛ� µ 6ºƒƪƯƢƑƹƓưƷŵNÂ

ôÖƸ× ôÖƸ×

TU×ðØ ßÝÞâTU×ðæÞßäØ ßÝÞãTU×ðæÞÞßØ ßÝÞâTU×ðæäàØ ßÝÞãTU×ðæâáØ ßÝÞâTU ßÝÞãTU×ðæÞÞáØ ßÝÞâTU×ðæÞàâØ ßÝÞãTU×ðæÞßÝØ

·�� àÛàÝ àÛáà àÛâà àÛâá MsĊĉ àÛáá àÛàá àÛáá

íîÙÖò

ñÙÖ.{Ç

ïÖ»©Ŏ�ªĖ$NėßÝÞãTUĖ$N

�Ö¿<Ñ�ė÷»©Ü�ªĕÍ�ĆđēĤ¤ğĄēÿĒĀČøõ÷»©Ü�ªĕ°:ġ�ĆąĨcćČøõ÷»©Ü�ªĒKĘÿùĎČøĖàÑ�Ēõ= Åg®ė÷ÞÛÖ"āċû]ħĔúøõ÷ßÛÖùĝĤċû]ħĔúøõ÷àÛÖĝù

ċû]ûøõ÷áÛÖþĔĤċû]ûøĖá�ËöàÑ�Ė= ĖSD�Ĩ·��ēĆČö

�ÖßÝÞâTUēßÝÞãTXĖ·��Ė�Áė�±§EņĺŊĕĢĎđ²úõ_(õMªĖ3-Ü3-Ė(Ė´>ř�.{ĖĞŚĨ8tĕf!Ćđ&zĆČ

�ÖßÝÞâTUēßÝÞãTXĖ·��Ė�Áė�±§EņĺŊĕĢĎđ²úõ_(õKÆĖ´>ř�.{ĖĞŚĨ8tĕf!Ćđ&zĆČ

K�·��

è×ÞÙÖßàáŚæßÛáÞ�

è×ÞÙÖÞßáŚæÝÛÞå� Ú è×ÞÙÖßâÝŚæÝÛââ

�

ñæÝÛÞßÙÖóßæÝÛÝÞ ñæÝÛãäÙÖó

ßæÝÛÝÝÞ Ú ñæÝÛáãÙÖó

ßæÝÛÝÝß

�ÖßÝÞâTUēßÝÞãTXĖ·��Ė�Áė�±§EņĺŊĕĢĎđ²úõ_(õMªĖ3-Ü3-Ė(õKÆĖ´>ř�.{ĖĞŚĨ8tĕf!Ćđ&zĆČ

�ÖßÝÞâTUēßÝÞãTXĖ·��Ė�Áė�±§EņĺŊĕĢĎđ²úõ_(Ė´>ř�.{ĖĞŚĨ8tĕf!Ćđ&zĆČ

$NŎeÒ�

Ş»©ş

Ŏ0�ÄĖo^1��)ÜĲĴĹŅĕďú

đ

Ş�ªŝ��1�AĖo^1��)ÜĲ

ĴĹŅĖMaē<ÓĨ�µĈĥş

×ÞØ6įŊŏŁĕ0�Ä$Ė��1�A

Ĩ,ĤVđĥ

×ßØ,ĤVđģĦČ��1�AĖ��o

^õ��o^õ��o^Ėo^1��)

ĨºĜđj%Ĉĥ

×àØ0�ÄĖo^1�ĕďúđÎ´ē�

¦Ė�Ïþģ<Óēµ�¡Ĩ~¶Ĉĥ

Ş�ªŝ0�ÄĖ1�<ÓĨµ�Ĉĥ�

bŁŌĳĬĮĻĨ�čăĥş

×ÞØĹŏŃĖiLŝÞØ0�ÄĖ1�PÈ

ĖCF�BĨµ�ĈĥŁŌĳĬĮĻõßØ0

�ÄĖo^1�Ė MŠ.�/Ĩ@ĥŁ

ŌĳĬĮĻõàØÖ1KÆãTÉĖKĘĨ M

ąĊĥJKnÐŁŌĳĬĮĻ

×ßØįŊŏŁĒĹŏŃĨÅgĆõŁŌĳĬĮ

Ļ¸}ĨĝēĠj%Ĉĥ

×àØp;ÿ�*ĆČ$NĕGĐĀõŁŌ

ĳĬĮĻ}Ĩ¨Ĥ�Ĉ

×áØ«}ĆČŁŌĳĬĮĻĕďúđŁŋķō

ĹŏĲňōĨ²û

×âØàãÝU·�Ĩ²û

Ş»©ş

ŎCFĒĖI�ÃlĖMÀĕďúđ¢

�

Ş�ªŝ��~¶ş

×ÞØCFĒI�ĒĖÊħĤÿZ´Ĕ��

Ĩj�

×ßØO½¬ĕOĈĥmkĨ6¯Ē~¶Ĉĥ

×àØëê�Ĩ�ĎđõZ´ĔmkĨįŊŏŁ

ĒĝēĠõ~¶Ĉĥ

Ş»©ş

ŎśTÉĖęĤÂĤ

ŎŉŀŋĮĲňōõ¥ÔKªõ��Kªĕď

úđ

Ş�ªŝKªr�Ė~¶ş

×śØ¯&ĖKªr�ĖłīōĻŎ<Ó�Ĩ

q�Ĉĥ

×ŜØQįŊŏŁĒ6¯ĖKªr�Ėłīō

ĻŎ<Ó�ĕďúđ¹Ćõ�úĕĩļĿīĴ

Ĉĥ

×àØQįŊŏŁĒ¹Ć7ĎČĄēĨįŊŏ

ŁĒ#wĈĥ

ßÝÞãTUĖHu�

Ŏ+x£ tĖ�ÉŋłŏĻř¯��Ė�

�ē1�j��)ĨºĜĥŚĕýúđõ,

ĤVđģĦČ¯��Ĩ9ğ��1�AĨ

�ªĒhVĈĥ

ŎēāĕĔĆ

Ú

ŎēāĕĔĆ

r� »©Ŏ�ª �ª »©Ŏ�ª »©Ŏ�ª

O½¬ "5»� Mª3-Ė1K�K� "5»� "5»�

ĹŏŃ 0�ÄĖo^1�ĕďúđKĚ CF1�Ė MĨ«üĥįŊŏŁ�ªCFĕýĂĥ��1��ĖÃlĖM

ÌĕďúđŉŀŋĮĲňōŎ��Kª

ŁŌŀĬĸĲňĽŉĵŅ�

\ēĖO[

ŎıńŇľĹĪõPÈÍ?õ��ěĖ¾�

ŎÕúĴĭŊē�¼ĕGĐāPÈ�MÀ

ŎPÈēĖÃlŎ2�



Ŏ1�PÈĖG�ēĔĥ�|Wdē�

��ĴĭŊ



ŎPÈēĖÃlŎ2�

Ŏ`¬�YĖİĩj�

Ŏ1�PÈĖG�ēĔĥ�|Wdē�

��ĴĭŊ

³ßåÛôyR1�JK'T�éìç��÷CF1�78ĶńĽŏÞøĖ»©Ŏ�ªĖ$N4ĘK�ĕĢĥ·�ŝßÝÞâTU4ĘßÝÞãTUĖ�ÁřďĐĀŚ

»©Ŏ�ª= ŐÚőÖÞÝv ŒÚœÙŔÚŕôÞÝÚÞßv ŖÚŗôÞv ŘôÞv

81

112

2016 3 2

2013

1

/ /

114

(a) (b)

(c)

(d)

2016 2

9

5

115 5

3 1 /

2 / 2

82

1. /

2. / 3. / 3

1. 2. 3. 4.

4 4. /

5.

/

"�# �� IPE ��

��$�

(1) !�

IPE

2015

2016 2017

(2) ��

2014

2015 2016

83

N 1 / 2

/ 2

N 1. / N 2. / N

3. / 3 N 1. 2.

3. 4. 4 N

3

N ( )

N

N N 2015 2016

N 2

N 2

N 0.01( ) 0.06( ) 0.14( ) 116

IBM SPSS Statistics 22.0 N p<0.05 N

(3)

― N

― N

o ― N (1)

N (2) N ―

(3) (4) (5)―

(6)―

N ― 27-2-58

N

(4)

P

2015 144 140 91.5 2016 129

123 95.3 29 N

2015 39 2016

17 2015

49.3 2016

N 2015 N

84

(68 )

M X

N 3

N 28 N 3 4

3.26 3.63 2015 3.3

2016 2015 N 9

3

2016 - /

2015 2015

3.19 2016 3.63 2=0.20 (1)

(2)

(3) 2

N (4)

(5) N

2015 N 2016

$/6,9��&#=��

� @BAC 8( )( 8( )(

�! ��'��! .-. 4/,. .-3 53,/

��' 06 /4,6 .4 .0,5

99�%�!D��E */1+ *.4,.+ *.0+ *.-,3+

99��!D��E *5+ *2,4+ */+ *.,3+

99��!D��E *4+ *2,-+ */+ *.,3+

�� 4. 2-,4 41 3-,/

�� 36 16,0 16 06,5

�<; 55 3/,6 35 22,0

�:? 2/ 04,. 22 11,4

�� "

>=�

/-.3��

*87./0+

/-.2��

*87.1-+

85

o N

N N

2015 3.43

3.00 Welch t t=5.11, df=109.0,

p<0.001 2016 o N

- , -

2015 5 2016 8

N

2016 ×

2015 2 2015

3.30 2016 3.60 2=0.11 AHRQ gency for Healthcare

Research and Quality TeamSTEPPSvi Team Strategies and Tools to Enhance

Performance and Patient Safety 4

117 N

× 2016 AHRQ

× N

× N N

2015 2016 ,

2015 2016

2015 3.53 2016 3.54 2=0.001

N

N

− (1)

(2)

vi AHRQ N

o N TeamSTEPPS

AHRQ N ×

×

86

N (3)

(4)

N N

(5)1 10 7 3

360°

, , (1)-(2),(7) 2015

3 2015 3.27 2016

3.52 2=0.10 o

2015

4 3 N

2016 3 N

N

(5)

× N IPE

× × N × 2013

× 2016

38

×

×

IPE

× N 6

IPE IPE

― ×

IPE N

× N 2015 2016

87

2016

2017 2016

2015 2016

118

88

i

N × 1

3

IPE × 3

IPE

(1) SM

2016

3 N N

Rotation-based

clerkship (RBC) Longitudinal integrated clerkship (LIC)

20 119

CBME Community-based medical education N

120 LIC CBME

×

3 LIC CBME

o

×

5 19 4 6

3

×

2 N

N 4

89

4 N 5

× 1 ×

×

(2)

1)

― ―

2 2016 9

2)

102 117

×

3 ×

15 N ―

2

3)

2 N

× 1 30 14

× N

N 2

N 4

N (5 )

(4 ) (3 ) (2 ) (1

) 5 N

4)

× 7

30 N

5 × 7

N t Welch

90

Welch 7

t (d) d

116 t 7 t

8 d 0.20( )0.50( )0.80( )

( )

( ) ( ) 2

1 2 2

0.01( )

0.06( )0.14( ) 99

1 0


5) ��

2

(5) 2

� ��

d

� ��

91

(3) #�

1) ��!��

97 ( 95.1%) 75.3% 30

(40.2%) (45.7%) 9

�� OQPRS @ ,

�� !� 73 75/3

�� 24 24/7

�&� ;� 25 25/8

<� 19 19/6

=� 14 14/4

>� 16 16/5

?� 23 23/7

�&KJ�� %�#DFC 37 40/2

-(�*�. MM%�#DFC 42 45/7

HENGLABIA 12 13/0

MM��#DFC 1 1/1

��#DFC 0 0/0

)30V��+'J��#��-@:97.T��$

�W� ��"�&J*�U

2) �"�� $��(�� 1)��

( 1) 7 30

t

31 7 30

t 0.01

(dDiff) 30

dDiff=1.06 dDiff=1.05

dDiff=0.80 dDiff=0.65

dDiff=0.64

32

92

30

�& �8 �8" Z Y UTWVV

5��x�AB\(7

DPC0E�� FNGI RHGHHI HGNM

5��x<-/�8DMC

0E�� FOGM RHGHHI HGPH

5��x`lnge^j

qb]\B$DLC0E�� FQGN RHGHHI IGHM

5��x1�/�@DMC

0E�� FNGH RHGHHI HGNL

5��x2>[%:DJC

0E�� FKGO RHGHHI HGKQ

5��x�+/y3�/

?�DKC0E�� FIGO RHGHHI HGIP

5��x9�6+DKC

0E�� FLGK RHGHHI HGLN

�<#*tKHC0u �� FQGQ RHGHHI IGHN

;KIv�.ish_daofpcm=�!DrkqIE\#*��DXSPPE

t'��4��w ,��)��.�8\=u

( )

( ) ( )

( )

( 1) 7 30

( )

33 6.3

5.8 0.12

( )

34

(p<0.001)

p=0.006 (p=0.03)

(p<0.001) (p<0.001) 30 (p<0.001)

+<

z+<

z+<

z+<

z+<

z+<

z+<

z+<

z

-�d

?-]yoil^

elal

dhaj

deah

dlae

iac

deaf

dcaf

dchal

�-]yoef^

elad

dgak

ddal

dlag

hag

dfad

dcaf

dcgac

"M��e

p��]yoef^

fcae

diad

dfak

dlai

iag

deah

dcac

dckai

q��]yodk^

fdag

diad

ddaj

ecac

iad

dead

ddae

dckaj

r��]yodg^

elad

dfah

ddac

dkai

hag

dead

laj

llag

s��]yodi^

elak

dhai

deaf

dlai

haj

dfah

dcai

dcjad

t��]yoed^

ekac

dhah

dead

dkag

hah

deah

dcac

dceac

"M��.*d

]O'S^

_\zncach`\__\zncacd`\___zncaccd

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

__

y{

___

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

y{

lgaf

hai

ddac

lak

deah

y{

I��¦

�YZ�7K

]k[C^

�1

��¡

Qfe¤�4$UN��2B&-��A� ��S%*�+<m"M�]yolj^¢3(�G� ¥)>��;��A"M�S£

__

y{

_y{

dlai

hal

deak

dcag

dcjac

dcak

djah

d\�82|5!]qvxuw9£

e\��XL�0�4]qvxuw9£ ��:6B��b

:6B��]yode^

H6B��b��

H6B��b��

��}~�}]yojh^

fcac

dhaj

eiaf

dfae

I��¦

O'J=

]f[C^

�R+<

¢fc[C£

I��¦

R@B M

]h[C^

I��¦

��

��Z,]g[

C^

I��¦

D#B"W

]h[C^

I��¦

ET�/P

]e[C^

I ��¦

�=B§F�B

V�

]f[C^

("�. J� %/� F8' b d eX

�� WYÛW W XYUX `VUVVW VUXW

� Y]U] W WUX VUX^ VUVW

�� ÛY W WUZ VUXZ VUVX

�� WYWUW W ZWU] `VUVVW VUYY

� W_U] W VU_ VUYZ VUVW

�� VUW W VUV VU^] `VUVVW

�� Y]WU_ W ]ZUW `VUVVW VUZ\

� XU^ W VUX VU\Y VUVVY

�� WUV W VUX VU\] VUVVX

�� \WUW W XZUY `VUVVW VUXX

� VUVVW W VUVVW VU__ `VUVVW

�� VU_ W VUZ VU[V `VUVVW

�� WZU] W WVUY `VUVVW VUWW

� WWUV W XU[ VUWX VUVY

�� VUVVW W VUVVW VU_^ `VUVVW

�� WU] W WUW VUX_ VUVW

� _U_ W WU] VUXV VUVX

�� WUW W VU] VUZV VUVW

�� WÛ\ W WVU] VUVV VUWW

� XU\ W VUY VU\V `VUVVW

�� XUY W WUY VUX[ VUVX

�� Y[\ÛZ W \_UX `VUVVW VUZ[

� W_ÛX W VU\ VUZ\ VUVW

�� YYUW W VU\ VUZX VUVW

("�. J� %/� F8' b d eX

�� XWVUX W Y[UW `VUVVW VUYV

�� W]YU] Z WUZ VUXZ VUV\

�� XXUZ Z VU_ VUZ[ VUVZ

�� W\]UX W [YU^ `VUVVW VUY_

�� WZ_UZ Z WU^ VUWZ VUV^

�� WXUY Z WUV VUZX VUV[

�� Z\]U^ W _[U\ `VUVVW VU[Z

�� ]YUV Z WU\ VUW^ VUV]

�� X\U[ Z WUZ VUX\ VUV\

�� ^VU] W YXU\ `VUVVW VUX^

�� [ÛV Z WU[ VUXW VUV]

�� WWUW Z WUW VUY[ VUV[

�� XVUX W WZU\ `VUVVW VUW[

�� WWUY Z VU\ VU\\ VUVY

�� ÛW Z WU[ VUXX VUV]

�� XU_ W WU_ `VUVVW VUVX

�� X_UV Z WUX VUYW VUV\

�� ZU] Z WUX VU[Z VUVZ

�� YXU^ W WÛW `VUVVW VUW^

�� [[UW Z WU[ VUXX VUV]

�� WUZ Z VUX VU_Z VUVW

�� Z^_[UX W _]U] `VUVVW VU[Z

�� W_\YUX Z WUZ VUXY VUV\

�� YV[U[ Z ]\UZ VUXV VUV]

A��6;�?�;N�

SYR<T

A��F#B6

SYR<T

�K)5�YVR<�

IYYUf�:y�xnsp�v�r}L!'S�{�WTi)5��g,�iQ��GD�~u�S�*3�T

hkl 1Sca^^T�0$�@��&7��4��:�EiL�

IYZ��:y�xnsp�v�r}L!'S�{�WTi)5��g�E��iQ��GD�~u�S�*

3�Thkl 1Sca^^Tf�0$�@��&7��4��:�EiL�

A��PQi2C

S^R<T

A��K9;�E

S[R<T

A��o|�wtmz�qjiQ

+

SZR<T

A��= ;�O

S[R<T

A��>Mg-H

SXR<T

A��6;�?�;N�

SYR<T

A��F#B6

SYR<T

�K)5�YVR<�

A��PQi2C

S^R<T

A��K9;�E

S[R<T

A��o|�wtmz�qjiQ

+

SZR<T

A��= ;�O

S[R<T

A��>Mg-H

SXR<T

'!�- I� $.� E7& a c dW

�� Y^TU V ]TX UTUUZ UTU^

�� YY\TX V V[TY _UTUUV UTV[

�� V]T^ V XTW UTU] UTUY

�� [WT^ V WVTX _UTUUV UTWU

�� VZ]T\ V \T] UTUU[ UTU]

�� VTW V UTY UTZW UTUUZ

�� WV\TW V YXT] _UTUUV UTXY

�� ZXTY V YT\ UTUX UTUZ

�� UTW V UTU UT]Z _UTUUV

�� WUTX V ]TW UTUV UTU^

�� VZUT[ V V^TV _UTUUV UTV]

�� [T] V WT] UTVU UTUX

�� VT] V VTX UTWZ UTUW

�� VXTW V WT^ UTU^ UTUX

�� YTY V XTX UTU\ UTUY

�� UTV V UTV UT]W UTUUV

�� VUXTW V WXTU _UTUUV UTWV

�� XTW V WTX UTVY UTUX

�� VVT\ V [T[ UTUV UTU\

�� VUTU V VTV UTXV UTUV

�� UT[ V UTX UTZ\ UTUUY

�� VZX\TZ V XUT] _UTUUV UTW\

�� Y^YVTU V V[T[ _UTUUV UTV[

�� VZVTW V XTU UTU^ UTUX

�J(4�XUQ;�

@��n{~vsly�pihP

*

RYQ;S

@��<�:�N

RZQ;S

@��=Lf,G

RWQ;S

@��5:�>�:M�

RXQ;S

@��E"A5

RXQ;S

@��OPh1B

R]Q;S

@��J8:�D

RZQ;S

HXZ��9x�wmro�u�q|K &R�z�VSh(4��f�D+&hP��FC�}t�R�)

2�Sgjk 0Rb`]]Se�/#�?��%6��3��9�DhK�

96

B2<

hfqgo

cdic

nel42<

C��RSk3E �� _XWXXY

C��L:<�G �� XWXX\

C��u��}zs��wmkS* �� XWXZ

C��>�<�Q �� _XWXXY

C��?Og,J �� XWX^

C��8�@�<P� �� _XWXXY

C��H"D8 �� XWZY

�L(7UZXT=V �� _XWXXY

�G+&UH"MV

'!�. bUKZ[ -�

KZ\W�;��~tyv�|�x�M &U��YVk(7g�G+&k

SUN/$�V��IF��{�U�)5�Vjpr�1Ua`]]V�0#�A�

��%9��6��;�GkM�

35 36

30

0.1 9 12

30

�� IPE ��

(1) ��

Interprofessional Education (IPE) 1960

97

RONOK

RQNTK

QUNR

QUNX

QS

QU

QW

RO

RQ

RS

RU

RW

�@ �@#

�X}�5qypjmkuovlsE��"LxrwPM

=��\�HIe.>]e$2(;

L�@&"�M

�A?�tnwL�%0�Mdgi�+LZYWWM

{* �:��!3��1��5�@|

��4�,L[YONOW~CRT)|

�@&"L<-6M

�@&"{b`haf^_c^z/-6|

PXNU

QPNQ

PVNT

PVNX

PU

PW

QO

QQ

QS

QU

�@ �@#

�PO}�5qypjmkuovlsE��"LxrwPM

=��\8�6�G]e$2(;L�@&"�M


{* �:��!3��1��5�@|

��4�,L[YONPO~CRT)|

�@&"L<-6M

�@&"{b`haf^_c^z/-6|

(q )

(q )

98

TNXQ

UNUW

TNTW

TNSQ

S

SNT

T

TNT

U

UNT

V

VNT

W

�@ �@#

�PP}�5qypjmkuovlsE��"LxrwPM

=��\9Fa'B]e$2(;L�@&"�M


{* �:��!3��1��5�@|

��4�,L[YONOV~CRT)|

�@&"L<-6M

�@&"{b`haf^_c^z/-6|

POVNOK

PPWNOK

XSNR

POONQ

WO

XO

POO

PPO

PQO

PRO

PSO

�@ �@#

�PQ}�5qypjmkuovlsE��"LxrwPM

ROJ7�D$2e$2(;L�@&"�M


{* �:��!3��1��5�@|

��4�,L[YONOX~CRT)|

�@&"L<-6M

�@&"{b`haf^_c^z/-6|

(q )

.

(q )

99

× Tribalism

16 N

IPE 2000 IPE

N 6 2001 N IPE

121 N N

IPE Randomized

Control Trial(RCT) ― N IPE

― 2

N IPE ― 2001

2010 N ×

122,123 3 124 1 125 N

126 Web N 127 IPE ×

o ― IPE

N N ―

IPE ―

o

2004

IPE N

108

N

1

× ―

128 2012

RIPLS129 KiSS-18102 N 99 N

N RIPLS

130 2013 99

o N N

100

N N N

N ×

2

(2)

1)

― ―

(10 ) (1 ) 2

2016 10 2017 1

2)

109

19

3)

2 N

N × 1 30

× N

N

N

4)

× ( ) 7

30 N

× 7

N t Welch 7

t N (d)

N d 116 t

6 t ( 7) N

d N 0.20( ) 0.50( ) 0.80( )

( )

101

( ) ( ) 2

1 2 2

0.01( )

0.06( )0.14( ) 99


5) �$&)�

(3) '!

1) ��#�� 128 ( 100.0%) (61.7%)

8 (85.2%)( 37)

15 70

(54.7%) 19

� JLKMO B 2

�� "� >@ =85>

�� ;@ :?5:

�1N�& ��1��& 87@ ?<59

��#�(HG� DI >7 <;5>

FE <? ;<5:

,:>5��/)G��$��3BA89?4

CCCP��&��8�!�*'0��+G-�Q

��#�1P%.�&6

�#��&6��#��

&Q8@ 8;5?

2) �%�� (��(�� 1)��"�� ( 1) 7 30

102

t

( 38)7 30 2016 10 (

) 2017 1 ( )

2 3 19.3 19.9

10.9 10.5

0.3

�& )H�'

LRPQV�QP(M

);�'

LRPQW�Q(Ma ` \ [^]]

8��

L�IJ�c+:}�� NQOVW POQP POQT

8��

LB/1�<M�� NPOUR POVQ POPV

8��

LgsunleqxidcJ"M�� NPOUT POUY POPT

8��

L3�1�FM�� NROVX POPPX PORW

8��

L4Db#@M�� NPOPU POYV POPQ

8 ��

L�-{51E�M�� NPOWX POTT POPW

8��

L?�9-M�� ROQR POPT PORS

�B!,LSPK2M �� NQOPV PORY POQQ

ASX~�0pzofkhvmwjtC��LyrxQMc!,��L_ZQRPM|*��6��Q�.

�=7G$%>cC}

39

30

30

->

~->

~->

~->

~->

~->

~->

~->

~

/�

B/e}wrnf

nkim

lqin

lnio

ltim

pip

lmin

lkis

lkrit

�/e}wotf

nkiq

lqiq

lpil

ltiq

pir

lmim

llim

lllik

!_¡!K

�!_�!Ke}wlknf

nkim

lqim

lnir

ltin

piq

lmin

lkit

lksil

gd~vkikphdggd~vkiklhdggg~vkikkl

9"��<6�9"exz|y{=¤�A��

��D#P��

�W->

£nkcF¤

nlim

lriq

lqin

mkil

pip

lmip

llin

lloip

ggg

lpik

ltit

ggg

lsis

gllin

llmir

��D!_HZ!Kj

?!D=!Kj:D=

!Ke}wltf

M�� ¦

WCE!P

epcFf

M�� ¦

��

��b.

eocFf

M�� ¦

G$E#]

epcFf

M�� ¦

IY�0U

emcFf

M�� ¦

?E§J�E

\�

encFf

M�� ¦

T(N?

encFf

}�

lkiq

}�

lkois

��e}wqrf

nlin

lril

��e}wppf

mtim

gg

lpiq

glmit

}�

}�

}�

gggg

}�

}�

}�

}�

gg

pip

}�

lmim

pir

lmio

Vnt¥�8%[Q��6E'/��D� ��X&+�->u,5`�4e}wlmsf£7)�K�!l*@�RL^12S�X¤

�3

��¢

M�� ¦

�ab��;O

escFf

}�

}�

ggg

}�

}�

}�

104

3

( 1) 7 30 3

( ) ( ) 3 ( )

N

(p=0.003) N (13.5) (14.9)

40 41 3 ( )N

N

3 ( ) ( ) 3 (

) N

(p<0.001) 30 (p=0.04) 42

N N 13.7

16.1 43 30

N 108.3 113.9

3 ( )N

N

3 ( ) ( )

3 ( )

N (p<0.001)

(p<0.001) (p<0.001)

(p<0.001) 30 (p<0.001) 44

N

45 2 N 0.17

3

( )N N

30 N

30

46

105

& �. L� #/� H7% e g h[

A��STk2C �� Z[X[ Z [Xb^ YXYb YXY[

�� [^XY Z ZXYY YX\[ YXYZ

�� YXb Z [Xb^ YX_^ YXYY[

A��M8:�E �� ZX\ Z YX\Z YX^a YXYY\

�� Z]XY Z YXa^ YX\_ YXYZ

�� YX\ Z YXYb YX`` YXYYZ

�� YXZ Z YXY^ YXa[ cYXYYZ

�� ZZ_Xa Z bX[Y YXYY\ YXY`

�� aXZ Z \XYY YXYb YXY[

A��<�:�Q �� Z`X_ Z _X^[ YXYZ YXY^

�� aXa Z ZXY] YX\Z YXYZ

�� YX] Z YXZ] YX`Y YXYYZ

A��=Oi+J �� YXZ Z YXY\ YXa_ cYXYYZ

�� YX[ Z YX_^ YXaY YXYYZ

�� YXa Z YX]a YX]b YXYY]

A��5�>�:P� �� ZXY Z YXa[ YX\` YXYZ

�� YX[ Z YXY^ YXa\ cYXYYZ

�� YXa Z YX_^ YX][ YXYZ

A��H!B5 �� bX^ Z ]X^a YXY\ YXY]

�� ZYXZ Z ZX\a YX[] YXYZ

�� YX[ Z YXZZ YX`] YXYYZ

�M'4V\YU;W �� ]_X] Z YXb] YX\\ YXYZ

�� `Y`X` Z \XYZ YXYb YXY\

�� _XZ Z YXZ[ YX`\ YXYYZ

K]YX�9{�zpur�x�t�N�%V�}�ZWk'4��i*�kT

��ID��w�V�(3�Wjmn 1VfdZ[YW�0"�?��Z$6�F@R,-GkN�

A��q~�yvo|�

slkT)

106

:, �,

D��VWk5F �� \[ba

D��O;=�H �� \[_b

D��q~�yvo|�slkW+ �� \[\\_

D��? =�T �� \[_]

D��@Ri-M �� \[c\�

D ��8�A�=S� �� \[c_

D��K#E8 �� \[^`

�O)7Y_\X>Z �� \[\d

N`]��<{�zpur�x�t�P!'Y�}�]Zk,�)7YQ2%��Z

hhhhh��LG��w�Y�*6�Zjmn�4Yfe]^\Z

hhhhh�3$�B��]&9�ICU/0JkP�

("�1,�

gYN`\�.�

%��- K� X ".� G6$ f h i\

@��STm1B �� \Y_ [ ZY`[ ZY^^ ZYZ[

�� \_YZ [ \^Yc_ ZYcc ZYZ[

�� [Ya [ ZY^Z ZY_] ZYZZ]

@��L79�D �� ZYZ [ ZYZ[ ZYc\ ZYZZ[

�� _]Yc [ ]Y]\ ZYZa ZYZ]

�� ZY` [ ZY[` ZY`c ZYZZ[

�� ZY_ [ ZY[b ZY`b ZYZZ[

�� [b^Y] [ [_Y\Z dZYZZ[ ZY[[

�� ]Yc [ [Y^] ZY\] ZYZ[

@��;�9�P �� _Ya [ \Y[[ ZY[_ ZYZ\

�� [_Yc [ [Ybc ZY[a ZYZ\

�� [Y^ [ ZY_] ZY^a ZYZZ^

@��<Nk*I �� ZYZZ[ [ ZYZZ ZYcb dZYZZ[

�� ZY\ [ ZYZa ZYac ZYZZ[

�� ZYZZ[ [ ZYZZ[ ZYcb dZYZZ[

@��4�=�9O� �� ZY[ [ ZY[[ ZYa^ ZYZZ[

�� ZY[ [ ZYZ[ ZYc[ dZYZZ[

�� \YZ [ [Ya_ ZY[c ZYZ[

@��G A4 �� bY^ [ ^YZ[ ZYZ_ ZYZ]

�� \Y^ [ ZY]\ ZY_a ZYZZ]

�� [YZ [ ZY^` ZY_Z dZYZZ[

�L&3V]ZU:W �� ZYZ] [ ZYZZ[ ZYcb dZYZZ[

�� ca`Y^ [ ^Y[c ZYZ^ ZYZ]

�� _bY\ [ [Y[c ZY\b ZYZ[

��

J^\��8}�|rwt�z�v�M�$V��[Wm&3��k)��RmT

jjjj��HC��y�V�'2�Wlop 0Vge[\ZWj�/!�>��[#5�E?

jjjjQ+,FmM�

@��s��{xq~�

unmT(

107

��U ��;�U

C��VWk5E �� \[_^

C��N:<�G �� \[\b\

C��q~�yvo|�slkW, �� d\[\\]

C��>!< S �� \[]b

C��?Qi-L �� \[bc�

C�� 8�@�<R� �� \[c]

C��J$D8 �� \[ab

�N*7Y_\X=Z �� \[\`

M`_��;{�zpur�x�t�O"(Y�}�]Zk�U�*7YP2&��Z

hhhhh��KF��w�Y�+6�Zjmn�4Yfe]^\Z

hhhhh�3%�A��]'9�HBT/0IkO�

)#�1�U

gYM`^�.�

)#�0 N� &1� J9( h j k^

C��UVo4E �� ]^[b ] _[\a \[\d \[\_

�� ^b_[a ] ]][`\ f\[\\] \[\e

�� ^[a ] \[b^ \[`_ \[\]

C��O:<�G �� ][\ ] \[^` \[b_ \[\\^

�� ]d^[a ] ]^[\\ f\[\\] \[\e

�� \[^ ] \[\` \[d` f\[\\]

�� ][] ] \[_d \[a` \[\\_

�� ^c_[_ ] ^`[]\ f\[\\] \[]c

�� ][_ ] \[`c \[`e \[\\`

C��>!< S �� ]e[_ ] c[]\ \[\\e \[\b

�� eb[\ ] ]^[_e f\[\\] \[]\

�� \[] ] \[\^ \[dd f\[\\]

C��?Qm-L �� \[\ ] \[\\^ \[ec f\[\\]

�� \[d ] \[^` \[b^ \[\\^

�� \[e ] \[b\ \[`` \[\]

C��7�@�<R� �� \[c ] \[b\ \[`` \[\]

�� _[b ] \[cd \[_d \[\]

�� \[\\^ ] \[\\] \[ec f\[\\]

C��J$D7 �� d[] ] _[e_ \[\a \[\_

�� ^_[d ] _[_\ \[\c \[\_

�� ][e ] \[e^ \[_` \[\]

�O*6Y_\W=Z �� b^[b ] ][^c \[^b \[\]

�� XXXXX ] ]e[c\ f\[\\] \[]`

�� ^_[c ] \[`d \[`e \[\\`

C��u��}zs��

wpoV,

M``��;��~tyv�|�x�P"(Y��]Zo*6��m��; G

llllpo��moV��KF��{�Y�+5�Znqr 3Yig]^\Z

llll�2%�A��]'8�HBT./IoP�

108

��oq

nsn��op

G��YZu8I �� `_dc

G��R>@ K �� i`_`à

G��{��y��}vuZ. �� i`_`à

G��B#@"W �� i`_`à

G��CUr/P �� `_fb

G ��<�D�@V� �� `_ch

G��N&H< �� `_`g

�R,:]c`[A^ �� i`_`à

+%�3

��?"Kvu��

l]Qdd�0�

Qde��?��z�|��~�S$*]��aû��?"Kvu��u

mmmm\5;�,:]T4(��^��OJ��]�-9!^twx�7]kjab`^

mmmmm�6'�E� a)=�LFX12MuS�

��$ 8� �% 5+� N P QD

�� BAD C BABI BAIK BABBC

�� CKAD C CAIH BACK BABC

�� FCAH C EAJE BABG BABE

�� CDGAC C CCAGB LBABBC BABK

�9�)?EB>-@ �� BAJ C BABD BAKB LBABBC

�� GCAF C BADG BAHD BABBD

�� ECGEAC C CGACB LBABBC BACD

7FHA,fqe[`]mcn_j:��?phoC@V�)��T!�S�<S

RRR�2WV�TV=�u�61�kbo?��(�@UXY�'?OMCDB@

RRRs&�.��C�*�3/;"#4V:�t

0��u\ildaZrgo^

WV=

109

(4) ��

1) � ��

1

8 (30 )

1.06

131

132

dDiff=1.05

133

dDiff=0.80

134,135

0.1

d=0.18

110

136

137

2) �� IPE ��

3

39

138

3

44 4 30

10

1

IPE

111

N

132 N 139

Generic Skills N

N

Specific 3 N

3) P S X 5

N

IPE N

N

N N

N vii

140 N

IPE 3

N

Hidden Curriculum o 141

vii

N

112

|N{ fwz*_h&��

N

N

Profession N

5

N

N 1990

N 3

N

α

N

1990

4

3 11 2

90 21 7 3

N N

N o

113

1990

20

N

N

N

o

3 N 3

N (1)

(2) N

(3)

N

259 2

1 N 2

2 N

1 N 30 7

114

2 N 31 8

N

1 N

N

IPE

2016 N

2015 2016

2016 2017 2016

N

N 1

1 IPE

3 -

IPE N

8

(30 )

IPE N N

N

N

N

PDCA N

PDCA

115

a� � n�

1. CAIPE. 2002; http://www.caipe.org.uk/resources/. Accessed 3/4, 2014.

2. Reeves S. Interprofessional education: effects on professional practice

and healthcare outcomes (update). Cochrane Database of Systematic

Reviews. 2013(3).

3. Szasz G. Interprofessional education in the health sciences. A project

conducted at the University of British Columbia. The Milbank

Memorial Fund quarterly. 1969;47(4):449-475.

4. , , . ,

N 21

Inter-professional N Rawson,D. . Quality

nursing : the Japanese journal of nursing education & nursing

research. 1998;4(12):1032-1040.

5. . N :

. : ; 2012.

6. ( ). IPW . :

; 2009.

7. Takahashi HE, Sato S. Establishment of the Japan Association for

Interprofessional Education and perspectives. Journal of

Interprofessional Care. 2009;23(6):554-555.

8. Ito T. JIPWEN(

) (Interprofessional

Education through JIPWEN (Japan Interprofessional Working and

Education Network)). Niigata journal of health and welfare.

2010;10(1):73-78.

9. . 19

2007; http://www.mext.go.jp/component/a_menu/education

/detail/__icsFiles/afieldfile/2015/06/22/1257660_001.pdf. Accessed

116

1/31, 2017.

10. Buring S, Bhushan A, Broeseker A, et al. Interprofessional education:

definitions, student competencies, and guidelines for implementation.

American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education. 2009;73(4):59-59.

11. Kent F, Keating J. Interprofessional education in primary health care

for entry level students--A systematic literature review. Nurse

Education Today. 2015;35(12):1221-1231.

12. Sakai I, Yamamoto T, Takahashi Y, Maeda T, Kunii Y, Kurokochi K.

Development of a new measurement scale for interprofessional

collaborative competency: The Chiba Interprofessional Competency

Scale (CICS29). Journal of Interprofessional Care. 2017;31(1):59-65.

13. Parsell G, Bligh J. The development of a questionnaire to assess the

readiness of health care students for interprofessional learning

(RIPLS). Medical education. 1999;33(2):95-100.

14. Mahler C, Berger S, Reeves S. The Readiness for Interprofessional

Learning Scale (RIPLS): A problematic evaluative scale for the

interprofessional field. Journal of Interprofessional Care.

2015;29(4):289-291.

15. Yamamoto T, Sakai I, Takahashi Y, Maeda T, Kunii Y, Kurokochi K.

Development of a new measurement scale for interprofessional

collaborative competency: a pilot study in Japan. Journal of

interprofessional care. 2014;28(1):45-51.

16. Frenk J, Chen L, Bhutta Z, et al. Health professionals for a new

century: transforming education to strengthen health systems in an

interdependent world. Lancet. 2010;376(9756):1923-1958.

17. Holtman M, Frost J, Hammer D, McGuinn K, Nunez L.

Interprofessional professionalism: linking professionalism and

interprofessional care. Journal of Interprofessional Care.

2011;25(5):383-385.

18. Chandratilake M. From the professionalism of a profession to the

117

professionalism of a multiprofessional team. Medical Education.

2014;48(4):345-347.

19. .

(IPE)N .

. 2012;43(Suppl.):19.

20. Carr-Saunders AMS, Wilson PA. The professions. F. Cass; 1964.

21. . . , ( ),

: . :

; 2005:xi, 482p.

22. Lieberman M. Education as a profession. Prentice-Hall; 1956.

23. . . : ; 1996.

24. Hall RH. Professionalization and Bureaucratization. American

Sociological Review. 1968;33(1):92-104.

25. Barr H. Universities respond together to the interprofessional

challenge in Japan. Journal of interprofessional care. 2012;26(5):350-

352.

26. . = . Vol 1: ; 1986.

27. . : .

. 1972;22(3):30-49.

28. .

. . 2010;20(3):251-262.

29. Weiler PC. A Measure of malpractice : medical injury, malpractice

litigation, and patient compensation. Harvard University Press; 1993.

30. Arnold L. Assessing professional behavior: yesterday, today, and

tomorrow. Academic medicine. 2002;77(6):502-515.

31. Arnold L, Stern DT. What is medical professionalism? In: Stern DT,

ed. Measuring medical professionalism. New York: Oxford University

Press; 2006:15-37.

32. Hafferty FW. Professionalism and the socialization ofmedical students.

In: Cruess RL, Cruess R, Steinert Y, eds. Teaching medical

118

professionalism. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2009:53-70.

33. Smith LG. Medical professionalism and the generation gap. The

American Journal of Medicine. 2005;118(4):439-442.

34. . . In:

, , ( )―

( ). : ; 2009:19-30.

35. . . 1995.

36. , , , .

- .

. 2006;18(1):45-57.

37. Cruess R, McIlroy J, Cruess S, Ginsburg S, Steinert Y. The

Professionalism Mini-evaluation Exercise: a preliminary investigation.

Academic medicine. 2006;81(10 Suppl):S74-78.

38. Arnold EL, Blank LL, Race KE, Cipparrone N. Can professionalism be

measured? The development of a scale for use in the medical

environment. Academic medicine. 1998;73(10):1119-1121.

39. AmericanBoardofInternalMedicine. ABIM Project Professionalism.

1995.

40. Aramesh KK. Measuring professionalism in residency training

programs in Iran. Medical teacher. 2009;31(8):e356-361.

41. Ahadi T, Mianehsaz E, Raissi G, Moraveji S, Sharifi V. Professionalism

in residents of physical medicine and rehabilitation in Iran. Journal

of medical ethics and history of medicine. 2015;8:3-3.

42. DeLisa JA, Foye PM, Jain SS, Kirshblum S, Christodoulou C.

Measuring professionalism in a physiatry residency training program.

American journal of physical medicine & rehabilitation.

2001;80(3):225-229.

43. , .

. . 2009;98(12):3178-3182.

44. Tsugawa Y, Ohbu S, Cruess R, et al. Introducing the Professionalism

119

Mini-Evaluation Exercise (P-MEX) in Japan: results from a

multicenter, cross-sectional study. Academic medicine.

2011;86(8):1026-1031.

45. Tsugawa Y, Tokuda Y, Ohbu S, et al. Professionalism Mini-Evaluation

Exercise for medical residents in Japan: a pilot study. Medical

Education. 2009;43(10):968-978.

46. Morreale M, Balon R, Arfken C. Survey of the importance of

professional behaviors among medical students, residents, and

attending physicians. Academic Psychiatry. 2011;35(3):191-195.

47. Al Eraky M, Chandratilake M, Wajid G, Donkers J, van Merrienboer

J. Medical professionalism: development and validation of the Arabian

LAMPS. Medical Teacher. 2013;35 Suppl 1:S56-S62.

48. Gillespie CC. Residents' perceptions of their own professionalism and

the professionalism of their learning environment. Journal of

graduate medical education. 2009;1(2):208-215.

49. Klemenc Ketis Z, Vrecko H. Development and validation of a

professionalism assessment scale for medical students. International

Journal of Medical Education. 2014;5:205-211.

50. Jahan F, Siddiqui M, Al Zadjali N, Qasim R. Recognition of Core

Elements of Medical Professionalism among Medical Students and

Faculty Members. Oman Medical Journal. 2016;31(3):196-204.

51. ¡̗ʭ , ȕɆ�Ƃ , Ŧˠŷĉ . ɁŎɏșĸ0q�oLbY�g�\y0

ßǮ . ɁŎɏșɬŎ . 2014;29(4):599-604.

52. Tanaka M, Yonemitsu Y, Rieko K. Reliability and validity of the

Japanese version of the behavioral Inventory for professionalism in

nursing. J�_�gY�g� nursing care research. 2012;11(3):21-29.

53. Kelley KAKA. Cross-validation of an instrument for measuring

professionalism behaviors. American journal of pharmaceutical

education. 2011;75(9):179.

54. Cohen JJJJ. Professionalism in medical education, an American

120

perspective: from evidence to accountability. Medical education.

2006;40(7):607-617.

55. Blackall G, Melnick S, Shoop G, et al. Professionalism in medical

education: the development and validation of a survey instrument to

assess attitudes toward professionalism. Medical Teacher. 2007;29(2-

3):e58-e62.

56. Ɇ̄ǃʻ . HKePyıɓĭǆʣ0Ɂ˚+œˬ . ɿÿÞȸǌɦ ; 2013.

57. ABIM Foundation, American Board of Internal Medicine, ACP-ASIM

Foundation, American College of Physicians-American Society of

Internal Medicine, European Federation of Internal Medicine. Medical

professionalism in the new millennium: a physician charter. Annals of

Internal Medicine. 2002;136(3):243-246.

58. GeneralMedicalCouncil. Good medical practice 2015. 2015;

http://www.gmc-uk.org/guidance/good_medical_practice.asp. Accessed

5/1, 2015.

59. TheRoyalCollegeofPhysiciansandSurgeonsofCanada. CanMEDS 2015

Physician competency framework. 2015; http://www.royalcollege.ca

/portal/page/portal/rc/common/documents/canmeds/framework/canme

ds_full_framework_e.pdf. Accessed 12/9, 2015.

60. ǐ ǧ ö ŭ ¯ . ö ŭ 0 ʢ ǻ Æ Ɂ Ƶ ̐ ( ǂ ˆ ȸ ). 2008;

https://www.med.or.jp/doctor/member/000250.html. Accessed 5/13,

2015.

61. ǐǧöŎǆʣŎ¯q�oLbY�g�\yǆʣ0V�]�X[FƁƦ�

?� WS _[SoN�[ . q�oLbY�g�\y0ǟʉä˿ɔǿǷ .

2015;

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1dxGjml_uJORyejdgdiQLSSAoXK3H_

Lj_qzlTUI1uITM/viewform?c=0&w=1. Accessed 5/18, 2015.

62. � Ɋ ö ŭ ¯ . ö 0 ĥ ̠ Æ Ɂ ʑ ̮ . 2006; http://dl.med.or.jp/dl-

med/wma/medical_ethics2006j.pdf. Accessed 2017, 2/1.

63. Miller BK. A model for professionalism in nursing. Today's OR nurse.

121

1988;10(9):18-23.

64. InternationalCouncilofNurses. The ICN code of ethics for nurses.

2012;

http://www.icn.ch/images/stories/documents/about/icncode_english.pd

f. Accessed 12/09, 2015.

65. AmericanNurseAssociation. Code of Ethics for Nurses. 2015.

66. ǐǧə˟ü¯ . ə˟ʡ0ÆɁʑ̮ . 2003; https://www.nurse.or.jp/

nursing/practice/rinri/rinri.html. Accessed 07/01, 2015.

67. AmericanPhysicalTherapyAssociation. Professionalism in Physical

Therapy: Core Values. 2012; http://www.apta.org/uploadedFiles

/APTAorg/About_Us/Policies/Judicial_Legal/ProfessionalismCoreValu

es.pdf. Accessed 10/01, 2015.

68. CharteredSocietyofPhysiotherapy. Code of Professional Values and

Behaviour. 2011; http://www.csp.org.uk/professional-union/

professionalism/csp-expectations-members/code-professional-values-

behaviour. Accessed 07/01, 2015.

69. AmericanSocietyofHealth-SystemPharmacists. ASHP Statement on

Professionalism. American journal of health-system pharmacy.

2008;65(2):172-174.

70. ǐ ǧ ʴ ç ŭ ¯ Ɂ � ¯ . ʴ ç ŭ Æ Ɂ ˁ ő . 1997; http://www.

nichiyaku.or.jp/contents/info_97/n971031.html. Accessed 2/1, 2017.

71. ŨĜɆ�̆ . ɐƝș . Vol 136, 210. ǫ£ : �ŁÖ˚ɦ ; 1967.

72. Guyatt G. Evidence-based medicine. American College of Physicians

Journal Club. 1991;114:A-16.

73. ȓɆ¿� . Ȇʁ.��B EBM 0Ţ̕ . ȟļɦ¯À̡ɢɲ . 2000;133:27-

37.

74. o��f^� . öɏ+Ś̔ŕǁ̉ . ǫ£ : ƙǔɦþɃ̘ ; 1992.

75. IPEC-Expert-Panel. Core Competencies for Interprofessional Collaborative

Practice. 2011.

76. �ǩɀƚ , ³ʵʜ¸ . ǄĕǄƖ]�_�.��B^�Y|��P�Ś

122

3 .

. 2014;17(5):716-723.

77. Kohn LT, Corrigan J, Donaldson MS, Institute of Medicine .

Committee on Quality of Health Care in A. To err is human : building

a safer health system. National Academy Press; 2000.

78. .

. . 2014;73(4):310-314.

79. Densen P. Challenges and opportunities facing medical education.

Transactions of the American Clinical and Climatological Association.

2011;122:48-58.

80. . SEIQoL Response

Shift . . 2014;2(2):19-24.

81. , , , .

. .

2013;36(4):39-46.

82. , , , .

. . 2013(43):3-

6.

83. . o .

2014.

84. . .

. 2015;4(1):43-49.

85. .

. . 2016;17(3):150-153.

86. . : N . ;

1980.

87. AmericanInstituteofArchitects. 2017 Code of Ethics and Professional

Conduct. 2017. Accessed 3/20, 2017.

88. . . 2014;

https://www.nichibenren.or.jp/library/ja/jfba_info/rules/pdf/kaiki/kaik

123

i_no_70_160525.pdf. Accessed 3/30, 2017.

89. . . http://www.meti.go.jp/policy/kisoryoku/.

Accessed 3/20, 2017.

90. . o

. . 2015;19:1-13.

91. . :

. . 2012(18):75-114.

92. . o :

1 . :

. 2016(23):71-78.

93. PROG. o PROG. http://www.riasec.co.jp

/prog_hp/generic.html. Accessed 3/20, 2017.

94. .

. . 2013;23:95-99.

95. .

. . 2010;41(3):189-193.

96. , , , , , .

SD Student Doctor

. 21 . 2013;8:31-37.

97. , , .

. . 2016;6(1):49-62.

98. , , , .

o . . 2014;45(3):163-171.

99. , , , .

(IPE) - .

. 2013(19):37-45.

100. DeVellis RF. Scale development : theory and applications. 3rd ed.

Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage; 2012.

101. Kaiser HF. An index of factorial simplicity. Psychometrika.

124

1974;39(1):31-36.

102. . KiSS-18 . .

2004;6(2):41-51.

103. . G o .

. 2007;10(1):45-51.

104. .

o . journal of uoeh. 2005;27(3):263-272.

105. . :

. : ; 2011.

106. Nunnally JC. Psychometric theory. McGraw-Hill; 1978.

107. . .

. 2012;101(5):1440-1445.

108. , , , .

IPE .

. 2013;6(1-2):33-34.

109. Sohma H, Sawada I, Konno M, et al. Encouraging Appreciation of

Community Health Care by Consistent Medical Undergraduate

Education. In: Watanabe H, Koizumi M, eds. Advanced Initiatives in

Interprofessional Education in Japan: Japan interprofessional

working and education network. Tokyo: : Springer; 2010.

110. , , , , .

(early exposure)

. . 2014;63(4):263-267.

111. , . 1

. . 2011;42(1):1-7.

112. Michaelsen L. TBL- :

. 2009.

113. . . . 2012;126(4):181-

188.

114. ( )― :

125

. ; 2015.

115. Barkley EF, Cross KP, Major CH. : .

; 2009.

116. , .

. 2010

. 2011:47-73.

117. AgencyforHealthcareResearchandQuality. TeamSTEPPS. 2012;

https://www.ahrq.gov/teamstepps/instructor/index.html. Accessed 2/1,

2017.

118. , , , .

. . 2007;38(6):377-381.

119. McLaughlin K, Bates J, Konkin J, Woloschuk W, Suddards C, Regehr

G. A comparison of performance evaluations of students on

longitudinal integrated clerkships and rotation-based clerkships.

Academic medicine. 2011;86(10 Suppl):S25-S29.

120. . ( 1 )

CBME N? . 2013;36(3):242-245.

121. Cooper H, Carlisle C, Gibbs T, Watkins C. Developing an evidence base

for interdisciplinary learning: a systematic review. Journal of

advanced nursing. 2001;35(2):228-237.

122. Miller A, Morton S, Sloan P, Hashim Z. Can a single brief intervention

improve participants' readiness for interprofessional learning?

Journal of interprofessional care. 2013.

123. Wellmon R, Gilin B, Knauss L, Inman Linn M. Changes in student

attitudes toward interprofessional learning and collaboration arising

from a case-based educational experience. Journal of allied health.

2012;41(1):26-34.

124. . ( 1

) . . 2010;3(1):10-19.

125. Wakely L, Brown L, Burrows J. Evaluating interprofessional learning

126

modules: health students' attitudes to interprofessional practice.

Journal of interprofessional care. 2013;27(5):424-425.

126. .

. .

2010;2(1):2.

127. Boyle M, Williams B, Brown T, et al. Student attitudes toward a web-

based interprofessional education package. Journal of allied health.

2013;42(2):e33-36.

128. , , , .

o

. . 2009;4:51-57.

129. , , , , . IPE

IPW

. . 2012;4(2):84-95.

130. Mahler C, Berger S, Reeves S. The Readiness for Interprofessional

Learning Scale (RIPLS): A problematic evaluative scale for the

interprofessional field. Journal of interprofessional care.

2015;29(4):289-291.

131. , η , , , , .

. .

2015;64(1):25-34.

132. Kururi N, Makino T, Kazama H, et al. Repeated cross-sectional study

of the longitudinal changes in attitudes toward interprofessional

health care teams amongst undergraduate students. J Interprof Care.

2014;28(4):285-291.

133. Tani K. Community-based clinical education increases motivation of

medical students to medicine of remote area: comparison between

lecture and practice. The journal of medical investigation. 2014;61(1-

2):156-161.

134. . . .

127

1996;1:34-38.

135. . .

. 1998;29(6):385-391.

136. Kataoka HUHU. Measurement of empathy among Japanese medical

students: psychometrics and score differences by gender and level of

medical education. Academic medicine. 2009;84(9):1192-1197.

137. Stratton TDTD. Does gender moderate medical students' assessments

of unprofessional behavior? Journal of general internal medicine :

JGIM. 2012;27(12):1643-1648.

138. , , , .

1 2

. Dokkyo journal of medical sciences.

2013;40(3):175-184.

139. . . . 2012(12):211-

236.

140. Reddy S, Farnan J, Yoon J, et al. Third-year medical students'

participation in and perceptions of unprofessional behaviors.

Academic medicine. 2007;82(10 Suppl):S35-S39.

141. .

o

hidden curriculum. . 2012;101(1):201-205.

128

�� b�

129

��$��!%"�� #��"� ��#

Ĳ À ¹¾º Ĳ À ¹¿º Ĳ À ¹Àº

Ĳ Á ¹¾º ¢¶[pħ�q�� Ĳ Á ¹¿º 8�ê0õ` Ç ¹¿º

8Ê�Ê�Ê=

¿¿ ïæðħYõ¨õ :�êYõ¨õħ�B � £�ħy�

¿½ ĞďûĀĤħĀĘý�� ĀĘýw�¼ģĕĨĆĤ y�

¿¾ ĞďûĀĤħĀĘý:� Co& 2üĚĦĐÍĞďûĀĤħĀĘýÎ:a :�

¾Ä ĞďûĀĤħĀĘý��¹¾º O5)³¼��f R¼:a��¡ y�

¾Å ĞďûĀĤħĀĘý��¹¿º ��ęĥĊĦĎĨćġĦ¼ĎĨěq9 y�

¾Æ ĞďûĀĤħĀĘýF5 F5S�¼;h_¼üĦċėĠĨ y�

ı Y¨õê`sĩ �Ī �B �ùëÞðY¨õê`sù8í £�ħy�

Å :�w�13�oêeôÝæ�H¢¶Ë$�ê|zéãÒäăĤĨ

ę�éi�£�ħy�

Æ»¾Ã 13$�4�:� "u«13ĩ��ñÝÙë�?ê�9Īå13x0:� :�

�.

�.

ąĜĠēĄĨćġĦĭĖĨĐĒĨćčę ��æ±øöUséãÒä8í £�ħy�

Á "u«ê13$�éãÒä¹¾º "u«ê13$�ê|zæ¢¶ £�

Â 13$�ù8íéÑáâä 13$�ù8íéÑáâäêKlÔ £�

Ã "u«ê13$�éãÒä¹¿º $��æÝä13ù�ö�ùçÓ·ÓÖ £�

¿ ÿģþĦĎĨćġĦ¹¿ºĞďûĀĤħĀĘýêP�ħ�d¼��éãÒäËăĤĨę

�R£�ħy�

À

�.

�.

�.

�.

ÏZj��ê8�]��nÐ

ĮĬ¸13$�ù@¯ßöáðéL�æÜ÷ö4g�è�¤ù{Jßöáðé

È13åeôß�æËàê<bê~téãÒä}�åØöÌÉ13��æ�Hê±ªù}�åØöÌ

įĬĖĨĐĒĨćčęùIRßö4g�QGù§éãÚöáðé

È¸�Bù}�ßöÛæË��ù}�ßöÛæé±KùXãÛæ×åØöÌÉ¸4g��µ±�ùl�åØöQGùæöÛæ×åØöÌ

İĬ��æê°å(`-ąĜĠēĄĨćġĦù:¦ßöáðé

È4g�èąĜĠēĄĨćġĦU�ù§éãÚöÌÉO5)³ħ\�ê7mèU�ê4gù§éãÚËzréMÞä¬�é�ÓÛæ×åØöÌ

ÏZjêk�Õóì8��ê!�Ð

Êg��ëË��$�8®æê*+ĀģĂĠĢĝåÑõËÁE°éøáõ©Eå¯£Ü÷ö13$�*+ĉĜĒĨéÕÚöĮE~ù>¥æÝá��åÑöÌ13$�ù@¯ßö�

åL�æèö4g�è�¤æËĖĨĐĒĨćčęùIRßö4g�QGù{JÝË"u«×WÔö��$�ê¢¶îê}�ùvðöÌïáË$�4�:�æĞďûĀĤħĀĘý

:�ù©ÞäË(`-ąĜĠēĄĨćġĦù:¦�é8íÌ

ÊèÕÊÍĞďûĀĤħĀĘýÎ:�ëË¢6c°é86ê��a�ò13å�ÓÛæéèöêåË�9Ü÷ác°6êăĤĨę j×L�æèöÌ

Ê

Ê/^ 8Ê�Ê�Ê¶ 8�`s >¥�

¾ ÿģþĦĎĨćġĦ¹¾º ąĨĈ��ī13$�ê:²éãÒä £�

13$�

��

V¾ %

��ąĨďûĔĨċĨ ĩÊÊTÊÊAÊÊĪ

Í$8]�ğďĤħąúħĀģĂĠĢĝÎæê±ª

āüđĢüĦê´�

ąĜĠēĄĨćġĦ N�æ$Dê±� ČĨĝ$�

�Ê�Ê, ��#� 8E'ì%^

13$�*+ĉĜĒĨĮ y� ¾ E ©E

�.

�.

�.

�.

�.

:�& 8~

:�& 8~

�.

�.

130

��$��!%"�� #��"� ��#

Ł ³ ®±¯ ćęĜĔĆĦĈĝĤ Ł ³ ®²¯ Ł ³ ®³¯

Ł ´ ®±¯ �«Rfĥ�g�� Ł ´ ®²¯ 1�ì,õX » ®²¯

J^y�

1¢ 1�

2�¨"�1t

2�¨"�1t

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

�*

�*

�*

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

�*

�*

2�¨"�1t

2�¨"�1t

�*

�*

1¢ 1�

�*

�*

1¢ 1�

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

2�"�1t

ķ°ĸ ½¾¼ĽčĦĚ x�®²¯-.ëÚÞö�� x��ì�Tì

2§ëæØço�

Ĺ

Ĵ 2�0)�ìm�®±¯ 2�ìPõ�õĥ�<��®±¯ o�

ĵ 2�0)�ìm�®²¯ 2�ìPõ�õĥ�<��®²¯ o�

Ķ 2�0)� o�

��ĥo�ľ?¤ì1îùPõ�ö �¬1�éğėġĄĈĝĤëæØç1ï®±¯

į �k ì-. xù1ï®·¯ �ku��kw¦ì��Ûô ��

İ°ı �k ì-. xù1ï®¸¯ -. xì�2ù�ÙöąĠĦĘo�®³¯ o�

Ĳ°ĳ �k ì-. xù1ï®¹¯ -. xì�2ù�ÙöąĠĦĘo�®0)�¯ o�

Ī �k ì-. xù1ï®´¯ �k ìUF xëæØç1ï®²¯ o�

ī°Ĭ �k ì-. xù1ï®µ¯ -. xì�2ù�ÙöąĠĦĘo�®±¯ ��

ĭ°Į �k ì-. xù1ï®¶¯ -. xì�2ù�ÙöąĠĦĘo�®²¯ ��

Î°Ï -. x/}2� -.ën,áçì2�®³°µZ¤¯ 2�

ħ ĀğÿĤďĦĈĝĤ ĀğÿĤďĦĈĝĤĥ�«S~ ��

Ĩ°ĩ �k ì-. xù1ï®³¯ �k ìUF xëæØç1ï®±¯ o�

Ê -.ì xĥ=etjù|ö®´¯ �7;ìtjé�Aĥ xĥ��ëæØç1ï ��ĥo�

��ĥo�

Ë 2�ĀğÿĤďĦĈĝĤ 2�ĀğÿĤďĦĈĝĤ ��ĥo�

Ì°Í -.ì xĥ=etjù|ö®µ¯ -.eÑG�àúì��Ûô1ï

Ç -.ì xĥ=etjù|ö®±¯ -.eì[ôáé�A�«Ñ xìrpëæØç`� o�

È -.ì xĥ=etjù|ö®²¯ -.eì[ôáé�A�«Ñ xìrpëæØç`� o�

É -.ì xĥ=etjù|ö®³¯ v�-.ìtjé�Aĥ xĥ��ëæØç1ï ��ĥo�

Æ �k ì-. xù1ï®²¯ =�_3w¦ì��Ûô ��

Å ĘĢėþĎĈĝēğĉĚÑ�a�s®²¯ ĘĢėþĎĈĝēğĉĚÑ�a�s ��ĥo�

ĘĢėþĎĈĝēğĉĚÑ�a�s ��ĥo�

Ä ćęĜĔĆĦĈĝĤĽĖĦđēĦĈĎĘ®²¯ ��é¥øöLhëæØç1ï ��ĥo�

Ã �k ì-. xù1ï®ľ¯ ]�u�]�w¦ì��Ûô ��

Â ćęĜĔĆĦĈĝĤĽĖĦđēĦĈĎĘ®±¯ xćęĜĔĆĦĈĝĤì/} ��ĥo�

Á ĘĢėþĎĈĝēğĉĚÑ�a�s®±¯

À ½¾¼ĽčĦĚ x�®±¯ čĦĚģĦĄĥğĦČĦĈĎĘ ��ĥo�

6��

¿ ĀğÿĤďĦĈĝĤ �{��Ñ:��ìiHÑąĠĦĘ1�ì/\ ��ĥo� �*

�*

ÕQa�{ì1�V�{dÖ

ľļ-. xù8£ãöåòëE�éà÷ö/\zê|�ùqCãöåòëÑ¿-.è[ôã�éÑäì4YìtjëæØçs�èÝöÑÀ-.��é�Aì¥

�ùs�èÝöÒ

ĿļĖĦđēĦĈĎĘùBJãö/\zI@ù�ëæÞöåòëÑ¿�<ùs�ãößéÑ��ùs�ãößéë¥DùOæßéÜèÝöÑÀ/\z�ª¥ ùc

�èÝöI@ùéößéÜèÝöÒÕQaìb�Úóî1��ì��Ö

Ð\�{íÑ�� x1¢éì%&āğăĜĞĚè×õÑ´?¤ëøåõ�?è£�à÷ö-. x%&ĊęēĦëÚÞöľ?tù6�éáå�{è×öÒ-. x

ù8£ãö�èE�éêö/\zê|�éÑĖĦđēĦĈĎĘùBJãö/\zI@ùqCáÑ�k ÜNÙö�� xì�«ðìs�ùlòöÒñåÑ��Ño

�Ñ x/}2�ù�âçÑ$X(ćęĜĔĆĦĈĝĤù2�zë1ïÒ

+W 1Ð�Ð�Ð« 1Ð�Ð�Ð5 1�Xh

Ó 1V�ěĐĠĥćûĥāğăĜĞĚÔéì¥�

ĂýĒĞýĤì©{

G�é >ì¥ G��DìčĦĚ x

-. x

º²

�º±!

�{ćĦĐüĕĦċĦ ĺÐÐKÐÐ9ÐÐĻ

ŀE�

�ŀ¡M

�Ð{Ð' �{�� 1?#î!W

-. x%&ĊęēĦľ o� ± ? �?

�

131

S S

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2016/4/19 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

/

1. 2. 3. 4. /

1. 2. 3. 4.

/ 1. 2. 3. 4.

/

1. 2. 3. 4.

1. 2. 3. 4.

/

/

132

(

2 4E 4 :M 1 8

53

5

6

5 5

6

K

5 E5

5 5

6 E5

5

6 E5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17 N

18

133

- ) ) (

3 2 4 1 2

33

3 3

10 &�F+�E�@3A3L9CN";A3=0

20 &�F �I��N$ E(GA3=0

30 �%4JFUPVSTRQN#��E�GA3=0

40 �%4JFUPVSTRQN�68�MA3=0

50 �,D�.BH�-:N�?A3=0

60 �*E�!B2?=0

70 ��N5>OC�/B5LIK�B)';=0

80 �%I�F�GE�;1<7��B5L��B2?=0

医療プロフェッショナリズム概念の検討および評価尺度の開発 ... · 2019....

Documents