pil - genprinciplescases

Upload: joseph-paul-alday-macasa

Post on 06-Apr-2018

234 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    1/121

    #05:-.4190!55308$&!#%

    ,3,

    #4.94-07

    #$50994307;8#&',80.:9;0$0.709,7#!#%#,8$0.709,741010380!#,8:/9470307,#,8$0.709,74142207.0,3/3/:897,3/$'##$0.709,741:89.0 708543/0398

    #,24343,083843-0,1,85099430711.04190$4.9470307,,3/89,38,4073,3/0147708543/0398

    !

    %88,3473,,.943147574-943957023,73:3.943

    98349/85:90/9,943$05902-07708543/0390.:9;0$0.709,7,:9470/9025479,94341943841147037.094-05:7.,80/174257;,9084:7.08,3/.70,90/,7.0574.:702039.4229900.425480/41904907708543/03980703 147902502039,943418,/5745480/25479,943%070:54347$05902-07070350994307#,24343,08,7.05,3907,3/5708/039419044!,,,3/473!,39078884.,943480202-078,7008003,0/390574/:.943417.0,3/.47310/905099430703,;07739,932,347,9902593942,08,/25479,94341147037.090,14702039430/708543/0398,70,.9394:9:78/.9434730.08841:78/.943-0.,:80#05:-..94.,00/7050,847,203/8#05:-..9405.9574-989025479,943417.0,3/

    .47390#.0,3/473/23897,94347 ,349074;0732039,03.9,950994307,83449075,38500/,3/,/06:,907020/39047/3,7.4:78041,,3/9,9,57023,73:3.943830.088,714790570807;,943419079841905,7908/:7390503/03.98.,80,3/94570;03990:/2039907031742.42330110.9:,!099430757,0/907014709,98,/509943-0;03/:0.4:7809,9,794157023,73:3.943-01479988:0/70897,33708543/039907,039847705708039,9;0817422502039390/0.84341900.:9;0$0.709,7942547990,14702039430/147037.0,3/9,9,1907/:00,73:/2039-0703/070/2,38,/3:3.9435072,3039

    4799708543/0398070706:70/9410907,38079490509943.90//,3/50994307857,147,794157023,73:3.943,88091470,73,9.-495,7908,550,70/,3/,7:0/47,4704;07,20247,3/:2,810/84799070,1907-90708543/0398438/073,907439,9907084:9438,/3./0392,706:708420

    57434:3.0203989,94:/-02470,557457,903,/0.8434390207984190.,80908,20,88091470,734390207989070,1907%05,790840;07,;0/907994,7:047,,94:.4:380147708543/039810/90720247,3/,

    $:11.03.415099430783907089

    #08543/03982,39,39,99089,9:84150994307,8,7.05,3907/408349;028:11.03939070899410905099430703,3/80.:709070019070357,0/147013/342079398570903805,791742574-939025479,943417.0,3/.473-90#.0,3/473

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    2/121

    /23897,94347,349074;0732039,03.#05:-..94/0.,7083$0.9439070419,99054.41904;073203989403,03905:7.,80419080-,8.144/8/70.917429480903,3981,7207874078574/:.078,3/,3/43078 390!553084894/8548041907574/:.98,9,57.09,9,1147/902,1,7,3/:89709:73147907,-47,3/.,59,3;0892039!:78:,399498574;84350994307,8,5,39079,7.0,3/418:-89,39,574547943 803990/94,.,3.0948094904;0732039907.0934

    800894-:,-74,/4704;0783.0905:7.,80418,/.4224/9,;094-00110.90/95:-.1:3/82,37,80/-9,,943,3/,8,7.0574/:.07,3/,3/4307509943072:8930.088,7-0,9,5,07914489,90,88:11.039507843,9,3/390708994800:/.,,8889,3.09,;09470897,33,90-00;0894-0,3,99025994:3,1:/8-:7808,/1:3/8

    ,:894341,/23897,9;07020/08

    #08543/0398,88,5099430787994907001857,0/147-0.,:800,83490,:890/,,/23897,9;07020/08,;,,-0942-01470.42394.4:790,;0,70,/0/40;079,990573.50706:7390570;4:80,:894341,/23897,9;07020/088349,55.,-0070906:089433/85:9085:70,0,430 4707090.43974;0790/,.985,90390,47,850714720/94:9:78/.9434730.08841:78/.9434707090708543/0398,/05,79203980.709,7480,.98,8,3,907044190!708/039-0,790250/47,88:20/,5574;,4190,9907:3088,.9:,/8,5574;0/-2470709070,70.7.:289,3.083/.,9390:703.41:/.,3907;03943 %0.,80,9-,71,8:3/070,.43041901470430.05943894900307,7:0#08543/0398.43903943890701470:3903,-0

    079841509943078.,:8041,.943

    #08543/03986:08943908:11.03.41509943078.,:8041,.943:5439090479,9905745480/25479,94336:0894383494;0730/-#05:-..9848,3/-:9,8,:9470/-90!708/039,8422,3/0730114729,7894.505:754808390007.80418,00/,:9479:3/07$0.94341422430,9.94 9,93.,8084130.088990!708/0394788:-47/3,9082,9,08:.570;039;020,8:7014790708947,9434144/47/07

    ,3/2,3903,3.04150,.0,3/9,9,8422,3/07301414:7,720/147.0890!708/0398/:9-4:3/945705,7014790.,03041970,9841,747020703.94:9 ,93147,3850.,,:9479

    #0,7/088410907#05:-..947050,8#05:-..94,8.43903/0/-50994307070343.4:7;0300/349-00570880/0,70:3,324:8419045343,88:239,98,/#05:-..948893147.09,99094.98,70,55.,-094905745480/25479,94336:08943-0.,:8090,3:,0418,/,888:.,8943.:/093905:7;0907041,25479,9438417.0,3/.47339490!55308!:78:,3994#05:-..9498,-0:3,1:147 ,3507843,884.,943.47547,943474;0732039,03.94254797.0,3/.473394,35439390!55308,94:-,410.059439,//89,9 90!708/0394190!55308 2,,:94709025479,943419080.4224/908974:,3

    4;0732039,03.9,902,/083,90890.43/94385708.7-0/3$0.943418,/.9,705708039$2,7#05:-..9405.90343890#.0,3/473/23897,94347 ,34;0732039,03.17422547937.0,3/.473

    #08543/0398,0040;079,98,/574;843841#05:-..948,3/574-939025479,943417.0,3/.473-,34;0732039,03./4349,559425479,94382,/0-904;07320399801-0.,:8090,99078349,4;0732039,03.%890478/0;4/412079%005,79203941,943,010380,3/90720/47.084190!55308,80,8708543/03980703,3/0,.,3/0;07411.07,3/025400414:74;07320394:74;0732039

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    3/121

    ,03.08,3/47,0398%0,55.,-9418,/,80;039425479,9438-904;0732039,88:.-0.42082470,55,7039030.438/079,9

    %025479,9435072990/3#05:-..94894-0,:9470/- 90!708/0394190!55308,3/03.0-4743-0,141904;07320394190!55308

    220/,90,19070343390#.0,3/473,/23897,943,3/,349074;0732039,03.17422547937.0,3/.473$0.94341#05:-..94,//89,9 9025479,943417.0,3/.47380199457;,905,7908 :5435,20394190.47708543/39,089:83/.,939,94357;,905,79082,254797.0:3/0798574;8438,3/

    8/017425708.7-3,1303490.00/3!,3/25784320394134924709,31;00,78147948048,;4,90,3574;84341#05:-..9447,37:0,3/70:,9435742:,90/5:78:,39907094$0.943418,/.9574;/089,919041103/078,5:-.411.,,3/47025400808,-08:-0.99490,//943,503,9850.10/907035:-.411.,8,3411.0741904;07320399801,8/893:80/1742411.078470254008413897:2039,90841904;073203903.0 90/:,:9470/,.984190147207,70948041904;0732039:30948041,4;07320393897:2039,9.2,,;0,507843,9419843

    /893.9,3/805,7,9017429,941904;0732039,88:.%0574;843841#05:-..94,7039870850.90;03247005.9$0.943907041574;/08,82,7,//943,503,9147,3411.074702540041904;07320394;4,908,-098479407,90890;4,94341,3574;843418,/.903.0903903994,55908,209497,38,.94382,/0 -90;074;073203985,9039

    3/00/9070897.943825480/38,/#05:-..98,702070 ,//943,9494805708.7-0/3422430,9.9403990/3.994;03,9;0574/:.98,3//42089.0399089057010703.03905:7.,8041,79.08 147904;0732039!:78:,3994$0.943907041

    %0!:7.,80,3/6:52039;84341904;07320394190!55308 ,3/4907411.078,3/025400841902:3.5,,3/574;3.,4;07320398 ,3/904;07320394190!55308,3/41.,79070/.908-4,7/8.42288438 -:70,:8/05,7920398411.08,03.08-7,3.08,3/-4/0841,3/08.759433.:/34;0732039430/.425,308,:9470/94706:89435:7.,8047.4397,.9472,0/8-:78020398147,79.082,907,8,3/8:55081475:-.:805:-.-:/38475:-.4788, ;057010703.0942,907,8574/:.0/390!55308 47390&390/$9,908,3/ 94/42089.039908 8:-0.99490.43/94380703-04850.10/25,888:550/

    &3/0798574;8433,5:7.,808 -904;07320393.:/394802,/0-,3/4714790,720/147.0857010703.08,-0;03942,907,8574/:.0/390!55308 %025479,9433;4;0/390.,80,9-,7;4,908980307,54.414:74;0732039,8/0174290574;843841#05:-..9848,3/

    %0,99025994:891905745480/25479,943-3;4370,8438413,943,80.:79

    570/.,90/:5439047803389:,9433,48,3/'093,2,3/9070.039903843.70,90/-90,,8,574-02,3/90,00/540784190!708/039,8422,3/0730141,,720/147.08390!55308:3/07$0.9434190,943,010380.9422430,9.944;07448901,.99,99057490.943414.,5,39078417.0,3/.4733,2,33079,94:/148907,3/,..007,908018:11.03.3904.,574/:.943418,/.4224/908.43899:908,1,.9479,98;9,944:7,-99420095488-03,943,020703.;0319039039325479344/83,39.5,943418:.020703.07094-48907:59,9,-990,99074:/3890,/-025,70/19025479,943070842,/0,894/8.4:7,04:71,72078174203,3390574/:.943417.0

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    4/121

    08/0890894.53417.0,3/.4731475:75480413,943,80.:79,3/473,943,020703.893905:7;041#05:-..94$0.943907041057088,:9470890#.0,3/473/23897,94394,..:2:,90894.8,8, 3,943,70807;038:.6:,39908,892,/002574507,3/30.088,7942009,3.439303.084704;07947/,389,9 90-:1107894.80/,8,3,943,70807;0-0/054890/-90,/23897,943974:4:990.4:397:3/0790574507/85078,5,38,3/2,-0700,80/43:543904..:7703.041.,,290847 020703.08

    25,88,550/

    ,390574;843841$0.94341422430,9.94:543.708543/039870842:.,7034980100.:947%020704:930900307,4-0.9;08418,/08,943%020,3814790,99,320394194804-0.9;08,708:-0.994.43708843,08,943%:890.43/9438:3/07.90807;.0841.9038,83/.,90/38,/$0.9432,-0,;,0/41,70574;/0/1473$0.9438,3/94418,/422430,9.94$2,7$0.943907041850.108902,33073.7084:7.0830.088,71474:73,943,/0103802,-080.:70/-904;07320394190!55308-:943 /:73,3,943,24-,943 ./4083490893107039,90701470390,-803.041,3,943,24-,9438,/7084:7.088,-0574/:.0/38:.2,3307,84370882,-4907,8574;/01742920949203841,7,87.0,3/.473,70.43.0730/#05:-..9848,3/,3/422430,9.94,708:.,8

    #08543/0398.9047338:554794190757090380-:93;,330,23,943419047.90/8489,94737010770/9490540784190!708/039/:73,7920 47030,85,.0/90.4:39747,5,79907041:3/072,79,, $3.030907.43/9434-9,38390.,80,9-,78,/472070574;089,9708543/039890471,..0590/4:/30110.95,.090!55308:3/072,79,,94:9,/0.,7,94341900.:9;0949,90110.9,98478094:/005:8507509:,:3/072,79,,

    9,8-0038:0890/9,90;031905745480/25479,943;4,90/#05:-..9848,3/984:/30;0790088-05072990/-0.,:80970/4:3/89490-03019419050450 $,:8545:0898:5702,0988,/

    19070070,4.,8479,0417.090,7:203929,;08420;,:0:990708543/0398,8

    411.,841984;0732039,;0057088,11720/,,3,3/,,39,990708347.08479,03/9025479,9438,;40/147894.50 41907234990.;,3545:,943

    :909:814490708543/03989703/4194:99,8,24708074:825.,9439,9,550,7843908:71,.0925089,91,300.:9;0411.07-00;089,9.425,3.09,.079,389,9:90349-03019905045008,9-07994/870,7/9%,9/0,2:89-0700.90/089;0:3/07,7:041,

    3/9039050450,700907574/:.07847.438:20784,8708543/039805.9,/29#05:-..9848,3/070,5574;0/-9008,9:7014790-0301941574/:.078,3/.438:20780905045092:891449,99001,7041905045008570.80390.425,3.098,/.98

    98349147708543/03900.:9;0411.078349480990743453438,,3899,9419008,9:70,3/,/45920,3847,8948099480.98,93,:93,9480,85072925479,943-:9:3/07.079,3.43/9438.,;0349-003,3/84:/-0.4250/9

    '%0.4397,.989'093,2,3/:72,

    98,89.43903/0/9,9904;07320394190!55308,8,70,/039070/39494.4397,.9814790!:7.,80417.0430990#05:-.41'093,2,3/,34907990

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    5/121

    4;073203941:72,9,99080.4397,.98.43899:90;,/00.:9;0,70020398:3/0739073,943,,9,98:.,70020398-0.,20-3/30110.9;0:54390833907041-705708039,9;08905,79089070949,93.,8041.431.9-09003#05:-..9848,3/4390430,3/,3/,14702039430/.4397,.984390490790,990784:/570;,-0.,:801,970,9,3/,89,9:90,703.4388903990,.490790.431.92:89-07084;0/:3/0790207.,3:7857:/03.031,;474190430.8,908935439419209,950994307

    0703,88,890;,/941,.9841900.:9;070,9;0941470370,9438390.43/:.941.90$:570204:79.,334939071070,3/90,14702039430/.4397,.98,;0,70,/-003.438:22,90/904;07320394190!55308,;3,70,/5,/9057.041907.03;4;0/90703974:770;4.,-009907841.70/931,;4741908041908,/.4224/9013/34207939857090380

    %04:7983498,9810/9,99089,9:8418,/97,.98,8,00/00.:9;0,70020398,8-0038:11.039089,-80/%05,7908948,/.4397,.98/434950,794,;070,7/0/908,20,800.:9;0,70020398:90;03,88:239,98,/.4397,.982,574507.438/070/,800.:9;0,70020398908,20,70:3,1:,80,83:,3/;4/1742,.43899:943,;054398,/,70020398-033.43889039990574;843841#05:-..9848,3/94:90!708/0392,:3/0790207.,3.43899:943,889020390739400.:9;0,7002039894:9570;4:808,9;0,:947902, 349-00.:9;0,700203903907394,97,38,.943.8574-90/-89,9:90803,.90/5747907094&3/079043899:943902,31:3.94341900.:9;089403147.0,803,.90/-437088%01472072,349390710703905071472,3.0419008,9;0540784190,99070.059390007.80418;094540702,349/010,908,9;003,.9203989,9,;0,.6:70/9089,9:841,- 3/70.97050,3908,20974:,300.:9;0,7002039574;/3147905071472,3.04190;07,.9574-90/-8,/,8

    %0207.,3904794900110.99,93900;03941.431.9-09003, 970,9,3/,89,9:9090430.8,908935439419208,570;,8349,55.,-09490.,80,9-,7147708543/039834943,/29-:9,84 38899,990.4397,.98,/;0790/94,70349970,908$,/90472,-0:8910/:5439074:3/9,9970,90894.90&390/$9,908883,947706:7090,/;.0,3/.4380394198$03,90,3/03.041,-7,3.419008,9;0/05,79203948:.:891.,943.,3

    -0;03,870,7/800.:9;0,70020398349,:9470/-570;4:808,94394:9.425090:58099390573.5041805,7,9434154078,3/908890241.0.8,3/-,,3.08.,701:3/,2039,34:7.43899:943,809:5,3/9,94190&390/$9,908

    870,7/8906:089430907,339073,943,,70020392,-03;,/,90/-4:7.4:7988:11.09948,9,99043899:9434190!55308,8.0,780990/9390,1172,9;0-574;/33$0.9434179.0'9070419,990$:570204:792,349-0/057;0/4198:78/.9439470;070;8070;078024/147,117243,550, .07947,747794107747,890,47907:0841.4:792,574;/013,:/20398,3//0.700841310747.4:7983.,8083.90.43899:943,947;,/941,3970,9,47/3,3.04700.:9;047/074770:,943836:089433490747/84:743899:943,:94708903:1.,94341,970,934943039.431.989901:3/,2039,, -:9,840397:38.4:390794,3,.941437088

    %0,00/.438:22,9434190,14702039430/.4397,.989'093,2,3/:72,/408349703/0798.,80,.,/02.#05:-..94034384:74;07320393491742039073394.4397,.98147905:7.,80417.0-:917422547937.00.059:3/0790.43/9438!708.7-0/38,/.9&543904907,3/#05:-..94,8942,310,9:7083,20,9706:708904;0732039945:7.,807.0,3/.473 /70.917424:74.,5,390787407847,3/43078,3/-9574-98 25479,9438417.0-904;0732039,3/0,;088:.25479,94389457;,905,7908%05;49,88:0398.,8080907905745480/25479,943.,8349-003.438:22,90/,80980,10,8-0

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    6/121

    ,89,:/.,/0.,7,943410,941905745480/25479,9434:/349.42504:74;073203994/01,:93905071472,3.0418:.4-,9438,892,,;0.4397,.90/9908007841907.036:08943-0.,:80,8/01742901,.99,98,/4-,94382,-0.4250/994:925479390.4224/939490!55308905745480/25479,9432,89-00,0/-.4253990574;84384190,14702039430/,8

    '%0794157023,73:3.943

    %0202-07841904:79,;0/;0703945343843906:08943090747349708543/0398070384:/-003430/17422502039390,14702039430/5745480/25479,94340;07902,4791,;4789030,9;0;0147.70,843903:3.94357,0/147.,3349-07,390/

    ##:/20398070-703/070//0.,739,9708543/0390.:9;0$0.709,7,/,3/,834540794,:94709025479,94336:089439,900.00/0/8:78/.94337,3938,/,:94798,/25479,94383498,3.9430/-,,3/8.4397,79498574;8438,3/9,9147,.4190706:8902,479903:3.94357,0/1472:89-0,3/8,..47/3/030/988447/070/

    0343!,/,,-7,/47#00843,3/,,39, .43.:7!,70/08,3/#0,,.43.:7390708:9

    $05,7,9053438

    &%$%.43.:773

    &3/07#05:-..94.9440110.943,98:3,1:147,3507843,884.,943.47547,943474;0732039,03.94254797.0,3/.473394,35439390

    !55308%00.059438190708,30893472230398479,0418:..4224/9412:.7,;9,894.43899:903,943,020703.3..,80,325479,9432,-0,:9470/-90!708/0390384.07910/-90,943,.4342.4:3.

    40;0743:30#05:-..9,803,.90/574;/39,99025479,943417.0,3/.473.,343-02,/0-57;,905,79089070-574-931742/438490#.0,3/473/23897,94347,349074;0732039,03.#05:-..9/4083490570887050,#05:-..9-:9437050,84724/10/94805,7989070419,9,703.43889039998574;8438%06:089439,934,78088,89003,.9203941#05:-..9900110.941574-93.425090904;073203917422547937.0,3/.47339490!55308

    ,3807839030,9;0$3.098.9/4083493,32,3307574;/01479025479,94341

    7.0,3/.4733.,80413,943,020703.90574;8434190147207,439,92,990784:/89,3/1479,983493.438890399,3574;84302-4/0/3#05:-..9%0#.0,3/473/23897,94347,349074;0732039,03.2,9070147089254797.0,3/.47339490!55308,8574;/0/3#05:-..9190708,/0.,70/3,943,020703.

    %03096:089439,9,78088,3904;0732039,:94709025479,943417.0,3/.47370,7/08841#05:-..919,98,:9470/-90!708/039,8422,3/073014190!553072,8,29,7570.,:943,720,8:7014729,7894.50

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    7/121

    #08543/0398,3807986:08943390,1172,9;0%0,/;,3.090,7:20399,99890!708/0398/:9948009499,990720/47.084190!55308,700,70/9490/01038084190.4:397,80,894901:12039414:739073,943,.4229203983$4:90,898,3900;0399050,.0,3/80.:794190,70,,703/,307%0894.53417.090,;078,3088039,706:70203941/0103805705,7,9433;04190290/4.,8:55,3/90574-,-0/87:59434197,/0,3/.42207.094:98/0.4:397083900;03941,720/489908,3/98

    29,7570.,:943,720,8:70830.088,7-0.,:804190:380990/.43/9438390$4:90,898,-47/07343,.9:,970,9841,720/.431.98,80;,:,90/-9039003.0$07;.041909,705,792039414:74;0732039%8,/;4.,.90.43903/13/88:554793903,943,/01038054.02-4/0/3$0.943414:7,943,010380.9422430,9.94.574;/08

    ,%0570807;,9434190$9,908904-,943410;07.903%080.:794190!55308,3/901700/423/0503/03.0,3/507509:,30:97,94190!5530#05:-.8,-0:,7,3900/-900254203941,.903894:9/893.943418047,0,3/,7084:7.08

    -%00254203941903,9438.9038,3/7084:7.081473,943,/0103808,-00110.90/-,3,943,24-,943

    .%03,943,24-,9438,3.:/09000.:94341,20,8:70830.088,7945,881742,50,.094,,714493

    /%0.;,:94798,,,8-08:57020%0!708/0394190!55308,890422,3/0730141,29,7147.088,-07085438-09,924-,94320,8:708,705705,70/,9,920825,888:550/

    3/00/13/39,9/0.,7,9434154.9,99080.:794190!55308,3/981700/42.43899:90890.4704190570807;,943414:7$9,90.890-,8./:9410;07.903,3/9,99480.:70.9803430/9,990!708/0390254,907084:7.08,98.422,3/:94;07,3/,-4;0,9,95407,3//:91:3/,2039,,8902,800290708903:3.9439,990.;,:94798,,,8-08:57020%83:3.943.,34320,39,90,570.,:943884:/-09,039438:709080.:79,3/570807;,9434190$9,90,3/94980110.9900254203941,7084:7.082,-07084790/9490,.9432:89,,8-09,03939017,20474190.;,:94799,7,:947984:/-0,72430/,3/.447/3,90/9.;,:947990430.05943-030390,.0,747/,384907800907#05:-..9347#05:-..9.439,38,30.0594331,;474129,7,.943.43.073325479,943417.0,3/.47330.059432:89-0897.9.43897:0/

    /893.94382,/0-09003904;0732039,3/4;0732039,03.3,3,990259949,0901472074:941904507,94341#05:-..9/8,700%04;07320394190#05:-.4190!55308:3/0790#0;80//23897,9;04/0701078949,90399974:.901:3.9438414;0732039,70007.80/3.:/390;,74:8,728974:.549.,,:947982,/0

    0110.9;0090790-0574;3.,2:3.5,4749071472414.,4;0732039070,8,4;07320393897:2039,970107894.47547,9438430/47.439740/-904;0732039945742490.079,3,850.9841900.4342.10414:7504504;0732039,03.907014702:8930.088,77010794904;073203998014190#05:-.,8/893:80/1742,34;07320393897:2039,9.,8,507843,9/893.9,3/805,7,9017429$0.943

    %025479,39543994/090723040;0780907084:/0343708543/03981742.,7734:99025479,94341907.0.,..47/3949070.47/,8-003,:9470/94-0254790/ 434;0732039944;07320390;09,550,739,990,77,30203994980110.9,8,70,/-003

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    8/121

    .43.:/0/904393,.3-03982502039,943%880;/0391742902,31089,9438:-2990/-90$4.9470307,07039,550,789,990.4397,.9147905:7.,80419438417.01742,/-0038343.94-07,3/147905:7.,804194381742:72,43.94-07-90,:9470/705708039,9;0841-494:74;0732039,3/904;0732039841'093,2,3/:72,70850.9;019897:09,94:74;0732039,8,70,/2,/0,1472,.42292039990803.4:397089070,7808906:08943,894090790,.9.,389-0

    250/0/,99889,041903049,9438%4:43988.47090708,/;0703.04145343987,9139434909,9902,479,80570880/9801,,3899%88,5,:8-0,999:/0147,/9079-00388:0/4:74;07320394:/,;0-0035,.0/3,570/.,2039070,8,30.088,7.43806:03.094:/,;094705:/,90,/:1472,0/,7002039949870,902-,77,882039,3/488411,.0%8,8,;4/0/-90:/.,89,9082,3850;3.0/-904:79

    ###.43.:773

    0.,:80415488-0.425.,94389,929-0,7,;,90/-28705708039,943419097:03,9:70,3/8.4504190.,80-01470984:79980947089,90,8.0,7,85488-09070,,3/4388:057080390/-90708543/03987057080393904;0732039

    74290,380710/-90$4.9470307,3-0,141708543/039806:490

    %025479,94341907.036:08943-90720/47.084190!553088147 29,7894.53,:9470/-90!708/0395:78:,399483070395407,8.422,3/073.01,3/,8,29,7570.,:943,720,8:70 3;09047803389:,9433,48,3/'093,2,3/92,,//0/9070.039903843.70,90/-90,,8,574-0238075025,888:550/

    :739047,,7:2039$03,947073,3/0,550,33-0,14190708543/039808070907,90/90254790/7.0,814729,7894.53,3/.0,/2990/9,984204190399490#.0,3/473/23897,9430025,80/,,3,3/,,39,97.0,83493903/0/14790#147/897-:9439450450,89070,8348479,0417.01479,95:75480-:99,8430.,30/1475,,-0.,:8098.4:/-09907570807;0/

    7429020247,3/:210/9070,1907-90$4.980307,,,390.,2,82,/0

    070850.91:70907,9090,7:2039834:7,3807/,90/.94-079,99025479,943417.084:9-003430/3985099438390007.804190,:9479;0890/390!708/0394190!55308,8422,3/073014190720/47.08 ,8,20,8:704129,75705,70/3088/02,3/0/-,70,,3/,.9:,970,941020703.390$4:9,898,3.4:39708 525,888:550/

    99089708834190:380990/.43/94383$4:90,898, 820704:73903943 94849030.088914790894.53417.0147,725:754808.890;0770,8431479025479,943

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    9/121

    8989025479,94336:089438-032,/0-90#05:-.4190!553081479843:80,3/907.083498:55480/94-054:70/3949045032,709,894,110.99057.094-05,/-905:-.525,888:550/

    ,90/4.43903/89,990,147,3941057088,3/.0,7574;843949,90110.9/4083493.:/0398574-94325479,943-904;0732039417.01479843:80,3/34914790.438:235:-.70,7/08841090790708479070834020703.525,888:550/

    74290,-4;0934943,550,78-:980;/0399,990708543/0398070349.43.0730/99057080397.089:,943.4317439390 .438:235:-.-:9070840,3/0.:8;0,190790894.53417.0147901:9:70:804190,72%088:0907014703.904;0732039,839070890/834909077.08254790/94;09050450,-074770,9078:55942,39,39057.0,9!507,39,147946:490,,3907.43903943907.083498:55480/94-054:70/3949045032,70994,110.99057.094-05,/-905:-.,89834914790.438:235:-.70,7/08841090790708479070834020703.-:909077.0.,30,-0

    254790/-90720/47.084190!55308,;40/147981:9:70:80349989,3/390574-947574;843841#05:-..9848,3/%02,47945343,-809814799070,8438984:79.,3349,..05990.439039434190708543/03989,99825479,9438-043/,3/4:98/0904507,94341908089,9:908.,343025,809,98003909047,/;,3.0/-90$4.9470307,,/,3074:89703/9,9-0.,:809054.0803:3.,90/390.90/,8,701479057490.9434190574/:.078,3/90.438:207890,7287024;0/1742907,55.,943%4,/459989047894574.,29008903.0390!553084197000.4342.74:5847.,880890574/:.07890.438:2078,3/90720/47.084190!55308,98247054790394:88900110.99406:,9090,729904;07320399801

    %03,,39025479,94341987.014729,7894.53884:994-0:8910/-90,00/970,941020703.390$4:90,898,3.4:39708:99008903.041988:55480/970,9,8:3,907,/0907230/-9005,79203941,943,010380,430070.,9,990700898,

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

    %0$:570204:793,77;3,990.43.:843:3,324:870,.0/81:,,704190/11.:9,3//0.,909,89,/94/8.,70985489438,-094-005490/-8420147907435:754808-.,23,3/2,39,550,79,9904:798:323/1:419059414:750450/:739080/,841,7/859,9957010770/94;08:-89,3.094903.09084190,9,300/90300/8419050450:7,380789,9904:79,801934,9073,9;09,/3.425,3.0998/:994/0./090.,80:543901,.9857080390/949%0708543/0398705708039390,/23897,943890,/1,892,39,30/,3/38890/9,990708347.08479,09,990254790/7.0834914790.438:235:-.,3/83498:55480/94-05,.0/3904503

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    10/121

    2,70994,110.99057.094-05,/-905:-.9,998840147894.534190,721471:9:70:80,8,20,8:704124-,9433901,.041,99005,79203941,943,010380:3,907,/0020/,970,9030/,720/.431.93$4:90,898,43174390/990801,.98:543.904;0732039,8-:9,3/70890/98.,800,;080,7.0/3;,31470,,:947947.403970,843894:8919825479,9432,/0,/2990/.4397,79490574;843841#05:-..9848,3/8,,/2990/-0.,:80708543/039830;07,82:.,8570903/0/9,990

    25479,9431:1890.43/9438850.10/39080,8-:9290/90280;089490.43903943.8907840/0103809,99825479,943/4083491,93908.450418,/,834:7;040;0790,8,70.0,7%0,8,70.42570038;0,3/907,55.,943/408349,/2941,30.05943%0,8,70,/06:,90425,3.0907098349/11.:92:.08825488-0%0,;40/020703.1,9,8349:7039220/,90

    398.4330.943985079303994-0,7323/9,990$:570204:79,8,/:9945071472:3/079043899:9439,894/0./003.,0/:54394/4843,3,557457,90574.00/3,.,8083.90.43899:943,947;,/941,3970,9,47/3,3.000.:9;047/074770:,943836:089430.,33490:/098/:9%4/4844:/-0.:5,-0/070.943434:75,7900825,909905:-.9,929-0,/;0780,110.90/,8,708:94198/0.843094:7825,9/408349,:9470:8948,3.943,3,.9.4397,794,55.,-0,8%01,:90899480489:--473.43903/0/,3/7057080390/-01470984:799,990708347.08479,09,990254790/7.083493903/0/14790.438:235:-.-:9147894.534190,723/1,834.,20/-01470905:-..4397,794904;0732039889,3/398.,809,990708300/147254790/7.09489,;0411:3074:708,9:70,8574;/0/1478:.,89:,9438,70,/89,90/90,8,70,/06:,90%025479,943417.0 :3/0790.43/94388091479390,8 2,-0,:9470/3494307090708,308938479,0-:9,8403908479,08 2230393490747/8,1:7020/9484;09089:,9438,;,,-014394804,;090/:99400.:9090,85071472907/:919070870,300/1479025479,943417.04,/4598420/:-4:820,38.30.0889,90870847994/4:-91:007.80419054074190!708/039,8422,3/07301419072349.4259902,3/,904190,:7888:55480/94-0,7020:3/07907:041,/45943,8,4;073203954.41909047419003/:891089020,38-7:83,8/0.43899:943,,3/0,70897,3982:89-0700.90/089003/:599003/411700/42

    47908070,8438.43.:7390/0.84341904:79

    #05:-.4190!55308

    $&!#%,3,

    #4,

    3843-0,1,3/3-0,1414907,03708/0398.47547,9438,3/5,79307858,/;0780,110.90/-#05:-..94 50994307;8#$0.709,7413,3.0,3/#$#%9%70,8:70741,3,708543/0398

    ,09,.,:.4,3/!.,4,3/$.5":8:2-3$,,,7,3/884.,9081475099430711.04190$4.9470307,2-7484!,/,,3/$4.947!,.1.4!/0,8974147708543/039

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    11/121

    $0.709,7413,3.098.,:0343008,3/8889,3998.,:44$$077,34147708543/0399%70,8:7074384#008,82.:8:7,0,7.,03/4,,82.:8:7,02,34#,;,774,82.:8:7,0

    ##

    %0.,80,3/88:030307,

    %84:79,8-01470990/0.,909,8415,883:54390;,/9,3/.43899:943,941,08,9;003,.920391:3/,2039,,3/1,770,.33831.,3.0%003,.92039548086:08943841/:0574.08854.05407,3/06:,57490.9434190,89,8454808,325479,3988:0411,.99,98090790.43/9438.90/85:90/,5:754798947020/70,47,.9:,089/2990/857331742,/00529,39,3/5489;03,943,89.25:8090,5:7547989457490.9.903,3/.4:397174290,03709,07%74:9,3/939010/410.4342970:,908437088,99025989497,38,903,943,,857,94381470.4342.3/0503/03.0,3/

    3,943,80.:7974490/390/7;0,3/:701473,943,8:7;;,,3/01,70394,.43.7090,3/9,3-020,8:708/0830/941700903,943,709,07174290.425093/423,3.04190,03849,990.4:397,3/903,9432,-017001742,8:55480/0.4342./0503/03.0,3/-43/,04901,.98,3/.7.:289,3.08:8919003,.92039

    !0793039574;843841#05:-..94

    #05:-..94803990/3.994#0:,9090#09,:8308830110.993,943,0890709,97,/0-:83088%02,3574;84384190.9,70,574-943,,3895078438349.90384190!55308,3/,,389,884.,94385,7930785847.47547,943890.,59,41.,703494430/-.90384190!55308174203,3/70.9473/70.9390709,97,/0,30.05943174290,-4;0574-94331,;4741,038,.9:,03,0/38,/-:8308843,4,70,40/94.4393:09403,0/90703:3088907.03808,701471090/3,..47/,3.0990,:39907/0,947;4:39,77097020393.,80413,9:7,5078438,3/1479030,78,190790,5574;,4190.947:3990057,9434190723.,8041:7/.,5078438,30.059439070174231,;4741.9038,3/:7/.,0399084190&390/$9,908,574;84314790147109:7041.038089403,0390709,-:83088147;4,9434190,8433,943,,943.43974098,3/20,8:708,3/,-47,3/4907,870,939497,/0.42207.0,3/3/:897,574-943,,38990089,-820394745033-,038,.9:,03,0/390709,-:8308841,//943,89470847-7,3.0841709,-:83088,574;843706:73,038,.9:,03,0/390709,-:8308894570803914770897,943990574507,:947908,;0710/89,902039.43.0733907-:8308808;3,24349072,99078903,9:704190-:83088907,88098,3/,-908,3/907411.08,3/573.5,411.0841:/.,039908,3/,574;843,439007841,0383403,0/390709,-:830884/094.4393:08:.-:83088147,5074/418243981475:754808416:/,943

    74:3/8:543.5099438-,80/3807907094

    !0994307147,3/3843-0,1,3/43-0,1414907,03708/0398.47547,9438,3/5,79307858,/;0780,110.90/-90574;843841#05:-..94-74:998,.943944-9,3,:/.,/0.,7,9439,98,/.98:3.43899:943,,3/94034390$0.709,7413,3.0,3/,49075078438,.93:3/0725,79.:,7.9,3/2:3.5,970,8:7078174203147.398574;8438!0994307,99,.890.43899:943,94190.9.43903/39,99/030894,03708/03989006:,57490.9434190,8,3//057;0841907-079,3/574507994:9/:0

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    12/121

    574.08841,908:-0.94190.983490570880/47.4257003/0/39099090704190.9;4,90839073,943,,3/970,94-,94384190#05:-.4190!5530890574;84384190.9,,3899097,3828843-,03841907709,-:8308897:070/9,78:..08843,3/9480706:73534.,59,,943147,.47547,943470399940399099403,0390709,-:83088;4,9090857941$0.9438,3/79.0,3/$0.9434179.0'419043899:943

    3,380790$4.9470307,,3/908.,4190941,3,.43903/9,990.9,85,880/390;,/007.80419054.054074190$9,90.007.808,:9470/39043899:9433903907089413,943,0.4342.8:7;;,90.9,8434308:-0.902-7,.0/39099034970,94739073,943,4-,9438,7031730/,870,7/8070/9,78:..08843439014728,110.90/-:990;,:041905745079834925,70/,3/903899:943413079,3.08434189,9:947473

    '!7023,7.438/07,943410,573.5083;4;0/

    ,%054.05407

    %0708346:089439,990.9,8,5574;0/390007.80419054.05407-:950994307.,289,998007.80398389,3.08,9903/0/-,;4,9434190.43899:943,706:702039841/:0574.088,3/06:,57490.9434190,8:9-01470574.00/39490.438/07,943,3/7084:9434190:92,9088:03;4;0/94:/-0094-0,7323/.079,3-,8.,3/1:3/,2039,,-0957023,7.438/07,9438390/090723,94341900;0770.:77039.431.9-0900354.05407,3/90:,7,3900841/:0574.088,3/06:,57490.9434190,8,98908.4504154.05407,3/4,7090/:0574.088,3/06:,57490.943.,:80870,90/949,9890574;3.0,3/5407419008,9:70,3/,98901:3.943,3//:94190.4:798%080.438/07,9432:89-0.0,7,3/.4770.9:3/078944/9,9907,55.,94394901,.984190.,802,-0-74:914799.,79,3/9088:0,..47/37084;0/

    9,8-0038,/9054.054078841,770,.338.4509,99,8-0.420,248925488-0942998800589/07;089808903.0174290;0708903.04190$9,9098019/408349300/94-00570880/47/0130/3988.450988,/94-0.409038;0980157490.943,3/8:7;;,,3/,88:.989024895489;0,3/,.9;041,4;0732039,574.08808902489088039,3889039,3/29,-0850.,8984:3/07,24/073/024.7,9.17,204707090/02,3/84184.09,3/413,9438,;02:950/94,2489:32,3,-057454794389010/,3/8.4504154.05407,8-0.420,2489-4:3/088:89,89010/8415:-.3907089,3/5:-.01,70,;0-0.420,2489,02-7,.3,3/,;097,38.03/0/:2,31470899078089,90/,80.,3349147080090300/8,3//02,3/8415:-.3907089,3/01,70398.4389,39.,33,3/5747088;047/840.,3349/029-01470,3/9009039478.4504154.05407-.,3/974:.90$9,90800894,99,347,.0;039070894701,70$4989,943899:9438/4349/0130908.4504709039419054.054074190$9,90,990/489480914799029,9438907041%0248925479,39419080,7090/:0574.088.,:80,3/9006:,57490.943.,:80

    -29,94384354.05407

    %0-,8.29,943841/:0574.088,3/06:,57490.943,7014:3/3901443574;8438414:743899:943

    $%45078438,-0/057;0/4110-07947574507994:9/:0574.08841,347,3507843-0/030/9006:,57490.9434190,879.0!43899:943

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    13/121

    %080.43899:943,:,7,39008.02-4/9008803.0413/;/:,-079,3/1700/423/024.7,.08,70349290/94.9038,430-:9,70,/2990/:3;078,3907,55.,94394:970,7/94,3/110703.08417,.041.44747413,943,9.4;845380/

    .%006:,57490.943.,:80

    %006:,57490.9434190,.,:808,,389:3/:01,;47,3/3/;/:,47.,8857;00,80,84890/8.723,943479045570884341306:,9983493903/0/94574-908,943.8290/09073904-0.994.98/70.90/47-907794793.8944507,909/408349/02,3/,-84:9006:,9,243708/039892070706:7089,9,50784388,-0970,90/,0:3/070.7.:289,3.08,3/.43/9438 -49,89457;008.4310770/,3/,-90803147.0/%006:,57490.943.,:80834931730/-08,943.,55084394948050784381,393,850.10/.,8819,5508,094,5078438938:..,88,3/70,843,-074:3/808981472,3,/893.943-09003948041,938:..,88,3/94804/434944043899:943,29,9438

    /%0/:0574.088.,:80

    %0/:0574.088.,:80,894/499070,843,-030884108,94303,.90/35:78:,3.0419054.05407890705:-.3907089,5:-.5:7548085:-.01,703;4;0/890.970,843,-30.088,714790,..42582039419008,9:7085:7548089349:370,843,-0,7-97,7474557088;0890708:11.03914:3/,9434770,8433.4330.9439902,99073;4;0/47,89070349-003,.,57.4:8:80419008,9;05407,390,28.43.0;0/-0,.0;0/-9020,38:80/47893492070,3:3:8910/390710703.0957;,903907089%080,70906:0894389,90,80390/:0574.08890898,550/

    %0.431.990701470-0900354.05407,3/90:,7,3900841/:0574.088,3/06:,57490.9434190,882470,55,70399,370,!7450770,90/905407,3/90:,7,39008,708:55480/94.4089%0-,,3.389008803.0478,9-08,/903/85038,-020,3814790,99,3203941092,90,857,943841,3/024.7,9.84.09%070.,3-034,-84:90540740;07007.8091479,94:/-097,33099070.,330907-0,-84:90-0791479,94:/20,3.0380,3/,3,7.$490$9,90.,3/057;050784384110-079,3/5745079574;/0/90708/:0574.08841,,3/50784382,-0.,8810/394.,8808,3/74:58574;/0/0;074308;039006:,57490.9434190,%090894789,3/,7/,8,,8870,843%054.0540708,9432:89-017274:3/0/435:-.3907089,3/01,70,3/,70,843,-070,9432:89089-090035:754808,3/20,383/1/893.943,3/.,881.,943,8-0032,/090702:89-0,70,843,-0-,881478,//893.943

    008,9;0/8.709433498:-0.994:/.,70;0

    43982,99074106:9,-0-,,3.3,98905745075,.0,3/7404190.4:79892:89349-04;07440/39017895,.09,99008,9:70.890.43899:943,7054894741

    54.05407,3/007.8089057074,9;041/09072339054.4190$9,908-147.041.7.:289,3.08572,790:/04130.0889,/06:,.4770,843,-03088,3/8/4241,3,5742:,90/390007.80419054.0540747419020,8:708,/4590/942502039905:-.54.4794,.0;05:-.39070893904907,3/.4:798,94:0,4:8:,7/,38413/;/:,-079,3/79,;030;07900880;3.0/,70:.9,3.09439071070990007.80419008,9;057074,9;0%0,;0/430840,70709070,8-003,.0,75,9039475,5,-0,7-97,7,3/:370,843,-0,-:80419008,9;057074,9;04704;07.4:798,703498:55480/944;077/0092,9054.,3/.4:79830;0736:70394908/424190,

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    14/121

    '.4342.574-02884:994-07020/0/

    990,-4;0.438/07,9438323/034574.00/94/0;0/70.93949088:03;4;0/190/85:90/08,9430702070,70:,943,8989903/.,90890704:/-0346:089439,991,89390092,908.4504108,9;05407:994081:7907,3/574-98,74:541708/039890,038174203,390703%0574-02-0.42082470.4250-0.,:8098

    8:-0.98,.4224397,/0474..:5,943,84/,884.099801.174290220247,,8,,8-003450394708/0398770850.9;0417,.0.44747.90385

    ,25479,3.041709,97,/03900.434241903,943

    3,5729;00.43420701,208574/:.0,9,990.438:20,3/.438:20,9,990574/:.090/0,0741.4:7808:3343:9,874:510/0;0458,3/1,208-0394;03.422:3908574/:.324709,3,990.438:20,3/300/3,3313903:2-074193890/4349574/:.090/0,07.420839408903.08;,08/0;045394-.422:3908,3/850.,,9433574/:.943-03890/0,07825479,3.0803,3.0/&3/0724/073.43/9438,3/89,3/,7/841;33.2,38300/8,;02:950/,3//;07810/94:3290/090398,3/574547943890709,07.4208,8088039,,890574/:.07-0.,:8097:29031390;,709

    41,79.0844/8,3/300/0/147/,10,705,.0/93900,870,.41.438:2078#09,/0,0785071472901:3.943841.,5,708390:2,3-4/97:.,90300/0/144/,3/8:5508,702389070/94202-0784190.422:3908.425783903,943

    %070.,3349-0,36:08943,-4:99025479,3.04190709,07390104190.422:39023890789490708/0398/,300/8144/3,983.70,8314728,3/90;,74:8990,/098,3/938300/0/147420,3//,100574;/088.:8942078,74:3/8894709907.047.4739018908,990;30,79085.08300/0/14790/,.4430,8.49894800;0390300/0,3/90970,/948090247/,7390.49089,90,74:9%0709,0790701470174290450//0790430741,82, 8,78,78947094904507,94741,/05,7920398947047,8:5072,7098842:.,5,7941/,94/,08903.0

    -%0,03709,07897,9

    %0,03709,072:89,;089,790/53897,/08398.4:397390-07.03907841545:,943%209070,8030,8:33433574;3.,9438,3/;,08$4-:97,/:,-03;,/0/9438,3/;,08340570/423,908390.908,3/-.03907841545:,94300;03543007831,7,,344807090-0333841.422:3910,550,723890739490/,300/84190708/0398,3/5:7.,83907,7.:9:7,574/:.01478,0390943898,3:3/03,-01,.99,932,3.422:390890,03,8705,.0/903,9;0709,070,884339897,/03/:89794:929,3/905,903.0,3/147-0,7,3.041,8,;0

    074,947059098,70:70/,92-:90,:8908041194:92:72:738:9841-70/,3/38403930-478,3/.:8942078,702,/0381,.0-:9000/8902349,3/0147098,3/

    147;08%0.422:399,083490412,80,550,7894-0,72088,3/097020:801:

    .00/,03.43974,3//423,3.0

    %0708,0307,100343905,7941905:-..,550,7894-097:0941,.9,-4:990.439743,3//423,395489439,990,03709,074/83903,94380.434244/,3/4907088039,8.493,2489,,79.0841/,1070,.90708/03982489974:23-.908,3/.03907841545:,9430,8,.6:70/34943570/423,3.0-:9,55,7039.439744;07/897-:94341,2489,3/84144/88:.,8:2-07,7/,709090874.0708/7:8

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    15/121

    8:,714:7,7.,3/8.470841490744/8,3/,79.083/070934914784203,943,.47547,9438090,7.90,2,7.490,.42,8,3/90.01,8.439744;07573.5,144/8,3/574/:.984:/0,8-0.4201:,3/.425090

    !0994307/03089,990708,03570/423,3.0,3/.43974390709,97,/03430-70,9988,/9,99010,78:314:3/0/,3/90970,982,30/3,3490798.,70/9,990,8

    207090708:9417,/.,82,3/5:70,3/:3,-,80/3,943,8203,0988,/8349,300203941.43974,84842,3:32,3,0,-01,.9478390709,-:830882,0.43974;79:,25488-0%01789,7:2039.-738:5,388:0411,.9207988074:8.438/07,943%049078,702,99078414534393900.:8;0.4250903.0419008,9:70,3/-043/4:757074,9;0945,88:543,3//0./0

    %0-0890;/03.0,709089,989.84390709,97,/0.5:9/43901:7083-,.,3/900900390.43899:943,.43;039430,7039010,741,03/423,943,3/.439744190709,97,/0,70,/10/9023/8414:70,/078910,78,3/28;38,3/900,7419003,.9203941903,943,,9434190709,97,/0,.9411.,89,989.8:3289,,-54394:994900;073.70,83/423,3.0,3/.43974-90,034190709,97,/0,8930889014439,-08

    88098 7488$,08

    0,7,3/#09,078,943,9

    489,-820398

    !0848!07.039

    897-:943!0848

    !07.039897-:943

    534

    3080

    9078

    534

    3080

    9078

    038:8

    534

    3080

    9078

    534

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    16/121

    3080

    9078

    534

    3080

    9078

    '#$$%$#$$$$!#$%$%

    0,7,3/#09,078,943,9

    90288098!0848

    7488$,08!0848

    534

    3080

    9078

    534

    3080

    9078

    038:8

    534

    3080

    9078

    534

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    17/121

    3080

    9078

    534

    3080

    9078

    892,90/88098,3/7488$,0841#09,89,-8203980,7,3/,943,941307803.2,7038:888:0/-90:70,:41038:8,3/$9,989.805,7920394142207.0,3/3/:89755413807

    %0,-4;089,989.8/43493.:/0.47547,9438,3/5,793078580901:70843534089,-820398,70,/3.:/020702,709;03/478480.,59,830.088,782,

    %0,-4;01:70870;0,9,93507.039,0/897-:94341,880898,3/74888,08,035,79.5,943,8890,/3.70,80//:73900,789897:041.4:7809,95348,;0900/03903:2-0741709,078-:9,03824709,32,0:5147903:207.,,5974:907,880898,3/74888,08.,;07,0-090038,3/80;03920894804190;072,3534709,078:2-0783709,078070/4349258:50747990,033;08982470.,59,-:8,3/80889480;0392082470,3/,382:.2470%08,20411.,705479543934:99490343570/423,3.041147030020398390709,97,/0702,789,990534709,078070,7003,0/32347709,07039075780884-807;0/-708543/0398903,9;03;08920398938570,/,3/90534709,07857,.9.,0508832,9907841.,59,.70/957.0,3/

    8:55

    /03.43974,3/970,98:-0.941,557003843343899:943,.43;03943

    9898/423,943,3/.43974.0-00;0,8-0038:11.039843940899,989008,9:7089,70939003,.920394190/85:90/3,943,,9434:/30;07,;0-003,/4590/%017,2078414:743899:943,84-00;0/39008903.04198,03/423,3.0,3/.439740390,5574;0/,7084:943.,9047.,/0.,73,24349079389,9989080380419043;039439,9905:-.3907089706:708903,943,,9434190709,97,/07:04%07,234190!553043899:9436:490/435,041!0994307%,9,89039940,78,4,3/900;039883.0903,;0349-003090750,8,3947.42147930,3$3.44190&3;07894190!5530840041,.422039343905,97243.,:80

    4190!70,2-0453089,9901,9078414:743899:943070207097,38,93900307,5704..:5,9434153484190/,30781742,03390708989,9,/,70,/-74:9:3/07907.4397490.42207.,,3/49070.4342.,.9;9084190.4:397$3.4!!49.,,90/5,3/,3,390.43.0734190202-0784190.43899:943,.43;03943147900.4342.104190.90383.4330.9439903,943,89.574;8438419043899:94308,8

    :99070,8-003,0307,10039,9,03/423,3.04;07900.4342.104190.4:3978349/087,-0,3/9,918:.,89:,94384:/702,3549.,3/0503/03.0

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    18/121

    ,430834:,7,3900943,943,89,-9,3/89703953457;,90.,59,8349-034:9470891742,03,3/890.4397441903,943,0.43424704;0798-:94170.0391472,943,3/03.0,703050703.0/92/,3/089,39&3/078:..43/9438904;0732039,8903897:2039,941903,943,,89489053,3/,88:209039,9;01349900,/0785390897:0147900.4342.1700/4241903,94338420,9908,20,9,99//390.7:8,/0147549.,1700/42%:89

    9043899:94303;8,08,347,30/24;020391479057490.94341903,94334943,,389905488-90841,720/3;,843-:9,84,,389980.4342.8:-:,943-,03390708983900.4342.10/!!49.,,-$3.490/5

    00139008903.041,03.43974,3/570/423,3.08109349076:,79078534-:830882032,3:1,.9:7078,3/574/:.078-00;0849010,790/,3078.4231742,03.43974,3/90057088803920398410.4342.3/0503/03.0930889070948#084:9434,5574;0/43:419019,943,.43;0394341534:83088203,3/,82,77084:943,5574;0/43,7.4190$0.43/,943,43;0394341,3:1,.9:7078,3/!74/:.078%02,3390897009,84-00;08,3/10,78,03570/423,3.0,3/.43974844:73085,5078.,;00/947,54390/4:93494394.43974-:994,03897,304/09070147013/,03/423,943,3/.4397494-0,1,.9,70,9574;0/-411.,89,989.8,3/109-,9080.9438,3/74:589,9.42548090534.422:39

    0,307841,03.43974,3//423,3.03709,

    :990/,3078,7831742,035,79.5,943390709,97,/0/4083498002940390570/423,3.0,43090708,570;,310039,98:.570/423,3.02,97:03/,307903,943,39070899,250.,59,:39415:75480,3/,.943,3/9474:47,3,943,03709,078,3/207.,398.,3,.938:..425090:3843,3/.43.079438:.;9,2,99078,890134157.0890/090723,9434190,24:394144/847,79.0894-02,/0,;,,-03902,709,3/0;0390.4.0419044/847,79.08904:/474:/3495,9743047/897-:909,910,7841/84.,94341903,943,0.4342,3/4190.4250908:-807;03.0413,943,0.4342,3/4190.438:235:-.,7034903970:314:3/0/,943,8574/:.078,3/.438:2078,0.,3-05,.0/.425090,9907207.%880,8:897,90/$:55480,3

    ,79.041/,:808/0870/94-05708.7-0/-90,038-0.,:8090574/:.07472547907/408349411079028:11.03957419847-0.,:80,30.425093,79.0411078-07574198147983974/:.9439,9,0384://4894,70094701:809480901789,79.0023,9391742907894.84110739030430,8,8:-899:9003.090574/:.078472547907841905708.7-0/,79.04798.438:207813/90,79.08://034:941905708.7-0/,79.04798.438:207813/90,79.08://034:941.7.:,943700/424197,/089:8.:79,0/,3/1700039075780.47708543/38:5570880/

    0.,30;0341,79079,3904709.,:897,94389484905073.4:831:03.0841,03/423,9437,;0,-:808,;0.,7,.9070/90007.804190709,97,/0-,03898,1,.993:/.,349.0..4:79841:89.02,3495745074;0744473470390390708984197:9,3/:89.09,990700898,0307,100343905,7941905:-.9,9,035,79.5,943390709,97,/0,8-003,9903/0/-,5073.4:8,3/39407,-057,.9.089020394341,1041.4:/8:11.01474:75:7548089,9,9842092047490790,;0.473070/902,70941088039,.4224/9080.473,3/7.0.70,93,791.,8.,7.90894:891,3/03,3.057419894:370,843,-057454794389,990,;04,7/0/088039,144/894903.43;0303.0,3/570:/.04190.438:235:-.842:.849,9904;0732039,8,/94089,-890,943,#.0,3/47347547,943948,;0905:-.1742907.4393:4:84,7/357,.9.08,3/903/03.089,990,;0;4,90/57.0.43974,80850.,43144/8,3/088039,.4224/9088:.9,99008,9:70,/9403,.9,,$0.#05:-..94,:9473907220/,90,3/,:942,9./05479,94314757.0.43974.43;.94389,990,;080.709.42-3,9438,24390280;0894.4397457.08.0,93904507,9434190,418:55

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    19/121

    ,3//02,3/9,990,;0.433;0/94-4.49943089207.,398,3/97,/07844:/349.,907470/94907/02,3/83:3,1:70897,39411700/424197,/0,3/039075780%0,70-00;0/-905:-.94,;00;,/0/9,,882:0/44/8,3/2430394,3/4:94190,3/;4,90/25479,3/05479574-9438.43974,8,3/9003/07843,3/.439025941,1:,:947998,84-00;0/9,990,;003,0/3.477:5935:-.411.,891,-:4:8-7-083/70.9.,:8390570;,03.0417,19,3/.477:59433904;07320398,2,9907411,.9,550,894

    :38.7:5:4:8,038,;0-0032,/0-49-904;0732039,3/-90743,1:/542,9.705708039,9;08,.943.250/,/298,570;,31003,-4:99008903.0412,34190,-4;057,.9.08

    %0.7.:289,3.08,-4;08091479.70,90014:3/0/10,789,947809382,.4203901:9:70%05708039/423,3.04190,03709,070850.,390-.03907841545:,94390701470-0.4208,549039,84:7.041/,307434..,843841,7474907.,,290/4349,;0070398.4:39784,90/74:5841,72088,038709,344/8,2433,943,8,90,;0,70047,30/,3/54071:74:589,9/423,9090/897-:9434144/8,3/.4224/908390.422:3908,3/-.03907841545:,943%04034,0,3.0474,99490$9,90,3/90$9,90.,334970:5439023920841.78847020703.0903,943,4/88108507843,3/857450798:-0.99490300/8418.4:39790,032,0;03-0.42090549039,03024190$9,90

    1,03,.90/33907089413,943,0.4342.8:7;;,,3/80.:79

    0,701:8,9810/:543,.438/07,94341,901,.98,3/.7.:289,3.089,990/85:90/,834990574/:.9417,.,4899570:/.047/8.723,943-:990057088434190092,90/0870,3//090723,94341905045097:907,:9470/705708039,9;08941700903,9431742900.4342.89:,9439,9,8:31479:3,90-0038,//0/:543979477439498/8,/;,39,0%0,8.0,7390390708941905:-.3,41903,943,80.:799801,3/3/85:9,-1,893908.4504154.0540797:.,3/-.90$9,9038:7089808903.0,3/80.:79,3/908:5702001,704198.9038

    '%06:,!7490.94329,943

    ,-0.943894,035,79.5,9433709,97,/0%03096:089439,9345480884:943840890,/039006:,57490.9434190,8854390/4:9,-4;09020701,.941,03,08907449,3/.,:804190/893.943-0900390,03,3/903,943,,8,97,/07%0,03708/039408,0,3.09490.4:397418-79478,/4590/.4:397889,0708147507843,.43;0303.008,997,.90/-90:7041,3,3/574198,2475:754804189,0,/29830907092,903472247,-:9083,9:7,,.339,98579414,9,3/039:8,8214798.4:3970700902547,789,8,3/2,088;347419,985794170,7/825,9,3/.438/07,9431478534.:8942078,84:/570;039217429,3,/;,39,0419070,3088,3/05493902%01,890702,08850900,707.,390,034-,.948-04;0/.4:397,3/8-04;0/3,3/.4:397203%0050703.04190.4:39789,990,03709,07,88438:.:9907/870,7/1478.:8942078,3/905045043

    4202,088574199,99,8-00314:3/30.088,794,/4599008,9437,/.,,892,8002

    349074-0.9439490,03709,07398.4:39789,9030;0770,2,08,03:30.4397-:943943,943,3.420,3/0,90:3/4:-90/.4397-:908940307,/897-:943-:990,38,3/57419802,08,703493;0890/33/:897089,94:/0590.4:39780.4342,3/3.70,803,943,0,9%0,0383907089398.4:397-03207097,38039,3/902547,794:/3/00/-0,/;80/94.4393:00397:89390;0725479,391:3.94341709,/897-:943948,3/8

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    20/121

    %057,.9.087084790/94-,038390.4397441/897-:943,8,70,/54390/4:9,-4;090780.7092,35:,943841894.841.4224/908,3/57.08907:9907/870,7/419001,7041907.:8942078,3/4190:92,90,55308841905045041903,94341.90,702070:0898.57,.9.082,35:,9438,3//870,7//4349,9903/90007.80419097,/0-903,943,8849008903.04170,,3/,.9:,5489;0,3/1:3/,2039,/110703.08-09003,3,03,3/,3,943,.1::8919008,9;0.,881.,943,/4590/390709,97,/0

    20,8:70%080/110703.08,70.079,3,;,/70,84314790$9,9094570107903,943,4;0790,03390709,97,/004:/-0/43;403.0941,.9,3/70,90700944/9,93470,8434774:3/147,092,90/893.943.,3-014:3/-09003430,3/904907

    -110703.03,03,28,3/5:7548088:11.039-,88147/893.943

    %0,-4;04-0.943,-0.,7,.90789.84190007.804190709,97,/0-90,038.,70,.9:,,3/70,1:7388:11.03974:3/814708,9;0.,881.,94341709,97,/0783943,943,8,3/,038$4202,/8,7009908/42419008,9:708.,881.,943%4980,38079,99889057074,9;04190,2,35407$3.0904:7913/89,990.,881.,9438,.9:,70,,3/70,843,-0,3/,507843841430.,88,70970,90/,0,3/,89.,3349-08,/9,990.,881.,94385,9039:370,843,-0,3/:314:3/0/983/:9-4:3/94/0.,709,99008,9:70,.90/9398092,9057074,9;0,3/9.,3349/0.,709,990,.997,38.03/890294106:,57490.943089,-80/-9043899:943

    74,/850,3905407419008,9:70942,0/893.9438,3/.,881.,9438,24350784388349.:79,0/47/030/-9006:,57490.9434190,8.,:80%008,9;05407,/29841,/08.45041/8.70943,3/,,.,3-0;4,9;04190.43899:943,29,943430390.,881.,943894:970,843,-0-,883,//9439490,:9479080,;00,707.90/0.,3,84701079490.,8041380;8,9:7,,7-43.,84 0/..0,7,3/8:..3.9/0130/90,55.,9434106:,57490.943.,:8094,,84:994-0;4/0/,8.4397,7907094

    %006:,57490.943.,:8041904:790039203/2039/4083499,017429089,9090540794.,881390,/459434154.0,8-:9,/2984190007.804190

    /08.45041/8.7094339,970,7/,3/,;4/8,98/43043039894:9,370,843,-0-,88,3/9070147085:70,7-97,7.,881.,943,;3842070,843,-0-,88/40834941103/,,3899,9.,:802070-0.,:80983492,/092,902,9.,3.0947-0.,:80357,.9.09708:9838420306:,90390.,881.,94338:.,,8.,0/36:089431,389,90411,.9870,843,-.,3-0.43.0;0/9,94:/8:89,399008903.0419,989,90411,.98,99092090,,803,.90/2:89-0,88:20/304,88,890.,881.,94338:.,,2:89.,7790-:7/03418439,99/4083497089:543,370,843,-0-,88-:98088039,,7-97,7

    .:94790870.433.90385,8-,88147.,881.,943

    %06:08943,894090747349.903858,0,,3/;,/74:3/147.,881.,943,8,70,/-003,1172,9;0/0./0/398:78/.943,80,83;,74:8.4:798390&390/$9,908390.,8041$2904;8,9;/,/!07090;,/941.944190!553008,9:70,8388:0-0.,:8041,.43/943907032939043078541;0880803,0/3.4,898097,/094.47547,943814720/-.90384190!55308,3/84790&390/$9,9089:8/033907994,0389,80/9,990!553008,9:70//349;4,909006:,57490.943.,:804190!553041#98%008,9:70303,.9390,,/,8:92,905:754809003.4:7,0203941!553085-:/3,3/908,10914790808,3/817421470339074507800/9,998,8,;,/007.80419054.05407,3/,

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    21/121

    5708:259438,7031,;474198.43899:943,938:-89,3.000/9,99029,94341/42089.43078541;0880803,0/3.4,898097,/094.90384190!55308/408349;4,909006:,57490.9434190,,3//:0574.08847,.,:8084190!553041#983703/0738,//0.84306:490/9,5574;,90.43.:7734534341:89.043843390.,8041--438;8/030,9,81448

    .0383,.9831,.9308,943,70:3;078,70897,33,.98,81470,250,.98.0383,234:808709,078418579:4:86:47809.%0,.9398389,3.08/893.9419,9.,7,.907,3/147285,7941,309038;088902904-0.941.89403.4:7,0207.,38553,3/5,.090243,306:,1449399085534149073,943824890;07.42207.,3,94370807;089498438:-0.98,2434544198.4,89397,/0,3/,.4:3907;,357;0031,;4741207.,385538.439025,90/3904008,9434190&390/$9,90843988:-0.99834994;090;0880,3207.,3.,7,.9079,990.038087,390/9,90110.9,8-003.4770.9,997-:90/9490,.9410703742039:99894.431074307207.,357;008,8.4397,/893:80/174214703,3/94570807;0904;0732039174217,:/-1470307838:7705994:8397:/390280;0839490207.,3.42207.,2,730,80,817,:/8:5439070;03:039097,/0.4,89809,998408890285740.90/

    %07:030307,8,81448

    038,70:3/0734850.,.43899:943,57490.943.147-/8,.,881.,943490780:8910/825-0.,:809029,9434190.,881,8,4390308413,943,9%,94:/-0706:73,07/07004157490.943147,038,8,.,889,314782,7.,88089,314782,7.,880841207.,3.903874,/850,390/110703.0389,9:8-09003.9038,3/,038.43899:908,-,8814770,843,-0.,881.,943390007.804154.054072:7

    3422430,9;8,3,,88,.:80998,89,9:904390.038341,078,3/50//078.574;/0/9,934430.,34-9,3,.0380:30880847,8/0.,70/8390394394-0.420,.9034190&390/$9,908,80/;,/14790144370,8439

    2,800280949008,9:70942990-:830884194804,708:55480/94,;070,7/1479001,7044/47/07,3/,5530884190.422:39,3/90.4:79.,33496:0894398:/2039,3/.43.:843344210/;8$9,90 4,89,9:90.570;0390/.079,35078438,243902,038174203,339097,11.416:478,814:3/34994-090708:9417,.0,970/4734859,947,/0-07,905:7548094/8.723,90-:9,8-,80/4390-0019,9,3,03.,3349-08:11.039,.6:,390/94:73899:9438,3/4:710,89403,-0294,5570.,909070,94341985,79.:,7-:83088944:70397084.,1,-7.,3/,8349907014703;,/34070,70;80.0-,. &$0/90&$$:570204:79,/:3/07.438/07,943,347/3,3.04190.9413.33,9574-939088:,3.041.038085448,3/-,7/7442894,03890/9,95,377,943,/8.723,943,,389,0388574-90/-:99/4083491449,9,037,.0,3/,0,3.02,349-0,738420389,3.088:.,70,94394,092,904-0.94108,943,894-02,/090-,88415072990/.,881.,943,3/9,99.4:/34989,909,99008,9438.0,7743,3/9,9,99:/02:89-0,40/1479008,9;0,557,802039414.,.43/9438,3/1479008,9;0.4.0412094/8147.439743,3,557003/0/0;%0.,8041 $9,90;8,77448,5,7,0.,809490430,9-,73 8,:7,;8941$0,990 !,8394390-:83088415,3-7443,8.438/070/,8,;3903/03.083:735:-.3907089,3/293994.9038893908.4504154.0540782,789,9:90/033,03890799403,03,:.9430073,8,848:89,30/3 79;8,#!330849,$4,8433943;8',330704390.4:798,/9,9,038,70:/.,34394,;0/110703939070898340/0,999:/058.44,3/4,903.090574-94384188:,3.041.038089490214790-:83088415,3-7407544-,7/

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    22/121

    .,7/7442/,3.0,8349,331730203941.43899:943,7983 %025,7;8.,3$9,904,7/41,23078.,3,,574-9390.038341,038,8-,7-078,80/;4/-:99070,84314790/0.843,890.4:79813/389,990007.804190-:83088-90,038/4083493,3,,110.990247,8900,9470;0390.43;0303.04190.422:393%,,,8;88,3/,204228843 0/,,1473,89,9:90-,3339088:,3.041.42207.,183.038089450784330-0

    94.90385,80/;4/-0.,:8090,.431.9890/07,54074;07227,943,3/-0.,:8090708345:-.39070893902070.,2414307854190,9078,3/90183902849070,834,/06:,90:891.,94314790/8.723,94391:7907,//0/9,990,,8904:974941,39,438294,7/90507843841,5,3080,3.089740;0794:89.08/880390/439090479,9183798,;0-003970,90/97,/943,,83,9:7,7084:7.0837,807;8.43,%,704 0/!0338;,3,,89,90,.25480/,9,430;070254074114703-473:33,9:7,0/2,050784384;070,7841,0,8/0.,70/;4/-0.,:8090.4:7914:3/9,99070,83470,84314790.,881.,943,3/909,,8,3,7-97,7/0/:.943174290/,,041,3025400

    /:947908.4397,05,30/

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

    5407843411.,89494/.4380393904507,94341,:3/708-49,8945078438,3/5,.0,8/0.,70/3;,/-:990.4:798,/9,99054077,390/,8,7-97,79,99070,83470,84314790/8.723,943.,9903/0/90,/23897,943,3/2502039,9434190,,3/9,990249;0907041,820707,.,48993 $9,90;84394207,30,,574-93,0389403,0,8,078,3/50//078,8/0.,70/;4/-0.,:8090/8.723,943-4703470,843,-0,3/:8970,9439490,.9370850.994.90.,881.,943,85745480/

    %0.,80,9-,787,/.,/1107039,3/901,.982,09028480,70,/,;08,/,038/43493,9:7,548808890825,909..438/07,943,3/70,7/14790.:894207894290.4203/,.439,.9347905,9749./08709405-48907903,94380.43420.0593841,7,8903,3.0890757419347904,9,3/,0,3.0.903,943,4089490,3/%08029,943843906:,1.,94384190,038,;0-003843432,34..,8438,3/389,3.080850.,3920841.788,3/020703.0.,3/434-099079,3-477490,3:,0413943;8',33094/7;04209070,9,3/831.,3.04190/893.943-0900390,03,3/903,943,9:8

    92,-0:/.,34340;079,9,03.42339498.4:397,7094:990392,90340/0414:7,8.:89428,3/:8,089,94:74350450,;0$4980803439,9.079,3.,880841,038,7041/110703958.4417424:7104.4:397203:79072470983,9:7,,3/70,843,-0948:554809,99014703-473480,0,3.0817899490743.4:397,3/480/0,8414;0732039,03;7432039

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    23/121

    ,3/.43974,;0-0030303/070/,3/14720/:3/0703970/110703970208,3/549.,889028,;0349908,203857,943147905:-.0,347,7090,80/85480/94,7/90&390/$9,908,894804-.90385,70,5,7941904;07320399801:790703,7020398:330.088,7,;08,/034:849,94-;4:89.,3349-0,11720/9,-84:90.431/03.09,99008,9:70,894:95,:8-070,8431472,390.,881.,943,3/90701470,557457,90/8.723,9438,,389,038,89

    70,90894908:-0.94108,943

    '%0:0!74.08841,29,943

    ,#0,843,-9909089419029,943/090723,943-08,9:70/0.8;0

    034.42094/:0574.088,8,29,9434390007.80419054.054079,8-00389,90/-90089,:9479390&390/$9,9089,9

    3/90:,7,3941/:0574.088,8,841903-0030//02,3/8439,990,8,349-0:370,843,-0,7-97,747.,57.4:8,3/9,99020,38800.90/8,,;0,70,,3/8:-89,39,70,94394908:-0.984:994-0,99,30/

    $41,7,890706:70203941/:0574.0888.43.0730/,3/390,-803.0414907.43899:943,70897.943,89,908170094,/459,90;070.4342.54.2,70,843,--0/0020/9457424905:-.01,70,3/9403147.09,954.-08,943,/,590/94985:75480%0.4:798,7094:9,:9479090794/0.,708:.54.470398/0.,70/-9008,9:70944;077/09190,85,880/,70800394,;0,70,843,-070,94394,57450708,9;05:75480,3/,7030907,7-97,7347/8.723,94790706:702039841/:0574.088,708,9810/,3/:/.,/090723,943949,90110.9703/078,.4:79 1:3.9:8411.40--,;80470/

    34907,:947989,90890573.509:8

    %442:.831.,3.0.,3349-0;03949047/70,843,-03.438/073908.450419054.054073,.43899:943,80380147909089:80/94/090723090.43899:943,9419020,3802540/-9008,9:7089436:7009079070897.94392548084379880.:70/943/;/:,8-9041#98,70:370,843,-0,3/34909079254808,370897.9438438:.798

    89,9:9094-0939854072:89,84-070,843,-03984507,943:543905078438429,110.982:89349-014790,334,3.041,5,79.:,7.,88,3/2:89349-0:3/:4557088;02:7$0.

    390.,8041,943;8$90000/9,8,840/

    %4:8919089,9039:83907548398,:94793-0,141905:-.92:89,550,717899,9903907089841905:-.0307,,8/893:80/1742948041,5,79.:,7.,88706:708:.390710703.0,3/80.43/9,99020,38,7070,843,-30.088,714790,..4258203941905:75480,3/349:3/:4557088;0:5433/;/:,8

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    24/121

    !7,9,&3/079,34;8$9,904,7/412-,23#10898908941.43899:943,9

    3/09072330907,;03,.9419008,9:705,880/390007.80419054.054079470:,90904507,94341,-:830888478349.43899:943,430419017896:08943894-0.438/070/-90.4:7980907905407,8007.80/,8,8:11.039

    14:3/,943370,8433.4330.9439902,99073;4;0/478,3,7-97,74557088;0,3/.,57.4:8:80419,9540794:98:-89,39,70,94394900,98,109247,8.421479,3/0307,01,7041905:-.

    -!09943078,7:2039.438/070/

    !099430782,3,7:203989,9709,8,.4224347/3,74..:5,94343041948057;00843,470.430/,8088039,949047/075:78:,3941,553088-17002039,998,,31:,3/430894..:5,943,3/90701470-043/905407419008,9:7094574-9,3/503,0/%8,7:203984;074481,.9,3/70,9,3/7089843,33.4770.9,88:25943,3/57028009,9398.4:397070904..:5,943803,0/3-509943079,8-0038403,0/-2-90,033,343089.70/9,-0,3/:3250,.,-02,330794:9,72473:79490

    .9038,3/94:9:92,90/,307949070.4342.50,.097,36:9,3/01,70:99008,9:70,814:3/,80,;0,8414:3/,3/3/.,90/9,99057;00,8-003847488,-:80/-90,0397:90092,90:80415073.4:8/0838,3/57,.9.089,90340348,24345489..4397441904..:5,943,3/970,9038,/0,/897,304/43903,94380.434203/,3073903,943,80.:793920841.788,3/020703.

    %070,6:08943,988:09070147083499,95480/-50994307.4;07448,3/34708901,.98,3/.7.:289,3.08-:9988900.:8433901:9:7041,038174290709,97,/0:370,843,-07-97,7.,57.4:89,3394,..4:3990092,90,3/5073.4:81472,3/2,33073.90,038,;007094147003,0/9070389:8.4770.989,90/90,38078.0,7%0,36:089438/0020/,-84:9030.088,794-73,-4:990/0870/08,9;04-0.9;009417003,943,0.43421742,03.43974,3//423,3.09834930.088,7:370,843,-0-0.,:809,110.9857;,90798,3/57;0082:755%09089

    4170,843,-0308841,,890,557457,90308847,/06:,.:3/07,.7.:289,3.08419020,38,/4590/94.,774:9985:754803940110.9 /:/0/-989089/85:90/08,943.8349207070,843,-0-:9,.9:,30.088,72:89-0.438/070/34994,;031730/90.43899:943,29,9434170,843,-03088

    %030.08894190,36:08943805,30/39005,3,94734909,9,..425,30/90-.,907,803,.90/394,

    %8-574548089470:,9090709,-:83088985:75480894570;03950784384,70349.90384190!553081742,;3,897,304/:5434:70.4342.1019050784384.4397498;9,,7907414:70.4342.10,7090430844034,0,3.09498#05:-.4,;03457414:3//0;4943944:717003899:9438,3/4,;034

    5072,303989,034:750450801,700,7034970,902,89078414:7/0893,850.98414:7100;034:73,943,80.:79-0,990207.41490750450

    3800394,..4258901470435:754800/4349574548094/057;050784384,70349.90384190!553084190720,3841;044/098-8008949,0,,174290,3/84150784384,70349.90384190!55308,54079,9.,3-00/0/945,7,0,,850.98414:73,943,10,3/03/,3074:73,943,80.:79970850.980893798

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    25/121

    %0,5574;,4198-830.088,71474:73,943,8:7;;,

    1549.,3/0503/03.08,092,90,857,94341,504509030.4342.3/0503/03.08343090088092,90700/42,3/-079,7034970,,3/5489;019050450,708:-0.994900.4342..43974,3//423,94341490780850.,134941907437,.047.4:397%07024;,,3/07,/.,94341908,.0841147030.4342..43974,3//423,94384304190

    34-089249;089,9,3,943,08,9:702,5:78:09825488-094.43.0;09,908,9439,9800894-739,-4:9.,33173090.43899:943,29,94341/:0574.088%0,99,3203941,092,90,857,94341,50450.,330;07-0-043/902984108,9;0,:9479

    .,0570880/-43899:943,43;0394394-09390850704108,9;0,.943

    %017,2078419043899:943.4:/349,;03903/0/942548090.43899:943,70897.943841/:0574.0884390,99,32039418:.,34-0249;0,81700/4217420.4342..43974,3//423,94397:90007.80419054.05407%01,9078419043899:9432:89,;0;03949008,9:701:,:9479,3/54079403,.908,9439,94:/5742490908:57020,5530884190504509071700/42,3/-079390570.8088:034-01470:8900570882,/0907;4.0.0,790,/4590/,7084:9430570883907-0019,99008,943

    36:08943893908.450419008,9;05407%:890/0.,70/90907#084:943

    %,9989080380419043;039439,9905:-.3907089706:708903,943,,94341709,97,/0-:99,-89,31742,5574;390,203/20393974/:.0/-9000,90147,3,77,309,,3/4907843982,9907-0.,:8098.43;3.0/9,990,943,8802-8,:9470/945742:,90,,.29894534,3/207.,3.90389057;009403,0390709,97,/07:04%07,234190!553043899:9436:490/435,08,3/41900247,3/:214790!0994307

    94://40947010794903,943,89.903/03.2,310890/3;,74:8574;8438419043899:943%:8390570,2-0,573.504-0.9;0890.43807;,94341905,9724341903,943,3/,8.474,790574;84329394.90384190!55308900549,943/0;0452039,3/:9,94341983,9:7,7084:7.083/3$0.9434179.0'98574;/0/9,93417,3.80.0791.,9047,34907147241,:947,943147904507,94341905:-.:998,-07,390/0.05994.90384190!55308%03,943,,9434190709,97,/0843,.4393:,3.041903,943,89.57490.9;054.,//43,8,572,74-0.9;0419043899:943,39-08,/9,9,,2-:0/9908,205:75480,3/8579:3/0732,34190574;8438419043899:9438:370,843,-03;,/,3/:3.43899:943,

    %08074:83088419008,9:708.43.073147905941903,943,8,82,310890/390,5574;,41907,/.,20,8:7088907014701::8910/94:/,;0-00370.70,399498/:90894,7/890.4:397,3/98504504:/9;09084775941903,943,8990.425,.03.,3/701:8047300.994,/459,7020/.422038:7,90990/02,3/8415:-.3907089,3/3,943,8:7;;,89070548947419084;070354074108,9439008,9:70,83/:9-4:3/941,.090574-02,3/2009974:,/06:,9020,8:70890/,307,3/970,9

    9,9,03/423,94341709,97,/054808943,943,0.4342

    /!74;843841,349:370,843,-0

    .:784789:/4190574;84384190,220/,9070;0,849407,39470,843,-09008,9:70,8-003%0,82,/0574850.9;0,3/70.43089079,3/57;00419480,70,/03,0/3904..:5,94394.4393:090703/:7390708941907;08,3/82,770.4394341907994.4393:08,..47/0/,884.,943841,038%0794757;008/030/94948043:543.43;.94341.079,341103808390/0-07,943841904:794398.,80

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    26/121

    ,9903943,8.,0/94901,.99,99057;0084:/349,;0-003/030/94./703,3/07841,0383403,0/390709,97,/0$:.574;8434://010,990,980198,28,3/5:75480808/090007.804108,9;0/8.7094383498:-0.994:/.,70;098080990/9,9904:7934936:7039490249;08419008,9:703475,88:5430307,2,990784108,9;0:/2039%008,9:708572,790:/0419030.088941,303,.920394741,34198574;8438,3/0;075708:25943831,;474198;,/9,3/94:90

    4:792,4/;083.438890399908/424190,92,349,33:9008,94313495,5,-30.088419008,9;05407:790724709090894190;,/941,,,99,.0/,8,;4,94341/:0574.08883499870,843,-03088-:998:370,843,-03088,3/013/90574;8438,70349:370,843,-0%080573.508,84,3807;,74:84907,7:203987,80/,,38990,842041.,709,990,/40834957424900307,01,709,994:8,3/841,0384:/-097434:941025420399,957.083.70,80-0.,:804190023,94341.425099439,99070834300/1479008,9439,9,/06:,90705,.020398574-02,9.,9,990702,-00307,-70,/439,990704:/-070507.:8843817421470307809.,3419080,7:20398,70/70.90/,,389908:55480/8/424190,.08840939008,9;057074,9;090/4349254793;,/9

    '00//010.93909904190,

    8:-47/3,9074:3/4770,84314790,00/3;,/94190,890.,29,9909909070418280,/347/0.059;0,89.43.0,89070,5:754804190-.8943,943,090709,-:83088,3/574-9,038174203,390703%0.43899:943,574;843.8.,20/94-0;4,90/3$0.9434179.0'.70,/8

    4-.2,-003,.90/390,8,02-7,.024709,34308:-0.9.8,-00570880/3909904190-

    ,990,-4;0574;843574-988/:5.99,98198990.4250901,894,557,809008,947847905:-.41903,9:708.450,3/.43806:03.084190,47984507,943$:907,3/$9,9:94743897:.943$0.5.:7847.438/07,9434190990,3/90574;84384190-1,8948490570803.041/:5.99897:09,990907270:,90/408349

    ,3/2,34970,/,3/,91789,3.0.43;090/0,413,943,,943,3/574-943.9072805708890942,35:754808,3/4-0.9;084190,:970:,908,-74,/0790729,30907574-943473,943,,94349419080,;0,,8-0033.:/0/9390907270:,943

    &3/079099041,3,.99470:,90908,041394.,936:4789008,9:702,574-9908,041394.,936:478$009;8941,-,83/6:490/35,0413807

    939020,33419043899:943706:739,9908:-0.9410;07,.9419008,9:708,-089,90/3909,0909909470:,90908,041394.,936:47809.8:11.03905708808908:-0.941,3,.9 574-93908,0418:.6:4789423478,3/

    945078438390,-9410993394.,90/8:.2,99078-035745073.:/0/93908:-0.94170:,93908,0,28;8$9,903/6:490/35413807

    %047/70:,90841-74,/25479,3/30.088,7 25088420/07004170897,39,3/574-94341,.98:8:,/4303.4330.9439909394-070:,90/047/70:,90/40834947/3,7.43;020,3341574-99070834,-84:9070,843984:/349,;08:.20,3303:80/3/00,9354.054073.4330.9439,

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    27/121

    9390-0894743011.,.4:870:,94341.3;4;088:55708843$9,90;847943$4,6:490/35413807

    %00307,7:0814790:80410307,9072839099041,-9,8,84-0038,/9,990990300/349-0,33/0949003970.43903984190,$:907,3/$9,9:94743897:.943$005%0,-4;07:0,81440/909904190.936:08943,/4590/9024700307,

    907270:,903890,/413,943,047574-9:7907247090,,84.439,3849077:081479070:,9434190709,97,/0.2,349-03.:/0/390907283,943,,94347574-9438407090990.,30/174270:,90943,943,047574-990704:/,;0-0032,3574;84383491,393908.4504190990.4:/,;02,/090.93;,/%0:804190907270:,909070147083,..47/990573.504;073390/7,1934189,9:908:3/07.,8250470307,907284:/-0,/4590/390990.4:/3.:/0,4907574;843814:3/390-4/4190.9

    305:754804190.43899:943,/70.9;09,9908:-0.941,-84:/-002-7,.0/398990894,557809008,947841905:754808903,9:70,3/8.4504198574;8438,3/570;0399003,.92039394,412,99078.,;070.0;0/90349.0,.943,3/89:/419008,94784741905:-.390.,80,9-,79.,3349-0.,20/9,99008,9478,;0-003,557,80/41903,9:704190,0850.,903,943,,943,3/90574-943574;8438%008,9478944,.9;03907089390/8.:88434190,,3/,70,92,341905078438,110.90/-90574-9438390,.43/:.90/,.,25,3,,38998,5574;,9.,3349-0.,20/907014709,99070,8438147/0.,7390,3;,/0;070890/%04-0.9432:8990701470-04;077:0/

    00/;4,9434139073,943,970,908,3/4-,9438

    349078:-47/3,90,7:2039,,38990;,/94190,8908:55480/;4,9439070-4190,79074190&390/,9438,3/41900.,7,9434190:2,3#98,/4590/-90&390/,94380307,8802-013/342079390,9438,790725480834897.9470,4-,943870,7/390798,3/1700/42419078:-0.98,380803%0,4190&390/,94380/55,3/900.,7,94341:2,3#98.439,38349324709,3,

    207070.42203/,94347,.4224389,3/,7/41,.0;02039147,504508,3/,3,9438 /5%,98:.890254794190&390/,9438,7907,/41900.,7,94341:2,3#98.,3-0310770/901,.99,9202-0784190&390/,94387,3,94388:.,847,,3/032,7574-914703078174203,33709,97,/0,3/324893,9438419047/,8,,3891470307803,0/3/42089.97,/0,70,/4590/

    %0%70,94129-0900390#05:-.4190!55308,3/90#05:-.413,41578,84.,20/94-0;4,90/-90,36:089439,990970,9:,7,39008806:,941970,92039949030803,943,8:543908,2090728,8903,943,841,34907.4:397:9903,943,8413,,70349/8.723,93,,389-0.,:803,943,841,4907.4:397080.05994804190&390/$9,9084,707,390/850.,798-9043899:943,70,574-90/174203,3390709,97,/0:90;038:554839,990,317308:543908,/970,990970,9

    8,,88:-0.9946:,1.,94347,203/2039-,8:-806:039,&$;8%4258430/,3/908,202,30;07.:79,4770897.9908.450419054.054074190$9,905,8943;8!0338;,3,0/

    43.:843

    #08:23,90,;08091479,-4;004/9,990/85:90/,,803,.90/947020/,70,,.9:,970,9,3//,307943,943,0.43425480/-,03/423,3.0,3/.439744190709,-:83088,3/1700.9038,3/.4:3971742/423,3.0,3/.439749,99003,.92039.0,71,8

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    28/121

    93908.450419054.054074190$9,9097:.,3/-.957490.989843507843,9,3/38:7089880.:79,3/1:9:709,990,/408349;4,909006:,57490.943.,:80419043899:943-0.,:808:11.03974:3/808914790/893.943-09003,03,3/.903390007.8041904..:5,94370:,90/34790/:0574.08841,.,:80-0.,:8090,8574850.9;034507,943,3/70.43089057;0041,038,70,/03,0/3904..:5,943,3/70,843,-57490.9890757;009,9908/42,3/011.,.4190,94.,77

    4:9984-0.9;08,550,794:894-05,30;/039,8,2,9907411,.998002834943,557457,90-:9,.9:,30.088,7,3/9,93,3.,808:.2,99071,8939057074,9;0419008,9:7094805407,3//8.7094390:/.,/05,79203941904;07320392,349390710709,990574;84384190,,70.0,702-7,.0/390990,3/988:11078174234/:5.9,3/,8349280/9008,947847908020394190545:,943,110.90/,3/9,99.,3349-08,/94-0;4/1478:55480/.431.99970,94-,9438-0.,:8034970,9,8,.9:,-003039070/39443908:-0.9,3/9054.054072,349-0.:79,0/478:7703/070/-,3970,947,34907.43;03943,,7002039

    $420202-07841904:79,704190453439,9907,/.,0110.984190,.4:/,;0-0032,/0088,7839825,.94390,038%:89889,90/9,990247092084:/,;0-003;03390,147906:/,943410893-:83088080390920.420814790294.480:70,/:940;078207094/0907230190,1,893908.4504108,9;0,:9479,3//40834997,38.03/9029,943841/:0574.088,3/06:,57490.943:,7,3900/39043899:943#020/08,,38990,7830884190,84:/-0,//70880/949008,9:7090,70-043/4:75407,3/:78/.943

    %05099438070-/030/9.4898,,38950994307

    !,7,80343#008,:989,30443.05.43#0083/03.,,3/0.43.:7

    $05,7,9053438

    !.43.:773,3//880393

    ,7009490574548943573.50477:09,9.4:7982,34936:70394908/4241,390.95,880/-90437088,3//:,5574;0/-90!708/0394190#05:-.:9907:0/408349570.:/0.4:798174236:73,3//0907233090790.941103/8,,389,574;84347574;8438419043899:943,28,9810/9,990.9,88,0/,8;4,9;04190/:0574.08841,,3/9006:,57490.9434190,8.,:808419043899:943/40834931730:5439023841,7,89,110.98,884.,94385,793078547.47547,943890.,59,41.83494430/-90.90384190!55308,3/,0384,70349,3/,;0349-00303,0/390709,-:83088,240;07:3,-0945078:,/028019,99/408349;4,908,/.,:808

    3841,7,890.9,550894,884.,9438,3/5,793078587010770/94390.9,3/94,0384,70,3/,;0070941470-00303,0/38,/-:830880390//03,0390709,-:830889070,834574-9434347,,3899029403,039%0,88:20/,3/-00;0/344/1,99007003990/9403,0/390-:83088%0.9,48,03894.4393:03-:83088:39907/0,947;4:39,7709702039174290-:8308847147109:7041907.0380,3/.47547,9438,884.,9438475,793078590.,59,41.83494430/-90.90384190!5530894.4393:0390-:83088147,5074/419030,78174290/,904190,5574;,4190.9:3047:3990057419072419008903.04190,884.,943475,793078547.47547,943.0;070;039.42081789%0574-94343.47547,943890.,59,41.8349

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    29/121

    4430/-.90384190!553089403,0390709,-:83088147,5074/4124709,39030,78174290/,904190,5574;,4190.947-043/90907241907.47547,9008903.0.0;070;039.420817898;,/,3/,1:-0.,:8090.4393:,3.0419008903.0418:..47547,943888:-0.994,90;07904370882,2548070,843,-:543902-8:-806:03908,943:990574-9439403,0390709,-:83088-,884.,9438,3/5,7930785890.,59,41.83494430/-.9034190!55308,19079030,78174290/,904190

    ,5574;,4190.90;03-014709003/419090724190708903.0,8,700/:543-90,884.,908,3/5,793078,3/-,03078944290709,-:83088897,382990/-90/0,941,3,0303,0/390-:8308847-800.:94747,/23897,947,24:39894,/057;,94341907574507994:9/:0574.08841,%4223/909030,75074/174290/,904190,5574;,4190.947:3990057,94341909072419008903.04190,884.,943,3/5,7930785.0;070;039.42081789,3/90824395074/7,390/94,0307841,/0.0,80/,03800.:94747,/23897,947946:/,9090-:83088/4349.:7090/010.94190,-0.,:80900110.94190574-943894.4250902948047/8548041907-:83088%057.04-9,3,-0,98:.147.0/8,04190-:830884:/-03,/06:,9094702-:780,3/.425038,9090,884.,908475,7930784190,884.,9438475,7930785,3/90,0307841,/0.0,80/,0303,0/390709,-:8308814790.,59,3;0890/39%0894.41207.,3/80-4:9,3/84/,9709,/408349,430.43899:9090-:83088%044/9,990,884.,9435,7930785,3/90,03,/-:9:5/:73,435074/410114795,903.0,3/

    50780;07,3.0147285,79418:.-:83088%0.43899:943,574;84389,9345078438,-0/057;0/418574507994:9/:0574.08841, ,3/9,9345078438,-0/030/9006:,57490.9434190,8 4:/,;03420,33,8,550/94,884.,9438475,7930785,3/,0307841,3,0303,0/390709,-:8308819007094-0.42500/948047/8548041907-:83088939030,78174290/,904190,5574;,4190.9,3/-014709003/41909072419008903.04190,884.,9438,3/5,7930785,8,700/:543-90,884.,9438,3/5,793078,3/93824398,190790/0,941907570/0.0884733907089

    %0,:9478419043899:943070;,39.,701:,3/0,4:83908,10:,7/41904307854157;,90,7.:9:7,,3/8.940907990,3/841905:-./42,3.43899:909057.00885,97243,3/2,389,41903,9430990//349/002980,3/57:/03994/057;0,038,3/907078418:.,3/8

    47908070,8438,24190453439,980.9434190.93841,7,89.42508,884.,9438,3/5,79307857010770/9490703943/:5907709,-:83088939030,78174290/,904190,5574;,4190.90;03-0147090057419090724190708903.0,8,700/:543-90,884.,908,3/5,793078,3/80.9434190.93841,7,89.4250890,03803,0/390709,-:830883810920800.:94747,/23897,947946:/,9090-:83088,703;,/14790;4,9090/:0574.08841,,3/9006:,57490.9434190,8.,:808419043899:943

    #05:-.4190!55308$&!#%

    ,3,

    #4,7.

    $#8,470307,#7,/070307,%&"&4430##%%#4430#&$4430!#%&,47##$'$&$$,3/##%!#%708543/0398

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    30/121

    !0/74$077,3480:-,3,3/-07,943.41475099430770/#:,89740/07.4703,8,7,3403.47#.,7/47.,,3/$0;0:880147708543/0398

    #

    $0347:74/,147207,0:903,390307,4190,5,30802507,72,3/422,3/30307,4190,5,30802507,47.083%0!55308/:73,5074/.4;073,3/4834.,70/-01470,29,74228843.43;030/-900141$9,114190720/147.084190!553089,;3:3,1:/870,7/0/,3/1,0/94/8.,708/:908,88:..422,3/507299390294.4229-7:9,,974.908,3/4907.7208,,389343.42-,9,39.;,38,3/5784307841902507,,5,308047.083;4,9434190,8,3/.:8942841,7.4208-01470984:79800394089,-8900,9410.:9;07/0744190!708/0394190!55308940343,3/574-9708543/03980;0$:880,3/#4-079!47917425,79.5,9339057480.:94341509943078.,80-01470909,74228843,3/945072,3039574-9708543/03981742574.00/3990.,8041509943078

    38:55479418.,8050994307903/078901443573.5,,7:20398

    789%,90.:9;07/07480,439074:3/9,99;4,9083494390574;843414:7.43899:943,,-:9,844:74.,,8948,349341901,.99,990!553088349,83,947347,3,/070399490,:043;0394343#:08,3/#0:,9438.4;073,3/,71,70,3/907014705099430788.,70/41.7208349-,80/43,3,943,,3/39073,943,03.050994307,7:08%,93;0411901,.99,998.4228843,8-003025,300/-;79:041,3:3.43899:943,,,30,47/0798.4228843894:9:78/.9439497070350994307

    $0.43/%,9905,79.5,94339057480.:9434190.,80,,38950994307-014709042288433-0,14190&390/$9,9041207.,41,99473080;0:880,3/#4-079!4794,70349,9947308,:9470/-90$:570204:799457,.9.0,390!553088,/23:943414:7507843,9,8,33/0503/03989,90,3/907,554392039,857480.:947,70,;4,943414:743899:9431479070,8439,990,703496:,10/9457,.9.0,390!55308

    %7/%,99947308:880,3/!479,;034507843,9,857480.:94390&390/$9,90349-03,5,7933907089390.,80

    0.:9;07/074089,-83,,943,,7720811.05708.7-37:0,3/70:,9434;07339097,41,..:80/,7.723,8,888:0/-90!708/0394190!5530843909/,841:%84:794/89,99847/078;,/,3/.43899:943,79.0414:743899:943574;/0839880.9439,9

    %0!553087034:3.08,7,8,33897:2039413,943,54.,3/,/4598900307,

    ,..0590/573.5084139073,943,,,85,79419041903,943

    3,..47/,3.09900307,,..0590/573.504139073,943,,41905708039/,3.:/390,:043;0394390030;,43;03943,3/831.,39570.0/03984139073,943,:7857:/03.0089,-80/-90&390/,943,948050784329,747.;,34,;0-003:9415,3335705,7347,3,,741,708843,3/4190.422884341.7208,3/41103808.43806:039,,3/3./039,9070943;4,9434190,8,3/.:8942841,741:2,39,3/.;,943,700/,..4:39,-0907014743806:0393905742:,943,3/

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    31/121

    03147.02039410.:9437/07490!708/0394190!55308,8,.90/3.43147299900307,,..0590/,3/54.084139073,943,,.,705,7941904:743899:943

    %05742:,943418,/00.:9;047/078,3007.80-90!708/0394185407,8422,3/073.0141,4:7,720/147.08,8:50/-984:79390.,8041

    ,2,89,;8$90711, 0308,/

    ,7834903/0/825-0.,:80489908,;0.0,80/1907.088,94341,720/4899083./03941,72,702,3503/3.84:/-0/85480/41,8392041,7325479,3.03./03994,.43/:.941,7890,/459434120,8:70-9029,7.422,3/34943947050,3//010,990030208-:994800,3/8:-0.994/8.53,720,8:70948003020843907,990259949,7947250/04:729,7011479,;0;4,90/90,41,75,790":73&$$:593/00/90540794.70,90,29,7.42288431479097,,3/5:38203941,7.723,88,3,850.941,3,73/390,3:,041,7907,29,7.4228843,8:78/.9438443,8,90.3.,89,9041,7.4393:08%83.:/08905074/41,3,7289.04729,74..:5,943:594900110.9;041,970,94150,.0,3/2,0903/-043/-970,9,7002039408 %7,41,7723,8-9,7%7-:3,8207.,,7884.,9434:73,:30

    43806:03990!708/039,8422,3/0730181:0254070/94.438:22,9098:31380/,850.941,73,209097,,3/5:38203941,7.723,974:9088:,3.0,3/03147.02039410.:9;07/074

    !0994307,7:089,9708543/0399,74228843,834:78/.943949750994307147,.98.422990/3;4,9434190,:043;03943,3/90030;,43;03943-0.,:8090!553088349,83,94794901789,3/830/9080.43/4339.,3349-0/030/9,9907:08,3/70:,9434190,:0,3/030;,.43;03943814725,7941,3/,704-,80/43900307,,..0590/573.5,84139073,943,,31,.9890807:08,3/573.508070,..0590/-9094-0070393,94390&390/$9,90,3/,5,3407083,9470894909443;03943$:.7:0,3/573.5089070147014725,794190,414:73,9430;03190!55308,8349,83,9479490.43;03943802-4/39021474:743899:943,8-003/0-07,900307,,3/09038;03988.450,3/8349.43130/949070.43943417:0,3/573.504139073,943,,,8.4393:0/33970,90894.4:74;07320392,,;0-003478,-0,83,947

    :790724700390.7208.,70/,,38950994307070,00/.422990/90!55308,8:3/079084;0703941&390/$9,908,3/9:8007006:,-4:3/940907990&390/$9,908,3/9,5,3949079,3/4-,943.439,30/390970,908-0900390-007039.4:39708%080798,3/4-,94307034907,80/-4:7,88:25943411:84;070391,9,4:7020703.,8,170089,90039908:89403147.09079434:74341973,3/5:38394804.422990/.7208,,389.7208,,3894:750450398.4330.9439809470202-07,90,;08,/390.,8041,:70;88,!

    %0.,30414:714724;07320391742422430,994#05:-./408349,110.99057480.:943419480.,70/990.72041970,843.422990//:73903422430,9-0.,:8098,34110380,,389908,2084;070350450

    908,209403,7.7208.422990/,,3894:750450,3/4:74;073203900070,422430,9,7097,-0,3/5:38,-0-4:75708039#05:-.

    !0994307.,0308905,79.5,9434194207.,3,99473083,200;0$:880,3/#4-079!47939057480.:943418.,80439074:3/9,98,/,9947308,703496:,10/94

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    32/121

    57,.9.0,3!553083,..47/,3.094:7#:0841.4:79,3/90,554392039418,/,9947308,857480.:94788;4,9;0414:73,943,84;07039

    39017895,.0708543/0399,742288438,850.,29,797-:3,4;0730/-,850.,,,3/349-90#:0841.4:79.4;07347/3,7.;.4:799,8,70,/-0038439,90.:9;07/074.574;/081479047,3,943418:.29,7.42288438,;,/

    ,3/.43899:943,,%0708349338,/00.:9;047/07.706:7089,9.4:380,550,73-014708,/.42288432:89-0,99473086:,10/9457,.9.0,390!553083,..47/,3.0990#:08414:7931,.9898.42243329,797-:3,89,9.4:380147905,7908,70:8:,29,7507843304,7030907,99473083470;0354880880/410,97,33

    $0.43/90,554392039419094207.,3,99473088349;4,9;0414:73,94384;0703998431,7,3/5745079,9&390/$9,908.,88:-2990/90;3/.,94341.7208,,389074;0732039,3/075045094,97-:3,414:73,94384:/-0,40/705708039,94339097,419480;07.720819070,8-003,37036:820394184;070399,8349-003-4:74;0732039-:9-90&390/$9,904;0732039.,80/0/94:89097,,3/5:3820394107030208%00,899,90.4://4390857941.429894,4902705708039,94338,/97,8

    039,990&390/$9,908349,5,7933907089390.,8050994307.,030890507843,941,9947308:880,3/!479,857480.:94789841.42243340/09,990&390/$9,90,3/9850450,;0-00306:,1349247070,9,70;0/-90.72089.5099430789,3/8.,70/-01470909,742288439.,3-0.438/070/,57;001474:7#05:-.9,9,0,/073,94384:/8:-2990;3/.,943419043474198.9038,3/984;073203994,29,797-:3,414:7.4:397

    %09,74228843,;3-003.43;030/-;79:041,;,/,9:78/.9434;0790.7208.,70/.1,:3/0790574;8438410.:9;07/074,3/,;38,/50994307398.:894/984:7934939071070990/:0574.088418:.9,7.4228843

    47,90147043905099438/030/9.4898 /041.4

    !,7,807,!,-40343%:,84343902,47,3/#008 .43.:7

    $05,7,9053438

    !#%/880393

    29,7.4228843,8025,300/430.02-079497903$0347:74/,147'4,9434190,8,3/.:8942841,3/,71,70

    0;0$:880,3/#4-079!479207.,3.9038,3/349,:9470/-90$:570204:799457,.9.0,070,554390/57480.:947705708039390207.,339097,4190.,80

    %0.4228843,8025,300/:3/0790,:9479410.:9;07/0744190!708/0394190!5530890;,/941.8.,030/-5099430743.43899:943,74:3/8!0994307,8,84.,030/90507843,9419947308:880,3/!47994,550,7,857480.:9478-0147090.4228843

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    33/121

    %0.,708,,38950994307,8-00310/83.0:303903,204190504504190!55308,8,..:8078

    0.438/07,943-70190.,030,,38990,550,7,3.0419947308:880,3/!4799,550,739,990,70,038,3/,;0349-003,:9470/-90$:570204:799457,.9.0,9070.4:/349-0,36:089439,98,/507843.,3349,550,7,857480.:9478350994307.,80,8

    98:.,550,7,3.0904:/-057,.9.3,,,38990,

    $,/;4,943;,380840;073943831.,3.0,9908/041902420394:86:089433;4;0/390.,030,,38990;,/9410.:9;07/074$,/47/078.,030/4380;07,.43899:943,74:3/%409,.0,7/0,41906:089437,80/9830.088,79470,/9040.43909418,/47/07.870574/:.0/,81448

    &%'##

    $%$%##$!#$##&$#&%'#%%#&$##

    ,3:0#4,85708/0394190!55308-;79:041905407;0890/320-9043899:943,3/,84190!55308/4070-089,-8,,943,,7720811.0.,70/9907085438-941,..42583908500/97,41,,5,3080,..:80/41,7.7208.422990/390!55308,3/5708.7-0907:08,3/70:,9438:.97,

    %0,943,,7.7208411.08089,-80/9390411.04190:/0/;4.,900307,4190724190!55308,3/8,1:3.943:3/0790/70.9438:507;843,3/.439744190:/0/;4.,900307,98,574.00/94.40.91742,,;,,-084:7.080;/03.041,7.7208.422990/390!55308174290.42203.0203941489908-,5,330.02-072,39,3,70.47/907041,3/-73,-4:99057425997,2,39,3,70.47/907041,3/-73,-4:99057425997,4190,..:80/

    %0,943,,7720811.08,2,39,3/70.9,8439900,$0.9430307,0,/6:,79078$:57020422,3/07147900/5407,3/8,0.,309908,/11.031472,943,3/0;/03.041,7.7208

    %014437:08,3/70:,9438,4;0739097,411507843,..:80/,8,7.723,8

    $%$%%#$$$

    ,0307,507843,..:80/,8,7.723,8,-0970/-29,7.422884394-0.43;030/-47:3/0790,:94794190!55308

    $%

    ,;07!07843%0029,7.4228843,554390/070:3/078,,;0:78/.9434;07,5078438.,70/9,7.72084,70390.:894/4190.43;033,:9479,990920419097,

    -;071103808%029,7.4228843089,-80/070:3/078,,;0:78/.9434;07,411038083.:/3-:9349290/94901443

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    34/121

    %05,3335705,7,94339,94347,341,,741,70884347,,73;4,9434139073,943,970,908,700203947,88:7,3.0475,79.5,9433,.422435,347.43857,.14790,..4258203941,34190147043

    '4,9434190,847.:8942841,7$:.;4,9438,3.:/0-:9349-0290/942:7/07970,9203947/05479,943948,;0,-474714749075:7548041.;,3545:,94341

    4734..:50/90779472:7/0747970,92039415784307841,7473907300847507843439080,8470800702574507970,9203941489,05:3/07415:-.4757;,905745079,3943/0897:.94341.908943847;,047/0;,89,943349:8910/-29,730.0889

    :7/07090723,943038,;02039/05479,943,3/49073:2,3,.98.422990/,,389.;,3545:,943-0147047/:7390,74750780.:94343549.,7,.,47704374:3/300.:9;041473.4330.9439,3.720/0130/07030907473493;4,94341904.,,8

    #$!$$$

    ,554392039%0202-078410,.29,7.42288438,-0,554390/-90

    !708/0394190!5530847:3/07,:9479/00,90/-29073,9082,-0,554390/-90.43;033,:9479$:.8,,9903/,8088434190.4228843,3/3.,804130884749073.,5,.941,3573.5,202-07,3,9073,908,9,0905,.0419,9202-073;,.,3.,24390202-07847,9073,9084..:773,1907,97,,8-0:32,-010/-90.43;033,:9479-:9908:-89,3.041,574.00/3,/0;/03.09,0339,9.,808,-02,/034394908,/30202-0747,9073,90%81,.988,-0,334:3.0/-905708/0394190.422884334503.4:79

    -:2-074102-078,..42288438,.43889413490889,39700202-078

    .":,1.,9438%0.43;033,:94798,,554399490.42288435078438420/0907230894-0.4250903994507147290/:9083;4;0/,3/349/86:,10/-507843,390708947570:/.0574;/0/9,9345078438,-0,554390/940,7,.,803.0507843,3;089,90/4707038570803.0,8,930888706:70/30850.,6:,10/202-074807:3813,3841,7,8.43.073890.422884343,34-0.9439490,/288-9410;/03.0411070//:739097,

    /'493.059,89490,/288-9410;/03.0,7:38,3/13/3419042288438,-0-2,479;4900.0599,9.43;.943,3/803903.08,-0-90,1172,9;0;490413490889,3.43;.943,3/803903.08,-0-90,1172,9;0;490413490889,39497/84190202-075708039

    0!708/302-073900;0399,990.43;033,:9479/4083493,204304190202-07,8905708/3202-079080347411.07,24390202-0741904228843

    57080398,5708/0

    '!#$&%#$

    ,554392039%0.43;033,:94798,/083,9043047247050784394.43/:.99057480.:943-014700,..4228843

    -:908%0/:908419057480.:947,70

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    35/121

    %45705,70,3/5708039.,708,3/850.1.,94381477010703.094,.4228843

    %45705,70.,80814797,,3/94.43/:.99057480.:943-0147090.422884341,.,8087010770/14797,

    '!#!#$$

    ,43/:.94190%7,42288438,

    431300,.97,897.9941,7,3/050/94:80,73439088:087,80/-90.,7080.:/37700;,3988:08470;/03.0,3/570;0393,3:330.088,7/0,47390710703.0

    0,8:22,79,3.439:2,.47.439025925483,3,557457,905:3820399070147

    4/5:-.80884303490780/0./0/-90.4228843

    4/0,.808843,98:.920,3/5,.0,898,/090723047,82,-0/70.90/-90.43;033,:9479

    -#984190..:80/%0,..:80/8,-003990/

    %4,;03,/;,3.0419097,,.454190.,708,3/850.1.,9438.0,747/0/84,894,5578090,..:80/410,.4110380.,70/

    %4-07057080390/574794,3//:7397,-.4:380,554390/-90.43;033,:947947.4:38041843.4.04794.43/:.9843/010380

    %4908913843-0,1,3/,;08.4:3805708039700;,390;/03.0,99097,3

    8:55479418/010380,3/.74880,2300,.,/;0780930884507843,,550,78-0147090.4228843

    %4,;0908:-89,3.04190.,708,3/850.1.,943890574.00/38,3/,3/4.:2039,70;/03.097,38,90/0308:3,-049078094:3/0789,3/902

    .9308808%042288438,,;05407

    %48:22439308808,3/706:70907,9903/,3.0,3/908924394,/2389074,9847,1172,9438949308808,3/49075078438,3/946:089439308808

    %4706:7090574/:.94341/4.:20398,3/49070;/039,72,907,

    %4/00,9090!7480.:9478,554390/-90.43;033,:94799054078,3//:90880914793,3/,-4;0

    %4,;00;/03.09,03-,850.,.422884307,554390/-90.4228843

    /;/03.0

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    36/121

    %0.42288438,,/298:.0;/03.0,8398453438,-041,8889,3.03574;347/8574;390.,70478:.,8390.42288438453434:/,;0574-,9;0;,:039023/41,70,843,-02,3%0.42288438,,55907:08410;/03.0,3/50,/38091479070399070,9089-07,994,.0;0050/94:8574.0/:7035,79.:,7,3/94:92933,3,908.45041901470430307,7:089014430;/03.02,-0,/2990/

    ,3/4.:2039770850.9;04198.,881.,943.,550,789490.422884394,;0-003830/4788:0/-,3411.07/05,792039,03.47202-074190,720/147.0841,34;073203994:957441419083,9:7047419088:,3.04190/4.:2039

    -3705479.,550,789490.422884394,;0-003830/4788:0/-9039073,943,#0/748847,202-0741,320/.,807;.05078433047-,33;089,9474739003.0411.0747-,3490750784342.4228843.438/078,854880883340/041902,99078.439,30/390705479

    .11/,;98/05489438474907830/89,9020398

    /3/,709907944907/4.:20393.:/3847389,9020398,550,739490.422884394.439,331472,94370,939490.,70

    0.4541,3/4.:203947490780.43/,70;/03.04190.4390398190473,8349220/,90,;,,-0

    %0.42288438,9,0:/.,349.0411,.9841.42243340/0411.,4;0732039/4.:2039841,33,943,3/90574.00/3870.47/8,3/13/384129,7474907,03.0841,34190&390/,943

    .42288432,706:709057480.:943,3/90/010380942,0,57023,7411074157441070:54390.42288432,7:03,/;,3.04390,/288-9418:.0;/03.0

    %0411.,5489434190,..:80/8,349,-84;0217427085438-9347-0.438/070/329,943415:382039:7907,.9435:78:,3994,347/074190,..:80/88:50747474184;07320398,349.43899:90,/010380-:92,-0.438/070/329,943415:382039190.4228843/090723089,9:89.084706:708

    5:75480/.4310884384789,90203984190,..:80/8,-00,/288-030;/03.094:9,38439,990070;4:39,72,/01988439,98:..431088434789,902039,8574.:70/-20,3.90.4228843-00;094,;0-003418:.,.,7,.9079,92,,;0.,:80/90,..:80/942,0,1,8089,90203990.42288432,89704:947/870,7/,38:.547943907041,8,884574.:70/

    0%7,!74.0/:70%0574.00/38410,.97,8,-0.43/:.90/8:-89,39,,81448:308824/10/-90.4228843948:9905,79.:,7.7.:289,3.08

    ,..,70,3/850.1.,9438,-070,/47988:-89,3.089,90/34503.4:79

    %05708/3202-078,,80,.,..:80/0907050,/8:94749:9

    %057480.:9438,2,0984503389,902039%05708/3202-072,,99847,34907920706:709057480.:9479489,90,90;/03.0057454808948:-299490

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    37/121

    .4228843,3/90.42288439070:5432,7:0:54390,/288-9418:.0;/03.0

    %09308808,3/49070;/03.01479057480.:9438,-00,7/4757080390/990.4804190.,801479057480.:94390.42288432,43249434190/010380147,13/341349:9.438/07,3/7:0090700;/03.0-0147090.42288432,/0107

    ,.94343,38:.24943,3/5072947706:709057480.:9439470450398.,80,3/574/:.0,31:7907,;,,-00;/03.0

    %0/0103802,2,0,34503389,9020395747945708039398.,80%05708/3202-072,,998,34907920706:7090/0103809489,90,90;/03.0957454808948:-299490.4228843070:54390.42288432,7:0:54390,/288-9418:.0;/03.0

    %09308808,3/49070;/03.014790/0103808,-00,7/4757080390/%070,19079057480.:943,3//0103802,3974/:.08:.0;/03.0370-:99,,890.42288432,7:0,8-03,/288-0

    %0/010380,3/9070,19079057480.:9438,,//708890.4228843

    %0.42288439070,19078,.438/0790.,803.480/808843,3/:3088490780/70.90/-90.43;033,:9479,334:3.034503.4:7998:/2039,3/803903.01,3%0.42288432,89,909070,84343.:/20398-,80/

    1#0.47/41!74.00/38,..42288438,2,0,805,7,9070.47/4198574.00/339097,410,..,80-74:9-014709%070.47/8,-05705,70/-9057480.:947:3/0790/70.9434190.4228843,3/8:-2990/9490/010380.4:380%0.42288438,-07085438-014798,..:7,.$:.70.47/.07910/-905708/3202-074190.42288434788:..088478,-0/0;070/9490.43;033,:9479,88443,85488-0,19079097,

    $03903.0%0.42288432,803903.0,3,..:80/:543.43;.94394/0,9-,33478449325784320391471047147,30889072130478:.49075:382039,890.42288438,/090723094-0574507

    5574;,41$03903.04803903.041,29,7.42288438,-0.,770/3940110.9:39,5574;0/-90.01411$9,11!74;/0/%,934803903.041/0,9471025784320398,-0.,770/39400.:943:39.431720/-90!708/0394190!5530847905:7548041870;0900141$9,118,.70,90,4,7/41#0;094-0.425480/4134924709,39700411.078343041428,-043/:9947,8830/9490:/0/;4.,900307,811.0%00141$9,118,,;0,:947994,5574;029,9070293404735,79.422:908:8503/70/:.047490780,90790803903.025480/4794:9570:/.09490,..:80/702,3/90.,80147700,73-01470,30

    29,7.4228843-:908,349,;0,:9479943.70,809080;0794190803903.0.059,80703490780574;/0/90:/2039,3/803903.041,.42288438,13,,3/3498:-0.99470;0-,3490797-:3,

    '#&!#

    $:5502039,7#:0,3/4728,..42288438,,/4597:08,3/14728944;07398574.0/:703493.43889039990574;84341987/07478:.7:08,3/14728,82,-05708.7-0/-90.43;033,:9479(47-90!708/0394190!55308

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    38/121

    '%0,24:3941,24:394180;03:3/70/94:8,3/508488070-809,8/04:94190,557457,943814790724190!55308147:80-90,943,,7720811.0390,..42582039419828843,80703,-4;08091479,3/8,-00503/0/3,..47/,3.099070.42203/,9434190:/0/;4.,900307,,8,5574;0/-90!708/039%0-:/3819:708389,,943820883,3/-09306:52039,3/490757450790701470:80/-9030,$0.943,3,7,3.41900307,0,/6:,79078

    $:57020422,3/07147900/!407.-09:730/4;07-90&390/$9,908729490!553084;0732039974:9047036:/,9434228843,3/90$:75:8!7450794228843,70070-850.1.,94370807;0/147:8041190,943,,7720811.0

    0.:9;07/074/,90/::898070-7050,0/

    430390941,3,989/,41:3900,741:747/3309003:3/70/,3/147980;03,3/41903/0503/03.04190!553089080.43/

    $!708/0394190!55308

    90!708/039

    0141900.:9;011.0

    &%'$%

    0.:9;07/0748,;079,-050.04108,9;020,8:7094:990-0301941.43708843,03,.92039

    %017896:089439,9897:89,94:71,.0850,70,/3,74:54149073408825479,396:08943809074734990!708/0394190!553082,007.809008,9;05407057088;0890/3437088-9043899:943

    %043899:943574;/08

    %008,9;0540788,-0;0890/3,4370884190!55308.8,.4388941,$03,90,3/4:8041#05708039,9;08$0.94379.0'

    09070834057088574;8433901:3/,2039,,574-9390007.804108,9;05407-,03.0849079,3437088,70,/3419040.43909419043899:9434://850,3/4:-9,89490.43899:943,390399,99008,9;05407894-0007.80/0.:8;0-4370888:-0.9439490;09454074190!708/0394190!708/0394190!553089490850.1.574;843.,4905708/0394190!55308948:8503/9057;00841907941,-0,8.475:8,3/945,.0,35,794190!55308:3/072,79,,,3/94907:02,35407057088;0890/-9043899:943390$:570204:79

    %070.,3349-0,36:089439,990202-07419043899:943,43;03943070-00;078390975,799088902414;0732039,8473,03:3.,90/-7894901:79070,-47,90/-43906:0:,3/,..0590/,3/57,.9.0/-24/073/024.7,.080850.,90&390/$9,9041

  • 8/3/2019 PIL - GenPrinciplesCases

    39/121

    207.,48043899:943,1907.4:78,8-0035,990730/,8,4.,90/9097005407414;073203908,9;000.:9;0:/.,94/893.9,3/805,7,90/05,792039414;0732039

    0.,:80905407;0890/-4:743899:943949080;07,/05,79203941904;0732039,703903,9:70417,39834970.43943415700893540734/05,792039414;07320392,007.80,3540747,:94793490570887,390/-9043899:94347-,-;79:0057088

    ,:9479419043899:943

    0.:9;07/074089,-808,,943,,7720811.0,3/90540794089,-84;0732039411.08088039,08,9;0

    %047/07574;/089,9507843,..:80/,8,7.723,88,-0970/-29,7.4228843809078:.,574;84388:-89,39;047,/0.9;098.0,708,9;033,9:709.431078:54329,7.42288438:78/.9439497,5078438.,709,7.7208%0540794/0130,3/,4.,90:78/.9431479057480.:94341507843,..:80/41,3.72080.:8;0;0890/-9043899:9433437088

    9574;/087:0841574.0/:7014790.43/:.94197,4197,%8574;84343574.0/:7,8:-0.9

    .43899:908,:8:75,94341907:02,35407;0890/-43899:943390$:570204:79

    9,:9470/29,7.4228843