title 英国の核災害時緊急事態対応体制と日本 citation policy ......2 nt.:
TRANSCRIPT
Title 英国の核災害時緊急事態対応体制と日本
Author(s) 進藤, 眞人
Citation 環境法政策学会誌 = Journal of Environmental Law andPolicy (2016), 19: 204-218
Issue Date 2016-03-24
URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/215757
Right © 2016 環境法政策学会
Type Journal Article
Textversion publisher
Kyoto University
1 . iff~O)~~ t § ~
Jii:t~:;lç~*~~
l&iililÀ
*Jl:mn:t1HMf~-W--Tn9êmm$Pll:1±, ~1=11t1:rt~JID1::1D1:M~~15~i1Jt
'I& !_,, B *5!:...t~~O)~:ljlîifil±.l i 1b t.: G L t.: (J:). T' *m~x ~ è ~T) 0
$Pl!:{~ 41f".W. __ b'.l'ffJ~ Lt.:m1:E it, *m~x ~i5t~1:m<:.1€l-"2'-tt- 7.i El :iii± "il.0 "(v>~Po *m~x•0)1~~a*i-t 7.i 1:1i, ;f<~X*"0)~1iiB-~, •tt L~1tn
li~ G ~"'~El li~*l:Gb7.io ~xwa~•A$i~Mr.t1*llrlJli, ~0)$0)·:rC"ëb.7.io ml~DO) J:-? 1:*m~XWi:i\<.h "lli, --~.$i~Mr.t~0)7i!L7'.1' *~~~Mt~~, OO~--~·R000)=$Pll:~it~-~-~~1b,~~
•~O)~n~G~n~n0)&••~#~"2'nk~ L~L, oo~--~O) jilîj$Pll:~O)fJl~ft:7'.1'~~"2' n7.i f!J0)20121f". 6 J3 1:, W--=rnm11ru~•~filtii: $0)l!rIJ7E:1: J: 7.i &• (W. T, i21f". 6 J3 &• t ~-t) 7'.I'~ "2' nt.:0)~(3\ *m ~XW~R:~ Lt.:~Mil' è\:. i ~Rfül"2'nt.:7'.l'li.~iEi~-t ~o
**' *11t~XWi~lt"l0)1Tft*!Ul0)1:E ~ nO)~m L i-â"tr&•O)• ~li, R~7'.l-G5!R"il. L "l$Pll:O);tj:~iEi1T-? OO~$pjc~O)pJTlf$~~ëb0 t.:(4 lo L il' L, R~li, !Bi~1:&f'!.i è L t.:pg:g:~~itO)h!:wJb t.:R~.±.$0) &•iMhkO)~,&•O)-~n#~bn~~-~,RM~$Mi~· L -r121f". 6 J3&•7'.l'frbnt.:7'.I', ~O)ftb ~ 1:oo~•Pll:~O)•~-~~~ 0)00~~~-*iir'*°i .l -r 31f".W.11'Jl:~m Li1T-? $è ~ 0 t.:(6lo ~O)~!: •~~~~,~•-t11'JW~X•t-t•#B-in7.i~ti•&-t7.im•~~# 1*1R "2' nt.:(1 )0 ~0)1~, 20131f".llfa3 1:W--=rnm11ru~•~filtii:t*O)-:g:~&JE il'~ "2' nt.: it 0)0), 121f". 6 Y3&•rO)~x•~•••t~Mr.t1*llrIJ (W.T, 121f". 6J31<$:$IJ è ~T) li~- "2' n "(v>~v>(8lo ~ 0) J: -J ~~~ilr'*i .ln it, *•~x•O)~w11i1tJ1!H:~rr, ~~O)oo~~~-*i~'*i .z -r, xi: W~ttO)Gb7.i~XW-•A$D1*~iW•-t7.i&O)K•~•tti1T-?•• li, 1:&f'!.iè l,"({i1Ijv>è~.Z7.io
"2' -r, *m~x•O)~w111i, :J:lt*U89.\\;l,~1:1:&0-r~ Gi.1-1: "2'n7.i'""-~ ~ ëb7.io ~ 1b ~ 1b, =·pjc~O)&••~ li~·f L itJ:t~Y*~~:ltill:"il.0-r~
204
2 nt.: <b 0)-c:'li~ <' -'f 0)1JH~I: li-t:'~lœ!Jt~:g:B:Jt <b Je,~lt G n~ 0 îtÉ-? l,•••~WO)&~iMi~l,.~W~ttO)~~-~·-·••DM rc:;1*î!f1Jim~i"~1:1i, if, =•McWWJO)f:!s t r•~Wifi.~L.t.:)'[;Jt§
~OOil;, t•O) J:-) ~-~-~RA$!~Mf,()1*$1Ji~ll l lit'~ O)il>J i .lt ®( l l, iW:1\rO):ff~;-JJti i:iït~~T ~&::-~il;~ 7:> -J o
*1iWiii, .::O)J: -J ~r .. ,m:W:~1:n:t::>, =•McWWJO)f:!s t19s1~1-=*mfl -~Wifi.~ lt.:~000)$1J& t O)J:tf;(?J-1Jîifr-? t.:-J ~ ""t', 12~ 6 .F.11*îlflJ i~füET~o ~000)$1jjj'.O);JIOC~i~~*BH::te'..t!i"~'.f:'.-~il'i?, ;ljl;::PJf~li, )( ~wm'.i:1:fJa ~ l, .±~00~:1\r""-O)!fm:i!B91 / ?' !::'. .:i -0).:f.7* i .WIH~ L. t.: WfüE1îJf~ i -~ l t.:(9lo ~00-c:'O)m.:1:111.WWJ'.i:li, 2014~ 9 .F.129Bil'G10.F.l 12 B l:il>ltl1T:b:l'Lt.:o
;1js;:fiWiO)mmt1i, if, ~001:.B1t~m.1fO)•~W-RA$!~Mrc:;{l.fï:$IH: 01t>l1IOCMT ~o ?XI:, i*0)3z:lfüè 1t>-) ;JIOC;%i1> G r .. ,mt ~ ~, RA$!~M f,(51:00-9 ~fr®'.F(fO) 7::fJ'7/?'l::'. 1}T1 lit{~H:01t>l0)~000)l!"JtffJl.Jj. i~
Mi"~o.-fll,=:$McWWJO)f:!sèO)ttf;(i~tl,•••~•O)ftmi
~ Gil>l:i" ~o :ii:1&1:, 12~ 6 .F.11iîlfIJil;.::nGO)ftWll iffiil' l lv'~ O)il> 1:01t>l~~iEifr1t>, B ;ljl;:il;4-1&1*~rZ~ :1Jf1il'liifl-#-i" ~o
2. •oo~~tl~-~-~~--~M~~~ ~00-c:'li, ~ W-~Jtl:Mi" ~ R~-•t~Mf,()1*$1J ii!t;1Jt1:, -~ W~:Mrc:;
T ~1.?,0)~~lEi:!.JD~ l, -~W•RA$!~Mf,()1iîlf1Ji~ll l l1t'~o -(-0) ~Hl!Hi, -~Wil;~:!t:g:BF,""t'§e:!t lf.:O)i1>!iX;1t>liiP'.$$F,""t'§e:!t lf.:O)il' ~: J: "'.) l ~~ ~ i1~0\ ;ljl;:fiWi-c:'li, B * t O)M J:t i;%EJU:, ~:!t:g:BF,""t'§e:!t l ~-~W""-O)•A$8Mf,()1*~~-~i--?l8t~o~,M•1t0)1.?,,
;ljl;:fiWi""t'~i 1 / 77 / rO)RA$t~Mrc:;1iîlf1J î:-~000) <b 0) t l ltb'l-J o
(1) ~1it~W-O)RA$t~Mrc:;1iîlf1J
~000)RA$8Mf,()1*~-fttHMi"~~-c:'·~~0)~,1Wat•:1JO)
1~~U?tt!!""t' ~ ~ o ~00-c:' li, .:: O)=-:::> li5.JIJ11m O):j:§'f.q!*mtEl:~;Q G n~ u~o .:: .:: ""t'-W:i':i"rZ~ li, r .::nG0)1~~U?ttfüi, OO~ffii:-T:/Jmoo (IAEA) il; RA$8Mf,()ff1r71/-c:'H%i"~*/~1rè*7~1r~Mf,()i"~
<b O)"""(:'~i~lt>J t "'-) .:: t """(:'~ ~ 0 IAEA 0) 'jf 1 r 71 /"""(:'~,% 2 n lV' ~ * /~1 r li-~HP'J:g:Btt§' l, * 7~1 Hi-fO)ŒJ;i2Hl!1.~it§'i"u2lo .::n~Mll~OO""t'~, RA$8Mf,()O)Mat~t%89~%•lli3~~
205
*/~1rt*7~1r0~~~MT~Mllii~bo
-~-•t~i:.t:Ht ~ iWf.5tMllili, ffil~i&R'fi.J>.±{:$:t ~-? -Cfi1t>, ~j!IH'îi&
•~0•••DMlliB•~:0-c&•~n~•~··#,aq0•~~G W:b~H:1t>t..:~ i "t."0Jt1:fi1Él-? o •~'1m~1i, •• · •fll'~ · •~0.=:lim ~i.J-G~~t~t!*Mëi~00 W~ff~•~f*0t l? i t<l6~5tifü-? t~!:iW
*IMlli!:~T ~ji~#Ç~:J'Uii~001;t, ::r-;v F · :=r7 / ?f-1."~~o .::. 0~5t~li:im., XWi.J'~~ LJ..:Jt':l:@t§ mf*0ff~~ji~ffff~i.J'i!J<l6 ~o ::r-;v r- · =r7/?f'-ii, xw~~m•i.1-G;!fü13JffiJiti111t>t..:•rfr (:lm• !i, *~Jt':l:@t§mf*01f~*:gfü i:ffl:.~:@-t / :7- t~T ~ iW*15i"j§f]%'8'~ ifill'.11 l -C, -t-.::. "t"iW*lMlli0aqwitÉl*T ~o m•MlliijiJi!ftT ~ ~i:af!l'~iM~T ~ 01i, -:/ Jv1~·- · :=r7 / :7·-1."~~o m•W&0ril!fL 1:~~J61n~0iill!1t~~, •fll'~0•~1i, xwm•"t."1i~ <, -r-01-t j/j:!:filt11~n~m:f:t!1.t~t!P.Jf"t"1Tbh~o IZS!Jj.!:, 1Bi:X l-Cfïê:ffl:I!"@!:~~ •iti7~~ l -c, m:f:t!1.t~t!rfr0f-t~~filt0$1imi.J'~•ftit G n -c"' ~ o X Wm:J:ji1Él*T~7·0/:Z:-. :=I7/?'-!i, -~~nt..:•fll'~i~fil-CX W0~Dfti:~t..:~o fàJ, ~000RA•t~Mlli"t."!i, filî7f:•iiJ]'UliJi.J'~ffl~
n -c.B l?, MM0#Ç~t~1Tlif- r A 7-;; 7'~i\:"t."1Tbh~o i t..:, .::.0 murn 1:: l')' 9ê t·0•••t~MlliliiW*IMlli0Jj. "t."7f:*i!fT ~(!4)0
.::. ni:M l-C1&~Mllili, î*~IJ~Xwi:~ l-C0Jj., i:ti:R:i&R'fi.J>.±{:$:t ~-? -Cfi-? o 1&~Mllif*l!îIHi, X W07*~1J&!:lli t.-c, .±8'§JT0Jj.i.J>.± •T~•it·.±&'§IT#M~rti±•T~•it·~M.±•0•-ft~~~n ~o 1&=~0•-ft1:1;t, ~M~%füJi~ (COBR) i.J'filtîl~n, 1&~Mllii t~t!T ~ t ~1:•~-•t~Mlli~f*0fltj§f)%'8'~ t ~ ~o 1&~Mlli!:.B1t>-C ii, i:ti:R:ï&R'f0~1Ji*1t-c0·1wf~ijx~ · ~*Ji'i:l!.:-?1t>t-=••B':lt~%0~ %, iVJ;f;IJl"t."0~lîthiP3it!:it<l6~~0Ms~ir.J~, ·-~~R0~).~t·
0JZ:1*~8i.J'1Tbh~o i t..:, ;1. 71 7Mlli~01t'f~ffith~M::9i-tJTOO<b~ i n~ù5)o fü l, ~Mi.J'iW*75t"t."0•A•t~MlliiŒI~t~t!T ~.::. t li~v'o
(2) ~X W~0•a•t~Mlli
~xw~0•••DMlli~,:im•07~-7/'r~~XWffl0*~-;/3
/ ift-9- lt..: <b 0 t ~-? -C1t>~(ls)o iW*l-z:·0•a•t~Mllili, XW0J5'1 i.J'~1iffifilt!JX:f:t!1.~ i:!l::. i ~:J:j-ft t ml:ill § mf:$:!:1éi:Wi.J'&~•-ft1:~1t-c~1im ~ n -Cv' ~ o J5'1i.J'~~filt!JX:f:t!1.~"t." !l::. i ~ î3l~0:f1~~-itt~0Mlli!i, -~B':Ji:•~~i.J>Jff:fi~-? o R:*~•itt"t."ml:ill§mf*i:1éi:Wi.J'&~•it
206
1: li, :im'itO)RJ@$i~:Mr.t1*11îiJ7'.J'ffciP:tl ·ciW*7'ltî5J%l'fB7'.J'mfl ~filai il', :t /-1J"1 r:Mf.t0)'.Jtff:li$.1!r7'.J'~ -7(17)0 :ft{XWiJ'~ tt..:~,g-, 1&7J:Mr.tN. 'CfR8$i~:Mr.t~{<$:0)~'i5J%J'fB-C·~ 1.i COBR li, lit?§ thB91: filttl ~ n 1.io~O)TT~W~&M~lli-)O)U, ~8WffT~1.ii*~~---Rth
'&' (DECC) èl*JMR8$i~:Mr.t$8fiùT~1.i(IB)o
(3) ••1lr1:J:7.i:t/-it1 riW*7t:Mr.t ••1lf t: J: 1.i R8$i~:Mr.tUWi O);f.±li, R~,$i~Mr.t*1iifi · ~* è fsfcWJ • *~ è M!ifilt~~-~ · ••*lfüm 0) lm-? il' G ~ 1.i o R~,$i~7'.J'~ t t..:~,g-, ••1lf•O)î5J%•è~1.JO)U,nffifiltl*JR8$DW~~/~-ŒEC~T~
1.io SECC li, $Mc!:~ l--CO)t9JJ~Mr.t!:Jr{:f:~fij:0o ~ l --C, ••1lfpq J'fBO)fxfr-rnBr~. ~!}l-'f.-.::.~ 1) /:7.i'fBr~èO)~·O)tiiJ» MJH~Dè l--C, ~m1!r·~?17·~e•oo·~-~O)Mr.t~fr-J~
1t!?.1J, ;t/-1J"1 H:J3!t7.i$Mr:~M1tl:li, l&Ffif'b00-9-i"l.io fri&t:J: 7.iiWaMr.tO)m•m•mt~7.iO)U,$Mr:W~~/~- ac~ T~l.io
SECC è ICC !ij!M~mt ~ ,g-\.t>, •Mr:m~t::mM{t0)~0)~1itlî$~~iJiH! T 1.i o m~~M!i$~0)fifîtlli, ~:kiR.O)Rft!:~:ifil!:Mr.tT ~ 1.i J:-) t::~th 1lJW~~ JÇ~iJ' G fr-) o $i&:iJ'1Jt::k lit:~ v./'{Jvl:: ~ ·::d..:~,g-, ICC O)Jj..~ Gf~CC1b,fiîa:Mr.tî5J%$T~1.i~·-~~/~-èj!M~•~1T -) Cl<» 0
(4) fiî*,'Jtî5J%$!: J: 1.i R8$i~Mr.t
fiî*,'Jtî5J%i'fM'W~i" 7.iR8•t~Mr.t1:1i, :t /-it1 r TO)$i&:~M1t0) Jj..~Gf, :t7-1T1rTO):JDcMail'L'.JO)'f±R~~i1b-2iitL1.io1±R~~O)
:f± e: L --c ~,JE~ n --c v, 7.i 0) 1i, ~ l*J1;f• e: 1±Rj1Jlt& if 3 '7 ~=tru 0) m~ffl T ~1.io ::O)pq, 1±Rj1JjH:00l--C:L:k.lf, $fijf:jlJUt@iJ'~'.iE~tl--Cv> 1.i~f*-Hiit@jlft!R~!HttlêB9~<, :ft{Mi!filtO)JajJHI 1 ~3.5km !ll*J!:~~·~
v'o fü l, $i&:iJ'::kmm;~~,g-, jlft!R~li1Jt5:R ~ tl1.i75Ef: ~-'.) "lv' 1.i~ l~l~#G,A1*~~7J~•Ufi~~~Gtl--CJ3Gf,~~1b~ v'_t.1:, :ft{M!!filtili?JeB1ix:im*~7'.J'~ i ~ •m~ n --cv'~v'~, j1JftlR~:tJt5:R
O)~~:Jrt11:1i~r .. ~7'.J'~ ~ n --Cv>1.i(22)o iWaî5J%l'fB7'.J'X wi:Ji!tJ.H:M~T ~ 1.i 7'.J> t•-) 7'.J>li, -~'•t~Mf.tO)ffltB
~~~-?o~OOTU,:ft{XWO)fiatt~~•l, ~-~~·~7/~-#
1Elv'~,'i!:f,~7E~1Tk.1.iJ:-)f:, :ft{m.l!î!Jff (ONR) O)iiJl.t~N:WiJ» l&Ffif
'}[)7
;J=tîillfDr"', (GTA) è l"C tcr:•W:i;j!--1:/:$'-!:iJRJt~noo •Mc@J:Hl, ••~0ttîillfU~#*7~1~T0fiaMŒ~~ToM8tft~#, GTA !±tcr:aW:i;j!-t: / :$' - f:~U;i L.(k~, -t"01f:$i5 I ~ m <· o GTA fi, */~1~MŒè*7~1~MŒ0~~~~ll,~o~~M•~~To
ttîillf~Msift~o·•~t-~MŒ$~~,GTA#~~~Msift~
o.l:~!:tbi1JTo.::èi~$1•HH:>:l'tlv'oo it.:, GTA!±, ï&cfffi1-t ~llfi*,'JlMŒf:~To~:fWèm~i1'H 0 .::0.J: ~ f:fiaMŒ0~è ~o GTAT~oi,){, -t"011iti!l'U!±~< iTl>MsT~~' :~U~é9~ft,l(!;i,#Ç7Ë:J'i
~lH±::J·-;vF · ::17/:$1"-7'.J;*-Jo .::0GTA01!fUoc!±, 1957fF071 / :t'.'T-Jv•M1:~0•~l5t:l'JT7'.J>G1~Gnt.: r•JJZW~•••i~MŒ!:~ l l 1±, ••~7'.1'G~!lrl'r. L.t.:;Jtmit~oîlf-~~Ms7'.1;,z,~T~oJ t P ~ fXWH: ~-?v>lfiltil ~nt.: li 0T~ o ~o
(5) 1~~MŒ
J*JM~"Îlfüit~ (COBR) !±, D/ F/i:J:l,l.,$7'.J'Gf~~MŒi;J=ljf!To
7'.J;, '.li:'.·~!:Œ t l-~~i:l:llti~T~ o*î1c~*JLfiM1H~i~T oo COBR 0i:J:l m: 1: ~ 0 l ft,l(!;f, iR:lË t ft ~ 0 !±, §;f§ i t.: !± .:r.. ;r, Jv :f'-1n.1~~1111.:î'
(DECC) *ê:i,){~*i$ô6o~lll~~jt$;T~oo -t-0""f0~1l•Jj!:g:~1±, •JJZW!:.J: o~~iiVHtT01?,0M•0•5Ët, %M!H:~To~~ift ~ 0 i t.:, •••i~JIX:Jîrf.+~Msm (SAGE) !±, COBR i*J0/ê-'i5'~~i,)î~,l(!;f, iR:7Ëifh ~!:'.li:'.·~~, f.+~89 · 1Hl'ifé9~Ms i:fH o fi*&MŒè 0~{,fT!±, COBR è0~;Ml-~~i@:W!ft~ 0!±, ::f-Jv F · ::J7/:$f"-;fljf!""f 0m:aw}j!-t: / ?7-1:m~Gno(24)0
COBR ifllî1ti:To1?,!:, .±.$'§1TT~o DECC 1=••••i~~"ÎJfüJi ~ (NEBR) 7'.J;filtil~:l'too NEBR011ittU!±, J>ZW~:!èiR.011'.!W, 1tB-~è0 ~~' ~U'f:OO~-~~~Yi--~ è 0~~~ t·T~oo .::nG0i:r1:1±, fi•'Pl"ÎJ$f:;J3v>li&cffftt111'iTDr"', (GTA) i1m1ti:T 0 ï&cfff3tt.î$~0iJR7t Ji.='' SAGE ""-0•$ ~m:1~ "& U' SAGE § ffl;f.+~Dr"', i!RJt~i,)î~ i n 0 0 1tB ~,n~-~-~T~o·•~IT(ONru ~,fia0••~ttcr:•W:i;j!-t:
/:$'-!:~~'§iiJR7tll, fiaMŒ01*ri~è~~Too ONR!±, NEBR i:li t l COBR è ~iMJ-tl&oÇ25)o
3. •W•~~--~M~tfi8W~7~~~~~~~1 ~00~$~00·T~o0T,•JJZW~0RA•DMŒ~~llli,•a
208
'i='.'l!t!.: J: 0 frJl&Jff O) 7 :tJ 7 / 7 t'. 1) T 1 ·WH:li!:O){:UJi(26)t~I! v·n,> 0 0 iO)~-è~o0)~.08•0)•A•1:f:O)*&~~o~~OOO)•···~ llfiJli, JJ&lffiJ'i:•:t~~M1tt~:MIH1'-J · ~;b$8'-Jl.:fr.:Z.o J:-? 1.:. A;!t1*~~1.:
Bt l~1t>~l IJ ~~4 ~mllf1J tfr-J.::. è iWf'ilT VClt>oo .::. ni.: J: IJ, •:t~
~M1t illi*-9 o 08 a 7'.J'i'.•8t~51"{1.:~frl~1t>.::. è & ü*~08a 0) •8t~W-to.::.è~.mnè2~Gno~•x••O)••••MŒ~ 1i • .::. O)m.27'.J'i:J@:ffl ~ n. 08a7'.J'i::lf'J@:w.J~frj}Jt~n1i. *u••*&v~••*O)Ma è ~ 0~9)0 .::. O)~*JUi. 08•7'.J'i:~JHft tJ-C1:f:81.:~t.: IJ. 1!!1iW1:f:~:k:t~1.:~(8G~1t>J:. ~~~~~ o o
08aO)fi*ifr-? O)li. •mllflJJT (ONR) ~~oo lltrff,ljtM$0)Wf:f:::iï ~ ~ 0 ::f- )V r . ::r? / 7"- li. JJ&lff:JiîitijJD:r,,, (GT A) il' G ft}J i§ t~it-c
~.1Gf,i*2 tfr-J il\ ftlJ i3 !1'1?&& u-~~flJ!ij'li~-c~c.~Jk ~ n. •1~'i='.'i!fO)M
aè~oo.fO)~O)tê.*08•~. *~·~:j:'.'l!fO)Maè~o~o~~~ 1i. •* tJW <''~1.:. m*08ardl~1:f:8~fr~:kiR.O)iffüï:liUltfr-J ·ifHr 7'.J'i:~ ~ -Clt'oo è !ilt>;t, lli*08a t~~1.:~)fi~-1t~1t>~!.:, l~~Ji -:J-f0)•.Si:~0)~~0)9;D5il.:~-:11t>-C~Gnt.:frjj)J 1.:~ l-Cli, fi*:5E. ·~;jt;ô'i:J};Z_ G no 0 11P.1J' 1~1JM$!.::B ft 0 !1'1Mi*21.: li. W1:f:*&7'.J'i: &!f~lt> è~2~n-C1t>o(3Uo
frll&W1:f:O)*&li. 08a 0)1mLA.1f1:f:*&iJ'i:iglv~iJ' Gfrbno~o • X WO)~::k ~ 1.:lfiJ;.nli, 5~1J ~W\11'.l!t;!t~l tif-t o .=f..ll.~a45i · ~rr~a 45i · ~i45i~5.JU~a45i0)~~•45i(33)7'.J'i:, •McWill'.'l!ttfr-J.::. è ~7.Et2~noo ;t t.:, •x•O)~t!J!DffiJI.: J:-'.:) -C!i, frll&JT ~ ~··1:f:&cffrll&W1H.:~ l-Cfi*O)Maè~IJ3oo~~.•~~O)•~~O)•#~,•Mctoom
89~5 I ~ ~ è-t ofi"t.: ~ r,,n!7'.J'i:f~1.:~ tt.:~-@-1.: li, ~45i::t / 7' :7."7 /7'.J'i: frll&:Jf1:f:i*&-9o.::.è~ifIJ1~oo -(-0)~!.:~f;;;f /7.Â""'< /li, ONR O):M'0·11u11t'ÊJ"~îtill:B'-J1.: ~-c 0)•51{~1* t il'Gv' Œï l -c. mJ!B'-J~ r,,,m t c)C~-t o~O):m:•tfr-J (34)0
4. ~~t~~âO)~IDll *îiP~li. lltrîiPi ~1.:J;.t.:~OOO)•XWM~,•:t~MŒ1:$:1!flJ è • .=:•McWill
O)rJCiJ:t!i'S t Jttl l-C, Jll~•XWO);JcIDll t~ G il'l.:-t oo
(1) lltri'1'!MŒ t iJt1E-t o :Q'.,~·li ~OOè B-*i.l:l::tllt.:~-@-. lltrfflM$0)1ë5f"{Jî!.:fi},l?i0)~7'.J'i:~oo =•
~)IJJ~ O)"ifij t.'ilM fit :a:-~~ itfniiO) i*L OO~$ Mc~ li' :t / -lt 1 1- M fit :a:-$~1\f 1:~*"-~ J: ~ 1:1!§ l-Cv\~Cl5li1\ $~1\fO)jfiJ~:f§BU::: P ~ r .. U!,~U:-:Jv\ -CIH~JJ[ l-Cv\~v\o JIUit•XW~O):t /-lJ-1 1-Mfitl:.Bv\-C, $~1\fi,);
~i:Pl:1$~ ff.Uti89t~*=l:Ji1Ji;i lt.::: t ti-IZSI t ~ ~, $t&i:P"O)ifü:Jk1±À iJ;J!Int.:000) li~c:~l:*'f l v\o ~001." li, ifiJ~;f§J~J: J: ~ a~O)MMiJ;~ G n~ v\$!i~ :a:-J!l!it ~~l:®:Jîfttfijt~r .. ~ (GTA) IUUJJ'.:a:-~À l -C, U:J!:Jîfi1; :t /-lf" 1 l-Mfitl:~-9-1-" ~ ~ J: ~ 1: ~ 0 -CP~ o ifiJ:fut;f§J~J: J: ~-X WO) tJt*:a:-~ <·~ 1: 1i, ~001:fl:a:-IIJ(~ /'{ ~ -r-th 0 ~ o
1t!!1J, ®:Jîf$Mc~ li, *t•X ~ 1: ~ l -C :t 7-lt1 1- -e / 7 -iJ;:J~U~ l ~'/,)>-:;> t.::: t 1:i[iJ7,, *m.mx WTL" t, •tm-r- ~ ~~:ffii.MM*$1*$1JO);fl ~:a:-:m:§ l-c"\~'37)0 i t.:, ~Jm$Mc~1i, *m.m•xw1:-t?tMfit-r- ~ ~.w:r~89~~1T~~~~O)~IJrut:a:-:m:§ l -C v\ ~ ci8lo :: n G O):J'!§ li, iW*·îMfit 0)•1iilJ7f' JE. :a:-t~:tiii-t ~ t, 0) \."' t, -::> t t, \."th~ 0
::O),r'/!,, ~OOO)•x•a~-~,$îi~Mfit1**'Hi*~~~1:~~0 rp\." t, 1± El ~ n~ 0) 1i, llW*IJ O)flJHl-r-th~ o 2. -r-h.t.: J: ~ 1:, ~oo-r-ii :t /-lf" 11- t:t7-lt1 H:.Bit~Mfit0)~1Ji1; liW*·îJ Mfitl:~ih~o ::ni: Ml-C, B*L"li llfüaJ :a:-:t/-lt1 J-t-:1t1:3*<1Wm-t~o Mel:, ~OO O)lfüaMfit-r-~ ~ jlbO)~fi!!.f~tlPJîl:;f§~-t ~ :t 7-lt 1 1- -e / 7 - 1:, lfüt.î ~%$~ffi~-t~~:ffii.MM*$0)&M:a:-mb%~•t,O)è~bh~o l~ l~i1;G, ::O)J: ~ ~ llWaJ 0)3*"\:f,@X.1J1:1i, 3'Mt1:r .. ~;mi1;th0t.:t ~b~--~ :a:-1~~\/\o :t /-lj-1 1- è :t 7-lJ-1 1- O)jjljj1Jl:.Bv\-ClWf•ÎMfit•n~ :a:--t:@:l:"*=t.:-t~1:1i, :t /-lJ-1 1-iJ'i? li;f§~ll!lht.::f;g;.PJTl:lfüt.î~%~~:a:
rutti-t ~~·~i1;th~o t ::0iJ;, :t/-lJ-1 HtJ!i:O)~:ffii.f~tl.PJTl:lfü*·î~%
~~0)1~iu:a:-mb%-C li 0 t.:~1:, *t•XWL"li, ~ilhf~tlPJTO)~JllXI: J:~1W-~%$i-r-ti#~O)-ftiH*=l-Cli0~o~l-C,~M%f
ïWt.îMfit1**'li1;N3~ l-C li 0 t.:~*' ** 11&1JMfitJ 89~1f~i1T~ ::t:a:-JJH~~n-cv\t.:i*JMiJ;, 7ë?t~•1imti~<:t/-lf"11-è:t7-lt11-
jj!jjfffü: ~ l -C, IWt.îMfit i 1T ~ îi.Bl El 1: ~ 0 -C li 0 t.: o :: 0) J: ~ ~ iW*·'ilM fit1*$1JO)ffl[~~1i::~i1\ *t•X~1:.B1t\-c~~.$îi~Mfiti*i!JlîLl:~(Bn
~~~L"th~o ::O)::è~,~*O)B*O)•XW~•A$8Mfit1*~0)
*89?z~(Bè l-C, ~og~~n~itnl!~G~v\o 1PJa~1:::0)J: ~ ~ lïWaJ 0)3*"\[email protected]&I:, •XWjfi~a~1:1i:t7-lt
11-0)RillŒ~O)-AJ!l!~ti·~~-~1."th~~ti~bGf, ièti~•
1imi1;~ ~ n -cv\~i1'0 t.:o =.$t&~*1:, 11:~J!l!~itïiIDO)/f'1imi1;*1l•X
210
~O)f&'.~~:Dt* l.J.:*ê tj~JZ9 t~=JLL -fO)['j(~O)·~·li~IDF*-. -Cv\~(40)0 :::.. 0) .i'I.., ilHUtOO O)~~jj·iif.: 0v\-C li~iîiil'-~ ~ l, 0) 0), :t :/-1)-1 r Mr.t
~:j:~:j:~ L -Cv\ ~ iW~Wl"Îi'iÎ'~il' GTA O)!}J i§ f.:~-?P-C :t 7-1)-1 r Mr.tl.: l, :Jî1f ~~ -J 5t000)-f*îlf1Hi, 11f.HUIE~~1rl.:fr-J •1.::ff~IJ t .~,bn~o
(2) •A•t~Mr.tî~)J ~W*891.:5m1t--9 ~~,~·li
Jllm:.rnx ~1.:• L -C li, iW*.'îlMr.t1*i!JIJ 0) JjijfjH.: f-~H i.il'iLil' § _n: "? t.::/.!!-" RMO)RA•DMr.tft)Jl,~bn~o :::..O)~~OOL-c~·~~~,-~~
T 1) :t ~mx. ~ fü:IH.:• L -Cl, '§f*IHflfil'-'JZff~il' G •Aa~-'"'..0).~0)-ljJ]f# *-~•-~êtj~-::i~:::..t,RA~~-L-cam~~~~f-1-~~!bi§~fr
-J 1±*Jl.il'X~O L -Cv\t.::::.. t, ~lfl.:P'JM0)15t~tl ~fü:~~1;fi:l.:OO-t ~--~ 0)'.@':.~,~~1.:.W~~-tt ~1;fi:îlîlJ~~~~ ê -Cv\tjiJ'-::i t.::::.. t ~, r.,,Jm,i'J., t L -C~lj-Cv\~<4JJ0
:::.. n G O)r.,,Jm,i'I.. ~ ~ij~--9 ~_t ~ l,, 5t001.:11&-J ""ê ,i'I..li~v\o Jllm:.rnx ~1.:• L-C~î~ Lï'jiJ'-::i t.:~*O)~ ~ /J~[',1(36~ 1.:1i, 1!*8'-Jtj['j(:!J~~
T~o~~, P'JM~·-~O)'.ê':m~~O)h~W~~-tt~~~~.5t000)1
-J 1.: flî*Jil t 1~/J~:J:ê'.:t!**-1ê ~ ?Hr ~ %~fü:Jfi89 tj RA•t~i!îlîlJ ~ ~1i--9 ~ :::..t~.:fr)Jtj~~&~~~1-Jo1TRM0)7nry:/7~071.~0)·
~~Gl,.~/JMr.t~W~~-tt~:::..t~P'JMO):Jî1f~a~_tO)l,O)~~~
T~O)li, ~~P'lMîlîiJJ.lffl_tO)~O~è~1i!!i~ê ~o :::..O).~ijt~i*ffl--9~
.,g-. 5t000)RMtt1fr~r.,, (GTA) 1.:;JfüMT ~f-1-~8'-J!bi§~fi, ffj(;•ii)Jj( J!IJ 1.:J!IJ -::i -CiW*7'îll.:~fü--9 ~:::.. t 1.: tj ~ o
1!! L. R~,•t~i:tîlîiJil'iTRMl.:5m*tj-~~-~~~1t-9---9 ~ l, 0)-C'~~ ~_t. :::..O)•~&~i*ffl-t~•,g-~~. A*l~•i:t~O);pt~C:frRM0)7
n ry :/ 7~ 1J 7 1 ~~îUJF:--9 ~ ~0)1±*Jl. l, raJR~l.:~fnlT ~:::.. t iJ>f!î:m: t tj
~o 3. ~ht.:1-JI.:, :::..0)1-Jtjft*füi, 5t000):.rnx~~-~-•t~Mr.t ~~î~ ~ -tt ~ _t ~' ~- 7T1 ;z, '/ r O):f5t!!J~*t.: L -Cv\ ~ 0 t-j-~~891.: B *~li, 17nry:/7~ 1J 71O)X~o1.: 1 ~ %fflt ~ nt.:1!!1i:Jî1f~*î~il', Jllm :.rnx~~~ t.:-tt L36t.:-IZ9~~ ~J t v\ -J :J:.lt*IJil» 00~-~~0)~jt:!H.: 1 ~ tj~n-cv\~(42)0 ~i~:t:/7.~'"'<":/~-2itr~Ji~~~~1!/&t--9~7n
ry:/7~071-~0)1±&~. B*~~•L<*H~~~~o L~L.Jll
m:.rnx ~O)~~ ~~~:il.&~ tjv\~1.: li. îlflJijt[',1(1JHIMiT"" ê ~li tjv\o
:.rnX~~RA•t~Mr.t1*îlîlJ f.:flP L -C~ *-.li, 5t000):.rn:Jil1.îlî1JIT (ONR) il'iW *·'llMr.t~~O)i,î:;j:J!t•1~·~~m~ L -CP~ O)li, 7nry:/7~ 1) T 1 0)
211
~1W:.:: f-il'~!RJL.:ijil!îiJ~~il':l'.ê.-? (f) 1.::5: ~ ;f§r.t L v\1~Mt!il' G-C:~ J.i o B ::$: 1.::Bv\-C ~, .:: (f),è: im:1'Ji"9« ê-C:~ .Q o Œlh!.:, ONR !iJl'§'~jf i$. ~"'(f)~)]IJ1>2.-c:».fî 0 -c "\ .Q (43)il', r'l5~~j{ mmurn 1.:lfîh:tt1i, s 7-li:-c: ~ fii1 ~(f)nitliP!Ëffl L-C~.Q«ê-C-~0-? o ]l!!.:,R~JI~!:• L-C'§1l'll'~fiil', ••e~•~~.Q.::t~<,Œ•i~-?-c:ê.Ql-?~-T.Qa~~,•oo-c:
${~~~(f)-~:JJ·~i~<l67.i (f)!:jt~ L-Cv\.Q, 08~ (f){imAW1f:llîiJ~(f)~ J..i:lï~!:~M'T«ê-C-~0-? o
(3) 1J~:JS
m~~G,•••~W(f)ftMtL-c,••~(f)~~~&(f)OOm·~•M
r.t~~(f)~ntt(f)OOM·*7~1rMr.t(f)oomim~-T.Qa(f)r~•Mr.t
(f):flt7EJ t, P'lM (f)1~i!fu(/)r",m · n~s9M § ~(/) r,,,m · fi°i&lff(f) 7 n '7 /
7~0~1(f)oomim~-T.Qa(/)r••••Mr.tft:t.J(f)•*~n1tJ#~
·~.:: t, il'~ G il'!:~ 0 t..:o
5 . 12.$ 6 F.l 'f*ffilj O)~fil! 7-li:iîJ-C:!i, 4. -c:~ Gil,!:~ 0 t..:•••~W(f)ft~Hlil'l2if. 6 J=HUIJ!:ffi
il'~ n -Cv\ .Q (!)il', 1:01t\-C~füE"9 .Q o
(1) ~*7'ilMf.t(f)~JliE
i21f. 6 Ji~JJ!i, •••~wm~i:?z?i L-cv\t..:* /~1 r · * 7~1 r~00-C:(f)R5$DMr.t~~"9.Q~-~i-·L~~~if.6Ji~~-c: !i, '§gM>:i';,\!!,iR:~t:l'~ff-ifi1t\, ··~il'* /~1 rMr.t, ~JB-!l!M•* 'SM'* 7~1 r Mr.tiWM!!T J.i o .:: (f){;fi:l!îiJT-C:, W, -î-:t.J:ijil!îiJ~~f,; (NRA) ii, m:-r:t.J~WM•*'li'~••Jlùt L-c, -gg~t*/~1 r · *7~1 r(/) ~m•(f)ME~t~.Qt~~,M•(f)Wnfü~•L-c~•~&Mifü-?~ NRA#m:•~&Mitfl-'.J(f)~f-(f)•Mtt~-c:~~, */~1rMr.tifü
*--9 .Q··~!:M L-C ~' •r,1Hl!f89~M•P'l~!=~ L-C1iîl-%ir"9.:: t il't-C:ê .Q(46)o .:: (f)5ji:t.J~t.U.~!i, ••~1: l .Q5fiJ~;f§&i~Jilt."9 .Q ~ (/) t L-CMf.if~:tL.Qo 1tt0-c, .::(f),è:!:~-T.Q•••~W(f)ftwll!i, itîil'~n
"(lt\J., tJlif1iffi-C:§: J.io
•·•~W~J.~(f)1;fi:l!îiJ(47)t!i~~~, 12if.6Ji1tl!îJH:!i, *7~1 rM r.t#ê~~t&h~in~o .:::ttitfl.*"T.Qm•MM7-li:H~*7~1r~
/ 7-1:t1i1,n.Qil't, •••~w(/)&~iiri1i<1 .:Z. -c, 1i:~nm~il'ffl:i':~ n
212
J.i ::. è: è: ~ -:i t.:(48) o L. i.P L., ::. 0)::. è: t J:J ·c iW*9'îlMlli{;fi:$lJ 0) Jli~~·lti.J':fW ti!f ~nt.: t :L: ;t J.i 7'.J>li1*twJrE ~ J.i o t v>-? 0) 1b, 121F 6 J1 f<fi:îlîlJ-C-li, J:JiW !i~OOO)iW;f;'îlPJ"Îlgfü::;f!Bl&T J.i 1~ttl tt.ê.-:i -c v> t.:m!ll!.MJft2fi:llB7'.1':t 7-it 1 rWŒè:~-:ikOCOO, :t/-it1rMŒt~•-t-J.i~OOO)m!IJ!.m•~~ffi*
T J.i llB~li1Jt5E ~ n -Cv> ~v>i.1' G -c-~ J.i o fJt-:i -c, J!Ut~X ~O)~WIJ li, "*-1iil§"7'.1> ~nt.: i::ll: i -:i -c v> J.i 0
121F 6 J1{;fi:î!îlrfO)*7-it 1 r MlliO)~!f*HHi, :IN~t•i.J> G O){±~~JJ~~O) 36-iJJ~{tJ:. è: m-11 t q:i-i:,,1::5Ecl6 G n -Cv> J.i (4g)o L. 7'.J> L. ~7'.1' G' 1 f-n G li~i\: t ~;t t.:t!lt-C-' f-O)W~:1J·ltli!)1jèr"v.:J è: T J.i :JJtfiJ7'.1'~ J.i $0) 0 ::. 0) lL ~OO -C-ib-~tt@O)JliÜttt"l='~~-~~~J.i~,~000)••*~'··~~ $:-5-E·lt t'Wjjt è: L. t.::RX 1J .A 7 O)f!:\; ~ t.f!H9l!!1::, ::. nt r"U!1l L. -c v> ~ v>(5l)o L.7'.J>L., ~00.J:: ~ 1b.ftr~1:::RX 1J .A:77'.1'i'iii<, it.:W~l::Jil'i:~X ~t*I.l.~J{ L. t.: 8 ;2fi:-C-li, f-0) .J::-) ~f1L1f-lifflv> J.i..-'( < ~ ~v>o Jll'i:~X ~ O)~WIJ tffii.1' L.t.: è: v>-? ~1illit1~J.i~1::1i, :t 7-1T1 r M~0)-~:1J'i:itf~ Jlf-t- J.i ~-~7'.1'~ 0-? o
(2) ~A•t~Mllifl~:/JO)~~iE
121F 6 J1 f<fi:î!îlHi, êî1§'§1%tJJL!i?: è: T J.i r Y 7 7"7 /~0)-$-11fî•*Më t~ffl L.-Cv>l.io f-O)"i='-c"O)i7'JM0)1~ttlli, §ffi;f,l~jO)-JlBtm!ll!.M~*
llB 1:: ~üi-t- J.i ::. t 7'.1'1Jt5E ~ n -c "\ J.i ~ 0) 0)(5~, ~*~ 1:: 1i * /-it 1 r · * 7-1T1 r jjiij@l::OO-t- 7.i~.'l!:f,#ÇJ-E~liJX'.til'-J::. è: 1::~-:i-Cv>J.io fft-:i-C, l7'J M7'.1'•m:~O)#ÇJ-El::W~-c- ~ J.i f±i%1l t~~T""' ~ è: v>-? Jll'i:~X ~O)~Wll li, ffii,)>~n-CP~v>o
121F 6 Jj {;fi:$1j li, •r,tt11t~fl~:1J t;ff-t- J.i mFf}J;J;UU~~$; (NRA) 1::~
A•DMŒO)•&H••tt.ê.b%,•&H~Gm•~WM•t~•L.-c,
•iWaO)W8*~M~t4;tJ.i::.è:t~:2fi:~ttè:L.-CJ.i~ L.~L.,§ffi '§!fü7'.1'i':.'l!:f,#ÇJ-E·ltt-t- 7.i~l::li, Jll'i:~X~a~fiîJ~, ~.ii~~Œ*t:fü~ L. -Cf.lj-~~M~ t~lt J.i::. è: l::~-:i -Cv>l.i(54)o "? i ~, ;i':,'l!:f,iR:5E*l::t-l-~89
M~·.til'-J fr*Jl.t~~T""'~ è: v>-) Jll'i:~X~O)~Wllli, ffii.1'~ n -Cv>~
121F 6 J1 f*îlîlJ-C-~ffl ~ n -Cv>J.i §;f§'§~BtUtii?: è: T J.i-$-11fî•*Më-cli, i*~iJ~*tHl~:i.J'!t t.t.:•-&l-0)1"J'J&:Jîfft, §1§7'.J'iK~r",bnJ.i PJt~·lii.1'
~ J.i (55)0 L. 7'.J> L., f-0) .J:: -) ~-i~ t*i*(56)7'.1'~5E L. -Cv> J.i 7'.J>I:: "?v>-C li, m MO)*!IJ!.~~0-?o ;:O)~,i*~OO*è:L.-c,17'JMO):Jîfft~5EL.k~-c-,
213
fi°i<fO) 717 7 -Y->' ~ 1J -r -ntf*O)fttJi ~-ttHf.g l -Cv' o ~OO 1:~ ~ llito '.i: ~H±*~ "' 1b 0) è: }i'!:',:bnoo i t.:, 12:$ 6 JH4i:llî1Jr"é'O) NRA !±, ;ft{$i'Oc O)•~è~t~•wO)•~~~~ToaO)~~•m~tt4~n~1bO)
O)~;ft{XW~MA$DMf.tO)~fi~~"é'~o~~~,fi"i<f0)7177-Y
7~ 1J-r1•f*O)t!J.1t'~l:1±~~1~~"'0 .:n"é'!±, ~~JL.mllîlJ~~è: l-C filt1i l.J.:'.f:P;IÇ-Jj;::f~•1: ~ o O)"é', NRA 0)1,!it~~:jl}J~J!lT o~'~7Î;~ o o J~t.t7i' G, fi°i<fO) 717 7 /->' ~ 1J 7 1 •f*O)fttJi ~-fnlT« ~ è: v' -J Jll t;ft{XWO)~IDll ib, 115'7i"~ n -Cv' ~v'.:: è: !±~ G 7'.P"é'~ o o
(3) 1J~:JS
:;zjs:Jm"é'O)~~iEO)*i1f*, 12:$ 6 JH4i:llî1H±, ~ftè: l-CJ!lîlt;ft{XWO)~IDll~ m-n- L. Wn -Cv'~v', è: ~-li' o o ffiît,'JlMr.t1:~ L. -c !±, ~IDllO)-$!±ffi7i' ~ n -c v' o 7i\ ffi7i"~ n -c v' ~ v''il~5J-1b fJ!::ff:T o o MiÊ',$t~Mr.tffü:/J 1: ~ 0 -c !±, Jflt;ft{XWO)~IDll7i;~ < m-n-~ n -Cv'~v'o
6 . B 2's: 1.J~-~1~1* .Q ~ ~ 1Jfél1i :;zjs:m"é'!±, ~000)$1J~0)5J-;flf7i'G, ~rO)J: -J ~3;oJe.~1~t.:o ~OOO);ft{
X W~MiÊ',$t~Mr.t1tllîiJ!±, 1m~·tim~IJ 1:~-:J ~ ïfiî*,'JlMr.t è: 1~1JMf.t0)1!it iu ~5J-!t-C .B ~, 11'JM7i;jiz~O)'.f:}G',i:R;J:El:,W:~"é' ~ o è: v' -J 5fIJ,è:7i;~ o o i t.:, ïfii*,'JlMr.tl:.Bv'-C !±, 5flJ~;f§,BlO)~Jïll:: è: 7177/->'~ 1J 7 1 -~1:,
~~JL.~~llîlJ~~-n;*~ ~1!ittU~*t-= L.-Cv'oo .:nGO)~f3&!±, ;ft{XWff'iJ:!: ~~~MA$DMr.t~fi-JL"é'Z~~~-è:~-l±'oo
L~ë'.~fil'fi .:Z. -c=:$i'Oc~O)&:!Jt!Ëi3 ~~M L.t.:*i1i*, Jflt;ft{XWO)~IDll
è: L. -c, lïfiiaMf.tO):tJtJ'tJ è: l°i&/tfO)MA$t~Mr.tffü:/JO):t!:;zjs:é'-J5~ftJ -n; ~,~~.:è:, -n;~-n-nt.=o l7i'l, 12:$6JHtllîlJ~~~iEL.t.:*fi*, .:nG O)~IDll ~115'7i' L. Wn -Cv' ~ v'.:: è: 7i;fljl'IJI L. t.:o îtÉ 0 -C, 12:$ 6 .F.I f<$:$1JO) Je. w: u:~t-= 0-r1±, =•~)c~O)tf˧~~OOO)l!î1J&~~~1:,. :f!*®~&:!J ~11'-J ~,~-n;~ ~ -J o -fO)l~H:, a *-n;4-1~1*o«~ nf"ËiJ'liè: L. -c, ~rO)=.è:-nt*i'f G no o
m-1:, ïfii*JitMr.tO)W:JtO)a1:, :t /~1 r è: :t 7~1 r O)jjlijlIDTi'iJ~T o IW*lMr.tftllîlJ ~~~T o ~,~-n;~ o o m=1:, °i&/tfO)MA$t~Mr.t~~:/J ~~*®~•ftToa~,ïfii•è:•1J~5t~o%"é'MA$D~~~-fnlT oè:*~' AM~~~~O)W:Jtè:fi°i<f0)7177-Y->'~071.~0)ft@
~•fnlTo~~~~oo-fO)•,~~~~OO•è:L.-C0)7177-Y->'~0
214
71 :iït{lii:O){:tff,ll.!:~ l --C li, 8 * è IWJ t < ~~i*JOOl!îlJ ~1*fflT 7.i~OOO)l!îlJ Ji'.7J>t?~U'1~7.i.::. è !i~lt'a
()î)
(1) +1iJf~li, f41iHf1iJf~ r i!!:W.O);J$:~~1.::i:31t J.i1~Mi*!.::~'"9 J.i WijJ'.J!HiJf~J (1iJf ~~U!ilti}: 26301003) 0)-~t L '"t1'f:bht.:a
(2) W:J?:1!!:1Jti~JJiH·:1J~~fiJî$Ml:WijJ'.l!t•M~ (00~$ittWijJ). $/l.f!i1J (20125f-7 }j 5 B). 20. 323-333; W:J?:'i'.:1Jti~LlJH·:1J~~fiJî!.::i:31t J.i$ittWijJ'.l!t · ~iiE •• ~ (iE,!cJ:f.f$ittWijJ). '1~$11.f!i (20125f- 7 }j 23 B). 366-374, 423-424. 435-436; ti~•~•Mi:~!l\JL.~iiE~•* <~rJJ$ittWijJ). ill~ · !!iN$/l.f!i1l cr 1 .A 7J 1'/7- · r '7::r..°":/'T1 '7 °":/ 2012), 94-119, 387-388
(3) JiFf-:fJJJ<.:gjif~!f#iU!IHH~"Sf-ft).115f-12}jl7B 1!1'1!:~156-5} (M~1!); Jifr :fJ!J!JplfiJ#t~iftŒ~ If füt245f- 6 }j 27 B 1!1'1!:~47-5} (M:JJ!.•~~1!)
(4l •1r!ltJJtii!Ni!if.:rJJJM1tm.JfJ."!ikill~~lf~~ "Sf-füt235f-10Jj 1 a rt1'!!:~112 -5}, l~
(5) M EB•füt. rM T-:1J:JJ!.llJIJ• M*~~ît!.:: ·::n,, '"t J 9 Research Bureau~~ 209. 209-214; ;fJf.wJ;ni!l. rrt1'l!:mmoo* · J*JM: M-T:t.Jm.fflu••*~~rt:s:izfüt =im5f-:t-: }j =-t B 1!1'l!:~lm-t-5} J 373 1!%ffm~#iit.'Jt 4, 4; iftJllît. 00*$ ittWijJ•M•.rM-T:t.J&•&•1!••0)M~~~~~TJ.i00*$ittWijJ•M•~ ~J (~~. 20125f- 2 }j 2 B); fü.~ilJ$)\. :f//~"T ;,-Â ~ilifc#ï!J).'f-1.: : {Jifr:fJfJ!, f/Jlf~R~J :6/fift""-17)/ûlv' (JP:J?:7°v.A7'7:t 2012), 107-109
(6) M:JJl.•~~1!. llftf!IJ 5 ~; fü.~ ( n 5) 109-110
(7) ~~l!JC~~·-~· !if7-:fJ!J1,f/J!J~Jf~iftŒ~~1.:fifY-7.i!If.HffiJtlll (Iffüt245f-6 }j20B), 27~
(8) 5!b.IL1'iilifc~ A!if r:fJ'k~fft#l!JUIJl7)/flffil.:MY- 7-i ~fflt "5f- füt255f-ll }j 22 B 1!1'1!:~82-5}. llftf!IJ21~
(9) +1ïJf~-C:-~ffl-2'nt.:~iiE1iJf~=F1!1.::~'"9J.i~UHHi, W.r~~~~-2'nt.:: Lo Teresa Odendahl and Aileen M. Shaw. 'Interviewing Elites· in J aber F. Gubrium and James A Holstein (eds), Handbook of Interview Research: Context & Method (SAGE 2002), 299-300; Sharan B. Merriam, Qualitative Research: A Guide to Design and Jmplementation (2nd edn, Jossey-Bass; A Wiley Imprint 2009) , 89-90; Hennie Boeije, Analysis in Qualitative Research (SAGE 2010) . Chs 5-6
(10) Cabinet Office (UK) , List of Lead Government Departments 'Responsibilities for: Planning, Response, and Recovery /rom Emergencies: Guidance, 17 January 2011
(1~ Cabinet Office (UK) , Emergency Response and Recovery: Non statutory guidance accompanying the Civil Contingencies Act 2004, Version 5, 29 October 2013 (ERR 2013) , s13 .1
(12) International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), Arrangements for Preparedness for a Nuclear or Radiological Emergency: Safety Guide (Safety Standard
215
Series No GS-G-21, 23 May, 2007) . 12-15 (13) Cabinet Office (UK) , Central Government's Concept of Operations:
Guidance, Revised Version, 23 April 2013 (CONOPs 2013). sl.5 (14) Civil Contingencies Act 2004 (UK) (CCA 2004), sch l; ERR 2013, ss 2.4,
4.1-4.2; CONOPs 2013, s 5, para 1.3 (15) ERR 2013, ch 13; CONOPs 2013, ss 2-4 (16) ERR 2013, paras 3.4.36-3.4.38; Department of Energy & Climate Change
(UK) . Nuclear Emergency Planning Liaison Croup Consolidated Guidance, 24 October 2013 (NEPLGG 2013) . ss 7. 3-7.4; Office for Nuclear Regulation (UK). ]apanese earthquake and tsunami: Implications for the UK nuclear industry: Final Report (ONR-FR-REP-11-002 Revision 2, September. 2011). 166-170
(17) Ionising Radiations Regulations 1999, SI 1999/3232 (IRR 1999), reg 12; Radiation (Emergency Preparedness and Public Information) Regulations 2001, SI 200112975 (REPPIR 2001) . regs 4-5. 7-9. 11. 13, sch 7; Health and Safety Executive (UK) , A guide to the Radiation (Emergency Preparedness and Public Information) Regulations 2001 (HSE Books 2002) . 62-64; NEPLGG 2013, s 10 .17; Phil Hallington _a; ( ~ 7 7 1 - Jv n± ; ~~!m96B'~-) ""-O)~~lliUJ~1t. (Seascale, 2014~10Jj 2 8)0 PXr, 1È:"CO)~~l[~~~1t ~~L-c, ffiL~&-~~1E*•O)~O)o
(18) NEPLGG 2013, ss 4. 4. 7. 3 (19) NEPLGG 2013, para 7.4.19; Hallington .a;,.,,_O)~ ~Ji)(~ ~1t ( n 17) (20) NEPLGG 2013. para 4. 7. 3; Hallington .a;,.,,_O) ~~Ji)(~ ~1t ( n 17) (21) NEPLGG 2013, chs 8-9; Office for Nuclear Regulation (UK) (nl6) 103, 145 (22) Sean Morris.a: (7/-Ti:A:Y'-m; ~l=m!3m1*Jlil-$$f,jjJ&~~1Em•)
""-0)~ ~lf~ ~ ~1t. (Manchester. 2014~ 9 Jj308); Stewart Kemp .a; (ITTî~I= m!3 is1*Jlil-$$f,jj.) ""-0)~ ~JI)(~ ~1t. (London, 2014~10Jj 4 8); Pete Wilkinson.a: (füw~-it-l!:A (NGO)) ""-O)~~Jl)(~~1t. (London. 2014~ 10Jj68)
(23) NEPLGG 2013, para 7.4.10, ch 10; Mark Foy .a; (~OOmm.llflJIT ; iUi.t~'§) ""-0) ~~Ji)(~ ~1t. (Liverpool. 2014~ 9 Jj 29 8)
(24) NEPLGG 2013. ss 4.4, 7.3-7.4; CONOPs 2013, s 3 (25) NEPLGG 2013, ss 4.7. 4.23. 7.3; Stuart Brewer .a; (~ooi;r,;v.:f'-~f~
-~~;~$mR•$•ttOOM~(1È:'OO)ffl*•··~)""-O)~~Jl)(~~1t. (London. 2014~10Jj 7 8)
(26) friJ:)CJff0)7i.J 7:;.,-:>'1! 1J 71 ifH~iH:~ L-Cli, PJ.T~~P.~~nt.: Lo ~m•~·•••A.r~**/7'~7/~~0)m•""~~-c-8*""-0)•
~J 8;<$:*/7'~7/~$; (;Ji), B+!::tf!:!F0::t:/f;;f?:/-fJJ.fetn~!::fJJft '!!i~15tilf- (~-$~1 2015). 341-343
(27) Crown Proceedings Act 1947 (UK) ; Hilaire Barnett, Constitutional & Administrative Law (lOth edn, Routledge2013), 211-214; Mark Aronson, Bruce Dyer and Matthew Groves. ]udicial Review of Administrative Action
216
(4th edn, Thomson Reuters 2009), 715 ~ CCA 2004. pt 2 (29) EnergyAct2013 (UK) (EA 2013), ss 74-760 .iHtl.:li, IDf*O)M~l.:li$ •*~~b~~O)~•*~~in~#,8~t~~n~O)~*~~~~•L f::.o
(30) Ibid, SS 78-79, 82-83, 85, 105-106, 113, sch 8; Foy ~-"'..0)1*] ~*~~'.li!: ( n23)
(31) EA 2013, s 74; Paul Barrett ~ (~OO.::c.;f,Jv::f-1ii:f19i:~UIJ~; ~·~~~-$ i~~t®Mr.t (;m~ ·:If!!.~) t!l.*i~Jlt~;filH!i:) -"'..0)1*] ~ Jfl( ~~'.li!:. (London, 2014~ 10,li 7 B): Brewer ~""'-O)l*J ~ Jfl( ~~'.li!: ( n 25)
(32) Patrick O'Connell ~ (~OO~f;;* :/':/~'? :/ : $~l'i'~) ""'-O)l*J ~Jfl( ~~'.li!:. (London, 2014~10,li 8 B)
(33) lit~*~. 1' .:f' '} .7. ,#,~ I : ~iE,lc C* fil~ 2013) . 257-272 (34) Rob Davies ~ (~ 00 ~if;; :;f :/ ':/ ~ 7 :/ ; ~~'il'~*) """- 0) l*J ~ Jfl( ~ ~'.li!:.
(London, 2014~10,li 8 B): William Moore~ (~OO~f;;:;f :/ ':/~'? :/ : ~'.li!: Fi~) -"'..0)1*] ~*~~'.li!:. (London, 2014~10,li 8 B)
(35) 00f;;$P$1:~ ( n 2) 20, 323-326, 328 (36) 00~$P9:~ ( n 2) 260-263; iE,fcrtf$P9:~ ( n 2) 373-374; ~F,Jj$P$1:~ ( n 2)
82-83 (37) iE,lcJf.f$P9:~ ( n 2) 435-436 (38) ~rai$P9:~ ( n 2) 388 (39) 00~$P9:~ ( n 2) 286 fiû) 00~$P9:~ (n 2) 20. 355-424; iE,fcrtf$P9:~ (n 2) 374-384, 423-426,
437-438:~F,ij$P$1:~ (n 2) 171-210, 384-385 (41) 00~$P9:~ ( n 2) 330-333; iE,fcf(f$P$1:~ ( n 2) 423-424; ~F,Jj$P$(~ ( n 2)
393-394 ~2) ~!1111\', 7GOOf;;$P$l:~~H~*· m·•~ 11'i~W-3€-$P$/:i.PG 3~{Œ-::>A,, bn
t:>nli{ilJ~~/vt!:b'JI (.7.l:'.'.'-7-, :lî~B*~è*77':/, •Jl'i:. 2014~3,lilOB) ~) EA 2013, s 86: Foy ~""'-O)l*J ~*~~'.li!: ( n23) (44l Tw*m. rm:-rn'lz:~mllio · m~&iJt f-0).:fJ ~ n1.:~-t ~-~~J 255 ~ ti~*~l!iE,lc8~ 619, 623-624
~5) l*JMJf.fg=i;R:lljj!J.(~~. /IJJJJ(.1/Pttffllff. &filit&. -'ffflè:27~ 7 Ji 7 B (lljj!J.(~* ~t®). 233-247: ml-f-:fJlljj!J.(f;;~. JJFf-JJJJ(.!HJ;f~7:=..:z 7Jv, &filit&. -'ffflè: 27~ 6Ji198 (ml!J.(7 .::..:z. 7 Jv). 8-16. 37-61. 77-145
(46) mt:!J.(t!. 20~ 3 ~: m:m~fill:~1t. ~ftJIU54~: lljj!J.(~*~t®. 243-244: m:x 7 .::. .:z. 7 Jv , 52-54, 95-97
(47) 00f;;$P$1:~ ( n 2 ) 286 (48) ml-T:fJmlliiJ~~~. NFJ-JJJJ(.!HJ;f~fgJf, &filit&. -'ffflè:27~ 4 Ji22B (ml!}(
tll:~t). ~2(9);rn:l!J.(7.::..:z.7Jv, 90 (49) mt:Xtll:H (50) -!Jd.ZI!, ~EH*~· l~EH~i~l,!j!;m$1 :/?71::'..:z.-: ~!f;!r$P$1:1.:1fr!LzGn~
v'ld':v' B *J 85 f-t~ 477
217
(51) Hallington ~""'-0) li8 ~ :lli1. ~ Wiilif: ( n 17) (52) @:j}.($, 19~; rn'(j}.( ""'< .=. .:i.. 7 Jv, 84-85 (53) ll.:lî~~*n®. 241-250; mtj}.( ""'<-=- .:i.. 7 1v. 95-96. 115-121 (54) m.:~""'<.=. .:i.. 7 Jv, 53. 94 (55) Li.PL, -fO)J:-"j ~$l!~~~~tJ.i~i.I', @:J}.(;;js:$~~0)~$1imt;!IJ~J=~J;i!Jè
~fL"'(lt>J.io @:~""'<-=-.:i..7Jv, 82 (56) B2fs:&J1.ii; BB~2lif:ll,EJ 3 B, 66~ 3 JJï: (57) m.::m.~~~$' 4 ~ 1 JJï: 8 % ' 23~' 30~' 31~
218