تنازع وتدافع الاختصاص
DESCRIPTION
تنازع وتدافع الاختصاصTRANSCRIPT
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
UB lb UM
wOe `U s rOd aOA WKOCH
U 5FL t& t bL UMO vK B 5*UF tK bL(bF
wK U vK qLA tF;b UB UM w; YU cN;wD& uGK vMF* w; _ Y*
bON9 wU Y*UNIH bM UCI hOBR YU Y*
UB u ld Y*UB UM u& fU) Y*
UB l;b UM u U Y*b WLJ w; 5O{UX 5 UB UM l;b _ uM
b WLJ w; fOz UX 5 UB UM l;b wU uM5LJ 5 UB UM l;b YU uM
nKJ* wHe WEU WLJ fOz
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
b WU[ WLJ 5 UB UM l;b ld uMd WOzUCX WN WLJ 5 UB UM l;b fU) uM
UB bF l;b lU Y*d WN t hR eM l;b sU Y*
_ Y*wD uGK vMF* w
WG UMWG UMWG UMWG UMWG UMUI tc wA lKX vK b `O& q& 5F e uM Ue teUI r&UR UM wUF* UO_ w; WU: WUM* tFKX
Z( U& WuB) w; WUM* uLB uI UMWG l;bWG l;bWG l;bWG l;bWG l;bW l;b wA WOM vK b b q& 5F UH b
rNCF l; uI l;b tU& s rNM b q[ tF; wA uF;b uIUCF
WG UB WG UB WG UB WG UB WG UBWLK WdH vK b UIM dH q& UB UB U)UB tBR wAU tB UIU&uB UO&uB d; t_ dO t d;
bdH t hBR d_U ; h dO 5 tMO Wd; lX bI; U?D& UBU?D& UBU?D& UBU?D& UBU?D& UB w?; q?B?H? WDK WOzUCX WN' tzU d_ w quR
5MOF UJ U b w; W&U WU UUCX
dO U bL b oOI% Ud' s U s bL 5 ( w_ WGK fOUI rF dE dO uEM s bL sb UL qCH w_ dF U U qO'
U v_ UL dF U WGK fOUI rF dE
dF U WGK fOUI rF dE WOzUCI WDK UE WO WFdA u{ w WuF WOdF WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM dE
U v_ Vb uF u'bK
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
VOB UCI UN s WN q[ VOB bb% v UB buX bNs? W?L?J?? q?[ V?O?B bu WOzUCI WN' q r[U; UI s WI q[
UNO; qBH u w UUM* s bu WID r[UU??D?& UB l;b UMU??D?& UB l;b UMU??D?& UB l;b UMU??D?& UB l;b UMU??D?& UB l;b UM 5??L?J? 5O{UX 5 U u
UU 5OzUCX 5NUK dO[U?U l;bU dF U UK l?;b?U bBI l;b UMU dOF s
l;b wKU UM wU
wU Y*bON9
wM U[U UM 5 qBH vu vUF tuI J rOMN rL UeKt l ur t???u???X W??? e U'M' UOp JU (Uo' Jr OsMU L UK t wM U& W XF U* W u YF
U?OK YF; WO bK iF v UCIU?O{UX sLO v tM tK w{ UF dF_ vu U YFb q[ YF t 5KU sLO v tM tK w{
s?? e????[ U??C??I??U? U?u?I? U?U?[ 5?;?R? s?L?O? U?[ ?R? v?Q?A?M WbMJ wuA bOL(b u'bK tIH UCI u{ w wzUCI UB bu_
UF*U WOU bF uU WBBc WM' b bF rOUF wu{u* nOMB
aU r_ bF d wUF rOLF bzU* u s W s
U M u s W s WU s 4 r_ Yb UCI nO' U WOC__ U' w 4 dE U U U UJ_ u cd lU r_ Yb UCI d' U UJ_ U'
r_ Yb ULN' lL v 5LB) 5 wCI w{UI w
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
ULNULt??H?M? d?_ w? v?u?? q?&_ W?U?F? W?u s t w{UI bLt?e UuB) d[ U l ULO p tOK cF bX YO UCIU S; uI( lOC rNMO UuB) qB; vu s bK q[ w; Vd d_ w s tDK bL dO_ c S; UCI Wu tM uI s d_ w UU?b?O?O?I? `?B? W?U?[u? U?C?I? w?; d?_ w? s? q?O?[ u? t? U?b?? UL[
UNIOKF
YU Y*UNIH bM UCI hOB'
u?B?) 5? q?B?H? b?O?H WUF rJ( W vUF tK rNL UNIH d[s? v?K? d??( s?b?d? d?O? u? w?; d?EM iF s rNCF uI( cU?U?&u? c?O?H?M? U?N?dA qLFO tKL uX w; dEM fK; tH tu
p dO UM s UN w s ZeUNIH Ud[c UL[ WOzUCI Wu u wK ULO; hBR bX Wu c sJ
lOL w; dEM wu Q p qLF uL w; dEM uL w{UI wu U?C?I? u? l? c? d_ w UDK lCR w dzU UJ_
UO YF q sLO v tM tK w{ UF YF aU w dE UO{U_ U `
Wb( Ud WJ Ud wuN fu s uBM* lMI * d ld* d dE WU
wzUCI UB bu_ dE dJH wuN fu s uBM* vNM d ld* d dE U?J?_ d?JH wuN fu s uBM* UM_ 7 s UMI UA'
wdF UJ dO U* bL s wKF WOMb Uu WOUDK UMI UA' vNM d ld* d dE
ULU tOu u qLF uL w dEM uL tOu u UB w d* U_ULb w U v_ wdF d UO dO UB e ULNO
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
u{u* UJ* YO s WO&UOUw?; d?E?M? vu Q p qLF uB w; dEM uL w{UI vu
5F bK UJ_ lOLUUw?; d?E?M? wu Q p qLF uL w; dEM uB w{UI wu
WJ_d_ w UDK lCR w dzU UFd?EM wu Q p qLF uB w; dEM uB w{UI wu
WOU* UUCI w;5F bK UUuJO; tu se s b b Q p 5F se UCI vu
W t uJ ; UbF b* c qX U UN UCI W tUUUNM tzUNU t wNM UNMOF WuB w; UCI vu
w; kHK c bR d c hOBR kH UB vK UNIH oKDY* c
ld Y*UB u
WKB* VU vK bb% w; bLF c UB bb UF;d* WLE vMFu v UB rI rNH uB) WKB WUFwHOu UB vL wzu UB _ uM
a?OA s s tKb s eeFbF WuF WOdF WJKL* w UCI u U; dE U v_
UMI UA' vNM d wuNK ld* d dE
U?L?F?M WHOM w U Vc w WbMN UH ULK WOUDK UJ_ dE wdF d UO dO bMN ULK s WUL UE aOAK
ULK WOUDK UJ_ dE Vb uF u'bK WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM dE
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
U?N? s? W?N? q?[ U?N? hR w UUM* u b% w buI pK uWb w;UN' c bF U UCI
U?U?M?* W?;U?[ w?; q?B?H?U WuF WOdF WJKL* w; WOdA r[U; hRs dAF WU U* p vK XB UL[ WUF Wu WU& wN; rzd'UN bF UM c d[ bX UEM vM U0 UCI UEWIKF* UbU hR UCX WN u c rUE* u v W;U{U; w{UIru WuJ( wbR* wHu* bUI WOb* Wb) UE w; bI* uI(UQ?A? s? WbI* Ub iuF U W dI w; sFD
U;d WuMF* UR_ b WuJ( uJ w uIFU WIKF* UUM* w;UNO; wzUCX UB UO U' qOJA vK UNO; h WLE_ s b b& bI;
p sU UNdUR UNKOJA w; l WU UUM* r WO q?L?F? U?N?d?U?R? U?N?K?O?JA w; l U;) Wu qLF U'
WOUL RAU l WU _ U'
U l suLK WOzUCI UK U gG UUCI We[d* UK
w? d?e ud UUCX rUE* u UB nO{ bI q p dO
wzUCI UB bu_ U?EM s 5F_ WMU U* dE aU r_ wJK* ud*U UB
aU r_ wJK* d_U UB rJK wU_ aU r_ wJK* ud*U UB rUE* u UE s WMU U* dE
aU r_ u fK d_ dE UbF U aU r_ wJK* ud*U UB ULF qLF UE dE
aU r_ wJK* ud*U UB WU _ UE dE aU r_ u fK d_ dE
aU r_ wJK* ud*U UB U gG WUJ UE dE
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
WOzUM' UUCI ss? b? WE q U[ tO; ud dO d UCI UN bF p aU rX u fK dX b& bX WJKL* w; UCIU 5LN*d? s? q?[ W?u?C? WOKb d uL WUzd WM' qOJA w{UI r?U?E?* u? f?O?z U? d WOUL RA qLF d bFb& r b WN w; WOzUCI UON bOu oKF U Y d) WF fOz
U&U aU rX u fK dXwK U vK Wd* WOULF WU UUM* w; qBH WBBR r[U UA
UIUJ s h l UF U0 d_ w Ub& w ULOKF WLE MUU UL Wb?F WOKb s WM' qJA
WOU* WOUL RA qLF U jODR d? X?% u?I?? d?) WF WOb* WbRK UF ub wMu UBXd? W?O?L?OEM buX s dI c w; U cOHM eK U dXU bF dvK WOzUCX nzU WOU UL s p tKD U dbI W WOzUCX
dI c aU s WM UNLN wNM WMK cp?K? u? w?u?{u?* U?B?? v?L? wuM UB wU uMW?F?U?? r?[U?; UI s WI q[ UN hR w UUM* u b% w buI
b WOzUCX WN'W?u?F?? W?OdF WJKL* w; WOU_ WOzUCI WN' w WOdA r[U; dF
rUE* u UE dE WOU lu dAMK WUN b aOA tKb s s ( WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM dE
Vb uF u'bK WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM U?M? wJK dQ WBBc r'U UA u t vK UCI UE s U* XB d_ vK
vK_ UCI fK aOA s ( WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM dE
V?b? uF u'bK WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM wzUCI UB bu_ dE
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
d[ o UL[ rzd' UUM* w; WUF Wu WU& ws uJ WOdA r[U; vK UCI UE s WU) U* XB bX
vK_ UCI fK eOOL WLJ
WUF r[U; WKF* r[U;
vK_ UCI fK5 r[U; vK vK_ UCI fK dA vK UCI UE s WFU U* XBU? v? W?;U?{U? v?u vK tM WMU U* XB UL[ UEM w; WMO* b( w;
wK U U&UB s UEM tMLCfK: qX s UNO; dEM d{ bF d d w WOdA qzU* w; dEM
fK: qX s UNO; dEM d{ d_ w d w qzU* w; dEM UM UCIU WIKF* qzU* w; d b bF d VK vK
rd lDI qIU UB UJ_ WFd w; eOOL WLJ dz b t vK tM dA WFd U* XB UL[UJ w; d dz w t c o UN s bF UdEM WOCX QWOKQ UdX WUF WON bB eOOL WLJ; WUF WON v WOCI XU WIUu[c* tu vK t dI bB r S; bFU U UNzUC wK s qI s? d?IH vCI0 p w; dX bBO vK_ UCI fK v WOCI XU
U*
UB u s _ uM dE U UN qLF U* c qOFH uJO dE WN s U Oz UJ_ qLF d bOu w
pc od eOOL WLJ d_ dA
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
U?E s WMU U* s WFd WOU dIH vCI0 vK_ UCI fK uIWUF r[U; s UB UJ_ s qOKX dO b iI WE obB UCIt? w??? V?? b r WXbB* dO eOOL WLJ s WXbB* WOze'UJ_ eOO9 Wz s dA WU( U* tOK W{dF* UUCI w; dU rJ(u?J?O?; U?( i?F w; rJ( w; o( eOOL WLJ; XD bX WOdA
v U s p fKLK
UOUeOOL WLJ5 e?O?O?L??K? W?F?{U?) U?J_ iI WE obB eOOL WLJ hRv?K? W?b?I?* U?{d?? w?; q?B?H? W?Oze' WUF r[U; s UB
U( iF w; UUCIU rJ% UL[ UJ_
UUW5UF r
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
e U t dX UL nXu U UJ Z b& Wu dB VM lK) D WO&u
V?u w U;dB w; rN UEM UO_ UO&_ WUX UCX bM rNe w{UI
UM s UN w s Ze UNUI WIHM d; 5KH* UNH vK e(
l?OL WOze r[U UNO; bu w e[d* UE;U; w; WUF r[U; uIUNUL v W;U{ WOze' WLJ; U&UB UL
UFWOze' r
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
UUM' w; UN&UB b w; WOzUM' WOR* eO[d dO s uM2 u U* UO( U
U??b? U?B UF;d* UE h bXw?; r?J?(U? h?R WOze' r[U; vK WOU Ub
Ud u UOK dF lM u \ U dA s UNLOX be w Ub
w?; \ U? n? v?K? t?O?; d?_ b?e U bIF WIKF* Ub \ U dA vK be U0 WUD* sLC dA dNA
\ U n vK tO; Vd d_ be qL bIF WIKF* Ub \ U dA vK be U0 WUD* sLC dA dNA w;
U?U?C?I? s WOze' r[U; UB bb% d bX UF;d* UE UM kUCI UE s U* w; tOK uBM* WOze' d UEM WOzUM'
Y?O? U?CX V WOze' r[U; w; UB bb% k UL[w; dOG* b* s lI U* dU d XX 5 UB qbF d
tKd s WKd q[ w; wzUCI qLF utU w; h aU UB UCI UE r t d[cU db
L? W?O?ze?' W?UF r[U; vK r[U; suJ WIKF* WU)]h? pc UU W?O?L??? c vK 5 WOU 5 WU( tU w; UF;d* UE
UU U qLFWOU dJU v_ WOL vK bK w; 5LJ; UL bM L WKF*U aU UB wdA UCI UOR eO[d UE w; U U0
U? v_ bF tzU tU R tcU WuF WOdF WJKL* w UCI dE
bF WJKL* w UCI dE
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
UA5UWBB'* r
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
WJ_ ULC WLJ5 WOUd?EM UN jO Ud WMb0 WJ_ ULC WLJ XA U w;w; dEM VU ULO WJ_ uI d wUL ULC U w;ULCK d WLJ qOJA d UL[ p u D U UJM W
b WMb0 WJ_
wLOI UB YU uMp?K? u? u?b? W?L?O?X U? v?K uI wuM UB s uW?N?' W?F?U?? r?[U?; U?I s WI q[ UN hR w Ub b% w buI
ub WLOX v dEMU b WOzUCXUN hR w WOU* Ub UB u s wU uM w; d[ o
Ub U0 hR WUF r[U; WOze' r[U;s?L?{ W?K? W?O?U u WOze' WLJ; dE UM dF w qzU* sq?N?; U?N?&U?B?? v?K? b?e? w?U? m?K?? v?K ub U;d `KD& r UN&UB
t e `KB c U WOze' WLJLKr?J?( `?K?B c U WOze' r[U; UCX s t vK XHX s d[ d
wK U* p t e tBrJ U0 fO UNF; bM uB) t VUD U0 ub WLOX dbI w; dF
tu* rJ t lU ubK lU `KB
UB Wd U$ Wd WuB) lDX eM UN w; V p UNK v uI(
Vb uF u'bK WJKL* w wzUCI rOEM bF WJKL* w UCI dE
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
l?O?Xu c - c `KB sb WOze' WLJ; w{UX uI rNCF drJ( U ULN t s td) te tB rJ tOK 5;dD
WB
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
d??zb?? w?; W? U?L?_ r?O?E?M? U?E? s? W??U?) U?* X?B? t??W?J?K?L?* q? U?[ t?O?K? vb* bK w; UI ub vK WOdA
UMu w; ub UI tM bK w; 5 vK ub UI p vK bK s d[ tOK vbLK U[ U( bK tOK vb* bK w; UO
bK w; ub WUX wbLKK; wb* bK UNMlI w WLJ; w; ub UI vK UF;d* UE s U* XB bXu?J?O?; W?J?K?L?* w; WUX q t sJ r S; tOK vb* q UN&UB UD w;vb* bF wb* WUX q UN&UB UD w; lI w WLJLK UBW?d??[_ W?UX q UN&UB UD w; lI w WLJLK UB U[ rNOKU?D w; lI WLJ U ub WUX w; UO)U wb* uJ U U w;
rb WUX q UN&UB
f5U) Y*UB UM u
Uu UB UMU?M?? w?U?? U?M?? v?_ u?BU?M?? w?U?? U?M?? v?_ u?BU?M?? w?U?? U?M?? v?_ u?BU?M?? w?U?? U?M?? v?_ u?BU?M?? w?U?? U?M?? v?_ u?BU? b? u? l?;d? u?
UMI UA' vNM d dE w r_ wUF obBU u*
b?F? qO' rOLF mK* aU r_ UOKF WOzUCI WON d_ dE w r_ vK_ UCI fK d_ w r_ W WOU* RAK
w r_ bF d wUF rOLF mK* r_ bF d rOLF mK* aU r_ WOzUCI WON d_ dE o?bBU u UE hOBc vK bI WOzUCI WON d_ uI qzUI wwbLK tOK vb* bK w ub WU_ w o( Q p s U WLE_ w bM dI u UL' wUF
UUBUML{ WdL o( c s UM tOK vbLK WOKL_ dK uC qOHJ t1bI UM VKD bM uC(U te wMF U( bK wUOML{ UH tO UA* dI dE o( c s
r?O?LF mK* aU r_ u fK fOz W' VUL UD dE w r_ UCI fOz
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
W?B?
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
UOU UdEMcOHM UL eK WLJ; fOz dI U l;bU[ UM bM qLF XKX
rK; eOOL WLJ dz s 5dz 5 q&U WOCX w; UM l;b U[ qBHU eOOL WLJ fOz hR tO; qBHU h
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
U?&U?BU?Ou U?O?LOX U?O?K s? U?N? d? w?? W?L?J; v UNUS uI; UDR v_ v UNU UN UN&UB b d_ S; UDR UN&UBX?F?M??X W?O?C?I? d?E? v?_ W?L?J?; v?K? U?B?? bF dX b& t?F?; U?N?&U?B s XO UNQ dX b& UNOKF; lMI r UN UN&UBU
U?I?; U?d?EM WB
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
bF WU[ UB s WKL'U dUX_U& _ p& U[ t rNCF dp?c WLJ; hR; WLJ; s
U?& U[ q?b?F? U? s? c? _ p?c? b?F WU[ hR; bF WU[ s bB t hR pB qbF pB
t?d? U?L?N?M? q?[ p?9 bF WU[ WLJ; 5 UM l;b uB bMu w; bO bF v d_ l; wLK V VUG w; rO;
F UDR UKeeK dO u VUG w; t WOBRA u_ UUCX eOO9 dz eOOL WLJ v p l; r cu? U?L?[ d?EM WB
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
UB UM WM'd WOzUCX WN U r[U; b U b u{u s u XF; UdE s ULb qR r d_ V u{u* w; Uub b%ULcOHM VK 5CXUM 5OzUN 5LJ Ub& UdE s ULUK[ UKR
UB UM WM' v WB
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
VKD U[ VKD w; X r v VKD UNQA bI* ub w; dO nXU?M tH UIK s UB UM WM' fOzdK; ub w; rJ( bF bXvK
5??{U??F????* 5??L??J??( c??O?H?M? n?Xu? d?Q? W??K?B?* V?U?& r?B?) V?K?ULb
WMK dNU? t?O; sFD u wzUN dX UB UM WM' bB c dId?I? q?? e?M? q?? v?K? Wu VU& bb% w; bUX dF d WN
IUB UM WM' 5CXUM 5OzUN 5LJ oKF dI U[ d???F? c?OHM u c rJ( u `B Wu WN' s U& ULb
sJ r Q[ dr? d? W?O?zU?C?X W?N? WLJ; 5 UB UM l;b oKF U cU?L?N 5O 5M' 5 UM l;b w; qBHU WBR WN w V b
ULb WLJ; XO wzUCX UB
lUA Y*UB bF lb
oOI XF{ UF UEMU wLOI wuM wzu UB buX oKFU? p? v?K? Vd tHOu tz W UCI dO s w WU WKB
wKU?O?z WLJ; UB bF l;b UOu U?OLOX t? rJ% ub dEM
o uB) s b qJ l;b c UNU b d r u UNH UIK s WLJ; UCI UE dE UCI UE dE
WU WOb* UFd* dE
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
t l;buJ WU w; wLOI wuM wzu UB bF l;b u t
UNKd s WKd w; UNOK ubtHU< rNXUHU d buI c WHUR vK UH uBRK u t
WUF buIKW??K?B?0 o?K?F?? U?/ W?U?F? WKB*U oKF ; wK; UB buX U
wK U p vK Vd uB) ub w; l; VK qX wK; UB bF l;b V t
tO; o( jIUO& rNXUH uJ tHUR vK UH uBRK u t UeK rN
W?O?C?I? d?E? w?; wK; UN&UB bF UNH UIK s wCI WLJ; UF UEMU p oKF bF
U?OK WBR dO WLJ; rB) uX U?d& uJ bX ub dEM bX UOML{ uJ VKD ub u{u* t{dF l;b cN l;b s rB) uJ;
uX tM dF l;UOML{ wK; UB bF l;bU tI UI WB
-
wOe `U s rOd aOA
d lO WU WM bF
s5U Y*d WN t h' eM lb
U?e dO l;b uB) b l; f?O d WOzUCX WN tO; qBHU hR Wb b dI WLJ; vKF; tO; qBH ub dEM w WLJ; UB sdF v WU( ub w; qBH sJ1 t tb b S; l;b c
ub w; UNLJ bB l;b qHG UNS; tU?N?S; ub u{u w; rJ( qX l;b w; qBH dC s t
U?L?J? U?N?? bB b rBRK b% UNU w ub nX dIUOzUN w?; s rJ( bB w; fUI rB) qL S; WB
-
UB lb UM
d lO WU WM bF
v?K? u?b? u?{u? w?; U?N?LJ oOKF WLJ; t vK U* XBV d0 ub nXu dQ; rJ( UNOK nXu d WQ w; qBH
ub w; dO VK uBRK uJ nXuU?u?{ W?X d?[ UCI UE s U* vI uLA c lt?K vK&
rK t& t bL UMO vK