˘ˇˆ ˝˛˚ ˜ ˆ! #˜$ %& '( )* ˘+, '( ) -! .( ( / · ˜ 1435 ˝ 2014 ˘ˇ , 1 ,...
TRANSCRIPT
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 69 –
�� �������� ���� �� �� ,26 ����� ,�1�" " , 69 − 89 ������ ,�2014��1435� �
����� ���� ��� ��� �� ����� ���� ����� :
��� � ��! "�� �#��$ %�&� '(��)�* ���+,� '(��)� -! .(��� ��(/ 0�������1 2�3 �! 4����517* , �#��9� ��: ;�! <*=�527
%��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ � , -.�� ��&22�01�1434;� -.�� 01&2 , 20�05�1434� �
)���?�@: 3 3� 34 �5 ,'6�7 �.(�)� 8*��9�� :;��� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* 87 :CD�� EF GH1�� ��IJ2 ��KL��� M��N2 ,O.�P� Q�R�SB*��>*�DT��U�VW� 8* GH1�� �.>7 XN�DY �&2�502 ��2 �>*�DZ� %L���� [�L��� ����� 8*�9�� :;�� Q�1��<2 �1�< 8* �1��<2 \�1��<�S��� �>]�.I �U�^ W
8*�9�� :;�� �>?���� �@�A9�� L�1BV� _>1(Y `Y GH1�� 4�� J _>AHB�2 , 8* '�D���61 �a �>?���� �@�A9�� ���J ��LJ b7 �7c�* d��e* : `g.�* `) h `����� i ����1B�� �&j���2 ,RDeB�� �A��(h `����2 ,k�;ABKj� �A��(h `����2 ,�>?���� �@���� 8*l?B ��2 �N�AB��2 `��� W m�)�T2 n&��U 8�* _�AHB�� `�Y �&2
o� p5�� ,nY�1I�0W84 �q�1N2�h �e�J 0*��* ���rBK� sV���� t�)Yu� �A��( W �&2 ��@�A9�� L��1BV� b�7 8*��9�� :;�� �1�< k��J 'J EF GH1�� v]�BN QL�wJ �>?����� ���x�Ly� �N�h X�>N�B* 1A�� =�B)�� 8* 0&J2 , \����Y z��80�% ���u� Q�| t2��@ ���+2 ���7 EF QL�wJ 6h ,F�>]�;�T O.�+ pR�SB� \���1Y
�KL��� M�N2 }��(�� M�N2 O.P� i 07�eB�� , t2�@ ��+2 EF QL�wJ �~.D� ,�>?���� �@���� �� , �KL�����U�^� %L����� Q��1��< ���;�� W ���V2 �* k�� , Q�>U�B�� 8* ��7 EF GH1��v]�BN 8* n.7 �eKJW
�A��B)� C��+� :�KL��� M�N ,O.P� ,�>?���� �@�A9�� ���JW _________________________________________________________________________________
Scientific literacy level of 8th grade students: A comparison between the governmental
schools and the private bilingual schools in the Sultanate of Oman
Abdullah Ambusaidi(1), and Marwa Al-Hinia(2) Sultan Qaboos University
(Received 06/12/2012; accepted 01/04/2013)
Abstract: This research study aims to investigate the scientific literacy level for the eighth grade students in the Sultanate of Oman, and its relation to gender and type of school (government / private bilingual). The study sample consisted of (502) 8th grade students selected
from governmental and private bilingual schools. To achieve the study main aims, a scientific literacy test has been constructed which
consisted of (61) items distributed on four dimensions (components) of scientific literacy. After that the test was verified through panel of judges to find out its validity. Its reliability was obtained by internal consistency method using Alpha Cronbach, which gave the value of
(0.84). The results of the study revealed that students' performance in the total scientific literacy test and its four components were below the
educationally accepted criterion (80%). In addition, the results showed no statistical significant difference in the scientific literacy level due to gender and type of school. However, the results showed that there was a statistical significant difference in the interaction between gender
and the type of school students in scientific knowledge dimension in favor of female students of private schools. In the light of these
findings, number of recommendations and suggestions were proposed.
Key Words: Scientific Literacy Dimension, Gender, Type of School.
_________________________________________________________________________________
�1��L�C* |�BKJ ������ O�L�Y t�<2 v �.* , ,O�L�B�� 2 v �.�� `)& �>�� �>�h ,%��& '�(�)�� ��*�+
�A)* ,'67 �.(�K , m "�533�*��� , p����� ��132���^�
(1) Associate professor of curriculum and methods of teaching science,
Department of Curriculum and Instruction, College of Education, Sultan
Qaboos University
Muscat, Oman, p.o box (533), postal code (132)
�2D��� ����� :[email protected] e-mail:
�2�k���>@ v �.* a]�;VJ ,`>��B��2 �>�� dL�c� )2 ( Physics curriculum specialist, the Ministry of Education
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 70 –
���)�
ks�* ,}�C�B* ML�)�B* ���7 , �.* ��e�� �>���>?���� Q�L�(B��2 }]� ��� ,:�&�BY u a�B�� �>.AB��2
2 �7�K 0h2 ��� 0h L�(BY2 ����BY � ��F 0 0h�A>&� W �&2 a�.AB��2 a��?���� L��(B�� �5� =�JEF L���~� 8��* R�9h
�1��UJ QjDC���� ����A� 'J pL2����� 8��* '�)��N�� \�*�rB)* �~�* 0*��B�� �N�AY2 ���7 8* nA1(�2 n@��� �*
(Mbajiorgu, 2003) WF'0h �?B�� �5 ��>�� M��N b7 ,��e�� �*�A��2��aB���Y 'J }� �5� l* �>P� 0*��B��
Q�L�(B��, ��~.* d��eBKu�2 ,QjDC* 8* �~.7 vBN �*2 �A��(n1�.� L��y��� B~I�� �& a�n���T 8��2 n)e.� ,
���RV 8* �>eB)�2 �~>�7 �>�� aB�� nB�>1�2 W Q��~� Q���>A�B��2 Q�L��(B�� �5 k�� ,2
'x� p���.Y Q��UJ , '�C�>�� 8�5��� ����@y� '��D� =�B)�* b7 ��>�� Q��?B� �z��7 ��>?���� ��@�A9�� 8�*
(Scientific Literacy) , \�A��K n�>�7 _��(� '��h �* 2J ,a?���� L�.B�� , dR1h �N�D* �| ��(;�� �5 �1UJ2
������ =�B)�* b�7 ��>?���� ��>�� Q�K�L�2 ��H (Millar, 2005)W
\��>�2� \��1�(* �1UJ �>?���� �@�A9�� �6B u� �'F; `B��� a��D�F)���� 8<������ �����7�2 , z s��H�� n���?B�
�2�����2 a��?>�&��2 (Bybee, 2008)2 , }���(�� �5�� ��>.��� ��>.<���2 �>�2��� Q�)K��� 8* ������ n Q��N
��������2 ���>�� d���HB�� `��*y� ���?g.* 0��9* ���>�� ���@�A9��2(United Nation Education Science
Cultural Organization) W ��?g.�� nYL��UJ ���AY ae@ �����7 ,1994� ����>?���� ����@�A9�� 'J b���7 Q����hJ
\�>��7 \�1�(B* XH1UJ �>+���.DB��2 ����@y� ��LJ ��* �|F ���S�� Q����?B� , i�7���@ ����N�D� 'J(UNESCO,
1994) Wu��� , �����(Y l�L�C* Q�~� 6h d�HB�� Q�� 4�� �>D��*y�Fy� }�C�� m�)h �>?�7 �@�AI aD��*
09* �1K�.* : M2-*2061� Project 2061� M2-*2 , _>)��.B�� ,l���BB�� ,z��� ��(Scope, Sequence and
Coordination) ���>.<��� R������� M2-��*2 , ���>����>?���� (National Science Education Standards)
� ,s72003�W� ���~e? �6B u� 'J �� p��� m��� l1BB��2
Q�>.>�1)��� ��A7 EF l�+�� �>?���� �@�A9�� '��A�� 8�* ��� ,�*�.7 d��HB�� Q���u��� , '������ :CBh�
d��T�2 ���@ }K�.Y dL�(�� ������ v �.* �'3J �>D��*y��1�(�� 8*, ,i�K�.~*2 k6��7 �1;�BK a�B�� ��e�� a
F G>T2 dR1D�� ��e�� �5 8* ��N�D� 8� �1�(�� �>1��¡ ' �5� ,l?B �� 8*'�h ���7¢ ��2��� `B� 'J })Ny� 8*
a?���� :A9�� 8<����, ������� v �.* dL�� zjV 8* �5�� _��>AHB� ���~�>£ �>��K�L��� 0��T���� , ����L��2
��S���2 �1��(^�J ,p�>�K�1*2002�W�
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 71 –
'F��� ��@�A9�� �6B u� 8�* ������� _�A� ��>?� b��7 k����K ���]��e������ =�B)���� 2J p����e�� =�B)
a76B+u�, �A9�� ���@y� �.¤ ��¢@ p��e�� =�B)�� b�@ `~B1&���*2 ,�>�>1(�� ���Ty� l* 07�eB��2 �� BKj�
��>1�� �>;rC��W ��@�A9�� ���Y a76B+u� =�B)�� b72 i.<���� l>?P ��L2� �>?����;`7��� }�h�h d���>&
�Ly�, ����>�>1(�� Q����&���� ����@�h b���7 }����SB��2 �>7�.;��2�Meichtry, 1992W� 6hJ L�wJ ¥� 2 ���.
(Ebenezer & Haggert, 1996) EF 'J ��>?���� ��@�A9�� ���¦��A�� z���T Q�L����& |���§� b��7 `��B���� �7�)��Y
y�2 ���>76B+u��������� ���(1Y��� ���>&jV, zj��V 8��* j� nB��KL�¨k�;��ABK, p5���� ©���( n���jV 8��* ����A�
Quª�)��B��,Q�R)��eB�� ©���&�2 , �����y� `����AY2 �� �?� aB�� ���Ty� , � ��C��2, '��DY 'J 0+J 8*
�>?�7 OKJ b7 �>.1* Q�L��A�� �5 , «7�*2 v]��B. ��?%�.�� �*�7 =�� ���1A* '�DY �AI�* W
��>?���� ��@�A9�� Q�N�D* EF d�g.�� Q���Y �A�2 Q��N�D�� �5�� ��U�^� Q�>?)�� Xe�BV�2 ,� ���J
,�V¬ �;rB* 8*��~.* ��g.� a�B�� ���2���� })T , z2��2 ���2 ®����2@(Trowbridge, Bybee &
Powell, 2000) �@�A9�� ��L2� Q���B)* ��LJ �2��T a �>?���� : ��>?���� ��@�A9��2 ,�>?Ku� �>?���� �@�A9��
� ���@�A9��2 ,���>e>���� ,���>]��+��2 ���>?> �e�� ���>?���
��>?���� ��@�A9�� ���Y2 ����y� d���B* �>?���� �@�A9��2 �>?Ku�JQ���B)�� 0&, d����B* ��>?���� ��@�A9�� 6.�>
� j7J a Q���B)��W �Y�1>w 8* 0h =�� 6.>2 �V¯� 8(Chiappetta et
al., 1991a; 199b) ���LJ ��� ��>?���� �@�A9�� 'J ����J Ja� �>�K�K : \6)�+ nBe;� `����� \6g.�* ��@���� 8�*
�A��< nBe; `����2 ,�>?����°AB��GH1��2 , `����2 RDeB�� �A��< nBe;, `���� i ����1B�� �&j��� \�RVJ2
l?B ��2 �>+���.DB��2 W �� �>��Y s� 6>@2��� �~>�F L�wJ aB�� ��Ly�
'2��V¯2 �Y�1>�w(Chiappetta et al., 1991a; 199b) , ±�|2'y ��Z� GH1�� � =�B)�* %�>& , �~>�7 �?B7
GH1�� �.>7 =�� �>?���� �@�A9��W 1 D ����� �=�)� �� EF�� E�GH E��� :
_]��AZ� i?��B�� m�)hF n �;A�,`> ��e��2 , iN��A��2,�7��A��2 ,��>?���� Q����g.��2 W 'J pJ�5�
'�D�� 2J }N�P�b7 �h����A@ ��@���� }�N�+ W 8�*2 Q�H�(;��� :���Y b7 `��B�� dL�& ±�| b7 ��9*y�
0�9* �>�K�Ky� �>?�����DNA��P� ,kpk���~D�� ,� ,m����� k6���� k��?KJ ��h5Y ±�5h2 2 z�� , i?�)��
������W 2 D �I=� J�B�! E��� K�����L :
Q�L��~* i�?��B�� m�)�hF `B� '�D�� �5 ,2
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 72 –
u���>?�7 ���� `>?;�Y �>e>h2 ,k�;ABK,� 5�>e.Y2 ,���RSB* �1�2Q�L�~�� 8* � R¡2 , W �5� ��9*J 8*2
'�D�� v����� 'J 8�D?� z���K ©�< b7 }��(�� dL�& `>>AY2 ,��DC�� ���² 09* �>?�7 �A��(=��* ��?]j*
mL� B�� =�TF k��+F , i�* m��KJW 3 D �I=� J�B�! E����N+B� :
2 i?��B�� m�)hF b7 �>h�� `B� '�D�� �5 , ©���<2 ,R)��eB��2 :��U��� 0��9* R��DeB�� Q�L���~*
��Q���+F 8�7 G�H1��2 ,Quª�)B W �5� ���9*J 8�*2b7 `��B�� dL�& '�D�� ��� v]�B.� a?�7 R)eY `��AY
k��� , ��>?�7 d� ��� L��(Y :�U22 ,d��� �>?�7Q�>(��� ³�W
4 D���)� PL��Q��G)�* ��R���+��* E��� -! / :
Q�L��~* i�?��B�� m�)�hF `B� '�D�� �5 ,2 ±�| �IJ2 ,�>+���.DB�� ���A>1(B �>?���� � ��g�� �L
��>1��2 l?B �� b7 W 'F �6B u��>?���� �@�A9�� ��Ly� ���y� ��* n�
}�K�.* =�B)* EF 0U2 �* �|F }��(�� 'F G>T �L��A*2 0h , �.?¦B�� Q�L�~��2 4L���� m�)Bh� 8* z�1
K \6BT nN¢@ ,�� '2� ´���� Q�L��(Y ��1h��* l>(B)>QjDC� ���B���& p��Y � EF� n L��J2 n�?B ?
J2 ~>@ �>�� aB�� ��>1��� W �&2 �5 JQL��w 8�* ������� ��>?���� ��@�A9�� z��� , X��+J aB�� Q�K�L��� 'J EF
\�R9h� 8* ��T b�7 ��AB��2 a*�.�� ����� z2� , ���@y a�B�� ��*cj�� Q��*�����2 Q�L��~�� '�D�B?� u k��K
`~.>�Y b7���>�� ���7 , �>�7 =�B)��� '2� `��J2 ,�>?���� �@�A9�� 8* z�1A��W ,������ `>���B�� =�B)* b�@
��K�L� ��~.* Q�K�L�2 ��H d�7 X��+J a.�L�1�U�2011� �aB��X@� F E ��>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* 4��Y
'�Ly� p�N�9�� z2y� :;�� �1�< �.7, ±��| �&j72 ie;��� k����>e�� d���* , `~�>;�² 8�* 0D =�B)�� ��>?���� �@�A9�� Q�µ�*2 ,i>K�Ky� µ����2 lK�B��
��¶y�,��KL�?�� ��>?���� ��>@�A9�� Q�µ���2 W ��&2@�A9�� =�B)* 'J GH1�� v]�BN X.> ��1�< �.7 �>?���� �
p�N�9�� z2y� :;�� '�h \�(K�B* ��&j7 Q��~� 6h , \�>]�;TF ���� ��1�< =��� ��>?���� ��@�A9�� =�B)�* i
d����* , `~�>;��² =�B)��*2 p�N���9�� z2y� :;����i>�K�Ky� µ����2 lK�B�� ie;�� , k���>e��, i�1Y2
���u� p| ��IJ ���+2 ��7 ±�5h�>]�;�TF Q�µ��� �A9�� ,��KL�?�� ��>?���� ��@�A9��2 ,d¶��� ��>?���� �@
�>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* b7 Q�µ��� ±�Y i 07�eB��2�1�(�� �.7W
6�h2 ��>� ���&¯ '2��V(Baldi et al., 2007) EF 4� GH1 , i>D��*y� �1�(�� v]�BN 0>�² ��?7
15 L��1BV� , �.K (The Program for International
Student Assessment (PISA) �����2006� 0�h , ,
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 73 –
������ 8*,Q�>������2 ,dk��A��2 W �&2Q�~�J v]��BN �5�� =�B)��* ����AAT '���D��*y� ���1�(�� 'J G��H1��
¦er.* \��&x� ��NL�A* ��>?���� �@�A9�� %�>A* , � , `�u� '2������B�� �����?g.* z2� �����>?.B��2 p��;����B&
(Organization for Economic Co-operation and
Development)W
�� GH1�� �*Jp5'2�V¯2 ��* n ��& (Mumba
et al., 2006), EF 4�� �A@ �1)�N ����² J k�� ��1�(��i>1*�����>?���� �@�A9�� L�1BV� , , 2 '�9T��1�� ��rBK�
L�1BV� \� ��@�A9�� Q��N�D* b�7 0?Bw� �>?���� �@�A9�� , 2 �Y�1>��w ���.7 ���>?����¯���V� 8(Chiappetta et al.,
1991a)W0U�Y �&2 EF '�9T�1�� J '��· �>?���� �@���� `I ,�1�(�� k��J , z2y� }>Y�� b7 0;T��· ��>1(��
`I ,�>]�;ABKu���· \�RVJ2 ,RDeB�� �A��(h `���� ��·l?B ��2 �>+���.DB��2 `���� i 07�eB��W
'67 �.(�K , �*J , �A@ p�*�¦��� ��&�2005�� GH14� EF ��>?���� ��@�A9�� =�B)�* 8�7 :CD��
`B � 6h ,-7 ��9�� :;�� �1�< =���@��? ³� �IJ 09* Q�RSB�� : �1�(�� Q� ���2 ,O.P�2 ,�KL��� M�N
�>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* b7 ������ �HN W ��rB�K� ��&2�>?���� �@�A9�� , \�L�1BV� GT�1�� , Q�� ��j� \�K�>A*2
� �HN�K�L��� 4�� J _>AHB� ����� WJ �&2 v]�BN QL�w 8�7 �1�(�� =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* ��Y EF GH1��
\����Y z�1A�� =�B)�� �1)�. L��& p5��2 ,�80W�% 6�hv]�BN QL�wJ \�¦�J GH1�� ��@ ���+2 ��7 EF 2 Q�| t
��u�F %L�����2 ��>*�DZ� %L����� �1�< i �>]�;T ,�U�^� '�h2* �1�(�� =�B)* 8* b7J Q�1��(�� =�B)
zjV 8* i1Y2 ,�>?���� �@�A9�� L�1BV� , G�H1�� v]�BN \�¦�J ��@�A9�� =�B)�* i� ��><�1YL� ��&j7 ��+2 ��7
������ �HN �1�(�� Q� ���2 �>?����W �r Q�+J 6h�2004� � \�9H =�B)�* %�>A�
01& `>��B�� mj< 8* �.>7 =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� a�*�P� �����)��� �>���� �D�?�� ±��| '��h �|F ��* ��@��*2 ,
n��>�F a��?B.� p5���� `)��A�� 4jBV��� :���B¸ =�B)����nN�h G>T 8* }��(��>?�7 \� J 2J>� \� , ±�5h2� 4jBV
}��(�� O.+W �9hJ Q�1��(�� 'J GH1�� v]�BN 8* i1Y2 8* b7J a?���� `)A�� �1�< 'J2 ,�1�(�� 8* �>?�7 �@�AI
<�1�%�>A�� b7 `��+L� �K�B* , �y� `)A�� W ,2GH a+��� n ��& �2002� � i� n�>@ 'L�&
p�N�9�� z2y� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)*p�N�9�� G��9��2, \�*�rB)* \�L�1BV� \�>.1* ����J �BK b7
�>?���� �@�A9�� ���J 8*a : �A��B�� �>76B+u� ���¦A�� � l�* 0�*��B��2 ,`����� ��>1<2 ,�>?���� �@����2 ,`���
\��6B7� ��>1�� `~@2 ,�>.AB�� `���� Q�� .*2 d�~+y� b7 H1�����1+��� �>?���� Q� ��u�2 ,��>1(�� �>?���� � W �&2 ��u� Q�| t2�@ �+�Y u n�NJ GH1�� v]�BN Q�~�J
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 74 –
z2y� :;���� ���1�< Q���+L� ���K�B* i�� �>]�;��TF p�N�9�� %�>A� �>�D�� �+L��� , p�N�9�� G��9��2 �@�A9���>?����, pJ J ��>?���� ��@�A9�� ����J , ��?N ��� � nN
���N�9�� ��T��� `~BK�L� d@ zjV �1�(�� =�� W �*J ¹e(;*�1990� �G�H1 ��& �A@� 3 3� 34 EF
���9�� :;��� ��1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* %�>&a?���� p�N�9�� �>?w��� �>N�Ly� �D�?�� ��rBK� �&2 , \�L�1BV� GT�1�� �>?���� �@�A9�� \��N�D* ����J ��IjI 8�*
a : `���� i 07�eB��2 ,`���� ��>1<2 ,�>?���� �@����l?B ��2 �>+���.DB��2W �&2 ��Y GH1�� v]�BN Q�~�J
6�h ,��>?���� �@�A9�� sD�� L�1BVu� b7 �1�(�� =�B)*� Q�~�J ·Y �>]�;TF ��u� Q�| t2�@ ��+2 v]�B.� =��
p2| ���;�� �>?���� ����� , �1�(�� 0>;² �K�B* EFleY��� 0>;HB��W
,a�*�P� =�B)�� b72=�+J8* 0h ��1��(^� p�>����K�1*J2�2002� � \����9H ��������� ����1�< b���7
%���& '�(�)��� ���*� ��>�� ��>�D Q�>������2* , `�~]�L¯ ���HB� ,��>?���� ��@�A9�� ���~e2��rB�K�
'�9T�1�� k��� , Q��N�>1�� l?P �N�1BK� ����J �Y�1>�w 2¯�V�8 (Chiappetta et al., 1991a) ��>?���� �@�A9�� W
`�~@ ` ��.7 ���*�P� ��1�< 'J EF G�H1�� 0U�Y �&22 ,��>?���� ��@�A9�� ��~e� _>�J ����� t2��@ ��+�Y n�N
F \�>]�;TB�Ku� b�7 ��1�(�� k��y =���Y �N�1 EF R�SB*
Q�1��(�� ���;�2 O.P� W ��. 22 ��H =�B� 0>�² , X9H Q�K�L�
�>KL��� }BD��, b7 ��6Bw� =�*2 ���J �>?���� �@�A9�� 2 �1��(V �K�L� 09*¯�V� 8�2012��, X�U�Y aB�� EF
JY2�eY ��. ' \� l����� ie;��� ������� }Bh z6Bw� , '�Ly� O*�^�2y��� ��.7 ���Ly� ��>?���� ��@�A9��
2 �Y�1>w¯�V�8 (Chiappetta et al., 1991a),'J2 ��� �1)N 8?¦Y lB? ��2 �N�AB��2 `���� i 07�eB��J �¨ 0&
`Y�&� , ������� a�?��� ��>?���� ��(���� 01& 8* nT ���>D��*y� d���HB�� Q����u���(National Science
Teacher Association)W 2 ±�5h'6>�@2 �Y�1>w �K�L� (Chiappetta & Fillman, 2009),���~>@ ����& a��B��
'�9T�1�� , dL��A�� k��>Ty� }�Bh 8�* �)�� 0�>�HB �~.?¦Y =�* �@��� �>D��*y� d�HB�� Q��u���y ����
��Ly� �>?���� �@�A9��� ,��@���� 8* `g.* `) h `�����(h `�����2 k�;�ABKj� ��A��(h `����2 R�DeB�� ��A�
l�?B ��2 �N�AB��2 `���� i ����1B�� �&j���2 W� 0�U�Y , \��Nc��Y �9hJ XN�h �9��Z� k�>Ty� }Bh 'J EF GH1�� `Y aB�� }BD�� �NL�A* �>?���� �@�A9�� Q�N�D� �~.?¦Y
8* �~�>�²15�.K W a���� �K�L�2�2004� �'6�7 �.(�K , , a�B��
X@��� EF =���* 8��7 :C��D�� �������� }��Bh 8?¦��Y [��Ky� `>���B�� 8* l�)�� EF O*�^� 8* 4�e;��
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 75 –
��N�AB��2 `����� i� �����1B�� Q��&j��� '6�7 �.(�)���>1��2 l?B ��2�>?���� �@�A9�� ���J �TJ �L�1B7� W �&2
Qu��� �)�� 8�* ��N�D* 0>�² d��J GT�1�� ��rBK�¹�H.�� �5� �(1Y�* W�K�L��� v]��BN X��U�Y2 'J EF �
�1)N %��)���2 O*��^� 4�e;�� ������ }Bh 8?¦Y ��N�AB��2 `���� i ����1B�� Q�&j��� [�Ky� l�)��2
��>1��2 l?B ��2 o�1Y�21% � ,����H�� ���7����* 8�* Q�B7�2�1).�� �5 0�9?� ¹�H.�� L��1B7� ,��>@�h R¡
\�N�D* \�>K�KJ �>?���� �@�A9�� ��Ly� ���y� 8* W i1B���A��B�� �A�)��� Q�K�L��� ����BK� 8*
�>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* ���HB'J EF X��U�Y �~B>1��¡ ����J , ��U�V ,�>?���� �@�A9�� , �1�(�� =�B)* ��Y
R�DeB�� ��A��(h `����, ��N�AB��2 `����� i� ��&j���2 l��?B ��2,Q���K�L��� 'J 6��h ����H1��2 X��*�& a��B��
Y }BD�� 0>�HB��7 EF �~B>1��¡ X�U����+2 'c���Y ��9hJ2 ,���Ly� �>?���� �@�A9�� ���y }BD�� 8?¦Y ,
�>?���� �@���� '�D* '�h \�.?¦Y ���y�W ��� � ��! S�&� E�����:
\���@�L \6>���Y '67 �.(�K , "�^� `>��B�� ��� a*�DZ� `>��B��, \��*6B � ��*�DZ� n�B�2J ��A@ \�R�1h ,
2JY�j� "��^� M��(A�� ��U�e�� XT z��� , L69B�K`>��B��, zjV 8* F ���AY a�B�� ��U�^� %L����� k�CN
��� i?>A��2 �.(�)�� k�.y `>��B�� Q�*�V W })�T2
���7 QL��U aB�� �U�^� %L��?�� �>?>g.B�� �H]j��2006�� ,`>��B��2 �>�� dL�c22006�� ��;�A�� '¢�@ ,
Y a �U�^� %L����B�� %L���� ±�a ����@J �~D�B?� �U�V Q�)K�* 2J Q�hµ 2J, ��~>@ `>���B�� ¹�A�B�2
>N67 mj<�i>N67 R¡2 ' W>Y¬� %L���� 0?CY2�: • [L��� 01& `>��B�� %L��*: %L����� a� 2
z��e<y� ������ �6��� v~.�� _1(Y aB��, ��� c���2 �>��7 v �.* _>1(YW
• ��D�� '¯�A�� º>e² %L��*��U�^� `�: a� 2 �����2 `��D�� '¯�A�� º>eHB� %L��*W
• �S��� ����TJ %L���� :2 `B�� aB�� %L���� a ��� l�>£ O�L�Y �~>@��� Q��S��� ���7 ��>���� ��S���
�>1.+y�� ���J ,p�>� NF�W • �S��� �>]�.I %L����: 2 `B�� a�B�� %L����� a
Q�>�������� �����* O�L���Y ���~>@,��������2 ,��>.AY2 �Q�*�����,�¬� }K�Z�2 , ��S��� =��VJ ����* pJ 2J ���>� N��,�>��7 v �.* O�L�Y �� c��2 W • �>����� %L����: 2 X�;�T aB�� %L���� a
��>��7 ��>?>��Y Q�)K�* 8* 4�7u�2 �6B7u� b7, X�² �>�K�L��� 0T���� l>£ , �>�2��� v*���� _1(Y2
��K��� =���TF 4�µF2 dL��F ���>����� ������� Q�)01& 8* �� 4��� dL�c���, \��7�@ '�DY �& 2J ��)��)�
�>��7 %L��* 8*W
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 76 –
• >�2��� %L�����:2 k�.J ��§ aB�� %L���� a �� Q���>��P����?>A dL�c����� ���~>�7 4-��Y2 �.(�)���� ,
�A@ \��L��F \�@�µFW �5�� , �*�rB)���� �������� v ���.* Q2���eBY2
%L������,���2 %L������@ ,�~)���L�Y , �*�rB)���� ���S O�L��Y , ��>N6��� v ��.�� ���rB�K� `B� �S��� ����TJ
������,��>���� ��S��� v ��.�� �5� %L ��Y2 , , 6.�> ��>��7 ��>?�7 0�KjK �6B�7� `B� �S��� �>]�.I %L����,
0��1& 8��* �����>� N�� ���S��� 0Kj)���� �5�� %L���Y2m��72 }�N�+J i�?��*, G�>H l��* ��?]jB* '��DY
a��B�� �������� �@�e;��*���~]�.1 X��*�& ���*���� ��������� Q�+�» }�¡J _A² G>H ,dL�c��� �U�^� %L��?��
`B� 6h ,�@�e;���~>@ �>]��I�2 �?7�� v �.* �6B7� W *2, 8�?DY G�H1�� �5� �>¼J '¢@ `I 8n�N�h
��>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* �UL , i9T�1�� 01& 8* ��2��[��Ky� 8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =��, i� ��NL�A* ��A72
��>]�.I ��U�^� %L����� �1�<2 �>*�DZ� %L���� �1�<�S����.(�)�� W,2 0�U�B�� `B>�K a�B�� v]�B.�� k��
Q��TA��2 Q�>�U�B�� 8* �7�?� `��AY `B>K ,�~>�F0*��� 8* ½'J ��~.* �>eB)�)�����2� ��>�� dL�c2 , '`>����B��2, O�L���Y =�B)��? ¹��&�Y Q�k����+F |���§�
��@�A9�� =�B)�* l�@L ���B��2 ,:;��� �5� , �������1�(�� =�� �>?����W
TU�� �+V�:
�6B u� �1UJ¢ �>?���� �@�A9�� i?��B�� m�)hZ� Q�L2� 8*>d� ±��| ,8�-����2 p��Z� '�A�� ,
��>.AB��2 ��>?���� Q�L��(B�� ����B*� �� '�A�� �5 'J ,8�-��� '�A��8*2 Q�L��(B�� �5� '�DY 'J l&�B��
�� `g.�� �'¢@ �5�2 ,M¶J2 �wJ����9��Z� �~>�7 }� 'J® ¾���§ ±���Y l��* 0��*��B�� b��7 8�L����& i��?��B*
Q�L��(B�� W Q���K�L��� n�>�F QL���wJ ��* zj��V 8�*2a������ =�B)�� b7 XN�hJ k��K �A�)�� (Mumba et
al., 2006; Baldi et al., 2007) J2 ������ ,a.�L�1�U2011;����r , 2004�a+����� ;, 2002�,¹e(;��* ; 1990� �J2 a.<������� ,p�*�¦�����2005� ����1��(^� ;
,p�>�K�1*J22002� � EF �1�(�� z�U2 ��7 G>T 8* n�+�Y k��� ,2 ,��>?���� ��@�A9�� 8�* z�1A* =�B)*
, �hL�C?�� �.(�)�� a�B�� ��>�2��� Q��K�L��� ³��)Y8*�9�� :;�� �1�< 4�~B , 0�9* Q��~+�B�� ��K�L�
�������2 Q�>������ , �>�2���(TIMSS) ��DC�* '¢�@GH1����Z� � , 0�9?BY ��@�A9�� =�B)�* 8�7 :C�D�
[�Ky� 8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?����, ±�| �&j72 M�N2 O.P� pRSB? }���(�� ��~>@ `��B� aB�� �KL���
2J �>*�DT ���h G>T 8*�U�VW TU�� W��X1:
��)¹���Z� G�H1�� EF 4���Y ��@�A9�� =�B)�*
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 77 –
6h ,8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?�������)¹ ��* 4���Y EF F '�h �|�� �5 =�B) :�B¸ ,}��(�� O.+ 4jBV�2 M�N
�KL��� �U�V �J �>*�DT ���h G>T 8* >]�.I��S��� W TU�� �Y�1:
�¹�)�5 87 ��+�� EF GH1�� ¬� ���Ky� �>Y: 1 W :;��� ��1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* �*
?[�Ky� 8*�9�� 2 W ��1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* :�B¸ 0
}���(�� O.+ 4jBV� 8*�9�� :;�����h| �¹�9NJ� , �KL��� M�N2��>*�DT ��U�V �?6~.> 07�eB��2 TU�� /*�A:
5���7 GH1�� d`>�?�Y 8* �² �2�T BN n� ]� ,a 2:
1W �>7����� �2�Z� : =�B)�* 8�7 :C�D��'67 �.(�) 8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� W
2W �>N�*��� �2�Z� : ������ , GH1�� _>1(Y `Y [�L���2012�2011�W 3W �>N�D�� �2�Z� : ��.>7 b7 GH1�� _>1(Y `Y
8*�9�� :;�� �1�< 8* '6�7 �.(�)� �A)* �g@�� , ,�� X�?w G>T ��1�<2 ��>*�DZ� %L����� ��1�< ��.>�
�U�^� %L����� \�I�NF2 \�L�h|W� ��(�� �#�=RZ� C�BI=���:
5�� `�~�� 8�* Q�H�(;��� 8* �7�?� GH1��
\�>]��+F �~e���Ya : �>?���� �@�A9�� : G�H1�� a.<���� O�� �� ��~@�7
���>D��*y� d���HB�� Q����u���(National Research
Council, 1996, 12) (NRC���x :À `> ��e�� `~@2 �@��* �¼�)���2 ,L��A�� l.U , ���(�� `���� Q�>�?72 �>?����
l?B �� , �>+�BN��2 �>@�A9��2 �>N��� �(CNy� ,Á W 8��* ���7�?� ��� «�x \���>]��+F '���9T�1�� ���~@���2
�>?���� 4L����� ,��>+���>1�� `> �e�� �A��B�� 4L������2����>]���>e ,'����D��2 k�¦���e��2 �Ly� ������72� ,
��L�F2 ,R��DeB�� Q�L���~*2 ,k�;��ABKu� Q�L���~*2 aB�� �>+���.DB��2 l?B ��2 `���� i ����1B�� Q�&j��� , �hL�C��� b�7 \�L���& \�Z��U \��.<��* }���(�� 0��
>?���� n�?B� ���¦& 0T2 �C&�.*� W 5 ,2����� ��@�A9�� %�>& `Y GH1�� k��x� ��>?
p5��� ��>?���� ��@�A9�� L��1BV� b�7 8*�9�� :;�� �1�<J��S�� �5� '�9T�1�� ��7W
�>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)*: }�� p5�� =�B)�� � 0;� 'JF ��>?�7 ��@�AI `Â��� «'x� `�DH�� ��1�(�� n>�
� =�B)�� ���AY `Y2 ,�1K�.*�80�% L�wJ �* _@2 ,F n>��A�)���� Q���K�L���2 '���?DH�� ���K�L� z���9*J 8��*
p�*�¦���2005�� W L��1BVu� b�7 _1(.Y �1).�� �5 2 0Dh����J2 ��Ly� �.?¦B��5 , �GH1�� W
������� `>����B�� %L����* : �����B�� %L������ a��
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 78 –
�>N67 mj�< ��~>@ `>��B�� ¹A�B�2 �*�DH��� R�¡ 2J ' \�A@2 ,i>N67 ,dL�c���� � ���² aB�� OKy�2 R���?�� �c2 4-Y2 \��L��F �~>�7 `>��B��2 �>�� dL \�>��*2 \�>.@2 ,
B» 0?CB� �~>@ �>?>��B�� v*����2 Q�N�D*�� �B¤2�� : [��Ky� `>��B��2 ����� `>��B�� 0T��*� ��>�� dL�c2
,`>��B��22001�W� �U�^� %L����: �~D�B?� aB�� %L���� ±�Y a
�� ¹�A�B�2 ,�U�V Q�)K�* 2J Q�hµ 2J ���@J `>���B �����TJ '��DY ��&2 ,i�>N67 R�¡2 '��>N67 �1�< �~>@
���S��� ���>]�.I 2J ,���S���, ���(1Y��� ���>����� %L������ 2J '67 , �>�Y aB�� Q�>��P� W
5 ,2� ��>]�.I %L����� 4��~B�K� `�Y GH1�� ���>� N�� �S��� ������ d��* �~>@ %L�Y aB�� �S���W
TU�� �G[��
* TU�� Q��\J����:
'�DY 8* GH1�� l?B� �3525� ��1��<2 \��1��< a*��DZ� `>���B�� %L���* , 8*��9�� :;�� �1�< 8*
2�520� %L��* , 8*�9�� :;�� �1�< 8* �1��<2 \�1��< [�L������ �������� , i� )����� "����^� `>�����B��
�2012/2011� � µ�2 }>)�� aB�u2 M�(& %L��* ,�) �A)* �g@�H� iB��B��'67 �.( W
�*J G�H1�� �.>7X�N�DY ��A@ 8�* �502 � \��1��< �< 8��* ���1��<2���1 ���>*�DZ� %L������ 8*���9�� :;����
`~.* �U�^� %L����2�252 � \�1��< %L����� 8* �1��<2 2 �>*�DZ��250 �,�U�^� %L���� 8* �1��<2 \�1��< �&2
X�?w �.>����210 � mj(�� 8*2�292 ���1��< G�>T ,i>�Y `Y����A.7 �>]��C7 �A��( �.>��� � z2�P�1 W�
]*�^�517 DJ_�N"�� `�* TU�� ��� /�=�1 QIa�_D
b�. �(�)�
2�^� ���+A %�c
�h| 67 143 210 ¹9NJ 185 107 292
M�? �� 252 250 502
TU�� <�/1:
1 D�[P�% �� �Hd��* TU�� <�/1 K��!:
���& GH1�� d��J `>?;B� EF M�+���� '��9T�1�������� Q�>�y� 8* ��7,�� l�&��*2 X�NN�1� a�B��
��� ���J2 ���>?���� ���@�A9�� =�B)��* �����² , X��9H ����~.*2 ,����e�Br��� ,p�*�¦�����2005�; ����1��(^�
,p�>�K�1*J22002�W� L�>BV� `Y 6h Q�~+�B�� �K�L��������2 Q�>������ �>�2���� TIMSS � k��.1� ±�H?h
1BV� �1)�.�� 8*��9�� :;��� �1�(� �>?���� �@�A9�� L� EF
)1( Massachusetts Department of Elementary & Secondary
Education, Science Exams for Grade 8 (For 2009- 2012
Academic Years), Retrieved March 15, 2012, http://www.doe.mass.edu
New York State Education Department, Science Exams for
Grade 8 (For 2004-2011 Academic Years), Retrieved March 20, 2012, http://www.nysedregents.org
TIMSS & PEARLS International Study Center Retrieved
March 2, 2012, http://timss.bc.edu/
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 79 –
��>?���� �@���� "�^� k�P ���HB� \u2J : Q�N�D?�� L�1BVu� �~.?¦B� aB�� `> �e��
a�� 2 �������� ���Ij9�� : ��������2 ���>+���>1�� �������� �>]���>e���k���>e��2 k�>?>D�� � k�¦�e��2 �Ly� ���72
'�D��2 W \���>N�I :0��h �1)��N ���Ij9�� Q���N�D�� 8��* '���D*
������ W \�9��I : �¡�>�U , ���Ky� ³� 8* d��eBKu� `Y
��Z� L�1BVu� Q���e* W y� dL�;�� XN�DY �&2 �>�2 8�* L�1BVj��63 �
u� M�N 8* d��e* ��7 ���B* 8* L�>BVd��e�� `�&L�27 � b�7 d���e�� �5 X�?Bw� G>T ,�>?���� �@���� �� ,
��LJ }��·< G>T ,�>)1�� z6h�� M�N 8* �>7�@ ���KJ����² ��~>@ }���(�� 8* d����� 2J ´�.��� ��>]6>D�� ,
FnB�+d���e�� �*�A* , n� ¹(�* � �¨ � L�B¸ G>H W Q���e�� X7c2 �&2 ��LJ b7����J ��@�A9�� �>�K�KJ
�>?����a : • �>?���� �@���� 8* `g.* `) h `����� ����KJ
e* ,k���>e��2 k�>?>D��2 ,k�>Ty� `> � �Ly� ���72 ,'�D��2 k�¦e��2W�
• k�;ABKj� �A��(h `����W • RDeB�� �A��(h `����W • l?B ��2 �N�AB��2 `���� i ����1B�� �&j���W
3�DY8�J�+ 8* L�1BVu� ',�B� p z2y� k��P� EF �@���� L�1BVu� Q���e* 87 ��+�� Q6>��Y b7
1�Y �U�^� �*���� Q�*����� k�+ ��}��< 0D k�P�2 ,L���1BVu� Q�����e* 8?¦��B� ����9��, ·< G��>T 8��* }���
�� z���T d���]�� l���� ���~.7 ����+�� }����(�� ����+��(��� ���Ly� 0]��1�� 8* � L�B¸ aB�� �H>H;��dn�� W
8*2J 8�* �B�K b�7 n���7 `Y n&�U 8* _AHB�� 0+ , "�;��BVu� p2| 8��* i��? �DH�� �������� O�L���Y
`���AB��2 %�>A��2, ��S��� , i;�;rB�� ��TJ b�72 �>����,s� 6>@ `~]�L¯ k��� ±�|2 :
• L�1BVu� �1K�.*�GH1�� 4�� J _>AHBW • L����1BVu� , �.?¦���B�� Q������e�� ����*kj*
�~>�F �>?B.�� Qu� ?��W • z�Dwy�2 Q�*�K���2 ,Q�H�(;�� ©��2 ,
���S��� �¡�>;�� �HU2 �&�2L�1BVu� Q���e� W • L���1BVu� Q�����e* 0�����Y, =���VJ �@����F2
��L2�2 �1K�.* ��2��W • 0�h2 ,0Dh L�1BVj� aDH�� =�B)�� �1K�.*
� 2 ����J 8* ���80W�%
³� �¡�>U 0���Y «̀ Y i? �DH�� k�L¯ k�� ,2 ³�� L��wJ 6h ,Q�*�K��� ³� �>��Y2 ,Q���e��
iY��e* 45T EF i? �DH�� L��1BVu� ®��VF 0���Y2 ,0~)� ¹BT� b7 7 ���+�� �1�(��>�n, 5�Vy� «̀ �Y ��&2
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 80 –
i? �DH�� 01& 8* �TA�� Qj���B�� W ���. '��h 6h �1)�N z��1& b�7 i�?DH�� i� �C�* t�eY��80 �%
0��Dh L���1BVj� a��D� =�B)��?h , 8��* '���D* 0��D�2��Ly� nY�N�D* W
2 D(���ce� C��$:
I 8* _AHB�� ��.>7 b�7 nA>1(Y `Y L�1BVu� Q�1GH1�� �.>�� ���C* �>7j(BK�, 8* XN�DY �30 � \�1��<
8*��9�� :;��� ��1�< 8* �1��<2, Q��1I m�)�T `�Y2 �� sV������ t�)��Yu�Q�����e? ���e�J 0��*��* m�)��H
q�1N2�h, i� ��1YLu� d�& EF RC� p5�� Q�19�� � 2 �� l* L�1BVu� , Q���e����1 �>?B.�� F L�1BVu� l*2 n>�
0Dh W Q�19�� 0*��* o� �&2 sD���0.84�, ���� �� 2 \�1K�.*Qj*���* X�N�h 6h ,GH1�� ��S� ���;���
i ©2�Y�0.35−0.85� , Qj*��*2 X�T2��Y �>>?B�� i�0.30−0.70� , =���� 8?�� l�AY Qj*���* a 2
Q�L�1BVu� , \�>]�;TF z�1A��W �� �hxB��8*L��1BVu� t�U , n�Y�1I m�)�T2
�1UJ–��>]�~.�� nYL�U , – s��e�� _�>1(B�� \�� ��+ 8* XN�DY aB�� nY���e?�61 �d��e* W z2�P� ����2
�2 � b7 Q���e�� l�c�Y���J ���Ly� ��>?���� ��@�A9�� �.?¦B��5 , � 0h Q�1I ±�5h2 ,GH1�� �5 8* ��
���y� W��y� ³� 'J ºTj�2 Qj*���* ��~>@ 0AY � 87 Q�19���0.70� , L��1BVu� '�h ;��DC* ��� u �5 2
�z��7 n�Y�1I 0�Dh L�1BVu� 'J2 ,��LJ ���J 8* '�DB�W �&2�>*�DZ� %L���� �1�(� L�1BVu� `��AY `Y, �1�<2
�U�^� %L������S��� �>]�.I � `�Y ��&2 ,��>���� �S���^� %L����?�� �������� ,-��* dL�C��BK� `����AB ���U�
��>���� �S��� L�1BVu�, `> ��e�� �>���Y `B�� 'J b�7 ���>� N�� �S��� `� �>?���� W
]*�^�527 Df+H (���ce�* (���ce� /��!1 �� ��! f+ C���* C�R(��* �Y��� /�� QIa�_D
��+)� �Y��� /�� C��� ��+� R(�� R(/g+U)� h���)�
�� �@�����>?�� 27* 0.75 30 24
k�;ABKu� 15 0.53 15 12
RDeY �A��(h `���� 10 0.66 10 8
l?B ��2 �N�AB��2 `���� i �&j��� 9 0.64 9 7.2 0Dh L�1BVu� 61 0.84 64 51.2
* z��)���27�Q�+L��� G>T 8* 0;e.* z��K ��J b7 n.* �>]�+ 0h ��*��* `Y2 ,�>7�@ Q�>]�+ lLJ n �1�,� ,�H>H;�� ��+2 � �eU��<�^� ��+�W
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 81 –
TU�� C�K�=Ri:
|���§� `��Y G��H1�� 4���� J _��>A² 0��+J 8��*�>Y¬� Q�k��+��:
1W �A�)���� Q���K�L���2 Q���>�y� ����+��*�>?���� �@�A9�� �A��B�� ,�~K�>& �>e>h2 ,� ��B)* ���²2
2W GH1�� d��J ���² , L��1BV� 8�7 dL�17 a 2� �@�A9�� , Q��>�y� EF M��+��� 8�* �u '�h2 �>?���
�A�)�� Q�K�L���2 , 8�* �;�;rB�� �>?���� l+����2L�1BVu� �5 Q���e* �¡�>U 0+JW
3W `>���B��2 �>�� dL�c2 �A@��* b7 z�;Z��@�~B)�� �.>��� b7 L�1BVu� _>1(Y 0+J 8* �.(�)��W
4W L�1BVu� Q���e� �>�2y� �¡�>;�� , ����²2��i�?DH�� zjV 8* n� t�; ,`�I ��.>7 b�7 n�A>1(Y
L�1BVu� Q�1I ���² 0+J 8* �>�Uy� �.>��� ���C*W 5W ��S��1�� ��K�L��� ��.>7 b7 L�1BVu� _>1(Y
�502 � ��U�^�2 ��>*�DZ� %L����� 8�* �1��<2 \�1��<
'67 �.(�) �S��� �>]�.IW 6 W L��1BVu� v]��BN ®��rBK� , ±��Y �C�&�.*2
8*2 ,v]�B.�� b�7 k�. Q�TA��2 Q�>U�B�� `��AY `I v]�B.�� ±�YW
Q�(��K�B�� ®��rB��K� `��Y Q���N�>1�� 0��>�HB�2�>�)Z� ,��L�>��� Q�@��HNu�2 ,L��1BV�2À QÁ ��.>���
2 ,z2y� z��)���� EF �1)��.�� d���T���� 8����1B�� 0��>�²Q�RSB�� ���B* a]�.9�� 8�* ���9�� z��)��� EF �1)�.��
GH1��W � j=��[�VP���* k#���:
1− :;��� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* �* ?'67 �.(�) 8*�9��
Q�(�K�B�� m�)�T `�Y z��)��� �5� 87 ��+Å��>�)��Z�, Q���@��HNu�2����L�>��� ,���?>&2 À QÁ ���.>���
d�T����; �>�)�Z� Q�(�K�B�� i� t2��e�� ��u� �He� A9�� =�B)� \����Y z�1A�� =�B)��2 �>?���� �@�� z2�P�3W�
]*�^�537 D �!��,� C� ���)� , I(���)� C���=U.e�* , ��P*l Cmf+H (���ce�* (���ce� /��!1 �� ��! f+ D
�����
e�� C ��P I=,� R(/
R(/ h���)�
g+U)�
W�=U.e�
0(���)�
h���)�
n��,�
R(��
��+� ����
0.001 47.003 501 24 5.36 12.75 30 �>?���� �@����
0.001 59.930 501 12 2.50 5.28 15 k�;ABKj� �A��(h `����
0.001 42.715 501 8 2.20 3.80 10 RDeY �A��(h `����
0.001 35.609 501 7.2 1.99 4.02 9 `���� i �&j��� l?B ��2 �N�AB��2
0.001 59.403 501 51.2 9.30 25.85 64 BVu�0Dh L�1
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 82 –
z2�P� 8* �¦B��3 � �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* 'J '2� '6�7 �.(�)� "��^�2 ������ `>���B�� �1�< =��
\�����Y z��1A�� =�B)�� 0�h , ����y� L��1BVu� ,2 ,0Dh,'J �¦B� 6h ��· �1Y��� b7 0;T �>?���� �@����
`��I ,n��>�7 ���1�(�� k��J , E2y�����· `������ ���A��(h�k�;ABKj ,��· k�+ `I `���� i �&j��� �>+���.DB��2
l?B ��2 \�RVJ2 ,��·RDeB�� �A��(h `���� W ������� n�>�F X�U�Y �* l* _eBY � >B.�� �5 «'F
Q���K�L��� 8��*�Mumba et al., 2006 ; ���1��(^� p�>�K�1*J22002�� 'J 8* ,��· 0;T �>?���� �@����
* z2y� }>Y�� b7 , �1�(�� k��J G>T 8 Q�L��1BVu� %�>A� X??U aB���>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* , ±�5h2 ,
�>KL��� ������ }Bh =�BH�� 0>�² W 8�* a��>1< �5 2 G>TF_]�AT 8* �>?���� �@���� ',`> �e*2 ,iN��&2 ,
8��D?� u2 ,���1�(�� `��B��� ����L2� ����Y Q�����gN22 ,�~.7 k�.SBKu�JJ }� �1�(�� «'L�& ��1)BD� ' \���@�2 \�
c��>B+�2 d����� , ©� .�� `~.D?� ¹BT �@���� ±�Y 8*���>.<��� Q�L���1BVu�2 ,J Q�A�)����2 Q���K�L��� \�¦���
�>�2��� (Dani, 2009)W i�?���� ��>h�Y EF � >B.�� �5 R)eY 8D?� 6h
�1�(�� �>?���� Q�*����� `��AY b7 \�R9h , �>?.Y z�e¡F2eB�� Q�L�~* b7 �L2� OD�.� p5�� ,k�;ABKu�2 RD
�*��.7 �~]�7�BK�2 Q�*����� ºeT EF '2x �>@ �1�(��
,Q�L���1BVu� , ±���| `~.��* }���(·� 'J EF �@������ =�B)�* EF ��1�(�� l@� , \�11K ��Y �~)eN Q�L�1BVu� R�DeB��2 k�;�ABKu� p�� , �>?���� �@�A9�� 8* '�B*
i ����1B�� �&j���2 0>¤ ���h ;l?B ��2 �N�AB��2 `���� Æ����1*2 `> ���e*2 _]���AT 8��* Q���*����� L���1BV� EF
Q���gN2 ,�e�Br�� Q�L�~�� `>>AY z�e¡F2 W `�~�� 8�*2uJ �>?���� �@�A9�� �>?.Y , \��+ o���1* �>h�Y ��. '�D�
, n>@,�>?���� �@���� �� �@�A9��2 ������ �g.� u ¹BT �>?����b7J �A@ ,��* =�B� �� (Roberts, 2007)W
'J _�)���� z2���P� v]���BN QL���wJ 6��h `������ k��J , ���9�� }�>Y�� b�7 0;T k�;ABKj� �A��(h �(C�Ny� ³�� ���. «'J EF ±��| ����� ��&2 ,�1�(�� `>���B�� , ������ }Bh , ,�CDBK� l�< Q�| �>?����
u X��N�h ½'F2 ,'6��7 �.(�)�� ������� =�B)��* EF ¹��&�Y aA>AZ� k�;ABKu�(Ambusaidi & Al-Zain, 2008) ,
Q�L���~* ���KL�¨2 � 5��>e.B }����(�� n��>@ ����A� p5����aA>AT 0DC ��jV 8* k�;ABKu� W� 8D 6L '�DY �&
�1�(�� �KL�¨y� �5� `���� l* �(CN '��>Ty� ³� , �&k�;ABKu� Q�L�~* ³� `~1)hJ , Q��~� a�B�� ]�BNL�1BVu� �5 , �1�(�� v W
� EF �1).�� �*J�U�^� %L��� , ¹.1Y 8* `¡���1@� %L���� �5 ³� ������� O�L��Y , ��>��7 0Kj)
,�>]�;��ABKu� �(C��Ny� ���KL�¨ b��7 ���h�Y'J uF ����&
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 83 –
Q�N�D*��, �@�Y ��72����r�� �����2 Q�2�y�a�B�� i�Y `����� b�7 5�>e.Y�(C�N�� ��1�(�� �>]�;�ABKu�
����@ dL�;`I 8*2 ,�(¦� `���� 0DC� � 5�>e.Y EF n*�>& 2J a7�£n)e. �1�(�� ��*J �� s?7 ��� W
z�;T �*J�� �>+���.DB��2 `���� i �&j��� l?B ��2G��9�� }>Y�� b7 , dL�& ��7 EF l+�� 6�@
Ç�.7 �L b7 �1�(�����1�� �5� �~¦�� l�* (Kim,
2006); ©-�� k�.IJ , ±�5 `���� ��>& ��7 }1), 2J ����� `>��B�� , �>KL��� }BD�� 'J�.(�)��� a�7��Y u
�&j��� �5 dR1h �1)., v]��BN n�>�F QL��wJ ��* _�@2 a������ ���K�L��2004�� , �1)��N 'J ���~>@ 0��U�Y a��B��
a� �&j��� �5 Q�N�D� �.(�)�� ������ }Bh z6Bw��21 �%�A@� W ¹�.1BY a�B�� ��U�^� %L����� }�Bh ��*J
R����* b�7 ��>.1* '��DY �A@ �>����� 0Kj)�� �~¦� \��>?�7 �*�AB* z2� 8* �>��7 ��L dL2� b�7 ��h�Y
��£�Y b�7 i?���� dL�& 8D� ,l?B ��2 �N�AB�� `���� O�L���B�� l��&�2 , ���*y� �5�� ���A�Z� a�� '���DY ���&
�� �5� l@�� 6��@ ,:��y� =��BH�� ��>(SY EF `���}BD�� ±�Y , 8?¦B�� ,���� , �L2 c��F ��2�� '2�
}��(�� n>@ �>�� p5�� l?B �� ±�|W �*J��·R�DeY �A��(h `���� , b�7 0;�T ��A@
\�e>�� n>@ �1�(�� k��J '�h2 ,RVy� }>Y�� \��+ W �5 2 u �.(�)�� ������ O�L�Y 'J b7 µ�*� z���b7 �h�
Q�L��~* ���(Y b7 �h�� n.* 0>�A��2 ,Q�*����� ºeT 8* ��251�� ��~P� 8* `¡��� ,QjDC�� 0T2 RDeB��
�.(�)�� , `>��B��2 �>�� dL�c2 01& , i�?���� l�@�R)��eB�� b��7 ���1�(�� dL���& ���>?.Y b��7 ���>h�� ���HN,
0>�HB��2, QjDC�� 0T2 (Ministry of Education,
2001)W ���&2 J 8��* �������� Q���h2 ��L���AB��y� Q���>� �A�)�����OECD, 2007; Sadler, 2009)� ±����| ,
J2 _����B� 6>��@ Q�����U ���1�(�� ���~+��* EF QL���wQjDC��� 0�T b�7 `�L�A,Q�L���A�� |��§�2 8�7
2 ,�>*�>�� d�>Z� QjDC*J`~�� 8* nN \��+ b�7 �>h�� ��1�� �5 �1�(�� }�L�Y zjV 8* IJ , ������ �K�L� k�.
�e�Br�� �>?���� p5��� l�?B �� 8�* QjDC* 0T b7 n>@ '�C>��Soobard & Rannikmäe, 2011)W�
_1�K ��* zj�V 8* ��@�A9�� =�B)�* 'J �¦�B� 0Dh L�1BVu� =�B)* b7 k��K GH1�� �5 , �>?����
2J =�B)�* b7 �����Jy� z��1A�� =�B)��� '2� ���L���Y \�u �� L�1B7 \�;rw `��B \�>?�7 �eA9* , 2 ±��| ����
d���7 Q�L�* EF�~¦�� EF dL��w�� `Y W 8�* 8�D�2 EF dL�w�� `B� 'J \��+ �>e��a�?���� =��BH�� v ��.�
, ��U�V ,v �.�� �5� i?���� 5>e.Y2 �>KL��� ������ G�>T ;k�;ABKu� z��k�;�ABKu� =��BH�� z2��.B�,
��2�� �>�?�h a?���� ,���2�>�� Q�L��~�� ��>?.B ¹�.�Y��>. | �>�?�h X)>�2 EF ��� �6B� u� ����T , p���Y
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 84 –
09* �>�A��� Q�>�?��� �1�(�� �jB*� :R)eB�� ,��1.B��2 ,%�>A��2 ,� R¡2 W L2� m��>¡ }1)��� '��D� ��& 6�h
0;�B�� L���A�� |��§� �.7 `��?�� l+�?h `���� �e)�@>)�L�B�� ��~�� `>?;Y2 L�>BV� �.B)� G>T ,� 5>e.Y2 �i?���� ³� �.7 L��A�� |�§�, 0¦@ ±�| EF L�wJ 6h
�1998� � L���1B7u� '2� ���>76B+� 2J ����L��F 0��*��7 EF dR�1h d�� @ ��+2 ±�| b7 }Y�Y2 ,�>@���� 0*�����
�>)�L�B�� Q�KL6��2 �>?���� �@�A9�� �>?.Y i W 2− � �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* :�B¸ 0 �1�< =�
}���(�� O.+ 4jBV� 8*�9�� :;�����h| �¹�9NJ� , �KL��� M�N2��>*�DT ��U�V �?6~.> 07�eB��2
0�>�² ���rB�K� `�Y ,z��)��� �5 87 ��+Å� , t2�e�� Quu� �@��� Q�RSB�� ���B* a]�.9�� 8��1B��
��N��2 L�h5�� i �>�)Z� Q�(K�B��,�� M�N2 �KL� �>*�DT�V ,U���,6~.> 07�eB��2 W
z2���P� ������2�4 � �>�)��Z� Q�(��K�B��8�RSB�� 8�5� ��L�>��� Q�@��HNu�2W
]*�^�547 D �!��,� C� ���)� ,TU�� C�N"�� �� N"�� f+ o���_ f+H (���ce�* ����� ���� /��!1 �� ��! f+ I(���)� C���=U.e�*D
2�^� )� b�. �(�
(�Hp� q�.Z� ���+A %�c ����
r s r s r s r s
z2y� 12.6 5.7 12.9 5.1 12.2 5.1 13.3 5.5
��9�� 5.16 2.6 5.38 2.5 5.14 2.4 5.44 2.6
G��9�� 3.74 1.9 3.77 2.3 3.70 2.1 3.80 2.2
l���� 3.90 2.0 4.11 2.0 4.00 2.1 4.00 1.9
0Dh L�1BVu� 24.8 9.5 25.7 9.1 24.6 9.0 26.0 9.5
z2�P� 8* �¦B��4 � \��&2�@ ���. 'J ���� �� 0h , �1�(�� k��y �>�)Z� Q�(K�B�� i���J 8* ��
0��Dh L���1BVu� ,2 ����Ly� ���>?���� ���@�A9�� W ���@���2
, E2y� d���(^� ���rB��K� `��Y t2���e�� ±���Y Quu� 2 ,Q�RSB�� ���B* a]�.9�� 8��1B�� 0>�²m�)T a `>&
��1� OD��2� z2�P�5W�
]*�^�557 D2�^� 0N"�) C�N"�)� /���� g#��� �I���� f��u k#��. , �(�)� b�.* ,�[��! f��B��*D
(��� �I���� ���) 2+�I* ��P ��Pl Wm !��U)� �v=B� I=A C�R(/ d &� I=A C�R(/ �#��AZ� e��
O.P��J� 0.993 0.817 4 486 0.515
� M�N�KL��� m� 0.998 0.740 8 972 0.656
�J � �m� 0.967 4.101 4 486 0.003
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 85 –
z2��P� 8* �¦B��5 �`>�& 'JÀ 4Á ��)�H�� ����� t2��@ ���+2 ��7 EF RCY ��1� OD��2 `>& b7
�� M�N2 O.P� pRSB* , \�>]�;TF�KL� RC�Y ��~.D� , ����� t2�@ ��+2 EFF \�>]�;�TO.�+ i� 0�7�eB�� ,
}��(���� M�N2 �KL� W _eBY2v]��B.�� �5� p�*�¦��� ��K�L� v]��BN l�*
�2005����B�� aEF RC��Y ���@ ����+2 ����72 ����u� Q�| tF��U�^� %L�����2 �>*�DZ� %L���� �1�< i �>]�;T ,
p�*�¦��� ��K�L� 8�7 :��B§ �~.D��2005�� ,2 ��K�L� �r�2004� �B�U�Y iB��� ,Q�1��(�� ���;� t2�@ EF �
� ��Z� GH1�� 6.>� �5 09* EF 0U�Bt2�e��W 8*��9�� :;��� �1�< 'J b7 z�Y � >B.�� �5 «'F
��7 0DC, \�L�h| ��N�hJ k��K =�B)* '�D�B?� \�I�NF �J \���+ mL�AB* �>?���� �@�A9�� 8* W M��N 'J EF RC�Y 6�h
�KL��� 2J`>��B�� Y '�hJ k��K u \�U�V �J \�>*�DT \6>�� \�&�@ 0DC� �1).�� EF�>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)*, , �5� 2
��A� nY�| �TF`>���B��2 �>�� dL�c2 8* 0D� iYL�w, L�*y� k�>�2J2: E2y� dL�w�� � ��U�^� ��>�� dL�c�
8�7 dL�17 `>��B��2�� 2 dL�c���� ©��(·� z���K : 0� , ��Z� a*�DZ� `>��B�� 0�+J 8�* m���(�� =�B)��
F l�* 0�*��B�� b�7 `~.�>�Y ��>?�7 ��@�AI �1�(�� m�)h´��� Q�1�(B*}N�+ 8* , nY���²2 �e�Br��}N�+ 8*
�V¯ �A��B�� �>N�9�� dL�w�� � �*J ? `B�>@ ;�U�^� %L���� %L���� �5 b7 i?]�A�� b7 ���Ky� 8* �7�?� ©�<
L�*y� k�>�2J b72 ,¹ 2 : 0 n��@�� p5��� o��1�� �2�*y� É@�D� 2J pc��� %L���� �5 , n]�.J `>��Y RgN
'�D>�K 0 2 ?[�L� 0>;² 8* }��(�� �5 nAA� �*0¦@Jn� 6�7 [�L���� �c�� NF , ��KL�* , ���·Y ���
�>*�DT 'F ?v]�B.�� , G�H1�� �5� ��~>�F 0U�Y aB�� �@�~B)�� �.>��� k�� u �~g�R�1h �>�¦@J %L���?�� d
b7 �U�^�%L���� �>*�DZ� , }N�P� �5 W , t2�e�� ���� ���² 0+J 8*2 �>?���� �@�A9�� ���J
�KL��� M�N2 O.P� i 07�eB�� �1).�� \�>]�;TF ������Y ,` ��>N�9�� d�( �̂ ���rBK� 8�* 8���1B�� 0�>�²a]��.9�� ����B*
Q�RSB��� ���²?���� �@�A9�� ���J , �> , ������� Q�RIx�B��E2y� d�( �̂ � �~H��� 6h z2�P��6�W
]*�^�567D ��� o���� ��� C�N$d�� /���)� g#��� �I���� f��u k#��. %Lc l Wm���) 2+�I* x� !��U)� D
�I���� (��� /��!1 ����� ���� C��!=)� b��\ I=,� C�R(/ C��!=)� h���� ��Pl Wm !��U)� �#��AZ� e��
z2y� 252.53 1 252.53 9.102 0.003 ��9�� 1.400 1 1.400 0.223 0.637
G��9�� 0.534 1 0.534 0.116 0.733 O.P� × d����
l���� 0.627 1 0.627 0.157 0.692
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 86 –
Q!�_ ]*�^�56 D7
�I���� (��� ����� ���� /��!1 =)� b��\C��! I=,� C�R(/ C��!=)� h���� ��PlW m !��U)� �#��AZ� e��
z2y� 13594.024 499 27.745 ��9�� 3076.952 499 6.280
G��9�� 2249.113 499 4.590 x(^�
l���� 1956.319 499 3.992
z2�P� 8* �¦B��6 � � �>?���� �@���� ��· 'J
TF z���� �A@ 0�7�eB�� , ���Ly� ���y� i 8* \�>]�; ������ ���@���2 ,`>����B�� 2J ���KL��� M���N2 O.��P� i� �>�)�Z� Q�(�K�B�� m�)�T `�Y ,���1�� �5� 07�eB��
i)��. �������N��2 L�h5���� � ���>*�DZ� %L������ , �U�^� %L����2� z2�P�7�W
]*�^�577 D (�Hpz� �z� f+ �!��,� C� ���)� b�z. {�zA q�z.Z�*
����� �=�)� ��! | �(�)�D
2�^� �(�)� b�.
(�Hp� q�.Z�
�>*�DT 12.9 11.9
�U�V 12.4 14.5
z2���P� 8��* º��Tj� �7 � , Q���1��(�� k��J 'J��1�(�� a&�� k��J 8�* 0¦�@J ��U�^� %L���� ��� ,
�>?���� �@���� Q��1��(�� "��T EF ±�| ���� �&2 ,–
C��7 0D− , 0¦�@J k��J b7 ��K�L��� "��e�� 'J2 , , 8� �T�B��%L����U�^� ���� , n.* �9hJ 6L %L��
,��T���� :;��� , ��1�(�� ���7 ��& }1) ;�>*�DZ�
�9hJ ���B*2 d�7�)* `���� `��AY2 W 'J º�Tj� 6hJ k�� n�.* 0¦�@J ������ `>���B�� , L�h5�� �1�(��, `>���B��
, "�^� ��1�� �5 W F5 '� GH1�� � Qu2��H�� 8?�� 8* ��2��
�>?>��Y Q�RSB* , Q�&2�@ 87 :CD�� EF ¹�)Y aB�� a*��DZ� `>���B�� i� ������� O�L�B �(1Y�* �>?��Y
"�^� `>��B��2W EF 0�U�Y ��& G�H1�� �5 '�h �|F2v]�B.�� ±�YH1�� 8* ���? ��>A�� «'J uF � Q�K�L���2 �
J ��� \��* \��L2� ���?�w �9hJ Q�*���* b7 z�;H�� ���(B �>N6��� �*�DZ� 8* ��Z� n+�B�� k�� , \�A?72
"�^�2 ����� `>��B�� 8* 0h, nNx�w 8* �* 0h `��AY2 6� k�AYLu� W
TU�� C��%�_:
�* k�� , v]��BN 8�* GH1�� n.7 Q�eKJ , n�N¢@s� 6 Ê��:
� d���c� M���? �6B u� Ë& 8* �>?���� �@�A9� 01 `>��B��2 �>�� dL�c2� ���x��e�Br�� , ��U�V2 ���·
R��DeB�� ���A��(h `������±���|2 v ���.�� zj��V 8��*
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 87 –
�>��K�L���, , k����K i��?��?�� �>e;���� Q���KL6��2 �>*�DZ� %L����J2 �U�^� %L����W
� b7 i?���� }�L�Y� RDeB�� �>?.Y Q�>��K8* �1�(�� =���e�B» 0?7 ÌL22 0¡�C* zjV W
� k�;ABKu� M���? �6B u�, 8* n z�ABNu�2 =�B)��b�7y� =�B)�� EF �>)1�� , n�>@ '��D� p5���
���Ky� ©�( ��A� 8* � }��(��, Ã�C�.�� �>(rB��2 �5>e.Y2 a]�;ABKu�W
� b7 }�a���22 v �.�� ±�5h , i�?���� `~)�L�YF� i �&j��� c��l?B ��2 �N�AB��2 `���W � }�%L���� b72 �>*�DZ� �U�^� ��T b7
��>A�� k��K i ������ ���* , �1�(�� n*�AY �* ��+��?=�VJ2 d@ ��>?B�� 8�* b�7J =�B)�* EF n� k�AYLj�
d��P�2W C�A}��TU�� :
s� �* ��Z� GH1�� ©A� 6h: � ������ }�BD� ��>�>�² �K�L� ��>A�� ������ �
�K�L��� �5 �~B�2�.Y aB�� ��Ly� , L2�� ±��| ��L2���y� �5� �1�(�� m��>BK� , `����W
� ��>?���� �@�A9�� z�� , =�VJ Q�K�L� ��>A�, ��hJ �.>7 b7, ��>*�DT %L���* 8�*2 2 8�* ��U�V
�A)* �g@�� �2�T ®L�V =�VJ �>?>��Y Q�g@��W � , =���VJ ����H2 Q���K�L� ����>A�� z����
�hJ �.>72 �>�7 4�eU2 Q���B)* b7 �>?���� �@�A9��W � ��1�< ��NL�A* °AB)Y =�VJ Q�K�L� ��>A��
Q�R�SB* , �.(�)��� "��^� `>���B��2 ����� `>��B�� Q��>�?7 0�9* ������� ��(1Y�* =��VJ �>?��Y �>?>��Y
������ �HN ���u�2 ,`����,RDeB�� 8* �e�B» M��NJ2 W * * *
�=)�QR
oe*1 : �!=�� QR�=)�:
�� �17 n< n�� ,�r� W2004� W� =��� a?���� L�.B�� =�B)* ��>���� ��D�?�� a�*��P� 0�1& `>���B�� mj< 8* �.>7
�����)�� W�>)�e.��2 ������ ������ ��� ,��>�� ��>�h , ,8��H1�� ��*�+5 �1� ,83−117W
-���2 ;8�?�J ,Q6>��72 ;�� 3�17 ,�1��(V ,d�&��.72 ;����F ,ie�}���¡ ,¹)�>7 a�.2 ;�c��T� W2012� W� }��Bh 0�>�²
, '�Ly� , i>�K�Ky� O*�^�2 l���� ie;�� ��������>?���� ��@�A9�� Q�N�D* k�� W����� v>��^� ����KL ,
123 ,191−222W ����17 ,p�>��K�1*J2 ;����17 ,�1��(^�� W2002� W� =�B)�*
�� 6h �>?���� �@�A9�� �>�� �>�h �1�< � �� ������ °;§Q�>������2 � %��& '�(�)�� ��*� –'6�7 �.(��K W
Q��K�L���2 ��H1�� �Y�*� �>N�)�N�� ������� ��)��K,�>76B+u�2 17�4� ,243−273W
0>�V ,¹e(;*� W1990� W� ��1�< ��.7 ��>?���� ��@�A9�� =�B)*�B&j72 ����N�9�� ���T��� ���� , a?���� M�e�� ³�1� n
Q�RSB�� W ,��>�� ��>�h ,dL�C�.* R�¡ RB)�+�* ���KL��*R�� ��*�+W
O>� �� �17�>]�.�� �?� d2�*2 ,p�>�K�1*J:8*�9�� :;�� �1�< =�� �>?���� �@�A9�� =�B)* WWW
– 88 –
��Í ,a����� W2004� W� 8�* ��>N�9�� ��A�Z� ������ }Bh 0>�² `����� ¹�H.* k��� , '6�7 �.(�)� [��Ky� `>��B��
��>1��2 l?B ��2 �N�AB��2�STSE�. R�¡ RB)�+�* ���KL ,dL�C.*�>�� �>�h�*�+ ,%��& '�(�)�� �W
�?� ,a.�L�1U� W2011� W� ��1�< ��.7 ��>?���� ��@�A9�� =�B)*'�Ly�� p�N�9�� z2y� :;�� , =�B)��� ±��| ��&j72
l��K�B�� ie;���� k�����>e�� d����* , `~�>;��² 8��* 0��D ���¶y� ��>?���� �@�A9�� Q�µ�*2 ,i>K�Ky� µ����2
�KL�?�� �>?���� �>@�A9�� Q�µ���2 D��� 0>�^� ��*�+ ,��H1�� 6�1� ,173−194W �L��1* ,p�*�¦���� W2005� � ���1�< =��� ��>?���� ���@�A9�� =�B)�*
'6�7 �.(�)� ������ `>���B�� 8* -7 ��9�� :;�� W ����KL%��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ ,�>�� �>�h ,dL�C.* R¡ RB)+�*W
�?� ,s7� W2003� W������� O�L�Y2 �>?���� �>�� W ,'67 L���7�1(��2 l�c�B��2 -.�� dR)��W
��*J ,a+���� W2002� W� `>���B�� %L��? ������ v �.* �>���@mj�(�� =��� a?���� L�.B�� �>?.Y , a7�.;�� p�N�9��W
�>�h ,�>?���� �>�� ��´�� �>�?P� ,�>?���� �>�� ��� ,O?w i7 ��*�+ ,�>��5�2� ,125−157W
0>1N ,0¦@W� 1998� W� |��§�2 ��>?���� ��@�A9�� ��>?.Y Q��*�A* ������ `>��Y , L��A�������AN �K�L��W ,������ ��� ��
,X��D�� ��*�+13�49� ,233−299W `>��B��2 �>�� dL�c2� W2001� W� `>��B�� ���(B� a.<��� ���AB��'6�7 �.(�)W ��>�� ��>N6��� ��>.<��� ��. ��� ,�A)�*
2 �@�A9��2������W `>��B��2 �>�� dL�c2� W2006� W� %L���?�� ��>?>g.B�� �H]j��
�� 0?��� 0>��2 �U�^� W�A)* :`>��B��2 �>�� dL�c2W
o��.�$ :QR�=)� ���R�� : Al-Mogee, A. (2002). The effectiveness of science
curriculum in industrial secondary school in
developing students'' scientific literacy (in Arabic).
Science Education Journal, Egyptian Society for
Science Education, 5(2), 125-157.
Ambusaid, A. & Al-Zain, M. (2008). The Science
Curriculum in Omani Schools: Past, Present and
Future in R. Coll and N., Taylor (Eds.). Science
Education in Context: International Examination of
the Influence of context on Science Curricula
Development and Implementation. Rotterdam,
Sense Publishers: 85-97.
Bakhsh, H. (2004). Scientific literacy level among sample
of pre-university students at Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia (in Arabic). Journal of Educational and
Psychological Studies, Kingdom of Bahrain, 5(1),
83-117.
Baldi, S.; Jin, Y.; Green, P. & Herget, D. (2007). Highlights
from PISA 2006: Performance of U.S. 15-Year-Old
Students in Science and Mathematics Literacy in an
International Context. NCES 2008-016. ERIC
Education Reproductive Information System,
ED499184.
Bybee, R. (2008). Scientific Literacy, Environmental
Issues, and PISA 2006: The 2008 Paul F-
Brandwein Lecture. Journal of Science Education
and Technology, 17, 566–585.
Chiappetta, E.L. & Fillman, D.A. (2009). Analysis of five high
school biology textbooks used in the United States for
inclusion of the nature of science. International
Journal of Science Education, 29(15), 1847-1868.
Chiappetta, E.L.; Fillman, D.A. & Sethna, G. H. (1991a). A
method to quantity major themes of scientific
literacy textbook. Journal of Research in Science
Teaching, 28(8), 725.
Chiappetta, E.L.; Fillman, D.A. & Sethna, G. H. (1991b). A
quantitative analysis of high school chemistry
textbook for scientific literacy themes and
expository learning aids. Journal of Research in
Science Teaching, 28(10), 939-951.
Dani, D. (2009).Scientific literacy and purposes for
teaching science: A case study of Lebanese Private
School teachers. International Journal of
Environmental & Science Education, 4(3), 289-299.
Ebenezer, J & Haggert, S (1996). Becoming a Secondary
School Science. New Jersey, Merrill.
Fathel, N. (1998). The pillars of developing scientific
literacy and decision making in science teaching
(Critical Study) (in Arabic). The Educational
�� �������� ���� �� , ��26 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2014��1435� �
– 89 –
Journal, Kuwait University, 13(49), 233-299.
Khatayba A. & Ambusaidi, A. (2002).The level of scientific
literacy as seen by Sultan Qaboos University (science
education major) (in Arabic). Mu'tah Lil-Buhuth wad
Dirasat: Humanities and Social Sciences Series
(University of Mu'tah), 17(4), 243-273.
Khatayba A., Olymat, A., Sherfeen, E., Anaqra, H., and
Beni Issa, G. (2012). Content analysis of Jordanian
fourth and fifth grade science textbooks in light of
scientific literacy (in Arabic). Risalet Al-Khaleej Al-
Arabi, 133, 191-222.
Kim, M. (2006). The Questions of Scientific Literacy and
then Challenges for Contemporary Science
Teaching: An Ecological Perspective. Unpublished
Doctorate Thesis, University of Alberta.
Mbajiorgu, N. (2003). Relationship between STS approach,
scientific literacy, and achievement in biology.
Science Education, 87, 31-37.
Meichtry, Y. (1992). Using laboratory experiences to
develop the scientific literacy of middle school
students. School Science and Mathematics, 92(8),
437-440.
Millar, R (2005). Scientific literacy: can the school science
curriculum deliver. In M. Claessens (Ed.),
Communicating European Research, 143–148.
Ministry of Education (2001). Basic Education in the
Sultanate of Oman: The Theoretical Framework.
Muscat, Ministry of Education.
Mumba, F.; Chabalengula, V. & Hunter, W. (2006).
Quantitative analysis of Zambian High school
physics textbooks, syllabus and examination for
scientific literacy themes. Journal of Baltic Science
Education, 2(10), 70-76.
National Research Council (1996). National Science
Education Standards. Washington DC. National
academy Press.
OECD. (2007). PISA 2006, Science Competencies for
Tomorrow’s World. Volume I: Analysis. Paris: OECD.
Roberts, D. A. (2007). Scientific literacy/science literacy.
In S. K. Abell & N. G. Lederman (Eds.), Handbook
of Research on Science Education (pp. 729–780).
Mahwah, NJ, Lawrence Erlbau.
Sadler, T. D. (2009). Socioscientific issues in science
education: labels, reasoning, and transfer. Cultural
Studies of Science Education, 4(3), 697-703.
Sbarini, M. (2001). The level of scientific literacy among
first secondary school in Jordan and its relationship
to their achievement level in physics for grades nine
and ten, the family scientific indicators and school
scientific indicators (in Arabic). Al-Khalil
University Journal for Research, 6(1), 173-194.
Soobard, R. & Rannikmäe, M. (2011). Assessing student’s
level of scientific literacy using interdisciplinary
scenarios. Science Educational International, 22(2),
133-144.
Trowbridge, L., Bybee, R & Powell, J (2000). Teaching
Secondary School Science: Strategies for
Developing Scientific Literacy. New Jersey, Merrill.
UNESCO (1994). The Project 2000 Declaration. Paris,
UNESCO.
* * *