terraqua barranca report powerpoint

64
Terraqua Barranca Progress Report August 1, 2011 Note: Since the “visuals” in Barranca have been compelling these last several weeks, this report is being done in a PowerPoint format.

Upload: paulskillicorn

Post on 02-Nov-2014

837 views

Category:

Technology


5 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Progress Report

August 1, 2011

Note: Since the “visuals” in Barranca have been compelling these last several weeks, this report is being done in a PowerPoint format.

Page 2: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater TreatmentThe system is now successfully treating an average flow of 1.0 l/s of raw wastewater coming from

Barranca and neighboring Santa Catalina. During this initial phase all system components – solids removal, influent calibration, duckweed bioreactors, sand filters, harvesters, collection tanks, crop removal, transport and post-harvest processing and storage; sand filters, ozone disinfection, post-ozone water storage, treated water distribution, crop spray maintenance and pest management – are being evaluated for performance, calibrated and integrated into “the system.” Protocols are being developed to allow efficient and safe operation of the integrated system under all conditions that do . . .and can . . . present. Testing of raw, semi-treated and treated effluent is being conducted by the best water quality laboratory in Lima. These data will continue to “inform” development and finalization of appropriate protocols.

The system, as it now presents, is visually attractive, compelling to watch “in process,” completely odor-free and completely mosquito-free. We would venture to say that it is already producing the highest quality of treated wastewater effluent in Peru.

In the slides which follow we visually present all relevant elements of the system – with brief annotations appended below and/or beside the pictures. Videos of most elements “in operation” will also be distributed forthwith.

Page 3: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Influent Raw Wastewater – Source & Volume

Raw wastewater coming to the site is diverted from a main now delivering a mixed, Santa Catalina / Barranca effluent to two “exhausted” parallel-flow facultative lagoons located on the lower strip (below the cliff) – an area which will eventually accommodate the “treatment phase” of the new Terraqua Barranca wastewater treatment plant.

Page 4: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Influent Raw Wastewater – Solids Separation

The “diversion manhole” is being altered a minimal cost to enhance passage of floating solids down to the facultative lagoons. A future capacity upgrade of the Terraqua Eco Parque project will subsequently capture 100% of this flow and deal with influent solids.

The adjacent Terraqua Eco Parque manhole now serves to capture most inorganic solids. A future capacity upgrade of the Terraqua Eco Parque project will subsequently capture 100% of this flow and deal with influent solids. Design work for this subsequent phase is being done by new team member Sara Norris, who has come to us from an engineering position with a futuristic algae-based NASA wastewater treatment project now being conducted in the San Francisco Bay area.

Page 5: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Bringing in the Raw Sewage

Page 6: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Excavating the Original Site

Page 7: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Influent Raw Wastewater – Flow Measurement, Calibration and Adjustment

System flows are now measured using a simple “V notch.” The depicted flow is approximately 1 liter per second.

Flow is now calibrated from a valved “hook” discharge nozzle built into the Parshall flume influent line.

These temporary yet effective systems will be replaced with robust electronic flow monitoring in a subsequent system upgrade.

Page 8: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Temporary SludgeDrying Bed

Page 9: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Temporary SludgeDrying Bed

Page 10: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Vermiculture Demonstration Unit

Page 11: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Aquatic Vermiculture Demonstration

Page 12: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Constructing1st BioreactorArray

Page 13: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Hydraulics

The subterranean structure of the site comprises tightly packed “round” rocks and stones – a structure which obviates use of simple earthen containment. LDPE liners have been successfully deployed. This picture shows the pond harvester assembly as well as pond influent and effluent lines – “T”eed, in the case of the influent line, to prevent short circuiting.

All ponds communicate below the surface to ensure a common “pond group” water depth. Removal of the harvester assembly provides a method by which to drain ponds through the harvester drain pipe. All ponds have been rigorously tested for leaks before final filling.

Page 14: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Hydraulics

A closer view of a harvester assembly shows how all systems were carefully “booted” to prevent leaks. The 12” “flare” at the top of the harvester assembly increases the rate at which the harvester can collect the floating duckweed mat. Since the harvester does not become inundated, a 6” pipe provides more than adequate drainage. Harvested material all flows to a common collection tank, from which water is again pumped back to the head of the plant. This photograph depicts a “complete fill” leakage testing sequence.

This photograph depicts a “complete fill” leakage testing sequence. Because the next pond in line is not yet ready for testing, influent water is being siphoned out through the harvester assembly.

Page 15: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Hydraulics

An adjustable weir attached to the outlet pipe of the final pond “sets” the pond level for each “group” of duckweed ponds. The exact depth of the ponds (relative to the height of the harvester mouth) is set in such a manner as to optimize harvesting. In what will ultimately be a carefully supervised and monitored public park, the innovative bamboo covering delivers both beauty and safety.

Once all ponds “passed” the rigorous leakage testing sequence, the ponds were filled with irrigation water and then charged with duckweed brought in from “wild growth” found to occur in the Callao region of Lima. Despite Lima being located in a desert, the wild growth occurs in wetlands that are supported by “irrigation theft” of raw Lima wastewater intended to be discharged directly into the nearby ocean. Eating raw strawberries in Lima is not recommended.

Page 16: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

1st BioreactorArray “Loaded”

Page 17: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Crop Management

This “discretely framed” tongue-in-cheek photograph shows an amused Kyle Lisabeth hosing down a disrobed Paul Skillicorn with disinfected wastewater that has been treated at the site. Paul had just been “doing the responsible thing” by entering the water to connect the harvester-ball cords. The photograph shows the abundant availability of treated water, the pressures attained by the “pressure tank system,” and the ability to generate a “large droplet heavy spray.” As one can infer from Paul’s benign response, the water has neither color nor odor. Netafim will be pleased.

Here, Kyle Lisabeth shows how the existing hand spray system can be used effectively to gently redistribute attendant duckweed over the entire pond surface following harvesting. Plans call for the existing hand spray system to be replaced with a fully programmable spray system featuring several fixed spray heads per pond. This spray, the most important “management/maintenance” tool in the plant managers arsenal, can also be used to mitigate high temperature stress and minimize the prevalence of pests such as aphids and harmful agents such algae and fungi.

Page 18: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Crop Management

This picture depicts a pond surface on which the attendant duckweed is perfectly deployed. Coverage is 100% -- serving as an effective barrier to mosquitoes and algae. Density from a growth point of view is also ideal – tightly packed, but not layered. This ensures that every frond has good access to both light and nutrients. Once harvesting takes place – as much as 20% of the crop – there will still be enough plants remaining to ensure the essential 100% cover required to maintain a healthy system.

In this picture, Alicia Torres, is untying the harvester chord preparatory to conducting a harvest of the attendant pond. She has already tested the pond density and determined how much duckweed needs to be harvested. In this instance, approximately 10 minutes of unassisted harvesting (no spray) proved to be sufficient. Once the harvest is completed, the “Terraqua ball valve” is simply pulled back over the flared harvester “mouth.”

Page 19: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Harvesters

The innovative Terraqua “ball-valve” harvesters are made from a child’s tethered rubber ball filled with about 1 liter of water (and, of course, air). They are fitted with a simple polyester cord that is tied off on opposing banks. One person can manage a harvest providing the opposing cord is pulled tight.

The top of the harvester is threaded to allow “fine tuning” the installed harvester height. Typically, the top of the harvester will be about 1 cm below the pond surface. The resulting flow, once the ball-valve is “opened,” provides efficient harvesting of the attendant duckweed mat.

Page 20: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Planning Harvests

Here, Alicia Torres Geary, measures the density of the duckweed mat preparatory to harvesting. The duckweed picked up on the 1/16th of a square meter “measuring tool” is drained and then weighed (below) to determine standing density. With Lemna Gibba, which has a pea-like shape, ideal standing densities are somewhat higher than with other species. As one moves down the nutrient chain, and away from the raw influent wastewater, ideal standing densities will gradually creep up to over 2 kg/s per square meter.

Page 21: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

HarvestingLemna Gibba

Page 22: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Harvesting

Six minutes after the ball-valve has been removed, the standing mat in the vicinity of the flared harvester mouth has thinned noticeably. This is a good visual cue for the ball-valve again to be replaced and the pond surface to be sprayed.

Harvested duckweed and attendant water from each harvester flow to a common collection tank. This picture shows the relatively heavy concentrations of duckweed delivered by the harvester.

Page 23: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Bioreactors – Harvest Containment & Movement

The buoyant duckweed floats to the top during a harvest, allowing the carriage water to flow out the bottom and up into the adjacent tank, from where it is continuously pumped back to the head of the plant. While we now use simple hand tools to remove harvested duckweed from the collection tank, and a wheel barrow to deliver it to a nearby compost pile, we are planning on automating the entire process using belts and screw pumps. Plans call for harvested duckweed to be disinfected with a combination of ozone and ultraviolet light before it is conveyed elsewhere for further processing into feed and feedstuff.

Page 24: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Bioreactor Lemna Gibba Crop

Page 25: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

A Community Event at The Parque Ecologico

Page 26: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

A Community Event at The Parque Ecologico

Page 27: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint
Page 28: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Duckweed Processing and Reuse

Absent a “phase-II” aquaculture complex, we intend using the harvested duckweed to feed a flock of Terraqua Free Range Chickens. These will be grazed in a series of simple “drag-cages” which will be placed on the grassy portions of both sides of the Eco-Parque – shown here surrounding the dome (in the aquaculture plot) that will be used to house the chickens. Duckweed will be “strewn” on the grass, while corn and water will be made available ad libitum from conventional feeders attached to both ends of the drag cages. We are now constructing a simple convection solar dryer that will be used to dry the duckweed preparatory to mixing it with some corn and a “vitamin mix” pending pelleting (floating pellet) for use in aquaculture.

Page 29: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

The TerraquaSolar DryerCutaway Demo

Page 30: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Sand Filters

In a Terraqua duckweed-based wastewater treatment system, the effluent may contain a significant amount of the normal “fauna” which inhabit the underside and the top of the mat. This can include everything from aphids to snails. There is relatively little of the “fines” (mostly bacteria) that typically escape an activated sludge system clarifier. As such, the performance requirements of a final “sand filter” differ greatly from systems used with activated sludge treatment. We have, accordingly, chosen to use a “local” twin chamber design incorporating fairly coarse sand. This “simple” system

does not have a backwash capability, and we believe it will require only occasional cleaning and maintenance. Early results have been promising.

The sand filters also provide additional treated water buffer capacity – a welcome circumstance while we remain without the larger treated water tank – construction of which is planned for a subsequent expansion phase.

Page 31: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Treated Flow Disinfection

Here, Kyle Lisabeth operates the small US-made ozone unit now used to disinfect treated effluent. Treated, filtered water is passed from the sand filters to the “ozone tank” where it is treated on a 2-pass basis – bubbling up the down-flow tank influent line, and subsequently by a diffuser placed in the center of the ozone tank (see below). A series of exhaustive tests planned for the coming weeks will conclusively determine both the safety and efficacy of this system. Despite concerns related to local humidity, early indications suggest performance will be excellent.

Page 32: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Treated Water Storage

Treated, ozonated water storage is currently limited to a single, 2000 liter buried plastic tank located immediately adjacent to the identically sized ozone tank. Future, phase-II plans call for construction of a large, bamboo dome-covered 400 cubic meter tank in the existing gully immediately below “Kyle’s Chapel” (see to the left). Water from this tank will then be used to supply the full range of on-site water applications: duckweed maintenance, aquaculture (processing and make-up water only) drip irrigation, spray irrigation and reverse osmosis.

Page 33: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Treated Water Distribution

A conventional pressure tank system draws treated water from the storage tank (see previous slide) and supplies it throughout the complex through a 2” lateral traversing the full site from north to south. Two inch feed lines also lead into the duckweed bioreactor complex, where they supply crop maintenance spray systems (now manual). An additional line passes to the adjacent main building, where it will supply the reverse osmosis apparatus. A further tap to the north of the property will supply the Netafim drip irrigation complex, and a final tap will supply the treated water requirements of both the vermiculture complex and the anaerobic digesters. Below, Stan Harmon, Kyle Lisabeth and Alicia Torres Geary marvel at the “geyser-like” power of the system.

Page 34: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Productive Use, Discharge, Overflow and Recycling

Absent back-up power systems, a critical operating rule mandates fail-safe power-off operating modes. Overflow from the sand filter, the duckweed harvester and the treated water storage tank are passed to a whimsical, rock-lined discharge channel that carries such water down below the cliff and out to sea. Extensive power-off testing has shown this system to perform perfectly under a wide range of “failure” conditions.

Page 35: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Wastewater Treatment Reverse Osmosis Treatment

Having now ensured that the basic sand-filtered, ozone-disinfected duckweed-treated wastewater meets our specifications as to quality, we are commencing installation of the small reverse osmosis system now being held in storage. This will then lead to the critical “glass of water” – the drinking of which will formally initiate anyone given the opportunity, into the Terraqua Club. While we intend extensively testing the safety of this “glass of water” in advance, the local mayor has asked that he be allowed to drink that critical first (public) glass. We intend obliging him on October 5 – the true inauguration day for the Terraqua Barranca Eco Parque. Anyone reading this note can also consider himself/herself to have been invited.

Page 36: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Barranca Mayor &Paul toast with a “Glass of Water”

Page 37: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Subsequently, everyone toastswith that Magical “Glass of Water”

Page 38: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Site Landscaping

It is our intention – and a realistic intention – that the Terraqua Barranca Eco Parque come to be regarded as the most beautiful and most interesting park (open to the paying public) in Peru. We have taken pains to employ a unique “stone architecture” system that echoes both Caral and the later Incas. We intend framing this architecture in filigree-like bamboo domes to give some effortless height and then clothing it in local perennials that provide sustained flowering brilliance. Bougainvillea’s will predominate, because they at once serve three purposes – growing quickly, blocking the wind (amazingly dense) and delighting the optic nerve. A number of other flowering trees and vines will also be deployed – as will select giant grasses, palms and cacti. We intend keeping grass to a minimum, and where it is used (on both sides of the main building), making it both brilliant and “special.” We intend using both textured and colored gravel and pebbles to give accent to other open surface areas (see above). This will be the most beautiful and interesting “parque” in all of Peru. We fully expect that every graduating high school student in Lima, 5 years hence, will have visited the park with his class.

Page 39: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque EcologicoLooking South over Koi Pond at Administration Complex

Page 40: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque EcologicoLooking South across Main Bioreactor Array

Page 41: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque EcologicoLooking Southeast across Main Bioreactor Array

Page 42: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque EcologicoLooking Southwest across Main Bioreactor Array

Page 43: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque EcologicoLooking East over Bioreactors 1 & 2

Page 44: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque Ecologico

Looking South over Bioreactor Array with Patterned Gravel

Page 45: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque Ecologico

Looking West over 2nd Bioreactor Array, Dome and Solar Dryer

Page 46: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque Ecologico

Looking Northwest over Fertigation-Irrigated Extractive Crop Array

Page 47: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua Barranca Parque Ecologico

Looking Northwest over 2nd Bioreactor Array

Page 48: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Treated Water ReuseDrip Irrigation – NETAFIM Partnership

We have our fingers crossed on this one. Netafim is unchallenged as the world’s #1 drip irrigation company. We believe, nevertheless, that we have much to offer them. We know, without doubt, that they have much to offer us. We intend that they “do” the extractive plant irrigation demonstration at the Terraqua Barranca Eco Parque.

Page 49: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Water Reuse Domed Aquaculture

Fish production is the financial “engine” of the Terraqua system – which we believe will quickly come to be know as the most efficient aquaculture system in the world: free water and free nutrients combined with a “better and more efficient” system. Each 0.5 mgd “modular” wastewater treatment system will have 3 “36’ aquaculture domes” housing a unique “concentric lane” recirculating water system which, unlike other such systems, will deliver a “zero nitrate” LST (low surface tension) treated water back to the fish. Also, unlike any other system, literally everything will be “captured” in that recycle – fecal matter and uneaten feed, along with the “waste” portion of the filleted fish (heads, guts, skin and bones – everything). The small, integrated-team personnel structure, rising slope reinforcement and strong internal competition across the system will drive efficiencies.

Tilapia

Barramundi

Arapaima /Paiche

IQF Fillets

Fresh Fillets

Page 50: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Intensive Tilapia Aquaculture: The “Chicken” of Fish

Page 51: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Aquaculture-grown Tilapia

Page 52: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

The earthquake-safe and massively efficient Terraqua Dodecahedron Dome

Page 53: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Water Reuse Tissue Cultured Arundo Donax

Fertigation buried-drip (Netafim innovation) irrigated Arundo Donax will produce more lignocellulosic biomass than any other plant on earth. We intend, with Netafim’s help, grabbing the top rung of this ladder and working diligently to stay there. In order to do so, we will also need, gradually, to develop increasingly efficient tissue culture approaches to producing Arundo Donax propagules. While the eventual “home run” to be hit is biofuels, we will, ourselves, concentrate on using AD to produce engineered lumbers and boards (followed by pulp and paper). As the most efficient biomass producer in the world, we can expect the “energy” technology eventually to come to us.

Page 54: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Water Reuse Harvested Arundo Donax Pressed Board & Engineered Lumber

Drying AD Stalks

Refurbished Single Opening Press

AD Engineered Lumber

Long-stalk veneer AD Engineered Board

Forage-harvested ADEngineered Board

Initially we will “self-consume” in Terraqua dome production all the AD engineered lumber we produce on our “refurbished” single-opening press. We will then begin selling “packaged home domes” as the market develops. Finally, we will sell the lumber directly. Lumber on the Peruvian Pacific coast costs twice what it does in the US.

Page 55: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Water Reuse Tissue Cultured Extractives

There are, today, well over a hundred plants, extracts of which command very high prices in the global market place. By combining the very highest fertigation drip technology and localized modular processing with a broad-based, but nimble and flexible approach to selecting among these plants, we should be able to surf this wave indefinitely.

We intend selecting a small number of “base” - easy to grow and easy to process “high demand” - extracts such as stevia to serve as the backbone of the business. We will rely on Ven Subbiah, our resident extractives expert to guide us on the others.

Developing a highly flexible tissue culture capability will be critical.

Our solar drying technology will also serve us well in this business.

Drying and extracting fruit as well as duckweed and, yes, even worms (for protein powder) will be an adjunct to this business.

Page 56: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Lavender: A high return Extractive Crop

Page 57: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Water Reuse Kenaf Seeds, Oil and (future) Fiber

We remain convinced that kenaf will find its place as an important global crop. Producing kenaf seeds will become the most remunerative niche in that business. At this time there are no reliable seed producers in the Southern Hemisphere (off season, therefore higher priced supply). Kenaf oil, with extremely high Omega 3s, holds some promise as a boutique oil and can become an adjunct to the mainline seed business. Producing kenaf fiber products can follow if South American demand warrants.

Page 58: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

A maturing crop of Kenaf: Construction Fiber, Oil Adsorbent and Filter Medium

Page 59: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Emerging Terraqua IndustryDomes

Terraqua Barranca now has three domes “under construction” at the Eco Parque site – two 24’ domes and one 36’ dome – the one depicted above. The purpose of the domes is to provide highly affordable working space in a configuration that is both effective and attractive – conceptually and visually. Domes will feature heavily in the aquaculture component of the subsequent Terraqua Barranca wastewater treatment plants, but they will also be used throughout the system for workspace, to house equipment and to provide storage. Interest in the domes from the local Peruvian public has been massive. In a region that features some of the most unattractive housing structures on earth, a plan is now emerging that will capture this interest in a spinoff commercial endeavor that will produce “dome kits” (structure, exterior and interiors) from arundo donax engineered lumbers and boards. Indeed, the local woodworking industry sent a delegation to Terraqua administrators “demanding” that we “include” such an industry in our business plan. This would initially happen as a simple adjunct to our internal consumption of domes. Requiring very little investment, it would grow as market demand manifests. The singular Lassiter Dodecahedron Geodesic Dome has truly arrived in South America.

Page 60: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua BusinessMunicipal Partnerships

Support for Terraqua within the province of Barranca has been unwavering. Providing we can swing the financing, all the wastewater produced within the province is ours for the taking. Barranca is offering additional value in its new urban expansion zone (10 hectares and possibly some co-financing). Supe is suggesting that a portion of its existing $15 million “water and sanitation” budget can move in our direction providing we “take on the job.” The town is now also providing us with 24/7 security support (see above) and building new roads to the site.

Page 61: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua BusinessInstitutional / Bureaucratic Partnerships

It’s wonderful, in a developing country such as Peru to feel confident that, when you see a police car drive up (above), that the officer is just “checking in to make sure everything’s OK.” This response is now universal in Barranca. In the top left picture we’re meeting with the top management of Semapa, the water/wastewater parastatal, to discuss the project. Below that, Pedro, the top official in Santa Catalina poses for a treasured picture – treasured by both of us, I might add.

Page 62: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua BusinessCampesino Partnerships

“Los Japoneses,” father and son, are “possessionarios” of the last plot along the 50 hectares of bottom land . . . up against the river. Ironically, they are already producing tilapia in ponds supplied with “agua filtrada” that comes down to them through the cliff. They will number among our fist group of village partners.

Page 63: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua BusinessLandowner Partnerships

This man (name escapes me) sought us out while visiting our Eco Parque site on Fiestas Patrias – Peruvian independence day – and invited us to visit his “chacra.” After spending an hour with him – sampling his pisco and two wines – it became clear to me that he would be amenable to “throwing in with us” if the circumstance presents. We’ll keep this connection alive. There are many other such “gentleman-farmers” in the region.

Page 64: Terraqua barranca report powerpoint

Terraqua BusinessInvestor Partnerships

These are just a few of the “interested” Peruvians having the private wherewithal to make direct investments into Terraqua Barranca and subsequent Terraqua endeavors. We continue to engage all four, and are expanding the conversation to include many others.