trends from the trenches - re-branding your "new" healthcare system for changing times
DESCRIPTION
Healthcare Innovation: Trends From The Trenches Re-Branding Your "New" Healthcare System for Changing Times Featured Speakers: Andrea (Andi) Simon, PhD and President of Simon Associates Management Consultants Dianne Auger, SVP, Marketing, St. Vincent’s Health Services The second webinar is a highly informative discussion about branding and re-branding from the perspectives of those going through the challenges of: - Re-branding their organization - Internally branding to incorporate new ways of "living the brand" - Transforming Physician Practices to Corporate Brands - Protecting the equity of long-established brandsTRANSCRIPT
BRANDING AND RE-BRANDING YOUR “NEW” HEALTHCARE SYSTEM FOR CHANGING TIMES
Healthcare Innovation: Trends from the TrenchesWebinar #2
Our Presenters
Andrea J. Simon PhDCorporate Anthropologist
PresidentSimon Associates Management Consultants
Dianne AugerSenior Vice President, Marketing
St. Vincent’s Medical CenterPresident of the St. Vincent’s
Foundation
Agenda For Today
Share early insights of research we are conducting on the abundance of name changes and re-brandings.
Diane is going to share the power of a hospital “brand” and how to protect and re-invigorate it during dramatically changing times.
Return to the question about why brands matter.
Why This Matters in Changing Times Can you create and communicate a brand that still, or
finally, makes you “the place to work” and “the place to go” for healthcare?
Can you inspire your associates and physicians to “Live the Brand” and become your brand ambassadors?
Is there a higher purpose? Can you do it in “innovative ways” that add “real
value”—not just change your logo or your color palette?
Trends from the Trenches
The Future Is Very Fuzzy
A lot of discussion around the Value of Brands in the Future for Healthcare?
Will they matter?
Or, Will Consumers Just Decide On…
Price? Convenience? Commoditized Services?
Maybe they will struggle with the “Paradox of Choice”?
Trends from the Trenches
Widespread Name Changes. Without A Focus on The Brand. Name Re-invigoration: Those Staying True to Their
Names and Building Their Brands, Internally and Externally.
What does the new name really mean?
So Many Are Changing Names!
Recent Research We Conducted
Found 100+ Hospitals or Healthcare Systems that have changed their names in the past year…and we are still digging.
Here Is A SampleOld Name New Name
Genesis Medical Center Genesis Medical Center, SilvisDirne Community Health Center Legacy Health LSU Medical Center University HealthE.A. Conway Medical Center University Health ConwayJefferson Regional Medical Center Jefferson HospitalLake View Hospital St. Luke's HospitalKennewick General Hospital Trios HealthJordan Hospital Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Plymouth Via Christi Hospital on St. Francis Via Christi Hospital St. Francis St. Joseph Health System St. Joseph HealthCheboygan Memorial Hospital McLaren Northern MichiganEvergreen Healthcare EvergreenHealthSisters of Mercy Health Systems MercyWhite County Community Hospital Highlands Medical Center Research Belton Hospital Belton Regional Medical CenterPalomar Pomerado Health Palomar Health Collier Health Services Healthcare Network of Southwest Florida BryanLGH Health System Bryan Health
Lots of New Logos, Signs, Color Palettes
Rebranding With New Logo Louisville, Ky.-based Baptist Healthcare System is changing
its name to Baptist Health and rebranding all seven of its hospitals throughout the state,
• Baptist Health Corbin• Baptist Health LaGrange• Baptist Health Lexington• Baptist Health Louisville• Baptist Health Madisonville• Baptist Health Paducah• Baptist Health Richmond
Eliminate Consumer Confusion
They found in the consumer focus groups that not one consumer could delineate between the facilities that had the Hughston name in them. Had to create better clarity.
Clarity of Who We Serve
Dirne Community Health Center changed its name to Legacy Health to communicate its openness to everyone in the community, regardless of health insurance. A common public perception was the organization served only people who could not afford insurance.
Better Reflect Commitment
Kennewick is now Trios. The name will better reflect its commitment to the Tri-Cities — the Washington cities of Kennewick, Pasco and Richland — and its growing range of services.
Return To The Original Name
Via Christi Hospital is changing three of its hospitals' names back to the originals. The health system changed the names of the Wichita hospitals to match their street names in 2009, but has decided the names should revert to their original brand.
New Name, Same Mission
St. Joseph Health System to St. Joseph Health. The name change reflects its broader health care
goals. It embraces the spirit of our new networks of care, which focus not just on hospitals, but on the broader delivery of health care through our medical groups, outpatient services and other health care programs.
Strengthening The Locational Difference The Methodist Hospital is now known as Houston Methodist Hospital.
Here are the new names of the four other Texas hospitals, all of which are located in Houston, unless otherwise noted:
• Houston Methodist Sugar Land (Texas) Hospital• Houston Methodist West Hospital• Houston Methodist Willowbrook Hospital• Houston Methodist San Jacinto Hospital (Baytown)
The Methodist system, now Houston Methodist, changed its name to differentiate its hospitals from approximately 80 other Methodist hospitals across the country.
Reasons Acquired/affiliated/merged (38) Communicate broader scope of care (17) To better communicate affiliation/alignment with brand (14) Went back to original name (6) Uniform name within group (6) Clarify people it serves (6) Improve name recognition/perception/reputation (5) Save money/privatization (4) Differentiate from competition (2)
Where Is The Strategy?
Name change is often not driven by a strategic process.
Rebranding often doesn't go much further than an organizational name change or creation of a new logo.
Hospitals and Railroads
Changing Times
Rise And Fall Of An Industry Railroads had a golden age for
about 40 years until cars and airplanes took over.
Railroads didn’t redefine themselves as being in the transportation business, quickly and strongly enough.
Hospitals Are Facing Changing Times
Hospitals are no longer in just the hospital business. Welcome to the care coordination business.
Hence, A Brand New Name
One way an organization can emphasize this renewed focus is through a name change.
The more important question — what should that name mean and how to you make it come alive?
New Names Don’t Mean Anything
If the role is changing, what is the new name representing?
If you don’t tell your story, people will just make one up.
The changes are generating fundamental questions about what they really represent.
New Names Are Not New Brands
Brands answer the question: “Why You?” Brands differentiate you from the rest. Make it easier for people to anticipate the care
they will receive. Help consumers make the right choices, for them. Very human to want to “belong.”
Our Consumer Research: People Worry
If they have the same name will I get the same care? Everywhere -- like Starbucks?
What does the new name really mean? Maybe, its name doesn’t even matter any more? Everyone is changing names, so it is another fad.
They Asked Us…
Isn’t or Shouldn’t Every Hospital Be The Same?
New Options Challenge Old Brands
Except Those With Higher Purpose
Curious, I Went Exploring Name changing is clearly old, yet the robustness is a
new trend. What if you kept your name and your brand? Should you keep your old name and invest in the brand
equity? Where could we see the new healthcare ‘manifesto’
emerging in the naming – “We are going to help keep you healthy.”
Changed its nameClear StrategyNow the entire experience
One Hospital System
One System Doing It Right: BayCare
Evolving name, brand and positioning since 1996.
It’s All BayCare Now
Future Focus
Name change set platform for acquisitions and integration.
Created a division of hospitals along with BayCarePhysician Partners.
Strategically focused on population health and wellness. Online experience emphasizes how they can help you,
throughout the entire BayCare.
From Clinical Care to Patient Experience
“What I can tell you is that health care systems should borrow a page from both the retail and hospitality sectors as medicine becomes more retail (outpatient and physician office) and focused on the patient experience. Our own system evolution has changed the definition of quality from a clinical focus to a focus on delivering a better patient experience in all care settings.” Stewart Schaffer, SVP Marketing
It’s All About The Experience
Many aspects of this are hospitality such as: making sure patients are comfortable with a minimum of pain, or a quiet hospital, patient advocacy, concierge-like care coordination and discharge planning, ‘all hands’ approach when responding to nurse call buttons.
BayCare’s brand is evolving to stand for a great health care experience using retail and hospitality benchmarks.
Build the brand. Introducing Dianne Auger.
Benefits of Strengthening Your Name
St. Vincent’s Health Services Story
Let me introduce Dianne Auger here to carry on the story about how she has led the process for her brand’s resurgence, the rise in internal purpose, and the “living the brand” effort at St. Vincent’s Health Services in Bridgeport, CT.
For St. Vincent’s…
In part, it is about the “Brand New.” In part, about the “Brand Direction.” And in large part, it is about “Brand Invigoration.” Not just about a name, but what it really means.
Welcome To St. Vincent’s
When you walk through these doors, you just feel like this is where you “belong.”
St. Vincent’s Health ServicesBridgeport, Connecticut
473-bed community teaching and referral hospital Family Health Center and outreach services 76-bed inpatient psychiatric facility Health sciences college Special needs school and residential programs Foundation Member, Ascension Health, Largest Catholic healthcare system in the U.S. Founded in 1903 as Daughter of Charity Hospital to serve poor and
vulnerable
The Need To Assess Our Brand Health care is changing
CT landscape in flux and competitive
Demographics are changing
Consumer expectations - more sophisticated
Social media – who are we in this world? Perceived strength in brand – is it optimizing growth opportunities across
our entire system, now and in the future? What is our position? (informs the brand strategy)
To Build A Comprehensive Brand Strategy
Capabilities -- What do we do? Personality -- How do we deliver what we say we do? Internal Values and Culture -- What do we care about most? How
do we treat one another? Shared Values and Community -- What do we have in common? Noble Purpose -- Why do we exist? Position -- Who are we in the market? Brand essence -- Is it unique? Is it a meaningful experience? Is it
scalable?
St. Vincent’s Master Brand
Previous Position And Brand State
System currently supports unique identities (affiliates, service lines and programs) and independent department decision-making regarding the position and marketing of those identities.
Individual goals, strategies, programs -- not yet fully integrated at this point in the life of SVHS.
Duplicative cost structure (websites, marketing efforts, collateral, advertising…)
Strategy for integration is evolving -- opportunity to evaluate and create end state vision.
St. Vincent’s Logos (sampling)
What is the positioning for the overall organization (SVHS)?
How can we leverage the power of SVHS to grow into new markets and new services?
What do our stakeholders think about us? Associates, physicians, patients, consumers, donors, volunteers
What about potential new affiliations and co-branding (MD Anderson, Quinnipiac Medical School, others).
Key Questions
Branding Journey Internal, external and competitive review Market research SVHS articulation of position – what makes it valued, different,
competitive, and relevant Determine if positioning is valued and understood by stakeholders
(internal and external) Not an exploration about logos, that was catalyst
Collective agreement about how we live the St. Vincent’s Brand
What Did The Employee And Physician Stories Tell Us About The Brand?
Caring and Sharing; Smiling, & Touch Like a “Family” Believe it is all about the patient Not just a “team,” but a “community” of
caregivers Very spiritual -- you just “feel it” and “see it” in
their faces, greetings, & the way they help you We anticipate what a patient, physician or
colleague needs It is a place where you belong.
Serious Work! At St. Vincent’s…
How Does Our Market Connect With St. Vincent’s? What Do Consumers Think?
That makes it simpler and easier Where they trust that the doctor is
worried about them Where the systems work well Where there is cleanliness and
orderliness “Where I can get the information that I
need, the way I want it, when I need it” Where someone cares about “me” And please, take out the complexity
Non-St. Vincent’s Patients They want a place …
St. Vincent’s Patients -- Similar or Different?
Much more focused on how it feels to get care
They want to feel like:
They belong, like family
That nurse’s smile and soft voice, touch is about them
Almost as if the doctor is necessary but the nurses are the critical experience
They understand what my family needs
Must be new and clean (and safe) -- all expected
Of course, has the latest technology and best doctors
And is really well organized: “ducks lined up in a row”
St. Vincent’s Patients Key Themes
Brand Personality Research
400 online and 200 telephonic surveys Probing key elements of the personalities perceived by
consumers of St. Vincent’s and the competition Designed to get at the personality drivers that answer
the question “why you?” and “why not the others?” Were we a brand that people want to “avoid vs.
approach”?
The personality characteristics of St. Vincent’s resonate with consumers.
This is a differentiator we can use to set the St. Vincent’s experience apart from the competition and it is the experience that they are looking for.
And we already behave that way -- the experiences that people want to approach (not avoid) are the ones already taking place, as evidenced by our own patient stories.
What’s The Point?
Compassionate Open to cooperation Comfortable Has a big heart Sensitive Confidently quiet Open to new ideas
Aims for achievement Seeks attention Formal Hurried Distant More clinical Lacks a calming influence
St. Vincent’s Largest Competitor
Contrasts In Personality
St. Vincent’s is: A healthcare system where there is a community of caregivers
whose compassion makes us better at what we do for our patients and their families.
We listen more carefully, we work together more effectively and efficiently, and we use the tools of modern medicine more skillfully.
We bring our hearts and our minds to work, every day. We help patients and their families feel calmer and more
confident in a stressful time in their lives.
What’s The St. Vincent’s Promise?
Cardiology Campaign
Key Question For Us
How do we fulfill the promise of "Gentler Hands and Sharper Minds" in everything we do—across the entire SVHS organization? Each other
Physicians
Our patients and their families
Our students and their teachers
Our friends and our community
Launch Mattered
Here’s How We Live The Brand Create an exceptional patient and family experience that
distinguishes our approach to healthcare across the entire organization.
Ambassadors: every associate must be an ambassador for St. Vincent’s. Keep the brand promise together Work here with pride Tell friends and families what a great place it is to work
Stories: Why This All Matters
And For The Staff
Engagement Is Key!
Living The Brand In Changing Times
Research Communicate Purpose Research (docs need this) Land on Position, Gain
Agreement Be consistent Tell your Story -- before someone
else does
Be intentional Use across the organization Communicate widely Launch with Fun Hire for “brand fit” Not a program, behaviors that
are trained, recognized and rewarded
Assess and Identify Position Live the Brand
To Thrive In Changing Times!
The Power of Brands
Times Are A’ Changing
Remember the railroads.
Branding Is As Well
The Internet is changing: How people decide. And, the power of brands in that decision making
process.
Not Same As Before
Maybe It Is More Than A Name
Healthcare systems should consider their brands as a vehicle to build relationships with consumers, again and in different ways.
Brands are a beacon to unify a system across multiple touch points and points of care.
Are you the Starbucks of Healthcare?
Paradox Of Choice Is Real
Coming from rising deductibles.
Confusion and cynicism over the changes.
Power of the habits and attachment to what they know and have always done.
In Changing Times, Healthcare Institutions...
Must simplify the decision process.
Inspire people to feel that youare the right solution for their new personal needs.
Be their compass.
Naming Decisions Should Focus On The Future
Name should set forth a map with a brand story for who you are and where you are going.
Creates the mind-map for your users.
What Stories Should Employees Tell?
What does the name mean to them? They are your “brand” ambassadors. Are your leaders, as brand builders,
driving change and inspiring employees, physicians and patients?
Word-of-Mouth Wins
You have to convince consumers to convince other consumers to believe in your brand, and talk about it as the right solution.
You should want a lot of good conversations happening.
All About The Experience
Must go beyond the expected and create experiences that separate you from the rest.
True to the brand promise. Brings the brand to life in a way that is ‘own-able.’ Are you the “best of the rest or the ‘only’?”
Remember We Are Humans
Brands Matter To Us Because…
Names Are Symbols
It is a name and a logo but much more about what each represents. We are symbolic creatures. Language and symbols matter. Intangible experiences have
meaning.
Cannot Just Change Your Name
People want to believe in your brand promise. They want to belong to your “flock.” They ask, “Can you:
Help Me Connect with Me Engage with Me”
Final Thoughts
To thrive in these changing times, remember that… Changing Names Do Not Create New Brands. And They May Dilute The Ones You Had. New names need new stories. Staff need to embrace and live the new brand. They need to tell the story with authenticity. The New Healthcare is not a place or a thing but an
experience.
What Do You Want To Be?
"They're not the best at what they do, they are the only ones who do what they do." Jerry Garcia
Your Questions
Can you suggest strategies that would help us grow our brand-share?
Do we have to have all of the named-hospitals or physician offices have similar experiences? And how do you do that?
Dianne, what are some specific things you are doing to get your employees to live the brand?
Your Questions
Is has always been especially hard for hospitals and other healthcare systems to take branding and marketing all that seriously, when their larger mission is to save lives and help cure the sick? Does marketing end up taking a backseat at hospitals more often than it should? Or is that changing now that hospitals need to become better businesses attracting new patients to survive?
Thanks To Our Sponsor: HIxD Healthcare Innovation by Design (HIxD) is a global
network of healthcare delivery and experience innovators.
HIxD is the premiere resource for healthcare innovation knowledge, networking and career development.
HIxD's 6800 members are executives, entrepreneurs, clinicians, designers, architects, engineers and IT professionals. http://www.healthcareinnovationbydesign.com
Next Webinar January 17th At Noon EST.
Webinar #3: Consumer Data, Insights and Innovation with Linda MacCracken, VP, Truven Health Analytics and Adjunct Lecturer, Harvard School of Public Health January 17, 2014 at 12:00 PM EST
For More Conversation And Information
Andrea J. Simon PhDCorporate Anthropologist
President, Simon Associates Management [email protected]
Office 914-245-1641www.simonassociates.net
@simonandi
Dianne AugerSenior Vice President
St. Vincent’s Medical CenterPresident
St. Vincent’s [email protected]
www.stvincents.org