| 2012 10 19() 10 | |

2012. 10. 192

, 10:00~10:10 , 10:10~11:30 1

11:30~13:00 2

13:00~14:00 14:00~15:30 3 ,

/ NGO 15:30~17:00 4

,

3

1 1 / 42 / 29

21 / 452 / 783 / 81

31 / 942 ,

/ 1083

/ 123

1 / 1492 / 155

2012. 10. 194

1 1

1)

/ HK

.

. (1 , ), (2 , ), (3 ), (4 ) . , 4 . 1~2 . . ( ) . , , , 3 1~2 . 1~2 3 .

1) , , 21 , 22 1 (2012), pp. 65-86 .

5

3 (Right of peoples to peace) . 3 , , , . 3 .2) .

3 . 3 . . (UNESCO) . . . . .

~ , . . .

II.

1.

, 2) Caroline Dick, The Perils of Identity: Group Rights and the Politics ofIntragroup Difference (Vancouver and Toronto: UBC Press, 2011) .

2012. 10. 196

. , . (Johan Galtung) ,3) , , , , . , , . , . , . , .4)

3 . , , , . , , , , . (human security) . (Amartya Sen)5) (Martha Nussbaum)6) (central humancapabilities) . , , , ,

3) Johan Galtung, Peace by Peaceful Means: Peace and Conflict, Development and Civilization (Thousand

Oaks: Sage Publications Ltd, 1996).

4) Johan Galtung, Human Rights in Another Key (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1994), p. 141.

5) Amartya K. Sen, Commodities and Capabilities (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985).

6) Martha C. Nussbaum, Capability As Fundamental Entitlements: Sen and Social Justice, Feminist

Economics, Vol. 9, No. 2~3 (2003), pp. 33~59.

7

, , . . . , .7)

. 1960 , 1970 , . .

2.

, 3 . ( ) ( ) 1966 . , .8) . .

1970 , . 3 (New InternationalEconomic Order: NIEO) 3

7) Patrick Hayden, Constraining War: Human Security and the Human Right to Peace, Human Rights

Review, Vol. 6, No. 1 (2004), pp. 44~45.

8) , , (: , 2005), 2~3.

2012. 10. 198

. . (Willy Brandt) ( ) 3 . .9) , .

1970 .1979 , , .10) 3 1986 (Declaration on the Right to Development) . . , , , .11) . 7 , , .

. , 2 1968 4 22 5 13 . 12) 9) , , : , (: , 1981).10) Philip Alston, Peace as a Human Right, in Richard P. Claude and Burns H. Weston, eds. Human Rights

in the World Community: Issues and Action (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1992), p. 199.

11) , (: , 2009), pp. 226~227.

9

, . . 19 , . . (Apartheid) , , , , . 1969 21 .

1976 2 27 5/ .13) , .

. .

. 1978 6 , , UNESCO . 12 15 . (Declaration on the Preparation of Societies for Life in Peace) . ,1978 .

, , , . .

1978 1981 (1981 AfricanCharter on Human and Peoples Rights) .

12) Proclamation of Teheran, Final Act of the International Conference on HumanRights.13) Further promotion and encouragement of human rights and fundamental freedoms,including the question of a long-term programme of work of the Commission. 1998/77, 2000/66, 2002/71 .

2012. 10. 1910

, ,3 . . 23 1 , . (Organization ofAfrican Unity) . . .

1984 11 12 (Declaration on the Right of Peoples to Peace) . . , . , . 92, 0, 34. . , , . .14)

, . 1, 55, 28, , . 2 , . . 1 .15)

14) Douglas Roche, The Human Right to Peace (Ottawa: Saint Paul University, 2003), p. 124.

15) Paul Gordon Lauren, The Evolution of International Human Rights (Philadelphia: University of

11

. , . . 3 . , .

.

1.

2 (UNESCO) . .

1989 (Yamoussoukro) . , , , , , , . 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) , , , . , , .16)

Pennsylvania Press, 2003), 6~7; Michael Freeman, Human Rights: Key Concepts (Malden: BlackwellPublishers Inc, 2002), pp. 32~41.

16) UN General Assembly, Culture of peace, A/RES/52/13, Fifty-second session, Distr. 15 January 1998; UN

General Assembly, Declaration and Programme of Action on a Culture of Peace, A/53/243, Fifty-third

2012. 10. 1912

1992 . , . . 1995 1996-2001 . , , , , , , . (Federico Mayor) , , (Towards a Culture ofPeace) , .17)

1) (2000) 2) 3) 10 (2001-2010) . . 1997 2000 . 1998 2001-2010 10 . 1999 9 13 . , , 9 , , 8 .

, . 1997 1 (The Human Right to Peace) , , , ,

session, Distr. 6 October 1999.

17) UN Human Rights Council, Progress Report of the Human Rights Council Advisory Committee on the

Right of Peoples to Peace, A/HRC/17/39, Seventeenth Session, Distr.: General, 28 March 2011, pp. 35~36.

13

. . . . . ,, . , . .18)

1997 6 6-8 . (human dimension) . 1) 2) 3) . 1 . , , , . . 2 , , , , , .19) 1997 11 6 . . . .

18) Federico Mayor, The Human Rights to Peace, United Nations Economic, Scientific and Cultural

Organization, January 1997.

19) Federico Mayor, Report by the Director-General on the Human Rights to Peace, 29 C/59, General

Conference, 29th Session, UNESCO, Paris, 29 October 1997.

2012. 10. 1914

. . . .20)

, .

2.

, . . , .

2002 ( 3) 132 . , . 90, 50( NATO ), 14 . 57/216 B (Alston 2006, 278).

.

- 53/243 (1999)

- 55/2 (2000)

- 60/1 (2005)

- 60/147 (2005)

20) Roche, The Human Right to Peace, p. 129.

15

- 60/163 (2006)

- 63/308 (2009)

, 2006 3 15 60/251 . 47 6 19-30 1 .21) 2002 (2002/71) . . 2008 8/9, 2009 11/4, 2010 14/3 . 8/9, 11/4 14/3 . 14/3 .

, . , , , , . , , .22)

. . 31, 14, 1 , , , , . , , , , , , , , . . .

21) Julie A. Mertus, The United Nations and Human Rights: A Guidefor a New Era (New York: Routledge, 2009), pp. 41~46.

22) UN Human Rights Council, Resolution Adopted by the Human Rights Council: Promotion of the Right

of Peoples to Peace, A/HRC/RES/14/3, 17 June 2010.

2012. 10. 1916

, . , . 1984 2010 . , . 14/3 4 6 , .23) 1997 . , .24)

. (A/HRC/14/38) , .

14/3 . (A/HRC/17/39). 25) , , ,

23) . 4. , , , . 6. , , , .24) Eileen Chamberlain Donahoe, Explanation of Vote by the United States of America: Resolution on the

Promotion of the Right of Peoples to Peace, UN Human Rights Council-14th Session. Geneva, 17 June

2010.

25) , dEscoto

17

, . .

(IGOs) . . 2008~2010 . 2010 12 10 .26) . . .

, . , . .

Brockmann, Heinz, Zulficar .26) Santiago Declaration on the Human Rights to Peace, Adopted at the International Congress on the

Human Right to Peace, 9-10 December 2010, Santiago, Spain.

2012. 10. 1918

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 , , , , 9 10 11 12

13

.

1.

., . . , . . . .

.2011 3 (A/HRC/17/39) , , (standard) .

19

1) 2) 3) .27) , , . . , , . .28)

, 1) 2) 3), .

(Karl Vasak) 3 1 , 2 , ( ) 3 . 3 , (, , , ) , , , . 3 1, 2 . , 1 . 3 1, 2

27) UN Human Rights Council, Progress Report of the Human Rights Council Advisory Committee on the

Right of Peoples to Peace, A/HRC/17/39, Seventeenth Session, Distr.: General, 28 March 2011.

28) , , .

2012. 10. 1920

3 1, 2 .29) 3 , , . , (), . .

2.

, , , .

, 3 , . 3 . (Philip Alston) . .30) (David P. Forsythe) 3 . 3 , , , .31) . ,

29) Roche, The Human Right to Peace, pp. 135~136; , , pp.201~202.

30) Philip Alston, Conjuring up New Human Rights: A Proposal for Quality Control. The American Journal

of International Law, Vol. 78, No. 3 (1984), pp. 627~621.

31) David P. Forsythe, Human Rights and Peace: International and National Dimension (Lincoln and London:

University of Nebraska Press, 1993).

21

.32) . , (Realpolitik) . 2010 14/3 .

, . . . . , . . . 1) , 2) , 3) , .33)

. , , , . , . .34) 28 , 32) Michael Ignatieff ed., AmericanExceptionalism and Human Rights (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2005).

33) Alston, Peace as a Human Right, pp. 204~206.

34) , (: , 2007), 7.

2012. 10. 1922

. , () .

. , . . , , , . (Luarca Declaration on the HumanRights to Peace, 2006.10.30) , ,, , , . 9(2008.9.8-24), 10(2009.3.2-27) (Indigenous peoples and the human rightto peace) , , , (Human rights to peace versus racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia andother forms of intolerance) 200 . .

. , . . . . . (Jack Donnelly) ,35)

35) , , : (: , 2002),

23

, . .

.

. . , . , . 1970 3 3 . . , .

. . , . , . , . , . , ,

pp. 67, 159.

2012. 10. 1924

. , .

, , , . , . .36)

. , . .

, . , , . , . , , . . 6 , .

.

36) , , pp. 81~82.

25

, . = . , 1987 . .37) , , ( ) , , ( , ) , ( ) . , . , , , , . , .

37) , : (: , 2011).

2012. 10. 1926

1. . . : , 2009. . . . : , 2005.. . : , . : , 1981.. : . : , 2010. . . : .: , 2002.. . : , 2007.Dick, Caroline. The Perils of Identity: Group Rights and the Politics of Intragroup

Difference. Vancouver and Toronto: UBC Press, 2011.

Forsythe, David P. Human Rights and Peace: International and National Dimension.

Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press, 1993.

Freeman, Michael. Human Rights: Key Concepts. Malden: Blackwell Publishers Inc,

2002.

Galtung, Johan. Human Rights in Another Key. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1994.

______________. Peace by Peaceful Means: Peace and Conflict, Development and

Civilization. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications Ltd, 1996.

Ignatieff, Michael ed. American Exceptionalism and Human Rights. Princeton: Princeton

University Press, 2005.

Lauren, Paul Gordon. The Evolution of International Human Rights. Second Edition.

Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2003.

Mertus, Julie A. The United Nations and Human Rights: A Guide for a New Era.

Second Edition. New York: Routledge, 2009.

Roche, Douglas. The Human Right to Peace. Ottawa: Saint Paul University, 2003.

Sen, Amartya K. Commodities and Capabilities. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985.

Spanish Society for the Advancement of International Human Rights Law (SSIHRL).

Luarca Declaration on the Human Right to Peace. Oviedo: Mad Ediciones, 2007.

27

2. . . . Vol. 114, 2001.. . 21. 22 1, 2012.. , . :

. 3 . , 2006 8 10.

. . . , 2006 12.. , :

. . No. 91, 2011.. . . Vol. 35, 2011.Alston, Philip. Conjuring up New Human Rights: A Proposal for Quality Control.

The American Journal of International Law. Vol. 78, No. 3, 1984.

______________. Peace as a Human Right, in Richard P. Claude and Burns H.

Weston, eds. Human Rights in the World Community: Issues and Action. Second

Edition. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1992; 2006.

Donahoe, Eileen Chamberlain. Explanation of Vote by the United States of America:

Resolution on the Promotion of the Right of Peoples to Peace. UN Human Rights

Council-14th Session. Geneva: 17 June 2010.

Hayden, Patrick. Constraining War: Human Security and the Human Right to Peace.

Human Rights Review. Vol. 6, No. 1, 2004.

Mayor, Federico. Report by the Director-General on the Human Rights to Peace. 29

C/59. General Conference, 29th Session. UNESCO. Paris: 29 October 1997.

_______________. The Human Rights to Peace. United Nations Economic, Scientific

and Cultural Organization. January 1997.

Nussbaum, Martha C. Capability As Fundamental Entitlements: Sen and Social

Justice. Feminist Economics. Vol. 9, No. 2~3, 2003.

3. Santiago Declaration on the Human Rights to Peace. Adopted at the International

Congress on the Human Right to Peace. Santiago, Spain. 9~10 December 2010.

UN Commission on Human Rights. Conscientious Objection to Military Service.

2012. 10. 1928

1998/77. 58th meeting. 22 April 1998.

UN Commission on Human Rights. Promotion of the right of peoples to peace.

2002/71. 56th meeting. 25 April 2002.

UN Commission on Human Rights. Towards a Culture of Peace. 2000/66. 66th

meeting. 26 April 2000.

UN General Assembly. Culture of peace. A/RES/52/13. Fifty-second session. Distr.

15 January 1998.

UN General Assembly. Declaration and Programme of Action on a Culture of Peace.

A/53/243. Fifty-third session. Distr. 6 October 1999.

UN Human Rights Council. Progress Report of the Human Rights Council Advisory

Committee on the Right of Peoples to Peace. A/HRC/17/39. Seventeenth Session.

Distr.: General. 28 March 2011.

UN Human Rights Council. Resolution Adopted by the Human Rights Council:

Promotion of the Right of Peoples to Peace. A/HRC/RES/14/3. 17 June 2010.

29

1 2

-

/

1.

2 . . 51 . 61 2 . , , .( 4) .1) 52

1) (663), (69), (921).

2012. 10. 1930

. , , , .

. 2 , . 4 , .

() .

2. ,

. . . , ,

31

()

, ,

/

( / ) (,

) , ,

( ,

)

(

)

(, ,

)

, ,

/ /

- (

, = / )

- ,

, - () ()

, ()

- , or () , ( ) ( -

)

-

- -

(, ,

)

- (), ,

, -

-

() -

(

)

.

, . .

. (Pax Romana)2) ( ) ()

2) .

2012. 10. 1932

. (, 213) . (,213) . () , .

2 UN . (1948) (11). , .

(1948) ( ) . 28 , , , . (1) . , .

. .

33

(Declaration on the Use of Scientific and Technological Progress in the interests

of Peace and for the Benefit of Mankind, 1975), (Life inPeace) (Declaration on the Preparation ofSocieties for Life in Peace, 1978), (Declaration onthe Right of Peoples to Peace, , 1984), (Resolution on Promotion of the Right of Peoples to Peace, 2003) (Draft Oslo Declaration on the HumanRights to Peace, 1997)

3) UNESCO . (1981) 231 , .4)

- v. - . - - 3 .5)

. . , , , . 3) (inherent right)

. , 225-64) , 180-184; , 224-9 .5) (Recht in statu nascendi) . 228-9

2012. 10. 1934

. , .(, 181 )

1. .2. .3. , , .4. .

. () () . , . . , , , , , .( , 48 )

3.

3.1. . - (Global PostureReview: GPR)

35

- .() . 48 . . (2008) .

6) . , 48 . . , . , , 87

6) (187) .

2012. 10. 1936

.

3.2. . ( 2004.04.29, 2003814) . 5 1 , , . . .7)

, , 5 . , 62 , , . .

7) 1( 2003.12.18.2003255) 2 .

37

5 6 .

2005 (( 2006. 2. 23. 2005268). . 10( , ) 37 1( ) . . . . , . , .

. 2007 10 37 1 . .8)

2012. 10. 1938

, , , , . , .

. 52 , .9)

3.3. . , 6

8) 6:3 . , , .9) .

, () , . . , , .

39

. . . .

10 " , . " . . . . .10)

. . , 371 . , .

. . (dignity),(living condition), (health) . 10 . , .11)

10) . 2006.02.23. 2005268. (2009) .11) . Shantistar Builders v. Naryan

2012. 10. 1940

. , .

. . .

. . .

( people ) , . , , - . , (respect), (protect) (fulfil)

Khimalal Totome & Others(1 SCC 520 (1990)), , . (shelter) . , .

41

.

3.4. (right topeace) . 1978 (Declaration on the Preparation of Societies for Life in Peace) UN 12) . 1998 (right tolive in peace) 13) , (4-1), (4-4) . .

. .( , 4-1) . , , .( , 4-3)

, , . , . 9 ,

12) 1978. 12. 15, A/RES/33/73.

13) , 1998, 120 , 126.

2012. 10. 1942

, . , , .14)

. , 15) . .

. . . . -, , , - , -, -

14) , . (2009) , , , () , () , (, ) , .15) , ,

, , (engagement) . , , , : , ? 2005. 9. 30 .

43

. , (Governmentality) .(Aihwa Ong, Neoliberalism as Exception: mutations in citizenship andsovereignty, Duke University Press, 2006) .16)

, . - - . . . . . .17)

- , , , - . . .16) (1994) .

, , , , . .17) - - -

- , .

2012. 10. 1944

4.

? . . .

. . . . . .

. . , . 48 . . , . , , , ?

45

2 1

1)

/

.

. 2011 105 , , . .

. ( )( )2) 2007 .3)

. 1) 41(200910)

.2) 2006. 2. 23. , 2005268 ,3) 2009. 5. 28. , 2007369 .

2012. 10. 1946

.

.

, .

II.

1.

1960. 1950 .

(). 1962 . 2 9( ) . . 9 .4)

. () ()() () 4) , (,1962), 5 .

47

, () . . 9 5) .

9 . , .

2 6)

() ()() . , .

, 10(35) . , .

173( 359 ) 1969 7 7, .

5) , (1967), 143, 175-176.6) , 32(, 2006)

.

2012. 10. 1948

, .

, 1969 () , () .

() . 1973 9 7, , . . , .7)

1 . 1976 8 5, . . 1982 9 14 , . .

, . , ,

7) , ()(1975)163 .

49

.

3

() 2 . .

( . 1956 , 9 . () .

() .8)

, . 9 .

.

8) (1999), 28 .

2012. 10. 1950

4

1990 . , , , , .

. 1990 8 , . 130 9)

1991 4 24 99 , 10).

1992 6 15 ( PKO) .11) PKO . ( ) , .

. .

9) , 1990. 8.30 .10) , PKO()(, 1992), 290.11) , , ,

, , , , , , (PKO 5) .

51

. 9.11 .

, . , , . , .

12). , , , , . 2003 .

, .

1991 , , , . , PKO 1993 , , . , .13)

12) 2001 9 11 .

2012. 10. 1952

, . .

, 1 , .

, , . , , 9 , .

, .

III.

, , , 13) (2006)101 ().

53

.

1.

() (). , ( ) 14) .

, . 1, 1 2 .

, . 9 . . 2 .15)

, ( ) , 14) , (3)(, 1995), 165-166.15) , (3)(1992), 646.

2012. 10. 1954

16) .

(). , . , 17) .

() .

. , 9, 13 . .18)

.

9 . 9 , 9 .

(). .

9 . 9 , .

, . ,

16) , , 647.17) , ()()(1983), 28.18) , (, 1992), 288.

55

.19)

() . , , . , . .

.

.

.20)

9 .

, 9 , .

, , . , . ,

19) , II(, 1989), 154.20) , (, 1992), 118.

2012. 10. 1956

.21)

, .

. a. , b. , . . . c. (, , ), d. (, ), e. ( ).22)

9 , (, , ) . . . 9 . .

21) , (, 1974), 136.22) , ,, 1987), 227, 234.

57

. . , , , ( ) . . , .

2000 () 9 , 3 , , , 23) .

() . , , , .24)

2.

.

23) , (, 1995), 120.24) , , 60.

2012. 10. 1958

. , . . . , , , . 25)

.

. , 26)

, . 9 .

. () . . 25) , , 63 .26) , , 227-228.

59

3 , . , 27) . 3 , . .

. () - . . , , . .28)

() . , () () , ( ) . .29) , .

27) 250(1976)19.28) , (, 1975), 207.29), , ()(, 1974), 39.

2012. 10. 1960

3.

. , , .

, , , , .

, .

, , ( ) . .

() 30) .

, 1 , .

30) 318(1975)8.

61

( ) , , . () , .

3 () . .31)

, , , , , , , 32) , , .33)

4.

1960 , .

31) 712(1973), 65.32) 1977 ,

. .33) , , 302-304 .

2012. 10. 1962

60 6 7 , .

,34) . 35)

. .

IV.

1.

. ,

34) 1 . , , 337(1966); , , 337(1966); , , 283(1969) , , , (, 1974); , , 606(1976); , , (, 1979); ,

, 48 11(1979) 35) ,

. , , , I,(, 1980); , , ,

(, 1986); , , 2(1992); , III()(

, 1993); , , 18(1994); ,

, 393(2004. 11).

63

.

1990 , . . . , , . 36)

, (brigade) , .

2003 11 25 , . 3 110 , 2005 3 2 8 (UEY) , 8-2- (UEY)-(UEX)-(UA) .37)38)

, , .

36) , , 2004 (125) .37) , , (2006 3), 21.38) , ((04-04))(,2004.8), 40 .

2012. 10. 1964

, .39) 40)

. , 1 ()(1922) (24 1) . (1907) 25 , , .41) . .42) .

5027 .

2007 , 5027 / . 2 , 1990 , 1990 .

39) , , 21 2004 2(35) .40) , ,

(, , 2005), 9-11 ..41) , , 303 .42) , , 303 .

65

69 .43)

2007 (RSOI), (FE) 6 29 , F-117 , (GPR) 44) 2007 3 18, 2007 .

2007 , 1974 45) .

, , . , , .

43) 2007 (2007369) 9 .44) 2000

M198 155mm , (TOW) 96 .45) 3

f g . f. 3 , g. , , . 2007 (2007369) 14-15 .

2012. 10. 1966

2.

2.1 . . 5 .

, . , .

.46) .

6.25 , , .

, . . . .

46) , , (, 2007), 334 .

67

.

2.2 , . . , . , .

37 1 .

. .

3 . 1977 (Karel. Vasak) , 3 (the third generation of human rights) (right to peace) .47) 1984 11 12 (Declaration on the Right of Peoples to Peace) , .48)

47) Karel Vasak, A 30-year struggle, The UNESCO Courier, November 1977,,

(, 1988), 290 .

2012. 10. 1968

100% . .

2.3 .

. , .

, , 3 .

. . , () . . () , . .

48) United Nations Resolutions, Series 1 General Assembly Vol. XXIII(1984-1985), 220. , 246 .

69

, , , .

, , , , .49) . , , , , () , () , (, ) , .

5 , , 39 . 37 2 .

, , , , .50) 37 2 , , , . , .51)

49), , 149-169 .50) , , ( ,2005. 11), 7-9 .51) 12) ,

.

2012. 10. 1970

2.4 . .

, . . , . , .

, .

3 . 1 , 2 , 3 .

, .

71

2.5 . . , , , , , .

. . . . .

, . 1919 3 . . .

, .52) . .53)

. 52) , , 286.53)

. , (, 2009), 51 .

2012. 10. 1972

. NO . . , 2007 , , .

2.6 . . , , .

. . .

3.

2000 , 2007 , .

73

.

, . . , , . .

. , 2007 , . .

, .

. , , .

2012. 10. 1974

., .

, , , .

. , .

.

3 . . .

. , 2007 .

75

.

. , , , . .

4

.

. 2007 . . , , , .

. , , . .

2012. 10. 1976

. , .

. . , .

.

, .

77

, , , 125., (17)(, 2007)., (, 2009)., , (, 2007)., , (2005.11)., , , (2005)., ((04-04)), (, 2004)., (, 1986).

, (, 1962).

, (, 1967).

, (, 1999).

, PKO(, 1992).

, (, 2006).

, (3)(, 1995).

, (3)(, 1992).

, (, 1992).

, II(, 1989).

, (, 1992).

, (, 1987).

, (, 1995).

, (, 1974).

, (, 1975).

, , 250(1976).

, (, 1988).

2012. 10. 1978

2 2

:

/

. . 2012 7 UN , , 1) . 7 (foreignoccupation) . , , (humanitarianintervention) (responsibility to protect) ? ? .

? . .

(Ehren K. Watada, 1978) 2003 9.11

1)

http://blog.unwatch.org/index.php/2012/07/06/u-n-rights-body-defies-u-s-with-right-to-peace-resolution-giving

-legitimacy-to-terror/

79

8 . 2005 2006 6 . UN, , (War Powers Act) . . 9.11 . (John Head) 2007 (mistrial) 2009 .

(missing movement) . . (stipulation of fact) . . .

/ .

2012. 10. 1980

.

crimes against peace .

81

2 3

/

.

2 . .

. 1)

1.

. 26 2 . .*

, .1) , , , 2010, 172-173; , , 12; , 2012, 290.

2012. 10. 1982

2.

. 24 1 . .

3.

. 26 1 . 26 1 . . .

4.

. . 4 3 . 4 3 . .

() .2) ( ) . .

2) , , UUP, 2007, 275-279. , - , 21, , 2002.2, 362-375. , , UUP, 2007, 283-297 .

83

1999 3 24 . . . .

. 1 . 2 . .

5.

. 26 1 . . .

. () .

, . , ( - ) , . , . , (. - EUCOM ) .3)

3) Deiseroth, Dieter(, ), , : , 23, , 2003.2, 477. , , UUP, 2007, 298-328 .

2012. 10. 1984

. 2+4(1990 ) . . , . , . .4)

. 5)

. . 2 . 1949 (BDR) (1949 5) . .

1950 . . . 1955 , . 1956 3

4) Deiseroth, Dieter(, ), , : , 23, , 2003.2, (500-503) 501.5) , , , , 2012.6.5., 6-13

.

85

. (4 3) 1960 .

. ,, , , , , , , , , , , , , . .

(Innere Fhrung). (Staat im Staate) , , . , , , , (Staatsverfassung) (Heeresverfasssung) .

. . . . . , , .

, . , , . . . ,

2012. 10. 1986

. . .

. 6)

, . . . .

1952 (Friedrich Beermann) . (Staatsbrger in Waffen) . (civil courage) . . , , .

(gute Staatsbrger), (vollwertige Soldaten) (freie Menschen) . . .

6) , , , , 2012.6.5., 13-20.

87

.7) . .

. , .

1.

. .8) .9) . . 2011 7 1 .

7) 17a ( ) , , ( 5 1 1 ), (8) (17) . (11), (13) .8) 2003 4

. . , (AWACS) , , . . . , . . BVerwG 2 WD 12.04- Urteil vom 21. Juni 2005. , , 43, 2010 .9) , , , 2008.

2012. 10. 1988

2.

. . 5 1 2 . , , , . 5 .10) .

3.

. (NJW 1992, 1249). . , , (BVerwGE 76, 267=NJW 1985, 1658). ( 14). . 5 1 3 .

10) () , . , , 40, 2009, 45~77.

89

4.

17a . . 15 4 . . . .

. . 9 2 ( ) . 9 3 . 9 3 (Soldatenbeteiligungsgesetz) . , . . (BVerfGE 57, 220). 9 3 . . , , . , 7() . . .

5.

.11)

11) 15() . . . .

2012. 10. 1990

. ( 15 1 2). . . (BVerwGE 28, 51). .12)

. . , , ( 25). 8.13) , .

. 14)

.15)

. . . .12) , , , , , , , ,

, , , , , , , , , , , , . , , , , , , , , . OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights,Handbook on Himan Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of Armed Forces Personnel, 2008, OSCE ODIHR,

61.13) 8( )

.14) , , , , 2012.6.5.,27-29 .15) 45b( )

91

. , (Primat der Politik) .16) . , .(7). (Hilfsorgan)( 45b; 1 1). . (13/15 4), 5 (14). (15 1), (5 1), (2), (16). . . . , , . (Besuchsrecht) . (3).

(1 2). (5 2). , . (6). . . . (7). . . .16) / , :

, 33, , 2007, 387 .

2012. 10. 1992

( 35). , , , (12).

.

. . 27 2 , 74 1 , 77 3 , 110 , 4 , 27 2 .

. , , 92 .

. . . .

. .

93

, , , 2010., , 12; , 2012. , - , 21, ,2002.2, 362-375.

, , UUP, 2007., , , 20, 2001, 153-177., , , , 2012.6.5., 1-32.Deiseroth, Dieter(, ), , : , 23, , 2003.2, 477-503.

2012. 10. 1994

3 1

:

/

. , , . , , .

. . . .

, (life) (property), (liberty) . . . , Life . ?

95

? , ? , ? .

() . . , , . ? . ? . ? . .

1.

. (H. Arendt) . , .1)

? . . .

?

1) , , (, 2004), 219.

2012. 10. 1996

? 3.1 4.19 , . , , , , , , , , 1948 7 12 8 . .

. 31 ? () 31 , () 31 , , , .() () .2)

31 ? 31 . , , , , . . .

31 . .3) / 2) 31 , 31, , (

, 2012) .3) 17, 12, 35, 2 .

15, 7, 7, 6 81 233 754 .

97

31 .

? 31 . . 31 . , . 31 419 .

1 . , . . . . . . , . , .

(Jrgen Habermas) , . . . . , , .4)

2012. 10. 1998

. . .

. , 5) . . , . . , , 6) . . , .

. , . 14 2001 1 17 . 31 . .

4) , , (, 2000), 30.5) , , 6.6) , 341~342.

99

, , .7)

? , , , , . , , , .

?

, . . , . , .

. 2009 10 2002 9 2009 7 87 44 (13) 3 . 60 . .

. , , , , , , , , , , . , .

7) , : (, 2001), 152~153.

2012. 10. 19100

, , .8) . . . .

, , . . .

2. ?9)

2001 7, , , . . 2, 30 . 30 . .

, . . . .

, , ?

8) , , 3: (, 2009), 357.9) , (, 2012) 4 .

101

. . . . .

. , .

, , . . , .

. , . .

. J. Brown .

. , J. Rawls

2012. 10. 19102

. . , . .

. , , , . .

.

, , . . . , . , . .

103

, . , . , , , . .

, . . . , , . . . . / .

. , , . . .

2012. 10. 19104

.

. .

. . . .

. , .

(judicialization of politics) . , . .

. , . .

. ,

105

.10)

. (public sphere) , . . .

, , . . .

, . . , , .

, , , . . , .

, . .

10) , , 368.

2012. 10. 19106

, . .

3.

. , . . . , , . . .

. . 4 . . , . .

? . . . . . . . . .

107

. . 38 . . .

11) .

. , . , . , . , . . .

11) , (, 1979), 88~89.

2012. 10. 19108

3 2

/

/ NGO

.

, , , . . .

. , . , , .

109

2012 10 4 Talk . .

- ,

-

-

- , ,

.

1970 1980 --() . , () .

--() right to development right to peace .

(1948) () . 28 , ,

2012. 10. 19110

.

1984 ( 39/11, 1984 11 12 ). , , , . .

... , .1. ,2. .

, . . , .

. , , (Dimitrijevic, Vojin, "Human Rights and Peace", in Symonides, Janusz (ed),

Human Rights: New Dimensions and Challenges, Ashgate/UNESCO, 1998).

55 . . . ,

111

. .

- . , . . .

. 1990 150 , 1998 5 , , , , , ,, , , "" . .

4-1. . , , , , . . , , , . , . .

4-2. . , . .

2012. 10. 19112

4-3. , . . , , .

4-4. , . . . . , . .

4-5. . , . . ( ) , .

1 , , , . .

, . , . .

/ / . / , , , .

113

.

.

(1) :

(2) :

-

- , , , , , , , , ,

- ,

- , 38 1

(3) [ ], 1984 39/11

, , , , , , 1 , , ,

2012. 10. 19114

1. .2. .3. , , .4. .

(4) ( ), , 1992

(5) , 1995

.

(6) [ ], 1999 53/243

(7) [ 1325], 2000

- , , . 1325 .

- , .

- , , .

(8) [ ] , 2003 57/216

115

(9) ,

. /

10 4, 20 Talk . , . , . 5 , . , , , .

.

2012. 10. 19116

- .

- , , , .

- .

- .

- .

- .

- .

- .

- , .

- .

- . .

- .

- .

- . .

- .

- .

- .

- .

- .

- .

117

- .

- , .

, : , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

, .

, ... . .

00 . , , , . . . . . . . .

00 . , , , . , . . . .

2012. 10. 19118

. .

.

00 00 . , .

, 7~8, , , , , , . , , , , . . . , , ... , . , , . . . , , . . 13 . 10 13 . , . , , , , . , . .

, . . 5 4 . , , , , . .

, . . , . .

00 . . . ...

119

. ... . . .. . .

, , . .

. . . .

00 . ... 2007 . . . (?) . . . . . ... 4 24 1... 4 5 . . . .

. .

. . . . . . . , , , . .

2012. 10. 19120

, . . . ... . . .

.

, . . .

.

, , , . .

, , , .

. , .

121

. .

.

, , , , , , , , , , , , .

, .

. .

. .

. . .

.

2012. 10. 19122

, . , , .

. 2 . . . .

. . . . .

. , .

. , . .

. . .

123

3 3

/

. . . . . .

- 1982 (Waddington)

1.

. .

. , , .

2012. 10. 19124

() . , ( ) .

, . () , .

2.

, , , , . . 2 4 . , , , , , . 40 . 1 500 . 500 , 40

125

, , , . . , , . . .

. . ( ) . . . , , , . .

.

2012. 10. 19126

. .

15 . . , , . , .

. . . . . . . . . . 749 . . . . . ., , , , . , . , . . . . ,

127

. , . . . . . . . . .

. .

. . 4 , , 10 1 , ., 10 3 1 . .

2012. 10. 19128

.

. 2010 08-301-1 (CVN-65) , (CNFK) . . . . 1998 3 . .

. . , . .1963 (UN) 16 . , . . , . . B 6()

129

, , , , , , , . 1996 (ICJ) . , . , 2 4 . 51 , . . , , ( ) .

. , . . . 21 . . , , . . . .

2012. 10. 19130

. , () . , () . . . . . , , .

. . 20% . , , . , , .

3.

131

. . . (http://ideas0419.tistory.com/404) .

, , , , , , , . 10 .

3 7 . , , . , , , . . .

2012. 10. 19132

3.1 ? . ( ) . () , . . (April Carter) , . (Brian Martin) (Wendy Varney) . , (Satyagraha), , , , , . , , , , , , .

, , . , , . (Gene Sharp) . , .

133

, , , , , . , (Howard Clark), (MichalRandle) . 30 , , (people power) . . . .

3.2 198 (Politics of Nonviolent Action) . 198 3 (Protest andPersuasion), (Non-cooperation), (NonviolentIntervention) . (War Resisters'International, WRI) (Handbook forNonviolent Campaigns) .

- 2003 2 15 . 600 .

- . , .

-

2012. 10. 19134

. . .

- . (1987 ) . .

- .

- 2 . .

- . .

- . , -, (peace observer).

- . .

3.3 . , , () . . (Boulding) 3 . (threat power), (economic power),

135

(integrative power) . . . , , , . . . . . . . . , .

3.4 . , . () . . , . , . . . , .

2012. 10. 19136

. . , , .

3.5 4 . (conversion) . . . .

(non-violent coercion) . . (accommodation) . . . (disintegration) 1989 .

137

. . . .

. . . . . .

4. Smash EDO

. . . 3

2012. 10. 19138

1990 . . .

2008 (Cast Lead) 1,400 2009 1 17 EDO/ITT . 5 (die-in), , , , 6 . 6 . . EDO . . . 6 250,000( 4 5 ) ( Raytheon 9 350,000 ). EDO/ITT .

2009 5, 9 .3 . . 4 , 2008 Ratheon 9

139

. 7 2, . (2009 Al-Quds ) .

5.

. , , . . , . , . (squatting) . . .

. .

2012. 10. 19140

. , ..

141

(2011) , C (2012) (2003) (2006) (2012) 3 15 (2006) , 21 7 12Angie Zelter (1999) 'Defence Notes of Angie Zelter Greenock 1999' Loch Goil and

Greenock Trial

Boulding, K. E. (1989) Three Faces of Power. Calif: Sage Publications

Carter, A., Clar, H., and Randle M. (2006) People Power and Protest Since 1945: A

Bibliography of Nonviolent Action. London: Housmans Bookshop

Sharp, G. (1973) The Politics of Nonviolent Action Boston: Porter Sargent

Sharp, G. (1990) 'Nonviolent Action: An Active Technique of Struggle'. in Nonviolence

in Theory and Practice. ed. by Holmes, R. L. Illinois: Waveland, 147-150

Martin, B., and Varney, W. (2003) Nonviolence Speaks. New Jersey: Hampton Press

War Resisters' International (2009) Handbook for Nonviolent Campaigns WRI

2012. 10. 19142

20119 2

3 [] 3 (1 ) 16 ,

20 375

10 1 [] 4 (2 ), 2~4 11 ,

6 , 10

10

11 , 1

18 , ( )

21 ,

29 [] 5 ! !11 7 , 5

7~14 ,

16 , ,

12 1 ,

3 [] 6 ! ! 7 ,

8 , 30 , , 2011 2012 96%

31

2012

1 10 , 29,

17 , , ! 26 ,

1. ( )

143

2 2 ,

3 , 5

7 ,

8 , ,

9 , 5

16 , 6

17, , /(

) / ()/ 4 ,

18[] 7

! , 14

21

, ,

, 4 (), ,

22 , 4

, ,

23,

, ,

24

, , () ,

, 4

8~6, 2 , 8 2 ()

24~26 26 , 16, 5 21 27 , 5 28 (),

29, , , 10 1771

5,7873 1 , 2 , 7 200m 6

2012. 10. 19144

2.

,

PVC . . , .

. . . 100% . . . . , . . 1998 3 . . .

145

.

. , . , . , 3 500 . , .

5 . , , ,, , . . , , ? . , . . . . PVC . .

. , . . , , ,

2012. 10. 19146

, , . , , , . ? ?

,

, , , . 5 . . . . .

9 21

, , , , , , ,

147

3. , ( )

26 . , , . .

. (TF), . .

2008 , . , .

. . , . , , .

. , .

2012. 10. 19148

. , .

, , .

: , , , , , , ,, , , ,

>

1. . ( 311)

2. . ( 314 1)

. ( 314 1 )

149

1

/ ,

.

. . . .

.

2012. 10. 19150

. . .

. . . 4.3 . . , . . . . . NLL . . . , , , , .

151

.

. . , . ( .) . .

. .

2000 500 2 . ?

2012. 10. 19152

. ? . . .

. (Aland) .

. . . .

. , , (Diego Garcia) .

153

. . . . , NLL (Chagos) .

. . . .

8 18 (drone) , . . . , . . ,

2012. 10. 19154

. , . . . . . (innocent blood) .

- (geo-spiritual dimension) . . . . . . . ?

155

2

/

-

1)

2) 3

- 1) , .

- (geo-political determination) , .

- , . , . . , () .

- , , . , . 4.3 , .

2012. 10. 19156

.

- . , ( ) ( , 2003).

- . (, p103. ).

- , .

- 2) . .

- , 2000 . . 2007 , . , 2) .

- , ? ? (attraction)? (extra-territoriality) ? .

- 1) 2) . .

- , () , / .

157

. . . .

- vs . , .

- / . , .

- , .

- . . . .

( : 02-6401-0514, 02-3458-0911)