ws lecture1
TRANSCRIPT
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 1/32
DEVELOPMENT OF MATHEMATICS IN INDIA
Lecture - 1
K. RamasubramanianIIT Bombay
ATM WORKSHOP @IIT BOMBAY
February 2013
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 2/32
Lecture 1 – OutlineMathematics in the Antiquity: Vedas and ´ Sulbas¯ utras
Introduction
Mathematical references in Vedas
Mathematics in the ´ Sulbas¯ utra texts
Bhuj¯ a-kot . i-karn . a-ny¯ aya (Pythagorean theorem?)Finding the cardinal directions
Tools involved in the construction of altarsNeed for the value of surds in ´ Sulbas¯ utras
Approximations to √ 2 & √ 3Derivation of these expressions
Transforming the shapes of geometrical objects
Circle to square and vice versaApproximate value of π
Citinirm¯ an . am : Construction of Fire-altars
Types of Citis ( ´ Syenaciti )Fabrication of bricks and constructional details
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 3/32
IntroductionBroad classication of Knowledge – Mun . d . aka-Upanis . ad
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 4/32
Mathematical references in VedasCitations that unambiguously point to the decimal system being in vogue
We nd a list of powers of 10 in the Kr . s . n . a-Yajur-Veda :
. . .
. . . 1
. . .
2
We also nd a list of odd numbers and multiples of four occuring
in Taittirıya-sam . hit¯ a (4.5.11):
. . .
. . .
We also nd a mantra referring to the notion of transnite ( ∞).
. . .
1¯ Aran . yakam 4.69.2Sam . hit¯ a 7.2.49.
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 5/32
Mathematics in the ´ Sulbas¯ utra textsWhat are these texts, and where do they fall in the Vedic corpus?
One of the prime occupations of the vedic people seem to havebeen performing sacrices , for which altars of prescribed shapesand sizes were needed.
Recognizing that manuals would be of greatly help inconstructing such altars, the vedic priests have composed aclass of texts called ´ Sulba-s¯ utras .
These texts (composed prior to 800 BCE ), form a part of muchlarger corpus known as Kalpas¯ utras that include:
– Employed in rituals associated with societal welfare.
– Rituals related to household. – Duties 3 and General code of conduct.
– Geometry of the construction of re-altar.
3¯ Adi ´ Sa ˙ nkara in his commentary on Upanis . ads denes the term dharma as
anus . t . hey¯ an¯ am . s¯ am¯ anyavacanam .
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 6/32
Problems dealt with in the ´ Sulbas¯ utra texts
Besides presenting the geometry related to the design of altars(of different sizes and shapes) the ´ Sulba-s¯ utras also presentvarious interesting approximations for surds .
The motivation for presenting estimates of surds could be tracedto the attempts of vedic priests
to solve the problem of “squaring a circle” and vice versato construct a square whose area is n times the area of agive square, and so on.
The expressions for surds presented in the form
N = N 0 + 1n 1 + 1n 1n 2 + 1n 1 n 2 n 3 + . . . ,
can be understood in different ways, two of which namely,Geometrical construction .
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 7/32
What does the word ´ Sulbas¯ utra mean? The word sulba stems from the root sulb (to measure).
Since all the measurements were done using ropes or chords, inthe very early times, it seems the word in due course wassynonymously employed to refer to the chords themselves.
The etymological derivation of the word sulba (referring to a rope)can be given as:
4
The exact derivation of the compound word ´ Sulbas¯ utras ,including the grammatical peculiarities is:
=
(
+
)5
Seven ´ Sulbas¯ utras , namely Baudh¯ ayana, ¯ Apastamba, K¯ aty¯ ayana,M¯ anava, Maitr¯ ayan . a, V¯ araha and V¯ adh¯ ula are extant today.
4This derivation is technically referred to as karan . avyutpatti .5This type of derivation is known as bh¯ avavyutpatti and the s¯ utra that
comes into play is ‘ bh¯ ave gha˜ n ’.
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 8/32
Tools involved in the construction of altarsConstructing a perpendicual bisector: Tool that nds application in many contexts
Two commonly employed methods for drawing the perpendicular
bisector of a given straight line were:
(drawing sh-gure)
(folding the cord)
As the former is too well known, and is taught in schools eventoday, we explain the latter as described in ´ Sulbas¯ utras .E
S
W
N
,
,
,
,
– distance between the two pins(along the east-west direction) – by repeating with the string
– hits a nail
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 9/32
Dertermining the east-west line
Determining the exact east-west line at a given location, is a
pre-requisite for all constructions, be it a residence, a temple, asacricial altar or a re-place.
The procedure for its determination is described thus:
‘
’
[Kt. Su. I 2]
O
X
E
W
N S
A
B
OB − afternoon shadowOA − forenoon shadow
Fixing a pin (or gnomon) on levelledground and drawing a circle with acord measured by the gnomon ,a hexes pins at points on the line (of thecircumference) where the shadow ofthe tip of the gnomon falls. That is thepr¯ acı .
a Astr. Signicance: r > 2OX .
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 10/32
Time from shadow measurement (not in ´ Sulbas¯ utras )
Figure: Zenith distance and the length of the shadow.
t = ( R sin )− 1 R cos z cos φ cos δ ±R sin ∆ α
∓∆ α.
If φ and δ are known ( ∆ α = f (φ, δ )), then t is known.
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 11/32
The ´ Sulva (Pythagorean?) theorem
A clear enunciation of the so-called ‘Pythagorean’ theorem – known as bhuj¯ a-kot . i-karn . a-ny¯ aya – is found in ´ Sulva-s¯ utras :6
7
The rope corresponding to the the diagonal of a rectangle makes whatever is made by the lateral and the vertical sides individually.
Terms their meaning – Rectangle (lit. longish 4-sided gure)
– the diagonal rope
– the measure of the lateral side
– the measure of the perpendicular side
6Bodh¯ ayana ´ Sulvas¯ utra 1.48.7 It is an indeclinable that occurs in the Vedic literature:
...
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 12/32
To construct a square that is n times a given square
Katy ayana gives an ingenious method to construct a squarewhose area is n times the area of a given square.
( n + 1 ) a
2 na
A
B CD
(n−1)a
2
( n + 1 ) a
[Kt.Sl VI 7]
As much . . . one less than that forms thebase . . . the arrow of that [triangle] makesthat (gives the required number √ n ).
In the Figure BD = 12 BC = (
n − 12 )a . Consider ABD ,
AD 2 = AB 2 −BD 2 =n + 1
2a
2
−n −1
2a
2
= a 2
4 (n + 1)2
−(n −1)2 = a 2
4 ×4n = (na 2)
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 13/32
To transform a square into a circleNeed for nding the value of √ 2 accurately ?
A B
CD
P
M
E
O
W
AB = 2a
OP = r OD = a √ 2ME = a (√ 2 −1)
According to Baudh¯ayana :
= semi-diagonal
= from centre to the east = whatever [portion] remains = with one-third of that
Radius OP = r = a 1 + 1
3(√ 2
−1)
= a
3(2 + √ 2) .
How to nd √ 2?
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 14/32
Approximate value of π
What would have been the value of π used by Sulvak¯ aras ?
If 2a is the side of the square, we saw that the radius of the circleis given by
r = a 1 + 13
(√ 2 −1) (1)
The vedic priests imposed the constraint that the transformationhas to be measure preserving .
This translates to the condition πr 2 = 4a 2 . Hence we have therelation
π 13 (2 + √ 2)2
= 4 or π ≈3 .0883 , (2)
which is correct only to one decimal place.
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 15/32
To transform a square into a circleHow did the Sulvak¯ aras specify the value of √ 2?
The following s¯ utra gives an approximation to √ 2:
, , ,
√ 2 ≈ 1+13
+ 1
3
×4 −
13
×4
×34
(3)
= 577
408= 1.414215686
What is noteworthy here is the use of the word in thes¯ utra , which literally means ‘ that which has some speciality ’(speciality ≡being approximate)
How did the ´ Sulvak¯ aras arrive at (1) ?
Several explanations have been offered over the last centuries.
Here we will discuss the geometrical construction approach.
√
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 16/32
Approximation for √ 2Rationale for the expression √ 2 = 1 + 1
3 + 13. 4 − 1
3. 4. 34 by Geometrical Construction
Consider two squares ABCD and BEFC (sides of unit length).
The second square BEFC is divided into three strips . The third strip is further divided into many parts, and these partsare rearranged (as shown) with a void at Q .
Now, each side of the new square APQR = 1 + 13 + 1
3.4 .
III
III
III
IIS I
1
2
3
II III 1
A B
CD
P
QR
E
F
void thatremains
√
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 17/32
Approximation for √ 2Rationale for the expression (contd.)
The area of the void at Q is 13.4
2.
Suppose we were to strip off a segment of breadth b from eitherside of this square, such that the area of the stripped off portionis exactly equal to that of the void at Q , then we have,
2b 1 + 1
3
+ 1
3.4 −b 2 =
1
3 .4
2
.
Neglecting b 2 (as it is too small) , we get
b = 1
3 .4
2
×
3 .4
34 =
1
3 .4 .34.
Hence the side of the resulting square
√ 2 = 1 + 13
+ 13 .4 −
13 .4 .34
√
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 18/32
Value of √ 3
000111I II III IV VIVS
III’
IV’
1V
V
VI
VI
2
3
1
2
3
V’
V’
VI’
VI’
1
2
1
2
BA
CD
P
QR
E F
H G
void that remainsto the filled
Each side of the new largersquare APQR = 1 + 23 + 13.5
So for closer approximation, letthe side of the new square bediminished by an amount y ,such that
2y 1 + 23
+ 13 .5 −y 2 =
13 .5
2
.
Neglecting y 2
as too small, weget y = 13.5 .52 , nearly.
Thus we get√ 3 = 1 + 23 + 1
3 .5 − 1
3 .5.52
l
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 19/32
Citi : Fire altar
– Platform constructed of burnt bircks and mud mortar.
: [the locus] unto which things arebrought into [and arranged].
(
)= assembling or fetching together
Shapes of the citis :
(isosceles triangle) (rhombus) (chariot wheel)
(water jar)
(tortoise) (bird, falcon type), etc.
Number of bricks used is 1000 (
...).
Altar has ve layers, hence 200 bricks in each layer
Ci i Fi l
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 20/32
Citi : Fire altar
Fire altars are of two types. The ones used for
—daily ritual. —intended for wish fullment.
One of the forms of wish-fullling re-altars is constructed in theform of a bird. They are of a few types:
The shape of there-altar is close to that of the shadow cast by the bird while ying.
(BSS.8.5) 8
8
(Taittirıya sam . hit¯ a 5.5.3.2)
S i i F l h d l
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 21/32
Syenaciti —Falcon-shaped re-altars
The origin of ´ Syenaciti can be traced back to vedas .
For instance in s . ad . vim . sa br ahman . a belonging to s¯ amaveda , . . .
9
Another version of the same statement perhaps on anotherBr¯ ahman . a which is more popular goes as
These sentences are cited in the Mım am . s¯ a text in connection with
the discussion on deciding the meaning of the word syena appears inthe injunction
9s . ad . vim . sa br¯ ahman . a ,4.2.3.
M t it d i t ti
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 22/32
Measurement units used in construction
10
a ˙ ngula = 14 an . u or 34 tila ks . udrapada = 10a ˙ ngula
pr¯ adesa = 12a ˙ ngula pada = 15a ˙ ngula
prakrama = 30a ˙ ngula aratni = 2pr¯ adesa = 24 a ˙ ngula
vy¯ ay¯ ama = 4aratni purus . a = 5aratni
10 Baudh¯ ayana-sulbas utra ,1.3
Constr ction of S iti : I
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 23/32
Construction of Syenaciti : ITypes of bricks: 1, 2 and 3
Bricks of geometrical shapes other than rectilinear are needed.
The ve types of bricks used:1. B 1 —one-fourth brick ( caturthı )—30 ×30 a ˙ ngulas ; i.e., a
square whose side is 14 pu .
2. B 2 —half brick ( ardh¯ a )—obtained by cutting the one-fourthsquare brick diagonally; each of 2 sides equals a ˙ ngulas and
the hypotenuse 30 30 √ 2 a ˙ ngulas 3. B 3 —quarter brick ( p¯ ady¯ a )—obtained by cutting B 1
diagonally; each of 2 sides equals 15 √ 2 a ˙ ngulas andhypotenuse 30 a ˙ ng .
A
B C
D A D
B C
A D
CB
B 32B1
B
30
30 30
3 0
30
1 5
2 2
Types of bricks: 4 and 5
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 24/32
Types of bricks: 4 and 5
B 4 —four-sided quarterbrick (caturasra-p ady¯ a )—ofsides equal to 22 1
2 , 15, 7 12
and 15 √ 2 a ˙ ng . The area is
15 ×15 a ˙ ng , the same asthat of B 3 . B 5 —(ham . samukhı )- halfbrick obtained by joiningtwo B 4s, along theircommon longest side.
E
C
B 4
A
F
✑
215
15
B 5
B
C
E
B
A
D
D
2
30
15
7
12
7
15 2
Outline of body and head of Syena I
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 25/32
Outline of body and head of Syena I
A
B C
D
G
H
IJ
K
L
240
150
FE
45
45
12
82
60
A
B C
D
30
30
Syenaciti : Falcon shape
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 26/32
Syenaciti : Falcon-shape
00000000000000000000000000000011111111111111111111111111111100000000001111111111000000000000000000111111111111111111000000000000000000111111111111111111000000000
000000111111111111111
0000000001111111110000000011111111
00000000001111111111
000000000000000000111111111111111111000000000000000111111111111111
Number of bricks used
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 27/32
Number of bricks used
Parts of the citi B 1 B 2 B 3 B 4 B 5 TotalHead 1 6 6 1 14Body 30 6 10 46
Wings 30 62 16 108Tail 8 4 20 32Total 69 72 52 6 1 200
´ Syenaciti : second layer
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 28/32
Syenaciti : second layerNumber of bricks used in the second layer
Parts B 1 B 2 B 3 B 4 B 5 TotalHead 10 10Body 12 28 4 4 48Wings 48 28 34 110
Tail 8 4 18 2 32Total 68 70 56 6 200
Fabrication of bricks
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 29/32
Fabrication of bricksIngredients to be added to the mixture of clay employed in manufacting the bricks
. . .
Extracts of gum from certain trees ( pal¯ asa )
. . .
Hair of the goat, of a bullock, horse, etc.
11
Fine powder of burnt bricks ..
12
The above process of strengthening is in practice till date. 1311 ´ Satapatha br¯ ahman . a , 6.5.1.1–6.12 Baudh¯ ayana ´ Sulbas¯ utra , 2.78–7913 The addition of y ash as well as pozzuolana is well known in the
manufacture of cement
Fabrication of bricks
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 30/32
Fabrication of bricksHandling the contraction in size of the brick (Sun’s heat + Burning in the kiln)
There will be reduction in the size of the moulded bricks:
14
Different ´ Sulbas¯ utra texts suggest different measures tohandle this problem of contraction
15
Appropriately increase the size of the mould.
,
16
Compensate the loss with the mortar.
14 M¯ anava ´ Sulbas¯ utra , 10.3.4.1715 M¯ anava ´ Sulbas¯ utra , 10.2.5.216 Baudh¯ ayana ´ Sulbas¯ utra , 2.60
Constructional Details
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 31/32
Constructional DetailsSpecications regarding the arrangement of bricks in different layers
Here the word “ bheda ” does not simply meandifference/distinction (in fact, this has to be maintained).What is meant is a clear segregation between two rowsacross all the layers. This is to be avoided.Joints should be disjoint! (not continuous)
17
The etymology could be:
(Arbitrary) foreign material should not be employed to llthe gaps.
The above-mentioned are very important principles from theview point of civil engineering.
17 BSS. 2.22–23. (RPK’s Book)
General observations
8/10/2019 Ws Lecture1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ws-lecture1 32/32
General observations
The purpose for which the geometry got developed in the Indiancontext is far different from the context in which it got developedin other civilizations.
The expressions used by the ´ Sulvakaras for expressing surdsseems to be quite interesting . What algorithm ?
The layout and construction of citis are discussed in the texts´ Sulbas¯ utras (Authors are architects of the Vedic age!)
Citis are platforms—having artistic looks—constructed out ofburnt bricks (+ mud mortar).
The archaeological excavations at Kausambi (UP) seems to
have revealed a ´ Syenaciti constructed around 200 BC. The different citis not only speak of the aesthetic sense , but alsoof the creativity and ingenuity of the different ´ Sulvak¯ aras to workwith several constraints imposed.