الحرية الفكرية

90

Upload: mohammad-tarraf

Post on 17-Jul-2016

319 views

Category:

Documents


10 download

DESCRIPTION

فكري

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: الحرية الفكرية
Page 2: الحرية الفكرية
Page 3: الحرية الفكرية

!"#$% &'()"%*+,-. / /0-123

L 4567% 4898:% ;<= / >?@A BC9A / D95(",-/.111,+ / ,-/..E,,, :FG90

,2/.3.,E1 :HIJKL* * *

!"#$%&' ()*%'[email protected]@[email protected]

* * *+,-.%' /012&' 3456' 777 89:"#$%&' ;<'=6'

www.sayedfadlullah.orgwww.tawasolonline.netwww.fadlullahlibrary.comyoutube/tawasolonlineyoutube/sayyedfadlullah

Facebook:SayyedFadlullah

&89'"% M% NOP QRJ6"% ;S@T% &8 RU'"% &(VW8X?Y D#Z N[%IG

Page 4: الحرية الفكرية
Page 5: الحرية الفكرية
Page 6: الحرية الفكرية

5

&///8 RQ/\8

!"#$%$&' ()*)+ (,-./0 1234./'- !5 6789'- :7 ;1<=<> "?@3A BC D5>E' F 6+$G B9'- (.2HI'- 1*.IJ'- !"* 6)K9'- :7 (L$M N6H&G 1/<K'- OPQ BC R)S3 BC"/H'- B75>T- UV.&'- BC :K3W XFG)2/# 1Y"&> ZKS'- -PQ BC "?'W"[G B9'- «16*.IJ'- 16*.K'-» (\.J7 .][0 XB/^[&'- N2<K9'-W 162&<_'- 1 6 )'- :7 a.2HI0 F<'- NbC .J_+ )62='- c"Cd- e#$9=2' "Q.f3 g)7 hi=9* X1234.` j$2_0 6k['- R./3

.."? l<V ("2K'- m<# 1Y$9J&'- !n"o&'-W !"* 6)K9'- g$9=7 m'A m`.* B75>T- p"^q<' ;1r' "?@3A .HVR N/_<' s9J2' t*.I'- j4./'- u^[9=3 1r<'- OPQW X1YW.^&'- D)qG gvL N 6I]G 162C._7 wx"9[0 y.q2'W X.2IJ9<' 1Y"> :7

..N2Mz- B75>T- 6{q'- |17)} |"#"SG 1234./'- !5789'- OPQ .][' u6C$h3 jR F<'- ~8=3W iC)* jR �_S'- ~W"K* :7� BC 6B75>T- �.IJ'- �W.]&<'

Page 7: الحرية الفكرية

..�W.]&'- -PQ "?<}-\ u[9q* 1&<f7 �$?V m'A �W.]&'- -P?0 jR m<# j$M.K* :2�<q7 ("#\ \$+$0 F<'- -��0 @t9* :' -PQW

..("2K'- (\"2` BC OLW\ D5>E' m/S*uC$&'- F<'-W

R]P9\^"% R]8U_:% `a@<"% @?Q8HI_I<"% Q R<b8 cJde

*+,-. C%fg / /0 -123 !"#$% hi9<S

***

Page 8: الحرية الفكرية

7

QJj<G

~$Y 16234.` !5 678G 1<=<> BC m'WR 1/<Y BG8* ZKS'- -PQ WR "[7"IY80 WR "[V$<=0 1<�'- !-� t2Q"J&'- :7 1#$&o7

.("2K'-W j$I'- :# "[G-L 6$�90 " �2=2>8G "|HK0 F3$V BC :&IG �KS'- 6B34./'- ZKS'- 12 6&QRW i*.]9<' ~ 6Wz- L)�&'- $Q t*.I'- j4./'- 6jR �"� )/C �" �2<2M8GW 1C._&<' ~ 6Wz- L)�&'- F63A N0 X{/C �'PV �2' :I'W XB75>T- �3"V ,-$>W Xt2Q"J&'- BC WR 1_*.]'- BC ,-$> X1 67"_0 16275>T- X"Q.2�W ( 6$S['-W u'"q'-W u<q'- t'"_0 1^SG.7 16*)/# t2Q"J7 OPQ

.("2K'"0 1^SG.7 16*)/# t2Q"J7 WR :# "|HK0 X 6B34./'- 6k['- N}-\ BC .IJ'- N2_JG (.IC �.^GW pL"o9'- 6jz �F2C �2_3 �P'- "[_`-W BC |1 @K<7 |(LW.% Xt2Q"J&'- 6D"_'- B75>T- ~"o&'- "[Q )�/3W XB75>T- .IJ'- "?%"} B9'- 1&x-)'- 1+"K'- �9S�R X!"Q"oGn-W eQ-P&'- � 6$[9' :%"K'- (-W.'- .S# ~$/[&'- Bx-W.'- 6k['- m69Y {SbG 16*L"2_7 162_+.&'

Page 9: الحرية الفكرية

8

�<='- �-.G :# |5bC F90"KM WR F920 NQR WR P lBS['- :# 1C._&<' 162x"?3 L\"�7 !.Sh9#- :*W"[# :7 �'� m'A "7 WR s'"�'-

."?[7 m<#R {0"% aL"2_7 6�R :# a~U_&0 162x5#R m<# :2/J697 � t?SQ-P7 m69]0 � j$&<=&'- j"V -�AW kY k# lm n? kQk? lXnJ ko Xl8 pN lq9k( n"% lmJlG nr k? kYs F<'- hD5V F63RW X 6B34./'- 6k['- �2/3 �P'- L"2_&'- j$I* jR BC F[7 L)+R �2<C X(�)tlmld nK kL nX l8 B3"&*T- �`"[9'- :7 6jz �D5>E' "?S=[3 B9'- "[&2Q"J7 6NV F2<# �'"q* X" �*)/# WR j"V " �2#.� X aD$?J7 6�80 P}83 jR B[* l)'- WR jR BrS[* n ;1?*)0 OPQW .12[*)'- 1C._&<' N2Mz-W ~ 6Wz- L)�&'- !"62'4 i%W �kq* "7 g$> � he=K3 "7 BC � ~)o'- "?2'A c 6.^9*

."?/2S^G m<# D$/G "&63A 16234./'- 16*L"2_&'- (.IC 6jR m'A �J<3 jR m/S* aN2<KGW ai&+ 162<&# $Q "&63A 6B34./'- D$?J&'- �"]I9>- 6jR ()#"` .�"S7 .2� aNI� BC WR (.�"S7 16'-)'- 16234./'- h!"*d- N 6I]G Xa,"[0W D$?J&'- $Q F2<# �"/h* "&C X�">z- -PQ m<#W .�$%$&'- m<# g$> j5 6I]G n )` :29*4 WR a1*4 m<# �"2/'- 6t9* jR n XFx"[0 )_0

.D$?J&'- O$+W :7 aF+W WR a,U+ .60)9'- $Q Xp"9I'- BC F'W"K[> "&C X�'� 6NV m'A - |\"[9>-W BI' X(.�"S&'- .2�W (.�"S&'- 1'n)'- !-� Xj4./'- !"*4 BC

.�� 1*d- X�< 6�C (L$> (�)

Page 10: الحرية الفكرية

9

BC 16275>T- 16*.f['- N 6I]* )` "7 ZKS'- 1*"?3 BC k<q9=3 BQW X.M"_&'- B[* l)'- .IJ'- BC |n)+ Nx"=&'- .HVR :7 1'8=7

.16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- 1'8=7&R?@Wd"% &R? R@b"% *Ijd8

h�2/3 � ltb'"0 � 6. hK'-» 6jR u@'"% D96" �$7"` BC \LW hi&o'-W X1 �7z- �2/3 :( 6. hK'-W ...L-. �YW ;L-.YR hi&o'-W X �)S_'- $QW X 6c l.'- h�5} : hu9_'-» :" |b*R F2CW X(�)« hF �/9#R hO �L @.YW ... h.x-.Y @.Y :7 X-s9J'"0– L-. �K'- $QW aL)�&' ;t>- 16* 6.K'-W .(�)«16* 6.K'- �$<&&'- !L 6.Y» :X?@b("% ;<v8 BCW .(�)- �. hY �L"M -�A X �. �K* Xtw%C x@ kb p8 ]l5 n)ko ]lP 9 k8 k>k" py nC kzk{ ]|{l}s :F'$`W ...u9_C F/9#R : 6.KC O\.JG jR $QW X)'$'- .*.KG F[7W X�G\"S_' - |\.J h7 �' " |�<q7 �R

.(�)«)o=&'- 17)}W F<'- 1#"^' 162K'- )'WW 12Sf'- )'WW D"&K'- �.C 6. hK'- B3"_7 BC .V� )`W X.&H'- �"[MR �_0 m<# �J<'- u<�R �'PVW X./�'-W 1J2^<'- @. hK'-» :u@'"% D96" BJC X,B]'- BC "7 NbCR m<# " |b*R u<�RW X"Q hL"2} : �1?V"J'- �. hYW X ;u29# : 6. hY ;�.CW X hF h/9#R : a,B� lNV :7

.� �¡ X�y X(�$K'- p\R .]3 X�Q��¢£ Xu@'"% D96" XL$f[7 :0- (�).���¡ X�¢y XF=J3 i+.&'- (�)

X.¤ .�Q ��¥� X�¦ X@~$%# �?Qb"% �?@� ]P &?9j5"% X:*)'- )o7 X.2�z- :0- :.f3R (�).�¥�¡ X�y Xj-.*A Xt` Xj"2<2#"&>A 1= 6>§7

Xj-.?� X�$bG.7 :.]3 X.¤ .�Q ��¥� X�¦ XX?@b("% ;<v8 X:*)'- .qC XBK*.^'- (�).�¥�¡ X�y Xj-.*A

Page 11: الحرية الفكرية

10

"? h >W a LR 6NV �. hYW X�O �.2� WR a._ �� :7 a.}"C a,B� �NV : 6. hK'-W 1+"Y n ;(.2HV �J<' 16*�"o&'- !n"&_9>n-W .(�)«"? hS2�RW

."[Q "Q\-.*T X¡$<q'- m[_7 jU9qG 16* 6.K'- 6jR 1fY57 $Q "[Q "[ 6&?* "7 sS�*W X.2r<' 162I<&'- \$2` :7 k6<qG -�A - �.Y h)S_'- sS�2C 16* 6.K'- 6jR t?J3 �'P0W X:o='- \$2` :7 k6<qG -�A - �.Y j"=3T- BC F[7 u<^[3 "7 -PQW X1%.9J&'- \$2/'- :7 L 6.K9'- m<# �~)G

.16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K<' D$?J7 )*)KG .IJ'- �NK7 $QW � N/_'- @jR B[_G 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'"C XF2<#W �3"V ,-$> XF2<# a1%.9J7 a1 @2+L"} a\$2` 6�R :7 ;L @.K7 � F+"93AW .2�8G :7 h¡$<q'"C X�'� m'A "7 WR 162=J3 WR 162>"2> WR 162#"&9+- .*.KG R)S7 m'A .2]*W X16*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'- N6H&* N7-$_'- �<G 6NV

.O-$> a)2` WR a.2�8G WR a~"/# 6�R :7 N/_'- \$2/'- O"oG BQ "&63A 16* 6.K'- 6jR )�/3 X«O-$>» :~$/3 "7)[#W 1/2/K<' �R XF=J[' �N/_'- hj"#�A " 67R .N/_'- 1_2S� :# 1+L"q'- hN/_'- F63z �16* 6.K'- BC"[* n -P?C X ai�"` aNI� BC "?VL)* B9'-

.~"K'- 1_2S^0 FG-�W F=J3 :7 ,B]'- L 6.K9* jR :I&h* nW XF=J3 ¤"/['- :7 " |_>-W |n"o7 " |7$&# 16* 6.K'- 1'8=7 !P}R )`W

.� �¡ X�y X.� .D XL$f[7 :0- (�)

Page 12: الحرية الفكرية

11

:# F<�C @sM -�A � B[* l)'-W B>"2='-W B#"9+n-W BJ=<J'- 1&2/'- N 6I]* � "3.�# BC � sSMRW X� F9/S> B9'- !n"o&'- B&2<_G WR 6B>"2> aD"f3 WR i&9o7 WR a\.C 6�R t*$/9' 16*L"2_&'- ~W)'- �_0 "?6[]G B9'- pW.K'- �_0 6jR m69Y X�'� m'A "7 WR i%W 6t9* Xg.}R a~W\ jW§� BC N 6})9'- �'PVW Xg.SI'- 1 6&?7 |( @\"7 N 6I� )`W ."?G-.*.SG 16*$'WR BC p$_]'- .*.KG j-$[# t7z- :# L\" 6�'- j"=3T- c$/K' B&'"_'- j5#T- 6\-$7 :7 �R.'- 1* 6.Y BC 6uK'- )YR 6NI'» :�© ( 6\"&'- BC ,"oC X()K69&'- X.2�8G �R jW\ :7 ,-Ld- B6[SG 16* 6.Y N&]* 6uK'- -PQW X.2S_9'-W �R 1^>-$0 L"ICz-W !"7$<_&'- N/3W B 6/<GW ZKS'- �'PVW

.(�)«162C-.ro'- \W)K'- :# ~U_&0 NM-$G 1<2>W j4./'- !"*4 BC N 6789'- ~5} :7 F[# ZKS3 �P'- D$?J&'-W X¨.9J h7 6B+L"} a)2` 6�R :7 - |L @.K7 N/_'- � 6.K9* jR $Q t*.I'-

.O)YW N/_'- 1^<=' 1_%"} FG"#"[` j$IG Z2K0 :7 �)?3 Xt*.I'- j4./'- BC D$?J&'- �'� :# ZKS3 "7)[#W N?C XD$?J&'- -PQ O"oG D5>T- 1*vL �2>8G m'A �'� ~5}

ªa\W)Y 6�R :&%W ªF2<# uC-$* : 6uK<' �U2<I3T- 6k['- BC ,"+ (�)

Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart

.information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers/http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr :.f3R

Page 13: الحرية الفكرية

12

Dg@\"% ]P &? R@b"% Bi@d8 ;8 &d�# NI]0 t*.I'- j4./'- BC � �$r<'- m[_&'"0 � 16* 6.K'- ( 6\"7 \.G t' "[3"I7A BC �2' F63R �'� m[_7 �2'W X:2'"o7 BC g$> X.�"S7 B9'- !"*d- :7 )*)_'- BC D$?J&'- !-\.J7 WR s757 )M.3 jR

." |#"SG "Q)[# �6 $9[> :"&?C X"&?2'A "3.�R j-P<'- jn"o&'- " 67R

F'$` "?[7 �i%-$7 ( 6)# BC \LW "7 $QW X)2S_'- .*.KG :� R#$% w95 l8 n� p8 kNkV k� X k8 k# w9� k) kL xYl} w95 l8 n� p8 kN pV n\ k? DkZ �X l8 n� p<l" kD9 ka 9 k8 k#s :m'"_G Dl� kP n%I p� xQ x�k? DkZ xYl} lmlK n0kZ !k"l} �& k< xK k6 �8 �& k? li k# �& k5 l8 n� �8 �& k( k� kC p@? l@ nbkV kP w9� k) kL kD9 ka Dl} k# �& k5 l8 n� �8 �& k( k� kC p@? l@ nbkV kP �X l8 n� n8 kI p0 k# n� pWx" �# pQ k� �* nI k� Xl8 kD9 ka �& k( k� kC p@? l@ nbkG k# lmlK n0kZ !k"l} �& k< xK k6 �8 �& k? lQ kP ��9k J |8 n� pjk5 nJ ko k# n� pWk5 nJ ko �* nI k� Xl8 n� pWl{9 k<n? kZ ]lP lI n� xK"9lo pm RK"% p� pa pz lL% k� p? kYs :m'"_G F'$`W X(�)tw&k5 l8 n� �8 kXJ la9 k6 k8 lB k@ k� k� p*9 k' nql} pm pG kC9 xd kW kP kD9 k<n? k$% p� �GQ x\ k� 9 k<lo � pa pz lL% k� p? X lW/k" k# X(�)t�&k( k� kC p@? l@ nbkG n# kZ n� pj pG kI n6 la n# kZ n� pWJlK n0kZ kDI p< l' n)pG 9 k8 l� k_ n#kZ nX l8 %I p"9 k� 9 k<l" kD# piI p'k? x� p~ n� ljl�9 k6|{ Xl8 kD# p@ l09 k� p? kX? lzx"% k#s :m'"_G F'$`W :I'W .*.K9'- m[_&0 \LWW �(2)t9 x_9 k<kV k? DkZ lNn( k� X |8 �& k( k� kC p@? l@ nbkV kP

.(�))<S'- (L$> BC «&(�C R>P» .2S_90.©� 1*d- X,"=['- (L$> (�)

. © 1*d- X()x"&'- (L$> (�).� 1*d- X1'\"o&'- (L$> (�)

.��1*d- X)<S'- (L$> (�)

Page 14: الحرية الفكرية

13

$QW XF[# ZKS3 �P'- "[#$%$&0 F' 1`5# n ~"&_9>n- -PQW �P'- «'"S'- D"&9Qn- m<# F9'n\ Z2Y :7 6nA X16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- 1623"=3T- 16* 6.K'- i`$&' a�"I_3- BC X)2S_'- .*.K90 D5>T- OnWR - |)x"> j"V �P'- 6c.'- D"f3 m<# Bb/* F<_+ �P'- .7z- �1 67"_0 F' � 6.�W Xi`-$'- .7z- 1<7"_7 D5>T- F_7 N7"_GW XD5>T- NS` pL"/9'- F=J3 �`$'- BC u 6/KGW XOL-.&9>- :7 i[&G B9'- PC"[&'-

.B#"&9+n- j�-$9'"0 6Nq* n "&0 i&9o&'- !"/S� :20 BC "7 !LP3 "7)[# j-.&# (R.7- j"=' m<# \LW "7 :]{9^"% pB kZ k@ n8% l�k"9 k� nfl}¬ :m'"_G ~"/C X�)/&'- �20 BC 17)q<' "?[^0 k�{kZ k>x{l} ]|5 l8 nNx( k\ kV kP w%C x@ kb p8 ]l5 n)ko ]lP 9 k8 k>k" py nC kzk{ ]|{l} |u kC kD% k@ n< l� Z2K0 X" |/<^7» �R (% wC x@b8) F'$/0 \$�/&'-W X(�)­ p�JlK k'n"% p;J l< x6"% WR F*)'-W 1^<> �'� BC ,-$> X16*.]0 a1^<> 16*z " |_%"} j$I* n N&_* N0 X a)YR 17)} BC N})* nW X a)Yz N&_* n $?C X:*.}d- j"^<> :7 FI<&* "7 BC :*.}d- D"7R - �.Y j$I2C XF920 D)q*W F<' -PQW �(�)«F' "|[27R " |7\"} OL"S9#"0 F<'- D"7R - |)S#W Xt?Q"oG F=J3 1_2S� :7W X"?`"2> :7 " |/<^[7 j$I* )` 1*d- BC .*.K9<' .2=J9'- "7 �_S0 B/9<* )` ;.2=JG $QW Xj-.&# (R.7- F9/<�R �P'- LP['- X16* 6.K'-W F<' 16*\$S_'- :20 1`5_'- :7 XBG8* "7 BC F' ¨ 6._9[>

.�£ 1*d- Xj-.&# ~4 (L$> (�) X�5&'- L-\ XD�©©  X�¦ XDg@\"% ]A# X8 @J6dG X:2=Y )&K7 )2='- XF<'- NbC :.f3R (�)

.��¥ ¡ X£y Xj"[S' X!W.20

Page 15: الحرية الفكرية

14

16* 6.K0 {SG.&'- "[#$%$&' |,-)90- F2<# �2>89'- i2^9=3 n "[6[I'W ." |b*R j"&*T-W .IJ'- "?2'A UIG.* ()#"`W R)S&V .IJ'-

(.�"S&'- .2� 1'n)'- !-� !"*d- BC ZKS'- ~W"K[> X�'P'W )[9=G B9'- ()#"/'- BQ 16* 6.K'- OPQ 6jR L"S9#"0 X.IJ'- 16* 6.Y m<#

.tQ.2� WR :2V.]&<' "?0"^} BC "?2'A

***

Page 16: الحرية الفكرية

15

&R?@Wd"% &R? R@b"% *Ijd<" &RJ6J_rV"% y9?�%

B9'- !"*d- :7 \)# c"^[9>- ~W"K[> "[63R m'A " |J34 "3.�R 1_0LR BQW X16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- 1'8=7 m<# 1 6&?7 1'n\ !-� "Q.S9_3 NM80 F�"SGL-W 6D"# NI]0 16* 6.K'- R)S&' � 6>§* "7 "?[7 ��"[MR "?[7W X,"0d- )x"/# :7 �`$&'- ~W"[9* "7 "?[7W Xj"=3T- :*$IG D$* BC p"=K'- 162b` BC 16*\.J'- 162'W§=&'- R)S7 m'A \$_* "7 D"&G :20W j"=3E' 162?'T- (P}-§&'- :20 {0.* "7 "?[7W X17"2/'-

.F2<# 1 6oK'-

&J5?IWV"% &R? R@b"% : wY R#Z F<'- 6jR :62SG B9'- �<G BQW X16* 6.K'- 1'8=&' 162=2>8G ;!"*4 1 6&� m<# 1^<='- �<&* $?C XO)20 j"=3T- !-L"2} N_+ )` m'"_G g)?'- L"9qG jR �<&G B9'- F9 �/ ®< �} 1_2S� :7 ; �"3 �'�W XFG\-LA

.162[*$I9'- 16* 6.K'- m[_7 $Q -PQW X~5b'- L"9qG jRW

Page 17: الحرية الفكرية

16

p�9 k5 n? kQ k0 k# * lXnJ kV kd ke k# w9{9 k6l" k# * lXnJ k5 nJ k� pm x" N k' nvk{ n�k" kZs :m'"_G ~"` ~"`W X 6.]'- u*.�W .2q'- u*.� X:2/*.^'- �R �(-)t lXn? kQ nvx5"% ~"`W �(+)t9 k0% kI n\kG k# 9 k0 kCI pv pP 9 kj k< kjn" kr kP*9 k0% xI k_ 9 k8 k# �� ndk{ k#¬ :m'"_G m^#R F<'"C X(�)­ w%CI pd ka 9 x8l} k# w%@ la9 ke 9 x8l} kNJl( x6"% p�9 k5 n? kQ k0 9x{l}¬ :m'"_G N6H&G °\"S7 m<# O.^CW Xw9[9=*W N6<K*W . 6IJ* |5/# j"=3T- �!"*d"0 j$[62S* |5>LW ,"2S3R F' Z_0W X162' 6Wz- 1*-)?'- .M"[# L"9q* � B'"9'"0 � $QW X1*-)?'-W 6uK'- N6H&G t?&2'"_G 6jR :2Q-.S'-W F<'- O"^#R "7 i`$7 :7 :*.C"I'- WR :*.V"]'- \-)# BC j$I* jR

.L"29}n- 16* 6.Y :7 "|[*$IG m<# F'5f0 B/<h* jR 6)0 n B[*$I9'- )_hS'- 6jR "[Q )o3 "[ 6<_'W 12[*$I9'- 16* 6.K<' j"=3T- F<'- ,"^#A 6jR m[_&0 XB_*.]9'- )_hS'- j"=3T- N 6& hY �P'- LW)'"0 1^SG.7 162?'A a1&IY :7 ;i0"3 $Q "&63A m<# j"=3T- \$+W :7 1*"r'- u2/KG m'A |n$MW F<2_JG 162'W§=7 m%L m<# ~$�K'- R)S7 .S# 16*\.J'- 12Y"['- :7 X¨Lz- OPQ 6B?'T- �W.]&'- u2S^G .S# 16*L"bK'- 12Y"['- :7W Xm'"_G F<'- !-\$+$&'- :7 - |.2HV F' . 6q>W j"=3T- u<}W O\-LR �P'- .2SI'-

.F<+R :7 !"_*.]9'- 6jR )o3 jR $Q B_2S^'"C X�">z- -PQ m<#W

.�¢-  !"*d- X)<S'- (L$> (�). -± j"9*d- X�&]'- (L$> (�)

.� 1*d- Xj"=3T- (L$> (�)

Page 18: الحرية الفكرية

17

j$I* )` F63�C �B[*$I9'- R)S&'- -PQ p.% m'A F 6+$9G n 162?'T- F 6+$9G "&63AW Xm'"_GW F3"KS> F<'- 1Y"> :# )2_S'- ZS_'- :7 " |#$3 N<q'- i`-$7 m<# F2S[9'- .S# X16* 6.K'- �<G D-)q9>- 1_2S� m'A � 6\§* �P'-W X"?Q"oG j"=3T- F2C i/* �P'- B/2S^9'- WR �.f['- $QW X 6N+W 6U# F<'- (\-LA 6)%W F9K<�7 6)% $Q "7 m'A j"=3T"0

.12Gd- :*W"[_'- ~5} :7 sb69* )` "7

�9o�% Q�9\� *98Z &R? R@b"% :9wJ{9~ 1'8=7 :# � 6)K9G !"*4 ( 6)# t*.I'- j4./'- BC !\LW )`W t?G\"S# WR 1�L-$9&'- t?9/*.� m<# �L"�9`n-W ,"0d- ��"S 6G- � 6&<GW XF</# t2IKG m'A j"=3T- h!"*d- OPQ F l+$GW .1> 6)/&'- O,"04 F2<# �)+W "7 6NV 1>-L\ BC Xt<_'- i`-$7W X1*-)?'- .M"[# t?_S6G- j"Q.S'-W N2')'"0 F2<# tQ "&0 j"=3T- i[9`- -��C X:2' 6Wz- t<_'- F9SH* t' "7 �"S6G- BC j"=3E' 1 6oY 5C 6nAW X1#"[/'- i`$7 :7

.,"0d- �()2/# �'� j"V $' m69Y Xt2<='- u^[&'-W n� pj kP* kXJ|"9 k� n� p0�9kog % nI kdn" kZ n� pjx{l}s :� L"['- NQR :# � m'"_G ~"` WR .�0)G WR a.2IJG jW\ :7 j$#.=h* �R �(-)t kDI p� k@ nj p? n� l0 lC9k~g !kK k�

.N 678G !kK k� 9x{l} k# �& x8 pZ !kK k� 9k{�9kog 9k{ nQ kS k# 9x{l} %I p"9 k� nNko¬ :m'"_G ~"`W

.±¢-¥© :j"9*d- X!" 6C"�'- (L$> (�)

Page 19: الحرية الفكرية

18

�@? lzx{ X |8 �& k? n@ k� ]lP k>lKn( k� Xl8 9k5 nK k_ nCkZ 9 k8 k>l" kz ka k# * kD# pQkV nj �8 � l0 lC9k~g kD# pQkV n\ �8 � l0 lC9k~g !kK k� 9x{l} k# �& x8 pZ !kK k� 9k{�9kog 9k{ nQ kS k# 9x{l} 9 k0I pP k@nV p8 k�9 k� xYl} 9 k<lo 9x{l} %I p"9 k� n� pa�9kog lm nJ kK k� n� �GQ kS k# 9 x<l8 h kQ n0krlo � pWpV n� lS nI k" k#kZ k�9 k� * WR N_J'- BC .2r'- �"S6G- $Q ,-)9`n-W .(�)­ kD# p@lP9 ka lmlo �pV nK l_ nC pZ "?2<# UIG.* B9'- ()#"/'- N6H&* �P'- .IJ'- BC �'PVW w?['- m'A )[9=* n ,-)9`n- 6jR "[Q ¨-.9Cn-W .w?['- WR N_J'- �'� BCW .t?o?[7W ,"0d- N_C N6H&G "?3$V g$> 162/^[7 a()#"` pm RK"% k� k { kZ 9 k8 !k"l} n% nIk"9 k'kG n� pjk" kNJl� % kfl} k#¬ :m'"_G ~$/* .}4 ai%$7 n� p0 p�9kog kD9 ka nI k" k#kZ 9k{�9kog lm nJ kK k� 9k{ nQ kS k# 9 k8 9k5 p( n6 kA n%I p"9 k� l�I p_ x@"% !k"l} k# kNJl� % kfl} k#¬ :" |b*R m'"_G ~$/*W X(�)­ kD# pQkV njk? kY k# w9� nJ ke kDI p< kK n'k? kY kD9 ka nI k" k#kZ 9k{�9kog lm nJ kK k� 9k{ nQ kS k# 9 k8 p;l( xV k{ nNko %I p"9 k� pm xK"% k� k { kZ 9 k8 %I p'l( xG% p� pjk"

.(�)­ l@J l' x6"% lu% kz k� !k"l} n� p0I p� nQk? pD9 k)nJ x�"% ,-)9`n- BC w?['- �'� ~ 6$K9* �2V s&<3 X.}4 ai%$7 BCW g$` :7 ( 6$` 6�z 1?+-$&'- B#)9=G B9'- 162S�_'- :7 a1'"Y m'A "|2C"V �'� .S h9#- Z2Y X,"0d- F2<# "7 m'A F 6+$9G B9'- .22r9'- %I p"9 k� �y9k5 |J ko 9k5 pG9 k?g n� ljnJ kK k� !kKnV pG % kfl} k#¬ :m'"_G ~"` ��"C)'-W (.��[<'

.(�)­ n� pa p�9kog pQ p( n'k? kD9 ka 9 x< k� n� pa xQ p�k? DkZ pQ? l@ p? �N pS kC xYl} % kz k0 9 k8

.��-�� j"9*d- X�.}U'- (L$> (�).�¢� 1*d- X()x"&'- (L$> (�)

.�� 1*d- Xj"&/' (L$> (�).�� 1*d- X8S> (L$> (�)

Page 20: الحرية الفكرية

19

:t�?3"=' m<# m'"_G F<'- O"IY "7 BC F�9*"� ��*)/9'- «�<S*W X(�)­9 kjlo 9k{ k@ k8kZ pm RK"% k# 9k{�9kog 9 kjnJ kK k� 9k{ nQ kS k# n%I p"9 k� w& k� lA9 kP n%I pK k' kP % kfl} k#¬ -PQ BCW XF<'- m'A ,"0d- !">L"&7 :7 O$�L-$G "7 j$S=[* Z2Y p"IGL"0 R)S* "7 ~ @WR �P'- Xj"=3T- 162[Q� BC (�)~�"[9'- m'A (L"�A U}W :7 p.?* 6t� X�'PV "?63R ht<_* $QW 8^q'- WR 1]Y"J'- "&?0 .7z- L)�* �P'- p-$�'-W �W._&'"0 "?J�2' �.2&b'-

. 6N+W 6U# F<'- :# !"*d- "?2<# UIG.G B9'- 162J<q'- 6j�C XD 6)/G "7 m<# " |=2>8G ,"0d- )x"/# 6jR B[_* X,"0²' m&#z- �"S6Gn- 6D� BC 16234./'- L 6.SG B9'- 1&2/'- FG-� BC N6H&* n t?o?[7W t?C-.#RW tQ)2'"/GW t<_'- .2*"_&' �'� 6NV ibq* jR BrS[* N0 X�"S6Gn- :7 j$<'- �'� X.2IJ9'-W N 6789'- m'A a(\.J7 6NV ibqG Z2K0 X1*-)?'-W N/_'-W 162_`$7 :7 ,"0d- �³'WR FI<&* " 6&# a~U_&0 XN2<K9'-W .60)9'-W m69Y XF=2>"YRW j"=3T- .#"]7 m<# {rbG 16*$^<> WR 162J�"# "?[7 FJ`$7 P}R Xa(\.J7 6NI' 1&2/'- )*)KG m'A j"=3T- NMW "7 -�A

.�± 1*d- X�-.#z- (L$> (�) FJa» :F'$` F[# \LW Z2Y Xm[_&'- -PQ m'A (L"�A P F<'- ~$>L :# 6�W.&'- BC 6N_' (�) :~"` ª:x"I' -PQ 6jA F<'- ~$>L "* :-$'"` X�W{9JVP c6P# �a�96{ !�q %f} p�95"% 9j �?Z �Wo ~$>L "* :-$'"` X@W5<"% X� ]j5"%# �#@'<"9o @8$% �Va@G %f} �Wo kFJa �m58 �QeZ# ��'{ �#@'<"%# 9 wP#@'8 @W5<"% �V?ZC %f} �Wo FJa �m58 RQeZ# X�'{ ~"` ª:x"I' -PQ 6jA XF<'- XD�©   XQ�%#`"% ;<v8 X(�Q ¢±) .I0 B0R :0 B<# :*)'- L$3 XB&H2?'- :.f3R .«% w@W58

.� �-� ¢¡ X±y Xj"[S' X!W.20 X162&<_'- e9I'- L-\

Page 21: الحرية الفكرية

20

$Q )/9_* "&0 " |7-U9'-W X1 6</9=&'- F9#"[` :7 " | 5^3- X" |bCL WR |n$S` �'� 1^<> :7 N/_'- .*.KG \)�0 1*d- 6jR B[_* -PQW � 6uK'- F63R O\-)97-W j"=3T- 162�q� :7 - |,U+ N6H&* �P'- XB+L"q'- .6�§&'-

.,"0d- �-.G $QW X�$[_&'- Bq*L"9'-

�&RJ[I�L «�9o�%» D%I5'" N0 1&*.I'- !"*d- 6jR X"[Q :QP'- m'A L\"S9* �P'- �%�6"% @:I'W "&' at*$/G 162<&_0 D$/* jR j"=3T- m<# 6jRW ,"0d- j-$[# !.V� �-.G :7 j"=3T- L 6.K9* jR $Q O)2JG "7 m�`8C B'"9'"0W XF2<# tQ n R)S&V 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- �*.IG 6jR ¨.9J3 "&[20 XO\-)+RW Fx"04 :7 j"=3T- m<# ¨._* "7 6NV N&]* "&63AW X�'� BC .�K[*

.t2Q"J7W )x"/#W !"Q"o6G-W aL"ICR :!"?+ ( 6)# :7 �'� m<# u%Iv"%#

BY$* �P'- .7z- �i&o'- 1r2�0 \LW «,"0d-» �J' 6jA : wY R#Z |1_C\ :*\$+$7 ,"0d- ,n§Q �2' �A �1�L-$9&'- 1<=<='- m[_&0 "[' B3"=3T- F�-.G �R XBq*L"9'- j"=3T- \-)97- t?0 \-. h* "&63AW X |()Y-W F2C N6H& hG 6B<S` i&9o7 :# "[Q � 6)K93 "[7\ "7W .F2'A B&9[* �P'- (L"�T- N6H&* aP³[2Y «,"0d-» �J<C X162S=3 162#"&9+- |()YW 1<2S/'- ,"[0z- "?2C �L-$9* B9'- 1<2S/'- N}-\ BC ,"&93n- 1_2S^' 162_`-$'- .�'� m'A "7W X"?2<# -$+L\ B9'- tQ)2'"/GW t?&2`W ,"0d- 1^<>

Page 22: الحرية الفكرية

21

\$�/&'- 6jR .S9_3 jR � F2+$9'- -PQ m'A - |\"[9>- � i2^9=3W O)2'"/GW i&9o&'- !-\"# iS^* �P'- Bq*L"9'- �-.9'- $Q !"*d"0 WR " �20UY |,"&93- WR " �2S �=�3 |,"&93- N6H7 ,-$> XF&2Q"J7W O)x"/#W F&2`W 162M$�} 16*R «,"0d-» j-$[_' h)o3 n �'P0W .�'� m'A "7 WR " �27$`

.1?+ :7 -PQ .~"o&'- -PQ BC .IJ'- 16* 6.K' � 6>§G .VP'- 1J3d- 16234./'- !"*d- �3"V -�A :9wJ{9~ D"7R 16* 6.K'- �<9' � 6>§G "?63�C X162q*L"9'- F962M$�q0 �-.9'- D"7R g$`R � "?9_2S^0 � ´*L"9'- 1^<> 6jz �m' ®WR u*.^0 .M"_&'- .IJ'- !"62M$�} :7 a,B� m'A "?' 6$K* ´*L"9'- 6jz �.%"K'- 1^<> :7 i7 |1?+-$7 "?9?+-$7 BC j"=3T- �$`W j$I* �'P'W X!-P'- "?0 j"=3T- 6�9K* B9'- (.M"_&'- L"ICz- N 6I]G "&[20 X!-P'- XFG-� :# " |+L"} "|³2� F+-$* "&V j"=3T- F?+-$* �P'- .}d-

.~"K'- 1_2S^0 �'� :7 N?>R -PQW 6nA X�'PV 162M$�} ,"0d- 16*$%"&' �2' F63A Xg.}R (L"S_0W N�* ) - |)x-� " |7-.9Y- i`$&'- WR (.IJ'- s[&G 16*$%"&'- 6jR 1?+ :7 m'A N�* t?3-)+WW �"['- �$<> BC - |L 6PoG WR X1>-)/'- 6)Y m'A XF2<#W .t?[# F'"�J3- :I&* n t?G-W� :7 - |,U+ F' tQL"S9#- 6)Y 16*)/# 17$f[7 �<9&* B>"2> WR B#"&9+- aL"�A 6NV 1*d- N&]9C $'W XF9KG �$b[&'- \.J'- m<# - |.2�8G �L"&G jR "?38� :7 12&2`W WR (.M"_7 "7 a1& @f[7 WR apUK' j"=3T- B&9[* )/C .- |.M"_7 j"V

Page 23: الحرية الفكرية

22

1_2S� :7W X�-.9'- WR ´*L"9'- :7 - |,U+ N6H&G nW X)?_'- 1H*)Y m<# � 1 67"_0 � L"�T- WR 1& 6f[&'- WR pUK'- ¨.J* jR ,"&93n- N�K*W XF 6 } BC .2=*W XFo?[7 w?9[*W XOL"ICR �u[9_* jR \.J'- {r% �KG � " �*L$_� n WR " �*L$_� � ��.* jR �-� Fx"&93- ,- 6.+ F2C )o* )` �P'- �`$'- BC X1 67"_0 B&2f[9'- WR B0UK'- L"�T-

.�-� WR �`$&'- -PQ .2� BC 6uK'- 1'">.'-W 1*v.'- uCW \ 6)K9* aL"�A 6�z ,"&93n- 6jA X~$/3 "[QW m<# L"�T- N&_* (.2SV "*"b/0 {SG.* "&0 "?/2/KG m<# N&_* B9'- m'A j$&9[&'- m_=* �'� N+R :7W X("2K'- WR i&9o&'- BC "?/2/KG !"*.o&' " |_SG 1# 6$[97 ��`-$7W a!"&<V .S# �'� u2/K9' L"�T- !"&<I'- j$IG 6jR �LW.b'- :7 �2'W X�-)Yz- 1V.YW i`-$'- ;�7"Q 1 6&� N0 X1'">.'-W 1*v.'- �<G i7 " |&x-\ |1&o=[7 �`-$&'-W 1V.YW X127$2'- ("2K'- !-)2/_G F%.JG X�'� BC 8^q'- :7 N_J'- !- 6\L WR 12G-P'- ��-$['- uCW e6</9G B9'- F=J3 j"=3T- ( 6.&9=&'- 1_+-.&'- ¨.J* �P'- .7z- ��'� m'A "7W 162+L"q'- � 6>§* �P'- B<}-)'- (�)sM"[9'- �-$3R :7 a�$[V Xtx-)'- )/['-W mo9VW"# mK" :~"` ª:&' :"[<` .&bJ�5"% X?Q"%» :P F<'- ~$>L :# Z*)K'- BC \LW )` (�) @8ro R�Vj? Y X8» :P F[# g.}R 1*-WL BCW X«�jV R89�# XJ<K6<"% & R<�$# m"I_@"# & R89'"# m898:# mo9VW"# m"I_@"# mK" 9 wb[9{ l�<?#  (�? �" X8# ��j58 �JKP XJ<K6<"% �09�8Z &89J\"% *I? mK"% Q5� w&"`58 �95"% ���Z RD}» :P F[#W X«�j58 �JKP XJ<K6<"% N+R :7 �R.'- ,-)0A BC ¡5}T- 1K2�['"0 \$�/&'-W X«m\K¡" &bJ�R5"9o m�CZ ]P D%`J8 X)&K7 X�.?]*.'- :.f3R X1K2�['- ~$Y Z*\"Yz- :7 )*U&<' .s�[9=&'- 1K<�7

.s�['- p"0 X��± ¡ X�y Xj-.*A XZ*)K'- L-\ X�Q���¥ X�¦ X&<Wb"%

Page 24: الحرية الفكرية

23

16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 N 6I]* X-PQ m<#W .(�) 6uK'"0 BM-$9'- R)S&' $QW X" �2]7"Q - |.7R �2'W X16*.]S'- pL"o9'- L 6$^9' 16*LW.% |1+"Y

.F<'- j��0 XZKS'- !"62� BC " �2<7 O)[# �6 $9[> "7

&R?i@d"% &RJ"#�6<"% :9w "9~ O �)YW j"=3T- 6jR :# ai%$7 :7 .HVR BC t*.I'- j4./'- � 6)KG .x"> jW\ - |\.C �F<'- BG8* X17"2/'- D$* BC F'"&#R 162'W§=7 N 6&K9* :20.`z-W 1<x"_'"V XF=[+ :7 t?0 {SGL- :7 @NV 6jRW X:2&'"_'- jW\ :7 t?_2^* :*P'- :2�"2]'"V XF=[+ .2� :7 WR Xi&9o&'-W

.162'W§=&'- p"=Y BC "|³2� j$< 6I]* n XF<'- l& k89kJ l\ n"% k* nIk? lmJlGg n� pj �K pa k#s :m'"_G F<'- ~$ )o3 ~"H&'- N2S> m<_C k� x#kZ n� pa9k5 n\ kK kL 9 k< ka h ki% k@ pP 9k{I p< pV n� lS nQ k\ k" k#¬ :m'"_G F'$`W �(+)tw%i n@ kP p� pa�9 k' kd pe n� pW k' k8 h k@k{ 9 k8 k# n� pa lCI pj p¢ �% kC k# n� pa9k5 n" xI kL 9 x8 �pV na k@kG k# �B x@ k8 9 x8 � pW5 k� xN k� k# n� pWk5 nJ ko k; x) k\ xG Q k\k" �9 ka k@ pe n� pWJlP n� pjx{ kZ n� pV n< k� k£ kX? lzx"% lm |8 pZ k# * lmJ lLkZ nX l8 p� n@ k<n"% �@ ld k? k* nIk?¬ :m'"_G F'$`W X(�)­ kDI p< p� n kG n� pV5 pa �(1)tlmJl5 n� p? �D nr ke �zl� k8 nIk? n� pjn5 |8 �¤ l@ n8% |N pWl" * lmJl5 ko k# lmlV k( lA9 k[ k# * lmJlo kZ k# �'�W X162#"&9+n- .�z- BC t2/'- 16*L-.&9>- j"&b' 12#"&9+n- �x"µ$'- g)YA �<G (�) Rcb"9o %I[%IG# y9b"9�"% %IK<�# %I58g X?z"% Y} � �@6L ]d" D96{:% RD}¬ :m'"_G F'$ $Q

.�-� j"9*d- X.�_'- (L$> :.f3R .t@(�"9o %I[%IG#.©£ 1*d- Xt*.7 (L$> (�)

.©� 1*d- XD"_3z- (L$> (�).�±-�� !"*d- X�S# (L$> (�)

Page 25: الحرية الفكرية

24

pm k" p¥ l@ n¡p{ k# lm l\ p5 p� ]lP p� k@l�¦ kq p�9 k5 n8 k n" kZ �D9 k6{l} xN pa k#¬ :m'"_G F'$`W k* nIkJ n"% k> l6 ndk5lo ! kd ka k>ko9 kV ka nZ k@ n�% * w%CI p�5 k8 p�9 k\ nK k? w9o9 kV la l& k89kJ l\ n"% k* nIk? 9 k<x{l� kP xN k� X k8 k# lm l6 ndk5l" HQkV njk? 9 k<x{l� kP h kQkV n0% lX x8 * w9(J l6 kA k>nJ kK k� k� k'n( k{ !xV kA kXJlo |z k' p8 9 x5 pa 9 k8 k# h k@ nLpZ kC n£ l# �B kC l£% k# pC l kG kY k# 9 kjnJ kK k� �N lOk? u2/KG O"o6G- BC � 6.K9G "? 6<V !"*d- �<G 6j8VW �(�)­ wYI p_ kC {rbG jR :I&* B9'- 162+L"q'- g$/'- O"oG j"=3T- g)' j�-$9'- m'A "7W X!"#"[/'- B6[SG BCW X�`-$&'- �"q6G- BC FG\-LA m<# " |>"2` aL$K&V F=J3 m'A .f[* jR j"=3T- m<# 6jR B[_* -PQW X�'� " |&o=[7 �'� :7 j"V "&C XF2C .6�§*W F'$Y LW)* "7W i&9o&'"0 F3$I' �2'W X�'� N+z |1&2` e=9V- X"?0 :7§* B9'- F&2` i7 �16*.IJ'- F`"=3RW FC-.#R WR O)2'"/G WR FG-\"# WR i&9o&'- t2` :7 OP}R i7W XF*)' 6uK'- .2*"_7W Xj"=3T- t2` �J'"} -�A OPQ 6jz �'P0 6uK9>- XF&2`W F`5}R WR OL"ICR 17$f[7 WR FJ`-$7 BC "?0 �'� BC F_7 j$I* :'W X162'W§=&'- N 6&KG t'"# BC (P}-§&'- .6�8G : 6&7 �`$&'- BC Ov"V.� nW Xt?/CW L"> :*P'- Ov"0.`R m'A "? hox"93 i+.G "?V.9* WR j"=3T- "?0 P}8* B9'- 1*-)?'"C Xt?0 FJ`-$7W j"=3T- !-L"2} 162'W§=7 jW.}d- N 6&K9* nW XF=J3 t?J`-$7W :*.}d- !-L"2} 162'W§=7 N 6&K9* n F63R "&V XF'"_CRW

.t?'"_CRW.�£-�� !"*d- X,-.>T- (L$> (�)

Page 26: الحرية الفكرية

25

!-L-$K'- �_0 � @�` B9'- !"*d- :7 .2HV BC )o3 "[ 6<_'W j"V ,-$> X:2#$S9&'-W :2_0"9'- :20 X17"2/'- D$* BC �.oG B9'- -P?' - |)2V8G X 6:o'- WR �3T- :2�"2]0 :2<@H �& h7 j$#$S9&'- ,n§Q "&2C ¶.Y j"=3T- 6jR m<# B[S&'-W X162'W§=&<' �\.J'- )_hS'- .g)?'-W 6uK'- .2*"_7 uCW FG-L"2} 162'W§=7 N 6&K9* F@[I'W XL"9q* lm RKl" n%# p£ k@ko k#¬ :F'$/0 m'"_G F<'- F2IK* "7 !-L-$K'- �<G :7 �pV{kZ nN kj kP w9'k( kG n� pWk" 9 x5 pa 9x{l} n%# p@k( nWkV n_% kX? lz xKl" �9 kd k' �O"% k�9 k\ kP w9'J l< kS n� pa9k5 n? kQ kjk" pm RK"% 9k{% kQ k0 nI k" n%I p"9 k� �� n] ke Xl8 lm RK"% lu% kz k� nX l8 9 x5 k� kDIp5 n� �8 pD9 k)nJ x�"% k�9 k� k# * �§J lb x8 Xl8 9k5 k" 9 k8 9k{ n@k( k[ n* kZ 9k5 n� l kSkZ 9k5 nJ kK k� �% kI k_ n� pW pV nd kK nLkr kP n� pW �GQ k� k# k# |c kbn"% kQ n� k# n� pa kQ k� k# km RK"% xDl} p@ n8 k$% k] lO p� 9 x<k" kU kP ]l" n� pV n( kvkV n_9 kP n� pW pG nI k� ki DkZ xYl} �D9 k) nK p_ X |8 � pWnJ kK k� k]l" kD9 ka 9 k8 k# ]|{l} x] lL l@ n� p<lo n� pV{ kZ 9 k8 k# n� pW lL l@ n� p<lo n9 k{ kZ 9 x8 � pW k6 pd{kZ n%I p8Ip" k# ]l{I p8I pKkG X(�)­ ��Jl" kZ �u% kz k� n� pjk" kXJ l<l"9 x�"% xDl} pNn( k� Xl8 lDI p< pV na k@ nekZ 9 k<lo py n@ kd ka :*P'- ,"J_b'- �³'WR :# �"C)'- m<# jWL\"` jW.SI9=&'- 5C X:2Q-.0 WR woY jW\ :7 tQ$_S6G-W Xt?' tQL$7R D"7� -$& 6<> nW Xt?2<# F3$%._* "7 BC 162'5/9>"0 . 6IJ9' t?'$/# -$V 6.K* t'W t?S<=* a{r% 6�R t?2<# �<&* t' F63z �tQL-�WR N&K* j"^2]'- �/9'- B9'- F<x">W � 6.Y "&63AW XL"29}n- BC t?9* 6.YW t?G\-LA ¦"/3 1*$/G m<# -$<&# $'W X�'� N+z t?9 6<%8C Xt?J_% ¦"/[0

.��-�� j"9*d- Xt2Q-.0A (L$> (�)

Page 27: الحرية الفكرية

26

."?'5} :7 t?2'A PJ[* jR j"^2]<' :I7R "&' �<G �_b'- m<# D)['- 1'"Y L 6$�* $QW m'"_G F<'- F 6�/* .}4 ;L-$YW �2VW X"23)'- ("2K'- BC FG-L"2} BC 6uK'- .2*"_&' j"=3T- 1J'"q7 F962'W§=7 D"7R j"=3T- �.S2' X17"2/'- D$* BC !"`5_'- 6NV i 6 /9G n%I p'k( xG% kX? lzx"% kX l8 n%I p'l( �G% kX? lzx"% kZ x@ k( kG nfl}¬ :� 6N+W 6U# � ~$/2C XO)YW nI k" n%I p'k( xG% kX? lzx"% k�9 k� k# * pu9k( n_ k$% p� ljlo n� k' x) k\kG k# ku% kz k'n"% n% p#kZ kC k# n� pjk"9 k< n�kZ pm RK"% p� lj? l@ p? k>l" kz ka 9 x5 l8 n%# p� x@k( kG 9 k< ka n� pjn5 l8 kZ x@ k( kV k5 kP wB x@ ka 9k5 k" xDkZ :m'"_G ~$�/*W X(�)­ lC9 x5"% kX l8 kXJ lS lC9 k¡lo � p0 9 k8 k# n� ljnJ kK k� �y% k@ k6 kA n� pa9k?9 k) kL nN l< nbk5 n" k# 9k5 kKJl( k_ %I p'l( xG% %I p5 k8g kX? lz xKl" %# p@ kd ka kX? lzx"% k�9 k� k#¬ ~$/*W X(�)­ kDIpo lf9 kWk" n� pjx{l} �� n] ke X |8 � p09k?9 k) kL nX l8 kXJlK l89 kblo � p0 9 k8 k# kXnJ ko H lzx"9lo kY k# lDg n@ p\n"% % kz kjlo kX l8 n� �{ Xk" %# p@ kd ka kX? lzx"% k�9 k� k#¬ :" |b*R !k"l} n� pj pO n'ko p; lS n@k? n� lj|o kC kQ5 l� kDI pPI p� nI k8 kDI p<l"9 x�"% lfl} h k@kG nI k" k# lm n? kQk? 9 x5 pWk" n� pV{ kZ kY nIk" %# p@k( nWkV n_% kX? lz xKl" %I pd l' nOpV n_% kX? lzx"% p�I p\k? k� nI k\n"% � n'ko n� pa9k{ ni kQ k[ pX nbk{ kZ %I pd l' nOpV n_% kX? lz xKl" %# p@k( nWkV n_% kX? lzx"% k�9 k� * kXJl5 l8 n� p8

.(�)­ kXJ l8 l@ nv �8 �pV5 pa nNko � pa�9 kS nfl} kQ n'ko h kQ pjn"% lX k� j"=3T- "?/<^* B9'- !-.*.S9'- �_S' 6B34./'- �C.'- )o3 )`W X:262#"&9+n- {rb'"0 WR 1³2S'"0 N6H&9G B9'-W X~5b'- OL"29}n B'"9'"0W XL"29}n-W (\-LT- p$<=7 F63R j"=3T- "&?_7 .S9_* B9'-W

.�¥±-�¥¥ j"9*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�).�� 1*d- X!$SI[_'- (L$> (�)

.��-�� j"9*d- X8S> (L$> (�)

Page 28: الحرية الفكرية

27

:m�'"_G ~$/2C XF7"7R 16* 6.K'- �<&* n "&0 P}-§* jR m<# BrS[* n 9 x5 pa n%I p"9 k� n� pV5 pa k�JlP n%I p"9 k� n� lj l6 pdn{ kZ ] l<l"9 k¢ p& kWl�© k<n"% p� p09 xP kIkG kX? lzx"% xDl}¬ n%# p@ lS9 kj pV kP w& k' l_% k# lm RK"% pª nCkZ nX pWkG n�k" kZ n% kIn"9 k� lª nC k$% ]lP kXJ ld k' nOkV n6 p8 kX l8 kXJ ld k' nOkV n6 p<n"% xYl}* w%@J l� k8 ny�9 k_ k# p� x5 kj kS n� p0% k#nr k8 k>l�/k" n# pr kP 9 kjJlP * wUJl( k_ kD# pQkV njk? kY k# w& kKJ lA kDI p'J l)kV n6k? kY lD% kQn" lIn"% k# �9 k6|5"% k# l�9 kS |@"% 6j�C X(�)­ w%CI pd k� w% RI pd k� pm RK"% kD9 ka k# n� pjn5 k� kI pd n'k? DkZ pm RK"% ! k6 k� k>l�/k" n# pr kP B#"&9+n- {rb'- L"�A :7 yW.q'- m<# (L)/'- j"=3T- �597- F63R " |/S=7 �._* j"=3T- 6jz � 6Nb* jR L"9}- �P'- i`$7 BC F<_o* {rb'- �'� )*U* )`W X{rb'- N 6&KG m<# (\W)K7 (L)` �<&* �KG " |&9Y i/2> F63R B[_* -PQW X17W"/&'- :# FG 6$ �_bG WR F2<# F<'- 6BS[' ix- 6.'- �`$&'- ~5} :7 t*.I'- j4./'- :620 )`W .O.2�8G ]l5k{I p� nQk? 9 x<l8 x]k"l} �� kAkZ pX nv |6"% |u kC k�9 k�s "7)[# Q �>$* F[&% :7W XF2C �2_* �P'- 1&V"K'- 1^<='- i&9o7 )�/*W tlmnJ k"l} xX p0 kQnJ ka ]|5 k� n� l@ n�kG xYl} k#¬ X,"=['- :7 t?9#\ ®: �7W U*U_'- (R.7- j"=3T- L-.MA 6jR "[' :620 X(�)­ kXJlK l09 kvn"% kX |8 X pakZ k# xX ljnJ k"l} p� n[kZ (.o?'"0 XF_`$7 .62r* jR F[7 Bb9/* XFx\"S7W F&2 i7 D"o=3n- m<# nW X 6\"b7 6B#"&9+- �>"&G u2/K90 WR Xg.}R ~-U_3n"0 WR X(L"G BC c.9K2> F63�C XL"['- BC F=J3 B/<* jR BC LP_'- j"=3T- �<&*

:~$/* �P'- .#"]'- �'� 1/*.� m<# X1*"?6['-�,"&'"0 @N�9 ®S �G jR ��"6*A ��"6*A hF' ~"`W " |C$9I7 lt�2'- BC hO"/'R

.©©-©± !"*d- X,"=['- (L$> (�).�� 1*d- X�>$* (L$> (�)

Page 29: الحرية الفكرية

28

D9Jo Uo u9\� Y :9 w'o%C k� k'n( k{ !xV kA kXJlo |z k' p8 9 x5 pa 9 k8 k#¬ :m'"_G F<'- ~$` uS> "7 BC "3.V� N/_'- F0 tIK* "7 m'A |(L"�A 1*d- OPQ !.Sh9#- Z2Y X(�)­ wYI p_ kC F<'- 1Y"> :# ;)2_0 s2S/'-W X«j"20 50 p"/_'- sS`» :7 �5/9=7 D$/G jR 6nA aj"=3A 6�R he`"_* n m'"_G F<'"C B'"9'"0W X 6N+W 6U# :7 ~$>.<' �2' �A �~$>.'"0 \$�/&'- $Q -PQW XF2<# 1 6oK'- N_o* "&0 X"?' - |) 6=o7W F<'- 1'">.' " |r 6<S7 F3$V g$> 162M$�} :2Q-.S'-W woK'"0 t?G"#"[` �*.KG BC X�"['- m<# |1 6oY F[7 wU p_ �C¬ :m'"_G F<'- ~$` O) 6V§* )` "7 $QW X162<&_'-W 16*.f['- lN p_ �@"% kQ n'ko �& xv pA lm RK"% !kK k� l�9x5Kl" kDI pWk? xUk�l" kX? lC lz5 p8 k# kX? l@ |�k( �8

.(�)­ w9<J lW kA w%`? l k� pm RK"% kD9 ka k# WR .IC :7 F2<# ¨ �._h* "&0 N/_'- �"[`A "? h/*.^C 1 6oK'- " 67R eS=0 �'� j"V ,-$> XN/_<' 1_[/7 hNxn)'- :IG t' -��C �j"&*A WR X�"[`T- �)?0 j"=3T- "?7 6)/* B9'- 16'\z-W :2Q-.S'- �_% F2'A D 6)/* :7 �W.f' j"=3T- �'� ("#-.7 D)# eS=0 �'� j"V WR 162C"/� WR 162=J3 !"Q"o6G- j"=3A 6NI' 6jz �"?0 i[9/2' (.IJ'-

.�"[`T- u2/KG N+R :7 L"S9#n- :2_0 P}§G jR 6)0 n 162#"&9+- j$+"9K* jW.}4W X162</_'- !n\"_&'- 6nA F_[/* n :7 1 6&HC

.�£ 1*d- X,-.>T- (L$> (�)

.�¥£ 1*d- X,"=['- (L$> (�)

Page 30: الحرية الفكرية

29

X!"6*)*.o9'"0 .2IJ9'- m<# -$0 6L)9* t' t?63z 162 6=Y 1<H7R m'A ap"^} m'A jW.}4W X 6�$` ap"^} m'A j$+"9K* �"6['- �_0W :7 �"q* F63z j"7z"0 6�K* jR m'A y"9K* :7 �"[QW X 6BJ�"# "|3"2YR 1³�"3 X.]S'- B[0 :20 a!"`W.C :7 �'� m'A "7W X a)*)+ 6�R �"%Wz- �_0 :7W X162C"/H'- 162M$�q'-W X120.9'- 1_2S� :7

."Q.2�W X1/</'- 162=J['- �162</# .2� �>R m<# D$/* �"[`T- 6jR � iS^'"0 � B[_* n -PQ ~n)9>n-W 1[Q.S'- m'A F9+"Y 6)=* "&' 6nA :#P* n N/_'- 6j�C 6)0 n � N/_'- m'A |1S=3 � 162+L"} i3-$7 1 6&� @:I'W X(.IC 6�R m<# "Q hL"S9}- 6t9*W N/_'- m'A N})G jR (.IJ'- i2^9=G m69Y "?9'-�A :7

.F7"f3 uCW aP³[2Y )_0 X1 67"9'- 1#"[/'- j"=3E' �<�Y -�A XD 6)/G " 6&7 " | 5^3-W \"J[9>-W X16*.f3 WR (.IC 6�z 1[I&&'- !"62%.J'- N&o7 L"S9}- p"/_'- 6uK9=* n F63�C X~"o&'- -PQ BC 1<&9K&'- 16'\z- 6NV FhHK0 6tG "7 -PQW .\"/9#n- 8^} :62SG $' "7 BC F<'- :7 (P}-§&'-W X«F96*L 6P_7W i^/'- 16*U 6o[7» j-$[# �KG F/J'- ~$MR t<# BC sS`» ()#"` 6jR "Q h\"J7 1o293 m'A �'� BC j$HY"S'- m?93- Z2Y �P'- L$K&'- $Q i[/&'-W NM-$'- j"2S'- N_oG «j"20 50 p"/_'- 6�R U 6o[9* B'"9'"0W �p"/_<' j"=3T- c"/K9>- 1'8=7 F'$Y LW)G F9#"[` WR XF_^/0 j"=3T- N6<_9*W Xj"=3T- F0 i^` -�A a�2<IG

Page 31: الحرية الفكرية

30

6uK9=* nW X\"/9#n-W 1#"[/'- �<G 8^} :62SG $' "7 BC 1 67"9'-. aP³[2Y " |K2S` j$I* N0 �p"/_'-

¥9V5V_%# &[UL " |7"o=3- 1 6&� 6j80 )o3 XO"[7 6)` "7 6NV BC !"*d- :20 13L"/&'"0 16* 6.K'- R)S7 �[620 B9'- 16234./'- !"*d"C ."?[20 "&2C " �2^0-.G - |L"=7W B75>T- F2+$9'- i7 �/9'- XF9/<} NMR BC j"=3E' 162[*$I9'- i`-$7 m'A 1*-)?'-W X 6uK'- �-L\A BC FG"62'4 uCW � 6.K9* j80 N/_<' FI<=2> �P'- u*.^'- m<# :2Q-.S'-W Nxn)'- �"]I9>-W X.2q'- XF2<# ;1^<> 6B+L"} .7R 6�z j$I* n Z2K0 X("2K'- BC j"=3T- 6uK'- i7 yL"q'- ,"/9'- i`$7 :7 yL"q'"0 j"=3T- {SG.* "&63AW Xj"=3T- "?/[9_* B9'- °\"S&'- N6H&G B9'- t2/'- .x">W .2q'-W B9'- 16234./'- !"*d- BG8G "[QW XFG"2Y tIKG " |�$^} "?<_o*W ¦"Sb3- \ 6)K9' X17"2/'- D$* BC 16*\.J'- 162'W§=&'- :# �� 6)KG N�"S'"0 F7-U9'- m<# he �>"Kh2> j"=3T"C X 6uK'- u^[7 uCW 16* 6.K'- "7 �5} �'� 6jz �wQ"[&'-W �$<='- WR 1_*.]'- WR ()2/_'- BC

.F*)' (.IJ'- y"93A )#-$`W N/_'- F2b9/*

***

Page 32: الحرية الفكرية

31

&R?@Wd"% &R? R@b"% *98Z yY9We}

16* 6.K'- R)S&' "[=2>8G D"7R �/G jR :I&* !n"I�A 1 6&� "? hb_0W X162#"&9+n- 1³2S'-W 120.9'"0 {SG.7 "? hb_0 X16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K' a�/> :7 F%.9J* "7W F=J3 j"&*T- 162b` m'A \$_* )` .16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'-W j"&*T- :20 �`"[9'- :7 a,B]0 B]* "&0 .IJ'- e3"o'- :20 ¦"SGLn- :7 F2'A "3.�R "7 m<# !n"I�A 1 6&� �'PV n "|[*$IG .IJ'- 16* 6.Y j"=3T- ,"^#�C XB_*.]9'-W B[*$I9'- m69Y WR X |5H7 6)G.&'- N9` tIKV X162?/J'- Nx"=&'- �_0 FS>"[* 1#"[` jW\ :7 m69Y F2/J'- �RL D-U9'- B[_* �P'- )2</9'- R)S7 NH7

.)l</&'- :7 X"?'$Y .2IJ9'- :*.2H7 X" |#"SG "?' ¨ 6._93 !n"I�T- OPQ "&63AW XZKS'- BC u 6&_9'- :7 .2HI'- m'A y"9K* )` "?b_0 6jR " 6&<#

."[0"9V �$%$&0 {SG.* "7 m'A "?2C "3.�R

Page 33: الحرية الفكرية

32

&�J("%# &Jo@V"% :� R#$% �9We:% F2'A B&9[* �P'- B_&9o&'- ~"o&'- 6jR uS> "7 BC "3.�R B6[SG m'A F_C)* Xj"=3T- m<# " | �"% - |.2�8G �L"&h* j"=3T- 16*$J# 1/*.^0 6t9* .2�89'- -PQW XO)2'"/GW FG-\"#W i&9o&'- L"ICR 162<&_'-W 162=J['-W 16*.IJ'- Fh9 62�q� N 6I]9G Z2K0 X(L$f[7 .2�W

."?2'A B&9[* B9'- 1³2S'-W {2K&'"0 (.l�897 12#"&9+n- 1³2S'"0 " �2Y |5H7 �'P' p.b3 jR i2^9=3 "[ 6<_'W j"=3T- iS^G � 120.9'- ~5} :7 � "?63�C X"?2C j"=3T- 8][* B9'- \$_* n m69Y X"Q)#-$`W "?&2Q"J7 17$f[7 m<# O.=/hGW "?&2/0 jR j"2Yz- :7 a.2HV BC hN&9K* nW X�'� :7 )_0R g.* j"=3T- L$�8&'- Z*)K'- 6N_'W .DU9<* "7 WR )/9_* "7 yL"} 6uK'- j$I* F�3-. l��[ h*W F�3-\ l$ �? h* O-$0R "&63AW X(.^J'- m<# )'$* a\$'$7 6NV» :Nx"/'- j"=3T- !"? 6+$G BC 120.9<' .�z- -PQ )2J* (�)«F�3"= lo �& h* WR

.162V$<='- FG"7-U9'-W FG-\"/9#-W �/* jR j"=3T- ~W"K* "7)[# {rb'- -PQ .2�8G a�$%$0 g.3W .2HI'- �SV m'A 8o<* Z2K0 X1³2S'- WR {2K&'- �'� �'"q* " |J`$7 i`-$'- t2` m'A D"I9Yn- (LW.b0 OL$_� :7 " | 5^3- OL"ICR :7 162<&# BC � �'� N+z � N})*W XF2C �2_* �P'- i&9o&'-W BC �_b'- .M"[# :# ZKS'- m<# "?'5} :7 N&_* 16*.*.SG

.���¡ X�y Xj"[S' X!W.20 XL\"M L-\ XQ<AZ Q568 X)&YR D"7T- XNS[Y :0- (�)

Page 34: الحرية الفكرية

33

XO)2'"/GW FG-\"#W i&9o&'- L"ICR BC ( 6$/'- .M"[# :#W XOL"ICR j"=3T- :&b* �'P0W X)x"=<' aP³[2Y � !" �2/^[7 � h.�['- j$I2' .�"S&'- .2� {rb'- ~ 6$K9* 5C Xi&9o&'- L"�A BC F=J3 175> FGL"�A BC m'"_G F'$` .2]* -PQ m'A F 6<_'W ..�"S7 a{r% m'A � l0 lC9k~g !kK k� 9x{l} k# �& x8 pZ !kK k� 9k{�9kog 9k{ nQ kS k# 9x{l} %I p"9 k� nNko¬ :F'$` m'A D"2/'- m'A j"=3T- iC)* )x"='"0 c-.r9>n- 6jA 6�R X(�)­ kD# pQkV nj �8 (.IC j$V $Q 1*-)?'- L"2_7 6jR "?2C .S9_* 1<7"� 16*.*.SG 162<&_0 N6H&* F 6<_' -PQW Xt?o?[7 WR tQ)2'"/G WR ,"0d- ()2/# N6H&G "7 m'A t2Q"J&'- F2C ~ 6$K9G �P'- .*.S9'- 162<&# :7 m�`z- g$9=&'- :# |1*"IY m'"_G F'$` �'� m'A .2]* "&V " |7"&G X10$</7 t2Q"J7 k�g %I pS l@ nLkZ %I p"9 k� DkZ xYl} lm l8 nI k� ku% kI kS kD9 ka 9 k< kP¬ :Q ¦$' �D$` (L"?^'- sS�hG Z2Y X(�)­ kD# p@ xj k)kV k? ��9k{ pZ n� pjx{l} n� pWlV k? n@ k� X |8 �«Ip"

!\"_0T-W ,"�`T- L 6.SG |1&?G �.K[&'- i&9o&'- .f[0 )[# �6 $9'- :7 6)0 n X~"I�T- -PQ m<# e2o3 jR NS`W n -�"&'W ª |5MR ~"o&'- m'A \-)]3n- -PQ -�"&' :B'"9'- ~-§='- X�RL :7 ~"o&'- -PQ 1^<> :7 "|2[*$IG - |L 6.K97 j"=3T- 8][*

ªF[7 L 6.K9'- F[7 e<^h* 6t� " �*$J# F' F#"b}A 6t9* jR :7 |n)0 BC 162M$�q'- OPQ 6jR m'A .2]3 jR BrS[* �'� 1o'"_&'W

.�� 1*d- X�.}U'- (L$> (�).£¥ 1*d- XN&['- (L$> (�)

Page 35: الحرية الفكرية

34

"?9b9`- "&63A XF0 O.6�8GW XF2'A O\-)]3-W i&9o&'"0 j"=3T- 1`5# t2/'- 16*L-.&9>- j"&b' �'�W X.20)9'-W u<q'- BC 1&IK'- XF9623"3R m<# "|*$^[7 a\.C 6NV j"I' "Qn$'W X~"2+z- ("2Y BC X\.C 6NV i7 .J�'- :7 R)S* X" |&x-\ " �*\.C t2/'- y"93A sSMzW g)' j"V X�'� N+zW .\$?o<' ;)*)SGW X.&_<' ;1�/[7 -PQ BCW :7 ( 6$/'-W :7z"0 ;L$_�W XB#"&9+- aL"_]9>- (U?+R "6[7 a\.C lNV j"=3T- h�WU# � �'� N+z � sSMRW X1#"&o<' ,"&93n- ~5} \-.CR i7 162/x5# NV"]7 BC F h'$}\W X162#"&9+n- ("2K'- :# .�'� FS�R "7 WR 6B=J3 ay5# m'A y"9KG 162% �.7 1<I]7 Xi&9o&'- BC � 6.K9* )` F63�C X\W)K&'- t'"# m'A B&9[* aj$3"` 6�8VW t2` ~ 6)S9G )` �A �{�"b'- OL"=7 m<# �.hG "7 -�A e<='- O"o6G- "?9K<�7 g.G B9'- ��-$['- �_0 1o293 N�"S'- O"o6G- BC i&9o&'- �W.µ eS=0 "?9'"MR :# - |)2_0 L"ICz- t 6qb9G )`W XN�"S'- i7 X.?/'-W �_b'- !n"Y BC FG-� :# iC-)* jR j"=3T- :7 �b9`- p$_]'- pL"o90 �"I9Yn- 1o293 L"ICz- �_0 p 6.=9G )`W X1? 6+$&'- 1C"/H'-W D5#T- 1V.Y 1o293 WR XtQL"ICRW g.}z- DU9<* jR m'A j"=3T"0 g 6\z Xj$3"/'- �'� �.hG $<C ��'� m'A "7W 6uK'- i`-$7 :# FC-.K3- F2C ¨.9J3 �P'- �`$'- BC �'� 6NV BrS[*W X" �*.f3 j"=3T- WR 1#"&o'- "Q)/9_G B9'- 1<2Mz- t2/'-W

." �2<&# "?/CW .2=* jR

Page 36: الحرية الفكرية

35

!"#"C\ :7 - |,U+ N 6I]* a{0"% m'A "[Q y"9K3 :K[C X�'P'W (\"#A $K3 F_C)GW XB#"&9+n- p59>n- O"oG 162G-P'- j"=3T- 1fK' 6NV BC X162#$%$&'- O.M"[# BC ZKS'- .S# Xi`-$'- (,-.` F*)' hZ_SG X1�\"Y !"62'"I�A WR X()*)+ !- 6)o9=7 F7"7R �/G !"0$_M WR !"* 6)KG F+-$* )x"='- i7 D"o=3n- 6j80 �"=YT- �`"[90 B' 6Wz- OL$_� :7 iS[G !"62'"I�A WR X162_`-W 162G"2Y N 6I]G t2` i7 WR X"Q)/9_* B9'- 1/2/K'- i7 WR X()2/_'- i7 i`-$'- !-\"_'-W L"ICz- 1>-L\ m'A �'� F_C)2C X("2K'- �0-$� :7 "|90"� X!"62'"I�T- �<G 6NY �)?0 X()x"='- WR 1�WL$&'- wQ"[&'-W a1#"[` m'A j"=3T- NMW $' m69Y X)*)+ :7 "?+"93A )2_* -PQW X"QL-.&9>- j"&% :7 6)0 nW 190"� " |&�2� N6H&* �'� 6NV 6jR h.S9_G WR !"* 6)K9<' 1o'"_7 WR !"62'"I�E' ~$<Y :# ZKS'- B'"9'"0W (\"#A 162'4 � 6.K9G jR ¨.9J3 )`W .g.}R a!"?+W :7 !"0$_�'- a~$<Y :# j"=3T- ZKS* jR BQW X162=I# 1/*.^0 i`-$'- t*$/G X.7z- F2<# m�_9>- -��C Xt2Q"J&'- WR t2/<' tx"/'- �u=['- :&% WR "?=J3 1&2/'- WR "?G-� (.IJ'- BC .f['- (\"#A :7 6)0 n F63R )+W

.F[2# D$?J&'- �R.'- :# .2S_9'-W X16*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'- 1>L"&7 �=2' " |_S� y"9KG "?63R )o3 �'P'W X |1<?> 162b` X1>L"&&'- OP?' 1o29[V "7 "|S'"� 1'8=&'- 6jz ��R.'- j5#A BC a1#"o� m'A :*. 6IJ&'- :7

Page 37: الحرية الفكرية

36

1? 6+$7 WR 162x"/<G 1/*.^0 � �L"&h* �P'- B_&9o&'- {rb'"0 D)^�G �LW.b'- :7 Xt_3 .i`-$'- BC .22rG 6�R :7 (L 6.b97 g$` :7 �– 1#"o]'- e3"+ m'A � 1&IK'"0 jW. 6IJ&'- m6<K9* jR "[Q �-)Qz- u2/KG "&63AW Xj"V "&J2V �R.'- ,-)0A �2' �)?'- 6jz 1/ 6&_7 1>-L\ e6<^9* -PQW X�-� WR �R.'- -PQ ,-LW :7 16*.22r9'- 162<&# FS 6<^9G "&' "|2#WW XF2C 1& 6IK9&'- g$/'-W FCW.µW i`-$<' j$IG n )` 162#$%$7 �W.µ . 6C$G ¨.JG "7 "|S'"� B9'-W X.22r9'-

:- |._� N2` )`W X(. 6C$97j"_o]'- 1#"o� �NS` h�R.��'-

B�3"�H'- �N�K&'- B�QW ;~ @WR $�Q 1³2S'-W 120.9'- 6jA ~$/'- i2^9=3 ) "[63�C X~"I�T- m'A (\$_'"0W

:!"fY57 ( 6)# \L$3 "[QW �16*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'- R)S7 i7 j"2C"[9* n (. 6IJ7 ( 6$/V � N/_'- 6j�C X1³2S'- .2�8G :7 t�.'"0 F63A � wY R#Z �'� m<# N2')'-W X12[*$IG 12Y"3 :7 F9V.Y BC ¶.Y � 1o9[7W -PQW X hF h7$` F0 . 6IJ* "7 .2� . 6IJ*W F9³20 ¨L"_* )` j"=3T- 6jR

.s%-W N7"# 6�80 .IJ'- .�8G D)# B[_* n 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 6jA �9wJ{9~ ,B]'- 1 6<# 6j�C X1 6<_'- m'A i3-$&'- N2S :7 "Q.2�8G @:I'W �B+L"} Bb9/&'- :.M"[# 1�5� :7 "?' 6)0 n "?ox"93 BC (.6�§7 j$IG BI'

Page 38: الحرية الفكرية

37

X hL"['- � .�z- $QW � c-.YE' Bb9/&'"C �i3"&'- D)#W ¦.]'-W n jRW Xt=o'- :7 "?0.` $Q c-.YT- BC L"['- .2�89' ¦.]'-W j$I* j8V Xmb9/&'- BC Bb9/&'- .2�8G :7 i3"7 �"[Q j$I* 1 67"G 16* 6.K0 N/_'- � 6.K9* BI<C X-PQ m<#W . |5H7 "|S�L ht=o'- 1V.Y u2_G B9'- i3-$&'- 1'-�T O)?+ F 6+$* jR :7 j"=3E' 6)0 n "7 :2# $Q -PQW Xt2<='- y"9[9>n-W .2IJ9'- 1V.YW �-L\T- 6jz �\-)+z-W ,"0d- �-.G :# �� 6)KG B9'- !"*d- O)�/G �3"V Xp$_]'- ("2Y BC L 6PoGW 1>-) :7 F/C-.* "7W �-.9'- -PQ 1_2S� j"V �'P'W X1 67"G 16* 6.K0 N/_'- � 6.KG :# " �2x"/<G " |_3"7 j$I2> n �P'- �*)/9'- 1S2Q F=J3 :7 i<q* jR j"=3T- :7 p$<^&'-

.j"Q.0 WR ;N2'\ F2<# D$/* 6B_ ®& �o'- N/_'- D"7R B34./'- F2+$9'- O"oG m[_&'- -PQ s&<3W X a~5/9>"0 hF h</# . 6IJ* n O-.9C X" �2J�"# j"=3T- F_7 c$=* �P'- !k5n k8 lm xKl" %I p8I p\kG DkZ �B kQ lA% kIlo � pW p� l�kZ 9 k<x{l} nN p� ¬ :m'"_G ~"` �'P'W kXnJ ko � pWx" �@? lzk{ xYl} kI p0 nDl} �& x5 lS X |8 � pWl( lA9 k�lo 9 k8 %# p@ xW kdkV kG x� p~ h ki% k@ pP k#

.(�)­ �Q? lQ ke �u% kz k� nH kQk? X(�) h:=YR BQ B9'"0 ~-)o'- m<# j4./'- )2V8G :7 t?J3 "[ 6<_' N0 m<# (.IJ<' e 6�_9'- .2�8G :# N/_'- \"_0A !"62'4 :7 162'4 �'� 6jR

.�¥ 1*d- X8S> (L$> (�) (L$> .t�j58 %I<K¢ X?z"% RY} X6AZ ]0 ]V"9o RY} u9VW"% N0Z %I"i9vG Y#s :m'"_G F'$ (�)

.�¥ 1*d- X!$SI[_'-

Page 39: الحرية الفكرية

38

XFG.IJ' L"�93n- 6nA ¶tQ F' j$I* n e 6�_9&'- 6jz �.IJ'- 1V.Y j"=3T- 1'"K' N/_'- �$b} B[_* -PQW X aN�"S0 WR ·uK0 ,-$>

.F'5/9>- )/J* $?C B'"9'"0W X12'"_J3n- i%-$9'"V X"?0 "[< 678G $' X" |b*R 162`5}z- !"62'd- :7 ;.2HV i7 L-$K'- m<# j"=3T- �"9J3-W :7§&'- 16'"% 1&IK'- L"S9#-W N*UG jR BQ "?G"62<oG h�_0 X�'� .2�W X�J['- 1S>"K7W .}d- )62/7 NI]0 . 6IJ* N/_'- N_oG B9'- 12#"&9+n-W 12=J['- i3-$&'-

. ·. hY .2� m<# .f['- @�r3 jR "[3"I7A BC �2' F63�C X�'� m'A 1C"%A X)/['- 6�Y 12&[G m<# B&2<_9'-W �$0.9'- D"f['- D$/* jR (LW.% �'� s&=* Z2K0 XB#$%$&'-W B&<_'- ZKS'- m<# e*L)9'-W 1<³>z- m69Y XF=J3 m<# j"=3T- "?Y.^* B9'- 1<³>z- U2JK90 F0 6.]G "&' 1S=['"0 m69Y " �*)/3 - |L"=7 B'"9'"0 Pq692' �16*\$+$'- D"7R �/3 "[QW X"Q.2� WR 162>L)&'- WR 162<x"_'- FG"2Y :7 j"=3T- X162= 6>§7 ("2Y 17$f[7 m'A )/['-W 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- N*$KG (LW.%

." |/Yn O)[# �6 $9[> " 6&7 X aL"=7W ·uKV 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- (.IC ) 6V89G XF 6<V �'� ~5} :7W !"62'd- t'"# BC F=J3 ¨.J* jR hZS<* n 6t� X:*$I9'- :7 R)S* y"93A BC 6uK'- -PQ u2S^G 175> m<# 1fC"K&'- �)?9=G B9'-

. 6\"b&'- .IJ'-W .IJ'-

Page 40: الحرية الفكرية

39

&R?@Wd"% &R? R@b"%# D9<?:% XJo :]{9^"% �9We:% 6jz �.IJ'- 1* 6.Y i7 mC"[9* F<'"0 j"&*T- 6jA :Nx"` ~$/* )` �2<C B'"9'"0W XF<'- F[62S* "&' " |_SG 1C._&<' - |\W)Y ¨.J* j"&*T- "|³2� ~"` F<'- 6jR F*)' �SH* "7)[# . 6IJ* jR BC L"2} N/_'- D"7R :m'"_G ~"` "�&V X"|³2� �~"` ~$>.'- 6jR �S� -�A �'PVW XF9S�R WR kDIW? DZ % w@8Z m p"I_C# pmK"% !O� %f} �&58�8 Y# �X8�<" D9a 98#s wYU� xN� Q\P pm k"I_C# mK"% l§'? X8# �0@8Z X8 pB k@kJ l¡"% �j"

.(�)t9w5J( p8 XB[*)'- 6k['- c"^[9>- m<# D$/* B75>T- .IJ'- 6jA 6t� F2<#W XB3"_&'-W !nn)'- \W)K7 6k['-W X |16[> 6DR j"V "|34.` (L"S_0W .FJ/=0 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K<' )22/G 6k['"0 B[*)'- D-U9'n- 6j�C "&0 6nA DU9<* n j"=3T- 6jR Bb9/* 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 6jA Xg.}R 1'n\ F9#"[` �J'"} $<C -PQ m<#W Xp-$�'- WR 6uK'- F63R i[9/* 6k['- ~$')7 �.9*W F9#"[/0 DU9<* jR BC F' s&=h* N?C X 6k['- XFM$�3W :* l)'"0 D-U9'n- mb9/7 "[J'"} t_3 "[<` j�C �B[* l)'- p"^q'- D$&# @jR e*L nW X�-� 16* 6.K'- R)S7 "[J'"} n "[< h jAW \ 6)K9G j"=3T- 1#"[ 6jRW 6k['"0 D-U9'n- m<# XO)#-$ N0 �B[* l)'-

.F/CW::29?+ :7 X�'� m<# p-$o'-W

.�¥ 1*d- Xp-UYz- (L$> (�)

Page 41: الحرية الفكرية

40

Rcb"9o *%`V"% mK"9o D9<?:% : wY R#Z k@['- ~$')&0 D-U9'n- "&V XF'$>LW F<'- ,"b/' t2<=9'- 6jA t2<=9'- �'� 6jz �.IJ'- 16* 6.Y R)S&' |1J'"q7 6)_* n XB[* l)'- B[9SG B9'- F<2M"JGW j"&*T- !"62M$�} :7 $Q "&63A D-U9'n-W .f[0 N6H&* �$> F[# L)�* "&C X 6uK'- F63R F<'"0 :74 :&C XF2<# :20 � F7-U9'-W :7§&'- j"&*A BC � �2IJG n �'P'W X1/2/K'- N/_'- xD krlo k>l" kf ¬:m'"_G ~"` . 6uK'- F6380 F9#"[` :20W F<'- :# L)�* "7

.(�)­ pN lq9k( n"% kI p0 lml{# pi Xl8 kDI p� nQk? 9 k8 xDkZ k# �c kbn"% kI p0 km xK"% 1JM N/_'- .f3 BC �S=9V- "?63R B[_* "7 a(.IC BC @uK'- 6jAW U62Y BC 1/ 6/K97 "?63R N/_'- .f[0 " �/Y "?3$V m[_7 6jz �162#$%$&'- at=+ 6�R m'A .f[* "&V j"=3T- "?2'A .f[* Xj"=3T- !-� yL"} -PQ BC a,B� 6�R �!-� :# N0 �:*.}d- !-W� :# N0 �F[# ayL"} BC 6uK<' 162#$%$&'- .M"[_'- h\$+$C F2<#W Xc$<q&'- \$+$'- $K3 j"=3T- iC)* BI' t'"_'- BC )2Y$'- ¸ 6$=&'- $Q a.7R 6�R m?9[7 -PQW ." �2<&# " |V$<> WR " �*.IC - |.7R j"V ,-$> XF0 D-U9'n- m'A F 6<_'W .!"`$<q&'- :7 F3-.`R 1?+-$7 BC B3"=3T- L 6.K9'- X(�)­ kXJl� li9 k[ n� pV5 pa Dl} n� pWk{9 k0 n@ po n%I pG9 k0 nN p�¬ :m'"_G F'$` .2]h* �'� 1 6KM m<# N2' @)'-W j"Q.hS'"0 j"2GE' " |7�57 c)�'- .S9#- Z2Y

.¥� 1*d- X 6wK'- (L$> (�).��� 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�)

Page 42: الحرية الفكرية

41

m<# j"Q.S0 j"2GT- m<# - |L\"` j"=3T- :I* t' -��C X(.IJ'- (.IC j$IG jR W)_G nW X162#$%$&'- "?9&2` )/JG F63�C XFG.IC

."?[7 ) 6V89'- WR u 6/K9'- t<_<' :I&* n 162�q� 10.oG WR 162G-� jR 6.K'- j"=3T- -PQ :7 e6<^9* :7 6NIC X�">z- -PQ m<#W :7 �'� y.q* jR F2<_C X" |V$<> DU9<* jR WR Xa(.IJ0 NS/* WR :#P* g)7 BC X1]`"[&'-W 1>-L)<' N0"` a�$%$7 m'A F' 6$K2' XFG-� L"�A F63R $Q F'$S/' iC-)'- �2<C .FG-� BC 6uK'- .M"[# m<# F'"&9�- !-� 1^<='- :7 ;L\"M ;.7R F63R nW X 6PJ'- 6B35J'- t�'"_'- :7 �L)M "?63R j"=3E' �SHG jR 1^<='- �<GW t�'"_'- -PQ m<# 6jz �( 6$/'- WR (.IJ'- ~"&9�- ~5} :7 X\"2/3n- WR 1#"^'- 6uY F2<# �<&G

.12#$%$&'- 6uK'- .M"[# m<# "&?2'A $#)G :*P<'- �$<='- 6NV BC 6uK'"0 " �*.^C j"=3T- ¦"SGL- 1'"MR m<# 6~)* " 6&7W X()2/_'- °\"S&0 t?�"SGL- j$# 6)* "&63A �"['- 6jR XFG"2Y jW§� :7 �'� m'A "7 WR X1V.K'- ¦$^} WR X1_*.]'- !-\.J7 WR jW8o<* )`W Xt?9#"[` BC 6uK'- N6H&* �'� 6j80 X("2K'- !"7-U9'- e_<'- ~5} :7 "?[# t?C-.K3- .*.S9' :23-$/'- m<# Nh*"K9'- m'A t?*)' j"V F63R WR Xt?S3"+ BC 6uK'- 6jR .*$�9' ¹"J'z- m<# .F[# " |C-.K3- jW.}4 O.S9_* �P'- t?V$<> WR t?J`$7 BC 6uK'- .S# 162<&_'- 12Y"['- :7 m6<o9* F<'"0 j"&*T- 6jA : ��<` ��³� jAW "?[7 B9'-W Xj"=3E' 1S=['"0 "?&2` )2=oGW F<'- �!"J�0 ¦"SGLn-

Page 43: الحرية الفكرية

42

"?0 DU9<* t2Q"J7 OPQW X�'� m'A "7W .2q'-W ~)_'-W 6uK'- F63R .*.SG m'A m_> " �2<&# "Q 6)% DU9'- -�A F63R m69Y X1?*)S'"0 j"=3T- X162#"&9+n- 162#W.]&'- e=9I2' �'�W X"?<6H&G "?63R m<# F9<_C lª nC k$% ]lP n%# pQ l6 nd pG kY n� pjk" kNJl� % kfl} k#¬ :m'"_G F'$` �'� m'A .2]*W w& k� lA9 kP n%I pK k' kP % kfl} k#¬ :m'"_G F'$`W X(�)­ kDI pblK n� p8 pX nbk{ 9 k<x{l} n%I p"9 k� �9 k� nb kdn"9lo p@ p8 nr k? kY km RK"% xDl} nN p� 9 kjlo 9k{ k@ k8kZ pm RK"% k# 9k{�9kog 9 kjnJ kK k� 9k{ nQ kS k# n%I p"9 k�

.(�)­ kDI p< kK n'kG kY 9 k8 lm RK"% !kK k� kDIp"I p\kG kZ F<'- :# L)�* "&0 h��3 "[@3R m<# )2V89'- :7 6)0 n Xt_3 "7 @NV 6jR !"S�A 1'8=7 6jz �R)S&'- Z2Y :7 X 6uK'- F6380 F�'$>LW )` F6380 1 67"9'- 1#"[/'- N/_'- g)' N6H&* jR 6)0 n F<'- m'A e=[h* ~$>L :# gW.h* WR N/[* "7 m'A 1S=['"0 �'PVW Xm'"_G F[# L)M XB[* l)'- lk[<' (\ 6)_97 !n"&9Y- \$+W 162'"I�A m'A |1C"%A XF<'- .IJ'- BC )*)o9'-W \"?9+n- :# Z*)K'- BC F2'A i+.[> "7 $QW 16* 6.K'- R)S7 m<# B[9S* �'� 6jR �"[Q )o3 )` "[63z �B75>T-

.\"_0z- (\ 6)_97 16*L"bY 1623"=3A 1V.Y BC m6<o9*W 16*.IJ'- 6NV 6j80 1#"[/'- ¨.9J* F'$>LW F<'"0 j"&*T- @jR X1M5q'-W B'"9'"0W X 6uK'- N6H&* $?C XF3"KS> F<'- :# "|[2/*W " |_^` �SH* "7 Xi`-$'-W 1/2/K'-W 6uK<' N/_'- 16*\$S# 6nA �2' F' j"#�T- 6j�C

.�� 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�).�  1*d- X�-.#z- (L$> (�)

Page 44: الحرية الفكرية

43

a~U_&0 F h=J3 hN/_'- F2b9/* "7 6nA $Q �2' N/_<' 6uK'- \"S_9>-W .16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- D$?J7 $Q -PQW X.}4 a.7R 6�R :#

i9jVSY% @(� |§5"% ¬9Vd{% :9wJ{9~ X"?G-L"=7 BC � 6.KGW X("2K'- m'A ~U3 "7)[# F �=J3 :* l)'- 6jA 6jR " |&IY B[_* -P?C XF962'W§=7 N 6&K9* jR j"=3E' )*LhRW 162=J['- !-.6�§&'- 6NI0 .@�89* X.]S'- ("2Y :7 - |,U+ sS�* :* l)'- n .1 67"_0 t?G"2Y BC .6�§G B9'- "Q.2�W 12>"2='-W 12#"&9+n-W �:*)'- t?C F0 )�/3 "[ @[I'W XB_`-$'- O\$+$0 :* l)'- "[Q )�/3 XB35J'- t�'"_'- 1*vL e=Y X:*)'- ht?C $Q "3)[# ;\$+$7 $Q "&C 6uK'"0 B/9<* )` "&0 XB35J'- eQP&'- WR XB35J'- O"o6Gn- WR !"#"[` N6H&* ~-$Yz- 6NV BC F6[I'W XB/9<* n )`W 6B_`-$'- w9[*W � 6.K9* BI' B_`-$'- 6uK'- �-L\A F h7 �U ®< �* n j"=3T-W X,n§Q 6uK'- F63R )/9_* "7 ~5} :7 �'� 6NV BC � 6.K9* F63A N0 XDU9<*W BC "?[# .6S_* B9'- BQW X1#"[/'- :7 "3\$�/7 $Q -PQW XB_`-$'- .(�)F96*L 6P_7W (:2/2'-) i^/'- 16*U 6o[7 1'8=&0 «F/J'- ~$MR» j-)27 F63R m<# :* l)'- m<# ~"I�T- BrS[* n F63�C X�'� m'A - |\"[9>-W �k['-W X lk['"0 ;D$IK7 F63R L"S9#"0 �.IJ'- 1V.K' " |J/>R ib* :7 "7 $QW X!-.62r9&'- (\W)K7 .2� ("2K'-W X1'n)'- \W)K7 p"9I'- L-\ X�¦ X&J{9^"% &\Kb"% / �I[$% �K� ]P �#Ci X.`"0 )&K7 XL) 6�'- :.f3R (�)

.��¡ X�© ¥ XB3"[S<'-

Page 45: الحرية الفكرية

44

" 67AW X:* l)'- eV-$9' ("2K'- 1<o# �"/*A m'A " 67A � 6\§* jR F38� ."?G-.62r97W ("2K'- L 6$^G j"=3T- eV-$* jR 1K<�&' :* l)'- �"/*A wQ"[7 m<# (\L-W j$IG )` 162'"I�T- OPQ @jR )/9_3 "[6[I'W !"7�R F+-$G )`W ()7"+ "?9_2S^0 BQ X:* l)'- t?C BC 1[62_7 �P'- �`$'- BC XF=J3 B[*)'- 6k['- (,-.` BC 162o?[7 WR 162C._7 162_^/'- 16[='-W j4./'- "[Q )�/3W XB[*)'- 6k['- m<# 6jR F2C )/9_3 eV-$* F63R m[_&0 X" �2Y"9J3- j$I* jR BrS[* XD5>T- B[_* "7 BC 162>">z- t2/'-W !"62 6<I'-W )#-$/'- )*)KG i`$7 :7 ("2K'- 1<I]7 N 6I]* n FG-� 6)Y BC -PQW X("2K'- tIKG jR BrS[* B9'- 1SV-$7 �2/0 � ~"H&'- N2S> m<# � 1 67"_'- c5}z- 6jA �A �16*.]S<' P[7 XtQ\"=C :7 t?Y5M �"2/' .2*"_7 �< 6I�W X.]S'- ("2K'

.¨Lz- OPQ m<# j"=3T- ) �+ hW jR XF2<#W X:* l)<' "[ h&?C BQ L 6$^9<' ibqG )` B9'- 1'8=&'- 6jA �P'- B_`-$'- O\$+W BC :* l)'"0 1/ 6<_97 :* l)'- !"S� 162%.JC ,"?/J'- t?C BC :* l)'- �2'W XF h'$>LW � F3"KS> � F<'- F&<_* F0 hi^/* "7 6jz � 6uK'- F6380 j$_^/* "7 BC m69Y X:*)?9o&'-W

.mJq* n "&V X.}4 j"=3T ·�� \L$7 j$I* )` ;j"=3A m<# X12[*)'- D$<_'- BC m69Y �L 6$^G aL"=7 D"7R "[Q :K3 X- |�A m<# D$/* L"=&'- -PQW Xg.}z- D$<_<' �L 6$^9'- L"=&'- L-.� )` �A �.62r9<' �j"_%"} F&?CW j"=3T- \"?9+- 6jR $QW X a�0"� R)S7

Page 46: الحرية الفكرية

45

"7 BC F9#"[` .62r* j"=3T- N_oG X()*)+ a!"2^_&0 ("2K'- "3 6)&G 6uK'"0 :7§&'- j"=3T- ¦"SGL- !"S� 6j�C F2<#W XN�"S'-W 6uK'- $Q Z2Y N�"S'- :# )_9S* jRW X�SH* hZ2Y 6uK'"0 DU9<* jR F2<# t69K* F2C F9#"[` �. �2 �r �G �.µ BC " |/0"> F0 " |_[9/7 j"V "&0 hD-U9'n-W ��SH* �">z- -PQ m<#W .j"&*T- 6)% -PQW X 6uK'- �5q0 ;D-U9'- $Q �"['- i[&' 6B[*)'- ~"o&'- BC �.IJ'- p"QLT- 1>L"&7 6jR )o3 XF<'- (\-LT ( 6\"b7 N6H&* X 6uK'- F63R jW)/9_* "7 i7 D"o=3n- :7 6uK'"0 F7-U9'- ~5} :7 F<' F96*\$S# :# .2S_9'- :7 j"=3E' " |_[7W

.FG"#"[` e=K0 $'W XN�"S<' FV.GW 1<�"&7 a!"#"[` m'A hN�* "7)[# j"=3T- 6jA X�'� N0"/7 BCW . 6C$G ~5} :7 6)o9=&'- .2IJ9'- ,$% m<# 1/0"='- !"#"[/<' �u0"='- .IJ'- :# �<9q* - |)*)+ - |.IC N6H&* -P?C X()*)+ !"2^_7 BC uC-$9'-W X(�)()*)+ !"2^_7 \$+W i7 F9o293 m'A NMW F63z X1/0"='- (.IJ<' - |L-.IG N6H&* n !"2^_&'- �59}- i7 wx"9['-

.u0"='- .IJ'- wx"93 i7 Fox"93 BC ;uC-$97 ;)*)+ .IC "&63AW 162C._7 a1^<> :7 �"[Q �2' F6380 g.3 XD 6)/G "7 m<# " |=2>8GW �W.f<' 1&x-\ (.M"_&0 O.IJ0 j"=3T- u<^[* jR $QW X)*)o9<' " |J*._G "|[&% "[Q �.^3 (�) !"#"[/<' (.*"r7 !"#"[` m'A FG"#"[` .22rG (LW.b'"0 �'� B[_* jR jW\ :7 X!-.62r9&'-W B9'- (.%"K'- 1fK<'- BC j"=3T- N6H&G "?[I' �()*)o'- !"2^_&'- "Q� 6U_G )` �A �1/0"='- �.IJ'- )*)o9'- �"2/C -PQ m<#W .!"2^_&'- �<G . 6C$G NS` j"=3T- N6H&G nW X"?2C . 6IJ* F<'-W �" |&9Y ()*)+ L"ICR m'A F'$M$0 �2'W XF96*$2YW .IJ'- 16*L-.&9>- �"2/0 j$I* "&63A

.L$7z- ux"/K0 t'"_'-

Page 47: الحرية الفكرية

46

�1[Q.S7 .2� |(.IC FG"#"[` m'A N})h* jR j"=3T- m<# t69KG X162[*\ ~n)9>n- wQ"[7 u2S^9' " |I<9&7 �R X- |) �?9o7 j"=3T- j"V -��C �'� 6jz �FG"#"[` �5q0 DU9<* jR F' �2<C Xy"9[9>n-W 1[Q.S'-W j"&*E' ;�`"[7 -PQW X 6uK'- �5q0 D-U9'n- � F2'A 1S=['"0 � B[_* HQj? I0# Rcb"% �I\?s $QW X(�)t Rcb"% I0s �P'- F<'"0

.(�)tNJ(6"% FG-,"# 6\- :# " |&x-\ :Q.S* jR B[*)'- .IJ'- m<# 6jA :~$/3 "[QW X aj"I7W aj"7� 6NI' ;s'"M ;:*\ F63R N2S` :7 a!-L"_� u<^* "7)[# 1 6oK'- ~5} :7 Xg.}z- !"YW.�z- 6NV m<# D @)/&'- $Q F63RW �-.�'- 1V.Y :7 R 6Uo9* n - |,U+ )*)o9'- j$I* �'P0W .j"Q.S'-W i7 F92Y5MW F92 6/YR !"S�A �)?0 XO.2�W :* l)'- :20 �.IJ'- 6B/2/K'- D$?J&'- F 6<_' "7 -PQW .L 6$^9'- !-L"=7W X!-.62r9&'-

.)*)o9<' 1*.IJ'- Nx"=&'-» 6jA F<'- NbC :2=Y ) 6&K7 )62='- ~$/* X162#$%$&'- !-\.J&'-W X162&<_'- �>z- i`$7 :7 � 6.K9G X162[7U'- NY-.&'- �59}"0 "Q\"_0RW "?ox"93 �<9qG )` B9'- ¦$rb'- WR X162G-P'- !-.6�§&'- WR X1623"I&'- !"62M$�q'- WR BC ~ 6)S9'- ¨.J* " 6&7 Xi`-$'-W j"=3T"0 1^2K&'- 162#"&9+n-

.¥ 1*d- X 6wK'- (L$> (�).� 1*d- Xp-UYz- (L$> (�)

Page 48: الحرية الفكرية

47

e3"+ m'A -PQ .g.}RW 1³20 :20 WR X.}4W a�`W :20 "?9_2S� 162[Q� ~5} :7 1J 6<q97 1o29['- N_o* )` �P'- BC"/H'- g$9=&'- ¨.J* �P'- .7z- �D 6)/9'- .M"[# ~5} :7 17 6)/97 WR X�6<q9'- N0 X!-.6�§&'- �<9' 1_%"q'- L$7z- 6NV BC " |&x-\ .f['- (\"#A BC .f['- (\"#A � !n"K'- �_0 BC � j"=3T- m<# ¨.JG )` L$7z- j$IG "7)[# X.}4W �`W :20 16*L$_]'- WR 16*.IJ'- FG"#"[` �"]9Vn "?2C FG.f3 \ 6)o2' XFG"2Y BC 1xL"^'- !n"K<' |1_%"} -�A �2IC X�-.K3- WR 8^} WR a�_% :7 "?2C )o* jR :I&* "7

.(�)«!ª:*.}d- !"#"[/0 |5�697 �$%$&'- j"V

«9\_} Y �Q?QvG )*)o9'- :# � 6)K93 "7)[# "[63R m<# )2V89'- :7 "[' 6)0 nW jR m[_&0 X 6B<}-\ )*)oG :# � 6)K93 "[63�C XB[*)'- WR X�.IJ'- O �)#-$`W hO"[�0 BC X:* l)'- 6jR m<# 6�)*)o9'- .IJ'- p"KMR :Q.S* !"YW.�z- :20 (\"2='- �<&* �P'- $Q XFoQ"[7W F&2Q"J7W ibqh* jR ~W"K* �P'- �-� - |)*)oG �2'W .g.}z- L"ICz-W 6t9* aL"2q0 {SG.7 X 6B>"2> ;�`$7 -PQ 6jz �)x"='- $Q "&' @k['- $Q )*)o9'- L"S9#- 6jz � 6k['- m<# F�"/>A WR XF' :* l)'- �"b}A WR X:* l)<' Bo?[&'- u=['- yL"} :7 ()*)o'- wx"9['"0 j"2GT-

.�±�¡ X�y XDg@\"% ]A# X8 @J6dG X:2=Y )&K7 )2='- XF<'- NbC (�)

Page 49: الحرية الفكرية

48

!"Q"o6Gn-W L"ICº' :*)'- �"b}A � 1�"=S0 � $Q XB[*)'- .IJ'- �"['- �`$&0 �'� {SG.* "7 L-)/&0 6nA - |)*)oG �2'W Xg.}z-

.O"o6Gn- -PQ p"KMR "Q.?fh* B9'- wx"9['- :7 B>"2='- �-.M ~5} :7 j$I* "&63A X�'� :7 u 6/K9'"C X~"Y 6NV m<#W 6t9* 162x"?3 1^0"% ,"^#A :I&h* nW X)/['- !"62'4 .S# F=J3 .IJ'- )*)o9'- 162<&# :7 162S<='- �`-$&'- 6jz �B'4 NI]0 "?/2S^G )#-$/'- :# ;�WP� F6380 6�)*)o9'- �R.'- B7L m'A 8o<G "7 - |.2HV u=['- yL"} :7 )*)o9'- 6jR ~"K'-W X"?#"S6G- D�5'- ~$Mz-W "?=J3 ~$Mz-W )#-$/'- �<90 u6<_9* )` )*)o9'- 6jR " |&<# X�'PV g.}R ()#"/0 BG8*W 1Sx"M .2� "?63R hF h=J3 h.IJ'- B# 6)* "7)[# )[9=* aUx"7 :7 6)0 5C F2<#W �u0"='- NMº' .*"r7 NMR WR "?3"I7 j$7$IK7 "[63R B[_* -PQW X)*)o'- .IJ<' 6B<}-)'- u^[&'- m'A -PQW X�.IJ'- ¦"Sb3n- u2/KG BC .IJ'- y"93A !"62'4 m'A " |&x-\ ( 6�"� "?6380 ()*)+ a(.IC 6�R B7L j"I7A D)# m'A � 1o29['"0 � � 6\§*

."Q�WP� m<# N2')'- 17"`A 6t9* t' "7 �$b} BJ3 m<# a)*)+ a)2V8G D"7R X"[Q :K[C X~-$Yz- 6NV BC 1^<='- OP?' 6)0 n N0 XF[# 1+L"} a1^<> 6�z 1C._&'-W .I�J'- t'"# .IJ'- 1V.K' )2Y$'- {0"b'- 6jR B[_* -PQW X"&?=[+ :7 j$IG jR a(.IC 1623" 6/Y m<# N2')'- tQ h)YR t2/* Z2KC XF=J3 h.IJ'- $Q "&63A XN2')'- �'� m'A :#P* �P'- N/_'- )S_9=* aPx)[_C X"?9620-$MW "7

Page 50: الحرية الفكرية

49

F �=J3 N/_'- 1#"[/' "&63AW X.}²' �=2' aPx)[# N/_'- 16*\$S#W .�$%$&'- U62Y m'A .}d- 162G-� :7 "?+W.} )_0 .}d- (.IJ0

]lP k�% k@ nal} kY¬ :m'"_G F'$` :7 t?J3 �'� ~5} :7 "[ 6<_'W L"S9#"0 � j"&*E' ~ 6Wz- 6NK&'- $Q �P'- .IJ'- t'"# 6jR (�)­ lX? |Q"% " |_%"} �2' � t<# jW\ :7 :*)'- m'A "?9S=3 6s�* n (.IC 6�R 6jR B+L"q'- �$<='- m'A F 6+$9* O-.VT- N0 X 6B+L"} aO-.VA 6�z "&0 1#"[/'- i7 F2<# �O �.I h�&'- hN_C i&9o* )`W X{/C j"=3E' O.VhR "7)[# .>"* :0 L" 6&# 1'"Y :# m'"_G F<'- mIY "&V XFJ'"q* ­Xl� k< n) p8 pm p( nK k� k# k� l@ na pZ nX k8 xYl}¬ :F3"KS> ~"/C X.JI'- 1&<I0 u^['- m<# lm RK"% kX |8 �� kO k� n� ljnJ kK k' kP w%C nQ k[ l@ nd pWn"9lo k¬ k@ ke X x8 X lW/k" k# lD9 k<?l:9lo O-.VT- D)# R)S7 m<# m'"_G FS2/_G " 67RW .(�)­ ��J l� k� �u% kz k� n� pjk" k# F<'-W � F0 \-.&'"C ­ |] k�n"% kX l8 pQ ne �@"% kXxJ k( xG Q k�¬ :F'$/0 :*)'- BC 6t9* j80 N/_'- �"b}A 162<&# N_o* L$VP&'- :�2S9'- 6jR $Q � t<#R

.1C �)?9=7 a(.IC 6�R BC )�.'- .M"[# . 6C$90 F#"[`A !"*d- :7 )*)_'- .C"bG )_0 ;s%-W R)S&'- -PQ 6jR )/9_3W �"['- ~$/# m<# 1^<> P lBS[<' j$I* jR BJ[G B9'- 16234./'- n%I p{I pWk? !xV kA k�9x5"% p� l@ nW pG k�{kr kP kZ¬ :m'"_G F'$/V X.�"S7 NI]0 �ljnJ kK k� k� n6x"* �@ |a kz p8 k�{kZ 9 k<x{l} n@ |a kz kP) :m'"_G F'$`W X(�)­ kXJl5 l8 n� p8

.�£� 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�).�¢¥ 1*d- XNK['- (L$> (�)

.©© 1*d- X�3$* (L$> (�)

Page 51: الحرية الفكرية

50

X(�)­ �i9 k0 �* nI k� |N pWl" k# �C lz5 p8 k�{kZ 9 k<x{l}¬ :m'"_G F'$`W X(�)­ �@ l)nJ k� p<lo �'PVW .(�)­ pu9 k6 lbn"% 9k5 nJ kK k� k# p® kUk( n"% k>nJ kK k� 9 k<x{l� kP¬ :m'"_G F'$`W X k8 H lQ njk? km xK"% xX lW¯k" k# k�n( k( nAkZ nX k8 H lQ njkG kY k>x{l}¬ :m'"_G F'$` hNH7 "?#\WR B9'- :23-$/'- F<'- 1*-)?0 \$�/&'- 6jR m<# ,"[0 X(�)­ p�9 k�k? ~5} :7 6nA �=2'W X16*.]S'- 1*-)?'- 1V.Y tIKG B9'- m'"_G F<'-

.FG"*4 ux"/K0 t'"_'- F<'-W �j"Q.S'-W 1 6oK'"0 N/_'- �"[`A

��5"% y9(~# C9WP$% @RJ�G XJo ;<v"% :�"9^"% �9We:% � 6\§G )` "?63R BQW X162'"I�A 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 D"7R �/G )` a\.JV j"=3T- L-./9>- :7 i[&* �P'- �-U9Qn- :7 1'"Y m'A B9'- t2Q"J&'- BC m%$J'- :7 a1'"Y m'A �'PVW Xi&9o&VW aj"=3A �NV B# 6)2> B9'- L"ICz- :7 aNx"Q ·tV D"7R �"['- N_oG j"=3T- LW)/7 BC �2'W X 6uK'- m<# 1&x"/'- FG"#"[` N 6I]G "?63R "[2YWR " 6&# |52< i+-.93 "[<_o* ) -PQW ��'� 6NV m<# .^2=* jR t'"# D"7R 16*.IC 16* 6.Y :# Z*)K'- :7 XZKS'- 1*-)0 P[7 F0

!O.>80 \$+$'- :20 � 1*-)S'- BC � c 6.J3 jR m'A y"9K3 X162'"I�T- OPQ 1o'"_&'W

.��-�� j"9*d- X12�"r'- (L$> (�).± 1*d- X)#.'- (L$> (�)

.�¢ 1*d- X)#.'- (L$> (�).£¥ 1*d- Xk�/'- (L$> (�)

Page 52: الحرية الفكرية

51

162_&9o&'-W 162<&_'- 1>L"&&'- 6jz �F9>L"&7 :20W 16* 6.K'- R)S7 (.x-\ BC R)S&'- 1>L"&7 B6<oG :7 i>WR - |\"_0R P}8G )` 16* 6.K<' "[<_o* )` 16234./'- !"*d- �_0 BC N 6789'- 6jz �16*\.J'- ("2K'- �W.f'- \W)Y BC �"/hG jR :I&h* n 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- L"�4 6jR g.3 BC N0 X�<G WR (.IJ'- OPQ "?2C u<^hG B9'- 1623"7U'-W 1623"I&'- ~W"[93 jR "[2<# ¨.J* "7 -PQW �16*.]S<' 1<*$^'- !-L"=&'- \W)Y �'�W X16*L"bK'- WR 162_&9o&'- F9*W-� :7 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7

:1�5� !-L"=7 .S#

&R?C%Ib"% B9Jb"% :� R#$% C96<"% eo* "7W j"=3T"0 1^2K&'- 1³2S'- .2�8G 1'8=7 :7 O"3.V� "7 6jA XO.IC 1V.Y m<# "?G-.2�890 t 6IK9'- :7 j"=3T- F2<# N&_* jR

.L-$K'- (LW.% BQW X162=2>8G a(.IC D"7R "[<_o* "?[ 67§* B9'- 1C"/H'- \W)K0 - |\W)K7 j"V -�A j"=3T- 6jR �'� FG"#"[`W O.IC 6j�C X 6Bx"/<GW 6�$J# NI]0 "?0 6.]9*W i&9o&'- F' 1?+W :7 6uK'- N6H&9> "?63R �R X�'P' " |_SG |1 62S=3 j$I9> O.2IJG 1V.Y tIKG B9'- 162C"/H'-W 16*.IJ'- FG"/<^[7 :7W XO.f3

.F*)' (. 6C$9&'- !"2^_&'- \W)Y BCW XFG"+"9[9>-W "*-W� m<# �5 6�5' a1&x-\ a1+"Y BC j"=3T- 6jR B[_* -PQW �'� j$I2' X.}d- i7 L-$K'- .S# j$I* "&63A -PQW X1J<9q7 a.f3

Page 53: الحرية الفكرية

52

g.}R 1C"/� N6H&G Xg.}R a.f3 1*W-� :7 �$%$&'- 1*v.0 FS�R h.IJ'- j"V g.}R ;!"2^_7 "?*)' . 6C$9G )`W X.}4 .2IJG w?[7W L-$K'- .S# !) 6V8G -��C �"?7)_0 " |_�"` WR "?[# - |.M"` ~ 6Wz- "?2^_* -P?C Xg.}z- 1*W-U'- :7 "?2'A .f['- :7 t�.'"0 (.IJ'- 1#"[` N6H&G )_G t' "?63R �'� m[_&C X�' 6)SG -�AW X1J#"b7 ( 6$` jR � F=J3 i7 " |7"o=3- � N/_<' 6)0 n B'"9'"0W X162'n)9>- 1623"Q.0

.j"2Yz- �_0 BC " |7"&G "?J=[* WR "Q.62r* WR "?' 6)S* 9x{l} p�9x5"% 9 kj �? kZ 9k?s :m'"_G F'$` :7 �'� (\"J9>- i2^9=3 "[ 6<_'W X(�)t%I pP kC9 k'kVl" kNl�9 k( k� k# w9oI p' pe n� pa9k5 nK k' kS k# !k { pZ k# �@ ka kf X |8 � pa9k5 n\ kK kL X162#"&9+n- .�z- � 6$[G ®N h/C WR XB<S/'-W B0$_]'- � 6$[9'- 6jA Z2Y j$I* "&63A �L"_9'-W X162C"/H'- !"62M$�q'- �">R m<# D$/* "&63A

.1# 6$[9&'- .�z- �<G N2S` :7 !"62M$�q'- OPQ L"S9}"0 :*.+"?&<' t*.I'- j4./'- �)7 6jR .S9_3 jR "[Q i2^9=3 "[ 6<_'W LP# D)# m<# O)2V8GW X:*)#"/<' F 67�W X1^�"b'- t?CW.µ :7 m<# 6jR Xt?C-.K3n - |L 6.S7 "QW.S9#-W t?CW.f' -$[#�R :*P'- " |b*R F=J3 .S9q* jRW X�W.f<' atx-\ aL"S9}- BC �2_* jR j"=3T- 16* 6.Y :7 ) 6V89'- !"62'4 :7 ;()Y-W OPQW X1# 6$[9&'- �W.f'- BC

.N/_'- 1V.Y L"S9}- m'A ( 6.&9=7 a1+"Y BC j"=3T"C XL-$K'- m'A |1C"%AW

.�� 1*d- X!-.oK'- (L$> (�)

Page 54: الحرية الفكرية

53

� 6>R " 6&7 Xt<_'- �"9J3"0 j$I* "&63A -PQW Xa()*)+ a!"2^_7 \$+W \$2/'- .=IG 1*d"C X(�)tw9< nK l� ]l{ ni l£ |u xC Np� k#s :m'"_G F<'- ~$ F' OL"S9#- D)# $Q j"=3E' s<Mz- �`$&'- 6jR .S9_GW Xt<_'- D"7R O$+W :7 F+W -P?C Xt<_'- e<� BC X\W)K<' WR X!"62x"?[<'

.\$&o'-

*9�{ !"} @Wd"% &R? R@A N?IbG :]{9^"% C96<"% )/['- 16* 6.YW .IJ'- 16* 6.Y R)S7 � 6>§* D 6)/G "7 6NV j"V -�A 6jR BQW X1 6&?7 1^/3 m<# "[Q )2V89'- )*.3 "[63�C XL-$K'- (LW.%W 16*.f3 |(.IC WR " �*\.C " |V$<> N6H&G jR BrS[* n �<G 1* 6.K'- 1'8=7 tQ"=GW X1?+ :7 1 67"# 1C"/� N 6I]GW tf9[G BI' "&63AW Xe=KC jR 6)0 5C X()*)o'- L"ICz"0 B3"=3T- �L"bK'- L"=&'- )CL BC

.("2Y D"f3 m'A ~ 6$K9G 162<&# � 6U_G B9'- X1=>8&'- (.IC m'A (.�"S7 "[<2K* -PQ 6jz �16*.IJ'- !"#-)0T-W !"# 6$[9'- :7 g$�/'- (\"J9>n- �0"]GW L-W\z- � 6�$G ~5} :7 � w9[G B9'- BQ 1= 6>§&'- )Y-$'- \.J'- (L) :7 .HVR � "?9KG :*$b[&'- \-.Cz- :20 !"`5_'- j$I* "7)[# " 67R X�\.J'- F_`$7 :7 w9[* . 6IJ&'"C .F+"93A m<# X:*.}d- ~$/#W F</# ~5} :7 w9[* $?C X.IC 1= 6>§7 :&%

.��� 1*d- XF� (L$> (�)

Page 55: الحرية الفكرية

54

"*-W�W a!"2^_7 .IJ<' : 67§* "&0 u6C)9'- t2f[90 s&=G 17$f[7 .S#..t?G"7"&9Q-W t?G"C"/�W :*.}d- L"ICR "?<6H&G X1J<9q7

uCW � 6.K9G jR 6)0 n 1*.IJ'- 16*.K'- 6j�C X�">z- -PQ m<# :&% O)M.3 jR :I&* "7 �'�W Xi&9o&'- "Q"#.* 17$f[7

:12Gd- :*W"[_'- y9_%CQ"%# °9bo$% `a%@8 /-

D$<_'- .*$^G BC !">-L)'-W �"K0z- UV-.7 tQ"=G BI' 1* 6.K'- R)S7 m<# D$/G jR 6)0 n X.*$^9<' {2^q9'-W X�L"_&'-W :7 i`-$<' .*.S9'- g.>R -$_/* n m69Y X:2HY"S'- g)' 1*.IJ'- �.K* "&0 Xg.}R 1?+ :7 162/2/K'- !"2^_&'- ,"J}T WR X1?+ BC )� �.'-W p-$�'- � "|2'"G � e3"o*W XFox"93W ZKS'- L"=7

.:2=K9'-W .*$^9<' {2^q9'- N2I]G BC L-$K'- (LW.% m'A " |/0"> "3.�R )` "6[V -�AW :7 �$%$&'- m'A .f@['- BC 1*\ 6)_G :7 �'� F2[_* "&0 X�L"_&'- :7 "?S*./GW (.IJ'- :29&G BC "?#$&o&0 tQ"=GW 1J<9q7 "*-W� �"[Q 1 6K<7 (LW.% e=9I* �$%$&'- -PQ 6j�C Xp-$�'-W 6uK'- .IJ'- 1=>87 m<# D$/G !">-L)'-W �"K0z- UV-.7 (.IC 6jz i2^9=* n "&0 Xwx"9['- 1 6 \ BC �e�* �P'- � 6$[9'- �">R m<# :7 6N_'W ." �2S=3 1_*.='- 162[7U'- ( 6)&'- BC O�"o3A )Y-$'- \.J'- �">R m<# �"K0z-W !">-L)'- UV-.7 � 6>§G jR "[Q 8^q'-

Page 56: الحرية الفكرية

55

N&_'-W wx"9['- ibqG Z2K0 X~ 6Wz- ~W§=&'- WR ~ 6$&&'- 1*vL N&_'- u*.C N2I]G 6t9* jR :# |5bC X�-� WR -PQ (\-LT BHKS'-.F9* 6.YW .IJ'- 1 6 \ D"7R (.r� N 6I]* �'� 6NV 6jz �)Y-W O"o6G- :7

&RJ<K'"% ;J89v<"% /+ � 6L)G B9'- )Q"_&'-W !-�$K'- 162&<_'- i27"o&'"0 )�/3W !"M"�9}n- !-� 162&<_'- !"_7"o'- �'PVW X162[* l)'- D$<_'-

.(\ 6)_9&'- �9S�R X1620.r'- 1>L"&&'- BC "&62> nW X!"_7"o'- 10.oG 6N_' $K3 t<_'- iC\ NJIG B9'- BQ 162&<_'- 16* 6.K'- 6jR 6�]'- NS/* n "&0 )V4 �-)0T- j"V "& 6<V .SVR 16* 6.K'- �3"V "& 6<VW X�-)0T- ¦$^} aZY"0 6NV m<# 6jR $Q �"K0z- iS^* "7 6tQR :7 6N_'W .�.>RW �b* t' $<C XFHK0 BC F'PS* �P'- )?o<' B&<_'- .*.S9'- D 6)/* jR L 6.S&'- )/J* F63�C X" �*.f3 $'W X- |)*)+ t<_'- (.2=7 m'A hZKS'-

.162&*\"Vz- �$KS'- 1[o' F2<# uC-$9' B#$%$&'- XuS> "7 m<# ,"[S'-W XL"ICz- s`5G O"o6G- BC iC\ F 6<V -PQ �P'- .7z- �)Y-$'- �$%$&'- m'A 1J<9q&'- .f['- "*-W� L"S9}-W aZK0 6NV "?2C N 6I� X1[62_7 a1^/3 ~$Y �"K0z- tV-.90 s&> 6NV 1o293 $Q 6B&<# a�"]9V- 6�R j"V m69Y XF2<* "&' - |)2?&G BC p 65^'- :20 1C"=&'- �`"%W X1/0"='- pL"o9'-W �$KS'- t' F=J3 B&2<_9'- D"f['- 6jz �t?GPG">R :20W 17 6)/9&'- NY-.&'-

Page 57: الحرية الفكرية

56

.�'� m<# tQU 6JY N0 Xt?GPG">R m<# -$` 6$J9* jR p 65^<' s&=* XB[*)'- )*)o9'- 1'8=7 ~$Y "Q"3.�R B9'- 1^/['- m<# " |=2>8GW D$<_'- BC "&V 12[* l)'- D$<_'- BC aL"+ 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 6jRW

::296*.Q$+ :29^/3 m'A (L"�T- "[Q )2J&'- :7 6j�C Xg.}z- )Q"_&'-W !-�$K'- BC 12&2<_9'- wQ"[&'- ¸$M (LW.% � R e'"^'- \-)#A 6t9* Z2K0 X)`"['- .IJ'- 12&[G �">R m<# 12[* l)'- ZKS<' 17�5'- 162<&_'-W 16*.IJ'- !-L"?&'- 6NV �<9&* BI' 6\-$&'- BC .f6['- (\"#A m'A y"9K* .7z- -PQW .y"9[9>n-W g$9=&'- �W"o9* n �P'- �L"?f9>n- t2<_9'- e2'">RW X12[2/<9'-

.�'� m'A "7W XBC._&'- D"f['- :7 - |,U+ F<_+W X1*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'- R)S7 1#"�A � p ,-L²' �*)/9'- B3"_7 :7 m|[_7 6�R \"_0AW XF �=J3 B&2<_9'- �/>R i%W D)#W X:2Q-.S'-W 16'\z- :# - |)2_0 !-\"?9+n-W �P'- $Q F 6<V -P?C .162&<# !-L 6.S7 m'A ()[9=7 .2� :2HY"S<' X("2K'- !-.62r9&' "|SV-$7 m/S* BI' B[* l)'- .IJ'- .*$^90 s&=* :&% � lk['- BC �]9I* jR aZY"0 6NI' s&=* $Q hZ2Y :7 i&` 6�R ! 6$J* "&[20 Xj$/0"='- FJ]9I* t' "7 � \"?9+n- )#-$` F=J3 D5>T- i`$7 m<# N0 Xe=KC "[2<# �2' X�'� 6NV �.IC

.i`-$'- 1V.Y BC

Page 58: الحرية الفكرية

57

*9�5"%# &R? R@b"% XJo :�"9^"% C96<"% 16* 6.K'- ~ 6$KG D)# {Sb* jR :I&* �P'- Z'"H'- L"=&'- :20 1`5_'- )*)KG $Q X�-U9Qn-W m%$J'- :7 a1'"Y m'A 16*.IJ'- 1V.Y 6jR �'� .L"ICz- e6</G :20W 162_&9o&'- 12[S'- L-./9>- D$<_'- D 6)/GW !"C"]9Vn- 1V.Y �L"=G i7 "&62> nW X.IJ'- 6\.'-W P}z- :7 1&x-\ 1'"Y BC L"ICz- N_oG X!"2^_&'- u6C)GW i&9o&'- ,"[0 j"V -��C X"?G"S� D)# B[_* �P'- .7z- �L"S9}n-W "7 BC m69Y .IJ'- 1* 6.Y ¨.9J3W XB=2>89'- .IJ'- m<# D$/* �">R m<# - �./9=7 " |_&9o7 B[S3 jR "[' :I&* �2IC X�'� 6kq*

ª 6./9=7 .2� BQ N?C Xi&9o&'- !"S� ¦$^} )*)K90 j$7U<7 :K3 "[Q �_0 u2/KG �">R m<# D$/G BQ WR X.IJ'- !-)2/_90 1^SG.7 ª"|S'"� 190"� L$7R BQW X16*.]S'- ("2K'- �JK' 1*LW.b'- .M"[_'- .2]G B9'- !"*d- �_0 ~5} :7 �'� m<# 162' 6WR 10"+A s&<3 "?2<# m[S hG B9'- 162>">z- (U2V.'- j56H&* :262>">R :*.7R m'A .,-Pr'-W :7z- "GU2VL "&QW X1 67"_'- .�z-W ~W)'-W !"_&9o&'- �±I pS X |8 � pj k< k' nqkZ H lzx"% l�nJ k( n"% % kz k0 xu kC %# pQ p( n'kJ nK kPs :m'"_G ~"` w& k? n@ k� wUk k8 pm RK"% ku k@ k� k#s :m'"_G ~"`W X(�)t �� nI kL nX |8 � pjk5 k8g k# l� p'n{ krlo ny k@ kd kW kP �D9 kW k8 |N pa X |8 w%Q k� kC 9 kj p� n£ lC 9 kjJlG nr k? w& x5l� k< n) �8 w& k5 l8g n�k{9 ka

.�-� j"9*d- X�*.` (L$> (�)

Page 59: الحرية الفكرية

58

~ 6)SG m<# )2V8G "[Q � l� nI k¡n"% k# l±I pvn"% k�9k(l" pm RK"% 9 kj k�% kf kr kP lm RK"% n� ljl5 kW n6 k8 ]lP �� k( k6l" kD9 ka nQ k\ k"¬ X(�)t kDI p'k5 n�k? n%I p{9 ka 9 k<lo � :2GU2V.'- �B kQ nKko pm k" %# p@ pW ne% k# n� pW|o kC l� n£ |C Xl8 %I pK pa ��9 k< le k# �XJ l<k? X k� lD9kV x5 kS �& k?g kXnJ ko k# n� pjk5 nJ ko 9k5 nK k' kS k#s :m'"_G ~$/* jR m'A (�)t �CI pd k� ­u kC k# �& k( |J kq 9 kjJlP %# p@J l_ k@ nJ x6"% 9 kjJlP 9k{ nC xQ k� k# wB k@ l09 k¢ h w@ p� 9 kjJlP 9k5 na kC9ko ]lV x"% h k@ p\n"%

.!"*d- :7 �'� .2�W X(�)t kXJl5 l8g w989 x? kZ k# k]l"9 kJ k" �P'- .2SI'- :bK'- "&?63R :2GU2V.'- :2G"Q LW\ t?J3 )`W jR i2^9=* n ix"o'- WR �x"q'- 6jz �j"=3T- 1V.Y :b9K* -��C -PQ m<#W .16* 6.K0 . 6IJ* jR nW X�)S* jR m<# L)/* nW Xw9[* t2/3 jR "[' :I7R X.IJ'- 1V.Y :20W �"&9+n- 1J2µW :20 "[< 6�C D"f['- �'� :b9K* �P'- �`$'- BC X a�0"� �">R m<# D"f['- 12J2V $K3 " |? 6+$7 F[7 ;,U+ j$I*W X�-)0T- 1* 6.YW X.IJ'- 1V.Y " |b*R -PQW XO\-.CR ("2YW Xi&9o&'- :7R L-.&9>- m<# 1fC"K&'-

..IJ'- 1* 6.Y !n"o7 :7 ;~"o7 t2/'- :7 1#$&o&' i&9o&'- ,"[0 y"9K* X�'� m'A 1C"%A t2/V X" |_2&+ �"['- :20 c"J6G- i%$7 BQ B9'- 1623"=3T- 162`5}z- N6H&* -PQW X�'� m'A "7W (,"JI'-W 13"7z-W ¡5}T-W c)�'- �59}"0 �<9qG n B9'-W X!"_&9o&'- L-./9>- :7 - |.2SV - |,U+

.��� 1*d- XNK['- (L$> (�).�¢ 1*d- X8S> (L$> (�).�  1*d- X8S> (L$> (�)

Page 60: الحرية الفكرية

59

." |7$&# L"ICz-W 1*.IJ'- !"Q"oGn- WR eQ-P&'- WR j"*\z- !"S�W L"ICz- :20 1`5_'- 1'8=7 N2<KG BC .HVR u 6&_93 )`W XL"ICz- t'"# BC m69Y .]S'- :20 �-.�'- 1V.Y �uCW Xi&9o&'- :20 XF=J3 �.]S'- � 6$�[9'- O. 6C$* "&63A !"SH'- :7 "|³2� @jR )o[' jR j$'W"K* :*P'- :20W X1�&*)/'- L"ICz- m<# !"SH'- aL"�3R :m�'"_G F�<'- ~$` F�2'A .2]* )` "7 -PQW X()*)o'- tQL"ICR -$9SH* X(�)t pª nC k$% ly kQ k6 kdx" � n' k(lo n� pj kO n'ko k�9x5"% lm RK"% p; nP ki kY nIk" k#s n� k8 |Q pjx" � n' k(lo � pj kO n'ko k�9x5"% lm xK"% p; nP ki kY nIk" k#s :m'"_G F'$`W X(�)tw%@Jl^ ka lm xK"% p� n_% 9 kjJlP p@ ka nz p? pQ lS9 k6 k8 k# �y% kI kK k[ k# �;kJlo k# p; l8% kI k[ j$IG n )` "?6[I'W Xp.K'- c"2> BC |(\L-W �3"V jAW B?C � 6D"# R)S7 !"62<oG :7 "|³2� hp.K'- N6H&G "&63AW X"?0 |(L$�K7

.t<#R F<'-W

N R8rG &)\{ �W.0 6jR BQW XZKS'- -PQ "[7"7R "QL"�R ;(.2}R ;1^/3 �2/0 tIK'- t'"# BC !"6*L$G"9I*)'-W �$^<='- i&/'- !"V.Y 16* 6.K'- R)S&0 !"_&9o&'- P}R D)# :7 8][G "&63A X!"7$IK'-W j"=3T- m<# R.^G B9'- !-.62r9&'- 1SV-$&0 s&=G B9'- 16*.IJ'- ."Q.2� WR 162>"2='- WR 162#"&9+n- WR 16*\.J'- �3"V ,-$> XF9V.YW

.�£� :(./S'- (L$> (�).�¢ : 6wK'- (L$> (�)

Page 61: الحرية الفكرية

60

X�$<='-W .IJ'- m<# "?=J3 ¨.JG !-.62r9&'- �<G 6jR �'� WR tV"K'- g)' s'"�&'- 1V.Y �`"[* )` " |&IY "?/CW .2='-W 6.&G X�">z- -PQ m<#W X�$J['- WR O"o'- WR 1^<='- eY"M X("2K'- )2&oG 10- 6$0 :7 O�$J3W FG-�"297-W F_`$7 m<# F9fC"K7 :7 j$I* "&63A -PQW XFK'"�7 D)qG (\ 6)K7 1^/3 )[# "?C"/*AW " �2>"2>W " �2#"&9+-W " �2C"/�W " �*.IC �"['- s2^=G m'A ,$o<'- ~5} XtV"K'- �*)/G 1'8=&' w*W.9'"0 s&=* �P'- .7z- ��'� m'A "7W xF k¡kV n_9 kPs :j$#.C w?[7 :# F<'- Z*)Y BC �'� s&<3 "&V j$#.C �"Jq9>"0 1#"^'- {0L :7 t?J3 )` �A X(�)tp�I p�9 kqkr kP pm k8 nI k� "7 WR ~$/* "7 )[# \$&o'-W F=*)/GW tV"K'- 1#"� 6jR XF7$/' �<G :7 j$7$IK&'- "?]2_* B9'- 1 6Jq'- eS=0 6t9* "&63A XF0 . 6IJ* :<_* jR BC B_&9o&'- 6uK'- j$#.C s[&* "7 -PQW .BY-$['- X(�)tli9 ke x@"% kNJl( k_ xYl} n� pW? lQ n0kZ 9 k8 k# h kCkZ 9 k8 xYl} n� pW? lC pZ 9 k8s :F7$/' XF�S_� tV"K'- .�9q2C X(�)tHl@nJ k� �m k"l} nX |8 � pWk" p� n<lK k� 9 k8 s s&=* n B9'- XtV"K'- !"62G-� :7 "|³2� hF h=J3 he_ 6]'- sS�h*W

!F[7 «"Q$`.=*» WR X"?2C -$C 6.�9* j80 :*.}²' :*P'- s'"�&'- p"KMR 6NV F>L"&* "7 $Q w?[&'- -PQ 6N_'W Xe=KC 6B>"2='- i`$&'- BC n X a)*)+ 6NV :7 .^q'"0 jW._]*

.£� 1*d- X�.}U'- (L$> (�).�© 1*d- X.C"� (L$> (�)

.�  1*d- Xk�/'- (L$> (�)

Page 62: الحرية الفكرية

61

XF=J3 :* l)'- N/Y m'A :2&9[&'- :7 .2HI'"0 �'� N6H&9* )` "&63AW WR XR)S&V )*)o9'-W 1* 6.K'- 1'8=7 12 6&QR j$_* n : 6&7 ,-$> ¹"JK'- 1V.Y BC ()*)o'- L"ICz- 162&QR j$S#$9=* n : 6&7 hL @$�hG )` �"['- :7 1 67"_'- @jR )o3 �'P'W .F=J3 :* l)'- m<# X:* l)<' ae*.qG WR a~5%A 1V.Y "?63R m<# )*)o9'- Nx"=7 t?' N2S> BC -$'PS2' j$/<^[* � t?M5}AW tQ"*-$3 :=K0 � tQ-.9C m'A .7z- N�* )`W Xwo<'- F9?+-$7 BC -$%$q*W Xw?&'- �'� he�.G n 1 67"_'- 6jz -PQ �2'W X" �*$[_7 WR " �* l\"7 :*\ l)o&'- D-)#A X!"_&9o&'- NM"J&0 t 6IK9G g$` 1 6&� @jz "&63AW X)*)o'"0 m<# (L)/'- "?' N_o* "7 -PQW X"?x"/0W "?G"+"Y 6)> BC "?9V.YW F+W BC X!"_x"]'- u*$=GW Xux"/K'- �2*UGW XL$7z- .*$KG :2C.9&'- :# m'"_G F<'- Z*)Y BC " �2<+ FK&<3 "7 $QW X:2K<�&'- .7z- �:2K<�&'-W ,"2S3z- F+W BC -$J`W :*P'- :*.SI9=&'-W ,n§Q 1^<> �"_%�0 � " |&I hY � �.&* �"['- .*.KG N_o* �P'- X:*\ l)o&'- N2YL )_0 6nA �'� u 6/K9* n "7 "|S'"�W XtQ.2�8GW "?=J3 X,n§Q "?C.]9=* j"V B9'- X!-.62r9&'- ¨.JG :2Y �'�W L"ICR m'A :*\W)]7 t?=J3R ,n§Q )o2C Xt?=J3R 1 67"_'- m<# 1`5_'- 162')+ BQ �<GW XtQ\$+W m<# -$fC"K* BI' :*\ 6)o&'-

.)*)+ :7 FG"2YW 16* 6.K'- i&`W .IJ'- �!$7W ,"/S'- 6eY :20 162G-P'- 12[S'- �_% :20 D�59'- u^[7 :# .6S_* "7 6tQR :7 6N_'W

Page 63: الحرية الفكرية

62

X!"6* 6.K'- m<# u22b9'-W �$^<='- i&/'- !n"Y �W.0 :20W �K ��"% !"} p¥9Vb? 9<R{}» :Q :2=K'- :0 6B<# D"7T- ~$`

.(�)« pFJ'O"%

X� ]j5"%# �#@'<"9o @8$%# @Wd"% &? R@A :�"9^"% �9We:%@W5<"%

6jR BQW XZKS'- -PQ 1*"?3 BC "?9o'"_7 :7 "[' 6)0 n 1^/3 1 6&� 16* 6.K'- (.IC :7 162[* l)'- ¦">Wz- g)' "&62> nW X" |�"K29>- 1&� °\"S&'- L-.&9>- :# j"=3T- 162'W§=7 m<# B[S[G B9'- 16*.IJ'- �W._&'"0 .7z-» R)S7 :&% �'�W Xi&9o&'- 1V.Y BC t2/'-W m|[_7 F' j$I* :' �'� 6jR B?*)S'- :7W X«.I[&'- :# B?@['-W e=K0 �W._&'- B[_* �W._&'"0 .7z- 6jR "3.S9#- -�A 6nA 6B_`-W �2IC ��'PV F9#"[` e=K0 .I[&'- :# B?@['-W Xj"=3T- 1#"[` j"=3A 6NI' 6jR ¨.9J* �P'- 16*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'- R)S7 i7 �'� e>"[9* F63R .}4 ;j"=3A )/9_* )` 6uK'- F63R j"=3T- )/9_* "7W XFG"#"[` jR :*.}d- m<# ¨.J* j80 |"#.� j"=3T- D �U< h* �2IC XN�"S'- R)S&' |1K*.M 1J'"q7 -PQ �2'R !ªN�"S'- F63R jW)/9_* "7 -$<_J*

!ª162?/J'- 12Y"['- :7 16*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'-::29?+ :7 �'� m<# e2o3 jR j"I7T"0 6N_'W

.&R?i9 Rv6"% &dJb�"% X1_&o'-W mK%z- B7$* BC Fx"#\ :7 (�)

Page 64: الحرية الفكرية

63

:# B?@['-W �W._&'"0 .7z- R)S&' 162?/J'- 1?+$'- 6jA X!"#$% 1'"Y BC :®*L$VP&'- B?@['-W .7z- p$+W ¦$/=0 Bb/G .I[&'- !"#"[/'- BC �59}n- WR X)2</9'-W \"?9+n- BC �59}n- j$I* n jR» X«Fh2?3W hO h.7R eo* :7» ¦W.� BJC ..}4 .2S_90 !n"Y BC "&V �'�W Xe+-$'- �.GW .I[&'- N_C BC - |LWP_7 "7W " |7-.Y �2' F<_J* "7 @j80 \"/9#n- !n"Y BC WR X(LW.b'- F_+.7 �RL WR X 6�\"?9+n- F*RL $Q �'� j$I' �"|S+-W �2' FV.9* �'� BC - |LWP_7 �6<I&'- j$V t< h# j�C XF2C O)2</G F' �$o* �P'- :7 F2<# D-)`T- )*.* "7 j$I* jR 6nA �B?@['-W .7z- p$+W {/> NQ"o'- :7 $'W X" |/<^7 "?#$`$0 m'"_G F<'- m%.* n B9'- L$7z- eo* F63�C X17.9K&'- �J@['- N9`W ¨Lz- BC \"=CT"V XNC"r'-W X(�)«"?2<# D$�87 .2� "?2C - |LWP_7 j"V $'W � aP³[2Y � "?[# F#\L D-U9'n-W 6D"_'- D"f6['- 1'8=7 m'A \$_* "7 BQ (.2}z- 1^/['-W N 6})9GW X�"['- 6NV F' ibq* "7 $QW XF/ 6/K* �P'- j$3"/'"0 j"=3T- hLP h#W XF0 ~5}T- :7 i[&'- N2S> BC 1^<='- WR 1'W @)'-

.s%-W $Q "&V i[&'- u2/K9' N 6})9'- 1/*.� \ 6)K* aP³[2Y !"#"[/'- "?2<# � 6>89G B9'- 16*.IJ'- 1* 6.K'- 1'8=7 " 67R aP³[2Y ("C"[7 nW XR)S&'- -PQ ¦W.� :&% ;13"�7 B?C X1J<9q&'-

."&?[20 L-\ XD�¢¢¥ X(1K 6K�7 1K 6/[7) �¦ X&'?@�"% m\P X:2=Y ) 6&K7 )62='- XF<'- NbC (�)

.��   1'8=7 X¥�± � ¥�¥¡ X�y Xj"[S' X!W.20 X�5&'-

Page 65: الحرية الفكرية

64

eQ-P&'- �_0 �"SGR F0 D$/* "7 6j�C X�'� �">R m<#W 162SQP&'- WR 16*\"?9+n- t?G"#"[` !"7U<9=7 ¨.C :7 16275>T- R)S&' ;�'"q7 ;.7R X($^='-W ( 6$/'"0 Xg.}z- eQ-P&'- �"SGR m<# "&V " |/<^7 �2' F63z �F=J3 .I[&'- :# B?@['-W �W._&'"0 .7z- !-\"?9+n-W !"#"[/'- �59}n a�-.7 $Q "&63AW X" |J34 "3.�R

.162?/J'- !"7-U9'n-W �W._&'"0 .7z- R)S7 i*.]G m'A .f@['- "[3"I7A BC 6jA X&J{9^"% )/9_* :7 m<# 1*-)?'- p$+W 1'8=7 �'PVW X.I[&'- :# B?6['-W U2JKG :7 a�$3 (L-\T ;U2JKG F63R m<# X~5 @b'- BC i`-W .}d- 6jR s%-$'- :7 �A �L"ICz- t'"_0 {SG.* "7 BC 6\"b&'- )/['-W )/['- R)S7 X a�W._&' ;�L"G WR X.I[&<' ;eIG.7 .}d- 6j80 akq� \"/9#- 6jR j"=3T- �'P' ;iC-\ X�'� 1620-$�0 F9#"[` 1?+ :7 �'� j"V $'W 1?+W :# iC-)* j80 .}²' ;iC-\W X.}²' O.f3 1?+W :62S* jz L 6$^9' " �*LW.% " |�.� N6H&G 16*.IC 1V.Y OPQW XN0"/&'- BC O.f3

.p"9I'- -PQ 1*"?3 BC F2'A .2][> "&V ("2K'- X)/['- .2*"_7 m'A D"I9Yn- m<# "[Q )2V89'- �LW. @b'- :7 Xt_3 m'A !"#"[/'- N*$KG �2'W XL"ICz- �-.M L"�A BC ¦"Sb3n-W "7 .2� BC X1<2bJ'- .]3W X 6uK'- :# �"C 6)'- t>"0 � �L"&G i& (-\R !"62'W§=&'- � 6�$G m<# "[0 6N^G 1'8=&'- OPQW XD"_'- D"f@['"0 {SG.* 6)Y BC u 6&_9'-W ZKS'"0 ;(.*)+ 1'8=7 BQW XD"fl['- 1V.Y :&%

."[#$%$7 e< hM BC N})G n �3"V jAW X"?G-�

Page 66: الحرية الفكرية

65

�@Wd"% &R? R@A ;8 QJK\V"% ;<Vv? FJa :;o%@"% �9We:% "&0 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 m<# "[Q ¨-.9#n- :I&&'- :7 �.2� �j"=3T- ,"?/J'- DU'R Z2Y XF/J'- BC )2</9'"0 F2<# s<^M- P}82C X a)?9o7 m'A i+.* jR B?/J'- \"?9+n- 1+L\ m'A NM-$'- "|0.% -PQ �2'R :~-§='-W X" �2<&# "?7U9<*W X1_*.]'- D"IYR F[#

ª"?' �2>89'- "['W"Y B9'- ()#"/<' ::29?+ :7 $?C X�'� m<# p-$o'- " 67R

NQR m'A �$+.'- (.IC m<# D$/G )2</9'- 1'8=7 6jA :!"#$% 6j�C Xt'"_'- BC ,5/_'- 6NV F2<# yL)* m|[S7 -PQW X¡"�9}n- F' �2' :7W X,"6S�z- m'A i+.* 6e^'- BC ¡"�9}- F' �2' :7 ;u �&_G F' �2' :7 �-PIQW X:2>)[?&'- m'A i+.* 1>)[?'- BC ;�"0 i+.* 1>"2='-W \"�9`n-W �J['-W �"&9+n- t<# BC 6B>-L\ BC a¡"�9}- N/Y $Q F/J'- t'"#W ."?0 :2 6�9q&'-W "?0"0LR m'A 6NV �2<IG y.K'- :7W X 6B<&# ;e3"+ F'W XB[*)'- 6k['- t?C ~59}- e+$* �'� 6jA N0 �F<2�KG BC O)?+ ~PS* j80 j"=3A DU'8C X 6Bx5/_'- w?['- -PQ m<# j4./'- g.+ �'P'W X�"['- ("2Y n j"V -�A X¡"�9}n- NQR tQW X.VP'- NQR ~-§=0 j"=3T- .(�)t kDI p< kK n'kG kY n� pV5 pa Dl} l@ na |z"% kN n0kZ n%I p" kr n_9 kPs :m'"_G ~"/C Xt<_* j"=3T- e<^* N0 X |1#"[` e6<^9G n 1'8=&'- 6jR t<_'- i7 F 6<V -PQ

.± 1*d- X,"2S3z- (L$> (�)

Page 67: الحرية الفكرية

66

X)?9o&'- 8^} :62SG $' "7 BC F<'- D"7R F=J[' 16*LWP_&'- "?2C F9 6oY 6j�C XF<&# )[9=7 :# � 17"2/'- D$* � F<'- F'8> -�A F63A Z2K0 X1_*.]'- D"IYR 1C._7 BC (.Sq'- F' :7 m'A �$+.'- j$I9> ;.7R j"=3T- !"#"[` BC ,B� ~"}\AW X ;,B� 16*LWP_&'- h1'8=7W

..}4 m<# 162[S&'- Nx"=&'- :7 BQ )2</9'- 1'8=&C X~"Y 6NV m<#W n N&_'"0 1^SG.7 BQW X162?/C 16'\z 1_%"} 162</# !-\.J7 F9J2µW )*)KG BC 1?+$'- OP?0 j"=3T- i[9`- -��C X!"#"[/'"0 F^0-$%W .IJ'- 16* 6.Y :7 - |,U+ )2</9'- (\.J7 �3"V 162<&_'-

.16*.IJ'- a�.^V 6k9q&'- .2� j"=3T- N})h3 jR j"I7T- BC 6jA :&J{9^"% 1/*.^'- m<# � 6JK9'- :I&&'- :&C F2<#W �)2</9'- 1'8=7 BC aN#"C )l</&'- LW\ L"S9#- BQW X1 67"_0 162?/J'- gW"9J'- "?2<# !.+ B9'- XB#.]'- tIK<' a)[9=7 6�R t?J* jR F' �2' F63RW Xu<^&'"0 " @2S<> NQR :7 �2' �R X« 6B 67"#» F63z �{/C P 6J[* jR BQ F9J2µW N0

.¡"�9}n- 6jR ¨-.9C- m<# D$/2C X aN#"C a�.^V )6</&'- �'� ~$}\ " 67RW N/_<' :I&* Z2K0 X" | 6=S7 $'W XO-$9C )[9=7 :62S* jR F2/J'- m<# 1^>-$0 $'W Xg$9J'- F2<# D$/G �P'- N2')'- �L)* jR �\"_'- t*.I'- j4./'- 1/*.� BQ "&V " |7"&G X{ 6=S7 aN2<_G WR as%-W ·k3

Page 68: الحرية الفكرية

67

�P'- R)S&'"0 WR 1&IK'"0 "?<2*PGW X162#.]'- D"IYz- ¨.# BC i7 R�2S'- NQR 1 6&xR 1/*.� F2<# �3"V "7 m<#W XF2'A )[9=G %f}» :~"` F63R Q .`"S'- ) 6&K7 D"7T- :# �WL )/C Xt?0"KMR

.(�)«mK"% u9Va X� ]{I"r_9P �]�o �WV~ RQA N2�KG m<# - |L\"` �6<I&'- N_o* )` XmK[&'- -PQ NH7W N6H&* F63R 6nA X |1#"[` :I* t' jAW 6:f'-W XB#.]'- tIK'"0 6:f'- 1 67"G 1#"[` N2�K9' F2<# m[S h* jR :I&h* X1#"[/'- :7 "|S*.` "|³2� "?>">R m<# �"['- � 6.K9* 162x5/# 1?+W " |b*R $QW X"|³2]C "|³2� m<# 1_*.]'- !L"> )`W X1 67"9'- 1C._&'- p-$0R jW)/J* "7)[# \)#W 1<S/'- )*)KG NH7 BC 6:f'- �"S6G- F' �Y"0R "7)[# "?[7 a,B�

.�'� $K3W !"_V.'- p"0 j$I* jR m<# |n"I�A N 6o=* jR ZY"S<' :I&h2C X�'P0W �6<I&'- N_o* �P'- m&#z- )2</9'- p"0 :7 F/J'- t'"# BC )2</9'- 1'8=&' �2>89'- :I&* )` "&63AW Xu<^&'- BC 162S<> 1'"Y �\"_'- )l</&'- :20 � BS=['- $'W � B0"o*T- N#"J9'- ()#"` m<# )2</9'- 6jz �B#.]'- tIK'"0 D-U9'5' i>WR "|0"0 s9J* "7 -PQW X) @</&'-W g$`R � 1 67"G :IG t' jAW � F0 162<2�JG 1#"[` :# �2<I90 D-U9'n- m<# 16'-)'- 12 l�@['- !"7$&_'- m'A - |\"[9>- "?3W\ :7 D-U9'n- :7 .S# j"=3T- m<# {rbG 162<&_'- ("2K'- 6jR "&62> nW X�"S6Gn-

.�� X �¡ X�©y X&'J�"% N�9_# XB<7"_'- .K'- (�)

Page 69: الحرية الفكرية

68

.!"62 6<I'- .S# n XN2M"J9'- ��"[<' 6D"_'- g$9=&'"0 " |�"SGL- 1'8=&'- OP?' 6jR )o3 "[63A @t� "[3"7� BC hiJ[* )_* t' X au0"> aj"7� BC �)o* j"V "7 6jR )o[C ~)o'- F2C .HVW X�"[<' 1 67"_'- 1C._&'- p$=[7 F2C iJGL- �P'- t2<_9'-W ~"�6Gn- Nx">W L 6$^G .S# �'�W XO.2�W BSQP&'- B9'- 1<³>z- :7 O"3.S} "7 -PQW X(�).�"S&'- .2�W (�).�"S&'- j"2S0 i[/* n j"=3T- !"SC XF=J3 B#.]'- tIK'- m'A F 6+$hG �G"0 "?2'A )[9=* B9'- ()#"/'-W N2')'- t?C m'A y"9K* "&63AW XF' tIK'- 6)Y BC � N6H&* -PQW �" �2?/C " |M"�9}- e6<^9* n a{ 6=S7 NI]0 $'W «2<S9'- N/Y BC :2<r9]&'-W ,"&<_'- m<# BrS[* 162'"I�A � FG-� 1'8=7 BC O.�R �'P' 6jz �"Q)[# �6 $9'-W "?9fY57 B75>T- �"['- D"?6G- F_7 6s�* n "&0 X12#.]'- D"IYz"0 �"['- D-U9'- .M"[_'"0 1'8=&'- N�69G "7 L)/0 Xj"&*T- �_%W �-.K3n"0 BC F2'A "3.�R �P'- $K['- m<# D-U9'n- ()#"` :29&9' 1*LW.b'-

.L$7z- ux"/K0 t'"_'- F<'-W �uS> "7

!"_7"+W �L-)7 :7 12&2<_9'- !"= 6>§&'- .S# � 6.K9* �P'- .�"S&'- t2<_9'"0 )�/3 (�) ."Q$K3W )Q"_7W

1IS]'- ~5} :7 . 6C$G �KSMR B9'-W NM-$9'- Nx">W .S# X.�"S&'- .2� t2<_9'- (�) .2HI'- m<# F0 s9J[GW Xj"=3T- 1C"/� B 6&[G B9'- 1C._&'- p-$0R :7 .2HI'- "Q.2�W 12G$SI[_'-

." |/0"> F[Q� BC LW)9' :IG t' B9'- !n"I�T-W 1<³>z- :7

Page 70: الحرية الفكرية

69

QjVv<"% @J� X8 HQ\'"% i9jVSY% :�89¡"% �9We:% ()#"` m<# F2'A �$+.'- ¨.J* ¡"�9}- N/Y F/J'- j"V -�A iS99=* n $QW XF2C 6k9q&'- m'A a~"o7 BC 6k9q&'- .2� �$+L jR " 67A �:*L"2} D"7R "[Q :K3W X |1#"[` e6<^9G ()2/_'- 6j�C X- |\"/9#- 16* 6.Y R)S&' ;�`"[7 -PQW XF/J'- 1<V"� m<# "?2C )2</9'"0 s&=3 �<9&* n F63R ¨W.J&'-W \"?9+n- F[7 e<^3 jR " 67AW �.IJ'-

ª1'8=&'- 6NK3 �2IC �\"?9+n- !-W\R )x"/_'- :20 u*.J9'- (LW.% m'A UIG.* �'� m<# p-$o'- B9'- 16*.f['- )x"/_'- :20W Xj"&*T- �2>89' 17�5'- 162>">z-

.F/J'- BC \"?9+n- L-.� m<# k l�q97 a\"?9+- m'A y"9KG "?2<# ~n)9>n-W X16*.^C )x"/# B?C 162>">z- )x"/_'- " 67R �'P'W XFG"*$9=7 !W"JG i7 6B3"=3T- N/_'- m<# ;N?>W ;{2=0 .2IJ9'- :7 m3\z- 6)K'- �<97- :&' - |. 6=297 "?2C \"?9+n- j"V \$+W m<# F<2'\ :# N³> �P'- 6B0-.#z- �'� .2f3 XB/^[&'- X.2=&'- m<# 6~)* D-)`z- .�RW X.2_S'- m<# �~)G h(._S'-» :~"/C XF<'- �2^<'- m<# �~)G n X ay"9GL- !-� ; LRW X ay-.0R h!-� ;!-W"&=CR

.«!ª.2Sq'- BC )2</9'- �-$+ D)_0 " |7$&# ,"?/J'- m9CR X�">z- -PQ m<#W O)x"/_0 1#"[/'- N2�K9' \"?9+n- aj"=3A lNV m<# 6jRW X()2/_'-

.162>">z-

Page 71: الحرية الفكرية

70

k l�q97 a\"?9+- m'A y"9KG �R X16*.f3 )x"/_'- �3"V -�A " 67RW �:S h* t'W X�"['- D$&# "?0 �6<I* t' �'� N+ºC X"?+"9[9>n 1#"[/'- N2�KG D-L :7W .(s'"�'- N&_'-) B<&_'- D-U9'n- "?2<# B9'- 1C"/H'- :7 :62_7 g |$9=7 N2�KG F7U<* !-\"/9#n- OPQ NH&0 "[63R i7 X"?%._* B9'- F96'\z " |_SG 1[62_7 a.f3 1?+$0 i[9/* F<_oG

.ZKS'-W N 6789'- :7 )*U&'- m'A y"9KG "[Q 1'8=&'- 6jR N&9K3

RQG@<"% NV� hIVP :�i96"% �9We:% X.IJ'- 1* 6.Y t'"# BC 162'"I�A 1'8=7 m<# 6N^3 jR "[2<# B/0 X1 67"_0 B75>T- F/J'- tIY Z2Y X:* l)'- :# \-)GLn- 1'8=7 BQW ac$S=7 .2� �R X" �*.^C j"V -��C � hN9/ h* D5>T- :# 6)G.&'- @j80 m<# j"V :7 aD"6*R �1�5H' hp"99=h* "&63AW X hp"99=h* 5C X.}4 a:*)0 D.9K* n D5>T- 6jR B[_* F �+$9'- -PQW X @)GL- 6t� t<>8C .}4 a:*\ " |b*R hN�* )/C Xj"&*T- m'A N�* )` "&V .IJ'- 6jz �.IJ'- 16* 6.Y .JI* jR m'A "?0 hi[9/* B9'- !"2^_&'- F0 � 6\§G "7)[# X �.JI'- m'A t*.I'- j4./'-W ª�2V .�<G WR 162[*)'- 1/2/K'- OP?0 :7§* n WR X k< kP n� pW|o xC Xl8 �c kbn"% lN p� k#s :m'"_G F'$/0 R)S&'- -PQ m<# ) 6VR )`

.(�)t n@ pd nWkJ nK kP �9 ke X k8 k# Xl8 n� pJ nK kP �9 ke ,"?/J'- h.IC $Q B?/J'- �`$&'- @jR X�'� m<# p-$o'-W

.�© 1*d- X�?I'- (L$> (�)

Page 72: الحرية الفكرية

71

�RL (\"2> @jz �N 6789'-W 1>-L)'- )_0 FC5} "[' sb69* )` �P'- �2' X162S<�z- ��RL WR " |#"&+A WR X" �2?/C «" |�-.G» N6H&* sSMR :62_7 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- R)S7 u6S^3 :K3 -P?0W X 6uK'- N6H&* jR (LW.b'"0 :20W "[[20W XZKS'- 1*-)0 BC D @)/G "7 BC !"*d- "?' �= 6>R B9'- !"62'"I�T- ,$% m<# "? h9]`"[7 6t99' :2Q-.S'-W 16'\z- �R.'- -PQ 12+L"q'- !n"I�T- "[Q )�/3 n .1'8=&'"0 {2KG B9'- 16*.IJ'- !"62'"I�T- "&63AW X.JI'- 16* 6.Y 1'8=&' :*.}d- 1*v.0 1^SG.&'- ¡$�['- ¨L"_G :7 8][G B9'- �<G �R X162<}-)'- 162C._&'- WR X(�)t lX? |Q"% ]lP k�% k@ nal} kYs :m'"_G F'$` N2S` :7 X"?=J3 12[*)'- X(�)t�@ l)nJ k� p<lo �ljnJ kK k� k� n6x" * �@ |a kz p8 k�{kZ 9 k<x{l} n@ |a kz kPs :m'"_G F'$` "7W X(�)t kXJl5 l8 n� p8 n%I p{I pWk? !xV kA k�9x5"% p� l@ nW pG k�{kr kP kZs :m'"_G F'$` WR \-)GLn- BC N9/'- tIY :20 e>"[9'- D)_0 BY$* " 6&7 �'� m'A 6)G.&'- tIK' �2>89'- :I&h* 5C XF2<#W .17 6)/9&'- !"*d- :20W nW X!"62'"I�T- �<G 6NY jW\ :7 ,"?/J'- O.VP* "7 uS� m<# !"*-W.'- :7 �S� )` N9/'"0 ¨.9J�&'- B#.]'- tIK'- 6jR "&62>

.� BG82> "&V � F<H7 :# j4./'- 6$<} 6Nµ BC NS` :7 X162>"2> 1J2µW \-)GLn- tIK' j$I* jR 6nA 6t?<'- n%I p5 l8g lu9kV lWn"% lN n0kZ nX |8 �& kdl�¦ xq �k"9 k� k#s :m'"_G F'$` BC \LW "7

.�£¥ 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�).��-�� j"9*d- X12�"r'- (L$> (�)

.©© 1*d- X�3$* (L$> (�)

Page 73: الحرية الفكرية

72

n� pj xK k'k" p� k@ lLg n%# p@ pd na% k# lC9 kjx5"% km nS k# n%I p5 k8g kX? lzx"% !kK k� k� l { pZ kH lzx"9lo �)?9=* 6B>"2> �$<=' - �)Y 1'8=&'- j$IG Z2K0 X(�)t kDI p' lS n@k? �<9q* -PQW X,"[S'- :7� BC B75>T- i&9o&'- 12[0 1_b_%

.Nx">$'-W �"%Wz-W 1[7�z-W �W.f'- �59}"0 j-$[_' ¨ 6._9G t*.I'- j4./'- BC ;!"*4 !\LW )/C X�'� i7W :m'"_G ~"` .N9/'- htIY "?2C \.* t' �'� i7W XF=J3 \-)�GLn- n� k)l( kA k>l�/k" n# pr kP �@lP9 ka kI p0 k# n� p<kJ kP lml5? li X k� n� pW5 l8 ni lQkG n@k? X k8 k#s 9 kjJlP n� p0 lC9 x5"% pu9 kb n[kZ k>l�/k" n# pZ k# lB k@ lL�% k# 9kJ n{ �Q"% ]lP n� pj p"9 k< n�kZ n%I p5 k8g x� p~ n%# p@ kd ka x� p~ n%I p5 k8g kX? lzx"% xDl}s :m'"_G ~"`W X(�)t kD# pQl"9 kL n� pjk? lQ njkJl" kY k# n� pjk" k@ ld n�kJl" pm RK"% lX pWk? n� x" w%@ nd pa n%# pi% ki n£% x� p~ n%# p@ kd ka x� p~ X k� n� pW5 l8 xQkG n@k? X k8 n%I p5 k8g kX? lzx"% 9 kj �? kZ 9k?s :m'"_G ~"`W X(�)twUJl( k_ �B x l�kZ kXJl5 l8 n� p<n"% !kK k� �& x" lf kZ pm k{I �( lbp? k# n� pj �( lbp? �* nI k\lo pm RK"% ]lGnr k? k� nI k6 kP lml5? li X(�)t ��l�� k& k8 nIk" kDI pP9 k¡k? kY k# lm RK"% lNJl( k_ ]lP kD# pQ l09 kvp? kX? l@lP9 kWn"% !kK k� p� pjk" kXxJ k( kG 9 k8 lQ n'ko X |8 � l0 lC9ko nikZ !kK k� %# �QkG nC% kX? lzx"% RD}s :m'"_G ~"`W

.(£)t n� pjk" !kK n8kZ k# n� pjk" k� xI k_ pD9 k)nJ x�"% h kQ pjn"% ,-Uo'- N_oG B9'- !"*d- OPQ 6NV :# 6�r'- "[' :I&h* nW ��W.]&'- ~"&VA 162<&# BC F' 1&2` n WR X" �*W.}R \-)GLn- m<#

.±� 1*d- Xj-.&# ~4 (L$> (�).��± 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�).��± 1*d- X"=['- (L$> (�).£� 1*d- X()x"&'- (L$> (�).�£ 1*d- X) 6&K7 (L$> (£)

Page 74: الحرية الفكرية

73

~�"qG jAW Fx"S#80 j$7$/* :7 F#W.]&' N 6?=* m'"_G F<'- 6jz ~5} :7 ,n§Q m<# i/G (L"=q'-W XjW.}4 6)GL- WR i+-.G WR BC hNMz- $Q j4./'- 6jR m<# "[2[0 -�AW .�'� �.� :7 t?3"7.Y BC h\.* aZ*)Y @�R @j�C X"QL"�AW D"IYz- BCW X"?9_>W t2Q"J&'- uCW FG)#"`W hO h\W)Y �\ @)KhG jRW X�'� m<# ¨._h* jR 6)0 n �1 @[='- N7-$_0 " | SG.7 " �2C.µ " �*.20)G " |&IY j$I* jR |5H7 i3"&'- "&C ��'� NQR 1 6&xR :# �W.3 "[63R "&62> nW ª |5MR .IJ'- 1* 6.K0 "?' 1`5# n :7 -$3"V :*P'- ()Y5&'-W 1`\"3U'- i7 a!-L-$Y R�2S'- $'W � �u@S� )` t?[7 " |7"7A 6jR \.* t'W X 6B75>T- i&9o&'- :&%

.tIYRW t<#R F<'-W �,n§Q m<# N9/'- g$9C � " �*.f3 (\L-$'- 16234./'- !"*d- �<G "[2JIG )/C Xn DR �'� 6tG ,-$>W BC"[* "7 m<# 6B34.` N2'\ :7 �2' F63A ~$/[' X\-)GLn- �$%$7 BC \.J<' NJV D5>T- 6jR $QW Xp"9I'- -PQ BC F' "[= @>R �P'- R)S&'- Xj"Q.hS'-W N2')<' - |\W)]7 m/S* j80 FS'"� F6[I'W XO.IC 16* 6.Y !-.6�§7W !-P'- !"K^� :7 .IJ'- 1*"&Y .M"[# :7 .�[_V XL"ICz- :20 L-$K'- !"62'4 � 6U_* "&0 XO.2�W B#"&9+n- {2K&'- 1'8=&'- BC ZKS3 "[63R " |&<# �"?7 6)/GW "QL 6$^G B'"9'"0W X"Q)/3W XB?/J'- ZKS'- " 67R XF' �2>89'- ~W"Y "7W t*.I'- j4./'- 1?+ :7

..}4 ;~"o7 F<C XB34./'- R)S&'- -PQ i7 ¨L"_9* "7 L-)/7W***

Page 75: الحرية الفكرية

74

Page 76: الحرية الفكرية

75

&R?@Wd"% &R? R@b"% &"r68 ]P &RJ{9<?:% &RJo@V"% &RJ R<0Z

B=J['- g$9=&'- m<# D-U9'n-W j"&*T- .�R BC "[Q ZKS3 :7 F' � 6>§* jR :I&h* "7W XDU9<&'-W :7§&'- j"=3E' BV$<='-W "7 BC .2H3W .1# 6$[9&'- !"�$rb'-W !"* 6)K9'- 1?+-$7 BC ( 6$`

:¦"/3 ( 6)# B<* :&2?&'- $QW Xu<^&'"0 j"&*T- N6H&* F<'"0 j"&*T- 6jA X wY R#Z nW ;j"I7 O 6)K* n �P'-W XL$7z- )2'"/7 O)20W XF 6<V \$+$'- m<# - |L$_� j"=3T- s[&* "7 -PQW X" |_2&+ "?' u'"q'- $Q N0 X ;j"7� $Q "7W Xj"I&'-W j"7U'- U62Y BC ;N}-\ $Q "7 6NV D"7R 16* 6.K'"0 :7 ,-$> X("2K'- FK[&*W X\$+$'- F2<# �2J* :7 m'A ;./9J7 h\$_* n XF0 ;{SG.7W F<'"0 :7§7 F63ºC XF<'- u<} .x"> :7 WR .]S'- ibq* F3-)+W BC ;i`$7 c$<q&' nW XFG-� BC F2<# ;1^<> a)Yz $Q aPx)[# F_S9* "&C X~)_'- WR 6uK'- N6H&* F63R F' �SH* j80 6nA XF' -PQW �FJ`$7 WR F<_C BC �$M$&'- ~)_'-W XF2C :7"I'- 6uK'-

Page 77: الحرية الفكرية

76

."?G"+L\ m<#RW X16* 6.K'- m?9[7 N6H&* j"2 6<o9* "&63A XF' 16*\$S_'-W F<'"0 j"&*T- 6jA Xg.}R (L"S_0W 6j�C X"7 a(.IC BC t?*)' 6uK'- �S�R "7 �NV �'P0W X 6uK<' 16*\$S# :7 6NVW Xt?G-\"/9#- 17$f[7 BC "Q$<})h* jR j"&*T- mb9/7 "&VW .F7-U9'- t?2<# t69K* �'� 6j�C X"7 a�$<> BC 6uK'- t?' �S�R uCW "?=J3 1* 6.K'- � 6.K9G N0 X16* 6.K'- 1'8=7 BC"[* n 6uK'- 6jR R)S&0 D-U9'n-W j"&*T- j$I* n �'PIC XF7)#W 6uK'- -PQ !$S�

."?' - |� 6U_7 N0 1* 6.K'- 1'8=&' "|2C"[7 F<' 16*\$S_'- " 6&7 j"=3T- L 6.K* n XFG\-L�0 D-U9'n-W XF<'"0 j"&*T- 6jA :9wJ{9~ OL 6.K* $?C X" |b*R �F�<}-\ :7 hO hL l.K* N0 Xe=KC F[# ;yL"} $Q WR O"o<' WR ~"&<' \$_* 5C X"QUx-.�W "?G-$?� :7 XF=J3 :7 mb9/&0 � �<&2C Xj"=3T- (\-LA m<# 1^<> g.}z- !-$?]<' XFx\"S7 i7 " |&o=[7 :I* t' -�A «n» ~"&<' ~$/* jR � F<'"0 j"&*T- L$o'-W t<f<' " |_`$7 j$I* "7)[# «n» O"o<' ~$/* jR i2^9=*W p.]'-W NVz- BC FGU*.r' ~$/* jR i2^9=*W X�"['- m<#

.F7-U9'- �'"q* "7 $K3 F0 s&oG "7)[# X«n» :"Q.2�W �[o'-W LW\ 6jR "[*R.' XD5>T- BC (\"S_'- :7 �)?'- BC "[/ 6 \ $'W F2C � 6=K9* �P'- XBYW.'- 6$&='- -PQ u 6/KG jR $Q (\"S_'- \$+$'- 1V.Y BC F_`$7 � B'"9'"0 � B_2C XF60L :7 F_`$7 j"=3T- ��-$3 :7 F?+-$* "7 D"7R FG\-LA BC ( 6$/'- m[_7 �2_*W X("2K'-W

Page 78: الحرية الفكرية

77

:m'"_G F'$` .2]* �'� m'A F 6<_'W XyL"q'- !"�$r%W N}-)'- lm xK"% p@ na lzk" k# l@ kW5 p<n"% k# �9 k� nb kdn"% lX k� ! kjn5 kG kB kU x�"% xDl} kB kU x�"% l�l� kZ k#s

.(�)t kDI p'k5 n�kG 9 k8 p� kK n'k? pm xK"% k# p@ k( nakZ :7 u<^[G "?63R m'A "[�<q' X1 67"_0 :* l)'- 1J=<C BC "3. 6IJG -�AW iC.G B9'- t2/'- N6H&* "&'W X("2K'- BC j"=3T- i`$&' 1623$V 1*vL g$�/'- \W)K'- $K3 O,-\R U 6JKGW X"?2C j"=3T- g$9=7 :7 .S# X�'� :# " |/x"# �/G B9'- i3-$&'- 6NV F[# hN*UGW X�-)0E' NI]0 � �J['- :7 B/<h* - |LW\ he_<G B9'- c5}z- :7 17$f[7 X1³62='- L"ICz- "?<6H&G B9'- X1 67"='- !"*"J['- @NV � 6.&9=7 j$I* n �'P0W ...1&'§&'- !"*.VP'-W X162S<='- .#"]&'-W 1623"=3T u2&_'- m[_&'- :# .}4 .2S_G g$> F<'- .7-W80 D-U9'n- ;w?[7 BQ "&63A X1* 6.K'- BC"[G - |\$2` "6[7 )Y-$'- hF h'"q* "7W Xj"=3T- BC yL"q'- BC 16*.K'- OPQ �I_[9C XN}-)'- :7 j"=3T- .*.K9'

.j"=3T- 1V.Y :*\"27 6NV * p& x5l� k< n) p<n"% p� ndx5"% 9 kj pV x? kZ 9k?s :m'"_G F<'- ~$` t?J3 )` "[QW ]lK pL ni% k# * Hli9k( l� ]lP ]lK pL ni9 kP * w& xJ l� n@ x8 w& kJ l�% kC l>|o kC !k"l} ]l' lS nC% �C"K* jR BQ ("2K'- OPQ BC j"=3T- 1J2µW 6jR BC X(�)t]lVx5 kS "7 $QW X"?9623"=3A BC"[* " 6&7 "?0 u<_* )` "7 6NV :7 F=J3 m<# m'A t?' 6$K* XF<'- \"S# :7 "|S2�3 Pq69* jR BC Xj"^2]'- F'W"K*

.�£ 1*d- X!$SI[_'- (L$> (�).�¢-�± !"*d- X.oJ'- (L$> (�)

Page 79: الحرية الفكرية

78

k²li9k( l� nX l8 xD kz l¡xG k k$ k�9 k� k#s :m'"_G ~"` "&V XN}-)'- :7 :2�"2� n� ljnJ kK k� k>k" k�nJ k" Hli9k( l� xDl}s hp-$o'- F2G8*W X(�)tw9�# p@ nd x8 w9(J l�k{ -$K&> :*P'- �³'WR :7 X(�)t kX? l#9 k�n"% kX l8 k> k'k( xG% lX k8 xYl} �D9 k) nK p_

.t?2<# �$K9>"C Xt?G.^J0 ZS_* jR j"^2]<' (\$# g$> «F<'- \"S# BC ~$})'-» �2' Xg.}R (L"S_0W j"V "&IC X1&2<='- "?G.^CW X12C"�'- "?9623"=3A m[_7 m'A �J[<' (L"7z- �J['-» F[# .6S_G jR :I&* "7 WR Xj"^2]'- 1#"��0 "?H*$<G m'A «F�$SQ»W 16[o'- :7 j"=3T- -PQ yW.q' "|S+$7 X(�)«,$='"0 Z*$<G :7 � j"&*T- 17$f[7 .S# � j"^2]'- i[7 6j�C X¨Lz- ~$` �'� m'A .2]* "&V X16[o'- m'A "?G\$_' ;e+$7 (.^J'- OPQ � pWn? kIko kZ k¥ k@ nLkZ 9 k< ka pD9 k)nJ x�"% p� pWx5 k5lV nd k? kY k* kig ]l5ko 9k?s :m'"_G F<'- 1_2S^0 {SG.7 .}4 ;ZK0 -P?C X a~"Y 6NV m<#W .(�)tl&x5 kvn"% kX |8 162�q]'- u&# BC j"^2]'- LW\W Xj"=3T-W j"^2]'- :20 1`5_'-

. �5/9=7 FHKS' �u @C$3 jR F<'- ~8=3 X1623"=3T- n j"&*T- 6jR "[' " |K%-W W)S* )` XD 6)/G "7 m'A - |\"[9>- :9w "9~ ./J'- .M"[# F2C B 6&[* nW XFG-P' O.*)/GW F=J[0 F9/� j"=3T- )/Jh* XBG-P'- ./J'- BC F' 1VL"]&'- g.}z- !-\$+$&'- D"7R BG-P'-

.��  1*d- X,"=['- (L$> (�).�� 1*d- X.oK'- (L$> (�)

9 k8 xYl} l�I �6"9lo �B kC9 x8 k$ k� ndx5"% xDl} ] l6 ndk{ p¤ |@ko pZ 9 k8 k#s : 1*d- X�>$* (L$> BC \LW "7 �'� (�).­ k]|o kC k� lA kC

.�± 1*d- X�-.#z- (L$> (�)

Page 80: الحرية الفكرية

79

g$9=7 m<#R D"7RW X�J['"0 1/� m<#R $K3 j"=3T- iC)* $Q N0 XO.2� WR "|3"=3A Xg.}z- !"`$<q&'- D"7R B=J['- �"S�T- :7 - |L$K7 j"=3T- L"S9#n " |=*.IG 12[*)'- (.f['- OPQ j$IG �'P0W ~5} :7 FS=I* "&63A �'�W Xc$<q&'- \$+$'- 1V.Y F'$Y LW)G X\$+$'- he+-W XF<'- $QW X 6B/2/K'- \$+$'- L$K&0 F�"SGL- m[_7 t?J3 -P?0W ..2}W ;c)MW ¶uY $Q "7 6NV BC �2J'- iS[7W u 6/K9* "&63A -PQ 6j�C �¨Lz- m<# F<'- 1J2<} j"=3T- j$I* jR 6NV D"7R L 6.K9'- ()#"` 16*\$S_'- OPQ j$I9' �F<' F96*\$S# ~5} :7 OUx-.�W F#�-$3 ~5} :7 �'� j"V ,-$> XFG\-LA m<# {rb* "7 t?J3 -P?0W .F0 1^2K&'- 162+L"q'- g$/'- ~5} :7 WR X12G-P'- X(�)t lD# pQ p( n'kJl" xYl} k�{l n:% k# xX lvn"% p� n\ kK kL 9 k8 k#s :m'"_G F'$` " |b*R Xe=KC 6B>$/^'- m[_&'"0 (\"S_'- �=2' "[Q (\"S_'- 6jA Z2Y XF=>R :7 " |>">R 162>$/^'- (\"S_'- u 6/KG �P'- L"=&'- BQ "&63AW j"^2]'- j"=3T- F+-$* F0 �P'- \$][&'- L 6.K9'- N_C (\"S_'- j$I9' .F9623"=3�0 F>"=YA i`$7 :7 F<'- (\-LA m'A tI9K*W 6.]'- ��-$3W ( 6)# F[# �� 6)KG �P'- .2q=9'- R)S&' L 6.S&'- t?J3 )` " |b*R -P?0W F<'- (\-LA u2/KG BC j"=3E' 17)} .2q=9'- 6j�C X(�)16234.` !"*4

.£¥ 1*d- X!"*L-P'- (L$> (�) �@8ro @b("% ]P H@vG >K pd"%# ªC$% ]P 98 �W" @ R¡_ mK"% RDZ R@G �"Zs :m'"_G F'$/V (�) @ R¡_ mK"% RDZ %#@G �"Zs X¥£ : 6wK'- (L$> � tm{f�o RY} ªC$% !K� ;\G DZ �9<6"% >6<?# :j"&/' (L$> � t&5q9o# B@09¢ m<'{ �WJK� ³(_Z# ªC$% ]P 98# y%#9<6"% ]P 98 �W"

.�¢

Page 81: الحرية الفكرية

80

|1bS j"=3T- j$I* jR t?J3 ) �'PVW XF2'A "3.�R �P'- m[_&'"0 :7 )_0R j$IG )` 1qJ['- �<G 6j�C �F<'- �WL :7 |1qJ3W :2^'- :7 �-)0T-W (L)/'-W (\-LT- 1qJ3 BQ "&63AW X("2K'-W \$+$'- 1qJ3 m'"_G F<'- "?_%W B9'- :[='- :&% !"[x"I'- )62=GW .*$^9'-W

.j"=3T-W j$I'- 1V.K' °\"S7 :7 " �&?7 R)S7 � 6>§3 jR "[Q i2^9=3 "[ 6<_' :9 w'o%C :* l)'- ~$Y .x-)'- ~)o'- j"V Z2Y Xj"=3E' 6�L"bK'- \$+$'- BC " �2>">R |5#"C F2C j"=3T- j$I* aLW\ :# ZKS'- BC L$K&9* (.H# .oY N 6I]* �P'- :* l)'- i7 1_2^/'- � 6&G �'P'W X("2K'- :*.2HV (.f3 m<# �'� .6�RW Xy"93T-W �-)0T- 1<o# c5^3- D"7R L"29}- m'A h�_S'- eQ� m69Y X�'� :7 F_`$7 BC " |7$&# :* l)<' 6N]* tQ.f3 BC OL"S9#"0 X("2K'- 1Y"> :# :* l)'- \"_0A WR \"K'T- ()[9=&'- 1V.K'- OPQ F2C N6H&G �P'- �`$'- BC Xj"=3T- 1V.Y

.1623"=3T- (L"bK'- y"93T 162>">z- ()#"/'- X1* 6.K'- R)S7 m'A :* l)'- m'A )2_3 jR i2^9=3 XD 6)/G "7 ~5} :7 "[63R "[Q )/9_3W X 6B3"=3A $Q "7W 6B[*\ $Q "7 :20 BC"[9'- iC.3 jRW X 6B3"=3T- O)_h0 "?G"+"93 :# .6S_G BI' "?9* 6.Y @NV 1623"=3T- 1V.K<' B^_3 jRW j�-$9'- B/SG B9'- t2/'- 6{} BCW XN/_'- g)Q m<# "?G"#-)0AW

.("2K'- L"=7 BC***

Page 82: الحرية الفكرية

81

HC9Ob"% �95("% «@e &R?@Wd"% &R? R@b"%

j"7U'- \W)K0 ;\W)K7 j"=3T- 6jR BC 6�� :7 �2' F63A h ._GW XN7-$#W �W.µ :7 "&QL"�A BC � 6.K9* "7W j"I&'-W aw?3 6�z �2>89'- 6jR D$<_&'- :7W X�'P' " |_SG !-.62r9&'- F2<# n X 6NIV 16*.]S'- 1V.Y y"9�3 m'A .f[* jR 6)0 n X 6�L"bY a)_h0 �� WR Xj"I&'- :7 (\ 6)K7 1_/0 m'A WR Xj"7U'- :7 (\ 6)K7 1*W-� m'A s&=* aL"=&' h�2>89'- p$<^&'"C �'P'W X\ 6)K7 6BC"/� y"93 m'A �'�W XF2C j"=3T- i`$7 .62rGW Xj"7U'- L 6$^9' " |_SG L"ICz- \ 6)o90 tIKG B9'- 162 6<I'- 1*v.'- u2/K9' 1&x-)'- 162%Lz- :278G �)?0

.¨Lz- OPQ m<# j"=3T- \$+W :&% "|3"20 (.IJ'- )*U3 X)*.o9'- (.x-\ BC "[Q m/S3 n m69YW

:12'"9'- ¦"/['- ¨Lz- m<# j"=3T- \$+$' � .2S_9'- @sM -�A � 162?'T- 1*v.'- 6jA :/Z $QW X� m'"_GW F3"KS> � F<'- g)Q m<# 1623"=3T- (L"bK'- ,"[0 BQ

Page 83: الحرية الفكرية

82

:j"=3T- �5q9>- :# �� 6)KG B9'- !"*d- :&% j"9*4 F9[620 "7 123"H'-W X(�)tw& kdJlK kL lª nC k$% ]lP �N l�9 kS ]|{l}s :m'"_G F'$ Xm'Wz- X k< kP h wQ p0 ]|5 |8 � pWx5 kJlG nr k? 9 x8l� kP w9'J l< kS 9 kjn5 l8 n%I p)l( n0% 9k5 nK p�s :m'"_G F'$`

.(�)t kDIp{ k nbk? n� p0 kY k# n� ljnJ kK k� �� nI kL kU kP kH% kQ p0 k;l( kG �.*$^9'- )_hS'- $Q (L"bK'- ,"[0 :# "[Q � 6)K93 "[<_+ �P'-W :20W � m'"_G � F<'- :20 g.+ �P'- L-$K'- :7 F2Y$9=3 �P'- -PQ :7 .Q"f'- 6jz �(j"=3T-) )*)o'- c$<q&'- ~$Y 1Ix5&'- D"2/'- :# jWU+"# � t?[*$IG 1_2S� BC � 1Ix5&'- 6jR L-$K'- ,"&>z- 6jR s+Lz-W X"?' hN @Q§&'- h:x"I'- $Q hj"=3T- Xa1 6&?&0 ;.7R -PQ 6j�C �e=KC ,"2�z- (�)L$M �=2' D\d F<'- "?& 6<# B9'- (L)/'- �R XL$�'- �<9' BV.K'- )_hS'- "&63AW X1Ix5&'- FVL)G )_hS'- � g.}R (L"S_0 � WR Xy"9[9>n-W N2<K9'-W e2V.9'- m<#

.t2Q"J&<' �.*$^9'- :7 a:2<2+ WR aN2+ ~5} :7 6t9* n �'� u2/KG 6jA :/ u t7º' m'"_G F<'- �5QA 1'8=7 :7 F2Y$9=3 "7 -PQW X.]S'- ("2Y �PY $Q \-.&'- 6jR L"S9#"0 X,"2S3z- �5MA m<# ��_9>- B9'-

.�¢ 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�).�  1*d- (./S'- (L$> (�)

D\d ,"&>z- F<'- t2<_G :# N³> F63R Q c\"�'- .J_+ D"7T- :# Z*)K'- BC \LW (�) «96("% %z0# :~"/C F9KG a¦"=0 m'A .f3 6t� X&?i#$%# u9'�"%# �9(v"%# XJ�C$%» :~"/C 1 6&xz- L"S}R LL)' 1_7"o'- L-$3z- L"K0 X.`"0 ) 6&K7 ´2]'- XB=<o&'- :.f3- .«m< RK� 9 R<8

.��¥¡ X��y XL"?�z-

Page 84: الحرية الفكرية

83

"&V XD"# NI]0 16*.]S'- 1*-)?'- 1V.Y m<# .6�§&'- BS<='- .�[_'- %# pQlK k? kY k# k² ki9k( l� %I �K lOp? n� p0 nC kzkG Dl} k>x{l}s :m'"_G F'$ �'P0 BY$* !n">.'- L 6$^G :7 �'� BY$9=3 "&V X(�)tw%C9 xd ka w%@ lS9 kP xYl} :# m'"_G F<'- mIY "&V X:7U'- !-.62rG m<# s9J[G �3"V B9'- k* |@ pA H lzx"% k n'ko � pWk" xN lA p l$ k#s :Q s2=&'- )62='- 1'">L n� p0 k@ n[l} n� pjn5 k� p; kOk? k#s :P ) 6&K7 F<'- ~$>L :# WR X(�)t n� pWnJ kK k� 6jR s 6+.3 "[<_o* " 6&7 �'� .2�W X(�)t n� ljnJ kK k� n�k{9 ka ]lV x"% k� kU n� k$% k# (1C5q'- LW\) ¨Lz- m<# FG\-LA u2/KG L"=&' 162?'T- (.f['- e=K0 |1 62'W§=7 N 6&K9* a\.C �NVW X16*.]S<' 6D"# L"=&0 {SG.G "&63A tQ tQ hv"&>R hi&<G :*P'- h,"&f_'-W X1<=<='- OPQ :7 F_`$7 BC \ 6)K&'- i`$&'- -PQ 17)} BC t?G"`"� 6NV j$< 6_J* :*P'- Xt?_`$7 :# -$'�"[G :*P'- tQ "&63A j$^/=* :*P'-W XF<'- 1&IY N2^_G m'A � 1*-)S'- P[7 � �)?* �P'- j"^2]'- (\"2/' -$&<=9>-W 1<=<> BC a\.C 6NV LW\ N2^_G .S# X¨Lz- m<# 6B?'T- �W.]&'-

. 6�.]S'- \$+$'- BC m'"_G F h'$` �'P' |,"K29>- "3)*U* )` X~-$Yz- 6NV BC 1&IK'- :# � -$',"=G WR � -$%.9#- "7)[# 1Ix5&<' �F�0-$+ �J=*W ¨Lz- BC )=J*» F63R ~"K'-W |1J2<} aj"=3A N_+ :7

.�± 1*d- X�$3 (L$> (�).£¢ 1*d- Xj-.&# ~4 (L$> (�)

.�£± 1*d- X�-.#z- (L$> (�)

Page 85: الحرية الفكرية

84

�P'- X(�)t kDI p< kK n'kG kY 9 k8 p� kK n�kZ ]|{l}s :� m'"_G � ~"/C X(�)«,"7)'- aL"=&0 {SG.G "&63AW X a\.J0 {SG.G n 1'8=&'- 6jR m'A (L"�A F63R F&?J3 m<# 6B?'T- �W.]&'- u2/KG BQW X162?'T- 162&9K'"0 B?9[2> ]lP 9k5 n( kV ka nQ k\ k" k#s :m'"_G ~"` "&V X1 6M"} j"=3T- .S#W X¨Lz- X(�)t kDI pbl"9 x�"% kHli9k( l� 9 kj p~ l@k? kª nC k n$% xDkZ l@ na |z"% lQ n'ko Xl8 lCIpo x "% ly9 kbl"9 x�"% %I pK l< k� k# n� pW5 l8 %I p5 k8g kX? lzx"% pm xK"% kQ k� k#s :m'"_G ~"` "&VW xXk5 |W k< pJ k" k# n� ljlK n( k� Xl8 kX? lzx"% kFkK n¡kV n_% 9 k< ka lª nC k n$% ]lP � pjx5 kdlK n¡kV n6kJ k" w95 n8kZ n� ljlP nI kL lQ n'ko X |8 � pjx5 k" |Qk( pJ k" k# n� pjk" ! kOkG nC% H lzx"% p� pjk5? li n� pjk"

.(�)tw9�nJ ke ]lo kDI pa l@ n�p? kY ]l5k{# pQ p( n'k? :7 F_`$7 j"20 BC P F<'- ~$>L :# \LW "&0 �389=3 "[ 6<_'W F63R �'�W XO"[J<>R �P'- m[_&'- -PQ � 6U_* "7 X1/0"='- !n">.'- 9jK<aZ# 9j56ArP % wC%i !5o �NSC Nk k<a XJRJ(5"% ]P ]Kk k8» :P ~"` DIPI)? �95"% N'vP �9j'O? �" �&5(" ;�I8 9jJP ²@G# �9jK<SZ# ]P 9{rP !&5(K"% �z0 p;�I8 R�G I" :DI"I\?# m58 DI(v'?# D9J5("9o ;¦"SGL- F' !n">.'- i0"9G 6jA �R X(£)«&5(K"% >KG ;�I8 XJRJ(5"% 1V.Y BC N7"I9* jR m'"_G F<'- )*.* "7 BC X16*.]S<' 6D"_'- L"=&'"0 k² lQ n< kblo p |( k6p{ pX nbk{ k# �9 k8 |Q"% p>ld n6k? k# 9 kjJlP pQ l6 nd p? X k8 9 kjJlP pN k' nvkG kZs :m'"_G F'$` �'�W (�)

.�¢ 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> :.f3R .t k>k" p� |Q k\ p{ k#.�¢ 1*d- X(./S'- (L$> (�)

.�¢£ 1*d- X,"2S3z- (L$> (�) .££ 1*d- XL$['- (L$> (�)

X��¥¡ Xj"[S' X!W.20 X.IJ'- L-\ XD�© � X�¦ X£y X�P7.9'- :[> X�P7.9'- (£) .�¥©��

Page 86: الحرية الفكرية

85

1*"?3 BC 1&G"q'- 1'">.'- N&K' |5 @Q§7 j$I* BI' Xj"=3T- .�"^&'-

{SG.7 �L"bK'- )_hS'- 6jR ¨.9J3 XD 6)/G "7 m'A - |\"[9>- :/ ¥ jW\ 162[7� 1S/K' WR X.}4 jW\ a\.J' �2'W X1 67"_0 16*.]S'- 1V.K0 ()*)+ ;!"2^_7 � ("2K'-W :7U'- L 6$^G N_J0 � j @$I9G )/C Xg.}R g)?'- 6jRW X1/0"='- L"ICz- BC �2' @uK'- 6jR i[9/* F<_oG j"=3E' 6uK'- N6H&G L"ICz- �<G �3"V "&63AW X1J'"='- pL"o9'- BC �2' -�AW X"?C.µ BC j"=3E' (. 6C$9&'- !"2^_&'- ~5} :7 g)?'- WR Xg)?'-W 6uK'- N6H&G "?6380 � F#"[9`- N+z � - |LWP_7 j"=3T- j"V ."?C5q0 ;i[9/7 $QW "?/CW L"> -�A F<'- D"7R - |LWP_7 j$I* :' F63�C u6C)9'"0 s&=G )#-$` \$+W (LW.% � a�$%W 6NI0 � B[_* -PQ �R Xm'Wz- (.&<' w9[G B9'- L"ICz- "?[7 ,-$> XL"ICº' tx-)'- X1/0"> �"%WR WR L"ICR �5M�0 {SG.G B9'- L"ICz- WR X162#-)0T- X)/['- 1* 6.Y R)S7W X.2S_9'- 1* 6.Y R)S7 D"7R :K3 "[Q .)/['- �R 1 67º' WR i&9o&<' �L"bK'- N_J'- L-.&9>n :262>">R :2�.]V

.1 67"_0 6�.]S'- \$+$<' WR m<# (L)/'- "[K[&* ,"2S3z- �_0 O"oG �\ 6)]9'- p"^q'- 6N_'W j80 � F3"KS> � F<'- m%.* n Z2Y XB6<I'- mK[&'- �'� 1*vL FG 6$S3 6jz �1<&3R )2` FG"62'W§=7 :# ~$>.'- WR 6BS['- )2K* 16*)*)oG 1<o# c5�T 1&x57 162q*L"G 1fK' BC BG8G F962'$>LW

Page 87: الحرية الفكرية

86

:7 .D"6*z- D\"` BC O$K3 � 6.K9G jR 16*.]S<' m'"_G F<'- )*.* "&' k� xI k\kG nI k" k#s :P - |) 6&K7 F62S3 F<'- F0 e�"} "7 p"^q'- �'� kXJlG kIn"% pm n5 l8 9k5 n' k) k\k" x� p~ * XJ l<kJ n"9lo pm n5 l8 9k{ nz kL k k$ * lN? l#9 k� k n$% k n'ko 9k5 nJ kK k�

.(�)t kX? l lS9 kA pm n5 k� �Q kAkZ nX |8 � pW5l8 9 k< kP *

XF2'A �?93- "7 m'A �?93- )` !5 6789'- OPQ �3"V -�A X" |7"9} BC 10.oG D 6)/3 jR "?'5} :7 "['W"Y X a.f3 1?+W m/SG "?63�C B[* l)'- .IJ'- D"7R ("2K'- "?Y.^G !"62'"I�A O"oG j4./'- c"^[9>- OPQ .f@['- 1?+W pP9oG jR BC ;N7R "[ 6<VW X" |7$&# �.]S'-W X8^} s 6K�* "7 1C._&'- 6{} m'A �2b9' Xg.}R a.f3 !"?+W �'� D"7R "[G"6*\W)K7 N7"I99' X |(.IC ) 6V§* WR X" |? 6+$G p 6$�* WR �OL$K7 N 6I�W XO"[_7 \$+$'- s[7 �P'- 6uK'-W XN7"I'- \$+$'-

.)�/'- ,-LW :7 F<'-W

***

.�±-�� !"*d- X1`"K'- (L$> (�)

Page 88: الحرية الفكرية

87

u9VW"% y9?IVb8

£ .......................................................1���7 l)�/&'-± ............................................................ )2?&G�£ ....................... 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- D$?J&' 162=2>89'- !"*d-�� .................................. 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- D"7R !n"I�A±£ ................. 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'- 1'8=7 BC 1623"&*T- 1620.9'- 162 6&QR � ........................... �L"bK'- ,"[S'- ¦.� 16*.IJ'- 16* 6.K'-

***

Page 89: الحرية الفكرية

88

Page 90: الحرية الفكرية