bim & breeam - value people · bim –what it isn’t –it’s not just 3d cad –it’s not...

Part of the BRE Trust

Role Initials Date

Author DR 26/01/15

Checker PAO 21/01/15

Approver PAO 21/01/15

BIM & BREEAMNick Tune

Director, BRE

ARCHITECTSBUILDERS

OWNERS

BIM - What it is

BIM, is an Integrated process built on

coordinated, reliable information about a

project from design through construction

and operation

– Create coordinated, digital

design information and

documentation;

– Predict performance,

appearance, and cost;

– Deliver the project faster, more

economically, and with reduced

environmental impact.

© BRE 2014

BIM Drivers – HMG Construction 2025…

BIM – What it isn’t

– It’s not just 3D CAD

– It’s not just a new technology application

– It’s not next generation, it here and now!

BIM is essentially value creating collaboration through the entire life-

cycle of an asset, underpinned by the creation, collation and

exchange of shared 3D models and intelligent, structured data

attached to them.

http://www.bimtaskgroup.org/bim-faqs/

2002 Egan Report

“Production Information is

generally, incorrect, incomplete,

uncoordinated and ambiguous”

But how do we know ?

Information may be ambiguous…

Information is uncoordinated…

There are also workmanship issues…

Or just no thought…

Poor information leads to non-desirable activities

1. Requests for Information

2. Variations

3. Contract Disputes

4. Rework

5. Cost Overruns

6. Programme Delays

7. Extensions of Time

Traditional vs. Digital (Music)

• One Library (iTunes)

• Many Objects (Tracks)

Each track has meta-data

• Song name

• Artist

• Duration

• Genre

iTunes

• Many Libraries (albums)

• No Objects

Each track has no meta-data

• Song name

• Artist

• Duration

• Genre

Vinyl Collection

Traditional vs. Digital (Music)

Traditional vs. Digital (Construction)

• One Library (Fed. Model)

• Many Objects

Each object has meta-data

• Object Name

• Manufacturer

• Size

• Classification

BIM

• Many Libraries (CAD files)

• No Objects

Each object has no meta-data

• Object Name

• Manufacturer

• Size

• Classification

Traditional

Building Information Modelling

(The process of creating the data)

Building Information Management

(Management of the process used

to create the data)

Building Information Model

(the data)

BIM

Graphical Model Non Graphical Model Documentation

Information ModelBuilding

BIM Dimensions

BIM – How Many Dimensions (D’s) ?

– 2D - Two dimensional line work (Drafting)



– 3D - Three dimensional (Models)




– 4D - Time (Construction programming)





– 5D - Cost (£/$/€/¥)





– 5D - Cost (£/$/€/¥)

– 6D - Life Cycle Management (FM)






– 5D - Cost (£/$/€/¥)

– 6D - Life Cycle Management (FM)

– nD +

Maturity

BIM Maturity

BIM Maturity

• Level 0

Unmanaged CAD probably 2D, with paper (or

electronic Paper as the most likely data

exchange mechanism.

Images courtesy of Roger Penwill

BIM Maturity

• Level 1

Managed CAD in 2D or 3D format using a

common data environment, and possibly

some standard data structures and formats.


BIM Maturity

• Level 2

Managed CAD in a 3D environment held in

separate discipline “BIM” tools with attached

data. The approach may utilise 4D Programme

data and 5D cost elements.


BIM Maturity

• Level 3

Fully open process and data integration enabled by IFC /

IFD. Managed by a collaborative model server. Could be

regarded as iBIM or integrated BIM potentially employing

concurrent engineering processes.


BIM Level 2 – Core Documents

1. PAS1192-2:2013

2. PAS1192-3:2014

3. BS1192-4:2014

4. CIC BIM Protocol

5. Government Soft Landings

On-going

6. Classification (Uniclass)

7. Digital Plan of Works

https://bsol.bsigroup.com/Bibliographic/BibliographicInfoData/000000000030281435



BIM Level 2 Certification Schemes

– BRE BIM Certificated Professional Schemes

– Task Information Manager

– Project Information Manager

– Project Delivery Manager

– BRE BIM Business System Certification Scheme

– Audited BIM Capability Assessment

Business Certification Scheme

BDP are the first firm to be Certificated under the BRE’s

Business Certification Scheme

“This is a significant step along our BIM journey, both validating the

investment and commitment … while also providing a recognisable

auditable standard to demonstrate our abilities externally.”

“Our next step is to achieve Business Systems certification for the

remainder of our studios and extend our employee capability through

the BRE BIM AP accreditation scheme.”

– Alistair Kell, BDP Director

Currently ~23 other firms completing their application forms

BIM Level 2 Education Course

– BIM Foundation Course (AP)

– Covering BIM processes,

procedures, information models,

management and collaboration

– BIM Level 2 PAS1192-2

– Project Information Manager (PIM)

– Task Information Manager (TIM)

– BIM Level 2 PAS1192-2

– Project Delivery Manager (PDM)

Part of the BRE Trust

The World of BREEAM and BIM

Nick Tune

January 2015

1

The measure of our success

BREEAM Aims & Objectives

BREEAM family of schemes aim to:

– Ensure best environmental practice

– Consider a broad range of environmental concerns

– Balanced to ensure quality, safe & healthy environment

– Set standards surpassing those required by regulation

– Challenge the market to provide innovative solutions

– Provide a credible environmental label

– Stimulate demand for sustainability in the built environment

1

Energy

Health and wellbeing

Materials

Management

Pollution

Land use and Ecology

Transport

Waste

Water

Range of Environmental Concerns

Environmental Standards

Re

gu

lato

ry m

inim

um

Minimal Aspirational

Pass

Good

Very

Good

Excelle

nt

Outs

tandin

g

A Standard Surpassing Regulation

Site

selection

Design and

planning

Construction &

post-

construction

Occupation End of life

Region scale

City scale

Neighbourhood

scale

Building scale

Non Domestic

Infrastructure

Communities

Domestic

RefurbishmentDomestic

In-Use

Non Domestic

Refurbishment

Communities

Across Scale & Life-Cycle

Existing

All from a single BREEAM

standard

How did it approach energy:

Neighbourhood level:

• 100% green heat and green

power use at the district level

supply of green power and

green heat to the surrounding

neighbourhood;

• decentralised generation , local

distribution – local supply:

matching supply and demand

for heat and power.

Building level:

• follows the criteria were

buildings are designed first to

minimise energy loss –before

the focus shifts to renewable

energy solutions;

• demand for heat reduced

through insulation and air-

tightness

• low-energy housing: K-level

26W/m2K (BAU = K45)

• maximisation of renewable

energy sources;

De Balk van Beel, Leuven, Belgium

LSE's New Students' Centre

• incorporated into the design

include a combined heat and

power unit (CHP) to generate both

heat and electricity, photovoltaic

(PV) panels on the roof;

• The design also facilitates natural

ventilation and cooling;

• An LED screen in the ground floor

foyer displaying dynamic

information relating to the PV,

CHP and integrated water

harvesting systems, and the DEC

rating (after a year of operation).

• A 254m2 PV system that

contributes to reducing of CO2

emissions by 32.3%, when

compared to the building

regulations’ Target Emission Rate

• Extremely efficient boilers and

CHP systems that meet the

energy heating demand whilst

also minimising NOx emissions

(less than 40 mg/KWh).

How did it approach energy

2

Drive Continuous Improvement

Imp

rov

e y

ou

r

bu

sin

es

s

Verification

Initial

assessment

Inception

Target setting

Action plan

Review

BREEAM In-Use

• BRE Environmental and Sustainability Standard (BES 5058)

• Designed to provide detailed and meaningful insight into the environmental performance of buildings throughout their entire operational life.

• Providing assessment of:

– the building (Asset Rating),

– the operation of the building (Building Management Rating),

– how Clients are managing their activities within the building (Organisational Rating).

Green buildings will become less

valuable than non-green buildings

Green buildings will become more

valuable than non-green buildings

There will be no change

• Business case beyond

operational cost savings.

• Emerging research shows link

between the financial &

environmental performance of

property assets.

• In order to protect and enhance

value, sustainability

characteristics need to be

continually monitored and

reported consistently.

THE

1,850 employees working there. Le Hive’s name is an acronym from the French for hall of innovation and energy showcase.

The retrofit of the seven-storey building reflects Schneider Electric’s position as an energy management specialist, incorporating comprehensive energy monitoring, and was carried out largely by the company’s own in-house experts.

Driven by research, science &

documented best practice

• BREEAM UK New Construction 2011

scheme

• Covers costs associated with:

• ‘Pass’ to ‘Excellent’ ratings

• Energy and water capital and life cycle

costs, payback and utility savings

• Key contributors

• BRE Global – project managers and

authors

• BRE Trust – funding body

• Sweett Group – provided costing

information, conducted cost studies and

produced cost results

Construction capital & life cycle cost study

– Three case study buildings:

an air-conditioned office

a secondary school

a community healthcare centre

– Base case building established (meets

statutory requirements)

– Range of sustainability measures

identified and applied

– Represented progressively higher levels

of BREEAM ratings

– Factors taken into consideration in

determining costs include:

Location (poor, typical, good)

Range of specification choices/design

decisions

Methodology Overview

Capital costs

– Achieving lower BREEAM ratings

incurs little or no additional cost

– Targeting higher BREEAM ratings

incurs some additional cost but this is

typical less than 2 %

Lifecycle costs

– The study of operational costs shows

that this can be paid back within 2 - 5

years through utility cost savings

Headline Findings

Increase in capital costs for each BREEAM rating

Location BREEAM score

and rating for

the case study

building

% Increase in capital cost relative to

BREEAM rating of Pass, Good / Very Good /

Excellent

Pass Good Very

Good

Excellent

Poor 35.8 (Pass) 0 0.15 0.34 1.71

Typical 43.0 (Pass) 0 0.05 0.22 0.96

Good 46.7 (Good) 0 0 0.13 0.87

Market feedback

Aviva investors use of BREEAM

“All new acquisitions must have a BREEAM

rating”

“BREEAM is a strong rating tool that helps

sound, responsible property investment”

“Tenants will discard of buildings that don’t

have BREEAM ratings”

Michael Borello, Aviva investors, MIPIM UK

2014

21%21%18%Transactions