p. gerald thacker courts consultant 2005 facilities and legal reform projects presentation for the...
TRANSCRIPT
Facilities and Legal Reform Projects
Presentation for the
Core Course on Legal and Judicial Reform for World Bank
Staff January 11-14, 2005
.
Gerald Thacker
• Administrative Office, US Courts– Assistant Director for Facilities, Security, and
Administrative Services
• US General Services Administration– Commissioner, Public Buildings Service– Head, Public Buildings Service, Atlanta
Region
Gerald Thacker (cont.)
• Consultant on Judicial support systems, primarily on court facilities program– Architectural firms– US Federal Courts Administrative Office– US State Courts– International Courts
• World Bank– Venezuela, Guatemala, Philippines
• USAID– Montenegro
The US Federal Courts Model
Not a good model for International courts• An adversarial system• Extensive use of juries• US not a unified system• Resource rich• Mature legal and internal governing system • Mature support system • Centrality of courthouses in US towns and cities
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
• A necessary tool
• Appropriate Facilities are Essential to the Administration of Justice– Impact of Facilities on Efficient, Effective
Judicial Operations– Independent Judiciary
• Judicial Involvement is Essential to Obtaining Appropriate Facilities
Appropriate Facilities Contribute to Judicial Reform Objectives
• Protection of human rights• Foundation of Economic Development• Independence of the judiciary • Timely, consistent, legally-correct resolution of
legal disputes • Reduction of case backlogs • Transparent, open, responsive and accountable
functioning of the courts • Capacity of the judiciary to formulate and
implement changes in court organization, practices and performance over the longer term
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
• Courtroom– Adequate space for jurors– Adequate space for public observers– Separation of litigants for privacy
• Courthouse– Adequate space for consolidated clerks office– Adequate space for records– Adequate space for evidence storage– Separated circulation patterns– Appropriate environment for automation
Integrated Courthouse Automation
• Current and Future Needs
• Design Implications/Costs and Alternatives
• Courthouse
• Courtroom
Automation in the Courthouse
• Business Processes• Electronic Filing• Case Administration• Recordkeeping• Public Access• Security• Telecommunications• Building Operating/Fire & Life Safety
Automation in the Courtroom
• Presentation of Testimony
• Presentation of Evidence
• Taking the Record
• Access to Ancillary Information
• In-Court Case Administration
• Public Access
• Security
The Smart Courthouse
• Equipment• Communications
– Cabling– Equipment
connections– Outside Access– Control Switching
• Infrastructure– Conduit– Power– Lighting– Sound Reinforcement– Accommodation– Lines of Sight– Flexibility
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
• Demonstration projects
• Master Plans for System-wide upgrades
• Allocation of resources
• Alternatives
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
Inevitably controls the project’s critical path
• Long lead time
• Relative expense
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
• Construction is the last choice
• Not the First
Timeframes
• Up to 2000 M2 : 9 to 14 months– 2 to 3 months to develop scope of work and contract
for design– 3 months to design– 2 months to contract for construction– 6 months to construct
• 10,000 M2 and up: 3 to 5 years – 3 to 6 months to develop scope of work and contract
for design– 6 months to design– 3 months to contract for construction– 24 to 36 months to construct
TYPICAL COURTHOUSE BUILDING PROCESS
2004
2005
2006
2007
2010
Oct
ob
erN
ove
mb
erD
ecem
ber
Janu
ary
Feb
uary
Ma
rch
Ap
rilM
ay
June
July
Aug
ust
Sep
tem
ber
Oct
ob
erN
ove
mb
erD
ecem
ber
Janu
ary
Feb
uary
Ma
rch
Ap
rilM
ay
June
July
Aug
ust
Sep
tem
ber
Oct
ob
erN
ove
mb
erD
ecem
ber
Janu
ary
Feb
uary
Oct
ob
erN
ove
mb
erD
ecem
ber
Janu
ary
Land AcquisitionOff-Site ConstructionPlanner/Programmer Selection 3 MoPre-Design Phase 3 MoProgramming 4 MoA/E Selection 3 MoSchematic Design 2 MoDesign Development 3 MoConstruction Documents 5 MoBidding/Award 3 MoConstruction 36 MoCommissioning 2 Mo
Timeframes
• Multiple projects can’t always proceed concurrently– Limits of courts– Limits of design and construction community– Availability of construction materials– Weather– Topography
Timeframes
• Successful techniques– Limit major new construction– Design Build– Pattern designs– Multiple construction awards
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
• Just a tool– IT– Training– Human Resources– Case Management– Court organization/administration– Budgeting and financial management– Facilities
• Supports other project goals—not a project goal itself
• Facilities component should be tied directly to other project goals
Example: Linking Facilities Investments to Reform Goals
PILOT COURTS INITIATIVES: KOTOR AND BERANE
JUDICIAL REFORM GOALSHuman rights X X X X X XEconomic Development X X X XJudicial Independence X X XDispute resolution XReduction of case backlogs X X X X X X XTransparency X X X X XOpenness X X X X X X X XResponsiveness X X X XAccountability X X X XFuture practice/organizationl improvements X X X X X X X X
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
Pre-Project Program Assessment
• General condition of facilities to support reforms
• Ability of court/government to implement facilities component
• Current resource allocation
• Support for on-going maintenance and operations
Comprehensive Facilities Program
• Functional Assessment/Profile• Design Guide • Document Current Conditions • Long Range Facility Plans• Multi-year Capital Plan (prioritization)• Yearly Revisions to Long Range Facility
Plans and Capital Plan • On-going maintenance and oversight
Design Guide Purpose and Use
• Describes the unique characteristics of courthouses in the Judicial system
• For Judges, court staff, architects, engineers
• Directly applicable for new construction
• Useful for renovations
Design Guide Elements
• Types of spaces• Activities/functions• Typical furniture/sizes• Appropriate office
sizes• Appropriate
adjacencies
• Any requirement different from other government buildings– Lighting/Electrical– Security– Wall/floor
finishes/telecommunications
– Location– Landscaping– Handicapped access– Façade design/appearance– Built-in furniture– Signage– Heating/air conditioning
Design Guide Spaces Described
• Courthouse exterior• Interior spaces
– Main Entrance/Public Lobby
– Courtroom– President Judge’s office– President Judge’s
secretary’s office– Judge’s office– Intake offices
• Civil• Criminal• Executing
• Interior spaces (cont.)– Court Archive– Typists’ office– Accountant office– Special spaces
• Housekeeper's office• Coffee Bar• Conference Room• Server/computer wiring
room• Telephone switching room• Holding cell• Evidence/seized property
room
Long Range Facility Plans for Each Facility
• Document Current conditions
• Identify needed repairs• Determine future
plans/needs
• Create inventory of “projects” – Maintenance
– Repairs
– Alterations
– New facilities
• Estimate costs for each project
Develop a Multi-Year (3-5) Capital Plan
• Prioritize projects• Assign to budget years
– Priorities– Costs– Available funding
• Reorder/revise plan based on– Government action on previous budget year’s
plan– New Information about facility needs
Suggested Criteria for Prioritizing
• Health and safety of employees
• Overall building structural integrity
• Security of employees and judicial process
• Operating efficiencies and economies
• Caseload impacted
Priorities and Relative Importance
ImmediateNeed
Long-termNeed
Maximum
Score
Health & Safety 35 25 35
Building Structure 25 15 25
Security 15 10 15
Operating Efficiencies
15 10 15
Impact on Caseload 10 5 10
Facilities in Legal Reform Projects
• Architecturally attractive
• Prominent siting
• Appropriate indigenous materials
• Durable construction materials
• Interior functionality and flexibility
• Local participation in design
San Luis Indigenous Court
San Jose JP Court
Office Interior Libertidad
Natural Ventilation San Andrus
Some Useful Websites
• Americans with Disabilities Act www.ada.gov
• Serviceability/functionality – International Centre for Facilities
www.icf-cebe.com
• Standards, reference documents, etc.– Whole Building Design Guide www.wbdg.org
Thank you.
Questions?